Very great conversation! Good points. Unfortunately wrong on the cause.. not the war is the reason. It's reason Arabs waged War on Israelis. It's Islamic Ideology. They won't get rid of it, no matter what Israel is doing in the future and as long there are several Tribes with Islamic Ideology or influence by Iran. It has to change with Leaders or external Rulers of the Arabs in Palestinian.
but that is not true since recent palestinian are fake, they came with turkish from different races and called them selves palestinians recently , real palestinian are another group most of them orthodox jews and christians . i think rudy is zionist and has different agenda against Israel . think about it
@@remy6968 In Gaza doing what? This is meaningful because he is speaking to people who protest and care about Israel and Palestine outside of Gaza and trying to talk and make a difference with them there. How would being in Gaza help at all?
israelis teach their kids that palestinians are human animals. Israel has subjugated palestinians for 76 years. Palestinians live under occupation in the west bank and under siege and bombardment in gaza.
@@rank1132 Even if all universities in the world protester against or for, there will always be problems there.. There are religious problems that are the root of all of this. Unless Islam reforms its religion to become more tolerant towards other religions, there will never be peace there. Even if Israel wasn't there at all, they would start fighting each other.
This is so beautiful, I’m a Muslim and I really appreciate you Rudy for constantly advocating for peace and calling for an understanding between Israelis and Palestinians where they can mutually co-exist and allowing for a platform to hear both sides of the story. You are amazing ❤️
Jews are brothers Palestinians and Jews are cousins No greater tragedy than when family fights Let us move forward together as Churchill once said One day we will have peace
@@giovanninaranjo1421 Well.. Gjengis khan is also at fault for disrupting the cultures of asia and central Asia.. but we don't blame him now do we? Move on from historical faults, that way you get faster peace.
Cannot happen unless the Justice is Paid & the seed of The power of Peace & love is given, so that you , the individuals, are changed in your heart as was Kamal Saleem and Afshin Javid, & Tass Saada, and messianic Jews. Ezekiel 3626. THIS IS NOT JUST FOR INTERNATIONAL relations, but family and neighbours, who are suffering lack of peace & love. All nations have internal conflict & abuse. Medication, religion & good intentions have no lasting strength. We need to respond to The God of Mercy, Justice & have personal relationship with Him, who sent Jesus Jn.18v37. Those mentioned above explain on youtube. GOD did nOt create us to be separated from Him eternally. IF YOU DON'T RESPOND AS GOD SAYS, THROUGH TRANSFORMED LIVES, then you are rejecting His proofs of His word and the Warnings within His Word.
I never realized how good the feeling of peace is. It's like a drug. If everyone could feel this, especially those causing issues these days, it would be amazing. Let's share our vision of peace with as many people as possible, let's get them hooked.
@lucymax2178 by prevail I mean prevail from the current crisis both in gaza and inbetween the Israelis, when I say "Israel will prevail" I mean Israel will come to know better times than what we experience today
This is what we need more of. Palestinians and Israelis talking it out. I’m tired of watching woke Karens chanting about a cause they have no stake in.
Lol Talking it out. Are you for real. Would you have said that to the Jews that experienced the Holocaust , to talk it out with the Nazis and Hitler, no you would not , so do not ask Palestinians to do that either. Put Israel in Haag , that is the talk out that is needed for this 76 years of Brutal Oppression to STOP
I think you're misunderstanding what he's saying. He's not saying that we should just open the floodgate and make the proverbial "one state solution". He's saying that in order for there to be peace, there needs to be a dissolution of the competing national narratives. There needs to be a situation where both national narratives are seen as non-contradictory and symbiotic. This is a mental shift which will take a long time to reach, which is why he's saying step 1 is to simply begin to see eachother as family.
@@trollnerd indeed, the only challenge, however how to fight said narratives. Being israeli Rudy can, at least, freely travel through Israel proper spreading his message, but how to reach for the palestinians? Not saying that it is impossible, but both governmental repression and the population's reaction to an isreali spreading such message in their territory (on the streets) may put him in danger. As he said, palestinians have no freedom of speech, and without it spreading a message of peace is much harder. As for convincing israelis there is still the chalenge of convincing them to look after the needs of people who they consider as terrorists. The israeli settlers in West Bank are, to me, the worst when it comes to embracing this worldview, and as terrorism continues to be practiced, more and more israelis feel desiluded of such possibility. In their minds they did all they could to live in peace, but the violence didn't stop, so they gradually get radicalized. Fighting against this flow (that exists on both sides) is extremely dificult, specially when you can barely comunicate to "the other side". I honestly hope Rudy can grow this movement evermore, because it is defenetelly needed.
@@trollnerd, good synopsis. If the work starts now, it could be accomplished for next generation. The Hamas schools of indoctrination would have to go. I saw an interview with an Arab journalist who was saying that based on her talks with many Arab citizens of Gulf States, they are tired of all the wars and want to find a way to peace. She said they are fighting terrorists groups in their own countries and are sick of them. So what is left? Islamic State of Iran (not the people, the regime), Hamas, and Hezbollah (she said most citizens of Lebanon want them out, look at what they have done to that beautiful country). These are the ones that affect the Palestinians and Israelis. The Houthis, ISIS, etc., are for the Arab states to deal with. She said a big problem now is that when the Arab countries kick them out, they go to Europe, the US and other Democratic countries and bring their hate with them. The West is going to have to step up in that regard. They are starting too, but have a long way to go. They are now indoctrinating the youth of the West.
He is showing himself to be the best of the Israeli and Jewish people, and an outstanding human being on top of that, which we all can take inspiration from, Jew and non-Jew alike.
Rudy, I am proud to have you as my Jewish brother. I have so much respect for what you are doing. I come to your channel and LISTEN because this, this my friend is truth. You are doing the world a Mitzvah. May Adonai continue to guide you on this path of Mashiach. Warm regards, Your American Jewish Brother 🇺🇸
Most times Rudy usually has peaceful chats with Palestinians and the rare ones will be aggressive. I have never seen Rudy lose his calm and that is what I like about him. He truly seeks to bridge the gap; very rare!!!
Most Palestinans in the West Bank, not the refugee ones, have high Jewish DNA. My wife is from Hebrew, and she is Muslim. Her Jewish DNA is high. That was shoking! I am from Lod, and I have 54% Levant, 5% Arabs, 19% Egyptian, and the rest are Anadolyan and Greek with zero Jewish DNA. People from cities in the Mediterranean Sea have low Jewish DNA, but those in the West Bank have high Jewish DNA. It is sad to know that Palestinians from the West Bank and Israelis fight and kill each other, and they both have very similar DNA. Both have Jewish DNA. Same Ancesteris, who converted to Christianity under threat from the Christian Creek Empire and then to Islam.
@@mujemoabraham6522 I am not talking about religions here; people in this land have similar DNA. Palestinan in the West Bank has a high Jewish DNA. They may have a higher Jewish DNA than the Jews from Poland. I am not trying to be racist, but that may be a fact. Most Jews were forced to change their religion when the Christian Empire controlled the region, then Islam took over, and most converted to Islam. People in Hewbew have a similar culture to Jews, and they protected Abraham's tomb for centuries before Israel was established in 1948. Think about why they protected the tomb for centuries. Their Arabic accent is super funny. They cannot speak Arabic like other Palestinians.
@@amaren133I know exactly what you are talking about! There are people with the DNA, and a religion. I’m Christian, and there is no DNA for that, but there absolutely is for J*w*sh people. You can have J*wish DNA and be a Christian or whatever. I was shocked when I saw mine too! It’s a mix of random stuff. I have heard people say J*wish people have larger noses, and you wouldn’t have a trait like that without DNA. I don’t know if that is true, but I have heard it.
@@joanmikeska8484 I have big nose and have zero Jewish DNA My wife has high Jewish DNA and has small nose Don’t know why people always says that Jews has big noses! I don’t know maybe Jews where living in Eastern Europe have big noses I have no idea!
@joanmikeska8484 Jews are uniquely both a physical and spiritual nation, so you can join by converting and automatically are 100% Jewish forever, Abraham and Sara become your forebears. Conversion to Judaism is very serious; candidates for conversion are committing themselves forever to acceptance of the Torah as the immutable word of G-d. Jews who marry out or convert to other faiths are still Jews, both by genetics and spiritually, because our covenant with G-d is forever, where we live it or not.
Videos like this, and people like you and Osama give me so much hope for the future. It's so nice to see an educated and respectful discussion in what has become a sea of hatred and ignorance. I'm Jewish, and I'm a Zionist, and all I want is peace for all, Palestinians and Israelis alike. Together we can heal the world. Am Yisrael Chai ❤
That's the difference, two intelligent and educated people who care more for life and what could be. The sad thing that's not the norm for the average Gazan, not only are they generationally brainwashed and do not value this life the hatred for Jews has been drilled into them. Hamas enforces this as well. The Arab nations the Palestinians have betrayed aren't keen on having them around either.
People like him are blatant naive idiots. The "cousin" is talking to is an idf soldier, i mean literally he was in the front line in the gaza invasion....
I agree with the right of return to be seen as valid as the Zionist belief, I think Israel has the responsibility to rebuild Gaza but I can’t agree on the reparations as that never works imo. I think there needs to be an influx of community support from the other side.
