Realizing that the girl David slapped earlier in the episode probably ate her dad for dinner that night in that stew was not the double whammy I needed before my morning coffee the morning after this aired
I think the writers not including David and Ellie killing a swarm of Infected together is better because it doesn't make sense for him to take down Infected in the show if he sees the cordyceps as his god
"i think the writers making excuses why they don't have infected in the show is good, because they don't have infected sequences in this episode" dude just admit it sucks. Just because something is explained doesn't make it good.
@@ryan80166 Nah you lost me when you said it sucks. Do I want more infected? Yes. Do I think the story sucks? No. I'm actually hoping the show does Part 2's story better because I despised that game's writing.
Honestly I suspected he wanted her sexually the moment he gave her the penicillin. She was partially responsible for the death of one of his warriors yet he insisted on sparing her. That behaviour is damn suspicious.
That and he uses common groomer tactics, talking to her like she's an adult, saying he wants a child to be his partner and that she's the only one that gets him.
When times get really tough, I fear stuff like this more than any zombie, demon, or supernatural mumbo jumbo. There’s not much that exists more scary than a desperate but capable human.
The movie The Road depicts how bleak and soul crushing the reality of a situation like that would be, the scene where they kept people naked and alive in a hole in the group cutting parts of them off one by one, terrifying
never made sense why they would resort to eating humans rather than growing food or even hunting. Its not like they aren't able to go outside anymore, and in a situation where most humans are dead, animal populations would have exploded through the roof by this point unless they were also getting wiped out by the fungus in massive numbers.
David does say that it's hard to grow crops and it's difficult for them to find game. I guess that their best hunters were taken by infected or accidents or illnesses, and when raiders pushed them into an area with such a harsh climate, they weren't able to find more people with hunting skills nor to grow any kind of vegetable.
The only way people used to be able to live like that was by being nomadic. Except you can't exactly be nomadic in a world with a zombie fungus. Things like deer populations rising, would also mean predator populations rise. That then leads to predator populations crashing again after they eat up all the food. Prosperity is not permanent.
I think this is actually an improvement to David, in the game the Cannibalism is so downplayed its almost pointless (other then giving you a self justified reason to kill him and his men) and they leaned too quickly into him creeping on Eli that it just turned him into a mustache twirling villain on a dime, having him be someone who was conflicted with murder even before the outbreak and now having to responsible for others I think really strengthens his character
Meh I prefer the original. He didn’t have to be a blatant pedo to be scary. Plus he was way more convincing as a the “nice guy” at the beginning. No offense to the actor for the show, but just looking at him makes you uneasy. I respect your opinion, and certainly not gonna call you brain dead(so childish)
They're both good! I love the different facets of the takes. Plus I like how the show kept a lot of the lines word for word. I think they downplayed the cannibalism extremely in the game, Ellie mentions it once and it wasn't terribly direct.
yeah i figured that they were probably eating people when i saw the episode. i figured that they were doing that when they brought in the deer while they were already eating something else, and david stated that game is incredibly sparse around their part
One of those rare times a character is written even better than the source material... The actor for David did a phenomenal job portraying this character... His performance definitely makes anyone's skin crawl
This adaptation is absolutely tremendous, just because it doesn’t have loud explosions, zombies everywhere, and a loud rap track for some doesn’t make it bad. It’s thoughtful, horrific, engaging and truly is a story with a plot and meaning. If you just want to see endless zombies and shooting I suggest you go back to playing the game
@@atanaZion I’m just wondering what tf rap music has to do with zombie movies/shows. It’s not a good show..it’s generic and has a total of 3 mins worth of “zombies “.
@@CensorTube84 Tlou plot has always been generic, tho, it is literally what the The Walking Drad game did earlt agos, but with action gameplay The series is based on the lore, that's why shooting zombies is pratically irrelevant
This episode was one of my favorites! There was just so much emotion at play, and as someone who never cries to a show or movie, this episode really got me
i reaaaaaaally wish they didn’t take out that when ellie kills david joel finds her bc in the show she just walks out of the thing and he has no clue what happened, in the game it was a moment of bonding and everything
They say that opposites attract, the fact he says that he see's her in him says that he's nothing but ego centrical and has no depth for another half of him. (maybe looking for a prodigy like the emperor Palpatine)
This scene was absolutely and positivity constructed perfectly from the very beginning to the end 😍😎👍💯 as it made me full of anxiety and adrenaline as it kept me on the edge of my seat.😱😰
The extra number of chops in the TV adaptation is totally earned given how he’s even more vile in than in the video game. Video game David is sickening and cruel, yes, but TV David has you wondering how far reaching his monstrosity has been in the past. With game David you’re glad it’s over. With TV David you almost want to climb into the screen and take over chopping duties once Ellie’s done hacking away at him. Really goes to show: The Infected are amoral entities. They are a disease, a natural disaster. David? Now that’s what evil looks like.
