Beginner with $50,000 RED Camera vs PRO with iPhone 13!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 พ.ค. 2024
- In this video, we compare the footage from a beginner using a $50,000 RED camera to a professional using an iPhone 13. Watch to see the difference in quality and to find out if the camera truly makes the filmmaker! Which one will come out on top? You'll have to watch to find out!
Thank you Storyblocks for Sponsoring This Video: www.storyblocks.com/parker
To join our new $27 Starter Course:
www.fulltimefilmmaker.com/sta...
To Land More Video Clients or Hire Video Pros:
vidlead.com
To see a full list of ALL the gear I use:
kit.co/parkerwalbeck
To learn how to create, market, and sell online courses:
coursecreatorpro.com/register...
Alyssa's Socials:
Instagram: / freshperspective.media
TH-cam: / @freshperspectivemedia
For business inquiries email me at business@fulltimefilmmaker.com
00:00 The Challenge
2:22 Alyssa's Shoot
6:53 Jake's Shoot
11:58 Judging the Videos - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA W2D2 | Summer | โหดจัด ซัดไม่เลี้ยง](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TJa9d7tpSP4/mqdefault.jpg)
I feel like Alyssa's video could pass for a TV commercial while Jake's video is perfect for social media which is exactly what the client want. Either ways, in the end Quality is subjective!
Agreed
Had the same idea
Let's be real he was helping her the whole time
Agree!!
💯💯
Alyssa, the Beginner, here... and Wow! I am absolutely blown away by all the positive feedback. I just want to thank Parker, Jake and the team for allowing me this growing opportunity to participate in this Beginner vs. Pro shoot. Walking in, I was nervous and had no idea what to expect. Walking out, I was so nervous about the feedback I would receive. Thank you to each and every person who has commented feedback, critiques, and compliments. I'll forever be humbled and grateful that I was able to do this challenge.
Nice job!
Congratulations! It’s truly inspiring. You have a great eye and natural instinct. It’s clear that you’ve had great references to soak up knowledge from. Well done!
It was super well done!
Great job!
I thought you did an amazing job, your video like was pointed out could be used on a website or tv. Great job 👍🏻
Both were good. My problem with Jake's is I've seen a lot of cheap/scam products that use that format (especially that opening AI voice). So although the production and everything was good, I felt skeptical about the validity of the product. Alyssa's had me more convinced this was a genuine quality product. Honestly both were good for respective platforms. Jake's for tiktok/TH-cam shorts/Instagram, Alyssa's for TH-cam and the like.
agreed- when it comes down to it I actually would consider buying from alyssa's ad, but was turned off by how disingenuous the robotic voice sounds and wouldn't buy from jake's. good job both though!
That is exactly what I thought!
THIS.
that tik tok voice and how the video was shot were automatically a turn off, because my brain almost adapted to skipping those bad reviews/ads from social media, and call the skeptics of it.
Play I didn’t see the process of cleaning. That’s 100% skip
100%
Alyssa has the potential to be one of the best film makers because of how well she’s done as a beginner. Never would’ve thought an amateur made it.
She went from beginner to amateur in a matter of 2 sentences.
@Christopher Mitonides she knew what an F Stop was… what are you talking about? She told me to bring it down because she knew that a lower F stop meant more light. She just didn’t know where to see it on the RED since she had never used it before. Nobody’s lying to you buddy
Yeah if she keeps working maybe . He did help her quite a bit lol
@@JakeWeisler stop setting up gear and helping with shots and etc. it feels contrived , just let them actually demonstrate what they know.
Indeed
The look on his face when he said it actually works 😂😂
As an aspiring filmmaker, I’m obsessed with these videos testing the boundaries of technology
Agreed
Forget about technology. Concentrate on the fundamentals. That works universally, regardless of your camera and equipment.
Honestly, when Jake said "Wow it actually works" and the look on the client's face... I was more sold on the product than anything else done in either ads. If that could have been in the ad, with something like a cut saying... "You bet your ass it works!" while sticking the product on the phone and waking out like a boss, might have pulled out my wallet right then and there.
I was looking for this comment 😂
We need more videos like this, showing how to interact with clients and what questions to ask when prepping for a product shoot. This is such valuable information.
