Will PM Modi’s US Visit Be A Transforming Moment Or Is That Flattery And Hype? | Karan Thapar Live
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ก.ค. 2024
- Support The Interview with Karan Thapar - fij.mojo.page/support-the-int...
A live interview with Fareed Zakaria, the world renowned author, analyst and commentator, on Narendra Modi’s state visit to the USA. Is this really a “transforming moment”, as Defence Secretary Lloyd has claimed? How significant is the state banquet and second address to Congress? Will a deal to make jet engines in India herald a major shift in the defence relationship? Will Biden continue to overlook differences with India on Russian oil and the Ukraine war? Will pressure from the US media force the White House to publicly criticize India’s democratic backsliding and Hindu majoritarianism? And, finally, is the India-US relationship built on shared values or on economic and strategic convenience? If it’s the latter, what will happen when the US stops needing India? Tune in at 3.30 PM to hear Fareed Zakaria address these issues in a live interview. - บันเทิง
Karan’s questions (in the 2nd part) had some negativity and skepticism due to his own bias and views. Zakaria was throughly professional, answered intelligently with excellent balance and pragmatism! Zakaria is a class when it comes to geopolitics!!
Your comment about bias is completely one sided. Modi snubbed Karan during an interview on Gujarat and since then has never given the Wire any interviews. Karan also has by choice lived in India whereas Zakaria migrated to the US. It is your bias which is questionable
Karan is italian family, slave
@@agnescraig2912 Very true. Right on!
Karan PakIstani couldn't keep his anti Modi bigotry away.
@@agnescraig2912Even Rahul Gandhi stays in India. Means absolutely nothing.
Fareed Zakaria's knowledge in strategic matters, and his clarity of thinking are amazing. And the way he puts them across is excellent.
We have always been with you and we pray for God's blessing upon you with good health and security. ,🙏🙏🙏🙌🙌🙌👍👍👍🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Fareed is superb. What an honest man. Salute 🙏🙏
I request American medias to interview to PM Modi and question to him about Manipur about burning of houses 🏘 and churches 💒
How does he get away from press conferences both in India and outside India ?!!!
I WISH THE AMERICAN PEOPLE ASK DIRECTLY TO MODI, THAT WHY HE IS NOT DOING ANYTHING IN MANIPUR N WANTS T VISIT USA?
@@hyd916 because it’s part of prior agreement of his visit not to ask in exchange for teaming against the Chinese !
Not only what is happening in Manipur but overall hate speeches, burning and demolition of Muslims shows etc at many places.
@@omgomg6602 He won't do anything against China, it doesn't serve his business interests.
Hats off to both Karan and Fareed👏
Deep insight by Fareed Zakaria-he schooled Karan pretty well on strategic matters and even democracy.
Karan needs to understand that democracy of English speaking elitist Lutyens Delhi is far different from what democracy means to 80 % of our population who live in rural and small town india.
Exactly. But not expected from any musllm to speak positive about this government do especially when Thapar is doing interview. Might have caught unawares, perhaps.
@@subbaraotanguturu9271 you have a very poor mindset about Muslim. It is mostly because you have not talked to many Muslims. It is just your own internal perception.
@subbarao tanguturu
You mean to say that Karan Thapar is thus also Muslim
Well maybe you should look up Fareed Zakaria or for that matter his father's social, political background...
@@subbaraotanguturu9271 Disgusting..always bringing religion and hate into everything, however straightforward! Pls read on this eminent commentator…thankfully he doesn’t have a typical ‘Indian’ mindset!
Awesome interview 👌Fareed stood his ground and didn’t take the bait from Karan and provided a good insight into the geo-political currents driving IN & US. As Fareed rightly pointed out the immediate catalyst i.e., China is drawing both the countries together but the people to people bonding factor is going to be the bedrock of this key strategic relationship. What we now need is export of Cricket from IN and American football to IN 😀
Even though I’m not a big fan of Karanji and his interviewing style, for this one interview I’m going to support KT Live.
Future guests of KT Live can learn from Fareed, how to handle KT in an elegant and diplomatic way.
Might be an idea,
USA-India in American football, also in cricket.
The rest of the Anglosphere? India will need to get acquainted with ice hockey, rugby and football.
Everyone else will need to play hockey😊🙃😊
Also trade English with Hindi😅😂
Fareed was excellent...
