7 Things in Red Dead Redemption 2 Critiqued by an Old West Buff
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.ค. 2024
- Taking a historic look at the new smash-hit game Red Dead Redemption 2.
Thanks to David Bresnick for the game footage.
Thank you to to Zanar Aesthetics for the clothes catalogue clipt.co/e5gZxf6C2a
Music:
"Roundup on the Prairie", creative commons.
“Sneaky Snooper” by Audionautix is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommons.org/licenses/...)
“Digital Gunslinger” by TeknoAXE (under creative commons 4.0 attribution license)
This video is not sponsored by Rockstar Games.
__________________________
Our friends and collaborators:
Trail Dust Town: www.traildusttown.com
Pinnacle Peak Pistoleros: / @pistoleroswildwest9050
Rick and Penny's Place: / old Tucson Studios: oldtucson.com
Batjac JW: / scorpio86ist
Jedi TV: / jedigunfighter
Dustin Winegar: / utahconcealedfirearm
Ravenna Old and New West Vestures: ravennaoldwest.comRavenna commercial: • Video St. Louis & Iron Mountain Railway: www.slimrr.com/
_____________________
Facebook: / arizonaghostriders
Twitter: / santee2171
Instagram: az_ghostrid... - เกม
Never really understood everybody’s obsession with westerns until I played this game. Now it is probably my favourite genre...
You took the blue pill. Congrats!
STUNTS My dad always had westerns on as I grew up. They will always hold a special place for me.
I always loved westerns growing up but i kind fo forget them when i got older and then i played rdr2 and i found that amazing nostalgia again lol
naippes same story mate
STUNTS EXACTLY
“This game takes 40-50 hours to complete”
*Laughs in 567 hours played and only 45% Complete*
The main quest? I'm not a gamer and I finished the main quest way sooner than 567 hours. CNET gave those facts, BTW
I meant that I can’t just do the main quests, I always find myself doing stranger missions, buying new outfits, or customizing my weapons.
Rockstar has always been good about that
@@cheznoob4307 Yeah, some folks on here were just interested in the main quest. I like the other side quests better, myself.
40 days played and at 97%...
@@TommyTombstone It happens! Great game tho
A fun fact: Arthur's hat was actually a keepsake of his father (even though they didn't have a good relationship).
"Arthur Morgan was born circa 1863 to Beatrice and Lyle Morgan. His mother died when he was very young, and his father was a petty criminal and outlaw, who was arrested for larceny in 1874 when Arthur was 11 years old. At some point, Lyle was killed and Arthur witnessed it, donning his hat afterward."
That's probably the reason why that very worn leather hat is Arthur's favorite and he wears it despite the weight and weather.
Yeah. But it's not practical to wear it in all weather. The 19th century folks on the frontier were practical. I agree he would have kept it, though.
Only for me to immediately buy a big valley hat like an hour into the game.
You figured it out
Even if different hats would have been more practical sentimental value means you would probably still stick with the hat
Me with a lazy stovepipe
Can confirm this game made me a Wild West fan
That's great to hear.
Same. WILD WILD WEST
@@thatonebananaboi4617 this game is based in 1899 kid the wild west was over by then
@@ArizonaGhostriders and horse connoisseur
@@s.c5714 Nope. Burt Alvord was robbing trains in AZ in 1900 and the AZ Rangers were hot on his trail. Chacon, too, was on the loose. Butch and Sundance as well.
NM and AZ became territories in 1912...that was about the time of calm.
“Grand Theft Auto critiqued by a professional car thief !”
Now that would be a good video, too.
I think you mean professional jewel thief, Larry lawton
@@goombamaui5343 r/whoooosh
@@iVladX17 wtf no One joked.
Goomba Maui no, it should be a professional car thief, hence the name for the game, “Grand Theft Auto”
A playable old western movie basically...count me in.
It is!
@Lee Everett so a western?
That's really good and has amazing cinematography, story telling, mechanics, and extremely relatable characters
When you get interested in the old west from playing red dead 2
Honestly this game made me watch some old Clint Eastwood westerns I've never watched them before and really enjoyed them.
Watch Tombstone, The Wild Hunch, and Unforgiven!
@@wetlettuce4768 I did the same! A fistfull of Dollars, A few dollars more and the good the bad and the ugly are masterpieces
The 1960's The Magnificent Seven is pretty good too
Glad I could help
Anyone else think the guy in the blue shirt looks like uncle
Yeah, most people who have commented. I had to tell him who Uncle is!! HA!
@dingir xul it's a serious condition
Same thought
@Dutch Van Der Linde We gotta stick to the plan, Dutch!
@dingir xul do you even know what lumbago is lol
16 hours? You gotta pump those numbers up
HAHAHA!
ikr
Those are rookie numbers in this racket
I have more then 100 hours now I buyed the game in december of past year , now I am in the epilogue trying to do 100 % completion .
indeed rookie numbers! :3
You seem like a genuinly good person to just sit down and have a talk about anything. Kinda like everyones favorite uncle.
