My personal favorite is modern sonic. If they just make his shoes look more like hot dog shoes and make his shade of skin darker like in generations and also make his hands and shoes a bit smaller and make his eyes go into his muzzle and last but certainly not least, make his quills shorter. And yeah I think it would look perfect
Honestly it's a testament to how incredible Sonic's design is when even the worst models on the list aren't even that bad to look at. Love that little blue racoon
BOOM MODEL. I like them mainly because of the practical aspect animation like you said but If he had a more traditional face shape and zero sports tape he'd be perfect in my eyes
3:28 you just said, you literally just said that you don’t like angular polygonal designs for sonic yet you put SADX Sonic under SA Sonic. Consistency?
I will literally pay money to a TH-camr to talk about 06 and not bring up P-06, golly. Great list, very rarely do I agree with lists in general. I'd add SADX and Forces max higher, lower Modern Gens (I actually dislike the Modern Gens model, feels too large and heavy), Boom RoL Sonic on number 2 and add 06 on the number 1 spot. Generally, I think almost everyone was visually perfected in 06, Knuckles amd Tails are the only ones that didn't click with me (Knux had a great promotional render too, what a shame, he didn't look good in-game tho). And yes, I didn't include Eggman with the ugly ones, 06 Eggman's peak. Sorry. Not. Sorry. Also, surprised you skipped some. Sure, not including all Classic and Adventure Era ones makes sense but there were some big ones. The Riders models, the Shadow the Hedgehog model, Jump Pro, Runners Adventure, Chronicles, Dash. No complains, just notable. Especially for Riders and ShtH 05, they feel like big ones to leave out.
Gonna be honest, I never really liked the Sonic model from Sonic Adventure (Dreamcast). It just looks very off to me. It’s not the worst Sonic model by no means, but I just don’t care for it, personally. My favorite Sonic model is definitely the Sonic Unleashed model. I like how long the quills look and the textures still hold up really good. The Sonic Rush Adventure/Sonic Colors DS model is another personal favorite of mine too.
Hey, pup... ...You missed out the model from Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood. Sonic 4 Episode 1 was counting on you to just barely save it from last place. 😅
19:40 me wonders if boom Sonic will appear 19:42 2 seconds later boom Sonic appers also i kinda suggested this idea well mi suggestion was more of an update to your old vid even thought you probably didn't see the comment
I prefer a rounder sonic model because it makes more sense canonically, as sonic needs to be able to roll into a ball so his quills would need to be more rounded and circular, also Jim being a bit stouter would also make it easier to roll into a ball. SA1s original model grasped this concept the best I believe
Yeah. While I prefer the art style the models went for in SA2… I’d have to say when putting “Sonic turning into a ball” into account, the Adventure 1 model nails that.
Sonic The Fighters model is the closest to legit Sonic proportions as it is balanced in length, roundness etc. Judging it mostly by its flat shading is inadequate. obviously my fav. then everyone else (modern from sa2) goes under, that's all.
I think my number 1 is the Dream Team model, I just love how expressive it is, in terms of an in game model it's probably the most expressive one weve gotten
one of my biggest hot takes is that i don't like boom sonic because his proportions are too humanoid, his mouth is centered, and he doesn't really have eyebrows. on that same note, i wouldn't like lanky 06 sonic, right? no. i dislike 06 sonic only because his eyes are slightly too far apart
I agree with a lot of choices in this video, but I do not understand the 06 model love, it just looks disgusting to me. Also, the best 2D Sonic design is 3/K, and the haters are wrong.
Hot take: i highly dislike the 06 model. The best way I can explain it is that it looks a bit much? Like his limbs are ever so too long and his quills are ever so too long, to the point that they look more like dreadlocks. And the way the model is unable to make literally any other facial expressions other than his default just makes him look gormless throughout 06.
