I am a Bangladeshi and I've finished almost all the videos of this series. You are the only Pakistani who described all the events from different perspectives with a neutral point of view. Huge respect for you.... May God bless you.
Iam very sorry for all the acts which our militants and political group have done to Bengals. Currently these exploitation is happening with our pashtoons ethnicity.
@@pranavkumar3782 I am from Bangladesh 🇧🇩.you are a West Bengali Hindhu and Third class citizenships in Hindhustan 😂😂. Tum kudki lia soco. Baluchistan ak desert land ha and Baluch 80 Lakh ha.
One thing many historian lost sight of was Bengal ( unpartitioned) had seen many reforms in religious, literature & cultural fields which was not the case in West-Pakistan.
sir, love ur lectures awesome art of expression. last year internet was shut here I went to Delhi downloaded ur lectures on Plato Aristotle. kant.etc love from Srinagar
You are a great intellectual of our country. I have been watching your videos and following you for last couple of years and I find your videos very informative. thank you for such nice work. I am a medicine guy...and your videos are an aspiration for me to persue and study political history of Pakistan.
Can you do this lectures with english subtitles please so that no Urdu speaking like me can understand perfectly. I'm from Bangladesh btw. Understood like 60-70% of it and I liked your talks.
Please i beg of you to do a video on the history and current crises of middle east. It is so complicated and TH-cam is fraught with the videos but one is still devoid of any cogent understanding of Middle East. We need someone like you to do a video series on the history and current crises of the Middle East.
I'm Bangladeshi . We had no similarities with the Pakistanis except for the only religious similarities. The country was under military rule. The Bengalis did not have the slightest bit of power in their hands. Development progress was happening all over Pakistan
Well there are two type of Pakistanis with different type of views, first type is of the people (including me) who think that we lost East Pakistan because of our own negligence. Let me explain it: Bengalis wanted Bengali as the official language of the country but West Pakistanis rejected it on the basis that it would raise ethinism. This point was true but the main thing which provoked Bengalis was the killing of 12 Bengalis students when they were protesting our Urdu as national language. This was the reason why we celebrate International language day on 21 February. They stated that the single largest Pakistani export is Jute and the largest part of Budget spending is military. There is no major border issue with India on the East Pakistan side. So Bengali wealth was being transfered to West Pakistan. Which was in fact was true. In West Pakistan the number of education and health care facilities increased by 160% where as in East Pakistan the increase was only 33%. The per capita income in W.P was 313 or around it and while in the E.P it was around 280 or around it. The toofan Bola which killed 5 million people in east Pakistan was like the final nail in the coffin. India was the first country to provide aid to E.P and Bengalis were offended to know that the aid too would come not by air but much slowly by road. Not accepting the 1970 election result was the final event to turn it upside down for W.P. Now the second type of Pakistanis they put the whole blame on India’s intervention totally forgetting the human rights violation W.P has made in E.P. In one of Pakistan’s textbook I found a very hilarious thing regarding the separation. Punjab Textbook Board published the following text on the causes for the separation of East Pakistan in 1993 for secondary classes. There were a large number of Hindus in East Pakistan. They had never truly accepted Pakistan. A large number of them were teachers in schools and colleges. They continued creating a negative impression among students. No importance was attached to explaining the ideology of Pakistan to the younger generation. The Hindus sent a substantial part of their earnings to Bharat, thus adversely affecting the economy of the province. Some political leaders encouraged provincialism for selfish gains. They went around depicting the central Government and (the then) West Pakistan as enemy and exploiter. Political aims were thus achieved at the cost of national unity.
i am the first one and completely accept that it was our fault....still we are not learning any lesson from our past and keep doing the same mistake in balochistan,fata gilgit baltista and azad kashmir....same things happening that to declare traitors to those who are demanding for their rights in these regions......
Agreed and the things like “there were a lot of Hindu teachers etc ...” were still there in syllabus of Punjab Text Book till 2012. I don’t know about current situation
There is no doubt that it was our fault who neglected the major portion of our country but Indian involvement can't be undermine as well. There is no surprise to that because that's what enemy do. But first it was our fault, which let this happen at the first place by thwarting the voices of their rights.
Hi Dr. Taimur, please I have to ask you if you could do this series again for english speaker to be able to reach a wider audience. This subject is very interesting
@@Taimur_Laal May I suggest using of AI technology for subtitles/translation? If you post some request online, I am sure many Pak CS students/experts will volunteer their help.
