Happy to see someone demo the realistic limitations of this tool. TH-cam videos too often show Adobe-friendly demos with perfect results. For my money, I’d rather see Adobe rewriting their software to optimize for modern hardware rather than incrementally improving these gimmicky features.
A good frank tutorial ..........you shared your frustrations ........I'm unsure if these "improvements" will stand the test of time. .......... a good straightforward tutorial!
I am sure I am the odd man out, but, it was nice to see a pro like you have problems with PS. So often the video works like magic and my life was more like your video today! Thank you!
Hey PHLEARN I never stop searching for you on youtube and finally I have found you. Thank you very much for taking me through great tutorials in 2017 and am happy to tell you that I have also use the approaches and am starting my youtube channel. I never thought I will get there.
Great demonstration, all the better for being ‘real’ and showing it not quite working. The techniques you used to work around this were just as informative. Thanks
Aaron, honestly I really enjoy learning with you, your tutorial was great. Especially when your debuting new subject matter, I find that your very thorough in presenting key information in the short time you have. Due to Covid-19 my wife and I have been staying inside spring cleaning, taking care of much needed upgrades I'm almost caught up, going forward I'll been spending a portion of my free time trying to improve on my photoshop skills. It's nice to know that you guy's do what you do, please take good care of yourselves and stay safe, thank you for sharing this information.
Appreciate your candor in showing strengths and limitations of the updated tool. I use it more than the prior version and see improvements. With more complex backgrounds, making several smaller selections seems to help. Some clone and healing needed to complete the job.
Ha. I hadn't even noticed they updated that tool. I'll probably use it now. If it can do 90% of the work on a messy shot, and all I need is a little brush work here and there, then I'm all for it.
I think when you combine it with the AI powered object selection tool (or preciser manual lasso selections), you can get great results with this. If you treat it like the old content aware fill with the old selection tools available you're not using it to your full potential. Love to see more videos about these new 2020 features.
Glad adobe is leaning towards A.I. software and they need to refine it better like other software.. I love the clone stamp tool and I also love saving time in my workflow.
The old ways are still the best. With these new automated tools you usually spend more time figuring out how to refine and improve it than if you'd just dived in and done it manually. And c'mon, making selections isn't exactly the hardest job in the world anyway.
Thanks for the vid. I did not even realize the new tool was there as I had just been right clicking my selections and hitting fill, and then selecting content aware. The new options are interesting, will have to play with them a bit.
I think it is great to have more tools than less. It's just like carpentry tools, you don't have to use all your tools all the time but every once in a while that unique job comes up where that one particular tool does the job better and easier. Even if the tool doesn't do a perfect job 100% of the time it could still get you a long way toward your objective leaving only a small amount of tweaking. Plus, there is not an add-on fee for the tool so why not have it available? Thanks for sharing your thoughts, Aaron.
Heh, I agree with there being still significant limitations to this tool - but this video made me feel like you could have gotten better results by refining your selection from within the tool, by fading/expanding/reducing it. But I also agree with the others here saying that it's great you're showing things as they are, and not making it look like black magic like some other TH-camrs! On a personal note, ever since I learned how to better use the clone stamp I actually use these automatic tools way less than I used to, but I still think they're exceptionally effective when used with a bit of patience!
Congrats for your video, but a huge question here: how to apply Content Aware Fill in 16-bit? I mean, I knew that any active selection reduces the bit-depth to 8-bit. So, is there a way to use Content Aware Fill without selecting an active area? Thanks in advance.