I’ve broken someone’s finger. You just bend hard and fast in any direction except the right one. You aren’t snapping bone, you’re dislocating joints. It really does not take much. 25 years later we are still friends and now he knows when it’s about to rain. Life is funny like that.
dont get me wrong i love David in the show but i prefer him in the game because they make him look like a normal person whos just trying to survive , you never knew if he was with you or against you
The game characters are much more convincing than this acting. In the game David’s voice actor used meaningful pauses that are indispensable, for example: “How did you put it? [pause] Tiny piece? [pause] See you in the morning, Ellie.” And, combined with David’s mild-mannered appearance and the evil look in his eyes, it produced a really strong effect. The HBO David speaks casually and fast, ruining the eerie effect. And Ellie, well, she just yells.
The voice actor for David in the game is the same voice actor who plays Nathan drake in uncharted. He’s also the same voice actor who voices superboy from young justice
No I disagree. I found the game version a little caricatured. Very 'gamey' if you know what I mean. Show-David just felt more real, like he's a monster who you could see actually existing in real life.
Game David was more generic evil psycho, the show one is more realistic. In the game it’s like he wanted to eat people, but in the show it’s better since they make it like he doesn’t want to but did it for the others. Show did it better this time.
Jehovah God Lord Jesus Christ always is good to us He died for our sins and rose from the dead He cares for us and is with us no matter what you did or do He always loves us He has open arm always ✝️❤️
I think it was winter and they couldn't find any food. Rivers were frozen, game was scarce. I really doubt they resorted to being cannibals when there were deer and rabbits wandering outside their houses
@@rainbow_doglover8301 yes, you're right about rivers, but there are still animals. Don't know why they couldn't find them. Because even Ellie killed a deer and rabbit before meeting them
The Best Reaction to this episode - th-cam.com/video/pING2yPlmBg/w-d-xo.html
3:34
This subtle 'Oh....' and the way she looks at his hand when she realizes his true intentions for her is a great bit of acting.
That was also in the game.
BAD TOUCH, BAD TOUCH. AAAAA-
David chose to be a monster, the infected didn't. Plus when he mentions he was a teacher it makes you think of all the children he must've abused.
That's a smart way of describing David as a character.
Aaaaand it's more than implied that he grapes victims before killing and eating.
her line delivery is amazing. i literally shouted LET'S GOOOO during the "tell them it was ellie who broke your finger" scene
ME TOO! They did such a fantastic job
Bit weird
THE NORTH REMEMBERS who broke your finger!!!!
Honestly bella as Ellie just clicked really well!
this actress is trash any other would be soo mutch betteer
Realizing that the girl David slapped earlier in the episode probably ate her dad for dinner that night in that stew was not the double whammy I needed before my morning coffee the morning after this aired
He ain't just a cannibal. She breaks his finger because she realizes he wants her as his child bride.🤢🤮
Oh, good lord. That's just sick.
That's what you called a "pedo" buddy
Glad someone got it. The way his voice changes when she touches his hand is terrifying.
That damn groomer...
@@rufousthefox9766 the impostor.
I think the writers not including David and Ellie killing a swarm of Infected together is better because it doesn't make sense for him to take down Infected in the show if he sees the cordyceps as his god
When you put it that way, it makes sense. I do wish we would’ve gotten some kind of scene where they had to work together
"i think the writers making excuses why they don't have infected in the show is good, because they don't have infected sequences in this episode"
dude just admit it sucks. Just because something is explained doesn't make it good.
@@ryan80166 Lmao nobody needs to “admit” something sucks if they don’t think it does, your opinion on this is prolly just your own 🤷
@@ryan80166 Nah you lost me when you said it sucks. Do I want more infected? Yes. Do I think the story sucks? No. I'm actually hoping the show does Part 2's story better because I despised that game's writing.
@@OneEyedCloud01 .............So you are hoping they change the story, because its so good?
If you listen closely the "oh" Bella does at 3:36 really sounds like the "oh" Ashley does in the game.
4:09 Bella gives it everything she has she’s such a brilliant actress :’0
I get chills at this part
Even sounds like video game Ellie. So good.
@@pangolothian no disrespect but I beg to differ
@@pangolothian they are amazing at acting I think she acts more like her then she does sounds like her
Worst actress
Honestly I suspected he wanted her sexually the moment he gave her the penicillin. She was partially responsible for the death of one of his warriors yet he insisted on sparing her. That behaviour is damn suspicious.
