ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 มิ.ย. 2019
- Facing pressure from Tamil Nadu against the draft National Education Policy’s recommendation for teaching Hindi in all the States, the Union government has issued a modified draft leaving out a controversial clause. In the modified draft uploaded by the Human Resource Development Ministry, a Section, titled ‘Flexibility in the choice of languages’ has been changed, omitting any reference to ‘which’ languages students may choose. There is no mention of Hindi in the clause. The revised policy requires proficiency in any three languages. The earlier draft education policy triggered outrage in southern states, led by Tamil Nadu, which said they will not tolerate Hindi imposition in the state that doesn't speak the language. In the previous version of the draft policy, English and Hindi were proposed as mandatory languages in non-Hindi speaking states while a third language was mandatory in Hindi-speaking states. On this edition of the big picture we will analyse the 3 language policy in the Draft National Education Policy.
Guest - Ganapathy Subramaniam, Chief of Bureau, Puthiya Thalaimurai,
Dr. Manisha Priyam, Political Analyst,
Aditi Tandon, Special Correspondent, The Tribune,
Sushil Chandra Tripathi, Former Secretary, Ministry of HRD,
Anchor - Frank Rausan Pereira
Only three-four points can be taken out the debate. 1. Build infrastructure to increase teaching capacity. 2. It should not be imposed 3. Professionalism in particular 3rd language is not required to be.
Well said by mr trivedi, learn why should be only three. learn 4-5 languages like Europian countries do. It will enhance the chances of employabilities. At the last Aditi tondon closed the debate with very well.said, languages should not divide us, it should take us together in one nation....
ty bro
Language is one of the medium for communication which in turn is important for socializing.
An analogy to this situation is that staying in foreign land and barriers that unknown language brings in living a normal life.
Bro learning national language is a part of national integration and not subjective to proffession or something else wt i feel and these cruel tamilians are not a part of it national integrations view
@@lokeshroyal7403 I am not a tamilian but I can say with all my heart that hindi is not the National language of India
@@majimakiriyu4872 well said ...
The real work that government should have done is promote civilizational research at the highest level as in doctoral research. There should be high quality doctoral research done on all the languages and civilization. This will create openings and train teachers and that's how languages are made available.
people do reasearch on the languages but does anyone take note of that ?? hen was the last time you took your time and studied a research paper on an indian classical language and civilization ??
New Education Policy, 2019
: Controversy around making Hindi compulsory than making it optional
- Pushback from south Indian states - Tamilnadu.
Three Language Policy:
- To improve the inclusive character of linguistic civilization of country
- Policy dates back to 1968 when India was a young country and the idea was to bring the country together.
- Non Hindi speaking states - English, mother tongue + any language
- Hindi speaking - Hindi + English + Sanskrit?
Benefits of three language policy:
- improves competency & employ-ability
- Helps in inter state exchanges - English helps in international exchange.
- To improve trade & prospects.
Future Steps:
- Relevance of three language policy needs to be more debate among academicians, parents, students
some Hindi speaking in south but not vice versa
- More autonomy to schools - new children more empowered
- Infrastructure availability around linguistic: institutes specializing in language training
interpreters not available in parliament
easy to find people to do research in Tamil in oxford than in north Indian states
- Different types of teaching at different grades - greater learning pool
It is in the best interest of people to make linguistic a freer economy & sufficient infrastructure must be built around the country to encourage students to learn more Indian languages.
Learning language should be more affinitive & should be uniting rather than dividing. We must move to more substantive policies in education.
All prepared for mains???@shashi ketan
@@parulsingh1426 definitely not started.. I will be here around for exactly 1 more year.
@shashi ketan kamal where u'll go then??
Ur summaries are really very crisp and short. I search for them in every big picture i see .0
Tamil nadu political history is based on anti-hindi issue and many party esp DMK has came into power because of this issue only. Now they have ordered that hindi to be boycotted in every govt school college office. Nothing else. They are useless. They know Tamil but that doesn't apply anywhere outside tamil, they can hardly speak English you will laugh on there kind of English and then hindi which they hate. Tamil not even 15% people speak in India when 60-80% people of the country speak one language then why not we learn that.
thanks for sharing bro. I was making my own summary which matches exacxtly yours . Would be following up on yours from now :P
Those who are commenting.. Majority would be upsc students
Of course.
I am from telangana ..my mother tongue is telugu..but i want learn hindi ...this is good but not compulsary ...hindi imposed on states is not good....languages learning is good habit to students...its improve the vision of students...but india have divesity of many languages...we all are to protect of that languages..and make oppurtunities to students
Well said. Learning another language is always beneficial and it doesn't have to be Hindi or Telugu or Tamil for that matter. Say you are moving to Chennai, it will be useful for you to learn Tamil as it is the medium of conversation there. The labour over there might not know English/Hindi. So it's better for us to be equipped with all the tools needed than forcing others in their land. And this is true for any other language, not just Tamil.
Aditi Madam made a relevant point. World is moving on with globalisation picking up many Skills and languages as many as they can. Irony is we are still debating about 3 language formula. Let Students decide which languages suit them and benefit them. I don't see any purpose learning regional languages! German, french, Mandarin, Japanese etc languages should take place of regional languages. By the way National educational policy is in preliminary form. Why people are losing their minds for unnecessary things?
Manisha Priyanka has put forward a valid perspective. Mobility within country is restricted due to language barriers. Law, doctors, government jobs, labors are some of the example.
The solution for inadequacy of teaching staff for a particular language the present day technology can be used ,online digital classes is one way.
Also online-examination and correction.
True its a kind of proven model. one example is an interview of an haryana girl where she spoke 8 accents of english @ 16 yrs of age only because of the interest on the language and it was possible through online training with instructors of the native language.
A person with Hindi as their mother tongue will be more proficient in it and thus will put everybody else who don't have Hindi as their mother tongue is disadvantaged in academics and profession. So for a highly diverse country as India, English works fine.
There is also an ethnic side to this problem. People with Hindi as their mother tongue will gain superior status by birth as their language has the sole ownership of India. While the rest of us will be relegated, politically and socially. English doesn't have this problem.
Besides English is a global language. Much of the modern Scientific and Medical innovations, inventions and discoveries are contained and recorded in this language. Use English as a tool, there is no slavery here.
Moreover, Central government spends a lot of tax payers money to promote Hindi in bureaucracy and have plans like "Dakshina Bharat Hindi Prachar Sabha". On top of this, it must be made mandatory too? Compared to the money that the Center spends on growing Hindi, they give pittance to 42 endangered languages in India!
You learnt English to connect with the world. I learnt English to connect with the world. But according to you we can't use English to communicate with each other and need Hindi? This isn't hypocrisy?
Teach poor kids English and break this elitism barrier that surrounds English. Let them all reap the reward.
If you want to learn a language, learn the language. You don't have the right to tell me what to eat, wear or learn. It's my right. If you want to learn Hindi, then choose Hindi as a language. Don't force others.
@BrainLogjam I can't agree for more! Language should be seen as just a way of communication not to create barriers further! If one language deserves respect so does all the other! This was in fact a political move!
Why to force students learn many languages, there are so much to learn in Maths, Science, and any stream that is helping the human being for the betterment of future. Every one has freedom to learn any language as hobby not by enforced law. Don't waste time learning too many languages. Mother toungue is there with which you are born, and English is there to aquire any knowledge. These 2 are enough to compete with world.