@@ryanberkowitz5399 what is the “other side”. So what do we do with all the Israeli’s living in the literal houses of Palestinians? The villages and towns that were turned into “wooded areas” are fairly simple right? Just rebuild, but many of the Palestinian communities were either built on top of or had Zionist immigrants moved into the literal house of an ethnically cleaned. How does this rite of return look? Full citizenship to all Palestinians in the diaspora? And btw, Germany has paid 87 billion to Holocaust survivors in reparations. They also returned 16,000 luted objects. Can we expect that towards the Palestinians? I as a us citizen know we will be footing much of the bill as we do for Israel.
In the past 6 months, I have learned more about my Jewish Heritage and our right to self-determination in our ancestral homeland than I have in the past 6 years! And I have people like Rudy to thank for it!! AM YISRAEL CHAI 🇮🇱
@@khadijahbegum3546 her ancestors have been in europe for 2000 years its good time period for such population to evolve and adapt to their new environment europe has low temp and sun exposure which means if a middle eastern had tanned skin and decided to immigrate to europe and his descendants kept living there they will eventually evolve and show white skin color
but that is not true since recent palestinian are fake, they came with turkish from different races and called them selves palestinians recently , real palestinian are another group most of them orthodox jews and christians . i think rudy is zionist and has different agenda against Israel . think about it
@@mujemoabraham6522 Search, *_"The Y Chromosome Pool of Jews as Part of the Genetic Landscape of the Middle East"_* November 2001, Nebel et al, _Am Journal of Human Genetics_
I am north african and i learned that i have a similar dna with people living in canary island. I surely didn't go there, formed extremist groups and colonized canary island and changed it's name all while white washing everything 😂
Yeah, he comes from a lovely place but they do not, only the ones that managed to get away, get educated and live away from the Arab mindset will care enough for peace and living side by side with people that have hated Jews for generations. I think it can happen just not there and not for a long time.
@@hannahanderson4305…..ones like Mosab Yousef; after all he is the son of one of Hamas founders. But Rudy takes the more diplomatic approach while Mosab just wants to take out Hamas so that both the Palestinians and Israel can live a better sense of security! Hamas is literally the ones holding the Palestinians hostages as they need them to shield from the IDF. They were trying to flee but Hamas kept sending them back or shooting them! Where is the outcry from the protesters then???! Not one word!
I now agree, I didn't know the extent of effort and hope in the peace camp in the 90s or maybe in the 80s. Israelis hoping for a good land for peace deal that everyone could accept. Then Einar Wilf describe the great disappointment that Arafat walked away. No prominent Palestinians objected to him walking away. Next, the intifada, the riots the stabbings the bombings the murder, AS THE RESPONSE TO SINCERE PEACE NEGOTIATIONS. I also loosely believed that Islam was like Christianity or the Jewish religion. I did not know that there were more verses committed to killing Jews than the number of anti-jewish versus in Hitler's Mein Kampf. Just a few months ago, I wouldn't have noticed because I didn't read it in the news, Apostate Prophet pointed out that Abbas in the West Bank ordered Islamic clerics to begin emphasizing the Gharqad Tree verse, which few Jews know about but every Muslim has been taught since childhood. It's a prophecy from Muhammad about annihilating the Jews, Sura 2922 in Sahih Muslim, meaning an authoritative source. That is a hump that is difficult to get over, culturally, though anything is possible.
I loved this conversation and both people's input. It really seems like both want real peace. We need more people speaking about and sharing this wisdom. I wonder if Rudy would do this same spiel with some of the Israeli settlers living in the West Bank: to help them understand that Palestinians are their cousins, not their enemies. I would love to watch that video.
Salaam and Shalom. God bless you. Sharing this video to people I know. May there be peace and love between Jews and Muslims, Israelis and Palestinians. Inshallah. Moshe was Israelite. His Zeporrah was Ishamilite. Both descents of Avraham/Ibrahim. May wisdom and love prevail. Amen.
I love your vision of the future Rudy. You’re a great man for what you’re trying to do. I hope one day it really does turn out that way. As skeptical as I am about it, I still truly hope it happens.
as an Indian, Israel-Palestine fells more complex than India-Pakistan best of luck guys peace ✌and thanks Late British empire for this mess Edit: Thank you for the likes, everyone. By the way, the "complex" terms I've used are subjective to me; they may be different in your views. I mentioned this because it's common to see Indians and Pakistanis working together in other countries with few or no problems, even on the internet, appreciating each other. However, I've observed that many Palestinian people have hatred towards Israelis which maybe justifiable for them and their opinion, and perhaps the same might be true on the other side, which is not morally right. We need to agree on certain grey areas that lead to peace, even if it may sound's unjust, as it is likely the most truthful path compared to other three options mentioned by Mr. Rudy. And I love the modern British people and I've mention their old empire not the modern people.
Radical Islam has it out for Jews, Christians, and incompatible Muslims throughout the world, but sure, let’s blame the late British Empire and only the late British Empire for radical Islam’s inability to tolerate a Jewish state in Judea. It’s always the West’s fault.
India Pakistan isn't complicated at all. That is 2 separate peoples who received their own lands. Muslims cannot live with idol worshipers. It's written in the Qur'an. Either we follow God or we follow individualism. Individualism is evil. Look at what individualism has done to western society. Israel Palestine is more complicated because there is only 1 land and 2 peoples. And the Jews believe in individualism.
It is far more complicated. The Mandate for Palestine was not a Colony, and yet the British broke basic International Laws that put the Mandatory under their governance by treating it as such. Their national policies caused huge amounts of Jewish Death while they were appeasing Arab Nations in exchange for Suez Access, and Oil. They sought to sabotage the mandated People of the Western Side of the Mandatory, while playing Patron to the Arab side. They were even part of the Jordanian Arab Legion when the Arab League attacked the brand new Israel.
Thank you Rudy for speaking the words of peace and love that many Israelis, just like you and me feel. My teacher Thich Nhat Hanh facilitated retreats where Israelis and Palestinians practice mindfulness together, helping them calm their emotions and listen deeply to each other. One of his methods was to focus on looking beyond labels and seeing each other as fellow human beings, cultivating empathy and compassion to each other. You are doing it here so beautifully. Very inspiring. Thank you!
but that is not true since recent palestinian are fake, they came with turkish from different races and called them selves palestinians recently , real palestinian are another group most of them orthodox jews and christians . i think rudy is zionist and has different agenda against Israel . think about it
They blamed us the British throughout this interview or debate whatever it is we should withdraw our support for either side and let them sort themselves out everyone is sick and tired of their fighting
yea because Gaza doesn't even have the most basic services like sewers, and the reason for that is the Isreal blockade plus many Palestinians at least had a single person from their family killed by isrealies soldiers or were arrested by isrealies soldiers keep in mind that over 80% of the Palestinian hostages taken by Isreal are minors and it was proved several times by many journalists, news channels and documents that most of them didn't commit any crimes, so you kill people, you blow up their houses and blow up their friends and family, you give them poor service and then you ask why they hate you?, and as I said above there are Arabs who live at Isreal and don't try to act like they got the same rights as isrealies they get far less rights but they get basic services like sewers, education and medical treatments, and there are no isrealies in Palestine because they don't even have the basic services and they will be kicked out the second they put their legs in.
I will say this as clearly as possible, I believe that the majority of people in the world think that the Israelis/Jews are a wise people, "the people of the book", so listen to this, as a Jew who represents a lot of Israelis and Arabs who are my neighbors, I am 100 percent sure that if the day comes when you stand up The State of Palestine on the entire territory of Israel, the amount of people who will die from wars between the Arab tribes who lived/live here will be catastrophic, I am begging the world to save human lives, think about who should be supported, in order to save human lives, and check objectively with all the facts, the truth. To all the freaks who shout in the world "free plasticine", come ask my Arab Muslim neighbors, if they want to live under the rule of Hamas in Gaza, or under the Palestinian Authority in Israel (or any Arab country in the Middle East), they will be willing to do anything to stay under the State of Israel, so before you beg for something for someone else, ask him.)❤️🇮🇱💪💪💪
5 million people suffering in Gaza and the West Bank from Israeli oppression and subjugation of their everyday life. And those 2 million Arabs in Israel can vote but are treated as 2nd class citizens. sure living in Israel as an arab is better than living in Syria or Yemen.
I'm not your neighbor, but can definitely confirm what you said. I don't think people realize that according to polls most of us are pro Israel, and that feeling only increased after October 7th. We might hate the current government, but the country overall is pretty good. It's not perfect, but it's home.
@@khaledassaf6356 im glad to hear an arab saying it... because let's be honest israel is best country in the middle east.... where all people can work study eat live buy things and all are equal.. of course israel has problem like any other country in the world! the problem is both people dont have that one pesron that can really be trusted and lead the community! hamas or pa not really a legit government... and in israel you don't have better options then bibi.... like all other are also clowns in terms of whos runing for PA
You blame the resistance but you are blind to the slavery that's on going. You want to live together but you continue the status quo. They started with throwing rocks, now rockets, God know what they will start to make to be just free. Don't blame the freedom fighters. Blame the people who have the power to correct this insanity. You know the saying with power comes responsibility.... What I can assure you guys is, if the tables were turned, the Jews, Israelis will be taken care of with equal rights. Jews need to get over their insecurities after their terrible past. Muslims, Arabs, Palestinians were never the culprit or their enemy. Besides we/they are one family.
