Israeli & Palestinian Activists Come Together
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ก.ย. 2024
- At the 2019 AIPAC Policy Conference, many protesters rallied outside to voice their opposition to the State of Israel. Most were vehemently against any form of Jewish empowerment and were not interested in any sort of dialogue that included talking about Jewish rights, suffering, or aspirations.
After spending hours debating individuals from different backgrounds, we finally came across a young Palestinian independent activist who was willing to engage in dialogue focused on building a better future for all peoples living in the region.
Today, most activists, or individuals in power, use one group's suffering as a tool to attack the other side and illustrate their vision of the future as a zero-sum game. In other words, most who are "pro-Palestinian" are actually just anti-Israel and use the Palestinian cause to mask their true intentions, and most who are "pro-Israel" never actually learn about Palestinian struggles nor take their future as human beings into consideration.
Although there was plenty that the two of us disagreed on, we were also able to find a lot of common ground, especially on our outlook for the region's future and bringing both sides together.
To resolve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, it will take both the Israelis and the Palestinians. Those currently in power have no interest in changing the status quo, so change can only truly begin with the people, particularly the younger generation.
It is the responsibility of those who live in the region to write a better future and to understand that life will only get better for one side when the other side is no longer the antagonist of their own storyline.
If you like our work and would like to see more projects like this please support us at www.patreon.com/rudyrochman
Video Produced by Leibman Productions
In collaboration with J-TV: Jewish Ideas. Global Relevance.
Hi Rudy! I am a Palestinian and I have come to really love and respect you’re perspective and approach. It really warms my heart and I pray that more people from both sides could learn to understand, respect and see each other as one people connected to the land❤ I pray for love peace and equality and respect for everyone everywhere.
Are you okay? 🙃
Thank you cousin
💕
@@nagi688 he's just opening up his perspective , good for him
@@mightybmx2900 I know I just asked because I know that the situation now between Palestine and Israel (my home country) is not the best
Just being a friendly neighbor 😊
This was the most civilised debate about this issue I have ever seen. Both people were composed and ACTUALLY LISTENED. Kudos to Rudy and the other person in this debate. Thank you for restoring my hope in the ending of the conflict.
👌
Ed Eduard
Agrea
Agreed
It's hard to have a conversation with a know it all bimbo'
indeed it was! amazing! usually such scenarios end up as a shouting match...
She is so much more intelligent than the college students. Thank goodness.
Props to the Palestinian girl! Very moderate and respectful. ❤️ from Israel
You only say that because she tries her best not to offend.
@@leaholiver9418
Or maybe you just don't acknowledge her positive aspects.
@@bigd795
Are you some sort of prophet?
SchnitzelBerry 13 oh hey said the truth luv
@@nunaapop9201
I don't even remember what she said because she deleted her comment. How do you know? And how is it true?
The british was the reason these things happened.
More like the Nazis
True man British also divided the asia and Indian subcontinent 😢
1000% with the British mandate in 1948 and as soon as the 1948-49 war happened, Britain ran away and disinvolved themselves from the situation that THEY created
@Wet Mustard cringe britaania is going to be extinct in 100 years
And Ireland
A civilized conversation. The world needs more of this.
Like back before 2000 it was ok to agree to disagree. Now its shaming the opponent competition.
@@wellthen...1539 you obviously were not of an adult age in 2000 or 1990s.
@@1czechit1 how do you know?
@@axeeliteghosted because in the 90s and 00's "shaming" an opponent was common. We just called it spin or "people stuck in the past" or other such nonsense.
If all Palestinians and Israelis were like that, there would have been no wars! We need to stop and listen and rationalize, since both nations are here to stay.
No most ruined it for good people the upcoming young. They learn them how "it is" and that is normal nobody talks to another or need too fuckin hate. sick realy tfoe
No the Palestinian should get their land back dont forget your land
@@armanious2567 We're not enemies..we should be allies. We're middle eastern brothers. Why fight for a land where we can live together in that land, in peace? 🇮🇱❤🇵🇸
@Film Play He is not a racist for specifying that a person should take the land that was stolen from them. This video only shows how Isreallis side-step the continious actions of taking palestinian homes illegally, the Isreali goverment and it's people both know they do this immoral, so they give reasons like oh we buildoze an entire house becuase a terrorist is hiding there, FALSE. Isreal has been taking land illegally since the 1980's and with the only reason of expanding isreal's land area is to squeeze all the palestinians from their homeland. By the way yes Armenians and Kurds both have the right of land from Turkey; not only that but Turkey should recognize the Armenian genocide committed in the beginning of the 20th century. Don't dare play the whataboutism card here, if you are just a decent human being, who agrees all human beings should have the same rights, then you would condemn Isreal and it's colonial terrorist strategies that has been waging for years.