"People with Hindi as their mother tongue will gain superior status by birth as their language has the sole ownership of India. While the rest of us will be relegated, politically and socially. English doesn't have this problem" ,, ENGLISH DOES HAVE THAT PROBLEM ,, ENGLISH HAS BECOME THE STATUS SYMBOL IN OUR COUNTRY ,, EXCEPT FOR POLITICS ENGLISH HAS BECOME THE SOURCE OF SUCCESS IN INDIA WHICH IA DISGUSTING TO SEE ,,
ENGLISH IS NOT A GLOBAL LANGUAGE ,, CHINA RUSSIA FRANCE GERMANY AND THERE ARE VARIOUS COUNTRIES WHO HAVE NOT BECOME A SLAVE OF ENGLISH AND YET ARE POWERFUL COUNTRIES ,,, RESEARCH PAPERS ARE PUBLISHED IN MANY DIFFERENT LANGUAGES AND THEN THEY ARE TRANSLATED INTO DIFFERENT LANGUAGES ,, WE CAN DO THE SAME IN OUR COUNTRY TOO
I FULLY SUPPORT THE VIEW THAT ALL THE LANGUAGES IN INDIA SHOULD BE SUPPORTED EQUALLY ,, I WANT AN INDIAN LANGUAGE TO BECOME THE LANGUAGE OF THE NATION ,, THIS DOES NOT MEAN A COMPLETE BOYCOTT OF ENGLISH BUT IT SHOULD BE REMOVED FROM THE POSITION OF A STATUS SYMBOL AND A REQUIREMENT FOR SUCCESS ,,
KIDS SHOULD BE TAUGHT IN THEIR LOCAL LANGUAGE ALONG WITH A COMMON INDIAN LANGUAGE (I REITERATE IT SHOULD NOT COMPULSORILY BE HINDI) AND ENGLISH GERMAN FRENCH OR ANY OTHER FOREIGN LANGUAGE SHOULD BE USED AS A SUPPLEMENTARY LANGUAGE FOR THE LATER STAGES ,,
I CANNOT TELL YOU WHAT TO EAT OR WEAR OR LEARN ,, ITS YOUR RIGHT TO DO SO ,, BUT ENGLISH SHOULD NOT HOLD THE POSITION OF SYMBOL FOR SUCCESS AND STATUS IN INDIA ,, WHO ARE YOU TO ASK THE GOVT TO TEACH POOR KIDS ENGLISH TO MAKE THEIR LIVES BETTER ,, BREAK THE ELITISM SURROUNDING ENGLISH BY ELIMINATING ITS STATUS AND NOT BY MAKING IT THE COMMON LANGUAGE IN INDIA
@@Neelinmact "Use English as a tool, there is no slavery here." English is a tool. I think its you, who is stuck in a colonial mind set. Nobody is professing to slavery. The disgust is in your thoughts. How many North Indians are learning South Indian languages? How many Indians are learning languages from North East? English is the perfect leveler for a country like India.
@@vaagai9808 english is not and will never be a perfect leveller in india ,, it was always and always will be a colonial language ,, and you are absolutely right about north indians they are not learning south indian languages and other indian are not learning languages from north east and that is our fault ,, its disgusting to know that they give preference to a foreign language than a language of their own country ,, let me tell you one thing the hindi speaking states prefer english as their 2nd language just like the southern states but english is actually the prefered language in all of the country ,, its a linguistic slavery ,,
that goes to show just how much we love the famed "diversity" of india ,,
My language is Indian and my religion is Humanity and I am proud of it 😌
wow
These r golden words to hear...but not practical to implement...
Problem with this country is that everyone is philosopher here..
So, how many Indian languages have you learned other than your mother tongue?
Why can't it be implemented we need to influence our Ministry and make a petition to change and coming to the question of how my language is Indian I can comment it by saying India is a land of unity in diversity so all one needs is to make each of our vernacular as Indian language and English as the official communicating media
An intelligent discussion. Thank you.
Yeah
I really don't understand why Hindi speaking Indians expecting non-Hindi speaking Indians should know or learn Hindi. It shows they did not understand a bit of how our India is formed and what Indian constitution law says. India is not a single country and it is a union of states including various languages, culture and traditions. According to this, all Indian languages are national languages of India and every Indian language must be treated as the way you are trying to promote Hindi in entire India. It should be noted that Hindi speaking people strongly trusting that "HINDI IS A NATIONAL LANGUAGE OF INDIA". Which is completely wrong- Indian do not have any national language or Hindi as it at all. India is a multilingual country and it can not take just one language as national language in fact should not at any cost in future as well.
By the way before 1930 Hindi was not even in printed currencies or in communication basis but other Indian languages including Bengali, Tamil.. and more. We have already Hindi and English as link languages to connect all Indians the way How I am communicating with you all here. Then why are imposing to non-Hindi people like “you should learn Hindi”. What is special about Hindi? Think if Non-native speaker let say Marathi people imposing to rest of Indians like everyone should learn Marathi (as an example)?
Seriously it shows you are proud of your native language -Hindi and demanding other should learn Hindi despite what language they speak in rest of India. OOPS, Keep in mind. Every language in India has long history in compare to Hindi and many of those languages hold rich set of literature and traditions which you won’t find in Hindi I am pretty sure. Well, I am not at all against learning any language including Hindi. If someone wants to learn Hindi let him/her learn according to need and purpose. But do not create the purpose of learning it by government forces or do not come up with statement “one language and one India”. Read the first two lines of this post again.
I learnt fundamental Hindi as I had to visit and stay in New Delhi for few days. It worked and I managed very well to communicate with all kinds of people in New Delhi without any issues. Similarly I had to visit Hyderabad so, I just followed and grasped my fellow friends who speak Telugu and I managed well there too. I never and ever said oops these delhiwallas don't know my beautiful language and they should have learnt it and all . Because, I understood completely that India is purely a multilingual country and we should follow the key "When you are in Rome be a Roman". Similarly If I visit or have to work in west Bengal then obviously I will learn Bengali in order to mingle with local people mind-set and culture. This is the called Indians who respect fellow Indians.
For example, if you are going to be in Kerala then you must learn some fundamental Malayalam before start up or learn while over there instead of asking people “ you don’t know Hindi” then you are anti Indian and all. The person who knows only Hindi and not knowing any other Indian lanugages + expecting fellow Indians must know Hindi then I would strongly say he/she is an ANTI Indian and more dangerous than terrirorists who may divide our country by creating langauge chavanism between us.
It should be noted, it is completely understandable if you don’t know how to speak other Indian languages expect your native language. But expecting them to speak Hindi is really unethical and shows your Hindi chauvinism. Then you must be ready to fight against Tamil/Manipuri/Gujarathi/… chauvinism(s). Already we people are speaking our own native language mixed with English which should be taken as serious issue as we are forgetting many beautiful words of our own native Indian languages.
Well, learning more than one Indian language is certainly helpful. However, it should be the choice of person for learning where it required. Every Indian is paying tax and most of the fund allotted for Hindi promotion only in compare to fund allotted for other Indian languages promotion (null in fact). Some people are keep on holding the statement like everyone like should learn “Sanskrit” again, in that case we have TAMIL, which is proved as one of oldest and classical languages of world and surviving till today (Official languages in some other countries I think) despite the influence of Hindi/Sanskrit/English. If Tamil speaking people provoke on it what would happen? Obviously Kannada and Bengali people would also raise that they their language is oldest and -----------------. So do not try to divide our multilingual country by imposing one language. Let the Indians learn the languages they like and to do not impose one language policy in a multilingual country and it is not a solution for language barrier (actually it is a negligble issue in our country at present).
