Game of Thrones - Walk of Punishment/Episode Revisited (Sn3Ep3)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ส.ค. 2018
- Aaron & Beau review the third episode from season 3 of Game of Thrones, "Walk of Punishment."
Game of Thrones - Walk of Punishment/Episode Revisited (Sn3Ep3)
FOLLOW US ON TWITTER, INSTAGRAM, SOUNDCLOUD, ITUNES & FACEBOOK!
PATREON - / nerdsoup
TWITTER! - / nerdsoup4u
INSTAGRAM - / nerdsoup4u
SOUNCLOUD! - / user-421750745
ITUNES! - itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/n...
FACEBOOK! - / nerdsoup4u - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
"Rhaegar fought valiantly, Rhaegar fought nobly, Rhaegar fought honorably. And Rhaegar died." One of my favorite lines in the book / show
The writing of GoT plays a lot with breaking the rule of three. They do it another noticeable time in season Six: Battle of the Bastards. When Ramsey shoots at Rickon he fires three times, misses three times. The design of that is to trick us as the audience into believing Jon will make it to Rickon. The rule is three, and Ramsey missed, so Rickon will be fine, the audience relaxes. Except that fourth shot that takes him through the chest and without knowing, the devastation is so much worse for the death because they 'broke the rules'. It's designed to take us to a false sense of security by manipulating the established structure. They break the rules and thus break our perception of the situation.
The way they accomplish that does seem like a little bit of a cheat however, as the true kill shot seems to kind of come a bit unrealistically quicker after the last 'failed' attempt, but not like plenty of movies and shows haven't played some with time in that way before. Also as Sansa tries to make clear the night before, there was just about literally no scenario in which they were going to come out of that with Rickon still living, technically it was more important Ramsay kill him than Jon.
EDIT: this idea only just hit me now too. I wonder if Ramsay had at all considered taking a much smaller group of men and just stealthily attacking their camp during the middle of the night, like they did with Stannis. Go in with the aim of killing Jon (not sure if he'd specifically want Sansa still alive at that point if they could kill her) and I guess like Davos and Tormund, too. it's totally his style.
@@kevinw712 the time difference was also them breaking with structure, only this time they had established the structure themselves, which was the time between shots. But this “rule” was also “broken” because if you remember Ramsay was being intentionally painfully slow notching his arrows and pulling back the bow and taking the shot each time..the last time he just took a kill shot showing Jon he had been missing intentionally all along, and in the process Jon had done the one thing he was cautioned against: Charging into the middle of the battlefield and Ramsay has the added benefit of Jon being within arrow range, AND, if his men don’t want to see him slaughtered they now must rush into waves of arrows.
"Stay at Craster's. When you're here...you're family." I WANT THAT T-SHIRT!
I love how this show feels like a show you might've seen on adult swim in the early 2000's
Indeed. Even bug man sort of sounds like coach Mcgircks potential bastard son. From home movies.
(Ignore the one month break we took) I will never forgive you for that. 😂
Be honest... how can you stay angry at these lovable nerds?
Love your videos just thought I'd let you know, I think Ramsay also sent those men after Theon because they were his Fathers loyal men, not his. So he could cut them down, blame theon and not have men loyal to his father reporting back to roose about his activities.
I just noticed that the guy Ramsey shot in the head was the same dude that peeled Theon's finger when his torture first began.
well first to most directly address part of what you said (a whopping 7 months before I'm making my reply here, so I'm sure you'll get right on reading it lol), but does that come with a perception that you don't think Roose already has a pretty good idea what kind of person his son is? I mean it does seem like maybe they tried to have it both ways a little, because when they do that one transition of Roose telling Robb "My bastard... has his own way of doing things" and cut to what we know's been going on awhile, but then also of course when Roose finally returns home he does seem some level of upset at what's been done.
But I just remember when I was first watching this, especially not being a book guy, I felt like it took me SO friggin long to truly catch up and sink in what the whole thing was. I mean maybe I'm just kinda slow, but for it to be that holy shit, he went thru (I think at least still in some significant part even accepting what you're saying) that whole play acting thing, and all of it really, just so that he had something "fun" to do. What. the. FUCK. But, I guess D&D also obviously knew Joffrey would be dying at the start of season 4 (that shocked me way more than the Red Wedding did, which already was a lot), and this whole scenario does set up the high level of batshit crazy villain that Ramsay will be in the larger story.
