Ranking EVERY MLB MANAGER Tier List
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 ก.ย. 2024
- Ranking EVERY MLB MANAGER Tier List
My current MLB Manager rankings so far in the 2021 MLB Season, who do you think the best managers in MLB are?
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TWITTER: / giraffeneckmarc
INSTAGRAM: / giraffeneckmarc
TWITCH: / giraffeneckmarc
Discord: / discord
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Business Email: giraffeneckgaming@gmail.com
![CAMPปลิ้น | EP.82[1/2] แก๊ง 3 สาวเพื่อนซี้บุก CAMPปลิ้นครั้งนี้ห้ามเสียอาการ](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_6WUjXHe1TM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[UNCUT] “บอสณวัฒน์” ลากไส้!! ใครหนุนหลัง "แม่ตั๊ก ป๋าเบียร์" I คนดังนั่งเคลียร์ I 30 ก.ย. 67](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QlD7mU2KKRk/mqdefault.jpg)
You should do tier list of broadcast teams, how entertaining they are.
YESSS
Rockies in D or F, Don’t hate Drew but he isn’t a good announcer
Yes I agree
Phillies #1. McCarthey and Kruk are the best
YES
“Aside from the WS year things have been pretty rocky in Washington” that is a pretty big thing to put aside lol
He’s a Mets fan whose never witnessed his team winning a World Series. He clearly doesn’t understand the local impact of a World Series win
Ya he likes the Mets they’re in the same division as the Nats and Marc is usually always bias against the Nats
but was he wrong? nats did everything they could in their 2019 2nd half window to win the WS and they did. props to them, but their windows has now closed. i dont see how thats a very controversial statement.
I mean other than those magical 5 months the nats have had 3 months with a winning record
@@andrewlee8623 yea, he was. leading a team to a ws win is a very good look for any manager
You should rank every number one prospect in each organization
Something my favorite team (Orioles) would actually be good at!
"And that's why fransisco lindor is the best manager of all time"
😐
Dave Roberts is the most overrated manager in baseball. Give anyone his payroll and they make the playoffs. He always blows it in crucial moments. Definitely C-D tier
Agreed. Coming from a dodger fan
He relies on jansen to much in my opinion and also keeps on using cody bellinger and he still does bad against righties too this season and roberts is still using him against righties
Wait he just hit a homerun...
Give anyone that roster and they are good
Analytically I agree with you, but I think he brings motivation and care more than anything to the table
“…and that is why luis rojas is the greatest manager of all time”
Kapler is “S” tier. That roster…..and the best team in baseball. You just hate him for his time in Philly
bro HES NOT BEING BAISED SHUT UP
@@bobataco210 you do know it was a joke lmao
#lolmets
Do a tier list of each teams farm system
Why would I care about the farm
What does the farm system do beside make the grass better
@@1biasedherbertfan979 Is that a joke
@@PoopScoopCoop ok if I am being honest
@@PoopScoopCoop I just learned this week that a farm system is minor leagues not people who do the farm
Tito at B is criminal
Tell me about it, every time you think the Indians are about to be bottom feeders and hard reset on a rebuild. He takes the most mediocre (Besides their pitching rotation) roster and makes them respectable. Especially this year, with all the Injuries to the pitching rotation.
Francona should be higher. I doubt you watch many Indians games, but every game the announcers always talk about how Terry gets the players hyped way up before every game. And also, they always perform FOR him (on top of the normal reason of winning ofc) when he's out
Thank you
Yea francona should be s even as I division rival teams fan
Lowass payroll and always competitive. S teur
S tier
I agree with you. I wish I could go back in time and tell the cardinals to have hired him. I bet they would have won another World Series in that 2012-2015 range
“…and that’s why Luis Rojas is a better manager than Kevin Cash”
Luis Rojas didn’t take out Snell in game 6
Other Tier Lists:
Other Starting Pitchers
Closers and or bullpens as a whole
DHs
Other starters would be cool
Announcers tier list would also be cool
A GM one would be cool but maybe that’s just me
@@alexanderstrubeck6253 I doubt he would be able to rank every one
Maybe a overrated, neutral rated and underrated thing too would be fun
I’m finally getting the respect I deserve
U sometimes make the stupidest decisions tho
@@XOTWOD415 Kapler is good and rarely makes bad decisions tbh
@@mnmproductions7403 no kapler was terrible in Philadelphia and is one of the biggest reasons why they underachieved and had ont of the worst bullpens in history he doesn’t know how when to pull guys and when to leave them in
@@davidlevison9334 And Bill Belichick was awful in Cleveland with the Browns, which was his first head coaching job. But smart leaders learn from their mistakes. I think Kapler has obviously learned a great deal; for example, the Giants' bullpen is very fine this year. He's not Belichick yet, and may never be, but let's watch and see...