Haha @ 10:57 when Jake said, “it actually works” and the guy just slowly turns and looks at him like 😑
I can’t believe that Alyssa only picked up a camera a year ago! That video was dope! Really good job!
10:56
Jake : wow , that's actually works
Cary : ". . . . Really jake?"
Honestly felt like Jake's video was made for 16 year old who are on TikTok, while Alyssa's video is targeted at a wider age group
Lol, Jake used an iPhone he couldn't do what Alyssa did with the RED camera.
@@andreigaming5581 he could definitely do that, he just chose to go the route of cringe-y tik tok advertising which i find lacking.
@@at_oussama Yeah, but The RED has many features that the iPhone does not have, but at the part with the cringe tik-tok, you're right.
@@at_oussama Well the client wants the ad to be seen by people who uses social media alot in that respect Jake wins easily
yes Alyssa is looks more clean and targeted towards a different group but this ad will be seen on social media not a website listing video
Not even, I feel like most 16 year olds absolutely hate ads because growing up in a fast developing digital world, they have seen ads all thier lives and they tend to like ads only when it doesn't even feel like an ad
Alyssa's video is undeniably good. She has a good understanding of the concepts, and little details like the slow motion water shot show this - this is something that needs to be planned at the time of filming because you need to adjust the shutter speed accordingly. I also think that from the perspective of editing and getting straight to the point and selling the product, Parker's video achieves this better. A great demonstration that both knowledge and experience are important.
2000 IQ play by the client, who used the competitive nature of the video's structure to pit these two into creating entirely different styles of video, specifically so he could use both of them for his various mediums. Two videos instead of one? That's what we call big brain!
In all seriousness, this video is so valuable for so many reasons. Amazing work and I can't wait to see more content like this!
Best joke at 10:57 and Cary's reaction. Great video. Good learning experience for me!
Lmao
Was going to comment the same xD
Finally someone who noticed it haha!
i was looking for that comment haha
Alyssa’s video: brand awareness
Jake’s video: sales and conversion
His face when Jake says it actually works 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I'm more impressed by Alyssas video tbh. She brought up that you can clean the screen cleaner itself and didn't use the same B-roll 3 times like Jake did :D Ofc the quality also helps.
Well, jake literally helped her so...
Honestly if I paid my money. I'm going with Alyssa. She nailed it.
I thought it was a nice touch to have James McAvoy showing his new product.
A video idea:
Why not give the beginner top end gear (Like the Red Cameras), the intermediate a mid end gears (DSLRs) and the pros phones. It would be nice to see more competitors in the video.
Alyssa made a better video because if I see that on social media I will doubt it actually works, but Alyssa's video gave me confidence about the product and put the message very clearly. Jake video's message was not effective as hers.
You could, we're currently at f/14🤣🤣
I systematically prefer Alyssa's video over Jake's in this case, not because of the quality of the footage but also because it is more engaging and slick in my opinion.
shot in a proper manner to be honest
@@alooposto23 yess
Yes, it felt like it was exactly what she was aiming for and looked nice and clean in general
Please make more videos like this, especially when client talks about how the output video feels to them and also how you keeping with trends
love these kind of videos! 👏😎
I like that you mentioned things like a CTAs etc. Shows that you're a creative that took the time and did the research as to why the client would want the vid in the first place, and acted upon it. I feel as vid/photogs, we tend to forget that sometimes. Kudos
Honestly Alyssa's vidéo is the best... Better lighting, simple, very incredible
Both videos were great, and especially for their respective platforms. Great job to Alyssa for an awesome job
Are the ads good? Yeah, they definitely are! I went from "Well, this thing is useless" to "Wow I want that! 🤩" just by watching these 2! Well done both of you!
Ok I need like a dozen waterbears!!
I really liked Alyssa's video. Very clean cut, well lit and amazing.
For social media the other shot is great too!
So I think he needs both for different applications.
Great stuff. The best thing about this channel is that I learn something new every video!!
