วีดีโอ

Uh that's a very good theory 👌

I think this is pretty absurd theory-crafting honestly. Making up a story about Daenerys being a Blackfire in order to discredit her ultimately does nothing but further delegitimize the Blackfire name and claim, which is the whole point of the Blackfire rebellion(s) in the first place: to make themselves legitimate.

Hasn’t grrm confirmed that bran will be king when all the dust settles like in the show

Here's the logic hole. If Dorn is so good at hiding people and has Dany in their custody, how and why would Doran Martell lose her to Illyrio in the first place?

Didn’t Jorah see a large shadow fly over the ship where they encountered the people with greyscale

It seems like the quote ending in "Brandon Stark could taste the blood" isn't referring to Bran, all the other parts of the story around it all refer to him as Bran not Brandon Stark. Skinchanging into past greenseers sort of thing.

Interesting how light and life are paired together, shadow presumably being paired with, in George's own words, 'another type of life' or something like that i.e. the shadows and the others. The life of the shadows are just that, a shadow of the being who is being illuminated by the light of life

You don't need all five fingers for knitting. Come on, this is ridiculous. You only need three. You lead the needle with two fingers and the thumb, you don't play the piano.

I think Dany and Viserys were meant to be distractions for Aegon. Robert and his court knew they were still alive so he'd have his eyes out for Targaryen survivors. If Dany was actively in hiding and Aegon was revealed as alive before they were ready, he'd be a much more credible threat as the 'son of Rhaegar' (whether or not he actually is). Dany and Viserys are essentially a smokescreen for Aegon, and a potential marriage pact should Aegon and Dany survive. It also explains why Dany and Viserys weren't really raised in the same way as Aegon. Sure they were housed and fed, but Viserys arrogant and vicious nature shows Illyrio probably wasn't a father figure for them. This would make sense if they weren't really supposed to survive, and just serve to keep eyes off Aegon.

GRRM Definitely did not have a character named "young griff" in mind when he wrote AGOT. Stop kidding yourselves

I just suposed it melts in summer and snows compact into ice during winter. Like glaciers, just vertical

It’s like poetry, it rhymes with

This seems like you came up with a theory then went looking for evidence that supports it, rather than looking at the evidence and drawing conclusions.

I don't think it's coming this year mate, I think you should just move on. Anyone reading this in 2025, please comment so that I can admit I was wrong or say I told you so.

WHY ARE YOU YELLING AT ME LIKE WE ARE ARGUING...i get it man, chill out and move to the next point. stop repeating yourself, stop increasing your volume& tone.

In the vast majority of places people didn't agree to or adopt feudalism at all, family. They were outgunned, pure and simple. The royalty and aristocracy may have, but most didn't. Especially in the beginning.

I wonder if this means the Others are essentially warging the wights.

In the Theon sample chapter the two ravens in the cage are very obviously warged (by Bran and Bloodraven most likely) and able to speak so the Wall doesn't seem to be an obstacle “Yet,” both ravens screamed in unison. Then one quorked, and the other muttered, “Tree, tree, tree.”

The Weirwood trees are basically wireless routers that are connected to the Weirwood network. Allowing for wired connection between the trees and wireless connection to the animals, people, and possibly even the dragons.

If what happens in the books doesn’t happen I’m gonna be mad

Bran knew that they were eating the Nights Watch deserters, he was not innocent of that "Meera turned the meat to cook the other side. Hodor was chewing and swallowing, muttering happily under his breath. **Only Jojen seemed aware of what was happening** as Coldhands turned his head to stare at Bran. “They were foes.”

"I pissed of the king, so now I piss off the edge of the world" just as GRRM intented.

Honestly I side less and less with George as time goes by, if he had a regular day to day job I think he would be an insufferable coworker getting little to nothing done always distracted… but seriously he signed off on these shows being made, if he can’t trust show makers with his story don’t do it. The whole IP took a huge hit with the last season because he gave someone else creative control over his story. I don’t feel bad if he is making the same mistake with making two new tv shows based on the first half of Targaryen rule and three short stories. Finish something George

The phrase "long in the dying" appears early on in the first book, A Game of Thrones. It's said in reference to Bran while he lies in a coma. So, if the show writer intentionally borrowed this phrase from the book, you can expect that they are simply setting up what actually happens in Fire and Blood.

From looking at how wights burst so easily into flame despite being frozen corpses and how brightly human sacrifices burn, souls appear to be inherently flammable. This suggests that wildfire itself might be magical in nature and might actually be made from distilled souls, providing the sacrifice in and of itself. With the link between Melisandre and Aerion, is it possible that Melisandre was a slave in Valyria prior to the Doom? It would be strange if worship of the Lord of Light never reached the fire-obsessed Valyrians, even if it was only practiced by the slaves.

