I was disfellowshipped for speaking to the elders. I told them that I had studied and found out the false doctrines that tje GB teaches. I wasn't specific on what exactly but I told them I had notes and I could prove to them. Next thing I get a call from an elder and tells me I would be disfellowshipped. They didn't even asked me what I thought was false, they didn't even want to hear it😢
That's terrible. And I'm hearing that basic response from elders in many life experiences of ex-JW's and their kangaroo court judicial committees. It' s all over TH-cam. Like Brother Wilson says here, they can't defend their positions with scripture, only man made rules in their elder book.
When I was studying with them, after a while, I decided not to get baptized Because, I was taught that, if I think any differently from the witnesses, I would be disfellowshipped I had to keep my mouth shut when it came to dating, for example I was 21 when I stopped attending meetings altogether It's a good thing I never got baptized Because, I would keep questioning them, and they would scold me
@cheneethompson5756 A brother that was studying with my husband straight out told him that if he wanted to become a JW he needled to obey the GB no matter what. And that he didn't hve to question anything because they were Jehovahs annointed people🤨. And that he had to trust them regardless. In that moment my husband knew he will have nothing to do with them. Unfortunately, it took me many more years to wake up and stand my ground. Jesus is my only Lord & Savior. Not a human nor an organization
@sallyAP exactly! Thanks for sharing! The governing body is always "the man" If a religious group tells you how to live, without question, it's not worth it
Excellent. Thank you for bringing up this subject. In the 70’s, when I was a JW, I didn’t even know there was a Governing Body. I truly believed it was all Jehovah. I never paid attention to an Organization. Now, it’s all about the Governing Body. That’s pretty much all that we hear. Wow. When did it happen. Slowly. Subtly. Pervasively. Thank you again for bringing this to our attention. And to think of those men treating their flock so harshly sickens me. I call them the collective “Wizard of Org”!❤
Yes. We never knew who the Governing Body was back then. A while back, Samuel Herd said in a talk that JW parents would urge their kids to write to the Governing Body. I was shocked.
Closer to the end, their falsehoods and evil wants become more readily apparent. Satan is indeed shrewd and sinister. He infiltrated the Organization, and like a frog, being boiled one degree at a time, slowly over time. Lucifer has cooked the organization and its membership. The lesson, Christ’s Church is whoever worships faithfully. They might reside in many “churches,” its membership among those who never met. Yet are united by their love for Christ, and their adherence to his Word.
@@thomassmart2790 The GB reminds of Luke 11:52: "Woe to you scribes and Pharisees! For you have taken away the key of knowledge. You did not enter in yourselves, and those who were entering in you hindered."
@@richlisola1this is also my point of view now. Many JWs are not my brothers because they do not act as real brothers towards me and my family, and many individuals amongst catholics , baptists, evangelists seem to have authentic love for fellow christians, even if they have doubts about their own organisations. We cannot judge anymore people on their religious affiliation, but on their personal faith and love
Good points outlined in an easy to understand manner. In 1999, I complained of what I regarded as excessively flattering praise of the UN's UNICEF arm, in the Awake magizine. Soon, I became aware of the WTB&TS actual joining of the UN as a non-govermetal organization. Also I complained of an inordinate amount of praise of Al Gores' environmental policies. This resulted in an uninvited visit to our home by the Elders. They asked why I was complaining. I answered the Holy Spirit, pointed this out to me, & it conflicts with my understanding of Christian neutrality in political affairs. They firmly asserted, " the governing body is the only source of information", & then demanded to know," was I loyal to them?" I answered, my spiritual loyalty is complete towards God, not to mortal men in New York City! They started to rebuke me in the strongest terms, when I interrupted their response, & unceremoniuosly ordered them out the door. I became free from their "spell" that day, & never looked back!
This is the sort of story that illustrates how a JW can be disfellowshipped for the slightest divergeance from the Governing Body's "information". Do they claim to be inspired by God. Oh, no, of course not. But can you disagree with them? No, of course not,... not unless you are ready for them to make your life miserable.
How did you find out about their dealing with the UN back then? I’m curious because I only became aware of it after many years later when more info was coming out online
Excellent video, I have debated with my JW family and debunked every article they have sent me and in the end they told me " It's a wonderful organization". I pray for my family to seek salvation through Christ rather than an organization.
@@joeldb That maybe true of others but not with Witnesses. I was one from 1970 -1991 and during that time I experienced teaching that don't make sense. Here are a few examples * 1975 Being the end of the system (Bible says nobody but the Father knows the day or hour) * Christ being just an angel * Doctrine around being annonited * Doctrine that says that a group of men are like the voice of Christ. * Doctrine that Christ came back invisibly and ruling in Heaven ( The Bible states signs and wonders and that all shall see him.) A flaw would be a misunderstanding ,crazy doctrine that goes against the bible that is something else.
It is a brutal indoctrination plus their use of subliminal messages; this sect practices sorceries (Revelation 18:23), idolatry, etc. The Bible tells us that that’s how the nations were deceived. Revelation 18:23; Revelation 12:9. That’s why the title Mother of the prostitutes fit its profile. Their followers are like drunk with all their false teachings and practices. Like Jesus said they are blinded by these wolves in sheep clothing. Matthew 23:15; Matthew 7:15-23; Matthew 15:14; Revelation 18:3-5; Revelation 17: 2-15; this man of lawlessness is so wicked 2 Thessalonians chapter 2; Revelation 18:24. That’s why we need the holy spirt . We need to continue praying for those who don’t have the holy spirt and are still trapped because they have been deceived regarding the holy spirt too. As Jesus said we are protected by the holy spirit. John 14:18-31; 16:13-15; Also 1 John 2:26-29 gives us the clue why the holy spirit is vital in our lives. Otherwise people will receive the mark of the beast Revelation 13; Revelation 17:2-17
@@joeldbExactly right! Each religion or even subset (denomination) is going to hell according to every other sect. It’s obvious to anyone who isn’t tied to any of them how foolish they are all.
