Fall of Dhaka-16th December | From East Pakistan to Bangladesh | Syed Muzammil Official
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ธ.ค. 2022
- A comprehensive analysis of the chain of events that led to the ultimate break away of East Pakistan- today’s Bangladesh.
#fallofdhaka #causesoffallofdhaka #16dec #1971fall #dhaka #divisionofpakistan #independenceofbangladesh #eastpakistan #westpakistan
Link to similar videos:
1) • Bangladesh vs Pakistan...
Follow:
Facebook: / syedmuzammilof. .
Instagram: / realsyedmuzammi. .
Twitter: / syedmuzammilofl
First of all, that's not fall of Dhaka, but liberation of Dhaka 🇧🇩👍
Different side different perceptive
@@Theactualstoic yes india was also poor one time.1990 was india worst time and india what their leader who give independence thought social economy india is Captislt economy I appreciate india for It but it does not mean other nation cannot progress Pakistan is facing same situation like 1990 of India I am happy Bangladesh people progress they are brother . And Yet there are problem everywhere infact Bangladesh this time also reach imf for bailout package problem is that social media is just tool where propaganda machine work best instead of telling solutions they highlight just
Ex muslim videos you tube par dekho Islam Mohamad sab he
Ex muslim videos you tube par dekho Islam Mohamad sab he
@@nvherman257 lol dude, looking at your way of writing Hindi we know aap kahan se aur kis mazhab se hain 😂
Dhaka didn’t fell, it was risen❤
I think next Balochistan, bcz Pakistan government Baloch koi support nehin korta, itni achhi facilities nehin hee
Chal bay chotye
@@MrTKB-tc2gs india walo k pas toilets ni.
@@barbarian8435 pakistan too h 😂
@@barbarian8435 toilet 😂😂unki pass nehin hee, Jo India ka Log nehin heee, aur wo log jadatur Peaceful categories ka log hee 😂😂😂
I am an Indian army retd officer who was part of Bangladesh operation and went upto Jessore. After the liberation of Bangladesh ,we stayed put there for sometime . Whenever went out of unit in our vehicles on roads,, children used to cheer us shouting "Joy(Jai) Indira- Joy Mujib, Joy Bangla- Joy Hind. This mood of Bangladesh then tells us all.JOY BANGLA, JOY HIND.
Indian army looted in 1971
Purbo pakistani rice making machines in Indian army trucks
Jute mschines
Tea process machones
Agricultural tractors
Fishing boats even Riskshaws
Poor bhoole bengalis did not know that they were cheated by hindos
@@akhtarshahbaz6951 Why are you lying dude? No document or any proof says that anything was looted! Why do you keep using "Hindus" as the selling point of Indians? Muslims also fought from India! Shame on your blind hate.
@@akhtarshahbaz6951 kitna propaganda material piya hai? There is no source to what you just said.
@@akhtarshahbaz6951idiots are not born they are manufactured see him 😂
@@akhtarshahbaz6951 hinduo ne julm Kia hai to vapis Muslim birathar Pakistan ke pas Jake west Pakistan ban jao Bhai, kisne roka hai?
As a Pakistani pathan. I'm happy for Bangladesh. They were destined to have thier own country. We could have separate countries without bloodshed and r*pe. Shame on those who killed and r*ped. We love Bangladesh from Pakistan.
We love also Pashtuns.We have no enmity with Indian and Pakistani civilians.Doesn't matter which Pakistani regardless it's Sindhi,Punjabi,Pashtuns,Baloch.
We have no enmity with these ethnicities in Pakistan.
Exmuslim mulhid apostate jindabad
@@munnabhaimbbs77735Now it's time to Free #Baluchistan & #Sindhudesh .
@prestallar4339 Doesn't matter Punjabi or Pathan.Even Sindhi or Baloch.He was evil.
Happy Vijay Divas To India🇮🇳
Happy Bday to Bangladesh🇧🇩
Happy Surrender Day to Pakistan🇵🇰
Congratulations Pakistan on Getting The Guinness World Record of 93,000 Soldiers Surrender... The Highest Ever Surrender by Any Army Post World War II.
Tea is fantastic...2019 Update....Forget 51 years old 1971
@@ranamutahhir1815 Yes, tea was fantastic, jisne apne old soviet plane se F-16 maar giraya, jiske dar se tere general ke pair kaanp rahe the, pasina aa raha tha. Uske liye tea was fantastic.
@@yashmishra1024 Kon se hmry general ko paseena aya tha??😂🤣....Godi media dkhta ha kya tu??
@@yashmishra1024 Generals se mjy try ek general ki bat yad ayi...5 rupay k sikay se Goli kesy roktay ha??😂2
@@ranamutahhir1815 ye Thumari Parliament mein record hein sun lo
Godi media ka bill har jagaha mat phada karo
Sharm karo Bangladesh tumse bahut aagey ho gaya seekho kuch bangaliyo se
Bangladesh will always be grateful to India and Russia ❤
Mujhe nahi lagta Bangladeshi ke logo ka reaction dekh kar😅
Grateful for the Indian army for abandoning the war on the first month and selling outdated weapons of 1965 war with 10 of amo and failing strategy. And return on the last week after General M.A.G Osmani besieged the Pakistani army in Dhaka and General Niazi radioed in to surrender on the 13th December 1971 than the 16th.
And very grateful for your Indian General Arora for turning up on the last week to shoot down General M.A.G Osmani’s helicopter to stop him from attending the surrender ceremony so the Indian army can write India next to Bangladesh on the surrender document to end their IndoPak war 1971. Thanks for stealing Bangladeshis victory when everyone is tired and wounded than face the Pakistanis on the western front.
Don't take my word for it read your Indian General Jack Jacobs book, Pakistani General Niazi's book and Bangladeshi General Syed Muhammad Ibrahim's Book and EX KGB Yuri Bezmenov's interview.
@@badrulhussain5545 I have one question, you guys won if we didn't support?
@@AnilYadav-ju7hqMan there's a complaint letter sent to New Delhi about your General Arora for his folly training.
I have 1 question for you. Do you think the Indian army defeated the west Pakistani army in 1 week? And Bangladeshis did nothing for 9.5 months?
