@@ThatOneHumanXOXO Yeah, and why he just gives up on her. Gamewise sure, she is supposed to be a players option, but still. Clint seems to have so less personality except for being me in my teen years :D
@@arakitanny I think they really appreciate the ancient fruit wine we give them. You might convince me to start shipping rice, veggies (over fruits) and cooked meals.
Yeah, I've played this game for a while - Kent has some serious PTSD - he used to like popcorn, but when Jodi cooked some in one of his heart events, it sounded like gunfire and upset him. So yeah.
Poppies fall apart within minutes of being picked and turn into an absolute mess - in real life that is. I've always figured that's why people don't like them. 😅
In Poland poppies are consider a symbol of sacrificed blood. We also have our own poem turned into song "Red Poppies on Monte Cassino" there is a fragment that says "... all the poppies on Monte Cassino will be redder because they will grow from polish blood"
@@PrinzPapiertuete There is a recipe in the game called "Carp Surprise" which calls for carp. Funnily while just needing Carp it is a liked gift for most.
@@Hankal31doscope yes in fact Jodi points out that he loves popcorn "But, dear... popcorn was always your favorite before you left." so he still loves to eat it ❤️ on a related note it's sad we can't cook popcorn... it would be a great gift
I liked the theory that penny had a relative that fought in the war and died like her dad or uncle and that’s why she loves poppies so much, to honour their memory
Thank you for making a video semi about my beloved w... dear Penny. I would never have thought, there was so much more behind this gift selection. With all of this careful consideration and deep thought, i pray, that CA will never become an evil genious.
As a kid i can remember beeing told not to smell or pick Poppies because they could give you a headache 😄🤷🏼♀️ Not sure if it's true but it surely kept us from playing with them
It might also be the national flower of the Gotoro Empire?...perhaps, but perhaps not? I mean, it isn't illegal to grow them, seeing as how you need them to make poppyseed muffins.
They definetly doesn't eanna think about War. Except Kent's family no one even talks about it. Also they have a eight festival for a year and i find it weird. İ also find it weird that Kent is a soldier but not any of the growing mans in the Pelican Town has nothing to do with this War. İ mekan aren't they suppossed to going to fight?🤨
Things still need to be done at home. Draft’s weren’t part of every war and few places do them. Plus I doubt the rest of the men in the town would have made good soldiers.
hiii i love your videos im so glad i came across this channel, i feel like all your lore theories make SO much sense and they're not a stretch at all! keep up the awesome work. 😁
@@kathrysn2534 thank you so much!!! I'm gonna knock your socks off when I upload my "Why every character is actually in a dream" video (the late night editing has rotted my brain)
This is a cool deep dive video! Also after 2 years of playing Stardew, today is the first day I realised, from your thumbnail, a portrait of Kent, I realised his jacket and colour of it, his top colour, looks awfully a lot like James Sutherland from Silent Hill 2, he also had military jacket on and dark grey top too, both are blonde haired too. I wonder if CA used James as an inspiration when he was making Kent, or it's just a pure coincidence.
Oooooh! I didn't know that from Poppy flowers, I knew there was something about them but didn't exactly know what. Now I know, thank you! Btw I love your deep dive on the universality loved gift in this vid, it's interesting! Btw I'll try my best to catch ya on a live stream! They're fun 😄❤ Also, I love that "Is poppy the wizard's daughter?" It caught me off guard but it was pretty hilarious 😂
Am fairly sure I’ve seen Penny mention that she would not mind/wishes that our farm has a field of flowers ( defenitely a Oz reference in my head 😅) and her wording differs if you are married or not to her when she states it. ( granted my mind is unhelpfull as to when she states it, but it is a fairly late game comment.) So the escapism is more than likely an underlying ’cause in my head so headcanon acceppted easily and already there 😂 thanks for sharing
@@sodorart You are welcome! Only got a ”few” hours in the game on pc and ipad 🙈 soo, got a few diffrent playthroughs ( only one is joja tho’) and while on my playthrough on my ipad I decided to marry Penny and she do have her uses when it comes to decorating 🤓 and do have a comment from Sebastian too in regards of slime hutches, but have yet to figure out if that is a mod or not as I’ve yet to marry him in og 😅
What Stardew Valley item should I make a theory video about? 🤔
Stardrop tea would make an interesting theory
@@ThatOneHumanXOXO Yeah, and why he just gives up on her. Gamewise sure, she is supposed to be a players option, but still. Clint seems to have so less personality except for being me in my teen years :D
@@ThatOneHumanXOXO tysm!!
the different gems and who likes what gem?