Great job, Eric. Ex-elder, Bethelite here. So nice to see fellow elders like myself who don't just critique or criticize the organization, but do as the ancient Beroeans did, that is , "carefully examined the scriptures,....to see if things if these things were so." Acts 17: 11) Earlier in that same chapter of Acts, it was mentioned that the Apostle Paul "reasoned from the scriptures with them, explaining and proving by references, that it was necessary for the Christ to suffer, etc. etc." So yes, I will and have a scriptural defense ready to send the US Branch "explaining and proving by references" why the 3 clowns that were called "Elders" or a "judicial committee", should not only be removed as elders; but also removed from the congregation as slanderers! And yes, the organization of JW's have slowly and insidiously succumbed to the proddings of this self proclaimed "faithful and discreet slave"; effectively idolizing them as God's spokesman, incapable of error or mistakes! That is not the organization we grew up in is it my brother??!!! 😊🤔😝
My mom, in her 80s, was born and raised in “The Truth” and has her entire life vested in it and makes excuses for every questionable teaching. The Governing Body now has Papal level reverence and authority.
@butziporsche8646 My mom is not quite that age, but she’s spent more than half her life in the religion. I was a born in, served as an elder and left on own volition 2 yrs ago after catching WT in a blatant deception both in a WT article and their 2021 Annual Meeting. If I didn’t have those older publications in hand, I wouldn’t have known about the deception. That led me down a rabbit hole, b/c I’ve always been taught if someone lies about little things, there’s a good chance they’ve/they’ll lie about bigger things, & just wow. I attempted to have open & honest dialogue w/ both my parents, w/ my father being a fellow elder. I showed that the org teaches Jesus is not our mediator despite what the Bible says. I showed them a July 2011 WT article showing our obedience to them affects our salvation. I showed them where they removed the word worship from Jesus in the scriptures, & used the phrase “substitute for him” only in the NWT. I proved scripturally, archeologically, secularly, mathematically that 607 BCE is a false date made up. Literally none of that mattered; the only thing they were concerned with was how the friends viewed them, & it wasn’t my place to question The Faithful Slave. It was a very surreal & scary moment, and after hearing Lett say babies should be addressed as Little Enemies of God, & to hear the friends in the review say that was a good point they never thought about, I knew I had to leave.
Your words 'The friends wouldn't like it ' hit the nail on the head. That is what they are about. FEAR.... Fear is destructive across the board perhaps your parents are more PIMOs than you realise but are frightened of the backlash of false 'love'
Yes very much 'Class' system orientated. Become very worldly and papal status who must BE OBEYED 😠 Your life is patrolled in every detail and gossiped about they will break secular law to even try to discredit you Yes some like to have power and control to elevate themselves above the more humble ones.
My wife and father do the same, with the UN situation she said they must have a reason 🫣 I showed her the revelation book and asked who is that sitting on top of the UN building, she said false religion. I said exactly that you!
I was VERY VERY fortunately to have parents that pressed upon me, that the TRUTH had to be my own and to QUESTION EVERYTHING to ensure that the TRUTH was in MY HEART and MY OWN. I no longer attend meetings, but read the Scriptures, pray , even do my own little memorial service. I believe with ALL MY HEART in Jehovah and his ONLY begotten Son JESUS who was sent to SAVE us and show us the TRUE WAY OF WORSHIP. I still speak to some of my family and friends who are JW's (by the way I class myself as a JW as I witness about Jehovah and our King Christ Jesus) and make this observation: They speak LESS of Jehovah and JC than I do. When I ask, have you prayed to Jeh about your problems, or a view on world events...they ALWAYS refer back to what the ORGANISATION will say in due course to sort things out....AND cop this they are AMAZED and BEFUDDLED that I can love and speak about my faith so freely and NOT want to go to Meetings.....They Just DO NOT get it or UNDERSTAND ME. They think that because I refuse to attend now, that I have turned my back on Jeh, JC and the Scriptures and believe differently and have become oh so worldly...??? Yet unfortunately, I find them to have become less reliant upon the Word of God and faith in Jah than I have....I know I have a good heart condition and I trust in Jeh I JC with ALL MY HEART as I know the word of GOD is what is FAITHFUL and TRUE.....I watched the Royal Commission into Child Abuse here in Australia and I WEPT many tears !! I asked Jeh, how he could let this happen and be represented by such people who say they are his direct link to us here on earth....I know the answers will become apparent , ALL in Jehs good time. I know there are 10's of Thousands of us out there who WILL NOT give up the FAITH and did not deserve to be thrown aside and I know that in Gods heart and memory we sit awaiting the rule of his son JC and we will be blessed as will ALL THOSE who love God. ❤😊
Hi Sonia, you seem to live your faith in a very genuine and intimate way. I appreciate that so much and I fully understand you when you are confronted with people who didn’t seem to feel any faith in God anymore.
You described it so well, I'm exactly in that situation. I told the elders: 1. Jehovah's organisation never equals Jehovah. It was Jehovah's organisation that killed Jesus, let alone the modern day blunders. 2. Faithful slave that produces food or Arrogant Master that issues orders? 2 Co. 1:24 3. I have no human head as Jesus Christ is my head and mediator. 1 Co. 11:3 Jehovah is my shepherd, Jesus is my head/mediator/ransom and the Holy Spirit guides me into all the truth. Enjoy life forever
Amen to that sister! I was DF'd 2.5 years ago, and after 3 appeals for reinstatement and either ignored or denied for stupid who knows what" reasons; I wrote the Society an 18 page letter exposing these corrupted elders and their lack of using the scriptures as a basis for shunning me and asking my family and friends to do the same. At the end of that letter, I told them: "Listen, I'm going to serve Jehovah WITH OR WITHOUT THE ORGANIZATION; my spiritual head is Jesus Christ, not the self-proclaimed governing body! I've witnessed frequently to neighbors, friends, etc. and have placed literature and started Bible studies (using the Bible only with topical old books discussing scriptural views) since being DF'd. I have felt and seen the operation of God's spirit on me like never before; and have prayed relentlessly for God to stir up the courage of lovers of truth to remove authoritarian elders and to REMOVE THIS CURRENT SET OF MEN SERVING, TYRANNICAL, PHARISAICAL GOVERNING BODY. I see it moving in that direction as they scramble to change their man made rules to try and appear less strict with the members! And the nations of the world initiate one lawsuit after another!
Thank you brother Eric. Just excellent. Keep those videos coming. It's "real spiritual food" at the right time. The end is near for the watchtower. Many blessings from Jehovah God and Christ. Amador, Kingdom Christian from sunny Puerto Rico.
