Indonesia's remote Natuna islands and the tensions in the South China Sea
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ส.ค. 2023
- Call it Indonesia’s Natuna dilemma: Native fishermen there would like protection from Chinese encroachment in their waters - but Jakarta would like to keep its biggest economic partner. Read the full story: cna.asia/3rZPkIx
Subscribe to our channel here: cna.asia/youtubesub
Subscribe to our news service for must-read stories:
Telegram - cna.asia/telegram
WhatsApp - cna.asia/whatsapp
Follow us:
CNA: cna.asia
CNA Lifestyle: www.cnalifestyle.com
Facebook: / channelnewsasia
Instagram: / channelnewsasia
Twitter: / channelnewsasia
TikTok: / channelnewsasia
Im a Filipino and i stand up with my Indonesian brothers!!!
China hanya akan bernasib sama seperti Amerika di perang Vietnam.
ketika negara Asean merdeka kita adalah bangsa yang tangguh, kita di jajah karna dulu kita terpecah belah
Ofc man, we are brothers, we are of the same race, the face of our nation is similar
Support Indonesia from Philippine 🇵🇭❤🇮🇩
Thanks brother❤
I hope the 3 brothers nation Indonesian, Malaysian and Philippines will join or combined to protect our dear island and water area
I admire Indonesia's strength for standing up against China. The Philippines fully support our brothers in Indonesia.
Indonesian History 🇮🇩
i am from the philippines 🇵🇭 and he said that is true never underestimate the strength of the Indonesian people because they are not afraid of anyone, even though your country has sophisticated weapons but against 200 million more Indonesian people men and women who are eager to fight like they were colonized before
Note : their fighting spirit is your nightmare
Did you see the Indonesian soccer match that killed 125 ppl , I can tell their fighting spirits so strong lol
🇲🇨 military are historicaly losing so many battle against foreign forces in the past,, and nowadays can't afford to fight separatism in there own papua province as their soldier just died reguraly there without futher credible action,
@@xinzhong01 you wanna try?
@@xinzhong01it is more than a terrorist, criminal armed group. there are other countries behind it
@@alldump676 His pfp alone says that he is a bot
Indonesian brother, greetings from the Philippines, please secure your territory against China, or else you will be having a problem against this intruder.
Yes, we will always be ready to face China. Indonesia has never surrendered to the invaders.
Give them an inch and they will take more.
Natuna is not west Ph sea (west PH sea now belong to china😂)
natuna is not part of wet philippine sea troll@@ghtrl8
Yeah, and you pinoy dont ilegal fishing in maluku northsea
Support Indonesia From 🇮🇳
AS A PILIPINO I ADMIRE INDONESIAN FIGHT FOR THEIR RIGHT IN NATUNA SEA
Go Go Go Indonesia!!! Let's all unite in fighting this bully China!!! Philippines here to support...
we Indonesians have quite strong enemies, on both sides,
China, and Australia, But we Indonesians are the descendants of people who have experienced a lot of war, atrocities, colonialism, violence, and massacres. We have nothing to fear anymore, because our goal has always been only one, Freedom or Death,
if we can't win, we must die, but if we don't want to die, we must keep winning
Salute brother from PH!
From Philippines🇵🇭 We support you brother Indonesia🇮🇩
We also killed each other a lot back then
No, Australia not enemy
Its enemy in china
@@Kampung_halaman62 elu aja penyefonk china yang percaya sama persahabatan kodok dan lumba lumba, aslinya mah cina musuh dalam selimut
ASEAN Countries esp with claimants (Indonesia, Philippines, Brunei, Malaysia & Vietnam need to cooperate each other to counter the Aggressive behaviour of China which is the enemy in Asia Pacific.
The above video is an old video probably around 2019.. 2 years ago if not mistaken indonesia has built a military base in natuna. To this day, we have never heard of China entering Indonesian waters.
Yup, in Teluk Buton, Sepempang, and Cemaga. Total there is 3 new military base in Natuna. But still, Chinese fishing boats entering Natuna Sea till now
Im pilipino proub to be a brother of Indonesia🇮🇩 country 💪💪💪
Terimakasih saudaraku,,
Kini laut Natuna Utara sudah menjadi pangkalan militer,dan kami rakyat Indonesia tidak pernah takut untuk berperang,terlalu lama leluhur kami di tindas oleh penjajah,oleh karena itu jiwa kami sebagai rakyat tidak pernah takut untuk menjaga negara kami sampai titik darah penghabisan,kami selalu punya pedoman dlm perang 10 November,yaitu"Merdeka atau Mati.
