@@regina5730 I do believe they are on the pricey side but she doesn’t have ANY investors for it. I think she’s worked very hard and the ingredients and packaging (the brightening serum) speaks for itself. I think we should give her some grace for that.
This is not unbiased at all and Dr. Idriss is not just some instagram dermatologist as you put it, but a dermatologist with a practice in NY and a long-proven track record. I'd always pay 30% more for high-quality skincare than pay less for mid-range skincare brands which we have way too many.
She's not an "IG dermatologist", she's is a practitioner in new york that also shares information on social media. I think its sounds so diminishing the way you said it 😢
@@DanaRipperton Dr. Idriss is a board certified dermatologist who treats patients in her practice and has an IG presence. To say "IG dermatologist" is down playing her qualifications. Not technically wrong, but surely the rest of her bio is the more important info.
Long post loading: I normally love your videos and I am going to remain kind but this one wasn't it. It doesn't seem like you've used the products consistently to see results or reap the benefits. On camera, it doesn't seem like you struggle with hyperpigmentation. I have followed her since before starting a skincare and don't remember her marketing for melasma specifically but saying it has helped with hers. I love the soft wash especially compared to prequels cleanser because it does remove sunscreen and excess oils for me and prequels didn't with double cleansing with the one product. But I also, only have my mid-afternoon application so I can't speak to heavy sunscreen. She created her line to minimize the need for additional products. Multi ingredients in one step and you may not need them all based on your skin's needs and climate. Don't make esters seem like they don't work or aren't as good. I'm a sensitive skin type and can't handle the active form but love them all. I'm too oily at the moment for the serum and moisturizer in the morning. Always do your research, and reach out to a brand with specific concerns because I didn't know I couldn't handle both and was ready to throw in the towels with the initial launch. Flash Mask is by far my favorite because I saw results instantly. Proceed with caution on any skincare product. Start with 5 minutes and build up but do what your skin needs and can handle. I dislike how everyone is like the products are expensive but you spend so much on 10 steps when you could have a simpler routine with multi-step ingredients in one. That's where the cost comes in. I'm currently just using the cleanser and flash mask. I don't need the depuffer as I don't have redness or puffy skin but she created it for all the people wasting money on jade rollers and Jillian Dempsey’s t-bar tool. It's to use as a tool to quickly wooly product but you could easily do without it. She's said that plenty of times. I think she's a dope educator and never told anybody to buy her line or it's better than anything else in the market. Just a true passion for fewer steps, and fewer products that don't irritate the skin and there is science to back up each ingredient. A little tidbit, flash mask is strong so we don't overuse it. You only need the thinnest layer and less is more with every product she's created so far. I bought them with my hard-earned coins and will continue. You used tret for two years before deciding is wasn't for you. Give Dr. Idriss’ products time to see if you yield results. Consistency over intensity. Results take a min of 16 weeks and that's being consistent.
While I appreciate your post, you are wrong on a few points. 1. I consistently used the products and have emptied almost all of them. 2. I have melasma and some sun spots, but they are not the worst because I am consistently using products to help them. The sun spot showed no sign of improving. 3. I said I like some of her products. I will always give fair and honest reviews, and I’m sorry if others love her and every product, but that wasn’t my experience. 4. I don’t mind expensive if they work. I won’t keep going, but just want to point these out. Please remember this was my experience and everyone’s skin is different. It’s ok if you love her products and I think they’re so-so. Not everything is for everyone.
@@DanaRipperton Thank you for letting us know you did use them up, Dana, I've seen so many creators just apply for a small amount of time and give negative feedback. I hope you find something better for your melasma that's gentle. Skincare is not so personal, and if my tone is aggressive I apologize, that was not my intention.
Totally get that! It takes me a long time to get to the point where I feel comfortable reviewing a brand and I should have done a better job explaining that and my method. Thanks for pointing that out, and I’ll be sure to do so for the next one 🩷 and with before and after pics. I’m terrible about that, but I will try to be better. Appreciate your feedback
I recently swapped over to this range from using SK-II for over a decade. I’m loving the full range. I have mature, dry skin which is very sun damaged. I’ve seen great results and follow her tabled application guidance which actually only has the flash mask twice per week. My only complaint is that I’d like larger sizes for the serum and moisturiser as you get through those quicker than the other products. Only a small amount of the cleanser takes everything off (sunscreen which gets reapplied plus or minus added makeup) at the end of the day but your skin still feels soft and non stripped (I use the prequel glenser after the gym in the morning before my morning Dr Idriss range). I’m very impressed with the full range and despite having to ship it internationally thus making it more expensive I’ve already repurchased the full range and plan on doing so as it’s been such an easy and seamless transition and a routine that is not time consuming nor complicated yet yields great results..
