if Yazeed didn’t order the killings of Prophets family than he did not punish his army for killing the family.. May Allahs Cruse be upon all those who harmed the prophets family and the ones who defend the killers / enablers of prophets family
@@mdshagor7762 Ali didn’t want to inflame an already tense situation. But, in this example, there is no distance between Yazeed and MBS (killing Khasahogi)
Yazid brought the head of Hussain- Master of the youth of paradise- in his dinking room and he and his party drank themselves silly till dawn; how can he deny not knowing about the death of Al Hussain! May he be damned forever.
@@mdshagor7762 because, there were many people who committed the deed, and Banu amuyah and other people you praise were complicit in it. Furthermore uthman played favoritism which angered many of the Muslims back then
At 26:35 I cried. Zazak Allah, Shaykh for presenting a balanced analysis. However, if anyone ever supported, sympathised or empathised with Yazid, then that individual is ill-informed and can be confused or even be deluded. The Ahlul Bayt, the most beloved to the Prophet (SAW) can never be insulted or criticised.
If the brutal killing of Imam Husain (a.s) is a historical event only then what about the selection of the caliphate took place in Saqifa Saeda took place. So if any sect of Islam do not believe in the caliphate of Abu Bakr based on a historical event not a theological event then why that group amongst ummah are always been tortured and killed by both Banu Umaiyyed and Banu Abbas rulers?
@@rory6860 we as AHLUS SUNNAH can guarantee where we will be with our love of AHLUL BAYT (A.S.). Can those that are sympathizers of naasibi yazeed, guarantee where they will be? There's no justification for harming AHLUL BAYT, by doing so you are taking up arms against ALLAH and our RASUL (s.a.w). The naasibi poked the blessed head of Al-HUSSAIN (that which our beloved NABI kissed and loved), Al-Hasan and Al-Husayn, sons of the Prophet's daughter Fātimah are the cream of the youths of Paradise. In other words, they are the chiefs of the youths of Paradise, except the prophets and the rightly guided caliphs. In Paradise, people will be of the same age; the youth age. There's noway a naasibi khaariji can be with the kings and Supreme queen of jannah!
The way this lecture was structured was incredible! Masha- Allah. How fortunate are we, in the 21st century to be able to learn like this. May Allah bless Sheikh Yasir so we may continue to benefit from him. Aameen.
No comment..my son's nsme and my grandsons name is Muhammad Yazeed ..both , of them are gentle , humble young people ..i leave sheik Yasir's opinion , and all cholars , for and againt's yazeed's to Allah s.w.a ..Ameen....
In the beginning it is said after Karbala massacre caravan in chain went to Yazid and granddaughter of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) gave the whole khutbah/speech in front of Yazeed and son of Imam Hussain (pbuh) gave the khutbah too. Please read those khutbahs. Not Theologian incident rather political. Well said Sir. My duty as a Muslim is to show the light of truth to my brothers and sisters without taking side of Shia or Sunni perspective. Here I believe it’s a theologian. Yazid has mentioned in his court today I have taken revenge for my forefathers. 1) Imam Hussain is the one who is the master of heaven and yet it is political. 2) That Imam Hussain to whom Prophet(pbuh) did not got off the Sajdah until Imam got out from Prophet’s back(pbuh). This act portrays the importance of imam Hussain. 3) that imam Hussain to whom prophet said he is part of me and I am part of him. A part of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) a master of Heaven was killed in humanely.yet it is historical event and not Islamic event 4) That Hussain (pbuh) upon his birth a prophecy came hadith narrated by Ummahatul moimineen Umm e Salama and more. This Hadith states that Angel Jibraeel came and told the death of Imam Hussain (pbuh) to prophet (pbuh) and the Prophet (pbuh) cried upon hearing this. Yet it’s historical? 5) every muslim in every prayer have to send salaam to prophet and his progeny (example Durood e ibrahimi) yet it is historical and not Islamic. May Allah guide everyone and Allah knows the best. I tried to shower light so that every Muslim as it duty should ponder upon and know the truth.
If our religion is divine and history is human, why does Quran refer to so many historical events that have Divine influence to them? All the historical events of prophets, Suleman, Yunus, Noah, Moses and the list goes on. All of these discuss Divine involvement. How can you separate religion and history, I’m confused. That’s like saying the people of Lot acting the way they did in an indecent manner is “history is human” but religion is something totally different and has nothing to do with that.
@@zakisadiq8963 well questioned! History is to be learned from and that is why Allah is always pointing to the historical situations. He wants us to learn how to be or not to be and also to remember that He watches everyone and everything; His power is sublime and His wrath not worth asking for. Human beings however do not learn from history; and actually end up worshiping historical figures rather than the One True Lord. Had Muslims learned from the history of Bani Israel then we wouldn’t be in the kind of world that we are in.
Today in India when the killers and xapists of Muslims are released form prison and garlanded by politicians for the sake of votes, we blame the ruling party for the crimes of those killers and xapists. We blame them 100%. It would be disingenuous for us to give any less blame to yazid after he failed to punish the culprits and even left the main politician with his titles, power and pelf.
The commander in chief must take responsibility for everything occur in the battle field, whether he did command or not everything happened in the battle
"Our religion is divine and our history is human". Excellent. Excellent. This statement puts the Fitna that happened in the first century of Hijra in its right perspective.
Do you think we live to the standards. We do ritual and call other muslims and non muslims Kafir. Is being muslim means beard & head coverings OR Is to follow Prophet 's Charters
I like the way you wiggle you way around this brutal character. The things he did and allowed to happened is beyond belief. Sadly, there are many such characters in Islam today Muslims should be educated about them.