@@badrulhussain5545 first give me my answer then I give you yours
I m INDIAN sindhi and proud of our INDIAN 🇮🇳 army that they gave their best in rise of bangladesh 🇧🇩
did they ??? we waited untill lakhs of women were raped , millions butchered ? Is this really our best ?
Shame on you Indians. Bangladesh become independent in 16th December 1971 And Indian army joined the war in 03rd December 1971. When we are too close to win then Indian army joined the war.
@@mdrajumia9155 namakharam
@@mdrajumia9155Ungrateful wretch that's what you are. India fed crores of fleeing refugees for months, trained & armed your youth . Hosted radio Bangladesh in Kolkata and you have no thankfulness for all that ? How can you dream that the unarmed civilians of your country would stop the rape & murder of innocent civilians!
This is what happens when you don't know about history and only get brainwashed in madrasas against India.
BTW: I was in college in those days and remember those terrible days vividly. We used to see pictures of the killings rape and genocide from mid 1970 when refugees started pouring into India.
@@mdrajumia9155_u r madarsa chap student dont know properly history___
Hats off to the Bangladeshi people. As a Pakistani I admire you. The way you guys fought against this cruel army, I salute you guys.
Dear Muzammil,
As a Bangladeshi, I salute your courage to speak the absolute truth. Pakistanis should also know the facts behind their failure. Regular listener from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
This is why so many of us left. After what they did to Awami League anybody who had some intelligence knew Pakistan was in the wrong.
@@mahiqazi4902 she is girl.
Bangalis were woke communities and had self respect to demand rights.same thing happening in other than Punjab states of Pakistan,like balochistan.exploitation of resources has been done and their people are the poorest and most illiterate,who were intentionally made to remain so.
All said and done but it was not a one sided affair. Multi Bhani inflicted a lot if atrocities and Bengalis should equally condemn that.
@@mahiqazi4902 after this your politician said that it's was India's conspiracy.... Thank you Muzammil bhai.. our Indian army went there only to save women who were going to rape continuously by Pakistani fauj... 🙏
I am from Bogra , Bangladesh and my father was a Muktijoddha / Freedom Fighter.. I am really shocked but also pleased to see that a trued gem like you still exist on Pakistan... I wish there were more guys like you y and things would have much much better for your country... May Allah Keeps you well brother ... JOY Bangla
Trust me we hate our establishment too
@@zaina5569 establishment kyon bolte ho apni army ko jaise koi private company ho
Bogra was famous for its “mishti doi”. Meethi dahi
@@anikettiwari4585 inke dimag me bhar diya gya hai "eastablishment"
@@princer2893 Establishment me sirf foaj nhi hota woh log bhi hote hain jo kisi regime se profit get karain..or hmare yahan Army me kuch generals ghalt hain baaki foaj me koi masla nhi bs ek process bnana hai jis me se ese log filter out ho sake..
If still Bangladesh have any soft corner for Pakistan....it s insult of those greatest souls who sacrificed their lives for freedom of Bangladesh...
There are West Pakistani Punjabi Mukthijudahs that protested against the genohcide and tried to bring awareness to the west Pakistani public but got arrested. Look it up.
I can't fathom how intellects like Syed just have 1.5 lakh followers but ordinary TH-camrs like Dhruv have over 1.5 million followers. It's a cruel world.
People don't want to know truth.
They just hear what they want to hear.
As indian
Dhuruv rathee leftist h 😏
Nitish rajput neutral
unbaised rahta hai 🙂
Kyo ki dhru rathi sanghio ki chat ta nhi hai…
Syed Muzammil Apne Behtareen andaze bayan ke sath facts samne rakhe ٫ Allah aapki hifazat kare۔
@@ArchanaKumari-hm3bg I think you mean liberal. The irony is syed is a liberal too.😂😂
Liberals are the ones talking about change and making comments that maybe unpopular for the conservative majority. The vast majority however is uniformed and conservative whether it be the hindu nationalists in india or the Islamic fundamentalists in pakistan.
Introspection and criticism of your own is very much a liberal idea.
The Notion of "Two Nation Theory" got demolished the day Bangladesh 🇧🇩 created & separated from Pakistan 🇵🇰
لوگوں نے کہا سقوط ڈھاکہ سے دو قومی نظریہ کا خاتمہ ہوا۔ اگر بنگلہ دیش زبان کی بنیاد پر بنتا تو تمام بنگالی ایک ہی ملک ہوتے، بھارت اور بنگلہ دیش میں (مذہبی قومیت کی بنا پر)منقسم نہ ہوتے
@@noob_donate_plz826 Despite the fact Bangladesh was Muslim Majority nation it separated from Pakistan. What happened to so-called Muslim ummah ? 😂😂😂
@@noob_donate_plz826 but reason of separation was not islam, it was bengali language and bengali ethinicity, here nationalism took over islamism
even bengali hindus were in mukti bahini fighting for their own bengali nation, bangladesh today is muslim majority nation but not islamic republic by their constitution
RIP two nation communal theory
those who cut both hands of my motherland in 1947, ends up in break up of bengali state lol
KARMA always answers
@@noob_donate_plz826 im from Bangladesh and we are secular country not muslim country 🤣
@@sujalverma4326 100% agree 👍
Best History telling in 28.19 minutes... Hats off Bro.... Much love 🇮🇳
iss bkl ne yeh nhi bataya ki 1million log mare the pak army ne
aur 15 lakh aurato ka rape kiya
*Liberation of Bangladesh is NOT Fall of Dhakha.* If this is the level of arrogance and ignorance among Pakistani "intellectuals", we can only imagine the rest with horror and sadness. 🙏🏽
As a Pakistani I agree that it was not fall of Dhaka but rather Raise of Dhaka. As for the title of the video he said Fall because that’s how it’s known in the world “unfortunately”.
रस्सी जल गई मगर बल नहीं गये 😅
Muzzamil shb ! The more I listen to you the more you inspire me in your analyses( plural ) of things
Totally agreed.
East Pakistan aaah !
I agree with the bengali bros it was not the fall of dhaka in fact, it was the rise of Dhaka.
