@@jewcvalemon8670 So is spelling. Oddly enough, I've never found ketchup to be acceptable on hotdogs. It's strangely gratifying to find that I've been right all these years!
@@k4zum4s4m4 Not just jusdge, anyone who deal with law know their ways of intelligently insult or threatening. That include politician, lawyer, prosecutor, etc...
My answer to those debates (is hotdog a sandwich, is cereal soup) is always 'if i ask for a sandwich, and you give me a hotdog, it doesnt matter what the dictionary says, it's simply not what i asked for'.
well you wouldnt 'just ask for a sandwich', you'd ask for a specific sandwich, like a ham sandwich, a pb&j, you get the deal. so that logic wouldnt make much sense either way
How have you ignored the historical namesake? According to Wikipedia: "The sandwich is named after John Montagu, 4th Earl of Sandwich, an eighteenth-century English aristocrat. It is said that he ordered his valet to bring him meat tucked between two pieces of bread. It is commonly said that Lord Sandwich was fond of this form of food because it allowed him to continue playing cards, particularly cribbage, while eating, without using a fork, and without getting his cards greasy from eating meat with his bare hands." This should at least be considered when defining sandwiches. Clearly a hot dot with moderate condiments could be consumed whilst playing cribbage.
Note that the "easy to eat with the hands" is an important part of a sandwich. If you have a super sloppy mass of condiments between two slices of bread, that is known as a "mess", not a sandwich! This also includes "bone-in" "sandwiches" - they are messes, not sandwiches (unless the bones are eaten as well). This is why "sandwiches" at Jersey Mike's served Mike's Way are NOT sandwiches!
Lucretia Evans he didn’t say “are hard boiled eggs boneless chicken MEAT” just if they are boneless CHICKEN, which they are. Eggs are chicken... convince me otherwise
Oreq but... they are chicken They are chicken eggs Like there are chicken feet and chicken feathers and chicken shite They ARE 🐔 chicken When you are eating eggs you are eating a chicken product... I’m not saying that eggs are chickens, they are not, but they are chicken flesh, they cannot be anything else
Reminds me of a story I wrote you are a dad with a job and after coming home you see your wife sitting on the couch emotionlessly. you shake her and get frosting on your hand and then she falls apart and you find out she is cake. you go to you son’s bedroom and he also sits emotionlessly on his bed you find out he is also a cake. then everything in your house falls apart. You run out of the house to escape. You run and run but you find out the road is cake you still decide to run. everything is turning into into cake everybody is cake. You try to escape this world that is turning into a cake. You find somebody who has a house and has not turned into cake yet. You talk to him and ask “How are you not cake?” He answers with “I drank something.” You ask if you can live in his house and he agrees to it. After going in his house you wake up. You think it was all a dream. But you find out it wasn’t a dream you fell asleep inside the man’s house. The man says to you “You’re finally awake.” He gives you a drink that looks like a mix of purple and yellow. You ask what drink it is and he tells you “it will make it so you can’t turn into cake.” But it did the exact opposite. He’s the one who turned everything into cake. You are now a cake and you no longer actually exist.
Chicken wings have three parts - drums, flats, and that pointy end (idk what it’s called) The drum pictured wasn’t a leg drumstick, it was part of a wing
When people ask me the go to ice breaker question: “if you had to eat only one food for the rest of your life what would it be?” And my answer is ALWAYS pizza because if you fold it in half and cut in the middle, it’s a sandwich. If you fold it in half but not all the way, it’s a taco. If you roll it, it’s a taco. You shred it up, it’s a salad. I guess it’s kinda a loop hole, because a pizza can have any toppings
There is 3 categories which every food can go: -Sandwiches : A meal which you stack ingredients (you can have a sandwich of bread for example with 2 slices) -Soups : Mostly liquid foods (can have a bit of solid food in it) -Salads : One or a bunch of food you put together, in piece or not (a fruit is a salad of on ingredient) Technically a hotdog is a sandwich, you can try with other foods, each of them can be in those categories.
So... is a tea... a soup? I actually love to think, that both tea and coffee are soups. I read it once from a Tumblr or Twitter post and just fell in love with it.
That court case is outdated. Merriam webster now defines sandwich as " 1a: two or more slices of bread or a split roll having a filling in between b: one slice of bread covered with food." A hot dog bun is a split roll.
At 15:06 he showed an image of a hotdog with ketchup and mustard. The Hot Dog and Sausage Council would probably be disappointed in this video because of this.
Yeah, I don't care what the national council says, if the woman selling hot dogs from her trailer asks me what condiments I want, you can be goddamned sure I will say: "All of them!" And she'll hit me with ketchup and mayo.
My dad, my stepsis, my stepdad, and I were actually debating this very topic a few months ago! Boy these channels answer all of my strange but important questions, I love it!!
Oh yeah, I have waited a loooooong time to hear MatPat say that! It would be so funny if he started another channel called "The Conspiracy Theorists," even if it was just a parody of actual conspiracy theorists.
Calling them hot dogs is a bit of a stretch. I'd call them baguettes. But hey they don't need to exclusively sell sandwiches. Just like how Burger King doesn't have to sell nothing but burgers.
@@v_ChimChim_x The issue, though, is that almost all, if not all, of Subway's products are open faced items folded over, which by the definition cited, makes them not sandwiches. Common sense dictates that they must be considered sandwiches from a legal standpoint in order for a Subway and Panera to be disallowed in the same shopping center, but the only way the ruling would say so _is_ by citing common sense, which is legally fluid, as the central definition would prevent a Subway product from sandwich classification.
They cut a baguette in two, butter it usually, and then put stuff in between, wadyu mean hot dog? With hot dogs the bun isn’t ever fully separated, if it was, then it would be a sandwich.
@@frostyminecraft9832 I don't know what Subways you go to, but at every one I've patronized, they don't slice all the way through the baguette nor butter it.
This is predicated on the idea that the bread is one piece as it's assembled, right? Well, but which of these things can you still comfortable eat if the bread halves come apart? The subway sandwich. In-hand handling has to be a factor as well. NO ONE likes a hotdog if the bread halves come apart.
