My Mario Challenge Videos Tier List
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.พ. 2025
- I've made 40 Super Mario Challenge videos, so figured it'd be fun to put them in a tier list based on difficulty before Mario Bros Wonder is out!
See my Videos Early! ► / @nathanielbandy
Bathaniel Nandy ► @RealBathanielNandy
Nathaniel Bandy Live ► @NathanielBandyLive
Merch ► crowdmade.com/...
Video Edited by: / beegjon_
Channel Avatars by @Charriii5
If you've missed a bunch of these videos, here's a handful of my favs you can check out if you'd like!
Super Mario 64 DS Without Mario: th-cam.com/video/xRmbFCFEOKc/w-d-xo.htmlsi=YWLbAJfbhKrZx6RO
New Super Mario Bros 2 Touching Every Coin: th-cam.com/video/oC_ZHFiueCc/w-d-xo.htmlsi=QOx_YPxP1iX9aHOc
Mario Party While Doing Absolutely Nothing: th-cam.com/video/6fxLOz16mvo/w-d-xo.htmlsi=fgZJDWTLTBrlmJrw
Super Mario 64 While Only Pressing Up: th-cam.com/video/-BYj62LSeJA/w-d-xo.htmlsi=-NK-4iBtyVCk0GlB
You’re a mook😒
Tier list all your tier list videos
Unrelated but what is this background music??? 10:18
bro, can't lie I grew up on these things. It was so cool to reminisce with you.
edit: No, I'm not 9, but I'm certainly not an adult lol
I remember waking up early so I could watch these kinds of videos.
lil bro it was only 4 years ago
@@rattfishthat’s a whole middle/ high school cycle (at least in America)
Exactly
I remember watching these videos when I was like 7
dawg its been like a year are you 9
I really like how instead of going like "oh, they're all great! you should go and watch them!" Nathaniel knows that some of his videos aren't great and admits it.
I mean I'm pretty sure this is a video on how hard the challenges were and not the quality of the video hehe
@@MapleLunii I was lazy and wrote the comment before I watched the vid
yeah we all knew that already. people like you are the reason youtube is insufferable nowadays
@@MapleLuniiEven still, he acknowledges when a video was lower quality than others (for example: all the ones from before 2019)
I like all of them
0:30 NSMBWii All Coins
2:42 SM3DW All Coins
4:05 Mario 64 All Coins
5:47 NSMBU/Luigi U All Coins
8:11 NSMB(DS) with only Feet 🦶🏻🦶🏻
9:05 NSMB(DS) All Coins
10:16 Mario 64 DS without Mario
11:00 Super Mario Maker Event Courses All Coins
11:58 NSMBU Without Touching the Ground
12:59 Super Mario Maker 2 Max Coin Count
13:59 NSMB(DS) Blue Shell Only
15:24 Super Mario Galaxy All Starbits
17:28 Super Mario Galaxy 2 All Starbits
18:54 NSMB2 All Coins
21:00 SM3DL All Coins
21:50 Mario 64 Riding a Koopa Shell
23:20 Win a Game of Mario Party while doing Absolutely Nothing
23:32 SMB3 No Blocks
24:41 Mario 64 Pressing Up
25:52 NSMB(DS) Backwards
27:09 Minimum Jumps Required in order to Beat Super Mario Sunshine
27:48 Lego Mario Max Coin Count
28:19 NSMBWii Backwards
29:37 NSMB2 Backwards
30:18 SMB3 All Coins
31:10 Mario 64 With Only Elbows
31:56 Bowser's Fury Crouching
32:15 SM3DW Backwards(Favorite video that NB has made ⭐)
32:38 Mario 64 and SM64DS at the Same Time
33:05 Super Mario Galaxy 1 and 2 at the Same Time
33:26 SM3DL Crouching(eventually with his feet too)
34:02 Lego Luigi Max Coin Count
34:12 Win a Game of Mario Party at 10,000% Speed
34:28 Mario 64 but Coins = Health
35:53 Mario 64 but you're a Koopa Troopa
37:02 MKWii and MK8 Deluxe at the Same Time
38:05 Mario+Rabbids: Sparks of Hope but you can't play as Mario(outside the tutorial battles)
38:58 SM3DL Backwards
40:11 100% All 3D Mario Games in a week
40:54 100% All Mario Kart Games in a week
Omg dedication
6:08 When he farted
@@jrahm95🤣🤣🤣💨💨💨
I like the "sm64 but your health drains every second if you don't have coins" challenge because you were able to collect all 120 stars, but not beat final Bowser
6:08 “but yeah, this was when I farted”
We’re all glad you feel comfortable saying that, NB, but next time keep it to yourself 😉
Seriously?