Joy Bangla❤️ Love from Punjab Pakistan ❤️
As a thinking Pakistani who has never studied the true history of my country and was taught the glorified BS in schools, I feel shame and disgust for the atrocities of Pak military in 1971. As much as I love and honor my motherland, i think its vital for us Pakistanis to look the past in its eyes and vow to never again give in to the propaganda of people in power! Grateful for your voice og sanity Muzammil and well done for never taking the easy way out. May Allah protect you! Ameen
Makes one wonder what else were you lied about 🤔
1971 ka rona 🤣😂
@@msa475 1984 Khalistan Movement was Karma
@@msa475 th-cam.com/video/xh4ur9FXKOY/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/xh4ur9FXKOY/w-d-xo.html
Bro mera ik question thumbnail ke map pr hai,agar apka Kashmir azad hai to fir map pe hai hi nahi and apne ne hamare Kashmir ko IOK likha hai
Thank you for sharing these elaborate episodes on the history of Indian subcontinent, narrating the time line of events with so much ease which is possible only through knowledge acquired over the years...really eye opening saga of struggles and sacrifices and also deceit & betrayal.!!
It wasn’t the “The Fall of Dhaka” but rather the fall of East Pakistan and the rise of Dhaka subsequently causing it to be the independence, freedom and birth of Bangladesh 🇧🇩 Thank you sir for you lovely commentary, we admire your open mindedness and knowledge of the situation in 1971.
I wish bangladeshi ek din un Indian soldiers ko bhi credit dein jinhone iske liye apni jaan di hai. Or Hindus ke against waha hate khatm ho.
@@kookie-tm8mg Bangladeshis know what indian leaders and soldiers did for our people and it is much appreciated. As for the hate against Hindus I do not know what the indian medias say but it is very rare in our country. The hate crimes that may occur are not driven by hate against Hindus or other minorities but are in reality very local level political power struggles by morally corrupt politicians in very remote rural areas but in reality there is no such hateful beliefs in any segment of the population. People in general are more focused on living their lives fruitfully than judging people based on their ethnic or religious identities
Yes Pakistan did changed the dna of bangladeshis. The current generation Bangladeshis are actually love Pakistan more then a Pakistani. Even some of them have desire to merge with Pakistan again.
I encountered this Hybrid young bangladeshis while I was traveling to Bangladesh.
The big example is during a Bangladesh Vs Pakistan cricket match played in Bangladesh( dhaka) this hybrid Bangladeshis were supporting Pakistan over their own country. Even this hybrid Bangladeshis are distancing themself from bangali culture and embracing Pakistani culture. I asked one of those hybrid Bangladeshis why? He said Bangali culture is indian hinduwani culture thats why they hate that culture.
@@dracula7058 trolling on the internet by cherrypicking or just simply making stuff up wont change the hatred bangladeshis have for pakistan. If such people would openly talk about merging about pakistan or even india for that matter they would be shamed and beaten at minimum. In all my life living here i have never seen anyone complimenting pakistan let alone wanting to merge back. Those that harbor such intent are descendants of the traitors and mass murderers that helped pakistani military carry out their genocide who forever live like rats in the shadow of our glory. I dont know if you are indian or pakistani but the first sentence of comment is very insensitive and incorrect and you should keep in mind that any pain or anguish you cause will come back to in this life and after death. Dont stoop so low just for some social media points.
@Dracula
If you actually believe that than I’m sorry to say that you’re living in cloud cucu land buddy, I advise you to seek specialist help for you mental health, it’s clearly twisted by the sounds of it lol. The so called Bangladeshi you spoke to us probaly one of those razzakar or bihari traitors whose ancestors are still shell schocked by the defeat of Pakistan in 1971, what can I say you have little traitors like these more or less in every country. As a Bangladeshi I can tell you that the majority of Bangladeshis love their motherland and will never forget the sacrifices of our people, so listen to the majority of our views and not the traitors unless it suits your convenience, I hope this helps buddy.
Muzammil Sahab, the moral of the story is
“Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it,” - George Santayana.
Keep up the good work!
In sub continent, this is best topic to earn highest clicks.
However well prepared n presented.
Amazingly very honest description. Very rare from most anchors who mostly I’ve vague information. Highly professional and honest. Hats 🎩 off.
*_Pen is sharper than sword because you cannot sign the '93000' surrender with sword_* - General Niazi 🇵🇰
Ye mst tha guru 😂😂😂
Na Bangladesh or pakistani lig nazar ayin gt.. Srf hindu motar peeny waly islam or Muslims py bhonky gy.. Hindu beta tm Muslims ky ghulam ho chay wo bnagali hon ya pakistani 🇵🇰💪💪🇵🇰💪
@@kumarm.....4108 712 sy1857 tak muslims ky ghulam thy hindu 💪🇵🇰HINDUS ARE SLAVE OF MUGHALS FOR 1000 YEARS 🇵🇰💪🇵🇰💪🇵🇰💪💪🇵🇰 and still slaves (world record of slavery
@@technologyt678 1971 mai Pakistani rape hui victim ki Nazayaz Aulaad h tu 😂😂😂.
Sale saare 🐖🐖🐖 ne mil k ek baada banaya, jise Porkistan k naam se duniya Jaanti hai
@@kumarm.....4108 hindu meri tatti or motar peee plzzz 😄😄🇵🇰💪🇵🇰💪dft
Pakistan 🇵🇰 lost for the same reason that Syria, Egypt, and Jordan lost to Israel in every war. Their officers were playboys from connected families, got their ranks through nepotism, and were treated like princes, while the soldiers were poor peasant boys and were treated like slaves. In all third-world armies, you have unmotivated troops and incompetent officers. India was different, For the Sikhs and Gurkhas, war was a tradition.
You forgot gurjars and Rajputs 🙂
Pakistan : Biggest fraud on muslims and Islam
We are blessed to have so many martial races and a competent officer core.
India was very lucky in its leaders who were prepared with a vision of what India was to be. The Constitution came out in 1951 and the structure of the governance, the separation of powers and the subordination of the armed forces to the elected representatives came into play. For Pakistan the problem in all walks of life I think started from elite capture. The North Indian elite Muslim families that went to Pakistan brought with them their extra privileged, exploitative by birth thought process. If you watch Satyajit Ray's Shatranj ke Khiladi, you will understand the indolent and indulgent spoilt as a two year old culture that landed gentry of Awadh had. They carried the germ of elite capture into their new country. For India, it was good riddance; we managed to get the land reforms going and abolished all princely privileges. The Pakistani people unfortunately imported some of the worst people living in the subcontinent and paid the price.