This shows, when you have 2 people discussing and respecting each other you can get things done. Thank you Rudy and Hassan for showing how life could be . A lot of work out there for the Israeli government and the Palestinians - getting rid of hamas and other terrorists and then working together . I was In Israel for a month in March this year and was balled over by the Israelis ( Jews, Arabs, Druze, Bedouins, etc ) living together . Thank you both for your humanity !
You are amazing!!! Thank you for representing so many of us Jews that are too afraid to take action. May you continue to spread awareness in both parties, Jews and Palestinians and we will be united and live in peace and harmony!
well said, he was also not letting Rudy off which is good cause Rudy then had more ways to dive into the deeoper stuff which he dosent say by heart already. It was different in a good way, creating a deeper convo, well done by both.
אחד הסרטונים החשובים ביותר בהסטוריה של ההסברה על ה'קונפליקט'!!! תענוג צרוף לראות ולשמוע את שניכם בשיחה המופלאה נעימה וראויה הזו!!! ישר כח ענק!!!! תודה רבה :)
Rudy - You need to debate Israelis who disagree with you about treating Palestinians and Israelis equally, in right of return and all aspects of life (if that is really what you believe should happen)?
Totally agree. As he says in this video, Israelis hold the power right now. It's just as important, if not more important for him to be speaking to the hardline Israelis who don't want or think it's possible to have a free Palestinian people. I want to believe what he says is possible, but just changing the hearts and minds of Palestinians isn't going to achieve it. We need to see what the hardline Israelis say in response to his spiel just as much as we need to see what Palestinians say.
You are a beacon of hope in an otherwise bleak reality. For a long time I’ve felt change has to start with us individuals, and it’s a huge inspiration seeing you put that ideology into action
Dear Rudy, thank you for your work and commitment! It is so valuable that people like you stand up for open dialogues. Option 4 is the path we should take!
רודי יקר, אתה מקסים באמת, ואומר כמה וכמה דברי חכמה. אבל גם אופטימיות יתר עלולה להביא לטעות.. יש הרבה אי דיוקים היסטוריים במה שאתה אומר. צריך ללמוד את החברה הערבית בצורה יותר מרובדת. יש שם הרבה בעיות קשות ברמת החינוך מילדות- לשנאת יהודים, לשנאת 'כופרים' והערצה למעשי רציחה, רצח על בסיס 'כבוד' וכו'. זה הרבה יותר מורכב מאיך שאתה מציג את הדברים. אבל עדיין, כוונתך יפה. אז מאחלת לך הצלחה
This is good. All UN representatives should watch to learn what a productive conversation looks like. Unfortunately, change is the hardest option and there is another greater problem which is the remaining Muslim countries surrounding Israel that also hate Jews.
Why verus? The Quran supports the Torah. (Quran 5:44) Surely We revealed the Torah, wherein there is guidance and light. Thereby did Prophets - who had submitted themselves (to Allah) -
@@jonnyblunt4755 Yes, you are right, although it is also true that the conflicts were exacerbated, but that may have more to do with the disappearance of an empire that brought them together. The same thing happened in Eastern Europe during those same years, or in Latin America when the Spanish empire fell. Still, with the number of times blatant lies were used to sow hatred and justify barbarism, I wouldn't mind if a lie helped bring about peace.
I disagree , hamas ideal are derived from muslim brotherhood. Fundamental groups exist without america or israels existence. This pattern can be observed if you study history .
I am so glad we can agree that Israel as an apartheid nation needs to be abolished and replaced by a secular, unifying government where people of all religions have equal rights and coexist peacefully. As someone who has identified as anti-zionist, I have never heard this definition of zionism. I absolutely agree that Jews should be able to live in Jerusalem, so long as they do not subjugate another peoples while they do so. From this day forth, I am a proud zionist!
I still think is not an open air prison. Every country has boarders, some are wide open to cross and others are very guarded. Border with Mexico and the US is very guarded and crossing it you have to have the proper documentation and you can wait at least 3 hours on a regular day. On a busy/holiday it can take you 6 or more hours. Also, they check your car as well, so should I say the US it’s treating everyone who crosses inhumane?!
Beautiful stuff Rudy. I hope there peace some day n that it's soon. If more people like you two n they get involved I see peace. God Bless both of you. And your right about who cause this tragic mess. Love from Canada
The Israeli and Palestinian people are fighting the same dynamics as us Indigenous Turtle Islanders. Both the Canadian and United States do their best to keep us Indigenous Turtle Islanders fighting amongst one another. This has to end, and we need to work together for a better world for our children's children. I say this not only for Indigenous Turtle Islanders but for the people of the middle east.
Its really difficult to understand how any semi educated person can listen to this chat and not hear a solution and a guy who has love for both sets of people. YET, you see him elsewhere bring called a racist and being attacked by campus clowns who dont want to hear his words. This is the solution for Israel/Palestine.
2:17 We had or almost had it cousin....... 1995 Arafat and Rabin 😢😢😢 we can only wish for it again....... Another Israeli leader and Palestinian (Moderate one not from Hamas) that both have the same hearts as those two men bada bing bada boom you got your peace treaty!!!!
And this is how a protest should look like, have your freedom of speech, but be able to talk to people who don’t agree with you. Justice for Palestinians is not the destruction of Israel, it’s the ability to live together and accepting the right of each other to live a peaceful and dignified life.
This idea that jews are europeans is so false, there are lighter toned peoples across the middle east, like Persian people, and the jews who have gone back from europe mostly came from east europe and most definitely dont look slavic or scandanavian.
@@miemie-uh3gv but i am asking as human from you i am not palestiane i am from Pakistan 🇵🇰 so my question is that before the attack of hamas why Israeli police and idf harassment Muslim man and Woman in the holy place Bait ul maqadus why they don’t allow Muslims for prayer why they arrest Muslims and killed even Muslim have no weapons and not other things except only for praying
@@miemie-uh3gv i also not in fever in that if hamas killed innocent means public but can you condemn the killing of innocent child man’s woman. I don’t read in any book that someone attacks school and hospital except Natun yaho he say hamas are present in Al shifa hospital if any terror present in the hospital or schools you have don’t permission to attack this places what about the more than 35k public what about the generalist and reporter even Israeli attack on UN people
@@miemie-uh3gv i also not in fever if the going to against public in Ukraine, if the war against public in Israel,if the war against public in Ghaza, or any part of the world if the public belongs to Muslims, Jews or christans or any other religious because it is the the order of our religion Islam that protects human everywhere in the world and i think the same in every religion order to support humanity
Rudy always speaks sense and with respect. As a British Jew, I’m sad to say that I didn’t realise that my government was so involved (negatively) in all this 😢 keep spreading the positive energy rudy, my brother
Idk about religious jews but many secular jews (they are about 50% of the Israeli population) will agree with him on almost everything he said in this video@@TalkAboutPalestine
Rudy.. we israelies do not believe in peace anymore. Not because we don't want peace, but because we realised the other side will never want real peace.
Peace has not been truly offered on the table in decades, though. That was his point. And he is right that by over-scrutinizing the past we cannot see a future...US and Vietcong vets now share lunch with each other, it is not impossible to imagine such a reality. He himself is an Israeli who believes in peace...
Shalom Rudy. As an ethnically Jewish, non religious American, I really appreciate that you take the time to have civil discussions with the other side. It’s hard for people to imagine Israelis want peace but in essence, that is who they are. They’ve won just about every war they fought, gained land in Egypt, returned that land to Egypt. I don’t know how many moderate Palestinians there are out there, but if you exist, please let your voice be heard!