I'll take it!
Hopefully not one with chronic lumbago, though.
@@jonathanb1406 HA!
But not RDR's Uncle
"I have terminal lumbago"
I'm disappointed you never mentioned the tragedy that was the massive outbreak of terminal *L U M B A G O*
It's a serious condition
@@wetlettuce4768 Yes! You're a compulsive liar
awww, get to work UNCLE
It's a slow and painful death my brother
@@seanr6338 Evidently!
40-50hrs?????? Hahaha rookie numbers
LOL! Careful, some folks on here are up to 100+!
Yeah, 40-50 hours is about the time it takes to just blast through all the main story missions. You're doing it wrong if you didn't spend at least that much time just screwing around, lol.
Well its better to take time and enjoy all the game that has to offer than to finish it as fast as you can. during my first playthrough, i blasted through the main story missions without doing any side missions or exploring the game itself and now finished the game i gotta admit it kinda ruined my experience.
As a completionist it takes over 100
@@davidn4956 Bragging about rushing a beautyfull game? Feel sorry for you.
Not a real western. Have yet to find the wilhelm scream
YES! HAHAHA!!! Thanks for making me laugh.
Intelkek weak
GOOD. I'm shocked that that's STILL being used unironically in mainstream media.
@@StuffyMc Maybe it's like a sound designer's rite of passage? Like, "No one takes you seriously until you use the Wilhelm Scream"
Fairly confident it is actually in the game
Something I love about Red Dead 2 is that it felt like a blend of hollywood spaghetti westerns and actual historical stuff, really great!
Thanks!
@European Patriot okay....?
@@dustinakadustin in my mind red dead 2 would be redemtion, but since nobody remembers red dead revolver, redemption 2 has that title now
@@dustinakadustin You especially get that Spaghetti Western feel when playing with headphones on during a gunfight, and you hear those _old_ bullet ricochet sounds. I love it.
@@NaruSanavai yeah they're sweet! Just wish they kept the Wilhelm screams in, they're in the first game and it's hilarious.
This game has greatly increased my love and interest in the Wild Western period. They did an absolutely phenomenal job with this game.
Absolutely.!
@@ArizonaGhostriders
This game made me interested in almost every western film .
I think it is not period accurate for the years which is 1899 and 1911.
There is a comment Charles makes in the post-game (few years later), that the thugs have Mausers now, and "technology is moving fast".
Yes.
Thugs got 50 round drums now on a Glock 17 lol 😭
This week on the Arizona ghost riders
Videogames in the old west
Now the pioneers didn't have xboxs at the time so they had to settle for Atari2600s
HAHAHA!
Took me 3 minutes but I figured out the joke....I think
@@notsoverysmartperson4743 You're my spirit animal.. I think
@@notsoverysmartperson4743 what joke? Don't laugh, our for Father's had only 8 bits to play with and they were dang thankful for them!
ShaddyCrunchum
ThEy hAd NiNTendO 3dS’s
I don't know what this channel is but I'm glad I found it via rdr2
Me too!
Same
When I was younger, I used to hate living in New Mexico but now I looooove how much western heritage is right at my front door
Good!! You have a bunch. Not to mention all the movies filming out there.
I'm not from the U.S but dang, western genre is just fascinating
👍
Would the button down shirt be more excused due to the prevalence of the French/European founded town of Saint Denis within the game?
Possibly. But historically, I've never seen a photo with anyone wearing the coat shirt from that era.
Arizona Ghostriders That May be so but at the same time we don’t have track of every personal life from that century so would that help to make it more uhhhh explainable? Like you don’t unlock the Mauser pistol until after you deal with the Italian guy in the game I believe
Dalton Waddell GODDAMN YANKIES
Yea he said it was at the same time just in different countries and the United States is built on foreigners especially off the coast's cuz that's how foreigners get here so being able to buy them in Saint Dane would make sense cuz it's South like maybe in the Luissianna area which where there is a lot of foreigners in Saint Dani
This game has actually sparked my interest in the old west, and since then I've been binge watching all your helpful and informative videos. Thanks for the great content and humor, keep it up!
Grayson, much appreciated!
watch 3:10 to Yuma, it's a classic
grayson Rothrock same here. I went to my local library and rented some cool western books. thanks rockstar!
Same here, I never understood my Great grandfathers obsession with westerns until now. In the early 80s when I was around 4 or 5, our family would go to his house every Sunday after church to visit and have dinner. I hated the fact that the only thing we were allowed to watch was westerns...lol. However I didn’t realize until playing this game that the Wild West still existed during his lifetime. He was in his late 90s in roughly 1983 and would have been a child during the timeline of this game, a bit older than I was when I watched them with him. I don’t know why it never dawned on me until now, but like many I always associated the Wild West with the early 1800s
Have you played the first one it's okay if you didn't otherwise
RDR2 has sparked a HUGE interest for me in the old West. I’ve always thought old gunslinger stories were cool, but this game has be obsessing over the real life nuances to what life was like back then; both for outlaws and regular folk.