@@e.k874 this is not defending there is something called being objective. Hassan and husayn are the youth of paradise but this doesn’t mean Hussain didn’t make an error by trying to rebel against a caliph that was unanimously accepted by bayah. Allah is the best judge
@@killerpie5981 unanimously accepted by bayah? no one gave him Bayah i was ither forced or reluctant.. plus Hussain rA never gave bayah to yazeed lannat on him if u dont care for Hussran rA than care about the city of Madinah and Makkah look at what that man and his army did in the battle of Harrah .. he starts his reign by decapitating Hussians rA and ends it with murdering raping looting the people of Madina
Wasn’t it the demand of beyat from Yazid which started the event of Karbala? Wasn’t Ibn e Ziad acting on the behest of yazid? Did umar Ibn saad bin abi WAQAS act on his own in the battle of Karbala? Mr Yasir can you refute these facts?
JAZAKU mul Allaho khairran. As Again and again. May Allah SWT reward you for doing this fantastic job. Because you are trying your best to clrify this controversial subject to the masses, which is imperative to be known. May Allah SWT bestow upon you blessing and good life. you are the assets for this modern age UMMAH. Jazak Allah khair. 🇵🇰✔👍🏾✔👍✔😍 Ameen summa Ameen. eat clearify this controversial subject
قُلْ لَا أَسْأَلُكُمْ عَلَيْهِ أَجْرًا إِلَّا الْمَوَدَّةَ فِي الْقُرْبَىٰ Qul: lā as’alukum ‘alayhi ajran illal-mawaddata fil-qurbā Say: I do not ask of you any reward for it but love for my near relatives (Sūratush Shūrā, No.42, Āyat 23)
Most balanced..not for balancing but based on facts.. historical analysis.. sound and sane reasoning..a mentally sound and hereafter fearing should adopt
May Allah swt keep Shaik Yasir Qadhi healthy and happy for ever! He is one of the greatest and fewest scholars who’s knowledge is unbelievable! I love you Shaik for the sake of Allah!
I, my wife and our 4 daughters saw it with our eyes 😭 we felt with our body and our hands the sea water and the sea wave of the uncomfortable beach around us became smooth and gentle when I spoke to the them, the beach and the sea: Allaahumma shalli 'ala Muhammad wa Aali Muhammad Allaahumma inna nas'aluka bihaqqi Muhammad wa Aali Muhammad then I just cried 😭😭 I'm crying now 😭😭😭 the sea water, the sea wave, the beach and the sea respects, praises and surrender to Rasulullaah and His Family 😭😭 I'm truly sure the whole universe loves Rasulullaah and His Family 😭😭😭 AsSalaam 'alaika Ya Aba Abdillaah AsSalaam 'alaika Yabna Rasulullaah 😭😭😭 Allaahumma shalli 'ala Muhammad wa 'ala Aali Muhammad 😭😭😭😭
@@iimaanabdulle467 Imam Hassan AS was not present in karbala. He was martyred before the events of karbala. Also, you have uttered a falsehood. We do mention Imam Hassan AS martrydom and in great detail.
@@mohammad-alhussainawi2004 The saddest deaths were Hamza Ibn Abu mutalib Umar ibn al khattab Uthman ibn affan Ali Ibn abi thalib and Hussain ibn Ali. May Allah be pleased with all of them.
@@AbuBakr-Siddiq to you, that is what beleive since your school of thought praises umar and uthmaan. I and many other people on the other hand have different and more accurate beleifs and thus are not saddened by the deaths of umar and uthmaan. Your mother aisha was not sad for uthmaans death at all. Infact she said "kill this nathal". It's in your sources.
Jaza'killah Khayr sheikh we needed to hear this from scholars of Ahle sunnah. Hiding the faults of Yazeed ibne Mawaiyyah did give false accusations against most of sehaba in shia believe. ❤
I applaud this attempt to show some diversity of perspectives about this crucial issue often ignored. It is quite surprising to me that Muslims would believe that groups who put their utmost effort to stop and destroy the emergence of the Divine growth of Islam during the holy Prophet alayhi salaam's life would suddenly stop after he left this world. Imam Hussein represents the light, breath, honor, truth and continuation of Islam and it's greatness. Hussain is a glowing figure of Islam's glory. Anything that comes close into the realm of killing off Truth/beauty/glory/honor/ ISLAM should be utterly condemned, cursed, rejected, separated from, bara'aaa.... there should be no doubt. AlHadulillah, THANK Allah for Hussain, a savoir of Islam
Forget exonerating Yazid, Muawiyya gets the blame too after his unilateral move of taking Sham from Ali bin abu Twalib Khilafa, this was the pivotal point of Division in the Umma. Lest we forget the battle of Siffin was the first major Fitna in this Umma. Muawiyya later handpicked his son to the throne despite his lack of knowledge & practice of Deen & thus setting the precedence of Father Son Dynasty or Tyranny in Muslim world hitherto. Sheikh Qadhi what's your take on this.
Jamal was the first major fitna war and Siffin came up next! Saqifah which is often portrayed as an election rather than a punch-up by three vs the Ansar is also one of the fitnas. We need to read history for what it is and not just rely upon our emotional beliefs. We all have to die one day and meet Allah one day. We cannot say I heard so and so say this and so I followed their version! Allah says in Surah Yaseen that they will call upon those that they associated with me and they will not be answered.
@@mrmiskeen8284 muawiya la3nat Allah ale, may God punish him, and not give him peace or mercy, may he burn in hell, and may his followers follow him into hell.
May Allah continue bless you Dr Qadhi. Very informative lecture as always. There is alot of beneficial hostorical lecturrs on sahabas and Umayyads. How I love the sheikh to do lectures for Abassids and other dynasties chronologically till the end.
I think this brother did a decent job and had courage to open up the character of Yazeed (May Allah’s curse be upon him) in front of our sunni brothers. May the Truth prevail . You can fabricate around truth but you cannot mess with the truth.
Family always comes first, he is trying to be logically but forgets family is first. The true understanding of the Quran can only be by the prophet and his family.
What Yazid did to Madina in Alharrah was even bigger crime than the killing of Alhusain. The Umaiads, save Omar b. Abdulaziz, were a curse on Muslims. Great lecture!