Their whole" bringing food in due season" is a parable.parable were always used to teaching around pharisisees and saducees not to the Church Age aka the church. So whole premise or foundation is faulty.
Thank you Brother - you adroitly describe a truly Pharisee-driven organization. Organized religion killed Jesus, even if by design. Escape is painful and the only way to the light. May all thrive by feasting on the WORD, to draw closer to Christ Jesus, The Way, The Truth and The Life as our only intercessor to our Heavenly Father. Amen 🙏
this has been one of the points i draw on in many of my videos. You have done a great job in this video. I would like to share a small protion of it on my LIVE. Just give me a heart if its okay.
What an exquisitely informative and quite enlightening video this is!! I was an elder before I left. I never gave this brilliant area a look. Great thanks Eric for your diligent videos. ❤️👍👏
Wrong Giv Bidy and elders are not God and we would never think of them as such. Only one true God Jehovah. I am with gratitude fir the GB and I live my religion. However, people who live the Trinity Doctrine even though it was never heard of until 400 yrs after Christ died have plenty of religions to choose from. If you like false religions then go for it.
@@LouiseWeber-b2m Of course you will say you do not see GB as god. No JW will say they treat GB as god, but in their subconsciousness, they do. The orders from the GB are just like the orders from your god.
Thank you Eric, OUTSTANDING WORD! Out of all those I do my best to listen to and test all things, you are the ONLY ONE that I can resonate with and fully respect. I greatly greatly appreciate you bro!
Thank you Eric for another insightful video. To everyone, FYI, the Org has not changed the "Revelation" book in the JW library on the website. I was really surprised! You would think they would want to hide that blatant lie of "bowing down".
Excellent talk Eric, I have gone through the fire. It is obvious the governing body class is a group of men who have run ahead, not waiting for the one inviting them to appoint them a seat, but have seated themselves in the highest position. . Everything that is elevated will be brought down when Jesus returns.
Thanks Eric Excellent . The number of rules within the organization is ridiculous and they keep flip flopping makes it clear that they are self appointed and the way the lieutenants (elders ) behave is obsessive . And I never felt safe around them either . How this situation developed over time is interesting and clever .
I only feel 100 % safe around "them". But not so much you and your demons. Making yourselves seeds of Satan. You are disgusting to Jehovah God and His people .
Great video. Idolatry of the GB for sure! We studied the Revelation Climax book 4 times. 1989, 1991, 1994 and 2007. It's not that I can actually remember it at all, however, you can look it up online. One of the few things not doctored lol.
I show 3 times, because in my book, I was a study conductor then and dated the start and stop points as we went thru the book. I don't show an '89; which makes sense because they released the book in '88. But not to argue over that; I did want to say too, that actually; I wish we would study that book every 5-6 years. The same holds true with the "Daniel" book, the "Word of God" book, and other deep prophecy examination books. Today's governing body and bodies of elders are feeding spiritually baby food and their own exaggerated opinions! I sometimes go to a meeting with my wife and I can't believe the elementary topics they study in the Watchtower. They haven't discussed deep prophecies in over a decade!! No wonder people are leaving! They want REAL SPIRITUAL FOOD and are being served bread crumbs by the "unfaithful and indiscreet slave"!!
I threw away a lot of literature, which I regret now, including both versions of the Revelation book I had. I am bad with remembering what happened in what year lol, so I looked up those dates in the Kingdom Ministries online. April 17, 1989 is when it says the first study started. I do remember a lot of publishers having no idea how to answer in this book or the Daniel book. That's why now they are only fed milk like the new Enjoy Life Forever book. I would be asleep 5 minutes in. 😂
Je tenais Éric à vous remercier pour vos vidéos. Elles sont la réponse à mes prières j’étais tellement mal dans cette organisation. Vos vidéos ont changé ma vie. Merci encore.
What got me so upset was when I recognized that JESUS is the Messiah and they have called him by the archangel Michael's name and demoted him from the Son of God our king and ruler. They did wrong by trying to say Jesus is Michael. Jesus, Yeshua, is the lord of hosts, also Jesus said he would not come in secret and that is the whole key of the JW's that Jesus came invisible only to a select few. No, the whole world will see him when he lands back on earth. there is not secret place, no desert place, no place in the wilderness .. he said all these are not him. for everyone will see him and KNOW it is HIM when he Returns to do Yehovah's work.
Not only did they lower the only begotten Son of God to an angel, they have poked him in the eye by celebrating the memorial on Nisan 13 last year and this year they celebrated it a whole month too early. I can't stand their blatant arrogance!
In 10 min.up to 14 minutes of your talk really hits hard to the rank & file JW's.And the proof you qouted is undeniable since it was of the book that we have studied 3 times since 1988. As usual you hit the nail. Good job bro
I agree, the "Governing Body", has become many things in the past several years = Faithful Slave, Voice like Christ and now an idolatry image as you have pointed out. Eric you pointed out Coi 3.5 which is spot on. I like the way the AMP Bible says it " So put to death and deprive of power the evil longings of your earthly body [with its sensual, self-centered instincts] immorality, impurity, sinful passion, evil desire, and greed, which is [a kind of] idolatry [because it replaces your devotion to God] "
Yes I remember in 2007 we had to paste revisions into the paragraphs! I agree. A couple of people said 4 times but my book is marked with the dates in each chapter as we covered the book. It was 3 times. I was a book study conductor then.
Great video, the older someone is the deeper the brain washing goes and the harder it is to admit they’ve been misled. I remember it took me a full year to even believe all of the information I was finding during my waking up. I was reading and finding Information Almost every day and still I’d make excuses. the hardest part was to admit that the great governing body could actually be wrong and misinterpret scripture.
I could feel my heckles rising when I read the headline. Then as the video started I guessed, correctly, that the idolatry accusation would be to do with blind allegiance to the GB. Its true they are followed blindly, but its not in the remit of anyone to judge anyone else. Wrong or not, even the GB are victims of victims. Anyone blessed with truth outwith the Society should be grateful for their freedom, not use it as a stick to beat their former brothers and sisters. Using advice gratefully received from Eric about writing letters to all i am close to, i am slowly but deliberately distancing myself from my congregation while using every second I have to speak to and encourage freedom in Christ(1Jn4.18). Im still grieving my beliefs though and whether i am DF tomorrow or in 6 months as planned, i will still love every one of my congregation and not use my freedom in Christ to attack any of them.