@@kadam.z who do you think should govern the land, Israelis or Palestinians?
a Muslim Syrian here! the israeli guy is beautifully spoken, articulate and i agree with everything he said! the fact that he is condemning some of the actions his country is committing takes guts! both people are beautiful human beings with beautiful souls! hope they can coexist together and find prosper in their futures!
omar ojjeh I think he trying to say that certain things Israel is criticized for are out of context. I don’t think every Israeli supports every law and/or action. The real conflict is on both sides.
It would be beautiful if Arabs/Palestines would condemn the actions of Hamas and other Islamic/Arab extremists, don't you think? Both the senseless attacks on Israel or Israeli people as keeping Palestines imprisoned in a prison created by Hamas itselve. Without the chance to vote or critisize their leaders.
Agreed. Loved how calm and willing to explain he was.
The discussion wasn't really balanced to be honest because the guy was just such a better speaker, better informed. But love the spirit of engagement here.
@@jiggeys20 She was younger (& clearly very single). He on the other hand was a good looking 'middle eastern' specimen. I wouldn't be surprised if they exchanged numbers at the end...
Hope one day they can Coexist in Syria 🇸🇾 one day.
This one had me crying... I've been going down the rabbit hole of better trying to understand this conflict and a resolution seems hopeless, but this interaction gave me hope. You have a gift Rudy. You are going to change the world.
@Alex Cham Hmmmm... sorry man I'm gonna have to go with no :-)
Yeah I really don’t want to put a finger to any side really. I just want them to live in peace and accept each other. And people with this kind of attitude need to be in power.
I simply agree!!!!
@@KA-jj4rc the “occupation” of Palestine is a mutual aggreement from the Oslo Accords, Israel was moving out of Area C and dismantled most military areas but the second intifada happened, so you can understand that the process is a little trickier than you might think at first
Daniel it’s only a rabbit hole because mainstream media hides all the facts from us and is full of smoke and mirrors. Just look at how many kids and innocent civilians get killed by Israel. It’s clearly an ethnic cleansing as the zionists are trying to push Palestinians off the map. There is so much I’d love to tell you because poker players in general are exceptional critical thinkers. Also the girl he’s debating with is not even that knowledgeable and he’s the one doing the editing. Watch Abby martins documentary on Gaza and it will give you a good idea. I am half Palestinian half American so I try and always stay open minded, but this is not complicated. This is apartheid, genocide, and murder. The IDF has way more blood on their hands than any resistance group.
They look like the perfect couple that will never happen
I ship them.
@@notafeminist5948 she will dilute Jewish blood
lol, yes
Their both very attractive people .
@@kevingutierrez9273 same
"British mandate for Palestine "
Brits again? 😂😂😂
As an Indian I can say that wherever the British set their foot they have created ruckus for generations.
yea..pakistan and india should never be seperated..
Yep. If you see 2 fish fighting in one lake know for sure that an englishman passed by the lake earlier.
Yeah true i from Malaysia also... British again
Rubbish
The British gave the Jewish people their ancient homeland back
That girl is so sweet. I really like her passion and care for her country.
She is scared that you will de-legitimize her as a non-hostile citizen.. it's a valid viewpoint. And AIPAC is also condemnable, bravo.
That said.
Either, make a citizen of "Palestine" a neutral party. Or Make official policy as war on Palestine. Which is ignorant. Remove the hostiles, and the conflict doesn't exist anymore..
Remove those who have violent jihad mentality. It is evident in speech from any islamist. Some
Israel should make certain who is or is not a "target of war" vs Palestinians natives. Israel isn't unaware of who exist as legal Palestinians and those who are entering illegally. They may obtain Palestinian identification, but see it from one side.. a woman with children who owns a Palestinian home isn't the "enemy". Unless them make that way, an enemy.
I'm tracking the entire conversation, but not seeing clarity on the stance, government wise or IDF as she mentioned early on.
@@abashedsanctimony154 Notice how nobody is responding to you?
1st its not her country. 2nd she said things that are demonstrably false (so does Rudy) and 3rd she is not a Muslim so of course she will condemn Hamas and Hizbullah. Let her condemn DFLP, PLFP, Fatah, and Tanzim.
@@abashedsanctimony154 no such thing as Palestinian natives. Everyone is an immigrant and I am talking about the Muslims and Christians. The only people who can claim to have "always" been there are some Jews and Samaritans.
@@1czechit1what does being muslim have anything to do with it?