Props to Alyssa for the amazing commercial for a beginner! 😊
I like the series....... Yall should do more where the client gets to come in and judge
I really liked how they broke down why each video was good, but also breaking down as to why they liked the videos so much. It’s nice to hear from the perspective of someone who’s watching it for the first time. Overall; great video and would like to see more of this! 🙌🏽🔥
What i liked the most is the detailed judging, it makes focus on the hidden pionts on how to make a good ad short video , great jobs guys we are looking for more of this type of videos
This is such a great series. Please keep these coming
Almost wish you both created a more similar style ad and both shot in the same format, because at the moment it felt like Alyssa’s video was higher in production value, just due to the nature that you chose to shoot your ad, which felt like a value added cutdown for social. Personally I would’ve liked if the styles were both in the same ballpark, shot in landscape, just so it’s an actual comparable scenario. I would’ve also liked to see if the client went in blind, not knowing who shot which video, select the one he would use.
I am learning so much from these! Amazing work!
both are amazing in their own way. Alyssa's felt like a youtube ad that's cool, and Jake's tiktok commercial was great too. i love these vids
Big brain move there. Not only do you have an amazing video for FTF, you also convinced everyone who watched this to go buy a water bear😂
Why just why you dummies
The audio for Alyssa’s reminded me a bit of a workplace instructional video
Both of you make a fantastic infomercial video about the cleaning product. The first video is good to use on TV, TH-cam and Websites as advertisements that attract future buyers. The second video is perfect for any social media, which the client wants to recognize and to endorse.
Honestly I didn’t like Jake’s editing. Showing the same shot 6 times with the phone in the hand flipping, going straight to that shot at the beginning and then he repeats exactly the same shot with the screen dirty. And at the end Again closing with the same shot for third time…
wow... I feel enlightened here, thank you so much for educating about various aspects of videography. I really like your videos
It's quite funny because I have an opposite opinion. If I see a "candid" ad on social media, I immediately stop watching because it feels cheap and scammy but if I see a "landscape professional" ad, I stay engaged and watch the whole thing.
both are great !!! First one is a commercial, second one is for social media
I like these kind of videos because the beginner asks the pro the type of questions id like to know the answer to.
Those types of videos are always great and always inspire me to learn more and more 😍
Amazing content literally what I needed to get back into videography
Both of you did awesome job
Both videos are amazing and tremendous.
That was really a eye opener. Both advertisements were wonderful. It just goes to show, $50,000 cameras and equipment don't make a winning campaign, but learning your craft does. We all have cameras now and can do the impossible with the smallest setup. Great video for learning.
Facts, u got budget cameras these days for like 500-600$ that are insane and in 4K. Saying that means quality of the video is no longer a question, its gonna be superb. What remains is how good you are at production and post production. Lovely times we live in for to be a video amateur
both ads are great, but jakes ad is superior because you can literary watch it without any audio and still get what's being sold.
Great job with this comparison. I loved it. Thank you
Amazing and very informative video. Keep it going guys💪
Love to watch your video, I learned many lessons from you guys. Thanks!
Alyssa did incredible! I would have assumed she was doing this for 3+ years with that video.
That was a super bowl level clip. The blonde guy had any talent at all (the editing was terrible)
@@dieterrosswag933 I agree with you so much. It looked like it was done by a typical 15 year old girl with a circular selfie lamp. We could see tons on this in shorts. I would never pay a pro to deliver to me such a product. Alyssa’s was great though.
@@hamfromburger btw why are ppl calling him "her"?
Wow, that was so interesting and inspiring!! Thank you for that great content! Best regards from Germany ♥
Came here to learn more about filmmaking, left with a Waterbear in my cart.
Would have started off commercial by having the cinema lens really smuged up, and he cleans it up with his product, then introduces himself lol
Jared - I am Cary Decker and I am stealing that idea. Haha that’s ingenious. I’ll call it the Jared Meche hook.
@@carydecker1491 Haha, this made my night. Good luck with everything!
Well done, Jake with an iphone and reflector....crazy good. The main star though is Waterbear, great product!!!!
We loved this experiment!! Well done to both parties!! 👍
THE COLORS, the whites are amazing and the highlights are smooth even in the sun with hard shadows . it's a pleasure to look at
Alyssa’s video is perfect for a TH-cam ad and Jake’s is perfect for a TikTok ad! Together these ads are an amazing package to give a client!
I would love to see this format of video but with a short film. Like having to create a script, and actors, and having to use your filmmaking to make the best short film.
Just the video I wanted to see! Thank you!
you have NO idea what seeing this means to me, today I finished my full time job as a photographer to set up a commercial video company over here in the UK... thanks for the video, you have a new subscriber..