@@DDCharles-zf5ye Very true. Family may argue and fight and even disband at times, but right down to our blood, we will always be family, and somewhere deep in our blood, the love for one another will exist forever. Let us heal our broken hearts. 🇮🇱❤️🩹🇵🇸
As an Israeli, it's so refreshing and heartwarming to see this peacful palestinian young man. I wish Rudy's dream will come true and both population can live together in peace and harmony, I wish it's not just a fantasy as it seams nowdays 😢
Rochman, your ancient Israelite land claims are just silly. Innumerable cultures, kingdoms and empires, big and small have existed throughout the history of humanity. ALL OF US alive today are descendants of individuals who inhabited those cultures, kingdoms and empires. Does that give ALL OF US rights (or at least some rights) to the land of those ancient cultures, kingdoms and empires? Or are land rights based upon other concepts like continuous inter-generational occupancy and things like (legitimate) purchases, rent or even just human need? The Israelites from some (relatively short-lived) kingdoms were dispossesed a few thousand years ago. Do Zionists or anyone practicing or converting to Judaism today around the world have more than just imaginary ties with them? Even if Israelis could prove a certain percentage of DNA relatedness, your 23andme ancestry report is not a land deed, and it certainly doesn’t entitle you to anybody’s house or paid mortgage. If my 23andMe ancestry results say that I have some percentage Mongolian ancestry, that doesn’t give me the right to reclaim the Mongol Empire and take somebody’s home in China or Russia where that empire was. Like I said earlier, everyone’s DNA is from a human past which was replete with (now long gone) cultures, kingdoms and empires. Imagine all the complications that would ensue if we traced everyone’s ancestors and tried to allocate some land rights they had based on that past, which probably involved different occupancies of the same land by different peoples and civilizations during different millenia. And how far back would we go? Could we include the longest period of Homo Sapiens existence-human prehistory- where humans were hunter gatherers? Even if we restricted these “land rights” to the “civilized” neolithic period, ALL modern nations today would have to cede some land rights to people from other nations because all modern nations exist on the land of previous cultures, kingdoms and empires- whose human descendants are all over the place. It’s comical to even attempt the thought experiment Even more so if we tried to allocate these land rights based on how much people’s beliefs approximate to those who occupied those ancient cultures, kingdoms and empires. Imagine I convert to Mongolian shamanism today. An ancient version of it. In that act of conversion, do Mongolians become my ancestors? Do I gain rights to their ancient land? Of course not The Mesopotamian civilizations worshipped the sun god Shamash. Imagine I convert to their Mesopotamian religion and become a sun worshiper. In that act of conversion, do Mesopotamians become my ancestors? Do I gain rights to their ancient land (e.g. Iraq)? Of course not If I can’t claim Mongolian or Mesopotamian ancestry (or certainly land ) merely by converting to Mongolian shamanism or Sun worshipping, why should I be able to claim Israelite ancestry (or land) merely by converting to Judaism? A much stronger claim to land rights is continuous occupancy. The Arabs of Palestine had resided continuously in that area for over 1000 years. True, the census around the year 1800 shows that about 5000 individuals practicing Judaism (Jews) resided in Palestine (co existing with hundreds of thousands of Muslims and a minority of Christians). This minority of judaism-practicing individuals and their descendants did have continuous occupancy for a long time (as long as the Arabs as far as I’ve read). Of course, there’s nothing wrong with immigration of any kind so long as it does not infringe on the rights of the people already in the land- in the case of Palestine the large majority of Arabs whose rights were violated. Zionists immigrated into Palestine with the intent of expelling Arabs and taking over their land in an ethnically preferential state. The result was war and a horribly abusive apartheid, now culminating in genocide. Nevertheless, by virtue of continuous occupancy, inter-generational Israelis have now gained certain rights to the land. The international consensus is a Palestinian state in the whole of the West Bank and Gaza, which gives Israelis far more land than they deserve- 78% of the former Palestine. Since even the 1948 partition that provided 56% to Israel was grossly unjust, this 78% doesn’t reflect an approach based on justice, but a realistic partial acceptance of the historical principle of “might makes right”. Of course, partial acceptance is not enough for most Israelis, who demand 100% of the land and no Palestinian state from the Jordan river to the Mediterranean sea.
Typical propagandist mixing facts with falsehoods. Arabs have not lived on the land continuously. Many of the Arabs today are descendants from migrants who came to the land during the late era ottoman empire and British mandate.
Rudy, your communication skills are off the charts, and your videos are excellent, and give me hope that one day calm, rational people like you will, on both sides, come to a comprehensive agreement. I like in hope.
The people cannot change government, politics and economy gain. Plus you never explain how you over come the pure hate and hate teaching, making videos is a nice idea but you need 100,000,000 followers not 100,000 😢
Clear-sighted, peaceful, tolerant, patient, attentive, compassionate... you're an example to follow. I love it when you say that “the solution will come from the people”. Congratulations and good luck, because not everyone thinks like the people you're talking to in this video. You're right on the money. Even though I'm not Jewish, Israeli, Muslim or Palestinian, I'd love to talk with you.
As an Israeli I'm speechless that was beautiful and I wish we as people unite and stop all the wars my best friend is Muslim it's why it's so hard to see what going on in the media so much misconception may we find peace ✌️ soon.
bro ... this is what we needed... peaceful talk, no screaming, no insulting, no aggression... I applaud that Palestinian man....
His government don't like his idea😢
Cool. But as long as state of Israel exists Israelis will be dominant over Palestinians. It's a country built on supremacy. So new state is needed.
Very great conversation! Good points.
Unfortunately wrong on the cause.. not the war is the reason. It's reason Arabs waged War on Israelis. It's Islamic Ideology. They won't get rid of it, no matter what Israel is doing in the future and as long there are several Tribes with Islamic Ideology or influence by Iran. It has to change with Leaders or external Rulers of the Arabs in Palestinian.
See, you still take side
you and i both know most of the palestinians are not like him by a longshot. thats why we dont have these kinds of conversations too often.
Peace comes from people, not from extremist authorities... botton up, not top down 🇵🇸♥️🇮🇱🕊️
Amen 🇮🇱🤍🇵🇸🕊
but that is not true since recent palestinian are fake, they came with turkish from different races and called them selves palestinians recently , real palestinian are another group most of them orthodox jews and christians . i think rudy is zionist and has different agenda against Israel . think about it
💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯
Jews & Germans can be friends. Jews & Arabs can be friends. Jews & Muslims? Eh... Jews & Nazis? Eh....
its nice to see people talk without screaming at each other
This all meaningless he said care about palestine he should be in gaza
@@remy6968 In Gaza doing what? This is meaningful because he is speaking to people who protest and care about Israel and Palestine outside of Gaza and trying to talk and make a difference with them there. How would being in Gaza help at all?
Look at this conversation between two human beings rather than all the nonsense happening on university campuses
israelis teach their kids that palestinians are human animals. Israel has subjugated palestinians for 76 years. Palestinians live under occupation in the west bank and under siege and bombardment in gaza.
@@rank1132 Even if all universities in the world protester against or for, there will always be problems there.. There are religious problems that are the root of all of this. Unless Islam reforms its religion to become more tolerant towards other religions, there will never be peace there.
Even if Israel wasn't there at all, they would start fighting each other.
This is so beautiful, I’m a Muslim and I really appreciate you Rudy for constantly advocating for peace and calling for an understanding between Israelis and Palestinians where they can mutually co-exist and allowing for a platform to hear both sides of the story. You are amazing ❤️
first time I agree too as a Palestinian with this young man that's the way It should its the only solution for both nations 👏👏👏👏
🇮🇱❤🇵🇸 I agree we need to influence as many as we can to make everyone think this way my cousin! This is step 1 of option 4
Jews are brothers
Palestinians and Jews are cousins
No greater tragedy than when family fights
Let us move forward together as Churchill once said
One day we will have peace
Not as long there is Islam, this will never happen. Islam is not a tolerant religion. Unless it reforms there will never be peace.
The Occupation comes home - Max Blumenthal at UMass th-cam.com/video/0UjNd2kMAXI/w-d-xo.htmlsi=wEsLyzXJhyexMm5Z
The Real Origins of the Philistines and Palestinians th-cam.com/video/IEmMdBfD3OQ/w-d-xo.htmlsi=rQNTWZteKIO8-z4F
I think its funny you quote Churchill when a lot would argue that the British are at fault for this division of culture
@@giovanninaranjo1421 Well.. Gjengis khan is also at fault for disrupting the cultures of asia and central Asia.. but we don't blame him now do we? Move on from historical faults, that way you get faster peace.
Rudy needs an all star team to spread the word
His government don't like his idea😢
Why do you make this same reply to every comment on the video?
I'm in, I'd trek the world of middle East to dialogue with communities
This Jew will happily join that all-star team!!
But it doesn't involve the government. It has to start from the grassroots. Common citizens need to work together @remy6968
I wish the best for both Israelis and Palestinians ❤ heal the world
Mûslims can't coexist with non Mûslims because in Quran they clear to kill and convert non Muslims
@Azeezi1 God bless you too, azeezi. God will help Israel 🇮🇱
Amen 🇮🇱🤍🇵🇸🕊
Cannot happen unless the Justice is Paid & the seed of The power of Peace & love is given, so that you , the individuals, are changed in your heart as was Kamal Saleem and Afshin Javid, & Tass Saada, and messianic Jews. Ezekiel 3626. THIS IS NOT JUST FOR INTERNATIONAL relations, but family and neighbours, who are suffering lack of peace & love. All nations have internal conflict & abuse. Medication, religion & good intentions have no lasting strength.
We need to respond to The God of Mercy, Justice & have personal relationship with Him, who sent Jesus Jn.18v37. Those mentioned above explain on youtube. GOD did nOt create us to be separated from Him eternally.
IF YOU DON'T RESPOND AS GOD SAYS, THROUGH TRANSFORMED LIVES, then you are rejecting His proofs of His word and the Warnings within His Word.
I never realized how good the feeling of peace is. It's like a drug. If everyone could feel this, especially those causing issues these days, it would be amazing. Let's share our vision of peace with as many people as possible, let's get them hooked.
This video should blast and go viral, all jews and palestinians should hear this, I hope for peace so much man fuck all those wars(as an Israeli)
It's always one sided. Israelis want peace but Arabs don't.
W but wt^ is that name ur saying Israel will prevail as if Palestine isn’t meant to prevail be fr if u care about peace don’t support war
@lucymax2178 by prevail I mean prevail from the current crisis both in gaza and inbetween the Israelis, when I say "Israel will prevail" I mean Israel will come to know better times than what we experience today
Lucy are you a jew or Palestinian?