This is so underrated, every person who hated on one side without knowing the perspective of the different sides should watch this. Share this around peeps.
There are so many people who treated this conflict like zero sum. Also there are a lot of people who spread false information.
@@noahremnek3615 it's mostly the media's manipulation that's also adding fuel to all these conflicts
bolshit
no need just give the land to israel and palestine shift to other islamic countries.
@@clowngamer7879 send isral wher they came from they are same as hitler
She is a person you can talk to . She is not blind the false facts. She listens she learn she reacts that’s amazing...
Yo can you tell me why Jewish people think palestine is their land??
SOLO it’s a biblical/historical belief.you can’t argue with that. It won’t help😏.
@@solo7208 The Bible/ The Old Testament
@@orig7.3.23 really??lol so i can literally tell you "its quran you cant argue with that"
@@solo7208 I agree with you partially, and i will explain why:
1.The Old Testament came before the Koran. So if we want to go to the timeline argument The Old Testament came first and that is a fact. but that's a bad argument because it doesn't solve the problem and its only makes it harder.
again that's a bad argument because it doesn't solve the problem and it's only makes it harder.
so in my opinion I do not think it is necessary to involve each nation religion to the argument, because it will not benefit anyone.
but i'm a minority :)
The fact is that there are 2 nations of people on the same land. one has a formal country, and the other one doesn't.
theirs
"im a pro israeli and not aniti palastine" this sentence is gold tbh
I really wish more people could express themselves this way. I too am pro palestinian and not Anti-Israeli. For some the idea of being Pro-Palestinian assumes that they are Anti-Semmitic, which is an illogical thought to me. I pray for Peace and better leadership on all sides.
@@ItsKarateTime war is only going to separate us and separation is going to lead to more wars.
We need to forget the past and move on into a better future. I to believe is possible only if governments from both sides agree to talk to each other accepting each other.
But for that to heppen the majority of people from both sides needs to understand that the best way for peace is through love and accepting of the other. Unfortunately it doesn't seems like the case from both sides.
I still believe and hope it will heppen soon we have all suffered enough
@@shinygames7730 I agree. There is nothing but pain and suffering in the past and it should be an invaluable teacher for the world. I do believe that there needs to be more accountability on both sides of this ongoing tragedy. The unfortunate reality here is that Palestinians and Israelis are more alike than they are different. Thank you for a civil discussion.
@@ItsKarateTime I recommended to study the history of Al aqsa 👍,
I'm pro palestine and not anti jews
פעם ראשונה שאני רואה דיון בו הצד הישראלי מכבד, יודע את החומר ועשה את המחקר, ורק מביא לנו כבוד ושם טוב.
תודה♥️
Kike Ms translate plz
Translation: Its the first time that i see the israeli side respect the person infront of him, knowing what he's talking about and studying the subject deeply. It made me feel proud.
Hezbollah🔥👑
Yes some of israeli can't talk like that and just cursing...
This guy is amazing and the conversation between them was amazing.
Instead of cursing or wishing death to each other (the two sides) people should listen and converse respectfully, because we are all ultimately human beings
זה ככ לא נכון. עם כמה שיש אנשים אלימים בצד שלנו, יש גם המון! שיודעים לדבר ולהתבטא. בצד השני תהיה בטוח שיש המון שמדברים באלימות, והמציאות מדברת בעד עצמה.
Both of you were great. Much respects to both sides in the video. Hopefully we can see more dialogue like this.
So agree. Why is it that states can't do this?
edo edo it’s not that easy as u think
Well sed
I wish the Conservatives and the Liberals in the USA were like this
@@landonorr91703 The world, too.
This is how a true Palestinian and Israeli talk...👍👍👍...not like some when they loose an arguement, they spit vulgarity and become violent, and insulting their opponents.
As a Zionist, that Palestinian lady has my respect. She's probably the best debater that Rudy ever had. Unlike others, she has respect for the other side, she's willing to listen, and most importantly, she acknowledges our Humanity.
I pray, one day this conflict will end, and our governments will come up with a peaceful solution.
Also did anyone else realize that the span of this video is 19:48?
oh hey period sis. You spit facts.
I think that was done on purpose.
@@3ball260
I don't think it was done on purpose. I think she just genuinely naturally has respect and acknowledgement of our Humanity.
oh yuh no israel more jews wouldve killed in Europe
@@schnitzelberry this is not your land to take over
The world needs people like rudy in big governments because humanity is his priority only big leaders can think like this.
