i once wanted to become a muslim. i asked my muslim friends to help me, which they all did. after so many of my questions answered, i was confident enough to attend a local mosque for friday prayer. a few days before i asked the many who helped me my last question: _"when i attend the mosque, i may be asked what i am, a sunni or shia, what do i answer?"_ this question ignited all who helped me to argue with such hatred that shocked me to the point where i lost faith in islam. i didnt know there was divison, to the point where i veered for some time until i returned to announce which side i was to choose. i chose neither sunni or shia, i am a muslim.
Yes if you stick to the Quran and Sunnah you will be on the right path... This Sunni and Shia is like a political disagreement... The Shias (some) curse and sware at the khalifas and insult Aisha. Allah proved her innocence but they still disrespect the prophets wife Aisha. This is very wrong.
@@N.Y.63 I would say it is slighlty more than a political difference but not by much. Honeslty the main difference in practicing shia and sunni beliefs is just about how you actually pray. All the other differences are mainly concerned with beliefs and not as much about practices of both sides.
Shaytan took advantage of the circumstances.. I recognize that people have different opinions but as long as they say I am Muslim; love them for the sake of Allah.. hatred has home with Shaytan only…
Be careful making sects the prophet peace be upon him told us there will be 73 sects only following the quran and our noble prophet pbuh will lead u paradise what was our prophet pbuh he was neither a Shia or sunni but a MUSLIM
I am a Shia from Pakistan and I am noding up and down whole lecture, very true and unbiased talk about both sects, Jazkallah khair. If half of scholars think and talk like you Muslim can become one ummah.
You clearly know nothing if you think that was unbiased. He actually blatantly misleading on some historical facts which are recorded in Sunni source's
@@hassanabbasbirmani you are Shia you really don't know 🙄. Others have said in the comments read them. I am not going through the video again. One example is he claims Shia believe all Sahaba conspired to prevent Ali becoming Caliph. Like it is far fetched. But Shia don't claim it like that he put his biased spin on it. There some other Sahaba who believe it should be Ali. Remember Malik was killed by Khalid bin Waleed. Also Ansar wanted caliphate but Umar got in fight at saqifa. Other words no we don't say all conspired we say many remained silent out fear or others biases, some believed in Ali & some conspired. Once they went round demanding allegiance claiming Muslims agreed who was going to stand against them when they killed others. Also he claim Umar never threatened to burn house of Fatima in the Sunni view. It is in their own hadiths! It might not be know to their followers but it is known without doubt he went to Fatima house & also they took fadak. No debate on these to those who are honest. Some Sunni scholars admit it & make excuses for it. Are saying you don't know any of this? There is more but you were too busy nodding away
@@hassanabbasbirmani Shia believe Imams/Caliphs are chosen by Allah (swt) as per the Qur'an in Sura baqarah & other verses & hadith. Now that is a big point but what does he mention imam needs to be descendent of Ali (as). At least say why, don't mislead others to make them think the Shia made it an Hereditary thing like a monarchy. No the real the criteria is Allah chosen them for their characters & attributes. Not any descendent of Ali can be an imam it is very misleading. Common attack on Shia accusing it to be like monarchy Hereditary when Imam were the most knowledgeable of their time. regardless of their lineage this was essential characteristics but see ones he mentions misleading bias. You can't see this!
I am a Sunni and I also love Hussein AS and Ali AS and everyone of the Ahlul Bayt but the most important person of them all is our Prophet Muhammad SAW
@Raza Mughal hello, my brother, I respect the sunni belief... but there's events that happened in history that can't be ignored. We have to be with who's right and not be with everyone. Why did Ayisha fight against the imam Ali in the battel of camel? We have to seek the truth and side with it.
@@JuanCarlosLawalataI hope you actually realize that we follow the Prophet and the Ahlulbayt. We have the same quran we hold on to the quran and the AHLULBAYT (AS). I have many sunni friends we pray together fasted together and everything 🙏 ❤❤
@@alialredawehbi9346what was the reason, you thought The shia believe is truer compared to sunni's? I just want to know what the angle from the shia perspective is ? Let's put a so called before shia and sunni .
@@Maricove_y me personally i'm still learning about sunni vs shia brother but i think a big difference between sunnism and shi'ism besides imamate and sahaba is that shia are more critical of hadith. majority of hadith are compiled by fallible people, people who can make mistakes. however because twelver shia believe in the infallibility of the imams, if an imam is within any chain of transmission of a hadith they can be sure that it is true. so i would say shia are definitely more critical of hadith and it makes sense as they are not leaving their faith up to chance and possibility but rather what they can be sure is true and intended from allah swt. but of course one must first believe the imams are infallible to hold this belief. me personally i am learning about shi'ism, i was introduced to islam as a whole through sunnism, but some aspects of shi'ism like the critical view of hadith makes a lot of sense to me. however there are some theological arguments which can be brought up to question the imams. inshallah we all find the truth and may allah be pleased with our efforts. ameen
I am a revert to Islam many years ago. I was always very hurt and confused by the division. But I came to slowly understand it better, but not completely. Your explanation is of great value to me Alhamdullilahdullilah. I love Allah( SWT) and our beloved Phrophet (PBUH) and the Ahleibhat. I am grateful for your Lecture. I am a Sunni and have Respect for our Ummah.May Allah ( SWT) guide us all. My Familie observes Muharam and are very saddened . We must unite and be understanding to each other. Ya Allah please Guide us Ameen🤲
Beautiful ! Don't ever let go of your belief ....... ' I LOVE Allah ( swt ) the Prophet Mohammed (sas ) and the Aalabat ' 👍 In Sufism this is in the top priority .
Surah Fussilat 41 : 37 prohibiting muslim to worship sky objects (sun, moon, stars) is recited by Muhammad (because he's illiterate) 3-5 years (AD 613-615) after he proclaimed as a prophet of allah in AD 610. He copied the Jews' Tanak (Bible: the Old Testament) Exodus 20 : 4, Deuteronomy 4 : 19 & 17 : 3 that Yahweh, the God of Israel that's worshiped by Abraham, Ishaq & Yakub, forbids the Israelites to worship sky objects but Q 6 : 77 muslims used to worship the moon goddess 🌙 & Q 53 : 49 Sirius the brightest star used to be Allah. William Tisdall says in his book "The Original Sources of the Qur'an - Its Origin In Pagan Legends and Mythology" during that time Muhammad followed some of Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabian belief and practices. At that time he was still befriended wth them. He had access to Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabians (ancient people of Mesopotamia (nowadays Iraq) until Syria) scriptures. He admitted the rightful Inhibitans of Israel in the Palestinian's land (Quran 5: 20-26), Jews & Christian are good friends. They'll go to heaven., but quran 5:82 to hate the Jews but Christians are the kindest to muslim, fight & slaughter the Jews (Sahih Muslim, Book 41, Hadith 6981 & 6985), quran 5:14 to hate Christians, quran 9:29 to fight theJews & Christias, 5 : 51, 1 : 7 the Christians & Jews are the cursed ones. Muhammad ordered muslims to pray 5x/ day to curse them, the Pact of Omar in AD 717, allah turned the Jews into pigs & monkeys Q 2 : 65 & 5 : 60, 7 : 163, rats are made from the Jews Sahih Al Bukhari, book 54, Hadith 524, cut the neck & fingers of the disbelievers Q 8 : 12 & 47 : 3 - 4, to kill the non muslims Sahih Al Bukhari Vo. I, p. 13, Q 9 : 14, to wipe out non muslims Q 6 : 44 - 45 & many more. The turning point is in AD 624. Muhammad wanted to be accepted as their new prophet (the Jew were waiting for their Masiah & the Christian were waiting for the coming of Christ for the 2nd time). When they rejected him he turned against them. Muhammad quarrelled with the Jews in AD 624 in Medina. Muhammad chased, killed & expelled them out of the Arabian Peninsula.... W. Tidall, p. 39. In the same page says in the same year Muhammad performed his 1st 'Idu'l Adha. While the Jews slaughtered lambs Muhammad slaughtered 2 kids. One for his people & one for himself.
I really enjoyed this lecture. I am what is referred to as a revert to Islam. I live in a area of the US with a very small Muslim community. Essentially I found islam by researching islam online listening to various speakers. So clarification in an unbiased way was very helpful. Mashallah I'm thankful for this lecture alhamdulillah.
I am a sunni imam who acted as imam in a shia masjid in 1980 and a sunni masjid in philly in 1985. Being frum Nur movement and Hizmet movement in Turkey I agree with br. Yasir 100 percent. I use the same approach in my lectures.May Allah bless and reward you.
As a Shia person, all respect for you. Tolerance and acceptance are the way forward, Our Allah is one, our Quran is one, and our Prophet Mohamad Salla Allah 3aleh Wasalm is what unites us.
If you are shia brother please answer my question above no one can and does that make sense to you... really sorry for being straight up but I've heard shia aalim especially the Zakir and people in general saying disrespectful things about Abu bakr Ra like I said you all known Abu bakr 1400 years later but our beloved prophet pbuh just didn't know he was a bad guy... really... Zakir need to chill on the language they use so disrespectful...are we the sunni missing something can someone explain or stop disrespecting one of the greatest sahaba...it really hurts that the last portion of this ummah will disrespect the first portion.. Allah guide us all and put love for the sahaba and ahle bait in our hearts AMEEN
@@moinejaz2804 Dear Brother, I understand your concerns about disrespectful behavior and spreading fitna (discord) among the Muslim community. It is essential to me to promote unity, mutual respect, and understanding among Muslims, regardless of our differences. Insulting or disrespecting the Sahaba (companions of the Prophet Muhammad) is indeed inappropriate and goes against the teachings of Islam. The Sahaba hold a special place in Islamic history, as they were close companions of the Prophet, and they played a crucial role in spreading and preserving the message of Islam. It is crucial to remember that Islam emphasizes respect for all individuals, including the Sahaba, and discourages divisive language or actions that can lead to disunity within the Muslim community. Instead of focusing on our differences, I believe that we should strive to foster an environment of compassion, tolerance, and open dialogue, so we can learn from one another and grow together as a unified ummah. I personally agree with the sentiment that we should all seek guidance from Allah, and may He guide us to love and respect the Sahaba and the Ahl al-Bayt (the Prophet's family). By promoting unity, love, and respect within the ummah, I believe that we can work together to strengthen our faith and positively impact the world around us. May Allah guide us all and grant us the wisdom to treat one another with kindness and compassion. Ameen. Furthermore, I respect my personal beliefs and upbringing, which forbid me from associating with extremists on either side. Striving for a balanced and moderate approach is commendable, and it is essential for me to distance myself from any form of extremism that could harm the unity and cohesion of the Muslim community. I also recognize that ignorance and a lack of education can contribute to the spread of fitna and misunderstandings among Muslims. It is crucial for me as an individual and for the community to seek knowledge, engage in open discussions, and learn from authentic sources to gain a better understanding of our faith. Regarding the reliability of some hadith, I acknowledge that it is a valid scholarly viewpoint to question the historical accuracy of certain narrations. The process of hadith transmission and authentication was complex, and there is a possibility that some fabricated or unreliable hadith may have been circulated for various reasons, including political motives. Therefore, I believe it is crucial to rely on trusted scholars and reputable sources when studying and understanding the hadith literature. In addressing fitna and promoting unity, I believe that we should emphasize the teachings of Islam that encourage compassion, forgiveness, and tolerance. Engaging in respectful discussions and seeking common ground can bridge gaps and foster harmony within the Muslim ummah. By staying informed, learning from reputable sources, and rejecting extreme views, I believe that we can actively work towards a more cohesive Muslim community based on love, respect, and understanding. Let us pray for guidance and wisdom from Allah, seeking the truth in all matters and striving to build a united ummah that upholds the true values of Islam. May Allah guide us and grant us the strength to navigate the challenges we face. Ameen.
@@moinejaz2804 I agree. The shia scholars of the highest eminence such as Ayatullah Sistani condemn cursing the revered companions by sunni's. Shaytan worshiped Allah for 6000 years and one of his sajdah's was for 2000 years. However, when it came down to bowing to Adam (a.s) he disobeyed God and went astray. Similarily, we believe Abu Bakr went astray due to being power hungry and went astray. Please do note that I am not doing takfir on Abu Bakr.
@@zulfiqarsyed7294 I living in this time Will not say anything about Abu bakr usman umar Ali radiallah anhum...the prophet pbuh new better than us these are sahaba that were very close to prophet pbuh
They only recite half of the verse chapter 3:102 and stop even though the verse starts with “and hold firmly to the rope of Allah and don be divided They avoid that verse most of the times because they are selective And it’s they know they are divided and want to keep divided so they hide/ chooses not to recite or discuss
“Surely you have nothing to do with those who have made divisions in their religion and become factions. Their matter is with Allah and He will indeed tell them (in time) what they have been doing”. Quran 6:159
Alhamdulillah I reverted for more than a month. Love learning about our religion. With regards the division as advice in Quran I choose to respect all. Inshallah may there be respect for all of us. We are one UMMAH. The same reason I reverted. No rich or poor in Allah's eyes we are his slaves and should focus on him. ❤❤❤
Shia viewer here 🙋♀️ Thank you! For being so respectful to our beliefs. If only more scholars were like you. I’ve heard soo many Sunni scholars be extremely disrespect and give out misinformation about Shias to fuel hatred between the 2 sects. These differences should be respected but should never be a cause for disunity within the Ummah!
