Have Modi-Biden Transformed India-US Relations Or Is That Hype and Exaggeration? | Karan Thapar Live
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ส.ค. 2024
- Support The Interview with Karan Thapar - fij.mojo.page/...
A live interview with Ashley Tellis, Tata Chair for Strategic Affairs at the Carnegie Endowment, on Prime Minister Modi’s state visit to America and its outcome. Was this a transforming moment as Defence Secretary Lloyd Austin predicted? How significant are the technology and defence deals? Could they stumble in Congress? Or are we likely to see America increasingly replace Russia as the source of India’s high-end weaponary? Is the White House reconciled to India’s equivocation over Ukraine? Was President Obama’s comment to CNN a coincidence or deliberate? How has the US responded to the sharp criticism Obama has faced from Indian ministers and the vitriol Sabrina Siddiqui has faced from social media? Does the visit prove the two countries share values or has concern about China cemented their ties? And, finally, does this visit suggest Biden is betting on Modi’s re-election in 2024? - บันเทิง
I’m not a jingoistic person, but I want India to succeed & prosper in every sphere, just because it would irk Karen Thapar even more.
He tried hard to bring the guest on
his line but... Truth prevails...
Karan let me tell you right in the beginning that this man will not give the real picture of modi's visit and its outcome.
That is exactly the reason Karan has brought him on.
End of the day US - India relation are important, whether it is modi or rahul or any other PM
Be careful what you wish for... white man spreaks with forked tongue 🖕
No, a leader creates a lead... Changes with vision.,..
You may name any names but for God sake don't mention Rahul 🙏you can not compare horses and mulls 😂😂😂
@@tigerking2742 Absolutely, Rahul or ANYONE ELSE for that matter should not be compared w/ the gawar PM.
with due respect to modi ji, gujaratis are so enamoured by america that they will do anything to migrate their...as if that is there promised land...
I am 90 years old. I lived 5 miles away from Bhangi Colony where Gandhi used to hold his so called prayer meeting. And read all his books and kept fasts when Gandhi kept fast.
English were past masters at "Divide and Rule". And India was an Ideal venue.
They ruled with Iron hand, 1.4 of the world. NOTE: This interview is being done in "English". It was also the language spoken on the moon. England has more scholars of Sanskrit thsn India
Jinnah was a Hindu. He gave away Panjab
Nehru was a Hindu He gave Kashmir.
Bose was killed.
I am a Hindu. In 1964 kicked out of my own land, by complicit of Hindus.
Nobody supports me. EXCEPT MODI.
Most certainly not Karan Thapar.
dowries
You are brave person, hat's off Sir. These people living in ignoring Modi and but identifing
PM good work .
So how does Modi support you? He has no integrity or humanity but extends "Divide and Rule" to its extreme, carrying out the genocide of 1100+ Muslims, gang rape, and the rest. And it is ok with you?
Like they say- dog's tail buried for 1000 years, still remains crooked!
Do you have a college degree?
@@paradigmnnf I live in the USA. My wife of 65 years is Usha. I am a Structural Engineer. I have played an important role, and fulfilled each and every desure I had in life. Like CEO of tech companies I am that kind of a HINDU. My Books are VEDAS (Knowledge).
Prime Minister of Pakistan has had 6 wifes and is still looking. Also he is Bankrupt.
But Mr. Thakar is a different kind of Hindu. That is why I left India. More of his kind than mine. He is looking for Subscription. Like Jinnah.
@@prv476 I live in the USA. I am a structural engineer. I deign Bridges, Buildings and Tunnels.
I have done everything my heart desired.
The Prime Minister of Pakistan has had 6 wifes and is still looking.. Also he is Bankrupt.
Thank God for Modi. I would sooner him than Thaoer who is looking for subscription, because he has nothing to offer.
That is Hindu's for you.
I keft for that reason. Hindus are in USA what we call "Suckers"
excellent interview! although a little point: India needs to get into this semiconductor packaging especially when India has chip design industry. BdW, packaging doesn't mean putting into cardboard box, packaging includes wafer handling, assembling layers of the nanometer thin layers and other important steps.
