MLB Manager Tier List
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ต.ค. 2024
- Get your first month of ad-free private search with Neeva by clicking here neeva.com/gira...
Ranking every MLB manager for the 2022 season on a tier list! #mlb #baseball #tierlist
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
🐦 / giraffeneckmarc
📷 / giraffeneckmarc
⏰ / giraffeneckmarc
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Business Email: marc@slashmgmt.com
![[Full Episode] The Restaurant War Thailand ศึกพ่อค้าซ่าแม่ค้าแซ่บ Episode 2 | 29 ก.ย. 67](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/r3lfLNH6Ke4/mqdefault.jpg)
“And that is why Buck Showalter is the greatest manager of all time”
The only reason why I don’t really like this guy is because he has such high expectations for the Mets and think they are the best when they literally are about to lose to the Padres. ( coming from a Yankees fan)
@@judahshorts4931 Don’t jinx us bro
@@judahshorts4931 How dare Mark as a fan of the Mets, the team he loves, have high expectations for his team 🤣
Jinx was real. Rip Mets 😂
they lose today haha
7:03, dusty baker is finally a World Series champion. He has now earned his spot in S tier🙌🏻
Craig Counsell, while I don’t think the brewers collapse was his fault, I think had his worst season in terms of decision making this season. Whether that is having a short leash on his starters or refusing to start Keston Hiura against righties. I still think CC is a great manager but he didn’t have a lot to play with this year.
Counsell should have been removed from managerial duties after the 2019 season and absolutely after the Brewers got eliminated in the divisional series last year. He really is holding the team back, they succeed in spite of his decisions. I can't believe Marc contemplated having him in the S tier let alone in the A tier.
@@FootballClubDavid_WI_USA don’t you think the talent on the roster has something to do with it??? Wouldn’t you think? The manager is never the sole reason why a team doesn’t have success
Love Brian snitker go Braves!
Thank you for showing Scott the love he deserves. Dude doesn't make perfect choices every time, but he has won so many 1 run games throughout his tenure and he has cultivated such an atmosphere in the clubhouse. His players clearly love him, and he always has their back. Dude is easily the 2nd best manager in team history and has a chance to surpass Lou in the next few years
Mariners definitely playing like a family!! Him and Baltimore’s manager should be co - managers of the year
Today’s game definitely knocked him down a tier or 5
Scott Servais ain't great, homie...
Rob Thompson better be high up for what he did for the Phillies this year
Agreed, should get some NL manager of the year consideration
Agreed
Idk.. A guy that almost blow a high probability chance to make the playoffs?!?!? Sure he did pretty well but let’s not get ahead of ourselves.
@@DAndreFalcon he didn’t start the year as the Phillies manager, when he took over the Phillies were still below .500. Him taking over sparked that big winning streak they went on in Junr
@@ninjabanana0885
Im very aware of that. They were like 4 or 5 games under .500, still doesn’t change anything. The team under performed with the talent it has and barely made the playoff regardless who the manager is. 🤷🏿♂️ maybe it’s just me but the Mets and Dodgers and Braves skipper had better seasons.
The Cardinals hiring Matheny over Francona back in 2011 still haunts us as a franchise.
Nope
To be honest. I thought he was good the first few years. He did take them to a World Series and a few deep runs to the NLCS.
Heres my top 10:
1. Terry
2. Snitker
3. Dusty
4. Counsell
5. Cash
6. Servais
7. Roberts
8. Hyde
9. Hinch
10. Thompson
I would maybe move Counsell down to 6 and bump up Cash and Servais, but this feels like the correct list
Joe Musgrove owns the Mets!!
I agree with the Dave Roberts ranking despite his pitcher usage mishaps in the playoffs. Yes, he has great talent but he consistently gets the best out of them. If it’s just about talent, why wasn’t Mattingly getting the Dodgers to the WS in 13-15? Why didn’t the Padres and the Mets make the playoffs in 2021? The 2022 White Sox had talent, right?
I’d agree as a Astro fan
Mattingly didn’t have the close to the team roberts has
Because mattingly did have near this team? 😂😂😂 he’s won 1 ring in how many years of being the best team in baseball?
@@officalatom4055 In all fairness, Mattingly had a different team built under a different GM. The teams that Roberts have are more in line with the modern game and have incredible depth. Mattingly was not the right manager for the Dodgers and that was obvious but in all fairness, he had a payroll but these later Dodgers teams are built better.
