ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.ค. 2024
- The Union Cabinet recently approved the new National Education Policy 2020 to bring “large-scale transformational reforms” in both school and higher education. The new education policy for the country comes after almost 34 years. It stipulates for a complete overhaul of the existing education system. Among the key highlights of NEP 2020 is the decision to make home language, mother tongue or regional language as the medium of instruction up to class 5. Experts believe this may create a long-term impact in nation building. Imparting school education in mother tongue or regional language may bring drastic change in the ongoing process of human resource development. Analysts believe regional languages help inculcate human values and emotions and learning mother tongue will also help future generations forge a relation with their own social and cultural fabric. In this edition of The Big Picture we analyse the importance of vernacular languages, culture and values in NEP 2020.
Guest Name:-
1. Dr. Shakila Shamsu, Former OSD, National Education Policy
2. Shivakumar Belavadi, Founder, Omnio Future Academy
3. Vikram Sampath, Historian & Author
Anchor:- Frank Rausan Pereira
Producer:- Sagheer Ahmad
News?
Among the key highlights of NEP 2020 is the decision to make home language, mother tongue, or regional language as the medium of instruction up to class 5.
Importance of vernacular language in primary education
1. The familiarity of the child with the language.
2. WHO nurturing framework- early childhood cares important. 1$ in primary age gets a return of 18$ which later reduces to 1$ and even lower later.
3. Children can learn multiple languages (up to 18).
4. Ownership and pride- educated people producing vernacular plays and prose. Example Kondi, Bhojpuri, Santhali, etc.
5. 10% of the world language going extinct is Indian.
CHALLENGES
1. Too many regional languages can make it impracticable.
2. Reading material, terminologies missing in the mother tongue.
3. Child of 18 years, emotional maturity of 3-6 years old.
OTHER CONCERNS
Three Language formula
1. What? Two natives ( 1 north +1 south) and one English.
2. North has failed to implement it, only focusing on Hindi and English.
3. However, it is made flexible so that the child can choose the language.
4. Also, a foreign language can be taught beyond class 7.
Ethical education can be challenging.
OTHER PARTS OF THE POLICY
1. Art and music are also integrated now into the system.
2. Vocational learning.
SOLUTION
1. Capacity building of the teachers and parents.
2. Modern Science + Ancient Learning integration.
3. Treating all the professions equally.
4. Self-empowerment holistically.
5. Swami Vivekananda: Education is a manifestation of perfection already in man. The intent has been made clear through this policy, also making it an India centric education policy.
6.Daily summaries -----> Telegram channel: iassimplifiedchannel
Great job👏
Thxs
It's really help
But as a English is international language and maximum articles books are in English...so don't you think that English should be spoken by everyone in our country..
Way forward points by Mr Shivakumar is not clear. Can anyone clarify plz 🙏🏻
Iam a big fan and constant follower of this show... Please really improve the quality of both audio and video.. for all of us... 🙏🙏
Thanks rstv but sounds are not clear please check this problem...
Thanks RSTV
Ty rstv for bringing such an important topic, infact I was about to ask you for it..so ty once again 🙏
Thanks a lot. Waiting desperately for the topic
Thanks to the holistic discussion on NEP... The same policy need to implement in letter and spirit. India needs to shift from Macaulay's idea of education... Please try to maintain good quality of video and audio.
Thanks Rstv☺
Thank you for providing the video
This change is much appreciated n need of the hour.
As a mother, i was throughly disappointed with the current syllabus of our kids. They knew more about Roman empire, French Revolution n European Renaissance..
Than Indian Mauryan Empire, King Ashoka, Sangam literature, or Swadeshi Movement or our noble Indian national movement.
This has led to disconnect from our own ethnic moorings. N uncritical glorification of english and western.
This change will have long term effects
one sided argument. english and modern culture needs the equal importance. live in the present rather than building castles of the past. i do not say focus on english only. but i say that dont politicize in the name of past culture and greatness do not forget the future
Thank you so much Frank sir 💜
Supob big show.big picture
Challenges NEP.
Most important is flexibility in policy
and mind set should change.
Government came new policy education good but many challenges and improve infrastructure.