Most sunnis are born to sunni families and most shia are born to shia families May Allah guide both sects to jannah and truth and have mercy on all of us
@@HMD1986- prophet said "MY UMMAH will be divided into ..." also everyone will go to hell that has commited sins that are not forgiven even the people on the right path. and the prophet never said they will go to ell for ever as disbelievers
In the holy quran there is no mention of Shia and sunni 🌹🕋🌹may Allah bless everyone ameen and keep loving prophet Muhammad piece be upon him ♥️and also ahlebait and sahaba
Yess there is Shia in Qur an but no Sunni, Salafi,Sufi And most surely Abraham was among the Shi’a of him (i.e., Noah)”(Qur’an 37:83) وَإِنَّ مِن شِيعَتِهِ لَإِبْرَاهِيمَ ﴿الصافات: ٨٣﴾ "And he (Moses) went into the city at a time when people (of the city) were not watching, so he found therein two men fighting, one being of his Shi’a and the other beinghis enemy, and the one who was of his Shi’a cried out to him for help against the one who was of his enemy”(Qur’an 28:15) فَوَجَدَ فِيهَا رَجُلَيْنِ يَقْتَتِلَانِ هَـٰذَا مِن شِيعَتِهِ وَهَـٰذَا مِنْ عَدُوِّهِ ۖفَاسْتَغَاثَهُ الَّذِي مِن شِيعَتِهِ عَلَى الَّذِي مِنْ عَدُوِّهِ..
@@spiderlocyugo In the Qur'an is noth Shia 😄 Shia can get marriage in short before reall merriage , there for to not comit sin , but Qur'an never mention it , that is only one thing , but there is many more Shia practice wich is not allowed in Qur'an ...so
@@lady7 So the sahaba ibn abbas was wrong in Sunni Books 😆😆 We read in Sahih Bukhari: “Narrated Abu Jamra: I heard Ibn Abbas (giving a verdict) when he was asked about the Mut’ah with the women, and he permitted it (Nikah al-Mut’ah). On that a freed slave of his said to him, “That is only when it is very badly needed and (qualified permanent) women are scarce, or similar cases.” On that, Ibn Abbas said, “Yes.” And sunnis believe it was 2 times allowed on travel and 2 times not,
@@lady7 There are a majority of Hadith in all Sunni books of Hadith that contradict each other. Many Sunni Hadith agree about Shia beliefs. Because of Shaitan, the Sunni's have subconsciously forgot about them "...It was none but Satan who made me forget..."(18:63) Shaytan causes forgetfulness. Don't forget that Aisha sinned against Allah when she disobeyed a direct Quranic command "And stay in your houses and do not display your finery like the displaying of the ignorance of yore" as she rode into the Battle of the Camel.(33:33) Logic and common sense say that the Shia's are correct in all their belief. But Allah gave you an intellect that is lower than mine so I cannot be against you. It is not your fault that you are this way. I love you the same as any other Muslim. It's like a father and his disobedient child. The father must love his child even though he is disobedient to the father. So therefore I love you as a Muslim, I treat you the same as a Shia Muslim.
I m a sunni n came across this video first time watching vc of sh yasir. It gives me new perspective in how i view the shia believers. Long story short we all worship the same god , followers of Muhammad saw puh, pray facing the sama qibla etc. No matter which sects we r in , make sure after every solah we seek from Allah to accept our prayers n doas, show us the right path towards jannahtul firdaus. Tqvm bro Sh Yasir, may Allah swt bless u.
This is an incredible lecture and so well explained. Thank you so much for this. I have saved this video and will reference it many times InshaAllah. I am Roman Catholic but have a very strong leaning towards Islam. Your lesson has made me so much wiser 🙏 Shukran.
Surah Fussilat 41 : 37 prohibiting muslim to worship sky objects (sun, moon, stars) is recited by Muhammad (because he's illiterate) 3-5 years (AD 613-615) after he proclaimed as a prophet of allah in AD 610. He copied the Jews' Tanak (Bible: the Old Testament) Exodus 20 : 4, Deuteronomy 4 : 19 & 17 : 3 that Yahweh, the God of Israel that's worshiped by Abraham, Ishaq & Yakub, forbids the Israelites to worship sky objects but Q 6 : 77 muslims used to worship the moon goddess 🌙 & Q 53 : 49 Sirius the brightest star used to be Allah. William Tisdall says in his book "The Original Sources of the Qur'an - Its Origin In Pagan Legends and Mythology" during that time Muhammad followed some of Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabian belief and practices. At that time he was still befriended wth them. He had access to Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabians (ancient people of Mesopotamia (nowadays Iraq until southern Syria) scriptures. He admitted the rightful Inhibitans of Israel in the Palestinian's land (Quran 5: 20-26), Jews & Christian are good friends. They'll go to heaven., but quran 5:82 to hate the Jews but Christians are the kindest to muslim, fight & slaughter the Jews (Sahih Muslim, Book 41, Hadith 6981 & 6985), quran 5:14 to hate Christians, quran 9:29 to fight theJews & Christias, 5 : 51, 1 : 7 the Christians & Jews are the cursed ones. Muhammad ordered muslims to pray 5x/ day to curse them, the Pact of Omar in AD 717, allah turned the Jews into pigs & monkeys Q 2 : 65 & 5 : 60, 7 : 163, rats are made from the Jews Sahih Al Bukhari, book 54, Hadith 524, cut the neck & fingers of the disbelievers Q 8 : 12 & 47 : 3 - 4, to kill the non muslims Sahih Al Bukhari Vo. I, p. 13, Q 9 : 14, to wipe out non muslims Q 6 : 44 - 45 & many more. Why there are many contradictions ??? The turning point is in AD 624. Muhammad wanted to be accepted as their new prophet (the Jew were waiting for their Masiah & the Christian were waiting for the coming of Christ for the 2nd time). When they rejected him he turned against them. Muhammad quarrelled with the Jews in AD 624 in Medina. Muhammad chased, killed & expelled them out of the Arabian Peninsula.... W. Tidall, p. 39. In the same page says in the same year Muhammad performed his 1st 'Idu'l Adha. While the Jews slaughtered lambs Muhammad slaughtered 2 kids. One for his people & one for himself. Dr. Daniel Alan Brubaker "Corrections in Early Qur'an Manuscripts". Dr. Dan says, "There are thousands seemingly endless deletions & insertions in the early quranic manuscripts (7th century)". Quran is just a man made book. Western & European historians are free from religious oppression, intimidation & collusion. Not like their fellow muslim historians in their muslim countries. Eventhough they don't live in muslim countries but they're still bound with their religion. By making a report which is contrary to the quran & islamic rules and agreements the muslim historian could still face death threat, eg. Salman Rushdie, etc.
Surah Fussilat 41 : 37 prohibiting muslim to worship sky objects (sun, moon, stars) is recited by Muhammad (because he's illiterate) 3-5 years (AD 613-615) after he proclaimed as a prophet of allah in AD 610. He copied the Jews' Tanak (Bible: the Old Testament) Exodus 20 : 4, Deuteronomy 4 : 19 & 17 : 3 that Yahweh, the God of Israel that's worshiped by Abraham, Ishaq & Yakub, forbids the Israelites to worship sky objects but Q 6 : 77 muslims used to worship the moon goddess 🌙 & Q 53 : 49 Sirius the brightest star used to be Allah. William Tisdall says in his book "The Original Sources of the Qur'an - Its Origin In Pagan Legends and Mythology" during that time Muhammad followed some of Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabian belief and practices. At that time he was still befriended wth them. He had access to Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabians (ancient people of Mesopotamia (nowadays Iraq) until Syria) scriptures. He admitted the rightful Inhibitans of Israel in the Palestinian's land (Quran 5: 20-26), Jews & Christian are good friends. They'll go to heaven., but quran 5:82 to hate the Jews but Christians are the kindest to muslim, fight & slaughter the Jews (Sahih Muslim, Book 41, Hadith 6981 & 6985), quran 5:14 to hate Christians, quran 9:29 to fight theJews & Christias, 5 : 51, 1 : 7 the Christians & Jews are the cursed ones. Muhammad ordered muslims to pray 5x/ day to curse them, the Pact of Omar in AD 717, allah turned the Jews into pigs & monkeys Q 2 : 65 & 5 : 60, 7 : 163, rats are made from the Jews Sahih Al Bukhari, book 54, Hadith 524, cut the neck & fingers of the disbelievers Q 8 : 12 & 47 : 3 - 4, to kill the non muslims Sahih Al Bukhari Vo. I, p. 13, Q 9 : 14, to wipe out non muslims Q 6 : 44 - 45 & many more. The turning point is in AD 624. Muhammad wanted to be accepted as their new prophet (the Jew were waiting for their Masiah & the Christian were waiting for the coming of Christ for the 2nd time). When they rejected him he turned against them with sword. Muhammad quarrelled with the Jews in AD 624 in Medina. Muhammad chased, killed & expelled them out of the Arabian Peninsula.... W. Tidall, p. 39. In the same page says in the same year Muhammad performed his 1st 'Idu'l Adha. While the Jews slaughtered lambs Muhammad slaughtered 2 kids. One for his people & one for himself.
I'm a shia Muslim and love the way you explained everything. The only way we can be united is if we understand our differences and respect each other's beliefs. To live and let live at the end of the day we are only humans and can have differences of opinion. I thank you so much for this effort and honesty l wish we have more knowledgeable scholars to enlightening. I love all my sunni brother's. I was never thought by my parents or in our mosque to disrespect anyone of my sunni brother's or thier Khalifa's. I always have respect for them for me its just a difference of opinions. Peace to all of you.
yes its just on social media where people are anonymous that many people create hate and create so much bad tension between people like sunni and shias
You sound like person from Ismaili tariqa. Who are most peaceful people in the World . Ismaili imamat with Government of Canada have founded Gobal Centre of Pluralism to make our world a Safe and peaceful place to live. Agakhan Museum in Toronto is founded by Ismail Imamat to foster understanding between all faiths Promoting PLURALISM. Note :: western public are ignorant about Islam , Sunnis are ignorant about Shia, and likewise Shia 12 er are ignorant about ismaili Islam
Dr Yasir Qadhi has spent over a decade studying Islam and has written academic papers and given (probably) thousands of khutbahs. He used to be a 'salafi' when he was younger. But that is still considered a branch of sunni Islam. After having done more research on his own he no longer identifes with that group. As for the shia sect, with all due respect, there are far too many things that simply don't add up (in my humble opinion). Somewhat like Christianity. This is what any unbiased person would conclude. But I sincerely ask Allah to guide you with goodness,
Surah Fussilat 41 : 37 prohibiting muslim to worship sky objects (sun, moon, stars) is recited by Muhammad (because he's illiterate) 3-5 years (AD 613-615) after he proclaimed as a prophet of allah in AD 610. He copied the Jews' Tanak (Bible: the Old Testament) Exodus 20 : 4, Deuteronomy 4 : 19 & 17 : 3 that Yahweh, the God of Israel that's worshiped by Abraham, Ishaq & Yakub, forbids the Israelites to worship sky objects but Q 6 : 77 muslims used to worship the moon goddess 🌙 & Q 53 : 49 Sirius the brightest star used to be Allah. William Tisdall says in his book "The Original Sources of the Qur'an - Its Origin In Pagan Legends and Mythology" during that time Muhammad followed some of Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabian belief and practices. At that time he was still befriended wth them. He had access to Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabians (ancient people of Mesopotamia (nowadays Iraq) until Syria) scriptures. He admitted the rightful Inhibitans of Israel in the Palestinian's land (Quran 5: 20-26), Jews & Christian are good friends. They'll go to heaven., but quran 5:82 to hate the Jews but Christians are the kindest to muslim, fight & slaughter the Jews (Sahih Muslim, Book 41, Hadith 6981 & 6985), quran 5:14 to hate Christians, quran 9:29 to fight theJews & Christias, 5 : 51, 1 : 7 the Christians & Jews are the cursed ones. Muhammad ordered muslims to pray 5x/ day to curse them, the Pact of Omar in AD 717, allah turned the Jews into pigs & monkeys Q 2 : 65 & 5 : 60, 7 : 163, rats are made from the Jews Sahih Al Bukhari, book 54, Hadith 524, cut the neck & fingers of the disbelievers Q 8 : 12 & 47 : 3 - 4, to kill the non muslims Sahih Al Bukhari Vo. I, p. 13, Q 9 : 14, to wipe out non muslims Q 6 : 44 - 45 & many more. The turning point is in AD 624. Muhammad wanted to be accepted as their new prophet (the Jew were waiting for their Masiah & the Christian were waiting for the coming of Christ for the 2nd time). When they rejected him he turned against them. Muhammad quarrelled with the Jews in AD 624 in Medina. Muhammad chased, killed & expelled them out of the Arabian Peninsula.... W. Tidall, p. 39. In the same page says in the same year Muhammad performed his 1st 'Idu'l Adha. While the Jews slaughtered lambs Muhammad slaughtered 2 kids. One for his people & one for himself.