Well, I'm glad to hear that. Hope this channel can help you with that obsession some of the rest of us share!
This episode is making me wanna try this game.
You should!
Please do!
Do it# it is very fun. Very immersive. Put time aside for it though...
You wouldn't be sorry you did. Great game.
DO IT! you wont regret it one bit!
One thing of note on the guns: The relative difference in damage inflicted by the firearms is off. For example, the Schofield is depicted as being more powerful than the Rancher, despite the latter being based on a gun that was capable of firing a more powerful cartridge due to the break-top Schofield having limitations on cartridge pressure. Also, the Volcanic pistol is depicted as being exceptionally powerful, when the real life version was so anemic that even something like a few layers of clothing could prevent the rounds from penetrating deep enough to cause significant damage.
Great info!
Not to mention with the volcanic, it was only in production for roughly a year from about 1851-1852 which makes it hard to believe that it would be so common by the time 1899 rolled around.
@@eddiepiszczek4820 The Volcanic is an odd choice. It was used in another western game, too. In the game I don't believe it's a common gun. I've honestly never seen one in person...yet.
The in game description mentions it is converted from it's propriety rocket ball ammunition to regular brass cartridges which attributes it's higher power.
It still makes little sense though.
Exactly! When I carry a shotgun, it's just for style lol... Express ammo in the Schofield is just as powerful...
This just appeared on my recommendations. Really glad it did
Me too!
I’ve always been around the old west. My dad raised me on westerns, on stories from his visits to arizona, on john wayne and clint eastwood.
But I didn’t really start to appreciate it until the red dead series. It reignited a fire that actually burns hot in me and brought me to your channel, now i love this stuff.
SO glad to hear it.
The first time I’ve ever actually laughed at someone calling someone a nerd, I didn’t see it coming, kind of like the slap to the back of the head except it didn’t hurt.
Yeah. Trouble with ghosts...ya never see it coming.
If you ever notice, there is a fued between two families and a member from each fall in love. It's in relation to the Hatfield's vs mcCoys
Yes!
T.O.K The Omessian King I thought it was Romeo and Juliet
The family's are called the grays and the braithwaites
So Dutch gang vs O’Driscoll in the game represent the actual feud?
@@jonathanraynard8572 no because that's not a love story she's talking about Penelope braithwaite and beau gray in chapter 3 of the game
Your style of comedy is very refreshing
Thank you!
Agreed
And his editing is creative
Whats interesting. Is that this game serves as a prequel. So it might be preferable to play this before the Red Dead Redemption I
Yes!
But you wouldn’t get all the nods to the first on if you do that.
Which is precisely why I'd like Rockstar to go back and do RDR completely anew, graphics-wise, and keep the bulk of the game identical to how it was previously, so that you could play the two games back-to-back and get the same level of graphical detail. It's one of the few games that is truly worthy of that treatment.
Colton Frederick you’ll get him once you play rdr1 tho
I generally find that when something is deliberately released as a prequel to an existing story, it's best to experience the original first. RDR2 assumes that the player has already played 1. Likewise, much of the interest in the first game is unraveling the story and relationships between John and his surviving gang members, an aspect that's lost on players if they've already played the second.
"40-50 hours to complete"
*looks at my 100+ hr playthrough with 70% in the story mode.
me: yeeeeeeaaahh...
Some on here would laugh, while others would understand. It's not a race, so it doesn't matter how long it takes to enjoy that game!
Wtf! The video is so dynamic, well done dude, props to your editing.
Thank you much!
i killed a guy and took his hat, when I returned to the ranch the kid asked me "you got a new hat pa?" freaked me out
yeah yeah yeah.... it so fun to watch.
I knew you were going to review this game, best video game of the year in my book. I beat the game a few days ago. The weapons that I usually carry in the game are a pair of of custom nickel plated engraved colt peacemakers, heavily engraved Winchester or sometime the Henry, and for shotguns either the 1887 or 1897 Winchester both heavily engraved
Nice!!
I've got a pair of schofields, blackened barrels, brass frames and cylinders, ivory handles with eagles on them, and the metal is engraved with silver inlays
Sweeeet!!
I use the Otis Miller and the Jim Calloway but I only started using them last night before that I was using 2 black Schofields with the most costing engraving and I made it gold and with a Pearl grip and long barrel
I carry Flaco and granger revolver Lancaster repeater dB improved shotgun.
Its honestly stunning how you could spot these tiny details and point them out, explain when they were used and what for. After this I’m really thinking about watching some of your older videos. Thanks again!
