American horror scares stupid people, that’s why people watch movies like “The Nun”. It’s for people with short attention spans that just want the movie to jump-scare them. Personally, I like horror movies that build tension overtime.
@@brandonhosman4697 It is just bizarre to me. There have been scenes in modern American films that were pretty creepy or tense, and then suddenly some loud dumb noise goes off and ruins the whole atmosphere.
The original also had those loud noises to scary you. I think the original is great but some parts, some transitions could be better. There are scenes that just "ends". Anyway, back to the loud noises, this original was from 2003 and already played with that "trope". It's played like a "ghost" horror story, but uses this to distracts you from the real drama, that the protagonist is crazy. But then reveals that yes, there's also a ghost there, it's both.
As much as I love Asian horror and hate remakes...The Uninvited was actually *one of the ONLY* American adaptions that impressed me. It took the core of the original story but crafted its own unique story. And everything was well-cut and directed and written. And the music. I was so happy and impressed. And even though I’m Asian and Korean, I think overall the 2009 adaption was better in the end of things. It wasn’t drawn out, and I truly feel it did a better job of telling a more concise, clearer, less-confusing story, after rewatching each one again back to back.
@elyx caraballoll i know thats your opinion but no. in fact you cant really compare those movies. yes they are all horror movies. But A tale of two sisters is the only psychological horror in that list. its a subgenre of horror movies that none of those other movies can compare to. the creepiness o a tale of two sisters is what the movie makes great. i love the other horror movies but a tale of two sisters is amazing and better then all those combined.
disturbing fact: A Tale of Two Sister produced for 3.7m garnered 1m in cinemas The Uninvited produced for (i cant find it tho i assume it wouldn't be past 10m or even 8) garnered 42m in worldwide box office. it is just sad to see this remakes do this well while the original lost money.
I saw The Uninvited about 3 times back when it released 12 years ago. And about 6 years ago, I went and scoped out some foreign horror movies that people recommended. So I saw Tale of Two Sisters and not even thirty minutes in , I started to I realize The Uninvited was a remake all along
A Tale of Two Sisters is a masterful psychological horror with so many greats things from the acting, the cinematography, the music, and of course, the story it tells. The Uninvited, on the other hand, while washed down and not as complex in comparison, is still pretty decent in my opinion and not as bad as other remakes of classic Asian horrors like Shutter or One Missed Call. But it honestly felt pointless in the end.... I mean, the original is flawless. It didn’t need a remake. And I would encourage anyone who hasn’t seen Tale of Two Sisters (or even those who’ve only seen The Uninvited) to give it a watch!
@@aspenbennett9041 Why am I not surprised to see you here again? And yet again, shutting down a proper comparison between the two films on a video doing exactly that. What? Can't handle that not everyone likes the American version? Do you find it personally offensive or something? In any case, you really need to get over it. Only thing better about the remake is its name.
Korean acting always seems to be so sincere and real, whereas American acting always seems to have this veneer of ironic detachment that makes the characters so much harder to connect with
I watched The Uninvited when it came out and hated it, then years later I watched A Tale of Two Sisters and it became one of my favorite horror movies of all time and it was only during the ending did I realize "wait a minute, I've seen this before!" and looked up if the uninvited was a rip off only to find out it was a remake. My point: The Uninvited fucking sucks. Lol
i haven't even seen the tale of two sisters ive seen the uninvited. But just seeing the comparing of both films the original Asian version seems so much better in every way. The original has fantastic cinemaphotography. I got t watch the original version now. Asians make the best horror films, its their kind of style from the atmosphere, culture, horror.
@@jalyceabraham1902 in a way yes but she was a cna that let her patient die because she was too busy having sex with her patients husband so.....she had an evil side even though she didn't mean her step daughter any harm
oh my gosh I forgot that the uninvited was a movie. I watched the movie in theaters years ago, but only because the new Friday the 13 movie at the time was sold out, and so me and my BF had to watch this because we didn't want to call our parents to pick us up. and we hated it. I still remember us getting out and him just saying, "Well that movie sucked!" I still laugh about it to this day. but the fact it was based off of another movie called, a tale of two sisters a movie is very shameless. I will admit I have never seen until this moment, but the opening already has a very strong hook, that with the context I know from the uninvited I feel so bad for the ending. It feels like it's going to hurt those watching a lot more with the truth that they will not be ready for it. So A tale of two sisters looks really good and should be remembered, and I hope people forget that the uninvited existed like I did for years after watching it.