If Aaron Boone is anywhere near A there will be a problem
he is a F
If u think boones the issue ur j a dumb fan
As yankees fan aaron Boone has to be an F
@@adamsharaf1188 he is mostly lol. He’s a below average manager. His lineups make no sense and like Marc said in the vid he plays guys like Brett Gardner and Tyler Wade way too much. Their both below average hitters and in today’s mlb you need hitters up and down the lineup. Also his pitching decisions are sometimes suspect. He’s D tier imo
@@Prodigy-ei7jg it’s common knowledge that that’s upper managements doing Boone doesn’t make the lineups
Dave robberts just has a good team that’s all I have to say
Exactly he’s a shit manager
@Prayingmantis211 he was the asg manager cause his team was the one who got the end. Don’t forget the year we were in 4th place in may/June and came back 20 games. For a dude who only does what he’s told he does everything else perfectly. His bullpen decisions are the front offices decisions almost all of the time and relying on the analytics is just a bet that doesn’t work out sometimes. He can work on taking more control in serious moments but in the end he won’t cause that’s what is gonna keep him at the helm.
I know, he’s just lucky. He and his team have also blown it several times before 2020. And they have the best team, why are they not at the top of their division. Imagine getting beat out by the Giants.
@@thecaynuck4694 we pretty much have one of our stars Injured every game of the season so far
Exactly. Anyone could manage that team.
The disrespect from joe maddon smh. Without trout, rendon and half the season from walsh maddon has held his own with a below average squad
Yessir Bob Melvin gets the best out of every player we have.
GO A’s!!!!
"Who is this guy again?" Perfect example of the A's, Melvin has been there for years and he just methodically wins games. If only they could win a WS, love their success. They were what the Cardinals were for a long time, pulling success out of their rears.
Can you rank every MLB Owner please?! That would be a nice video
Rockies in F
I’m a Yankees fan and even I would put Boone at F tier
He should be at z tier 🤣
As a Yankees fan I would have loved for you to put him in F tier he had 1 good moment and it was the savages in the box moment.
YESSIR I LOVED THAT MOMENT
You’re definitely right dude, he definitely didn’t take the 2019 Yankees to the ALCS after 30+ injuries. You’re goddamn right
@@bri.51 it wasn't cause of him
@@mistersunshine1330 you’re right dude. It’s not him who helped the 2019 Yankees, but it IS his fault for the 2021 Yankees 😂
@@bri.51 You been watching?
Really think you’re underrating Tito. He’s an A I think. He’s done a lot with bad ownership in Cleveland.
You should do a tier list of every front office.
Dodgers
- gap -
Everyone else
Andrew Friedman in Godtier
@@aaroni.3655 That couldn't be further from the truth hahahahah. Throwing ridiculous amount of money around does not make them good
@@aaroni.3655 throwing big amounts of cash and buying championships don’t make you good ownership. The best front offices are the ones who went through the rebuild process and developed their teams.
@@thecaynuck4694 oof that was a rough try.. Dodgers have been the best team in the league at developing talent. They haven’t bought anything.. even Mookie was traded for. All trades under Friedman have included young top prospects. Dodgers fan or not, that argument you brought up holds no weight, this isnt the early 2000 Yankees
Marc: Dave Roberts doesn't have a lot of ego and changes his decisions.
Dave: Jensen will be the closer of this team until his arm falls off.
Charlie Montoyo is a F Manager and deserves the boot and Pete Walker deserves the Manager role he is the best Pitching Coach in the MLB Robbie Ray, and J.A Happ are 2 examples of careers that got turned around by him
Craig Counsell and Kevin Cash are clearly the best managers
Bob Melvin
Cash, Counsell, and Melvin are obviously the top managers because they the managers of Rays East (Rays), Rays North/Central (Brewers), and Rays West (Athletics).
Gabe Kapler?