I did an entire essay back in highschool about a grilled cheese sandwich, spent days researching sandwichs, history and anatomy, technically a sandwich doesn't need two pieces of bread, it can be one, heck look at every subway sandwich, regardless, a hotdog is a sandwich, and by that means, most grains and dough also count, so also sandwiches are jelly donuts, taco, peta bread pockets, and yes, technically, an egg roll. Pop tarts, ravioli, which reminds me, Pop tarts are basically ravioli, ravioli is basically stuffed noodles, pop tarts are noodles. Fight me.
Dan Slater funny story. I was raised in northern Connecticut. Moved away after 6th grade and didn’t see Worcester’s name for a couple decades. When I was back there while working, I totally forgot how to pronounce it. When a local corrected me, I felt like an idiot having forgotten the pronunciation.. lol
I said it here and I said it first, Matpat is 100% going to make another channel with blue colour and call it a conspiracy theory. Somebody give me a medal in __ years __ month __ days "but thats just a theory a conspiracy theory annnnd cut"
I had an idea regarding the definition of a "sandwich" A sandwich is any food with a bread related base, regardless of filling and can be classified as several types and sub-types: True Sandwich: 2 slices of regular loaf bread with any filling. Sub-True Sandwich: 2 slices of other bread based material (bagel, tortillas, submarine, burger bun, etc.) with any filling, as long as both sides are not connected physically like a (hotdog bun, taco, etc). Open-Pseudo-Sandwich: Only 1 piece of bread related base material with any topping but an open form (such as pizza). Closed-Pseudo-Sandwich: Only 1 piece of bread related base material with any filling and a closed form (such as a tortilla). Semi-Parted-Pseudo-Sandwich: Only 1 piece of bread related base material with any filling and a Half-closed/open form (such as a hot-dog, taco, etc). False-Sandwich: A sub class that can apply to all the other classes if they are made with something other than bread as the base. Husk: A sandwich that is just the bread. Non-Sandwich: Food that lacks a bread base and does not class as any form of sandwich. Stack: A sandwich with more than 3 layers of bread based material of any type that act as bases for filling.
MatPat may have made a reference to it at the beginning, but I would like to draw everyone's attention to the "Cube Rule of Food". As far as I can find, the "cube rule of food" originated from a Twitter post from user Phosphatide in March of 2018, who presented an image detailing the classifications of different foods based on the location of the starch in relation to the 'additions' (Including anything that falls under both 'toppings' and 'fillings'). The image not only lays a solid foundation for the definition of 'sandwhich', but also for things like 'toast', 'taco', and several other food nomenclatures. Phosphatide seems to have reverse-engineered a 'common sense' type approach and then using the broadest terms to describe/define. What makes a sandwich a 'sandwich'? According to the Cube Rule of Food, any assortment of two separate intact starches with any number of non starch/different starch ingredients between them. Nobody with 'common sense' could argue that any example using this formula is NOT a sandwich. Also, I think that by changing the identifier 'bread' to 'starch' it saves on trying to define 'bread' and including the other types of wrappings (I.e corn/flour tortillas, potato bread, buscuit, begal, etc). Check out the original tweet yourself or the website cuberule and have a look for yourself and see if you can possibly disagree with these definitions. thank you , and have a good day.
NY also classifies sandwich because of food stamps, a food stamp user cannot buy prepared or hot case food. Oddly enough, stores in NY will put prepared fried and rotisserie chicken in the cooler case and then it's food stamp approved. Gotta love NY.
*HOW MATPAT IS FORMING THE INFINITY GAUNTLET:* Time Stone: Game Theory Reality Stone: Film Theory Soul Stone: Food Theory Space Stone: Conspiracy Theory Power Stone: Theater Theory Mind Stone: Book Theory Edit: Music theory is a actual copyrighted term. So yeah that’s not gonna work
Would English captions be able to be added? I know it’s an old video but captions help sooooo much 💖🥺 even auto generated would be great with Mats great annunciation 👏
At 7:13 he said “And that’s just a theory, a conspiracy theory.” And it was blue. A few days ago when he launched this channel he said he had an idea for the 5th channel. It was blue. And the conspiracy theory was surrounded by blue. He is going to make conspiracy theories. But hey, that’s just a theory. A conspiracy theory.
No, no, no, the other slot on his logo won't be for Conspiracy Theory, it will obviously be for Conspiracy Theory Theory where he deep dives Conspiracy Theories to find out what the usual Conspiracy guys AREN'T telling us.
When you look at other definitions. Technically Chicken Wings, Nuggets, and Tenders are Dumplings. They are fully-enwrapped meats in a breading, just like a Dumpling.
@@diannt9583 yeah, wings are the one where it can varry wing to wing, but some chicken wings do have breading all around so those do classify as Dumplings.
It ain't a real Donut Burger if it doesn't have two whole Krispy Kreme donuts as the buns. Some people say it has to be a bacon cheeseburger to be authentic but I feel like a plain burger is okay
Just checked the Merriam-Webster dictionery and the defenition of a sandwitch is: a: two or more slices of bread or a split roll having a filling in between b: one slice of bread covered with food so I guess that a hotdog is a sandwich
Matt, I believe “egg” was included in their definition of poultry (which would explain why they specify it and would also address your concern at 8:06)
I prefer lucidchart’s explanation: no starch creates a salad, one side of starch is toast, two sides is a sandwich, three is a taco, four is a sushi, five is a quiche, six is a calzone, and layers of starch is a cake. So yes, hotdogs are tacos. Also chicken wings are not sandwiches... they are calzones.
So a pizza could either be toast or a quiche depending on whether the crust on the sides rises above the toppings in the middle, a burrito is halfway between sushi and a cake because the wrap often has some part where multiple layers exist, or possibly a quiche or calzone rather than sushi if one or two of the ends are sealed, putting an extra piece of bread in the middle of your sandwich makes a cake, and a steak is a salad...
Love you man. You help me get through my work days!!! Also, eggs are classified as poultry products. So the USDA's definition would include egg sandwiches.. in my opinion. Would love to hear your thoughts.
Did you forget the final point of the video? Why the hot dog is really not a sandwich? It uses only one piece of bread. It is not typically buttered. Etc.