Fareed’s answers were far more sophisticated vis-a-vis questions asked. He is a class apart.
Not knows what Arfa, the wire about i.e Hates Modi, the staunch Hindu.
@@subbaraotanguturu9271. She RIGHTLY does! Anybody with truth and a Value system will agree with her, a great journalist!
Thank you Mr. Thapar for interviewing Fareed Zakaria. Fareed is a well connected with American policy makers and a well respected journalist and an authority on Foreign affairs of United States of America.
😊😊😊😊q0q00q😊😊qqq😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊qq😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
True. And I believe, he is quiet objective in his assessment as well, irrespective of what his political positions are.
Excellent analytic conversation between two great minds on such important matters
As always fantastic show. I tried supporting via the link provided but seems like US based credit cards are not accepted. Any other option to support?
Fareed is very articulate and distinct about his views and opinions vis-a-vis India and US relationship 👍👍
I’ve started liking Fareed after he has just visited India and gone back. He has a more realistic and balanced view. We need more of this kind of journalism. All the communities in our country need to work together to make our progress faster as we have a hawk on our border virtually owning another country’ on the other side. I remember reading about cutting of Chinese melon in history book, we shouldn’t end up like that with more and more dictators against us, so we need America, even with caution
Who's throwing spanner in the works? Modi's govt absolutely silent on Manipur and Uttarakhand where minority community is being bounded out of towns where it's been for several decades! Fascist elements of sangh parivaar like VHP and Bajrang dal whipping up hatred. Both Modi and his MHA silent! Just like Manipur! Is it because BJP has an agenda there?
Your greatest enemy is within
@@alziracolaco641 yes you’re right about Manipur. That should have been handled better. About Utrakhand , I hope both communities heads are able to solve issues rather than emotional action. That’s never been appropriate
Farid says " with due respect India does not have that kind of a navy, to help the USA on Taiwan."
Earlier we used to have bilateral relationships but now the emerging reality is Strategic Relationships.
A discussion between a Hindu Indian and an Indian Muslim American citizen, where the latter , if any, is prepared to concede that Hindus are tolerant but the former is not. The former is clear that the Indian Government is anti-Muslim, neither democratic, nor liberal and is virtually pleading with the latter to concede that America may need India but India is unreliable and opportunistic.
Nowhere is either questioning
a) How truly democratic America is (there are many who consider it a plutocracy)
b) Racism in America
c) The lies about WMD, leading to the war in Iraq, the killing of lakhs of people...the unleashing of ISIS
d) Getting into bed with terrorist Pakistan..defending genocide of Hindus/Muslims in Bangladesh
e) Getting into bed with Pakistan to use Jihadi terrorists from across the world to fight the Soviet Union
f) Spending $2trillion over 20 years only to take away Afghanistan from the Taliban then shamefully return it, along with $80 billion worth of weaponry
g) Keep its eyes firmly shut to jihadi terror unleashed by Pakistan in India
h) The horrors it unleashed at Guantanamo Bay.
WHICH DEMOCRACY WAS DOING ALL THIS, WHILE MAINTAINING ITS RIGHT TO CALL OUT INDIAN DEMOCRACY FOR TEENY WEENY INFARCTIONS IN COMPARISON.
So, why is India getting into bed with America !
Thanks Karan for another wonderful interview.
Zakaria is not venomous but Thapar has been! Thapar must understand that Indians are very democratic but some people are over religious... Thapar must understand the danger of over religious people than the democratic majority.
Any doubt!? Don't we know what Arfa is about so also Varadarajan and co!? Jihadis supporters Hindu haters so Modi who wears his Hinduness on sleeves.
Many of my Indian friends there were saying, Moti left the country burning with Darnas everywhere and here he comes to promote Democracy, my best buds used the term Regime' for this government way back and she was labeled anti national. 😂 Moti do all your arounds before 2024, this time for you will never come again except in history books
Sponsored dharnas abetted by Soros, Congress. Andolanjeevies
Don't stalk me , mental woman, making your comments invisible, way back your I.d was Nick P' are you using the same I.d or you hVe changed to some other male I'd? Woman you need serious help, or a mental home awaits you. Or will you delete your comments like before after I caught you?
Are you suggesting a de-Modi-tisation of India?