@@Anonymxus1 used to think the brewers and royals had a lot of turnover between the two. Obviously the Grienke trade did a lot of that, then the Moose trade, then Cain came back to MKE. And the Royals even took our former manager in Yost
I’m a Yankees fan and I think Boone was to high
Same
Been watching Dave Roberts since his first year, and I can pretty safely say the Dodgers would not have had the success they've had without him. The main thing about him is that his greatest strength is also his greatest weakness, which is trusting and relationships with his players. He's an extremely active and expressive guy, and has and makes great connections with his players, but sometimes his trust and relationships with the players can get in the way, namely with bullpen managing (take 2019 NLDS for example). All and all, really smart manager in most situations, and probably the best players manager in the game, glad to have him on the team, cause the Dodgers would be empty without him.
My overall assessment of Kapler: he has done great this season of course and is probably the runaway manager of the year for the NL. Some of his bullpen decisions this year have thrown me off. I'm not ready to throw him into the elite category until we've seen how he performs in the playoffs. Hopefully the experience he gets from this year, assuming we make it, will help him in later playoff runs
I agree his bull pen decisions are shit
@@XOTWOD415 A lot of them make sense tho if you listen to his press conferences
@@XOTWOD415 He made some that didn't work early on, but he's fixed that. A big part of being a good manager is identifying the players who will help you in the long run, and I think he has done that with the Giants' bullpen. Early on he had a lot of guys he had to try out, but the ones who were inconsistent or unreliable aren't there anymore.
Cora has made a lot of weird moves lately, some of which have cost the Red Sox big time. He's been really good overall, but, just like the rest of the Red Sox, has had a bad August so far.
As a bias Jays fan BANG ON MARK!!
Terry Francona is S in my opinion because each year he takes the lowest payroll team in the league and he makes them somewhat competitive each season.
@Dogboy Gacha look at the past 5 years.
@Dogboy Gacha a whole 1 game. Wow
For real
Gardners last 15 games, he’s had a .293 average. Sure, his numbers aren’t the best right now but for our past week, Gardner has been carrying the Yankees with clutch hits: (Walk off against Seattle, Tying the game in two different extra inning appearances against the Royals).
Nicky Lopez has been clutch for the royals does that mean he would start everyday for a playoff contender?
@@joshclose9515 well no because the royals aren't a contender. Fact of the matter is Garder is on a contender and playing well.
Esteban Florial has to start not Gardner he sucks
I don't know anything about baseball, but I trust you
i’ll be honest. counsell does make some questionable decisions but he is amazing at what he does. great manager
As a Reds fan, Counsell is incredible. His job isn’t to do the obvious decision 24/7, anybody can do that. But he has taken the good Brewers and brought them a level up this season
Watch the mariners comeback against the Astros where they did the insane double switch and Servias absolutely played Dusty Baker like a fiddle
What’s the date on that?
exactly lol. he’s high b low a at least
@@dylanashford July 26
I think Joe Maddon should be higher look what he did with the cubs him and theo epstien turned that God awful team into world series winners.
The tigers have been so much more fun to watch this year with A.J. Hinch
Rojas and Boone need to go down
Respect for putting BoMel in S tier. He's done so much with our A's teams over the last decade with a lot less to work with than most teams have. He's currently the longest tenured manager in MLB for a reason: he's simply great.
And now Bob is going to a team with a real payroll in San Diego. Let's see if he can work his magic there as well.
You're completely right about Mike Matheny. One of the Cardinals' biggest highlights of the past few years was firing him.
As a Yankee fan I think that you overestimated Boone I say he's a f
Royals fan here- the problem isn’t Matheny. It’s our GM Dayton Moore. He’s absolutely atrocious. His boneheaded moves give any manager an impossible job.
I agree as a Royals fan. I don’t think Matheny is great but he’s definitely not the worst manager in baseball
"So this is why Luis Rojas is an S tier manager"
It’s so impressive what Bob Melvin is able to do. A’s have been to the playoffs more than any team but the Dodgers since 2012 and when you look at the rosters he’s had since then they are nowhere near as good as many others. Yes, playoff success eludes him, but his rosters don’t have much business being in the playoffs to begin with when you look at them on paper.
Yea and Bob Melvin always finds a way to get us to win games in clutch moments, the A’s got the most walkoffs since 2012 for a reason.
@@Grievous_ definitely. I also love his adjustment of being more aggressive on the base paths. Once they got Marte, not only has he let him run wild, but lots of other guys have been getting in on it too and it’s led to a lot of runs.