There is not a single verse in the Qur’an that says Pharaoh actually killed Israelites children in his own hands and yet Allah held accountable Pharaoh for that crime. "ان فرعون وهامان وجنودهما كانو خاطئين" “Surely Pharaoh, Haman, and their solders were sinful” If Yazid didn’t punish the wrong doers, I rest my case.
Actually imamHussain left madina and left hajj because in both instances yazid had given a command to kill imam Hussain (a) of imam Hussain (a) did not pledge allegiance. So shaykh it’s is incorrect to say that yazid (la) left the door open or was ambiguous
Unfortunately we give free pass to Companion of Prophet inspite them doing greatest crimes. Eg Walid bin Kalid who killed a Tribal Chief and raped his beautiful wife (after the death of our beloved prophet). He was forcing people to pay zakat to first khaliph (so was loved by ignorant masses) Same situation is being used today saying when you become Muslim all your sins are forgiven. That means a non-Muslim (eg Hindu) rapes & kill 100s of women ( including Muslim women) in India & Pakistan their Sins are forgiven once they recite Shahada in Arabic in Front Dr. Zakir Naik . As Muslim from minority branch we believe only sin committed to Allah is forgiven not against his creation. Otherwise we have unjust GOD. This is political Islam and not spiritual Islam.
@@alimohamed9698 malik bin nuwaiyrah had joined up with the false prophet musaylamah. He had divorced his wife, and he also said words of Kufr which made Khalid kill him.
@@farjana7202 I just wanted to say that Imam Hussein AS did not go to Kufa only because he was invited. Kufa was one of the many stops he intended to make. If his final destination was Kufa, he wouldn't have went to Makkah after leaving Medina but would have gone straight to Kufa. He went to Makkah to assess the situation and see the state of the muslims there. He had already seen that people in Medina had been subjugated and no one was willing to stand up for the truth. He saw the same in Makkah, also there was danger to his life in Makkah as well since Yazids forces were coming to attack him. He was planning on launching a campaign where he would go to multiple towns and cities and gather up support peacefully. Eventually it would reach a point of physical retaliation but it never reached that point. He did not draw out his sword until the tyrants against him took out their swords at karbala.
It’s time for Sunnis to take back the narrative of love of the prophets family and to denounce Yazid and bani Umayyah, you do not need to be a genius to see a common thread, abu sufyan fought against the prophet *ﷺ* his son(muawaiyyah) fought against Ali RA, and his grandson (yazid) fought against Al Hussein RA.
If Husain had given allegiance and not risen against a "Muslim Khalifa" Yazid (do you realize what he would have changed in young religion), neither the Ahl-e-Sunnah nor the Shia would have had the Islam they are following currently. Historical, yes? Theological, yes !
Jazakallahu khairan for clearing this clouded subject... and may Allah bless your view to become the mainstream view to reunite the ummah into one ummah!
Yazids mother was a great Arab Bedouin poet named Maysun bint Bahdal. I recently read her poetry and was blown away by the depth and beauty of her poems. Wow! Mashallah. Just goes to show that everyone is different and will be judged according to their own actions. She was a great women and her son turned out to be a Tyrant.
This is what happens when we play politic. The leadership was built based on election between the Muslims. And he was put there by his father to change the way of life. Unfortunate😢
If y are aware of Hadith where rasulullah ASWS was asked from his companion : when begin education of a kid ( or kids) ! Rasulullah replied 20 ~ 25 years before his birth ! This hints parents should be educated first . A question you should ask to yourself to have more clarity is who ordered or has finger in killing of beloved companion and Khalifa uthman ibn affan ! This crime was intentionally to blame Ali ra ... We saw brutal fight between companions . So there were munafiks Incorporated inside companions . I will mention what abu bakr and what umar said about Sufyan father of Muawiya, they said that they don't have fully trust in his repentance. We have seen what happen to uthman then Ali and how yazid destroyed khilafat. Mission completed. However we r Muslim and we don't need worldly gains alhamdulilah.
It is not just a “historic” event. It’s about our prophets family martyred by an evil person who cannot be considered Muslim. He was 100% responsible and he will burn in hell forever IA
A very sad point of history. It shows humans sometimes can lose their touch of humanity. I believe we should learn history and turn the page and focus on our very own lives and can we do to bring a change in humanity
Masha Allah, very well explained the sensitive topic and explicitly responded to the controversial and historical character of Yazid Paleet. leaving NO grey area saying bluntly black is BLACK and white is WHITE. Truly demonstrates A Courageous personality. Jazakallahu Khair
I was about to comment a long comment then I read the newest comments and realized Alhamdulilah the people aren’t blind no more and aren’t fooled anymore either, the books speak for themselves, the records speak as well. Nobody’s love comes above or ever near the love we shall have for our beloved Prophet Mohammad صلى الله عليه وسلم and his Ahlulbait. Because those are the people he SAW loved and we love whom he loves. End of discussion. Funny thing is that now non shia people are waking up and standing up for the love of Ahlulbait, and we need to stick together for the love, honor and respect of those for whom Prophet SAW used to get out of his seat and for whom He used to not pick his head up from sujood because Hasnain AS had climbed up his back. SubhanAllah. May Allah increase the love of Prophet SAW and his beloved family in our hearts because he did warn us about them in Jami` at-Tirmidhi 3788
Ya shaykh, I have a question. Makkah and Madina were declared haram by Allah and his prophet. In fact Makkah was considered a haram even during jahiliyah. You said in your lecture that he made these sanctuaries halal by waging war and genocide there. Does this then not make him a kafir?
Cursing Yazid ibn Muawiya does not contradict morality. The act of cursing those who killed the Family of Muhammad, peace be upon them, is a means of getting closer to Allah, the Glorious and Exalted. And with sincere faith, we all curse the oppressors and hypocrites
Mashallah my thoughts too, how can they carry out killing of not only a Muslim but the grandson of our beloved Nabi. How could they do that if they had Iman?.
