Centre Opposes Pleas To 'Criminalise' Marital Rape In SC, Affidavit Sets Off Debate | Urban Debate
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ต.ค. 2024
- In today's episode of 'The Urban Debate', anchor Shreya Dhoundial discusses Cetre’s move on marital rape in SC. The central government has taken a stand in the Supreme Court, opposing the criminalization of marital rape, sparking a nationwide debate on the issue. In its affidavit, the Centre argued against treating marital rape as a crime, leading to widespread criticism from activists and women's rights groups who are calling for greater protection for women within marriages.
#maritalrapecase #sconmaritalrapecase #supremecourt #sc #affidavit #maritalrapedebate #topnews #latestnews #mirrornow
SUBSCRIBE NOW for more such videos ►bit.ly/2LesD8T
For More Updates ► www.mirrornowne...
Like us on Facebook ► / mirrornow
Follow us on Twitter ► / mirrornow
Follow us on Instagram ► / mirrornow_in
When a man is not willing to pay money to wife she must also accept...no means no ... Man is not a object of women to keep giving her money whenever she has a need
So paying money to your wife And raping her is same for you?
@@bsankarkumaran_fashionIcon don't force them to stay at home to look after kids. Let them work or force them to do so. Don't let her do the household chores alone contribute to it. Your parents are your responsibility not her.
@@gauravshukla9962so force mutual in marriage.
There is no outside involvement.
@@gauravshukla9962Who told you that working women are not getting alomony or who guarantee that they will not use false allegations to take mont
@@cauhanronak just because one can misuse the law does not undermine its gravity. If that would be the case, even murder should be made legal as it's one of the most misused laws in our IPC.
Who will prove consent has given or not in bedroom where sex is supposed to happen and there is conjugal rights..
If Women's dignity have been violated there's remedy and provisions.
Bro i see this your fourth comment....i see this triggered something in you. Rape is accompanied with physical evidences like injuries etc....do you think all rapers get convincted?
@@anonymous5573 that's not reason to criminalize marital rape.
If a man says "no", it is a no...but few women complain husbands are not having sex with them..
They complain but at least don't force themselves on men
Incel detected
Lamo you know nothing@@gauravshukla9962
It's all about vmen and their wants.
If a wife asks husband for money, jewelry etc..after marriage it should be declared "financial harassment" and wife thrown in jail immediately. Are women ready for this law??
Rape and extortion is same ?
Did your wife inserts that money, jewellery etc into you without your consent forcefully?
@@gauravshukla9962 First, define rape properly. The laws are totally biased. There are many situations that aren't actual rape but are considered as such, like false promises of marriage or non-consensual sex
@@gauravshukla9962 financial extortion is "Ra*e" for men.
@@gauravshukla9962physical rape vs mentally rape you mean
Anchor Madam why you believe Women can't rape men? Why men can't file rape cases like women does? There must be gender neutral laws..
Selective approch thik nhi h.
Western countries have all laws are gender neutral.
How about gender neutral marital rape law?
@@beingsaee Give men same rights as women have..
bro remember last year in TN they arrested 12 year old boy child. the 17 year old girl assualted him. the women force arrested the innocent child instaed of that culprit girl.
under pocso the girl is default victim even if she is the offender.
so much foe equality. the 12 year old boy still in jail.
@@AmarjeetKumar-ip1pl
Makes sense.
Unfortunately I don't make law.
Were you raped by your wife?
Awww fake feminists got triggered 💀
Firstly make all pro- women and anti-men laws gender neutral. then make marital rape a crime. Institution of marriage is already failing and this can accelerate the fall of institution of marriage..
Indian people are not liberated, open minded.
Govt points of views are absolutely right..
Why doesnt these learned people say article 15 is biased against men'?
Why are they ignoring men's concern??
Anchor ji, rape is rape but what about rape against men?
😂😂😂😂
You are a biased individual
😂
Yes bro
Marital rape word does not exist
When a wife feels she is being raped by husband , then the husband can be granted divorce if he wants, without all the fuss and drama inside court rooms . After a couple years of marriage , most husbands anyhow lose intrest in their wives and I am surprised why there so much of noise .
Mrs Journalist does a husband has any right to say no to sex or only wife has a right to say no...if no means no then it has to be for both sexes...
Where gender neutral law in India
Under Indian law men have no right when women have done wrong with them but why say against that use that in favour and earning money by it. Women are feminists but when it comes to taking man's money or enjoy that pleasure.
I was a virgin before marriage, and my wife was not. However, I still married thinking that she would love me for the rest of my life. However, she did arranged marriage with me to have a better life in America, have 2 kids and then move into a separate bedroom (I was 33) withholding any kind of intimate physical or emotional relationship with me. It's been 14 years+ with not even a kiss, and she makes sure I don't have any other relationship outside of this one-sided marriage, and when frustrations comes out she threatens me with Divorce Lawyers sending notices to my parents & siblings for inheritance money on top of my assets. WHAT DO I DO?