@@-No_3- Which is, also nonsense. Meat is meat, it doesn't matter if the animal is warm or cold blooded, or covered in fur or not, most excuses to exclude fish from being called meat are just ridiculous.
sandwich are two piece of bread... hot dog had just one cut up.... when come to what is what if you ask people what it is...first thing they come in mind usually is..not18 min video...that just overthinking...
Can’t wait for the “Is Cereal a Soup?” Video
MrTurkeyRulz “Is Mac N Cheese a soup?”
I was literally about to say the same thing lmao
no, that’s vsauce
Is ketchup a smoothie?
Cereal is probably a stew.
“Ketchup is not an acceptable topping to put on a hotdog”
Me: That sign can’t stop me because I can’t read
How ketchup isn’t an excerptible topping for a hotdog is beyond me.
The rest of the non American peeps the what
If those girls could read they would be very upset
Good
@@jewcvalemon8670 So is spelling.
Oddly enough, I've never found ketchup to be acceptable on hotdogs. It's strangely gratifying to find that I've been right all these years!
“...and as dictated by common sense” - that is the most passive agressive way I’ve ever heard anyone call someone else “stupid”
Judges develop a interesting way to call people stupid in their rulings xD
Gonna have to start using that.
@@k4zum4s4m4 Not just jusdge, anyone who deal with law know their ways of intelligently insult or threatening. That include politician, lawyer, prosecutor, etc...
Some people deserve it. They brainwashed me into thinking pizza was a sandwich!!!
or "imbecile" if theyre extra aggressive on calling stupid people
14:55 "And as dictated as common sense" that roast was completely unnecessary... And I love it
During class, we started talking about ‘is pizza a sandwich.’ Oh boy, I was so ready for that debate, all thanks to MatPat.
I've heard more people call pizza a pie rather than a sandwich, which I think is more fitting.
I asked my kid, he said no. I said what about if you fold it in half? He said yes.
@@stevesamson3940 so a calzone is a sandwich to your kid?in my opion i agree
O
J
Ik mhmm
@@bencroyle3962 I guess pies are sandwiches now.
Now we just need to know if cereal is soup
Hes too powerful to be left alive.
It’s not
🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
I think cereal is a soup
I vote yes
Okay but seriously. When are we getting a "Conspiracy Theory" channel with that blue on the logo? Because that would probably be the best channel.
I know right
no
it should be book and comic theory
No because if he makes one on flat earth everyone will think flat earth is real
@@40watt53 Exactly.
My answer to those debates (is hotdog a sandwich, is cereal soup) is always 'if i ask for a sandwich, and you give me a hotdog, it doesnt matter what the dictionary says, it's simply not what i asked for'.
well you wouldnt 'just ask for a sandwich', you'd ask for a specific sandwich, like a ham sandwich, a pb&j, you get the deal. so that logic wouldnt make much sense either way
Well here’s your chicken wing…
what about a burger
Here, have your pizza with an upside down pizza on top
Matpat: Ketcup is not on that list.
Me: NOT SCIENTIFICALLY POSSIBLE!
I feel like I’m being lied too rn
Ah yes, ketcup, my favorite!
Ketchup is overrated
@@commanderstars7631 fry sauce is where it's at!! :D
Fried human too
Why do hot dogs come in packs of 10 while the buns comes in packs of 8?
Money
Yes
In case you burn one
So the person cooking them can snack on 2 of them straight off the grill.
Why Don't Hot Dogs and Hot Dog Buns Come in Packs of Equal Number? th-cam.com/video/9g3wDafZKU4/w-d-xo.html
Me: *eats hot dog with ketchup*
National Hotdog and Sausage Council: *you weren’t supposed to do that*
I only eat hotdogs with a sans amount of ketchup (any undertale fan will get it)
I have nothing good to reply
Belda Williams so a whole bottle
@@stupiddreamsyt2955 half that actually
@@beldawilliams3282 lol yes same
Who’s coming back to watch MatPats old videos after knowing that his amazing theorising will come to an end, we’ll miss you MatPat
DONT REMIND ME
So, I watched the video until the end and didn't get it. Is it a sandwich or not?
I’m watching these for the first time. I only discovered these channels yesterday and I’m gutted that he’s leaving
@@timgorg1919 are u baiting?
@@instantchaos2385 What?
Whenever the bun annoyingly splits apart then the hotdog gets to become a sandwich
Thank you, somebody who knows
Yes
I mean it can be a sandwich but then it isn't a hot dog
This is incontrovertible for sure
Yes
Everyone: “It... it’s all a sandwich..?”
Tax regulators: *Cocks Gun* “always has been.”
Lol
lmao, good one.
*[ANGRY CUOMO NOISES]*
😳
Wait it’s all nugget. Always have been
How have you ignored the historical namesake? According to Wikipedia:
"The sandwich is named after John Montagu, 4th Earl of Sandwich, an eighteenth-century English aristocrat. It is said that he ordered his valet to bring him meat tucked between two pieces of bread. It is commonly said that Lord Sandwich was fond of this form of food because it allowed him to continue playing cards, particularly cribbage, while eating, without using a fork, and without getting his cards greasy from eating meat with his bare hands."
This should at least be considered when defining sandwiches. Clearly a hot dot with moderate condiments could be consumed whilst playing cribbage.
Note that the "easy to eat with the hands" is an important part of a sandwich. If you have a super sloppy mass of condiments between two slices of bread, that is known as a "mess", not a sandwich! This also includes "bone-in" "sandwiches" - they are messes, not sandwiches (unless the bones are eaten as well). This is why "sandwiches" at Jersey Mike's served Mike's Way are NOT sandwiches!
I like this (a sandwich is anything that can be eaten while playing cards
That includes many things, like wraps and pizzas. I'm totally open to that, but some people might whine.
Using the original use of a word invented centuries ago is silly. For example, the word "silly" used to mean something similar to "pious".
@@david2869 so, no sloppy joe's? thassa bullshit
7:10 omfg i can die happy now having this sound bite
5:22 love the fact they accidentally found oswald
I didn't notice that, that's really funny.
I can’t wait to see the “Are hard boiled eggs boneless chicken” episode
Yo....