Excellent analysis , great interview , thanks The Wire team. 🙏
Two of my most favorite people to listen. Tons of Respect to both of you!!!
This is what you call balanced journalism! Positive, optimistic and aspirational words from Fareed Zakaria
hahahahaha
@@rathranjankumar1
Joke of the century 😂😂😂😂, love from the UK 🇬🇧
He is simply scared and definitely it looks balanced. He may have something left in India and wants to avoid pangey.😂
@@razorr1920 😆
Here comes the experience of Zakaria as a journalist. I enjoyed the discussion .
Hope American press will press Modi to comment on the ethnic cleansing of Kuki in Manipur......Kuki owe you the American press a heartful humane idealism if you raise this inhuman harrasment of a minority christian tribal community...
No way. They want positive ties with India as Chinese pressure is mounting. Remember they removed travel ban on Modi when he became PM. It’s an internal problem with needs to be dealt with swiftly.
you mean minority militants with victim card?
The kukis are from myanmar and they ethnically cleansed hindu meities from there,i would urge the kukis to return to their original homeland which is mayanmar
Modi never gives press conference. May be some other officials will.
Modi is not going to face an journalist questions. He has put that condition
I can understand your pain. All the best folks. Keep going.
I don't know if such an amazing and important discussion be available to Indian in their local languages
@Dileep Koulyou seem to be ignorant of colonial history. It's the colonial rulers who lit the communal fires, instituted draconian laws like sedition and divided and ruled India. Exactly what Modi and BJP are doing. So, who's colonial?
The priority for Indians is Religion caste culture and the dreaded traditions of arranged marriages based on the above criteria. Changing the world and society is not in the Indian DNA
He is talking so much sense which i have never heard… zakaria sir is so brilliant.
Both journalists did a great job.
Difficult questions, more difficult to answer.
Fareed very good understanding of India many thanks very articulate
So articulate, yet with diplomacy .... Every inch the suave American journo👌
KT was totally disinclined to interrupt
When you have someone who is well read ,educated , experienced in journalism and well informed abt the dynamics of the world and shifting scenarios then everyone can gain and learn frm them.
So well informed he predicted the demise of PM Modi on Indian express. Such an insightful journalist 🤣
th-cam.com/video/z3UJ_2e_88o/w-d-xo.html
Lol, he's just mediocre.
lol 😂speaking English with accent doesn't make you a intellectual,
these are so called intellectual, of left wing, who massage their personal biases or hatred towards modi
@fareedzakaria's unique position to know political and economic situations in both the countries minutely shows in this interview.
Karan Thapar tried his best to put his perspectives and words into Mr Fareed. Not only that Mr Fareed very cleverly and intelligently dodged those attempts, he did counter those anti Modi , Anti India rhetoric with very pointed reasoning. Excellent interview. A lot to absorb from this conversation
Foreign Policy is about trade agreements. Wish the same was covered in more detail to measure how successful India's foreign policy has been in the last 25 years.
Excellent analysis of the situation.
Great enlightening interview
You had been my favourite right from the beginning for being BOLD INDIAN JOURNALIST. Thank you Sir Karan Thapar.
Karan ji, wishing that you take interview of Rahul Gandhi one day. My regards for your type of journalism. I salute your boldness. God bless you.
Shame on modi who preferred to go to the US instead of staying back and doing or saying something on the worsening condition in Manipur he just left the state to burn
How would one expect of a SHAMELESS person whose lies and stupid, parochial, and also some borrowed sermons have been able to befool so many Indians for so many years, We deserve to suffer for our own stupidity.
Did the US president stopped travelling when bkack lives matter took place
@@mohanrao6 And that is the Straw Man comment. If you want an actual event that matters, do remember that Biden had the Debt ceiling crisis and cancelled his trip to Australia. Modi went anyway to Australia in spite of cancellation of the event. Modi loves escaping and cannot handle any conflict or questions.
fools like you are born every minute
@@mohanrao6 Oh please. They don't remain silent in the US when mass tragedies occur. Stop lying to yourself. You know exactly what is going on.
two amazing journalists together! it felt so intelligent listening to you!
Fareed Sir, it was great to hear to you! Excellent and unbiased views!
Thapar has found a real and substantive platform with regards this Modi visit to the US. Other media are hyperventilating!
Modi is giving too much concessions to American so that they don’t question about India’s democracy and religious freedom.