Gabe Kapler should be bottom 5
Let me be more specific, he's a D and that's being generous, if you were a Giants fan you'd agree
Derek Shelton is F tier. I can confirm
These tier lists are really entertaining
Dave Roberts ? Even a kid would manage the best team in basesball
Yes but if you bring the team to the LCS or World Series pretty much every year for the past five years then you have to give him credit. There are some managers who constantly waste talent with bad decisions.
@@franzreyes846 Dont hate
@@johnnycage1057 what? I'm responding to the comment hating on Roberts and saying we should give him credit.
@@franzreyes846 My bad I totally miss read your reply
Mets = Musgrove Ended Their Season
Buck Showalter should head to the C tier for crying wolf on Musgrove. That was clearly a motion of weakness.
I'm so glad he gave Scott Servais some love this year. I think if he beats Houston this series he should be bumped up to S tier. AL manager of the year between him and Francona for sure.
If Terry Francona is not the al manager of the year there is a problem because everyone and their mother had them finishing as a bottom 5 teams.
Servais >
Servais >
Back to back 90 win seasons while managing a team that’s become the best in the league in 1 run games statistically. 🤷🏻♂️
I do think francona had an amazing season all things considered, I believe servais has to be right there with him. Especially how he managed the bullpen and the culture he has helped build in this mariners franchise.
@@jacksonmatthew6447 Francona in his last year in the league beats everyone
Agreed. This may be Francona’s best managing season ever. Guardians expected to be bad (many predictions had them in 3rd or 4th, with some even having them 5th with 90-95 losses). Not only that, but they have an average roster age younger than the average AAA team, with a total of 17 rookies making their major league debut. Also only like 2 players above the age of 30. Say what you want about “It doesn’t count because it’s the AL Central!!!”, but winning 92 games with that extremely inexperienced roster is unbelievable
Boone is severely underrated, yes he has all the money but in his first year as manager everyone got injured and he still managed to win 103 games
He makes a lot of questionable decisions when it comes to lineup building and bullpen management. He could be worse but you’d have to be particularly bad to not have a good record with the resources the Yankees have
@@mx4159 bullpen management I could understand as a knock. But lineups are out of his control, I’d be willing to bet. Front office is probably writing up those lineups with some of his input.
@@somekindofchris_ that’s probably correct. I guess I can’t completely hold that against Boone but it’s still frustrating nonetheless lol
Overrated****
@@mx4159 ya youd have to be Joe Girardi levels of trash
“All managers struggle with bullpen management”. Scott Servais would like a word
"It is time for Andres Muñoz to pitch"
To be fair it’s harder to mess up with a bullpen that good
@@organicorange37 “hm yes, today I would like to win this baseball game methinks”
uh oh
And then he decides to put Sewald in after what happened in Toronto
Ross had not a lot to work with coming into the season, started rough finished strong but the guys played hard all season. Really couldnt ask more of him tbh
Love my cubbies
I think with all the Red Sox injuries to their key guys Cora did a really good job keeping them near .500. Not to mention they were a really competitive team against teams not named the rays and blue jays.
and yankees.
@@joetheegg6333 Yeah they played a lot of competitive games against the Yankees tho. 15 games were decided by 1-3 runs
As a Red Sox fan, it's ridiculous to blame any of it on Cora. Dude is the only reason they made the playoffs last season and has consistently done more with less since 2018. Bloom and the Henry's are failing him.
He was given a god awful bullpen too and gave guys like Schrieber a chance to strive. The blame should really be on bloom for giving him such a shitty roster outside of like 3 or 4 players
@@yourdad1805 still went 6-13 against the Yankees
"Sometimes he's a little too dependent on the numbers"
Marc just described Brandon Staley to a tee
Marc must be sweating bullets now. Mets are one game away from packing it in. Also, Gabe Kapler is not a smart guy. I don't care what anyone says.
You should do every starting pitcher
Dusty is going to the hall of fame regardless if he wins a World Series. He should be in the top tier..
I completely agree. Dusty always seems to manage great teams. Maybe Dusty has something to do with that.
well there is no debate now on that world series bit
Buck Slowalker tried to rattle my man Joe Musgrove tonight and it back fired. I’m sure he called that hbp on Grish. Coward move, couldn’t handle his pitchers getting owned by him lol what a joke. Go home Mets, not this year🤣
Rob Thompson is the best manger this year.
Mets were just upset by the Padres and are the only 100 win team to not make the ALDS since its inception in 1995
Dave Roberts is the most overated manager
Who else is here after the Mets got eliminated lol
And that is why Buck Showalter will win Manager of the Year and MVP in 2022.