I'm glad these are back on a weekly schedule
I'm rewatching the series to show it to my girlfriend and we just passed this episode. I'm really looking forward to watching these reviews with the episodes so fresh in my mind. This is such a great revisit of the show and you guys are awesome as ever. One thing that I missed in this episode on my first watch was the shade that Varys throws Littlefinger during the small council meeting at the beginning; "In Stark's absence, Roose Bolton holds Harrenhal... which would make him Lord of Harrenhal, in practice if not in name," all the while basically laughing right at Littlefinger and poor Littlefinger is not even looking at him - just fucking grimacing and trying not to feed the troll. Absolutely hilarious.
Syrio Forel: YOU are late Nerd Soup! Next week u will upload on Thurs 😉
Just so.
I want a T-Shirt for Krastors Keep now with the tagline "When you're here, you're family!"
21:39 all these sports analogies lol
I liked the rock music at the end, i think it adds to the wtf just happened moment of jaime's hand.
Yeah it's totally on purpose, but I'm not sure I like it. Maybe me not liking it is what makes it good tho lol.
I feel like out of place rock version of the Bear and the Maiden Fair was designed to confuse the viewers so that we would feel like Jaimie in that moment. Something like "What?! What's just happened?!"
I remember being on my toes when I saw the end of the intro say Directed By David Benioff. So glad I wasn’t the only one that felt that way about the end credits. I agree it should of went straight to silence with Jaime’s scream sounding more distant the longer the screen went to black with silent credits or at least a really lulled theme playing slower and quieter through the end. It really took me out of the moment.
The guy who plays Carl Tanner, Burn Gorman, also appeared in an episode of Always Sunny in Philadelphia. That episode of Sunny was written by Benioff and Weiss, which is kinda cool.
I’m a new fan! I have watched all your game of thrones videos so far. Keep it up guys!
Man, I have to say that the rock version of bear and maiden fair was so unexpected and I loved it. Like this episode as a whole was pretty funny. idk, I think it was a good choice.
I love how u guys are keeping the GoT Videos up!
3:15 “doesnt make any....(rises in such a godlike way) sense” i lost it lol
Oh wow I'm so damn happy to see you guys again so soon!! Love your work!
I love the analysis style of these videos!
Nerd Soup thanks so much for doing these again!
Jaime is good until he's around Cersei. She brings out his worst impulses.
Well to be fair our introduction to Jamie was when he threw a child off a tower apparently in order to protect his and his sisters' incestuous affair. When viewed through the lens of passed time however, the cat, whilst just as reprehensible, increasingly seems as much a protection of lives as a destroyer of one, given that the revelation would almost certainly have resulted in the deaths of Jamie and Cersei Lannister _and_ the children Joffrey, Myrcella and Tommen Lannister. And that would be without considering the refusal of Tywin Lannister to believe such accusations and his thus inevitable ensuing conflict with the Crown. Hesitation would have been fatal... plunge the kingdom into war or murder a child? I imagine that when one is already universally reviled as a Kingsguard "Kingslayer" it's easier to disregard to hit to one's reputation one would have to take...
Addiction.
@@YellowTissueBox Exactly. Cersei is straight up black tar heroin and Jaime's like a first ballot hall of fame-level junkie, he was like Robert Downey Jr level, given his general life of prestige he had to start with. actually that might be really right on now I think about it, with the redemption arc Jaime's getting to have, not unlike RDJ himself.
The Tywin chair scene. BEST SCENE EVER.
Jamie's redemption arc started on the back of that horse for me. The first time, I thought he is not as bad as he seems, was when he admitted that he has only been with Cersei. But I really saw him, as a man that can care when he warns her about fighting back. He respects her. And when he lies about the sapphires... so sweet. I think his weakness is actually caring for the weak. But he buries it all to protect Cersei and their lies
Always a great pleasure to watch your reviews, please continue !!
I actually loved the song in the end. I thought it suited perfectly with the crazy that just happened.