Respect
There are already enough empty apologists for Israel
if you listen carefully to him he doesn't believe in Palestinians having a homeland, he is a Zionist, he believes all Jewish people around the world have a right to live in Israel (Israel that includes all of Palestine) so if every Jew from around the world make there way to Israel there would be no space for anyone.... then there would be 'who are the righteous Jews?' and have a 'greater ' right to be in Israel.... dont be fooled by the charm, he has a youtube channel that is an income stream
@@Avi-tc2ym why is Rudy an "empty apologist" to you?
@@humeragondal2135 if you listen to what he actually says, he believes both people should co-exist peacefully. It's you who doesn't understand what zionism is because you've been indoctrinated to demonize the other side.
@@lights473 he justifies israels terrorism with fanatical religious dogma and emotional sjw-ism
I am from Sri Lanka - age 82 years. I am no Arab nor Israeli, just an average human being who greatly respects human dignity and social justice irrespective of creed color or race. This decent and intellectual debate between the young Palestinian lady and the young man from Israel is a model for mature politicians everywhere in the world. I sincerely wish that more and more people will follow them to bring an end to this senseless conflict.
too bad it was full of falsehoods and demonstrably factious claims. For example Nazareth was never bulldozed nor were its residents evacuated. The opposite. The city fell after a short battle, after which the commander (Ben Dunkelman) gave his word to the residents that no harm would come to the civilians of the town even though they joined the ALA.
שמע רודי, אני עוקב אחריך כבר תקופה אחי, פשוט תענוג לראות אותך, השליטה בידע, צורת ההגשה והכבוד שאתה נותן למי שמולך, אתה עושה עבודת קודש ומעורר השראה.
הסרטון נתן לי תקווה, מקווה שנשמע עוד קולות כאלה כמו הבחורה מהסרטון.
❤🇵🇸
Stop racism once and for all th-cam.com/video/hTwft2KX9xE/w-d-xo.html
@@omh5479 ❤🇮🇱
@فريدي كروجر i love you from Israel you are honorable man
@فريدي كروجر we need more loving people like you
As an Israeli teenage girl I'm seek of my government and really all I want is peace.
I'm SO tired just living in a middle of a war zone and there are MANY OTHERS like me.
I truly believe that we could live in peace one day❤️
מספיק לדבר שטויות. בבקשה
אולי תחכי קצת ככה שתגיעי לגיל 17+
living in a middle of a warzone באמת. את צריכה להעריך את מה שיש לנו. את מבולבלת.
Come on you need to use your brain where in the world that you can have peace and you are surrounded by the people or countries that want and love to massacre you don't be weak in this world the weak is always a victim
Im a Palestinian and I really want to go to my home town Majdal (you guys call it Ashkelon) I want to live in a country called Palestine but I want you guys to be able to live with us
@@hamoodtatari This❤️ agreed Palestinians should be able to go home
there will be peace if both sides are prepared to compromise on certain things.
If only these two were Israeli and Palestinian leaders. We’d have peace in a day or two
Sadly, the Israeli leader is a selfish piece of shit that doesn't care about peace, and the Palestinian leader only wants to kill innocent Israelis
Britain was to blame. They gave the Jews that land without applying a structure to how to govern and both sides became irritated with each other.
@yt man You guys only claim it is important to you guys after the Jews got their land back. There were pictures of the Mosque Al Aqsa before 1948, and it looked as if it had not been used in decades. There were roots growing and grass that was so tall. You guys only made it seem like it was extremely holy to y'all after we got our land back. Not to even mention that the mosque was built over the ruins of a jewish temple, which is solid proof that the jews were at this land over 2000 years ago.
@@mrmcjinx4047 it was never your land you came killed thousands of Palestinians and stole it and America backed you up saying its yours
@@abdelrahmanalattar2915 No there is literally archeological proof that Jews were there over 2000 years. You completely ignored my argument talking about that. And not to mention, the land was taken from us by the romans and the named was changed in spite of us.
@yt man But it was never your house to begin with. It is indigenous to us, and was taken from us first.
@Lel E Well if this is your claim then you Palestinians have no right to the land either but there is a completely different context to what happened to the canaanites. and if im correct, most arabs and jews are descendants of the canaanites since they were in the Levant region during the time. And the argument here is that we were native to this land before you guys, and you guys have no claim over this land. You guys got over 3/5 of pre-1948 Palestine and still want more land. Its just an excuse to hate on the jews and take away the one piece of land that unifies us. Its sad.
