This ghazal was written in 1971 by Naseer Turabi, expressing his sadness and sorrow of the secession of East Pakistan now Bangladesh. وہ ہم سفر تھا مگر اس سے ہم نوائی نہ تھی کہ دھوپ چھاؤں کا عالم رہا جدائی نہ تھی نہ اپنا رنج نہ اوروں کا دکھ نہ تیرا ملال شب فراق کبھی ہم نے یوں گنوائی نہ تھی محبتوں کا سفر اس طرح بھی گزرا تھا شکستہ دل تھے مسافر شکستہ پائی نہ تھی عداوتیں تھیں، تغافل تھا، رنجشیں تھیں بہت بچھڑنے والے میں سب کچھ تھا، بے وفائی نہ تھی بچھڑتے وقت ان آنکھوں میں تھی ہماری غزل غزل بھی وہ جو کسی کو ابھی سنائی نہ تھی کسے پکار رہا تھا وہ ڈوبتا ہوا دن صدا تو آئی تھی لیکن کوئی دہائی نہ تھی کبھی یہ حال کہ دونوں میں یک دلی تھی بہت کبھی یہ مرحلہ جیسے کہ آشنائی نہ تھی عجیب ہوتی ہے راہ سخن بھی دیکھ نصیر وہاں بھی آ گئے آخر، جہاں رسائی نہ تھی
@@nightwolf728 At our parting of ways, Neither you cried nor I, But then, what’s this that neither you nor I slept peacefully He was my companion (fellow traveler)… He was my companion… He was my companion but with him I didn’t have like mindedness (harmony) He was my companion but with him I didn’t have like mindedness (harmony) Like the clouds and sunglight, Like the clouds and sunlight, together but as apart as can be He was my companion… He was my companion… There were feelings of animosity, Indifference and anguish (between us) but, There were feelings of animosity, Indifference and anguish (between us) but, my departed lover had everything (but) hadn’t had unfaithfullness My departed lover had everything (but) hadn’t had unfaithfullness Like clouds and sunlight, Like the clouds and sunlight, together but as apart as can be He was my companion… He was my companion… Put kohl The graininess of the kohl is tough to bear In the eyes that hold my beloved Who else can be beheld At the time of parting, his eyes had my song At the time of parting his eyes had my song And it was the song that I had never sung aloud And it was the song that I had never sung aloud Like clouds and sunlight… Like clouds and sunlight, together but as apart as can be
Your video reminded me how much we have been discriminated. Its so painful. You are the first Pakistani I came across, who acknowledged the fact. We can't thank Allah enough that He helped us get rid of Pakistan
Only the Bangladeshi people helped themselves to getting rid of Pakistan. As for Allah, you can ask Him why His beloved Muslims ( alongside many Bangladeshi Hindus as well) were discriminated, tortured, killed and ethnically cleansed in the first place - that also at the hands of fellow Muslims only.
@@dilshadimon4402 Your comment is very weird. If I believe in a higher authority and divine justice, what's the problem with you? Justice will be delivered when there is an injustice involved, right? So the injustice has to take precendence in sequential order, isnt it? Human has been given free will. Commiting crime is human decision, but the consequences are decided by the divine, I believe, I am not imposing my belief on you.
@@hakunamatata3935 Never said I have any problem with whatever you want to believe. Just had a question that I thought you should ask Allah. As for justice, there are innumerable instances where it is never served.
Sir I am your New studen and I have listened your completel 126 lecture history of philosophy and learned enough in 3 days and make notes I say bundle of thanks
Excellent analysis sir. Being a student of political science, I profoundly send exponential level of gratitude for making a neutral analysis based on truth and facts. These videos might not help you financially but we as a student, taking full benefit from these... Please keep it on!
Perhaps, you should have translated the $2.6 Billion amount in today's money for people to get a better understanding. I must also add that what's on the record about economic disparities is only half the picture. Somehow you are not bringing up the overt racism towards Bengalis at all throughout 47-71 period. But, I must say you have the most accurate narrative of what happened (even from a Bangladeshi point of view). I am curious to listen to the next installment and will be looking forward to it, because I feel it gets a little tricky for a number of reasons. Pakistani ruling class actually thought that they will be better off without us. Also, I really think a lecture on contemporary Pakistan-Bangladesh relations will be great too. Greetings from Dhaka Faisal
Mr. ganguli, brother, right now with the help of allah, Bangladesh also gained lead over India!! I really believe both India and Bangladesh don't count pakistan as an opponent in any positive aspect! 🇧🇩
@@jahan442 apni jor kore alochona dhormo'r dike nile to hobe na ! Mr. ganguli bangladesher lead ke 'capitalist development' bolchen ami shudhu add kore etai bolte cheyechi GDP te Bangladesh ekhon india'r theke ektu beshie! Thats it!
