Harry Potter TV Series REBOOT! What’s It Going To Be About? | Harry Potter Film Theory
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 เม.ย. 2023
- Go to joinkudos.com/super and use code SUPER to 2X your rewards today.
Today Ben dives into the Wizarding World to explore the supposedly soon to be announce Harry Potter TV show, and what it’ll be about then counts down his TOP 10 Hopes for things to see in the show!
#supercarlinbrothers #HarryPotter
Edited by :: Riley Murtagh & Ethan Edghill
Carlin Brothers Coffee ►► www.CarlinBrothersCoffee.com
Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► www.SuperCarlinBrothers.Store
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
J's V L O G➜ / jonathancarlin
T W I T T E R➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Intro Music Created by RKVC
/ @rkvc
Intro Animation Created by J. Cutt Productions
/ @j.cuttproductions
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..) - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
I want the whole plot of Percy siding with the ministry. It shows how much the Weasleys have endured in their choice to support and love Harry.
yess! They only showed hi in the background. Maybe he felt forced to since he worked there already, like the dad was still working there at some point when everything went down
came here to say this!!
100 % this. After all, he is the Slytherin amongst Gryffindors. Not to say Percy didn't belong, but his bravery was aimed at the wrong place - to prove, that the Weasley family can achieve great things. To prove, you don't have to slave away at the ministry, as his father did and yet they never had any money. To show, he can be better. Better than Bill and Charlie, who got all the attention. Better than the twins, who forced the attention. Better than Ron, who was best friends with the most known person in the recent history. Better than Ginny, finally the daughter that Molly and Arthur wanted so much.
He wanted to be better than everyone else and was willing to be brave enough, to do some difficult decisions. Even cut himself from the family, he loved so much, despite it must've hurt so bad, just to prove himself but in the end the name of the Weasleys as well. He wanted to help the name of his family so much, he got blinded by all of this and did bad things exactly to the thing, he was initially trying to help. Which is why his redemption arc, guilt, admittance of all the wrongdoing and the actual return is so much more powerful. I love Percy as a character and I wish, he got more screen time along with the other Weasleys.
1000% agree great idea
I like it!
I would love for Ron and Hermione to be like the book characters and not a perfect person and a comedic relief
Agreed! This is all I want!
Definitely
agree!! hermione needs to be much more bookish and annoying. and ron's knowledge/harry and hermione's ignorance of the wizarding world needs to be highlighted more
Watch the films then.
They weren't those things in the films.
WE NEED A CHARLIE WEASLY DRAGON TRAINING SEGMENT!! I don’t even care how long it is! It would even be hilarious to just have an episode showing what each of the Weasley bros are up to and right after showing Percy at the bank doing some boring paper work or something it just cuts to Charlie in full protective gear just getting roasted like a marshmallow by a temperamental dragon!!
We need more of the Silver Trio with Neville, Ginny and Luna.
The St Mungo's scene with Neville and his parents. Ending the episode with him going home and in fact having a wall covered in wrappers.
Ginny being more interactive with people outside of the Golden Trio. Showing student life outside of all the destinies going about.
And showing Luna's loneliness. Remember, she had no one from Ravenclaw in her "friends" painting in her room. I see a scene where she's alone reading her Quibbler next to a window in the Ravenclaw Common Room and everyone else just ignoring her.
I LOVE these ideas, especially the scene with Neville and his room covered in gum wrappers. ❤
If this Series happens,I really want Daniel,Rupert,Emma to recreate the Epilogue at the end of the series...It would be a great Cameo
I'd like Dan and Bonnie to play James and Lily.
@@matthewpatrick7263 omg and if emma watson goes ginger her n rupert playing the weasley parents!
Every episode is a 60 mins and is the back story of the character
I don't see any of them returning to HP.
Lol they might actually be the right ages for the scene by that point
What I want from the show is just a faithful retelling. Justice for the real Ginny being most important 😊
Totally agree! Along with Ron and Hermione too!
Maybe they wouldn't screw it up, It's the post-Velma HBO production
How do you think they should handle the part where Hermione is laughed at for being anti-slavery?
@@inthedriversseat928 just as it's written.
@@inthedriversseat928 that’s a very good question! I think they should approach those topics carefully, because in canon, things like slavery and racism and homophobia are just *there* and they’re not addressed. But it would be great if they could show how there are problematic beliefs in the wizarding world, just like there are in the Muggle world, and those things need to change.
I would love to see more of an exploration into Regulus's story. He's one of my favorite characters and has such an impact on the later books, a flashback episode with Kreecher telling his story would be top-tier.
Yes! Regulus *and* Andromeda need to be talked about more.
"Kreacher's Tale" is a top 3 chapter for me in the whole series. We & the heroes learn so much in the chapter. And we view Kreacher differently too (honestly, a lot of life lessons too: treatment of others, etc.)
Wishlist for a Potter series:
1. Ravenclaw gets an eagle.
Justice for Ravenclaw! haha
Yes please, and new merch. I'm a Ravenclaw and cannot wear any merch.
