There were many British people in positions of influence who were on the Arab side, and many who were on the Jewish side. Loads of British soldiers were killed by Stern Gang and Irgun terrorists and eventually the UK told America and the UN "If we are not allowed to protect each side equally and limit Jewish immigration (which was a major reason for Arab tensions being so high) then we give up. We are leaving" The Mandate was unworkable and many UK politicians wanted to avoid the responsibility in the first place. I mean what did Britain get out of it? A few hundred dead soldiers? The same was true for America - many Americans didn't want to get involved. When the British left and as the UN was debating what to do a massacre of a Palestinian village, which led to hundreds of thousands of Palestinians to flee their land which was then captured by Israelis, forced the issue. The facts on the ground were changed. I'm not saying the UK can't be criticized for certain actions in Palestine but to blame the ethnic conflict on the UK is insane. I wonder what Palestinians would say, the actions of Britain 70 years ago or the actions of Israel for the past 70 years? And Israelis would probably say the same.
Why did you not mention that the Arabs, the Mameluks, and the Ottomans colonized Palestine before the British did? Palestine was taken by the Arabs in the 7th century during their imperialist and colonialist invasions of jihad and fatah, conquest and subjugation of non-Muslim populations.
What you failed to mention is that the settlers didn’t move in without permission. They moved in with government support and encouragement, kicked and demolished Palestinian homes and murdered many with full military support and then and only them they started to “settle” as you nicely and smoothly made it sound.
Wait. Show a single home demolished ans family punished that wasn't connected to them doing crimes. This practice isn't just a Jewish thing, but Palestinians do it aswell. If your caught doing certain crimes, your home is destroyed and your entire family is punished. This is a cultural thing that's very common over there, yet people like you portray it as some evil only commited by jews. You use this to try making them victims, when it's actually the way the world works over there. You judging Palestinian culture?
@@ThinRedLine_Matt but I thought we are civilized now and don’t do that , why is the US helping Ukraine against Russia? So it’s about the strongest? So you are agreeing that Israel stole their lands.? And i am talking since 1948 I believe that the UN divided the land for Palestine and Israel.
to those blaming britian, it seems you didnt watch the video, UN was the one who split the land and the palestinians rejected and declared war and lost. what the palestinians shouldve done is, accepted the UN partition and call UN peace keeping forces to protect the borders, instead of declaring war.
@@thehonesttruth415 You could as easily say jewish immigrants should've simply stayed away from palestine, and that would be a very unfair reduction of a quite complex historical situation in the same way what you said. The partition was quite controversial, and arguably split the land unfairly (a lot of muslim people now suddenly lived in a jewish state) Also why should the UN at that time, which had no representation for any group present in palestine and which was (and still is) completely undemocratic, be recognised as the deciding authority here? Palestinians had no seat at the table, how could they even "accept" the resolution? All muslim member states voted against the partition as put forward by the UNSCOP by the way, shouldnt that have been reason enough to question its peace-bringing power? Also there was no declaration of war by palestinians, it was a civil war at first, the other arab nations who declared war are not palestinians. Also the conflict didnt start at this resolution, the english are to a high degree responsible for what happened before.
Unfortunately, this is what happened to my great grandpa. A home which we had owned for 6 whole generations was destroyed to make way for Jewish roads and settler movements without our knowledge. For hundreds of years, me and my family tree (dads side) had owned this land, and once it was flourishing with livestock, a market place, plants and trees for any fruit/veggie you could think of, a good university nearby, a mosque, a comfortably sized home, etc. Until Israeli settlers, dare I say unrightfully stole the land we’d been making for so long and claimed it as theirs. We now own 1/5th of the plants we used to and the other livestock, market place and house are now occupied by Israeli settlers completely not under our control. I now live in America but my grandparents unfortunately couldn’t afford to go to America so they illegally snuck outside the refugee camp we’d been out into and into Jordan. They were deported to Kuwait and that’s where my parents were born. My grandparents didn’t have enough money to go to America or stay in Kuwait so they moved back to a small, shady apartment in Jordan where they live now. It could’ve all been so different though. Better even.
@@ajvorob9117 Lies? bruh my grandpa has his grandpa's land deed that was signed and sealed by the Ottomans. I don't know who the owners are now but good luck bringing better proof
What Israel is doing is wrong but Palestinians should now accept the small land they have cuz I don’t see any way Israel will stop. Hamas needs to calm down and talk, try negotiating otherwise Israel will just use its massive advantage and slowly take every inch of Palestine
“My ancestors lived here thousands of years ago, so I’m entitled to break international treaties and stake my claim.” Let’s use that same logic and apply it to the US. Members of the Apache Nation can move into Maricopa County, kick out non-Apache residents from their homes, and this will be enforced by tribal police. I’m sure the Netanyahu supporters here will be in favor of these settlements.
Unless you are Sephardic you have no claim of ancestry for being in Palestine . And yes , the Apache Nation do have a claim as those 'treaties' were made under duress and have not been respected by the US government for over 100 years .
Britain colonizes foreign lands and its people. Due to British investment in infrastructure, agriculture and industry these colonies became far more industrialized, wealthy and far more heavily populated. The native people then demands the British to leave which they then do because they don't want to destroy everything they helped set up. Natives then go blame Britain for leaving because as Britain left the also stopped their investment,.
@@Joseph_ebuka hamas sees it as a major provocation from israel, and that as well as wanting to get their prisoners back is a major reason why hamas did oct 7th
@City Tech Captured?? It belonged to jews way before islam was invented😂 if muslims beleive Israel is Captured then they should leave iran,iraq, afganistan, pakistan since all belonged to diff religion once before islam plundered the land
I love to see the jewish Americans go after Palestinians, saying that Jews lived there for thousands of years. However, they never seem to support Native Americans who actually did live in America for 1000s of years. The logic seems to be that whoever can perpetrate a genocide deserves to take the land.
Th united states is a much more developed nation in comparison to old palestine. It doesnt make sense to return so much land to such a small percentage of people. Not only that, there was no palestanian goverment in israel and it was mainly just small settlements governed by the british. The british have the right to give the land to israel no matter who is living in the land.
British Partitioning countries based on ethnic religious lines creates conflict India- pakistan partition Israel-palestinian partition Maybe other former colonies with ethnic conflict - sri lanka And Many others where ethnic divisions have created disharmony
Dude it’s so complicated, did you know Israel attacked America also? Knowing it was us and was gonna try to blame it on Egypt to get us involved? There’s documentaries on TH-cam about it
@@CrackerBarrelkid555yes, I agree it very simple. One group has a history of attempting to destroy cultures, nations and propagate devisoveness among local people, propogating degeneracy and pioneer in immorality in the form of businesses and thought movements. One group has been historically, spanning more than 5000 years been kicked out of places, not because of their dedication and services to that place. One group believes they are superior and that all other human are simply beasts in human form to serve them. Everyone around the world who has experience historically with this group innately and instinctly despise them. This group is extremely powerful and is now commuting ethnic cleansing in the region. It's is not hard to see the reason for the current militarisation. Where is the proof of atrocities that they claim Hama* has commited? They have a history of employing such tactics to militarize. This could be an attempt to cometely take over and bud the third temple.
At 6:03 he said Palestinians can drive on almost all of the roads in the West Bank, which is incorrect, Palestinians that drive on Israeli made roads get stopped and arrested, even though it’s in there lands, some villages and cities are surrounded by settlements and it looks like a ghetto, because they are blocked from the rest of the cities and people. He also talks about checkpoints as a minor annoyance, which is incorrect, trips that should take 20 minutes end up being around three hours or more!. Hey paints this people who live there as good and nice people, I’m sure some are, but a big majority go live there to support taking the land and kicking out of Palestinian, some of them literally take houses in the middle of cities, someway they dedicated their life to be an annoyance for Palestinians, and that is horrible.
a lot of things you said are actually incorrect and i will like to see your source of information. first of all if a palestinian drive on an israeli made road he will not be arrested if he didnt cross the border to israel illegally or committed any crime. you are welcome to show a case where an Israeli law enforcer arrested Palestinians randomly without any reason. as for the checkpoints, you should not forget why they exist in the first place. they were created as a result of the intifadas and actually serve their purposes well as they are making it easier for the Israeli law enforcers to stop a terrorist attacks before they are happening. and btw these checkpoints are not taking hours as you said, and usually going through a checkpoint is like going through an airport check when going to another country.
@@eit2000 I have a feeling that what you learn in school is just a tiny part of the truth. Broaden your horizons, it's more complicated and complex than you think but also it's a great feeling to see the whole picture. Shavua Tov.
So the only justification Israelis have is that this land, 2000+ years ago, was owned by their ancestors? And after 1948, it was the time for them to return to it? Imagine if every group of people decided to go back to their ancestral land and kick out anyone who did not belong in that same land, just imagine what kind of chaos will happen in the world. Might as well go back in time even further and all of humanity better go back to Africa.
the "most popular book in the world" also says “This is what the Lord Almighty says... ‘Now go and strike Amalek and devote to destruction all that they have. Do not spare them, but kill both man and woman, child and infant, ox and sheep, camel and donkey.’” (1 Samuel 15:3)
I guess everyone is ignoring the plainly obvious fact that if the surrounding Arab nations did not attack Israel TWICE, this situation between Israel and Palestine would not be the way it is today.
Certainly agree. And the world would have just sat back and watched. I truly believe that they bring a sense of stability to the region as the others certainly cannot stand each other.
This is shitty logic, the arabs and indeed the people living on that land were not consulted when a foreign entity (Great Britain) decided to divide it up. They were fully within their rights to reject the proposal to give up swaths of their land to people who were shipped in by boat by a foreign entity.
No like during reighn of Sultan Abdulhamid the II The cursed man called "Theodore Herzl" stole his father's idea which his father abondend and then locked is own father in a basement for a whole year until he was saved by and protected by the Sultan. You know israel is a cursed thing when you first hear about its origins
@SHUBHAM YADAV Jews got scattered all over Europe and some Jews even went to the Ottoman Empire for immigration since that happened. And some Jews still lived in the Ottoman Empire. So that mean more Jews could have migrated there or just stayed in Europe as they were already rich. But they didn't and made a cursed country on Palestinie. Let me repeat, they got scattered so Palestinians settled there and the area was then known as Palestine. Some Jews also lived there. And Jews could also have immigrated there. But they made a state kicking them out which they left for 2000 years. And india historically had many religions. Hindusm and Islam were the largest.
so with this argument the aborigines tribes of america, south america and Australia can just take over the land of europeans and foreigners who have settled in their land?