That you put Dusty Baker anywhere other than ‘F’ puts your entire tier criteria into question. Baker never, ever in his career been an even competent manager. He is a coattail riding screw off who gets primo gig job after someone else builds the teams the year before. Joe Girardi, same issue but he is a very capable manager. But same thing, he won the ‘09 World Series with a Joe Torre built team.
I agree with a lot of your choices but I think AJ Hunch should be on the S level. I'm born and raised in Detroit but I'm not being a homer. After watching the Tigers the past 5 to 6 seasons it's actually fun to go to Comerica or watch them on tv cause they are so competitive and fun to watch. I truly am encouraged about the future for the Tigers
Even as a Giants fan I was thinking Gabe Kapler was not a good fit for our organization but he really is proving us all otherwise this year. For some reason this rag tag squad Zaidi built works well with his managerial style.
Davey Martinez may not be the best manager in baseball but I do think he is one of the best and nicest person in baseball
“What’s this guys friggin name Bob Melvin?”
Most fans including myself thinking that Charlie Montoyo was bad hire . He was for the most part a career- minor-league manager in the Tampa Bay Devil Rays/Rays system until 5 years ago when he was promoted to Tampa's major league coaching staff after 18 years working in the minors. Being that he is 55 years old; one would think he would've been given a chance much soon than 2019 if either Tampa or another organization thought that he was worth the risk to be promoted/hired as the manager.
I’m a Yankees fan and if Boone isn’t F then this list is bad
Lol
Horse shi*. That’s dumb putting Boone at C dumb dumb dumb. He has lead them to the playoffs every year he was with them. Rank him higher.
As a Yankees fan I believe Boone is F tier. Our best lineup doesn’t include Gleyber or Gardner. Idc how good Gleyber could be he just doesn’t produce on both sides of the ball. And with Gardner I mean cmon he’s like 90 years old he can’t still be starting. And on top of all of this he literally has no idea how to use the bullpen. Sorta like Joe Torre he needs everybody around him to do his job. Just a puppet is an understatement
Gabe Kapler is hands-down NL Manager of the Year. Tory Lobella was extended. Jayce Tingler is already gone.
All the Yankees fans saying Boone is F, he’s def not great but the ENTIRE pitching staff is out right now and management put together a bunch of strikeout prone, swing for the fence righties to be the team for the season until recently. He’s not great but he’s not F, they’ve also had the most injuries in the league w pretty much every starter going down a some point
Mets: the mets are losing this year, but it is not luis Rojas fault.
Every other team: they are losing so this manager is bad.
This guy thinks terry francona, a baseball legend, barely makes a difference
Les go w
Terry francona in b tier ?????
YESSIR!!!! Bob finally got some respect
Wtf is the disrespect for tito? He literally is the winningest manager in indians history. This is easy s tier. It is complete disrespect to have terry francona in the same category as tony la russa
Maybe its time, for a GM rankings, also Baltimore has said that Hyde is the manger of the future, we just arent seeing it because the parts have not been installed yet
Bob Melvin S tier but costing the As the playoffs everytime
Roberts is a C tier manager, he just has so much talent around him its almost impossible to fail in the regular season, when it comes to big games he makes dumb moves to make his team lose (constantly bringing Kershaw in from the bullpen, pitch Kenley almost every game, etc.)
As a dodgers fan I agree
Montoyo worst manager in baseball, no question
Agree!
“What’s this guy’s name? Bob Melvin? S tier!”
here after Montoyo blew another game with a boneheaded pitching change..
Bluejays have not had a competent manager since Cito Gaston
Montoyo is going to be the reason the jays miss the playoffs by like 2 games
Shildt is f tier. He has a very talented squad in St. Louis and still continues to run them into the ground. The cardinals players underperforming is part of it, but I put 85% of the blame on schildt. I would matheny over schildt any day. Personally I really matheny and I think he did have positive effect on the cardinals in his time in St. Louis.
I would take matheny*
Personally I really like matheny*
Dusty Baker is a "C" at best. His teams do well in the regular season because he always inherits loaded rosters. I'd like to see how he does with the Pirates' or Orioles' rosters.
Dude what the hell is your problem? What did Gabe ever do to you?
Tingler is good, and is usually pretty smart, but it seems sometimes that he never has his players' backs
I'd have rated him B-C tier. The Padres have great young players and are developing well but I am not confident Tingler can lead them to a World Series title. He is much better than Andy Green was but Andy Green was a solid F tier manager.