I believe both the heart of winter and the heart of summer have been corrupted. If the heart of summer had been restored, the Doom would not still reign in Valyria. I don't think that hearts of winter/summer need restoration, I think they must be destroyed and replaced with a different system.

Na, this theory doesn't sound as plausible as the other ones.

I think most of this theory is spot on, but I have a pretty hard time seeing leaf=nettles. The children of the forest hated fire magic so much, they likely were involved in killing Valyria. The hammer of the waters breaking the arm of dorne earth shattering magic and the doom of Valyria back to back mass eruptions magic seems pretty darn similar. While yes the ghost of high heart was present for Summerhall, it seems she likely helped sabotaged it if anything given fire magic is associated with Rhylor, whereas wierwood death magic is associated with the faceless god

I’m liking the direction you are taking but I have a couple questions. If this process creates the Others, why do it then? Also why is Blood Raven trying to stop it? From all implications he is being controlled by the children or this hive mind however you want to interpret it. If the Undying are the shadow bound form of these people stuck in the wall, are they also manifesting as the Others?

I think the whisper was blood raven in HOTD. Bran doesn't care enough personally about that situation to blurt out "traitor"

What about the broken moon?

HOLY SHIT Melisandre has Davos's finger bones. She stole them before the Blackwater and replaced them with stones. That's why he lost his sons, because she took his luck. Basically Davos is going to come back from Skagos and start hearing about how he did some heinous shit that he didn't actually do.

The toxic butterflies are a red herring. HotD will differ from the book when Melania, blade of Miquella blooms for a third time in westeros for some reason

She suckered me in with talk of Ice Spiders.... they never came!

acording to what he posted it will be like 4/5 years ,. He want to make few seasons of his two projects now first.

Awesome work on the investigation and very interesting deduction! 😮

Just starting the video but Abraham comes to mind.

Dire Wolves-ok it's wierd though because of the Le Brea tar pits? Maybe I AM crazy BUT! The 'oily black stone'? Dire Wolves? There is also Northern Lights? What world is THIS really? Also though for Winterfell? It isn't just Winterfell being warmed by whatever runs through those walls Cat is talking about. There are springs and pools that are warm as well...and the waters tend to be black. You know what else is steaming hot and black/oily? Mel's blood..not just hers either. IF a dragon flew out from under Winterfell? It came OUT of the pool by the Heart Tree in the Godswood there, see? JUST like Osha bursting out when Bran sees her AND she talks about dragons to Bran. And if it is hiding? It is hiding in the Vale. That Tourney Baelish and Sansa are planning...hmmm. You know what else I just thought of? The 'healing waters' of Maiden Pool. I wonder what color that water is currently?

Really fits with the idea that Westeros is post-apocalypse. You should talk about that in a future video.

Will you talk about the fused stone walls at Storm's End?

1. Arya gets the courage to leave Harrenhal because the Weirwood speaks to her as Ned 2. Brienne it prompted to take out Oathkeeper because of a Weirwood at that abandoned castle by the sea which saves her life fighting the Brave Companions 3. Theon gets the courage to help (f)Arya escape Winterfell because the tree calls him Theon Probably are other examples I missed but there is direct communication with people

I see it as creation, conflict, end times. Iron like the swords in the crypts, bronze like the crowns the kings of winter wear to war.

This makes a surprising amount of sense. I have to wonder what an alternate reality looks like where the books came out in a more timely manner - I feel like in some ways the fandom has flourished because we've had so much time to comb through every detail of the story, leading to theories like these

Is it me or did they not make Sunfyre as beautiful as he is supposed to be? Also I cant help but feel like Syrax was made to look more appealing while also having more screen time as part of the huge Rheanyra bias. Syrax is supposed to be yellow but looks gold with dark red accents while Sunfyre looks dull, like a faux gold and his pink accents are almost non existent. When i look at him I ended up thinking why does Syrax look better?

Well now we know that visions of danearys bringing back the dragons was prophesied, so she is sorta like a prophetic incubator needed to bring back the dragons

Stay with me, magnets. If the trees are fed blood, then when they circulate that blood through the tree it might create a magnetic field because there is "iron in the blood". This is what disrupts warging type abilities. Magnets.

Long and short of it, in Game of Thrones Joffery said Rhaenyra was killed by her brother's dragon - I know this could be Vhagar but i do believe it'll be Sunfyre

naw he is not Joffrey said so in the future

He’s not dead. Pointless video

The Dragon has three head. Dany, Jon, and fAegon.