I though it strange and very one sided to only show Jewish people getting kick out of Gaza and no mention of the Palestinians that are removed and homes demolished all the time...
@@richert8 Egypt, Jordan, Syria. When Jews came back to Israel during the early 1900s, Arabs from the surrounding countries came to take advantage of the land our people improved.
Did you and the 20 people who liked this comment just skip the video before commenting? He just explained the situation and how it's not a black-and-white case of colonialism.
Hi Yonatan, did the Whites in Sout Africa bomb the ghettos of the Blacks? Israel is the worst case of colonialism. And as a German i am glad that more and more Israelis/Jews are coming to live in Germany. Sorry for my awful English. :/
This video starts off terrible by saying there were growing tensions between jews and arabs so the land was split by the UN but the arabs couldn't except it. This misses out the essential context that initially it was almost all arab and they got on with the jews there, then there was a huge amount of jewish immigration following the tensions that brang the UN split the land (which was promised by britain to both the arabs and the jews) which gave the more fertile and more land to the jewish people who made up a minority. I think that the context behind why palestinas called a war in 1948 should be known and good journalism should show it.
Alex A Well that's not very exciting. I was hoping for you to say the controversial option where they are withholding information for an unknown reason
Well the possible reasons are obvious its either they don't know whats going on or they lack journalistic integrity. Most likely it's a mixture as any sane person who knew whats going on could not support such a burtal regime. However someone who believes the story put out by the israelí goverment may think the twisting of the story is for a good cause.
The way the Israeli state was established is not that simple as it's described here. There was a Jewish question in Europe as European nations were not sure what to do with Jews in Europe after WW2. A Jewish guy named Theodor Herzl made some agreements with the UK and they allowed European jews to settle in Palestine. Millions of Jews from all over the world immigrated to Palestine, aka Aliyah, and then with the Support of the US and the UK (lots of money) established a State. So it wasn't like millions of Jews lived in Palestine and decided to become independent. Millions of Jews moved to Palestine.
Well millions of Jews lived in israel even before islam or christianity. They were driven out from their home land. There was never ever an independent country called palestine.
@@aswing2706 yeah and many Jews lived and owned businesses in Germany before WW2. Should they now fight Germans to get their lands/businesses back? oh wait, Germans are too powerful unlike Palestine.
Jews left and unoccupied their land, they shouldn’t be able to just be handled back or have the option to be backed by larger powers to take back the land. I never understood how they try to eradicate a race when they already had that done to them
No Jews were sent to Palestine, they moved there on their own. There have always been Jews living there, even after the Roman expulsion, almost all towns have Hebrew names, even the Arab ones (example Beit Hanina, an Arab town means house of pardon in Hebrew). As far as the Arabs, most of them moved to "Palestine" as the same time the Jews came. Yasir Arafat, the " Father of the Palestinians" is from Egypt!
Palestinians who have been displaced not only endure the loss of their homes but also face challenges in asserting their right to reclaim their land. Regrettably, they are often labeled as terrorists by the majority of the world. who is the victim now?
It was not called the 'Balfour Agreement', it was the 'Balfour Declaration'. It was never agreed with the people who actually lived in Palestine and it was only an 'agreement' in the sense that it was intended to ease the path for another agreement (from the US and Swiss banks) to approve a massive war loan to the British government while the outcome of WWI was still in the balance. The British banker (Lord Rothschild) was a prominent figure in the Zionist Federation and thought to be influential with his US and Swiss counterparts and the Balfour Declaration was presented to him without any consultation with the inhabitants of Palestine who were still Ottoman subjects. Also; the British had already promised the Arabs an independent Arab nation (to include Palestine) as a reward for mounting a rebellion again the Ottoman Empire which was fighting alongside Germany (look up the McMahon Hussein correspondence if you want to research it). History is important here so don't use misleading and inappropriate terms like 'agreement' when you really mean 'a unilateral imposition'.
@@exiled_londoner I'm Taiwanese and I'm familiar with people presenting "declarations" as hard evidence regarding sovereignty. In my opinion, the only legal method of transferring the sovereignty of land is through an official treaty, and I do not believe that such a treaty was created prior to the establishment of the State of Israel. Alternatively, another method of acquiring sovereignty over a given territory is through military conquest. This is the "Might is Right" mentality and I oppose it. I personally believe that the State of Israel was created through military conquest and other very unfair and undemocratic processes. And yet, people claim that Israel is a democratic country and a beacon of freedom in the Middle East.
The comment section will be filled with nothing but reasoned, emotion-free, rational arguments that enlighten and further the intellectual conversation on this very serious subject...
your strikingly inventive line of thinking that isn't a near word for word copy of what was a popular comment in one of their last videos that included obviously bias opinions.
A british aristocrat*. These aristocrats that ran the empire treated working class brits (which was at least 95% of the pop. at the time) worse than their foreign subjects. Victorian Britain was notoriously tough for the working class, with children being forced to work in factories, and sweep chimney's. The British aristocracy today are filthy rich because of what they stole from the empire. No other Brits saw this wealth.
Going back to 1948 isn't far enough. You should go back to 1917, when the Ottomans ruled here, or 1880s, when the first modern settlers, both Jewish and Arabs, started migrating. Or even back to 900 BCE, when the kingdoms of Judah and Israel were founded.
This video also skims on a lot of details. Like how Jews were expelled out of the West Bank by the Jordanians. Or how Yasser Arafat was not just a "Palestinian leader" but the leader of a Terrorist organization known as the PLO.
I think the video is fair, yes, it skipped over how problematic Arafat was (who is certainly in the club of people who never should have gotten the Nobel peace price) but it also skipped over Israel overreacting extremly to rocket attacks by the Hamas resulting in extremly high losses of civilian lifes in Gaza. Both sides play dirty here and this is just the first video which basically just explains the map and skips over most other things which aren't relevant to understanding the map - you don't need to know Arafat to understand the map nor do you need to know about many other things.
i also thought they shuld have mentioned that oslo practicly *made* him the palastinian leader. but this video is 8 minutes and is already very dense. and it does mention the significance of the place in biblical times.
Israel coming back to their native homeland Judea isnt stealing , and they've never stole Palestine because there was never a state called Palestine, it's how the Romans called the land after colonizing Judea
@@khagan5951 How is it stealing? the owner of the land (Britain) gave it to the Jews and the Palestienes. Basically 50-50. Now remember that the Jews wernt the one that declared war on Palestine for living in "their land"
@basil al sadi" Human need for survival should never take over our morals". Ideally, but the history of the human race indicates alternative course of actions is usually applied in a cold and unforgiving manner.
@@kamelsharaf314 yes, And everyone knows that Palestinians where there 4,500 years ago even before prophet Ibrahim ...... Alkanaani, and Alyabosi, Those tribes left Yemen 4,500 to stay in Palestine. My brother it's not about the religions Muslims, Christians, Jews all are sons of prophet Ibrahim and they pary to one God.
As a Palestinian i believe the logical solution would be a joint state between Israelis an Palestinians where both work in the same direction of advancing their country as one! similar to what happened in US in its civil wars.. but for that to happen, the following needs to be done: 1- Promoting co-existing on both sides 2- changing the name from Israel or Palestine to something neutral. 3 proper representation based on citizenship and governing by constitution and not religion 4- ceasing advancements on holy structures and allowing everyone the freedom of religious practice under mutual respect.
this has precedent in Bosnia where the Serbians Bosniaks and Croats divided the land among the three groups and they have three precedents why cannot Israel do the same thing سالام في شروك الاسط صديكي
You start with 1948 as if the Israeli were living there. You might need to go back a few years when the European decided to move the Jewish from Europe to a new place (Palestine) most of them are European citizens that European didn't want to deal with them anymore, and it goes all the way before the WWII
@@bobbobb4804 yes, allies. To the extent of killing American soldiers and attack the USS Liberty ship, for their own interests (Israel killed American soldiers, and blamed Egypt, so as to provoke America to be directly involved in the war and support Israel more deeply). The reason why the US supports Israel is because of the greed of American politicians who are easily bribed ("lobbying"). However, the money they send actually comes from taxes from Jewish businessmen & billionaires, who are not willing to use their money to build and repair bridges, roads, access to cheap health care, improve social inequality (homeless).
Disliking their politics concerning Palestinians is not equal to hating them or wanting them attacked, nor does it prevent western countries from giving military aid and selling weapons to ensure Israel's security.
mangalores-x_x So what you're saying is the world should sit back while the Arab world rapes and murders its way across Israel? I agree there needs to be a solution but it can't involve the destruction of Israel or the internment of Palestinians. It needs to build a brighter future for everyone. That CANNOT happen through violence.
Vicenzo " you do exactly that. Just because I don't agree with your Islamist worldview doesn't mean you are any less stupid than you already are." of what Islamic vision you speak subnormal, is the vision of decent people who are against crime, brutality, torture, theft ... in short, people who are in favor of Human Rights and Justice
This is also why, no matter how many people call for "free Tibet", or "land back" here in the West,, it would never happen as the activists intended - all these settlements over the years are now fully entranced in the areas of the West Bank, just as similar as the ethnic Han Chinese settling in Tibet since the 1960's, or the hundreds of years that European settlers have in the Americas. The only realistic solution (for better or for worse), is for us to all learn how to peacefully co-exist with one another, based on mutual understanding and mutual respect. There's not much we can do with the past, but I doubt trying to re-segregate ourselves for the future would be a good idea.
@Anwar El sharkawy i am not jewish in the first place. but if you consider it right that the romans "kicked" the jewish out, who are you than do say that the jews don't have the right to do the same thing with palestinians?
This is all about ethnic exceptionalism wherein one group thinks they have been chosen by God to rule the land. Another name for ethnic exceptionalism is racism. Seems amazingly similar to another movement that occurred in central Europe towards the middle of the 20th century.
Before is irrelevant. Powerful nations conquer weak ones all though history. The land belongs to the strongest. What they should have done is traded independence for Israeli citizenship. Living conditions would have been better for everyone.
Simply taking Israeli citizenship might not have given them a very good deal either. Look at how much good 'integration' did for the native americans in the US, every bit of land that had value was taken and given (either through direct government action, or actions only well financed and connected private institutions can take) to americans of european decent. Same basic thing was happening there, even in the original Oslo accords. The early two state solution saw the bulk of the profitable land and critical infrastructure going to jewish group. So if arabs did simply integrate, they would be doing so from a position of poverty and lock out of critical resources, relegated to second class citizen status.
neeneko Exactly why they have no other rational choice. Have you seen native peoples living conditions in countries like the US and Canada. It would have been better to give up the reservation lands and integrate. Life is hard - there is no shame in surrendering against impossible odds.
life is all about fighting against impossible odds "Life is hard, members of the French resistance. Germany won, there's no shame in surrendering against impossible odds!"