This song is in memory of those who died on 21st February 1952 in Dhaka. The background of 21st February starts in March 1948, when Mohd Ali Jinnah visited Dhaka and proclaimed that Urdu and only Urdu will be the national language of Pakistan. The rest is in the video link below. Ekush in Bengali means 21 th-cam.com/video/9qkxknQf5gE/w-d-xo.html
Thanks to the freedom fighters n all the departed souls of the liberation war of Bangladesh. Thanks Sheikh Mujibur Rahman. Joy Bangla, Joy Bongobondhu, long live Bangladesh. Ameen. Mr. Taimur, you deserve a 👍.
@@AnnieZehraJinnah? So who are Sir Salimullah, Sher A Bangla, Sahrawardy who played a leading role in the birth of Pakistan. Jinnah had no illusions about Bengal. 47 Pakistan became separate in Bengali movement.
Excellent Videos coming out by you Sir, Looking forward to see more videos like these .... please do also make videos on Pakistan’s Relations with our Neighbors and other Countries..... best ho jaye ga literally 😅
agree, but dosro ko blame krne se pehle ye socho ke jin logo ko aap apna wakeel bna kr assemblies me bhejte ho wo kio nai apke haqooq ke lye awaz uthate. 5 saal wo ap logo lo lot'te rehte he aur jb agle election ki bari aati he to kehte he Centre hmare haqooq kha gya. aur ap log phir dobara sympathy me unhi logo ko vote de kr jutwa dete ho. Why dont you raise you voice against PPP who is looting sindh since more that 20 years Brother, pehle apne wakeel badlo phir dosro ko ilzaam do. Thanks
What a powerful presentation on truth!!! Isn't meant that without money of "West", present Pakistan's economy is lesser than ethiopia?? Greetings from Bangladesh Sir.
Pakistan's economy is sure to be around 1 trillion dollars, we only need to formalize our very large informal economy. You should be worrying about your own economy, you have imf loans to pay.
@@Taimur_Laal Sir if its possible could you use simpler words or just English in some cases? As Bengalis, we understand Hindi to some extent but tough Urdu words make it difficult. That way the content will be more inclusive, I feel. For instance, using capitalism and feudalism in place of "sarmayadari" and "jagirdari"
@@dilshadimon4402 most of the Bangladeshi people don't understand urdu or hindi.Bangladeshi people only understand Bangla and English.I hope you understand.
Thanks, sir for this lecture and I hope this question will answer your last question. What are we moved towards peace, stability and economic development by doing inequality with other provinces especially Balochistan and the other parts of Fata and old NWFP is the last 71 year (1947-2018)? I hope, it's adequate for your question. Thanks
Sir drain of resources from East to West was an undeniable fact but can you kindly pin point how these resources were directly used in Kashmir policy, the policy that kept no attraction for East Pakistan.
thank you sir for presenting the Truth . I hope, New generation of Pakistan will learn from it. Maximum Pakistani always blame Sk mojib, Bengali and India but they Don't know the fact and kidna beinsafi kiya bangaliko sath west Pakistani leaderso ne. Love from 🇧🇩 to you and new Pakistani generation.
Thank u brother 4 true speech. 2019 Pak budget 40 billion usd, while Bangla 65 billion usd which 7 time smaller than Pak. Today Pak rupee below than napali repee. From Dhaka
Being a pakistani In 2023 i would say bangladesh was lucky to be seperated from west pakistan. in equality and in justice is still running successfully in pakistan. thats why we are now behind india and bangladesh.
