18:31 That's it ? Is that all you have to say about magic being a genetic trait ? Nothing about what it implies or the impact it has on the story ? I mean, at the very least, it brings some perspective to the whole muggle sympathizers/blood-purist conflict. Suddenly it's not all black and white. The good guys are kind of in the wrong cause it turns out that blood, and bloodlines are important, but the bad guys are kinda right even if for all the wrong reasons. You could have gone into more detail about how in their search for "blood purity" wizard society became inbred, wich we know tends to lead to all sorts of malformations, notably squibs, who tend to settle outside of magical society (just like Ms. Figg Harry's neighbor). Generations down the line, two squib descendents meet, fall in love, and have a magical baby. Wich would also mean that muggleborns are a myth btw
I don't think this can be considered 50 series because well about half of the list is repeated so it might be more like 25 theories because well the other 25 are repeated from the first ones
Dumbledore could "see" what the boys were up to because he was on the Chocolate Frog cards. Just like the portraits of headmasters could move to any other portraits of themselves, Dumbledore could visit any of his Chocolate Frog cards. When he was stripped of all his titles, he even said it's ok as long as they don't take him off the cards. When Harry got his Dumbledore card, Ron explained that you can't expect him to hang around all day!
Wouldn’t ron’s frog card just allow dumblodore to see the inside of ron’s trunk, his room and maybe inside’s of his pocket if he carries one of the six dumbledore cards he owns?
You know they’re not actually IN the painting right? The painting is just a snapshot and representation of the witch or wizard in that moment not to mention it’s more likely it’s a photograph on the chocolate frogs than a painted magical photo right?
*Another theory:* Mr and Mrs Evans loved and preferred James Potter (who they found amusing and charming) a lot more than they did Vernon Dursley, and this only exacerbated Petunia's resentment and jealousy of her sister Lily even more. What are your thoughts on that?
@@matthewmeyer4422 Nowhere is it stated that Lily's parents were killed by Voldemort. It is entirely likely that the Evans' would like James better than Vernon, as Vernon had a rather nasty bigoted attitude toward wizards, and they were proud to have a witch in the family, indicating they liked the wizarding world. Also, Rowling has stated that Vernon and James met each other during a double date and that it didn't go well. So, no....the Potters were not dead by the time Vernon came along. Other than that, I'm not really sure your sentence makes sense.
I can agree with it. I think magic aside, Vernon and Petunia were simply unlikable. Even when they were acting as “gracious hosts” they were pompous and irritating. James and Lily were lovable, fun people. Even if we can’t find definitive proof I can stand with this one
I actually love the idea that Lily accidentally put her parents in the line of fire by joining the Order of the Phoenix, because it MASSIVELY enhances Petunia as a character. Petunia's cruelty of Harry initially seems to be from jealousy of Lily. Petunia never got to go to Hogwarts. She was the disappointment of the family. That understandably creates resentment, but makes her cruelty of Harry seem insanely petty. And yes, I know many people are that petty, but Uncle Vernon already serves that role. But perhaps Petunia's true hatred of Lily is actually because she believes Lily got their parents murdered by death eaters. Harry isn't just Lily's son. He's a daily reminder of everything wrong with Lily; both her mistakes and magical blood. If Lily had just been born normal, their family would have survived and been truly happy. Additionally, every time Petunia looks at Harry, she's reminded that one day, death eaters may come again, for her, her husband and her son. By putting Harry on her doorstep, Dumbledore placed the exact same target on Petunia's back that Lily placed on her parents. No wonder she hates raising him. And so it makes even more sense that Petunia's only kind moment is when her nightmare becomes real. There's no point hating Harry anymore for what he may or may not cause. It's happening.
on the limbo at kingscross, I thought everyone knew it was voldemort, its the exact same thing that was dropped in the cauldron in the graveyard, in goblet of fire
I want to point out that trelawney did say some prejudiced things about Firenze, but so did he and the centaurs were incredibly prejudiced towards humans and seers. I think that it was mostly a difference in opinion, because centaurs used the cosmos to predict the future and seers seemed to have more of a psychic inclination, and that difference in opinion caused them to be against eachother since they had to share divination and each thought the others methods were bunk.
@@jacksonmcnuggets7488to be entirely fair there were legitimately good seers and many of her predictions, even ones she consciously seemed to make up on the spot, ended up being true 🤷♀️ . At the introduction of her character I felt she was a lush phony but now I see her as someone just very insecure snd who’s ego got in the way of her actual talent.
I love the Snape code theory so much, if you look closely in the film, before Snape starts his code, he pretty much makes fun of harry because knows nothing of the Wizarding world. What's funny is that Snape thought he wasn't paying attention, so ij the film when Snape walks up to Harry, he looks down and sees the notes, evident that Harry WAS infact paying attention, that's when Snape starts the code, and it makes sense, after calling him out, and realizing that he actually wanted to be a charised and hard working wizard to learn his culture, he then says the code, which is essentially I'm sorry, for you and your mother, then he says, let us begin
It adds the fact that Hermione always knows about something in class but this time Emma Watson portrayed her with an expression as if what Snape said made no sense, as if it was not a real potion but something else
What about this theory? In the book Tale of Three Brothers, the veil represents Death and the bridge (referenced in the book) refers to the pathway between Life and Death. The three brothers create the hallows to safely use beyond the veil - the invisibility cloak will let the user to safely pass through the veil and navigate whatever is beyond the veil, the elder wand is the only wand powerful enough to use on the other side of the veil, and the resurrection stone is the only way to safely recall the person who entered the veil, to be brought back to our world. The three brothers were very powerful Wizards who found a way to safely go beyond the veil and also use the Deathly Hallows in our world as well.
I have a theory: Draco actually knew he was the owner of the Elder Wand after he disarmed Dumbledore. The reason he didn’t take it or was open about it, was because he knew that Voldemort would’ve killed him and his family for it. Draco grew up in a magical family that dated back for centuries, and his house was full of magical relics and history, surely he would’ve known about the Deathly Hallows and how the Elder Wand worked.
Many people thought it was a fairytale, or a myth if they happened to learn about the wand from other source than deathly hollows tale; just look how xenophilius lovegood was treated like a weirdo for it, and many people didn’t know what the symbol means, like krum saying it was grindelwald’s symbol. Unless malfoys themselves believed in the wand’s existence, i highly doubt someone like draco would spend time analysing how a mythical wand works edit: good theory tho
About Harry making just the Dursleys mad by being a horcrux. Could it not be that it built up in them over time from the best part of 10 years of constant exposure. The breaks between school terms could mean that the effects of the horcrux are lessened within his magic friends. Moreover, the times during school in which the Durlseys aren't exposed could also lessen the effects, but takes much longer due to the amount of exposure. This could explain why Dudley shows remorse towards Harry when they leave him (in Order? in a deleted scene?)
Dramatic effects of the locket Horcrux is better explained with proximity of TWO horcrux in overlapping same area of effects. First Movie Opening Scene: McGonagall: "Albus, do you really think its safe, leaving him with these people? I've been watching them all day. They're the worst sort of Muggles imaginable. They really are" Trusting McGonagall accuracy. Worst sort of Muggles imaginable before exposure to Harry. Unless they were already exposed to a Horcrux that was never mentioned, I would call single Horcrux exposure unlikely cause of Dursleys being the worst sort of Muggles imaginable.
@@brentnakamura2488 Also, if each is half of what the "main soul" was at the time... Harry's scar is among the smallest. The Diary was biggest, being the first-- and its affect on Ginny was enormous. We see some with the locket, while the others tend to get destroyed before causing much anything..
Anyone notice that Uncle Vernon hoped that Harry would get the death penalty in Order of the Phoenix. There's an argument that the Dementor's Kiss is a form of death penalty in the wizarding world. So the fact that Harry saved Dudley from a dementor attack, Uncle Vernon was hoping his son would get the wizarding death penalty too. Both penalties are equal in my view, you lose your soul with the Kiss, so you might as well be dead.
yes im pretty sure they hated harry so much was bc of his parrents/(someone had a theorey that the evans couple loved james more that vernon so that created Jealousy and bc harry lookes like james he can relive or remember the way james was more loved and he had so much hatred so yeah
@caseycopeland626 Dobby too. He had no choice until Hairy gave him his sock and freed him by engineering his sock into the Horcrux Lucius Malfoy passed to Dobby. Dobby was sweet and loved Hairy just as Hedwig did.