@@The_Accuser You are clearly not educated enough about this conflict! If you sanction Israel they will not be able to fund the "Iron Dome" (Anti Missle system which saves millions of lives daily) and clearly its palestines fault for all of this chaos, AND I am not done yet! Israel offered more then 5 times a peaceful SOLUTION to the conflict, Palestine refused all of them! Plus any palestinian civilian deaths were not intended by the IDF and were military accidents BECAUSE "Hamas" (Palestinian terrorists organasation) fires rockets from palestinian residential areas. So exuse me if i support Israel D: AND every palestinan expelled from there homes were either: Ilegel buildings without premissions from the controlling area,Terr0orists,Were in territories won by DEFENSIVE wars which means they are no longer supposed to be there because according to the "United Nations" Every territory gained from a defensive war automatcly belong to the defensive side IF they won, And remember! not only the palestnians are suffering from this conflcit! Israelis too!
@@mohammadfranko8445 Since the Roman empire was here, only 2000 years ago. It was "Kingdom of Israel" and "Hasmonean Dynasty" before the Romand bro. Also, the fact that the land was called Palestine, is completely meaningless. Palestinians today are just arabs from other countries, they had never identified as Palestinians until 1960's They are embarrassing bro. There was never an Arab state here and never a Palestinian autonomy
Israel already is a secular state (for the most part). Palestinians are the ones who don't want to live in a secular state. They want to live in a Muslim-only state.
lol is that what u tell yourself to kill kids and then sleep at night ? they just want thier land back .they do not care about the jews . u all can stay as long as they have countery and government . but they do not we both now that
@@porschecollector727 REMEMBER Canaan kids will take it back, keep that in mind ... Eat it, drink it, dream about it .. Canaan sons will take it back ALL of PALESTINE.
@@jonahb3520 Lol Not even close, 3 Intifadas, Israeli eviction of Palestinians from their homes, occupation of Palestinian land, and Police Brutality say otherwise The clear solution is a 2 state one based on 1967 borders and the resettlement of Jews in Palestinian territory Back to Israel
@@jonahb3520 Jews had been leaving in Palestine since they were scattered. The Quran literally tells Muslims to treat Christians and Jews with respect. It was actually Crusaders from Europe who indiscriminately killed Muslims, Jews, and probably Christians as they sacked Jerusalem.
Why start at 1948? Who was in control over Palestine before the british? Leaving out that small detail i see. What right did the British have to rule over Palestine?
That would be the Ottoman Empire. Before The Ottoman empire would be the Byzantine Empire, before that the Roman Empire as a whole and before that idk.
+Yaakov Adam Yeah, as you say. ExistED. As sa das it is, it has been over. In no way decades of illegal oppression, occupation, colonization in absolute impunity can be justified because your "ancestors" lived here in another era.
+Insan Lazuardi Is this community also over-represented in high key positions in politics, medias, international institutions, lobbies and finance ? Because it helps a lot in order to impose your will, such as claiming a land "back".
It just gave a permission to BUY land and emifrating. Just like you do in western countries bringing your violent islamic religion and your families. We welcome you, why dont they do the same? Because they are just something more than beasts.
@@tarasbulba7114 Only beasts are white colonists that invaded almost every single country on this planet through racist colonialism based on racist white supremacy ideals that thought everyone else deserved to serve them under death. We know who the true evil in this world is.
Basically, the current Palestinians are the original people who lived there more than three thousand years ago, and the children of Israel are Canaanite tribes that inhabited Palestine. They do not own the land on their own. They succeeded in building a kingdom for themselves, but it collapsed. A small number of its people were displaced, but they returned in the end. As for the current Israelis, they are Europeans who have no relation to the Semitic peoples. The Canaanites are Semitic peoples, and the Arabs are as well, but the Israelis are a mixture of peoples and not a race.
The Caananites ( israelis ancestors ) are the historically first people recognised to have inhabited the land which today's Isreal disputes with Palestine. Meanwhile the palestinians were brought there by the Roman empire.
@@yunhel people overestimate and overemphasise the contribution of western powers to Israel's supremacy, look into the 6 day war a bit more. Yahweh is the lord of hosts and has not forsaken the covenant he made with the people who first recognised him, despite them having strayed from his word numerous times.
@@yunhel Israel had to smuggle in weapons in the 48 war because the UN and the Europeans just left them there defenseless. They were virtually on their own again in 68.
The British didnt start it.....the Roman empire did.... The whole land was originally known as Judea which was later renamed Palestine as purnishment to the Jews for revolting ...
More like 5000 years BC, since Babylonian times. I would guess that the Khazars are not the true Israeli people, judging by the whiteness of their skin (Palestinians are much closer in physiology to how an Israelite would like). An their Talmud is Baal inspired.
It wasn't palestinian, the Israel has inhabited that land from their cannanites ancestors first. This however doesn't justifies the illegal jewish settelements in the West Bank. So both Israel and Palestine have their own part of truth and rights, but both of them also have their fair share of guilt.
Squatter is different, these lands were inhabited by Palestinians. they built the settlements over Palestinian houses, farms and Palestinian dead bodies.
JESUS CHRIST is coming back soon ❤❤So call upon the name of the Lord Jesus Christ, the Prince of Peace, the one and only SAVIOUR of all mankind, and save your soul before the death happens 🙏""""The Lord is not slack concerning His promise, as some men count slackness; but is longsuffering to us-ward, not willing that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance.""". Other than JESUS CHRIST❤ there is salvation in no one else. God has given no other name under heaven by which we must be saved.”
Maybe Israel wanted to exist, and so they fought a defensive war(So they could remain in existence and all), and then pushed back against their enemies
Yeah. Haven't some Israeli officials admitted that the "pre-emptive strike" was in fact a land grab and that they knew all along that even the forces of all their neighbours combined could not defeat Israeli military, because despite smaller numbers, Israel has better training and better weapons... So it was never for fear of being caught in a surprise war by Egypt that would wipe them out, it was to seize land.
@@jjanon2371 I’ve never heard that but I have read that the Egyptian president at the time said that closing the Strait of Tiran (one of the causes of the war) was an intentional act to promote unrest and to cause a war. A war in which Egypt hoped would result in the destruction of Israel.
The historically correct assumption would be what if the huge United States all the time attacks small Israel and when it loses all the wars it starts over and over again. When Israel takes over a small portion of US lands for its own defense purposes like any rational country will do.
It took the recent events for the WORLD to protest FOR Palestine. I think we are seeing a cultural shift.... However, it will not matter if the USA and UK keep supporting Israel as they always have.
Honestly, if a stranger invited me to live in ur house & after a while i started taking over, became hostile, attacked your family, & then "offered" you the spare room but no water in an ultimatum, how would you feel? May seem like a basic example but it's not far from the truth
@@Mutant_Miniatures well, I can confirm to you that those people failed their history class or they have not opened an authentic history book concerning this matter! Support your claim with evidences sir!
Those 'Palestinians' are always trying to take over the entire house and always issuing ultimatums, that's the problem ... 99% of the Middle East isn't enough, they want it all ...
Which would have revealed only 5% of Palestinians were still jews at that time. Clearly that would have greatly switched the balance toward the palestinians.
Actually it is nothing of the kind. "Palestinians" never stop complaining about the largely nonexistent roadblocks in Samaria and Judea. How would they notice them if they weren't driving. Maybe @Research0digo should stop and reconsider?
@@akshitthakur6833 It was not humane when the Arab countries sent their armies into Israel in 1948 because they wanted to stop a state called Israel from existing. Those Arabs who left their homes in 1948 were not allowed to return, that is true. But they simply resettled down the road, not changing their culture, except to increase the hatred they had against the Jewish inhabitants who, like the Arabs, had bought property and settled the land.
I ride the roads of the West Bank. The Arabs drive everywhere on the main roads with the Palestinian Authority license plates. But no cars with Israel license plates are allowed inside the roads governed by the Palestinian Authority. If someone with Israel license plates enters by accident, he has to get rescued by the Israeli army.
You have no idea about the signs in Judea and Samaria warning all Israelis not too travel beyond 'this point' or you will be in mortal danger' thats the reality of travelling in j&s... Funny how the PA doesn't invest in infrastructure whilst Israeli taxes pay murderers in Israeli prisons 220 million dollars to be precise, money that could and should have been used to prosper
1650 Tanks, 75000 Armoured Vehicles, 650 Self Propelled Artillery, 300 Towed Artillery, 100 Rocket Projector, 241 Fighter Aircraft, 23 Dedicated Attack Aircraft, 128 Helicopters, 48 Attack Helicopters? Do you expect them to own this? They put up a resistance against israel and that's their right. Any nation under attack has a right to defence. Israel is not under attack, Israel is the attacker. They fire bb rockets at israel highly inaccurate that everybody knows are going to be shot down. The purpose of these rockets is psychological.
Bankers, war is profit. I can't prove hell exist not should I inflict my belief of hell on to anyone.. But If hells is actually a place then the warmongers better start praying.
"Israel must exist and has the right to exist, and is one of the great outposts of democracy in the world." Martin Luther King Junior Shame the world kept silent during the Arab oppression of the Jews I.e massacres of the 1920s, 30s and 40s and expulsion from west bank in '48.
Israel bombed the Gaza strip with regular air strikes during a modern 'war', after Hamas attacked with mortars and kidnapped and killed 3 settlers-teens (ages 16-19).
The downside to drinking and YouTubing is that you can't pull up your comments the next day LOL. Once and a while I get a reply from an old comment and get a good laugh 🙃
British have a bad history dividing their colonies and leaving conflicts behind.
There were many British people in positions of influence who were on the Arab side, and many who were on the Jewish side. Loads of British soldiers were killed by Stern Gang and Irgun terrorists and eventually the UK told America and the UN "If we are not allowed to protect each side equally and limit Jewish immigration (which was a major reason for Arab tensions being so high) then we give up. We are leaving"
The Mandate was unworkable and many UK politicians wanted to avoid the responsibility in the first place. I mean what did Britain get out of it? A few hundred dead soldiers? The same was true for America - many Americans didn't want to get involved.