Nearly the same story is being repeated in Karachi and its citizens (I mean the locals who donot have any other home town in any other province or in rural sindh)
This lecture series is a beautiful example of objective analysis of history, a fundamental objective of Marxism. I do not understand Urdu, but I was still listening and could make sense out of most of it because Urdu and Hindi have much in common and I do understand Hindi. I think one should add English (or at least Hindi) subtitles to this lecture because that will make it accessible to large number of people in the sub-continent. Common people in India and Pakistan have very little understanding of the historical processes that control our political atmosphere, and therefore they fall prey to narrow-minded sectarian politics. The masses will greatly benefit if they are exposed to these types of lectures.
you understand hindi but you do not understand urdu? its soooo foolish, its like someone in the west says we love american english but hate to speak british english. Albeit british english sounds tadbit better than american english. And i'm also really surprised at why many people in our pakistan not able to question this obvious bigotry in bangladeshi people! dude, have you been to kolkata? They prefer urdu over hindi - urdu ghazals and poetry iis much loved in west bengal precisely kolkata.
@Akar Acharya Bengali should have Bangladesh, Kashmiris should have Kashmir, Dravidian should have Dravida Nadu, Punjabis should have Khalistan and so forth.
Sir kindly apna khayal rakha karen. Hum jis country me rehte hain uska politician general judge har koi capitalist hy. Woh apne faaide k lye kuch b kar skte hain. So kindly apna khayal rakhen sir i respect marxist people.
@Radwan Ahmed I'll see what I can do. I am sure Bengalis already know this history. I made it in Urdu so that people in Pakistan would also know the history.
I'm very impressed with your lecture iam a bengali muslimfromwestbengal migrated in eastpakistanliving inDhaka QamarAhmed Dhaka Bangladesh ican tellu the true fact of1971
Alhamduliallah we are independent country now. Today’s Pakistan is build by our money.We made a country by ISLAM but West Pakistani never treated us as a Part of Pakistan.West Pakistani thought east Pakistan as a Colony.We got Independence in 1971 with war but we work hard and recovered our loss.Now our Economy is 3 times bigger than todays Pakistan.Our GDP 8.3% but Todays Pakistani GDP 2 or less.Our passport is much better than Pakistan.
No doubt that without support of bangalis, pakistan would have never emerged at the world map. I read a lot about discriminatory behaviour of West pakistan towards east pakistan. We made huge blunders and the result is what happened in 71! We shouln't blame outside forces, when from the inside, such practices were going on! Bangladesh liberated and today it is prospering! And I wish them Good luck ahead..
social science is very interesting... the answer to your question is: certainly such disparity will end in choas and hatred.. your question also applies within the province too when it is very large (population-based) like Punjab when the people from the south are struggling for a separate province...
Comparison of South Punjab and Central Punjab is very interesting which can be equated with Pre-American revolution America. Central is industrial hub (like unionists), whereas south is agricultural (land lords like Confederates). South are at economic advantage after seperation, whereas Central has political advantage in a unified province.
Excellent research sir big fan of yours from Bangladesh 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩❤️❤️❤️
This ghazal was written in 1971 by Naseer Turabi, expressing his sadness and sorrow of the secession of East Pakistan now Bangladesh.
وہ ہم سفر تھا مگر اس سے ہم نوائی نہ تھی
کہ دھوپ چھاؤں کا عالم رہا جدائی نہ تھی
نہ اپنا رنج نہ اوروں کا دکھ نہ تیرا ملال
شب فراق کبھی ہم نے یوں گنوائی نہ تھی
محبتوں کا سفر اس طرح بھی گزرا تھا
شکستہ دل تھے مسافر شکستہ پائی نہ تھی
عداوتیں تھیں، تغافل تھا، رنجشیں تھیں بہت
بچھڑنے والے میں سب کچھ تھا، بے وفائی نہ تھی
بچھڑتے وقت ان آنکھوں میں تھی ہماری غزل
غزل بھی وہ جو کسی کو ابھی سنائی نہ تھی
کسے پکار رہا تھا وہ ڈوبتا ہوا دن
صدا تو آئی تھی لیکن کوئی دہائی نہ تھی
کبھی یہ حال کہ دونوں میں یک دلی تھی بہت
کبھی یہ مرحلہ جیسے کہ آشنائی نہ تھی
عجیب ہوتی ہے راہ سخن بھی دیکھ نصیر
وہاں بھی آ گئے آخر، جہاں رسائی نہ تھی
I am from Bangladesh..Can you plz tell me which song is it?Don't understand urdu 😑
@@nightwolf728
At our parting of ways,
Neither you cried nor I,
But then, what’s this that neither you nor I slept peacefully
He was my companion (fellow traveler)…
He was my companion…
He was my companion but with him I didn’t have like mindedness (harmony)
He was my companion but with him I didn’t have like mindedness (harmony)
Like the clouds and sunglight,
Like the clouds and sunlight, together but as apart as can be
He was my companion…
He was my companion…
There were feelings of animosity, Indifference and anguish (between us) but,
There were feelings of animosity, Indifference and anguish (between us) but,
my departed lover had everything (but)
hadn’t had unfaithfullness
My departed lover had everything (but)
hadn’t had unfaithfullness
Like clouds and sunlight,
Like the clouds and sunlight, together but as apart as can be
He was my companion…
He was my companion…
Put kohl
The graininess of the kohl is tough to bear
In the eyes that hold my beloved
Who else can be beheld
At the time of parting, his eyes had my song
At the time of parting his eyes had my song
And it was the song that I had never sung aloud
And it was the song that I had never sung aloud
Like clouds and sunlight…
Like clouds and sunlight, together but as apart as can be
♥️👌👌👌
how weird that the Bangladeshis do not even acknowledge these ghazals, they have been hating the very language they were paid tributes in.