Bro has the balls to rank his videos and not put all of them in s tier.
+1000000 respect
he's ranking the difficulty of them tho
Bro same he has the balls
one of Nathaniel’s greatest rivals: *coin splatters*
It's generally agreed that Super Mario Sunshine is the hardest 3D Super Mario game by some distance.
Oh for sure. I feel like every level has at least 3 or 4 difficult shines. Plus all the blue coins and secret shines
Galaxy: I exist
@@Paper246 Galaxy 1 and 2 are not difficult at all. Never really played Sunshine but I can tell that game is harder than both Galaxies
@@skyeassassin6237 you don’t know what suffering I went through
Sunshine blows.
6:08 “This is when I farted…”😂
6:08 this is the moment when Nathaniel farted
I've been watching these videos for years and years now, so cool seeing the behind the scenes of some of my favourite TH-cam videos from my childhood
This was prime content it’s crazy how much time flew by
The elbows only challenge, despite how difficult it was, is by far one of my favorite challenges that you have done. I felt your pain in that video but your dedication was incredible😊😊
I agree gamefan 😎
^^^ Hiiii Nicho@@NichoXR
A look back at NB’s Mario challenge videos. Very classic memories! 👍
I’ve been a fan since just before Covid, during Covid I was very lonely, you and these videos kept me company. I’ll rewatch it all after this. Keep up the amazing work 👍.
This is as meta as the “How Nathaniel Bandy Triggers You” video
Nathaniel B is the type of guy to do a tier list of his own videos
The sambucha stuff has spread all over TH-cam 😂
He made top 10 worst nathaniel bandy videos video too
Don't start the trend here. That joke stays in Sambucha's channel.
@@ajjtheamazing5615 no it shouldn’t not even be in sambucha it’s annoying
@@Conor5fr bro
8:28 dan schneider really happy rn
It’s cool to know that striving for originality has gotten you this far
I remember watching these challenge videos all the time, seriously they were so cool
Also 6:08 that was crazy
Mario 64 DS without Mario is in S tier of all TH-cam videos ever
I like many of your challenge videos. Also It was an honor getting to meet you at the Cleveland Game Convention, and my friends wanted to say thank you and we hope you continue making awesome videos going forward.
I can’t wait for the Mario Bros Wonder Coins Challenge Video. It’s going to be verry interesting if it’s possible or not to beat the game with collecting all the coins
I remember watching the blue shell one and thinking this looks super fun and then I tried it and it was so damn hard
6:08 "but yeah this was when I fated-"
:/
6:08 Subtitles: This was when I farted
22:18 “Finding enough coins that I can beat with the Koopa shell.”
It's always nice to look back on the old challenges....good times.
Also who here thinks it will be a good idea to update the tier list with every new challenge video?
Yeah
Agreed. He should also rank the rest of his challenge vids too
It was cool to see all these type of challenges. I know I couldn't do any of them. These videos give a whole new perspective of the game I never imagined.
cant wait for ''is it possible to beat super mario bros wonder while collecting every coin''
Nathaniel bandy videos are amazing and creative i watch a lot of the triggers videos and i never get bored of them and the is it possible to videos are amazing too keep making videos
whenever im bored, i always come back to your challenge videos for some reason. id say they’re likely some of my most watched videos on all of youtube
Always enjoy when Nathaniel looks back at his old content
Nathaniel is the type of guy to make good content 👍
Yes he is 😉
Video Request: “The SMG4 x Marvel Iceberg”
Description: “How much does SMG4 and Marvel have in common?”
It's nice to look back on the old challenges....good times....
Also who here think Nathaniel should update the tier list whenever he makes a new challenge video?
6:08 ‘this is when I farted’
i did grow up on these videos. it’s nice to see you ranking these.
Bro a blue shell power up would be the BEST in super Mario Bros Wonder
Love this video idea. It’s almost like a commentary of his old videos
6:08 - 6:09 This is when i farte- finally started to use maps.
You can't hide it buddy.