LOL 10.5 GAME LEAD BLOWN I THOUGHT METS RAN NY? WHAT HAPPENED??? WE SMOKING ON THAT MET PACK 🚬🤣
calling our ws in 19 "flukey" is so cringe we literally had a top 3 rotation with guys like turner, rendon, soto, zimmerman, kendrick on offense; "they just got hot" we had a top 3 record in baseball from june on but ok lmfao
Exactly, people say the same with my Braves
No way he put buck in b lol
Totally agree on Rocco Baldelli. Too many blown games and he’s terrible at managing pitching.
“Dusty Baker. The guy’s a great manager. His player’s love him!”
Tell that to Mark Prior and Kerry Woods’ arms.
Didn’t realize there were that many managers named Dave lmao four in a row 😂
How do you feel after that monumental loss Marc? Mets fans mouths write checks that their asses can’t cash
I’ve been very critical of Kapler in the past but I’m willing to cut him some slack this year because of the lack of talent on the roster. Our entire lineup this year was made of of platoons pretty much. Lack of star power and everyday players makes it tough to succeed. We’ll be able to give critical opinions on Kapler once he has a roster expected to compete for the playoffs.
Nah fuck that fire him now
Can you do mlb radio announcers tier list?
Mets lost WHY DID THIS TEAM CHOKE THEY WERE MY NLCS LOSER
As a twins fan I hope we fire Rocco. D tier is fitting, he has good qualities like caring about the players and health management. He just doesn’t put the best lineup out there, uses his bullpen excessively and poorly and he doesn’t steal like ever. The number of close games we had a chance to win if we played a little small ball is astronomical
THANK YOU SOMEONE FINALLY AGREES WITH ME
brian snitker is the best manager ever
I hope he doesn't become another Bobby Cox though, winning all those division titles and only 1 world series.
I think the dbacks make a playoff run next year
Marc is 100% correct about Davey Martinez, he was never a good manager and when the Nationals got hot in 2019 he wasn’t even managing the team due to heart problems
Did you text 👆him?
sorry about your mets marc, can’t believe a roster with that much talent got shut down at home.
boone deserves more credit hindsight is 20/20 everyone called us a 3rd or 4th place team and he managed us to first place and in 2019 he won 103 games with judge stanton and others missing significant time
yeah he should be B-A
He also didn’t help with the Yankees collapse towards the end of this year
Dave roberts masterclasses whenever he puts in craig kimbrel
“And this is why Buck Showalter is the best manager in MLB and deserves manager of the year”
This is realistic so it’s not really funny
@@legendarywatermelon1678 But it's not lmfao
@@legendarywatermelon1678 Has a 300 million dollar team and couldn't even win the division
Sorry for the mets to lose😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
I’m glad u put Rocco Baldelli very low. Little people know this since Minnesota is a smaller market but might be one of the dumbest in game managers we have seen for a while. The front office is just as bad or even worse, but yeah the Minnesota Twins coaching as a whole is very very bad.
@@Thomas-yq8fs exactly, Rocco was a really good in game manager this season but Twins fans need to blame someone
back to let you know mets got bounced in wild card round
“And that is why Craig Counsell is actually my twin brother”
In my opinion Marmol should be A teir
Craig Counsell is not a good manager. Good video
“STAND UP SAN DIEGO,STAND UP”!!!!!
My top 3 managers for this season would be Francona, Showalter, and Thompson. My bottom 3 are Larussa, Matheny, and Montoya. Hope Buck gets a ring!
I actually think this is a very fair and accurate list
Agreed, but he rated Buck Showalter too low with a "B". After this list came out Buck won the fourth Manager of the Year Award of his career (the others being with the Yankees, Rangers, and Orioles). He hasn't won them by luck or accident; Buck's the real deal!
Philly rob is the best manager in the game
Dusty Baker invented the high-5, that alone should put him in S-Tier
Boone is the worst manager in the MLB.
Mets got cooked, never talk on Yankees again
Boone is a B based on how you ranked other managers after him. Guy took a 4th place predicted Yankees team and won the division easily. Averages 97-98 wins a year in the toughest market. Team has won a post season series* every year except in 2021. Bullpen fell apart 2nd half this year and he pieced it together.
*-WC game = series
Who else is here after the Mets meltdown? lol
Thank you so much for the tedo love
METS WHAT HAPPENED?????🤣🤣🤣
Thank you for putting Nevin in F. He deserves it for starting the fight with the Mariners
"And that's why Buck Showalter is the best manager in baseball"
4 managers named david or Dave Lol
As a Jays fan, no thank you to Jays keeping Schneider after that Seattle series
I really do feel for you my guy.