The remake was okay but I will always and forever love the tale of two sisters it's a absolute masterpiece and very beautiful but also really sad especially the ending of the movie 💘😍💔💔😭😭😭
Seriously? I didnt watch the tale of two sisters but i did watch the uninvited and then suddenly bcoz of the youtube recommendations i watch this video and now i know that the uninvited is the american adoptation of the tale of two sisters .
Lol the remake is so bad. Shouldn't have done it at all. Might as well make a whole new story. They changed the feel to the story and even the characters felt different.
As much as I love Asian horror and hate remakes...The Uninvited was actually *one of the ONLY* American adaptions that impressed me. It took the core of the original story but crafted its own unique story. And everything was well-cut and directed and written. And the music. I was so happy and impressed. And even though I’m Asian and Korean, I think overall the 2009 adaption was better in the end of things. It wasn’t drawn out, and I truly feel it did a better job of telling a more concise, clearer, less-confusing story.
I have never seen the univited and just from looks of it, it looks like dookie lol i dont understand why america films feel to need to add all this Unnecessary music.
Fun fact: Jun Ji Hyun was offered the role as Sumi but turned it down because it was too scary, but later got a role as the lead in a horror movie called "The Uninvited"
is it supposed to be confusing, like the girl had serious mental issues like split personality, delusions, hallucinations due to guilt its about her mental state. it a pretty straight forward story telling even tho i had just watch it the first time. are you just brain dead the whole time watching and just waiting for scares that you would look the other way? the remake was just straight forward spoon feeding with info that is just bland and uncompelling.
![[Live] ศึกมหึมันส์มวยไทยสังเวียนเดือด เวทีมวยชั่วคราวสวนสยาม | จันทร์ 30 กันยายน 2567](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pM1k6f7JXUc/mqdefault.jpg)
The step mom character in the original is fantastic! The writing and acting is absolutely amazing. They changed her character so much in the remake.
It’s because in the remake, she’s actually real and not a hallucination
@@brianaguilar8283 in remake, She died because of her but i never watch original.
@@brianaguilar8283 And she's also more sympathetic
I'll never understand why modern American horror films feel the need to put in obnoxious sound cues. It's not scary and takes away from the tension.
American horror scares stupid people, that’s why people watch movies like “The Nun”. It’s for people with short attention spans that just want the movie to jump-scare them. Personally, I like horror movies that build tension overtime.
@@brandonhosman4697 It is just bizarre to me. There have been scenes in modern American films that were pretty creepy or tense, and then suddenly some loud dumb noise goes off and ruins the whole atmosphere.
Americans knew how to make international remakes with the Ring. Wtf happened?
The original also had those loud noises to scary you.
I think the original is great but some parts, some transitions could be better. There are scenes that just "ends".
Anyway, back to the loud noises, this original was from 2003 and already played with that "trope". It's played like a "ghost" horror story, but uses this to distracts you from the real drama, that the protagonist is crazy. But then reveals that yes, there's also a ghost there, it's both.
As much as I love Asian horror and hate remakes...The Uninvited was actually *one of the ONLY* American adaptions that impressed me. It took the core of the original story but crafted its own unique story. And everything was well-cut and directed and written. And the music. I was so happy and impressed.
And even though I’m Asian and Korean, I think overall the 2009 adaption was better in the end of things. It wasn’t drawn out, and I truly feel it did a better job of telling a more concise, clearer, less-confusing story, after rewatching each one again back to back.
The original is so much better!! Nothing, I repeat nothing, can beat Korean 2000s horror movies.
@elyx caraballoll i know thats your opinion but no. in fact you cant really compare those movies. yes they are all horror movies. But A tale of two sisters is the only psychological horror in that list. its a subgenre of horror movies that none of those other movies can compare to. the creepiness o a tale of two sisters is what the movie makes great. i love the other horror movies but a tale of two sisters is amazing and better then all those combined.