Kal ky bachy b ab pakistan py tabsra kryin gy.. Nikal
As a young person living in Calcutta during this period, I was a witness to this, but I do n ot see any mention of the millions of refugees who came to India.
That was a bollywood propaganda. Because the Bangladeshis stayed to fight the West Pakistani army and risked their lives to rescue Bengali Hindus families from getting graped and unalived for 9.5 months brother, because no one came to help.
Thanks for telling truth brother.
Love from 🇧🇩 Bangladesh.
We bengali Hindus still feel the pain of separation, coming from Bangladesh to India. Leave our motherland behind.
do not forget majority of brutality was done on bengali hindu women....
do not feel...just save our now bengal...
712 sy1857 tak muslims ky ghulam thy hindu 💪🇵🇰HINDUS ARE SLAVE OF MUGHALS FOR 1000 YEARS 🇵🇰💪🇵🇰💪🇵🇰💪💪🇵🇰 and still slaves (world record of slavery
@@samarth5991 712 sy1857 tak muslims ky ghulam thy hindu 💪🇵🇰HINDUS ARE SLAVE OF MUGHALS FOR 1000 YEARS 🇵🇰💪🇵🇰💪🇵🇰💪💪🇵🇰 and still slaves (world record of slavery
Bangali hindus are cucks
During Bangladesh liberation war it was clear that Pakistan's forces were depleted and Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw asked Niazi, commander of Pakistani forces, to unconditionally surrender in front of the Indian Army.
*93,000 Pakistani troops surrendered to the Indian Army in 1971 making it the biggest surrender since World War II.*
1971 was a freedom struggle by Bangladeshis. Why do Indians get an orgasm from it? India's role was purely that of a sponsor, like it does TTP now. If your fake news were in fact true, there would have been East Bengal, not Bangladesh. India was at war with Portugal over Goa, and they just let Bangladesh form instead of East Bengal. Lmao! We all saw how a surrenderer was made a hero recently in India, so India's propaganda factory still fools its people.
@homosapien7238 great, appreciate it truely..and it's Mid December 1971 so in round off we should correct the records. Ideally it should be 1972...🙏
@homosapien7238 Your own Country Pakistan Released Stamp in next year 1972 mentioning those 93,000 Pakistani Army surrender to India, Media Outlets of Your Ally The New York Times, BBC, Al-jazera , even Pakistan's Most prestigious Media outlet The DAWN have mentioned that 93,000 Pakistani Army surrendered to India in 1971.
@@n0thng25 it’s a new narrative bajwa started.. IT WAS 93K.. do not let them off with this fake narrative..
@Homosapien 93k were war prisoner it's UN record.
War prisoner are solders not civilians .
Lagta hai DGISPR ne bataya hai tumko
00:02 The division of East and West Pakistan in 1971
02:13 Unilateral declaration of national language led to seeds of hatred
06:26 Economic exploitation and lack of development in East Pakistan led to discontent.
08:30 Proposal for separate accounts for foreign exchange earning
12:47 Power transition from democracy to military rule in Pakistan.
14:53 The bloody operation in Dhaka under the leadership of Yaya Khan Saheb led to Pakistan's eventual accession to Bangladesh.
18:55 The fall of Dhaka led to a full-scale war between India and Pakistan.
20:51 Pakistan's surrender and the rule of Bangladesh
24:46 Niazi's military briefing and the consequences of oppressive tactics in East Pakistan
26:47 Political failure contributed to the fall of Dhaka
Best unbiased vlog on Bangldesh history i have ever seen.... salute to you.
As a proud Bangladeshi Hindu, I have to admire your works bhai. Hope we will see such content in future too. Jai Bangla Jai Hind.
Only Joy Bangla. We Respect India but no need to say Joy hind
@Ramesh shinde is it necessary to spread hate did you meet anyone they hate government not people.
@@Afghani2688 jay shree raam 🚩🚩🚩
Jai Hind !
How bro, how is life for Hindus over there?
Jinnah - No one can undo Pakistan!
India - Really? take your hostage Niazi and 93000
🤣😂🤣
98000 randian soldiers surrendered against China
Lost Azad Kashmir and tried to take Lahore but instead took L=🇮🇳 😂😂😂
Sun Randian🇮🇳....This is not 1971 anymore....50 years have passed till 1971.... Remember 2019 in which Tea was fantastic 😂🥱
@@ranamutahhir1815 next is Balochistan and fata.. Taliban already in action.
Na Bangladesh or pakistani lig nazar ayin gt.. Srf hindu motar peeny waly islam or Muslims py bhonky gy.. Hindu beta tm Muslims ky ghulam ho chay wo bnagali hon ya pakistani 🇵🇰💪💪🇵🇰💪
@@Ashwantpakhrin Na Bangladesh or pakistani lig nazar ayin gt.. Srf hindu motar peeny waly islam or Muslims py bhonky gy.. Hindu beta tm Muslims ky ghulam ho chay wo bnagali hon ya pakistani 🇵🇰💪💪🇵🇰💪
As a Pakistani who has studied the facts of 1971, I don't have words to express to my Bangladeshi brothers and sisters how profoundly sorry I am.
What our ancestors did in the years leading up to Bangladesh's formation is absolutely horrific and deserving of the harshest punishment.
I wish there was a way we could take it all back, some way we could remedy those injustices. And if it's some consolation, I assure you the overwhelming majority of ordinary Pakistanis both then and now would hang their heads in shame if they knew the real history.
It's too much to ask but I hope today's generation of Bengalis can look past their grievances and anger and see us as their friends and brothers who want nothing but the very best for you and your country.
May the nation of Bangladesh prosper, stays independent, and moves from strength to strength. May you achieve greatness in all domains, be it economy, technology, social harmony, or military.
as a pakistani, ham dua krtay hain k hamray bangladeshi bhai hush aour safe rhain aour hamai asay leaders and generalu say mahfoooz rakhain
সঠিক ইতিহাস তুলে ধরার জন্য ধন্যবাদ স্যালুট মোজাম্মেল সার।💖🇧🇩
আপনাকেও একইভাবে অভিনন্দন ও শুভেচ্ছা জানাই | এপার বাংলা থেকে।
600,000 biharis were killed by mukti bahini. 83000+ Pakistanis have been killed by indian-backed terrorists since 2001. Pakistan is one of the biggest victims of terrorism. Kashmir will be separated from g*ndia very very very soon. Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistani Balochistan and Pakistan will be saved very very very soon
Pro-Pakistan bangalis also killed bangalis
th-cam.com/video/xh4ur9FXKOY/w-d-xo.html
When tyranny takes place rebellion becomes duty. 🇧🇩
Absolutely bro
You're right
@Tehreek-e-Khalistan Panjabistan (TKP) Kashmir has no right to be independent
@Tehreek-e-Khalistan Panjabistan (TKP) failed movement!