You onto something tho 👀
Lucretia Evans he didn’t say “are hard boiled eggs boneless chicken MEAT” just if they are boneless CHICKEN, which they are.
Eggs are chicken... convince me otherwise
@@attatawil Eggs can be duck. Even human. 😶
(I get what you're saying, just playing pedantic.)
Oreq but... they are chicken
They are chicken eggs
Like there are chicken feet and chicken feathers and chicken shite
They ARE 🐔 chicken
When you are eating eggs you are eating a chicken product... I’m not saying that eggs are chickens, they are not, but they are chicken flesh, they cannot be anything else
There's about 8 acceptable ways to pronounce "Worcester" in Massachusetts. Brave of Matpat to bypass them all and invent his own.
*N O W T H E R E I S N I N E , A N D N O B O D Y C A N S T O P M E ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !*
As someone who lives in western MA, the only answer I've heard be accepted is "wooster"
"Language is a democracy" -MatPat 2020
@@nish5799it’s Wooster OR woosta
Am from MA and I just about had a heart attack hearing him pronounce it lmao
When everyone is talking about everything being a cake but then you learn everything is actually sandwich
Is meatloaf meatloaf or is meatloaf a meat cake with sauce icing?
is cake a sandwich
Reminds me of a story I wrote
you are a dad with a job and after coming home you see your wife sitting on the couch emotionlessly. you shake her and get frosting on your hand and then she falls apart and you find out she is cake. you go to you son’s bedroom and he also sits emotionlessly on his bed you find out he is also a cake. then everything in your house falls apart. You run out of the house to escape. You run and run but you find out the road is cake you still decide to run. everything is turning into into cake everybody is cake. You try to escape this world that is turning into a cake. You find somebody who has a house and has not turned into cake yet. You talk to him and ask “How are you not cake?” He answers with “I drank something.” You ask if you can live in his house and he agrees to it. After going in his house you wake up. You think it was all a dream. But you find out it wasn’t a dream you fell asleep inside the man’s house. The man says to you “You’re finally awake.” He gives you a drink that looks like a mix of purple and yellow. You ask what drink it is and he tells you “it will make it so you can’t turn into cake.” But it did the exact opposite. He’s the one who turned everything into cake. You are now a cake and you no longer actually exist.
A two layer cake...is a sandwich
@@davidharshman7645 wait... dang welp I guess the cake is a lie
The thing that really bothers me about this whole situation is that the US Department of AGRICULTURE apparently doesn’t deal with PLANTS
Right? I'm highly confused. I'm pretty sure I've seen nutrition facts about produce on their site tho.
And they do the plant hardiness zone maps, I'm pretty sure
I beg your pardon
Matpat: “ Ketchup is not on that list, Mayo is definitely not on that list”
Me really loud: “what!?”
Horse Radish is not on the list either.
*HERESY!*
What Hersey are you mad
NK17 was a rule for hotdogs that nobody over the age of 17 should put ketchup on a hotdog
Some rules are souppused to be broken
I know this is kinda silly but, “Does an apple a day ACTUALLY keep the doctor away”? Just a suggestion. Loved the vid!
Lol
Simple answer: no
Long answer: well that’s just a food theory ;)
YES! I SWEAR IT DOES!!!
(but you have to have a good throwing arm and decent aim)
@@spyda1857 r/holdup
It may keep the doctor away but not the dentist
Matpat: "chicken wing" *shows drumstick/thigh*
Me: Is a drumstick a chicken wing?
If u go to roosters and get chicken wings they will give u drumsticks
Chicken wings have three parts - drums, flats, and that pointy end (idk what it’s called)
The drum pictured wasn’t a leg drumstick, it was part of a wing
I can’t believe this had to be explained to you🤣
Yes
Is hummus a smoothie and is coffee a soup
I adore this channel - its ability to cover so much interesting terrotory off such direct and simple prompts is to be commended.
When people ask me the go to ice breaker question: “if you had to eat only one food for the rest of your life what would it be?” And my answer is ALWAYS pizza because if you fold it in half and cut in the middle, it’s a sandwich. If you fold it in half but not all the way, it’s a taco. If you roll it, it’s a taco. You shred it up, it’s a salad. I guess it’s kinda a loop hole, because a pizza can have any toppings
A german company made a chocolate pizza. Anything can be pizza.
Tarte is pizza
Can’t be a taco without tortilla
It can't have any toppings, pineapple is strictly prohibited
Tom Louis Müller that is beautiful
Me: It's all sandwiches?
Food Theory: Always has been.
The goverment*
TheHipOne *bang*
No they have all been pies like open faced sandwiches
YES
Nah, everything is a cake
I think the last channel should be "Conspiracy Theory" now.
BionicleFreek99 or book theory i guess
YES GET THIS MAN A MEDAL
Dang you beat me to it!
Last, I think you mean next.
iluvpikachu YES I WILL LOVE THAT FOR THE NEXT ONE
There is 3 categories which every food can go:
-Sandwiches : A meal which you stack ingredients (you can have a sandwich of bread for example with 2 slices)
-Soups : Mostly liquid foods (can have a bit of solid food in it)
-Salads : One or a bunch of food you put together, in piece or not (a fruit is a salad of on ingredient)
Technically a hotdog is a sandwich, you can try with other foods, each of them can be in those categories.
So... is a tea... a soup?
I actually love to think, that both tea and coffee are soups. I read it once from a Tumblr or Twitter post and just fell in love with it.
@@mif_sovremennosty Technically, yes ^^
jello? steak?
@@theredpotatochip301 Jello and steak ? salad
Rice, Chapatis, tandoori kababs ??
The rapid fire "IS THIS THING A SANDWICH" honestly made me want to curl up in a ball and cry because my entire life has been a lie
I'm your 100th like
I just kept screaming No at the screen.
It was such a painful experience :'(
That court case is outdated. Merriam webster now defines sandwich as "
1a: two or more slices of bread or a split roll having a filling in between
b: one slice of bread covered with food." A hot dog bun is a split roll.
Can we go back to the definition from the Earl of Sandwich?
So is a sub a hotdog.