La Russa Will win manager of the year this year. Although he has a great team, virtually most of the starting lineup has been hurt for great amount of the year and this team was 20 over .500 by the time Robert and Eloy came back.
Let’s be honest. You, nor I have any idea how good these managers actually are. We aren’t in the clubhouse
Braves fan here, but from watching how he manages and his interviews before and after the game, he definitely has opened up to analytics
Although I agree with you, I definitely still have Snitker around B. Might be able to creep up to a very low A. Definitely feel some bullpen choices can be very odd from him, but also feel like Kranitz has a lot of influence there, so is it 100% Snit? Idk. At the end of the day, they know baseball better than I do. But I definitely think I have Snit hovering around high B. (Braves fan if you didn’t realize).
It does feel wrong to have Snitker and Girardi in the same tier as Terry Francona, David Bell, and Tony La Russa. I definitely have both of them above these guys.
Argument against Dave roberts in a: Donnie baseball did the same thing really. Roster is super talented and I think roberts really overmanages in big spots
I understand some of the complaints against Robert’s but imo he’s a good manager. Even though they have lost in some big moments the Dodgers weren’t making it to the World Series without him. They’ve been to the World Series in 3 of his 5 years as manager. No matter how talented your team is baseball is such an unpredictable sport so that’s a surprising amount of success at the beginning of his managing career.
Yeah he makes questionable decisions in the bullpen but he’s still a good manager.
Luis Rojas is the kind of manager that the players love to play for because he’s not about discipline and the players feel more relaxed. I personally think Rojas has to draw a line with the players and discipline them, tell them they’re not playing well and they need to step it up, instead of just showing that he’s a pushover and that the players can do whatever they please.
Pretty good rankings for the most part. I’d move Joe Madden to A tier personally though. Went to World Series with Rays, won World Series and broke 100 yr Cubs curse and is playing .500 baseball with Angels team with no Mike Trout, Anthony Rendon as a shell of himself due to injuries and still a very meh pitching staff.
Also, I’d move Luis Rojas to C tier. Just haven’t seen enough from him, but I like the fact hell fight for his players. Along with Tiengler who is probably B tier.
“That’s why I think Luis Rojas will lead the Mets to a World Series and therefore he goes into S tier”
You say the same thing every video about Marc being extremely biest
But your not wrong
I wonder what Phillies fans think about seeing Kapler higher than Girardi
I personally absolutely love Tony won’t shift.
The reds have been burnt by using the shift so much this year.
As a Royals Fan I’m glad I’m not the only one that sees how bad Mike Matheny is.
EVERY BROADCASTER TIER LIST PLEASE MARC
MLB Team Broadcast Commentators Tier List Please
As a Yankees fan I can honestly say we would have won a world series if we kept Girardi or got Cora.
no
As an Angels fan, C tier is about right for Maddon
Now do hitting coaches
Eating the Mike Shiltz hate right now.
I think LaRussa should be at least S or A but your right he doesn’t shift.
Agreed
It offends me how Boone is ahead of Montoyo
As a Reds fan, I cringed when you put Bell that high 🥴
That what I’m saying David bell is like D tier the only thing that saves him from an F to me is the players seem to like him 😂. Other than that he’s garbage I’m waiting for him to realize we need to cut Doolittle he’s so bad.
Melvin babyyy
S: Cash, Tito, Hinch, Counsell, Cora, Kapler
A: Dusty, Melvin, Girardi, Tingler, Tony, Davey
B: Shildt, Snitker, Maddon, Rojas, Servais, Ross
C: Baldelli, Hyde, Black, Shelton, Lovullo, Bell
D: Boone, Montoyo, Matheny, Woodward, Roberts, Mattingly
Managers shouldn’t get the credit for hitting and pitching coaches
Hey Marc the Mets still “chocked” the division
Chocked??? As in the block that holds up a boat???
@@Ampaof3 it’s a joke go to his Twitter
David bell is f trust me he is so bad
As a yankee fan he deserves to be lower
Aaron Boone at C is wayyyy to high he is an F-
Roccos been good this year he’s been better than the other guys in the c tier his guys have just not helped him out and the team sold with injuries and not a whole lot of depth hurt this team
Rocco’s use of the bullpen along as his leash with his starters has been absolutely terrible all year long regardless of injuries
Mets bias 4 sure on Luis Rojas😫
Francona is S tier
Bob Melvin is the man