No one person was judged. The skinned and thrown about sheep may find much healing and support from such. We have all been warned about the wolves in sheep's clothing. The Man of Lawlessness will be revealed. 2 Thes 2: "Don’t let anyone deceive you in any way, for that day will not come until the rebellion occurs and the man of lawlessness[a] is revealed, the man doomed to destruction. 4 He will oppose and will exalt himself over everything that is called God or is worshiped, so that he sets himself up in God’s temple, proclaiming himself to be God."
@@mamajan99 The man of lawlessness is not the single possession of witnesses. To single them out would be wrong even though they make up part of that group who have been misled. More important to keep ourselves clean and not be pointing the finger at any one group. Personally, my leading is that we are ambassadors not judges 2 Cor 5.20.
@@PollokBhoy 1 Jn 4:1 Beloved, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God, for many false prophets have gone out into the world
Absolutely love your content. Its just facts. You have so much credibility since you walked the walk for decades and knows the inner politics that govern that community. You may have single handedly spared deception, confusion and heartache for tens of thousands if not more from such an intense religious denomination. For those who have ears and decide to listen. I decided to walk away after more than 5 years of attending. Never committed, but when i decided to introduce my family, i saw such hypocrisy from several elders against me. The mask had come off. They expected for me to surrender to them. Its not in my personality to surrender to hypocrites. Just walked away with my wife just been apointed non baptized publisher. I have no animosity towards any of them. I continue to accept calls from members and will always give them a hand if they ask. Its just thier politics, idolatry of the elders and governing body and the false interpretations of several scriptures that is unacceptable to me, and so will continue to keep it at bay until they change. I have looked for credible ex witnesses as to why they left. I have found you to be the best example for the right reasons. Others leave because they have the itching ears towards false Christian doctrine that gravitate towards wordly lifestyles they prefer. They dont seem to really believe in GOD or his laws. Only a few like you have spoken up and have not strayed from scripture, but instead up hold it.
Hi, Omar. They are completely the hypocrits that you accurately saw for yourself. I was a "born in" JW. I only woke up four years ago. They definitely want to dominate others. Watchtower stole my youth, my young adulthood, my middle age, and was well on the way to ruining my old age. At whatever age... run from them. Jw's consider it a badge of honor to "turn in" an apostate to the elders.
@OmarMartinez-tw4to • Thank you for your encouraging words. I hope that soon more will join us and speak out against such hypocrisy in all religious while holding to the truth from Scripture and spreading the good news. There is still time.
To answer your question about how many times we studied the Revalation Climax publication we studied the first iteration three times which I conducted as for a forth time after its revision I don't know, I had already woken up by then.
Hi, I may not always agree with what you say. But I do appreciate your time and effort you put in to your videos. I also like the way you answer comments, with respect. No name calling no yelling. Thanks again
Bing gives this definition: Dispensationalism is a theological framework of interpreting the Bible which maintains that history is divided into multiple ages or “dispensations” in which God acts with his chosen people in different ways. Dispensationalists use a literal interpretation of the Bible and believe that divine revelation unfolds throughout the Bible. They believe that there is a distinction between Israel and the Church and that Christians are not bound by Mosaic law. They maintain beliefs in premillennialism, a future restoration of national Israel, and a rapture of the Church that will happen before the second coming, generally seen as happening before a period of tribulation.
Thank you, Eric, well I have been studying with JW back in the early 2000s, but I never got baptised, I have been questioning some things about them that made me not to join them. But I wanted to ask, what organisation can one join that serves God in truth, and spirits.
@tochukwuoparaku5671 • Any organization will eventually descend into human rule. That is why the word is not in the Bible and we are encouraged to bond with fellow believers with Christ as our only leader. If you'd like to join with such ones as Jesus described in John 4:23, 24, check out beroeans.net/events/
My great grandmother is 103 and she has been loyal almost her entire adult life and when I talk to her she really believes the elders and the governoring body are Jehovah’s channel. To me it’s like believing Jehovah has a telephone and only calls the governing body. Her excuse for any questionable behaviors excuse “ we are not perfect”
I had a conversation about four years ago with an 80 year old JW brother who had that same answer for everything. He had even "perfected" that defense for Watchtower. He gave me the illustration that he, as a business owner, can't know exactly what each of his employees does or says every minute. I had only woken up a couple of months before talking with this brother, and sadly, at the time, I was woefully short on any rebuttals. He hasn't answered his phone since we spoke, whenever I've called.
Thanks. This is exactly what I needed. Yes, Watchtower's leadership wants to have their members worship or serve them. Idol worship indeed. Jehovah God wants exclusive devotion. Exodus 20:5, Exodus 34:14, Deuteronomy 5:9
We studied the Revelation book 4 times. The hilarious thing is that by the last time it was studied there were so many revisions and “adjustments in understanding” that it rendered your previously studied copy essentially worthless. Being near Bethel, it became yet another means of judgement if you chose to keep your old book vs. bringing the new book to the book study.
I thought it was four times, but that seems so ridiculous that I began to doubt my memory. I just remember being incensed that instead of studying something truly beneficial like the Greatest Man book, we were yet again studying that stupid book full of outlandish speculation. I remember one friend joking that Armageddon will probably start at Cedar Point, Ohio.
@@BeroeanPicketsI totally agree...why we did not study the Greatest Man book in the book study is just amazing to me, but of course if we had it would have illuminated the the error of the Governing Body as having userpt the position of the Christ.
@@aiercooledengineWhy would the JW study The greatest man book it's about Jesus. The Lord doesn't get mentioned it's all follow the governing body and the organisation and the spiritual shepherd's. So sad the rank and file witness do not see it . Fortunately I did and left
You are a very confused person. I studied the Greatest Man publication. You had the same opportunity. And here is where the heat is on for you. Jw's practice the first century teachings of Christ. And only what he taught. His two commandments : 1. You MUSTt love Jehovah God with your whole mind, body and spirit.. 2. You MUST love your neighbor as yourself. ot a problem with that ?