That's what i thought, because by the earlier definition subway sandwiches would not be considered sandwiches
@@xPingviinix I was just trolling but this is genuinely interesting.
hold on, according to "b." toast is a sandwich
MatPat: "According to the National Hot Dog and Sausage Council..."
Me: *Pauses video to question humanity*
*hold up*
He almost started to laugh. You could hear in his voice how bullshit the council is.
At 15:06 he showed an image of a hotdog with ketchup and mustard. The Hot Dog and Sausage Council would probably be disappointed in this video because of this.
Not the fact that we fight over the definitions and categorizations of food?
@@lylacor8401 That and the fact that we create ENTIRE COUNCILS to fight over it for us!
Is anyone else in 2024 going back to watch all of matpat's videos to because they aren't ready fpr him to retire?
Omg YESSS
yes. yes i am
He’s gone… my childhood’s gone…
Yep 😢
Me
As someone who had looked after and cared for dogs, I can safely say that they do not become sandwiches when hot
Oooooookkkkkkaaaa- wait what. Oooooohhhhh.
Thanks for clearing it up, I've been confused about this for the last 2 years
I could have known that before I lit my dog on fire, for scientific reasons of course...
_Are you really sure about that?-_
Then I should call PETA for myself.
Me: **hears that ketchup is not a condiment for hot dogs**
Also Me: **still do it**
Truly a person of culture.
Yeah, I don't care what the national council says, if the woman selling hot dogs from her trailer asks me what condiments I want, you can be goddamned sure I will say: "All of them!" And she'll hit me with ketchup and mayo.
Same
Imagine being part of ketchup gang.
@@stevenbobbybills imagine commenting on someone's comment just to be a hater
Instead of “everything is cake”, now it’s “is everything a sandwich?”
Is cake a sandwich?
@@wavechild5164 no the bread isn't thin if it is considered bread at that point
Wave Child And that is the paradoxical question.
It's a food with starch on top and bottom
its a frosting sandwich
My dad, my stepsis, my stepdad, and I were actually debating this very topic a few months ago! Boy these channels answer all of my strange but important questions, I love it!!
Mat : "A Conspiracy Theory"
Me: That's it boys. The circle is complete.
we finally did it bois-
Mr Membrane finally... I have them all
Yeah
Yas queen!
Oh yeah, I have waited a loooooong time to hear MatPat say that!
It would be so funny if he started another channel called "The Conspiracy Theorists," even if it was just a parody of actual conspiracy theorists.
Then by that judge's logic, subway doesn't sell sandwiches either. They sell hot dogs
Calling them hot dogs is a bit of a stretch. I'd call them baguettes. But hey they don't need to exclusively sell sandwiches. Just like how Burger King doesn't have to sell nothing but burgers.
@@v_ChimChim_x The issue, though, is that almost all, if not all, of Subway's products are open faced items folded over, which by the definition cited, makes them not sandwiches. Common sense dictates that they must be considered sandwiches from a legal standpoint in order for a Subway and Panera to be disallowed in the same shopping center, but the only way the ruling would say so _is_ by citing common sense, which is legally fluid, as the central definition would prevent a Subway product from sandwich classification.
They cut a baguette in two, butter it usually, and then put stuff in between, wadyu mean hot dog? With hot dogs the bun isn’t ever fully separated, if it was, then it would be a sandwich.
@@frostyminecraft9832 I don't know what Subways you go to, but at every one I've patronized, they don't slice all the way through the baguette nor butter it.
This is predicated on the idea that the bread is one piece as it's assembled, right? Well, but which of these things can you still comfortable eat if the bread halves come apart? The subway sandwich. In-hand handling has to be a factor as well. NO ONE likes a hotdog if the bread halves come apart.
Internet: “Is a hot dog a sandwich?”
Tax Collectors: “Yes.”
Massachusetts + MatPat: “No.”
Me: “Yesn’t.”
*NoYes*
Nes
Meme Man comment uploaded 3 SECOND AGO
but it *IS* a type of sandwich
it's a Hoagie
ITS A GLIZZY
8:05 I'm gonna say they probably meant eggs under the weirdly separated "poultry" statement
My sister: puts ketchup on hot dog*
Hot counsel: breathes intensely*
You can't put me in jail I WILL PUT KETCHUP IN IT CUZ IS A LOGICAL THING TO DO
@@iriswav7379 exactly. I mean do you not eat sausages with ketchup? Its fucking delicious. I dont think adding some bread is gonna change much
@@khatunamezvrishvili6211 I'm gonna fight for ketchup to be a condiment on hot dogs
@@iriswav7379 good.
Glizzy gobblette
"People need to stop arguing if their hotdogs are sandwiches. Just eat your lunch."
A hot dog is a hot dog
I'll consider your other comments
Food is food
NEVER
If you cut the bottom of the hotdog then it’s a sandwich
"aye bruh what kind of sandwich you want"
"Chicken wing"
Pull that off please
Chicken wing minus the chicken wing plus the bread minus the bread plus the sandwich
@@kationkat7400 i'll take two
I did an entire essay back in highschool about a grilled cheese sandwich, spent days researching sandwichs, history and anatomy, technically a sandwich doesn't need two pieces of bread, it can be one, heck look at every subway sandwich, regardless, a hotdog is a sandwich, and by that means, most grains and dough also count, so also sandwiches are jelly donuts, taco, peta bread pockets, and yes, technically, an egg roll. Pop tarts, ravioli, which reminds me, Pop tarts are basically ravioli, ravioli is basically stuffed noodles, pop tarts are noodles. Fight me.
Matt: "is the kfc double down a sandwich?"
me: no, its a entrance to cardiovascular diseases
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Łøł
I wanna try one, ngl
@@katiehunt8993 me too
@@VezlyGracies Thrice
Everyone: debating on what's a sandwich
Me: Matpat said "Worcester" wrong
Came to the comments to make sure this was here. 👍
This
It’s not his fault. It’s pronounced nothing like how it’s spelt and he’s American...
Dan Slater funny story. I was raised in northern Connecticut. Moved away after 6th grade and didn’t see Worcester’s name for a couple decades. When I was back there while working, I totally forgot how to pronounce it. When a local corrected me, I felt like an idiot having forgotten the pronunciation.. lol
i know it bugged me to but glad that Massachusetts was the one to settle the debate.