When you are really into this period of history, you pick out things. I picked out more, but Rockstar did a good job of finding things that "could have been" present.
I've been going on a spaghetti western binge BECAUSE of this game
Good!
I want a LOTR rockstar game. With their graphical capabilities, amazing attention to detail and the amazing world made by Tolkien and Peter Jackson would make an amazing game that I would pay easily one hundred for.
Elias Harben no because it has giant spiders in.
also the Witcher and elder scrolls dominate that sub-genre
I want a game that at least has quality of Shadow of Mordor but with more role-playing depth.
Elias Harben what is LOTR?
@@1fbgsp Lord of the rings
People would be pretty skeptical of an open world Lord of the Rings sandbox game. Especially due to there being so few successful Lord of the rings videogames.
These people riding on the fame of RDR2 are geniuses. I love all things late 1800s, so I subscribed, but this would generate so many potential subscribers.
It could, andt a game about this era is important to spread the interest in the Old West.
This game got me to trade my double action for a single action! I already dressed like a cowboy but after playing this for a while I started leanin hard back to the cowboy life. I'm a cowboy courrier, people seem to love when I walk in and great everyone by tipping my hat and saying "Howdy" (tho I do scare small kids in walmart)
HA! Well, that is still cool.
The carcano 1891 was Italian, so ya it probably would have been difficult to acquire one as an outlaw in the states in 1899 but i agree it was mainly there just to add in variety and serve as an upgrade ti the bolt action rifle the player would have had for a while at that point. Fun fact, the rifle still served as the main battle rifle for the royal italian army during the second world war, 50-ish years after its inital introduction
Yeah, I read that. Interesting rifle, eh?
Even as a non-gamer, I wanna play this! Great review, my friend!
Hey, wait a minute... Why don’t other videos about the game show a t-rex? LOL!
Glad you like it.
You should get it, probably the greatest game I have ever played. It'll be the best £60 you'll ever spend, believe me!
as a gamer this game is a grate digital experience it looks grate and has a lot of detail built in it that will have you amazed as you find how just how much detail is in this digital experience
but as a game it sucks the controls are clunky and take a long time to get use to them the bounty system is not very well explained in game like the majority of the mechanics its left up to the player to figure out how thy all work and intertwine and the time it takes to do anything is just way to long it is a vary slow game it is literally a chore to play so much so it is not fun to play which is key to being a game a lot of the times animations will lock you up and you cant abort the actions that you can actually die from it you allies in mission are dumb bullet magnets so much so that you will fail more missions because one of them died then you will fail a mission because you died
and the ending to this game is more drown out and has more false endings then the third lord of the rings movie that everyone complains about for never ending the last 20 hours of this game drag on needlessly the climax has already happened and because this is a prequel most of what is played out in the last 20 hours was already covered in the first game and took less time to cover it
playing threw the ending of this game i was literally singing out loud
this is the game that never ends it goes on and on my friend some people started programming not knowing what it was and thy will keep on programming just because this is the game that never ends it goes on and on my friend some people started playing not knowing what it was and thy will keep on playing just because this is the game that never ends it goes on and on my friend some people started programming not knowing what it was and thy will keep on programming just because this is the game that never ends it goes on and on my friend some people started playing not knowing what it was and thy will keep on playing just because this is the game that never ends it goes on and on my friend some people started programming not knowing what it was and thy will keep on programming just because this is the game that never ends it goes on and on my friend some people started playing not knowing what it was and thy will keep on playing just because this is the game that never ends it goes on and on my friend some people started programming not knowing what it was and thy will keep on programming just because this is the game that never ends it goes on and on my friend some people started playing not knowing what it was and thy will keep on playing just because this is the game that never ends it goes on and on my friend some people started programming not knowing what it was and thy will keep on programming just because this is the game that never ends it goes on and on my friend some people started playing not knowing what it was and thy will keep on playing just because this is the game that never ends it goes on and on my friend some people started programming not knowing what it was and thy will keep on programming just because this is the game that never ends it goes on and on my friend some people started playing not knowing what it was and thy will keep on playing just because this is the game that never ends it goes on and on my friend some people started programming not knowing what it was and thy will keep on programming just because this is the game that never ends it goes on and on my friend some people started playing not knowing what it was and thy will keep on playing just because this is the game that never ends it goes on and on my friend
game of the year this is not their is just to much wrong with it for it to be game of the year
thy dropped fun for realism and gamer's don't play games for realism we play them to we play them to have fun and to escape from reality
@@rayzimmermin It seems from the comments a lot of people do want the realism, but only to a point. Like loading and cleaning the guns. They want to do it, but not take as long as in reality.