Useless isn’t accurate. People die that’s a true fact of life. Anyone of your friends and family will die all your pets will die. Death isn’t useless and they were not helpless they made their choices knowing full well they could die. But their death was needed so Harry could live. It is the greatest act of love one can commit. That’s why we all loved snape in the end because everything he did was mostly out of love. Even with Draco he killed dumbledore so that Draco can live he knew that the elder wand would transfer to Draco but wanted to make sure Voldemort didn’t know that. Like it blows my mind how much love some of these characters show that’s so misunderstood by everyone else I try to talk to about these subjects.
As a twin Fred & George got me the most, I was so upset I put the book down and didn’t pick it up for awhile, hoping that maybe he wasn’t actually dead and was gunna be ok like healed or faking it for a laugh like before like with the holey joke idk. Still upset about it especially cause they were so close doing everything together I can’t imagine em going on without each other. I hate the post saying how he wouldn’t be able to look in the mirror after he died cause he’d see him or how if he looked in the mirror what he’d see would seem like it was just him but was cause it was actually his twin 😭😭😭
Here are some shocking facts about the Potters deaths: *- Multiple people were responsible for it:* Voldemort for obviously doing the job, Peter for betraying the Potters by giving away their location to Voldemort, and Snape for telling Voldemort the prophecy which caused him to go after and kill the Potters. *- It all could have been easily avoided:* if Snape had never told Voldemort about the prophecy in the first place, if the Potters had accept Dumbledore's request to be their secret keeper, if Sirius (who was the initial secret keeper) hadn't convinced the Potters to switch their secret keeper to Peter, if the Potters had not agreed with Sirius's idea to make Peter their secret keeper, or if Peter hadn't given up the Potters location. *- Most shockingly of all,* still bitter over his past treatment of Snape, the fans took it out on one man (James Potter). Tell me what you think of all this!
The fact that Hermione is so gifted has very much to do with her being muggle-born. She's not the first muggle-born to be a top student either. I think it has to do with the fact that a muggle-born wouldn't take magic for granted like kids of all-magic families.
On Lily and Petunia's parents' death, the "normal Muggle death" could've been seemingly normal but also involved foul play- perhaps the Death Eaters caused a fatal car accident? That could even be where the lie the Dursleys told Harry about his parents came from
Well if a muggle was hit with the killing curse it would just look like they died in their sleep or had a heart attack, although both of them dying at the same time would be suspicious
Remember the guy I think frank from riddles manor? And the other muggers found dead assumed even after autopsy to be a heart attack? Sorry been about 3 full years since I've read the full series
Timestamp 40:30 😂 let me just say you made my day. I had to rewind it six times to make sure that audio was actually in the video and not just playing in my head. Give your editing team a raise!
Rowling has addressed the Dursley behavior being due to the "horcrux" in Harry. She said simply that the Dursleys were just mean and there was no relationship between the two.
You’re not wrong she never acts out to all centaurs ya she was rude to him and it was bad but you wanna talk about someone being prejudice then they need to look at umbridge
I don’t even know if this guy read the books cause one of the first ones about hedwig he said what happened in the movie and didn’t even mention what actually happened
The Imagination theory: Year1: Harry finds a nice stone. Year2: Harry kills a snake. Year3: Harry sees a black shaggy dog. Year4: Harry gets a new cup. Year5: Harry reads a book. Year6: Harry's favorite neighbor dies, old mr. Dumbledore. Year7: Harry runs away.
Do we know where Godric’s Hollow is? In Philosopher’s Stone Hagrid mentions Harry falling asleep while flying over Bristol in the first chapter. Given that he’s arriving in Surrey, would that put it somewhere in South Wales?
Something I’ve been thinking about is the Dursleys has had Harry since he was a baby. They had to potty train him, teach him to walk, teach him to talk, deal with potential colicky issues, bathe him, change his diapers, deal with teething, or give him bottles bc I HIGHLY doubt Petunia was nursing Harry. But it just makes me think about how magical Harry was compared to Dudley and are overcompensating with gifts and have another layer of resentment towards him bc they had to “train” him. But it always makes me feel bad bc what did they do to baby Harry vs 10 year old Harry?
The Draco is a werewolf theory is a lot more in depth than mentioned here - there's a pretty good super carlin brothers video on it for anyone who CBA reading this comment, but here's the evidence: - the mark on Draco's arm, though confirmed to be present, is never confirmed to be a dark mark - when he shows the mark to borgin, he specifically threatens borgin with greyback and borgin believes malfoy knows and has sway with greyback without question after seeing the mark. - at the top of the tower the night dumbledore died, the death eaters put up a magical barrier that only bearers of the dark mark could pass through. The barrier goes up after Draco gets to the top of the tower and is taken down before Draco leaves the tower. Why would the death eaters stop to remove it if they all had dark marks? - at the beginning of deathly hallows, Voldemort taunts the malfoys about their cousin, tonks, marrying Remus. He says to Draco "will you babysit the cubs?" Which is a very specific and odd taunt. - throughout book 6 Draco is described as sickly, pale, skinny, dark circles under his eyes, regularly disappearing - same descriptions and odd circumstances as lupin in book 3. Obv he is disappearing to work on the vanishing cabinet, but that might not be the only reason. - Also in 6, dumbledore expresses surprise that Draco would invite greyback to hogwarts where his friends live. Draco refuses to make eye contact with greyback and says he didn't know he'd be coming, seems extremely upset to be near him. - narcissa specifically seeks out Snape to help Draco in the sixth year, Snape is known to be capable of brewing wolfsbane potion which in 3 lupin says not many can do reliably. Maybe she knew Draco needed Snape's potions skills from that year on. JK said this theory is untrue, but it's one of my head canons. I think though most, if not all, of this evidence is circumstantial there's more than enough here to be plausible.
@@JDF1996 all of my arguments are based off the book. But you're right, in the films he does show one. There are a lot of plot differences between books and films, like how in GoF in the book it's actually Dobby who gives Harry the gillyweed, not Neville. And in HBP, the burrow is never burned down. That's only in the films. One of my favourite moments from OotP is a film only scene, when Sirius yells "nice one, James" to Harry when they are fighting death eaters together in the ministry. Doesn't happen in the book but it's a brilliant moment. GoF basically changes genre entirely from a murder mystery whodunnit (book) to an action suspense (film) because the film reveals Barry crouch jr way at the beginning and the book doesn't reveal him until after the third task/graveyard when Harry returns to the school. In the book Karkaroff, Maxime, Crouch SR and Ludo Bagman (a book only character) are all red herrings for who put Harry's name in the goblet but in the film you just know from the start that moody isn't moody because of that dumb tongue flicking thing they had him do. But yeah the werewolf theory does not hold up in the world of the movies, only the books. A lot of fan theories apply only to one or the other because there are so many differences.
@@MinorMutiny This makes a lot of sense. I’ve read the books a few times but I much prefer the films, purely for the visuals🤩, so those are what stick in my head. I can see how the book being more vague about his disappearances and the lack of a mark would make this plausible… I also love that scene with Sirius in the ministry! I like to think he realised at the last moment as he fell into the vail… hence the slightly vacant look 💔
@@JDF1996 the film visuals are pretty spectacular. I've just listened to the audio books more times than I'd admit lol. That Sirius moment is heartbreaking for sure. That paired with Molly telling him "he's not James" when they argue at the beginning of the book 💔
@@MinorMutiny Book or film both are tragic. Honestly… I’m at the point where I (M28) can’t watch the films without crying… I miss Alan and Robbie so damn much. I recently rewatched them (as I do almost every year 😅) and actually I wailed at the end of philosophers stone when Hagrid says “Though I’d let you leave without saying goodbye” 💔😭
9:46 - 9:50 "wormwood means absence." In real life, wormwood is used in Absinthe, which is what I thought our esteemed host of this video said at first. I wonder if someone trained in knotting up loose threads can make an end out of something such as this.
Does Mrs Norris really have to be Filch's wife for him to take her 'death' but really petrification badly, and not just care about her because she's his cat and deserves for him to care about her?!
This makes me sob bc my Henchmaniacs and me theorized that Mrs Norris was Filch’s wife turned into a cat when we were younger- you called younger me out-
Thank you for the warning about the varying audio levels. It always trips me out when it changes unexpectedly. Check my phone volume or check for a notification on my phone. First world problem now that I say it out loud lol
This is my beef. Ron turned his back on Harry during Goblet of Fire and refused to believe Harry when he tells Ron that he didn't put his name in the cup.