Anything: *has a confusing origin*
MatPat: "I'm about to end this man's whole career."
obvsly-
MatPat: I fear no man... but that thing!
*fnaf story line*
MatPat: it scares me...
matpat nakey nakey th-cam.com/video/a4RBR5eDayk/w-d-xo.html
Agree
Hearing you say "That's just a theory. A conspiricy theory" made me laugh. When's the fifth theory channel coming?
People coming over from Film Theory:
“And that’s just a theory, a Fil-uhh-FOOD Theory
I said it here and I said it first, Matpat is 100% going to make another channel with blue colour and call it a conspiracy theory. Somebody give me a medal in __ years __ month __ days "but thats just a theory a conspiracy theory annnnd cut"
@Psycho Gamer i hope im right though only time will tell, also i subbed to ur channel i would really apreciate it if you checked mine out to
What about game theory and gtlive
@@RegiMags8340 ? does he reveal another channel
@@RegiMags8340 noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo, i just saw the video now and they alreayd said conspiracy theory why!!!
“Ketchup does not count for a hot dog”
Me eating a bratwurst: you have no power here
A bratwurst is a sausage and those guidelines were for hotdogs *and* sausage.
@@impossiblepath1972 scheize
@@ieatmicroplastics sorry if I seemed like I was attacking you, now that I think about it, I shouldn't have said anything.
wursts are the best without anything
Ketchup on a bratwurst? Yeah I'm pretty sure you're gonna go to jail for that.
Everyone: Its all cake.
Food Theory: Nope! Its all sandwhich.
But, is cake a sandwich?
I got u it’s a cakewich or sandcake
Nani??!!!?!!
What if you replace bread with sand?
SandSandwitch
Eating pizza while watching food theory is the perfect combo.
"Wait, it's all sandwiches?"
"Always has been."
*Inaudible gunshots because sound doesn't travel in space*
*But the gun doesn't work since there's no air to let the gun ignite to fire the bullet*
@@aurora6256 *the first one turns around with a machete but loses grip on it because they're in space*
@@filelost9194 grip exists in space though
@@Chriscraft-ug3sz well it might be hard to grip it because of the lack of gravity
H
I had an idea regarding the definition of a "sandwich"
A sandwich is any food with a bread related base, regardless of filling and can be classified as several types and sub-types:
True Sandwich: 2 slices of regular loaf bread with any filling.
Sub-True Sandwich: 2 slices of other bread based material (bagel, tortillas, submarine, burger bun, etc.) with any filling, as long as both sides are not connected physically like a (hotdog bun, taco, etc).
Open-Pseudo-Sandwich: Only 1 piece of bread related base material with any topping but an open form (such as pizza).
Closed-Pseudo-Sandwich: Only 1 piece of bread related base material with any filling and a closed form (such as a tortilla).
Semi-Parted-Pseudo-Sandwich: Only 1 piece of bread related base material with any filling and a Half-closed/open form (such as a hot-dog, taco, etc).
False-Sandwich: A sub class that can apply to all the other classes if they are made with something other than bread as the base.
Husk: A sandwich that is just the bread.
Non-Sandwich: Food that lacks a bread base and does not class as any form of sandwich.
Stack: A sandwich with more than 3 layers of bread based material of any type that act as bases for filling.
You have acquired too much wisdom
He is too dangerous to be left alive
This is my sandwich compass for now on!! Thank you 😁
Next years dictionary: Hotdog - Not a sandwich
Yes
Hot dogs are tacos
Matpat:we were wrong
Bruh Moments that’s a bruh moment
A pizza is actually toast.
MatPat may have made a reference to it at the beginning, but I would like to draw everyone's attention to the "Cube Rule of Food". As far as I can find, the "cube rule of food" originated from a Twitter post from user Phosphatide in March of 2018, who presented an image detailing the classifications of different foods based on the location of the starch in relation to the 'additions' (Including anything that falls under both 'toppings' and 'fillings'). The image not only lays a solid foundation for the definition of 'sandwhich', but also for things like 'toast', 'taco', and several other food nomenclatures. Phosphatide seems to have reverse-engineered a 'common sense' type approach and then using the broadest terms to describe/define.
What makes a sandwich a 'sandwich'? According to the Cube Rule of Food, any assortment of two separate intact starches with any number of non starch/different starch ingredients between them. Nobody with 'common sense' could argue that any example using this formula is NOT a sandwich.
Also, I think that by changing the identifier 'bread' to 'starch' it saves on trying to define 'bread' and including the other types of wrappings (I.e corn/flour tortillas, potato bread, buscuit, begal, etc). Check out the original tweet yourself or the website cuberule and have a look for yourself and see if you can possibly disagree with these definitions.
thank you , and have a good day.
Mat pat: spends hours figuring out what makes a sandwich a sandwich
Me: *Hey, Alexa*
Alex Jones: Alexa you're lying to me
Me: eating hotdogs with ketchup
FBI: *wait...... that’s illegal*
I do miracle whip
Tria Maxwell death penalty
Them not including ketchup is insanity
@@jdjdfg431 I'll die with tasty meat in my mouth.
We're both from Roblox
This is the longest subway ad I've ever seen.
Underrated
very underrated
haha guys he did the funny
@Patrick Shaughnessy III
True
Lol
NY also classifies sandwich because of food stamps, a food stamp user cannot buy prepared or hot case food. Oddly enough, stores in NY will put prepared fried and rotisserie chicken in the cooler case and then it's food stamp approved. Gotta love NY.
That intro is the most meta intro yet
Edit: A hot dog would truly be in hufflepuff
Indeed
As some say, it “slaps”
Yup
Hufflepuff is not the worst hoouuuussseeee
@@trisle2764 you sound like you're in Hufflepuff
The current Merriam Webster Dictionary definition of a sandwich: “two or more slices of bread or a split roll having a filling in between”
Molly Clare S P L I T R O L L
Subway can open next to that panera I can confirm we serve everything on one piece of bread
well yes, but actually no
Ravioli is a sandwich and I will not be taking questions.