You guys are friggin hilarious and i cant believe i just found out about you guys. Keep up the great work
Love how long these are getting. Keep it up
One of the best endings to a tv show ever (and i kinda dig the music at the end, it just kinda fits the chaos)
I think the end-credit song was meant to rattle you more than you already were. 😲 Great job as usual, guys. 😊❤️
angie 808 it was so funny I forget if it was the DVR version or the stream but when it first came out the song came in like 10 seconds before he lost the hand, it was super jarring
I love "Bear and the maiden fair" great song. But that rock version is awful.
It totally undercut the scene that preceeded it too. Took me right out of the moment when it kicked in the first time I saw it.
@@BooshmanLee when the music kicked on i raised up from my seat and was like, "What the F*CK IS GOING ON!!??"...
@@BooshmanLee Yeah. I mean it's totally the point to fuck with our heads but I don't think I like it either.
Tanner is played by Burn Gorman - he was also in Turn / Washington Spies series, which was on AMC. I agree with you guys - he's very good!
Another day another nerd soup video! Rejoice!
Another on time thursday game of thrones upload.
3:31 There is a Brynden Rivers in the books. He's also been called Lord Bloodraven and the Three Eyed Raven.
Bloodraven is Three Eyed Crow in the books. And although it's a small thing, I think changing it to Three Eyed Raven was one of the dumbest changes in the show because it loses the meaning of him being a former brother of the Night's Watch
The Small council rooms has the four top best Players of the Game of Thrones, Tywin, Varys, Littlefinger, Tyrion, Maester.
How 'bout Vary's face as Tyrion drags that chair and starts talking to Tywin. Pricless
"Craster's: When you're here, you're family!"
lmao XD
Thankfully, I just finished the essay from last 😌 I can watch this guilt-free
Only 6ep till the red wedding review I'm pump for that one
Matty, The Slav pretty sure they'll still be making the videos and I don't got school anymore so I ain't worried
ILOVE THIS CHANNEL. I ONLY SUBSCRIBED BECAUSE OF THE INCESSANT HIP HOP REFERENCES.
This has always been my most favorite episode of the whole series. From start to finish I give it an 11
Yay! Game of thrones review, these are great to kill time until the last season returns.
I live for these recaps
I love these re reviews
The Rock song at the end was good. Idk what Mr Blue bug is thinking. It should of been done by the drop kick murphys
Love the videos...and the fact that you're NBA fans....if you could drop a Simmons or Embiid reference I'd be sooooooo happy. Maybe once the giant comes back in future episodes. keep up the good work!
love your videos you guys are so funny and always have great commentary! you mentioned eighth grade i was wondering if y’all were going to review it? maybe on a podcast??
Can we get a weekly GoT podcast? Also I'd love if you guys would review the books especially stuff from 'The World of Ice and Fire'.
The only thing that gets me through folding my laundry is the goat NETD SOUP
I gave out such a dirty chuckle at 7:07 🤭Just great content as always.
You left out the funniest line from the pod vs the three whores scene. When Tyrion is introducing the whores and he said something about pod saving him with the spear and Tyrion intros the whore as such and such “sheees quite the spear handler herself”
The actor that you noticed is named Burn Gorman he is an English actor who was in the BBC series Torchwood (spinoff from Doctor Who with John Barrowman as Captain Jack Harkness the man who couldn't die). He also plays the Marshal in The Man in the High Castle. He us a great character actor who almost always plays a jerk or the "strange one".
It's funny that in this he's a pumped-up psycho spewing up razor sharp naked red death but the last movie I saw him in - Pacific Rim - he was the ultimate cliched uncoordinated weedy crippled bespectacled Nerd.
love these video. Nice content
That small council meeting is objectively THE best moment in the show.
The Bear and the Maiden Fair was sung by The Hold Steady at the end of the episode
That rock song at the end also caught me off guard. I felt like there was something wrong with the network.
I want you to know that of all of my subs your channel is the only channel I click the bell for. I need these episodes.
You guys are the best! 😸
Gendry tapped Hotpie on the shoulder and then Arya tapped him on the shoulder in season 7. Nice foreshadowing.
then Hot Pie tapped her on the ass. so rude.
She liked it.
definitely
End credits rendition of "The bear and the maiden fair" is by the band The Hold Steady
Love your vids guud!