Absolutely not
soundtrack in the original was beautiful. thats a rare thing to say coming from a horror movie.
disturbing fact: A Tale of Two Sister produced for 3.7m garnered 1m in cinemas
The Uninvited produced for (i cant find it tho i assume it wouldn't be past 10m or even 8) garnered 42m in worldwide box office.
it is just sad to see this remakes do this well while the original lost money.
It’s South Korea’s highest grossing horror film
I saw The Uninvited about 3 times back when it released 12 years ago. And about 6 years ago, I went and scoped out some foreign horror movies that people recommended. So I saw Tale of Two Sisters and not even thirty minutes in , I started to I realize The Uninvited was a remake all along
A Tale of Two Sisters is so beautiful! It's visually stunny. The remake looks so tacky when seeing them right next to each other 😅
A Tale of Two Sisters is a masterful psychological horror with so many greats things from the acting, the cinematography, the music, and of course, the story it tells. The Uninvited, on the other hand, while washed down and not as complex in comparison, is still pretty decent in my opinion and not as bad as other remakes of classic Asian horrors like Shutter or One Missed Call. But it honestly felt pointless in the end.... I mean, the original is flawless. It didn’t need a remake. And I would encourage anyone who hasn’t seen Tale of Two Sisters (or even those who’ve only seen The Uninvited) to give it a watch!
Girl stop
@@aspenbennett9041 Why am I not surprised to see you here again? And yet again, shutting down a proper comparison between the two films on a video doing exactly that. What? Can't handle that not everyone likes the American version? Do you find it personally offensive or something? In any case, you really need to get over it. Only thing better about the remake is its name.
Korean acting always seems to be so sincere and real, whereas American acting always seems to have this veneer of ironic detachment that makes the characters so much harder to connect with
agree
Yes. Koreans know what is a feeling. Americans just pretend to know!
@@conceptualmessiah01 lmao what 😂😂😂😂
Interview: Do you have any special skills?
Me: I can watch two movies at the same time.
5:21 That “you’re next” is so cheesy
I watched The Uninvited when it came out and hated it, then years later I watched A Tale of Two Sisters and it became one of my favorite horror movies of all time and it was only during the ending did I realize "wait a minute, I've seen this before!" and looked up if the uninvited was a rip off only to find out it was a remake.
My point: The Uninvited fucking sucks. Lol
Same here , the uninvited is bored remake and a tale of two sisters still my fav one
The ending in A Tale of Two Sisters broke my heart. 💔
That scene always makes me sad 💔💔😭😭😭😭😭
A Tale of Two Sisters is merely perfection. I'm mean, just look at it. It's kind of unfair to compare these lol
I didn't even know that there was a remake.
same!
I've watched the uninvited but i didn't know that it was a remake of ATOTS
@@redblossomaaron5975 they changed the title. It was supposed to be called “A Tale of Two Sisters” just like the original
I've only seen the remake once it was okay but the tale of two sisters is a true effing masterpiece
i haven't even seen the tale of two sisters ive seen the uninvited. But just seeing the comparing of both films the original Asian version seems so much better in every way. The original has fantastic cinemaphotography. I got t watch the original version now. Asians make the best horror films, its their kind of style from the atmosphere, culture, horror.
nahh the remake cannot even come close to the original lmao
Which is the remake, the tale of two sisters?
@@moonlightprincess12 the uninvited is the remake
I wish someone like martin scorsese did the remake
Elizabeth Banks isn’t nearly as creepy playing the stepmother
The stepmother (from the original) isn't "creepy", she is bitter.
@@deathdoor she’s unsettling because she’s always forcing herself to smile
She didn't have to be creepy, anyways. She was not the killer here.
The stepmother in the remake was benevolent and not at all evil but the stepmother in the original was evil and wicked.