This is what I call an honest and extraordinary presentation!
I would love to see your videos on :
-Presidential vs parlimentrary system
-New provinces vs local govt system
Thanks a lots....
From Bangladesh
🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩Thanks a lots....
From Bangladesh
🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩Thanks a lots....
From Bangladesh
🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
Sir, thank you for your video, lots of love and respect for you and your family from Bangladesh.
Your video reminded me how much we have been discriminated. Its so painful. You are the first Pakistani I came across, who acknowledged the fact. We can't thank Allah enough that He helped us get rid of Pakistan
Only the Bangladeshi people helped themselves to getting rid of Pakistan. As for Allah, you can ask Him why His beloved Muslims ( alongside many Bangladeshi Hindus as well) were discriminated, tortured, killed and ethnically cleansed in the first place - that also at the hands of fellow Muslims only.
@@dilshadimon4402 Your comment is very weird. If I believe in a higher authority and divine justice, what's the problem with you? Justice will be delivered when there is an injustice involved, right? So the injustice has to take precendence in sequential order, isnt it? Human has been given free will. Commiting crime is human decision, but the consequences are decided by the divine, I believe, I am not imposing my belief on you.
@@hakunamatata3935 Never said I have any problem with whatever you want to believe. Just had a question that I thought you should ask Allah. As for justice, there are innumerable instances where it is never served.
Hukona Matata, I second Dilshad. To your religion to us ours.Salamulikum
I an astonished to see the discrimination between East and West Pakistan. Now, I think that Pakistan became rich with blood cost of Bangladeshis.
Now Pakistan has to pay ...and They are paying ...
Not pakistan the people who did it are responsible not pakistan as a whole country
It was obvious & a known fact right from the get go
Comrade Taimur,
Please, can you upload this historical videos with Engslih subtitle. Revolutionary greetings from Turkey.
Apni bohut durust bola....Thank you very much !!
- From Bangladesh.
Sir I am your New studen and I have listened your completel 126 lecture history of philosophy and learned enough in 3 days and make notes I say bundle of thanks
Very informative video with undeniable facts and truths... take my greetings and love from Bangladesh
Excellent analysis sir. Being a student of political science, I profoundly send exponential level of gratitude for making a neutral analysis based on truth and facts. These videos might not help you financially but we as a student, taking full benefit from these... Please keep it on!
Probably the best series on this issue. Keep up the good work
Thank you for giving the real fact ; May Allah bless you and give you the ability to tell the truth.
Thanks for sharing Sir
I wish we had more in PAKISTAN
Like you. Who has courage to speak the TRUTH
seeing your English i can assume you're a Bangladeshi, to your surprise, almost everyone in Pakistan acknowledges these facts!
Well done comrade❤ waiting for your new video on East Pakistan
Perhaps, you should have translated the $2.6 Billion amount in today's money for people to get a better understanding. I must also add that what's on the record about economic disparities is only half the picture.
Somehow you are not bringing up the overt racism towards Bengalis at all throughout 47-71 period. But, I must say you have the most accurate narrative of what happened (even from a Bangladeshi point of view). I am curious to listen to the next installment and will be looking forward to it, because I feel it gets a little tricky for a number of reasons. Pakistani ruling class actually thought that they will be better off without us.