@@natrodsjo8324 I love the serum and agree that it would be great to get it in a larger size. I bet the Idriss products seem cheap after a decade of SK-II 😂
The ONLY product, which helped to reduce the appearance of the lentigo (also called liver spots) on my skin is Major fade hyper serum from Dr Idriss!! I am buying it again and again from USA… Dr Idriss is a very honest dermatologist, I learned a lot from her and upgraded my skincare with products,which really work!
Is everyone forgetting she is an actual dermatologist with her own practice and not just an influencer. She has funded all of her own products and testing so that’s does justify the price…
No one is forgetting, but she sure does lean into the influencer aspect reaaaal heavily. As for price, people are allowed to think they are cost too much. Not all products are for everyone and that’s ok
@@DanaRipperton She spent 10 years studying and another two years on extensive medical research. You are coming across as very ignorant and bitchy! Not your best look.
I personally don’t think Dr Idriss products are overpriced. Keep in mind the percentage matters and if you look at the Paula’s choice products and others are about the same price. When it comes to skin care I think is what fits your skin needs.
All dermatologist influencer's brands on social media, I automatically ignore them when they present their products. They ALWAYS try to make us feel like their products are unique, better and magical but none are. They are literally not better than what I use from the drugstore. I am not saying they are not good tho. They might be very good but not better. Actually, brands from drugstores as La roche Posay, Cetaphil, Aveeno, Eucerin etc etc are all developed from Dermatologists too. Reason why the majority of people still buy the basics at the drugstores (cleanser/moisturizer/spf) even tho ordering online is popular. Drugstore's products are a go to.
Dermatologists are endorsed to promote these brands, some Dermatologists may have be involved in the process of creation of those products. But at the end of the day, they are always formulated by cosmetic chemists, or pharmacists ( in France where I live) and not Dermatologists and they are not developed by Dermatologists. If you don't have the final word to a product it's not fair to say that. But their marketing team knows what to do. What matters the most is who owns the brand. They are the one choosing which direction the brand should take, which includes the image, the purpose, the ingredients, the pricing, the trends or lack of trends. The owner is the one truly developing the brand and the brands you named are not owned by Dermatologists. I don't think that Dermatologists brands are automatically better because at the end of the day like any cosmetic brands their choice in ingredients is the same since they are not medecine but inci ingredients. And pharmacists or cosmetic chemists specialised in this field know better how to formulate a product in order to make it work from choosing the right ingredients, how to get the right pleasing texture or the right PH, the right combination of preservatives, ingredients that are compatible, the right packaging for a formula... Dermatologists don't know all of that since they are specialized in the medical way of treating a patient.
The depuffer has become a staple in my morning skincare routine. It really does reduce puffiness in my eyes. That's mainly why I use it. For the redness, I didn't notice much change.
I like the tips we get from dermatologists on YT. Dr. Dray, for example, is very technical and I appreciate that. I don't think they want to do us harm in any way. What I take with a grain of salt are their recommendations. Even when they are not sponsored, come on, they get a buck if we buy the products they are mentioning. They are always the same in every channel. It sounds just like PR. And I say that because none of the products they recommend are actually the products that my dermatologist/cosmetic chemist gave me to save my skin. Absolutely none of them. Same ingredients, but in effective percentages.
Thank you for taking time to review Dr. Idriss's products. I use all of them and have seen results with all. I do like them quite a bit and will continue to purchase the flash mask, soft wash, and moisturizer. I'm not sure about the serum but will stick with it for a bit longer. I think you have to be consistent for a while with any over the counter product that helps with dark spots. I have noticed a slight improvement with my dark spots; however, mine are tough. I've used lasers and it got rid of a lot of my milasma but not all. The last bit has been a bit tough to get rid of!
Social media dermatologist are soooo tough on other brands, then they come out with their own products and none of them make sense?? I trust Dr. Sam and that's it!
Dr Shereene Idriss is the sole funding agent of her skincare line. She talks about this extensively and explains it as the reason her products cost a little more...whereas both Naturium and Prequel are backed by the Center so they churn out the products and the prices are lower. I definitely enjoy several products from both brands as well. I enjoy watching Dr Idriss's channel tho and adore her authenticity overall. However , I'd be disingenuous if I didn't say I'm kinda sick of EVERY video of hers being used as a vehicle to hawk only her own products anymore. She used to give great suggestions and recommendations for a variety of skincare concerns but now everything she talks about boils down to evening out the skin tone as the end all and thus a springboard for her to tout her own products over everything else (because her products all focus on evening out the skin tone). I love the soft wash and actually prefer it over the gleanser as the gleanser to me has an odd odor. Both are wonderful cleansers tho. Also enjoy the hyper serum, the gel cream and the arnica/niacinamide roller. Sadly, I can't use her flash mask because of its high concentration of tranexamic acid and my prothrombin mutation. Bummer too as it seems to be her most loved product.