Jealousy. Teenage hormones. Wanting to impress Hermione. Wanting to be seen. Im a guy, it doesnt surprise me. Nor so that Ron comes back everytime to have his brother back.
@@rickardrakkoon2500 There’s several examples of Ron behaving like this… He was jealous when Harry made seeker. He was adamant Sirius was a psycho killer/ not to be trusted. He valued A RAT over the word of his friend. He dined Voldemorts return (initially) And he turned on Harry rather quickly when wearing the locket… Just to name a few. Before you blame the horcrux… I believe they worked sort of like a bogart, amplifying a persons fears. Yes it made them all aggressive but it affected Ron worse. At the time, Harry probably feared the trials to come and hermioney likely feared she’d never return to her family… Ron’s biggest fear was losing her, hence his reaction (almost killing Harry with the sword of griffondor). Non of this means he was a bad friend, he was still extremely loyal and brave (when it counted)
I would love to see Dudley have a child or grandchild that is magical. If Petunia is still alive, would be interesting to know how she would react, because the child is from her baby boy.
Here's the theory I came up with: The events of the series never actually happened. It was all being watched by Tom Riddle in his prophecy and the entire thing was shown as what would happen if he went down the darker path.
Dude, your voice is so relaxing. I went back to sleep this late morning playing your latest upload on the HP Tv series, and ended up napping through this entire compilation, which automatically played next. Haha Thank you! 💙🤍🛌 😌😴
32:00 Harry's muggle grandparents. I fully agree they were likely killed by death eaters but I'd go as far as to guess they were killed in a car crash caused by death eaters and that's where Petunia got her story about how Harry got his scar.
About the magic gene, it doesn't just appear out of nowhere ("muggle borns") nor disappears ( "squibs"). You need to have it in your genes. Hermione's mother probably had a great great grandparent who was a Wizard and married a muggle, then the magical gene went on, until she met Hermione's father, who certainly had a wizard great great grandparent. As both had the magical gene within their DNA, Hermione got it from both and was born a Witch. The same goes for Squibs. There must be at least a muggle in the bloodline. They are like two different species who are similar enough to produce offspring
Hermione does not say what the third thing she smells is, although Rowling revealed in an interview that the third smell was Ron's hair. However, in the film version, Hermione states that the third thing she smells is spearmint toothpaste, due to the fact that in an earlier scene at The Burrow where Ron points out to Hermione there is toothpaste on her face and her parents being dentists.
I think what people are missing with the theory that Dumbledore knew Sirius was innocent is that Sirius TRIED to kill Pettigrew in public. There were DOZENS of witnesses. And no one, except Sirius and Pettigrew, knew that Pettigrew and not Sirius ended up being the secret keeper. Sirius was also in Azkaban for Pettigrews apparent murder, not just for the Potters deaths. There isn't exactly much point of a trial for a "murder" that happened in full view of a streetful of people, not in the wizarding world anyway. Given that Dumbledore had no reason to think Pettigrew was still alive and didn't know he had been the one to betray Lilly and James, he would have no real reason to visit Sirius.
10:15 I hate this theory because it fails to take into account this was a pre-internet book. Like we expect this type of thing these days but I’m sorry if I call BS that a waitress raising her kids and writing this book in her spare time is going to get obscure botany books to make a hidden message for that scene. Especially with the pacing and planning shown in the early books. Like Rowling just isn’t that good of a writer, and I feel the bools would be very different if she was going that far to put in this type of planning.
I think Ron is much nicer than James, sure he hasnt always been the smartest character but I cant imagine him bullying anyone. Personally I understand why Snape hated James and that he didnt care about what'd happen to him BUT I think he should've cared about what happens to an innocent child if he tells everything to Voldemort.
Btw I wonder if a dementor would've sucked out Harry's sould+the part of Voldemort's soul, what would've happened? Would the horcrux be destroyed? Would it be the opposite and after that it wouldnt be possible to destroy it at all?
@@kuuttinenListen, if you hate how James is portrayed as a popular hero who is well liked by a lot of people (excluding Snape and the Dursley's), then you should blame JK Rowling for that. I don't care how much you hate the fact that James Potter is JK Rowling's "golden boy".
3:00 Hedwig's death was the stupidest thing ever! Honestly, She'd been sent ahead plenty of times before or sent her with a letter to someone he knew far away. Also, there was no need to take the cage he could have just left the cage and got a new one or sent someone back later to get it.
4:16 OH… Hedwig..Snape, I never thought about that….makes sense…especially if he wanted to keep up appearances…i can add to this a bit, other than it being obvious that his loyal pet would give him away, it brings Snapes skills in Legilimency to mind, had he been tuned into Hedwigs intentions and that’s how it seemed to be a “flawless” accident? is it possible for a wizard to do with an animal? Am I thinking too deep into this? (But it’s that the point to fan theorying? 😎)
Harry didn't snap the wand in two in the book but put it to rest with Dumbledore as was supposed to happen. Dumbledore is also human. The amount of evidence against Sirius was overwhelming.
I like the theory that the death eaters killed the Evans' because it gives more weight as to why Petunia hated Harry and everything to do with the magical world so strongly.
Harry and Ginny: read the books! Ginny always had feelings for Harry. And Harry spent the first half of sixth year fighting his jealousy towards her boyfriends and the conflict that she's his best friend's sister and therefore should be off limits. When he drinks Felix felicis accidentally makes Ginny and Dean fight and break up. Then he's in detention for the quidditch finale so Ginny takes his post as seeker and wins the cup for the team. They first kiss at the celebration party and are together since. Harry breaks up with her after Dumbledore's funeral to protect her. They resume their relationship after the battle of Hogwarts. Harry's feelings for Ginny grew slowly over half a school year, there was no need for Ginny to give him love potion. Especially as Harry maintained his feelings for her while being away on his mission, there's a scene when he goes to Voldemort under the cloak that he meets Ginny and wishes he could get together with her but then he decides it is more important to end the battle and sacrifice himself to save the others. That doesn't come from a love potion either.
all the theories abt snape and his love for lily really cuts deep i don't ship them but i love snape sm and if those theories are true then its just too sweet
I would like to know if you ever did a video over a theory on what happens to witches or wizards who are born mentally challenged. I'm not talking mentally ill as we see with Lord Voldy(he's clearly ill) but like with challenges. Is there a special school they are sent off to, are they killed, are their powers yanked from them some how? If you haven't I would like to hear your theory. I'm sure i'm not the only one who has thought of it.
Crabb and Goyle are evidently mentally defective. and Luna is clearly on the spectrum. i think its a matter of degrees. If they have enough focus and intellegence to train they get to be witches or wizards if not then they probably become obscurus and its off to saint mongos with them.
I don't think one's magical powers can be taken from them. It is explained in the books that magical powers cannot be stolen nor rid of if you don't want them anymore (remember Dumbledore's sister).
26:29 I love the subtle reference here, even with an appropriate scene! 😂 27:09 I know Cedric didn’t die because of Hogwarts technically but still… 28:55 mate knew what he was doing when he said that 💀 but it would be inaccurate if you considered the cursed child as canon 33:33 well if they did that it made it only harder for them to get Harry as he had to go with the Dursleys instead 35:21 yep, SIRIUS circumstances 37:00 MY POOR HONEY 😭😭😭😭😭🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤 37:19 ‘other death eaters’? I know they thought he was close to Voldemort but he was NOT a death eater! 40:23 this would be very unlikely, as then this would destroy the entire fan base 42:40 yep, very SIRIUS flaws 49:45 she said in the first book that she read about him in a book 1:08:52 they were awful people before they even received Harry, McGonagall confirmed this
Since I wrote the last five novels, Harry, Ginny, Ron, and Hermione died in their old age together, and had a reunion with all the important people in their lives.