Yes. We would finally get to stop correcting people when they get it wrong every time.
Also the proper house colours
And blue and bronze as their house colours.
I NEED 1 full ep being Dobby's POV while working at Hogwarts during The goblet of fire. Showing kitchen, daily life of students and professors (maybe some funny secrets), some mischief and eventually leading to helping Harry in 2nd task.
How do we get you guys to help write this!?! We the Harry Potter fans deserve good writers! I would LOVE to see what’s going on behind the closed head masters doors with you’re whole “Dumbledores big plan”. It would be amazing!
Look SCB has some decent theory videos and know a lot about the Wizarding World. That doesn't make them good screenwriters
I have consumed every drop of Star Wars content, books, comics, TV etc. But I would never ask someone to try and make me a screenwriter because screenwriting is far more complicated then just knowing the universe well
And since you mentioned D Big Plan, a lot of their thoughts make sense but there are some really dumb parts to some of the videos. I got examples for when they are flat out wrong a lot of the time if you want them. But either way, just because a theory you made was correct, again, doesn't make you a good story teller
@@cameronfield4617 It would be really dumb to hire them as screenwriters. But I liked their ideas for the fantastic beasts movies much more than the actual movie. Therefore they could be great advisors regarding the fan perspective and what should or shouldn't happen. How it is then presented should of course be left to the professionals. However, it would not be the first time that a major franchise wants the expertise of passionate fans on staff.
Yeah they could just help them avoid plot holes, ideas for new stories that the fans want, and general tips on most of it, while someone thats good at screen writing takes up all of this and create the show based on it
They arent just great fans, theyve developed excellent theories, solutions to plots that arent explained in the books, new versions like the “what ifs”, they are great creators of new content inspired in harry potter which is what the new stuff needs if they dont want a flop like fantastic beasts and specially having the movies which were great bc of the cast always there to be compared with
While I would love to see SCB's ideas come to fruition, you do realize that we'd lose the direct-from-the-source material we get here. The very first thing the brothers would sign is a non-disclosure agreement.
You guys act like they’d be hired as LEAD screenwriters and not supporting writers that are really there to keep the references in check and to make sure there’s no conflicting plotlines with what’s already established
The movies made Snape a nicer character, so I hope the tv show would make him more like the books. That would probably annoy a lot of people but it would also be fun to see all the times when he gets so wound up by his students.
But he was ultimately good, but yes he was meaner in books to point
@@AshePBlack I wouldn’t say ultimately good he was selfish in his reason for everything that he blames himself for the death of the person he loved which he was, I personally feel like after joining Voldemort he was unforgivable even being a spy won’t bring back the people he helped get killed
Great points. In the movies, Alan Rickman does a stellar job of bringing Snape to life, and his facial expressions are priceless. Alan Rickman's raised eyebrow tells a thousand words. Rickman is as effortless a storyteller as Snape is a duelist. Snape is described as countering spells almost lazily, and Rickman's storytelling is also effortless, precise, and spectacular. What a treat to have him as Snape. May he rest in peace.
In the books, the character is much more spiteful. He takes every opportunity to torment and humiliate certain students like Neville and the Golden Trio. It is bizarre how much pleasure he takes in tormenting students.
Imo, the fact that he's a triple agent almost fully redeems him at the end of the books. He had to walk a very fine line and fool Voldemort and every Death Eater for many years.
No, it doesn't bring back the dead and it doesn't excuse relishing abusing his students, but it is heroic all the same. He had to show great skill, loyalty, and a true change of heart.
Idk, it would be a tricky balance to do. Because on the one hand, it would be really interesting to see some of hoe snarky and rude Snape actually is, and use that as building blocks for Dumbledore's plan, and how not all people working for good are actually good people. But on the other hand, if they did that, there would have to be other changes made in order to maintain themes and improve on the ones that the books missed. Specifically: Snape is one of the only half decent Slytherins present in the movies (and theres basically none in the books) so it would take away from that representation. And also, it makes Harry naming his son Severus so much worse. I stand by the fact that it's terrible in the books too, but in the movies it's forgivable. .. ish, still creepy when you think too hard about it, but it's better
it’d be cool to see you guys do a 7 video series where you outline what they could do with each of 10 episodes for each book
This^^^^^^^
That would be great
10 episodes?
We need them to just work on the real project!!!
correct ages for the marauders era characters with lots of flashbacks, Peeves and Charlie actually being characters, and actually seeing all of the different classes, like have a gag where it cuts from action to the middle of Professor Binns teaching class with the class all asleep and then back, are all things that I would like to see.
As much as I would love a complete reboot with one book per season, I'm interested in seeing an Auror cop show, preferably set immediately after the Battle of Hogwarts when the Ministry is in total chaos.
That requires writing new material from JK and we all know the controversy around her. They won't let her do that.