People like you guys are the ones who should be in power. Not those extremists that we have in Israel and Palestine.
inshallah :P
InshaAllah, Be'ezrat HaShem leaders will show up that actually care about their people
This is the kind of person we need more of; generating thoughtful, calm discourse as means to find a way to end the conflict.
both seem like they actually want to listen to each other’s narratives and are really interested in engaging with one another. This is so refreshing to see!
vampire israel devil's child israel
What is this activist's name, she seems very intelligent and could be a bridge in the future
They destroying bridge later to many variety from them
Wtf? She is pro-islamic pro-Palestine terrorism.
@@kurdebele which side of your body are u listening to this from.
?
Kareem Rajeh uneducated why? There is Palestine but in this Palestine region is State of Izrael, Palestine it’s not a country, Jews lived there before Arabs many many years ago (look to Bible).
This looked like a scene from Romeo and Juliet. They were so calm and peaceful. I think they secretly fell in love.
Honestly, they are perfect match😆The girl is pretty and cute then the guy is tall and handsome.They are both smart too and they understand each other😅😅😅.
@@mae-annagusto4108 now kith
They are both beautiful.
Omg🤦🏻♀️
You know that you're insulting her right? That's the worst thing to ever say about a palestinian girl fighting for the freedom of her country.
Wow both of them were ready to hear eachother and actually have a real conversation which doesn't happens much...love and peace to both Palestine and Israel.
Wow man. You're seriously an inspiration. Like seriously. You and the Palestinian girl were both amazing!
I don't know what the full solution to the Israeli Palestinian conflict is. But part of the solution is definitely that people like the two of you need to be the ones in power.
both sides are amazing! this girl is GOLD .. yes i see hope here (respect from israel)
Respect from palästine☺️
its Palestine FUCK Israel
L1onesse yeah, people like u are the problem❤️
Danya a ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
@Solitary confirmed Shitzophrenic well actually Jerusalem never mentioned in Quran. it said he was flying to al-Aqsa (the far) mosque which still believed by many Muslims to be about 30 km from Mecca. Only after Muhammad death and the Muslim/Arab occupation of the land of Israel they build a new mosque on the Jewish temple mount and decided that this is el aqsa.
As an Israeli is amazing to see both sides really listening to each other and have a tallk instead shouting each other blames , the girl is amazing btw ,
Peace and love to all ☮️
I watched many videos (I’m not personally involved in this debate due to the fact that I’m from Germany and don’t know the backgrounds exactly) of this topic and I’m so impressed of the respect that is shown in this one... they listen to each other and are always respectful towards each other... rather if they disagree or agree big props for this one
i just wanna say that what she said its true about if you support hammas publicly you will go to prison , its some sort of a PA way to make sure that they are the ones that stays in power , i know this is kinda of an old video but your "fact check" said wrong and its true in the west bank , BUT in gaza strip its different Hammas are the majority there , so people have no other choice .
Many people were condemned and executed for refusing to join hammas in Gaza so they called them traitors and israeli spies and they just executed them.
Do more research you will see she is right .
I'm pretty sure both of them meant to u.s. where their conversation happened.
This young women is incredible, can see her empathy lies with humanity not one side or another. Referring to Jewish brothers and sisters and taking arguements so well. In particular the man responding to the ball dozing of homes, including her own families, as specifically terrorists homes. Noticed the man cuts off her response and later she apologises for interrupting. Man is also amazing for setting out to publicise young activists coming together to find common ground on the conflict, debate Is key💘
This woman is amazing. So calm, so sharp, so focused. Are there more videos of her speaking?
I want to know as well, I wish they would meet again in Israel
@@kot1pelto 😐🤦♂️
@@kot1pelto There’s no israel
@@phatmaabdalla9280 I don't understand.
@@phatmaabdalla9280 so for Palestine to exist, Israel can't?
"Screw Hamas" I like her, she's bold.
Lol no she’s not, most Palestinians dislike hamas. But the problem is with westerners who think everyone in palistine is an extremist 😂
@@ycc7744 Doesn't help that I hear about attacks against Israeli checkpoints. People trying to murder Israeli soldiers by running them over. Plus, I never was close to a Palestinian and the only ones I've met were jerks. That's why she surprised me, she wasn't aggressive, bold but not aggressive.
@@ycc7744 That's completely irrelevant. The problem is that Hamas rules by force and normal people don't get a say in what happens. What they actually believe becomes irrelevant to what goes on between Hamas and Israel.
twistedyogert “the only ones I met were jerks” lmao talk about generalisations, just because you didn’t like the Palestinians you met doesn’t mean they all like hamas.