When the British left and as the UN was debating what to do a massacre of a Palestinian village, which led to hundreds of thousands of Palestinians to flee their land which was then captured by Israelis, forced the issue. The facts on the ground were changed.
I'm not saying the UK can't be criticized for certain actions in Palestine but to blame the ethnic conflict on the UK is insane. I wonder what Palestinians would say, the actions of Britain 70 years ago or the actions of Israel for the past 70 years? And Israelis would probably say the same.
Why did you not mention that the Arabs, the Mameluks, and the Ottomans colonized Palestine before the British did? Palestine was taken by the Arabs in the 7th century during their imperialist and colonialist invasions of jihad and fatah, conquest and subjugation of non-Muslim populations.
Or genius option to return once a competing empire has retracted their influence for the time being
Marc A. The land is rightfully of Cannon. Son of the oldest of prophets after the flood. So why aren't black canaanites owners of Israel.
@@colinthomson5358 What's with India Pakistan border? Is it not a bad partition?
I thought India-Pakistan is a mess... But this on another level....
Ira Khan
💯
Indo pak wasn't mess until chacha nehru and jinnah started doing land grabing
@@ivanedswin ***nehru+Jinna+Brit
India -Bangladesh is a total mess ,just checkout
Well said .....well said
If you're looking at a global conflict and wondering how it began, Britain is usually a good place to start from
Lawrence of Arabia had some great ideas but the French and some British Elites were like no way!
ha ha ha ha ha
@Theseustoo Astyages Boris Johnson?
That's not entirely accurate. The conflicts were there before the british arrived as well. But yes, the way they divided it up definitely didn't help.
as they say all roads lead to rome, todays rome being the west. (UK, USA etc)
What you failed to mention is that the settlers didn’t move in without permission. They moved in with government support and encouragement, kicked and demolished Palestinian homes and murdered many with full military support and then and only them they started to “settle” as you nicely and smoothly made it sound.
Of course israel stole their lands . Calling palestine terrorists is unjust when they are the victims.
@@tulio3571 not really Israelis just taking back whats theirs Historically
Wait. Show a single home demolished ans family punished that wasn't connected to them doing crimes. This practice isn't just a Jewish thing, but Palestinians do it aswell. If your caught doing certain crimes, your home is destroyed and your entire family is punished. This is a cultural thing that's very common over there, yet people like you portray it as some evil only commited by jews. You use this to try making them victims, when it's actually the way the world works over there. You judging Palestinian culture?
@@tulio3571 Technically all land on Earth has been 'taken', 'conquered', 'won', whatever descriptive word a human chooses just insert it there.
@@ThinRedLine_Matt but I thought we are civilized now and don’t do that , why is the US helping Ukraine against Russia? So it’s about the strongest? So you are agreeing that Israel stole their lands.? And i am talking since 1948 I believe that the UN divided the land for Palestine and Israel.
*It started with the British*
Me, an Indian: Here we go
Same same uniqe name
to those blaming britian, it seems you didnt watch the video, UN was the one who split the land and the palestinians rejected and declared war and lost. what the palestinians shouldve done is, accepted the UN partition and call UN peace keeping forces to protect the borders, instead of declaring war.
It’s this what is also happening to Bangladesh and India?
@@thehonesttruth415
You could as easily say jewish immigrants should've simply stayed away from palestine, and that would be a very unfair reduction of a quite complex historical situation in the same way what you said.
The partition was quite controversial, and arguably split the land unfairly (a lot of muslim people now suddenly lived in a jewish state)
Also why should the UN at that time, which had no representation for any group present in palestine and which was (and still is) completely undemocratic, be recognised as the deciding authority here? Palestinians had no seat at the table, how could they even "accept" the resolution?
All muslim member states voted against the partition as put forward by the UNSCOP by the way, shouldnt that have been reason enough to question its peace-bringing power? Also there was no declaration of war by palestinians, it was a civil war at first, the other arab nations who declared war are not palestinians.
Also the conflict didnt start at this resolution, the english are to a high degree responsible for what happened before.
Best read a different history book
Britain is the type of guy that will accidentally ruin a bookshelf in the library and just runs away
ippos_khloros they totally did it on purpose man
That's why I hate the British so much.
Where are you from Bro?
Where are you from Bro?
Where are you from Bro?
You know when there is a conflict between nations over land you know there is British involvement in that.
"There was no war or conflict until the British Empire" - Total Smooth Brain
@@HerewardWake
Never known what set the british empire on a pedestal. Except for their wealth, knowledge and weaponry. .........ohh that's it!
yea knida as britian once ruled half the world!
@@alexjabocs7573 As soon as other countries had access to guns the British empire got exposed
and jews
Unfortunately, this is what happened to my great grandpa. A home which we had owned for 6 whole generations was destroyed to make way for Jewish roads and settler movements without our knowledge. For hundreds of years, me and my family tree (dads side) had owned this land, and once it was flourishing with livestock, a market place, plants and trees for any fruit/veggie you could think of, a good university nearby, a mosque, a comfortably sized home, etc. Until Israeli settlers, dare I say unrightfully stole the land we’d been making for so long and claimed it as theirs. We now own 1/5th of the plants we used to and the other livestock, market place and house are now occupied by Israeli settlers completely not under our control. I now live in America but my grandparents unfortunately couldn’t afford to go to America so they illegally snuck outside the refugee camp we’d been out into and into Jordan. They were deported to Kuwait and that’s where my parents were born. My grandparents didn’t have enough money to go to America or stay in Kuwait so they moved back to a small, shady apartment in Jordan where they live now. It could’ve all been so different though. Better even.
@@ajvorob9117 ISRAEL IS NOT A COUNTRY, JEWS ARE JUST A REFUGEE NATION.
Their time is coming.
@@ajvorob9117 facts don't care about your feelings
@@ajvorob9117 Lies? bruh my grandpa has his grandpa's land deed that was signed and sealed by the Ottomans. I don't know who the owners are now but good luck bringing better proof
then ask ottomans why others took the land :D@@TheVeemon
I come back to these videos every time the conflict sparks up again....who else is here after seeing the recent news in May 2021?
My heart breaks for Palestine
🇵🇸
@@overtonwindowshopper who shoots rockets and killing civilians lol
@@חגיגוזלן-ט7ד israel did it more succesfully. lol
@@חגיגוזלן-ט7ד Israel and the IDF
What Israel is doing is wrong but Palestinians should now accept the small land they have cuz I don’t see any way Israel will stop. Hamas needs to calm down and talk, try negotiating otherwise Israel will just use its massive advantage and slowly take every inch of Palestine
I'm honestly surprised the comment section is enabled lol
Same thought
I am sure even the sponsors of this video are too 😂
I wonder for how long
Me too ….. Lol .
I say it's a power move
There is a saying in India "If two fish fight in the pond , the British are behind it"
And america
It is a old amerücn word not indian
both fish the blame
@@timdacey4520 cheese ramen
@@luskalaf19 well, from Telegraph of UK, it is an old Iraqi saying: if two fish fight in the Tigris, the British are behind it.
“My ancestors lived here thousands of years ago, so I’m entitled to break international treaties and stake my claim.” Let’s use that same logic and apply it to the US. Members of the Apache Nation can move into Maricopa County, kick out non-Apache residents from their homes, and this will be enforced by tribal police. I’m sure the Netanyahu supporters here will be in favor of these settlements.
Unless you are Sephardic you have no claim of ancestry for being in Palestine .
And yes , the Apache Nation do have a claim as those 'treaties' were made under duress and have not been respected by the US government for over 100 years .
Imagine a mongolian said that,
You know it’s gonna be bad when Britain leaves literally anything
Melon and you know its gonna be bad when america gets involved
You are right melon.... India-pakistan issue is also because of Britain.... Britain's policy is divide and rule
Melon
You are right about this point .
It is in India Pakistan case also
@@nirkaya
Worked, didn't it?
While you're busy killing each other, you can't bother anyone else.
@Maria Hewitt
Well, elaborate.
"It started with the British"
Ireland, India, Cyprus, Palestine etc: "Here we go"
Hong kong?
Pakistan, the United States, Canada, South Africa. Yes you’re right, we could be here all day with the British.
hongkong and malaysia/singapore too
Sri Lanka!
@@stevenmiller2820 I'm offended, Australia too!
As history has always let us know that you should never trust a British guy with a map
@Wayne Gittins Exploitation is not civilized.
Britain colonizes foreign lands and its people.
Due to British investment in infrastructure, agriculture and industry these colonies became far more industrialized, wealthy and far more heavily populated.
The native people then demands the British to leave which they then do because they don't want to destroy everything they helped set up.
Natives then go blame Britain for leaving because as Britain left the also stopped their investment,.
@@sebastianwallin3726 don't forget how much britain loot from them
@@laxman6223
Maybe not. But don't forget the hard word done to achieve that welfare
@@sebastianwallin3726 look at british museum, filled with looted stuff
Israel support of settlers in the West Bank is a big part of what is causing the inflammation from Hamas
Yes
Nope hamas is another different entity don’t justify hamas at all even I see the settlements as illegal but that dosent justify hamas at all
@@Joseph_ebuka hamas sees it as a major provocation from israel, and that as well as wanting to get their prisoners back is a major reason why hamas did oct 7th
@@adamelghalmi9771 no, hamas is ethnically cleansing jews due to islam. Nothing more nothing less
@@Joseph_ebukaEuropeans will not know the pain of being colonized? haven't you destroyed enough of our countries for centuries?
Can you also interview the Palestinian living in West bank ?
They are not gonna do that cause it won't attract fanatic western rich people to live in Israel.
U need to know if u go with non palestinian car in zone A ,they will probably weigh you with stones.
Read the definition of what are non believers in Talmud.
@City Tech Captured?? It belonged to jews way before islam was invented😂 if muslims beleive Israel is Captured then they should leave iran,iraq, afganistan, pakistan since all belonged to diff religion once before islam plundered the land
This is a travesty. The Jews had no right to this land. It remains Palestine. Simple.
should have interviewed Palestinians in the area too
U mean in Palestine?
@btm56841 come on continue the argument i already opened the popcorn , f*** this
@@talentless2790 he is bot from Hasbara...
He would’ve been the next victim of a butterfly bullet
btm56841 even though it’s in the UN
I love to see the jewish Americans go after Palestinians, saying that Jews lived there for thousands of years. However, they never seem to support Native Americans who actually did live in America for 1000s of years. The logic seems to be that whoever can perpetrate a genocide deserves to take the land.