@@Taimur_Laal taimur Bhai Jo julum app ko Kia he hamara sadh Allah app look maf nahi karega Mera baba Jo bola 1971 app ko hamara sadh app look Muslim kehe te BHI hum ko saram atahe
Please if possible make a program on Kazi Nazrul Islam . There is nothing I have heard so beautiful and so power so rebellious in my life of 55 years. I have read so many poem's of Allama Ikbal and many others but I never found any poet like Kazi Nazrul Ialam (THE REBAL POET). His works showcase an intense rebellion against oppression of humans through slavery, hatred and tradition. His poems on poverty, injustice, politics, love, women's freedom even on suffering and tears of the prostitutes and persecution. His each poems is so different and so unique than the others. He was silenced by the British in prison and lived and as poor and never accepted nothing from no one .
☆☆ سانحہ ء مشرقی پاکستان ☆☆ ☆☆ اک رنج اٹھائے ہوئے پھرتے ہیں کاندھے ۔ ☆☆ اک زخم کہ بھرنے کو آتا نہیں کب سے ۔ ۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔ شاعرہ ::::: فوزیہ بشیر علوی ۔ 🇵🇰🍀🌼✒
Oh it takes so long to do that. Frankly, easier to remake the series in English. But sometimes my Indian comrades add subtitles. The first video of Marxism and the Modern World is out. You can watch that now.
خیر ہم نے ماضی میں جو غلطی کی سو کی۔ مگر اب بھی ہم بجائے ماضی سے سبق سیکھنے کے نتائج سے آنکھیں موڑے وہی غلطی دوبارہ دھرا رہے ہیں۔ ا ب بھی کئی صوبے و شہروں میں احساس محرومیاں بنگالیوں کی طرح بڑھتی جا رہی ہیں۔
Feeling spellbound, i guess i will have to watch it again and again to assimilate the precious truth into the very structure of brain veins...hats off to you sir! ✌️
very informative video dr sahib..always admire your efforts of educating the public in a very simple and concise way... I have a question related to this video ...what is the stand of Laal and Mazdor Kisan Party about Saraiki belt and their separate identity based on Language,culture etc everything...?
p.s.: Bengal was not part of the geographical variables of original "Pakistan equation" as proposed by Chowdhuray Rahmat Ali in 1933. In that sense, current Pakistan is closest to what was envisioned by Mr Ali decade before Lahore resolution.
You are right. Actually original plan was to form Pakistan in north west of India which was Muslim majority area. But that included whole Punjab and Jammu & Kashmir also. And in the east it was plan to form independent united Bengal state which would be another Muslim majority state in East of India. But congress with the help of British govt divided Punjab and Bengal, which was a blunder by Muslim league to accept this demand
It's one thing to be an expert on a topic, and a completely different thing to have the ability to express it in a language that a common man understands. Sir, you have excelled in this regard. Being an Indian I totally agree with how you have painstakingly put forth the DNA of a Bengali. Even today they don't take shit from anyone...and take pride in carrying out peoples' movements!!
بہت انفورمیٹیو۔ اک دو باتوں پہ آپ کی رائے لینا چاہوں گا۔ اک تو آپ نے فرمایا کہ ڈھاکہ فائرنگ واقع نئی ریاست کا پہلا ایسا انسیڈنٹ تھا لیکن میرے خیال میں اس بہت پہلے ہی بھابھڑا بازار واقع سے یہ نوزائیدہ ریاست یہ پیغام دے چکی تھی کہ مستقبل میں عوام کس طرح کے سلوک کی توقع رکھیں۔ دوسری بات مجھے حیرت ہوئی کہ کس طرح آپ نے بھارت سے آنے والی اردو سپیکنگ لاٹ کی ہٹ دھرمی کو مکمل استثنا دے دیا۔ جب کہ حقیقت یہ ہے کہ یہی لاٹ پہلے 10 سال پاکستان کے سیاہ سفید کی مالک تھی اور وہ پورے پاکستان پہ اپنا کلچر اور اقدار زبردستی تھوپنا چاہتی تھی۔
Hi Mr Laa, following is a link for Translation service, designed especially for TH-cam content creators. All you need is to upload your clips, and then follow few steps. I look forward to understand your work. But I still wish I could speak Urdu/Hindi. Mai samjha thora thora, lekin enough nehi.