Moreover, as we are in digital world, everything can be translated and soon we will be accessing digital translator devices via our mobile phones or eye glasses or wrist watches or other sources. Therefore, this kind of imposition is really useless. I was told like Europeans learn more than two languages and all. I was and in Europe. Yes they learn more than two languages. But all official and personal communications within a country goes with their native languages exist in those country despite the population (majority or miniority). For example, all Finnish people should learn both Finnish and Swedish ( Just 15% of population are native speakers of Swedish in Finland) even though majority of population are from Finnish language background. Similarly if you search for Switzerland I think similar language process exists. This is the way the multilingual country should run. It doesn't mean that all Indians should learn 22 languages (or more) of the country at all. Already we are learning our native language and English which is totally enough to lead our country and if required then we can learn another language at any time (age is not a barrier at all for people who learn it with purpose or eat when you are hungry). So, do not impose Hindi as only link language of the country in the union of states- our lovable country India. Respect your fellow Indians by accepting and speaking their native language if possible but do not try to impose they should learn or speak in Hindi. to you because you know Hindi. We are from multilingual Indians. If you love me despite what Indian language I speak then obviously I will love and die for you as fellow Indian.
Just bring the touch of different languages at the school level and let the dynamics of interest and requirement take its own course(first for regional languages).
Even for bringing that touch, infrastructure has to be improved dedicatedly. After English and my mother tongue, I had a limited choice between Hindi and Sanskrit as third optional. I had standard communicating knowledge in Hindi, thanks to Bollywood, Hindi dubbed cartoons and Hindi media since my childhood and due to their higher production quality, but I felt to know my cultural language Sanskrit on which I had very less knowledge, so I chose Sanskrit.
If any case either of Hindi or Sanskrit was made compulsory, people like me would have lost the flexibility. There were some of my colleagues who chose Hindi to increase their proficiency in Hindi instead Sanskrit.
So get the infrastructure ready, provide a basic touch, and let the dynamics of interest and requirement take its own path.
Manisha mam made very valid point . A wonderful debate👍
and Hindi speaking state adopt modern Indian language like Tamil Malayalam Marathi Kannada and Telugu Bangla Sanskrit provide more employability
👆🏾😂😅
🤣🤣🤣
Nice if you, but leaning English, Japanese, German, French will open more job opportunities. Mother tongue is good for speaking with friends and family.
The basic reason before learning a language is for communication purpose and this purpose of communication between the states with different regional languages need to be done, so there should be atleast 1 common language, it could be either hindi Or english so that the connectivity between the states can be improved on the linguistic basis.
it is obvious that we are on backfoot in education in comparison with rest of the developed world because they are on their own method of teaching but we are trying to copy their teaching and also adopting then how can be we more in any sector if we forget our own culture and tradition and try to follow others...if we focused on our own then perhaps we would have been in better condition..now we are fighting in our own and focusing on becoming more rich on comparison with others which is creating more discrimination and which is the main reason of our deterioration...so if we all want to be in better condition then firstly see everyone as like our own don't create the thinking of forward and backward , rich or poor ..let everyone feel equality in everything ..dont be egoistic
For me every student should be given option and appropriate infrastructure to learn any number of Indian languages in schedule 8....
My suggestion would be like..in North India make students aware of south Indian languages and vice versa in South India. I mean at least make them learn the basics and grammar. I don't know if this is a practical solution but it is definitely going to unite India
Good understanding is possible only in mother touge.
Teaching In Kannada, Telugu, Malayalam, Tamil, Bengali, Marathi, Kashmiri, etc good.
one of the most sensible discussion on the 3rd language policy by far (:
Very very good lecture and narrated very very beautiful explained very easily thank you for this great lecture
I am a Tamilan.. I like Hindi and i need hindi.. I can learn it only if it is taught in govt schools which is not a reality yet.. Lets just start introducing Hindi in govt/aided schools as "VOLUNTARY" choice.. Lets just start this way... And lets c how this goes...
And i want to learn tamil and i am trying on my own until i find a proper teacher... I have lived in chennai for around 2 years and have many Tamil friends...:)
Doc eb: I want to learn Chinese, because I feel Indians can benefit immensely if they learn Chinese. Hindi has nothing to offer and its utility and functional value zero. Should I ask the Govt of TN to teach Chinese in all govt. aided schools as a choice language?
@@ThuraiMugil ya do tht... Also read ur message again...u ll know Hindi is also definitely useful...u itself said "Indians"
@@doceb7538 : I do not understand what you are trying to say. Either write in Tamil if you feel comfortable writing in Tamil or write in English properly. I am unable to understand what you are trying to say.
@@ThuraiMugil learn mandarin (chinese language). But Hindi is most important than mandarin. U itself said "Indians need"... Our constitution makers gav hindi a special place for a reason... Read about Ambedkar's Honourable Constituent Assembly debates.
I dont get this whole point of learning so many languages (in disguise of employability).. Kid's brains have limits they need to pick up more valuable skills than stuffing up languages in their head..
Personally, hindi has been a headache in my school.
All are agreeing to improve infra ..☺️. Hope it will happen..
The most joyable part of the debate was done to bring common conclusion on the topic by all the wise people. A very rare case. It was done because it is RStv and none of the panelist was a politician or a religious hypocrite!!
Though the government maintains good number of teaching staff and infrastructure to carry out the policy successfully, it should also be aware of students choice diversion on the language he/she have to choose. It should be noted that students and their parents give more preference towards marks and grades which could hinder the process of active learning by the students. So, policy discussions should not only focus solely on languages infrastructure etc., but also the optimistic ways to groom the student atleast to use the language outside his institution and strictly maintaining "NOT FOR THE SAKE OF MARKS" learning pattern. JAI HINDH.
Why there is so much conundrum regarding TLM(three language formula). I just want to ask to GOI, have they really done their work on grass rout level only for Hindi and English. What the irony is that after a graduate who has done in any language, go for coaching to be expert or for taking as a profession. Then, why this drama, if you have not well infrastructure only for these two languages.
manvendra singh: Please listen to this and it answers all our questions.
th-cam.com/video/wrr2CRiq9tQ/w-d-xo.html
What Aditi says makes sense. Did the 3-language formula in the last 50 years deliver? It is clear it has not. Aditi herself is a good example. She kept saying "Kannad"; she can't even pronounce the name of a language.
Then why are still keeping the 3-language formula? The leaders of the past in TN had great vision on this and I am so thankful to them for their contribution and helping us to not to waste our precious time and resource learning a 3rd language.
A subject like Education doesn't have a student in the panel, great irony. Pereira, can we bring in diversity in the panelists.
With digital classes, we can solve teacher problem. Because we can't solve teacher problem early as we want but ecource are easily available.
there is no need for a burdening third language for our children. english is already a common language and useful language for self-learning any subject . rural kids can be taught basic spoken english so they can communicate with other state people.
THIS IS MY 3 LANGUAGE FORMULA
1) MOTHER TONGUE
2) ANY INDIAN LANGUAGE (OTHER THAN YOUR MOTHER TONGUE) AND WHICH REPRESENTS A DIFFERENT REGION OR A DIFFERENT STATE
3) OPTIONAL LANGUAGE (ENGLISH , FRENCH , GERMAN OR ANY OTHER LANGUAGE)
That sounds like a good idea Neel....that is an interesting proposal.
