HDD booting: Artix and Arch Linux.
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ก.ย. 2024
- We compare the boot times of Arch Linux with systemd and Artix Linux with Dinit, Runit, and S6 on an HDD drive. This video and the preceding one may be compared to highlight the differences.
Yeah it gave quite distinct results, when it seemed that systemd tie with runit, on HDD it is not true! 19s is long compared to 13s dinit which surprised me a lot. Overall I would say dinit is in both disk category the winner. I don't rate usability, only speed and lightness on those comparisons.
Yeah, Dinit is quick and extremely simple to use. S6 is also fast but hard to configure.
Dinit and S6 are at the top with 13s, followed by Runit with 16s, and Systemd is the last.
the funny thing systemD when first came out was claiming it was faster than sysVinit and that was one reason they claimed it was created (fast boot and load times) and that's when they stole/adopted systemDboot analyzer
@@RHTORAS Yeah, with systemD, I never had any speed.
Very impressive, now let's see Open RC's startup time.
I did make a video about all 4 (Dinit, S6, Runit, and OpenRC).
th-cam.com/video/LHPk3PIxh-8/w-d-xo.html
Interesting... I would have expected a much bigger difference and soystemd to be the significantly slower. But the difference is just a couple of seconds.
Yes, the setup shown in the video was the default, however when you start adding services, it will become much slower. The others hardly undergo any kind of change.
Those are definitely in margin of error which is expected.
Some services just needs some optimization applied or be done in parallel with others.
I set up each init system to its default settings. Yes, you can speed up the boot by optimizing them.
@@alphab91 I meant in General terms, not just the init system. (Except systemd maybe, cause they're basically the whole OS now. No longer GNU/Linux, rather SystemD/Linux lol)
Given how much time is wasten on some services like Network services which can definitely start at a later stage, E.G once the Desktop is up&running.
@@Mempler Yes, other init systems can be pushed farther, but not SystemD.
where is openrc i have gentoo with openrc
OpenRC and other init systems are demonstrated in a video I've previously created. and since openRC finishes third, I naturally utilize the init system default config.
I use Alpine Linux in the video.
th-cam.com/video/Cg8S47n7VQA/w-d-xo.html
I think you can do some optimization.
I'm not really sure when the boot sequence finished, can you tell us the leaderboard here?
Well, Dinit and S6 are first with 13s, then comes Runit with 16s, and last is Systemd.
@@alphab91 when did systemd finish?
@@korigamik SystemD is last with 20s.
HDD as in mechanical drive ? The non SSD drive ?
In this video, I'm using a mechanical drive, and for a solid state drive, see the previous video.
@@alphab91 were these installed on bare metal ? Or in a virtual machine with a virtual disk ? Because if it is a virtual disk, with the host os doing buffering and maybe cache ram caching, it could very well hide the HDD slowness.
@@Winnetou17 You don't think I know that.
@@alphab91 Ok, I just wanted to be sure it was taken into account. You never know!
@@Winnetou17 I was conscious of it.
Lmao zystemd btfoed
SystemD really is a mess.