Dr Taimur Rahman, I am a Bangladeshi who was born in Pakistan and speak fluent Urdu. After listening to your Lectures in Philosophy,, world history etc. which were very informative, I listened to your series on East Pakistan to Bangladesh. I must say that you are a wonderful teacher and when you speak Urdu, it seems pearls are dropping from your mouth. I live in the US and have referred so.e of my friends to your lectures, However, not one could understand your Urdu as I could sincec they grew up in Bangladesh. Do consider doing this series ini. English for my daughters and grandchildren. interviews and podcasts. PS. Please, please, do pronounce Bangladesh correctly. Baangladesh. Bangla the way you pronounce it, means a building in Urdu. Here, Bangla is our language. You are an extraordinarily brave and learned individual. Hats off to you!
There's nothing brave about someone from pakistan talking about bangladesh, i seriously find it super funny that bangladeshis think it'd be an uncommon thing in pakistan to acknowledge our part in making of bangladesh. Dude, this has become way too common. In fact some other ppl totally exaggerate things, this professor on the contrary is totally rational. He's quoting a lot of facts.
To be honest, i never liked ur program. I always found u in a debate mode wherein u would highlight only ur view point. This is the first video where i got many angles to view the separation of East Pakistan. Thank you
Urdu was not the language of any of the provinces of East or West Pakistan. In fact in West Pakistan the Punjab had Punjabi, Sindh had Sindhi, Baluchistan had Baluchi, Brahvi and Pushto, NWFP had Pushto, and Hindko, and East Pakistan had Bengali languages. Urdu was the language of Indian Muslims who migrated from India to West Pakistan, and maybe because it was understood by majority of the Indian Muslims, Quaid i Azam might have thought to adopt it as national language.
Another reason for Bangali’s not accepting Urdu as the only national language was due to the writing style, urdu is easy to read and understand for all ethnicities in west pakistan as it is closed to Arabic style of writing even some words are common and have similar meaning, but Bengali is writing is similar to Hindi and have nothing common with Arabic or Urdu, so it also give unfair advantage to west Pakistanis
Your Pakistani army and with the collaborators of Pakistan, failed to understand and estimate the spirit and strength of Bengal. Blaming India was their political propaganda which was baseless. The liberation war was literally turned into a ethnic clinging genocide in Bengal. I am from Bangladesh seeing you and hearing from you. Thanks.
اچھی بات ہے مگر اپ خود بھی اس کے بارے میں سیک سکتے ہے ۔۔۔یا اپ کو rahimia institute of quranic science youtoub channel ko subscrib کرنا چاہئے ۔۔۔اور ساتھ کلاس join kegy...thakns
I am from Lahore and I want to apologize to all my Bangali brothers. Pakistan was born from the womb of British colonialism and remains a country captured by the elite. You got out. We still live in oppression.
What a beautiful explanation of the facts about our Bangladeshi brothers and sisters. Israel is another state which came in to being in the name of religion however there is a lot of emphasis on Hebrew language and culture. We Punjabis have a problem we have labeled Pathans, Sindhis etc as lesser human beings, we still laugh at their language accent, look how Western Punjabi makes fun of Eastern Punjabi, Pakistani Punjabi elite has damaged the unity of Pakistan in 1971 and it continues to damage Pakistan by not being able to work with political parties of Pakistan. We are moving to a very dangerous direction.
Nice discussion. But not being an Urdu speaker i think i managed to absorb only 60-65% of the lecture. Is it possible to provide english subtitle to the lecture? Not just this video but all the videos of this channel.
May I request you post some of your videos with English sub-titles? I am being selfish, because I don't understand Urdu/Hindi. Time to learn I suppose, but till then, English sub-titles would be great.
ARAB ISRAEL CONFLICT was indeed a great work ov yours,but history & creation ov KSA & al_e_saud was missing in that. Please enlighten us on this topic. Regards
Being a Bangladeshi, I must appreciate your late acknowledgement. Pakistan now is a fail state, don't know when you stop begging. Above all, I hope and believe, your recent realization will help you out to overcome the present situation.