@@PiginaCage doesn't have to there's plenty of people who write just as well as JK if not better being approved by JK for a spinoff series is easy she's too busy to write because she's a billionaire, I reckon it will be a smash hit even if George Harris doesn't return as Kingsley shacklebolt all they need is the same Casting director to find perfect actors for each character and maybe someone to convince at least Rupert Grint to come back and it wont be the same without Mark Williams too
i dont think a cop show in any realm of storytelling would be well received.................
An entire Ep dedicated to the life of one eyed Moody? See him fight in his prime.
Problem is that if you’re chucking it right in after the Battle of Hogwarts, that mixed with the fact that Harry would soon be working to become an auror, now you struggle to find a valid reason audiences will accept not to include Harry. Include Harry and you really have to include the rest of the trio. Before you know it you’ve fallen straight into old territories and lost the novelty of an addition that goes to new places.
I would really love to see more of Neville’s character! He is one of my favorite book character’s and I think there’s a lot more they could do with him on film! They could show more of his relationship with his grandmother and how he gets treated by professor Snape
Or even his friendship with Ginny!
Agreed. Neville is awesome
I totally agree, The Neville story more of that, because it also have a certain importance to the main story to.
Agreed I want more of the neville, ginny, luna friendship
Definitely he was one of the few students who stood up to Voldemort.
If this is to happen I would love to see S.P.E.W. make it in. It was a rather large part or Hermione's story, As well as Kreacher. His story gets so glossed over in the movies that you don't even find out his role in the final battle of Hogwarts. There are a lot of other side stories that I would love to see make it but these two are the ones that I wanted to point out.
Both of those are easy cuts when adapting the books to films.
Kreacher appearing in the Battle of Hogwarts always brings a tear to my eye ❤ I agree, we need Kreacher's Tale in the TV show.
Honestly it could be about the founding teachers, the marauders, and the original story. All they gotta do is start at the beginning, they'd have sooo much to go off of. It could just continue. It wouldn't be a mini series. BUT AN ACTUAL SHOW!
One thing I always wondered: How was Voldemort (a half blood) able to convince pure blood mania families (like the Black and Malfoys) to follow him so devoutly, despite Voldemort being what the pure bloods despise?
In the Chamber of Secrets book, Dumbledore mentions that very few people actually connected the dots that Voldemort and Tom Riddle were the same person. So my theory to that would be: they didn't know he wasn't a pure blood. Either that or just his connection to Salazar Slytherin convinced them.
I think it was the love of the potential outcome that they cared about. Love of what Voldemort could give them over love of Voldemort.
The proud pure blood families would love to follow someone who “recognizes blood purity” regardless of that persons blood status.
Basically, it was a combination of power, personal hatred for his muggle side, and his (magical) family tree being tied to Salazar Slytherin himself; Voldemort being the last living heir.
Dumbledore explained it a bit in Half Blood Prince; Voldemort wanted power and immortality - for that he needed followers and in order to gather followers, he used the facts that he despised his father for lacking magical abilities and for abandoning him and his mother as well as being the descendent of Salazar Slytherin which carried huge weight with the purebloods to win many of them over who had bias toward muggles (and sometimes half-bloods too). Mind you, not all Slytherins (or Voldemort's followers for that matter) are purebloods and Voldemort didn't always prefer a pureblood over a halfblood. As an example, Voldemort's inner circle - he is far more trusting of Snape (half blood) in certain scenarios than even his most loyal followers like Bellatrix (pure blood).
Sort of how evangelical Christians in the US voted for Trump, despite him being the least bit Christian. It's the believe that this person can help us achieve our goal. It's the message, not the messenger they really care about.
I mean.. why do conservative white Americans like Candace Owens and Clarence Thomas? Think about it.
Would definitely love to see Peeves in the series. Also some backstory on Dobby to be fair, like his life at Malfoy manor and maybe afterwards when he's free what he gets up to. Would also love to see Hermione promote liberation and rights for House Elves like she does in the books. And of course the whole deal with nearly headless Nick and his attempts to join the headless hunt.
I hope Warner hire you guys! You know this series like the back of your hand you are very connected to the fan base so you know what the fan base would want
I just made a similar comment.
They don't understand the wizarding world well. They often say that magic works one way when it clearly doesn't. Their ideas for stories are contrived and forced. And just because the fans online think they want something, it doesn't mean that that's a good thing. Creators are often supposed to think of new things and that's something that SCB never do. It's always built off of what it already revealed rather than having new information revealed.
Movie flame would be better
Wouldn’t mind a completely British production again
@@shashankshekhar6952 I agree because he is more focused on the life of characters then what Quote on quote fans want but no hate J and Ben I love you guys but i am just saying what is better for the profit of the creators
I hope they don't ruin it with the usually "modern audience" adjustments. Super cringe
@@decimanightelf4135 that's the problem, people are so afraid to speak out against woke culture
@@K4inansnowflake
@@sebluthy2300 your reading comprehension is terrible
@@K4inan so is your history comprehension. He's calling you racist.
based
I want to see Ginny Weasley actually have a personality and more into her relationship with Harry and her 6th year without Harry
True other than some of the Chamber of Secrets the only scene from the movies which accurately represented Ginny was the Quidditch scene in Half Blood Prince when she says “shut it”.