I follow several derms on YT. I think it really became a thing during the pandemic. I've watched Dr Idriss grow her following from nothing and eventually launch her skincare line. Of course, she hawks her line, she funded it, and believes in it but what hasn't gone away is educating her followers. I disagree that she doesn't give recommendations about other lines, or drugstore budget products. I use her line but bc of the price I also use some of her budget-friendly recommendations. Every Saturday she posts a YT on a most requested topic from her comments. Take a look you'll see she is still true to herself.
I do think her products are overpriced but I’ve always said if someone wants to spend a lot on skincare for whatever reason its their money and they can do as they please but my issue with all these brands is them coming out with vitamin c products because i have high doubts that they even work especially when they add many other ingredients that do similar things as an actual stable l ascorbic acid product and being dermatologists it disappoints me that they push vitamin c as if its matters when formulation and the form of it matter more. Like you mentioned something that is proven to work like the c+e ferulic.
She definitely does, but I have to assume her being a Derm also means she has access to lots of other things other than just skincare (peels, lasers, etc). She looks great, but assuming it’s just from her skincare (that’s only been out a year or two) is definitely part of the problem. Kinda like if people assume Kim K. has her skin from just her skincare line alone. Just a thought 🤗
@@DanaRipperton Yes, I agree with you! She does appear to have great genetics as well, but to NEVER have Acne, Melasma, etc or any other skin condition is pretty rare (like 1-10%) of the population!
@WaffleRedondo Yes, the Axis-Y product seemed to accelerate the lightening of my dark spots after using Vit C for months. I've started to use the Axis-Y on old dark scars to see if they can be lightened too. I just started doing that this week, so no results yet.
I really love the bright pink tube "Softwash" that she makes but it is somewhat more expensive than my usual CeraVe Face wash for normal to dry skin! I've been using that and Cetaphil since around 1980 and it is about half as much as the Softwash (about $30.00 per tube). I also use the Depuffer but it can be somewhat drying for my Rosacea-prone skin! But it works!
I love the major fade and the mask. To me, the serum is the best one yet, I've seen so much improvement in terms of hyperpygmentation, it's got great ingredients and yes, it's pricey but works well. I suffer from acne hyperpigmentation and it's awesome. In addition, I suggest that you do more research in terms of vitamin C and esthers, not all people can tolerate ascorbic acid hence the reason she used THD as the esther form on her moisturizer so to minimize the sensitivity, she's explained this multiple times. It's ok to have your own experiences and opinions but it's disrespectful not to get to know the brand before trying it and posting about it.
I have seen much results with the serum. The moisturizer is great but i don't need it. I need something richer. The mask is nice and brightening but doesn't do much dor my spots
I bought her stuff once and it was nice but it didn’t lighten my skin like they promised. It’s a nice moisturizer light and nice under makeup but that’s all. I can’t use glycolic acid so maybe that’s why but they said it would still work. I won’t buy it again too expensive for just moisturizing
Social media dermatologists are my go to for skincare consultation and advices. Its educational and practical. But their own skincare line up is another story though.
Are you using other products underneath? Could be related to that. Also, you’re not going to see changes quickly with almost any skincare product. Takes a long time!
@@DanaRipperton nope, just a toner underneath. I used it during the day instead of vitamin C serum+moisturizer. But as you said in the video, this form of vitamin C is not very potent. So I finished it because it wasn’t cheap, but didn’t like it
I have a comment on the morning face wash... I would agree that it's not necessary if you wash your hair every evening and don't use hair products to bed. And also if you replace your pillow case every couple of days. Otherwise it will make sense to wash your face in the morning.
Most skincare professionals would disagree. Unless you need to for a skin-related reason, washing with water is sufficient. Of course now for everyone, but for the most part we don’t need to disrupt our moisture barrier more
@@DanaRipperton Yes, I do agree with stripping the barrier. There are ultra gentle washes out there though... I'm just saying that hair oils, hair products and skincare products transferring to the pillowcase make it not such a clean place that you want to leave on your face skin all day next day. For example, I have a hair product that I would put on in the evening after the shower. It's one of those Korean leave in sprays for scalp health... I absolutely love it on my hair, but I noticed I would sometimes wake up with a mild dermatitis on my cheeks. So now I only put it on in the morning. Might be the essential oils that it contains.
I’m sorry to hear that! Dermatitis is never fun. In your case, I would agree, washing might be good. I think my overall argument is more that plain water should be fine for most people and for normal debris that may get on your face at night. Of course there are always exceptions 🤗
Trying to understand the “Instagram dermatologist, which I never thought I would be saying that” comment. She a dermatologist that produces educational videos, is that a bad thing or am I misreading your tone?
I completely agree with you on the flash mask. It is sooo zippy, wow! I put it on while I am in bath....miserable!!! lol Next time I will wait for my face to be really dry.