Do Hindi states follow this formula?
Gujarat has given great leaders as well as simple script to the nation.If English can be second language in Hindi states than why not in Gujarat? Gujarat needs to teach political Hindi in India's simplest Gujanagari script.Don't Pakistan learn Hindi in Urdu script? Don't the westerners learn Sanskrit in Roman script?
We south indians when we come to north we should speak hindi , but wen north indian cm to south even then we should speak hindi but he do not utter a single south language word ...
In my state subject teachers are not available how can possible three languages policy will implement by state gov.first language hindi I learnt from mother second language English I learnt from mobile I mean digital platforms of English third language English I learnt from my teacher and fourth language Korean I learnt from Korean drama.for me language learning is Joy and I seriously enjoyed it.when my English is not good and my brother English is much better then I felt guilty and decided I will do this and finally I did.seriouly it's not easy process when no guiders are provided.no body helped me .I watched a lot of English drama.english news debate like rajasabha Times now republic India.Two genius person discussion on single topic.first I came on big picture my purpose is simple I have to learn English not I have to clear civil service exam.when I feel I can write speek or understand English then I thought rajasabha debate is much good platform to provide knowledge as compare to other political debate.
Sorry third language is sanskrit
Good
In today's highly competitive world, Language can serve only one purpose 'EMPLOYABILITY'. So let the students decide, which language they choose. It may be French + German + Japanese
.
Regarding inclusiveness, cultural preservance and national integration, don't burden students with these shallow points. We are inclusive & integrated.Just because my Tamil roommate don't understand Hindi, doesn't means we are not integrated. Speaking same language is not a parameter of inclusiveness. Entire Western world speaks English, are they integrated and inclusive?
.
Regarding growth of Indian languages, Only SCIENTIFIC & LITERARY ACHIVEMENTS can do this.
Students of ICSE already learn 4 languages
ICSE students are from different planet
@@SS-hw1ou hahahahahhahaha
Thank you for the session.
Are we facing any problem with lang diversity ??
one or two teachers is appointed for five classes i.e. 1,2,3,4 and 5. This is the primary education system of india which is so unfortunate .
India needs more on line tools for an instant translation, transliteration and transcription to provide equal education/information regardless the medium of instruction. India needs two scripts formula instead of three languages formula to save regional scripts and languages. Devanagari Lipi Parishad prefers printing ink wasting Devanagari script for all languages despite it's simplification in nukta and shirorekha free Gujanagari sript. Maharashtra and Bihar have lost Modi and Bhojapuri scripts.
If Pakistan can learn Hindi in complex Urdu script then why can't India in regional scripts?
One may save language and script by learning political Hindi if needed in chosen script through a script converter.
We have to take some where stand as per language concerns ,Hindi is being speaks many more States of India so this is the only way to make a strong bonding btw indian citizen
why do you want to make bond between states? naturally, we are indians, but diversity is our pride. do not disturb them by saying everything anything one india one tax, one culture , one language, etc., every state has its own identity. we should not perish by imposing anything on them by saying modernisation. so study english as the second language , it is good for all.
Hindi’s influence is centered in the Indo- Gangetic Plain, and from there it steadily loses how many speakers claim it as their own the further you leave this region and cross into new ones, how can Hindi create bonds with Austronesian, Dravidian and Tibeto-Burmese language speakers when it does not incorporate very many features of the other language trees?
my question is that is there enough faculty to handle the third language any one among 22 in every region of India and from my opinion student who are in govt school in interior area will suffer more due to lack of enough faculty and practically it takes more time to implement even it is a very good idea
ultimate
Sanskrit must be given priority.It should be mandated along with vedic and regional transformation studies.We can't deprive from our past experiences.We have 5000yrs old experience in studies.
Haha... Sanskrit and Manuscript
I am from hindi belt and learned colloquial Marathi and Gujrati on my own. Although I do agree that Hindi should not be imposed in TN but I am sure they are the least respectful towards our ONE of our OFFICIAL languages.
Edit: I had written National language instead of official language. And all the mugs showed more interest in correcting me rather than acknowledging the issue.
If at all you had any education, you would ve known that WE DONT HAVE A NATIONAL LANGUAGE as such.
@@Antagonistock No, I didn't have any education. I am a prick who knows a dumb prick to whom I reply.
👍
Every one knows English is kind of a global language and it is acceptable and taught across india not just in South. Hindi is just one of the official languages like Telugu and tamil so why is Hindi being given such importance and why not other official languages? Why is there a proposal that south people should learn hindi? Till now there is no proposal that North people should learn any one of South languages? For me it is acceptable only when north indian people should learn any one of south indian language and south indian people should learn any one of north indian language.
Hindi is spoken by over 80 crore people
Or 60% of population.
@@AnimalUniverse8 So? What's your point? Just because more people speak hindi doesn't mean it is superior to other official languages. if you want soutt indian people to learn hindi then you should also learn any one of South Indian language. If you don't agree with it then your hypocrisy is obvious.
@@wonderful304 no, I m a nationalist hindu,
I m learning Marathi and Telugu
@@AnimalUniverse8 Don't mix Hindi with Hindu. I'm also a nationalist Hindu, but that doesn't mean I'm bound to learn Hindi which is itself not purely Indian. My mother tongue Odia is more ancient and rooted than Hindi.
@@wonderful304 That's their colonial mindset bro. By imposing Hindi, they have destroyed Bhojpuri, Rajasthan, Chatishgarhi and many ancient languages. Now they claim 60% of India speaks Hindi, so everyone must do. This is nothing but colonialism and looking down upon others.
Me myself from Maharashtra we have no problem with Hindi we learn Hindi Marathi and English and feel proud all Indian language
Yes brother. And also wants to mention that not a single student in Maharashtra who studied in govt school is neither proficient in English nor Hindi nor Marathi.
Will you learn Odia if you get to work in Odisha in future? I'm asking this because most of the non-Odia students/workers here never intend to learn Odia and demand others to speak in Hindi with them. It's not nationalism, it's only because the Hindi belt people consider their language superior. If you don't respect anyone's mother tongue, how do you expect someone to accept your mother tongue!
@@shyamashyam391 yes bro I'm preparing for civil service of course if I got opportunity definitely I'll learn odia 😄
Make tamil telugu malayalam kannada mandatory in entire north India ....
I'm tamil and i speak hindi but whats the point in learning it? We have everything we wanted in tamil nadu and most of us prefer to travel to asia & europe for better exposure. Please my dear northern friends, We don't hate hindi, We just don't want it though we don't speak hindi GDP and educational standards in tamil nadu is quite higher compared to whole india, Let us be who we are.
@Roopam Rathi We are ready to learn any language, either interested or mandatory. But, Tamil and English are sufficient for us. So we are not ready to learn any Imposing Language. You are not a Tamil, but you came Chennai and have learnt our language right as well. Likewise, we will learn, when it comes necessary!
Let me ask you Roopam, how many students do you have and how interested are they in Hindi? I think the very fact that it is voluntary in Tamil Nadu means that the quality of instruction and interaction between student and teacher will be high. They sincerely sought you out to teach them and you are instructing them with your own heart. What you have under voluntary Hindi is a good thing.