Shd is ugly as hell wtf
That and he uses common groomer tactics, talking to her like she's an adult, saying he wants a child to be his partner and that she's the only one that gets him.
Yes, he actually did
@@Imme121K actual groomer final boss 💀
@@SuperNeedforsleepBRO IM CRYING😭😭😭😭💀💀💀
That finger snap sound hit harder than in the game.
When times get really tough, I fear stuff like this more than any zombie, demon, or supernatural mumbo jumbo. There’s not much that exists more scary than a desperate but capable human.
The movie The Road depicts how bleak and soul crushing the reality of a situation like that would be, the scene where they kept people naked and alive in a hole in the group cutting parts of them off one by one, terrifying
This is how, sadly, I realized, human beings can be monsters.
You hit the nail on the head there humans are definitely more scary
This show does such a wonderful job of showing the best of humanity and the worst of humanity in the same episode
never made sense why they would resort to eating humans rather than growing food or even hunting. Its not like they aren't able to go outside anymore, and in a situation where most humans are dead, animal populations would have exploded through the roof by this point unless they were also getting wiped out by the fungus in massive numbers.
clearly growing crops didnt work because otherwise theyd have had some already, and they were hunting, just not enough for it to sustain the village
David does say that it's hard to grow crops and it's difficult for them to find game. I guess that their best hunters were taken by infected or accidents or illnesses, and when raiders pushed them into an area with such a harsh climate, they weren't able to find more people with hunting skills nor to grow any kind of vegetable.
The only way people used to be able to live like that was by being nomadic. Except you can't exactly be nomadic in a world with a zombie fungus. Things like deer populations rising, would also mean predator populations rise. That then leads to predator populations crashing again after they eat up all the food. Prosperity is not permanent.
I think this is actually an improvement to David, in the game the Cannibalism is so downplayed its almost pointless (other then giving you a self justified reason to kill him and his men) and they leaned too quickly into him creeping on Eli that it just turned him into a mustache twirling villain on a dime, having him be someone who was conflicted with murder even before the outbreak and now having to responsible for others I think really strengthens his character
You’re actually brain dead if you think David was improved 💀
and the fact that 390 people liked this comment is crazy lmao@@AdrikPartida
Meh I prefer the original. He didn’t have to be a blatant pedo to be scary. Plus he was way more convincing as a the “nice guy” at the beginning. No offense to the actor for the show, but just looking at him makes you uneasy. I respect your opinion, and certainly not gonna call you brain dead(so childish)
They're both good! I love the different facets of the takes. Plus I like how the show kept a lot of the lines word for word.
I think they downplayed the cannibalism extremely in the game, Ellie mentions it once and it wasn't terribly direct.
These mfs tryna argue with this 😂Cannot accept that they cooked wit this show
I almost yelled out, "GET 'EM, LYANNA!"
"And as for you, Lord Cerwyn, ..."
YES
I yelled "GET 'EM, HILDA!!!" 💀
You almost did, but you refused the call!😉😂
Man vs Bear?
More like Pedo vs Bear
BEAR WINS
How did they manage to make him even more creepy
David is one of the most F ed up fictional characters i have ever seen. Dam
Not telling people your name is wise. They should stay in the habit of doing that lol.
Yup, I know Tommy would never have a name related incident ever
@@AdnanShaikh-zh5zd😂
yeah... 😊
@@AdnanShaikh-zh5zdnice one😂
yeah i figured that they were probably eating people when i saw the episode. i figured that they were doing that when they brought in the deer while they were already eating something else, and david stated that game is incredibly sparse around their part
I’ve just met Scott Shepherd (the actor of David) in the bus, here in Berlin 😂 He is nice in real life 😂
I hope so, because he plays some messed up characters!
I’m currently working with him and he is SUCH a nice guy!!
@@noonac814 Waaw nice !! Can you tell more about the project ?
@@lastarfolle1 he’s currently one of the leads in a show at Bard college so he’s always running around the lobby before the show talking to people!!
@@noonac814 Waaaa Nice !!
Judge you?
YOU EATING PEOPLE YOU SICK ****...!!!!
Now that made me scared of the villain! 😭😭😭😭
One of those rare times a character is written even better than the source material... The actor for David did a phenomenal job portraying this character... His performance definitely makes anyone's skin crawl
0:43 At the bottom of the screen, you can see the plate which Ellie kicked is gone. However, at 0:54 it's back.