Not gonna lie, the "relationship" between movie Harry and movie Ginny feels at times more awkward and cringe than even Anakin & Padme from "Attack of the Clones".
Fred and George being actual characters instead of just Jokesters seems great to me. when re-reading those books you realize how much George and Fred were friends to HArry and also Hermoine (the example in the second year with Draco calling her mudblood springs to mind)
I want to see A LOT more details from the book. Dumbledore talking to the Dursleys before taking Harry in the half-blood prince, SPEW, Charlie Wesley…… etc. ❤❤❤❤❤
I am really hoping for an origin story for Lord Voldemort and his rise to power in a post Grindelwald world. As well as this see the beginnings of the order of the phoenix on screen and view powerful wizards fighting powerful wizards in epic battles.
We don't know nearly enough about the main villain of the franchise though I agree it would be interesting to see other characters I just think Tom Riddle is so complex we need a television origin story.
@@jinxithexit3546 ....we DO know about the villain though? It was all explained in DETAIL in the sixth book. In terms of his ADULT life then yeah that would be fascinating to look at.
@@jinxithexit3546 We know a lot about him actually. Half-Blood Prince alone has at least 5 episodes worth of material about Tom Riddle and his past.
@@PiginaCage I know but I would like to see more detail and how he first came to power and more detail of his horcruxes and how he became so strong.
I agree, especially since they skipped most of the Voldemort origins in the HBP movie.
If we finally get to see Voldemort's History such as seeing the Gaunt Family i'm all for this.
they robbed us of this in the og movies... to put more LAVENDER
That is going to be my most hyped thing going into this series (and in general, getting the adaptation of HBP we truly deserve)!
Nothing would make me happier and more excited than the Super Carlin Brothers being the writers for the Harry Potter tv show series
I don't think they'd be qualified, but it would be awesome if they got invited to visit the set.
@@ItsAnIsaac or some kind of cameo, like as muggles on the street or something
They should at least be involved as "Guardians of the Lore" with an indisputable veto right against dumb screenwriter decisions. Screenwriters and producers not understanding the material they are working with in the slightest has been the #1 plague of movie adaptions especially in the last decade.
I'd actually find an Umbridge storyline really fascinating, it might answer the question of "who hurt you/why are you so terrible but not actually on the side of evil"
Dolores Umbridge was the textbook example of what a Lawful Evil Character is in Dungeons and Dragons. Law and Order is her bread and Butter and achieving that end sometimes means doing things that others might view as bad or evil. But, in Umbridge's mind, sometimes you have to do awful things to get the result you intend. The ends justify the means for someone like her and besides "What the Minister doesn't know won't hurt him." We don't need a story for her.
Um. She IS on the side of evil. Duh
We really need to see more details on Voldemorts past like the Gaunt family and all of the flashbacks that weren’t included in Half Blood Prince
As extremely excited as I am for the show and all the details they can add in to it, I wish it was the marauders or something. I don't feel 'old enough' for a reboot already 😂
I’d agree though even if it is a retelling of the original story. They’d be able to dedicate entire episodes to things like the Marauders, or Lily and Snape’s friendship, what the wannabe death eaters were doing as kids, etc. just because it’s a retelling of the OG HP doesn’t mean it can’t dig in deeper to the past.
It is 2 decades old though... I do think there is a lot of potential for other stories, but I think after they kinda fumbled Fantastics Beasts they want to try something they know will do well. This does give them the opportunity to dive into some of the other historical stories and test those waters as well.
@@ThatOneLadyOverHere oh please don't tell me it's 2 decades old....I already feel old
@Paige Leftwich the 1st movie came out in 2001. Crazy huh? I think the reason it feels weird is because the main characters were all children and aren't that old nowm
Well, it's 22 years since the first film came out
I really want to see Jude Law continue as Dumbledore
Something I always wanted from Harry Potter was more "everyday" things. Like what some people work with, how they use magic, how you use magic at home, interesting non-school people etc.
I've also thought of side characters getting more explored with a different focus each year, but it was more about groups and their relationships:
Y1 - Gryffindor Boys (they're always around, so it seems a good place to start)
Y2 - Gryffindor Girls (Hermione being muggle-born is most relevant this year, and we never get to see her dormmates supporting her through it or not)
Y3 - Teachers (the height of teacher drama with Snape, Lupin and Black. Can't follow them because of twists, but maybe the others are speculafing while they have chats in The Three Broomsticks)
Y4 - Hufflepuff (the angle on the lovely rival Cedric's support, probably also following him in the tasks and dating Cho)
Y5 - Ravenclaw (Luna and Cho are pivotal, but in the original story they tend to be gone long and present shortly. In the book we mainly just hear second-hand about how they're being treated by other people)
Y6 - Slytherin (not necessarily on Malfoy, moreso about how the rest of his house are finding his unusual behaviour and how they impact him. If we do follow him, though, that's all 3 rival seekers getting pseudo-main character status)
Y7 - Howard's? (Flip-flop on if I want to spend time with the DA continuation. It's an obvious that lots of people are interested in, but it could take away from the discomfort not spending there and then the relief when we go back)
Your year 6 idea is really interesting for me , because I want to know about others slytherin student more too.