India's multiple local languages so face and how to handle.
Starting is very difficult but after is comfortable education system.
Sates are check education ground level.
Vikram 🙏👏👏👏👏👏👏🙄
I also think that the lack of professional counsellors in schools, especially in the secondary stage is a major drawback. Most kids are not capable of understanding and estimating their capacity and most of them end up picking their streams based on what their parents say or what their peers are opting for. There needs to be a dedicated counselling department starting Class 9 onwards in both public and private schools.
I agree. And I fear that it's becoming a limitations for this policy. I whole heartily appreciate the thought behind it and education is one of the section which need revolution for long time.
In case of teaching through mother tongue upto Class 5, what about the kids of parents with transferrable jobs who might be studying in states other than their native? For this section of kids, it might be harder to learn the local language if say, the child belongs to UP but goes to school in Assam. Has the government paid heed to situations like this?
Really it is important question
i appreciate this question , this needs to be taken care , i feel english should remain in the nascent stages even
Yep. This question has already been raised by tge experts
Even most of us are belongs to different state and stay at different state and how a person of Uttarpradesh could study kannada language.Their parent are unable to understand the language.
Yeah already Kendriya vidyalaya schools said it wont be practical to implement that
Good point by sir vikram sir
It would be helpful if subtitles are provided concerning reduced sound quality
Most impressive part is succint summary by Pereira sir
voice is not audible clearly... Sir Please correct it
Please bring a discussion on Draft EIA 2020
Yes its required
Modi Govt quite stubborn over improving country's EoDB ranking. EIA will help in improving the EoDB ranking, Modi will pass the bill anyhow.
Sir
being a constractive debat lover...i watch and follow only this channel...but sorry to say all the private news channels have improved in thier sound quality but this channel the superior to allnews channels still suffering from sound hazard...plzzz improve it. This is my humble request.
But if we are promoting regional languages, it should be done by teaching the language rather than teaching in that specific language. Vikram Sampath himself said that children upto age of 5 learn more than the later age groups. Then, why shouldn't we try to teach English in this age group only so that, the children do not feel lost later on? In the era of globalisation, I guess English should be given more priority in medium of studies! India has many regional languages which would make this process clumsy and in the meantime, many children will lose confidence in their English which is still primary language for many jobs(eg: this debate is also done in English).
I absolutely agree with you, English must remain the main focus throughout a child's education unless we've decided to cut cords with the world for good.
they can still learn English. Only the medium of instruction will be home language.
But too much english threat to our culture. Today, if a person speaks English ,he is called as educated, but if a person speaks in vernacular language, he will be called as uneducated. We want to brake english's superiority.
@@mangalorelove That must be blamed on our society as a whole, not on the medium of instruction. This language shaming happens only in India and its deplorable. We must change our mindsets and be more accepting of people from all walks of life, of people who don't speak English, even people who speak broken English. Instead of making fun of them, we must encourage them to learn more. English is the only language that connects the whole world together and so your idea of breaking its superiority is downright whimsical but that obviously doesn't mean that we put it on a pedestal. Supporting Hindi and other local languages is just as important. Think about it!
@@curiouslyunruffled English connects the world but won't develop this country since English medium education is all about copy pasting paragraphs from textbooks to answersheets. So making mother tongue the medium of instruction is better.
The only question is from where the Government expects to get the Money to implement such an Education Policy??
India is a Nation of 1.3 Billion people its focus should on Educating & Training the Masses for Jobs & Skills sets that are acceptable at Global level.
How can Nation achieve such things if its going to have Multiple Educational Boards & Medium of Education??
There is a need for Standardization of Education for upcoming generations to provide them Equal Opportunities irrespective of their Caste, Class or Regional Backgrounds.
GoI needs a 3-Language Policy with:-
(1) "English" as the Medium of Education & Compulsory Literature subject till 12th standard
(2) "Regional Language" as compulsory subject till 12th standard
(3) "Sanskrit" as the compulsory 3rd Language from 6th to 12th standard.
English will allow Global Connectivity & Access to International Knowledge systems
"Regional Language" will allow preservation of Regional linguistic & cultural identity.