@@syedbakeruddinbekar9433 Keep dreaming. Khalistan means Merging West Panjab and east punjab
Pakistam still owes an apology to Bangladesh. Great video brother with intricate details. Christopher Hitchens photo in the background was enough to subscribe your channnel. Keep making such videos and enlighten the people.
Jazakallahu khaira for updating authentically
The level of war crime Pakistan army did in Bangladesh was much brutal than what Japan did with China in WW2.
No.. U don't know the history if you are comparing these things.. I knw it was bad but nothing as bad as japan and china.... Japan literally fcckddddd china harder than anything
and do not forget majority of brutality was done on bengali hindu women.....my grand nani have told me many of the horror stories
@@samarth5991 Hindus have been persecuted everywhere in south asia.. But we still didn't undertood it
@@samarth5991 they were the primary main targets and the one whoever helps them.
@@axelsouvik3325 yes! Pakistani 🇵🇰 even rap,ed the female members of the Bengali Muslims who were helping hindu women & children from the atrocities of Pakistani Army.
The seeds for creation of Bangladesh was sown by Mohammad Ali Jinnah - when he declared at Dhaka that Urdu will be the official language of Pakistan. (Both East and West Pakistan) Language is more powerful than religion. Same religion cannot certainly unite people but language unites people more stronger. Obsession & Assertion of Urdu over Bengali lead to that great seperation.
How can we Indian live together with more than 20 languages....... 🙏
@@siddhugoldi Because we don't have any National Language. 😇
@@siddhugoldi that is the biggest achievement of our country. The existence of India after 75 years is still a wonder. The only reason I can think of is our respect for our diversity.
irony is no one except muhajirs(migrants) mother tongue is urdu. shows you the slave mentality of pakistanis.
@@Tehreek-e-KhalistanPanjabistan Pakistani killed by Indian terrorist?? What nonsense?? U don't have any proof what so ever but demands every fucking thing in the world. Yes Pakistan has seen many many deaths over terrorism but India has nothing to do with it, it's only because of Pakistan's Afghan policy where they manufactured factories of terrorists.
Urdu is such a sweet language I really enjoy listening to it.
96000, is just not a number for us indians....its an emotion💓
🥲
@@AsfandyarDotPK use burnol....
Beta tm aik aik hindu ko sir ko juda kr ky dum lyin gy hmmm... Na Bangladesh waly tmry ho sky na pakistan 💪🇵🇰💪🇵🇰
@@samarth5991 hindu beta jaa kr motar pr gobar khaaa
#PKMB #CKMB😂😂
Thank you for accepting the truth
Love you from Chittagong Bangladesh 🇧🇩
Muzammal! You are doing phenomenal work. I use to think about doing similar things when I was in Pakistan but couldn’t gather the required courage and left Pakistan instead. But at least I feel proud that the work I use to plan is being done even better by people like you. You are the reason I can’t say that Pakistan will always remain like this…! Well done! Keep it up.
from india you are ultimate pro, what a narration brother, i have read these incidents and thought why pakistanis are not understanding this ? chalo kuch to log jo pakistan ki bhalayi chahte hain, bhagavan aap ko kuch responsibility den, aap jaise log to politics me hona chahiye
Having run into this video by accident. I cannot but say I am impressed. I wish you well, Syed. There should be more like you.
hard hitting truths from Muzammilji 😊😊 salute to bengalis from Bangladesh to take pride in their culture and language and not consider themselves descendents of arabs or turks
Dear Muzammil,
That was a wonderful brief on the reasons for the creation of Bangladesh. I am a student of history, and in fact, I have written a novel based on the Indo-Pak war history. While doing my research on the subject, I came across some other vital aspects that must be mentioned.
1. Among the most compelling reasons why the East Pakistanis voted for Sheikh Muj was a cyclone - Cyclone Bhola! It struck East Pakistan and east coast of India on November 7-8, 1970. This was the greatest natural disaster of the 20th century, killing up to 500,000 people, ... apart from the devastation is caused to the economy and livelihood of the Bengalis. The cyclone lasted for 6 days but the best effort by Yahya Khan was an air tour of the skies days after the cyclone had receded. Until then there had not been a single effort to help the affected, while the world was sending all the help it could (India had alerted the East Pakistan stations about the impending disaster heading its way. That's the reason India suffered a lot less in comparison.
2. The massacre under Operation Searchlight. Here, as you mentioned a lot of atrocities were committed by the army ... but there was another evil that was predominantly responsible for this - the Jamat e-Islami which created many proxy forces which carried out the dirty work of the Pak army. Mainly among them were the militias - Al Badr and Al Shams, and numerous others. They killed the intellectuals of East Pakistan and dumped their bodies in the canals and rivers.
One must read a book by Taslima Nasreen - 'Lajja (meaning SHAME in Bengali). The narration is heart wrenching and depressing if you are one of those whose family was on the receiving end. It was in a real sense 'INHUMAN' like stabbing bayonets into the stomachs of young pregnant females.
Another factor worth considering. When it was almost a foregone conclusion that Pakistan was going to lose the war, and that Bangladesh's creation was indeed becoming a reality, An incident is treated like a heroic action. Mr. ZA Bhutoo tearing up the UNSC proposal on the floor of the assembly. Bhutto should have accepted the peace proposal and thus saved Pakistan from breaking up. Guess what the date was when he tore up the papers? December 15, 1971. The next day Lt. A A K Niazi surrendered.
Was it all coordinated? I am not sure.
There are several other factors worth considering.
But kudos to you for two points - 1) In short, vlog you put in most content that was possible. 2) You have been honest and truthful.
Thank you for that.
Very Well Put Sir!! Where can I read Your Material??Many thanks from Canada!!