Isn't quite harsh? One thing we need to keep into our mind, the crisis of the mass people of Bangladesh, India, and Pakistan is the same. Contradictions between the ruling class and mass are almost the same in Indopakbengal. Mainly perception of religion and ultra-nationalism are the two main elements creating constant obstacles to the development of the hole jurisdiction. My
Balochistan k logon k pass access to internet nhi he s wajah se lockdown k ethno deno baad b balochistan k universities online classes arrange nhi kr parhi ha or digital Pakistan vision ka main priority ha " treat access to internet and the knowledge that comes with it as a fundamental right for all Pakistanis" tu keya hm baloch Pakistani nhi ha jo hme a right nhi di ja rahi he ...serf quetta mn baloch rehthe un k pass access to internet he baki s right se mehrom ha
@@ahsanagha8862 hame taraqi nazar nhi aati Gawadar bht important city ha jab ap wahan jaenge tu ap ko pata chalega k wahan k local logon klea kuch b nhi horaha ha
Very interesting and illuminating programme, but need a bit of historical correction. Kh Nazimuddin, Suhrawardi and Mohd Ali Bogra were not ethnic bengalis. There were Urdu speskers, settled in Bengal during Mughal rule as In other states like Nizam of Hyderabad. The above three Pakustani PM's and their families did play a very significant role in Bengal politics.
Although I understand why, but it's unfortunate that many Pakistanis consider only Bangladeshis, erstwhile East Pakistanis, their brothers/sisters. They forget that Indians are their brothers and sisters too, at least they were till 1947. Bangladesh-India-Pakistan--legacy of a broken and dysfunctional family dynamic; yet, however dysfunctional it was till 1947, the promise of a greater Sub-continental brotherhood was never hollow and was never without substance. All they needed some sincere, optimistic and visionary leaders when the Raj was closing shops. How sad it is that they allowed few foreigners and merely handful of leading politicians to decide on behalf of more than a billion and still allow them to dictate how they should hate each other.
इतिहास समाज का परिदृश्य और सभी प्रकार की समाजिक कृतियां राजनीतिक स्थिति और सत्य के आधार पर विवेचना करना आपकी महानता को और बढ़ा देता है | यही सत्य के आधार पर साहित्य और इतिहास का सत्य वर्णन कर्ता का कार्य होता है | जिसके लिए धर्म यह किस देश का है ..यह होना अनिवार्य नहीं |
I am a Bangladeshi and I've finished almost all the videos of this series. You are the only Pakistani who described all the events from different perspectives with a neutral point of view. Huge respect for you.... May God bless you.
Iam very sorry for all the acts which our militants and political group have done to Bengals. Currently these exploitation is happening with our pashtoons ethnicity.
@@OFFROADVLOGGING you are doing same to baluch
thanks for information
@@OFFROADVLOGGING Now-a-days Pashtuns what Bengalis faced from 1947 to 1971.
@@pranavkumar3782 I am from Bangladesh 🇧🇩.you are a West Bengali Hindhu and Third class citizenships in Hindhustan 😂😂. Tum kudki lia soco.
Baluchistan ak desert land ha and Baluch 80 Lakh ha.
Unbiased, insightful lectures. Love from 🇧🇩
Excellently researched. Thanks.
From Bangladesh.
One thing many historian lost sight of was Bengal ( unpartitioned) had seen many reforms in religious, literature & cultural fields which was not the case in West-Pakistan.
sir, love ur lectures
awesome art of expression.
last year internet was shut here I went to Delhi downloaded ur lectures on Plato Aristotle. kant.etc
love from Srinagar
Say safe brother in corona lockdown. Love from Kolkata.
Brilliant. Thank you so much for making a video on this topic. :) 🙏
You are a great intellectual of our country. I have been watching your videos and following you for last couple of years and I find your videos very informative. thank you for such nice work. I am a medicine guy...and your videos are an aspiration for me to persue and study political history of Pakistan.
مختصر، جامع اور مستند لیکچر۔ زبردست۔
Watching from Bangladesh. 😍
SIR you are sharing the facts and knowledge in very simple way .THANKS SIR
Very informative and detailed video...u really is awaesom
Can you do this lectures with english subtitles please so that no Urdu speaking like me can understand perfectly. I'm from Bangladesh btw. Understood like 60-70% of it and I liked your talks.
Please i beg of you to do a video on the history and current crises of middle east. It is so complicated and TH-cam is fraught with the videos but one is still devoid of any cogent understanding of Middle East. We need someone like you to do a video series on the history and current crises of the Middle East.
I'm Bangladeshi .
We had no similarities with the Pakistanis except for the only religious similarities. The country was under military rule. The Bengalis did not have the slightest bit of power in their hands. Development progress was happening all over Pakistan
Well there are two type of Pakistanis with different type of views, first type is of the people (including me) who think that we lost East Pakistan because of our own negligence. Let me explain it:
Bengalis wanted Bengali as the official language of the country but West Pakistanis rejected it on the basis that it would raise ethinism. This point was true but the main thing which provoked Bengalis was the killing of 12 Bengalis students when they were protesting our Urdu as national language. This was the reason why we celebrate International language day on 21 February.