From what I heard Some of them had something against Hazrat Ali they didn’t like him yazid was a tyrannical and narcissistic who wanted power so he’d go to any limit
@@a_x_ii4318 I think it's more about once Yazid was given power by his father, nobody respected him so Yazid started doing all this because he had the power to do so.
when Ali bin al-Husayn Zayn al-Aabideen (rahimahullaah) saw the people of Kufah wailing and crying, he rebuked them, saying: You wail and cry for us, so who are the ones who killed us? [Maqtal Husayn of Murtadaa Iyaad (p. 83), Tadhlim al-Zahraa of al-Qazweenee (p. 257) and al-Malhoof of Ibn Taawoos (p. 86), Nafs al-Mahmoom of Abbaas al-Qummee (p. 357)]
Ali bin Hussain (Zainul Abedeen) said: "O'people Love us to respect Islam, for your excessive love for us has reached a stage which has become disgrace to us(Ahle Bayt) Source: Tahzib al Kamal & Bihar al Anwar
reporting this narration, ‘Abbas al Qummi writes that those angels also: ولعنت می کند اجتناب کنندہ ازاں را Invoke the curse of Allah upon the one who abstains from Mut’ah until the Day of Qiyamah.
Narrated Abu Huraira: Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "Allah has ninety-nine names, i.e. one-hundred minus one, and whoever knows them will go to Paradise." (Please see Hadith No. 419 Vol. 8) Sahih Al-Bukhari 2736 Narrated Abu Huraira: Allah has ninety-nine Names, i.e., one hundred minus one, and whoever believes in their meanings and acts accordingly, will enter Paradise; and Allah is witr (one) and loves 'the witr' (i.e., odd numbers). (Hadith No. 419 Vol. 8, Sahih Al-Bukhari 6410)
Karram Allahu wajho (May Allah sanctify his blessed face). I dont care if you shia or sunni or whatever ahle bayt is ahle bayt and due respect must be given.
if Yazeed didn’t order the killings of Prophets family than he did not punish his army for killing the family.. May Allahs Cruse be upon all those who harmed the prophets family and the ones who defend the killers / enablers of prophets family
Why Ali radiallahu didn't funish killer off utman radiallahu?
Buy the I hate yazid
But we don't curse anyone
@@mdshagor7762 on state of rebellion hazrat ali could not punish usman killers although he tried his level best .
@@mdshagor7762 Ali didn’t want to inflame an already tense situation. But, in this example, there is no distance between Yazeed and MBS (killing Khasahogi)
Yazid brought the head of Hussain- Master of the youth of paradise- in his dinking room and he and his party drank themselves silly till dawn; how can he deny not knowing about the death of Al Hussain! May he be damned forever.
@@mdshagor7762 because, there were many people who committed the deed, and Banu amuyah and other people you praise were complicit in it. Furthermore uthman played favoritism which angered many of the Muslims back then
At 26:35 I cried. Zazak Allah, Shaykh for presenting a balanced analysis. However, if anyone ever supported, sympathised or empathised with Yazid, then that individual is ill-informed and can be confused or even be deluded. The Ahlul Bayt, the most beloved to the Prophet (SAW) can never be insulted or criticised.
“Our Religion is Devine and our History is Human” No words for these words of Wisdom ,Truth Facts in One Simple Sentence.God Bless you. Keep Continue.
If the brutal killing of Imam Husain (a.s) is a historical event only then what about the selection of the caliphate took place in Saqifa Saeda took place. So if any sect of Islam do not believe in the caliphate of Abu Bakr based on a historical event not a theological event then why that group amongst ummah are always been tortured and killed by both Banu Umaiyyed and Banu Abbas rulers?
Say that to Allah on the day of judgement and expect the prophet's intercession. The lengths and breadths people go to defend these two
I would never give my kids such a name as Yazeed. History speaks for itself. Not just a tragedy, but a crime.
He itself not just far from religious, his lifestyle itself even more worst than world leader today
@@rory6860he was not a muslim he drank alcohol openly in his courts
@@rory6860what would you expect if someone kills the Prophet's Son
@@rory6860I pity you and your understanding of faith.
@@rory6860 we as AHLUS SUNNAH can guarantee where we will be with our love of AHLUL BAYT (A.S.). Can those that are sympathizers of naasibi yazeed, guarantee where they will be? There's no justification for harming AHLUL BAYT, by doing so you are taking up arms against ALLAH and our RASUL (s.a.w). The naasibi poked the blessed head of Al-HUSSAIN (that which our beloved NABI kissed and loved),
Al-Hasan and Al-Husayn, sons of the Prophet's daughter Fātimah are the cream of the youths of Paradise. In other words, they are the chiefs of the youths of Paradise, except the prophets and the rightly guided caliphs. In Paradise, people will be of the same age; the youth age.
There's noway a naasibi khaariji can be with the kings and Supreme queen of jannah!
The way this lecture was structured was incredible! Masha- Allah. How fortunate are we, in the 21st century to be able to learn like this. May Allah bless Sheikh Yasir so we may continue to benefit from him. Aameen.
😢 May God bless Mohammed 's soul . I'm sure he would have liked your lecture .He was my husband .He died over a year ago
No comment..my son's nsme and my grandsons name is Muhammad Yazeed ..both , of them are gentle , humble young people ..i leave sheik Yasir's opinion , and all cholars , for and againt's yazeed's to Allah s.w.a ..Ameen....
Allah humma laan qatalatka,
Allah humma laan zalamatka
Allah humma laan samayat be zalika faraziyat beh. Ameen
*Our religion is divine and our history is human . This is a huge statement deserves to be written a books*
he is son of yazid
@@nobleM137 Yazid was a good man
What about the Battle of Siifin and the Battle of Camel which were fought between companions?
In the beginning it is said after Karbala massacre caravan in chain went to Yazid and granddaughter of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) gave the whole khutbah/speech in front of Yazeed and son of Imam Hussain (pbuh) gave the khutbah too. Please read those khutbahs.