Yes the checkpoints attacks are bad, but let’s be balanced here, the Palestinian Territories are basically occupied and Israel implements a system of apartheid in their own lands. Don’t even get us started on the indiscriminate missile barrages in gaza. Both sides suck
@@ycc7744 I'm not saying that all Palistinians are jerks. I was only calling those particular people jerks. Also, the only reason for apartheid over there is security. You can never tell who is or who isn't a terrorist, especially if they don't work for a particular group that is monitored by the IDF. However, there are certain people who fit the profile of a terrorist, for Israel it's the palistinians.
אחד הדיונים היותר מעניינים והיותר נעימים שיצא לי לראות, איזה כיף לראות שכל זה נעשה בנועם ובכזאת אינטלקטואליות מצידך, כל הכבוד רודי (:
אני לא כל כך קוראת ומבינה אנגלית טוב אז יש לי שאלה האישה וגם האיש לצידנו או לא?
Wooow ! That’s the most hopeful interaction i’ve seen between the two sides, that was beautiful ❤
The most civilized one so far...
Just two people, who want to listen to the other's side.
Unlike the other videos that the people are just yelling their opinion and not willing to listen.
This woman is telling her opinion silently, and he is listening, and then he is telling his opinion silently and she is listening. BEAUTIFUL.
And the best... they agree
This was the most humane way of speaking out this war (not conflict) i've ever seen.
As an Israeli, this is an honor.
Ty for your acts. Wish I could be standing there, by your side.
I really really like the Palestinian girl. She is what you’d call open minded and I am so happy she doesn’t support terrorism.
Too complicated,my palestine 🇵🇸 always will have my support.
you are the problem. simple minded sheep.
If a conversation to find common ground is too complicated for you, please stay away from the conflict. We need sane, level-headed rational people that are willing to sit at the table and come to agreement, not annoying people with short attention spans that just want to shout slogans.
So the introduction being “screw hezbollah and Iran” is quite intriguing cause the leaders of our country iran makes us pay enormous taxes and donations to Palestinian territory and the terror organisations coming with it. the people of iran (not all ) celebrate al quds day and are not allowed to fly to either palestine or israel. I’d love to see more palestinians saying the truth about what they think about Iran, so the people suffering here can stop glorifying hezballah and hamas. We honestly have more problems than imaginable.
lala we have terrible regime wich Is torturing us from 40 years😭😭😭
کوروش نیکولو midoonam aziz, but the muslim world doesn’t care cause then they would see their own errors in the religion
lala دقیقا😥😡
Shoma iran zendegi mikonin?
lala man ham kharejam
If the entire world was like this everything would be perfect. I a Scottish Atheist admire this man.
Alright..
The man looks more Arabs, and the woman looks more Israeli.
pure irony
That’s the beauty of Israel, you can’t assume anything about someone just by looking at them.
@Wahyu Mardiarto
The most prominent thing in Israel.8 million people, and so many people from different ethnicities and backgrounds, Europeans, Arabs, Russians, South Americans
i legit thought he was the arab palestinian until they actually started debating lol
Well both are tecnically the same race
As an Israeli I love this much respect and a very nice conversation you dont get to see it a lot.
That was such a productive conversation! The next generation needs to come together for peace. It’s not easy but it’s the only solution
God bless both of you for having good hearts. May we show Hashems love for both Israel and for Palestine.
The United States of Israel and Palestine
Could this be a balanced Solution ?
She is the reason why Israel will always win in front of the world’s eyes!!
Beautiful discussion. Didn't know Palestinians like her exist. The moment she said "F* Hamas", I had respect for her.
Oh shut up
What a stupid statement. Yours
@@odaenathus7825 stfu- and f! Hamas
@@rimaelayoubi1294 oh stfu- i
@@flowchrx854 cant u be more creative?so stereotypical of u,coppying and stealing everything.
A major love to rudy from palestine 🇵🇸❤❤❤🇮🇱
🇮🇱🤝🇵🇸
Why did this lady say the UN recognized the British Mandate before 1948 as Palestine? That’s just not true. In fact, the UN was very new in 1948. Prior to that, the League of Nations existed, which endorsed the Balfour Declaration.
Because most people have no idea what the facts about Palestine actually are. Almost nothing true is ever said about either side by any source. It's amazing really. "Israel and Palestine" have become this mythical allegorical conflict in the world's consciousness that can be dressed up to argue whatever political or religious point you wish, having almost nothing to do with what's actually happening.
Don’t forget the fact that the man definitely is older and has more experience in the argument
@Edward Teach A.K.A Blackbeard Can't complain
@@talknight2 it's all because man of power benefit
All this conflict is about that
Imagine this lady is the president of Palestine and Rudy is the prime minister of Israel. 💚💙💚💙💚💙💚💙💚💙💚💙
They Will have many children together Amen
as a Palestine girl i do think the only way is peace.
there will be peace if both sides are prepared to compromise on certain things. are you palestinians prepared to compromise ?