@@LouiseWeber-b2m Alternatively modern version you must love the organisation or society and the governing body with your whole heart without question Psa 146 v 3 Do not put your trust in nobles or the sons of man . Trust the Scripture's and Christ and not any religion. And as for the golden rule it's something all individuals should strive to do. Something that should come naturally. As my Wife is a witness a few weeks ago in a Watchtower that I overheard it was talking about showing love kindness respecting young and elderly fatherless boys etc . What a sad state of affairs when you as witness have to be told and reminded to do these things. True Christians don't need to be told about these things they just do it . And they don't need to tell others how wonderful they are and count time for it either. You shouldn't be on these sites unless you are searching for something you don't have a relationship with Christ.
I accidentally found you weeks ago while researching: "Religion is a Snare and a racket!" The first few observations that you offered were exactly in line with my views. Holy Spirit at work? Jn 14:26: "The Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in my name, will teach you everything and will remind you of everything I told you." No mention by John of some "Governing Body"!
It is absolutely appalling that they tell followers to obey them even if it doesn't make sense from a human standpoint. No mention about using their bible trained conscience to obey after proper examination as well as consideration that they are uninspired and imperfect.
Correct. All the logic they use to convince members of other religions to examine their faith's teachings goes out the window when turned on themselves.
It reminds me of the words of the Apostle Peter, 1: 16, where he said, (NWT)..."it was not by following artfully contrived stories that we acquainted you with the power and presence of our Lord Jesus Christ, but it was by becoming eyewitnesses of his glory,..(at the transfiguration). The Watchtower org. seems bent on "artfully contriving " stories through their now elaborate use of videos. They use these videos to dumb down the members, and to sway their emotions instead of stimulating their intellect! Paul said at Hebrews 5: 14 that we all need to train our "perceptive powers to distinguish between right and wrong". That means deep study of the scriptures; thinking critically and logically to allow the Bible to answer it's own questions! Not to "trust in the faithful and discreet slave," no matter how stupid their counsel seems"!
John 10:7So Jesus said again: “Most truly I say to you, I am the door for the sheep. 8 All those who have come in place of me are thieves and plunderers; but the sheep have not listened to them
Hello Eric. Great video, thanks for the good thoughts. You mentioned the book "Revelation-Its Grand Climax At Hand!" (9:34), only you quoted paragraph 14 first, not 18. But this does not affect the content in any way. Thanks again.
Thank you for the explanation The scripture that keeps coming to my mind is: Matthew 10:28 - 'Fear not those who kill the body.......but Him who can destroy both soul and body in Gehenna.'
You know, I've been browsing through this 'money-luxury' youtube channel and watching pieces on 'old money' [who are all connected to 'secret societies' and 'clubs']...I think the WT 'society' has so many 'classes' now, that this money/luxury channel could do a piece on their 'eliteness'. My eyebrows flew up into my hairline over the similarities.
"Salvation is in Christ alone; where will those appear who despise him as their Mediator, and revile him in his disciples? May they stand in awe, and no longer sin against the only remedy." Matthew Henry's Concise Commentary on Ps 4:6-8
Yes, they want you to bow down to the govering body, and obey anything they say. This is Truth, they want you loyal to the governing body & watchtower, not the Bible or God.
This is soo true Eric. JWs worship the religion rather then Jehovah. They substitute the governing body for Jesus Christ and they think angels are leading the teaching work rather then the Holy Spirit. It’s unfortunate because the members, no matter how sincere they are, are totally being misled by the teaching of men. Jesus and later Paul reiterated and emphasized not to be deceived by the many deceptions of Satan and unfortunately they did not seem to heed that warning. As always, great video and Hopefully a few will wake up from this religious nightmare. Peace
Looking at the principals of this topic you can really run with it, and I have. And the solutions run from God creating us like robots, or some Buddhistic type of perspective on life.
@@BeroeanPickets Food a wife your job regular exercise even if you don't want to do certain things, I've always found Paul's definition about submitting yourself to do something makes you a slave to it, which makes almost any regular and consistent activity idolatry or could the definition change if has to do with setting those things up over God, only if their considered normal activities? Such a fine line to walk. Much like walking on eggshells. Makes you not want to think about it to much otherwise you'd be overwhelmed with a since of paranoia.
Eric, thank you so much for this video!! One more nugget of your wisdom to add to my "sinful JW"bag. I am so happy to see you looking so well rested. God bless you my brother!!
You are 100% correct about everything and I have kinda of thought about it - if JW are correct and being the correct religion gets you into paradise / heaven I worry for my family.
Instead of debating what "the goat herders guide to the galaxy" does or does not command, can we debate whether it is indeed the word of our creator? There is good reason to beleive it is not
Like the nod to Douglas Adams. I know for those seeking to discredit Scripture that there appears to be good reason do claim the Bible is not from God. However, much of that is based on a faulty premise, one that is unfortunately applied by the churches themselves.
Eric, this was a great video. Thank you. I think that I do the idol worship goes beyond the governing body. I truly believe they idolize the organization just like another religion idolize the Virgin Mary. In many ways, they idolize themselves for their own righteousness…..Galatians 2:21
@@alcedo_kf - Christmas, Easter, Halloween, The Cross, Wedding rings, Fasting (lent), The idea that people have immortal souls, The Greeks taught that at death the soul would separate from the physical body, it did not come from the bible. The ancient Egyptians developed the concept of going to heaven. The list goes on and on, and on, and on... Christianity is stolen mythology, it is SERVING TWO MASTERS!!!
Gosh I remember it was either 4 or 5 times but I was only a child, my understanding now is because they thought the end was actually at hand due to the passing of brother Franz (their oracle or prophet who was the mind behind all their publications after Russells death). 9:30
That's all they talk about is the gb as if they died for our sin, or the Jehovah, Jehovah it's really sickening. They should be giving glory to Jesus John 14:6 and also keep in mind John 17: 17 The father word never change
My parents had an issue seeing me wear a cross and having a picture of a Jesus in my house but they had no issue having a picture of Charles T Russell hanging in their house. One time my dad had a shepherding visit to a guy in the congregation who had a plaque with a bible verse but it had a cross on it. The guy said he loved the verse and it’s message and my dad likened to having the cross on it to a swastika and demanded he burn it.