Also, I really think a lecture on contemporary Pakistan-Bangladesh relations will be great too.
Greetings from Dhaka
Faisal
Very instructive & informative .
Love from Dhong ,Gujerkhan
Very logically and beautifully explained and esp. economic disparity was very well explained without any biasness.
This is the best series 🙌😍 great opportunity to learn about our grim history.
Sir i am regular viewer of you videos. Please produce a video concerning local govt act 2019 punjab. Which has been implemented on 1st of May 2020.
Red salute to comrade , for telling the truth , Bangladesh has a great lead , over Pakistan, though it is capitalist development
Mr. ganguli, brother, right now with the help of allah, Bangladesh also gained lead over India!!
I really believe both India and Bangladesh don't count pakistan as an opponent in any positive aspect!
🇧🇩
@@munadilhasan5430
ek bangali arek bangalir tarif korle, take indian bole shob noshto korar proujon nei. dormo o nak e golanu dorkar nai.
@@jahan442 apni jor kore alochona dhormo'r dike nile to hobe na ! Mr. ganguli bangladesher lead ke 'capitalist development' bolchen ami shudhu add kore etai bolte cheyechi GDP te Bangladesh ekhon india'r theke ektu beshie! Thats it!
@@munadilhasan5430 jai houk.
bangladesh shudu ek capitalist developement unar bul darona. ar capitalist hole o kichu ashe jai na amader.
This song is in memory of those who died on 21st February 1952 in Dhaka. The background of 21st February starts in March 1948, when Mohd Ali Jinnah visited Dhaka and proclaimed that Urdu and only Urdu will be the national language of Pakistan. The rest is in the video link below. Ekush in Bengali means 21
th-cam.com/video/9qkxknQf5gE/w-d-xo.html
Informative. When you will upload cover remaining slybuss of Das Capital???
Respect to you Sir. Every video is so resourceful.
Thanks to the freedom fighters n all the departed souls of the liberation war of Bangladesh. Thanks Sheikh Mujibur Rahman. Joy Bangla, Joy Bongobondhu, long live Bangladesh. Ameen.
Mr. Taimur, you deserve a 👍.
do you also thank jinnah for giving us pakistan because had there been no pakistan bangladesh could even be imagined? i'm sure you don't.
@@AnnieZehraJinnah? So who are Sir Salimullah, Sher A Bangla, Sahrawardy who played a leading role in the birth of Pakistan. Jinnah had no illusions about Bengal. 47 Pakistan became separate in Bengali movement.
Thank you so much for highlighting the true history. May Allah reward you and your family for this
Dr. Taimur Rahman you are really great.
Crystal clear presentation
Excellent Videos coming out by you Sir, Looking forward to see more videos like these .... please do also make videos on Pakistan’s Relations with our Neighbors and other Countries..... best ho jaye ga literally 😅
Your government should say sorry to Bangladesh officially..
دا سر تيمور په شان پوهان خلق دا نه مری ❤❤
Hope Pakistan will do such analysis with reference to Balochistan also and take corrective action to avoid further disintegration.
I knew about the maximum things you mentioned. thank you for exploring the valuable information. May Allah bless you
I salute to You dr from Bangladesh.
100 % agreed
aaj kal ye he sindh k sath ho raha hai.... khudara asa na karen k fhir koi rasta he na bachy aap k pass...
Bilkul
agree, but dosro ko blame krne se pehle ye socho ke jin logo ko aap apna wakeel bna kr assemblies me bhejte ho wo kio nai apke haqooq ke lye awaz uthate. 5 saal wo ap logo lo lot'te rehte he aur jb agle election ki bari aati he to kehte he Centre hmare haqooq kha gya. aur ap log phir dobara sympathy me unhi logo ko vote de kr jutwa dete ho. Why dont you raise you voice against PPP who is looting sindh since more that 20 years
Brother, pehle apne wakeel badlo phir dosro ko ilzaam do. Thanks
Lal salam from India Ladakh
What a powerful presentation on truth!!! Isn't meant that without money of "West", present Pakistan's economy is lesser than ethiopia?? Greetings from Bangladesh Sir.
you really need to improve your english my good sir, read your comment twice but couldnt understand!
Pakistan's economy is sure to be around 1 trillion dollars, we only need to formalize our very large informal economy. You should be worrying about your own economy, you have imf loans to pay.