Hats off to Ashley Tellis for the enlightening answers. He appears an epitome of knowledge in many fields including Semi-conductor industry, a very specialized area.
All superficial diplomacy, nothing more...
Tellis is such an eloquent orator. 🤝
Karan tried with Shivshankar Menon. Tried very hard to get him to say critical things about the visit.
When menon didn't play ball, Karan gets Tellis.
Hype & Exaggeration !!
With all respect to Ashley, this visit is on its own in terms of its significance and the deliverables it achieved. The jet engines were the last tech that we needed to be self reliant, a 10 year effort from 2012 came to fruition now. The high tech agreement, source code sharing and most important- minerals suppliers group agreement are milestones that will shape the entire global order in the years to come.
"Values" - the most hypocritical phrase used by western leadership especially the Americans. Amazing , coming from an elite for whom making regular and coordinated wars in all crucial strategic theaters of the globe was the mainstay of their decadal mission of dominance. That was their dharma or core value. We all understood and accepted that. We still do. If dominance continues to be the central goal of their existence , leader nations should welcome a newly minted India eager to challenge emerging new threats to global stability. . This is the best "value" the western world can expect from India - just the pill ordered by the doctor to keep the emerging scourge called China from devouring every one in sight. If theoretically India became a ' moral exemplar' in their eyes but a weak nation with a fissiparious polity created by the dubious dictates of so called democracy , of what use would such a nation be to America's strategic needs ? Would Tellis then have even remotely considered India an" American bet " ? These folks know that the inflection point in global history is around the corner. These are postures of grandeur increasingly irrelevant in tomorrow's brave new world order. The India of western , patronising judgement is passe. It is a balancing force in its own interests. So valuable to all. Full stop.
Perfectly said and wish the other part of the globe read it in the practical way than to become a fake orator.....
India buying Oil from Russia has stabilized the oil market. If India did not buy oil from Russia, oil would be selling at $200 a barrel. India in addition, exports refined oil to the western countries. So it is helping the west in many ways. Other than rhetoric, I think west likes the India position.
Thapar would like to leave the question of India manufacturing semiconductors to "economists" like Raghuram Rajan!! This when we have Ashwini Vaishnaw & Rajeev Chandrasekhar steering the boat. Really Mr.Thapar!
Insightful 🙏
The gist of the visit by PM to USA, beyond the noise, very nicely captured in this interview.
Great interview , thanks The Wire team. 🙏
90% of indians think that if USA does not stop meddling in our affairs and does not stop lecturing than we wud be better off without their friendship
And who are these 90%? The Hindu Fascist, the RSS Mafia? Do you care for a total hypocrite, fascist and illiterate PM?
And the 90% of indians is you ?😁
You are genius!! @@vivekyadav1
Mr Thapar - no questions to Mr Tellis about the discrimination (treatment of minorities) faced by Indian-American students in college admissions? US Supreme Court has recently ruled that discrimination illegal which means that discrimination was happening. Does this concern about protecting minorities flows only one way? Your viewers can make their own judgment based on the questions you asked, or did not ask.
There is very little in common as far shared values between two countries are concerned. A caste system ingrained in majority Hindu India, cow being a highly revered religious symbol, Hinduism considered as a polytheistic religion VS an America whose large population follows monolithic religion, are one of the largest consumers of beef and is a great proponent of human equality with no tolerance for a caste creed division at state and societal level. So the newfound love and the basis of relationship is only of shared interest of containing the global expansion of China.
Good interview thanks
No country will help when our country really needs . This is applicable all Countries As per the previous History.What is unfortunate is it appears that goals especially votes to win the elections are more important than security of our Country and
killing even our Military personnel . Even after long time of our Indipendence we are only learning how to efficiently divide ourselves instead of struggling to unite strongly.
Depends on the vision and capacity of leadership..
Do the leaders care for anything except kursi? Godhra to pulwama, all the way killings for personal gain. The country will not prosper in this way. How many hindu businessmen have quit this hindu rashtra, does anyone talk about it? We will benefit other nations, not ourselves.
For MQ-9B drones, 20% Indian components should not be problem as one version of Engine used in drones is already license produced in India , also sensor fusion should not be an issue as many high end sensors are already been produced in India
your country is so polarised that it can be divided into two halves...and u are lecturing india...