Ryan Anderson facts 💯
@ippos_khloros Native Americans weren't "scattered in a diaspora", they were decimated in a genocide. You're totally missing the point.
Palistiniesn lived there for 2000-3000 thousands years
@@KikogamerJ2 man you need to do some research. That land dosent have more than 2000 years being named Palestine
Th united states is a much more developed nation in comparison to old palestine. It doesnt make sense to return so much land to such a small percentage of people. Not only that, there was no palestanian goverment in israel and it was mainly just small settlements governed by the british. The british have the right to give the land to israel no matter who is living in the land.
Applauding all those here in 2023 trying to learn more about this conflict 👏🏽
British Partitioning countries based on ethnic religious lines creates conflict
India- pakistan partition
Israel-palestinian partition
Maybe other former colonies with ethnic conflict - sri lanka
And Many others where ethnic divisions have created disharmony
Cyprus
The only way the US and Europe can remain the economic leaders is to keep the rest of the world in conflict.
Hongkong.....taiwan.....n many more commonwealth country which used to be under british now suffering all kinda problems that british left behind
@@sukahati2020
Taiwan was never under British rule.
Go back to school, o uneducated one.
Taiwan have been colonised by 6 colonialisme.....netherland, spanish, british, japanese, chinese until present.....
1:14:- "Back then, all this land was controlled by Great Britain"
Summary of this mess
Yeah if you want to look at it in an overly simplified, ahistorical and false narrative. Sure, good summary 👍
Just on paper, kinda a temporary deal after the Ottoman empire collapsed.
@@matthowells6382 same thing happened with india
Literraly the first phrase and I was like, excuse me. Aghhh
"If I don't steal your home, someone else is going to"- Settler to a Palestinian
Disgusting!
No Justice, no peace. x(
lol no names though right
@@lukephilip2388 what? There's a video of it fam google is free
@@lukephilip2388 yakub
@@lukephilip2388 it’s a man called yaku or Jacob an American land stealer like you
Honestly I knew this conflict was complicated, I didnt know how complicated it really was until this video
Dude it’s so complicated, did you know Israel attacked America also? Knowing it was us and was gonna try to blame it on Egypt to get us involved? There’s documentaries on TH-cam about it
It gets complicated when a country (israel) steals land from another country.
It's way more complicated than this video let's on, fyi.
It’s actually pretty simple
@@CrackerBarrelkid555yes, I agree it very simple. One group has a history of attempting to destroy cultures, nations and propagate devisoveness among local people, propogating degeneracy and pioneer in immorality in the form of businesses and thought movements. One group has been historically, spanning more than 5000 years been kicked out of places, not because of their dedication and services to that place. One group believes they are superior and that all other human are simply beasts in human form to serve them. Everyone around the world who has experience historically with this group innately and instinctly despise them. This group is extremely powerful and is now commuting ethnic cleansing in the region. It's is not hard to see the reason for the current militarisation. Where is the proof of atrocities that they claim Hama* has commited? They have a history of employing such tactics to militarize. This could be an attempt to cometely take over and bud the third temple.
At 6:03 he said Palestinians can drive on almost all of the roads in the West Bank, which is incorrect, Palestinians that drive on Israeli made roads get stopped and arrested, even though it’s in there lands, some villages and cities are surrounded by settlements and it looks like a ghetto, because they are blocked from the rest of the cities and people. He also talks about checkpoints as a minor annoyance, which is incorrect, trips that should take 20 minutes end up being around three hours or more!. Hey paints this people who live there as good and nice people, I’m sure some are, but a big majority go live there to support taking the land and kicking out of Palestinian, some of them literally take houses in the middle of cities, someway they dedicated their life to be an annoyance for Palestinians, and that is horrible.
a lot of things you said are actually incorrect and i will like to see your source of information. first of all if a palestinian drive on an israeli made road he will not be arrested if he didnt cross the border to israel illegally or committed any crime. you are welcome to show a case where an Israeli law enforcer arrested Palestinians randomly without any reason. as for the checkpoints, you should not forget why they exist in the first place. they were created as a result of the intifadas and actually serve their purposes well as they are making it easier for the Israeli law enforcers to stop a terrorist attacks before they are happening. and btw these checkpoints are not taking hours as you said, and usually going through a checkpoint is like going through an airport check when going to another country.
@@ofeknahon7579 they teach them lies in school. Am israel chai.
Settlers despise me. Who do you have to be to act like this? Horrible and despicable🤢
@@eit2000 I have a feeling that what you learn in school is just a tiny part of the truth. Broaden your horizons, it's more complicated and complex than you think but also it's a great feeling to see the whole picture. Shavua Tov.
@@ofeknahon7579 Actually, You, Who came from an western view, Will learn more "true things" When all your looking at is a western point of view.
So the only justification Israelis have is that this land, 2000+ years ago, was owned by their ancestors? And after 1948, it was the time for them to return to it? Imagine if every group of people decided to go back to their ancestral land and kick out anyone who did not belong in that same land, just imagine what kind of chaos will happen in the world. Might as well go back in time even further and all of humanity better go back to Africa.
According to your logic they belong there now and that is their country. Just saying review your logic.
the "most popular book in the world" also says
“This is what the Lord Almighty says... ‘Now go and strike Amalek and
devote to destruction all that they have. Do not spare them, but kill
both man and woman, child and infant, ox and sheep, camel and donkey.’”
(1 Samuel 15:3)
You could say the same thing about america-that it really belongs to the British
+Deenster S Not the Native Americans?
Thanks to Israel, jews could flew from persecution. Especially in other arab countries.
I guess everyone is ignoring the plainly obvious fact that if the surrounding Arab nations did not attack Israel TWICE, this situation between Israel and Palestine would not be the way it is today.
More than just attack, if you do research it is obvious if Israel lost there would have been a genocide in Israel.
yeah, Israel had some real balls to withstand the wars it did
Certainly agree. And the world would have just sat back and watched. I truly believe that they bring a sense of stability to the region as the others certainly cannot stand each other.
This is shitty logic, the arabs and indeed the people living on that land were not consulted when a foreign entity (Great Britain) decided to divide it up.
They were fully within their rights to reject the proposal to give up swaths of their land to people who were shipped in by boat by a foreign entity.
Israel still undefeated after 2 wars and they did it without any western government military coming to their aide.
It's not a conflict, it's a clear case of colonial occupation and genocide.
😂😂😂 what a joke
Stop spitting random statements
And give me facts, give me evidence
Why don't you guys start from 1900
Have to start before Balfour Accords
@@ranbirvaid449 that's a bit extreme Don't you think how about before humanity
No like during reighn of Sultan Abdulhamid the II
The cursed man called "Theodore Herzl" stole his father's idea which his father abondend and then locked is own father in a basement for a whole year until he was saved by and protected by the Sultan.
You know israel is a cursed thing when you first hear about its origins
@SHUBHAM YADAV Jews got scattered all over Europe and some Jews even went to the Ottoman Empire for immigration since that happened. And some Jews still lived in the Ottoman Empire. So that mean more Jews could have migrated there or just stayed in Europe as they were already rich. But they didn't and made a cursed country on Palestinie.
Let me repeat, they got scattered so Palestinians settled there and the area was then known as Palestine. Some Jews also lived there. And Jews could also have immigrated there. But they made a state kicking them out which they left for 2000 years.
And india historically had many religions. Hindusm and Islam were the largest.
@SHUBHAM YADAV Well, it looks like "R7" just told you about yourself!
"They didnt want to seize the land", but they seized it?
It is their land. The Jews are from Judea
so with this argument the aborigines tribes of america, south america and Australia can just take over the land of europeans and foreigners who have settled in their land?
I don't care about the foreign lands. I care about Israel.
If you care about an explanation I have one.
Dude do you have proof other then a book written 5000 years ago , that the Palestinian people don't believe in
I though it strange and very one sided to only show Jewish people getting kick out of Gaza and no mention of the Palestinians that are removed and homes demolished all the time...
preach
People in Gaza belong to Egypt. Go there. Leave Israel. Gaza belongs to Israel.
@@richert8 Israel doesn't exist!
@@wokesheep Uhhh it's on every map of the middle east... not very woke of you to not notice (see what I did there?)
@@richert8 Egypt, Jordan, Syria. When Jews came back to Israel during the early 1900s, Arabs from the surrounding countries came to take advantage of the land our people improved.
Never ask a woman her age.
Never ask a man his salary.
Never ask a British to draw maps.
@somulaychirr4202 it's easy to dunk on the English but hard to ask yourself deep questions about human nature.
it was the UN who drew the map
😂
this is the worst colonialism ever
Learn about how the Belgians treated the people in their colony in the Congo.
Did you and the 20 people who liked this comment just skip the video before commenting? He just explained the situation and how it's not a black-and-white case of colonialism.
Um, Belgian colonization of the Kongo much?
Should have probably listened during history classes...
Hi Yonatan, did the Whites in Sout Africa bomb the ghettos of the Blacks? Israel is the worst case of colonialism. And as a German i am glad that more and more Israelis/Jews are coming to live in Germany. Sorry for my awful English. :/
This video starts off terrible by saying there were growing tensions between jews and arabs so the land was split by the UN but the arabs couldn't except it. This misses out the essential context that initially it was almost all arab and they got on with the jews there, then there was a huge amount of jewish immigration following the tensions that brang the UN split the land (which was promised by britain to both the arabs and the jews) which gave the more fertile and more land to the jewish people who made up a minority. I think that the context behind why palestinas called a war in 1948 should be known and good journalism should show it.
I wonder if they knew all of this, or are withholding the information for a secret reason...
+Real Man They are probably not that aware of it and in their attempt to be neutral have been completely biased
Alex A Well that's not very exciting. I was hoping for you to say the controversial option where they are withholding information for an unknown reason
Well the possible reasons are obvious its either they don't know whats going on or they lack journalistic integrity.
Most likely it's a mixture as any sane person who knew whats going on could not support such a burtal regime. However someone who believes the story put out by the israelí goverment may think the twisting of the story is for a good cause.
Well then you have to mention why there was a huge amount of Jewish immigration, like the 1,00,000 jews that were expelled from arab countries.
The way the Israeli state was established is not that simple as it's described here. There was a Jewish question in Europe as European nations were not sure what to do with Jews in Europe after WW2. A Jewish guy named Theodor Herzl made some agreements with the UK and they allowed European jews to settle in Palestine. Millions of Jews from all over the world immigrated to Palestine, aka Aliyah, and then with the Support of the US and the UK (lots of money) established a State. So it wasn't like millions of Jews lived in Palestine and decided to become independent. Millions of Jews moved to Palestine.