@@orvillosimon8531 Surah Fussilat 41 : 37 prohibiting muslim to worship sky objects (sun, moon, stars) is recited by Muhammad (because he's illiterate) 3-5 years (AD 613-615) after he proclaimed as a prophet of allah in AD 610. He copied the Jews' Tanak (Bible: the Old Testament) Exodus 20 : 4, Deuteronomy 4 : 19 & 17 : 3 that Yahweh, the God of Israel that's worshiped by Abraham, Ishaq & Yakub, forbids the Israelites to worship sky objects but Q 6 : 77 muslims used to worship the moon goddess 🌙 & Q 53 : 49 Sirius the brightest star used to be Allah. William Tisdall says in his book "The Original Sources of the Qur'an - Its Origin In Pagan Legends and Mythology" during that time Muhammad followed some of Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabian belief and practices. At that time he was still befriended wth them. He had access to Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabians (ancient people of Mesopotamia (nowadays Iraq) until Syria) scriptures. He admitted the rightful Inhibitans of Israel in the Palestinian's land (Quran 5: 20-26), Jews & Christian are good friends. They'll go to heaven., but quran 5:82 to hate the Jews but Christians are the kindest to muslim, fight & slaughter the Jews (Sahih Muslim, Book 41, Hadith 6981 & 6985), quran 5:14 to hate Christians, quran 9:29 to fight theJews & Christias, 5 : 51, 1 : 7 the Christians & Jews are the cursed ones. Muhammad ordered muslims to pray 5x/ day to curse them, the Pact of Omar in AD 717, allah turned the Jews into pigs & monkeys Q 2 : 65 & 5 : 60, 7 : 163, rats are made from the Jews Sahih Al Bukhari, book 54, Hadith 524, cut the neck & fingers of the disbelievers Q 8 : 12 & 47 : 3 - 4, to kill the non muslims Sahih Al Bukhari Vo. I, p. 13, Q 9 : 14, to wipe out non muslims Q 6 : 44 - 45 & many more. The turning point is in AD 624. Muhammad wanted to be accepted as their new prophet (the Jew were waiting for their Masiah & the Christian were waiting for the coming of Christ for the 2nd time). When they rejected him he turned against them. Muhammad quarrelled with the Jews in AD 624 in Medina. Muhammad chased, killed & expelled them out of the Arabian Peninsula.... W. Tidall, p. 39. In the same page says in the same year Muhammad performed his 1st 'Idu'l Adha. While the Jews slaughtered lambs Muhammad slaughtered 2 kids. One for his people & one for himself.
Brother just make it simple and the the Australian dude the Maula Ali was born in kabba sheriff. And Allah"s Prophet on the Gaddi ur khum had raise Maula Ali's hand and had declared him as a Wali.Mann kuntum maula far haaza Ali un Maula. Means who
A beautiful educational polite and factual response. Let’s focus on the similarities ❤ rather than the differences between us. At the end of the day we are one Ummah. ❤
I just know that I'm a Muslim who follows the Sunnah and the Quran as much as possible.. but definitely I am always falling to a sin. Alhamdullillah for we have a rabb who is so excessively merciful to forgive😢 , so right sir that all the believers are brothers and I do not think that I'm better than my brother,I love you all for the sake of ALLAH(swt). Respect to all my bro..
May Allah swt make it Easy for you to break away from the sins that are causing you so much grief and hurt, and erase all your sins and replace them with reward and bounty InshaAllah.
I am a shia Muslim and i liked the fact that he was transparent in delivering both sides ideologies.....ultimately we are one ummah of prophet Mohanmad sws with different interpretations of deen and shariya
Ayatollah Al-Khoei was a Chain Smoker. He said, *“Deen is Taqiyya & Taqiyya is MY DEEN.”* Ayatollah Bahjat Foumani couldn’t even read Quran with proper Tajwid. He said, *“Only 3 Sahabah remain Muslim the rest apostate after the demise of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). Those 3 resulted in 500 million (Shi’ites) today. Taqiyya did all of this.”* Ayatollah Sayyid -SEXTANI- Sistani said, *“Intrauterine insemination (IUI) - Getting Pregnant with a Stranger’s Sperm! is HALAL in Shi’ism.”* May Allah SWT destroy the CURSED Imami Ithna’ Ashari Sect.
*Shia Fiqh* - Mut’ah Marriage (Shia Prostitution) is HALAL in Twelver Shi’ism. There are many Mut’ah Markets in Iran & Iraq. May Allah SWT destroy them.
I grew up in Iran with Shia school of teaching and when I came to US I realized the majority of masajid are based on Sunni school of teaching. I did not find it difficult to practice my religion which is Islam in all of these masajid by adapting some of the norms of Sunni teaching. There is truly no major differences.
@@rastgo3231 خود حضرت علی مخالف هرگونه دودستگی در امت بودند. امام حسن خلافت را رها کردند تا بتوانند از جنگ و خونریزی در امت جلوگیری کنند.حالا ما بعد از ۱۴۰۰ سال شدیم کاسه داغتر از آش.
My daughter had asked me about shia because she met a shii imam whose position is like that of br. Yasir, I had explained the same things. Now I have sent this link to her . Very helpful. Young generation should listen to it.
Subhan-Allah , and jazakh-Allah Sheikh for making me understand something very important. Originally I am from Fiji Islands, currently living in USA... Allhamdolillah. I really appreciate your message about unity in the end. That's how I was raised back in multiracial country of Fiji. We respected all religions and upon living in USA for past 30+ years, I came to understand, y religion better by Sheikh s like you. I am still learning something new every day. In-shaa-Allah, I will continue to learn till I die.... ameen.
SubhanAllah! JAZKALLAH Khair dear Dr Sh. YQ, extremely grateful to Allah SWT to be able to listen to this lecture of yours clarifying the difference s between sunni and Shia. Honestly I had asked so many people till now about the differences but nobody was able to clarify that for me with the facts....Like I have mentioned few times already that DR YQ and Mufti Menk are main anchors in my life with islamic knowledge and immense learnings..I wish and pray to Allah SWT to Grant them Jannatul firadaus..Ameen.... Many many many thanks EPic family for sharing so many good lectures really! May Allah SWT bless you with barakah and the reward... Kindly kindly send my best wishes and lots of duas to DR Sh. YQ 🙏🏼🙌, 🤲
Thank you for promoting tolerance and peace. Also the fact that so many Shia people watching this clip knowing it’s from a suni scholar shows that as a umah we are learning to unit more and more with the help of allah.
Thank you brother! May Allah swt bless you, your parents and your loved ones with the best in this life and the hereafter. Ameen. I am from the country of Habesha (Ethiopia) Darul hijreteyin.
Jazaakallahu khairan sheikh Yassir. You are one of the few leaders in the community who have the ability to bring people together. May Allah put baraka in all your efforts.
@@drhasanjabir4193 I am sure we are on right path but the ones who has lack of knowledge about us have no fault because we failed to teach them about us 🤷🏻
@@drhasanjabir4193 Salam, I am alhamduliallah also a Shia Muslim and just want to say that I also completely have faith in your statements expect one, For us this is defiantly the path to paradise and if you have your akhlaq and practice haram and halal/wajibat then yes but THAT is our faith for sunnis they might be a different point of view and that is completely ok. In conclusion no shia or sunni should say they are right or on the right path because only Allah knows who's faith is right or wrong so just stick
Very clearly and precisely as always, may the Allah Most High reward you. And the devils and politicians are always nearby and should be taken good care of!
As-salaamu Alaikum I'm a Christian revert who was Sunni and now is Shia. I thought your lecture was the best from a Sunni source on the differences in Islam. Pragmatic tolerance is all we can do. Thanks for your honest words and may Allah (swt) bless the Ummah with unity at the right time.
Please try to adopt a simple Islamic lifestyle. To go towards Shisms is confusing especially related to 12-Imams; idolisation of Ali, Hassan, Hussein etc. Please research on the true teachings of Islam
@@miketiong8441 shut up, its the sunni sects who are confused LOL! name the 12 caliphs that The prophet said will come after him then, LOL! ill wait . :)
Thank you for this lecture. 30 yrs revert Sunni, not knowing of differences then, have always wondered about the dilemma. Great to hear this analysis without defaming one or the other. A thin line to navigate on.
His comments at about 36 minutes in are the key issue: both sides are ultimately working with historical narratives that contradict one another. And we easily forget that no one alive today was there to witness the events that are described in these books. As a convert to Islam who picked up a copy of the Qur’an- or rather, an explanation of it- making sense of this conflict, which is based on events described outside of the Qur’an, has been a real ordeal. It means being reborn i to a broken family. Everyone insists that their side is correct (naturally) but if we’re brutally honest, both sides are, for the most part, following what was passed down to them. Both stories were told to me at about the same time and not passed down from my family over centuries. At this point in my “career” as a Muslim, I say “aleyhisalam” when talking about the Ahlul Bayt but guess what? So did Imam Bukhari. I mourn Hussein (as) every Muharram, but not to the point of, say, thinking it’s not a good idea to get married during that month. I also say “radhiullahu anhu” to Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman, who were also members of the Prophet’s (S) family by marriage and, in Abu Bakr’s (ra) case, an ancestor of the sixth Imam, Jafar Sadiq (ra)- who was apparently a teacher of Imam Abu Hanifa. I hope to be able to study these issues more in depth but in the meantime, although there were some details that differed from what Shi’i brothers have told me, the Sheikh did a good job of addressing this and I will keep him my dua. May Allah reward him, and guide him and guide me and all of us. And with this issue especially, it’s good to remember to say “Allahu alim”. Salams from Utah (Which, on a far lighter note, I affectionately refer to as “Mormonistan”).
Peace be upon you. As a revert to Islam myself I commend your efforts to make sense of a very sensitive and partisan issue. your background will stand you in good stead compared to a born Muslim who has family and society to worry about. You are simply after the truth and are not motivated by family heritage or any other legacy issues. You are fortunate to have found out about the Ahlulbayt, Imam Hussain and the Karbala so early on in your journey. I was Muslim for over 16 Years before I found out about Karbala, Imam Hussain, or even heard the term Ahlulbayt. I spent an entire year studying the differences in depth and alhamdulillah I chose to follow the path of Ahlulbayt. I had been sunni for most of my adult life so I have spent time in various communities/sects such as sufis, Tableeghis and even Deboandis. May Allah bring you and all of us back to Quran and Ahlulbayt - Wa Salaam
@@RocketAfriqueZA Aleykumselam brother, may Allah indeed help us all to understand the Ahlul Bayt as they ought to be understood and more importantly, love them as they ought to be loved- and may we all help each other in that journey.
Lol Mormonistan is very accurate, so you are actually a Mormon convert? If so then wow, I had a Mormon friend who disperately tried to convert me for more than a year and then gave up
@@fatality153 Indeed. I also tried (or more correctly, hoped) to convert a Muslim friend or two to Mormonism and it had the opposite effect! Alhamdulillah.
@@marashimujtaba1 I still think we are always quick to criticise on the little mistakes rather then look at the larger picture (especially in this video). It’s a job well done and no doubt the Imams are sinless and are of the purest form.
@@marashimujtaba1 not that I agree with Sunni doctrine fully but all prophets committed mistakes and repented . Our nabi was scolded by Allah several times . And yet all Shia Imams are infallible . They are above Mohammad ( pbuh) ?
@@kingofdetroit358 I don't think that's a nice comment. There was nothing wrong with what the poster said. There were no insults or foul language used. Please delete your comment.
Shaykh Ninowy's (a Sunni Scholar) explanation is actually, THE most tolerant, balanced and comprehensive that there is. Try to listen to a few of his series on historical events.,
Beautiful I'm a shia muslim and love the way you explain things what shia and what is sunni Stay Blessed I love Allah( SWT) and our beloved Phrophet (PBUH) and the Ahleibhat.
Masha'Allah. Great message of tolerance and unity. There are many more similarities between the Shia and Sunni and these must be celebrated and highlighted as a way to move forward. Keep up the good work!
This was an incisive and empathic delineation of the key differences between our sunni and shia brothers/sisters. Surely the most sensible way forward is one of pragmatic tolerance, continued dialogue, and as the community of Iqraa', furthering our edification and understanding of the palpable differences and similarities between us. In times of polarization, postmodernism and anti-Muslim pogroms (both real life and virtual), we must work together in the spirit of the Most Merciful and our most merciful habib, our beloved Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, and all that follow him.
May Allah Swa bless you, alghamdulilah so beautifully said without no malicious comments. As a Sunni I too have a better understanding of the beliefs of the Shia. Shukran Sheikh 🌷
Thank you Sheikh. I'm from Iran, and I have heard about young Shia who feel like Shias get a lot of flack on the internet, and they feel depression from this because something they love so much gets put down, along with them, it's almost like bullying, but you doing this tries to clear the divide, and brings the ummah one step together. Very positive words thank you!
How could prophet Muhammad s.a.w leave his ummah without any leader knowing the fact that after such long struggle Islam had finally flourished n couldn't be left just at the mercy of people...
How many Shias of Ali r.a were presnt in battle of Badr, uhud, khandan, huanain, murah,Tabuk etc during the time of prophet s.a.w ?? How many Shias of Ali r.a were present in the battle of Yamaha (40000 led by false prophet musaylma and 13000 sahabas led by Abu Bakr r.a )?? How many Shias of Ali r.a were present in the battle of Yarmouk(sahabas against Roman Empire) and battle of qadisiyah (Sahabas against Persian Empire)?? How many Shias were presnet during conquest of North Africa, Sind led by Osman r.a ??? Shias of Ali dint participate in any of the battles but they appeared during the seige of Osman r.a and wanted to rule over muslims by taking the name of Ali r.a and his descendants...
Sunnis and Shias don't hate each other, only few among them. But in general Sunnis and Shias don't hate each other and are friends and sometimes marry each other. If some Sunnis hate Shias (and vice versa) they're just making the enemies of Islam happy.