@@LeonGustaveStuart1899 try to guess
This is what we need more of. Palestinians and Israelis talking it out. I’m tired of watching woke Karens chanting about a cause they have no stake in.
Lol Talking it out. Are you for real. Would you have said that to the Jews that experienced the Holocaust , to talk it out with the Nazis and Hitler, no you would not , so do not ask Palestinians to do that either. Put Israel in Haag , that is the talk out that is needed for this 76 years of Brutal Oppression to STOP
Even though I do not share Rudy's optimism, I do encourage the calm and intellectual discussion.
I think you're misunderstanding what he's saying. He's not saying that we should just open the floodgate and make the proverbial "one state solution". He's saying that in order for there to be peace, there needs to be a dissolution of the competing national narratives. There needs to be a situation where both national narratives are seen as non-contradictory and symbiotic. This is a mental shift which will take a long time to reach, which is why he's saying step 1 is to simply begin to see eachother as family.
@@trollnerd indeed, the only challenge, however how to fight said narratives. Being israeli Rudy can, at least, freely travel through Israel proper spreading his message, but how to reach for the palestinians? Not saying that it is impossible, but both governmental repression and the population's reaction to an isreali spreading such message in their territory (on the streets) may put him in danger. As he said, palestinians have no freedom of speech, and without it spreading a message of peace is much harder. As for convincing israelis there is still the chalenge of convincing them to look after the needs of people who they consider as terrorists. The israeli settlers in West Bank are, to me, the worst when it comes to embracing this worldview, and as terrorism continues to be practiced, more and more israelis feel desiluded of such possibility. In their minds they did all they could to live in peace, but the violence didn't stop, so they gradually get radicalized. Fighting against this flow (that exists on both sides) is extremely dificult, specially when you can barely comunicate to "the other side". I honestly hope Rudy can grow this movement evermore, because it is defenetelly needed.
@@trollnerd, good synopsis. If the work starts now, it could be accomplished for next generation. The Hamas schools of indoctrination would have to go. I saw an interview with an Arab journalist who was saying that based on her talks with many Arab citizens of Gulf States, they are tired of all the wars and want to find a way to peace. She said they are fighting terrorists groups in their own countries and are sick of them. So what is left? Islamic State of Iran (not the people, the regime), Hamas, and Hezbollah (she said most citizens of Lebanon want them out, look at what they have done to that beautiful country). These are the ones that affect the Palestinians and Israelis. The Houthis, ISIS, etc., are for the Arab states to deal with. She said a big problem now is that when the Arab countries kick them out, they go to Europe, the US and other Democratic countries and bring their hate with them. The West is going to have to step up in that regard. They are starting too, but have a long way to go. They are now indoctrinating the youth of the West.
But guys he’s an IDF soldier. How hypocritical is that?
He is showing himself to be the best of the Israeli and Jewish people, and an outstanding human being on top of that, which we all can take inspiration from, Jew and non-Jew alike.
Keep spreading your messages of love and peace. Your voice is immensely valuable Rudy!
❤ Blessed be the Peacemakers........
Amen
That’s the scripture that came to mind! ❤
For they shall be called sons of God. I had thought of it too. Rudy is doing something incredible, speaking peacefully over this whole situation.
...for they shall be called sons of God ❤
They. Will inherit the earth ❤
This was so nice to see. Two mature adults having a conversation with mutual respect.
Rudy, I am proud to have you as my Jewish brother.
I have so much respect for what you are doing. I come to your channel and LISTEN because this, this my friend is truth. You are doing the world a Mitzvah.
May Adonai continue to guide you on this path of Mashiach.
Warm regards,
Your American Jewish Brother 🇺🇸
יישר כח אחינו... כיף גם לשמוע עוד קול פלסטיני שוחר שלום, זה תמיד נותן תקווה לעתיד משותף בשמחה ואחווה.
Peace everybody 🖖🇮🇱🇵🇸
מסכימה ומחזקת ❤
Most times Rudy usually has peaceful chats with Palestinians and the rare ones will be aggressive. I have never seen Rudy lose his calm and that is what I like about him. He truly seeks to bridge the gap; very rare!!!
Right on Rudy. Always being calm and controlled while expressing balanced facts and great aspirations.
בשום עתיד משותף לא תהיה שמחה או אחווה, צא מהקונספציה
On god
Most Palestinans in the West Bank, not the refugee ones, have high Jewish DNA. My wife is from Hebrew, and she is Muslim. Her Jewish DNA is high. That was shoking! I am from Lod, and I have 54% Levant, 5% Arabs, 19% Egyptian, and the rest are Anadolyan and Greek with zero Jewish DNA.
People from cities in the Mediterranean Sea have low Jewish DNA, but those in the West Bank have high Jewish DNA.
It is sad to know that Palestinians from the West Bank and Israelis fight and kill each other, and they both have very similar DNA. Both have Jewish DNA. Same Ancesteris, who converted to Christianity under threat from the Christian Creek Empire and then to Islam.
Please note that Faith or Religion has no DNA so its wrong to say a Christian , Jewish, Muslim, Hindu, or Atheist DNA .
@@mujemoabraham6522 I am not talking about religions here; people in this land have similar DNA.
Palestinan in the West Bank has a high Jewish DNA. They may have a higher Jewish DNA than the Jews from Poland. I am not trying to be racist, but that may be a fact.
Most Jews were forced to change their religion when the Christian Empire controlled the region, then Islam took over, and most converted to Islam. People in Hewbew have a similar culture to Jews, and they protected Abraham's tomb for centuries before Israel was established in 1948. Think about why they protected the tomb for centuries. Their Arabic accent is super funny. They cannot speak Arabic like other Palestinians.
@@amaren133I know exactly what you are talking about! There are people with the DNA, and a religion. I’m Christian, and there is no DNA for that, but there absolutely is for J*w*sh people. You can have J*wish DNA and be a Christian or whatever. I was shocked when I saw mine too! It’s a mix of random stuff. I have heard people say J*wish people have larger noses, and you wouldn’t have a trait like that without DNA. I don’t know if that is true, but I have heard it.
@@joanmikeska8484 I have big nose and have zero Jewish DNA
My wife has high Jewish DNA and has small nose
Don’t know why people always says that Jews has big noses!
I don’t know maybe Jews where living in Eastern Europe have big noses
I have no idea!
@joanmikeska8484 Jews are uniquely both a physical and spiritual nation, so you can join by converting and automatically are 100% Jewish forever, Abraham and Sara become your forebears. Conversion to Judaism is very serious; candidates for conversion are committing themselves forever to acceptance of the Torah as the immutable word of G-d. Jews who marry out or convert to other faiths are still Jews, both by genetics and spiritually, because our covenant with G-d is forever, where we live it or not.
Videos like this, and people like you and Osama give me so much hope for the future. It's so nice to see an educated and respectful discussion in what has become a sea of hatred and ignorance. I'm Jewish, and I'm a Zionist, and all I want is peace for all, Palestinians and Israelis alike. Together we can heal the world. Am Yisrael Chai ❤
That's the difference, two intelligent and educated people who care more for life and what could be. The sad thing that's not the norm for the average Gazan, not only are they generationally brainwashed and do not value this life the hatred for Jews has been drilled into them. Hamas enforces this as well. The Arab nations the Palestinians have betrayed aren't keen on having them around either.
Shalom! What do you think about the right of return, the rebuilding of Gaza and reparations for the displaced Palestinians?
People like him are blatant naive idiots. The "cousin" is talking to is an idf soldier, i mean literally he was in the front line in the gaza invasion....
I agree with the right of return to be seen as valid as the Zionist belief, I think Israel has the responsibility to rebuild Gaza but I can’t agree on the reparations as that never works imo. I think there needs to be an influx of community support from the other side.
@@ryanberkowitz5399 what is the “other side”. So what do we do with all the Israeli’s living in the literal houses of Palestinians? The villages and towns that were turned into “wooded areas” are fairly simple right? Just rebuild, but many of the Palestinian communities were either built on top of or had Zionist immigrants moved into the literal house of an ethnically cleaned. How does this rite of return look? Full citizenship to all Palestinians in the diaspora? And btw, Germany has paid 87 billion to Holocaust survivors in reparations. They also returned 16,000 luted objects. Can we expect that towards the Palestinians? I as a us citizen know we will be footing much of the bill as we do for Israel.
In the past 6 months, I have learned more about my Jewish Heritage and our right to self-determination in our ancestral homeland than I have in the past 6 years! And I have people like Rudy to thank for it!!
AM YISRAEL CHAI 🇮🇱
Same here!
No your white luv😂
@@khadijahbegum3546 I am an Ashkenazic Jew ✡️ what do you expect?!
@@tashikoweinstein435 yh I can tell luv. You look European. Which is farrrr from indigenous mate😂💀
@@khadijahbegum3546 her ancestors have been in europe for 2000 years
its good time period for such population to evolve and adapt to their new environment
europe has low temp and sun exposure which means if a middle eastern had tanned skin and decided to immigrate to europe and his descendants kept living there they will eventually evolve and show white skin color
Rudy is definitely one of a kind. Peace be with you brother🙌
This is Rudy's "I Have a Dream" speech, very moving at the end too.