This line seems so overpriced for a cocktail of ingredients that are already in so many products on the market for less. Remedy dark spot serum has a slew of other additional ingredients and is $30 less! plus great formula and packaging
I think you misunderstand the Depuffer--it is to help with puffiness, not redness, which are different things. Puffiness has to do with fluid retention, seasonal allergies (rather than contact allergies), can also be caused by some medications. That is why it has a metal roller--to help with cooling and drainage of fluid. Redness has more to do with irritation, rosaecea, etc. You kept referring to redness and how you don't have redness, but that is not the point of the product. Also I agree that the serum is overpriced, but you do get a full 30mL which is standard (because you get two 15ml in each package) so your math on that was wrong.
I don't misunderstand the point of a de-puffer, I just was more focused on the formula than the device. The device is nothing revolutionary. Thanks for pointing out the difference though!
@@twlee1930 the depuffer literally says “Redness-Reducing Serum” on the front of the package. That said, I’m not sure it’s done much to help my redness & I’m almost done with my 2nd tube :/
Unfortunately I gave up on the hyper serum as I couldn’t justify the price for the amount you get. I used it consistently for a year and seen absolutely no results. It just felt really nice on my skin that’s all 🤷♀️ I also had the vitamin C moisturizer included which also felt so nice and light on my combination skin however just like the serum, it did absolutely nothing for me. If I’m going to be spending my money on a product that just feels nice, there are plenty of options out there for a fraction of the price!
@Dr.Idriss Her face wash is so amazing! I no longer have to remove my make up before washing my face! Its eye safe and Im able to safely removes my eye make up and prevent stys which I historically struggled with .
I was so excited when she announced she was coming out with a line. Then, I looked at the prices and my excitement was gone! Thank you for this review, though. It's truly useful! Ps. you are STUNNING Dana!
Personally I think you should always take a stand no matter if they still are gonna sell it anyways. It still makes a difference, but thanks for sharing where you stand, since you’re “below taking a stand”
Everyone has different thresholds for when they take a stand on something. What's important to me might not matter to you, and vice versa. Social media controversies aren't high on my list since anyone can post anything about others, whether it's true or not.
@@TrappedQue More info is always great. Dr Dray & Dr Idriss have helped me cure my acne that I’ve been dealing with for 10 years. No derms in my area have been successfull in this.
She drives me nuts! There's no way i would support her line. I had to stop following her because it just felt soooo condescending when she was speaking/educating. Also, her smacking her hand down while "educating" was just obnoxious. I moved from her channel and never looked back. Lol, the price point is ridiculous for OTC products . Thanks for reviewing
Dr. Idriss: "You don't have to spend too much on skincare."
Also Dr. Idriss: released overpriced skincare products.
😂✌️
100% accurate
Yes but UNlike the brands Prequel and Naturium, Dr Idriss's skincare line is solely funded. It's why her products cost a little more.
@@regina5730 I do believe they are on the pricey side but she doesn’t have ANY investors for it. I think she’s worked very hard and the ingredients and packaging (the brightening serum) speaks for itself. I think we should give her some grace for that.
@@pamelagileno5483it still doesn’t make them worth the price.
@@regina5730 except she isn’t just some influencer pretending to know what she’s talking about sooo
This is not unbiased at all and Dr. Idriss is not just some instagram dermatologist as you put it, but a dermatologist with a practice in NY and a long-proven track record. I'd always pay 30% more for high-quality skincare than pay less for mid-range skincare brands which we have way too many.
To each their own. I offer my opinions and that’s all 🤗
I love her skincare. I'd say her flash mask and serum are my favorite items to treat my hyperpigmentation
It's great that she is coming out with products for Melasma and other forms of hyperpigmentation!
She's not an "IG dermatologist", she's is a practitioner in new york that also shares information on social media. I think its sounds so diminishing the way you said it 😢
She can be both (and is), but she is known because of her social media presence, so I don't think I'm wrong in calling her that.
@@bb.schneider she says she's a board certified dermatologist in her videos. You say she's lying?
She’s a board certified dermatologist who specializes in cosmetic procedures
One of the h0ttest cougars
@@DanaRipperton Dr. Idriss is a board certified dermatologist who treats patients in her practice and has an IG presence. To say "IG dermatologist" is down playing her qualifications. Not technically wrong, but surely the rest of her bio is the more important info.
Long post loading:
I normally love your videos and I am going to remain kind but this one wasn't it. It doesn't seem like you've used the products consistently to see results or reap the benefits. On camera, it doesn't seem like you struggle with hyperpigmentation.
I have followed her since before starting a skincare and don't remember her marketing for melasma specifically but saying it has helped with hers. I love the soft wash especially compared to prequels cleanser because it does remove sunscreen and excess oils for me and prequels didn't with double cleansing with the one product. But I also, only have my mid-afternoon application so I can't speak to heavy sunscreen.
She created her line to minimize the need for additional products. Multi ingredients in one step and you may not need them all based on your skin's needs and climate. Don't make esters seem like they don't work or aren't as good. I'm a sensitive skin type and can't handle the active form but love them all. I'm too oily at the moment for the serum and moisturizer in the morning.