Are we just not gonna talk about how Ron blatantly uses AT LEAST 3 unforgivable curses in the last two films… We hear him cast imperio in gringots And on (at least) 2 other occasions we see green come from his wand. I doubt he would use the killing curse but one of these occasions was in direct defence of hermioney, in the room of requirement, so it’s not hard to believe he would use crussio out of anger. Arthur Weasley also uses one during the battle of hogworts, as do many of our “heroes”. Edit: Also, who let Filch participate in that battle?!? Tf is he gonna do, like fr 🤣
1:07:47 “acted quite civil with other members of society”? Suggest you reread the beginning of Philosopher’s Stone, in which Vernon takes great pleasure in shouting at multiple people before lunch…
Dumbledore taking a 12-13 year old Hermione on a heist to the department of mysteries mind numbingly dumb of a theory. However, I do like the idea that Hermione might have stolen the Time Turner. It's said McGonagall was the one who gave it to her, so maybe the real truth is that for some reason McGonagall had one in her office, perhaps for private study, and Hermione passed through, saw it, recognised it from a book, and swiped it. And the reason McGonagall didn't notice it was missing is because Hermione would use the Time Turner to duplicate the Time Turner. Just as she was in multiple places at once, she would have one version of herself replace the Time Turner in McGonagall's office, perhaps even creating some form of time loop. It would all work so long as she had a justifiable reason to visit McGonagall's office once a day. Since McGonagall seemed to be personally managing Hermione to ensure she could actually handle the increased workload, Hermione could have dropped in for 5 minutes each day. McGonagall may have only noticed Hermione had the Time Turner once she heard that Hermione had physically been in two classes at the same time. Perhaps prior to that stage, she'd thought Hermione was just doing the coursework of extra subjects in her personal time, without a teacher's help, using the textbooks. She must have been utterly amazed Hermione was keeping up until she heard Hermione was actually present for classes she was enrolled in but not expected to actually attend. Then she probably sat Hermione down and waited for her little time loop to end, which likely would have involved the Time Turner on McGonagall's desk vanishing right in front of both of them (as it went back to the beginning of the loop, becoming the one on Hermione's person), and then for McGonagall to demand Hermione take it out of her pocket.
My theory is that all the different horcruxes had various different affects to them with the locket being the specific one to make people be more moody and irritable.
I don't think Dumbledore could have had Harry grow up knowing who he was. It would have gone to his head, it'd have to. Without the suffering and humility it engendered Harry couldn't have defeated no nose.
Also fun fact. On numbani, if you look in the reflections of the buildings, you can see the reflection maps of the PvE map. It's mostly just added boxes and force fields to zone areas. But it also has the addition where the map continues to the side of the airport
I honestly like the idea of Dudley marrying cho chang, or any other witch really, not only because of the potential character growth it implies, but also because I think the idea of a magical Dursley kid would be a fun and interesting story to explore.
Neither James or Lilly have black hair… Harry seems to share more traits with snape than those we know of James… This could have been as simple as James being infertile… Or as twisted as polyjuice… (I’ll leave that one to your imaginations) Edit: yes it could be a recessive gene… But this idea is more interesting Edit2: also, snape was there the night the potters died… implying he knew their location. So him and Lilly must’ve reconciled.
35:00 Why would Ginny go give Harry a love potion and then go have a makeout session with someone else? (Yes that was the moment Harry realized his feelings in the book.) Some try doing that to get someone jealous but with a love potion there's no reason to do so.
Hermione used to go on holiday with her parents for 2 weeks at the beginning of the summer then go to Rons. She also went home for Christmas and Easter.
The dursleys were exposed to a hurcrux a lot longer than anyone else in the story. They have no innate magical protection against the influence like the magical community would. And they don't go into detail about how he was treated as a baby (as far as i remember)
judging by birthdays alone, hermine's birthday is just 10 months before harrys, while technically possible, its ~315 days between their birth and a pregnancy is ~280 days, and you cant instantly get pregnant again from my understanding.
1) Dumbledore used a time turner to always precisely where needed the most and to explain off the deus ex machina contradicting the entire series of Ron being able to mimic parseltongue at the final battle. This implying that Dumbledore had studied the future to learn that the only way Voldemort could be killed was to use Harry as a sacrificial piece and puppet like he did, among many other things that had to go precisely as they did.
The theory of Ginny giving Harry a love potion isn't true because when Harry smells Amortensia, he smells Ginnys perfume. He smells a flowery scent that reminded him of the Burrow.
27:13 Didn't Cedric Diggory die while he was headmaster? I mean, he died far from school grounds so maybe that explains it but he certainly died while Dumbledore was headmaster.
I’ve thought being master of death was true since I read the book, I thought that was another reason for snapping the wand. The horcrux angle never even crossed my mind, and it doesn’t seem as solid. Why name the book after them and not the horcruxs if they weren’t finally brought together? What was the point? Voldemort was already powerful, he didn’t need a special wand to kill Harry unless J. K. had another reason for that storyline.
VERY Interesting and thought-provoking. As for the last theory: if close proximity to the horcrux caused the Dursley's to be nasty to Harry -- explain Aunt Marge.
MORE LONG VIDEOS: th-cam.com/play/PLB5djWCQq2_e0UCOmVbhRP8HkxetpzXUV.html
This is awesome
18:31 That's it ? Is that all you have to say about magic being a genetic trait ? Nothing about what it implies or the impact it has on the story ?
I mean, at the very least, it brings some perspective to the whole muggle sympathizers/blood-purist conflict. Suddenly it's not all black and white. The good guys are kind of in the wrong cause it turns out that blood, and bloodlines are important, but the bad guys are kinda right even if for all the wrong reasons.
You could have gone into more detail about how in their search for "blood purity" wizard society became inbred, wich we know tends to lead to all sorts of malformations, notably squibs, who tend to settle outside of magical society (just like Ms. Figg Harry's neighbor). Generations down the line, two squib descendents meet, fall in love, and have a magical baby. Wich would also mean that muggleborns are a myth btw
"long videos"
all videos are 20 minutes MAX
I don't think this can be considered 50 series because well about half of the list is repeated so it might be more like 25 theories because well the other 25 are repeated from the first ones
~27 minutes in 👉 A student did die while Dumbledore was Headmaster. CEDRIC DIGGORY
Dumbledore could "see" what the boys were up to because he was on the Chocolate Frog cards. Just like the portraits of headmasters could move to any other portraits of themselves, Dumbledore could visit any of his Chocolate Frog cards. When he was stripped of all his titles, he even said it's ok as long as they don't take him off the cards. When Harry got his Dumbledore card, Ron explained that you can't expect him to hang around all day!
Wouldn’t ron’s frog card just allow dumblodore to see the inside of ron’s trunk, his room and maybe inside’s of his pocket if he carries one of the six dumbledore cards he owns?
@@jeanv8249yes but he can probably hear him
Oh I love this theory
You know they’re not actually IN the painting right? The painting is just a snapshot and representation of the witch or wizard in that moment not to mention it’s more likely it’s a photograph on the chocolate frogs than a painted magical photo right?
@@bruhdon4748well dumbledore could have one of his own cards that reports back to him with news of their activities
*Another theory:* Mr and Mrs Evans loved and preferred James Potter (who they found amusing and charming) a lot more than they did Vernon Dursley, and this only exacerbated Petunia's resentment and jealousy of her sister Lily even more. What are your thoughts on that?
I agree
I feel they where dead long befor Vernon came into the picture, killing of course by valtamor
Now THIS idea has legs!! Though never hinted at by Rowling, this is quite possible.
@@matthewmeyer4422 Nowhere is it stated that Lily's parents were killed by Voldemort. It is entirely likely that the Evans' would like James better than Vernon, as Vernon had a rather nasty bigoted attitude toward wizards, and they were proud to have a witch in the family, indicating they liked the wizarding world.
Also, Rowling has stated that Vernon and James met each other during a double date and that it didn't go well. So, no....the Potters were not dead by the time Vernon came along.
Other than that, I'm not really sure your sentence makes sense.
I can agree with it. I think magic aside, Vernon and Petunia were simply unlikable. Even when they were acting as “gracious hosts” they were pompous and irritating. James and Lily were lovable, fun people. Even if we can’t find definitive proof I can stand with this one
I actually love the idea that Lily accidentally put her parents in the line of fire by joining the Order of the Phoenix, because it MASSIVELY enhances Petunia as a character. Petunia's cruelty of Harry initially seems to be from jealousy of Lily. Petunia never got to go to Hogwarts. She was the disappointment of the family.
That understandably creates resentment, but makes her cruelty of Harry seem insanely petty. And yes, I know many people are that petty, but Uncle Vernon already serves that role.
But perhaps Petunia's true hatred of Lily is actually because she believes Lily got their parents murdered by death eaters. Harry isn't just Lily's son. He's a daily reminder of everything wrong with Lily; both her mistakes and magical blood. If Lily had just been born normal, their family would have survived and been truly happy. Additionally, every time Petunia looks at Harry, she's reminded that one day, death eaters may come again, for her, her husband and her son. By putting Harry on her doorstep, Dumbledore placed the exact same target on Petunia's back that Lily placed on her parents. No wonder she hates raising him.