Excellent Interview.
Very important messages delivered by Mr Tellis to the Indian Govt and Indians as a whole .
Liberal values, mature responses are all called for . Pretty sure America is very business minded but then it will want to do business with India and will go quite a distance to woo India. India needs to be liberal understanding smart and agile to engage with America and get the best for both great countries.
Karan.sar..very.good
Journalists are more politicised then politicians
Thank you Mr Tellis.
Truth must come out
microchips/semicondertors are essential comodity of 21st century as it is used everywhere. Any country's economy can be crippled and brought to grinding halt by controlling microchips supply, as shown during Covid supply chain disruptions. So made in India chips chips are strategically essential to India's security and not aimed at providing jobs. I hoped this point was highlighted in the discussion.
16:15 so that’s why he is pissed 😂😂, he doesn’t want the middle man cut to be gone , cus if India succeeds in getting some weapons components made in India then , the chances of the production line being moved there altogether will be much higher for future orders 😂😂
As an Indian I could not care less how it went down in America. I am confident in myself.
Ashley Trellis: The most significant visit was of MMS, ... No Modi visit is significant.. Karan Thapar: AHH .. HAH ! Music to my ears that is why I called for 3rd interview on the same topic. Farid Zakaria did not give me a chance to bash Modi.
Micron is not producing wafer (Semiconductor) : AHH .. HAH ! More music to my ears.. Completely ignoring the fact that ISMC and Vendanta are setting up semiconductor plants. Also, the most important role of semiconductor manufacturing is national security. In the future, any nation that does not have it's own semiconductor products ( Manufacturing or IP) would be a colony of the one that does that.
Mr Tellis is a diplomat par excellence! He is very well informed and an articulate speaker. His strategic outlook is well known. KT is at his obnoxious best!
I admire the questions from Karan Sir. If people in power has this level of intellect and if healthy debates happen in parliament, India can be a true global leader.
But unfortunately most of the leaders doesn't like questioning and have "do what i say" mindset.
Wish the parliamentarians to come upto that lavel...
Untill u r in india this country will remain 3rd world 😢
So now the muslim have no faith in islam and quran. They are interested in economy of kuffar
Abdul gang belivers of aurangzeb
If we have men and women like Karen sir, where would India be!🤗🤗🤗
Karan trying his best to derail the relationship..well done Karan..
Correct
You are really smart...
US bombing is part of US foreign policy, it is very different from Indian domestic situation where elected officials make irresponsible racial comments.
Black, native killing
No! Jin Ping-Siddharth Varadarajan's relations will transform the fate of your Channel!!!
questions are bold but answers are evasive. What I understand U.S. is very particular that it gets market for its product and Modi opened it with a huge cost for India.
all politics are local
Modi ke visit se liar ki jali hai 😂😂
Do you expect this level of journalism from godi channels.....definitely not. Now stfu
Sirf AVM hatbao Or Desh bachao.
Ashley is just another diplomat kind of person with not much depth in human terms. The fact is that India's goal is a Religion that survives on the hatred against Muslims. Such a communal and tribal country will not survive for long.
Technology, etc. are secondary.
Very truly said!
Why is your show anti Modi ? Should you not focus on economic growth to counter China?? These conversations are not very fruitful unless you can back it up by GDP - shared values is a meaningless concept!! What values do USA and China have in common!!
Indians are also entitled to opinions and USA should not be upset.
India and US are close parters not because of Modi but despite Modi and his hinduvta politics.
his politics aren't jihadi that's why the world are proud of him
@@angelbaybi997it's because of china.....otherwise they don't give a f**k
It definitely strengthen u may doubt but not India people
Very cunningly set up interview with the objective of puncturing the positive outcomes of Modi’s state visit to the US
When has Russia ever 'advertised' it's weapons the way Western arms mfrs like Boeing or Raytheon do?? Just love the way pundits in the beltway lie with a straight face when talking about the _quality_ of Russian weaponry but fail to mention that 'sophisticated' American weaponry hasn't won a war since 1945 that too, with the blood & sweat of over 20 million Russians! Nowhere has the US faced a near peer adversary while the Russians with minimal effort and making use of mostly Soviet era stockpiles have barely scratched the surface of their modern stockpile are beating NATO in Ukraine! They lead the world in Hypersonics, nuclear ballistics and various other forms of electronic counter warfare which the might of the US, UK, France, Germany, Japan and over 200 satellites have have failed to defeat and the Russians have still not mobilized fully!