Asalaamu Aliakum Shaykh Yasir Qadihi, Alhumdulilah I am Revert Muslim sister for 20yrs now. Your one out of three favorite teachers of Islamic Theology of mine. You have given me clarity on this vital issue of my belief. My husband was a Sunnie Muslim,before returning to ALLAH, and that's all I know. Fortunately, TH-cam has been very good in presenting me, in the beginning of my quest for knowledge, with Scholars of Sunni perspective. I have listened to two other teachers on this matter, Alhumdulilah, you have given me detailed information that wasn't confusing as the former lessons I've endured. JazkAllah Khair for presenting your lesson in an elementary level. I, being 6? years young, would get the complete understanding I desired when you announced that your presentation would be on a level that a newly😅 Reverted teenager could understand. You are an excellent teacher with excellent skills of giving historical fact that I appreciate so much. 🤲🏿May☝🏿ALLAH ble$$🌻you and your L💓ved ones, keep you safe, healthy, productive, prosperou$, and guide us all to the straight🕋path 🙏🏿Ameen🙏🏿
Anyone who hates the companions of our beloved Prophet saws is not from us. Live in peace but know our loyalties lie with Allah, His Messenger, and family of Prophet and the companions of the Prophet.
The problem is that sunni books tell us that sahaba changed the religion and thats why there is no baraka Narrated ‘Abdullah: The Prophet said, “I am your predecessor at the Lake-Fount”. ‘Abdullah added: The Prophet said, “I am your predecessor at the Lake-Fount, and some of you will be brought in front of me till I will see them and then they will be taken away from me and I will say, ‘O Lord, my companions!’ It will be said, ‘you do not know what they did after you had left.’ Sahih Bukhari, Volume 8 Hadith 578 Narrated Ibn ‘Abbas: When the time of the death of the Prophet approached while there were some men in the house, and among them was ‘Umar Ibn al-Khatttab, the Prophet said: "Come near let me write for you a writing after which you will never go astray.”‘Umar said: "The Prophet is seriously ill, you have the Qur’an, so Allah’s Book is sufficient for us.” The people in the house differed and disputed. Some of them said, "Come near so that Allah’s Apostle may write for you a writing after which you will not go astray,”while the others said what ‘Umar said. When they made much noise and quarreled greatly in front of the Prophet, he said to them, "Go away and leave me.”Ibn ‘Abbas used to say, "It was a great disaster that their quarrel and noise prevented Allah’s Apostle from writing a statement for them. Sahih al-Bukhari Hadiths: 9.468 and 7.573
@@spiderlocyugo wrong. Nothing about changing the religion in first Hadith. There's a another Hadith saying my ummah. And the second Hadith was on a Thursday. The Prophet died 3 days later and even gave a khutbah, if it was so important, then he would say it Try again rafidhi
@@badalrana10 Soo if the Prophet says you Will never go astray and you dont care??? They Will follow the same path as the sahaba of Musa as and Isa as changing.
@@badalrana10 😂 A boom in the forehead, these Rawafid follow their whims and desires, they disbelieve the Companions, may Allah pleased them, and cite some of their hadith, well done bro. 👍
Masha Allah so beautifully explained. This is so informative for both youngsters and adults. So simply explained making it easy to understand. Jazzak Allah Khayran for this.
Not really, he is not stating the facts for why Shia believe the things they do and pretty much just saying them. I'm not saying that he is being biased towards sunni but most of the points he talk about are things Shia believe but he does not go into the facts of why they believe it. Like he doesn't explain why Shias believe the prophet appointed Ali as his succesor but rather just states it.
I am Sunni and never knew the fundamental differences. Shukran for sharing this knowledge for our understanding May Allah swt reward you abundantly Ameen
Allahu Akbar. Thank you so much for this lecture. I have for a very long time taken this stand you talked about today and I am very happy to know that I am not alone on this side of the coin which can foster peace.
I respect your integrity. I have conducted a comparative study between the Sunni and Shia for more than 10 years. This is the first time for me to hear someone from the Sunni group presenting the facts as they are. You are a real Scientist guided by logic. Thank you for your honesty. God bless you !
I am a Christian and have listened to this lengthy discussion to be more enlightened on this subject. I enjoin you not just to preach pragmatic tolerance of other Islamic sects but pragmatic tolerance of all human beings and their faiths. You said that the Quran recognizes the diversity of peoples and nationalities, doesn't it recognize the diversity of faith? I truly appreciate your call for intolerance of clerics promoting hatred. They are the supporters of those causing so much pain, killings and afflictions all over the world. This face of Islam is worrisome and undesirable for humanity.
@@olufunmilayoogunsi7622 I think he was answering a specific question about Sunni and Shia. The form and approach of his answer could probably be applied to questions about relations with other faith groups. In fact he has had respectful dialog with Christian pastors. Do all Muslims engage with this level of balance and civility? Unfortunately not. Nor do all members of other faith communities. May we all avail ourselves of the spiritual practices or prayers of our respective traditions and strive to do better with each other.
Dear brother Yasir Qazi. Assalamu Aliekum. Thanking you in anicipation for the great cause you are serving to this dividend UMMAH. It is very imperative to Clarify this complicated, controversial, subject to the masses. May Allah SWT reward you immensely for this great job. We pray for your good, healthy, and long life.Take care.
I am Sunni, having lots of respect for all Ahle-Bait. JazakaAllah, for teaching our teens and youth regarding the change of views (different lense) which is existing.
I am an Iranian living in Canada; in my search for an accurate and possibly easier to understand English translation of Quran for my children I came across your video in you tube. I enjoyed your teaching, your message and learned about the differences of shia and sunni. I will certainly listen to your other teachings to learn more about Islam. I was born Muslim but I can not claim I am Muslim until I become one that Quran describes. Thank you for your explanation of these differences not just for teenagers but also for older people like me. Your efforts not just helps us to learn more about our own religion but will also help none Muslims to have a better understanding of Islam. What Iranian government did/does in the name of Islam had a big negative impact on the Iranian 's faith as well as the world views of Islam. God bless you and all scholars like you in your ways.
ive noticed a lot of iranians that are in the west are secular and dont identify with religion because there was a rebellion and many iranians didnt want the laws in iran, insha allah they come back to islam
@@z4kry44 Iranian living in Iran are more religious than the ones outside of Iran, but also other Middle Eastern people in the USA tend to be more secular in comparison to the ones in the M.E
@@agostocobain2729 i disagree with what you said about other middle eastern people, most of the middle eastern people in america are religious and actually lots of arabs living in middle eastern lands are secular
@@z4kry44 in Iran people tend to get religious when they reach 40, that’s why you see aunts, uncles,grandparents, etc. praying fasting and going to hajj, and we call those older people hajj agah. I’m also Turkish and Turkey now is super secular. I never been to Iran though unfortunately. I’m born and raised in Los Angeles and my friends are Egyptians and you’re right, they are religious. I love them best friends to have Egyptians.
Dear Dr. Yasir, Thank you so much for your respectful explanation of both theologies. I appreciate the way you presented this issue because at this time, many of the representors of Islam only address this issue in a subjective, harsh, and hateful way. May Allah bless you and the Islamic community 🙏🏻❤
You are the most knowledgeable, sophisticated, unbiased speaker or IMAM I shld say to both (Shia & Sunnis). love listening your lectures. You are a g8 asset for the younger generation. May Allah be with you. I am a Sunni- from Aust.
JazakiAllahukhaerian Sheih Br. Sajeed, gave right question, my country 100% Sunni Muslims, that why I didn’t know Muslims separated to Sunni and Sheia, I was confused too Then one of Imam talk about history of Islam, (I advised read history , you will understand why became sunniu and sheia I am agree we can not blem Sheia- we all Muslims no matter Cristina and Jew - we should respect each other- how Dr Yaseer said that between them and God AlhamdilAllah I am sunni muslim and worshipping Allah SWT and his messengers and last messenger our prophet Muhammad RAW
![🔴 [TRỰC TIẾP] U20 Thái Lan VS LPBank Ninh Bình | Cúp VTV9 - Bình Điền 2024 | JET STUDIO](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3wRNdAy3DXs/mqdefault.jpg)
i once wanted to become a muslim. i asked my muslim friends to help me, which they all did. after so many of my questions answered, i was confident enough to attend a local mosque for friday prayer. a few days before i asked the many who helped me my last question: _"when i attend the mosque, i may be asked what i am, a sunni or shia, what do i answer?"_ this question ignited all who helped me to argue with such hatred that shocked me to the point where i lost faith in islam. i didnt know there was divison, to the point where i veered for some time until i returned to announce which side i was to choose. i chose neither sunni or shia, i am a muslim.
Good there is no Sunni or shia in Quran or Sunnah. Only Islam. May Allah bless you
Yes if you stick to the Quran and Sunnah you will be on the right path... This Sunni and Shia is like a political disagreement...
The Shias (some) curse and sware at the khalifas and insult Aisha. Allah proved her innocence but they still disrespect the prophets wife Aisha.
This is very wrong.
@@N.Y.63 I would say it is slighlty more than a political difference but not by much. Honeslty the main difference in practicing shia and sunni beliefs is just about how you actually pray. All the other differences are mainly concerned with beliefs and not as much about practices of both sides.
Shaytan took advantage of the circumstances.. I recognize that people have different opinions but as long as they say I am Muslim; love them for the sake of Allah.. hatred has home with Shaytan only…
Be careful making sects the prophet peace be upon him told us there will be 73 sects only following the quran and our noble prophet pbuh will lead u paradise what was our prophet pbuh he was neither a Shia or sunni but a MUSLIM
I am a Shia from Pakistan and I am noding up and down whole lecture, very true and unbiased talk about both sects, Jazkallah khair. If half of scholars think and talk like you Muslim can become one ummah.
Actually biased talk begins from min 10 and troughout the video and the Shia beliefs arent presented accurately
You clearly know nothing if you think that was unbiased. He actually blatantly misleading on some historical facts which are recorded in Sunni source's
@@syedajabeen4734 can you point out where he was misleading?
@@hassanabbasbirmani you are Shia you really don't know 🙄.
Others have said in the comments read them. I am not going through the video again.
One example is he claims Shia believe all Sahaba conspired to prevent Ali becoming Caliph. Like it is far fetched. But Shia don't claim it like that he put his biased spin on it. There some other Sahaba who believe it should be Ali. Remember Malik was killed by Khalid bin Waleed.
Also Ansar wanted caliphate but Umar got in fight at saqifa.
Other words no we don't say all conspired we say many remained silent out fear or others biases, some believed in Ali & some conspired.
Once they went round demanding allegiance claiming Muslims agreed who was going to stand against them when they killed others.
Also he claim Umar never threatened to burn house of Fatima in the Sunni view.
It is in their own hadiths! It might not be know to their followers but it is known without doubt he went to Fatima house & also they took fadak. No debate on these to those who are honest. Some Sunni scholars admit it & make excuses for it.
Are saying you don't know any of this? There is more but you were too busy nodding away
@@hassanabbasbirmani Shia believe Imams/Caliphs are chosen by Allah (swt) as per the Qur'an in Sura baqarah & other verses & hadith.
Now that is a big point but what does he mention imam needs to be descendent of Ali (as). At least say why, don't mislead others to make them think the Shia made it an Hereditary thing like a monarchy. No the real the criteria is Allah chosen them for their characters & attributes. Not any descendent of Ali can be an imam it is very misleading. Common attack on Shia accusing it to be like monarchy Hereditary when Imam were the most knowledgeable of their time. regardless of their lineage this was essential characteristics but see ones he mentions misleading bias.
You can't see this!
I am a Sunni and I also love Hussein AS and Ali AS and everyone of the Ahlul Bayt but the most important person of them all is our Prophet Muhammad SAW
🫡
The prophet did not just say to love his household but to also follow them and hold on to them. 🙏
( Hadith al-Thaqalayn) you can also find this in Sahih al-Bukhari the original copy 🙏
Good so you love Ayesha and all the wives of the prophet and all the four daughters of Muhammad saw,
@Raza Mughal hello, my brother, I respect the sunni belief... but there's events that happened in history that can't be ignored. We have to be with who's right and not be with everyone. Why did Ayisha fight against the imam Ali in the battel of camel? We have to seek the truth and side with it.
As a Shia I can say that this is the best lecture I have heard from a sunni scholar on this topic. May allah guide us all.
As a Sunni, I pray to اللهُ عَزَّ وَجَلَّ to guide you back to the true path of Rasulullah ﷺ
@@JuanCarlosLawalataI hope you actually realize that we follow the Prophet and the Ahlulbayt. We have the same quran we hold on to the quran and the AHLULBAYT (AS). I have many sunni friends we pray together fasted together and everything 🙏 ❤❤
Bro . Help me out . Tell me , why should I consider shia believe as opposed to sunni ?
Let me know the other side of the drama
@@alialredawehbi9346what was the reason, you thought
The shia believe is truer compared to sunni's?
I just want to know what the angle from the shia perspective is ?
Let's put a so called before shia and sunni .
@@Maricove_y me personally i'm still learning about sunni vs shia brother but i think a big difference between sunnism and shi'ism besides imamate and sahaba is that shia are more critical of hadith. majority of hadith are compiled by fallible people, people who can make mistakes. however because twelver shia believe in the infallibility of the imams, if an imam is within any chain of transmission of a hadith they can be sure that it is true. so i would say shia are definitely more critical of hadith and it makes sense as they are not leaving their faith up to chance and possibility but rather what they can be sure is true and intended from allah swt. but of course one must first believe the imams are infallible to hold this belief.
me personally i am learning about shi'ism, i was introduced to islam as a whole through sunnism, but some aspects of shi'ism like the critical view of hadith makes a lot of sense to me. however there are some theological arguments which can be brought up to question the imams. inshallah we all find the truth and may allah be pleased with our efforts. ameen
I am a revert to Islam many years ago.