Yes, this feature helps a lot. As anything in this world, we can't just give a task to a robot or an AI that ambiguous. This technology still need human intelligence to do exactly what we want flawlessly. 1st, by giving an exact command, in this case is by providing a good selection to begin with. 2nd, by providing a relevant data to sample. Photoshop is only giving you some more option to help you. And that's pretty cool and useful. We can't just expect an instant 1 click of a button to fix every case. In the end of the day, user's understanding, preference workflow is still the key to achieve the best result. some case are just better and faster to do it with manual clone stamp tool, some case are just better and faster to use healing or spot healing, and even using brush. This feature is not meant to replace the old tools, it's just another option. To me, this is progress is still a great step to the right direction. Of course there are still rooms for improvement, but so far this is pretty darn amazing. Anyway, thank you Aaron and Phlearn for always providing a great photoshop content. Have a nice day :)
Played with it tonight (my Google searches probably led to your video being suggested) but ended up using clone stamp. Maybe give it another try after watching this. Thanks.
I love that they are taking the steps utilising AI for those tasks that no one wants to do too often. Even though the results aren't close to perfect just yet. Also, I wouldn't mind if Adobe adds an option to send image and selection data to their servers (without personal information), so it actually turns into a data set the AI can learn from. (It just needs to be easy to turn off again when working on top-secret client projects. 🤫)
Actually I just noticed you do not have an APPLY button. I take it this was this added later. Currently watching video end of May 2020. Seems to be a learning curve. I selected first area , duplicate layer then apply to stay in dialogue box. Use losso (tool top right corner ) to select new area with current layer. Edit is merged on the now duplicate layer. Auto selects new collection area around it , but custom needs to have any previous collection area removed and repainted if not suitable. Yes thanks for a real tutorial. Not sure how much I'll use this as I tend to be a healing brush tool / clone stamp tool user.
How do we know how much extra space around object to be replaced, to include in our initial selection? I notice you include a relatively generous amount...Thanks!
Great feature! That preview dialogue box isn't popping up for me after selecting content aware scale in the edit menu. I get a box around my selection.
Thanks for your great tuturial. I tried doing it and ended with the area being replaced as “foggy” or sort of transparent. How do I adjust the opacity?
I used to use content aware every day. The new one 2020 just is NOT working for me. I keep on getting an error message that says, "Could not fill because there are not enough source pixel on the selected layer." Any ideas? When I click on ok, it closes the content aware window, so I cannot even use the custom tool or the rectangle or auto. It closes down and kicks me out. UGHhhhhhhh
I liked the video overall. Towards the end you kind of shut us all out when you brought in the new layer and then stopped teaching. I would have liked to understand what you did on the new layers.
I continue to wonder about the integrity of content removal (and cloning, for that matter). What shots can we clean up, and what should we leave alone?
I cant even brush with the new photoshop. It gets all weird and stops. I have a pretty good computer but it just cant handle it. Photoshop keeps getting bigger but they need to stop making it so big that my goof computer cant handel it anymore. Its annoying and I can not work properly. Not even that good of an update
As with most tool "upgrades' Adobe manage to over complicate whereas the tool was fine in it's more primitive state. There are plenty of other ways to do the same job. Don't think I'll be using this much!
It f-ed up the horizon line. I am a little disappointed - the old fill-in was doing a pretty good job as well and it's pretty old in terms of in-painting technology.
It looks like you phoned this review in. You didn't seem to use it correctly or in a way a real pro would do. You should have made those cutouts tighter. Spend an extra 10 second getting a better cutout instead of fiddling with other options.
No improvement at all in regards to the AI Adobe Sense except for the custom button. We expect more from Adobe sense like what Skylum did in Luminar 4 AI Enhancement and AI sky replacement. Unfortunately, Adobe lately becomes more money oriented rather than creativity oriented.
This is not AI. AI is when the computer figures out how to do something by itself, this is just an algorithm coded by a human to do something a 3 year old could do, so its not THAT intelligent either.
I see no reason/value for that large video of yourself? You're hogging valuable screen real estate.Your demonstrations are much smaller than they could be. I'm not sure why you think we need to see you at all?When you show the layers panel. You are literately devoting over 25% of the screen to You.......from left to right. I want to see the examples/what you're doing.Not you drawing on your pad.I can't learn a thing watching you work at your desk. The layers panel could be easily reduced by around 80%. Without the layers panel, you still hog almost 25% of the screen from left to right. I like your content, I've been away for a while.I find this newer "look at me" format as overkill, without value.