And so it makes even more sense that Petunia's only kind moment is when her nightmare becomes real. There's no point hating Harry anymore for what he may or may not cause. It's happening.
on the limbo at kingscross, I thought everyone knew it was voldemort, its the exact same thing that was dropped in the cauldron in the graveyard, in goblet of fire
Yh i saw that to
Also the fact dumbledore even said in the film that it was apart of voldemorts soul that latched on to harry when he killed lilly
@@christopherhine9154 at least someone was paying attention 🤣🤣
Also didnt Dumbledore littarly tell us?
Obviously.. it was piece of his soul..
I want to point out that trelawney did say some prejudiced things about Firenze, but so did he and the centaurs were incredibly prejudiced towards humans and seers. I think that it was mostly a difference in opinion, because centaurs used the cosmos to predict the future and seers seemed to have more of a psychic inclination, and that difference in opinion caused them to be against eachother since they had to share divination and each thought the others methods were bunk.
She was also wasted the entire time on large amounts of Sherry. People can be mean when drunk.
Scientists va pseudoscience
@@jacksonmcnuggets7488to be entirely fair there were legitimately good seers and many of her predictions, even ones she consciously seemed to make up on the spot, ended up being true 🤷♀️ . At the introduction of her character I felt she was a lush phony but now I see her as someone just very insecure snd who’s ego got in the way of her actual talent.
I love the Snape code theory so much, if you look closely in the film, before Snape starts his code, he pretty much makes fun of harry because knows nothing of the Wizarding world. What's funny is that Snape thought he wasn't paying attention, so ij the film when Snape walks up to Harry, he looks down and sees the notes, evident that Harry WAS infact paying attention, that's when Snape starts the code, and it makes sense, after calling him out, and realizing that he actually wanted to be a charised and hard working wizard to learn his culture, he then says the code, which is essentially I'm sorry, for you and your mother, then he says, let us begin
It adds the fact that Hermione always knows about something in class but this time Emma Watson portrayed her with an expression as if what Snape said made no sense, as if it was not a real potion but something else
What about this theory?
In the book Tale of Three Brothers, the veil represents Death and the bridge (referenced in the book) refers to the pathway between Life and Death. The three brothers create the hallows to safely use beyond the veil - the invisibility cloak will let the user to safely pass through the veil and navigate whatever is beyond the veil, the elder wand is the only wand powerful enough to use on the other side of the veil, and the resurrection stone is the only way to safely recall the person who entered the veil, to be brought back to our world.
The three brothers were very powerful Wizards who found a way to safely go beyond the veil and also use the Deathly Hallows in our world as well.
How the hell do you not have more likes??? This is a brilliant theory!
Because this isn’t a theory, the hallows were used to escape death. The cloak to hide from it, the wand to overpower and the ring to bring you back.
I have a theory: Draco actually knew he was the owner of the Elder Wand after he disarmed Dumbledore. The reason he didn’t take it or was open about it, was because he knew that Voldemort would’ve killed him and his family for it.
Draco grew up in a magical family that dated back for centuries, and his house was full of magical relics and history, surely he would’ve known about the Deathly Hallows and how the Elder Wand worked.
No.
Many people thought it was a fairytale, or a myth if they happened to learn about the wand from other source than deathly hollows tale; just look how xenophilius lovegood was treated like a weirdo for it, and many people didn’t know what the symbol means, like krum saying it was grindelwald’s symbol. Unless malfoys themselves believed in the wand’s existence, i highly doubt someone like draco would spend time analysing how a mythical wand works
edit: good theory tho
It's a good theory. Even if he didn't believe the tale he wouldn't risk it. Even tho he could just disarm Draco, voldemort would def kill him
@@bryanxjames1215cared to elaborate
@@Gecko_Zen even Voldemort didn’t know.
About Harry making just the Dursleys mad by being a horcrux. Could it not be that it built up in them over time from the best part of 10 years of constant exposure. The breaks between school terms could mean that the effects of the horcrux are lessened within his magic friends. Moreover, the times during school in which the Durlseys aren't exposed could also lessen the effects, but takes much longer due to the amount of exposure. This could explain why Dudley shows remorse towards Harry when they leave him (in Order? in a deleted scene?)
Dramatic effects of the locket Horcrux is better explained with proximity of TWO horcrux in overlapping same area of effects.
First Movie Opening Scene:
McGonagall: "Albus, do you really think its safe, leaving him with these people? I've been watching them all day. They're the worst sort of Muggles imaginable. They really are"
Trusting McGonagall accuracy. Worst sort of Muggles imaginable before exposure to Harry.
Unless they were already exposed to a Horcrux that was never mentioned, I would call single Horcrux exposure unlikely cause of Dursleys being the worst sort of Muggles imaginable.
@@brentnakamura2488 Also, if each is half of what the "main soul" was at the time... Harry's scar is among the smallest. The Diary was biggest, being the first-- and its affect on Ginny was enormous. We see some with the locket, while the others tend to get destroyed before causing much anything..
I like the theory but fails when we learn McGonagall told Dumbledore how horrible they were before leaving Harry with them
Anyone notice that Uncle Vernon hoped that Harry would get the death penalty in Order of the Phoenix. There's an argument that the Dementor's Kiss is a form of death penalty in the wizarding world. So the fact that Harry saved Dudley from a dementor attack, Uncle Vernon was hoping his son would get the wizarding death penalty too. Both penalties are equal in my view, you lose your soul with the Kiss, so you might as well be dead.
yes im pretty sure they hated harry so much was bc of his parrents/(someone had a theorey that the evans couple loved james more that vernon so that created Jealousy and bc harry lookes like james he can relive or remember the way james was more loved and he had so much hatred so yeah
When Hedwig and Dobby both died--“I CRIED FOR DAYS”! The useless death of helpless innocents always is so hard to accept!
@caseycopeland626 Dobby too. He had no choice until Hairy gave him his sock and freed him by engineering his sock into the Horcrux Lucius Malfoy passed to Dobby. Dobby was sweet and loved Hairy just as Hedwig did.
Useless isn’t accurate. People die that’s a true fact of life. Anyone of your friends and family will die all your pets will die. Death isn’t useless and they were not helpless they made their choices knowing full well they could die. But their death was needed so Harry could live. It is the greatest act of love one can commit. That’s why we all loved snape in the end because everything he did was mostly out of love. Even with Draco he killed dumbledore so that Draco can live he knew that the elder wand would transfer to Draco but wanted to make sure Voldemort didn’t know that. Like it blows my mind how much love some of these characters show that’s so misunderstood by everyone else I try to talk to about these subjects.
Yes that's true, look at the helpless children dying in Gaza
As a twin Fred & George got me the most, I was so upset I put the book down and didn’t pick it up for awhile, hoping that maybe he wasn’t actually dead and was gunna be ok like healed or faking it for a laugh like before like with the holey joke idk. Still upset about it especially cause they were so close doing everything together I can’t imagine em going on without each other. I hate the post saying how he wouldn’t be able to look in the mirror after he died cause he’d see him or how if he looked in the mirror what he’d see would seem like it was just him but was cause it was actually his twin 😭😭😭
Lol mom it’s hedwig not poke e man
Here are some shocking facts about the Potters deaths:
*- Multiple people were responsible for it:* Voldemort for obviously doing the job, Peter for betraying the Potters by giving away their location to Voldemort, and Snape for telling Voldemort the prophecy which caused him to go after and kill the Potters.
*- It all could have been easily avoided:* if Snape had never told Voldemort about the prophecy in the first place, if the Potters had accept Dumbledore's request to be their secret keeper, if Sirius (who was the initial secret keeper) hadn't convinced the Potters to switch their secret keeper to Peter, if the Potters had not agreed with Sirius's idea to make Peter their secret keeper, or if Peter hadn't given up the Potters location.
*- Most shockingly of all,* still bitter over his past treatment of Snape, the fans took it out on one man (James Potter).
Tell me what you think of all this!
31:00 James and Lilly were 21 going on 46 in the movies good lord
The fact that Hermione is so gifted has very much to do with her being muggle-born. She's not the first muggle-born to be a top student either. I think it has to do with the fact that a muggle-born wouldn't take magic for granted like kids of all-magic families.