I was always very hurt and confused by the division.
But I came to slowly understand it better, but not completely. Your explanation is of great value to me Alhamdullilahdullilah.
I love Allah( SWT) and our beloved Phrophet (PBUH) and the Ahleibhat.
I am grateful for your Lecture.
I am a Sunni and have Respect for our Ummah.May Allah ( SWT) guide us all.
My Familie observes Muharam and are very saddened . We must unite and be understanding to each other.
Ya Allah please Guide us Ameen🤲
Assalamu'alaikum....by God willing you will be guided to the right path. From nigeria
Beautiful ! Don't ever let go of your belief .......
' I LOVE Allah ( swt ) the Prophet Mohammed (sas ) and the Aalabat ' 👍
In Sufism this is in the top priority .
Surah Fussilat 41 : 37 prohibiting muslim to worship sky objects (sun, moon, stars) is recited by Muhammad (because he's illiterate) 3-5 years (AD 613-615) after he proclaimed as a prophet of allah in AD 610. He copied the Jews' Tanak (Bible: the Old Testament) Exodus 20 : 4, Deuteronomy 4 : 19 & 17 : 3 that Yahweh, the God of Israel that's worshiped by Abraham, Ishaq & Yakub, forbids the Israelites to worship sky objects but Q 6 : 77 muslims used to worship the moon goddess 🌙 & Q 53 : 49 Sirius the brightest star used to be Allah.
William Tisdall says in his book "The Original Sources of the Qur'an - Its Origin In Pagan Legends and Mythology" during that time Muhammad followed some of Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabian belief and practices. At that time he was still befriended wth them. He had access to Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabians (ancient people of Mesopotamia (nowadays Iraq) until Syria) scriptures. He admitted the rightful Inhibitans of Israel in the Palestinian's land (Quran 5: 20-26), Jews & Christian are good friends. They'll go to heaven., but quran 5:82 to hate the Jews but Christians are the kindest to muslim, fight & slaughter the Jews (Sahih Muslim, Book 41, Hadith 6981 & 6985), quran 5:14 to hate Christians, quran 9:29 to fight theJews & Christias, 5 : 51, 1 : 7 the Christians & Jews are the cursed ones. Muhammad ordered muslims to pray 5x/ day to curse them, the Pact of Omar in AD 717, allah turned the Jews into pigs & monkeys Q 2 : 65 & 5 : 60, 7 : 163, rats are made from the Jews Sahih Al Bukhari, book 54, Hadith 524, cut the neck & fingers of the disbelievers Q 8 : 12 & 47 : 3 - 4, to kill the non muslims Sahih Al Bukhari Vo. I, p. 13, Q 9 : 14, to wipe out non muslims Q 6 : 44 - 45 & many more.
The turning point is in AD 624. Muhammad wanted to be accepted as their new prophet (the Jew were waiting for their Masiah & the Christian were waiting for the coming of Christ for the 2nd time). When they rejected him he turned against them. Muhammad quarrelled with the Jews in AD 624 in Medina. Muhammad chased, killed & expelled them out of the Arabian Peninsula.... W. Tidall, p. 39. In the same page says in the same year Muhammad performed his 1st 'Idu'l Adha. While the Jews slaughtered lambs Muhammad slaughtered 2 kids. One for his people & one for himself.
Stay away from the Shi'ite religion. It was founded by Ibn Saba the Jew. It has fundamentals that are different from Islam.
@@joeyahoo4493 death tells no lies you got some studies to get on with
I really enjoyed this lecture. I am what is referred to as a revert to Islam. I live in a area of the US with a very small Muslim community. Essentially I found islam by researching islam online listening to various speakers. So clarification in an unbiased way was very helpful. Mashallah I'm thankful for this lecture alhamdulillah.
I am a sunni imam who acted as imam in a shia masjid in 1980 and a sunni masjid in philly in 1985. Being frum Nur movement and Hizmet movement in Turkey I agree with br. Yasir 100 percent. I use the same approach in my lectures.May Allah bless and reward you.
West Philly?
Don't mind me asking but why does hizmet people insist on shaving beard ?
It seems ridiculous to say the least.
Did you the same in both mosques you prayed
Did you prayed the same waye in all the mosque you prayed
You lying no shia pray after a hyoocrite
As a Shia person, all respect for you. Tolerance and acceptance are the way forward, Our Allah is one, our Quran is one, and our Prophet Mohamad Salla Allah 3aleh Wasalm is what unites us.
If you are shia brother please answer my question above no one can and does that make sense to you... really sorry for being straight up but I've heard shia aalim especially the Zakir and people in general saying disrespectful things about Abu bakr Ra like I said you all known Abu bakr 1400 years later but our beloved prophet pbuh just didn't know he was a bad guy... really... Zakir need to chill on the language they use so disrespectful...are we the sunni missing something can someone explain or stop disrespecting one of the greatest sahaba...it really hurts that the last portion of this ummah will disrespect the first portion.. Allah guide us all and put love for the sahaba and ahle bait in our hearts AMEEN
@@moinejaz2804 Dear Brother, I understand your concerns about disrespectful behavior and spreading fitna (discord) among the Muslim community. It is essential to me to promote unity, mutual respect, and understanding among Muslims, regardless of our differences. Insulting or disrespecting the Sahaba (companions of the Prophet Muhammad) is indeed inappropriate and goes against the teachings of Islam. The Sahaba hold a special place in Islamic history, as they were close companions of the Prophet, and they played a crucial role in spreading and preserving the message of Islam.
It is crucial to remember that Islam emphasizes respect for all individuals, including the Sahaba, and discourages divisive language or actions that can lead to disunity within the Muslim community. Instead of focusing on our differences, I believe that we should strive to foster an environment of compassion, tolerance, and open dialogue, so we can learn from one another and grow together as a unified ummah.
I personally agree with the sentiment that we should all seek guidance from Allah, and may He guide us to love and respect the Sahaba and the Ahl al-Bayt (the Prophet's family). By promoting unity, love, and respect within the ummah, I believe that we can work together to strengthen our faith and positively impact the world around us. May Allah guide us all and grant us the wisdom to treat one another with kindness and compassion. Ameen.
Furthermore, I respect my personal beliefs and upbringing, which forbid me from associating with extremists on either side. Striving for a balanced and moderate approach is commendable, and it is essential for me to distance myself from any form of extremism that could harm the unity and cohesion of the Muslim community.
I also recognize that ignorance and a lack of education can contribute to the spread of fitna and misunderstandings among Muslims. It is crucial for me as an individual and for the community to seek knowledge, engage in open discussions, and learn from authentic sources to gain a better understanding of our faith.
Regarding the reliability of some hadith, I acknowledge that it is a valid scholarly viewpoint to question the historical accuracy of certain narrations. The process of hadith transmission and authentication was complex, and there is a possibility that some fabricated or unreliable hadith may have been circulated for various reasons, including political motives. Therefore, I believe it is crucial to rely on trusted scholars and reputable sources when studying and understanding the hadith literature.
In addressing fitna and promoting unity, I believe that we should emphasize the teachings of Islam that encourage compassion, forgiveness, and tolerance. Engaging in respectful discussions and seeking common ground can bridge gaps and foster harmony within the Muslim ummah.
By staying informed, learning from reputable sources, and rejecting extreme views, I believe that we can actively work towards a more cohesive Muslim community based on love, respect, and understanding. Let us pray for guidance and wisdom from Allah, seeking the truth in all matters and striving to build a united ummah that upholds the true values of Islam. May Allah guide us and grant us the strength to navigate the challenges we face. Ameen.
@@moinejaz2804 I agree. The shia scholars of the highest eminence such as Ayatullah Sistani condemn cursing the revered companions by sunni's. Shaytan worshiped Allah for 6000 years and one of his sajdah's was for 2000 years. However, when it came down to bowing to Adam (a.s) he disobeyed God and went astray. Similarily, we believe Abu Bakr went astray due to being power hungry and went astray. Please do note that I am not doing takfir on Abu Bakr.
@@zulfiqarsyed7294 I living in this time Will not say anything about Abu bakr usman umar Ali radiallah anhum...the prophet pbuh new better than us these are sahaba that were very close to prophet pbuh
He isn’t a Shia
A Shia will never say
Prophet Muhammad sallah allah saleh wasalm.
وَاعْتَصِمُواْ بِحَبْلِ اللَّهِ جَمِيعاً وَلاَ تَفَرَّقُواْ
“And hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not become divided.”
Read the books of dr Samavi. "Then I was ğuided"
They only recite half of the verse chapter 3:102 and stop even though the verse starts with “and hold firmly to the rope of Allah and don be divided
They avoid that verse most of the times because they are selective
And it’s they know they are divided and want to keep divided so they hide/ chooses not to recite or discuss
“Surely you have nothing to do with those who have made divisions in their religion and become factions. Their matter is with Allah and He will indeed tell them (in time) what they have been doing”. Quran 6:159
@@pahmancanteat2637 ❤️
@@pahmancanteat2637 tell that to the nasibis
We are one. We don't have any divisions. La Ilaha Illal Lahu Mohammdar Rasoolallah.
S. A. W❤
Denying reality doesn’t help the ummah… shiaism isn’t a fantasy..
@@keppros57one Islam
@@jasminerice00 one islam with many clans
you are a liar
Alhamdulillah I reverted for more than a month. Love learning about our religion. With regards the division as advice in Quran I choose to respect all. Inshallah may there be respect for all of us. We are one UMMAH. The same reason I reverted. No rich or poor in Allah's eyes we are his slaves and should focus on him. ❤❤❤
Shia viewer here 🙋♀️
Thank you! For being so respectful to our beliefs. If only more scholars were like you. I’ve heard soo many Sunni scholars be extremely disrespect and give out misinformation about Shias to fuel hatred between the 2 sects. These differences should be respected but should never be a cause for disunity within the Ummah!
I8
As long as you aren’t a rafidah🤷🏽♂️
@@ishaq_os dude who r u to say who is wrong and who is right? Let allah judge
@@tasmiabano2862 Much love and respect to you too sister!
"And hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not become divided.”
Anyone whom practices open taqiyah in a generalized form is not a Mu’min, Mohsin nor Mustanbetin they are deemed Ahl e Qibla
Most sunnis are born to sunni families and most shia are born to shia families May Allah guide both sects to jannah and truth and have mercy on all of us
One 1 sect go to heaven. And 72 sect are in wrong path .
@@HMD1986- In the wrong bath=path to hell.
@@HMD1986- prophet said "MY UMMAH will be divided into ..." also everyone will go to hell that has commited sins that are not forgiven even the people on the right path. and the prophet never said they will go to ell for ever as disbelievers
@@HMD1986-they all will go to jannah after getting their punishment of making sect if they have remain eman
{ إِنَّ ٱلَّذِینَ فَرَّقُوا۟ دِینَهُمۡ وَكَانُوا۟ شِیَعࣰا لَّسۡتَ مِنۡهُمۡ فِی شَیۡءٍۚ إِنَّمَاۤ أَمۡرُهُمۡ إِلَى ٱللَّهِ ثُمَّ یُنَبِّئُهُم بِمَا كَانُوا۟ یَفۡعَلُونَ }
[سُورَةُ الأَنۡعَامِ: ١٥٩]
Surat Al Anam- 159
In the holy quran there is no mention of Shia and sunni 🌹🕋🌹may Allah bless everyone ameen and keep loving prophet Muhammad piece be upon him ♥️and also ahlebait and sahaba
Yess there is Shia in Qur an but no Sunni, Salafi,Sufi
And most surely Abraham was among the Shi’a of him (i.e., Noah)”(Qur’an 37:83) وَإِنَّ مِن شِيعَتِهِ لَإِبْرَاهِيمَ ﴿الصافات: ٨٣﴾
"And he (Moses) went into the city at a time when people (of the city) were not watching, so he found therein two men fighting, one being of his Shi’a and the other beinghis enemy, and the one who was of his Shi’a cried out to him for help against the one who was of his enemy”(Qur’an 28:15)
فَوَجَدَ فِيهَا رَجُلَيْنِ يَقْتَتِلَانِ هَـٰذَا مِن شِيعَتِهِ وَهَـٰذَا مِنْ عَدُوِّهِ ۖفَاسْتَغَاثَهُ الَّذِي مِن شِيعَتِهِ عَلَى الَّذِي مِنْ عَدُوِّهِ..
@@spiderlocyugo In the Qur'an is noth Shia 😄 Shia can get marriage in short before reall merriage , there for to not comit sin , but Qur'an never mention it , that is only one thing , but there is many more Shia practice wich is not allowed in Qur'an ...so
@@lady7 So the sahaba ibn abbas was wrong in Sunni Books 😆😆
We read in Sahih Bukhari:
“Narrated Abu Jamra: I heard Ibn Abbas (giving a verdict) when he was asked about the Mut’ah with the women, and he permitted it (Nikah al-Mut’ah). On that a freed slave of his said to him, “That is only when it is very badly needed and (qualified permanent) women are scarce, or similar cases.” On that, Ibn Abbas said, “Yes.”
And sunnis believe it was 2 times allowed on travel and 2 times not,
Who are the black stone worshippers? The shia or the sunni?