Ice cream sandwich has no bread
*HOW MATPAT IS FORMING THE INFINITY GAUNTLET:*
Time Stone: Game Theory
Reality Stone: Film Theory
Soul Stone: Food Theory
Space Stone: Conspiracy Theory
Power Stone: Theater Theory
Mind Stone: Book Theory
Edit: Music theory is a actual copyrighted term. So yeah that’s not gonna work
What about GTlive
the next is conspiracy theory
Power Stone would be Country theory
@@keatonjudd1476 Well GTLive is green, so still Time Stone
@@VertonungenGedichte Why?
Would English captions be able to be added? I know it’s an old video but captions help sooooo much 💖🥺 even auto generated would be great with Mats great annunciation 👏
I still wonder to this day if the generic image of a man knows he’s in almost every MatPat theory video.
That guy IS MatPat
@WizLou 02 No, I mean the man at the far left at 2:19. That isn’t MatPat.
@@vanillasita8026 point taken. I do see him in almost every video
Its probably a stock image so he knows hes getting seen a lot
@Maxx E Well yeah I know it’s a stock image
"Is Hot Dog Classification just a joke to these people?"
-MatPat 2020
Edit: Woah, 273 likes in 14 hours?! Thank! Like if you got that reference.
@Carp what?
It's arguments like these, why liberals are so angry, confused, and going crazy lol!
Real question though, is hummus a smoothie, and is coffee a soup?
Everyone asks:
"Is a hot dog a sandwich?"
But no one asks:
"Is a sandwich a hot dog?"
But no one asks: how is hotdog
Somthing to think about
Everyone wants to know WHERE Waldo is, no one ever ask HOW Waldo is
The question was literally covered in the video.
Everyone asks:
“Is Zuckerburg a human?”
But no one asks:
“Is a human Zuckerburg?”
That’s logic doesn’t make sense.
I brought the hotdog question to my school a few years ago, and there were actual fights breaking out because of it
Legally speaking, a pizza is just an open-faced calzone.
Pizza Is pizza
Um, which came first?
A calzone is just a folded pizza.
E. Khalilah pizza
@@kvgm a calzone is a hotdog.
When you realize that subway doesn’t serve sandwiches according to MatPat...
uh ohh-
Hmmmmm
A sub is a sub, not a sandwich. Subs are a unique meal
@@ReaperOKnowledge if that were true then in that shopping center where that panera bread restaurant was a subway or something could've been opened.
@@ReaperOKnowledge subs are sandwiches, they're bread rolls and count as sandwiches in the original British sense xx
At 7:13 he said “And that’s just a theory, a conspiracy theory.” And it was blue. A few days ago when he launched this channel he said he had an idea for the 5th channel. It was blue. And the conspiracy theory was surrounded by blue. He is going to make conspiracy theories. But hey, that’s just a theory. A conspiracy theory.
It’s a joke
don't bother mate, obviously he doesn't understand the joke
I can only hope for a conspiracy theory channel
No, no, no, the other slot on his logo won't be for Conspiracy Theory, it will obviously be for Conspiracy Theory Theory where he deep dives Conspiracy Theories to find out what the usual Conspiracy guys AREN'T telling us.
I thought of the same exact thing and was about to post it when i saw your comment.
If a hotdog isn’t a sandwich, then what on earth is subway selling?
Matpat before: "Who is the Purple Guy? Who is Golden Freddy?"
Matpat now: "IS A HOTDOG A SANDWICH?"
@@humanrosess i could totally imagine that happening
@@humanrosess lol what if this what happened really
game theory: who is purple guy
film theory: willy wonka rigged the golden tickets
food theory: I S A H O T D O G A S A N D W I C H ?
Is purple guy a sandwich?
Oil-Pumps Holy 💩 you put that in my mind and I hate lol
Can’t wait for the “are eggs wet boneless chicken?” video
Lol
Is the shell a bone
Sir Shiro I never watched the seven deadly sins
@@markdahlia9543 no
When you look at other definitions.
Technically Chicken Wings, Nuggets, and Tenders are Dumplings.
They are fully-enwrapped meats in a breading, just like a Dumpling.
Mind = Blown lol
My chicken wings are never enwrapped in breading. Just a good hot sauce!
@@diannt9583 yeah, wings are the one where it can varry wing to wing, but some chicken wings do have breading all around so those do classify as Dumplings.
Not really. A dumpling is never breaded. They are wrapped in dough.
@@lancelindlelee7256 Dough is a type of/state of bread.
Bread Dough?
11:30 LOL from ChIcKeN WiNgS 🍗🍗🍗
MatPat: ketchup isnt supposed to go on hotdogs, apparently.
Sans: *why are we still here...? Just to suffer? Every night?*
Omgosh yes
*gaster blasters are readied*
you dont deserve hotdogs if u put ketchup on them
ketchup and onions on my hotdogs. I can beat genocide sans any day.
I don't see anything wrong with putting ketchup y'all
“How the sausage gets made”
*inhale*
*”nO ONE REALLY KNOWS HOW THE GAME IS PLAYED, THE ART OF THE TRADE, HOW THE SAUSAGE GETS MADE”*
we just assume that its happens, but no one else is in the room where it happens
*trumpet noises*
If you want this video than, “WAIT FOR IT, WAIT FOR IT!”
@@MattieBear THOMAS CLaiMS
I WANNA BE IN THE ROOM WHERE IT HAPPENS, IIIIIIII~~~~
The most American thing I’ve ever seen is the Donut Burger. Not a joke it’s an actual burger between 2 halves of a glazed donut.
It ain't a real Donut Burger if it doesn't have two whole Krispy Kreme donuts as the buns. Some people say it has to be a bacon cheeseburger to be authentic but I feel like a plain burger is okay
@Rebecca Solomon Now that I think about it it is 2 donuts and no I haven’t tried it
I HAVE TO TRY IT
i'm from america and have never heard of it before now.
I've had one and it is delicious as it clogs my arteries
Just checked the Merriam-Webster dictionery and the defenition of a sandwitch is:
a: two or more slices of bread or a split roll having a filling in between
b: one slice of bread covered with food
so I guess that a hotdog is a sandwich
Vegetarian: Hmm maybe i'll have a sandw-
USDA: NOPE!