I have never crossed the line because like being loved by my wife.
Yeah false cases is also ur right..everything is only ur right and men don't have any right ..right? News anchors like u just speak for the sake of speaking with any sense of the reality...how will proof that it was rape or not in a marriage ? If ur husband is forcing u then there is a law of domestic violence ...already enough laws for women..why u want more laws ? Aren't the misuse of current laws enough for you??
Please look at what happened with Shekhar Dhawan Divorce case exploiting current Indian broken foreign Constitution based Legal System.
Did that male panelist just redicule husbands as servants of wife...he better learn some manners first...
Why were you so triggered?
@@anonymous5573 if a panelist comes on national media and says brides are servants of husband...u already know what feminists will to to such panelist..
@@rakeshgaru1598 every godman says it...most of the politicians says it....central government is trying to block marital rape law...womans are getting rape every hour..... But you got triggered by a panelist
@@anonymous5573 first learn the fact that there are already provisions in law to protect married women from domestic violence, sexual harassment etc. In marital relation
@@phoenix281287 if there are already provisions... why there is so much debate about adding rape?
Difficult to prosecute, and prove/defend depending on the party having onus of proof. May lead to marked rise in frivolous complaints. Maybe, provide for mandatory court ordered mediation or separation in such cases, if reported by complainant.
I’d like you to take a step back and provide an objective overview of the matrimonial dispute landscape for men, especially considering how burdensome marriage can feel nowadays. To fully grasp the legal framework you mentioned, I suggest looking into three key statistics:
1. The total number of cases registered.
2. The number of cases that were settled and the grounds for those settlements.
3. If possible, a breakdown of how many cases were based on false or fabricated claims.
Specifically, consider the following laws:
- Section 498A
- The Domestic Violence Act
- Section 125 of the CrPC
It seems that journalism today often leans more towards activism than objective reporting, lacking thorough research and failing to present both sides of the story.
Just yesterday my mother was forcing me to get married and settle down and today this News came in😂😅thank you Mirror Now I am saved🙏
An unmarried woman means there's a happy single dude somewhere with his wallet intact..
People think that today's women are naive😂
Where is the single law for men
🎯💎🏆 Great insightful Debate 🏆💎🎯
लोकः समस्ताः सुखिनो भवन्तु
( May all beings lead prosperous life across Globe 🌍 )
The subject is just superficially discussed as it is won't to be in mainstream media due to paucity of airtime. Hope these small discussions lead to larger detailed discussion and real dialogues in the society on what laws are required and how to also protect the potential sufferers of misuse - the collateral damage for a larger good or a section for whom due recourse should be explicitly included into these legislations so as to be a detergent for those who might want to indulge in misuse. Food for some thought.
I don't understand the news anchor here (the executive editor Shreya) who is pleading this argument of center opposing to criminalise marital rape, and puts Deepika on stand to hear out her side of perspective and when asked to respond, deflects the question to some other pupil. On one hand, you are presenting yourself strongly concerned with the legalization of this law and comparing with first world countries but don't have a single word to counter the gender biased realiy in India.
Tahira Hasan uses the Straw Man Fallacy here and deflecting the injustice done to men.
Women have dignity, and we as a nation have progressed a lot in achieving so. So, please can we stop playing the victim card in even 2024 about the dignity of women.
Does the dignity of a man doesn't count at all?
And how would the victim can proove that the heinous incident happend and not just abuse and file a fake marital rape case on a men.
Do the notion to criminalise marital rape also hold women accountable if she does it to her husband?
These feminist or women's rights activist's in this video don't even acknowledge the misuse that could happen under such laws, or even care about men's dignity.
If potential to be misused is applicable to every law, don't you think why all such laws consider only women as the victim and thus, misused by WOMEN only.
The News anchor in the end goes "This law is just an addition to the other laws only, what's the issue if one more law is added to the list of gender-biased laws already existing in India."
KUDOS.
Mr. Vikram SIngh and Deepika got the gist and had well contructive arguments that destroys anthing the other panel members had to say.
Don't play victam card 😂
Women right to diginity and equality should be protected.If a man have such right over women then the women should have the right to deny it.
All laws might be misused. Because of that, the core intension of law can not be compromised
Rightly said. Provisions can be made to prevent misuse.
In every case, accuser need to prove.
But in cases related to vmen, accused needs to prove and it is against natural justice.
@@itsme-sq5rd I'm more concern about victim and law protection. You are concern about accused and loop holes..we can't fire a house for a rat. Think rationally.
@@premprabhakar1083 accused become victim when accused don't do the crime.
It's not accused responsibility to prove.
Otherwise, any one can accuse and harass anyone.
@@itsme-sq5rd so according to you there are no cases of crime against women ?
Good
Women ☕☕☕