Not Theologian incident rather political. Well said Sir. My duty as a Muslim is to show the light of truth to my brothers and sisters without taking side of Shia or Sunni perspective. Here I believe it’s a theologian. Yazid has mentioned in his court today I have taken revenge for my forefathers.
1) Imam Hussain is the one who is the master of heaven and yet it is political.
2) That Imam Hussain to whom Prophet(pbuh) did not got off the Sajdah until Imam got out from Prophet’s back(pbuh). This act portrays the importance of imam Hussain.
3) that imam Hussain to whom prophet said he is part of me and I am part of him. A part of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) a master of Heaven was killed in humanely.yet it is historical event and not Islamic event
4) That Hussain (pbuh) upon his birth a prophecy came hadith narrated by Ummahatul moimineen Umm e Salama and more. This Hadith states that Angel Jibraeel came and told the death of Imam Hussain (pbuh) to prophet (pbuh) and the Prophet (pbuh) cried upon hearing this. Yet it’s historical?
5) every muslim in every prayer have to send salaam to prophet and his progeny (example Durood e ibrahimi) yet it is historical and not Islamic. May Allah guide everyone and Allah knows the best. I tried to shower light so that every Muslim as it duty should ponder upon and know the truth.
“Our religion is Devine and our history is human”
Ma Sha Allah very well put
👍
Our ummah some are good, some are not 😥
Brother it is written Divine not Devine. Devine is a word that may be read as Devillish.
If our religion is divine and history is human, why does Quran refer to so many historical events that have Divine influence to them? All the historical events of prophets, Suleman, Yunus, Noah, Moses and the list goes on. All of these discuss Divine involvement. How can you separate religion and history, I’m confused. That’s like saying the people of Lot acting the way they did in an indecent manner is “history is human” but religion is something totally different and has nothing to do with that.
@@zakisadiq8963 well questioned! History is to be learned from and that is why Allah is always pointing to the historical situations. He wants us to learn how to be or not to be and also to remember that He watches everyone and everything; His power is sublime and His wrath not worth asking for.
Human beings however do not learn from history; and actually end up worshiping historical figures rather than the One True Lord. Had Muslims learned from the history of Bani Israel then we wouldn’t be in the kind of world that we are in.
Today in India when the killers and xapists of Muslims are released form prison and garlanded by politicians for the sake of votes, we blame the ruling party for the crimes of those killers and xapists. We blame them 100%. It would be disingenuous for us to give any less blame to yazid after he failed to punish the culprits and even left the main politician with his titles, power and pelf.
I enjoy his lectures more than any other us scholar because he has such detailed knowledge
Agreed.
Yah mashallah his break down is great
The commander in chief must take responsibility for everything occur in the battle field, whether he did command or not everything happened in the battle
This shaykh talks about all the topics that no one else talks about. JazakAllahu khyr. May Allah reward you and bless you for discussing the topics
"Our religion is divine and our history is human". Excellent. Excellent. This statement puts the Fitna that happened in the first century of Hijra in its right perspective.
Do you think we live to the standards.
We do ritual and call other muslims and non muslims Kafir.
Is being muslim means beard & head coverings OR Is to follow Prophet 's Charters
Mashallah sheikh dr qadhi so knowledgable and well read and always a great storyteller and super eloquent, مشاء الله
I like the way you wiggle you way around this brutal character. The things he did and allowed to happened is beyond belief. Sadly, there are many such characters in Islam today Muslims should be educated about them.
I always learn alot from Dr. Qadhi, every lecture i watch i find new info on islam that helps me
I didnt mean that in a good way!!😂😂 i mean it helps me not believe
Same here Masha Allah Alhamdulillah
I have learnt a lot of things and learning now about islamic history, thanks to this genius
Mashallah very well explained! :)
اللَّهُمَّ إِنَّا نَسْأَلُكَ ، بِمَا سَأَلَكَ نَبِيُّكَ مُحَمَّدٌ ، عَبْدُكَ ، وَرَسُولُكَ ، وَنَسْتَعِيذُكَ ، بِمَا اسْتَعَاذَ بِهِ ، نَبِيُّكَ مُحَمَّدٌ ، عَبْدُكَ ، وَرَسُولُكَ ، أَنْتَ الْمُسْتَعَانُ ، وَعَلَيْكَ الْبَلَاغُ ، وَلَا حَوْلَ وَلَا قُوَّةَ إِلَّا بِاللَّهِ 🤲
excellent lecture, may we never have another person like yazid in our ummah
You have a biased non sensical hate
@@killerpie5981 may Allah raise the supporters of Husaain rA with Hussain rA and defenders of yazeed with yazeed
@@e.k874 this is not defending there is something called being objective. Hassan and husayn are the youth of paradise but this doesn’t mean Hussain didn’t make an error by trying to rebel against a caliph that was unanimously accepted by bayah. Allah is the best judge
@@killerpie5981 bro's really saying Yazid was in the right and Hussain RA made an error💀
@@killerpie5981 unanimously accepted by bayah? no one gave him Bayah i was ither forced or reluctant.. plus Hussain rA never gave bayah to yazeed lannat on him if u dont care for Hussran rA than care about the city of Madinah and Makkah look at what that man and his army did in the battle of Harrah .. he starts his reign by decapitating Hussians rA and ends it with murdering raping looting the people of Madina
Wasn’t it the demand of beyat from Yazid which started the event of Karbala? Wasn’t Ibn e Ziad acting on the behest of yazid? Did umar Ibn saad bin abi WAQAS act on his own in the battle of Karbala? Mr Yasir can you refute these facts?
Ma sha Allah. Excellent analysis
May Allah Bless you shykh
Deep knowledge is what this man has !! May Allah continue blessing him and his family 🙏
Very interesting
Tabarak Alrahman.May Allah bless and protect Dr.
Waiting with bated breath. I am sure Sheikh Saheb will throw some light on some of his behaviour which we do not know. Insha Allah!!