Always do your research, and reach out to a brand with specific concerns because I didn't know I couldn't handle both and was ready to throw in the towels with the initial launch.
Flash Mask is by far my favorite because I saw results instantly. Proceed with caution on any skincare product. Start with 5 minutes and build up but do what your skin needs and can handle.
I dislike how everyone is like the products are expensive but you spend so much on 10 steps when you could have a simpler routine with multi-step ingredients in one. That's where the cost comes in. I'm currently just using the cleanser and flash mask.
I don't need the depuffer as I don't have redness or puffy skin but she created it for all the people wasting money on jade rollers and Jillian Dempsey’s t-bar tool. It's to use as a tool to quickly wooly product but you could easily do without it. She's said that plenty of times.
I think she's a dope educator and never told anybody to buy her line or it's better than anything else in the market. Just a true passion for fewer steps, and fewer products that don't irritate the skin and there is science to back up each ingredient.
A little tidbit, flash mask is strong so we don't overuse it. You only need the thinnest layer and less is more with every product she's created so far. I bought them with my hard-earned coins and will continue.
You used tret for two years before deciding is wasn't for you. Give Dr. Idriss’ products time to see if you yield results. Consistency over intensity. Results take a min of 16 weeks and that's being consistent.
While I appreciate your post, you are wrong on a few points.
1. I consistently used the products and have emptied almost all of them. 2. I have melasma and some sun spots, but they are not the worst because I am consistently using products to help them. The sun spot showed no sign of improving. 3. I said I like some of her products. I will always give fair and honest reviews, and I’m sorry if others love her and every product, but that wasn’t my experience. 4. I don’t mind expensive if they work.
I won’t keep going, but just want to point these out. Please remember this was my experience and everyone’s skin is different. It’s ok if you love her products and I think they’re so-so. Not everything is for everyone.
@@DanaRipperton Thank you for letting us know you did use them up, Dana, I've seen so many creators just apply for a small amount of time and give negative feedback. I hope you find something better for your melasma that's gentle. Skincare is not so personal, and if my tone is aggressive I apologize, that was not my intention.
Totally get that! It takes me a long time to get to the point where I feel comfortable reviewing a brand and I should have done a better job explaining that and my method. Thanks for pointing that out, and I’ll be sure to do so for the next one 🩷 and with before and after pics. I’m terrible about that, but I will try to be better. Appreciate your feedback
I recently swapped over to this range from using SK-II for over a decade. I’m loving the full range. I have mature, dry skin which is very sun damaged. I’ve seen great results and follow her tabled application guidance which actually only has the flash mask twice per week. My only complaint is that I’d like larger sizes for the serum and moisturiser as you get through those quicker than the other products. Only a small amount of the cleanser takes everything off (sunscreen which gets reapplied plus or minus added makeup) at the end of the day but your skin still feels soft and non stripped (I use the prequel glenser after the gym in the morning before my morning Dr Idriss range). I’m very impressed with the full range and despite having to ship it internationally thus making it more expensive I’ve already repurchased the full range and plan on doing so as it’s been such an easy and seamless transition and a routine that is not time consuming nor complicated yet yields great results..
Glad that it’s working for you 🩷
@@natrodsjo8324 I love the serum and agree that it would be great to get it in a larger size. I bet the Idriss products seem cheap after a decade of SK-II 😂
I agree with you.
The ONLY product, which helped to reduce the appearance of the lentigo (also called liver spots) on my skin is Major fade hyper serum from Dr Idriss!!
I am buying it again and again from USA… Dr Idriss is a very honest dermatologist, I learned a lot from her and upgraded my skincare with products,which really work!
Glad that it works for you!
Is everyone forgetting she is an actual dermatologist with her own practice and not just an influencer. She has funded all of her own products and testing so that’s does justify the price…
No one is forgetting, but she sure does lean into the influencer aspect reaaaal heavily. As for price, people are allowed to think they are cost too much. Not all products are for everyone and that’s ok
@@DanaRipperton She spent 10 years studying and another two years on extensive medical research. You are coming across as very ignorant and bitchy! Not your best look.
What was the newish La Roche Posay product that you mentioned? I don’t see the link for it- thanks☺️
The mela B3 serum?
@@DanaRipperton yes that’s it- thanks
I personally don’t think Dr Idriss products are overpriced. Keep in mind the percentage matters and if you look at the Paula’s choice products and others are about the same price. When it comes to skin care I think is what fits your skin needs.
All dermatologist influencer's brands on social media, I automatically ignore them when they present their products. They ALWAYS try to make us feel like their products are unique, better and magical but none are. They are literally not better than what I use from the drugstore. I am not saying they are not good tho. They might be very good but not better. Actually, brands from drugstores as La roche Posay, Cetaphil, Aveeno, Eucerin etc etc are all developed from Dermatologists too. Reason why the majority of people still buy the basics at the drugstores (cleanser/moisturizer/spf) even tho ordering online is popular. Drugstore's products are a go to.