I agree with your most points but on the role of Jamat islami you are describing a typical Indian stance. JI was defending Pakistan and providing s response to multi Bahani crested by India. Indian coercive role should be discussed and acknowledged but you choose not to. No country has the right to intervene into another country’s affair but India did and this hastened the process. There was indeed discontent but it was allowed to prosper due to India’s vested interest because India never accepted creation of Pakistan and thus presented a golden opportunity.
@Ashard Khwaja It is not an 'Indian stance' its a reality. Bangladesh courts recently awarded death penalty to JeI head for his actions in 1971.
Most 'Razakars' who formed the militia were from JeI.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bangladesh_Jamaat-e-Islami
@@ashardkhwaja657 if India would have done it, they would have tried to absorb the area into India not make a new country
আপনার বইটির কী নাম? বইটি কি পিডিএফ এ পাওয়া যেতে পারে?
Politics in Pakistan has always been Punjabi centric. Resources from East Pak to West Pak then shifting Captial from Karachi to Isl and now exploiting Balochistan to make Punjab parha likha. Seems like these punjabi generals have signed a great pact sort of thing that power must revolve only around them.
Watching this at 16 December 42 yrs of Liberation 😂😢😮😅😊😂
Much appreciated Bhai atleast one person from Pakistan is speaking the truth
There are many like him. But you have not come across.
17:55 *I strongly Object at your point that Indian Government helped Mukti Wahini bcz they were fighting against Pakistan, our conventional enemy.. But the reality is that uncontrolled migration of Bengalis into India caused the Indian Government to intervene in this civil war of then Pakistan. Otherwise India would not have jumped into this war. There are evidences in which Indira Gandhi is asking for Western Countries help to ask Pakistan to stop atrocities on Bengalis.*
Pakistani always lie
Exactly! I am astonished that Indians are all going ga ga over this video, while he is verbalizing the subconscious belief of all Pakistanis that India is against it. That said, at least people like him are now waking up to the real world 🙂
He has still tried to find the facts and has done a great job. .. Even we are not 100% perfect in every analysis we do.
He is clearly stating a lot of facts that we as Indian bangalis have known since long. Great Job !
Bound to appreciate your narratives with perfect analysis. 🙏
My father, who was Lt Colonel at that time and was deputed there from West Pakistan in 1969 was also held POW for almost two and a half year from Dec 1971 to April 1974(mostly in Agra jail and for 6 months in Deolali)
Deolali is Nashik city ,Maharshtra ....good weather❤❤❤
Thank you brother for highlighting the true story, may Allah give you long life ameen
🇧🇩
Happy Victory Day to All Bangladeshi 🇧🇩✌️💪
Joy Bangla 🇧🇩
And
Bangladesh Zindabad 🇧🇩
@Tehreek-e-Khalistan Panjabistan (TKP) chal be madarchod 😂🤣
Pakistan did changed the dna of bangladeshis. The current generation Bangladeshis are actually love Pakistan more then a Pakistani. Even some of them have desire to merge with Pakistan again.
I encountered this Hybrid young bangladeshis while I was traveling to Bangladesh.
The big example is during a Bangladesh Vs Pakistan cricket match played in Bangladesh( dhaka) this hybrid Bangladeshis were supporting Pakistan over their own country. Even this hybrid Bangladeshis are distancing themself from bangali culture and embracing Pakistani culture. I asked one of those hybrid Bangladeshis why? He said Bangali culture is indian hinduwani culture thats why they hate that culture.
@@dracula7058 They were Biharis living in Mirpur and The Offspring of Razakars, who helped Pakistan Army in 1971. The normal people of Bangladesh don't represent those kind of traitors. You are lying, i can guarantee that. Please stop spreading hate anymore. And by the way, i think you are a Pakistani bot. So, please stop spreading your dark agenda further.
@@TruthSeeker9080 I am expressing my personal experiences. Young hybrid Bangladeshis love Pakistan. They show support towards Pakistan in every possible way.
And a bangladeshi ( not bihari i know bihari very well) he lives in cumilla said me this that Bangali culture is hinduwani culture thats way they don’t practice it and if i am telling lie then how would i know the word hinduwani its a Bengali word.
murder of sheikh mujibur rehman and his family was karma. murder of indira gandhi was karma. 1984 Khalistan Movement was karma. collapse of soviet union was karma
We all brothers are fighting with each other from last 75 years 🇮🇳🇵🇰🇧🇩 . and western countries are taking advantages. Let's drop a brotherhood comment here where all are fighting in the comments box.
Pagal hai kya pakistan can never be anyone's brother
Very wise meaningful and true analysis for those who love human dignity and survival of remaining Pakistan.
After Dr Ishtiak Ahmed we have another gem that's Syed Muzammil who have ball of steel to speak truth 🙏Huge Respect 🙏
I am so ashamed of our Army, the level of genocide they committed and we lost a significant part of the country - it’s a national loss on so many levels -
They are doing same in Balochistan
murder of sheikh mujibur rehman and his family was karma. murder of indira gandhi was karma. 1984 Khalistan Movement was karma. collapse of soviet union was karma. 2023 Khalistan Movement is Karma. adani crisis is karma
@@vandematram4 the world knows what g*ndian army is doing to Kashmiris. A Pakistani Baloch soldier named Captain Qadeer Ahmed captured kulbushan jadhav in 2016. Kashmir, indian punjab, etc will be separated from india very very very soon. Pakistan will be saved very very very soon
indian general gd bakshi says that the Pakistan Army destroyed indian army in 1948, 1965, Siachen and 1999: th-cam.com/video/xh4ur9FXKOY/w-d-xo.html
@@Acts17Apsychopathics let world cry .. what can world do ??? Just take care of your own pakistani ..
You can't even feed your own people ..
All Kashmiris are living much better life than you people ..
And you are no voice of world ..
You are not even voice of Muslim world ..
Jinki khud ki sarkar koi or bahar ke log tay krte he ..
Vo hme lecture na de ki democracy kya hoti he or public ko kese sahuliyat di jani chahiye ..
The first step towards rectification/restitution/improvement, is to acknowledge your errors. The tragedy of the subcontinent is that we never learn from our history. If you rewrite history by half-truths and misdirections, history will rewrite you. Well done Mr Muzammil, it takes a special kind of courage to speak out thus...but please, please do also exercise caution. Our subcontinental history tells us that we often (almost always) punish our truth-sayers in the most horrific manner.