Imagine if Daniel Radcliffe comes back as James Potter, Tom Felton as Lucius Malfoy, Robert Grint as Arthur Weasley, Bonnie Wright as Lily Potter, and Emma Watson as Bellatrix
Please say they'll have the actor playing Harry have the same eye colour as Bonnie (Lily)!!!
Emma wasn't Bellatrix, Emma was Hermione. Even in the Shell Cottage and Gringott's scenes it was Helena Bonham Carter, not Emma
And it's Rupert Grint, not Robert
@@catnip824 whoops meant Rubert, also I know Emma is Hermionebut it could still be cool
@@catnip824 I think the point made in the main comment about Emma playing Bellatrix is because it isn’t much fun to have her play Hermione’s mother or something, because we’d barely see her; whereas Daniel and Rupert could play the father to their original character
I wonder what universal studios the park thinks of this. If a new generation grows with a new reboot that looks different from the parks will universal still make money??
The movies will always exist so it doesn't matter.
no one other than Alan Rickman could ever play Severus Snape, R.I.P🙏
I hope they make it a faithful retelling of the book. Sometimes these series tend to add a bunch of side stuff (not as good as the source material) until it's something completely different from the original. To me, the reason to do this show is to have the space for true adaptation. I suppose if I trust anyone with it, it would be HBO. I'll give it shot, but I'm keeping my expectations low. I don't mind them adding some detail that could have easily been there but was just never mentioned in the books. I guess where they would have room to do that would be the first 3 books, as they are significantly shorter. You could cover them in a season and still have room for Lupin to have some flashbacks of his friends, and maybe some extra memories of Harry's childhood. Maybe even some moments between Hermione and her parents or a memory from Petunia of her and her sister as children.
Usually this is the case, but they sre going tk have to add some stuff. Sure once they hit season 4 and beyond they have a lot of material but unless the first 3 seasons are only like 5 episodes long they are going to have to stretch it out
I want to see more of Neville, Seamus, Dean, Lavender, Parvati and the rest of the classmates. And the classes, show all the professors at work at least once for a little bit 😊😊
I would love to know more about Remus, Sirius, Tonks and Mcgonagall. Also Seamus, Dean and maybe even Bill or Charlie Weasley. I just really want to know more canon things about these amazing characters!
Personally, if they are doing a retelling of the whole 7 books- can Ron have his lines back?
The “We are cheap” line sent me rolling 💀 😂
I hope they don't change too much, i really love the story! Thanks for making this video!
If they wanted to really milk it, they could run it from the end of Fantastic Beasts (since they left us hanging) through the Cursed Child. Along the way they could fill in a lot of back stories on many of the characters. When it comes to the original series, in general they can go by the books, since it was already written, filling in those parts that are left kind of vague.
I’d love for it to be animated, so many creative possibilities and don’t have to worry about cast aging issues.
Yes! and then maybe then Maggie Smith could still be casted. I know she wasn't able to do as much acting while in motion when the last 2 films were being shot due to her health, so sitting in a sound booth sounds much easier.
That would be so cool!! I'd love an Arcane style Harry Potter show
I wouldn't mind if Harry Potter theorists were hired to direct this new series. Personally, I believe Ben and Jay would be an excellent option and the series would be enriched by what they would add to the overall story and bring to the forefront more of the magical world for the benefit of the audience who is not already engrossed in the Wizarding World.
And what? End the series as a harmony cringe fest like the movies?
NO. we need writers who have affection for the story the way it is without inserting their own made up ship like movies did
@@kabitaneogi2325 I find Morgan from Movieflames could be a better option. He has studied cinematography and has a very deep love and understanding of the series.
direct is the wrong word
With each season being each book that's ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT because it allows FOR SO MUCH that was left out to be put in.
We can FINALLY get "it unscrews the other way." even. Iconic.
The idea of making a movie from a book always seemed strange to me, regardless of the source.
@TheNinthGeneration the HP films are VERY well done adaptations, but they aren't perfect. And with the series being in HBO's hands, I'm not worried at all. They've crushed it with their live action shows.
@@TheRibottoStudios I’m not saying they’re bad, just that you have to leave out so much by necessity unless you want to make a 6 hour movie
We can get more insight of what voldemort/tom did before the main timeline like when he asked dumbledore for the dada job and him cursing it
@TheNinthGeneration that argument is over done and doesn't hold up when they add in useless sht like the Weasley home burning them just LOOKING AT IT SADLY when they could use aguamente on it to douse the flames hello lol. Don't add nonsense and yet leave out important things. Some changes worked very well like Severus' characterization but the good changes are few and far between.
There's a book series called A Series of Unfortunate Events that got a film, that later got a Netflix Series. However with ASOUE, the film only covered the first three books in a 13 book series, so it needed the Netflix series, and it was much more faithful to the books.