Well millions of Jews lived in israel even before islam or christianity.
They were driven out from their home land. There was never ever an independent country called palestine.
@@aswing2706 yeah and many Jews lived and owned businesses in Germany before WW2. Should they now fight Germans to get their lands/businesses back? oh wait, Germans are too powerful unlike Palestine.
Jews left and unoccupied their land, they shouldn’t be able to just be handled back or have the option to be backed by larger powers to take back the land.
I never understood how they try to eradicate a race when they already had that done to them
Free palestine
No Jews were sent to Palestine, they moved there on their own. There have always been Jews living there, even after the Roman expulsion, almost all towns have Hebrew names, even the Arab ones (example Beit Hanina, an Arab town means house of pardon in Hebrew). As far as the Arabs, most of them moved to "Palestine" as the same time the Jews came. Yasir Arafat, the " Father of the Palestinians" is from Egypt!
Palestinians who have been displaced not only endure the loss of their homes but also face challenges in asserting their right to reclaim their land. Regrettably, they are often labeled as terrorists by the majority of the world. who is the victim now?
It is interesting not a single news media talks about Balfour Agreement
amd rothchild fingerprints
What was that pls explain?
Carl Jhonson research lol
It was not called the 'Balfour Agreement', it was the 'Balfour Declaration'. It was never agreed with the people who actually lived in Palestine and it was only an 'agreement' in the sense that it was intended to ease the path for another agreement (from the US and Swiss banks) to approve a massive war loan to the British government while the outcome of WWI was still in the balance. The British banker (Lord Rothschild) was a prominent figure in the Zionist Federation and thought to be influential with his US and Swiss counterparts and the Balfour Declaration was presented to him without any consultation with the inhabitants of Palestine who were still Ottoman subjects. Also; the British had already promised the Arabs an independent Arab nation (to include Palestine) as a reward for mounting a rebellion again the Ottoman Empire which was fighting alongside Germany (look up the McMahon Hussein correspondence if you want to research it). History is important here so don't use misleading and inappropriate terms like 'agreement' when you really mean 'a unilateral imposition'.
@@exiled_londoner I'm Taiwanese and I'm familiar with people presenting "declarations" as hard evidence regarding sovereignty. In my opinion, the only legal method of transferring the sovereignty of land is through an official treaty, and I do not believe that such a treaty was created prior to the establishment of the State of Israel. Alternatively, another method of acquiring sovereignty over a given territory is through military conquest. This is the "Might is Right" mentality and I oppose it. I personally believe that the State of Israel was created through military conquest and other very unfair and undemocratic processes. And yet, people claim that Israel is a democratic country and a beacon of freedom in the Middle East.
"If I dont steal your house, someone else will"
Jacob from Brooklyn, 2021
I know exactly what you're talking about !
Jacob the Great Pragmatist! Got to admire it!
Jacob the Great Pragmatist! Got to admire it!
@@VeridicusMaximus Would u be saying that had the roles been reversed?
Is there anything you can say that's not a slogan?
The comment section will be filled with nothing but reasoned, emotion-free, rational arguments that enlighten and further the intellectual conversation on this very serious subject...
Do you not understand sarcasm Winter Christian?
syke!
Kappa
LMAO
your strikingly inventive line of thinking that isn't a near word for word copy of what was a popular comment in one of their last videos that included obviously bias opinions.
02:12
"Israel wasn't looking to take over land in this war"
While this is literally why Israel started the war
Ye? What about in 48? When Arabs starred a war to not just take the land, but to annihilate the Jews off the land.
Behind every conflict in the world, a british guy walked away.
A british aristocrat*. These aristocrats that ran the empire treated working class brits (which was at least 95% of the pop. at the time) worse than their foreign subjects. Victorian Britain was notoriously tough for the working class, with children being forced to work in factories, and sweep chimney's. The British aristocracy today are filthy rich because of what they stole from the empire. No other Brits saw this wealth.
Going back to 1948 isn't far enough. You should go back to 1917, when the Ottomans ruled here, or 1880s, when the first modern settlers, both Jewish and Arabs, started migrating. Or even back to 900 BCE, when the kingdoms of Judah and Israel were founded.
This video also skims on a lot of details. Like how Jews were expelled out of the West Bank by the Jordanians. Or how Yasser Arafat was not just a "Palestinian leader" but the leader of a Terrorist organization known as the PLO.
I think the video is fair, yes, it skipped over how problematic Arafat was (who is certainly in the club of people who never should have gotten the Nobel peace price) but it also skipped over Israel overreacting extremly to rocket attacks by the Hamas resulting in extremly high losses of civilian lifes in Gaza.
Both sides play dirty here and this is just the first video which basically just explains the map and skips over most other things which aren't relevant to understanding the map - you don't need to know Arafat to understand the map nor do you need to know about many other things.
The city of Hebron/Hevron is a good example.
Many people seem to think Jews came only after Israel was founded.
i also thought they shuld have mentioned that oslo practicly *made* him the palastinian leader. but this video is 8 minutes and is already very dense. and it does mention the significance of the place in biblical times.
why did u stop there go to when the first civilization there was the ARAB Canaans.
I think you meant to say in the title "How Israel stole Palestain ft. Britain"
Israel coming back to their native homeland Judea isnt stealing , and they've never stole Palestine because there was never a state called Palestine, it's how the Romans called the land after colonizing Judea
@@falula5290 Jews were 8% in 1946, suddenly boombed to 30% in 1948 and beyond. Not stealing?
@@khagan5951 Jews were 95% in Judea, and it's not stealing because the British Mandat promised them the land before they left
@@khagan5951 jews were 95% before muslim has came.
@@khagan5951 How is it stealing? the owner of the land (Britain) gave it to the Jews and the Palestienes. Basically 50-50. Now remember that the Jews wernt the one that declared war on Palestine for living in "their land"
The generosity of Britain deserves to be envied...it is always giving away things that it doesn't own...
Vox Ignored how they got there lmao
FaiisHD ur mom
Alex Starck Big boy !
@basil al sadi" Human need for survival should never take over our morals". Ideally, but the history of the human race indicates alternative course of actions is usually applied in a cold and unforgiving manner.
basil al sadi Jews got kicked out by a lot of countries tho.
basil al sadi 109 countries since 250AD.
"If I Don't Steal It Someone else's Gonna Steal It" - Yakoub 2021
who is he...i wanna know.....ive been seeing comments about this Yakob guy in every Palestinian Israeli related videos...im trying to catch up
@@akinyi5368 A settler who took over a Palestinian’s house. The two families got in an argument, and thats what the settler responded wiht.
@@akinyi5368 he jewish american that born in america somehow forced to living in israel
You forgot about the second intifada.
He seems to have, conveniently, 'forgotten' about a lot of historical facts.
They've literally made a separate video for it
You cant mention everything in only a ten minute video. They have many other videos about it
Including the fact that the United States used it’s veto against the UN’s resolution against the settlements.
Wow a history lesson from Vox about some of the most complex regions in the world in 10 minutes. It must be the truth.
Whay didn't you tell the real story before Britain came to the middle East???
Muhammad Alsabri you know that jews was there 3000 years ago
@@kamelsharaf314 yes,
And everyone knows that Palestinians where there 4,500 years ago even before prophet Ibrahim ......
Alkanaani, and Alyabosi, Those tribes left Yemen 4,500
to stay in Palestine.
My brother it's not about the religions Muslims, Christians, Jews all are sons of prophet Ibrahim and they pary to one God.
Muhammad Alsabri so what’s your problem?
@@kamelsharaf314 Just tell the truth?
@@M.SABRI79 You mean Jebus? They live in Jerusalen before Jews came to Jerusalem from Egypt
more please :) , when is the next video?
+yoni shirion next week! -Johnny
Cant wait for this
As a Palestinian i believe the logical solution would be a joint state between Israelis an Palestinians where both work in the same direction of advancing their country as one! similar to what happened in US in its civil wars.. but for that to happen, the following needs to be done:
1- Promoting co-existing on both sides
2- changing the name from Israel or Palestine to something neutral.
3 proper representation based on citizenship and governing by constitution and not religion
4- ceasing advancements on holy structures and allowing everyone the freedom of religious practice under mutual respect.
סוף סוף קצת על ישראל אה?
this has precedent in Bosnia where the Serbians Bosniaks and Croats divided the land among the three groups and they have three precedents why cannot Israel do the same thing سالام في شروك الاسط صديكي
If I don't steal it, someone else will"
~Jakob from Brooklyn(Israeli settler in Westbank, Palestine ), 2021
Jerusalem not WB
@@linahadj2650 In the part of West Bank.
Jakob is pretty based
You start with 1948 as if the Israeli were living there. You might need to go back a few years when the European decided to move the Jewish from Europe to a new place (Palestine) most of them are European citizens that European didn't want to deal with them anymore, and it goes all the way before the WWII
Jews are indigenous to that land and they were migrating to their indigenous homeland , while the Arabs are indigenous to the Arabian peninsula.
Yeah, tell that to the people who moved there during the First Aliyah when the land was solidly Ottoman territory
U forgot to mention how USA helped and funded Isreal. They had a big part to play here
Yes, in the same way the Soviets backed the Arabs
I am more surprised by American peoples who allow their tax dollars to be enjoyed by other countries for free.
@@FitraRahim well they’re allies with Israel and they’re largely investments that benefit America in the long run
Its because there's a lot of tech nerds grew up in Israel and a lot of companies (including US tech giants) are investing in that country
@@bobbobb4804 yes, allies. To the extent of killing American soldiers and attack the USS Liberty ship, for their own interests (Israel killed American soldiers, and blamed Egypt, so as to provoke America to be directly involved in the war and support Israel more deeply).
The reason why the US supports Israel is because of the greed of American politicians who are easily bribed ("lobbying").
However, the money they send actually comes from taxes from Jewish businessmen & billionaires, who are not willing to use their money to build and repair bridges, roads, access to cheap health care, improve social inequality (homeless).
With Israel all the way!
- love from India and America
REALLY? america is the only country that likes isreal lol ISREALmost hated country in the world
Think there are a few more hated countries buddy
Disliking their politics concerning Palestinians is not equal to hating them or wanting them attacked, nor does it prevent western countries from giving military aid and selling weapons to ensure Israel's security.
funny how india occupy kashmir...
mangalores-x_x So what you're saying is the world should sit back while the Arab world rapes and murders its way across Israel? I agree there needs to be a solution but it can't involve the destruction of Israel or the internment of Palestinians. It needs to build a brighter future for everyone. That CANNOT happen through violence.