@@ChrisWilliams-ur7fn this video and many 06 fans say it’s one of their favourites. Idm if it’s anyone’s favourite but I just don’t like it myself, especially since his model in the CG cutscenes looks more like the typical sonic model and to me looks 10x better
Hey man this is supposed to be comparing like. The models and sprites, right? You're supposed to be comparing between *models?* Can you like. Actually do that? And not compare the *materials?* Feels like you compared the colors and materials of the sprites and models more than you compared how Sonic looks, putting IDENTICAL MODELS at completely opposite sides from the list Forces and Frontiers - they're the exact same model, the only difference is the materials, where Frontiers added some subsurface scattering and a fur texture. Not the model, the materials. Unleashed and Generations - Even more identical. There's actually *nothing* different between them. Like, the textures and materials aren't even different. You seem to have put Generations lower because... his skin sometimes looks greener? That's LIGHTING. That's not even the texture or material and definitely not the model, that is the *location that he is in* Classic Generations and Frontiers - same deal. The model isn't different, just the colors and the lighting of the places he's in. And this insistence on ranking based on colors and materials rather than the actual look of Sonic has permeated through a lot of your rankings too - The most obvious one is Mania, you've decided that just because his color is too cyan - which is a criticism I agree with - that means the ranking is way lower than it should be. Same with Advance, I agree the skin tone is a bit too yellow but that is an offensively low ranking for sprites that get so much of Sonic's best design traits down. And don't even get me STARTED on Heroes - dude, yes, the model is a little bit too shiny, but like??? Why is THAT alone reason to put it *second lowest on the list?* As if everything else about the model isn't PERFECT MODERN SONIC??? As if that is not a beautiful conversion of Sonic's best design traits, from the nice circular head and muzzle flow and all the cartoony charm we love these characters for? Colors are an important part of a design but they absolutely should not be such a big deal that they overwrite what the title says the video is actually about. (Sorry if I seem overly angry in this comment, I'm really not that angry lol)
@@ChannelPup Totally get that, but it feels to me like you're focusing too much on the colors and only the colors, rather than the actual look of Sonic. Again colors are important but, this feels to me like if I hue shifted the SA1 model slightly too cyan you'd place it in like 17 instead of 1. I mean hey it's your list at the end of the day but it just kinda baffles me lol
@@fyb3rotik I understand man, mania just felt so good for me bc of the garbage we had been getting for 6 years and classic generations isn’t prefect in my opinion.
10:30 ain’t no way your dissing 06 sonic, he doesn’t look lanky in the slightest, 06 sonic was the best he every looked in a sonic game he looks more mature, has more of a chill laid back hero personality and to put rumble sonic, classic sonic or meta era sonic over this really shows your bias
To anyone reading this, please repent and believe the gospel! There is a loving God who wants to save you. And because He loves us, He (Jesus) died on the cross and resurrected so we can be forgiven of our sins and be saved. Please think about the state of your soul, don't let this chance pass you by. Believe in Jesus and follow Him so you may have salvation. Life is short, please make the right choice today before its too late. Jesus loves you and is waiting for you to put your faith in Him.
You cannot tell me the Sonic 3d Blast model is a better model than the Heroes model.
really does tho
The Sonic Spinball model isn't on this list.
@@nathanielvaughn6728 sprite*
Advance sprites are the most iconic ones out there
I know why, you know why, we all know why
ILL CRUSH YOU
@@adreeeandanothere510”Now I’ll show you!”
Fun list. Kinda thought you would talk about the outside-of-battle dialogue sprites from Sonic Battle considering how unique they are.
As someone who's been using Blender to make lots of Chao Garden assets, I'm glad I can understand Pup's special language.
I’m also another Frontiers model defender. I like his bright shade of blue.