Thank you for being the voice of honesty and hope the rulers learn from history . Watching from Bangladesh.
19:50 I differ with you sir on this point. USA and varioud other western allies gave total support to Pakistan. And USSR stood beside India due to Indo-Soviet treaty of 1971. And Even some various documents confirms the claim that USA was about to attack India using Nuclear weapons but Soviet backed Nuclear submarines already reached to Bay of Bengal and USA aborted their decision of using nuclear power against India.
Yes. U r right. The Nuclear threat delayed India's action & India was forced to go for 'Indo-USSR' friendship treaty by loosing its independent non-align status so as to decisively act.
gd bakshi says that the Pakistan Army destroyed indian army in 1948, 1965, 1999 and Siachen: th-cam.com/video/xh4ur9FXKOY/w-d-xo.html
Syed you are one of the intellectuals I have seen in TH-cam...keep this positivity going on...all the best 🙏👍
Are you from uttarakhand 😊
You Need to do more research on this, India didn’t have any ulterior motive to go into war with Pakistan other than stopping infiltration from East to West Bengal. PM Gandhi took up with UN requesting their intervention in stopping the Pak Army from torturing the innocent civilians but in vain as only Russia stood by her.
Your analytical skills are at great but not unquestionable. Other then few disagreements I fully endorse your analysis. Good job young man
India had also chosen winter for this operation strategically bcz in winter China can't come to that region bcz of heavy snow. Also Russia countered American naval fleet. That's why India and Russia has an emotional relationship.
Russia ALWAYS stood by 🇮🇳
You really believe theres an emotional relationship between countries?
@@daddydaddy9942 these guys are very immature
Emotional relationship... 🤣🤣... Indians are too easy to manipulate... No wonder they were enslaved for more 1000+years.......
@@daddydaddy9942 India is emotional country bruh. On a political level it's just strategic friendship but on the citizen level it's on another level. Russia and Israel will always have a soft spot in indian hearts irrespective of their current views.
You are Spitting facts and truth as always. Love you Genius ❤️
@syed muzammil i think you are wrong in one case. 90k pakistani soldiers were in Bangladesh - joint custody of India & Mukti bahini - not Indian jails. Also there 13million refugees from East pakistan to India due to the military action.
Bhutto was too intelligent. To be a good leader of the country one has to be very moderate in intelligence
How you know the truth. You are first youtuber in Pakistan who told reality. You are talented. I think you are educated and read books.Salute from India.🙏🏻
Wow Muzammil bhai three videos in 10 days😱
More power to you Muzamil! Well done.
Jald hi hum Balochistan ko bhikaristaniyo se azadi dilayenge. Jay hind jay baloch
Jesy k aaj hum balocho k sath hora hy balochistan me..jb hum apny haq k lye awaz utha thy hn to khety hn ye to gaddar hy..😕
Balochistan Zindabaad, Free Balochistan
Support Imran khan for haqqiqi Azadi
Pakistan ke abhi 10 hisse aur hone hai baloch aur queta afgan ka hissa banenge talibani lekar rahenge wo hissa
I was in my final semester last year when my Professor, who happened to be a Major as well, gave us a presentation on the split of East Pakistan. He made the presentation and handed us a script of it. We were asked to stick with it and let the "bygones be bygones". We were not allowed to say anything other than the script. God forbid if we did it, we probably would have failed the course.
Masha Allah bhai aap bohat haqeeqat par mabni speech karty hain. God Bless You
Thanks brother.Love and respect from Bangladesh.
Joy Bangla. Long Live Bangladesh 🇧🇩💚
Thanks. I conducted livestream with legendary Prof Ishtiaq Ahmed on this topic today. I hope we learn from our mistakes.
Have you published it on TH-cam? Can we see it?
@@Gappasappa Absolutely.
U can learn and understand as an individual but your politicians will do all those things which will ruin your country very soon and that is painful.. They have loose tongue which they don't control..
It was Genocide of highest order ...... period
Empathy for our Bangla brothers from Bharat for there sufferings
Aj b Balochistan baqi napakistan ko paal rahi hai aur aj b sub say ziyada foj Balochistan may Hai. Aur aj b Baloch osi halat say gozar raha hai jis say bangali gozray tay bus ab result b wohi ho takay Balocho ka dunya k monafiq taren logo say jan chot jahey . Ameen
We (Bangladeshi) respect those people who thought like you 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
God bless you . Agree 100%. Longlive 🇧🇩 got independence from punjabkistan, same situation is with Sindh , Balochistan , kpk , Pojk , Pogb.
Excellent deliberation. You have described true story to every Pakistani whe were not aware of march to December 1971 situation.
It’s all good, india supported n helped the liberation and Bangladesh was created.. despite all the support why we still hear n read news about Hindu temples n heritage being destroyed in Bangladesh even today…. Our friends from Bangladesh may respond….
That’s a matter of honor, gratefulness , imaan in the respective religious teachings.
Rest in peace "two nations theory"😌
Chutiya insaan two nation theory still lived in Pakistan and after 1971pakistan islamic republic
Also Rest in peace"No power on earth can undo pakistan".
@@vedantjadhav5462 😃😃
@@vedantjadhav5462 Rest in Peace....India....#FreeKhalistan
@@ranamutahhir1815 khalistan can become a state of the Indian Union with Lahore as its capital 👌
Mr. Muzammil, At least one million Muzammil's are required for any ray of hope for Pakistan to survive. You have a balanced & studied opinion about the subjects you talk about. Keep up the great work that you are doing. My best wishes to you Bhai.
Hey Muzammil. Very well said. Wow!!! Amazing enlightenment indeed. Blessings for the confidence to speak the hidden truth. These facts are not in our history textbooks. Remember, everything in history is false except names and dates!!☺️🙏👍
💯 true
Army wale hamesha apni failure ko politicians pe dal dete he.
Completely unbiased analysis sir .love u . As usual talking with facts and reality .
Wao aaj my pahelibar Dekh rahahu ki Pakistan me ese Bhi log rahate hai Jo sachai demorac ki Bhi bat Karta ho Bhi ham Bharat SE aap Jaise logo ki jarurat hai Pakistan me pakistan KO Chahiye ki aap Jaise logo KO aage Kare taki Pakistan ek Achi rah pe chal sake dhanyabad
Pakistan needs more young visionaries like you.