Or both?
@@lady7 There are a majority of Hadith in all Sunni books of Hadith that contradict each other. Many Sunni Hadith agree about Shia beliefs. Because of Shaitan, the Sunni's have subconsciously forgot about them "...It was none but Satan who made me forget..."(18:63) Shaytan causes forgetfulness.
Don't forget that Aisha sinned against Allah when she disobeyed a direct Quranic command "And stay in your houses and do not display your finery like the displaying of the ignorance of yore" as she rode into the Battle of the Camel.(33:33)
Logic and common sense say that the Shia's are correct in all their belief. But Allah gave you an intellect that is lower than mine so I cannot be against you. It is not your fault that you are this way. I love you the same as any other Muslim. It's like a father and his disobedient child. The father must love his child even though he is disobedient to the father. So therefore I love you as a Muslim, I treat you the same as a Shia Muslim.
Subhanaallah! May Allah swt bless you your parents and your loved ones with the best in this life and the hereafter. Ameen
I m a sunni n came across this video first time watching vc of sh yasir. It gives me new perspective in how i view the shia believers.
Long story short we all worship the same god , followers of Muhammad saw puh, pray facing the sama qibla etc.
No matter which sects we r in , make sure after every solah we seek from Allah to accept our prayers n doas, show us the right path towards jannahtul firdaus.
Tqvm bro Sh Yasir, may Allah swt bless u.
This is an incredible lecture and so well explained. Thank you so much for this. I have saved this video and will reference it many times InshaAllah. I am Roman Catholic but have a very strong leaning towards Islam. Your lesson has made me so much wiser 🙏 Shukran.
Surah Fussilat 41 : 37 prohibiting muslim to worship sky objects (sun, moon, stars) is recited by Muhammad (because he's illiterate) 3-5 years (AD 613-615) after he proclaimed as a prophet of allah in AD 610. He copied the Jews' Tanak (Bible: the Old Testament) Exodus 20 : 4, Deuteronomy 4 : 19 & 17 : 3 that Yahweh, the God of Israel that's worshiped by Abraham, Ishaq & Yakub, forbids the Israelites to worship sky objects but Q 6 : 77 muslims used to worship the moon goddess 🌙 & Q 53 : 49 Sirius the brightest star used to be Allah.
William Tisdall says in his book "The Original Sources of the Qur'an - Its Origin In Pagan Legends and Mythology" during that time Muhammad followed some of Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabian belief and practices. At that time he was still befriended wth them. He had access to Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabians (ancient people of Mesopotamia (nowadays Iraq until southern Syria) scriptures. He admitted the rightful Inhibitans of Israel in the Palestinian's land (Quran 5: 20-26), Jews & Christian are good friends. They'll go to heaven., but quran 5:82 to hate the Jews but Christians are the kindest to muslim, fight & slaughter the Jews (Sahih Muslim, Book 41, Hadith 6981 & 6985), quran 5:14 to hate Christians, quran 9:29 to fight theJews & Christias, 5 : 51, 1 : 7 the Christians & Jews are the cursed ones. Muhammad ordered muslims to pray 5x/ day to curse them, the Pact of Omar in AD 717, allah turned the Jews into pigs & monkeys Q 2 : 65 & 5 : 60, 7 : 163, rats are made from the Jews Sahih Al Bukhari, book 54, Hadith 524, cut the neck & fingers of the disbelievers Q 8 : 12 & 47 : 3 - 4, to kill the non muslims Sahih Al Bukhari Vo. I, p. 13, Q 9 : 14, to wipe out non muslims Q 6 : 44 - 45 & many more. Why there are many contradictions ???
The turning point is in AD 624. Muhammad wanted to be accepted as their new prophet (the Jew were waiting for their Masiah & the Christian were waiting for the coming of Christ for the 2nd time). When they rejected him he turned against them. Muhammad quarrelled with the Jews in AD 624 in Medina. Muhammad chased, killed & expelled them out of the Arabian Peninsula.... W. Tidall, p. 39. In the same page says in the same year Muhammad performed his 1st 'Idu'l Adha. While the Jews slaughtered lambs Muhammad slaughtered 2 kids. One for his people & one for himself.
Dr. Daniel Alan Brubaker "Corrections in Early Qur'an Manuscripts". Dr. Dan says, "There are thousands seemingly endless deletions & insertions in the early quranic manuscripts (7th century)". Quran is just a man made book.
Western & European historians are free from religious oppression, intimidation & collusion. Not like their fellow muslim historians in their muslim countries. Eventhough they don't live in muslim countries but they're still bound with their religion. By making a report which is contrary to the quran & islamic rules and agreements the muslim historian could still face death threat, eg. Salman Rushdie, etc.
Leave roman catholic and join a true Christian church only then will you understand about Christianity.
You've to read your Bible so you've the right foundation.
Surah Fussilat 41 : 37 prohibiting muslim to worship sky objects (sun, moon, stars) is recited by Muhammad (because he's illiterate) 3-5 years (AD 613-615) after he proclaimed as a prophet of allah in AD 610. He copied the Jews' Tanak (Bible: the Old Testament) Exodus 20 : 4, Deuteronomy 4 : 19 & 17 : 3 that Yahweh, the God of Israel that's worshiped by Abraham, Ishaq & Yakub, forbids the Israelites to worship sky objects but Q 6 : 77 muslims used to worship the moon goddess 🌙 & Q 53 : 49 Sirius the brightest star used to be Allah.
William Tisdall says in his book "The Original Sources of the Qur'an - Its Origin In Pagan Legends and Mythology" during that time Muhammad followed some of Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabian belief and practices. At that time he was still befriended wth them. He had access to Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabians (ancient people of Mesopotamia (nowadays Iraq) until Syria) scriptures. He admitted the rightful Inhibitans of Israel in the Palestinian's land (Quran 5: 20-26), Jews & Christian are good friends. They'll go to heaven., but quran 5:82 to hate the Jews but Christians are the kindest to muslim, fight & slaughter the Jews (Sahih Muslim, Book 41, Hadith 6981 & 6985), quran 5:14 to hate Christians, quran 9:29 to fight theJews & Christias, 5 : 51, 1 : 7 the Christians & Jews are the cursed ones. Muhammad ordered muslims to pray 5x/ day to curse them, the Pact of Omar in AD 717, allah turned the Jews into pigs & monkeys Q 2 : 65 & 5 : 60, 7 : 163, rats are made from the Jews Sahih Al Bukhari, book 54, Hadith 524, cut the neck & fingers of the disbelievers Q 8 : 12 & 47 : 3 - 4, to kill the non muslims Sahih Al Bukhari Vo. I, p. 13, Q 9 : 14, to wipe out non muslims Q 6 : 44 - 45 & many more.
The turning point is in AD 624. Muhammad wanted to be accepted as their new prophet (the Jew were waiting for their Masiah & the Christian were waiting for the coming of Christ for the 2nd time). When they rejected him he turned against them with sword. Muhammad quarrelled with the Jews in AD 624 in Medina. Muhammad chased, killed & expelled them out of the Arabian Peninsula.... W. Tidall, p. 39. In the same page says in the same year Muhammad performed his 1st 'Idu'l Adha. While the Jews slaughtered lambs Muhammad slaughtered 2 kids. One for his people & one for himself.
May Allah continue to bless you with happiness in this life and in the next
I'm a shia Muslim and love the way you explained everything. The only way we can be united is if we understand our differences and respect each other's beliefs. To live and let live at the end of the day we are only humans and can have differences of opinion. I thank you so much for this effort and honesty l wish we have more knowledgeable scholars to enlightening. I love all my sunni brother's. I was never thought by my parents or in our mosque to disrespect anyone of my sunni brother's or thier Khalifa's. I always have respect for them for me its just a difference of opinions. Peace to all of you.
yes its just on social media where people are anonymous that many people create hate and create so much bad tension between people like sunni and shias
You sound like person from Ismaili tariqa. Who are most peaceful people in the World .
Ismaili imamat with Government of Canada have founded Gobal Centre of Pluralism to make our world a Safe and peaceful place to live.
Agakhan Museum in Toronto is founded by Ismail Imamat to foster understanding between all faiths Promoting PLURALISM.
Note :: western public are ignorant about Islam ,
Sunnis are ignorant about Shia, and likewise Shia 12 er are ignorant about ismaili Islam
@@alimohamed9698 Hi brother, I'm a 12 er shia Muslim but I respect your opinion thank you and peace ✌️ 🙏
we can never respect balatantly incorrect beliefs shia hold
Shia is not a Muslim
MasyaAllah this lecture is so informative and well delivered. May Allah guide us always Ya Aleem Ya Hakeem 🤲🏼
What matters most is that we believed in one Allah and Prophet Mohammad is the last messenger of Allah.
I love how respectful he was.
0
@@johnessmathew4114 plz to get some local p
Dr Yasir Qadhi has spent over a decade studying Islam and has written academic papers and given (probably) thousands of khutbahs.
He used to be a 'salafi' when he was younger. But that is still considered a branch of sunni Islam. After having done more research on his own he no longer identifes with that group.
As for the shia sect, with all due respect, there are far too many things that simply don't add up (in my humble opinion). Somewhat like Christianity. This is what any unbiased person would conclude.
But I sincerely ask Allah to guide you with goodness,
Surah Fussilat 41 : 37 prohibiting muslim to worship sky objects (sun, moon, stars) is recited by Muhammad (because he's illiterate) 3-5 years (AD 613-615) after he proclaimed as a prophet of allah in AD 610. He copied the Jews' Tanak (Bible: the Old Testament) Exodus 20 : 4, Deuteronomy 4 : 19 & 17 : 3 that Yahweh, the God of Israel that's worshiped by Abraham, Ishaq & Yakub, forbids the Israelites to worship sky objects but Q 6 : 77 muslims used to worship the moon goddess 🌙 & Q 53 : 49 Sirius the brightest star used to be Allah.
William Tisdall says in his book "The Original Sources of the Qur'an - Its Origin In Pagan Legends and Mythology" during that time Muhammad followed some of Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabian belief and practices. At that time he was still befriended wth them. He had access to Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabians (ancient people of Mesopotamia (nowadays Iraq) until Syria) scriptures. He admitted the rightful Inhibitans of Israel in the Palestinian's land (Quran 5: 20-26), Jews & Christian are good friends. They'll go to heaven., but quran 5:82 to hate the Jews but Christians are the kindest to muslim, fight & slaughter the Jews (Sahih Muslim, Book 41, Hadith 6981 & 6985), quran 5:14 to hate Christians, quran 9:29 to fight theJews & Christias, 5 : 51, 1 : 7 the Christians & Jews are the cursed ones. Muhammad ordered muslims to pray 5x/ day to curse them, the Pact of Omar in AD 717, allah turned the Jews into pigs & monkeys Q 2 : 65 & 5 : 60, 7 : 163, rats are made from the Jews Sahih Al Bukhari, book 54, Hadith 524, cut the neck & fingers of the disbelievers Q 8 : 12 & 47 : 3 - 4, to kill the non muslims Sahih Al Bukhari Vo. I, p. 13, Q 9 : 14, to wipe out non muslims Q 6 : 44 - 45 & many more.
The turning point is in AD 624. Muhammad wanted to be accepted as their new prophet (the Jew were waiting for their Masiah & the Christian were waiting for the coming of Christ for the 2nd time). When they rejected him he turned against them. Muhammad quarrelled with the Jews in AD 624 in Medina. Muhammad chased, killed & expelled them out of the Arabian Peninsula.... W. Tidall, p. 39. In the same page says in the same year Muhammad performed his 1st 'Idu'l Adha. While the Jews slaughtered lambs Muhammad slaughtered 2 kids. One for his people & one for himself.
@@orvillosimon8531 Surah Fussilat 41 : 37 prohibiting muslim to worship sky objects (sun, moon, stars) is recited by Muhammad (because he's illiterate) 3-5 years (AD 613-615) after he proclaimed as a prophet of allah in AD 610. He copied the Jews' Tanak (Bible: the Old Testament) Exodus 20 : 4, Deuteronomy 4 : 19 & 17 : 3 that Yahweh, the God of Israel that's worshiped by Abraham, Ishaq & Yakub, forbids the Israelites to worship sky objects but Q 6 : 77 muslims used to worship the moon goddess 🌙 & Q 53 : 49 Sirius the brightest star used to be Allah.
William Tisdall says in his book "The Original Sources of the Qur'an - Its Origin In Pagan Legends and Mythology" during that time Muhammad followed some of Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabian belief and practices. At that time he was still befriended wth them. He had access to Jewish's, Christian's & the Sabians (ancient people of Mesopotamia (nowadays Iraq) until Syria) scriptures. He admitted the rightful Inhibitans of Israel in the Palestinian's land (Quran 5: 20-26), Jews & Christian are good friends. They'll go to heaven., but quran 5:82 to hate the Jews but Christians are the kindest to muslim, fight & slaughter the Jews (Sahih Muslim, Book 41, Hadith 6981 & 6985), quran 5:14 to hate Christians, quran 9:29 to fight theJews & Christias, 5 : 51, 1 : 7 the Christians & Jews are the cursed ones. Muhammad ordered muslims to pray 5x/ day to curse them, the Pact of Omar in AD 717, allah turned the Jews into pigs & monkeys Q 2 : 65 & 5 : 60, 7 : 163, rats are made from the Jews Sahih Al Bukhari, book 54, Hadith 524, cut the neck & fingers of the disbelievers Q 8 : 12 & 47 : 3 - 4, to kill the non muslims Sahih Al Bukhari Vo. I, p. 13, Q 9 : 14, to wipe out non muslims Q 6 : 44 - 45 & many more.