Dermatologists are endorsed to promote these brands, some Dermatologists may have be involved in the process of creation of those products. But at the end of the day, they are always formulated by cosmetic chemists, or pharmacists ( in France where I live) and not Dermatologists and they are not developed by Dermatologists. If you don't have the final word to a product it's not fair to say that. But their marketing team knows what to do. What matters the most is who owns the brand. They are the one choosing which direction the brand should take, which includes the image, the purpose, the ingredients, the pricing, the trends or lack of trends. The owner is the one truly developing the brand and the brands you named are not owned by Dermatologists. I don't think that Dermatologists brands are automatically better because at the end of the day like any cosmetic brands their choice in ingredients is the same since they are not medecine but inci ingredients. And pharmacists or cosmetic chemists specialised in this field know better how to formulate a product in order to make it work from choosing the right ingredients, how to get the right pleasing texture or the right PH, the right combination of preservatives, ingredients that are compatible, the right packaging for a formula... Dermatologists don't know all of that since they are specialized in the medical way of treating a patient.
The depuffer has become a staple in my morning skincare routine. It really does reduce puffiness in my eyes. That's mainly why I use it. For the redness, I didn't notice much change.
I like the tips we get from dermatologists on YT. Dr. Dray, for example, is very technical and I appreciate that. I don't think they want to do us harm in any way. What I take with a grain of salt are their recommendations. Even when they are not sponsored, come on, they get a buck if we buy the products they are mentioning. They are always the same in every channel. It sounds just like PR. And I say that because none of the products they recommend are actually the products that my dermatologist/cosmetic chemist gave me to save my skin. Absolutely none of them. Same ingredients, but in effective percentages.
Thank you for taking time to review Dr. Idriss's products. I use all of them and have seen results with all. I do like them quite a bit and will continue to purchase the flash mask, soft wash, and moisturizer. I'm not sure about the serum but will stick with it for a bit longer. I think you have to be consistent for a while with any over the counter product that helps with dark spots. I have noticed a slight improvement with my dark spots; however, mine are tough. I've used lasers and it got rid of a lot of my milasma but not all. The last bit has been a bit tough to get rid of!
So glad to hear they are working for you!! 🤗
Social media dermatologist are soooo tough on other brands, then they come out with their own products and none of them make sense?? I trust Dr. Sam and that's it!
Hahahaha very good point!
Dr Shereene Idriss is the sole funding agent of her skincare line. She talks about this extensively and explains it as the reason her products cost a little more...whereas both Naturium and Prequel are backed by the Center so they churn out the products and the prices are lower. I definitely enjoy several products from both brands as well.
I enjoy watching Dr Idriss's channel tho and adore her authenticity overall.
However , I'd be disingenuous if I didn't say I'm kinda sick of EVERY video of hers being used as a vehicle to hawk only her own products anymore. She used to give great suggestions and recommendations for a variety of skincare concerns but now everything she talks about boils down to evening out the skin tone as the end all and thus a springboard for her to tout her own products over everything else (because her products all focus on evening out the skin tone).
I love the soft wash and actually prefer it over the gleanser as the gleanser to me has an odd odor. Both are wonderful cleansers tho.
Also enjoy the hyper serum, the gel cream and the arnica/niacinamide roller. Sadly, I can't use her flash mask because of its high concentration of tranexamic acid and my prothrombin mutation. Bummer too as it seems to be her most loved product.
Appreciate your nuanced response 🩷 I really like the soft wash too and could see quite a few people preferring the texture over gleanser.
@@DanaRipperton I love the texture of both. The gleanser has a strange plastic-y odor to me for some reason.
I follow several derms on YT. I think it really became a thing during the pandemic. I've watched Dr Idriss grow her following from nothing and eventually launch her skincare line. Of course, she hawks her line, she funded it, and believes in it but what hasn't gone away is educating her followers. I disagree that she doesn't give recommendations about other lines, or drugstore budget products. I use her line but bc of the price I also use some of her budget-friendly recommendations. Every Saturday she posts a YT on a most requested topic from her comments. Take a look you'll see she is still true to herself.
I do think her products are overpriced but I’ve always said if someone wants to spend a lot on skincare for whatever reason its their money and they can do as they please but my issue with all these brands is them coming out with vitamin c products because i have high doubts that they even work especially when they add many other ingredients that do similar things as an actual stable l ascorbic acid product and being dermatologists it disappoints me that they push vitamin c as if its matters when formulation and the form of it matter more. Like you mentioned something that is proven to work like the c+e ferulic.
They’re really not overpriced when she funds her own business.
I have used all of these products and this review is pretty spot on.
Will you please review Dr. Kappel's mdaire line. There are no reviews on youtube that I can find. Thank you!
I’ll look into it but honestly never heard of it
You all must admit that Dr. Idriss looks FANTASTIC! She appears to have the most flawless skin (albeit with foundation etc)!