They stated that the single largest Pakistani export is Jute and the largest part of Budget spending is military. There is no major border issue with India on the East Pakistan side. So Bengali wealth was being transfered to West Pakistan. Which was in fact was true.
In West Pakistan the number of education and health care facilities increased by 160% where as in East Pakistan the increase was only 33%.
The per capita income in W.P was 313 or around it and while in the E.P it was around 280 or around it.
The toofan Bola which killed 5 million people in east Pakistan was like the final nail in the coffin. India was the first country to provide aid to E.P and Bengalis were offended to know that the aid too would come not by air but much slowly by road.
Not accepting the 1970 election result was the final event to turn it upside down for W.P.
Now the second type of Pakistanis they put the whole blame on India’s intervention totally forgetting the human rights violation W.P has made in E.P. In one of Pakistan’s textbook I found a very hilarious thing regarding the separation.
Punjab Textbook Board published the following text on the causes for the separation of East Pakistan in 1993 for secondary classes.
There were a large number of Hindus in East Pakistan. They had never truly accepted Pakistan. A large number of them were teachers in schools and colleges.
They continued creating a negative impression among students. No importance was attached to explaining the ideology of Pakistan to the younger generation.
The Hindus sent a substantial part of their earnings to Bharat, thus adversely affecting the economy of the province. Some political leaders encouraged provincialism for selfish gains. They went around depicting the central Government and (the then) West Pakistan as enemy and exploiter. Political aims were thus achieved at the cost of national unity.
i am the first one and completely accept that it was our fault....still we are not learning any lesson from our past and keep doing the same mistake in balochistan,fata gilgit baltista and azad kashmir....same things happening that to declare traitors to those who are demanding for their rights in these regions......
Agreed and the things like “there were a lot of Hindu teachers etc ...” were still there in syllabus of Punjab Text Book till 2012. I don’t know about current situation
There is no doubt that it was our fault who neglected the major portion of our country but Indian involvement can't be undermine as well. There is no surprise to that because that's what enemy do. But first it was our fault, which let this happen at the first place by thwarting the voices of their rights.
💯 ✅
Hindus sent their earning to Bharat? To whom? Jamai? You are not Sweet Princess, you are dumb princess
Very instructive & informative .
Love from Dhong ,Gujerkhan
Subhan Allah bohat khob ....plz Balochistan ky maslay ka bhi aisa hi tajziyati video banain.shukriya.
Hi Dr. Taimur, please I have to ask you if you could do this series again for english speaker to be able to reach a wider audience. This subject is very interesting
It is a lot of work. But I'll see what I can do.
@@Taimur_Laal
English subtitle could be add to understand in English.
@@Taimur_Laal May I suggest using of AI
technology for subtitles/translation? If you post some request online, I am sure many Pak CS students/experts will volunteer their help.
@@Taimur_Laal taimur Bhai Jo julum app ko Kia he hamara sadh Allah app look maf nahi karega Mera baba Jo bola 1971 app ko hamara sadh app look Muslim kehe te BHI hum ko saram atahe
@@Taimur_Laal app ka Pakistani army ne hamara 3lakh ma behen ke rape kia bhir BHI app look khud ko Muslim kehe te saram nahi atihe
Your explanation is very deep, intense and historic. Its really knowledgeable. Thanks from a Bangladeshi Bengali.
Please if possible make a program on Kazi Nazrul Islam . There is nothing I have heard so beautiful and so power so rebellious in my life of 55 years. I have read so many poem's of Allama Ikbal and many others but I never found any poet like Kazi Nazrul Ialam (THE REBAL POET). His works showcase an intense rebellion against oppression of humans through slavery, hatred and tradition. His poems on poverty, injustice, politics, love, women's freedom even on suffering and tears of the prostitutes and persecution. His each poems is so different and so unique than the others. He was silenced by the British in prison and lived and as poor and never accepted nothing from no one .
Thank you for making unbiased content and sharing with the us.
Love this - we need more of this kind of education
At last someone spoke.
Hts of 2 u sir
☆☆ سانحہ ء مشرقی پاکستان ☆☆
☆☆ اک رنج اٹھائے ہوئے پھرتے ہیں کاندھے ۔
☆☆ اک زخم کہ بھرنے کو آتا نہیں کب سے ۔
۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔
شاعرہ ::::: فوزیہ بشیر علوی ۔
🇵🇰🍀🌼✒
Sir please upload remaining lectures of das capital.