Salam hangat saudaraku Filiphina❤
I will ALWAYS support my Indonesian brothers, from Phillipines.
WE BROWN ASIANS OF SOUTH ASIA ALWAYS UNITED.
cina spotted 😂😂😂
*The international law* is very clear on the South China Sea:
- parts of it belong to some ASEAN countries including Indonesia 🇮🇩,
- the rest of it is the international water,
- no part of it belongs to China🇨🇳 or Taiwan🇹🇼.
South China Sea belongs to China
Nobody cares about the international law. South China Sea belongs to the strongest country and in this case, its China.
Cockroach 🪳bot has turn up again after 3 months
What international law? And what do they say about the disputes between ASEAN countries themselves?
Stop talking rubbish.
@@TheTestTubes the US and UK did not sign, China signed up after article 11 was added regarding provisions about historical claims before being a signatory. China did not violate the agreement, you should do research on it. Look up UNCLOS article eleven.
*I know this is impossible but I want to have a United Coast Guard of South East Asian Nation or UCGSEA. This will surely protect every inch of our own respective territories*
Exactly! This must be stopped.
It's never happen, ASEAN it self can't United in any military issues.
There are too many rivalries within Asean itself. Cambodia vs Thailand, Vietnam overlap claim in Natuna with Indonesia. Indonesia and Malaysia dispute over Ambalat. United Asean is ver very far way to be a real thing
@@guzt3680 Asean Union would be better for everyone. Otherwise Asia will to be grinded down in between the two world powers.
@@guzt3680 you forgot to mention Philippines vs. Malaysia on Sabah territorial claims of the Philippines.
Asean must unite to stand against China overtaking South China Sea 🌊 🇨🇳👎🏻
中國和印尼已經對納土納群島歸屬做了最終的結果，那就是中國承認納土納群島歸印尼所有，印尼也承諾兩國領土糾紛是兩國內務，不允許西方國家牽扯其中，自2018年後，中國官方船隻再也沒有進入過納土納群島海域，而印尼也和中國進行了大量的高技術採購和建造，包括高速鐵路，鋼鐵製造等問題。菲律賓則不同，因為菲律賓一開始就想拉美國進入南海，所以中國在南海主要針對的就是菲律賓。
Jangan pernah terpropokasi banyak orang Malaysia yang komen di sini yang memojokkan bangsa Indonesia, sedangkan laut Serawak mereka masih di klaim cina mereka merengek minta bantuan Indonesia, Indonesia jangan ikut campur urusan Malaysia lebih baik diam,
We should be grateful for their dedication.Because they maintain the existence of a country in the middle of the sea, it is very difficult.
UNCLOS: "Limits to 200 nautical miles."
Indonesia and the Philippines: "Yes, it limits to 200 nautical miles."
China: "2,000 nautical miles!"
US: "20,000 nautical miles!"
China & US: "We provide fundings to the UNCLOS on its decisions."
Indonesia and the Philippines: "😓"
The U.S does not claim territorial waters past 200 nautical miles.
The U.S is not a signatory to UNCLOS.
China is the one who signed UNCLOS yet doesn't follow its rules.
It is China who wants to claim more than the 200 nautical miles.
You lost me at the US part.
US never had any claims at South China Sea
But the US isn't claiming the entire south china sea lol
US is 4x bigger than China in total area. It doesn't need the tiny china sea lol
INDONESIA IS A BEAUTIFUL COUNTRY I HOPE TO VISIT ONE DAY KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK PROTECTING YOUR TERRITORY
🏄🏄🏄🏄
Well done Indonesia! ❤
Old video, now Chinese coast guard ships never again enter the waters of the Natuna exclusive economic zone, Chinese coast guard ships now always enter Malaysia and the Philippines
The date stamp on the Indonesian Coast Guard video is Dec 2019. That's 4 years ago.