I like the model too it's slightly better than forces although I hope they change it for frontiers 2 to be it's own model
Unleashed model is elite
I agree, but i also like the 06 model
@@zach9760 fair
Peak design too, since it’s the closest to the marza design
@@zach9760fr bro
Hot take:The 06 Model and Heroes are Peak
06 good, heroes?!? Your mad
I agree the 06 model is peak and hell it’s the model that sonic is currently using in sonic 3 which I noticed immediately which is sick
Yeah? Heroes?
Somebody is a fan of Vaseline it seems.
O6 I think so too heros no
Heroes? You must be high on that crack right now 😂😂
My personal favorite is modern sonic. If they just make his shoes look more like hot dog shoes and make his shade of skin darker like in generations and also make his hands and shoes a bit smaller and make his eyes go into his muzzle and last but certainly not least, make his quills shorter. And yeah I think it would look perfect
Sonic Heroes in second to last hit me like a bullet 😭🙏
I LOVE THIS NEW ANIMATION STYLE!!! THAT OLD FRAME WAS CRUSTY
Hot Take: I prefer the SADX models to the Dreamcast models.
I honestly agree but i still prefer the way the dreamcast version of the game looks overall so i just bite the bullet and play that version instead
I love the sadx models but the Dreamcast world textures
I prefer it but I would like it better if it didn’t have the shiny look to it
The Sonic Rush/Rush Adventure & Colors DS models are top-notch.
Honestly it's a testament to how incredible Sonic's design is when even the worst models on the list aren't even that bad to look at. Love that little blue racoon
Pup is on the void the Eggmans got sent on the end of Generations
Every time u upload i get exited idk why probably cuz ur a great TH-camr ❤️
SADX Sonic is criminally underrated, one of my favorites.
I just think of all the flash games and animations when I see the advance sprites lol
Ultimate Flash Sonic. Pure nostalgia.
Pup I don't think you're surviving after this one...
I did a video like this a couple years ago and you and I had VERY different rankings.
Dude! I literally asked for a video like this. Thank you!
BOOM MODEL. I like them mainly because of the practical aspect animation like you said but If he had a more traditional face shape and zero sports tape he'd be perfect in my eyes
The best model would have to be the unleashed and SA2 models, and the best sprite would have to be S3&K, Mania, and the advance sprites
I 100% agree with your goofy polygonal choice for #1
"He's shaped like a friend."
18:34 Yea I light torches under my fingers all the time. Yet I always smell something burning afterwards
No Sonic Chronicles, Sonic Shuffle, Battle, Master system games, Game gear titles, riders, etc etc
Definitely not every model and sprite is ranked
He also neglects the DC SA2 model, only including the SA2B model, despite having the DC SA and SADX as separate entries.
Is movie sonic on here? He has 2 game models but if not is dream team sonic on here?
Sonic adventure 1,2 and 06 are my FAVS
I agree with the number one spot hell he looks like the transition between modern and classic
3:28 you just said, you literally just said that you don’t like angular polygonal designs for sonic yet you put SADX Sonic under SA Sonic. Consistency?
I will literally pay money to a TH-camr to talk about 06 and not bring up P-06, golly. Great list, very rarely do I agree with lists in general. I'd add SADX and Forces max higher, lower Modern Gens (I actually dislike the Modern Gens model, feels too large and heavy), Boom RoL Sonic on number 2 and add 06 on the number 1 spot. Generally, I think almost everyone was visually perfected in 06, Knuckles amd Tails are the only ones that didn't click with me (Knux had a great promotional render too, what a shame, he didn't look good in-game tho). And yes, I didn't include Eggman with the ugly ones, 06 Eggman's peak. Sorry. Not. Sorry.
Also, surprised you skipped some. Sure, not including all Classic and Adventure Era ones makes sense but there were some big ones. The Riders models, the Shadow the Hedgehog model, Jump Pro, Runners Adventure, Chronicles, Dash. No complains, just notable. Especially for Riders and ShtH 05, they feel like big ones to leave out.