Any plans to add english captions? I loved the PEP lectures and learned so much. (and looking forward to the Marxism in the Modern World series)
Oh it takes so long to do that. Frankly, easier to remake the series in English. But sometimes my Indian comrades add subtitles. The first video of Marxism and the Modern World is out. You can watch that now.
Not at all. Watch the entire series and then tell me if there is even an iota of hate for anyone.
خیر ہم نے ماضی میں جو غلطی کی سو کی۔ مگر اب بھی ہم بجائے ماضی سے سبق سیکھنے کے نتائج سے آنکھیں موڑے وہی غلطی دوبارہ دھرا رہے ہیں۔ ا ب بھی کئی صوبے و شہروں میں احساس محرومیاں بنگالیوں کی طرح بڑھتی جا رہی ہیں۔
Feeling spellbound, i guess i will have to watch it again and again to assimilate the precious truth into the very structure of brain veins...hats off to you sir! ✌️
Excellent analysis!
From someone who saw the breakup of United Pakistan.
very informative video dr sahib..always admire your efforts of educating the public in a very simple and concise way... I have a question related to this video ...what is the stand of Laal and Mazdor Kisan Party about Saraiki belt and their separate identity based on Language,culture etc everything...?
sir as usual once again tremendous video
Sir you are doing great job. I am no words to compliments your job. I am a great fan of you.
Sir 2nd part.... patiently awaiting
p.s.: Bengal was not part of the geographical variables of original "Pakistan equation" as proposed by Chowdhuray Rahmat Ali in 1933. In that sense, current Pakistan is closest to what was envisioned by Mr Ali decade before Lahore resolution.
You are right. Actually original plan was to form Pakistan in north west of India which was Muslim majority area. But that included whole Punjab and Jammu & Kashmir also. And in the east it was plan to form independent united Bengal state which would be another Muslim majority state in East of India. But congress with the help of British govt divided Punjab and Bengal, which was a blunder by Muslim league to accept this demand
আমার সোনার বাংলা 🇧🇩
Thank you sir.
Tui to sala Indian 😂
@@md.muzahedulislamrifat5982ামারের বাইচ্ছা, গালি দেখে 😊নিশ্চয় বুঝতে পেরেছেন আমি কোন দেশের নাগরিক।।
This is not only Pakistan history but also Bangladesh history.
Very nice and reality of history video from karachi
It's one thing to be an expert on a topic, and a completely different thing to have the ability to express it in a language that a common man understands. Sir, you have excelled in this regard. Being an Indian I totally agree with how you have painstakingly put forth the DNA of a Bengali. Even today they don't take shit from anyone...and take pride in carrying out peoples' movements!!
بہت انفورمیٹیو۔ اک دو باتوں پہ آپ کی رائے لینا چاہوں گا۔ اک تو آپ نے فرمایا کہ ڈھاکہ فائرنگ واقع نئی ریاست کا پہلا ایسا انسیڈنٹ تھا لیکن میرے خیال میں اس بہت پہلے ہی بھابھڑا بازار واقع سے یہ نوزائیدہ ریاست یہ پیغام دے چکی تھی کہ مستقبل میں عوام کس طرح کے سلوک کی توقع رکھیں۔
دوسری بات مجھے حیرت ہوئی کہ کس طرح آپ نے بھارت سے آنے والی اردو سپیکنگ لاٹ کی ہٹ دھرمی کو مکمل استثنا دے دیا۔ جب کہ حقیقت یہ ہے کہ یہی لاٹ پہلے 10 سال پاکستان کے سیاہ سفید کی مالک تھی اور وہ پورے پاکستان پہ اپنا کلچر اور اقدار زبردستی تھوپنا چاہتی تھی۔
You’re absolutely right and going well so far but where is part-2 🤔?
Hi Mr Laa, following is a link for Translation service, designed especially for TH-cam content creators.
All you need is to upload your clips, and then follow few steps. I look forward to understand your work. But I still wish I could speak Urdu/Hindi. Mai samjha thora thora, lekin enough nehi.
Informative video with facts.
Dr Taimur Rahman, I am a Bangladeshi who was born in Pakistan and speak fluent Urdu. After listening to your Lectures in Philosophy,, world history etc. which were very informative, I listened to your series on East Pakistan to Bangladesh. I must say that you are a wonderful teacher and when you speak Urdu, it seems pearls are dropping from your mouth. I live in the US and have referred so.e of my friends to your lectures, However, not one could understand your Urdu as I could sincec they grew up in Bangladesh. Do consider doing this series ini. English for my daughters and grandchildren. interviews and podcasts. PS. Please, please, do pronounce Bangladesh correctly. Baangladesh.