yes games don't mind realism as long as its still fun once the realism interferes with the fun that's is ware the deal is broken and RDR2 brakes that deal on so many levels its not even fun its just a chore
and its not even the loading or cleaning of the gun that is the problem in RDR2
its the cooking mechanics ware you have to cook one piece of meat at a time no batch cooking for Arthur the horse riding ware you hit trees all the time horses will not run in to a tree that's why only videos you can find that shows a horse running into a tree its from a video game even the creators of zelda knew this little fact about horses that why in breath of the wild you cant hit a tree on a house the wanted system is never fully explained and is actually very in depth and needs explanation to fully understand but its never explained how it all works also defending your self gets you in trouble but thy don't get in trouble for attacking you like i was jumped on the road so i killed my attackers another NPC saw this and ran off and reported that i murdered the people who were trying to kill me and i got a bounty or i road up on a NPC looking at a dead body i did not kill but he reported me the person who shows up to the crime scene after he found the body's i did not kill but because he saw my face i got a bounty for people i did not even kill that's how bad the bounty system is and no i could not have killed them and forgot about it because it was the first time i was ever in that area and somehow he know my face and my name to report me for a crime i did not commit like i was wearing a name tag the control scheme is so bad do you press it once tap it repeatedly or hold it thy all do something different and are all contextually based and why is the get on your house button and the grapple someone button the same button so if someone is next to your house and you try and jump on your horse you ether start choking a random NPC or you straight up tackle them to the ground getting you a bounty ( side not im dyslexic and use google to try and make sure i spell things right like control scheme and the first thing that popes up as a suggestion was control scheme red dead 2 that's how bad it is ) its the fact you cant abort actions mid way threw the action once you hit that button you must let the animation play out
its the fact that their is 6 different visible stat bars you must keep an eye on and one invisible one each with their own restore item
1 health bar
2 health core
3 stamina bar
4 stamina core
5 dead eye bar
6 dead eye core
and the invisible weight meter
that's not counting ammo honor gun degradation cleanliness and so on
then their is 4 visible stats for your horse and i invisible one each with their own restore item
1 health bar
2 health core
3 stamina bar
4 stamina core
and the invisible weight meter
that's not counting bonding or cleanliness
this game is an exercise in extreme multitasking their is so much to keep track of on a moment by moment basis
their is your health stamina dead eye how is your horse health stamina how is your wights are you eating enough how are your weapons are thy clean how is your camp you bringing them food and money you buying them stuff are you tracking down the items thy request because even tho thy can go out and do what you do all thy do is stay at cam asking you to do for them so realistic
its the fact that your gang members will step out of cover when their is still people shooting and get shoot and die which fails you the mission
the hunting only perfect hides are worth anything finding them is a chore on its own then their is having to know the exact weapon and ammunition to use to get the perfect hide and if you accidentally hit the dead body with your horse or kick it because you pressed the wrong button by mistake it lowers the quality of the hide
the legendary animals consist of the same thing find 3 hints that are realy close together then kill the animal and as long as you don't use explosives or shotguns to kill them the hide is always good making it easier to take down a legendary then it is to fined and skin a perfect hide thus making legendary animals more underwhelming then thy should be
their is just so much wrong with this game for it to be fun and the longer you play it the more you see its flaws i have completed the main story once with a 84% total completion then i started a new game ware im currently just starting chapter 3 with a 45% total completion so i have more then enough experience with the game to know what it is im talking about
what is sad is im having more fun playing threw spyro reignited then i did with RDR2 and its not because its an easier game but because when i fail in spyro i feel like it is my fault because i messed up as ware when i fail in RDR2 all i can blame is the game and how it control's because instead of letting me open my satchel and use an item its grayed out because Arthur is currently in a animation and by time i back out to let him finish the animation so i can go back in and use the item he has died because i could not use the item i needed when i needed to use it or one my other gang members in their wisdom decides walking into gun fire is a good idea
also picking what guns i want in my load out on the way to a mission just to find out once i hop off my horse my load out did not equip so i have to walk up to my horse just to get the weapons i already put in the slots i wanted them in before i got off my hose back into the slots i had them in is frustrating
or you on you horse using a bow shooting deer and you need to hop of your horse somehow the bow you were just using got left on the horse as you hoped off
or you were just using a rifle and you skin an animal and another one you want walks up you thing if i pull up my gun it should be the last gun i was using that's ware you would be wrong because rock star knows deep down inside that you realy wanted to draw was your handgun not your rifle and you shoot a perfect deer with a handgun instead of a rifle and their goes that perfect hide or lets say your mid skinning animation and a bear or wolf attacks and what you realy want is your rifle that you were just previously use but instead of your rifle you first get mauled because you cant exit an animation and the animation of you carrying a pelt make the animation of you drawing your weapon slower but you also default to your hand gun which is not vary effective against bears and wolfs
if i don't stop now i could keep going forever my point is this game has to many probables to be fun all relating to them trying to make it to realistic
Red dead redemption 1 was what got me into cowboy action shooting. Thanks for reviewing it. Check out the soundtracks for red dead one and red dead revolver also, masterpieces in their own rights.