On Lily and Petunia's parents' death, the "normal Muggle death" could've been seemingly normal but also involved foul play- perhaps the Death Eaters caused a fatal car accident? That could even be where the lie the Dursleys told Harry about his parents came from
Well if a muggle was hit with the killing curse it would just look like they died in their sleep or had a heart attack, although both of them dying at the same time would be suspicious
Remember the guy I think frank from riddles manor? And the other muggers found dead assumed even after autopsy to be a heart attack? Sorry been about 3 full years since I've read the full series
Timestamp 40:30 😂 let me just say you made my day. I had to rewind it six times to make sure that audio was actually in the video and not just playing in my head. Give your editing team a raise!
Rowling has addressed the Dursley behavior being due to the "horcrux" in Harry. She said simply that the Dursleys were just mean and there was no relationship between the two.
Prof. Trelawney wasn't prejudice. She just didn't like him. How would anyone feel about having to share a job that was yours alone for years?
Because blaming Firenze was the right thing to do and the one to blame could simply not hire her
For 20 years…
You’re not wrong she never acts out to all centaurs ya she was rude to him and it was bad but you wanna talk about someone being prejudice then they need to look at umbridge
@@anthonyblizard2948 the producer themselves was prejudice lavender went from black to white due to a bigger part in the film
@@arklife99 I’m sure there was other reasons they changed crab to a black guy and he’s a big part so what you said is invalid
I think the theory that snape is Harry’s father might be the worst one yet, like how would you read the books and that’s your conclusion
I don’t even know if this guy read the books cause one of the first ones about hedwig he said what happened in the movie and didn’t even mention what actually happened
um since when people thought snape was HARRYS FATHER?!?!?!?!?!?!!?@@qiyo2812
Tough love
@@qiyo2812This guy doesn't seem to actually know that much in the books. I've realized this over the past few videos of his I've seen
@@FabricatedPheonixthat’s because he’s just reading an AI script probably not even a true fan tbh
I don't believe the remaining twin is Willy Wonka, but I LOVE that theory and it makes me feel warm and fuzzy.
The Imagination theory:
Year1: Harry finds a nice stone.
Year2: Harry kills a snake.
Year3: Harry sees a black shaggy dog.
Year4: Harry gets a new cup.
Year5: Harry reads a book.
Year6: Harry's favorite neighbor dies, old mr. Dumbledore.
Year7: Harry runs away.
Him reading a book doesn't make sense for ootp
Year 5 correction as he never reads a book in that year: Harry accidentally leads his godfather to his death
Do we know where Godric’s Hollow is? In Philosopher’s Stone Hagrid mentions Harry falling asleep while flying over Bristol in the first chapter. Given that he’s arriving in Surrey, would that put it somewhere in South Wales?
Something I’ve been thinking about is the Dursleys has had Harry since he was a baby. They had to potty train him, teach him to walk, teach him to talk, deal with potential colicky issues, bathe him, change his diapers, deal with teething, or give him bottles bc I HIGHLY doubt Petunia was nursing Harry. But it just makes me think about how magical Harry was compared to Dudley and are overcompensating with gifts and have another layer of resentment towards him bc they had to “train” him. But it always makes me feel bad bc what did they do to baby Harry vs 10 year old Harry?
Thank you for making this video I needed a break from reality
No way Hermione wiped her parents memory earlier because she’d have to use magic outside hogwart before legal age so the ministry would’ve known
They were 17 and the trace was off of them.
I've always theorized that the Australian school is on top of Ayers Rock.
Kangaroos are actualy magical creatures with dimensional pockets but muggles never got close enough to tell
@@Lyko5 damn
Could be why we're not allowed to climb it anymore 😂
The Draco is a werewolf theory is a lot more in depth than mentioned here - there's a pretty good super carlin brothers video on it for anyone who CBA reading this comment, but here's the evidence:
- the mark on Draco's arm, though confirmed to be present, is never confirmed to be a dark mark
- when he shows the mark to borgin, he specifically threatens borgin with greyback and borgin believes malfoy knows and has sway with greyback without question after seeing the mark.
- at the top of the tower the night dumbledore died, the death eaters put up a magical barrier that only bearers of the dark mark could pass through. The barrier goes up after Draco gets to the top of the tower and is taken down before Draco leaves the tower. Why would the death eaters stop to remove it if they all had dark marks?
- at the beginning of deathly hallows, Voldemort taunts the malfoys about their cousin, tonks, marrying Remus. He says to Draco "will you babysit the cubs?" Which is a very specific and odd taunt.
- throughout book 6 Draco is described as sickly, pale, skinny, dark circles under his eyes, regularly disappearing - same descriptions and odd circumstances as lupin in book 3. Obv he is disappearing to work on the vanishing cabinet, but that might not be the only reason.
- Also in 6, dumbledore expresses surprise that Draco would invite greyback to hogwarts where his friends live. Draco refuses to make eye contact with greyback and says he didn't know he'd be coming, seems extremely upset to be near him.
- narcissa specifically seeks out Snape to help Draco in the sixth year, Snape is known to be capable of brewing wolfsbane potion which in 3 lupin says not many can do reliably. Maybe she knew Draco needed Snape's potions skills from that year on.
JK said this theory is untrue, but it's one of my head canons. I think though most, if not all, of this evidence is circumstantial there's more than enough here to be plausible.
Sorry to burst your bubble…
But Draco presents his dark mark to dumbledore that night on the tower…
At least in the films.
@@JDF1996 all of my arguments are based off the book. But you're right, in the films he does show one. There are a lot of plot differences between books and films, like how in GoF in the book it's actually Dobby who gives Harry the gillyweed, not Neville. And in HBP, the burrow is never burned down. That's only in the films. One of my favourite moments from OotP is a film only scene, when Sirius yells "nice one, James" to Harry when they are fighting death eaters together in the ministry. Doesn't happen in the book but it's a brilliant moment. GoF basically changes genre entirely from a murder mystery whodunnit (book) to an action suspense (film) because the film reveals Barry crouch jr way at the beginning and the book doesn't reveal him until after the third task/graveyard when Harry returns to the school. In the book Karkaroff, Maxime, Crouch SR and Ludo Bagman (a book only character) are all red herrings for who put Harry's name in the goblet but in the film you just know from the start that moody isn't moody because of that dumb tongue flicking thing they had him do.
But yeah the werewolf theory does not hold up in the world of the movies, only the books. A lot of fan theories apply only to one or the other because there are so many differences.
@@MinorMutiny
This makes a lot of sense.
I’ve read the books a few times but I much prefer the films, purely for the visuals🤩, so those are what stick in my head.
I can see how the book being more vague about his disappearances and the lack of a mark would make this plausible…
I also love that scene with Sirius in the ministry! I like to think he realised at the last moment as he fell into the vail… hence the slightly vacant look 💔
@@JDF1996 the film visuals are pretty spectacular. I've just listened to the audio books more times than I'd admit lol.
That Sirius moment is heartbreaking for sure. That paired with Molly telling him "he's not James" when they argue at the beginning of the book 💔
@@MinorMutiny
Book or film both are tragic.
Honestly… I’m at the point where I (M28) can’t watch the films without crying…
I miss Alan and Robbie so damn much.
I recently rewatched them (as I do almost every year 😅) and actually I wailed at the end of philosophers stone when Hagrid says
“Though I’d let you leave without saying goodbye” 💔😭
9:46 - 9:50 "wormwood means absence." In real life, wormwood is used in Absinthe, which is what I thought our esteemed host of this video said at first. I wonder if someone trained in knotting up loose threads can make an end out of something such as this.
can you maybe make an audio book of all harry pottter books . your voice would be perfect bro
Agreed 😂
Yesss ❤
Does Mrs Norris really have to be Filch's wife for him to take her 'death' but really petrification badly, and not just care about her because she's his cat and deserves for him to care about her?!
This makes me sob bc my Henchmaniacs and me theorized that Mrs Norris was Filch’s wife turned into a cat when we were younger- you called younger me out-
Credence mother was a Maledictus who turned into a goat. This is why Aberforth Dumbledore has such affinity for goats.
That makes sense..he was hiding what she was❤
I often wonder why a writer would put beastality in a children's book.🤔
the filch part that would have been a good addition. i hope the potter universe keeps going it seems very deep when you talk about it
Thank you for the warning about the varying audio levels. It always trips me out when it changes unexpectedly. Check my phone volume or check for a notification on my phone. First world problem now that I say it out loud lol
This is my beef. Ron turned his back on Harry during Goblet of Fire and refused to believe Harry when he tells Ron that he didn't put his name in the cup.
Jealousy. Teenage hormones. Wanting to impress Hermione. Wanting to be seen. Im a guy, it doesnt surprise me. Nor so that Ron comes back everytime to have his brother back.