As a mariners fan, I can't remember how many times I thought, is this the year? And come the end of September we would pack it up and wait a whole off-season. Twenty one times over we did that. It sucks. But I think this jays team is something special l. I think they're going to have a fire under their skin and it will motivate them for next season making the right moves and playing the game the right way. I'm really excited for them! Honestly
@@jacksonmatthew6447 ya blowing the lead they did was inexcusable and I just had higher hopes for them, I do root for your Mariners right now though… beat them Astros! Lol
@@bcarroll15 I feel it man.
Houston? Cake Walk.
Yanks? We were their daddy in the regular season!
Braves? You know how the last series we played against them went. Walk off win hitting two bombs in a row to win two outa three. Let's go Ms
@@bcarroll15 Ultimately the Astros losing is what really matters lol. Here’s to hoping the Ms can make it happen
@@tjtribble. Astros & Yankees… they both need to lose 😂
Hahahahah mets l Padres trash on ya
When are you going on your apology tour?
How are you doing on your playoff predictions? So far you were wrong on three of four. Can I be this horrible at predictions and have a TH-cam channel, too?
Well Dusty has his ring S tier
Marc clearly made this more than 2 days ago.
If you're talking only this year, I have to agree with you about David Ross. However I think when he had his manager debut in 2020 after Joe Maddon got fired, I thought he did a great job managing that team. I feel like if Maddon was still managing that year, they wouldn't have won the division. And I know it was the covid year, but he knew what kind of team he had, and used it to the best of his abilities. I think the differences with this new team he has is that it's a new team. He doesn't fully know how to properly steer the ship because it's brand new. But the second half of the season shows me that he's learning more about his team and how to steer it in the right direction.
David Ross is purely a locker room guy
Where you at Mark? Lol
How about them Mets
Aaaaaaaaaand da mets lose!
Hahaha hahaha mets rip
dusty baker s tier
Mets p plzzzzzzzzz hahahahah
Can we get a new playoff bracket video since the Mets season is over😂
METS ARE POVERTY
Everything you say from here on in is 100% facts someone hire this man at ESPN
Buck at B is insane
Marc, what were you thinking by rating Buck a mere "B"? You talk about be solid but making mistakes, but that can also typify this selection. Granted, you were premature, coming out with your rankings before the Manager of the Year selection. By now you know he won the NL award this season. That makes four times he's been picked for that honor, including prior selections with the Yankees, Rangers, Orioles, and now Mets. He didn't do that by luck, and you should show a little more respect.
Astros v braves
While I do believe Dave Roberts has gotten better over the years, I still can't see him as a good manager. The team is so stocked that they really don't need much to be unstoppable (and that's been a growing thing since Mattingly), yet that doesn't work the same way for playoff baseball. Roberts has made it further than Mattingly, but as I said, team's only been getting more and more stocked. Of those 3 WS trips, 2018 was horrible, and only got there because Brewers were even worse at the last NLCS game. 2020, a very shortened season, and that last game was more on Kevin Cash than Roberts, pretty much like the game before that, only backwards
You're being kind placing Shelton in the D tier. He is clearly F class. Horrible lineups, horrible BP decisions, left that poor bastard LH relief pitcher (name forgotten) out for over 50 pitches to just get shelled, sat out Ke Bryan Hayes at an early season weekend home game and was called out by the local media for not thinking that maybe just maybe the local fan base might want to see him play. The list goes on......
I don’t really agree with most of this list. As usual. Love your content tho even tho I don’t normally agree with a lot. Especially your love for Horrible Joey Gallo. BUT genuinely LOVE your channel for sure you put a lot of work in. Respect :)
I’m so glad you put La Russa down in the F tier. Even though he’s won a World Series, my uncle who played for him always told me he was the biggest idiot in baseball. Would make 10 insanely stupid calls and 1 would happen to work and the media would crown him “The Genius.”
Bias b word
David Bell is an awful game manager, however I respect him. He steps up for his players big time. Takes responsibility for when things go wrong. Willing to physically fight for his players.
Dusty Baker is the Andy Reid of baseball. Constantly having good seasons, but never winning the big one...and yes I know Andy Reid won the super bowl with the Chiefs a couple years back
Imagine losing in the wildcard round. Mets suck. Braves are going to win back to back!!! Suck it Marc!!
Alex Cora should be S this guy won a World Series then his owners traded away Betts then he leaves we suck come back make ALCS then had the worse pitching staff in mlb this year and Injury’s
I feel like David Ross was just royaly screwed when it came to the 2nd half. I mean he was able to get the 2020 team to the Wild Card in his first year, and even for it being 2020, that was good for the Cubs. He's also just really good for the club house