Why should they have any cause to complain? Wouldn’t a Tamil speaking student in Delhi or any other Hindi speaking state or Union Territory be expected to learn Hindi? Such is the nature of things. My cousins who spent their childhoods in North India learned Hindi.
@Roopam Rathi Madam ennoda intention ungala hurt pannanum nu apdi rply panla😊 Engalukku Tamil&English eh sufficient, so matha language venumna kathuppom😇 "தமிழ்" kaaga ethana protest and uyir poyirukkunu theriyuma?💔 Naanga ethaiyum oppose panla, but venumna kathukkarom nu dhaan soldrom😊
Tamil people ku sondha mannulaiye velai kedaikkarthu illa! Railways job yellam North Indians fraud pani vaangidraanga recent ah Nadantha scam ungalukku theriyum nenaikkiren. Adhu mattum illama inga Banks la work pandra North Indians, vayasu vithiyasam paakkama chinnatha oru Thappu pannalum vayasana Thaatha paattis ah kevalama thitraanga avangaluku enna theriyum sollunga? Ithellam nan neradiya paathurukKan! Summavey ivanuga dominate pannanum, velaiya thirudanum nu pandranuga, idhula inga Hindi compulsory panita oru velaiya kuda Tamil kaarangalukKu tharamaatanga Central, YellaaMey North karangaluKu kudupanga fraud pasanga.
Nan Matriculation la 6th to 8th vara Hindi padichittu dhaan vanthurukkan! Ippo irukka technologies la mobile era la yedhu vendum vendaam nu youngsters ku theriyum. Neenga oruthar Hindi vendum nu soldranganu paakka kudaathu Majority enna soldranga nu dhaan paakkanum☺️✌️
Tamil la irundhu copy adichi vanthadhu dhaan Hindi😊 Foreign kaarangaley "தமிழ்" ku neraiya importance kudukaraanga Hindi ah vida Bcz The mother of all language is Tamil☺️❤️ Engaluku central government olunga na priorities kudukkaama mosamana projects kuduthu Tamilnatta azhikka dhaan paakkarangana ippo intha Hindi impose vera, konjam understand pannikonga, engala enga language ah kaapatha vidunga😊
@Roopam Rathi மிக்க மகிழ்ச்சி! ஜல்லிக்கட்டுல கலந்தமைக்கு கோடி நன்றிகள்!🙏❤️💐
*Frankly saying no state will accept 3 Language formula, because of political stands some states imposing hindi.
*Create linguistic universities all over the country .
*Just learning letters and sentences will not change any social, economical status..
*Political pressure should be avoided in this matter..
*Need quality of education..
if a govt in the centre announced that tamil or telugu or any other language is to be learned compulsorily ,, that govt would fall in a matter of days even if it had 352 seats in the lok sabha ,, regional , linguistic , religious identity are the primary fodder for the indian politics ,, besides hindi imposition was a political move for the political nationalism that we have seen over past few years
Thank u so much . Do not make hindi compulsory , leave it for the people's choice . India is symbol of diversity.😄
I can t understand why when non hindi states are given a choice to teach english, mother tongue and third any other language (Even Foreign) then why is that Hindi states have to choose Hindi, English and third language has to be from any of the 22 scheduled languages.
That's unfair, system should be open for all.
Bhai Abhi sirf draft hai ....I am sure southern states too will have too choose from 8th schedule .
Haha, for hindi speaker hindi is going the regional language hence
Everyone wants Hindi needs to be third Language... then why not English has reached u people ??? English is worldwide... if we know English and u know English thats for communication... why you want Other states to learn Hindi..?? Can anyone explain
Naveen Muruganandam Mt padho bhai
@@ppremprakashpriyadarshi8776 tk bhai mein padtha nayi padtha aapko kya aathi hei.. muje chayiye toh padtha
They are illiterate.
Because only 15% of this nation can speak English. Which eventually becomes influential even if they are not that effective. Hindi is neccessary to fill this gap.
Tamil nadu political history is based on anti-hindi issue and many party esp DMK has came into power because of this issue only. Now they have ordered that hindi to be boycotted in every govt school college office. Nothing else. They are useless, although not all. They know Tamil but that doesn't apply anywhere outside tamil, they can hardly speak English you will laugh on there kind of English and then hindi which they hate. Tamil not even 15% people speak in India when 60-80% people of the country speak one language then why not we learn that.
Did you listen to the debate Sir ? Who where and when is imposing hindi ?....
Can you explain sir
What about constitutional obligation regarding hindi
Multi lingual literacy will eat the time ....a person like me by the time i develop proficiency in hindi I can learn gate electrical subjects ....
Political leaders need to use more regional languages words in their speech and use translators to reach out more people.
Gujarat has given great leaders as well as simple script to the nation.
India has more English speakers than Great Britain and most of them are polyglots and yet India is unable to provide equal education/information regardless the medium of instruction through transcription, transliteration and translation. Most world languages have modified their alphabets and use most modern alphabet in writings. Vedic Sanskrit alphabet have been modified to Devanagari and to simplest Gujanagari(Gujarati) script and yet Hindi is taught in a very printing ink wasting non cursive complex script to millions of children in India. Why not adopt a simple script at national level? Indian states can retain their languages, scripts and culture by teaching highly propagated Hindi/Sanskrit in regional scripts to impart technical education through a script converter or in India's simplest Gujanagari script along with a Roman script to revive Brahmi script.
अ आ इ ई उ ऊ ऍ ए ऐ ऑ ओ औ अम् अन् अः...........Devanagari
અ આઇઈઉઊઍ એ ઐ ઑ ઓ ઔ અમ્ અન્ અઃ.........Gujanagari(Gujarati)
a ā i ī u ū ă e ai ŏ o au am an aḥ...............Roman
a aa i ii u uu ae e ai aw o au an am ah
क ख ग घ च छ ज झ ट ठ ड ढ ण
ક ખ ગ ઘ ચ છ જ ઝ ટ ઠ ડ ઢ ણ
ka kha ga gha ca cha ja jha/za ṭa ṭha ḍa ḍha ṇa
त थ द ध न प फ ब भ म य र ल व
ત થ દ ધ ન પ ફ બ ભ મ ય ર લ વ
ta tha da dha na pa pha/fa ba bha ma ya ra la va/wa
श स ष ह ळ क्ष ज्ञ
શ સ ષ હ ળ ક્ષ જ્ઞ
sha sa ṣa ha ḽa kṣa gya
अं आं इं ईं उं ऊं एं ऐं ओं औं अँ आँ इँ ईँ उँ ऊँ एँ ऐँ ओँ औं
ȧ ā̇ ï ī̇ u̇ ū̇ ė aï ȯ au̇ a̐ ā̐ i̐ ī̐ u̐ ū̐ e̐ ai̐ o̐ au̐........Roman
Make portal@22 of schedule language upload all language tutorials which is accessible to all Indians who is interesting can access those language tutorials simple... feeling of oneness is absence here is also one of the problem
This is a very good education draft.
But.
Please close all private school, college and educational organisations up to 12th standard . This will help a lot in good and equal education system because there are many discrimination in our society towards private school and government school . If there will be not any options for private schools then most of people ( politicians, bureaucrats and officers of education ) concentrate on development of government schools.
Also set up micro manufacturing unit in the Government school ( above 6th standard ).
#Discrimination creates differences
This is my own opinion, if any body agree with me. Like and raise your voice in favour of United India and developing India.
Jay Hind .
Thanks
No need three language two languages enough
No it's wrong!