…by the way, your book “Shutting The Door To The Kingdom Of God..How Watchtower Stole Salvation From Jehovah’s Witnesses” ~ very much appreciated and I Highly recommend to all no matter where you are in your spiritual journey ~ if you can not order it due to circumstances ~ ask someone to do it for you…Thank You Brother Wilson ~ hope all is well.
The kingdom was established when those four kingdoms were still in existence. That was the time of Christ. However, the kingdom of God and of the Christ will only crush those kingdoms at Armageddon. That may be soon, or it may be a while yet. There's that word again: "Soon". 😁
I was disfellowshipped for speaking to the elders. I told them that I had studied and found out the false doctrines that tje GB teaches. I wasn't specific on what exactly but I told them I had notes and I could prove to them. Next thing I get a call from an elder and tells me I would be disfellowshipped. They didn't even asked me what I thought was false, they didn't even want to hear it😢
@sallyAP -- I am so sorry you were treated like that.
That's terrible. And I'm hearing that basic response from elders in many life experiences of ex-JW's and their kangaroo court judicial committees. It' s all over TH-cam. Like Brother Wilson says here, they can't defend their positions with scripture, only man made rules in their elder book.
When I was studying with them, after a while, I decided not to get baptized
Because, I was taught that, if I think any differently from the witnesses, I would be disfellowshipped
I had to keep my mouth shut when it came to dating, for example
I was 21 when I stopped attending meetings altogether
It's a good thing I never got baptized
Because, I would keep questioning them, and they would scold me
@cheneethompson5756 A brother that was studying with my husband straight out told him that if he wanted to become a JW he needled to obey the GB no matter what. And that he didn't hve to question anything because they were Jehovahs annointed people🤨. And that he had to trust them regardless. In that moment my husband knew he will have nothing to do with them. Unfortunately, it took me many more years to wake up and stand my ground. Jesus is my only Lord & Savior. Not a human nor an organization
@sallyAP exactly! Thanks for sharing! The governing body is always "the man"
If a religious group tells you how to live, without question, it's not worth it
Excellent. Thank you for bringing up this subject. In the 70’s, when I was a JW, I didn’t even know there was a Governing Body. I truly believed it was all Jehovah. I never paid attention to an Organization. Now, it’s all about the Governing Body. That’s pretty much all that we hear. Wow. When did it happen. Slowly. Subtly. Pervasively. Thank you again for bringing this to our attention. And to think of those men treating their flock so harshly sickens me. I call them the collective “Wizard of Org”!❤
Couldn’t agree more. They are getting more power hungry and everything is focused on them more and more it’s horrible
Yes. We never knew who the Governing Body was back then. A while back, Samuel Herd said in a talk that JW parents would urge their kids to write to the Governing Body. I was shocked.
Closer to the end, their falsehoods and evil wants become more readily apparent. Satan is indeed shrewd and sinister. He infiltrated the Organization, and like a frog, being boiled one degree at a time, slowly over time. Lucifer has cooked the organization and its membership.
The lesson, Christ’s Church is whoever worships faithfully. They might reside in many “churches,” its membership among those who never met. Yet are united by their love for Christ, and their adherence to his Word.
@@thomassmart2790 The GB reminds of Luke 11:52: "Woe to you scribes and Pharisees! For you have taken away the key of knowledge. You did not enter in yourselves, and those who were entering in you hindered."
@@richlisola1this is also my point of view now. Many JWs are not my brothers because they do not act as real brothers towards me and my family, and many individuals amongst catholics , baptists, evangelists seem to have authentic love for fellow christians, even if they have doubts about their own organisations. We cannot judge anymore people on their religious affiliation, but on their personal faith and love
Good points outlined in an easy to understand manner. In 1999, I complained of what I regarded as excessively flattering praise of the UN's UNICEF arm, in the Awake magizine. Soon, I became aware of the WTB&TS actual joining of the UN as a non-govermetal organization. Also I complained of an inordinate amount of praise of Al Gores' environmental policies. This resulted in an uninvited visit to our home by the Elders. They asked why I was complaining. I answered the Holy Spirit, pointed this out to me, & it conflicts with my understanding of Christian neutrality in political affairs. They firmly asserted, " the governing body is the only source of information", & then demanded to know," was I loyal to them?" I answered, my spiritual loyalty is complete towards God, not to mortal men in New York City! They started to rebuke me in the strongest terms, when I interrupted their response, & unceremoniuosly ordered them out the door. I became free from their "spell" that day, & never looked back!
This is the sort of story that illustrates how a JW can be disfellowshipped for the slightest divergeance from the Governing Body's "information". Do they claim to be inspired by God. Oh, no, of course not. But can you disagree with them? No, of course not,... not unless you are ready for them to make your life miserable.
How did you find out about their dealing with the UN back then? I’m curious because I only became aware of it after many years later when more info was coming out online
Excellent video, I have debated with my JW family and debunked every article they have sent me and in the end they told me " It's a wonderful organization". I pray for my family to seek salvation through Christ rather than an organization.
All worshipers of Christ are as fundamentally flawed as the Witnesses, just in their own ways.
@@joeldb That maybe true of others but not with Witnesses. I was one from 1970 -1991 and during that time I experienced teaching that don't make sense. Here are a few examples
* 1975 Being the end of the system (Bible says nobody but the Father knows the day or hour)
* Christ being just an angel
* Doctrine around being annonited
* Doctrine that says that a group of men are like the voice of Christ.
* Doctrine that Christ came back invisibly and ruling in Heaven ( The Bible states signs and wonders and that all shall see him.)
A flaw would be a misunderstanding ,crazy doctrine that goes against the bible that is something else.
It is a brutal indoctrination plus their use of subliminal messages; this sect practices sorceries (Revelation 18:23), idolatry, etc. The Bible tells us that that’s how the nations were deceived. Revelation 18:23; Revelation 12:9. That’s why the title Mother of the prostitutes fit its profile. Their followers are like drunk with all their false teachings and practices. Like Jesus said they are blinded by these wolves in sheep clothing.
Matthew 23:15; Matthew 7:15-23; Matthew 15:14;
Revelation 18:3-5;
Revelation 17: 2-15; this man of lawlessness is so wicked 2 Thessalonians chapter 2;
Revelation 18:24. That’s why we need the holy spirt . We need to continue praying for those who don’t have the holy spirt and are still trapped because they have been deceived regarding the holy spirt too. As Jesus said we are protected by the holy spirit.