What happened to MLK? HE NEEDS TO PULL BACK. A SECURITY GUARD AINT NOTHING WITH 🔫 BANG BANGS, I IMPLORE HIM AGAIN. NOT THE TIME EITHER.
but that is not true since recent palestinian are fake, they came with turkish from different races and called them selves palestinians recently , real palestinian are another group most of them orthodox jews and christians . i think rudy is zionist and has different agenda against Israel . think about it
I am Jewish and have relatives that are Bedouin’s in the Negev. From a dna test.
Great, What is your Haplogroup ?
@@mujemoabraham6522
Search, *_"The Y Chromosome Pool of Jews as Part of the Genetic Landscape of the Middle East"_* November 2001, Nebel et al, _Am Journal of Human Genetics_
Which jewish group? I presume mizrahi, correct. If so, have you tried to reach out to your relatives?
Yeah because some Bedouin’s in the Negev are doing dna tests lmao
I am north african and i learned that i have a similar dna with people living in canary island. I surely didn't go there, formed extremist groups and colonized canary island and changed it's name all while white washing everything 😂
Hearts and minds, Rudy. Its been tried before. It usually does not work. But keep preaching, the world needs true believers like you.
Yeah, he comes from a lovely place but they do not, only the ones that managed to get away, get educated and live away from the Arab mindset will care enough for peace and living side by side with people that have hated Jews for generations. I think it can happen just not there and not for a long time.
I mean, Israel is proof that it does, in fact, work.
It will if more and more people are on the same page. It will take time but it has to start from the bottom up, nothing else has worked thus far!
@@hannahanderson4305…..ones like Mosab Yousef; after all he is the son of one of Hamas founders. But Rudy takes the more diplomatic approach while Mosab just wants to take out Hamas so that both the Palestinians and Israel can live a better sense of security! Hamas is literally the ones holding the Palestinians hostages as they need them to shield from the IDF. They were trying to flee but Hamas kept sending them back or shooting them! Where is the outcry from the protesters then???! Not one word!
I now agree, I didn't know the extent of effort and hope in the peace camp in the 90s or maybe in the 80s. Israelis hoping for a good land for peace deal that everyone could accept.
Then Einar Wilf describe the great disappointment that Arafat walked away. No prominent Palestinians objected to him walking away. Next, the intifada, the riots the stabbings the bombings the murder, AS THE RESPONSE TO SINCERE PEACE NEGOTIATIONS.
I also loosely believed that Islam was like Christianity or the Jewish religion. I did not know that there were more verses committed to killing Jews than the number of anti-jewish versus in Hitler's Mein Kampf.
Just a few months ago, I wouldn't have noticed because I didn't read it in the news, Apostate Prophet pointed out that Abbas in the West Bank ordered Islamic clerics to begin emphasizing the Gharqad Tree verse, which few Jews know about but every Muslim has been taught since childhood. It's a prophecy from Muhammad about annihilating the Jews, Sura 2922 in Sahih Muslim, meaning an authoritative source.
That is a hump that is difficult to get over, culturally, though anything is possible.
I loved this conversation and both people's input. It really seems like both want real peace. We need more people speaking about and sharing this wisdom.
I wonder if Rudy would do this same spiel with some of the Israeli settlers living in the West Bank: to help them understand that Palestinians are their cousins, not their enemies. I would love to watch that video.
Salaam and Shalom. God bless you. Sharing this video to people I know. May there be peace and love between Jews and Muslims, Israelis and Palestinians. Inshallah. Moshe was Israelite. His Zeporrah was Ishamilite. Both descents of Avraham/Ibrahim. May wisdom and love prevail. Amen.
I love your vision of the future Rudy. You’re a great man for what you’re trying to do. I hope one day it really does turn out that way. As skeptical as I am about it, I still truly hope it happens.
Same here. Very skeptical, and I think he's wrong when he says Israel hasn't tried option 4 before. But I love the idea of this happening
as an Indian, Israel-Palestine fells more complex than India-Pakistan best of luck guys peace ✌and thanks Late British empire for this mess
Edit: Thank you for the likes, everyone. By the way, the "complex" terms I've used are subjective to me; they may be different in your views. I mentioned this because it's common to see Indians and Pakistanis working together in other countries with few or no problems, even on the internet, appreciating each other. However, I've observed that many Palestinian people have hatred towards Israelis which maybe justifiable for them and their opinion, and perhaps the same might be true on the other side, which is not morally right. We need to agree on certain grey areas that lead to peace, even if it may sound's unjust, as it is likely the most truthful path compared to other three options mentioned by Mr. Rudy. And I love the modern British people and I've mention their old empire not the modern people.
Radical Islam has it out for Jews, Christians, and incompatible Muslims throughout the world, but sure, let’s blame the late British Empire and only the late British Empire for radical Islam’s inability to tolerate a Jewish state in Judea. It’s always the West’s fault.
Well said.
India Pakistan isn't complicated at all. That is 2 separate peoples who received their own lands. Muslims cannot live with idol worshipers. It's written in the Qur'an. Either we follow God or we follow individualism. Individualism is evil. Look at what individualism has done to western society. Israel Palestine is more complicated because there is only 1 land and 2 peoples. And the Jews believe in individualism.
It is far more complicated. The Mandate for Palestine was not a Colony, and yet the British broke basic International Laws that put the Mandatory under their governance by treating it as such. Their national policies caused huge amounts of Jewish Death while they were appeasing Arab Nations in exchange for Suez Access, and Oil. They sought to sabotage the mandated People of the Western Side of the Mandatory, while playing Patron to the Arab side. They were even part of the Jordanian Arab Legion when the Arab League attacked the brand new Israel.
This is precisely the problem with muslims. Expecting coexistence elsewhere but refusing it when it comes to their countries.@@AS-vq3wt
Thank you Rudy for speaking the words of peace and love that many Israelis, just like you and me feel. My teacher Thich Nhat Hanh facilitated retreats where Israelis and Palestinians practice mindfulness together, helping them calm their emotions and listen deeply to each other. One of his methods was to focus on looking beyond labels and seeing each other as fellow human beings, cultivating empathy and compassion to each other. You are doing it here so beautifully. Very inspiring. Thank you!
Peace is the only way forward.
We're all human. Love from the UK. 🇬🇧
but that is not true since recent palestinian are fake, they came with turkish from different races and called them selves palestinians recently , real palestinian are another group most of them orthodox jews and christians . i think rudy is zionist and has different agenda against Israel . think about it
They blamed us the British throughout this interview or debate whatever it is we should withdraw our support for either side and let them sort themselves out everyone is sick and tired of their fighting
There are 2 million Arab Israelis, you can ask them what it's like to live in peace with Israelis. There are zero Jews living in Gaza.
yea because Gaza doesn't even have the most basic services like sewers, and the reason for that is the Isreal blockade plus many Palestinians at least had a single person from their family killed by isrealies soldiers or were arrested by isrealies soldiers keep in mind that over 80% of the Palestinian hostages taken by Isreal are minors and it was proved several times by many journalists, news channels and documents that most of them didn't commit any crimes, so you kill people, you blow up their houses and blow up their friends and family, you give them poor service and then you ask why they hate you?, and as I said above there are Arabs who live at Isreal and don't try to act like they got the same rights as isrealies they get far less rights but they get basic services like sewers, education and medical treatments, and there are no isrealies in Palestine because they don't even have the basic services and they will be kicked out the second they put their legs in.
Yes that was only when the Israeli state was created. All lived in union before that and the Nakba.
@@photorayya I guess that's why the Muslims were slaughtering Jews in 1929 in Hebron?
are you joking? do you know what gaza is?
@@emeneensj445 Yes. I have been there twice. Have you been?
Rudy, please stay safe.
I will say this as clearly as possible, I believe that the majority of people in the world think that the Israelis/Jews are a wise people, "the people of the book", so listen to this, as a Jew who represents a lot of Israelis and Arabs who are my neighbors, I am 100 percent sure that if the day comes when you stand up The State of Palestine on the entire territory of Israel, the amount of people who will die from wars between the Arab tribes who lived/live here will be catastrophic, I am begging the world to save human lives, think about who should be supported, in order to save human lives, and check objectively with all the facts, the truth. To all the freaks who shout in the world "free plasticine", come ask my Arab Muslim neighbors, if they want to live under the rule of Hamas in Gaza, or under the Palestinian Authority in Israel (or any Arab country in the Middle East), they will be willing to do anything to stay under the State of Israel, so before you beg for something for someone else, ask him.)❤️🇮🇱💪💪💪
Amen
5 million people suffering in Gaza and the West Bank from Israeli oppression and subjugation of their everyday life. And those 2 million Arabs in Israel can vote but are treated as 2nd class citizens. sure living in Israel as an arab is better than living in Syria or Yemen.
I'm not your neighbor, but can definitely confirm what you said. I don't think people realize that according to polls most of us are pro Israel, and that feeling only increased after October 7th. We might hate the current government, but the country overall is pretty good. It's not perfect, but it's home.