Great to see a Pro struggle with some of the tools. Thanks for an honest tutorial!
Happy to see someone demo the realistic limitations of this tool. TH-cam videos too often show Adobe-friendly demos with perfect results. For my money, I’d rather see Adobe rewriting their software to optimize for modern hardware rather than incrementally improving these gimmicky features.
A good frank tutorial ..........you shared your frustrations ........I'm unsure if these "improvements" will stand the test of time. .......... a good straightforward tutorial!
I love your tutorials!!!!!!!
Very helpful. Thank you for sharing the issues that you had. VERY Helpful
It’s a test, guys, not a tutorial. He tested and showed us the weaknesses of the tool.
super clean super clear LOVE IT ❤️❤️
I am sure I am the odd man out, but, it was nice to see a pro like you have problems with PS. So often the video works like magic and my life was more like your video today! Thank you!
Great tutorial Nate.
super helpful and real thanks!
Hey PHLEARN I never stop searching for you on youtube and finally I have found you. Thank you very much for taking me through great tutorials in 2017 and am happy to tell you that I have also use the approaches
and am starting my youtube channel. I never thought I will get there.
Thanks for taking the time to show us this! This helped me as a beginner to photoshop
Great demonstration, all the better for being ‘real’ and showing it not quite working. The techniques you used to work around this were just as informative. Thanks
Aaron, honestly I really enjoy learning with you, your tutorial was great. Especially when your debuting new subject matter, I find that your very thorough in presenting key information in the short time you have. Due to Covid-19 my wife and I have been staying inside spring cleaning, taking care of much needed upgrades I'm almost caught up, going forward I'll been spending a portion of my free time trying to improve on my photoshop skills. It's nice to know that you guy's do what you do, please take good care of yourselves and stay safe, thank you for sharing this information.
Thank you! This helped so much, xoxo
Pretty hard to see this as an improvement on the previous version...
Appreciate your candor in showing strengths and limitations of the updated tool. I use it more than the prior version and see improvements. With more complex backgrounds, making several smaller selections seems to help. Some clone and healing needed to complete the job.
Ha. I hadn't even noticed they updated that tool. I'll probably use it now. If it can do 90% of the work on a messy shot, and all I need is a little brush work here and there, then I'm all for it.
good video I have this program and like it a lot thank you for your video it was very helpful
I think when you combine it with the AI powered object selection tool (or preciser manual lasso selections), you can get great results with this. If you treat it like the old content aware fill with the old selection tools available you're not using it to your full potential.
Love to see more videos about these new 2020 features.
I'm not sure if any of this is new in mac. But this functions are all on PS last version on windows.
Complicating a previously simple process. I guess it will become simple again with practice. Thanks for sharing.
Adobe keep up the good work , everyday photoshop keeps getting better and most of all thank you Aron
Thank you, very much! Very nice feature!
Glad adobe is leaning towards A.I. software and they need to refine it better like other software.. I love the clone stamp tool and I also love saving time in my workflow.
The old ways are still the best. With these new automated tools you usually spend more time figuring out how to refine and improve it than if you'd just dived in and done it manually. And c'mon, making selections isn't exactly the hardest job in the world anyway.
Thanks for the vid. I did not even realize the new tool was there as I had just been right clicking my selections and hitting fill, and then selecting content aware. The new options are interesting, will have to play with them a bit.
I think it is great to have more tools than less. It's just like carpentry tools, you don't have to use all your tools all the time but every once in a while that unique job comes up where that one particular tool does the job better and easier. Even if the tool doesn't do a perfect job 100% of the time it could still get you a long way toward your objective leaving only a small amount of tweaking. Plus, there is not an add-on fee for the tool so why not have it available? Thanks for sharing your thoughts, Aaron.