JAZAKU mul Allaho khairran. As
Again and again. May Allah SWT reward you for doing this fantastic job. Because you are trying your best to clrify this controversial subject to the masses, which is imperative to be known. May Allah SWT bestow upon you blessing and good life. you are the assets for this modern age UMMAH.
Jazak Allah khair.
🇵🇰✔👍🏾✔👍✔😍
Ameen summa Ameen.
eat clearify this controversial subject
قُلْ لَا أَسْأَلُكُمْ عَلَيْهِ أَجْرًا إِلَّا الْمَوَدَّةَ فِي الْقُرْبَىٰ
Qul: lā as’alukum ‘alayhi ajran illal-mawaddata fil-qurbā
Say: I do not ask of you any reward for it but love for my near relatives
(Sūratush Shūrā, No.42, Āyat 23)
u mistakenly used an ayah that had nothing to do with the ahlul bayt
May Allah protect you and bless you . Ameen
Jazak-Allah Khair!
May Allah forgive us all and grant us all Jannatul-Firdaus. Ameen
This is going to be interesting....cant wait 😊
Inn Shaa Allah
Brilliant!!! What a top lecture
Jazak Allah Khair
I respect and deeply value our shia brs n srs.Thank u 4 exposing the truth dear br qadhi.May A bless u!
Hazrat Ali (pbuh) said Verily TRUTH is not known through men, Know the TRUTH (first) and you will know it’s people.
Most balanced..not for balancing but based on facts.. historical analysis.. sound and sane reasoning..a mentally sound and hereafter fearing should adopt
Baraka Allah fikum. May Allah protect you always. Truth will always stand out clear from falsehood
May Allah swt keep Shaik Yasir Qadhi healthy and happy for ever! He is one of the greatest and fewest scholars who’s knowledge is unbelievable! I love you Shaik for the sake of Allah!
I, my wife and our 4 daughters saw it with our eyes 😭
we felt with our body and our hands the sea water and the sea wave of the uncomfortable beach around us became smooth and gentle when I spoke to the them, the beach and the sea:
Allaahumma shalli 'ala Muhammad wa Aali Muhammad
Allaahumma inna nas'aluka bihaqqi Muhammad wa Aali Muhammad
then I just cried 😭😭
I'm crying now 😭😭😭
the sea water, the sea wave, the beach and the sea respects, praises and surrender to Rasulullaah and His Family 😭😭
I'm truly sure the whole universe loves Rasulullaah and His Family 😭😭😭
AsSalaam 'alaika Ya Aba Abdillaah AsSalaam 'alaika Yabna Rasulullaah 😭😭😭
Allaahumma shalli 'ala Muhammad wa 'ala Aali Muhammad 😭😭😭😭
Ahhh come on
What about imam Hasan Ra he was shaheed too peace and blessing be upon them all
Shia only mention imam Husain Ra
@@iimaanabdulle467 Imam Hassan AS was not present in karbala. He was martyred before the events of karbala.
Also, you have uttered a falsehood. We do mention Imam Hassan AS martrydom and in great detail.
@@mohammad-alhussainawi2004 The saddest deaths were Hamza Ibn Abu mutalib Umar ibn al khattab Uthman ibn affan Ali Ibn abi thalib and Hussain ibn Ali. May Allah be pleased with all of them.
@@AbuBakr-Siddiq to you, that is what beleive since your school of thought praises umar and uthmaan. I and many other people on the other hand have different and more accurate beleifs and thus are not saddened by the deaths of umar and uthmaan.
Your mother aisha was not sad for uthmaans death at all. Infact she said "kill this nathal". It's in your sources.
Very informative and impartial
Jaza'killah Khayr sheikh we needed to hear this from scholars of Ahle sunnah. Hiding the faults of Yazeed ibne Mawaiyyah did give false accusations against most of sehaba in shia believe. ❤
I applaud this attempt to show some diversity of perspectives about this crucial issue often ignored. It is quite surprising to me that Muslims would believe that groups who put their utmost effort to stop and destroy the emergence of the Divine growth of Islam during the holy Prophet alayhi salaam's life would suddenly stop after he left this world. Imam Hussein represents the light, breath, honor, truth and continuation of Islam and it's greatness. Hussain is a glowing figure of Islam's glory. Anything that comes close into the realm of killing off Truth/beauty/glory/honor/ ISLAM should be utterly condemned, cursed, rejected, separated from, bara'aaa.... there should be no doubt. AlHadulillah, THANK Allah for Hussain, a savoir of Islam
Beautifully said my brother- very true
I think you are part of the extreme groups he was talking about
@@socdaaliyodamaashad6669And I think you are from Bani Ummaya.
❤️❤️❤️ from Bangladesh ❤️🇧🇩
This was very well delivered by Sheikh. Presented history and opinions accurately and stuck with Imam Ibn Hanbal's opinion.
What about the Battle of Siifin and the Battle of Camel which were fought between companions?
JAZAKALLAH KHAIR
Great lecture MA. I'm glad you bring these topics up and explain honestly. I am on the side of sending la'nah but I respect your search for the truth.
أَلا لَعْنَةُ اللَّهِ عَلَى الظَّالِمِينَ (هود،18)
وفقكم الله لما يحبه ويرضاه و جعلكم من الضاحكين المستبشرين في جنانه
Thank you dr. You always try to be impartial
Forget exonerating Yazid, Muawiyya gets the blame too after his unilateral move of taking Sham from Ali bin abu Twalib Khilafa, this was the pivotal point of Division in the Umma. Lest we forget the battle of Siffin was the first major Fitna in this Umma.
Muawiyya later handpicked his son to the throne despite his lack of knowledge & practice of Deen & thus setting the precedence of Father Son Dynasty or Tyranny in Muslim world hitherto.
Sheikh Qadhi what's your take on this.