Karan thapar is an Indian by looks but a Pakistani in his heart. bastard never gets tired while deriding India every time he comes out public.
it’s also the platform he works with Wire it’s run by communists
Thapar ji 🏵️🙏
Toolkit
Could you please share with your audience the source of the funding of the the channel Wire?
After all the POMPOUS Self Introduction ,
The BEGGING STARTS ! 😂😂
Didn't get you....
A rare interview in which two Indians speak from an American perspective. One is, of course, an American citizen, entitled, even required to speak from an American perspective, but still being rational, which is a prime requirement of his trade. But it is Thapar's case which is truly remarkable. Such is his hatred of Modi & the Govt. that it never occurs to him to ask even once, how untainted American democracy is, which arrogates to itself the right to judge whether India has "approved values"
Priminister Narendra Modi has indeed achieved a watershed in US India partnership. Nevertheless, continued presence of Russia in defense which may be take much longer time to taper off has the potential to cast long shadows
Value ? where ? does it exist ?
I wonder why Modi is keeping quiet at this time about Manipur incident. Its not safe for minority Christians & Muslims. Its all about BJP propaganda
My Name is Hakim Salehi from Afghanistan i studied my bachelor in BBA at Bangalore University since the government of Afghanistan collapsed by Taliban India give us scholarship now i graduated MBA from Mysore university so I’m looking again for the help of India to give us scholarship at phd level because still Afghanistan is under the control of taliban and So many students who are India cannot go back to Afghanistan and this year India decided to not give us scholarship please cover this issue to reach our voices to the authorities and we get the help
Modi pulled all our knicker but Biden pulled his knickers
chotaa bhai ka pyjama...thikh se pehenn..katti l00llli baahar dikh raha hai...lol
Believe what you like to believe.
Yeah Modi is the first PM that addressed the congress twice and got standing ovation ten to fifteen times and here is the headline of karan gay thapar
Yeah, and he blatantly lied in his carefully pre-prepared address. Modi without lies is like a man without clothes.
@@budsurtees4224 yes everyone has nothing to do except lying. worldbank lies, elon musk lies, biden lies. the only people who speak truth are the italian bar dancer and the men who pay her
yeh buddha aag lagane mein koi kasar nahi chorta...congressi
Likely that US strategy folks have evaluated scenarios when Modi wins big again in 2024 and the likely acceleration of illiberalism in India. But that’s theirs job. I wonder if people in India have considered the first year of 3 term of Mr Modi in power. May be Mr. Thapar you’d oblige with meaningful discussion on the topic. Thank you.
This sort of free speech should be banned..Glad that The wire is just a you tuber now..Karan being their poster boy influencer
I was patiently listening when ashley said Obama spoke his mind and there is nothing wrong. I kind of agree with him on that because I feel that is a fair thought. But when the Indian ministers spoke their minds Ashley suddently became disturbed. Why can't the indian ministers speak their mind. I can't understand the left media and their guests. Their logic will take different turns many times during a single interview.
First to understand that Russia helped India in 1965 ... and during 1971 US supported Pakistan but Russia stood by India... such licks of uncle Sam's... a stunning blow ... when the US and Australia kept the dragon at bay only to praise ... the mule in such global times of unpredictable politics... ! and the joker's crystal burning in few corners ... ain't much of hopes and dreams in a fragile world...
✌️🌎🤨🌿🌻🌿
Karan Thapar seems constipated when Tellis says the visit was a huge success.😂
Rajan has been quite silly on a number of things lately. So I would disregard anything he says. For india semiconductors are very strategic. India would be subject to blackmail in certain circumstances if it can’t get into semiconductors.