The animations are great but I just listen to boe and Arron when I’m going to sleep u guys are awesome at this can you please review the books so I can die happy
The end of this episode is perfect, and the song is just so jarring it's like dude what the fuck just happened
Big fan guys keep it up !
Looove that Dothraki theme, I wish they released that track
Such a great video - whats the last movie/show you survived the plot! Haha love it, I would survive the Good Place 😂
YEEEES. Not a 4 week break. Just kidding love these videos and game of thrones
The House Bolton words: "We're just this group of individuals."
This was hilarious and informative
speaking of the song at the end, have you ever seen the yoube video of that song playing at the end of a bunch of other episodes of game of thrones including the red wedding?
th-cam.com/video/DkuIufeL94w/w-d-xo.html
Wait all week for your review
The guy that plats Edmure is great. He is great in GoT, Doctor who and most of all Rome. Great actor.
The guy that plays Karl Tanner is the westerosi version of Dennis from its always sunny in Philadelphia
why did they never knight Pod?
Carl i bet they will season 8
still time. and brienne
he is still a young squire and hasnt yet finished training with brienne
Who would knight him? He serves as Brienne's squire, and she cannot knight him as would normally be the case, as she herself is not a knight. He would thus have to commit a noble or heroic act worthy of being raised to knightood by his Lord. But... as his current Lord would appear to be The King in the North and Northerners don't hold with knights, being part of the Southron religion of The Seven and no of the Old Gods. And Jon will not revoke the Old Gods just because he is Valaryan.
he was barely a squire
Jamie convo with kyburn reminded him he is a knight, so he saved Brianne and shared why he killed maf king. Like the hound. A true knight
In four years we're gonna get a dragon and ur work is gonna be fresh
Finally caught up! I started watching your GoT vids last week. Good stuff. Now I know the Boltons are assholes but I always thought it was stupid of Locke to chop Jaime's hand off. Roose wants to him right, obviously he's priced possession. Roose wants to make a deal with Tywin. This could have jeoparized the whole thing.
30:07 Imagine if that rap song played at the end of the Red Wedding
Please re-upload the dragon and the wolf review! :( I love your videos!
Brienne is a beast and a tank, the show makes her even tougher too, but in the books her inner monologue says she barely could hold him off while Jaime was starved, chained and weak. He says she's up there in strength comparable to the top 3 so she's top tier for sure though, it's those Dunk genes haha.
Artwork is best part of your show! Commentary is cool to. Xo
i felt bad for edmir missing those shots
chill mccool yea his father just died give him a break
Yea. Poor Ed. He was super drunk in the books too. Not that it’s a real great time to be drunk but his Dad just died and the war and stuffs. I dunno, I felt bad too.
Hey hey!!!! So excited for this today. These Got videos make my day. Both of you have some sexy voices too 😉
The next episode is going to be like Christmas for Aaron!
Wow y'all are ?still going on this series!!
Well keep on keeping on
these guys are def northern jersey or ny pa area right? i feel it. but im going jersey. they just remind me of friends from home
First one after becoming a patreon supporter. Now I wait until I find my name lol.
You guys had a video of your top 10 characters. Still hold true to that list?
I'm disappointed you guys didn't do a review for hereditary.....I wanted your thoughts on the movie . Damn you need soup dsmn you!!
I'm watching the show again and reading the books along. I can't watch these cuz I'm still on the second season/book😭
Greatness!!! 🙌🏽
Jaime can cross sword with anyone but he can't talk his way out like Tyrion 😁
Thanks for the video 😘
Can't wait for more analysis of Karl fookin Tanner, legend of Gin Alley!
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA I FINALLY GOT THE NOTIFICATION
Christmas has come early again
I sooo knew that was Tomen off top lol
The closing credit song is supposed to catch you off guard, especially when his hand has just been chopped off. If you weren't expecting it (non book reader) then the song enhances your feeling of "what the f**k just happened". Seems like if you knew he was losing his hand it just seems a weird choice.
Good stuff
Dany is basically Sam Hinkie. She's tanking right now, not really getting any W's yet. Not far removed from wandering the desert -- but she's picking up crazy good assets. About to take over! #TrustTheProcess !!!!!!!!!!!!!!