Sonic Rush/Rush Adventure and Colors DS are nothing but top notch perfection in every way. Detail, model, cuteness. It perfect
My favorite (classic) Sonic sprite is Sonic Mania. I js wish his blue was a bit darker. But I still dig it.
I can't believe Pup hasn't mentionned the objectively best sonic model: sonic from sonic chronicles the dark brotherhood🙃
Gonna be honest, I never really liked the Sonic model from Sonic Adventure (Dreamcast). It just looks very off to me. It’s not the worst Sonic model by no means, but I just don’t care for it, personally.
My favorite Sonic model is definitely the Sonic Unleashed model. I like how long the quills look and the textures still hold up really good. The Sonic Rush Adventure/Sonic Colors DS model is another personal favorite of mine too.
Your intro in 1.25 speed goes hard
Hey Pup, are you planning to rank all of Shadows models after SXSG releases?
Hey, pup...
...You missed out the model from Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood.
Sonic 4 Episode 1 was counting on you to just barely save it from last place. 😅
forgot sonic shuffle, movies and sonic from collaboration games
19:40 me wonders if boom Sonic will appear 19:42 2 seconds later boom Sonic appers also i kinda suggested this idea well mi suggestion was more of an update to your old vid even thought you probably didn't see the comment
I prefer a rounder sonic model because it makes more sense canonically, as sonic needs to be able to roll into a ball so his quills would need to be more rounded and circular, also Jim being a bit stouter would also make it easier to roll into a ball. SA1s original model grasped this concept the best I believe
Yeah. While I prefer the art style the models went for in SA2… I’d have to say when putting “Sonic turning into a ball” into account, the Adventure 1 model nails that.
24:30 hey tails check out this cool cat!
Sonic The Fighters model is the closest to legit Sonic proportions as it is balanced in length, roundness etc. Judging it mostly by its flat shading is inadequate.
obviously my fav.
then everyone else (modern from sa2) goes under, that's all.
My favorite is the unleashed model.
Will you be doing a model and sprite rank for Shadow as well?
Not even a mention of the Sonic Chronicles sprites/model?
You forgot Sonic Spinball and the 8 bit games
24:55 I didn’t know WhisperWolf possessed you.
I honestly prefer Sonic to have longer quils and for Classic Sonic to be light blue.
I think my number 1 is the Dream Team model, I just love how expressive it is, in terms of an in game model it's probably the most expressive one weve gotten
NGL, yall forgetting the Werehog model. Ignoring gameplay (even though its really good) the design rig, and execution is absolutely on point.
I thought advance sonic sprites was trying to replicate ukowa artwork
Best Sonic Aveture 2 Sonic!! For me.
I love boom model
The best model is the sonic rush adventure model and the 06 model (not really a hot take but that’s my opinion argue with me if you want lmao)
I really love SADX sonic
Shadow models and sprites next?
6:36 why is this higher than the bottom 2. Why is mania only one place higher?
22:32 fin.
What about the Olympic Games ones.?
Best one: the one from Sonic Chronicles 🤌🏻🤌🏻🤌🏻
sonic blast is goated
one of my biggest hot takes is that i don't like boom sonic because his proportions are too humanoid, his mouth is centered, and he doesn't really have eyebrows. on that same note, i wouldn't like lanky 06 sonic, right? no. i dislike 06 sonic only because his eyes are slightly too far apart
25:24 fin.
BASED.
Sonic and the black knight?
Sonic Blast sprite is actually the best one
Sonic Adventure (Dreamcast) has the best in my opinion
So no Sonic Runners?
I agree with a lot of choices in this video, but I do not understand the 06 model love, it just looks disgusting to me. Also, the best 2D Sonic design is 3/K, and the haters are wrong.
Sorry, I genuinely couldn't see what you were looking for.😅😅😅
Hot take: i highly dislike the 06 model. The best way I can explain it is that it looks a bit much? Like his limbs are ever so too long and his quills are ever so too long, to the point that they look more like dreadlocks. And the way the model is unable to make literally any other facial expressions other than his default just makes him look gormless throughout 06.