Bangla the way you pronounce it, means a building in Urdu. Here, Bangla is our language.
You are an extraordinarily brave and learned individual. Hats off to you!
There's nothing brave about someone from pakistan talking about bangladesh, i seriously find it super funny that bangladeshis think it'd be an uncommon thing in pakistan to acknowledge our part in making of bangladesh. Dude, this has become way too common. In fact some other ppl totally exaggerate things, this professor on the contrary is totally rational. He's quoting a lot of facts.
I want to remember your lectures as if you..but I can't do this,may you share your experience plz sir,,,I have listened your all lectures plus songs,,
To be honest, i never liked ur program. I always found u in a debate mode wherein u would highlight only ur view point. This is the first video where i got many angles to view the separation of East Pakistan. Thank you
Urdu was not the language of any of the provinces of East or West Pakistan. In fact in West Pakistan the Punjab had Punjabi, Sindh had Sindhi, Baluchistan had Baluchi, Brahvi and Pushto, NWFP had Pushto, and Hindko, and East Pakistan had Bengali languages. Urdu was the language of Indian Muslims who migrated from India to West Pakistan, and maybe because it was understood by majority of the Indian Muslims, Quaid i Azam might have thought to adopt it as national language.
Very informative and interesting. Glad you gave the definition of nationalism and background of language riots.
A new approach .
Excellent lecture series 🙏
Very well analyzed
بہت اعلیٰ تیمور صاحب
Very informative. From Dhaka Bangladesh.
Pls do one video on the topic in eng. Great canal. Martin from Sweden.
you are great sir Than you ......from Gilgit.
@ Is this true? Holy shit that has to be by far one of the dumbest decisions taken by Pakistani elites...
Another reason for Bangali’s not accepting Urdu as the only national language was due to the writing style, urdu is easy to read and understand for all ethnicities in west pakistan as it is closed to Arabic style of writing even some words are common and have similar meaning, but Bengali is writing is similar to Hindi and have nothing common with Arabic or Urdu, so it also give unfair advantage to west Pakistanis
Assalamualaikum Sir, thank you for the video.
Your Pakistani army and with the collaborators of Pakistan, failed to understand and estimate the spirit and strength of Bengal. Blaming India was their political propaganda which was baseless. The liberation war was literally turned into a ethnic clinging genocide in Bengal. I am from Bangladesh seeing you and hearing from you. Thanks.
Thank You.
Dr. Sahib
100% your explanation is correct.
Very good explanation
Marvelous Teacher
Very informative. 👍🏽
It’s superb program you recorded on Bangladesh and I want to say bluntly Pakistan name has changed that’s is now Bangladesh
سر اگلی وڈیو امام انقلاب مولانہ عبید اللہ سندھی کے نظریہ پر بناٸے پلیز
اچھی بات ہے مگر اپ خود بھی اس کے بارے میں سیک سکتے ہے ۔۔۔یا اپ کو rahimia institute of quranic science youtoub channel ko subscrib کرنا چاہئے ۔۔۔اور ساتھ کلاس join kegy...thakns
Please search Sir Agha Khan statement / suggestion about National language of Pakistan
I am from Lahore and I want to apologize to all my Bangali brothers. Pakistan was born from the womb of British colonialism and remains a country captured by the elite. You got out. We still live in oppression.
You should start recommending books as well
Very nice explanation. I think the best one by a pakistani.
Please explain, whether this history could be repeated, if lessons from history not learnt
সত্য কথ্যা বলার জন্য ধনভাদ
ধন্যবাদ।
great videos sir...
What a beautiful explanation of the facts about our Bangladeshi brothers and sisters. Israel is another state which came in to being in the name of religion however there is a lot of emphasis on Hebrew language and culture. We Punjabis have a problem we have labeled Pathans, Sindhis etc as lesser human beings, we still laugh at their language accent, look how Western Punjabi makes fun of Eastern Punjabi, Pakistani Punjabi elite has damaged the unity of Pakistan in 1971 and it continues to damage Pakistan by not being able to work with political parties of Pakistan. We are moving to a very dangerous direction.
Good video and good job
Sir plz suggest book in which we study to better understand all about East Pakistan.
Sir please make videos on how pakistan was made too. That would be as enlightening also.
fantastic videos sir.v.informative.im frm west bengal having east bengali origin.my wife having w.pakistani origin
Dr saib please "Political Theory and world Political systems " pe videos banai .