@@GlenCocoon I wrote this down!
There is a war. No wonder being a Farmer is so profitable. We are single handedly providing food to the whole army
@@arakitanny I think they really appreciate the ancient fruit wine we give them. You might convince me to start shipping rice, veggies (over fruits) and cooked meals.
I understand why Kent hates something used to symbolise lost soldier during wars
Yeah, I've played this game for a while - Kent has some serious PTSD - he used to like popcorn, but when Jodi cooked some in one of his heart events, it sounded like gunfire and upset him. So yeah.
@@AgdaFingersHe also gets nervous during the flower dance because the open field doesn't provide any cover
But it's a way to honor them?
@buyingmilk I know, but his (presumably) best friend died, and that might not be a good thing for his PTSD
“Is Poppy the Wizard’s daughter???” is the funniest thing I’ve ever heard 😂
LOLOLOLOL
@@sodorart Interesting to note though that Kent advises if he and Jody had a daughter, they would name her after a flower..
Poppies fall apart within minutes of being picked and turn into an absolute mess - in real life that is. I've always figured that's why people don't like them. 😅
LOL
Yeah, if you pick up a poppy whole with your bare hands you are in possession of some sinister powers
This explains why when I once gifted Sam a poppy (he said he liked flowers) his sprite looked off to the side and he said “You just don’t get it…”
my boy,, (ಥ﹏ಥ)
In Poland poppies are consider a symbol of sacrificed blood. We also have our own poem turned into song "Red Poppies on Monte Cassino" there is a fragment that says "... all the poppies on Monte Cassino will be redder because they will grow from polish blood"
interesting deep dive! but there's a universal hated gift that absolutely confuses me: the carp. Literally what did an average lake fish do.
I'll make a video!!
I think thats because some people consider it a "trash" fish. As in a fish that either lives in dirty water or is just annoying to prepare.
Maybe it's holy and catching it off the lakes and gifting it is a sacrileg?
@@PrinzPapiertuete There is a recipe in the game called "Carp Surprise" which calls for carp. Funnily while just needing Carp it is a liked gift for most.
@@PrinzPapiertuete sometimes you can find carp in their trashcans...
Recently I took Kent to the theatre and looked up what concession food he liked… popcorn 🍿😭
Simple pleasures 💛
@@sodorart he is triggered by the sound of making popcorn but seems like if he doesn't have tk hear it he is fond of it...
@@GlenCocoon ohhhh I see !!!
The sound of it popping reminded him of the war, the taste alone wouldn't traumatize him
@@Hankal31doscope yes in fact Jodi points out that he loves popcorn "But, dear... popcorn was always your favorite before you left." so he still loves to eat it ❤️ on a related note it's sad we can't cook popcorn... it would be a great gift
I liked the theory that penny had a relative that fought in the war and died like her dad or uncle and that’s why she loves poppies so much, to honour their memory
And here I was thinking Penny is a secret narcotics addict
@@Cephas nope! 7000 crab attack! 🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥
Sees poppy
"It's a war criminal"
The Wizard of Oz is also where I first found out about people being put to sleep with poppies - however I saw the movie (1939) first.
@@AgdaFingers OLD!
This might be a 1.5 thing, but Alex is just neutral towards daffodils, he likes other flowers, but daffodils are just OK.
Thank you for making a video semi about my beloved w... dear Penny. I would never have thought, there was so much more behind this gift selection. With all of this careful consideration and deep thought, i pray, that CA will never become an evil genious.
It's amazing how much lore is in the tiniest parts
As a kid i can remember beeing told not to smell or pick Poppies because they could give you a headache 😄🤷🏼♀️ Not sure if it's true but it surely kept us from playing with them
I actually never thought about it , but this makes a lot of sense!
:D
I love Stardew Valley videos but I especially value yours because of the deep dives into the lore and theories. Thank you for creating this content!
Glad you like them!
It might also be the national flower of the Gotoro Empire?...perhaps, but perhaps not? I mean, it isn't illegal to grow them, seeing as how you need them to make poppyseed muffins.