"Sanskrit" will allow Preservation & Promotion of Indian Civilization, Culture & Traditions.
Once Sanskrit Linguistic skills get to an acceptable level within the Nation then GoI can replace "Hindi" with "Sanskrit" as one of its Official Languages.Then GoI will 2 Official Languages of "English" & "Sanskrit".
English representing Global Connectivity & Sanskrit representing Connection to Ancient Indian civilization traditions.
The focus shouldn't only be on Traditional School education but also on :-
(1) Yoga
(2) Meditation
(3) Indian Classical Dances forms as per Region + Indian Contemporary dance form
(4) Indian Painting Style
(5) Indian Architecture
(6) Development of an Combined "Indian Martial Arts" Tradition just like China did with WUSHU.
(7) Sports especially the ones that are Popular in India or have major Overseas market.
English should not be only option as a medium
Good
The new education policy 2020 is a good policy, but not until this policy is implemented well. Until then it will not be beneficial for us. Because we need this type of reform in the field of education. Because we wanted to create world class education.
I really appreciate with this debate but I didn't satisfied with the audio. I request to big picture that plz improve the sound quality of this program
Today of not clear sound sr
please improve the sound quality
Appropriate time today FRP🙏
☺🙏
❤️🙏🙏
The new NEP stresses the greatest importance on quality, qualified and passionate teachers. Or else the noble concept would just lay flat laying undue stress on children.
Sir what about foreign languages. Do you think they are not important for students holistic development?
Three language formula is using to impose Hindi. Peoples are smart to enough to understand this.
In a nation still has not attain a 90 plus literacy , three language is a challenge.
How do children gonna bear this load.
What are the steps to empower teachers.
How do we level the disparities in educational institutions.
Even the schools are still not being met the standards pressed by the NEP 1986 even this moment, when would we meet NEP 2020.
Chutiye. States are given right to choose Language . And 3 rd language will be only be taught from 6th to 8th . Why can't Tamil Nadus incumbent leaders select a 3rd language another than hindi
As a result of the NEP , English (the language of the world) will not be accessible to the majority of India, which is poor and lower middle class. As a result they will be shut down from the world. I am shocked why no expert is discussing this.
Language of the world. What a joke. Countries like Japan, China, Korea, Russia, France, Germany, Spain, Italy, etc became a developed country without speaking English. Some examples of English medium education are Nigeria, Pakistan, India, Uganda, Kenya, Ghana, Ethiopia, etc. Almost all are backward. This is what happens when you educate children in an alien language instead of native language. English medium education is beneficial only for native English speakers not for non English speakers. You just need common sense to understand it.
Way forward points by Mr Shivakumar is not clear. Can anyone clarify plz 🙏🏻
He just emphasised on implementation of NEP and reiterated the modern science+ancient learning method.
Sound problem please reduce this problem
why is anil kumble present in the debate?
Audio problem...
Sound quality is not sound😂😂
What if parents have interstate marriage...
Whose language will be preferred?
The quality of voice is quite low , improve it
The cds ssb interview should be conducted in hindi language ...
Haha abhi conference out hua hoon
our education system has much much much bigger problems of quality. IMO the issue of culture could've been taken up the day we stop being one of the worst ranked countries in the PISA index (72/74). India has been, and will be doomed under Brahmins prioritizing frivolous issues over real issues.
Seriously? Large part hasn't implemented three language formula???
They don't have money to pay Teachers for two languages also!