Still same😂😂😂😂😂😂
We teaching Chinese to sailor and this is what we got. Only one way to finis this is become strong country first Indonesia must make Singapore stop steal money, because Singapore steal 370 bilion USD per year!! From Indonesia
Your govt official steal tax money, not singapore
Hope indonesia, malaysia,vietnam,brunie,Philippines will stand up and fight for your rights dont let china overlaps thier claim
the "ONLY" problem is Chinese tofu people did'nt accept Int'l law
China jauh di Utara ngapain ngaku ngaku laut china selatan..!!
Kalau mereka beralasan bilang dan melihat sejarah itu adalah jalur perdagangan sutra china..
Jadi mongolia berhak mengaku seluruh daratan china adalah milik mongol..
Begitu juga indonesia bisa mengaku daratan Thailand sampai jawa adalah milik krajaan Majapahit (Indonesia)
Bahkan sampai ke Madagaskar..
Dan Inggris juga bisa mengaku lebih dari separuh dunia ini adalah miliknya..
Dan Belanda juga bisa mengaku bahwa Indonesia adalah miliknya..
Begitu juga jepang, mereka bisa mengaku daratan Pasifik adalah Miliknya...
Lucu sekali china ini...!!
Lol
Memang gila itu Cina, serakah & gak logis. Sejak zaman kerajaan dulu Cina pasti gagal masuk & menguasai perairan Nusantara krn kerajaan2 dulu sangat armada lautnya (terutama masa Majapahit & Sriwijaya)
sukak2 kita,,, ikan disana banyak choi
@@xinzhong01 Gak heran KORUPTOR kebanyakan keturunan Cina .. jiwa & karakternya "suka-suka kita" .. serakah , gak memikirkan orang lain & dampak ke orang lain. BIADAB & gak punya ADAB ‼️
@@AZA020406 ngomong masih kumur2,🤣🤣🤣
@@TheRocktion Di Disini polda metro jaya, Bawa sekalian teman2 loe sekalian biar gw kirimin brimob nanti, LOL
INDONESIA harus punya power stop sudah jadi bangsa yang selalu direndahin negara lain apalagi negara kecil
Onething i say for sure is ... Never test our patience . We simply doesn't want to be bothered ....
The United Nations must help small countries to defend their territory. Ships illegally in Philippines and Indonesian waters must be boarded and the crew arrested.
Yes.. Indonesia has destroyed at least 76 Flipino fishing boats for illegal fishing in its waters.
United Nations helping small countries against a permanent security council member? Are you insane?
@@madsam0320 LMAO that guy probably forgot that one most important fact
Small.
@@wangchung7599 small number compared to the Chinese intrusion inside Indonesian EEZ.
im from philippine and we support indonesian...
The Philippines is facing the same problem in the Spratlys group of islands and Cay group of islands which are under the Philippines' Exclusive Economic Zone. It only shows that China doesn't respect international maritime and land borders.
Philippines, Indonesia will stand together
Waters around Natuna, we named it North Natuna Sea. Naming it South China Sea is a political and historical mistake and can cause disaster in the future.
Ancient Xhian has come in peace through Admiral Cheng Ho and we inaugurate him as Sam Poo Kong but todays Communist China are totally diferent.
What China did increase the hatred leading racial issues against the indonesian chinese or peranakan but the most to the chinese expat here in indonesia.
Galing ng Indonesia...dapat ganyan ang mga coastguard ng pilipinas matapang...eh wala eh walang bayag nabayaran ng Chinese
Hahaha tas ang mahirap pa nito nangunguna ang pinas sa South East Asia na mas malakas at mas maraming coastguard tapos Yung coastguard natin pagka may training sa ibang bansa ang lakas mag pasikat tapos pag nandito na sila sa sariling territory hinahabol Lang sila sa Chinese coastguard 😂
@@empegaming9070 correct...
@@empegaming9070 saan mo naman po napulot na ph ang mas malakas at mas madaming coast guard haha, kong totoo yan ei di sana nababantayan natin ng maayos ang mga isla natin.
Sama sama. To our indonesian brothers - divided we were conquered. Learn from history. Do not let our people fall into slavery and colonialism to the chinese. Tulong!
Chi na, get out of Vietnam water!!!