For Thapar, to pose critical questions is always his style. He has brought out some important quotes from eminent personalities and journalists with their perspectives to the new India-US alliance, some of them seeing it as an alliance of convenience. On the other hand, Fareed has an excellent grasp on the new alliance being forged by the two great nations as he believes there cannot be a better moment to consolidate against a common adversary. Hats off to Fareed and I truly trust his insight on global matters.
His hatred for Modi is very
apparent God help India if his party wins
US - Great Britain - Europe collaboration has to do with people sharing a common ancestry. Surprised that it was grossly missed out by both.
Excellent Interview. Learned a lot
Fareed's analysis of the whole situation is spot on
Great to listen to Fareed Zakaria.
His opinions appear unbiased and balanced
Wow! This channel keeps getting better and better
Fareed Zakaria has politely snubbed Thapar on his anti Modi and BJP questions.
Excellent, Marvelous nothing less. A informative and thought-provoking video. Hats off to you.
What did he finally say!? Positively or negatively about Modi!?
@@subbaraotanguturu9271 who cares what US says/thinks about ‘Butcher of Ghodra’. US will flatter even Hitler if they earn via Trade, selling commercial Aircraft, military equipment, etc. listen carefully and live w your choices!
Two very knowledgeable and seasoned journalists engaged in this manner is very informative. Thank you both:)
Yeah very seasoned propagandists 🥱
Brilliant interview! Making Fareed Zakaria struggle for a credible answer occasionally is no mean achievement! Truly one of the few independent journalists in our country in the dog whistle and lapdog media age !
Till 2029 Modi then Yogi till 2049. Period. Just relax folks and watch history unfolding.
The Wire News is becomming the most credible news from India.
Only for a bunch of ricebags and Jihadis!
Yes credible for minorities😂😂😂
You mean most credible anti government propaganda channel 😅
@@CuriousDiaries anti hindu u mean..
@@neelamcreations7190Why not add anti national as well? I guess it's time for you to go back to Republic TV
Mind blowing conversation between two best and bold journalists of the world. Mr. Karan very skillfully asked and Mr. Fareed gave the very balanced answers with the inside scoop. Thank you both.
Love to see both together. I am long time viewer of Freed Zakaria GPS on CNN Sunday. Both are great journalist I hope Goddi media watch this interview and see them self in mirror and feel shamed if they have any shame.
Pigs will fly if Godi media....
Loved this talk!
Excellent and impartial analysis by Fareed Zakaria on the current India USA current relation and the future ! 👏🇮🇳🇺🇸
With China getting closer to Russia, India needs US to contain the aggressive attitude of China and to prevent the emerging bully in Asia..
China wants to be a global power and it would go a long way to achieve that...
US did not support Ukraine. NATO is also not supporting Ukraine wholeheartedly even refused to ad it Ukraine in NATO which was the irritating point on which the war began. Had NATO declared well in advance that Ukraine would not be in NATO, the war would have been avoided. Taiwan also would be in deep trouble if not a perfect balance and distance with US is not maintained. Advantage for US is that all wars are fought in other subcontinents
Two stalwarts putting the hype in perspective. Awesome discussion.
Time well spent. Good discussion.
Why does this man keep visiting US at public expense from time to time? One who cannot discharge the basic functions of running a nation goes around travelling the world and enjoying the luxuries at the expense of the people of India, including the majority of over 70% of India's population that didn't even elect him to the office. In fact, he is trying to optimize the travel opportunities at public expense before his tenure comes to an end. That's why instead of even visiting a State like Manipur to find a solution for the peace of the State he is blithely touring the world.
Spot on! The man is heartless and evil! The suffering of the people in India is of little consequence to him. That was seen in his total disregard of the migrant workers during the COVID lockdown and now in Manipur, without overlooking the Bilkis Banu saga and the wrestler women's tribulations.
He is a rogue type of shameless person . He has no sympathy for anybody or anything . He is leading a luxurious liffr at our cost .His face needs to be blackened .
@@thepeacefulwarrior2879peaceful community😂😂😂
What are you laughing at?
How about you hold the CM of Manipur accountable for once? If you want Modi to do everything then should we abolish state govts completely?
The clown and the scientist in the PM should remember that 56" is a limited space.