Yes, they are. Very fun games.
I love playing rootin tootin cowboy shootin aka grand theft horse. Great way to unwind after a frustrating day... you know, those days when you wish you could still just hogtie and rob those that annoy you
@@jordanhicks5131 Oh yes!
@@jordanhicks5131 nah, its different from GTA.
Thank you for this! I've been waiting for a video like this since this game was released.
Thank you!
I a person who’s never been into westerns, this game has definitely sparked my interest. While playing, I noticed how Arthur and the gang had to live and how everything was back then. Now I’m watching westerns on Netflix and doing some research on the history. Just shows how great this game is.
TH-cam recommendations is working again
Great to see.
Uncle plays Space Invaders?!? Learn something new every day :D
HAHA!
although your guy looks way younger than Uncle, just to be clear :))
@@ericsbuds He's in the early stages of lumbago
I like how frequently the word "folks" is used. It kinda has a western/rural touch to it
I didn't know you existed! Now I do! And now I'm subbed!
Isn't it amazing how murder, thievery, and banditry in video games bring us all together?
Yeah! Tomorrow is a follow up to this one. Please catch it!
Lol how’d you get uncle and Dutch to feature in this
I know people.
Good job for embracing this new form media and its story, I know a lot of older people don’t acknowledge gaming as a history storytelling vessel that it can be. So it’s nice to see you talk about it:)
I keep seeing people commenting similar things, it's not like the guys in his 80's haha
This is so wholesome!! Thanks for the review it makes me happy to see this game receive so much well-deserved praise.
this is the level of nerdiness I came for. excellent attention to detail and accuracy
Thank you so much!
I watched 3:10 to Yuma a couple of days ago so you know I’m rocking the duel wield schofield revolvers
You go, Charlie Prince!
Not sure if this has been said already, but Actually, It kinda makes sense for the Mauser to be in the game. Later on, when it appears, The gang gets into a bit of trouble with a man named Angelo Bronte, Who’s an Italian businessman. It would kinda make sense for him/his bodyguards to have Mausers.
Good point!
That was actually how I acquired my first Mauser.
El Matador Yup same here.
Alex Ovi Angelo bronte has a Mauser if you loot him bud
Gavin’s Friend hence why I said ‘For him/his bodyguards’.
Now THIS one I liked. Very informative, it's as though you weren't pressed for time. A loo so love your comedic touch.
Thank you!
I had no idea this channel existed, but now I will binge all of the videos.
Thanks!
This game is set in 1899 so that means the c96 mauser IS plausible to own. Pretty hard i imagine but possible none the less.
Definitely is plausible, but I haven't seen many period photos in the Western US depicting folks wearing them. Since photos and documentation is provenance from the period, it's hard for me to say they were common. But....I keep looking!
Arizona Ghostriders that is a good point! And i loved the video btw!
Could you perhaps do a part 2 to this video since all this western stuff is really intriguing and i would love to know what else rockstar games got right and what they got wrong? I mean from clothing to way they speak..whatever! Ever since i played the original Red Dead Redemption i've been really interested in the 19th century america from the weapons to how they got their food! And you seem to know your stuff so i'd be interested in more.
Greetings from Finland!
@@Fl4m3tu5 Thank you and yes I will. Let me get some more recorded gameplay and I'll pick it apart!
Arizona Ghostriders hell yes! Thank you! You just earned a subscriber!
Especially the C-93 Borchardt
I remember getting interested in the wild west when I was 7, by watching for a few dollars more. Lee Van Cleef became my hero, and I always wanted to experience the wild west. Playing a game like rdr2 sure gave me that feeling.
That is a perfect reason for getting interested. Similar to my own.
I love any channel like yours who take their subject matter seriously but present it in a light hearted and well mannered way.
Much appreciated.
That was FUN to Watch..Nice Editings..
woah! i totally wasnt expecting you to review this! pleasantly suprised! i used to play the old game all the time, and i fricken loved it. im obsessed with the genre and im a bit of a cowboy myself anyways. ive been playing rdr2 nonstop for a couple weeks now. its great! not always perfectly accurate, but its probably as close as a triple a game is gonna get. i even put together an outfit i thought at least looked a little more accurate from afar with the buttons only halfway down and a white big valley hat with some batwing chaps. i should upload a video in the getup sometime. thank you for makin this video! loved every second of it!
So glad to hear it.
Great video! I did a mission where you’re bringing a criminal back to be the first human experiment for the electric chair and Arthur goes into graphic detail about stumbling across a field after a storm and finding cattle that had been struck by lighting. They def didn’t skimp on research on writing for the most part
They did a great job.