How is that a hot take? Everyone says it's way too lanky.
@@ChrisWilliams-ur7fn this video and many 06 fans say it’s one of their favourites. Idm if it’s anyone’s favourite but I just don’t like it myself, especially since his model in the CG cutscenes looks more like the typical sonic model and to me looks 10x better
I prefer the jam model over like half of them
You missed the sonic riders model lmao
Why do you change your theme? Your old theme is better
I feel like you missed a bunch of things.
Man just forgot the Rivals games and Pocket Adventure exist?
#FakeFan
Super sonic 3 sprite solos
Hey man this is supposed to be comparing like. The models and sprites, right? You're supposed to be comparing between *models?*
Can you like. Actually do that? And not compare the *materials?*
Feels like you compared the colors and materials of the sprites and models more than you compared how Sonic looks, putting IDENTICAL MODELS at completely opposite sides from the list
Forces and Frontiers - they're the exact same model, the only difference is the materials, where Frontiers added some subsurface scattering and a fur texture. Not the model, the materials.
Unleashed and Generations - Even more identical. There's actually *nothing* different between them. Like, the textures and materials aren't even different. You seem to have put Generations lower because... his skin sometimes looks greener? That's LIGHTING. That's not even the texture or material and definitely not the model, that is the *location that he is in*
Classic Generations and Frontiers - same deal. The model isn't different, just the colors and the lighting of the places he's in.
And this insistence on ranking based on colors and materials rather than the actual look of Sonic has permeated through a lot of your rankings too -
The most obvious one is Mania, you've decided that just because his color is too cyan - which is a criticism I agree with - that means the ranking is way lower than it should be. Same with Advance, I agree the skin tone is a bit too yellow but that is an offensively low ranking for sprites that get so much of Sonic's best design traits down. And don't even get me STARTED on Heroes - dude, yes, the model is a little bit too shiny, but like??? Why is THAT alone reason to put it *second lowest on the list?* As if everything else about the model isn't PERFECT MODERN SONIC??? As if that is not a beautiful conversion of Sonic's best design traits, from the nice circular head and muzzle flow and all the cartoony charm we love these characters for?
Colors are an important part of a design but they absolutely should not be such a big deal that they overwrite what the title says the video is actually about. (Sorry if I seem overly angry in this comment, I'm really not that angry lol)
1:07 the video is titled that purely because I don't know what else to title it. It's just a ranking of how Sonic looks exclusively in-game.
@@ChannelPup Totally get that, but it feels to me like you're focusing too much on the colors and only the colors, rather than the actual look of Sonic. Again colors are important but, this feels to me like if I hue shifted the SA1 model slightly too cyan you'd place it in like 17 instead of 1. I mean hey it's your list at the end of the day but it just kinda baffles me lol
sonic unleashed is superior idc what anyone says
Any sonic after like 2010 is bunk
Generations models, mania sprites????
@@The_real_tomold don’t like mani just because the color but it’s pretty good. Generations I didn’t like too much
@@fyb3rotik I understand man, mania just felt so good for me bc of the garbage we had been getting for 6 years and classic generations isn’t prefect in my opinion.
10:30 ain’t no way your dissing 06 sonic, he doesn’t look lanky in the slightest, 06 sonic was the best he every looked in a sonic game he looks more mature, has more of a chill laid back hero personality and to put rumble sonic, classic sonic or meta era sonic over this really shows your bias
I'm unsubbing now
To anyone reading this, please repent and believe the gospel! There is a loving God who wants to save you. And because He loves us, He (Jesus) died on the cross and resurrected so we can be forgiven of our sins and be saved. Please think about the state of your soul, don't let this chance pass you by. Believe in Jesus and follow Him so you may have salvation. Life is short, please make the right choice today before its too late. Jesus loves you and is waiting for you to put your faith in Him.