Judge: "Two slices of bread"
Me: [Cries in Sub/Hoagie]
Carrow's: [Cries in Club Sandwich and French Dip]
Matt, I believe “egg” was included in their definition of poultry (which would explain why they specify it and would also address your concern at 8:06)
Also, fried chicken is usually covered inside of breadcrumbs/flour and egg based batter.
Came to the comments for exactly this!
th-cam.com/video/ej4omqT9RV4/w-d-xo.html
@@tommyegan2181 What the
@@tommyegan2181 If your gonna pull a move like that at least use rick astley
Sandwich is a vibe. Its about the purpose of the structure of the food.
I prefer lucidchart’s explanation: no starch creates a salad, one side of starch is toast, two sides is a sandwich, three is a taco, four is a sushi, five is a quiche, six is a calzone, and layers of starch is a cake.
So yes, hotdogs are tacos.
Also chicken wings are not sandwiches... they are calzones.
mind blown
I TOLD YOU PIZZA WAS TOAST YOU HEAR THIS MOM I WASN’T LYING WHEN I SAID I HAD TOAST FOR DINNER
So a pizza could either be toast or a quiche depending on whether the crust on the sides rises above the toppings in the middle,
a burrito is halfway between sushi and a cake because the wrap often has some part where multiple layers exist, or possibly a quiche or calzone rather than sushi if one or two of the ends are sealed,
putting an extra piece of bread in the middle of your sandwich makes a cake,
and a steak is a salad...
What if I make a sandwich by putting bread, meat, bread, meat, bread? Three layers, so would it be a cake?
So, if I were to fold my pizza in 2, I'm eating a taco and if I put 2 pizza pieces on each other, I'm eating a sandwich, got it
Everything’s a sandwich. Including humans:
Bones.
Meat.
Skin.
Technically sandwich
Ah,yes. My favorite part of the sandwich.
Bone.
May i ask why you used "meat" instead of "muscle" ?
Well yes but actually no
@Sevin because you don’t beat muscle
I think its a pepperoni roll
National Hot Dog and Sausage Council: *states acceptable toppings*
Me: *cries in ketchup and crushed potato chips*
Yes
Same
I put mayo and barbecue on my hot dog so I understand
@@yamea8216 why both??!
@Luis Santiago Trestini onion sauce? I can't stand mayo.
Love you man. You help me get through my work days!!! Also, eggs are classified as poultry products. So the USDA's definition would include egg sandwiches.. in my opinion. Would love to hear your thoughts.
This is missing a big piece: the sub sandwich.
Really, a hotdog is more like a sub sandwich. Which is a sandwich.
A bit more specific would be to consider a meatball sub. I consider that to be a sandwich and it isn’t flat
This is exactly what I was about to comment!! A hot dog is exactly like a sub therefore it should be classified as a sandwich.
This is way shorter than this video. Thank you.
Did you forget the final point of the video? Why the hot dog is really not a sandwich? It uses only one piece of bread. It is not typically buttered. Etc.
How often do you go to subway and they butter the bread or cut it all the way in half?
"the most American thing to come out of America"
Matpat, meet Fried Butter
that the south
Then KFC released the double down meal with a large bottle of coke dipped in glock magazines and sixty nine sticks of fried butter...
@@Nate-tx9fp ehhh..that just sounds like assisted suicide
bacon egg n cheese crussle wouldn’t be surprised considering it’s America...
There's also Fried Ice Cream
When he said that ketchup wasn't allowed on hot dogs, i panicked. I imagined the FBI knocking on my door.
@Jaden Min
Seriously, if I ever put anything on a hot dog (which is pretty much all the time), it’s always ketchup...
You get used to it. Im at the top of FBI's most wanted because I put Oreos in my hot dog.
@@tigerboy977 😱
@@tigerboy977 *holy music stops*
@@tigerboy977 I put dogs on my hot dog
So you’re telling me that a subway sandwich is NOT a sandwich until the one piece of bread that’s sliced like a HOT DOG BUN is separated into two??
i love how he spent like a minute arguing about how poultry is already meat and they didn't have to say "poultry or meat"
But it’s like when there’s a separate area on the menu for fish and a separate section for meat
shut up mat pat is aa beutiful baby boi who should noit be shunned in this way!
@@-No_3- Which is, also nonsense. Meat is meat, it doesn't matter if the animal is warm or cold blooded, or covered in fur or not, most excuses to exclude fish from being called meat are just ridiculous.
You fail Matt.
Eggs are classified as poultry products, not dairy products
@@kimberlyjacobsen4148I was just thinking about that while watching this
its art in it self, making the question "is a hotdog a sandwich" a 18 minute long entertaining video worth to watch
Wow
sandwich are
two piece of bread... hot dog had just one cut up.... when come to what is what if you ask people what it is...first thing they come in mind usually is..not18 min video...that just overthinking...
ah yes, the three harry potter houses;
- sandwich
- taco
- hufflepuff
I guess Ravenclaw was never a house 🤔
Wait, then where do I belong
like if agree
Always has been
Don’t forget hot dog
tutin Wait, it’s all hufflepuff
If hotdogs aren't sandwiches, neither are subs.
Someone: Hotdog is a sandwic-
MatPat: *break down the wall like the kool aid man* NO
Matpat isn’t nearly as powerful as the koolaid man though
Unoriginal
OH NOOOOOO
Duane Mgendi noice
Angela Hsiao or is he? We don’t know what he does in that closet XP. I mean the kool aid man is going to be the next thanos so-
These are the questions people think about when crying in the shower "is cereal a soup? Is pizza a sandwich?"
“Is ketchup technically a juice?”
I consider soup to require a broth: that being hot water with added flavoring, usually as a powder.
Meaning: I _hate_ the question “is cereal a soup”
No
Cereal is definitely a soup
@@thaias9654 "hot water with added flavoring" could describe bathwater.
"A thin layer"
Me putting 10 layers of salami on my subway: So ive never had a sandwich?
Subway doesn’t sell sandwiches, they sell Subs or ‘Submarines’ 🙄
10 layers aren't considered 1 layer
Sandwich: two pieces of bread with something in between
Hotdog: not a sandwich
And that’s *not* a theory, it’s a fact