The turning point is in AD 624. Muhammad wanted to be accepted as their new prophet (the Jew were waiting for their Masiah & the Christian were waiting for the coming of Christ for the 2nd time). When they rejected him he turned against them. Muhammad quarrelled with the Jews in AD 624 in Medina. Muhammad chased, killed & expelled them out of the Arabian Peninsula.... W. Tidall, p. 39. In the same page says in the same year Muhammad performed his 1st 'Idu'l Adha. While the Jews slaughtered lambs Muhammad slaughtered 2 kids. One for his people & one for himself.
May Allah SWT bless our new Muslim brothers and sisters. Ameen.
AAAMIIN
Ameen
Brother just make it simple and the the Australian dude the Maula Ali was born in kabba sheriff. And Allah"s Prophet on the Gaddi ur khum had raise Maula Ali's hand and had declared him as a Wali.Mann kuntum maula far haaza Ali un Maula. Means who
@@rukshanaab999 yes seyid Ali is declared Waliyullah not a prophet .
The question was about our Muslim youth
Amin
A beautiful educational polite and factual response. Let’s focus on the similarities ❤ rather than the differences between us. At the end of the day we are one Ummah. ❤
I just know that I'm a Muslim who follows the Sunnah and the Quran as much as possible.. but definitely I am always falling to a sin. Alhamdullillah for we have a rabb who is so excessively merciful to forgive😢 , so right sir that all the believers are brothers and I do not think that I'm better than my brother,I love you all for the sake of ALLAH(swt). Respect to all my bro..
Respect brother Dr Yasir Qadhi
May Allah swt make it Easy for you to break away from the sins that are causing you so much grief and hurt, and erase all your sins and replace them with reward and bounty InshaAllah.
I am a shia Muslim and i liked the fact that he was transparent in delivering both sides ideologies.....ultimately we are one ummah of prophet Mohanmad sws with different interpretations of deen and shariya
Ayatollah Al-Khoei was a Chain Smoker. He said, *“Deen is Taqiyya & Taqiyya is MY DEEN.”*
Ayatollah Bahjat Foumani couldn’t even read Quran with proper Tajwid. He said, *“Only 3 Sahabah remain Muslim the rest apostate after the demise of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). Those 3 resulted in 500 million (Shi’ites) today. Taqiyya did all of this.”*
Ayatollah Sayyid -SEXTANI- Sistani said, *“Intrauterine insemination (IUI) - Getting Pregnant with a Stranger’s Sperm! is HALAL in Shi’ism.”*
May Allah SWT destroy the CURSED Imami Ithna’ Ashari Sect.
*Shia Fiqh* - Mut’ah Marriage (Shia Prostitution) is HALAL in Twelver Shi’ism. There are many Mut’ah Markets in Iran & Iraq. May Allah SWT destroy them.
@@MuhammadAbdullah-kx3kn um my dear muslim brother what are you talking about?
What is mut'ah marriage and markets?
@@MuhammadAbdullah-kx3kn youre a fitnah
@@MuhammadNafay I always speak the Haqq (Truth) even if it goes against my own self. Allahu Akbar ☝🕋
I grew up in Iran with Shia school of teaching and when I came to US I realized the majority of masajid are based on Sunni school of teaching. I did not find it difficult to practice my religion which is Islam in all of these masajid by adapting some of the norms of Sunni teaching. There is truly no major differences.
@@rastgo3231 برادر باید اختلافات را کنار گذاشت و علیه دشمن قدرتمند اسلام متحد شد.
@@rastgo3231 خود حضرت علی مخالف هرگونه دودستگی در امت بودند. امام حسن خلافت را رها کردند تا بتوانند از جنگ و خونریزی در امت جلوگیری کنند.حالا ما بعد از ۱۴۰۰ سال شدیم کاسه داغتر از آش.
no there is big different if u are shiah rafidah or imamiyah.
@@JohnWick-jz6yx what is the major difference?
@@rastgo3231 why do you not embrace Islam and leave the Shiite religion founded by Ibn Saba the Jew.
My daughter had asked me about shia because she met a shii imam whose position is like that of br. Yasir, I had explained the same things. Now I have sent this link to her . Very helpful. Young generation should listen to it.
shia are muslims
Subhan-Allah , and jazakh-Allah Sheikh for making me understand something very important. Originally I am from Fiji Islands, currently living in USA... Allhamdolillah. I really appreciate your message about unity in the end. That's how I was raised back in multiracial country of Fiji. We respected all religions and upon living in USA for past 30+ years, I came to understand, y religion better by Sheikh s like you. I am still learning something new every day. In-shaa-Allah, I will continue to learn till I die.... ameen.
I am from sunni your answer is satisfactory . Jezakallah kheyr. What will be the answer if this question wos asked the Shia folowers ?
SubhanAllah! JAZKALLAH Khair dear Dr Sh. YQ, extremely grateful to Allah SWT to be able to listen to this lecture of yours clarifying the difference s between sunni and Shia. Honestly I had asked so many people till now about the differences but nobody was able to clarify that for me with the facts....Like I have mentioned few times already that DR YQ and Mufti Menk are main anchors in my life with islamic knowledge and immense learnings..I wish and pray to Allah SWT to Grant them Jannatul firadaus..Ameen....
Many many many thanks EPic family for sharing so many good lectures really! May Allah SWT bless you with barakah and the reward...
Kindly kindly send my best wishes and lots of duas to DR Sh. YQ 🙏🏼🙌, 🤲
May Allah bless you, this video gives me such clearity.
Thank you for promoting tolerance and peace. Also the fact that so many Shia people watching this clip knowing it’s from a suni scholar shows that as a umah we are learning to unit more and more with the help of allah.
Thank you brother! May Allah swt bless you, your parents and your loved ones with the best in this life and the hereafter. Ameen. I am from the country of Habesha (Ethiopia) Darul hijreteyin.
Jazaakallahu khairan sheikh Yassir. You are one of the few leaders in the community who have the ability to bring people together. May Allah put baraka in all your efforts.
Thank you so much. May Allah preserve you for us. Ameen
Never heard such a good speech about Muslims. May Allah bless you brother.🤲
😮Mashah Allah. Excellent speech Sheikh. Leave it to Allah.
I am immensely impressed by this lecture and its clarity. But strongly feel that all sects be United to make
progressive and educated community.
Same here... he's such a huge asset to the community.
Yeh, lets unite on Kufur.
Perhaps let's also unite with al-Qaida
😂
@@drhasanjabir4193 parizad
@@drhasanjabir4193 I am sure we are on right path but the ones who has lack of knowledge about us have no fault because we failed to teach them about us 🤷🏻
@@drhasanjabir4193 Salam, I am alhamduliallah also a Shia Muslim and just want to say that I also completely have faith in your statements expect one, For us this is defiantly the path to paradise and if you have your akhlaq and practice haram and halal/wajibat then yes but THAT is our faith for sunnis they might be a different point of view and that is completely ok. In conclusion no shia or sunni should say they are right or on the right path because only Allah knows who's faith is right or wrong so just stick
my son listened to it today and loved it. I'm now listening to it.
I never knew the differences. Thank you for this informative lecture!
Those who call them self Shia or sunni can’t claim they are muslimeen chapter 3:102,103,104,105
Chapter 43:69
Chapter 45:6
Chapter 77:50
I am Sunni but look at all Muslims as my brothers and sisters
even shia?
Very clearly and precisely as always, may the Allah Most High reward you.
And the devils and politicians are always nearby and should be taken good care of!
As-salaamu Alaikum
I'm a Christian revert who was Sunni and now is Shia. I thought your lecture was the best from a Sunni source on the differences in Islam. Pragmatic tolerance is all we can do. Thanks for your honest words and may Allah (swt) bless the Ummah with unity at the right time.
Wait, are you a Christian or a Shia? And also, if you are Shia, what made you change sides?
Please try to adopt a simple Islamic lifestyle. To go towards Shisms is confusing especially related to 12-Imams; idolisation of Ali, Hassan, Hussein etc. Please research on the true teachings of Islam
Wa alaykumassalam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh
@@miketiong8441 shut up, its the sunni sects who are confused LOL! name the 12 caliphs that The prophet said will come after him then, LOL! ill wait . :)
Love you my shia brother. May Allah bless you.
Thank you for this lecture. 30 yrs revert Sunni, not knowing of differences then, have always wondered about the dilemma. Great to hear this analysis without defaming one or the other. A thin line to navigate on.
Ma Shaa Allah...
Well explained
Allah guide us all
His comments at about 36 minutes in are the key issue: both sides are ultimately working with historical narratives that contradict one another. And we easily forget that no one alive today was there to witness the events that are described in these books. As a convert to Islam who picked up a copy of the Qur’an- or rather, an explanation of it- making sense of this conflict, which is based on events described outside of the Qur’an, has been a real ordeal. It means being reborn i to a broken family. Everyone insists that their side is correct (naturally) but if we’re brutally honest, both sides are, for the most part, following what was passed down to them. Both stories were told to me at about the same time and not passed down from my family over centuries. At this point in my “career” as a Muslim, I say “aleyhisalam” when talking about the Ahlul Bayt but guess what? So did Imam Bukhari. I mourn Hussein (as) every Muharram, but not to the point of, say, thinking it’s not a good idea to get married during that month. I also say “radhiullahu anhu” to Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman, who were also members of the Prophet’s (S) family by marriage and, in Abu Bakr’s (ra) case, an ancestor of the sixth Imam, Jafar Sadiq (ra)- who was apparently a teacher of Imam Abu Hanifa. I hope to be able to study these issues more in depth but in the meantime, although there were some details that differed from what Shi’i brothers have told me, the Sheikh did a good job of addressing this and I will keep him my dua. May Allah reward him, and guide him and guide me and all of us. And with this issue especially, it’s good to remember to say “Allahu alim”. Salams from Utah (Which, on a far lighter note, I affectionately refer to as “Mormonistan”).
Also broski, I agree with most of the other points you brought forth. Also, please don't get offended by my msg (forgive me if you did). Take care! :)
Peace be upon you. As a revert to Islam myself I commend your efforts to make sense of a very sensitive and partisan issue. your background will stand you in good stead compared to a born Muslim who has family and society to worry about. You are simply after the truth and are not motivated by family heritage or any other legacy issues. You are fortunate to have found out about the Ahlulbayt, Imam Hussain and the Karbala so early on in your journey. I was Muslim for over 16 Years before I found out about Karbala, Imam Hussain, or even heard the term Ahlulbayt. I spent an entire year studying the differences in depth and alhamdulillah I chose to follow the path of Ahlulbayt. I had been sunni for most of my adult life so I have spent time in various communities/sects such as sufis, Tableeghis and even Deboandis. May Allah bring you and all of us back to Quran and Ahlulbayt - Wa Salaam
@@RocketAfriqueZA Aleykumselam brother, may Allah indeed help us all to understand the Ahlul Bayt as they ought to be understood and more importantly, love them as they ought to be loved- and may we all help each other in that journey.
Lol Mormonistan is very accurate, so you are actually a Mormon convert? If so then wow, I had a Mormon friend who disperately tried to convert me for more than a year and then gave up
@@fatality153 Indeed. I also tried (or more correctly, hoped) to convert a Muslim friend or two to Mormonism and it had the opposite effect! Alhamdulillah.
Being a Shia and watching this. A lot of respect given to Shias. Much respect to you this lecture has been very neutral and that’s amazing
@@marashimujtaba1 my comment is based on his overall representation to content in this video, which majority is pretty respectful
@@marashimujtaba1 I still think we are always quick to criticise on the little mistakes rather then look at the larger picture (especially in this video). It’s a job well done and no doubt the Imams are sinless and are of the purest form.
@@marashimujtaba1 not that I agree with Sunni doctrine fully but all prophets committed mistakes and repented . Our nabi was scolded by Allah several times . And yet all Shia Imams are infallible . They are above Mohammad ( pbuh) ?
@@afiahidrees5296 listen to the 18 lectures of mufti taha karaan about shiasm
@@marashimujtaba1 listen to the 18 lectures of shiasm by mufti taha karaan (r.a )
Mashallah this was a beautiful lesson. I really admire how u give the lecture. Tabarakallah
This was amazing. You have explained it in the best way possible. JazakAllah Khairan.
Thankyou for this answer... I was confused about as well... This bring me clarity about this subject. May Allah bless us all.
@@mortazaarefi537 All what you say is lies.
@@auzdeee Why are you so negative?
@@anjumanara3493 Truth is always positive
Very true .
Ameen Ya Rabbal Alameen
I’m a Shia and this is by far the best explanation with tolerance I have seen from a Sunni Scholar. Thank you Shaykh Yaasir.
U son of mutah?
@@kingofdetroit358 I don't think that's a nice comment. There was nothing wrong with what the poster said. There were no insults or foul language used. Please delete your comment.
@@WillScarlet1991 but mutah is not bad in Shia sect . So why bad comment
@@kingofdetroit358 its rude.. not appropriate language for a Muslim
Shaykh Ninowy's (a Sunni Scholar) explanation is actually, THE most tolerant, balanced and comprehensive that there is. Try to listen to a few of his series on historical events.,
Beautiful I'm a shia muslim and love the way you explain things what shia and what is sunni Stay Blessed I love Allah( SWT) and our beloved Phrophet (PBUH) and the Ahleibhat.