She definitely does, but I have to assume her being a Derm also means she has access to lots of other things other than just skincare (peels, lasers, etc). She looks great, but assuming it’s just from her skincare (that’s only been out a year or two) is definitely part of the problem. Kinda like if people assume Kim K. has her skin from just her skincare line alone. Just a thought 🤗
@@DanaRipperton Yes, I agree with you! She does appear to have great genetics as well, but to NEVER have Acne, Melasma, etc or any other skin condition is pretty rare (like 1-10%) of the population!
Thanks for this review! It seems to me that the best product is the peel. I think it’s really worth the price for such a sophisticated product!
Really love the peel and the cleanser is very nice, but obvi I love my gleanser even more
I will stick with the Axis-Y Dark Spot Corrector and Timeless Vitamin C. I'm seeing a slow but noticeable improvement on the sun spots on my cheeks.
Is it good?
@WaffleRedondo Yes, the Axis-Y product seemed to accelerate the lightening of my dark spots after using Vit C for months. I've started to use the Axis-Y on old dark scars to see if they can be lightened too. I just started doing that this week, so no results yet.
thanks for the review! what are your favorite OTC products for brightening and hyperpigmentation?
Vit C and I’ve been using the new LaRoche Posay Mela B3
I think you meant melasma can't be cured. It can be treated by OTC products.
Yes! Thank you!
@@DanaRipperton You're welcome 🙂
I really love the bright pink tube "Softwash" that she makes but it is somewhat more expensive than my usual CeraVe Face wash for normal to dry skin! I've been using that and Cetaphil since around 1980 and it is about half as much as the Softwash (about $30.00 per tube). I also use the Depuffer but it can be somewhat drying for my Rosacea-prone skin! But it works!
I love the major fade and the mask. To me, the serum is the best one yet, I've seen so much improvement in terms of hyperpygmentation, it's got great ingredients and yes, it's pricey but works well. I suffer from acne hyperpigmentation and it's awesome. In addition, I suggest that you do more research in terms of vitamin C and esthers, not all people can tolerate ascorbic acid hence the reason she used THD as the esther form on her moisturizer so to minimize the sensitivity, she's explained this multiple times. It's ok to have your own experiences and opinions but it's disrespectful not to get to know the brand before trying it and posting about it.
I’m not sure you watched the video. I most certainly tried it for multiple months. Having opinions that differ from yours is ok
What’s the “gleanser” you use?
It’s the Prequel gleanser. I added a link in the description. I also have a full video on Prequel
I have seen much results with the serum. The moisturizer is great but i don't need it. I need something richer. The mask is nice and brightening but doesn't do much dor my spots
I bought her stuff once and it was nice but it didn’t lighten my skin like they promised. It’s a nice moisturizer light and nice under makeup but that’s all. I can’t use glycolic acid so maybe that’s why but they said it would still work. I won’t buy it again too expensive for just moisturizing
@@piercingtheveil40 try prequel and remedy from Dr shah
Social media dermatologists are my go to for skincare consultation and advices. Its educational and practical.
But their own skincare line up is another story though.
I have the moisturizer and it's pilling! Also, didn't notice much difference after using it all
Are you using other products underneath? Could be related to that. Also, you’re not going to see changes quickly with almost any skincare product. Takes a long time!
@@DanaRipperton nope, just a toner underneath. I used it during the day instead of vitamin C serum+moisturizer. But as you said in the video, this form of vitamin C is not very potent. So I finished it because it wasn’t cheap, but didn’t like it
@@blondebot Totally get that! Hate when they pill!
I have a comment on the morning face wash... I would agree that it's not necessary if you wash your hair every evening and don't use hair products to bed. And also if you replace your pillow case every couple of days. Otherwise it will make sense to wash your face in the morning.
Most skincare professionals would disagree. Unless you need to for a skin-related reason, washing with water is sufficient. Of course now for everyone, but for the most part we don’t need to disrupt our moisture barrier more
@@DanaRipperton Yes, I do agree with stripping the barrier. There are ultra gentle washes out there though...
I'm just saying that hair oils, hair products and skincare products transferring to the pillowcase make it not such a clean place that you want to leave on your face skin all day next day.
For example, I have a hair product that I would put on in the evening after the shower. It's one of those Korean leave in sprays for scalp health... I absolutely love it on my hair, but I noticed I would sometimes wake up with a mild dermatitis on my cheeks. So now I only put it on in the morning. Might be the essential oils that it contains.
I’m sorry to hear that! Dermatitis is never fun. In your case, I would agree, washing might be good. I think my overall argument is more that plain water should be fine for most people and for normal debris that may get on your face at night. Of course there are always exceptions 🤗
Trying to understand the “Instagram dermatologist, which I never thought I would be saying that” comment. She a dermatologist that produces educational videos, is that a bad thing or am I misreading your tone?