John 14:18-31; 16:13-15;
Also 1 John 2:26-29 gives us the clue why the holy spirit is vital in our lives.
Otherwise people will receive the mark of the beast Revelation 13; Revelation 17:2-17
@@joeldbExactly right! Each religion or even subset (denomination) is going to hell according to every other sect. It’s obvious to anyone who isn’t tied to any of them how foolish they are all.
That ‘bow down’ part in the revelation book is extremely telling on how the governing body see themselves. Wow!
Great job, Eric. Ex-elder, Bethelite here. So nice to see fellow elders like myself who don't just critique or criticize the organization, but do as the ancient Beroeans did, that is , "carefully examined the scriptures,....to see if things if these things were so." Acts 17: 11) Earlier in that same chapter of Acts, it was mentioned that the Apostle Paul "reasoned from the scriptures with them, explaining and proving by references, that it was necessary for the Christ to suffer, etc. etc." So yes, I will and have a scriptural defense ready to send the US Branch "explaining and proving by references" why the 3 clowns that were called "Elders" or a "judicial committee", should not only be removed as elders; but also removed from the congregation as slanderers! And yes, the organization of JW's have slowly and insidiously succumbed to the proddings of this self proclaimed "faithful and discreet slave"; effectively idolizing them as God's spokesman, incapable of error or mistakes!
That is not the organization we grew up in is it my brother??!!! 😊🤔😝
@connormusic9274 - So very true brother!
Yes we have to continue to exam the word, learn from it. Agree with all.
My mom, in her 80s, was born and raised in “The Truth” and has her entire life vested in it and makes excuses for every questionable teaching. The Governing Body now has Papal level reverence and authority.
@butziporsche8646
My mom is not quite that age, but she’s spent more than half her life in the religion. I was a born in, served as an elder and left on own volition 2 yrs ago after catching WT in a blatant deception both in a WT article and their 2021 Annual Meeting. If I didn’t have those older publications in hand, I wouldn’t have known about the deception.
That led me down a rabbit hole, b/c I’ve always been taught if someone lies about little things, there’s a good chance they’ve/they’ll lie about bigger things, & just wow.
I attempted to have open & honest dialogue w/ both my parents, w/ my father being a fellow elder. I showed that the org teaches Jesus is not our mediator despite what the Bible says. I showed them a July 2011 WT article showing our obedience to them affects our salvation. I showed them where they removed the word worship from Jesus in the scriptures, & used the phrase “substitute for him” only in the NWT. I proved scripturally, archeologically, secularly, mathematically that 607 BCE is a false date made up.
Literally none of that mattered; the only thing they were concerned with was how the friends viewed them, & it wasn’t my place to question The Faithful Slave.
It was a very surreal & scary moment, and after hearing Lett say babies should be addressed as Little Enemies of God, & to hear the friends in the review say that was a good point they never thought about, I knew I had to leave.
Your words 'The friends wouldn't like it ' hit the nail on the head. That is what they are about. FEAR....
Fear is destructive across the board perhaps your parents are more PIMOs than you realise but are frightened of the backlash of false 'love'
Yes very much 'Class' system orientated. Become very worldly and papal status who must BE OBEYED 😠
Your life is patrolled in every detail and gossiped about they will break secular law to even try to discredit you Yes some like to have power and control to elevate themselves above the more humble ones.
My wife and father do the same, with the UN situation she said they must have a reason 🫣 I showed her the revelation book and asked who is that sitting on top of the UN building, she said false religion. I said exactly that you!
@@bygeorgehemayberite8385 how are you doing now, did your wife and children follow you out of Babylon the great?
I was VERY VERY fortunately to have parents that pressed upon me, that the TRUTH had to be my own and to QUESTION EVERYTHING to ensure that the TRUTH was in MY HEART and MY OWN. I no longer attend meetings, but read the Scriptures, pray , even do my own little memorial service. I believe with ALL MY HEART in Jehovah and his ONLY begotten Son JESUS who was sent to SAVE us and show us the TRUE WAY OF WORSHIP. I still speak to some of my family and friends who are JW's (by the way I class myself as a JW as I witness about Jehovah and our King Christ Jesus) and make this observation: They speak LESS of Jehovah and JC than I do. When I ask, have you prayed to Jeh about your problems, or a view on world events...they ALWAYS refer back to what the ORGANISATION will say in due course to sort things out....AND cop this they are AMAZED and BEFUDDLED that I can love and speak about my faith so freely and NOT want to go to Meetings.....They Just DO NOT get it or UNDERSTAND ME. They think that because I refuse to attend now, that I have turned my back on Jeh, JC and the Scriptures and believe differently and have become oh so worldly...??? Yet unfortunately, I find them to have become less reliant upon the Word of God and faith in Jah than I have....I know I have a good heart condition and I trust in Jeh I JC with ALL MY HEART as I know the word of GOD is what is FAITHFUL and TRUE.....I watched the Royal Commission into Child Abuse here in Australia and I WEPT many tears !! I asked Jeh, how he could let this happen and be represented by such people who say they are his direct link to us here on earth....I know the answers will become apparent , ALL in Jehs good time. I know there are 10's of Thousands of us out there who WILL NOT give up the FAITH and did not deserve to be thrown aside and I know that in Gods heart and memory we sit awaiting the rule of his son JC and we will be blessed as will ALL THOSE who love God. ❤😊
I think you’ll change your mind, when you find out what Yahweh really is. And no, Yahweh is not the Father of Christ. Keep praying for truth 🙏🏼🩵
Hi Sonia, you seem to live your faith in a very genuine and intimate way. I appreciate that so much and I fully understand you when you are confronted with people who didn’t seem to feel any faith in God anymore.
There’s many of us.
You described it so well, I'm exactly in that situation. I told the elders:
1. Jehovah's organisation never equals Jehovah. It was Jehovah's organisation that killed Jesus, let alone the modern day blunders.
2. Faithful slave that produces food or Arrogant Master that issues orders? 2 Co. 1:24
3. I have no human head as Jesus Christ is my head and mediator. 1 Co. 11:3
Jehovah is my shepherd, Jesus is my head/mediator/ransom and the Holy Spirit guides me into all the truth.