As soon as I heard the TikTok voice on Jake's, I was like "nope nope nope". Alyssa's video is way better imo
This was a fantastic video. I agree with all points made
Parker, I absolutely love your videos, I shot my first wedding video last weekend, and fortunately it went well thans to you and your team. I was wondering if you an make video about unhappy clients or any difficulties you faced with clients, and how you dealt with those situations, thank you😁
Y’all should make more videos like this, plus adding the editing process
Yess! more content like this please! we need it
BTW Thankyou for bringing this video Peter, just bought 2 sets of this cleaner 😀👌
This was great. Both videos work great, just on different platforms.
Since it was used for social media, it was better shot in portrait mode and not landscape mode. Both videos looked good, it’s helpful to show the practical use and ability of a product in a video.
I think the bigger question becomes;
Will the client even give you a chance if you show up to film with a cell phone
Dude! I liked Alyssa best!
Crazy.
I felt Jake’s was a little repetitive visually.
But there were some tidbits I would take from Jake’s. Like the re-sticking of the cleaning pad.
But as a viewer I would have left Jake’s add as soon as I heard the Siri voice at the beginning.
I can’t stand the generic robot voice that EVERYONE uses. So not authentic.
The next eject moment for me was the second he repeated a shot.
So as a person being marketed to…. I would have left that video within 2 seconds.
Alyssa’s video kept me stimulated through the end and it seemed to end so fast that I wanted more.
I couldn’t wait for Jake’s video to end.
Sorry Jake. I love your work. But this one was a miss for me.
You raise good points tho
@@emilyesnyman thanks Emily
Great stuff! Jake really needed an ND filter on that iphone! But for a social media ad that's all candid, it's great!
The beginner's video is amazing simple short and all in one go.
Wow, what an amazing comparison. We need more videos like this👍
I love this series.
Jake alway best.
I really like the content of the film making❤
As a advertising student I have to say that, I'm amazed. Both of the ads are amazing, you have made greate ads, both of you. For me Alyssa's add is amazing, but Jake made what the client wanted and that is the point. Alyssa didn't make and add that the client wanted which was a social media add. Her first step should be "recognising" what the devices are mainly used for those, and the answer to that are cell phones. So your work "surface" is a lot smaller becose it isn't a horizontal screen, but a vertical mainly, her add would be good for TV or TH-cam, if you would cropp it to fit for lets say TikTok you would loose a lot of footage.
Really enjoyed this episode. I liked how you got clients opinion instead of yourself and Parker’s. Do more of these, it helps a lot.
You guys should make a 10 tips video of how to practice filming and what to do to improve and make your film/videos/movies better
Very interesting to watch as usual!. Jake's video is very self-explanatory and cool for sure, BUT next time how about if you guys try not to tell the final judge who the PRO is and who the BEGINNER is (from the beginning). Because sometimes, PRO word itself may change the perception of the person about the final work.
I think that her video is more like an ad on TH-cam, before your video plays or an dedicated ad in your stories between stories. His video is more like a random video posted on TikTok, which is basically an ad, but not posted as an ad so you have it in feed. So booth would be great for socials, but different approaches and settings
Woooow alyssa did a great job
Filmmaking vs Communication are two different crafts. You need both!
Nahhhhhh man Alyssa killed it great job. They both have their use, and platforms they could go on. But the fact that Alyssa picked a camera a year ago for the first time, I'm proud of her.
Jake's video looks like the type of video they use for scams XD.
It just needed the "invented in the military "
hahaha totally agreed
Yeah, I don’t see that as an “hip ad” I see it as a scam product that’s not worth a second more of my time, especially with that terrible voice over voice.
Love these videos
Im a beginner and decided to start my channel using a iPhone 13 pro max with a Kenko 0,75X pro series lens and i am very happy with the results.
Its very simple to use and can do everything on my phone including all the editing.I use Luma Fusion.
Ha, same here great minds think alike! It’s refreshing to know that truly it comes down to knowing basics and then applying them.
both did a super amazing job.
We want this kind of videos from you guys
Jake smashed it. Brilliant video!
They were both great! Now I need some Waterbears!
BOTH LOOKED PRO! Couldn’t even tell who was the beginner or pro. Well done 👏🏽
This is the best channel on video production edit EVER!
beginner is superb bravo clean work
Those videos fit different purposes and were different styles, both executed well I think