plz clean the audio
भारत की कोई राष्ट्र भाषा नहीं है।[1] सरकार ने 22 भाषाओं को आधिकारिक भाषा के रूप में जगह दी है। जिसमें केन्द्र सरकार या राज्य सरकार अपने जगह के अनुसार किसी भी भाषा को आधिकारिक भाषा के रूप में चुन सकती है। केन्द्र सरकार ने अपने कार्यों के लिए हिन्दी[2] और रोमन भाषा को आधिकारिक भाषा के रूप में जगह दी है। इसके अलावा अलग अलग राज्यों में स्थानीय भाषा के अनुसार भी अलग अलग आधिकारिक भाषाओं को चुना गया है। फिलहाल 22 आधिकारिक भाषाओं में असमी, उर्दू, कन्नड़, कश्मीरी, कोंकणी, मैथिली, मलयालम, मणिपुरी, मराठी, नेपाली, ओडिया, पंजाबी, संस्कृत, संतली, सिंधी, तमिल, तेलुगू, बोड़ो, डोगरी, बंगाली और गुजराती है।
लेकिन मेरा मत यह है भारतीय संविधान में आर्टिकल बनाकर हिंदी को राष्ट्र भाषा के रूप में लागू करना चाहिए क्योंकि हिंदुस्तान का अर्थ ही होता है हिंदू वह हिंद जहां लोग हिंदी बोलते हैं तथा अन्य भाषाओं का भी सम्मान करना चाहिए लेकिन राष्ट्र की लिए राष्ट्रीय हिंदी को दर्जा देना ही चाहिए 🙏🙏🙏
जिसमें तमाम देशों की अपनी अपनी भाषा है चीन जाइएगा तो चीनी पाकिस्तान जाइएगा उर्दू रूस जाइए रसिया लैंग्वेज सभी देशों की अपनी-अपनी भाषाएं हैं लेकिन हमारे देश का कोई भाषा ही नहीं है जो बहुत गलत है होना चाहिए। ताकि पश्चिमी सभ्यता भारतीय सभ्यता पर हावी न हो।हिंदी को इम्पोज़ नही कर रहे पर जो सीखना चाहता है तो उसे मौका मिलना चाहिये। भाषा एक एसेट्स है, दूसरे लोगों से interact करने का। विश्व भी हिंदी को ही भारत की भाषा मानता है। हिंदी विदेशों में पढ़ाई भी जाती है। विदेशी भाषा अग्रेजी पढ़ सकते है तो हिंदी पढ़ने में क्या समस्या है, विरोध क्यों? जो पढ़ना चाहता है उसे क्यो रोका जा रहा है?सभी प्रदेशों में हिंदी बोलने वाले व समझने वाले लोग हैं, सबसे ज्यादा इस देश मे हिंदी बोलने वाले हैं। जो सीखना चाहता है तो मौका दो, फ्रेंच जर्मन व अन्य विदेशी भाषा सिखाई जा सकती है तो इस देश की ऑफिसियल भाषा हिंदी क्यों नही। गन्दी भाषा की यह राजनीति ठीक नही।
संवैधानिक रूप से हिंदी को राष्ट्रीय भाषा का स्तर प्राप्त नहीं है... किन्तु 85% भारत में सर्वाधिक रूप से समझने एवम् बोलने में हिंदी सहज भाषा है, अधिकांश सभी क्षेत्रीय भाषाओं में हिंदी के बहुत से शब्द भी है!
भाषा पर कोई विवाद या किसी प्रकार का हस्तक्षेप नहीं होना चाहिए!
सभी क्षेत्रीय भाषाएं तमिल, तेलगु, उर्दू, भोजपुरी, अवधि,ब्रज भाषा, राजस्थानी, कन्नड, उड़िया, सिंधी,गुजराती, पंजाबी, मराठी,बंगाली, असमिया,पूर्वोत्तरी क्षेत्रीय भाषाएं...""भारत की भाषाओं की सुंदर भरी हुई टहनियां हैं जो भाषा की सुंदरता का फल प्रदान करती है""...हिंदी की जड़ इनके बिना फल फूल नहीं सकती!.
English also is a foreign language then why other foreign languages are suggested late in NEP
My doubt is..
Will private schools n international schools impart the primary education in vernacular language unlike exsiting English language is used?
Please enlighten me.regards
But as a English is international language and maximum articles books are in English...so don't you think that English should be spoken by everyone in our country..
Some examples of English medium education are Nigeria, Uganda, Kenya, Ethiopia, Pakistan, India, Ghana, etc. Almost all are backward. And Some examples of mother tongue medium education are Japan, Korea, Russia, China, Germany, France, Spain, etc. Almost all are developed. So education in mother tongue is better than education in an alien language.
In every programme, where govt agenda of opinion building is concerned, it seems all the members of penal are selected by RSS
Panelists are talking about "shedding English" in English. Irony just died.