Fast fetna become when disbelievers kiled utman radiallahu
Muawiyyah Ibn Abi Sufyan rediyallahu ahn ❤️❤️❤️
@Rahma, Rightly made point,
Jamal was the first major fitna war and Siffin came up next! Saqifah which is often portrayed as an election rather than a punch-up by three vs the Ansar is also one of the fitnas. We need to read history for what it is and not just rely upon our emotional beliefs. We all have to die one day and meet Allah one day. We cannot say I heard so and so say this and so I followed their version! Allah says in Surah Yaseen that they will call upon those that they associated with me and they will not be answered.
@@mrmiskeen8284 muawiya la3nat Allah ale, may God punish him, and not give him peace or mercy, may he burn in hell, and may his followers follow him into hell.
May Allah continue bless you Dr
Qadhi. Very informative lecture as always. There is alot of beneficial hostorical lecturrs on sahabas and Umayyads. How I love the sheikh to do lectures for Abassids and other dynasties chronologically till the end.
I think this brother did a decent job and had courage to open up the character of Yazeed (May Allah’s curse be upon him) in front of our sunni brothers. May the Truth prevail . You can fabricate around truth but you cannot mess with the truth.
Family always comes first, he is trying to be logically but forgets family is first. The true understanding of the Quran can only be by the prophet and his family.
Allah has blessed us with you Sheikh Yasir qadhi ... You explain beautiful
What Yazid did to Madina in Alharrah was even bigger crime than the killing of Alhusain. The Umaiads, save Omar b. Abdulaziz, were a curse on Muslims. Great lecture!
Wholesome and nuansed analysis.Thanks shaikh.
I certainly luv your analysis respect sir ❤🙏
Very Excellent lecture. Extremely informative and lucid. MashaAllah Tabarakallah
There is not a single verse in the Qur’an that says Pharaoh actually killed Israelites children in his own hands and yet Allah held accountable Pharaoh for that crime.
"ان فرعون وهامان وجنودهما كانو خاطئين"
“Surely Pharaoh, Haman, and their solders were sinful”
If Yazid didn’t punish the wrong doers, I rest my case.
I am sunni but the rot didn't start with yazeed but from Muawiya who started a tradition of cursing on Ali A.S and then paved the way for Yazeed.
mashAllah. Our religion is divine, our history is human. Great words. May Allah reward you for all the great work.
Actually imamHussain left madina and left hajj because in both instances yazid had given a command to kill imam Hussain (a) of imam Hussain (a) did not pledge allegiance. So shaykh it’s is incorrect to say that yazid (la) left the door open or was ambiguous
Agreed, and also Imam hussain didnt go to fight, he has been invited, a leader dont go to fight with all family members and without any soldiers.
Unfortunately we give free pass to Companion of Prophet inspite them doing greatest crimes. Eg Walid bin Kalid who killed a Tribal Chief and raped his beautiful
wife (after the death of our beloved prophet).
He was forcing people to pay zakat to first khaliph (so was loved by ignorant masses)
Same situation is being used today saying when you become Muslim all your sins are forgiven.
That means a non-Muslim (eg Hindu) rapes & kill 100s of women ( including Muslim women) in India & Pakistan their Sins are forgiven once they recite Shahada in Arabic in Front Dr. Zakir Naik .
As Muslim from minority branch we believe only sin committed to Allah is forgiven not against his creation.
Otherwise we have unjust GOD.
This is political Islam and not spiritual Islam.
These are all made up rafidi lies
@@alimohamed9698 malik bin nuwaiyrah had joined up with the false prophet musaylamah. He had divorced his wife, and he also said words of Kufr which made Khalid kill him.
@@farjana7202 I just wanted to say that Imam Hussein AS did not go to Kufa only because he was invited. Kufa was one of the many stops he intended to make. If his final destination was Kufa, he wouldn't have went to Makkah after leaving Medina but would have gone straight to Kufa. He went to Makkah to assess the situation and see the state of the muslims there. He had already seen that people in Medina had been subjugated and no one was willing to stand up for the truth. He saw the same in Makkah, also there was danger to his life in Makkah as well since Yazids forces were coming to attack him. He was planning on launching a campaign where he would go to multiple towns and cities and gather up support peacefully. Eventually it would reach a point of physical retaliation but it never reached that point. He did not draw out his sword until the tyrants against him took out their swords at karbala.
It’s time for Sunnis to take back the narrative of love of the prophets family and to denounce Yazid and bani Umayyah, you do not need to be a genius to see a common thread, abu sufyan fought against the prophet *ﷺ* his son(muawaiyyah) fought against Ali RA, and his grandson (yazid) fought against Al Hussein RA.
Mashallah jazakallah sheikh for shedding the light on this matter
mashahallah..very well said sheikh,,may Allah protect nd bless you immensely…
Mashallah Sheikh! You speak the truth for both Sunni and Shia.....Amazing hope we agree and unite as one Ummah.
If Husain had given allegiance and not risen against a "Muslim Khalifa" Yazid (do you realize what he would have changed in young religion), neither the Ahl-e-Sunnah nor the Shia would have had the Islam they are following currently. Historical, yes? Theological, yes !
Very very good point.
"Our religion is Devine and history is human" nice
Jazakallahu khairan for clearing this clouded subject... and may Allah bless your view to become the mainstream view to reunite the ummah into one ummah!
Yazids mother was a great Arab Bedouin poet named Maysun bint Bahdal. I recently read her poetry and was blown away by the depth and beauty of her poems. Wow! Mashallah. Just goes to show that everyone is different and will be judged according to their own actions. She was a great women and her son turned out to be a Tyrant.
This is what happens when we play politic. The leadership was built based on election between the Muslims. And he was put there by his father to change the way of life. Unfortunate😢
His mother was litterly a cannibal
If y are aware of Hadith where rasulullah ASWS was asked from his companion : when begin education of a kid ( or kids) !
Rasulullah replied 20 ~ 25 years before his birth !
This hints parents should be educated first .
A question you should ask to yourself to have more clarity is who ordered or has finger in killing of beloved companion and Khalifa uthman ibn affan !
This crime was intentionally to blame Ali ra ... We saw brutal fight between companions . So there were munafiks Incorporated inside companions .