Just because its call South China Sea does not meant China have e rights to everything within 😡 always displaying big bullies attitude 😡
because there were no real countries around the area when named it.
India should claim the sea around HK likewise. No one will say anything right ??
@@SivalinPuthery for India, just look yourself in the mirror at first, you don't yet have the ability to annoying here right now, please just take care of your people at first, especially the women, don't want to hear any negative news about the women abusing from India anymore.
@@SivalinPuthery india already has territorial disputes with all of its neighbors, I think they got their plate full.😂
Well, it’s not called west Philippine sea, nor east Vietnam sea, everybody called it South China Sea 😅
In 2022, China's direct investment in Indonesia reached US $ 21.5 billion, accounting for a quarter of Indonesia's total foreign capital. The bilateral trade volume reached 150 billion US dollars.
As we all know, Indonesia now has the best bullet train in the world.
Hanya menjaga wilayah kami, hak kami, kami tidak akan menembak sebelum anda memulai, aturan laut adalah aturan, harus dipatuhi milik hak negara lain, salam baku hantam, kamu jual kami beli😊
Why they don't change the name from South China sea to north Filipino sea or asean sea?
Where you from CNA admin?
Singapore
Japan, Indonesia, Philippines.
Amazing number of CCCP trolls and cybertroopers in this thread
China never learns
learn what?. don't tell me you guys just becoming moral degradation,
Very Similar Situation here in West Philippines Sea .. CHINA always bully us in our own Territory or EEZ .. INDONESIA language are also similar word example is when you say "TAKOT AKO" it means Im Scared .. (Pilipinas language) and even the weapon "SANDATA" here mean WEAPON ..
From everything I’ve seen, it’s clear to me that China is cruising for a bruising
Just Firing A Warning Shot!
Why is it discussed again
Indonesia is hosting ASEAN summit next month , most english media need to follow U$A agenda to pressure Indonesia.
They want ASIA to be divided.
This few days most western media together popping up dated negative news about Indonesia.
e.g. Indonesian maid's torture highlights lack of legal protections
😅Now U$A EU UK suddenly felt Indonesia is lack of "Democracy" & "Human Rights" .
As Indonesia working closer with China and going to join BRICS.
I truly believe kindness in every humanity exist regardless of there nationalities but this kind of bullying coming from china is really a wicked thing. Greediness at its finest!
🚫Not South China sea, but North Natuna Sea✅
Indonesia 🇮🇩 Please... we better change the name of “China Sea” to “Asian Sea”. Kawit Cavite 🇵🇭Preambler-Butler
Indonesia navy is too soft, should be more strict especially when someone is encroaching into your territory. Fire few rounds, show you are serious.
not when enemy is superpower
where does it come from, Indonesia has the 4th strongest navy in the world, the problem is Indonesia is a large archipelagic country, there are many more waters that must be guarded
@@xinzhong01 Russia is seen as Second Powerful Army in the World
Now they are the Second Army in Ukraine
@@Kokudou_Risa third army where seen as NATO + USA in ukraine
@@xinzhong01superpower in gutter oil
Chinese mainlanders claiming ancestral waters of Austronesian islanders like the Filipinos and Indonesians is next level in ridiculousness. Like the Cow trying to annex water from the Fish.
Like brother and sister claiming the same toy
Isu ini haram tenggelam!, sesungguhnya China terus mengawasi kita. Indonesia welcome dengan bisnis mereka tetapi soal wilayah kita bisa korbankan semuanya. Sejauh ini pemerintah Jokowi bisa membuktikan itu tapi tetap jangan lengah.
Tapi ketua banteng malah ngejual wilayah kita😅, padahal udah mati2an di perjuangkan
@@ANIMELOVERS-ij9rqyang mana yang dijual?
@@editorizalLigitan sipadan ke malonte malaydesh
@@liammoye5238 waduh
@@liammoye5238apaan sih ga jelas, dua pulau itu dinyatakan milik Malaysia oleh pengadilan internasional. Indonesia kalah bukan dijual
Indonesia should file case as Phlippinnes did..
It’s should be so
U mean UNCLOS case funded by US? What's funnier US never rattified UNCLOS and a country who ignore UNCLOS but funding his puppet UNCLOS 😂
@@paranoya733What's funnier is that China lost.