Despite the number of books, I think the Harry Potter series is longer, and still has many stories left to tell. I hope if they do readapt the books, they're more faithful to the source material.
I want to see Ginny’s story from her Sixth year on. Like what is happening at Hogwarts and how she is running the DA. After that I want to see how school is after the war and then her quidditch career. I also want to see Hinny develop and their wedding etc. I just think that would be absolutely amazing
Id appreciate a show about the marauders in their prime!
I need more Lupin. He was my favorite from the books and is left out so much from the movies
They could give everyone a backstory in the same way that Orange is the New Black did. With a plot in the present but in each episode you also follow the past of one of the characters. Probably starting with Harry, Ron and Hermiony and then their friendgroup + draco, and later on to all of the teachers
I think SCB needs to be the on site "canon checker" like what they have for Mandalorian
I am really exited for this if it happens, there's a lot of things cut that really can be put in that could change how the story forms compared to the movies, especially everything with Draco, he says less than 50 words between Azkaban and phenix in the movies.
as long as draco doesnt get something like the deleted scene wand shot I am fine with it
*excited
My main concern is the casting of hagrid. Nobody can replace Robbie Coltrane
Same with Alan Rickman
This is one of my problems with this they would have to recast everyone the students are to old now to play themselves as children and a lot of the adult cast teachers included are dead.
My main concern 😟 is that they'll cast mostly Americans 😢
Why is everyone speculating like it hasn't already been leaked that it'll be a reboot of the books? Everyone here hoping for Aurors, Founders, Marauders, but it very clearly won't be that...
I would love to see Daniel play James, or even Sirius.
I wold love for a founders tv show just to see the people who made the Hogwarts houses and when the falling out between Gryffindor and Slytherin started and how it progressed to him leaving the school
Your second idea is the same doubt of mine in every minutes that I've seen movies or read books of this franchise.
Who would really want to see a series with James as a bully answer that one
Plus we finally got a game where we can play as a Hogwarts student so shut up
@@matthewbates9629 I just want to know when the animosity between Gryffindor and Slytherin started and true reason of this issue. Do not want to see James Potter and three marauders as the bullies or see snape as a bullied. So sorry if I making you misunderstand me.
It’s cool but honestly I was uncomfortable when I saw the memory of Snape getting bullied cause I could relate
I love your ideas of fleshing out the defense teachers! That would be an amazing way to go, especially in the first 3 seasons where there might not be enough source material to make a full season. HBO, if you want to know how to make this a hit, watch things like this made by real fans.
A full backstory on Igor Karkaroff. Headmaster of Durmstrang. Voldemort's influence and followers, as far as we know from the books, focuses on Britain. Igor, however, is likely not from Britain, and was a death eater as well. When Voldemort went down for the first time, Igor turned his back on him, and betrayed fellow death eaters. There's plenty of story to tell there. What were Igor's motivations. What was Voldemort's influence outside of Britain (focusing here I guess, on Central and Eastern Europe)?
The Carlin brothers will absolutely write the best cannon the what If Harry was in slytherin series is a good portfolio
I think it would've been fun to show the timeline between the second Wizarding War ending and when the children go off for their first year of Hogwarts. I want to see the fallout, how it effects the ones who were there, maybe Hermione going back to finish her 7th year...
There was actually a whole fan series made, proper TV show length doing just that, taking place during the Golden Trio’s 20s.
@@jeromevaleska2014 Where was that at?
Also remember that the Golden Trio broke a ton of laws throughout Deathly Hallows:
- Harry's underage magic over Little Whinging
- Using magic in Muggle areas
- Stealing several amounts of food, Moody's eye, Bathilda's book and two Horcruxes
- Taking hair from Muggles without consent to use in Polyjuice Potion
- Trespassing
- Physical assault via spells
- Releasing a dragon that caused extreme vandalism to Gringotts and the deaths of numerous goblins
- Using Unforgivable Curses
- Impersonating Ministry employees
- Harry showing up basically anywhere while he was an Undesirable
- Association with Pettigrew's death
The list goes on. They would definitely go on trial, with or without Kingsley presiding.
@@coolnerdlll6053 I think a lot of those things would be overlooked for the greater good in things, but yeah those things need to be addressed if that was how they went about it.
*affects
They should just make an “untold stories” series and have it be a mashup of all the stuff they left out of the movies 😂
like "Adventures at Hogwarts" or something generalized so we can see multiple character's points of view and of course the side stories that we didn't see.
The marauders has so much potential because it can literally be from when they were kids right up until their death. You’d see just how dark those times were that slughorn was talking about. Snape, voldermort, death eaters, the order….. its just a shame we will probably never get it
Because there wouldn’t really be anything original about a Marauder movie, if we’re being honest. Everything worth knowing about them we already learned in the books and there isn’t really any aspects of the first wizarding war that we didn’t get to see in the second war.