3:44 she closed the trap! 🪤
This adaptation is absolutely tremendous, just because it doesn’t have loud explosions, zombies everywhere, and a loud rap track for some doesn’t make it bad. It’s thoughtful, horrific, engaging and truly is a story with a plot and meaning. If you just want to see endless zombies and shooting I suggest you go back to playing the game
Wtf does rap have to do with a zombie show lol
What in the boomer is this comment
@@CensorTube84 Trying so hard to miss the point
@@atanaZion I’m just wondering what tf rap music has to do with zombie movies/shows. It’s not a good show..it’s generic and has a total of 3 mins worth of “zombies “.
@@CensorTube84 Tlou plot has always been generic, tho, it is literally what the The Walking Drad game did earlt agos, but with action gameplay
The series is based on the lore, that's why shooting zombies is pratically irrelevant
That acting is incredible. -C
Exactly, both should earned Oscars for best performances
Kid named finger
THE CHICANERY WILL NEVER END!!!
WALTUH…. PUT YA DIC AWAA WALTUH
@@lukekiely2450 Abbeh Put your club away abbeh. I'm not playing golf with you right now, Abbeh.
Bruh
Kid maimed finger
I wish the actor delivered the same inflection as David from the video game. It would've added some power to these scenes.
still great. they’re separate entities. show does better in some ways and vice versa. not worth complaining. this season was a gift.
@@jackchase6461 stop dismissing their criticisms so quickly, it's their opinion
3:59 oh my golly gosh he used the big bad c word
The fact that he wasn’t nominated for an Emmy or a golden globe is a travesty
That was so badass
Spot on everything was just like the game I just wanna see Riley too
She’s in episode 7!
You know what I see when I look at you
I don't know a sandwich a pork ribeye
We need Jesse Pinkman here
He’s always good at escaping hostage situations
Oh my god, no matter where I go I cannot escape the breaking bad fans. They are the real contro fungus whatever thing
Beeeeeeeraaaaaaachhhhh
Ah, cannibals in a zombie apocalypse, how Ironic
Uhm give Bella Ramsey a damn award!!!!
This episode was one of my favorites! There was just so much emotion at play, and as someone who never cries to a show or movie, this episode really got me
@@roopkd this episode was my favorite out of the nine.
i reaaaaaaally wish they didn’t take out that when ellie kills david joel finds her bc in the show she just walks out of the thing and he has no clue what happened, in the game it was a moment of bonding and everything
Ladies and gentlemen, ✨HER✨
this character has more depth and must be more fun for her to portray than when she played greta thurnberg in game of thrones
Even a half decent outdoors man could keep people fed.
Lol whatever 😂
@@vjc25 He's not wrong. Food is literally everywhere, if you don't require a neon sign to see it.
Yeah biggest plothole bcuz after a pandemic animals would be thriving
Right?? Especially because Ellie is not an experienced hunter and she took down a deer in that area like it was nothing.
Exactly!
They say that opposites attract, the fact he says that he see's her in him says that he's nothing but ego centrical and has no depth for another half of him. (maybe looking for a prodigy like the emperor Palpatine)
her acting. My god, one for milion.
Well she did get an Emmy nomination for this episode.
I wonder if Ellie was playing grounded mode
100%
You’d be able to tell it’s deer meat, it has a distinct flavor XD
Its a big, empty world with canned goods, animals to hunt and gardens that have gone wild. So he eats people.
at 0:39 she kicks the plates away then at 0:54 the plates are still there near the gate?!
Oh yeah what the hell xD
Continuity error
Maybe the plate love hers leg😅
OH NO😭
lmao yeah
"You're an Animal"
"Well yes we all are that's sort of the point"
Me: Ah yes we're all an Animals🐾 we can eat whatever what we want🍴🍖
It made me chuckle, just cuz we’re animals doesn’t mean we’re supposed to eating our own kind 😂
I wasn’t even mad when Ellie cut and chopped Davyreal good.
This scene was absolutely and positivity constructed perfectly from the very beginning to the end 😍😎👍💯 as it made me full of anxiety and adrenaline as it kept me on the edge of my seat.😱😰
The extra number of chops in the TV adaptation is totally earned given how he’s even more vile in than in the video game.
Video game David is sickening and cruel, yes, but TV David has you wondering how far reaching his monstrosity has been in the past. With game David you’re glad it’s over. With TV David you almost want to climb into the screen and take over chopping duties once Ellie’s done hacking away at him. Really goes to show:
The Infected are amoral entities. They are a disease, a natural disaster.
David? Now that’s what evil looks like.
No zombies or infection needed, this dark future will happen after an EMP or Solar Flare takes out the power grid.
true
So glad I'm not a girl.