The closer you can lasso your target area, then the closer your sampling area can be, which usually makes for a better result
nice tutorial from victor! hello brother come on lets get this project done bro
Heh, I agree with there being still significant limitations to this tool - but this video made me feel like you could have gotten better results by refining your selection from within the tool, by fading/expanding/reducing it. But I also agree with the others here saying that it's great you're showing things as they are, and not making it look like black magic like some other TH-camrs!
On a personal note, ever since I learned how to better use the clone stamp I actually use these automatic tools way less than I used to, but I still think they're exceptionally effective when used with a bit of patience!
Congrats for your video, but a huge question here: how to apply Content Aware Fill in 16-bit? I mean, I knew that any active selection reduces the bit-depth to 8-bit. So, is there a way to use Content Aware Fill without selecting an active area? Thanks in advance.
Great and professional, as always
Yes, this feature helps a lot. As anything in this world, we can't just give a task to a robot or an AI that ambiguous. This technology still need human intelligence to do exactly what we want flawlessly. 1st, by giving an exact command, in this case is by providing a good selection to begin with. 2nd, by providing a relevant data to sample. Photoshop is only giving you some more option to help you. And that's pretty cool and useful. We can't just expect an instant 1 click of a button to fix every case. In the end of the day, user's understanding, preference workflow is still the key to achieve the best result. some case are just better and faster to do it with manual clone stamp tool, some case are just better and faster to use healing or spot healing, and even using brush. This feature is not meant to replace the old tools, it's just another option. To me, this is progress is still a great step to the right direction. Of course there are still rooms for improvement, but so far this is pretty darn amazing. Anyway, thank you Aaron and Phlearn for always providing a great photoshop content. Have a nice day :)
Great video, Aaron. Nice to see you struggle just a bit, like the rest of us. But I totall Phlearned stuff!
Muchas gracias Aaron!!!
I like it, with reservations.
Played with it tonight (my Google searches probably led to your video being suggested) but ended up using clone stamp. Maybe give it another try after watching this. Thanks.
Now this is a vast improvement of this tool!
I love that they are taking the steps utilising AI for those tasks that no one wants to do too often. Even though the results aren't close to perfect just yet.
Also, I wouldn't mind if Adobe adds an option to send image and selection data to their servers (without personal information), so it actually turns into a data set the AI can learn from. (It just needs to be easy to turn off again when working on top-secret client projects. 🤫)
Actually I just noticed you do not have an APPLY button. I take it this was this added later. Currently watching video end of May 2020. Seems to be a learning curve. I selected first area , duplicate layer then apply to stay in dialogue box. Use losso (tool top right corner ) to select new area with current layer. Edit is merged on the now duplicate layer. Auto selects new collection area around it , but custom needs to have any previous collection area removed and repainted if not suitable. Yes thanks for a real tutorial. Not sure how much I'll use this as I tend to be a healing brush tool / clone stamp tool user.
thank you
How do we know how much extra space around object to be replaced, to include in our initial selection? I notice you include a relatively generous amount...Thanks!
thnx dude
thanks
Great feature! That preview dialogue box isn't popping up for me after selecting content aware scale in the edit menu. I get a box around my selection.
thank you :)
Thanks for your great tuturial. I tried doing it and ended with the area being replaced as “foggy” or sort of transparent. How do I adjust the opacity?
I am happy for the upgrade but my beaten paths will take some time to widen.
TY, it will improve
I'm using a mouse with this feature and it appears way blotchy. Is this because I'm not using a pressure sensitive stylus?
Horizon on the second one is still pretty bad Aaron... ;-)
OMG THANK YOU! I'm cc on Sims 4 and they put bunnys on everything :D
I do not understand how splashes were moved 10:57. If someone got it could you please explain.
Would be easier to just clone stamp that surfing image
it is awesome
GooD Job
I used to use content aware every day. The new one 2020 just is NOT working for me. I keep on getting an error message that says, "Could not fill because there are not enough source pixel on the selected layer." Any ideas? When I click on ok, it closes the content aware window, so I cannot even use the custom tool or the rectangle or auto. It closes down and kicks me out. UGHhhhhhhh
Hey Aaron, can you add a feather to the content-aware selection? That might help take away the harsh edges. Great video
Within the dialogue box the lasso tool now has all the options normally available including feather.