GREAT VIDEO DUDE I’m glad someone did something like this there’s something great about knowing how accurate your favorite games are!
Nice to know they did good, eh?
Great video! One of my all time favorite games!
I've been thinking about doing a video on the guns of Red Dead, might be a good opportunity for another collab.
That'd be cool.
I have no idea about the 'Volcano pistol', I think, in the game, and that would be interesting to see some information on.
@@MrPaul-bn9cl It's a rare gun now, but a lot of games use it. Not sure why.
You know I'm game, Duke.
The volcanic pistol is one of my favorites. Would of loved to have seen cartridge converted civil war era revolvers though. I wanted a 1847 walker to make a appearance.
Joshua Baker, just wait til it’s out for pc and people start modding. You’ll get your wish for sure
It's uhh actually not exactly a western, it is about the last days of "the west" and how the idea of the wild west was dying.
The entire game is actually spent running east/northeast.
The hat thing you mentioned? Well the gang didn't plan on going to the snow they were forced up there so he didnt get time to prep for clothes he just had what was on the caravan.
Some of the little critiques are actually related to the way story unfolds in the same way as the hat. But a fun watch this was.
Thanks for your input.The gang getting caught in the storm is sort of understandable,...yet they had coats. It wasn't a critique about the winter so much as the material the hat was made of.
True
The gang wasnt prepared for the storm but not because of clothing, but because of food and medicine
If they had both of those, the storm wouldnt be so bad
@@ArizonaGhostriders I think Arthur wears that hat because it used to be his fathers, so he would wear it no matter the weather
Yeah it’s the later part of the frontier age, but it’s 1899. It was still 12 years before rdr1 takes place, which is still considered a western.
So it's the Wild Wild East?
I just love the channel. Grazie!
You're welcome.
Very few cowboys needed controls to move.
HA!
Hope this isn’t the last time you visit Red Dead Redemption 2. Red Dead is the reason I subscribed to your channel a while back.
Great video but I wanted much more.
Oh, I'm sure I'll do more, but with a FT job it's hard to make a longer video.
What i hated was that they lacked the proper gun customization, in the sense that much of the guns weren’t polished, the nickel looked wrong, there weren’t any ivory grips, and the engravings weren’t that diverse. But for the most part it wasn’t that bad. I loved the game overall but I wish they would have done it a bit better.
Maybe the next one. They are on a roll.
There ARE ivory grips. The Schofield even has a "Hero" ivory grip with a good looking bald eagle on it. You can get it if you have high enough honor.
@@tinycockjock1967 Peacemaker also has it.
@@Siggorillo Ah sorry. Thanks for letting me know.
Personally I prefer the wood grips
Lotan saltoun those aren’t ivory grips, if you read the name you would know they say “pearl grips”. In light you will see that they are pearl grips not ivory.
this video is too wholesome for my heart, thank you
I just found your channel and I already love it! Glad to see how much effort Rockstar put into the game and it’s accuracy.
Glad you enjoy it!
I was always a fan of Western stuff. Not a hardcore fan but I enjoyed it.
Gunslingers and wanderers were always an interesting topic for me, so if I may, i would like to ask you a question
Are gunslingers an actual group of people? Meaning; when gunslingers walked around towns, they were called gunslingers? Or they were just folk with jobs like lawman that were real good at shooting?
And if they job was to be gunslingers, they got paid? Lawman just let them pass?
Another quick question: would you consider Rdr2 a game that could be use to learn a little bit from Western USA? If I say to my friends stuff like “The double barrel shotgun was common on that time” would I be correct? Cuz I aint an expert on USA since i am not from there
Sorry for the long comment, good video, i really enjoyed it!!!
Yes on the double barrel shotgun. Gunslingers were called shootist, gun-toters, gunmen, pistoleers...a whole lot of titles. Many were vets from the Civil War that had skills with guns and made a living out of using them. Lawmen, outlaws, hired guns (range wars, private detectives, bounty men, etc)
@@ArizonaGhostriders I understand now, thank you for the reply!
Instantly charmed by the light hearted humor! You got a new subscriber!
Thank you. It's our thing!
This got me into your channel, love your videos :)
Thank you so much. Welcome!
Just bumped into your channel a couple days ago and well. 'Became a subscriber immediately'!
My love for the Old West goes back to my childhood like most. The Old black and white shoot em ups and the singing cowboys.
But all that is a long stretch from reality.
When I really started learning about 'The Real West', the romance just grew out of control.
Anyway, love the fact versus fiction in this great era, that you provide, and will continue to watch. You guys stay cool and 'Watch your top knot'.
...And yes, 'I play RDR2', and love it... Thanks👍
Glad to hear it! We try too keep it interesting and educational.
Can u do another review once u finish the game?
Yep!
@@ArizonaGhostriders i can't wait for you to finish it:) it's "the best movie i played"
Arizona Ghostriders awesome!