@@rickardrakkoon2500
There’s several examples of Ron behaving like this…
He was jealous when Harry made seeker.
He was adamant Sirius was a psycho killer/ not to be trusted.
He valued A RAT over the word of his friend.
He dined Voldemorts return (initially)
And he turned on Harry rather quickly when wearing the locket…
Just to name a few.
Before you blame the horcrux…
I believe they worked sort of like a bogart, amplifying a persons fears.
Yes it made them all aggressive but it affected Ron worse.
At the time, Harry probably feared the trials to come and hermioney likely feared she’d never return to her family… Ron’s biggest fear was losing her, hence his reaction (almost killing Harry with the sword of griffondor).
Non of this means he was a bad friend, he was still extremely loyal and brave (when it counted)
I would love to see Dudley have a child or grandchild that is magical. If Petunia is still alive, would be interesting to know how she would react, because the child is from her baby boy.
J.K Rowling admitted she wanted to do a book where Harry helped out Dudley’s magical child with spells but didn’t think it would work.
More like she couldn't make it work @@Battmatt22
Didn’t Harry’s squib neighbor breed kneazle cats?? Could it be that Crookshanks was born in her care and then some how ended up at that shop??
27:08 what about Cedric? Ohh he didn't die at Hogwarts but at the graveyard
Here's the theory I came up with:
The events of the series never actually happened. It was all being watched by Tom Riddle in his prophecy and the entire thing was shown as what would happen if he went down the darker path.
Harry didn’t break the Elder Wand… he placed it back with Albus.
in the movie they break it
@@soleilassail the movie isn't canon
@JCurry1123 The movie is canon. The book is original canon and takes precedence.
I’ve never see it mentioned anywhere…
Harry’s son’s name is Albus Severus Potter.
ASP - An asp is a venomous snake.
Is this a thing?
Dude, your voice is so relaxing. I went back to sleep this late morning playing your latest upload on the HP Tv series, and ended up napping through this entire compilation, which automatically played next. Haha
Thank you! 💙🤍🛌 😌😴
Holy shit. The possessed fetus theory is DARK
32:00 Harry's muggle grandparents. I fully agree they were likely killed by death eaters but I'd go as far as to guess they were killed in a car crash caused by death eaters and that's where Petunia got her story about how Harry got his scar.
I personally would’ve liked the numbering re recorded to be in order😂 but I understand that would’ve been a lot of work lol, great video
About the magic gene, it doesn't just appear out of nowhere ("muggle borns") nor disappears ( "squibs"). You need to have it in your genes. Hermione's mother probably had a great great grandparent who was a Wizard and married a muggle, then the magical gene went on, until she met Hermione's father, who certainly had a wizard great great grandparent. As both had the magical gene within their DNA, Hermione got it from both and was born a Witch. The same goes for Squibs. There must be at least a muggle in the bloodline. They are like two different species who are similar enough to produce offspring
Agreed! The gene was activated in hermione as it was a recessive gene in both her parents.
That's assuming the magic gene follows scientific rules, and not, you know, magic
The hedwig one made me burst into tears 😭😭😭
Wait. Hermione smelled freshly cut grass, parchment and spearmint toothpaste. Did they change that from the books only listing grass and parchment?
Hermione does not say what the third thing she smells is, although Rowling revealed in an interview that the third smell was Ron's hair. However, in the film version, Hermione states that the third thing she smells is spearmint toothpaste, due to the fact that in an earlier scene at The Burrow where Ron points out to Hermione there is toothpaste on her face and her parents being dentists.
@@TrissTess thank you for the clarification
The way that you explained that made me get tears! rest in peace Hedwig 😢 ❤
I think what people are missing with the theory that Dumbledore knew Sirius was innocent is that Sirius TRIED to kill Pettigrew in public. There were DOZENS of witnesses. And no one, except Sirius and Pettigrew, knew that Pettigrew and not Sirius ended up being the secret keeper. Sirius was also in Azkaban for Pettigrews apparent murder, not just for the Potters deaths. There isn't exactly much point of a trial for a "murder" that happened in full view of a streetful of people, not in the wizarding world anyway. Given that Dumbledore had no reason to think Pettigrew was still alive and didn't know he had been the one to betray Lilly and James, he would have no real reason to visit Sirius.
Thank you for always supplying us with HP videos ❤❤
My pleasure 😊
I have a theory that Squibs were a bit more magical than is presented in the story. They maybe not be able to do it but can detect it
Pidgeons are also called squibs
10:15 I hate this theory because it fails to take into account this was a pre-internet book. Like we expect this type of thing these days but I’m sorry if I call BS that a waitress raising her kids and writing this book in her spare time is going to get obscure botany books to make a hidden message for that scene. Especially with the pacing and planning shown in the early books. Like Rowling just isn’t that good of a writer, and I feel the bools would be very different if she was going that far to put in this type of planning.
I think Ron is much nicer than James, sure he hasnt always been the smartest character but I cant imagine him bullying anyone. Personally I understand why Snape hated James and that he didnt care about what'd happen to him BUT I think he should've cared about what happens to an innocent child if he tells everything to Voldemort.
Btw I wonder if a dementor would've sucked out Harry's sould+the part of Voldemort's soul, what would've happened? Would the horcrux be destroyed? Would it be the opposite and after that it wouldnt be possible to destroy it at all?
@@kuuttinenListen, if you hate how James is portrayed as a popular hero who is well liked by a lot of people (excluding Snape and the Dursley's), then you should blame JK Rowling for that. I don't care how much you hate the fact that James Potter is JK Rowling's "golden boy".
3:00 Hedwig's death was the stupidest thing ever! Honestly, She'd been sent ahead plenty of times before or sent her with a letter to someone he knew far away.
Also, there was no need to take the cage he could have just left the cage and got a new one or sent someone back later to get it.
4:16 OH… Hedwig..Snape, I never thought about that….makes sense…especially if he wanted to keep up appearances…i can add to this a bit, other than it being obvious that his loyal pet would give him away, it brings Snapes skills in Legilimency to mind, had he been tuned into Hedwigs intentions and that’s how it seemed to be a “flawless” accident? is it possible for a wizard to do with an animal? Am I thinking too deep into this? (But it’s that the point to fan theorying? 😎)
Harry didn't snap the wand in two in the book but put it to rest with Dumbledore as was supposed to happen. Dumbledore is also human. The amount of evidence against Sirius was overwhelming.
I like the theory that the death eaters killed the Evans' because it gives more weight as to why Petunia hated Harry and everything to do with the magical world so strongly.
Harry and Ginny: read the books! Ginny always had feelings for Harry. And Harry spent the first half of sixth year fighting his jealousy towards her boyfriends and the conflict that she's his best friend's sister and therefore should be off limits. When he drinks Felix felicis accidentally makes Ginny and Dean fight and break up. Then he's in detention for the quidditch finale so Ginny takes his post as seeker and wins the cup for the team. They first kiss at the celebration party and are together since. Harry breaks up with her after Dumbledore's funeral to protect her. They resume their relationship after the battle of Hogwarts. Harry's feelings for Ginny grew slowly over half a school year, there was no need for Ginny to give him love potion. Especially as Harry maintained his feelings for her while being away on his mission, there's a scene when he goes to Voldemort under the cloak that he meets Ginny and wishes he could get together with her but then he decides it is more important to end the battle and sacrifice himself to save the others. That doesn't come from a love potion either.
all the theories abt snape and his love for lily really cuts deep
i don't ship them but i love snape sm and if those theories are true then its just too sweet
A Very Good Video 👍🏻
@18:30
The Magic Gene
It's called the 'Hermoine' Jean
.
.
.
I'll let myself out...
No, no. Get back in here and make more great puns!
I liked the part where Harry says, "By Grabthar's Hammer, By the Sons of Warvan, YOU SHALL BE AVENGED!"
IIRC that was before he destroyed the one ring but after he blew up the Death Star, right?
That Snape one at the battle of 7 potters is wild. Probably true.
wdym "probably", do you have evidence to support?
1:05:14 👏👏👏Very good. My favorite team.
My thought: Lily’s parents might have died in a car crash and that’s where Petunia and Vernon got the excuse they told Harry about his parents.
i wouldn't be surprised if it was true lol
I would like to know if you ever did a video over a theory on what happens to witches or wizards who are born mentally challenged. I'm not talking mentally ill as we see with Lord Voldy(he's clearly ill) but like with challenges. Is there a special school they are sent off to, are they killed, are their powers yanked from them some how? If you haven't I would like to hear your theory. I'm sure i'm not the only one who has thought of it.