@@45641560456405640563How to lost when China don't attend the fight ? 🤣
😂😂😂
7 May 2021 , Roa Duterte said U$A still not yet pay back US$30 million to Philippine tax payer
The Philippine media disclosed that the Philippine government paid as much as US$30 million in lawyer fees for the South China Sea arbitration case, and the United States should pay the lawyer fees instead of the Philippines.
Our island 🇵🇭 also claiming by china they repelled our fishermans and supply boats.
In Indonesia india warship parking ready to monitor china puppys
India?? 😅
@@liammoye5238 China🤭
Dear Indonesian brothers, don't you know that China's national sport is encroachment. If China's border countries work together, that dragon's nuisance can be eliminated
Mengerikan jika salah satu yang GK mengalah sudah crot perang kita perang
Not China stop... Taiwan and Philippines 🇹🇼🇵🇭❤️💚✌️
Now they want your Island too ! It's included in their list !
China eagerly want to get all South China sea because there is no more fish in their waters, also south china sea in Philippines side (territory) is also rich in oil untouch they also want that oil
ASEAN must join together against china bullying in south china sea
Joko met Xi recently to discuss further joint-development projects and regional politics. He's unlikely to turn on China like Bongbong.
why philippines cant do that to china? poor philippines.. love from mindanao🇵🇭
🇮🇩: No Negotiation on Sovereignity !!!
Indonesia adalah mimpi buruk bagi para petualang dan negara yang tamak para penjajah pernah merasakan keganasan rakyat yang bergabung dengan tentara Indonesia saat era kolonial dahulu.berbekal senjata seadanya kami mampu membuat mereka tidur tidak nyenyak pendekatan kekuatan senjata dan kekuatan militer itu tidak membuat kami takut semoga mereka tidak memulai jika tidak ingin menjadi bangkai 😅😅😅
China Coast Guard, we repeat our order: Chow Mein, Chicken Feet & Fried Rice . . . over !
TF 😂
China cuma bisa mengintimidasi tapi tidak akan pernah melakukan penyerangan,,,kita indonesia lebih tegas, dan tidak pernah takut dengan negar manapun,,karna kita bangsa pejuang
Indonesia needs to have a rerun of 1998 and 1965 on the Chinese.
Dont worry your wish will be granted
@@ju5e3 Doubtful.
Jangan woiii.. beda masalahnya itu.
China owns 11 dash scs since 1947. Its Indonesia that cannot dispute north natuna eez which is not their territorial waters. Its only an entitlement within chinas territory that Indonesia needs to negotiate peacefully with china . It's best Indonesia respect international law not to treat their eez as territorial waters.
China coastguards and navies will be there to defend their SCS.
According to international law, it is Indonesian water. Do your research before you comment
@@TomTomdog international law does not state eez is your territorial waters.According to international law it's international waters .
While SCS 11 dash is China's territorial waters. That's why china coastguards ship is there to protect their fisherman fishing within their SCS.
Improve your knowledge before commenting here.
@LeeSkJohn-sv8wi international law permits 200mmiles as their territory. The china is claiming 50000 mmiles from their mainland. That's why people call China Animal. China should not be there in the first place. You need to do some research
Jika ad perang besar di negara plipina mlasia burunai singapur udh pasti indo ikut bantu brperang.klo jauh dri perang pling y bgtu aj.
We need to stop calling the South China Sea as it is. We need to call it Sunda Sea or Champa Sea
It's the competition between two economic superpowers.
One side is determined to disrupt China's trade with ASEAN (and other regions on the globe).
It's up to the Indonesian govt to decide if it wants to be the pawn.
Indonesia tdk akan pernah menjadi pion utk keduanya.... Indonesia justru akan memanfaatkan keduanya...