My opinion is one world one language! Easy to understand all over the countries, all people in the world!
Wish one day we have a language called 'Indian'.
Just like the foreigners think Indians speak. "Do you speak Indian? ''
@@manpreetrox30 😁😁 yeah, something like that
You can go to European Union and see the love , they have for their mother tongue
That's right, lets kill the pluralism. everything should be one. One language, one culture, one religion and one political party like in China. That's what BJP should be working towards. I guess they are, aren't they.
Have sense before speaking.
If Tamil/Malayalam/Kannada/Tulu/Telugu is a regional language, Hindi for us is a pakistani foreign language. Period. We are good with British foreign language (English) rather than pakistani foreign language (Hindi).. Vanakam
Let's people decide which language they want not politician I found number of Hindi speaking classes in Tamilnadu .politician oppose Hindi due to their own political interest .
No bro people's mindset bhi yehi hoti ... muje Hindi patha hei... lekin muje chaayiye toh pad lethum lekin sabko force karna nayi
Please... I am not a politician. We students from South find it very irritating to study Hindi..... I don't wish to get imposed with a language which I don't like and what is the use for us to study Hindi. No use at all.
I’m sorry Naveen, what did you say about people’s minds?
Why dont you all understand, no one is forcing Hindi on South Indians......I am from Chattisgarh, lives in Maharashtra.....I can speak chattisgarhi, Marathi, Hindi, etc....Marathi people did not force me to learn Marathi.
By learning Hindi, non-English-speaking South Indians will get large numbers of Hindi speaking consumer. You can easily promote your products in other than South parts of India.
It seems Hindi gives sleep paralysis to south Indians.
As expected from the Government.
Mother tongue is base of creative thought,but unification single language is must. But congress is failed on these ground hence we will have to borrowed language ie english to unify country. Long after effect of bad policies in past. In t.n politician does not want immigrant by keeping language constraint also keep public within there domain by keeping them in dark .
Why the policy makers want the proficiency in three languages when a command over two languages can be a good option. People are made to acquaint with multiple languages while they master in none. Why they just need to overburden the students with extra subjects
"Tamil was not merely the language of South India but before the Aryans came it was the language of the whole of India and was spoken from Kashmir to Cape Comorin." - Babasaheb Dr. B.R. Ambedkar.
Lol. It's not applicable today. Have sense.
@@shantanubansal1473 That's why the Cow Belt is still under poverty and Rape capital of the World.
Please support Hindi language for only as our national language.... Hindi is not my mother tongue but I support Hindi as a national language because One national language is very necessary and Hindi is the right language for national language... Hindi is only one language which connects to all Indian people... Try to understand the importance of Hindi language...
Connects all people? I just find very difficult and irritating to take Hindi as a national language..... and I am sure that I am not alone then how will it connect all the people?
@Yuvraj Poudyal yes English is connecting the whole world...... I don't think there is a need for a national language.
All 22 languages by their very reality are national languages. I am sympathetic about Indian languages having a larger role as languages of law, official record, and the like...I just do not see why it is Hindi and only Hindi for that job. Why not have one language from each of the four language trees in India as an all-India language or atleast a language of record? Why is the job solely for Hindi?
English should be the national language and it connects Indians.
seen the unseen no. The North Indians would refuse. At the end of the day respect goes both ways and you have to be consistent.
It's just a political issue , they don't want to learn an Indian language. Just political parties will control the public for their vote bank and power in the southern states.
If you don't know the ground realities then leave it don't talk rubbish what is not a political move imposing a language is not a political move.
Unrest imposing any language on anybody.
In fact you also do the same easy importance Tamil or malayalam on you.
We are happy with English so let it be like that
Not a good debate at all core issues were not even touched upon.
Instead of imposing hindi. It should be Sanskrit. So that people can read their scriptures and connect to each other of other States.
Just check with Tamil then, which is the oldest and has rich set of literature and surviving in many countries including India . Why don't we take a long live language than a dead languages or just spoken by a few people. Even many evidences showed that Tamil is better than Sanskrit as it is alive with strong archilogicla proofs. FYI 60% of archialogical evidences are taking in India are in Tamil than Sanskrit .
Two language system is very good. tamil nadu practiced this very successfully. so we do not need any other languages. we should concentrate upon two languages. it is better for our bright future. do not try to confuse us by imposing unnecessarily third languages which will definitely make confusion, so do not disturb us (Tamil Nadu) by imposing anything on us.
why do you accept english as your 2nd language ???? why not telugu or malyali or any other indian language ,, why is it that a foreign language is so much imporatant to you than a indian language ,, and you are not alone every state in india has the same 2 language the 2nd being common over the whole country ,, english is not our language ,, its a reminder of colonial rule ,, it was supposed to be a language for commercial communication and not the symbol of success and status in india
@@Neelinmact though english is an foreign language, it was imposed on us during the english rule. further it is also recognised international language which will definetly help us as linking language with other countries. we should not forget India is a union of states , we can not make common language in india. Tamil is one of the official languages in india. so we learn tamil for our indian status and identity with english as international language. why do we need third language? Do not try to make one nation, one tax one culture, one language etc., which is not feasible in our country.
@@kathirraja9062 answer me honestly which is the common language in india ?? do you seriously think english is not the common language ,, dont misunderstood that i am trying to impose hindi on you or anyone else ,, i just wish that a indian language is the connecting language in india ,, i dont hate english ,, india is and always will be union of states but it never says that english should be the language of interaction between north south east and west of india ,,
I do not think a single language at this time can unite India, Neel.
@@suryavajra of course not but its a good start
Don't impose your mother/language on others. It is a shame. Keep your language and your mother safe.
"The official language of India shall be Hindi. Since Indians wish to unite and develop a common culture, it is duty of all Indians to own up Hindi as their language.
Any Indian who doesn't accept this proposal (Hindi as national lang) has no right to be called
Indian"- Ambedkar
@@hangout4434 "Tamil was not merely the language of South India but before the Aryans came it was the language of the whole of India and was spoken from Kashmir to Cape Comorin." - Babasaheb Dr. B.R. Ambedkar.
@@hangout4434 u dont know value of one language... hindi is nit even a classical language..... language is not a language alone..its replicates culture moral... historical values ..... dont impose any one language .... we dint give respect for the languages what it actually deserves.... here everything is politics..... first acknowledged language as classical is tamil.... then sanscrit... and othet dravidian languages.... govt is not giving any preference to any od schedule language other than hindi out of 22 scheduled one... who made hindi as official.... the same politician who drafted bill.... not god or some super power..... learn how many language u want .... its individual perception... dont impose it
@@Richard_Parker_Offl Even if I agree on babasaheb's assumption but it's foolish to think that Tamil should be common language for Indians. Tamils were pushed back by Aryans and aryans dominated the entire subcontinent ..this is the truth doesn't matter whether you like it or not. WE should think of moving ahead not just lingering on the past. Learning Hindi will increase the employability of non-hindi speakers. It's the only language which is not alien to 1.25 billion people.
@@adityaaks583 Pls man try to come into reality..... In tamilnadu , most of the daily wages are from up and Bihar..... We r providing the employment for those who are starving for food at hindi speaking state.... And one more thing bcoz of south india GDP, LITERACY, HUMAN CAPITAL, EASE OF DOING BUSINES increased and competing with other countries..... South Indians are always having moral, humanity and ethics .... Any one can welcome to south india, we will provide better standard of living..... First respect other languages before posting comments.....