It is good only for gujarath
mr., we had enough of democracy...time has come to be just like islamic countries...declare itself a "hindu rashtra of bharat" on the lines of islamic republic and have special priviledges for the majority ...with curtailed rights for the minorities...time will come...jai shree ram
Ashley's analysis of Indo-US relationship is bingo.
What would have been if the 25k crore drone deal was signed
It is not signed..proposed by us..now the deal will go
US is concern about the Liberalism in India n we Indians r concern about racism in US ! 🤩
We Indians should focus on our pathetic condition and depleting liberal values
@@agnosticatheist4093 We don't believe in liberal values
*The line of questioning in this interview was phenomenal! Just the right balance of depth and intrigue*
what is that depth?
*Congress ke Banner me Likha Hai*: Desh Ke Vikas Ki Buniyad Nitimata
Except Thapar, no one in India wants Semiconductor factories to provide employment. No nation of India's size can afford NOT TO HAVE. semiconductor manufacturing facilities. And technologists, who ought to know a thing or two are spearheading & periodically modifying policies & processes to ensure that we succeed. Like anyone playing catch-up, it requires vision, focus, realism, self-belief and a large dollop of cash. [Incidentally and without bile, we owe our backwardness in almost every field to Congress wallowing in socialism & even the sabotage of Indian efforts in becoming self-reliant in areas ranging from cryogenic engines to semiconductors]
that man was chewing gum when he attended our republic day celebrations...so much for the culture they follow
Like father - Like Son
Modi kai saath jo interview hua tha. Maja aa gaya. Modi ko sahi mai paani pila diya. Bechara tab se na koi press conference, na he bade logo mai uthna baithna
It is wire you don't need to discuss Modi.
Every one know what you say ? So chill have good weed😂
Oh just hype only ..it doesn't mean that when Modi delivered prepared speach in Joint Congress transformed US-India relation.
Karan trying his best to discredit Modi’s US visit. Look at his ancestry and see why he’s doing it.
Watching this episode alone, very closely, will reveal the hatred Thapar has for the country.
He brings people who criticize India on Democracy ultimately a political agenda driven . The guest trying to be over smart just by getting a American citizen.
Karan Thapar:
Question: India centre government going for ucc , if there is huge protest by Muslim(Expected from them) Sikh(included for number only), Adiwasi (again include for number), then USA can lecture India so congress and there ecosystem can misguide Hindus(Which congress ecosystem main target) to steal some vote.
Answer: It is your internet matter we don't have anything to in this.
😂😂😂
Akhand bejati 😂😂😂.
Listen thapar we know countries work for there interest, not for looking good in others eyes.
They get selected by people to work for them, not to push narrative.
And Do you think USA having such control over social media doesn't know what going in india.
They know congress is finished project, so they will join the winning team, for future dirty work they will through some dollers to you to keep rulling party in check, example: jarge Sarosh
But as servent you should agree with them.
Such a negative thoughts and questions from this anchor towards india
who are you (USA ) to talk about values...your country will be the last in the Q ,if someone wants to imbibe values😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Independent you are not!
sorry mr. , barack hussain obama is not held in high esteem in india...he may be regarded highly in ur country...not ours
Concur for that matter here in the US he is also not regarded well. It is just an illusion by left to portray him as highly regarded
A brave enemy is better than a deceitful friend..Looking over legacy that makes history is important. Friendship made at 😢 the cost of reliable bosom by ❤ will give out results in time to come
Katwe, tera to wise bhi chila hua hai.
Karan is disappointed. 😅
who is raghuram rajan...a congress lackey
Wire is biased and negative to Modi government always. Stopped listening it.
Do you expect this kind of interview from godi media....?
Well done wire to discredit bjp😂😂😂😂
KT has done so much reasearch to ensure Modis visit is seen as a flop and the bots just love him
Everything is a hyperbole for Mr. Thapar. Pls learn to also ask a few optimistic, positive questions rather than just being negative, doubtful all the time. Even the guest is more optimistic than Karan and brings more positive energy.
It appears that The Sickulars e Hind not happy with Jai Jaikaar of Hindutva Maharaja in the US and the world ! What can we say ! Tough shit.
Karan and his dishonesty ...but 'leave that aside'
Who care about joe biden he can even walk properly