I mean if i were staved and the other person was dead i might do it
I don’t know why but his voice and cadence remind me of an adult in South Park
4:17 I wonder where did she learn such language
A modest amount of attention to the story shows where she learned such language.
13 years old people swear
The actor that played David is such a good actor
Got this on dvd watched it twice
It's good they brought back The Walking Dead for a 12th season.
...
She shouldve played along to get out of the cage and then run away later
Nah, the ending was way more powerful the way it played out
I still think they did this part kinda better than the game imo
bella is a exelent actress wow
Amazing performance by Bella Ramsey when she shouted I BROKE YOUR FINGER!! i thought Wow 😮
I would rather die then turn to cannibalism
okay. do you mind if i nibble on you, after you're dead? you won't feel anything.
I can't believe the actress who plays Ellie is 20 years old. She looks 13
to be fair Bella was 17 when they filmed season 1
In the tv show I can't recall David eating what the others were eating? Makes sense he'd be eating the little food there was and the others....
That's actually very true but I don't think the writers know cannibals bones are 30 x weaker than the average person
I’ve broken someone’s finger. You just bend hard and fast in any direction except the right one. You aren’t snapping bone, you’re dislocating joints. It really does not take much.
25 years later we are still friends and now he knows when it’s about to rain. Life is funny like that.
I liked how this dude did David. Not too bad. He should've done it more southern tho😂
... why was there a random ear just lying around? 🤨
Choppy choppy
@user-ub6gh9km4d But surely they wouldn't be dumb enough to leave it lying around for their prisoners to see right? 🤔
@@solidsnake9898 idk, A he's a pedo B he's weird C. He's dumb
This is more dark than the game itself wdf
Great actor was in true detective s3 and scorcese new film he plays a bad guy well
Nice one ellie!
dont get me wrong i love David in the show but i prefer him in the game because they make him look like a normal person whos just trying to survive , you
never knew if he was with you or against you
Jesus above... I need to watch this show!
What show is this?
The last of us
Dexter
They couldn’t have made the clothes more worn in and dirty?
I liked ot better in the game where they she sees them preparing an entire body. But oh well.
Psycho, cannibal and pedo
She ended him for good
I completely forgot about this show.
3:47
This is not ellie how is she
You forgot....IT LOVE'S 🖤
The game characters are much more convincing than this acting. In the game David’s voice actor used meaningful pauses that are indispensable, for example: “How did you put it? [pause] Tiny piece? [pause] See you in the morning, Ellie.” And, combined with David’s mild-mannered appearance and the evil look in his eyes, it produced a really strong effect. The HBO David speaks casually and fast, ruining the eerie effect. And Ellie, well, she just yells.
I think Ellie here delivered, but I do agree with you here on David.
I found David much more creppy on the show.
The voice actor for David in the game is the same voice actor who plays Nathan drake in uncharted. He’s also the same voice actor who voices superboy from young justice
No I disagree. I found the game version a little caricatured. Very 'gamey' if you know what I mean. Show-David just felt more real, like he's a monster who you could see actually existing in real life.
Game David was more generic evil psycho, the show one is more realistic. In the game it’s like he wanted to eat people, but in the show it’s better since they make it like he doesn’t want to but did it for the others. Show did it better this time.
HEYY YOU GUYSSSS
4:13
I need to get my heart rate down.
0:08-0:11 :D
watching this scene isolated shows how kinda bad it is, weird take but
Jehovah God Lord Jesus Christ always is good to us He died for our sins and rose from the dead He cares for us and is with us no matter what you did or do He always loves us He has open arm always ✝️❤️
I love Ellie
wow.
There are plenty of animals or fish out there. Why did they become cannibals? Guess they just picked the easiest way
I think it was winter and they couldn't find any food. Rivers were frozen, game was scarce. I really doubt they resorted to being cannibals when there were deer and rabbits wandering outside their houses
@@rainbow_doglover8301 yes, you're right about rivers, but there are still animals. Don't know why they couldn't find them. Because even Ellie killed a deer and rabbit before meeting them
Nolan North played David in the game and he should have played David in the TV series he was much better than this guy Nolan scared the hell out of me
F*ck off. Just play the f*cking game if want the same damn thing.
I just thought he was a nonce lmao
I was thinking with the cannibalism this guy had ancestors in the royal navy.
how scary is she🤢
the game scene was way better
She looks JUST LIKE ASHLEY JOHNSON in the thumbnail!!! It's crazy! Ashley is her voice in the game
I'm still having difficulty with this show
Same its overrated
@@davidlima9461mid opinion
I was so scared when she put her hand down, and then i realized she’s 🏳️🌈… still, he’s gross…
I really like David. He is honest to Ellie .
Poor casting …