India had lost many regional and local languages. And it may continue to do so unless a good language policy measure is taken and implemented properly. As for as 3 language policy is concerned it is not the solution but the problem itself. As the panelist have pointed out Good infrastructure is definitely a big problem. And lack of clarity in the draft the way it will implement the policy. Consider 40 students in a class. 20 wants to learn Language A, 10 wants to learn language B, 7 wants to learn language C and 3 wants to learn language D, my question is does the 3 students who wants to learn the language D will still have a teacher to teach them that particular language they desire to learn or will they be asked to pick up from other three languages that they dont want to??
Already young minds are having pressure in studying enough subjects already. Why to force them study one more subject? As they grow based on their interest and their need they will learn new language if it will uplift them. So instead of creating problems find solutions.
A special dedicated institute for learning all regional language. A special institution for studying foreign language can be considered. And bring junior, senior, diplomo ,Bachelor's level in that insitute. Make it part time, or full time on week ends. Or improve more. This might save languages on the verge of death.
Just my suggestion.
young minds having pressure of studying different subjects is a different matter than the problem of english being the "primary" language in india ,, it is very disgusting to know that a foreign language has acquired a position like that in india ,, india is a bizzare country in which we take pride in ourselves for being linguistically diverse yet we have a colonial language as a symbol of status and success and all other "diverse" languages have been reduced to a inferior position ,,
@@Neelinmact Hello Mr. Neel Patel. It is so kind of you to read and reply to my response. Thanks for your time. :) I dont want this to be a point of argument. Diversity is a basic part and special feature of our country. Promote and preserve every language. And Let's not show our patriotism only in common language. :)
@@divyamurugesan5557 if diversity is a basic part and special part of our country tehn lets promote it ,, every indian language must be preserved , promoted , and the oppurtunity to succeed should not be limited to just one language
@@Neelinmact That's what I meant. Let there be a dedicated institute separately to promote local and indigenous language. They can also make these institutes to collaborate with schools to promote Indian languages. It might solve the issue of infrastructure part too.
The hindi penetration would allow the North bound parties and leaders to speak to South region people directly in Hindi instead of growing a local leaders for their party - This is the 1st reason why central govt is trying since 1956 (The run against Hindi started during british india in 1930's
Even this Draft is following 2 language formula, because the Draft is released in 2 language only. TN is following 2 language formula over 50 years and it successfully developed the life style of people. Making 3rd language compulsory to learn cause burden for the students. Instead of 3 language formula, create sabha for all 22 official languages all over india. That sabha should teach free of cost for learning process. Centralisation is the another problem in this Draft. Education policy making and medical science should be in the power of state government.
Why there should be hindi compulsory.. one regional language and one universal english language is enough.. why we should take burden of reading 3 languges.. if it is so far national integration then integrate with English..
Sanskrit should be the legitimate link language. The 3-language formula should be: (1) Sanskrit (2) English (3) Mother tongue.
Yuvraj Poudyal Sanskrit is far from dead. In fact, it’s undergoing a quiet revival. The spoken Sanskrit movement is afoot. संस्कृतभाषा न लुप्ता न मृता न मृतप्राया। As Hebrew was reinstated as the civilisational language of Israel from a situation much worse than Sanskrit, so must Sanskrit be given that place in India. It’s a no-brainer to anyone except those with no brains.
Yuvraj Poudyal Yes, Sanskrit has been treated cheaply so far. That should change.
@@agnimitrabrf4862 Sanskrit is a alien language to Tamils.
Common Man Rubbish. Even the earliest Tamizh grammar Tolkappiyam has explicit rules to absorb words and grammatical structures from Sanskrit. 41% of tamizh vocabulary is from Sanskrit. They are organically inseparable. That’s why Samskrita Bharati has the fastest growing presence in TN and Kerala. English is definitely alien to Tamizh and all Indic languages.
@@agnimitrabrf4862 Fuck that prostitute language Sanskrit. Tamil is older and a different family.
Should have called some one elae from TN rather than Ganapathi.
Unity in diversity is India not this
Mr. Tripati's says, since 60% can speak Hindi, it is okay if we impose Hindi upon the remaining 40% who don't know Hindi and are happy with their own rich mother tongues. According to his logic, more then 80% eat Meat therefore it is okay to force the Vegetarians to eat Meat.
Absolutely
@@brocklesnar5385 If crow's color was Saffron and not Black, these Cow Belt politicians would have made it a National Bird.
Only idiot can think like this....language is used to integrate people and job opportunity ...u people link with food....
@@divyavethavanisekar3655
Hindi doesn't unite India
*IT DIVIDES*
English should be made optional instead of compulsory especially after class Xth.
Why?? Will you be finding diverse subjects in hindi or any Indian language Except English??U really overestimate Hindi bro! Learn Hindi only if you are a native speaker or want to be a profession in the subject. What exist now is the best, no need to change. U still can write UPSC or any govt. exams in Hindi.
Unless I don't plan to work as a labourer why should I learn Hindi as compulsory subject?
For a Tamil, his language is the expression of his identity, history, culture and values. It is as important as his mother.
What a stupid comment.
@@ThuraiMugil sir never accuse anyone before knowing about them correctly... it will only add to our bad karma...
All languages are worthy of respect... Tamil is a beautiful language and amongst the oldest ones... even I am trying to learn it ...
But that does not mean one can look down upon other languages and other organisations.
It's kerala and karnataka , not keral and Kannad.
different language have different pronountition ..
people in west ..call KARM as a KARMA
yog as yoga
and everybody knows kerala and karnataka
In Hindi, Karma cannot become Karm, because the r and the m are conjunct consonants and hence the अ must be pronounced.
@@suryavajra you are absolutely right bro.......We have a Persian style pronunciation. Hangover of North's Muslim rule past.
Hi there Navneet! Actually I learned Persian! It is interesting to see similarities and differences. I guess my only point is that I have recently been teaching myself a bit of Hindi and the rules to writing Hindi in the Devanagari script with the implied अ.
@@suryavajra I m a native hindi speaker but I find south indian languages better than Hindi on grounds of technical and cultural reasons . I am so happy that we would get to learn some south indian language in northern states.
English is asked to give less priority. How is it possible this is one of the global languages. Students might proceed their studies in European countries.
This new educational policy is not properly framed. This policy brought only to emphasize the future students but not the candidates who had passed out. It is not possible to make any Indian languages to be learnt by force. Make all the INDIAN 8th schedule languages must be optional. Each and Every student has the right to learn a language of his/ her choice.
It is better to focus on learning with understanding and skill than rote memorization.
By the way Maharashtra doesn't opposing hindi compulsion.
would they accept tamil imposition ??
@@Neelinmact dude, hindi is national language and mainly spoken by more than half of the population.
Mr. Perrira, why dont you pick up people from different state for debating on issues of language imposition especially Hindhi ? Why you call only these salaried people for discussing real issues for time pass ????? You bring in the people who have questions on languages not the experts. Experts are biased.
So how many states in Hindi belt have included Dravidian languages in their curriculum... As much as I respect the Constitution of India, adopting Hindi as an official language is the most amateur exercise in the country's 75 year history. It gives unfair advantage to 40% of the population making non-hindi speaking people as 2nd class citizens.
Even UPSC discriminates non Hindi candidates by setting the preliminary exam question paper only in English/Hindi.