Now we need a tier list of his tier lists
These were my favorite videos to watch. Thanks for all the behind the scenes!
yeah this is when i farted-finally
I think this is the video I’ve been waiting for
With mario wonder, you have to do a challenge without touching the ground. It would work so well with the bubble flower and parachute cap
This is by far the best Nathaniel Bandy Mario Challenge Tier List video on TH-cam uploaded today
I loved your super Mario 64 only with elbows video that was hilarious but painful to watch 😂
I like how in some parts, Nathaniel just has Vietnam flashbacks
I like it when youtubers are critical about their content and don't pretend like everything they have made is perfect.
6:09, famous last words.
not a hater btw
22:30 The only other game that you can use a shell in besides 64 and NSMB would be Mario 3D World, which would actually be fun to see you try
That game only lets you in the shell for a little bit and then your character jumps out automatically unfortunately. It would be cool if here was a mod that let you stay on forever though. Also Bowser’s Fury has the shell thing too.
I didn't really think about that lol, maybe he could get someone to mod it differently idk
I loved the all coins/no coins challenge videos. The commentary and editing make for a very fluid captivating video
"So this is where I farted... [paraphrased]" -Nathaniel Bandy
Ah yes, the try not to PTSD challenge
me, being a hardcore nathaniel bandy fan and knowing he forgot to rank the mario 64 in VR video
Seeing Nathaniel Bandy having PTSD over his videos tells you that those specific ones were extremely difficult
I can’t wait for Super Mario Bros Wonder. Great tier list my friend.
Nintendo making Mario fans starve so bad that bro has to do a teir list of his own self imposed Mario challenge runs
I think everyone can agree that we all wish Nathaniel recorded his reaction to finally getting all of those blue coins in New super Mario bros Wii.
Now we need a tier list of tier lists
The dedication that went into this video was probably CRAZY!
5:25 makes the like button light up
One of my favourite concepts for a video yet! Good job
6:08 was when he farted
You probably know this but you can ground pound the multi coin blocks and then the group at the end will spawn down rather than sprout up
6:08 "But yeah this was when I farted"
Ha
I’m a Mario fan since 2008 (I was 3) it has been 15 years and damn I know how you feel, there’s gonna be a lot of videos of Mario wonder videos be the first to do that!!!
6:08 when you what?! 💀
The 64 elbows was the most insane 😂
Can't wait to see the tier list for your ranking videos
Im so excited for all the videos on mario wonder!!
These and Nicobbq’s challenges are my comfort videos
5:24 lights up the like button
Cool video, Nat! Could you make a video called "Top 70 Crazy Sonic Boss Battles"?
This is pretty cool!
30:18 You Still Need To Do New Super Mario Bros. U Backwards!
And Luigi U. He still hasn't done that either
Can you do a Marathon of 100%ing every Mario 2D Game in one week?
for Mario wonder you should do a challenge where you have to stay underground the entire time with the new drill power up.if you did have to get out you cant walk or move just jump out of the ground.
They were all great!
I wonder how he thinks about the Sonic and Pokémon challenges?
Just an idea for these videos how about speed running collecting all coins and comparing them? Since you said some where more easier than others speed running them would be fun to see!
Cant wait for the tier list of all your tier lists
6:08 "This was when I farted"
Reminds me of back in the day when NB reacted to his old old Top 10s, good times
6:08 bro farted
Time for Nathaniel to rank every video on his channel
im more excited for Mario vs donkey kong, but I'll be sure to get wonder when it comes out...I did not know it was coming out so soon
Idea: Every 2d Mario Game In A Week (Including Donkey Kong, Mario Bros, And Mario Run)
He’s doing it live in the Live channel.
Keep up the good work Nathaniel Bandy 👍
honestly, i was genuinely feeling bad for Nathaniel when he was doing the 7 day 3D Mario challenge: i could really feel how much this challenge was draining his physical and mental health
True I couldn’t imagine doing all of that bs in a week considering how big Mario odyssey is
Nice video! Nice tier list!
I can’t wait for all the Mario wonder content
NB every time he is in a coin based level
NB: Since when was I playing NSMB2
probably no blue shell badge but cant wait for the Jet Run badge only run
These challenges show that NB is a true major league gamer.
Sm64 DS without Mario was the first video I've ever seen from him
Your videos are so fun to binge wafch as of late.
17:50 OHHHH!! TRUST ME. Galaxy Max Coins is really hard. I made a video on it. I won't even touch Galaxy 2 Max Coins for a few years.
We need a wonder affect for super Mario bros wonder where the art style changes to super Mario bros 1 and all the enemies change too! And the new ones and the 3 new power-ups.