I liked and subscribed, no kidding!
I was very impressed with the RDR2 and I have always liked old western memorabilia and history.
Thank you for doing this!
So glad to hear it!
This game did indeed spark an interest in old west things for me. Great video!
Thanks!
Loved this video and glad to say it ignited my interest in the old west and I’ve been trying to find some good movies to see!
Keep up the good work from Dundee, Scotland
Thank you! Appreciate the comment.
Gotta admit I prefer spaghetti westerns for the most part, but Red Dead 2 is just an absolute masterpiece overall. Genuinely epic. I just wish there was a way for non gamers to enjoy the whole story, they could watch videos but then they'd miss on all the details and choices that make the player bond with Arthur so much which gives the story so much impact
the story is just literally amazing. and yes, you would miss a crap ton by watching the cut scenes.
I usually associate the term “spaghetti western” with the style of cinematic music pioneered by Ennio Morricone. Red Dead is filled with it, especially during the mission horse rides and gun fights.
Red Dead Revolver is a Spaghetti Western
@@deadcaliph6414 Redemption 1 is kinda one too
Dude where u guys been all my life o.o i subscribed thanks guys
Thanks.
Nice video fun bit at the end lol
Absolutely loved this channel then slowly drifted. Recently made an account for the first time, and the algorithm brought me back. Swiftly subscribed
Thank you!
The game has been incredible, extremely Immersive and very hard to put down. Rockstar really took their time with it and the quality shows. Like your videos pure quality! i wish i knew how to record my ps4 to the computer for youtube. Great video!! Absolutely well done as always. Have a wonderful weekend and Happy Thanksgiving
Thank you, Brendan
@BrendanTheGent Even without a capture card, there should be an option to stream directly to a streaming service from your console. From there, you can grab your recording off of the recording site. You can even just stream to TH-cam if you wanted to have it on TH-cam.
@@NotStephenColbert i appreciate the info i will look into it, im still learning all of this. Thank you!
@@BrendanTheGent Not a problem! I'm always happy to help.
@@BrendanTheGent use the share button and you can save up to 15 mins of clip and upload it to youtube or you can stream from i believe twitch and youtube im not sure
I can officially say that this game has grown on me too much
Naaaawwww!! Never too much.
@@ArizonaGhostriders yep
Great info, loved the video.
Thank you very much!
One thing about the horses in this game. There was no Turkoman horses in the late 1800s and onwards. They had gone extinct in the early 18th century. Its closest relative would be the Akhal-Teke horse.
Good point.
I’m curious too about the way they talked. Was that accurate? Meaning like the words and language their used.
Mostly. There is a lot of conjecture as to whether or not folks used contractions, since court stenographers and documentarians showed they didn't...uh did not.
Can you make a seperate video discussing the currency and conversion rates?
Sure.
I love this game so much! And your review is sooooo good. Thank you!
Thanks!
I enjoyed this video very much.... loved the funny parts a lot! I love also the fact comments even get an answer even when just a short one and I think that's priceless. I just can't wait to see a final review when the game is over!
Keep up that ride, cowboys... Yeeeee-haw!!!!
Glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for watching!
This popped up in my suggestions. Man have you earned a subscriber. Also, although I'm a foreigner Arizona is my favorite state. Hugs from afar!
Thank you! Welcome!
Remember Ohio is the worst state. They steal land from smaller states and and have the worst sports team in not only the US, but the entire world. You can trust me because I'm from Michigan the state Ohio stole from.
@@trentn1127 well politically yeah, but it's a really beautiful state when it comes to natu- wait the fires killed everything. You're right it is the worst state. Ohio's a close second though.
@@trentn1127 I lived up in Northern California for about two years with my aunt and uncle when I about 15. The mountains we're beautiful (A little bit terrifying to drive on)This was right after gay marriage was legalized so the state wasn't as crazy and in fact where I lived was basically the opposite of the south politically. In fact there was a segregation sign in a town in el dorado county that said no colored people allowed. Of course it was a null law and black people were allowed in, but the city refused to take it down asserting it as a historical monument. People were understanbly outraged and I'm not exactly sure how the situation ended.
The first time you encounter the carcano rifle it is when you are in Guarma. It is made available after that.
Thanks for this video!
You're welcome.
One of TH-cam's recommendation hidden gems. I'm very glad to find this channel. I hope you have as much fun playing the game like I did!
Thank you.
What about the fact they load ALL bullets into the single action revolvers? Loading all bullets may allow for a misfire if the firing pin is even tapped up against a cartridge.
Yes, but in a gunfight you want 'em all.
If you dont take care of your guns they start missing firing.
Very good and funny review i love it good job.☺
This was great! I'd love it if you did something further in depth in a longer video.
Me too, but with a full time job it's all I can do to get these out.
Excellent review!
Thanks!