Ys bro.....creating bureaucratd without any discrimination. Is the job of UPSC.....BUT...UPSC itself did /done /do...discrimination...by set question papers...in hindi english onlyyyy.......
Is it fair...???
my friend studied in france and he narrated an incident where he met a couple of indians and they started talking in english ,, there was a french guy among them and he asked why dont you guys speak in your own language ??
we speak about lingusitic diversity and regional diversity but please dont let it become a hindrance for the identity of a nation ,,
i dont care which language it is it but please make an indian language as the language of the nation ,, i dont even care if you want to make a new indian language which takes elements from all the languages in india (a very far fetched idea)
i dont hate english language but the importance that we have attached to this foreign language is appaling ,, it has become a synonym of success in indian society ,, its bad and disgusting ,,
however i dont favour a hindi imposition simply becasue north indians did not give importance to other regional languages ,, even to those languages which are more ancient than hindi and are more "indian" in nature ,, would hindi speaking states favour the imposition of tamil , telugu , malayalam , bodo , khasi , bengali etc ,,, i live in MP and my mother tongue is hindi and i know hindi speaker would never accept that imposition ,, a govt at the centre would fall in a matter of days if they actually came up with a idea like this ,,
I sympathize with a lot of things you say, Neel, but no one Indian language no matter how ancient or modern or however many the speakers are, can ever be tthe sole pan-India language. Really it is a role for a number of languages to share together.
I think the idea of a vernacular which takes from all of the Indian languages is an interesting idea and not as far fetched as you might think. There are informal speeches that organically sprang up in many cities where they already do just that. Like a kind of creole language.
English was a foreign lg..but not anymore..why are you guys then hvng discussion in English
....creating bureaucratd without any discrimination. Is the job of UPSC.....BUT...UPSC itself did /done /do...discrimination...by set question papers...in hindi english onlyyyy.......
Is it fair...???
Because UPSC conducts exam for union not for states and centre has hindi and English it's official language .
Crct..bro....but union itself collection of states.....to avoid discrimination..it can use ENGLISH ALONE.....
Be frank....a rural village student want to become IAS...he doesn't know hindi...but he performs well in his regional language.....
He can lose even 1 mark bcz of misunderstanding english..,its a big fault..the same rural hindi student can gain 1 mark...by knowing hindi....
Is it equal...??
This is the most rootcause....
If ur are that ..rural non hindi person who lose his IAS carrer bcz of non hindi background.....compare with other hindi known candidate got some xtra marks bcz of understand qustns in hindi ....
U can tolerate it??
Set question paper in English only....its common or english and their state language....
@@muralidharan992 read constitution India is not union of states but it has a strong centre and weak states . Hindi is spoken and understand by half of nation and since it's adopted as one of language of union u can't call it discrimination .
If a rural guy dont understand English or Hindi then he can appear in other exams including state PSCs .
Hindi was destined to be national language of India but that dint happen now let it atleast be in par with English in terms of union .
It's gross hypocrisy that people like u can accept supremacy of English but will die of ass ache when listen the name of hindi .
In era of internet and information it's hypothetical to think a candidate is from rural non hindi speaking area and he fails to get into CSE exam because he dint know English hindi well .
At first place no candidate can pass any exam in India without knowing English .
I think...u have to read cons of india...if not possible just read ARTICLE 1....
Half the states accept hindi ..BUT. the other half states ..doesn't accept hindi....strong centre with weak states...is not to impose / dump others..but to have fair rights to states....
Non HINDI students ...write including state PCS is wrong....
They onlyyyy WRITE STATE PCS....
And ...not all are PHD IN ENGLISH......so even u also can read questions in hindi ,if u cant understand some meaning of the questions in english......this is undeniable truth.....
Kk....
And in the era of internet....y hindi speaking most of the students can't speak english well....
So.....hindi speakers can protest and give us rights that " NON HINDI STATES questions can frame in their language and english.".
U cant do it..
As u said.....in era of internet..bla bla...reallyyyy
....In ur state ..rural people .... students can understand all in english ....and appear in exams and write without seeing hindi questions...????
Bro practically.....hindi states has advantage in cntrl exams....u cant tell its a myth...
@@muralidharan992 don't debate with me file a writ .....this is what constitution is ..hindi can't be demoted as per your demand albeit can be made national language of India ....learn to live with others ...u don't wanna learn then don't learn Hindi but u can't remove it .
And half of state officially accepts hindi and on other hand more than 70% population in India understands hindi that's important .
Take care
"The official language of India shall be Hindi.
Since Indians wish to unite and develop a common culture, it is duty of all Indians to own up Hindi as their language.
Any Indian who doesn't accept this proposal (Hindi as national lang) has no right to be called Indian"- Dr. Ambedkar
This is called arrogance not nationalism
The constitution recognises 22 official languages in the 8 the schedule. Everyone must have the highest regard for the constitution.
I would suggest ...we should made compulsary for every education institution in india to teach top 5 spoken language of india along with the state language....Which total comprises of 6 six language a indian must study...This will not only unite india even more stronger but every indian will learn about a lot of different culture and will not face any language discrimination if he or she goes to other state for study or jobs...
How would you teach six languages, math, science, history and everything else to a child? It would seem like it would be too much.
First you learn the top 5
@@suryavajra we can reduce e the syllabus of science math history and other subjects...And can add them in 11th 12th respectively...And not to add that language since their 1 st or 2nd grades....We can add them slowly according to ease of the language in different grades...After 5th or sixth....You can teach a student of 3rd grade 4th grade their own state language and english along with one easy language decided by state government....And there u go...3 language has accomplish....remaining 3....And you have 6-7 years for them...Hope u like the plan....Any suggestoon from you ...Most welcome...🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳
And this will not only promote the young unemployed youth to learn the language and get a job on basis of this in any institution in india....This will only creat new jobs. ah!!!!...One more step to kill unemployment .
@@commonman2806 sir I already know 4 languages of india...And currently learning one of the most spoken language of the world...Hope u know which is that language...
Why central government conduct exams only in English and Hindi?
If Hindi made compulsory in non Hindi states , then regional languages will definitely destroy
For 1000 years there have been Sanskrit . Regional Languages did not get destroy. It is English which is destroying Regional languages and not Hindi.
@@sadenb what about exam medium ?
Simple answer is Hindi is an official language along with English,this was set during the beginning of constitution.nothing to do with central trying to push Hindi it was given 75 years ago
My point being any central body will use Hindi and English
And as for regional language any central exam you can choose your language of requirement
Because there is something called official language of the union which is hindi and english only.
@@sadenb Please learn from East Pakistan, which is no longer the part of Pakistan.
Please remove these experts. They are old and don't know present situation. They are talking old bookish garbage.
Hindi has potential and it will grow and flourish. No matter south learn it or not.
जय हिंद
Jai Hind aur Jai Hindi is different .. pls try to understand
జయ తెలుగు
ఫక్ హిందీ
Put your kids in Hindi medium school and all the best.
Tamil has potential to flourish as at present. There is no dependency on new speakers either !
Can an amendment to make Hindi as proceeding language fares better as an inducement to learn Hindi???
I mean in supreme court
vairamuthu .D you mean as a language of the court?
@@suryavajra yes.
I think rulings should be in the language that those whom are involved in the case can understand. In that sense it is right to make Hindi a language of legal rulings in the Northern States, so long as the same can be said in other states with regards to Tamil/ Malayalam, Punjabi, etc.