I think this video perfectly explains my concerns with it. A lot of the story lines and character development that you mentioned were flashbacks and flash/forwards, aka not a retelling of the books but a prequel or a sequel. When the target audience still have the source material fresh in their minds, it’s too soon for a retelling.
I think a book per season show is a great format! But I don’t think it’s been long enough since the movies. I’m also worried that they won’t be totally faithful to the books
The movies is so good and holdes up good grafic wise still. So hopefully it is a new story. 😍😍
I still havent found 1 comment that are hyped for a reboot. People want a new story. Maby about voldemort orgin, marauders or the hogwarth orgin?
Sorry for my englishen
@@PumpiPie no I dislike the movies and many other book lovers do too.
I despise the movies.
@@PumpiPie I am very hyped for the reboot. Can't stand the movies. Now you finally saw one comment. ,
I have a suggestion for your what-if series "what if Voldemort went to live with Tom Riddle SR instead of Wool's orphanage"
I wholly agree with more Draco i believe he deserves a redemption. I also want more Fred, George, Bill, Charlie, and Neville 💯
No one is going to be able to do Snape justice like Alan Rickman
Especially Americans. No offence. The voice alone is everything 😊
To be honest I think what most of us miss from the movies are not our favorite character getting more screen time. At least I miss more the things that was put in the movie differently not because things in movies can’t be directly translated from the book but rather favoritism to certain characters or “better” solutions from the books themselves. There is always something that can’t be properly transferred from our personal understanding from the books but to outright just change things just because, those are the things that really makes me scared for the outcome of these potential new series.
The way I see it there is nowhere to go but up, because the movies commit so much character assassination, it honestly makes me angry.
Bottle episodes are really about saving money by mostly only filming in 1 location. Quidditch would not be a cheap episode
Decided to look through to see if someone else had said this already, since that was my first thought. Quidditch World Cup would be basically the opposite of a bottle episode. They're usually meant to have just core cast, few sets (usually ones already built for the main show) or effects, and yeah, be cheap. Quidditch World Cup would be none of these if done well. Unless the entire episode was a close up of the main cast in the box reacting to the game, with no actual shots of the game. Which could also be entertaining if rather infuriating to again miss the game.
I would love to see an anthology show featuring the various events and adventures going on in other parts of the wizarding world, like Japan or at Durmstrang. Alternately, a police drama focusing on the Aurors and their hunt for dark wizards. CSI: Wizarding London.
I really wish the studios would cooperate with you! Look at all the amazing work you put into the 'What if Harry was sorted in Slytherin' theory. The suspense, the plot-twists, the re-tying of loose ends, incredible!
I just hope they remain faithful to the original story, and not give it the 2020's touch
The movies had many things cut short and were never well descriptive. Specially in movies 4, 5 and 6. with a series you can tell so much better the events of the books without having to hurry the story.
Yo! Harry as DADA prof would be sooooo cool! He’s super well suited for it, as seen in the DA, but I think it would also be super cool to see him grapple with how he treats Scorpio Malfoy, having his enmity with Draco in mind but also how Snape treated him for his anger against James
Those all sound like great ideas.
I really hope they include all the cut stuff from the books: eg. Peeves; Snape's potions room; the cut Quidditch matches and especially all the important cut stuff from books 4-7.
I hope that we get a more diverse cast and that they change the more outdated and problematic elements from the books.
So glad you did this theory! I just commented about this the other day. You made some great points. As long as it's done at least as well as His Dark Materials by staying true to the source material, I'm pretty much here for it.
Redoing such a beloved series (albeit in TV show form) is such a huge risk. It's basically forcing the fandom to choose which version of the Wizarding World they prefer. And if it's not a success, the studio will have to answer for a failed TV show, and for abandoning Fantastic Beasts. It makes way more sense to focus on completing and improving Fantastic Beasts and then exploring NEW corners of the Wizarding World we haven't already seen before. A series focused on the Founders is prime material!!! Let's focus on filling in the Wizarding World before starting a Wizarding Multiverse!!!!
Beloved? Nah, the movies are horrible disfigured abominations of the books.
I will NEVER forgive what they have done to Ron and the Wesley's not to mention Rupert Grint!
I agree with you 💯
I think it would be really cool to explore the motivations and emotions of characters who initially seem a little boring. Like Cho Chang, dealing with the grief of her boyfriend dying. And Regulus Black, and what made him switch to the good side. And even Aberforth and his estrangement with Albus. And Dean Thomas and Seamus Finnegan and the other Gryffindors who had to choose whether to side with Harry or the Ministry.
Honestly... NO, please no... I don't want a new series... There are so many possible things that could go wrong and ruin the story... Starting with casting the main 3..
I mean, yeah, it would be cool to see more of what the original movies had to leave out from the books, but is it really worth the risk?
It seems rather like a pointless cash grab like the horrible live action Disney movies.
I'd much rather see the (promised) continuation of the Fantastic Beasts movies or an official recording of the Cursed Child...
I'd still watch the series if it truly comes to pass, but I'm very conflicted.
I hope there is enough gravitas to pull in big name actors even for small roles. It would be so important to surround child actors with great talent and mentorship to raise the overall bar of performance.