Can this same concept be applied in Affinity Photo?
I liked the video overall. Towards the end you kind of shut us all out when you brought in the new layer and then stopped teaching. I would have liked to understand what you did on the new layers.
Is better but not perfect, with some help from others tools after is fine.Nice tut as always.
good video
How to watch Phlearn videos:
Step 1: like the video
Step 2: then watch the video
Same or similar function to Healing Brush tool and Clone stamp
Plz do a video on How to make low key images in photoshop
excellent!
I can't do it ? Why is that
Whatever happened to not getting the picture?
The simple image is an image from my country, Greenland! *_*
always love it when it works and despise it when it fails and I have to spend time getting it right the old way. Guess i am just a bit lazy?
Thanks from Iraq
Perfect!!!!!
Nothing wrong with the old clone brush. Doesn't seem much of an improvement to me.
In another timeline you just made a power outage in a small coastal village!
Great Kermit the frog impression
Ah, yes, brother
I continue to wonder about the integrity of content removal (and cloning, for that matter). What shots can we clean up, and what should we leave alone?
I cant even brush with the new photoshop. It gets all weird and stops. I have a pretty good computer but it just cant handle it. Photoshop keeps getting bigger but they need to stop making it so big that my goof computer cant handel it anymore. Its annoying and I can not work properly. Not even that good of an update
Thank you Sir.
It is very good Video for me.
As with most tool "upgrades' Adobe manage to over complicate whereas the tool was fine in it's more primitive state. There are plenty of other ways to do the same job. Don't think I'll be using this much!
You are adorable, Aaron. Not in a I think you're cute kinda way, just an I wanna smoosh your cheeks kinda way 🤭🤣
Didn't know Tony Stark is using Photoshop
It f-ed up the horizon line. I am a little disappointed - the old fill-in was doing a pretty good job as well and it's pretty old in terms of in-painting technology.
Good demo except when you suddenly leaped to "color range" and completely lost me.
I like the tool and I like using AI. AI can be continually updated and improved.
I HATE power & phone lines, utility poles, etc.
It will be a significantly life-prolonging experience if only Adobe gets chosen to put the "A.I." into Boston Dynamics Robots.
Is it really necessary to introduce yourself in each and every video for all those years again and again?
اول تعليق 🌹🤣
This text is not fully content aware
🙌🏻⚡️💪🏻💥💻👏🏻
It looks like you phoned this review in. You didn't seem to use it correctly or in a way a real pro would do. You should have made those cutouts tighter. Spend an extra 10 second getting a better cutout instead of fiddling with other options.
Hate it, I liked the old version better.
This is the least useful update imo
No improvement at all in regards to the AI Adobe Sense except for the custom button. We expect more from Adobe sense like what Skylum did in Luminar 4 AI Enhancement and AI sky replacement. Unfortunately, Adobe lately becomes more money oriented rather than creativity oriented.
This is not AI. AI is when the computer figures out how to do something by itself, this is just an algorithm coded by a human to do something a 3 year old could do, so its not THAT intelligent either.
I hate this now!!!!! Its soooooo much more work. It does a horrible job even when you choose areas to use.
This new version really sucks!! Too over and too complicated makes it become more stupid than before!!
I see no reason/value for that large video of yourself? You're hogging valuable screen real estate.Your demonstrations are much smaller than they could be. I'm not sure why you think we need to see you at all?When you show the layers panel. You are literately devoting over 25% of the screen to You.......from left to right. I want to see the examples/what you're doing.Not you drawing on your pad.I can't learn a thing watching you work at your desk. The layers panel could be easily reduced by around 80%. Without the layers panel, you still hog almost 25% of the screen from left to right. I like your content, I've been away for a while.I find this newer "look at me" format as overkill, without value.
Well, Obviously its nice video. But try to make it short as possible without. I think you can made this video 6 or 7 minutes. I just my opinion.