Crabb and Goyle are evidently mentally defective. and Luna is clearly on the spectrum. i think its a matter of degrees. If they have enough focus and intellegence to train they get to be witches or wizards if not then they probably become obscurus and its off to saint mongos with them.
I don't think one's magical powers can be taken from them. It is explained in the books that magical powers cannot be stolen nor rid of if you don't want them anymore (remember Dumbledore's sister).
So, I'm the only one that thought the killing curse was less derived from Abara Cadabara, ans was much more supposed to be, "I want a kadaver?"
26:29 I love the subtle reference here, even with an appropriate scene! 😂
27:09 I know Cedric didn’t die because of Hogwarts technically but still…
28:55 mate knew what he was doing when he said that 💀 but it would be inaccurate if you considered the cursed child as canon
33:33 well if they did that it made it only harder for them to get Harry as he had to go with the Dursleys instead
35:21 yep, SIRIUS circumstances
37:00 MY POOR HONEY 😭😭😭😭😭🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤
37:19 ‘other death eaters’? I know they thought he was close to Voldemort but he was NOT a death eater!
40:23 this would be very unlikely, as then this would destroy the entire fan base
42:40 yep, very SIRIUS flaws
49:45 she said in the first book that she read about him in a book
1:08:52 they were awful people before they even received Harry, McGonagall confirmed this
In the Book The Deathly Hollows The 7 Potters All had an Owl(Fake Ones)in a Cage.. and Hedwig was Killed in her Cage...
I needed this!!! Thank you
Got to him talking about how steadfast & loyal Ron was and decided to "nope" out.
Since I wrote the last five novels, Harry, Ginny, Ron, and Hermione died in their old age together, and had a reunion with all the important people in their lives.
Are we just not gonna talk about how Ron blatantly uses AT LEAST 3 unforgivable curses in the last two films…
We hear him cast imperio in gringots
And on (at least) 2 other occasions we see green come from his wand.
I doubt he would use the killing curse but one of these occasions was in direct defence of hermioney, in the room of requirement, so it’s not hard to believe he would use crussio out of anger.
Arthur Weasley also uses one during the battle of hogworts, as do many of our “heroes”.
Edit: Also, who let Filch participate in that battle?!?
Tf is he gonna do, like fr 🤣
Couldn't Dudley have a recessive magical gene, as his Aunt Lily was a witch?
1:07:47 “acted quite civil with other members of society”? Suggest you reread the beginning of Philosopher’s Stone, in which Vernon takes great pleasure in shouting at multiple people before lunch…
He says he can't think of any student that died while Dumbledore was there... He forgot about the spare...
And Cedric
@@nickhawkes2188 Cedric is the spare....
Moaning Murtle
@@Lyko5 was Dumbledore headmaster then? I think he was just a teacher.
@@overthehillskating6244 now that you say, im not sure
I liked the Crookshanks theory that he used to belong to the Potters.
I enjoy these videos thanks for putting then all into one big video
Dumbledore taking a 12-13 year old Hermione on a heist to the department of mysteries mind numbingly dumb of a theory. However, I do like the idea that Hermione might have stolen the Time Turner.
It's said McGonagall was the one who gave it to her, so maybe the real truth is that for some reason McGonagall had one in her office, perhaps for private study, and Hermione passed through, saw it, recognised it from a book, and swiped it. And the reason McGonagall didn't notice it was missing is because Hermione would use the Time Turner to duplicate the Time Turner. Just as she was in multiple places at once, she would have one version of herself replace the Time Turner in McGonagall's office, perhaps even creating some form of time loop. It would all work so long as she had a justifiable reason to visit McGonagall's office once a day.
Since McGonagall seemed to be personally managing Hermione to ensure she could actually handle the increased workload, Hermione could have dropped in for 5 minutes each day. McGonagall may have only noticed Hermione had the Time Turner once she heard that Hermione had physically been in two classes at the same time. Perhaps prior to that stage, she'd thought Hermione was just doing the coursework of extra subjects in her personal time, without a teacher's help, using the textbooks. She must have been utterly amazed Hermione was keeping up until she heard Hermione was actually present for classes she was enrolled in but not expected to actually attend.
Then she probably sat Hermione down and waited for her little time loop to end, which likely would have involved the Time Turner on McGonagall's desk vanishing right in front of both of them (as it went back to the beginning of the loop, becoming the one on Hermione's person), and then for McGonagall to demand Hermione take it out of her pocket.
My theory is that all the different horcruxes had various different affects to them with the locket being the specific one to make people be more moody and irritable.
I don't think Dumbledore could have had Harry grow up knowing who he was. It would have gone to his head, it'd have to. Without the suffering and humility it engendered Harry couldn't have defeated no nose.
Also fun fact. On numbani, if you look in the reflections of the buildings, you can see the reflection maps of the PvE map.
It's mostly just added boxes and force fields to zone areas. But it also has the addition where the map continues to the side of the airport
I honestly like the idea of Dudley marrying cho chang, or any other witch really, not only because of the potential character growth it implies, but also because I think the idea of a magical Dursley kid would be a fun and interesting story to explore.
Neither James or Lilly have black hair…
Harry seems to share more traits with snape than those we know of James…
This could have been as simple as James being infertile… Or as twisted as polyjuice…
(I’ll leave that one to your imaginations)
Edit: yes it could be a recessive gene…
But this idea is more interesting
Edit2: also, snape was there the night the potters died… implying he knew their location. So him and Lilly must’ve reconciled.
I would assume Dumbledore or Voldemort told him where they were after their death.
Snake didn't visit Godric's Hollow I the books.
35:00 Why would Ginny go give Harry a love potion and then go have a makeout session with someone else? (Yes that was the moment Harry realized his feelings in the book.) Some try doing that to get someone jealous but with a love potion there's no reason to do so.
Hermione used to go on holiday with her parents for 2 weeks at the beginning of the summer then go to Rons. She also went home for Christmas and Easter.
Trelawney being a pisces makes sense as to why she is a divination teacher lol
you said the same theory twice, the one about snape speaking code to harry
The dursleys were exposed to a hurcrux a lot longer than anyone else in the story. They have no innate magical protection against the influence like the magical community would. And they don't go into detail about how he was treated as a baby (as far as i remember)
judging by birthdays alone, hermine's birthday is just 10 months before harrys, while technically possible, its ~315 days between their birth and a pregnancy is ~280 days, and you cant instantly get pregnant again from my understanding.
You can get pregnant again 3-4 weeks after giving birth
1) Dumbledore used a time turner to always precisely where needed the most and to explain off the deus ex machina contradicting the entire series of Ron being able to mimic parseltongue at the final battle.
This implying that Dumbledore had studied the future to learn that the only way Voldemort could be killed was to use Harry as a sacrificial piece and puppet like he did, among many other things that had to go precisely as they did.
The theory of Ginny giving Harry a love potion isn't true because when Harry smells Amortensia, he smells Ginnys perfume. He smells a flowery scent that reminded him of the Burrow.
27:13 Didn't Cedric Diggory die while he was headmaster? I mean, he died far from school grounds so maybe that explains it but he certainly died while Dumbledore was headmaster.
I’ve thought being master of death was true since I read the book, I thought that was another reason for snapping the wand. The horcrux angle never even crossed my mind, and it doesn’t seem as solid. Why name the book after them and not the horcruxs if they weren’t finally brought together? What was the point? Voldemort was already powerful, he didn’t need a special wand to kill Harry unless J. K. had another reason for that storyline.
VERY Interesting and thought-provoking. As for the last theory: if close proximity to the horcrux caused the Dursley's to be nasty to Harry -- explain Aunt Marge.
Maybe Marge just took to the hatred of the Dursley’s and also started to hate harry
Hatred by association. People can hate other people based on the opinions of others, plus their own misgivings.
If jkr was a Wattpad author, her comment about harry and hermione ending up together would actually be supporting evidence for the sibling theory 😂
43:58 according to mcgonagall they were just awful people and she said this litteraly a day after harry became a horcrux.
I’ve always wanted to know why Harry couldn’t see the thestrals after his parents death, or watching Quirrell die..
I think JKR said that she was aware of that plot hole, but it wasn't a good time for the thestrals to appear in the story before OOTP.
16:28 is explained in the movies tho, im confused. Or is this specifically relating to the books?