Bitter Truths...Amazing video.
Please, can you upload this historical videos with Engslih subtitle. Revolutionary greetings from Bangladesh
Yar its a lot of work.
@@Taimur_Laal Sir if its possible could you use simpler words or just English in some cases? As Bengalis, we understand Hindi to some extent but tough Urdu words make it difficult. That way the content will be more inclusive, I feel.
For instance, using capitalism and feudalism in place of "sarmayadari" and "jagirdari"
@@dilshadimon4402 most of the Bangladeshi people don't understand urdu or hindi.Bangladeshi people only understand Bangla and English.I hope you understand.
Doosro pr kasoor🤓
💯 Percent right sir.....
Sir! You are an amazing lecturer. You have bulk of knowledge and information regarding history and the best thing is that you know how to deliver..
Thanks, sir for this lecture and I hope this question will answer your last question. What are we moved towards peace, stability and economic development by doing inequality with other provinces especially Balochistan and the other parts of Fata and old NWFP is the last 71 year (1947-2018)? I hope, it's adequate for your question. Thanks
Sir drain of resources from East to West was an undeniable fact but can you kindly pin point how these resources were directly used in Kashmir policy, the policy that kept no attraction for East Pakistan.
thank you sir for presenting the Truth . I hope, New generation of Pakistan will learn from it. Maximum Pakistani always blame Sk mojib, Bengali and India but they Don't know the fact and kidna beinsafi kiya bangaliko sath west Pakistani leaderso ne.
Love from 🇧🇩 to you and new Pakistani generation.
Thank u brother 4 true speech. 2019 Pak budget 40 billion usd, while Bangla 65 billion usd which 7 time smaller than Pak. Today Pak rupee below than napali repee. From Dhaka
All this is just a temporary phase, we'll rise again and stand victorious over everybody not just you. tbh, we dont consider you a competitor.
@@AnnieZehra😂
Sir is that same thing isn't going on here with also in this Pakistan ? if we see Punjab's in comparison with other provinces.
Thank you sir for your informative explanation. Love from 🇧🇩❤️
I keep saying this to my friends and family that we Pakistani needs to ask for forgiveness everytime we meet a Bangladeshi. 😢
What a loss!!
sir, Thanks for all the lectures!
Plz make videos on the history topics like history of USA,Europe,Indo-Pak etc. Plz Sir.
Thank you sir!
Ohhh really Amazing sir , THANKS 🙏💞 for sharing such an evidential arguments about bengal separation .
A commendable attempt -- unbiased presentation of truths
Very thorough analysis and research.
q
Such a natural analysis i agree with you hundred percent. From East Pakistan after 1971 divided Pakistan Bangladesh
Our generation missed this very important information kept secret. So nice to aware us about muslim brothers in USA .AMM
sir soo kind of you for such beautiful contribution..❣
Please, can you upload this historical videos with Engslih subtitle. Revolutionary greetings from Turkey.
Hats off to you sir 👍🏻 amazing analysis
Excellent Sir
Such a neutral analysis.i have to praise your lecture and analysis.love from Bangladesh🇧🇩
Being a pakistani In 2023 i would say bangladesh was lucky to be seperated from west pakistan. in equality and in justice is still running successfully in pakistan. thats why we are now behind india and bangladesh.
Nearly the same story is being repeated in Karachi and its citizens (I mean the locals who donot have any other home town in any other province or in rural sindh)
Good video and good job
Bundle of thanks
Would Pakistanes will learn any lesson from this unbiased critique ? Hats off you sir
Would they still blame india
I am from India
No one is to blame,it's was us and still repeatig the same 😢
This lecture series is a beautiful example of objective analysis of history, a fundamental objective of Marxism. I do not understand Urdu, but I was still listening and could make sense out of most of it because Urdu and Hindi have much in common and I do understand Hindi. I think one should add English (or at least Hindi) subtitles to this lecture because that will make it accessible to large number of people in the sub-continent. Common people in India and Pakistan have very little understanding of the historical processes that control our political atmosphere, and therefore they fall prey to narrow-minded sectarian politics. The masses will greatly benefit if they are exposed to these types of lectures.
you understand hindi but you do not understand urdu? its soooo foolish, its like someone in the west says we love american english but hate to speak british english. Albeit british english sounds tadbit better than american english. And i'm also really surprised at why many people in our pakistan not able to question this obvious bigotry in bangladeshi people! dude, have you been to kolkata? They prefer urdu over hindi - urdu ghazals and poetry iis much loved in west bengal precisely kolkata.