It’s definitely not a bad thing, but it is part of her story, hence why I called it out.
Can you review the curology over the counter dark spot serum?
Will look into it🙂
you look incredibly glowy gorgeous!! what base were you using??
Thank you 🥰 I always list any makeup I wear in the description. For the glow, it’s more where I live and my skin type than the products I used 🤣
I completely agree with you on the flash mask. It is sooo zippy, wow! I put it on while I am in bath....miserable!!! lol Next time I will wait for my face to be really dry.
Hahahah yep, gotta be careful with it 😬🤣
This line seems so overpriced for a cocktail of ingredients that are already in so many products on the market for less. Remedy dark spot serum has a slew of other additional ingredients and is $30 less! plus great formula and packaging
Which La Roche Posay are you talking about?
I’ve added it in the description 🤗 under the products I mentioned
Its funny because she is also on TH-cam and she just did a review of that Laroche Posay serum and she said she didn’t like it.
you should do Stratia next!
Good idea!
I think you misunderstand the Depuffer--it is to help with puffiness, not redness, which are different things. Puffiness has to do with fluid retention, seasonal allergies (rather than contact allergies), can also be caused by some medications. That is why it has a metal roller--to help with cooling and drainage of fluid. Redness has more to do with irritation, rosaecea, etc. You kept referring to redness and how you don't have redness, but that is not the point of the product. Also I agree that the serum is overpriced, but you do get a full 30mL which is standard (because you get two 15ml in each package) so your math on that was wrong.
I don't misunderstand the point of a de-puffer, I just was more focused on the formula than the device. The device is nothing revolutionary. Thanks for pointing out the difference though!
@@twlee1930 the depuffer literally says “Redness-Reducing Serum” on the front of the package. That said, I’m not sure it’s done much to help my redness & I’m almost done with my 2nd tube :/
Unfortunately I gave up on the hyper serum as I couldn’t justify the price for the amount you get. I used it consistently for a year and seen absolutely no results. It just felt really nice on my skin that’s all 🤷♀️ I also had the vitamin C moisturizer included which also felt so nice and light on my combination skin however just like the serum, it did absolutely nothing for me. If I’m going to be spending my money on a product that just feels nice, there are plenty of options out there for a fraction of the price!
Very fair review, thank you. I had the same experience. Very nice products, not much result. Too expensive for no results.
@Dr.Idriss Her face wash is so amazing! I no longer have to remove my make up before washing my face! Its eye safe and Im able to safely removes my eye make up and prevent stys which I historically struggled with .
Glad it works for you!
You should try Remedy by dr Shah next!
I have some! Will be testing soon🥳
What are your credentials? For the way you are disrespecting liscensed doctor you cant just be a skincare influenser, right?
Why are you so mad? It’s just an opinion.
Oh geesh. Dana is simply giving her opinion of the products. She literally explains that at the beginning of this video.
I was so excited when she announced she was coming out with a line. Then, I looked at the prices and my excitement was gone! Thank you for this review, though. It's truly useful! Ps. you are STUNNING Dana!
Yeah, the prices are pretty steep. And thank you, so sweet of you
The flash mask is all i bought
Love brand reviews! Brands i would be interested Peach and lily, Equalrxn, Remedy, then i met you… and many more ;) 😅
Her name is pronounced E-Driss not I-Driss. I follow her here on TH-cam 😄
👍🏼
Personally I think you should always take a stand no matter if they still are gonna sell it anyways. It still makes a difference, but thanks for sharing where you stand, since you’re “below taking a stand”
Everyone has different thresholds for when they take a stand on something. What's important to me might not matter to you, and vice versa. Social media controversies aren't high on my list since anyone can post anything about others, whether it's true or not.
To each their own. I 100% agree with @nickimontie here and just don’t want to waste my time on social media controversies.
Please review Untoxicated Skincare.
Amazing review! I also love the glenser, it has ruined most cleansers for me. I hope you reviews Remedy from Dr Shaw soon
Thank you! Yes! I have 2 Remedy products so I just need to get through some other products I’m using first so I can test them 🤗
Thank you for your honesty. We need more people like you! I'm so glad I found your channel.
I don’t trust YT or IG dermatologist. I can’t take them seriously.
Exactly. Real derms and doctors are doing the hard work everyday away from the social media glare.
@@drc4168why can’t she be both ? She IS doing the work everyday still with the hundreds of patients she sees. I don’t understand this take
@@TrappedQue More info is always great. Dr Dray & Dr Idriss have helped me cure my acne that I’ve been dealing with for 10 years. No derms in my area have been successfull in this.
She is board certified dermatolohist with a practice in NY
Gimmick
She drives me nuts! There's no way i would support her line. I had to stop following her because it just felt soooo condescending when she was speaking/educating. Also, her smacking her hand down while "educating" was just obnoxious. I moved from her channel and never looked back. Lol, the price point is ridiculous for OTC products . Thanks for reviewing