I will mention what abu bakr and what umar said about Sufyan father of Muawiya, they said that they don't have fully trust in his repentance. We have seen what happen to uthman then Ali and how yazid destroyed khilafat.
Mission completed.
However we r Muslim and we don't need worldly gains alhamdulilah.
In what languagw you rear it poemsa
@@AM-kt6tb
May Allah bless y and thank y for info.
Well said
So so true sir
It is not just a “historic” event. It’s about our prophets family martyred by an evil person who cannot be considered Muslim. He was 100% responsible and he will burn in hell forever IA
Wa alaykumassalam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh
salaykum Salam akh
MashaAllah! It's a very good information that we knew. May Almighty Allah SWT bless you.
Thank you for speaking the true facts
A very sad point of history. It shows humans sometimes can lose their touch of humanity. I believe we should learn history and turn the page and focus on our very own lives and can we do to bring a change in humanity
so forget the prophets family
Not at all.
Masha Allah, very well explained the sensitive topic and explicitly responded to the controversial and historical character of Yazid Paleet.
leaving NO grey area saying bluntly black is BLACK and white is WHITE. Truly demonstrates A Courageous personality. Jazakallahu Khair
I was about to comment a long comment then I read the newest comments and realized Alhamdulilah the people aren’t blind no more and aren’t fooled anymore either, the books speak for themselves, the records speak as well.
Nobody’s love comes above or ever near the love we shall have for our beloved Prophet Mohammad صلى الله عليه وسلم and his Ahlulbait. Because those are the people he SAW loved and we love whom he loves. End of discussion.
Funny thing is that now non shia people are waking up and standing up for the love of Ahlulbait, and we need to stick together for the love, honor and respect of those for whom Prophet SAW used to get out of his seat and for whom He used to not pick his head up from sujood because Hasnain AS had climbed up his back. SubhanAllah.
May Allah increase the love of Prophet SAW and his beloved family in our hearts because he did warn us about them in Jami` at-Tirmidhi 3788
Masallah
Ya shaykh, I have a question. Makkah and Madina were declared haram by Allah and his prophet. In fact Makkah was considered a haram even during jahiliyah. You said in your lecture that he made these sanctuaries halal by waging war and genocide there. Does this then not make him a kafir?
The reason you gave is true , that is the Reason why Imam Hanbal gave fatwa of Yazeed been kafir.
Cursed son and father
Summary:
Shia hate yazid
Sunnis dislike yazid
Salafis like yazid
Source: Zakir Naik
Made up
It’s true salafis love yazid
@@khalidqawdhan3265 who care?
Only an ignored Muslim could like Yazid!
Jazaak Allahu Khairan Kasira.
Cursing Yazid ibn Muawiya does not contradict morality. The act of cursing those who killed the Family of Muhammad, peace be upon them, is a means of getting closer to Allah, the Glorious and Exalted. And with sincere faith, we all curse the oppressors and hypocrites
Only a crystal can rival Sheikh Qadhi in the matter of clarity --- and the spectrum of his opinions so rainbowesque. What a blessing.
Mashallah my thoughts too, how can they carry out killing of not only a Muslim but the grandson of our beloved Nabi. How could they do that if they had Iman?.
It's difficult to imagine but we can't equate sins regardless how major to Kuffr.
From what I heard Some of them had something against Hazrat Ali they didn’t like him yazid was a tyrannical and narcissistic who wanted power so he’d go to any limit
So touching so hurtful my heart is bleed after hearing this story .
@@a_x_ii4318 I think it's more about once Yazid was given power by his father, nobody respected him so Yazid started doing all this because he had the power to do so.
Good closure brother
Ma Shaa ALLAH for the beautifully explicit nd well balanced lecture from the Respected Sheikh.
LA'ANA ALLLAHU
ala yazeed!
Not controversial , this is what truly happened
when Ali bin al-Husayn Zayn al-Aabideen (rahimahullaah) saw the people of Kufah wailing and crying, he rebuked them, saying:
You wail and cry for us, so who are the ones who killed us?
[Maqtal Husayn of Murtadaa Iyaad (p. 83), Tadhlim al-Zahraa of al-Qazweenee (p. 257) and al-Malhoof of Ibn Taawoos (p. 86), Nafs al-Mahmoom of Abbaas al-Qummee (p. 357)]
Ali bin Hussain (Zainul Abedeen) said: "O'people Love us to respect Islam, for your excessive love for us has reached a stage which has become disgrace to us(Ahle Bayt)
Source: Tahzib al Kamal & Bihar al Anwar
reporting this narration, ‘Abbas al Qummi writes that those angels also:
ولعنت می کند اجتناب کنندہ ازاں را
Invoke the curse of Allah upon the one who abstains from Mut’ah until the Day of Qiyamah.
Narrated Abu Huraira:
Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "Allah has ninety-nine names, i.e. one-hundred minus one, and whoever knows them will go to Paradise." (Please see Hadith No. 419 Vol. 8)
Sahih Al-Bukhari 2736
Narrated Abu Huraira:
Allah has ninety-nine Names, i.e., one hundred minus one, and whoever believes in their meanings and acts accordingly, will enter Paradise; and Allah is witr (one) and loves 'the witr' (i.e., odd numbers).
(Hadith No. 419 Vol. 8, Sahih Al-Bukhari 6410)
Plz let us know when these stories were written,
After 50 year or hundred years
Karram Allahu wajho (May Allah sanctify his blessed face). I dont care if you shia or sunni or whatever ahle bayt is ahle bayt and due respect must be given.
Who's Ahl beit ? Muawia 🤔🤔🤔
@Me, Myself and I
What about Hussein ? Who said what, about Hussein ?
If he poked the face of hussein radiyallaahu anhu,I will start cursing him now.
Very disturbing story but that part is poking the face of our beloved Prophet pbuh grand son causes me to cry
May Allah bless you for saying the truth
Walaikum Salam
I hate even his name but I will listen. Maybe I will learn more about him