Masha'Allah. Great message of tolerance and unity. There are many more similarities between the Shia and Sunni and these must be celebrated and highlighted as a way to move forward. Keep up the good work!
Jazak Allah brother live long, it's a very good explanation between two sunny and shea learned so much from this speech 👏
This was an incisive and empathic delineation of the key differences between our sunni and shia brothers/sisters. Surely the most sensible way forward is one of pragmatic tolerance, continued dialogue, and as the community of Iqraa', furthering our edification and understanding of the palpable differences and similarities between us. In times of polarization, postmodernism and anti-Muslim pogroms (both real life and virtual), we must work together in the spirit of the Most Merciful and our most merciful habib, our beloved Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, and all that follow him.
The Quran said:
"Nothing was left out in the Quran "
This means all one needs is the Quran
No man made Sunni or Shia..
One Quran one faith
JazakAllah kher. Love the unbiased information. ❤
May Allah SWT bless him and all muslims. The concept of tolerance was soooo useful and cleared my many questions.
May Allah Swa bless you, alghamdulilah so beautifully said without no malicious comments. As a Sunni I too have a better understanding of the beliefs of the Shia. Shukran Sheikh 🌷
Mashallah what a beautiful lecture.
May Allah give jazaa to the sheikh and wisdom.
Alhamdulillah, I'm a Muslims. Not Sunny or Shia. "Hold the rope of Allah and do not be divided." There is no Sunni or Shia in the Quran.
Very very good lecture. Thank you so much. May Allah bless you and give you more wisdom.
May Allah with his mercy guide us all and grant us all jannah
Jazaka Allah kulla khayr Shaykh. Another knowledge aquired from you masha Allah.
The fact that most of us are literate makes a huge difference
And to listen with an open mind and accept and respect each other is most important
Thank you Sheikh. I'm from Iran, and I have heard about young Shia who feel like Shias get a lot of flack on the internet, and they feel depression from this because something they love so much gets put down, along with them, it's almost like bullying, but you doing this tries to clear the divide, and brings the ummah one step together. Very positive words thank you!
This is AWESOME!
Bless you!
God Loves You
Well presented on this delicate subject . May Allah protect you and your family. Ameen .
Very good and fair informative one with true facts.. May Allah grant you blessings
Wow masha'Allah sir. As a shia this was a very good lecture. may Allah guide us all. Ameen
Salaam.... mashaAllah very coherent & sincere explanation of major differences between the Shia and Sunni believe systems.
How could prophet Muhammad s.a.w leave his ummah without any leader knowing the fact that after such long struggle Islam had finally flourished n couldn't be left just at the mercy of people...
How many Shias of Ali r.a were presnt in battle of Badr, uhud, khandan, huanain, murah,Tabuk etc during the time of prophet s.a.w ?? How many Shias of Ali r.a were present in the battle of Yamaha (40000 led by false prophet musaylma and 13000 sahabas led by Abu Bakr r.a )?? How many Shias of Ali r.a were present in the battle of Yarmouk(sahabas against Roman Empire) and battle of qadisiyah (Sahabas against Persian Empire)??
How many Shias were presnet during conquest of North Africa, Sind led by Osman r.a ??? Shias of Ali dint participate in any of the battles but they appeared during the seige of Osman r.a and wanted to rule over muslims by taking the name of Ali r.a and his descendants...
Final sermon of Prophet pbuh declared and clealy mentioned " I am leavung Quran and my examples for you to لو upon"
no he said the quran and the his householders
Sunnis and Shias don't hate each other, only few among them. But in general Sunnis and Shias don't hate each other and are friends and sometimes marry each other.
If some Sunnis hate Shias (and vice versa) they're just making the enemies of Islam happy.
Asalaamu Aliakum Shaykh Yasir Qadihi, Alhumdulilah I am Revert Muslim sister for 20yrs now. Your one out of three favorite teachers of Islamic Theology of mine. You have given me clarity on this vital issue of my belief. My husband was a Sunnie Muslim,before returning to ALLAH, and that's all I know. Fortunately, TH-cam has been very good in presenting me, in the beginning of my quest for knowledge, with Scholars of Sunni perspective. I have listened to two other teachers on this matter, Alhumdulilah, you have given me detailed information that wasn't confusing as the former lessons I've endured. JazkAllah Khair for presenting your lesson in an elementary level. I, being 6? years young, would get the complete understanding I desired when you announced that your presentation would be on a level that a newly😅 Reverted teenager could understand. You are an excellent teacher with excellent skills of giving historical fact that I appreciate so much. 🤲🏿May☝🏿ALLAH ble$$🌻you and your
L💓ved ones, keep you safe, healthy, productive, prosperou$, and guide us all to the
straight🕋path
🙏🏿Ameen🙏🏿
Anyone who hates the companions of our beloved Prophet saws is not from us. Live in peace but know our loyalties lie with Allah, His Messenger, and family of Prophet and the companions of the Prophet.
The problem is that sunni books tell us that sahaba changed the religion and thats why there is no baraka
Narrated ‘Abdullah: The Prophet said, “I am your predecessor at the Lake-Fount”. ‘Abdullah added: The Prophet said, “I am your predecessor at the Lake-Fount, and some of you will be brought in front of me till I will see them and then they will be taken away from me and I will say, ‘O Lord, my companions!’ It will be said, ‘you do not know what they did after you had left.’ Sahih Bukhari, Volume 8 Hadith 578
Narrated Ibn ‘Abbas: When the time of the death of the Prophet approached while there were some men in the house, and among them was ‘Umar Ibn al-Khatttab, the Prophet said: "Come near let me write for you a writing after which you will never go astray.”‘Umar said: "The Prophet is seriously ill, you have the Qur’an, so Allah’s Book is sufficient for us.” The people in the house differed and disputed. Some of them said, "Come near so that Allah’s Apostle may write for you a writing after which you will not go astray,”while the others said what ‘Umar said. When they made much noise and quarreled greatly in front of the Prophet, he said to them, "Go away and leave me.”Ibn ‘Abbas used to say, "It was a great disaster that their quarrel and noise prevented Allah’s Apostle from writing a statement for them.
Sahih al-Bukhari Hadiths: 9.468 and 7.573
@@spiderlocyugo wrong. Nothing about changing the religion in first Hadith. There's a another Hadith saying my ummah.
And the second Hadith was on a Thursday. The Prophet died 3 days later and even gave a khutbah, if it was so important, then he would say it
Try again rafidhi
@@badalrana10 Soo if the Prophet says you Will never go astray and you dont care??? They Will follow the same path as the sahaba of Musa as and Isa as changing.
@@badalrana10 maybe thats why all the wars after the Prophet left and no mention of ahlul bayt in sunni islam???
@@badalrana10 😂 A boom in the forehead, these Rawafid follow their whims and desires, they disbelieve the Companions, may Allah pleased them, and cite some of their hadith, well done bro. 👍
Assalamu Alaikum 🤲🏻
May Allah Almighty make it easy on us all.Ameen ,Ameen,Ameen my brother your words and advice are so so easy to understand.
الله اکبر
Masha Allah so beautifully explained. This is so informative for both youngsters and adults. So simply explained making it easy to understand. Jazzak Allah Khayran for this.
From this lecture it is clear that Sunni muslims are in the right path.
Not really, he is not stating the facts for why Shia believe the things they do and pretty much just saying them. I'm not saying that he is being biased towards sunni but most of the points he talk about are things Shia believe but he does not go into the facts of why they believe it. Like he doesn't explain why Shias believe the prophet appointed Ali as his succesor but rather just states it.
No hate has position just love and respect all human been
Thats what allah loves
Well done brother yasir, you definitely tried hard to be as objective as possible, amazing effort May allah bless you and guide us all 🙏🏻
Ameeen suma ameeen
I am Sunni and never knew the fundamental differences. Shukran for sharing this knowledge for our understanding May Allah swt reward you abundantly Ameen
Allahu Akbar.
Thank you so much for this lecture. I have for a very long time taken this stand you talked about today and I am very happy to know that I am not alone on this side of the coin which can foster peace.
I respect your integrity. I have conducted a comparative study between the Sunni and Shia for more than 10 years. This is the first time for me to hear someone from the Sunni group presenting the facts as they are. You are a real Scientist guided by logic. Thank you for your honesty. God bless you !
_Attend the lectures of Ashraf Ghareeb to study more_
I am a Christian and have listened to this lengthy discussion to be more enlightened on this subject. I enjoin you not just to preach pragmatic tolerance of other Islamic sects but pragmatic tolerance of all human beings and their faiths.
You said that the Quran recognizes the diversity of peoples and nationalities, doesn't it recognize the diversity of faith? I truly appreciate your call for intolerance of clerics promoting hatred.
They are the supporters of those causing so much pain, killings and afflictions all over the world. This face of Islam is worrisome and undesirable for humanity.
@@olufunmilayoogunsi7622 I think he was answering a specific question about Sunni and Shia. The form and approach of his answer could probably be applied to questions about relations with other faith groups. In fact he has had respectful dialog with Christian pastors. Do all Muslims engage with this level of balance and civility? Unfortunately not. Nor do all members of other faith communities. May we all avail ourselves of the spiritual practices or prayers of our respective traditions and strive to do better with each other.
@@kevinmogg6379 I am muslim I share your ideas very much becuse it's a reality
Masha Allah nice simple suit
May Allah give you a blessing long life so that you can carry on with what you are doing
Dear brother Yasir Qazi.
Assalamu Aliekum. Thanking you in anicipation for the great cause you are serving to this dividend UMMAH. It is very imperative to Clarify this complicated, controversial, subject to the masses. May Allah SWT reward you immensely for this great job.
We pray for your good, healthy, and long life.Take care.
Thank you, this was very balanced. I appreciate your intellectual honesty.
Allah give u lot of jazza for explaining the difference, it's a reality, we need to accept and move forward Ameen.
Alhamdulillah to be A Muslim,Thank You Our Brother,Interesting Da'awa, from Ethiopia 🇪🇹.
MashaAllah well stated. A speech that is neutral and unbiased. Jazakallahul kheir.
I love this video, I’m so glad that I came across this.
I wish all the muslims could listen to this and especially the end of this video.
Jazakallahu khair for this answer 👌❤️ Best answer a Sunni scholer can give for this question
Explicitly explained. JazakAllah kheiran Kaseera .
I am Sunni, having lots of respect for all Ahle-Bait. JazakaAllah, for teaching our teens and youth regarding the change of views (different lense) which is existing.
you have no respect to Ahle-Bait. , because you love their killers
I have to admit, this is the most sophisticated mature answer I have ever heard. Mashallah Sheikh, we need so much more people like you. ❤
I am an Iranian living in Canada; in my search for an accurate and possibly easier to understand English translation of Quran for my children I came across your video in you tube. I enjoyed your teaching, your message and learned about the differences of shia and sunni. I will certainly listen to your other teachings to learn more about Islam. I was born Muslim but I can not claim I am Muslim until I become one that Quran describes. Thank you for your explanation of these differences not just for teenagers but also for older people like me. Your efforts not just helps us to learn more about our own religion but will also help none Muslims to have a better understanding of Islam. What Iranian government did/does in the name of Islam had a big negative impact on the Iranian 's faith as well as the world views of Islam. God bless you and all scholars like you in your ways.
ive noticed a lot of iranians that are in the west are secular and dont identify with religion because there was a rebellion and many iranians didnt want the laws in iran, insha allah they come back to islam
@@z4kry44 Iranian living in Iran are more religious than the ones outside of Iran, but also other Middle Eastern people in the USA tend to be more secular in comparison to the ones in the M.E
@@agostocobain2729 i disagree with what you said about other middle eastern people, most of the middle eastern people in america are religious and actually lots of arabs living in middle eastern lands are secular
@@z4kry44 in Iran people tend to get religious when they reach 40, that’s why you see aunts, uncles,grandparents, etc. praying fasting and going to hajj, and we call those older people hajj agah. I’m also Turkish and Turkey now is super secular. I never been to Iran though unfortunately. I’m born and raised in Los Angeles and my friends are Egyptians and you’re right, they are religious. I love them best friends to have Egyptians.
Dear Dr. Yasir,
Thank you so much for your respectful explanation of both theologies. I appreciate the way you presented this issue because at this time, many of the representors of Islam only address this issue in a subjective, harsh, and hateful way.
May Allah bless you and the Islamic community 🙏🏻❤
JezakAllah Dr. Yasir you explained it well! I am a Sunni Muslima!
You are the most knowledgeable, sophisticated, unbiased speaker or IMAM I shld say to both (Shia & Sunnis). love listening your lectures. You are a g8 asset for the younger generation.
May Allah be with you.
I am a Sunni- from Aust.
Assalamualaikum sir. Thanks for giving such information on very important subject which I never knew earlier.
Mashallah, I really enjoyed the lecture
Now more than ever we need the ummah to be united!! Please share this
JazakiAllahukhaerian Sheih
Br. Sajeed, gave right question, my country 100% Sunni Muslims, that why I didn’t know Muslims separated to Sunni and Sheia, I was confused too
Then one of Imam talk about history of Islam, (I advised read history , you will understand why became sunniu and sheia
I am agree we can not blem Sheia- we all Muslims no matter Cristina and Jew - we should respect each other- how Dr Yaseer said that between them and God
AlhamdilAllah I am sunni muslim and worshipping Allah SWT and his messengers and last messenger our prophet Muhammad RAW