Also share us videos on current data of provincial resources and its usage of Federal Government. How does deal Pakistan with its provinces
Highy appreaciated and mature analysis sir carry on please
May god bless you sir. I learn always from your videos.
Well, I'm happy that we are not with Pakistan & india. I'm really happy...being a B'deshi
@Akar Acharya haha really?
@Akar Acharya Bengali should have Bangladesh, Kashmiris should have Kashmir, Dravidian should have Dravida Nadu, Punjabis should have Khalistan and so forth.
I am ashamed to hear all this, sadly it seems that we havent learnt a lesson from history even today :(
Salute to you sir..
Good work..
Sir kindly apna khayal rakha karen. Hum jis country me rehte hain uska politician general judge har koi capitalist hy. Woh apne faaide k lye kuch b kar skte hain. So kindly apna khayal rakhen sir i respect marxist people.
Sir this relates so much to current Karachi.
Do you plan on adding English subtitles?
A Asante not to this video. I’ll make other stuff on English. Are you interested in specifically this subject?
@@Taimur_Laal yes I want to know more about South Asia. Don't worry I will just learn Urdu.
@Radwan Ahmed I'll see what I can do. I am sure Bengalis already know this history. I made it in Urdu so that people in Pakistan would also know the history.
A very good analysis
It was a netral analysis Sir
Very Impressive
I'm very impressed with your lecture iam a bengali muslimfromwestbengal migrated in eastpakistanliving inDhaka QamarAhmed Dhaka Bangladesh ican tellu the true fact of1971
You executed the postmortem masterly. Weldon. Thanks.
Very educative
زبردست ۔ تجزیہ اور معلومات ملیں ۔ شکریہ
that was one good video.
Very informative sir
Please make these series in English too 🙏🙏
Sir how would you analyse failure of state owned enterprises like Pak Steel, PIA etc vis a vis improved performance of Ptcl after privatisation?
Equality is essential in every field of a country whether it is economy, education or language for keeping prestige of that very country..
Please also make vedio about economy after carona virus pendemic.
See my channel. There are several videos on Corona already.
I appreciate you for telling us the truth🇧🇩
th-cam.com/video/_iqDP7pwF3w/w-d-xo.html
(سقوط مشرقی پاکستان کے اسباب--- ڈاکٹر اسرار احمد)
Thanks for confessing the truth. I think every Pakistani people should watch this video.
Sorry for everything we did bro
@@azeemsarfarazlexicon101 thank you bother.
I request make videos on political systems
Alhamduliallah we are independent country now. Today’s Pakistan is build by our money.We made a country by ISLAM but West Pakistani never treated us as a Part of Pakistan.West Pakistani thought east Pakistan as a Colony.We got Independence in 1971 with war but we work hard and recovered our loss.Now our Economy is 3 times bigger than todays Pakistan.Our GDP 8.3% but Todays Pakistani GDP 2 or less.Our passport is much better than Pakistan.
No doubt that without support of bangalis, pakistan would have never emerged at the world map. I read a lot about discriminatory behaviour of West pakistan towards east pakistan. We made huge blunders and the result is what happened in 71! We shouln't blame outside forces, when from the inside, such practices were going on! Bangladesh liberated and today it is prospering! And I wish them Good luck ahead..
@@aliiqbal6310 thank you
@@aliiqbal6310 wow unique pakistani ❤️
Worth learning sir
Sir plz detailed lectures about modern philosophers
Great.
Same discrimination can also be found in early economic surveys between Karachi and Punjab.
social science is very interesting... the answer to your question is: certainly such disparity will end in choas and hatred.. your question also applies within the province too when it is very large (population-based) like Punjab when the people from the south are struggling for a separate province...
Comparison of South Punjab and Central Punjab is very interesting which can be equated with Pre-American revolution America. Central is industrial hub (like unionists), whereas south is agricultural (land lords like Confederates). South are at economic advantage after seperation, whereas Central has political advantage in a unified province.
Sir waiting for next lecture.
At 3:00 in the video you did sound like
"As flies to wanton boys are we to gods they kill us for their sport"