Ethnic Background of Generals in 1971 Indo-Pakistani War.
During the 1971 Indo-Pakistani War, the number of Generals in Pakistan Army was 14. One was Commander-in-Chief of Pakistan Army and 13 were Lt Generals.
Four were posted at the GHQ/CMLA HQ,
Four were corps commanders.
Four were governors under the martial law.
One at the CENTO HQ in Ankara, Turkey.
Out of 14 Pakistan Army Generals in 1971 Indo-Pakistani War;
1. General Yahya Khan (Pathan) was the Commander-in-Chief,
2. Lt General Abdul Hamid Khan (Punjabi) was the deputy C-in-C,
3. Lt Gen S.G.M.M. Peerzada (Muhajir) was the PSO CMLA HQ in Rawalpindi,
4. Lt Gen Gul Hassan Khan (Pathan) was the Chief of General Staff (CGS),
5. Lt Gen Khawaja Wasiuddin (Muhajir) was the Master-General of Ordnance (MGO).
6. Army's Eastern Command was under Lt Gen A.A.K. Niazi (Pathan).
7. 1 Corps was under Lt Gen Irshad Ahmad Khan (Punjabi).
8. II Corps was under Lt Gen Tikka Khan (Punjabi).
9. IV Corps was under Lt Gen Bahadur Sher (Pathan).
10. Governor Punjab was Lt Gen Attiqur Rahman (Punjabi).
11 Governor Sindh was Lt Gen Rakhman Gul (Pathan).
12. Governor NWFP was Lt Gen K.M. Azhar (Muhajir).
13. Governor Balochistan was Lt Gen Riaz Hussain (Muhajir).
14. Lt Gen Muhammad Shariff (Punjabi was sent as Permanent Representative to the CENTO HQ in Turkey.
The GHQ posts of QMG and AG was under the rank of Major-Generals.
Hamood-ur-Rehaman Commission recommended Public Trial of the following Officers:
(1) General Yahya Khan (Pathan), Former Commander-in-chief.
(2) General Abdul Hamid Khan (Punjabi) ex Chief of Staff to the President.
(3) Lt. Gen. S.G.M.M. Pirzada (Muhajir), ex PSO to the President.
(4) Lt. Gen. Gul Hasan (Pathan) ex Chief of General Staff.
(5) Maj. Gen. Ghulam Umar (Muhajir), ex Second-in -Command of NSC.
(6) Maj Gen A O Mitha (Muhajir), ex Deputy Corps Commander.
(7) Lt. Gen. Irshad Ahmad Khan (Punjabi), ex Commander 1 Corps.
(8) Maj Gen Abid Zahid (Muhajir), ex GOC 15 Div.
(9) Maj. Gen B.M. Mustafa (Muhajir), ex GOC 18 Div.
The Commission recommended Court Martial of the following officers:
(1) Lt Gen A.A.K. Niazi (Pathan), ex Commander, Eastern Command.
(2) Maj Gen Mohammad Jamshed (Muhajir), ex-GOC 36 (ad hoc) Division.
(3) Maj Gen M. Rahim Khan (Pathan), ex-GOC 39 (ad hoc) Division.
(4) Brig. G.M. Baqir Siddiqui (Muhajir), ex COS, Eastern Command, Dacca.
(5) Brig Mohammad Hayat (Punjabi), ex Comd. 107 bde. (9 Div).
(6) Brig. Mohammad Aslam Niazi (Pathan), ex Comd 53 Bde (39 Ad hoc Div).
The Commission recommended Departmental Action against the following officers:
(1) Brig. S.A. Ansari (Muhajir), ex-Comd, 23 Bde.
(2) Brig. Manzoor Ahmad (Punjabi), ex-Comd 57 Bde 9 Div.
(3) Brig. Abdul Qadir Khan (Punjabi), ex-Comd, 93 Bde. 36 Div.
The Commission observed that the suitability of the following officers for continued retention in military service would not be justified:
(1) Maj Gen M.H. Ansari (Muhajir), GOC 9 Div.
(2) Maj Gen Qazi Abdul Majid (Muhajir), GOC 14 Div.
(3) Maj Gen Nazar Hussain Shah (Punjabi), GOC 16 Div.
(4) Maj Gen Rao Farman Ali (Muhajir), ex Adviser to the Governor of East Pakistan.
(5) Plus 19 brigadiers.
Also Zulfiqar Bhutto a key actor in this sordid drama was "Sindhi".
Also calling any Pakistani elite a "Punjabi" is ridiculous if they are so ashamed of their language.
#5. Lt. Gen Khawaja Wasiuddin was from the Nawab Family of Dhaka. He returned to Bangladesh in 1974 by own choice. He was rumored to be recommended by C-in-C of Mukti Bahini Gen. Osmani to the post of Chief of Bangladesh Army, but President Sk. Mujib installed him in civil service instead to not create any seniority crisis in Bangladesh Army. He was Bangladesh's ambassador to the United Nations.
He is revered by Bengali officers and soliders who also served in Pakistan Army prior to 1971. He didn't give a damn to what the Pak high-ups would view it as but addressed the darbar of East Bengal Regiment units in Bangla language. His name plate in his house in Rawalpindi was inscribed in Bengali language.
I am from India. Love you because you are honest person.
😏Mulk tutne se dukh to hota hai bhai....!
😔Jaise hum Indians ko hua tha 1947 mein Pakistan ban ne ki wajah se....!
🤨Pakistan ko uske karmo ki saza mili hai....!
Wow. I love the way you are presenting history as it is. Salute to you sir 🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤
18:00 correction. The main reason India got into the fight was the millions of people flooding into West Bengal and Assam states. Otherwise you can oppress your people as much as you want, India won't interfere.
So,india is best the peaceful country in the world,😂.india used refugees to intervention east pk crisis, they assisted mukti bahini, even when UN said india to let go the refugees in east pk,but they denied it.u ppls history knowledge is too poor.
@@imtiazahammedsabbir8211 Let gothe refugees in East Pk, from exactly where they ran away from?
.You know it's international law to not throw out a refugee, so UN can't even ask to drop refugees back in East Pk. Now let's talk about the mass rape in Bangladesh by your army.
At last you accept truth. I know you aware about many genocide crimes but you hiding that but appreciated your bravness❤️🇧🇩
Yeah even as a Indian I also know but kudos to him he accept many of them