Dude you have an incredible talent, the way you speak and the way you are able to find common ground.. much respect
Omg can she be the leader of Palestine! She can even take Bibi’s place! She would be respectful to all people living in that land!! She even understands the geopolitics of the area.
Unpopular opinion: Even when humans settle down at Mars, this conflict will never end
Most wont end too
That opinion is popular.
Sounds like two Libras trying to seduce each other.
Lol I never thought I'd find a fellow astrology nerd in comments like these. I'm a Capricorn btw. Have a great day ✌ 💘
@@schnitzelberry Happy belated bday!
@@zenmanyo35
Aye thanks dude!
Yoooo astrology ganggggg this is truueeee am a Libra ♎️
Lmao
I hope all dialogues will be like that.This girl is Open minded,Communicating Palestenians need this kind of leadership
This is amazing I’m not Israeli or From Palestine but this is really amazing ❤️ I like how you face check both of you to not be biased u really are the future
Know yout land and your rights that were taken from u
This the most peaceful conversation between him and her. i hope this for everybody.
This a video about diplomacy, not that Palestine being legitimate nation.
There is a two state solution for the time being, but there needs to be an integrated system for removing Palestine as a Islamic entity in Israel, it is simple to do. Not the Nazi method, but the Jewish method. Palestine becomes servant to Israel. But according to Jewish Law, you must respect your servants. For the master is judged more harshly. That is biblical, look it up.
Proverbs 31:9
“Open thy mouth, judge righteously, and plead the cause of the poor and needy.”
If Israel is to make Palestine desolated then they will suffer judgement for murder of the innocent. Either remove the hostile and forego the slaughter of children now or receive eternal suffering later.
These discussions are very important and clearly show that Palestinians and Jews can come together, but nothing can change as long as Hamas and Hezbollah exist.
Wow!!! I did not expect this debate to go this smoothly.
Woah thats luffy
You are like an angel from the sky. Keep doing this holiness work! The conversation was amazing and it is refreshing to see people from the other side that are open to learn and have this type of conversation❤🇮🇱سَلام🤝🏽שלום❤
Love to everyone from Israel.
The Israeli man is amazing
so is the palestinian women
You nuzzer
Agreed .
🇮🇱❤️🇵🇸
He is a minority. The Israeli society is rightwing, war driven and not interested in an independent Palestinian state. No Israeli prime minister will allow an independent Palestinian state.
The root is teaching young Palestinian children not to hate Jews.
She was stunning and so sweet I wish the people I had an argument with would be like her as well, she's the perfect example of a good person that's was a great conversation I could literally see the understanding and the hope, I love this❣x
Lol, si got owned. She 0 preparation on the topic
וואו אתה חכם אחי ריספקט על הדיבור המכבד❤️
They both would make a perfect couple. Lovely couple 💑.
HAHA Was thinking that!!
Rudy Rochman future wife Amen 🙏
I have been saying this for years, the young new generation needs to stand up and make a difference.
what is the name of the Palestinian woman? We need to prop up and empower the best of both sides.
I fell in love with her. She's so cute
Wow dude you’re so rare. If the world had more of you we would be living in a beautiful place
Both of you were bringing strong, solid points and i just loved to see how the debate stayed in low tones and civillized.
Good for both of you!!! ❤
You know you failed as a human when you casually say "we call five to twenty minutes before bombing the houses" like you are ignoring the whole fact that these are homes of innocent people mostly and hamas attack is nothing compared to what isreal did to Palestinians so this is basically double standards that you are having right here.
5-20 minute in apartment how to save family life? Hamas told throw media a day before
Why do you ignore the fact that hamas soldiers are using its own civilians as shields?
@@kofibonsu8466 1948-1949 hundred palestinian died. That time no PLO and no HAMAS. They don't have any army. Do you have any idea who make them as shields. Goggle news at that year and explains to us.
@@sitiyati6515 because surrounding Muslim nations waged war against Israel , completely disregarding the two state solution proposed by Britain. Which gave Palestinians 87% of the land
@@kofibonsu8466 Do you know that zionist Israel leaving their holy place almost 1500 years and come back on 1948 after holocaust tragedy? Until now im asking a lot of Israel why they leave the holy place that god give them mentioned in Torah. No one answer me. Do you know that the Israel peole their grandparents all come around from US and Uk? The palestinian live there from year 670 AC until now 2021. They dont have right to that land that they never leave.