Yes ap nay teek bola
Lovely Video Sir 👍👌
Feeling sorry for my Bangladeshi brothers...
Nice presentation
Hello Professor, could you please add english subtitle? .. From Bangladesh.
Sir from where we can get Mr.Jinnah's speeches in written form??
Nice discussion. But not being an Urdu speaker i think i managed to absorb only 60-65% of the lecture. Is it possible to provide english subtitle to the lecture? Not just this video but all the videos of this channel.
سر اگلی ویڈیو علماء دیوبند کا تقسیم ہند میں کیا کردار تھا
سارا جون لوک ارسطو پلیٹو کے بارے بہت ویڈیو بنائی
May I request you post some of your videos with English sub-titles? I am being selfish, because I don't understand Urdu/Hindi. Time to learn I suppose, but till then, English sub-titles would be great.
please could you provide name of any book on this topic
sir can u plz deliver these lectures in english bcz u use such difficult urdu words that we do not understand
बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद।दिल्ली।
Thanks for the vedio.
Please can you upload also in English?
ARAB ISRAEL CONFLICT was indeed a great work ov yours,but history & creation ov KSA & al_e_saud was missing in that.
Please enlighten us on this topic.
Regards
Being a Bangladeshi, I must appreciate your late acknowledgement. Pakistan now is a fail state, don't know when you stop begging. Above all, I hope and believe, your recent realization will help you out to overcome the present situation.
Bangladesh will become a fail state if it persecutes Hindus. So stop flames of extremism engulfing ur nation by banning BNP.
Isn't quite harsh? One thing we need to keep into our mind, the crisis of the mass people of Bangladesh, India, and Pakistan is the same. Contradictions between the ruling class and mass are almost the same in Indopakbengal. Mainly perception of religion and ultra-nationalism are the two main elements creating constant obstacles to the development of the hole jurisdiction. My
@@sleepyjoe7518 U r confidently confused by the narrative of a certain anti-people school. The way u r trying to portray
@@sleepyjoe7518 Change this uncluttered title.
@@quamrulhassan8205 , Socialist Pirate is most likely an Indian of RSS stripe. There is no persecution of Hindus in Bangladesh.
Great sir
Balochistan k logon k pass access to internet nhi he s wajah se lockdown k ethno deno baad b balochistan k universities online classes arrange nhi kr parhi ha or digital Pakistan vision ka main priority ha " treat access to internet and the knowledge that comes with it as a fundamental right for all Pakistanis" tu keya hm baloch Pakistani nhi ha jo hme a right nhi di ja rahi he ...serf quetta mn baloch rehthe un k pass access to internet he baki s right se mehrom ha
shahab shahab baki parts me bhi internet hain Inshallah Balochistan me bhi taraqi ho rahi hai ab Gwadar
@@ahsanagha8862 hame taraqi nazar nhi aati Gawadar bht important city ha jab ap wahan jaenge tu ap ko pata chalega k wahan k local logon klea kuch b nhi horaha ha
Facts are well narrated.
Very interesting and illuminating programme, but need a bit of historical correction. Kh Nazimuddin, Suhrawardi and Mohd Ali Bogra were not ethnic bengalis. There were Urdu speskers, settled in Bengal during Mughal rule as In other states like Nizam of Hyderabad. The above three Pakustani PM's and their families did play a very significant role in Bengal politics.
Although I understand why, but it's unfortunate that many Pakistanis consider only Bangladeshis, erstwhile East Pakistanis, their brothers/sisters. They forget that Indians are their brothers and sisters too, at least they were till 1947. Bangladesh-India-Pakistan--legacy of a broken and dysfunctional family dynamic; yet, however dysfunctional it was till 1947, the promise of a greater Sub-continental brotherhood was never hollow and was never without substance. All they needed some sincere, optimistic and visionary leaders when the Raj was closing shops. How sad it is that they allowed few foreigners and merely handful of leading politicians to decide on behalf of more than a billion and still allow them to dictate how they should hate each other.
Please I want to visit your library.
इतिहास समाज का परिदृश्य और सभी प्रकार की समाजिक कृतियां राजनीतिक स्थिति और सत्य के आधार पर विवेचना करना आपकी महानता को और बढ़ा देता है | यही सत्य के आधार पर साहित्य और इतिहास का सत्य वर्णन कर्ता का कार्य होता है | जिसके लिए धर्म यह किस देश का है ..यह होना अनिवार्य नहीं |