So when the US is inflating your ego-balloon, do not wander into the empty space !
You need to come back and address problems in the country and face elections ! 🙏
Excellent conversation ,enlightened various trivial issues
Loved listening to this quality talk. Par excellent
Thapar Sahib, I request you to interview Punjab Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann.👍
He will face Karan and give responsible reply unlike our great G
You never fail to amaze Karan!!! I hope you keep going forever.
Proud of Fareed Zakaria
Your programs are always professionally conducted. The information you provide is very useful and unbiased. Thanks.
Great two journalist on the show,the discussion and analysis made was superb and points to ponder upon..both have exhibited true journalism ,worth listening to these two great minds.
Two SUPERB Journalists 🍃 together what a treat!! Thank you, Karan Sir for asking all the tough questions & Fareed Sir for answering them so transparently. Love The WIRE.🍃
😮😮😮😮
Great interview, balanced answers..
Thanks!
On India being a democracy :.
From being ' Democratic' with a Capital ' D' we are now ' broadly democratic' ( "an euphemism at best) .
On Indo-US relationship :"
Ashley Tellis is spot on in his assessment : what India can deliver in return.
A more pertinent question :
Can India ever be a bulwark against China,; that is the kind of bulwark the US wants it to be?
Fareed sounds like a spokesperson for American military industrial complex.
So a cautious approach makes the conclusion inconclusive.Hope but no action.
Kuram felt disappointed with fareed's optimistic answers it seems!! 23:36
Rahul Gandhi will be the substitute of Mr.Modi in 2024.God bless him jai congress Vijay congress
No chance for pappu. Third time fail
Mohammad gajini 17 times he should fail
@@SrinivasRao-vd4kiPappu meaning 56 inch?
Are you day dreaming!?
@@SJ-tm6iq No Rahul Pappu who makes gold out of potatoes using a machine.
The relations between two countries are mostly based on convenience and not on values. There were people in past who pursued idealistic foreign policy. But in present times it is purely based on mutual interest.
Your observation may be true between China and US. India and the US share several common values, despite their cultural, historical, and political differences - Democracy, Freedom and Liberty, Diversity and Pluralism, Education is highly valued by both, Scientific Collaboration and many more
Nehru did it with China and it was disastrous for India
I think cultured drama based on hidden benefits for future India it's soft diplomatic move
"There were people in past who pursued idealistic foreign policy." - This is a myth. Foreign relations have never been based on values. Countries interests are always the primary driver.
The Wire & Thapar as usual, true to its character, remained only concerned about internal issues of Indian democracy & modi bashing rather than focusing on India-US strategic & what opportunities this visit holds!!
Zakaria, whereas had no illusions about what Modi's state visit to US is mainly about! India & US binding on China & getting entwined for future geopolitical crises! Its a relation of necessity & pragmatism, in which internal matters/politics in individual countries matter least.
Once in a while, a publication has to come out of its propaganda house & see things as they're...for Real!
Great Fareed and Karan both had their space on this dialogue
Excellent conversation and analysis between two great minds
Great interview really appreciate both of you🎉
Farid Fantastic - Karan, as usual.
Fantastic conversation ! Salam to Mr Arif! You are gem of a person.❤
Mr Arif???? I think you're confusing his name with that of his cousin, the actor Arif Zakaria. This is Fareed Zakaria...🙏
Will Indian Prime Minister face US press? I think no.
Not possible
Very true . Modi does not like a free press .
Great interview and Very neutral journalism from both worlds...Keep it up.
Well done Fareed, although you sound super American thinking. However, thought through.
Karan Bhai we understand your heart placement...
Good to know the significance
PM Manmohan singh was an economic intellectual and great Statesman with mission of every visit less showman , he use to carry press during all his foreign visit to get what was results.... Not just showman like approach.... US now needs a few 100s of Airbus orders and defence deal for getting more billions on flattery of one individual
Moun Mohan puppet of Italian bar attender Antonio Maino fake Gandhi w/o Rajiv Khan
One of the best interviews.. what a clarity in the answers!!
Thank you.
Again in current times we are moving from bilateral relationships to strategic partnerships.
Both did smartly as journalists.
The icons of todays world locally and internationally 🎉
Karan Sir interviews are tough as our Indian IAS interview questions answers...👍💪
Lol
Fareed hats off
Karan, this was a very good interview