CNA pintar mancing komen orang Indo,,,mending kita komen biasa.... lihat diatas perlengkapan kita usang diungkap, bikin mancing negara lain aja yg teknologi kapalnya tinggi jadi dan memcoba nyuri ikan di natuna,,, hahahah
Kapal Maritim kita Terlalu Kecil,
Itu sebabnya harus ada perubahan ukuran Kapal Perang! 🔥
anggarannya harus diperbesar + kemauan dari para petinggi negara
Itu tahun 2016 videonya sekarang pangkalan indonesia udah ada di natuna dan kilang minyak indonesia udah di bangun, makanya sekarang udah jarang mendengar merka masuk di indonesia. Itu sama aja bikin mati dan gerah salah perhitungan mereka menempatkan indonesia jadi clem mereka😏 Itu perhitungan yg salah dan rugi besar bagi china bila indonesia di ganggu
TNI has deployed Apache attack helicopters in Nutuna, perhaps some servo of Hell fire missile should teach those encroaching CCP sampang some lessons.
Kt jaga laut kita jangn ada kta titik garis merah.kedaulatan harga mati
SEA countries should form something similar to NATO..
China and Indonesia bestie
Harusnya yg ngusir tentara laki2 sihh... Yg suaranya keras dan tegas.
Classist.
indonesia bosan dijajah sama asing, sekarang siapapun yg berani ambil satu inci tanah kami, majulah kami dengan senang hati melawan
Take a stand
if Chinese claim natuna...Indonesian people will get drone from.Russia and Iran also USA to sink Chinese Tanker ship ...when they passing thru.MALACA strait..!note that😂
As an Indonesian,I think Indonesia should approaching Russia as a close friend for a comfortable our North Natuna...🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩
This would be a dumb decision seeing that China is in good terms with Russia. We should be aligning closer to the US like PH did if we want to stand a chance against a full-on Chinese aggression.
@@lordtroublesome after PH closed US military base in Subic and Clark,they theoritic alone...
When some island in their teritorry occupied by PRC,they did nothing....
It will be different if US base still in PH 'till to day....
And at the recent years,Dyadya Vlad more powerful than Uncle Sam...
US inferior than PRC because of their debt with PRC...
Do you know how disgrace if we fight with anyone who borrowed us their money....
And remember,Russia is PRC's big brother....
PRC will always avoid confrontation with Russia....
Close with US will makes PRC more agressive to Indonesia....
The Last one thing...
US always intervention in internal/domestic issues....
US have backed up PRRI/PERMESTA with weapon to against Indonesia during 1950's...
And Russia haven't...
Russia is a failure in ukraine😂
@@familyguantero355 I knew...
They did it just to show NATO who is the Boss in Estern Europe...
But they haven't problem with Indonesia so far....
So don't be a Russophobia...
If Indonesia close to Russia,US can't dictate us...
And PRC uncomfortable to press US, because of their relationship with Russia...
We get the benefit isn't it???🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩
what do they really want to do in our seas, you bastards
We call North Natuna Sea, Not South C**** Sea
indonesia peace country and dispute area with china just in sea area zee not only china but US navy not respect about zee in indonesia water because they not follow unclos law but simple solution just using this dispute area for civil like catch fish
How i wish there will be one asean cost guard who will protect against bully china.
Doesn’t Malay always act high and mighty, let them have clash with China, As Indonesian I don’t care.
Anyone understand what the chinese coast card said ?
"US has postured as enforcing the 1982 United Nations Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) against violations. Ironically, the US has never ratified UNCLOS. 🤨🤨Amid the US’ posturing, China and ASEAN have pushed closer to establishing a joint code of conduct for the South China Sea, which will govern their interactions and disputes in line with UNCLOS once it enters force. A working group meeting last month saw the partner states commit to producing a working document 👉within three years.
it doesnt mean that china can violate it.
Slava indonesya.
Indonesia 🇮🇩 will take reaction if China try into our area...
we patroling small pieces of ovelapping area of your north Natuna seas and just have like that already!. it happen every 1-3 per week,, it become normal
@@xinzhong01 no problem
The Republic of Indonesia dares to die at sea in the air, The people are ready for war sent to the island
chinese people are fine but the government is horrible...
Why is the ned putting so much money in Indonesia? This for 2021 alone.
👉Ensuring Democracy Delivers For Indigenous People - $525,000
👉The Next Generation of Political Party Leaders: Catalysts for a Resilient Democracy
-$700,000. 👉Promoting Tolerance, Democracy, and Human Rights to Prevent Violent Extremism $600,000
Ga ada gigi.
Masih dipanggil sir.
Kalau US Ronald Reagan udah dikasih tembakan peringatan itu