I hope we’ll see more Palestinians like her, and more Israelis and Jews like Rudy come forward these coming years. I’ve seen many pro-palestine Israelis, but almost no pro-Israel palestinians. I still think the best had been a one state solution similar to how India and Pakistan were fine before being separate countries.
I love to have debates and Rudy motivates me to actually make a difference with a cool mind and peaceful talks.
Thanks man
Rudy, can you actually please have her come back for a conversation where you both prepare points on certain topics and have a discussion? She seemed so reasonable and I think it would make for a great debate to come towards each other and find a middle ground.
Israel is doing a favor to Palestine to be free of Hamas.
If all the Palestinians were like this girl we would have lived side by side as brothers. But unfortunately there are many blind and hypocrites on both sides especially the Arab side...
lmao last time I checked there re more hardcore zionists calling for the COMPLETE genocide
@@Johncena-tw8tc those vocal genocidal types are few and far between and DO NOT have the support of the public in Israel (in fact they are not even allowed to run for the Knesset if they are deemed to express racist views). Violent extremes are always worse for their own side than for their supposed enemies at the end of the day, whether it's the Kahanists or Hamas.
@@jme7298 what about hammas? Lol they are an entire militia devoted to wipe israel off the map along side the muslim brotherjood and the full support of the iranian ragime , if the idf was devoted to wipe out gaza gaza wasnt suppose to exist in 1967 , but they let em live .
I’ve learned so much in 19 minutes
The first girl was respectful but she clearly didn’t have facts or was willing to concede that she lacks knowledge. When you argue, you need to concede to facts. But i appreciate that she had a legitimate conversation and distanced herself from all external groups. She still doesn’t get that when he said ‘we need people like you’, she legitimately needs to go into politics bc she has a good heart
these two should marry
True
Damn Rudy is fine, it was difficult to concentrate on the points with him talking
Haah girls getting wet over him
Right
I love that she said Fuck Hamas. How wise of her to understand the manipulation, the control, and the propaganda is theirs.
B’H he finally found someone to talk to that is willing to listen and have a real conversation, I hope there’s more people like her in the very near future
Wow! The best debate I've ever seen so far! Two person strongly defend their sides but listen to each other. That is the best manifestation of respect. They are both right!
I really love this girl. She’s should definitely be front in center in this conflict
I haven't see this type of Israeli advocacy for quite some time...very happy to hear a moderate tone from someone willing to listen. I can also say its warming to hear a much more nuanced position from a Palestinian woman...who is genuinely interested in her people than any political agenda. This was promising...keep up the good work.
"let her speak, let her speak." nice
Don't let the civil discourse dictate how the authorities proceed with jurisdiction. If she has no ties to any anti-Israel organization then she should be eligible for Israeli citizenship, sine she loves in Israels borders like he showed.
Until Palestine dismantles Islam within Israel, you will not see an end to violence. This isn't a Jew-Palestine war it's Islam vs Jerusalem. That doesn't mean Islam vs Judaism, but rather anti-God vs God. One can be a Palestinian and not be anti-Israel but until hatred is renounced for another , it is impossible to be anything but anti-inflammatory.
Jews and Palestinians have always lived in the area in peace. There were minor issues, but when all the European jews came, they bought many lands, and Palestinians got scared that they would occupy them, which they were right. So they tried to fight, but because Britain and the USA backed up Israel, we lost the war. Arabs are very prideful and will never give up what they believe is rightfully theirs; that's why there's so much conflict. Also, Israel isn't fair and didn't know how to treat both ethnic groups as equals, making many Palestinians feel that they're occupied and not part of this new Country. Additionally, as Palestinians, and I think I speak for all. We don't support Hamas, Hizballah, the Palestinian freedom organization, Saudi, or Iran. We also don't support Israel because of the inequality. We can talk and argue forever, but Muslims know that Palestine will remain occupied and will never see freedom until the return of Christ and the day of judgment.
Fact-Fact check: Yes, it was called the British mandate Palestine, but that was not the flag it was a British ensign with the word Palestine in it that was used in that period (1920-1948) and that blue and white flag with the Zion star that they showed was never officially used.
We need more people like her
Yes we need more people that give their opinion on topics they don't even understand, the girl didn't even know where the word palestine comes from, lol.
@@sn1kzZeso what?
Both need to be leaders for both states. Unfortunately, bigots are ruling the territories.
first time hearing you, already a big fan. You actually know a lot about multiple things that most protestors dont know or ignore
Conversations like this need to be had now more than ever
I'll marry her and we can be the connection that brings Jews and Palestinians together in peace :) 💚
Rudy Rochman Will married her not you