I actually really agree with you on Harry ending up as a DADA professor. I always thought that it would be nice if Harry had his time as an auror but then realised he wanted to find out who he was without all the fighting but still put his DADA knowledge to good use. We know from OOTP he was a good teacher during DA. One tv idea I would be interested in seeing (apart from the Marauders obviously) would be Tom Riddle's rise to Voldemort but from his POV.
After everything I’ve learned and realized about the Harry Potter books and movies over all of these past years thanks to your channel, personally would just like to say, that if any fans would be deserving of being a part of and adding to the canon story of Harry Potter, would definitely be you guys the SuperCarlinBrothers! 😎💪💯
I feel it will be hard for fans of the movies to see anyone else in the roles of these iconic characters.
I would like to see more fun episodes like what a quiditch game is like. Actually what if they just showed Quidditch.
Hopefully this time Dumbledore gets depicted similar to how he was in the books and in the first two films!
I think that Michael Gambon was fine but the director of GOF (4) was awful 😖 (well OK but not the best) and gave him bad direction especially in "that" scene 😏
A lot of people think because of the "times" we are in, it might be ruined by casting and changing of stories to fit the "today" world.
I’m excited that this is happening and can’t wait to watch…and I will unless I see that they are changing the original story and/or characters (i.e. The Cursed Child). The second I see that I’m out. There are a million little side stories that can be told that stay directly in line with the original story. Crossing my fingers it plays out that way!
I think it would be cool if they made a show based off of your “What if Harry Potter was in slytherin”
I honestly wish it was anything but a reboot. Like there's so much that could be explored or added and instead they choose to redo what we already have. And the idea of seeing the characters recast is just sad like I can't imagine them as anyone else. I wish we could get to see the founders in a series or the marauders time at hogwarts or even a brand new character exploring a part of the wizarding world we barely know about.
How did I only just realise that "The Secrets of Dumbledore" is a film that exists?
I think I would like a marauders show
this feels like how theyre turning percy jackson into a show
Ooh, hope it's not like the movies
Probably
except the percy jackson movies were awful
yea they really were the worst
Stories I would like to see. Peeves fun and games and also Argus Filch beeing the opposite of a poltergheist. House elfs and goblins and why the one race loves humans while the other hates them soo much. Lastly, Azkaban prison, and why the dementores agree to work for the ministry when they could get so much more "food" from just beeing monsters like the boogie man.
Was hoping they'd do a finding founders series. Would be so interesting set in medieval England, with maybe characters like Merlin and King Arthur making appearances (I'm not sure on the years so maybe won't line up idk).
At least you're not suggesting an American series 😂
I’ll be fascinated to see how this plays out with JKR’s involvement specificslly
This would be my main concern, if she has any editorial control at all I'd be worried she might try to twist it into an outlet for her bigotry.
Anyway, she’s going to get paid, and that is something that doesn’t sit well with me personally. I don’t want to financially support a well-known bigot who actively speaks out against things I consider to be basic human rights for equality. She herself has come out and said that she considers any investment in any of her products, a confirmation and support of her statements. (This is not a quote.)
@@jasoncrownover8947I love how before jk was cancelled for wanting trans and womens accomplishments separated, she was hated by the conservatives and loved by the progressives for being supportive and including all groups on pottermore. Now everyone forgot that and hates her for not wanting men that became women to get awards that women deserve
@@brandonvierra8177 If everything you just said wasn't a lie, I might bother to engage. But both of us know that her comments and actions haven't had anything to do with "athletics" in the first place. Youre either lying intentionally, or you care too little about the truth of the things you say to even use Google. So your post here is just a bs smokescreen.
It is ironic on her end that she's placed herself alongside actually misogynistic figures in order to lash out at trans people. But the far-right's angle on it really isnt surprising. Fascists never care about being consistent, and if turning her into a weapon supporting their anti-trans legislative crusade is as easy as just love bombing her on Twitter...
you know what I'd LOVE! a Tonk's teenage years at Hogwarts story!!! or OR sequal series to HP about Ted Lupin where Daniel and Tom Felton come back to play their iconic roles, as Ted's Godfather and Uncle respectively!
I can't predict how cute if your idea would happen.
I'd love to see more on how voldemort convinced people to side with him and their perspective on the Wizarding world (in the books they don't see themselves as evil, they see themselves as liberators). I'd like to see the first episode be something about the first Wizarding war (subtlely introducing some of the characters that come back later). I want to see more of Snape and maybe even some more of Lily and Pentunia's relationship (like a flash back from Petunia's perspective). I'd like to see more about the Weasley family and their relationships with other pureblood families.
I always wanted to see a true-to-book Ministry fight from the Order of the Phoenix. It always was so cool in my head; the doors, the brains, the baby-head, the tension of people being actually hurt.
What if they brought the story to today's world? We all know you can't use electricity in Hogwarts so I would like to see muggle kids missing TikTok or Dudley taking a selfie with his tail 🤣