They definetly doesn't eanna think about War. Except Kent's family no one even talks about it. Also they have a eight festival for a year and i find it weird. İ also find it weird that Kent is a soldier but not any of the growing mans in the Pelican Town has nothing to do with this War. İ mekan aren't they suppossed to going to fight?🤨
Maybe there hasnt been a draft
@@sodorart some drafts are random instead of all of one age group. It could be that Kent was one of the men randomly picked.
Things still need to be done at home. Draft’s weren’t part of every war and few places do them. Plus I doubt the rest of the men in the town would have made good soldiers.
Poppies are also used as a symbol of remembrance in Australia, we wear them and plant them on Anzac day :))
@@dairyblitz in remembrance for what? :O
This is such a cool theory, it makes so much sense
Thank you!!
I downloaded a mod that turns poppies into talking flowers. I love poppies now.
That's so lovely!!
It’s on nexus mods if you want to download it.
I like the explanation of why penny likes poppies ❤️ it really adds up
Thank you!!
hiii i love your videos im so glad i came across this channel, i feel like all your lore theories make SO much sense and they're not a stretch at all! keep up the awesome work. 😁
@@kathrysn2534 thank you so much!!! I'm gonna knock your socks off when I upload my "Why every character is actually in a dream" video (the late night editing has rotted my brain)
@@sodorart ahhh im actually so excited to see what you come up with!!
This is a cool deep dive video! Also after 2 years of playing Stardew, today is the first day I realised, from your thumbnail, a portrait of Kent, I realised his jacket and colour of it, his top colour, looks awfully a lot like James Sutherland from Silent Hill 2, he also had military jacket on and dark grey top too, both are blonde haired too. I wonder if CA used James as an inspiration when he was making Kent, or it's just a pure coincidence.
@@girlytomboyx thank you! And yeah, wow, I see the resemblance! :O
Oooooh! I didn't know that from Poppy flowers, I knew there was something about them but didn't exactly know what. Now I know, thank you! Btw I love your deep dive on the universality loved gift in this vid, it's interesting! Btw I'll try my best to catch ya on a live stream! They're fun 😄❤
Also, I love that "Is poppy the wizard's daughter?" It caught me off guard but it was pretty hilarious 😂
I'm glad you enjoyed the video !!! And thank you for the kind words!!
I gotta pull a fast one to keep peeps on their toes LOL
figuring out penny is extremely suicidal is not what i expected from this video
Aren't butterflied shrimp just little bug steaks?
@@EtherealSlate ayo?????
Woah ive never thought of this. Awesome video btw :D !
Thank you!!
It's interesting how Poppies are universally hated, but Poppy seed muffins are loved by some characters
I just finished Kent's request on a board, and you know which it was? Bring joja cola to him. He hates it so i find it really funny.
@@killsthelight5511 LOL
Wow sodor nice video!! You are so very epic
Thank you so much!!! I hope you enjoyed the video!!
I love the Wizard of Oz and Penny loving books and thus loving poppies because potentially of the wizard of Oz is very cute and I like it
Make a theory about Mr Qi, and what he is doing/ who he actually may be.
Am fairly sure I’ve seen Penny mention that she would not mind/wishes that our farm has a field of flowers ( defenitely a Oz reference in my head 😅) and her wording differs if you are married or not to her when she states it. ( granted my mind is unhelpfull as to when she states it, but it is a fairly late game comment.) So the escapism is more than likely an underlying ’cause in my head so headcanon acceppted easily and already there 😂 thanks for sharing
Thanks for commenting and sharing your thoughts!! 😄
@@sodorart You are welcome! Only got a ”few” hours in the game on pc and ipad 🙈 soo, got a few diffrent playthroughs ( only one is joja tho’) and while on my playthrough on my ipad I decided to marry Penny and she do have her uses when it comes to decorating 🤓 and do have a comment from Sebastian too in regards of slime hutches, but have yet to figure out if that is a mod or not as I’ve yet to marry him in og 😅
Me, who just gives flowers to everyone because I like flowers, and if they don't like them I don't wanna be their friend
Which editing software you use for making your video??
Capcut!
i would think them disliking poppies would have to do with opium?? id get mad if someone gifted me drugs.
Why in Stardew Valley poppies are brown ? I'm living in Europe and here they are red with black seeds in center .
@@Roland_Volpahart they come in different colors in the game
Fiance? Tell us more :3
I wonder who it could be
Opium?
cmon we all know penny is just a drug dealer
@@hizashi_tsugikuni 7000 crab attack 🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀💥🦀🦀🦀🦀🦀💥💥💥💥
v
I love this! #never been covered.