@@khaledassaf6356 im glad to hear an arab saying it... because let's be honest israel is best country in the middle east.... where all people can work study eat live buy things and all are equal.. of course israel has problem like any other country in the world! the problem is both people dont have that one pesron that can really be trusted and lead the community! hamas or pa not really a legit government... and in israel you don't have better options then bibi.... like all other are also clowns in terms of whos runing for PA
You blame the resistance but you are blind to the slavery that's on going. You want to live together but you continue the status quo. They started with throwing rocks, now rockets, God know what they will start to make to be just free. Don't blame the freedom fighters. Blame the people who have the power to correct this insanity. You know the saying with power comes responsibility.... What I can assure you guys is, if the tables were turned, the Jews, Israelis will be taken care of with equal rights. Jews need to get over their insecurities after their terrible past. Muslims, Arabs, Palestinians were never the culprit or their enemy. Besides we/they are one family.
This shows, when you have 2 people discussing and respecting each other you can get things done. Thank you Rudy and Hassan for showing how life could be . A lot of work out there for the Israeli government and the Palestinians - getting rid of hamas and other terrorists and then working together . I was In Israel for a month in March this year and was balled over by the Israelis ( Jews, Arabs, Druze, Bedouins, etc ) living together . Thank you both for your humanity !
You are amazing!!!
Thank you for representing so many of us Jews that are too afraid to take action. May you continue to spread awareness in both parties, Jews and Palestinians and we will be united and live in peace and harmony!
Love Rudy, he’s working so hard to change the world. True visionary.
This video should get 20+ million viewers. Iyh
His government don't like him
well said, he was also not letting Rudy off which is good cause Rudy then had more ways to dive into the deeoper stuff which he dosent say by heart already. It was different in a good way, creating a deeper convo, well done by both.
Everything begins from our soul, mentally and our hearts..goal is to have Peace for the world..🤙🏻
Rudy is such a solid foundation for the Israeli people and such a good representation of our people and land!
אחד הסרטונים החשובים ביותר בהסטוריה של ההסברה על ה'קונפליקט'!!! תענוג צרוף לראות ולשמוע את שניכם בשיחה המופלאה נעימה וראויה הזו!!! ישר כח ענק!!!!
תודה רבה :)
One of the best conversations that I've seen in months
Rudy - You need to debate Israelis who disagree with you about treating Palestinians and Israelis equally, in right of return and all aspects of life (if that is really what you believe should happen)?
Totally agree. As he says in this video, Israelis hold the power right now. It's just as important, if not more important for him to be speaking to the hardline Israelis who don't want or think it's possible to have a free Palestinian people.
I want to believe what he says is possible, but just changing the hearts and minds of Palestinians isn't going to achieve it. We need to see what the hardline Israelis say in response to his spiel just as much as we need to see what Palestinians say.
More talks like this, thank you Rudy! So rare and so needed.
Bro... this is what's called metanoia, a change of heart. And you are doing it beautifully. God bless you Rudy. 😊
You’ve spoken for the right people.
You’re doing an incredible job.
Form 🇮🇱❤ 🇵🇸
You are a beacon of hope in an otherwise bleak reality. For a long time I’ve felt change has to start with us individuals, and it’s a huge inspiration seeing you put that ideology into action
May peace flourish above the world!
I believe in you Rudy, keep going. Bravo.
Love both these men, intelligent, good, peaceful people, true cousins. Sending support for a better future from New Zealand ❤️
That was sweet!!! Hugs to both of you, especially to Osama!! From another neighbour Israeli 💗
Rudy you are the man keep up your great work 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Dear Rudy, thank you for your work and commitment! It is so valuable that people like you stand up for open dialogues. Option 4 is the path we should take!
" if the arabs love their children more than they hate the jews, we might have a chance for peace".
Golda Meir.
I can't say this enough in your comments... You're so great, Rudy. You make my day every time I watch you. You are so necessary especially now.
I love this. Way to move towards healing.
רודי יקר, אתה מקסים באמת, ואומר כמה וכמה דברי חכמה. אבל גם אופטימיות יתר עלולה להביא לטעות.. יש הרבה אי דיוקים היסטוריים במה שאתה אומר. צריך ללמוד את החברה הערבית בצורה יותר מרובדת. יש שם הרבה בעיות קשות ברמת החינוך מילדות- לשנאת יהודים, לשנאת 'כופרים' והערצה למעשי רציחה, רצח על בסיס 'כבוד' וכו'. זה הרבה יותר מורכב מאיך שאתה מציג את הדברים.
אבל עדיין, כוונתך יפה. אז מאחלת לך הצלחה
The Jews evolved, the others devolved
This needs more exposure. Such a refreshing take. You can't continue being niche Rudy we need you to be the mainstream
Wow that's satisfactory 😊❤ i am not both palestinian and israeli but this is very satiafactory discussion 🇵🇸❤🇮🇱
I pray for the healing of both sides to begin.... Education that passes down to children is essential...
This is good. All UN representatives should watch to learn what a productive conversation looks like. Unfortunately, change is the hardest option and there is another greater problem which is the remaining Muslim countries surrounding Israel that also hate Jews.
Both Isaac and Ismail were created and blessed by HaShem.☝️
its quran vs tanakh, read my friend
Why verus? The Quran supports the Torah.
(Quran 5:44) Surely We revealed the Torah, wherein there is guidance and light. Thereby did Prophets - who had submitted themselves (to Allah) -
@b23456 Can you be more specific? Because I don't get what you trying to tell me.
And the enmity was there long before the British
@@jonnyblunt4755 Yes, you are right, although it is also true that the conflicts were exacerbated, but that may have more to do with the disappearance of an empire that brought them together. The same thing happened in Eastern Europe during those same years, or in Latin America when the Spanish empire fell. Still, with the number of times blatant lies were used to sow hatred and justify barbarism, I wouldn't mind if a lie helped bring about peace.
From the river to the sea...From the bottom to the top! Keep this beautiful mindset please! 🥰🤲
You want to erase the Jews and Christians?
No politician wants peace because there is where , power ends, position ends and money ends.
אלוהים נתן את ארץ ישראל לבני ישראל וזה כתוב בקוראן בברית החדשה ובתורה הקדושה. שמע ישראל אדוני אלוהינו אדוני אחד. ברוך שם כבוד מלכותו לעולם ועד
It would be amazing if after Israel gets rid of hummus, Israel goes on and takes care of everyone for peace
Read your comment again my dude
Bruno is that you?
noooooo hummus is so tasty. how dare you
hamas would never have existed if the Palestinians were treated well by the Israeli government.
I disagree , hamas ideal are derived from muslim brotherhood. Fundamental groups exist without america or israels existence. This pattern can be observed if you study history .
I am so glad we can agree that Israel as an apartheid nation needs to be abolished and replaced by a secular, unifying government where people of all religions have equal rights and coexist peacefully. As someone who has identified as anti-zionist, I have never heard this definition of zionism. I absolutely agree that Jews should be able to live in Jerusalem, so long as they do not subjugate another peoples while they do so. From this day forth, I am a proud zionist!
nice
Palestine is an open air prison because Hamas created that not the Israelis.
I still think is not an open air prison. Every country has boarders, some are wide open to cross and others are very guarded. Border with Mexico and the US is very guarded and crossing it you have to have the proper documentation and you can wait at least 3 hours on a regular day. On a busy/holiday it can take you 6 or more hours. Also, they check your car as well, so should I say the US it’s treating everyone who crosses inhumane?!
Are you joking, they literally throw their trash down on their cages below. They can barely cross a street.
th-cam.com/video/aEdGcej-6D0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=qL27nfe14g6yBdrh
@JMac-27 have you been to Gaza? Obviously not because you have no idea what you're even talking about
Beautiful stuff Rudy. I hope there peace some day n that it's soon. If more people like you two n they get involved I see peace. God Bless both of you. And your right about who cause this tragic mess. Love from Canada
The Israeli and Palestinian people are fighting the same dynamics as us Indigenous Turtle Islanders. Both the Canadian and United States do their best to keep us Indigenous Turtle Islanders fighting amongst one another. This has to end, and we need to work together for a better world for our children's children. I say this not only for Indigenous Turtle Islanders but for the people of the middle east.
Its really difficult to understand how any semi educated person can listen to this chat and not hear a solution and a guy who has love for both sets of people. YET, you see him elsewhere bring called a racist and being attacked by campus clowns who dont want to hear his words. This is the solution for Israel/Palestine.
I think this discussion does not take Islamic fundamentalism into account sadly.
It’s all because of the Islamic Arab conquests.
They colonized Palestine and Egypt and other areas, leading to many conflicts like this
Palestine wasn’t traditionally and wasn’t originally Arabic
2:17 We had or almost had it cousin....... 1995 Arafat and Rabin 😢😢😢 we can only wish for it again....... Another Israeli leader and Palestinian (Moderate one not from Hamas) that both have the same hearts as those two men bada bing bada boom you got your peace treaty!!!!
And this is how a protest should look like, have your freedom of speech, but be able to talk to people who don’t agree with you. Justice for Palestinians is not the destruction of Israel, it’s the ability to live together and accepting the right of each other to live a peaceful and dignified life.
Excellent video! People need a vision! Thank you for your efforts!
This idea that jews are europeans is so false, there are lighter toned peoples across the middle east, like Persian people, and the jews who have gone back from europe mostly came from east europe and most definitely dont look slavic or scandanavian.