@@jalyceabraham1902 in a way yes but she was a cna that let her patient die because she was too busy having sex with her patients husband so.....she had an evil side even though she didn't mean her step daughter any harm
Thanks for the comparison! A Tale of Two Sisters is one of my favourite psychological thrillers out there.
oh my gosh I forgot that the uninvited was a movie. I watched the movie in theaters years ago, but only because the new Friday the 13 movie at the time was sold out, and so me and my BF had to watch this because we didn't want to call our parents to pick us up. and we hated it. I still remember us getting out and him just saying, "Well that movie sucked!" I still laugh about it to this day.
but the fact it was based off of another movie called, a tale of two sisters a movie is very shameless. I will admit I have never seen until this moment, but the opening already has a very strong hook, that with the context I know from the uninvited I feel so bad for the ending. It feels like it's going to hurt those watching a lot more with the truth that they will not be ready for it. So A tale of two sisters looks really good and should be remembered, and I hope people forget that the uninvited existed like I did for years after watching it.
Haven't seen the English one but boy the original one, I couldn't sleep after watching it😭
ATOTS is one of my most fav korean horrors of all time and I feel so dumb for not knowing that The Uninvited is a remake of it
You know why the Original is better? Its bc they know about that stuff really happening
The remake was okay but I will always and forever love the tale of two sisters it's a absolute masterpiece and very beautiful but also really sad especially the ending of the movie 💘😍💔💔😭😭😭
The Korean stepmother is more gibberish and annoying, which makes it more impressive.
She’s annoying but idk bout gibberish
That's the point. She was suppose to be unlikable for her to be the supposed "villain"
the way Korean stepmom carried the girl is also more believable than the American remake.
Very nice comparison!!
i dont even have to watch lmao anything that doesnt need a remake yet americans do will always be bad
This made The Uninvited 100x more terrible.
OMG it's very very cool😍😍😍
Seriously? I didnt watch the tale of two sisters but i did watch the uninvited and then suddenly bcoz of the youtube recommendations i watch this video and now i know that the uninvited is the american adoptation of the tale of two sisters .
take of two sisters is way better
Lol the remake is so bad. Shouldn't have done it at all. Might as well make a whole new story. They changed the feel to the story and even the characters felt different.
I loved a tale of two sisters the stepmom in that film was a bitch though and was evil but in the uninvited it didnt make any sense
Hollywod loves to water things down lol
Whoa didn't know that The Uninvited was a "remake"
i didn't know a tale of two sisters had a remake
Please do Mirrors ( US VERSION ) vs Into The Mirror ( Original Korean Version)
As much as I love Asian horror and hate remakes...The Uninvited was actually *one of the ONLY* American adaptions that impressed me. It took the core of the original story but crafted its own unique story. And everything was well-cut and directed and written. And the music. I was so happy and impressed.
And even though I’m Asian and Korean, I think overall the 2009 adaption was better in the end of things. It wasn’t drawn out, and I truly feel it did a better job of telling a more concise, clearer, less-confusing story.
Americans out here copying asian movies... why :(
Cuz ever since The Ring came out people wanted to get in the trend it too but they fail at it
No copy but remake.
I have never seen the univited and just from looks of it, it looks like dookie lol i dont understand why america films feel to need to add all this Unnecessary music.
I liked the American version idc idc
Uninvited looks so bad
love A Tale of Two Sisters!
Fun fact: Jun Ji Hyun was offered the role as Sumi but turned it down because it was too scary, but later got a role as the lead in a horror movie called "The Uninvited"
Even the cinematography alone couldn't compare.
It sucks when the remake is more well known the original
The Uninvited to me is the scariest that’s just my opinion
The unsettling theme, that eerie vibes of the original is way better than this remake crap
Ooh snap
I liked the remake better from the story point of view.
Same lol the original storyline is quite confusing
But the a tale of two sisters story more creepy and sad than the uninvited
is it supposed to be confusing, like the girl had serious mental issues like split personality, delusions, hallucinations due to guilt its about her mental state. it a pretty straight forward story telling even tho i had just watch it the first time. are you just brain dead the whole time watching and just waiting for scares that you would look the other way? the remake was just straight forward spoon feeding with info that is just bland and uncompelling.
I liked the serial killer theme but nothing beats the daughter having attempted incest with the dad
The original is the best. Ever american remake 🤮