The only similarity between:
a. Israel and Palestine &
b. India and Pakistan conflicts
= "British"
Vamshi Kanamarlapudi em matladthunav
They let India & Pakistan fight, but we still have chance to take the matters under control..
nobody cares about india (and pakistan)
@@bartekmazurek456 We too dont care what you people think 🙄
Vicenzo " you do exactly that. Just because I don't agree with your Islamist worldview doesn't mean you are any less stupid than you already are." of what Islamic vision you speak subnormal, is the vision of decent people who are against crime, brutality, torture, theft ... in short, people who are in favor of Human Rights and Justice
This is also why, no matter how many people call for "free Tibet", or "land back" here in the West,, it would never happen as the activists intended - all these settlements over the years are now fully entranced in the areas of the West Bank, just as similar as the ethnic Han Chinese settling in Tibet since the 1960's, or the hundreds of years that European settlers have in the Americas. The only realistic solution (for better or for worse), is for us to all learn how to peacefully co-exist with one another, based on mutual understanding and mutual respect. There's not much we can do with the past, but I doubt trying to re-segregate ourselves for the future would be a good idea.
start by not steal the Palestinians land and offer it to settlers for free then we can talk about coexist, this is an ongoing thing.
I know you are a big liberal but you are actually correct.
Imagine Indian Americans (native) deciding to take over America because it was originally theirs. 🤷🏾♀️
Well we were just strong enough to do it if they were strong enough they would have done it too I'm sure
@azi fabli It certainly does they started the war and we won it defensively
@azi fabli we fought for it therefore it's rightfully ours
@azi fabli if you consider getting land thru military actions not righteous, what do you think about how palestinians got the land in the first place?
@Anwar El sharkawy i am not jewish in the first place.
but if you consider it right that the romans "kicked" the jewish out, who are you than do say that the jews don't have the right to do the same thing with palestinians?
Vox didn't thought this video would get viral in 2021.
True
@@vola5793 ❤️
This is the very first time I actually understand the map..!! it took me about 20 years.. Thanks VOX
Vamos VOX, solo quedan las elecciones.
It is not true at all
How is the update the map in 2023? As the war has began between Israel and Hamas?
This seems to me a very good start on explaining the later history of Palestine. Look forward to the next part.
This video is years old
This is all about ethnic exceptionalism wherein one group thinks they have been chosen by God to rule the land. Another name for ethnic exceptionalism is racism.
Seems amazingly similar to another movement that occurred in central Europe towards the middle of the 20th century.
If the native Americans were be all alive and want to return to their native land ill support that.
Same with Israel
@
Benjamin Netanyahu says Israel is ‘not a state of all its citizens’!! Yes the palestinian are racist, sure
@@NinesNX no brain...no worries...
@@DeusHex the natives were in small numbers then, and smaller numbers now
@@yurichtube1162 up until 1492 they were approximately 112 million native Americans
who did the land belong to before the British came? I get the feeling its a stupid question but.....
Before is irrelevant. Powerful nations conquer weak ones all though history. The land belongs to the strongest. What they should have done is traded independence for Israeli citizenship. Living conditions would have been better for everyone.
Simply taking Israeli citizenship might not have given them a very good deal either. Look at how much good 'integration' did for the native americans in the US, every bit of land that had value was taken and given (either through direct government action, or actions only well financed and connected private institutions can take) to americans of european decent.
Same basic thing was happening there, even in the original Oslo accords. The early two state solution saw the bulk of the profitable land and critical infrastructure going to jewish group. So if arabs did simply integrate, they would be doing so from a position of poverty and lock out of critical resources, relegated to second class citizen status.
neeneko Exactly why they have no other rational choice. Have you seen native peoples living conditions in countries like the US and Canada. It would have been better to give up the reservation lands and integrate. Life is hard - there is no shame in surrendering against impossible odds.
life is all about fighting against impossible odds
"Life is hard, members of the French resistance. Germany won, there's no shame in surrendering against impossible odds!"
TheBoldImperator Yes and because France surrendered they didn't get bombed like the British.
What a mess. Feel sad for those people that have to deal with it.
Completely agree brother.
Poor Palestineans.
@@The_Accuser You are clearly not educated enough about this conflict! If you sanction Israel they will not be able to fund the "Iron Dome" (Anti Missle system which saves millions of lives daily) and clearly its palestines fault for all of this chaos, AND I am not done yet! Israel offered more then 5 times a peaceful SOLUTION to the conflict, Palestine refused all of them! Plus any palestinian civilian deaths were not intended by the IDF and were military accidents BECAUSE "Hamas" (Palestinian terrorists organasation) fires rockets from palestinian residential areas. So exuse me if i support Israel D: AND every palestinan expelled from there homes were either: Ilegel buildings without premissions from the controlling area,Terr0orists,Were in territories won by DEFENSIVE wars which means they are no longer supposed to be there because according to the "United Nations" Every territory gained from a defensive war automatcly belong to the defensive side IF they won, And remember! not only the palestnians are suffering from this conflcit! Israelis too!
Yes. My heart goes out to the Israelites. ❤
Who’s back here for a refresher in October 2023?
:D same
Share this video!
8:00 map needs to updated every month
Yup, Israel occupy a new land every month, I'm a Palestinian in West Bank and Israel occupy new land every day
@@mohammadfranko8445
And you were given the lands Israel occupied in the 90's accords, you have never really owned it, then shut up
@@lior995
It is Palestine since the beginning of the history
@@mohammadfranko8445
Since the Roman empire was here, only 2000 years ago.
It was "Kingdom of Israel" and "Hasmonean Dynasty" before the Romand bro.
Also, the fact that the land was called Palestine, is completely meaningless.
Palestinians today are just arabs from other countries, they had never identified as Palestinians until 1960's
They are embarrassing bro.
There was never an Arab state here and never a Palestinian autonomy
@Detasemen Khusus Anti Kuffar Then how did "palestine" lose to Israel?
Just turn Israel into a secular state. give the Palestinians Israeli citizenship. That would be the best solution.
they dont want a "citizenship". they want us out, and by "out" i mean dead. nothing more nothing less mate.
Israel already is a secular state (for the most part).
Palestinians are the ones who don't want to live in a secular state. They want to live in a Muslim-only state.
lol is that what u tell yourself to kill kids and then sleep at night ? they just want thier land back .they do not care about the jews . u all can stay as long as they have countery and government . but they do not we both now that
is there any Palestinian who got citizenship and gets proper education in the West Bank? Just curious and asking
By the Israeli government's actions you could be justified in saying the same in reverse.
why start from 1948...what happen in 1900..?
Mohd Hafiz desolate land that was waiting for its children to return.
@@porschecollector727 majoriry of Israelis oppose settlements why is it handicapped by the opinions of a group of extremist
Why not from 1st century
@@Some_Jihadi_Warrior-me1rz Israel along with china is one if the most disliked countries of earth 57% have an unfavourable rating of them
@@porschecollector727 REMEMBER Canaan kids will take it back, keep that in mind ... Eat it, drink it, dream about it .. Canaan sons will take it back ALL of PALESTINE.
They are occupied territories not settlements...They are making it sounds better
depicting settlers as heroes...not showing how they forcefully evict palestinians from their houses. a masterpiece of propaganda
jews never lived in peace under arab rule, but arabs live in peace under jewish rule
@@jonahb3520
Lol Not even close, 3 Intifadas, Israeli eviction of Palestinians from their homes, occupation of Palestinian land, and Police Brutality say otherwise
The clear solution is a 2 state one based on 1967 borders and the resettlement of Jews in Palestinian territory Back to Israel
@@jonahb3520 Jews had been leaving in Palestine since they were scattered. The Quran literally tells Muslims to treat Christians and Jews with respect. It was actually Crusaders from Europe who indiscriminately killed Muslims, Jews, and probably Christians as they sacked Jerusalem.
Why start at 1948? Who was in control over Palestine before the british? Leaving out that small detail i see. What right did the British have to rule over Palestine?
That would be the Ottoman Empire. Before The Ottoman empire would be the Byzantine Empire, before that the Roman Empire as a whole and before that idk.
The Kingdom of Israel existed before the Romans, the Greeks, the Syrians, the British, the Arabs invaded. Am Yisrael Chai.
+Yaakov Adam
Yeah, as you say. ExistED. As sa das it is, it has been over. In no way decades of illegal oppression, occupation, colonization in absolute impunity can be justified because your "ancestors" lived here in another era.
Canaanites called, they want their land back.
+Insan Lazuardi
Is this community also over-represented in high key positions in politics, medias, international institutions, lobbies and finance ? Because it helps a lot in order to impose your will, such as claiming a land "back".
Balfour Declaration ?
I guess not...
It just gave a permission to BUY land and emifrating. Just like you do in western countries bringing your violent islamic religion and your families. We welcome you, why dont they do the same? Because they are just something more than beasts.
Miftahul Firdaus try the bible.
@@tarasbulba7114 Only beasts are white colonists that invaded almost every single country on this planet through racist colonialism based on racist white supremacy ideals that thought everyone else deserved to serve them under death. We know who the true evil in this world is.
Balfour 1917. Not even an actual document, and the conditions were never adhered to as well.
Basically, the current Palestinians are the original people who lived there more than three thousand years ago, and the children of Israel are Canaanite tribes that inhabited Palestine. They do not own the land on their own. They succeeded in building a kingdom for themselves, but it collapsed. A small number of its people were displaced, but they returned in the end. As for the current Israelis, they are Europeans who have no relation to the Semitic peoples. The Canaanites are Semitic peoples, and the Arabs are as well, but the Israelis are a mixture of peoples and not a race.
The Caananites ( israelis ancestors ) are the historically first people recognised to have inhabited the land which today's Isreal disputes with Palestine.
Meanwhile the palestinians were brought there by the Roman empire.
UN was sleeping during 6day war and suddenly woke up
Since they all were assuming Israel will lose....but Israel won...thats where things changed fore ever
@@Preach_and_Teach-fe3vl Israel will always win, man the power of the elites yo, America, Britain, Australia all supports Israel.
@@yunhel people overestimate and overemphasise the contribution of western powers to Israel's supremacy, look into the 6 day war a bit more. Yahweh is the lord of hosts and has not forsaken the covenant he made with the people who first recognised him, despite them having strayed from his word numerous times.