Hamas needs to go if we want to see the coexistence of Israelis and Palestinians. Palestinians need to have a good and peace loving leaders
What about natunyaho
@@HADAFIAN.KING.s we'll see how he handles the situation after hamas is gone
@@miemie-uh3gv but i am asking as human from you i am not palestiane i am from Pakistan 🇵🇰 so my question is that before the attack of hamas why Israeli police and idf harassment Muslim man and Woman in the holy place Bait ul maqadus why they don’t allow Muslims for prayer why they arrest Muslims and killed even Muslim have no weapons and not other things except only for praying
@@miemie-uh3gv i also not in fever in that if hamas killed innocent means public but can you condemn the killing of innocent child man’s woman. I don’t read in any book that someone attacks school and hospital except Natun yaho he say hamas are present in Al shifa hospital if any terror present in the hospital or schools you have don’t permission to attack this places what about the more than 35k public what about the generalist and reporter even Israeli attack on UN people
@@miemie-uh3gv i also not in fever if the going to against public in Ukraine, if the war against public in Israel,if the war against public in Ghaza, or any part of the world if the public belongs to Muslims, Jews or christans or any other religious because it is the the order of our religion Islam that protects human everywhere in the world and i think the same in every religion order to support humanity
Hate for Jew comes from their book u can't change their mind
Rudy always speaks sense and with respect. As a British Jew, I’m sad to say that I didn’t realise that my government was so involved (negatively) in all this 😢 keep spreading the positive energy rudy, my brother
I wish all Israelis and Palestinians would interact like this. There would be peace then 🕊 ✌️ ☮️
The Palestinian fellow seems reasonable. Unfortunately, he represents less than 5% of the population.
Do you think Rudy represents most religious Jews in Israel?
Idk about religious jews but many secular jews (they are about 50% of the Israeli population) will agree with him on almost everything he said in this video@@TalkAboutPalestine
He represents maybe 0 people in Israel at most. @@TalkAboutPalestine
@@Jewcas770says you
@@bjkorb7272 yea, I said that
Rudy.. we israelies do not believe in peace anymore. Not because we don't want peace, but because we realised the other side will never want real peace.
Peace has not been truly offered on the table in decades, though. That was his point. And he is right that by over-scrutinizing the past we cannot see a future...US and Vietcong vets now share lunch with each other, it is not impossible to imagine such a reality. He himself is an Israeli who believes in peace...
Congratulations on 100.000 subs..:-)
Rudy people like are the reason we have hope! Peace will come from the people- not from our corrupted so called leaders…
Shalom Rudy. As an ethnically Jewish, non religious American, I really appreciate that you take the time to have civil discussions with the other side. It’s hard for people to imagine Israelis want peace but in essence, that is who they are. They’ve won just about every war they fought, gained land in Egypt, returned that land to Egypt. I don’t know how many moderate Palestinians there are out there, but if you exist, please let your voice be heard!
Unfortunately, that will never mean you are loving cousins.
🤦🏻♂️ not even all Brothers and sisters on earth loves each other but if you find just some cousins they have love for another it’s a win
@@DDCharles-zf5ye 100%
@@DDCharles-zf5ye Very true. Family may argue and fight and even disband at times, but right down to our blood, we will always be family, and somewhere deep in our blood, the love for one another will exist forever. Let us heal our broken hearts. 🇮🇱❤️🩹🇵🇸
The origin to the conflict is religion, no land.
what if they both were atheists.
@@pantethine66
Then switch it to ideology instead of religion.
well then everyone lives happily ever after
No conflict before brits barged in. They lived happily Christians Jews Muslims atheists
The origin is israel occupation
Not the British being the source of everyone's problems 👁👄👁
Yes, the same British that helped them against the Nazis. The same British that helped them back to Isreal in the first place.
As an Israeli, it's so refreshing and heartwarming to see this peacful palestinian young man. I wish Rudy's dream will come true and both population can live together in peace and harmony, I wish it's not just a fantasy as it seams nowdays 😢
This was heart warming, light shining and immensely healing. Thank you to both of you. Fantastic work, keep it up. New hope is here to stay.
Rudy for Israeli PM 2025
אין דבר כזה עם פלסטני .זאת המצאה .תלמדו היסטוריה🇮🇱♥️🇮🇱
th-cam.com/video/M0qxMNO7G9E/w-d-xo.htmlsi=nzv23Bzfilw2iigR
Rochman, your ancient Israelite land claims are just silly.
Innumerable cultures, kingdoms and empires, big and small have existed throughout the history of humanity.
ALL OF US alive today are descendants of individuals who inhabited those cultures, kingdoms and empires.
Does that give ALL OF US rights (or at least some rights) to the land of those ancient cultures, kingdoms and empires?
Or are land rights based upon other concepts like continuous inter-generational occupancy and things like (legitimate) purchases, rent or even just human need?
The Israelites from some (relatively short-lived) kingdoms were dispossesed a few thousand years ago.
Do Zionists or anyone practicing or converting to Judaism today around the world have more than just imaginary ties with them?
Even if Israelis could prove a certain percentage of DNA relatedness, your 23andme ancestry report
is not a land deed, and it certainly doesn’t entitle you to anybody’s house or paid mortgage.
If my 23andMe ancestry results say that I have some percentage Mongolian ancestry, that doesn’t give me the right to reclaim the Mongol Empire and take somebody’s home in China or Russia where that empire was.
Like I said earlier, everyone’s DNA is from a human past which was replete with (now long gone) cultures, kingdoms and empires.
Imagine all the complications that would ensue if we traced everyone’s ancestors and tried to allocate some land rights they had based on that past, which probably involved different occupancies of the same land by different peoples and civilizations during different millenia.
And how far back would we go? Could we include the longest period of Homo Sapiens existence-human prehistory- where humans were hunter gatherers?
Even if we restricted these “land rights” to the “civilized” neolithic period, ALL modern nations today would have to cede some land rights to people from other nations because all modern nations exist on the land of previous cultures, kingdoms and empires- whose human descendants are all over the place. It’s comical to even attempt the thought experiment
Even more so if we tried to allocate these land rights based on how much people’s beliefs approximate to those who occupied those ancient cultures, kingdoms and empires.
Imagine I convert to Mongolian shamanism today. An ancient version of it.
In that act of conversion, do Mongolians become my ancestors?
Do I gain rights to their ancient land?
Of course not
The Mesopotamian civilizations worshipped the sun god Shamash.
Imagine I convert to their Mesopotamian religion and become a sun worshiper.
In that act of conversion, do Mesopotamians become my ancestors?
Do I gain rights to their ancient land (e.g. Iraq)?
Of course not
If I can’t claim Mongolian or Mesopotamian ancestry (or certainly land ) merely by converting to Mongolian shamanism or Sun worshipping, why should I be able to claim Israelite ancestry (or land) merely by converting to Judaism?
A much stronger claim to land rights is continuous occupancy.
The Arabs of Palestine had resided continuously in that area for over 1000 years.
True, the census around the year 1800 shows that about 5000 individuals practicing Judaism (Jews) resided in Palestine (co existing with hundreds of thousands of Muslims and a minority of Christians).
This minority of judaism-practicing individuals and their descendants did have continuous occupancy for a long time (as long as the Arabs as far as I’ve read).
Of course, there’s nothing wrong with immigration of any kind so long as it does not infringe on the rights of the people already in the land- in the case of Palestine the large majority of Arabs whose rights were violated.
Zionists immigrated into Palestine with the intent of expelling Arabs and taking over their land in an ethnically preferential state.
The result was war and a horribly abusive apartheid, now culminating in genocide.
Nevertheless, by virtue of continuous occupancy, inter-generational Israelis have now gained certain rights to the land.
The international consensus is a Palestinian state in the whole of the West Bank and Gaza, which gives Israelis far more land than they deserve- 78% of the former Palestine.
Since even the 1948 partition that provided 56% to Israel was grossly unjust, this 78% doesn’t reflect an approach based on justice, but a realistic partial acceptance of the historical principle of “might makes right”.
Of course, partial acceptance is not enough for most Israelis, who demand 100% of the land and no Palestinian state from the Jordan river to the Mediterranean sea.
You talk a lot for someone who seems to use propaganda as fact.
Exactly 💯
Typical propagandist mixing facts with falsehoods. Arabs have not lived on the land continuously. Many of the Arabs today are descendants from migrants who came to the land during the late era ottoman empire and British mandate.
Wow that was so mind blowing what a conversation round of applause for those two men
Rudy, your communication skills are off the charts, and your videos are excellent, and give me hope that one day calm, rational people like you will, on both sides, come to a comprehensive agreement. I like in hope.
❤❤❤
🇮🇱❤️
The people cannot change government, politics and economy gain. Plus you never explain how you over come the pure hate and hate teaching, making videos is a nice idea but you need 100,000,000 followers not 100,000 😢
have to start somewhere right?
Clear-sighted, peaceful, tolerant, patient, attentive, compassionate... you're an example to follow. I love it when you say that “the solution will come from the people”. Congratulations and good luck, because not everyone thinks like the people you're talking to in this video. You're right on the money. Even though I'm not Jewish, Israeli, Muslim or Palestinian, I'd love to talk with you.
As an Israeli I'm speechless that was beautiful and I wish we as people unite and stop all the wars my best friend is Muslim it's why it's so hard to see what going on in the media so much misconception may we find peace ✌️ soon.
This makes me well up every time I listen to it 🥺 Great conversation 😊✌️