@@yunhel israel get support as a trade for support which isnt very helping... and the support started after israel won the wars not before
@@yunhel Israel had to smuggle in weapons in the 48 war because the UN and the Europeans just left them there defenseless. They were virtually on their own again in 68.
Meanwhile British watching this video: * sips tea *
It’s a chai latte actually.
The British didnt start it.....the Roman empire did....
The whole land was originally known as Judea which was later renamed Palestine as purnishment to the Jews for revolting ...
Marvelous tea.
@@abrahambiz2353 The british decided to give land, that did not belong to them to a people that had no right to expell the inhabitans
tea tht they steal from india
Re writing history since 1948 ? You need to go back.....
More like 5000 years BC, since Babylonian times. I would guess that the Khazars are not the true Israeli people, judging by the whiteness of their skin (Palestinians are much closer in physiology to how an Israelite would like). An their Talmud is Baal inspired.
He means 1948 when Israel was created. Palestine existed before, but this video mainly focuses on Israel
@@liammcnicholas918 thank you for the honesty
Or 750 BC?
Your forgot something very important: in 1948, the whole land was Palestine under British occupation.
It wasn't palestinian, the Israel has inhabited that land from their cannanites ancestors first.
This however doesn't justifies the illegal jewish settelements in the West Bank.
So both Israel and Palestine have their own part of truth and rights, but both of them also have their fair share of guilt.
"If I don't steal your house,someone else is gonna steal it"
-Yakub the Great🐖 2021
"If I don't steal your house,someone else is gonna steal it"
-Jacob the israeli settler to a palestinian 2021
In South Africa, they use the term "Squatter"
Squatter is different, these lands were inhabited by Palestinians. they built the settlements over Palestinian houses, farms and Palestinian dead bodies.
Next video, Harambe Explained
do it
just do it
+ Winter Christian good
Damn right
No need for a video, I can explain it in just two words: DEAD MEME.
Absolutely change the law, Palestinian need to have their own airport, their own stuff free Palestine 🇵🇸
Then go and fight he for Palestine in war.
JESUS CHRIST is coming back soon ❤❤So call upon the name of the Lord Jesus Christ, the Prince of Peace, the one and only SAVIOUR of all mankind, and save your soul before the death happens 🙏""""The Lord is not slack concerning His promise, as some men count slackness; but is longsuffering to us-ward, not willing that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance.""". Other than JESUS CHRIST❤ there is salvation in no one else. God has given no other name under heaven by which we must be saved.”
🙏 amen
Why? They declared to have a state and it’s their problem.
Actually, no one is preventing Palestine from having an airport. it's just that hamas uses all of the money of weapons.
Do yourself a favor and don't scroll down.
Too late. Ack.
Should've heeded your warning...
just wanted to say that
PrimaPrime Productions yeah
yeah stupid people making stupid comment that they think that there opinions are going to change history
"israel wasnt looking to seize land" then proceeds to seize tons of land. israel's entire history in a nutshell
Maybe Israel wanted to exist, and so they fought a defensive war(So they could remain in existence and all), and then pushed back against their enemies
Thats right,arabs countries attacked and got defeated and humiliated simple as that.
Yeah. Haven't some Israeli officials admitted that the "pre-emptive strike" was in fact a land grab and that they knew all along that even the forces of all their neighbours combined could not defeat Israeli military, because despite smaller numbers, Israel has better training and better weapons... So it was never for fear of being caught in a surprise war by Egypt that would wipe them out, it was to seize land.
@@jjanon2371 where did you hear that?
@@jjanon2371 I’ve never heard that but I have read that the Egyptian president at the time said that closing the Strait of Tiran (one of the causes of the war) was an intentional act to promote unrest and to cause a war. A war in which Egypt hoped would result in the destruction of Israel.
what's your reaction if "Israel" took the united states??
I'm really waiting someone to answer
Bobo K
hahaha me too !!
The historically correct assumption would be what if the huge United States all the time attacks small Israel and when it loses all the wars it starts over and over again. When Israel takes over a small portion of US lands for its own defense purposes like any rational country will do.
I'd be like "lol, didn't see this coming!", because it'll never happen....what type of question is this anyways? USA+Israel= ALLIES
Daniel Pearson
so you admit that USA support terrorism ??
It took the recent events for the WORLD to protest FOR Palestine. I think we are seeing a cultural shift.... However, it will not matter if the USA and UK keep supporting Israel as they always have.
" Do you support the violent dispossession of me and my family? "
-mohamed elkurd 🇵🇸🇵🇸
Honestly, if a stranger invited me to live in ur house & after a while i started taking over, became hostile, attacked your family, & then "offered" you the spare room but no water in an ultimatum, how would you feel? May seem like a basic example but it's not far from the truth
Not basic at all, great example
A lot of people feel that way about the Muslim conquest
@@Mutant_Miniatures Read about it more.
@@Mutant_Miniatures well, I can confirm to you that those people failed their history class or they have not opened an authentic history book concerning this matter!
Support your claim with evidences sir!
Those 'Palestinians' are always trying to take over the entire house and always issuing ultimatums, that's the problem ... 99% of the Middle East isn't enough, they want it all ...
Vox, you should have started explaining the Israeli history from the early 20th century
Even if it was shortened, it will take several hours to explain the entire backstory to this subject alone.
what would changed if they did?
This is just part 1. There are total 8 parts I believe.
Which would have revealed only 5% of Palestinians were still jews at that time. Clearly that would have greatly switched the balance toward the palestinians.
Yes but the muslim palestines just got kicked out by random european jews and people think they wont be upset
It's interesting that you start history from 1947. This was Palestinian land, and will remain
Hard to say that when there has never been a Palestinian state
I don't know who told this kid that Palestinians can drive on most of the WB roads. That is total BS.
Actually it is nothing of the kind. "Palestinians" never stop complaining about the largely nonexistent roadblocks in Samaria and Judea. How would they notice them if they weren't driving. Maybe @Research0digo should stop and reconsider?
It's very inhumane Palestinians should be given their lands ..
@@akshitthakur6833 It was not humane when the Arab countries sent their armies into Israel in 1948 because they wanted to stop a state called Israel from existing. Those Arabs who left their homes in 1948 were not allowed to return, that is true. But they simply resettled down the road, not changing their culture, except to increase the hatred they had against the Jewish inhabitants who, like the Arabs, had bought property and settled the land.
I ride the roads of the West Bank. The Arabs drive everywhere on the main roads with the Palestinian Authority license plates. But no cars with Israel license plates are allowed inside the roads governed by the Palestinian Authority. If someone with Israel license plates enters by accident, he has to get rescued by the Israeli army.
You have no idea about the signs in Judea and Samaria warning all Israelis not too travel beyond 'this point' or you will be in mortal danger' thats the reality of travelling in j&s... Funny how the PA doesn't invest in infrastructure whilst Israeli taxes pay murderers in Israeli prisons 220 million dollars to be precise, money that could and should have been used to prosper
Its not their land, that's why its called settlers...
Anton Haddad it is their land, they are indigenous to it. It’s like saying native Americans aren’t allowed to live in America
NAT --- All the native are placed in reservations, stop acting like anyone actually respected Native American land control
Baby Boo no one does, that’s why we sympathise with them. Israel is not the enemy
Mich Sky then why did millions immigrate there after 1948?
@@Sunsets-nr6lv no they are not...
The real owner of the land is the palestinians
"If I don't steal your house someone else is going to"
~Ultra Orthodox J. to a Palestine
@@mr_whyy "Let me respond by bombing you ten times harder killing 90% civilians in the process" - Israel
@@ivanfloresvazquez7490 pay the price
1650 Tanks, 75000 Armoured Vehicles, 650 Self Propelled Artillery, 300 Towed Artillery, 100 Rocket Projector, 241 Fighter Aircraft, 23 Dedicated Attack Aircraft, 128 Helicopters, 48 Attack Helicopters?
Do you expect them to own this?
They put up a resistance against israel and that's their right. Any nation under attack has a right to defence. Israel is not under attack, Israel is the attacker.
They fire bb rockets at israel highly inaccurate that everybody knows are going to be shot down.
The purpose of these rockets is psychological.
@@ivanfloresvazquez7490 revenge
@@zylnexxd842 Why revenge on the civilians, though?
Remarkable omission at the beginning: "Those Jews came from Europe".
Very unauthentic way of explaining how this started.
Tmillchr
Try again kid globalists despise Israel because of their nationalism.
Bankers, war is profit.
I can't prove hell exist not should I inflict my belief of hell on to anyone..
But If hells is actually a place then the warmongers better start praying.
Zippy Zayden
Definitely. There's war mongers everywhere today it seems
Antisemitism is a hell of a drug (see comment section of this comment).
C Kyle
Are you joking. They're staunchly pro-Palestine and anti-Western.
“The ultimate tragedy is not the oppression and cruelty by the bad people but the silence over that by the good people.”
Martin Luther King, Jr. quote
Mind making a coherent point?
@@jameshorton3692 Mind reading better?
"Israel must exist and has the right to exist, and is one of the great outposts of democracy in the world." Martin Luther King Junior
Shame the world kept silent during the Arab oppression of the Jews I.e massacres of the 1920s, 30s and 40s and expulsion from west bank in '48.
Correct me if I'm wrong but didn't Israel use Napalm bombs on Palestinian land to "make way" for Israeli settlements?
nope
Shhh. You're not allowed to say that. Our masters will not be pleased.
not naplam they used nukes , and mass floodings
Israel bombed the Gaza strip with regular air strikes during a modern 'war', after Hamas attacked with mortars and kidnapped and killed 3 settlers-teens (ages 16-19).
Nukes? Mass floodings? What planet are you living on?
Anyone else come here for a refresher?
*A peace country with different religion having a good time
Britain : imma stop you right there
I'm drunk and completely support youtube videos
Sandwichism 😂😂😂
The downside to drinking and YouTubing is that you can't pull up your comments the next day LOL. Once and a while I get a reply from an old comment and get a good laugh 🙃
The lack of transparency is quite disappointing .
what do you mean
I am a history lightweight, but appreciate the clear, well delivered content of your work here.
They left out lots of facts
@@DeanRasmussen of course they did. They can't include all the facts in a conflict spanning multiple millennia's in an 8 minute video.
but to start at modern politics is forgetting the cause. Literally the difference between the victim and aggressor view.
❤ long live Palestine ❤️🇵🇸
Well DUH, how are you going to condense thousands of years of history down to 8 minutes@@DeanRasmussen