Enjoy life forever
Amen to that sister! I was DF'd 2.5 years ago, and after 3 appeals for reinstatement and either ignored or denied for stupid who knows what" reasons; I wrote the Society an 18 page letter exposing these corrupted elders and their lack of using the scriptures as a basis for shunning me and asking my family and friends to do the same. At the end of that letter, I told them: "Listen, I'm going to serve Jehovah WITH OR WITHOUT THE ORGANIZATION; my spiritual head is Jesus Christ, not the self-proclaimed governing body! I've witnessed frequently to neighbors, friends, etc. and have placed literature and started Bible studies (using the Bible only with topical old books discussing scriptural views) since being DF'd. I have felt and seen the operation of God's spirit on me like never before; and have prayed relentlessly for God to stir up the courage of lovers of truth to remove authoritarian elders and to REMOVE THIS CURRENT SET OF MEN SERVING, TYRANNICAL, PHARISAICAL GOVERNING BODY. I see it moving in that direction as they scramble to change their man made rules to try and appear less strict with the members! And the nations of the world initiate one lawsuit after another!
Thank you brother Eric. Just excellent. Keep those videos coming. It's "real spiritual food" at the right time. The end is near for the watchtower. Many blessings from Jehovah God and Christ. Amador, Kingdom Christian from sunny Puerto Rico.
Their whole" bringing food in due season" is a parable.parable were always used to teaching around pharisisees and saducees not to the Church Age aka the church. So whole premise or foundation is faulty.
Thank you Brother - you adroitly describe a truly Pharisee-driven organization. Organized religion killed Jesus, even if by design. Escape is painful and the only way to the light. May all thrive by feasting on the WORD, to draw closer to Christ Jesus, The Way, The Truth and The Life as our only intercessor to our Heavenly Father. Amen 🙏
AMEN WE HAVE TO ENDURE MANY MORDAN DAY PHARISEES.
this has been one of the points i draw on in many of my videos. You have done a great job in this video. I would like to share a small protion of it on my LIVE. Just give me a heart if its okay.
What an exquisitely informative and quite enlightening video this is!! I was an elder before I left. I never gave this brilliant area a look. Great thanks Eric for your diligent videos. ❤️👍👏
@haynehifanny8006 - I am so glad you enjoyed it!
Thanks a lot, Eric. JWs also have their own version of the Trinity: Jehovah, the GB and the organization. They are all god to JWs.
That,s so true!!!!
Wrong Giv Bidy and elders are not God and we would never think of them as such. Only one true God Jehovah. I am with gratitude fir the GB and I live my religion.
However, people who live the Trinity Doctrine even though it was never heard of until 400 yrs after Christ died have plenty of religions to choose from. If you like false religions then go for it.
@@LouiseWeber-b2m Of course you will say you do not see GB as god. No JW will say they treat GB as god, but in their subconsciousness, they do. The orders from the GB are just like the orders from your god.
@@LouiseWeber-b2m you should check out arianism for where your beliefs originated
Thank you Eric, OUTSTANDING WORD! Out of all those I do my best to listen to and test all things, you are the ONLY ONE that I can resonate with and fully respect. I greatly greatly appreciate you bro!
Thank you so very much. I shall endeavor to be worthy of that respect.
Thank you Eric for another insightful video. To everyone, FYI, the Org has not changed the "Revelation" book in the JW library on the website. I was really surprised! You would think they would want to hide that blatant lie of "bowing down".
Could you touch upon this more for me? I'm not familiar with the bowing down part.
Excellent talk Eric, I have gone through the fire. It is obvious the governing body class is a group of men who have run ahead, not waiting for the one inviting them to appoint them a seat, but have seated themselves in the highest position.
. Everything that is elevated will be brought down when Jesus returns.
@linvest8466 - Well said!
Brother Robert King said the freemasons infiltrated the society/congregation. The scriptures say the wolves come from within.
Thanks Eric Excellent . The number of rules within the organization is ridiculous and they keep flip flopping makes it clear that they are self appointed and the way the lieutenants (elders ) behave is obsessive . And I never felt safe around them either . How this situation developed over time is interesting and clever .
@louiskucinski5016 - Well said Louis!
In-DEED❤
You are a disgrace and so is your propaganda
I only feel 100 % safe around "them". But not so much you and your demons. Making yourselves seeds of Satan.
You are disgusting to Jehovah God and His people .
Excellent video..before this video started I already knew it's the GB
Thank you Eric, for explaining everything so nicely.
Great video. Idolatry of the GB for sure! We studied the Revelation Climax book 4 times. 1989, 1991, 1994 and 2007. It's not that I can actually remember it at all, however, you can look it up online. One of the few things not doctored lol.
I show 3 times, because in my book, I was a study conductor then and dated the start and stop points as we went thru the book. I don't show an '89; which makes sense because they released the book in '88. But not to argue over that; I did want to say too, that actually; I wish we would study that book every 5-6 years. The same holds true with the "Daniel" book, the "Word of God" book, and other deep prophecy examination books. Today's governing body and bodies of elders are feeding spiritually baby food and their own exaggerated opinions! I sometimes go to a meeting with my wife and I can't believe the elementary topics they study in the Watchtower. They haven't discussed deep prophecies in over a decade!! No wonder people are leaving! They want REAL SPIRITUAL FOOD and are being served bread crumbs by the "unfaithful and indiscreet slave"!!
I threw away a lot of literature, which I regret now, including both versions of the Revelation book I had. I am bad with remembering what happened in what year lol, so I looked up those dates in the Kingdom Ministries online. April 17, 1989 is when it says the first study started. I do remember a lot of publishers having no idea how to answer in this book or the Daniel book. That's why now they are only fed milk like the new Enjoy Life Forever book. I would be asleep 5 minutes in. 😂
Je tenais Éric à vous remercier pour vos vidéos. Elles sont la réponse à mes prières j’étais tellement mal dans cette organisation. Vos vidéos ont changé ma vie. Merci encore.
Je suis très heureuse de savoir que les vidéos m'ont aidée. Je vous remercie.
What got me so upset was when I recognized that JESUS is the Messiah and they have called him by the archangel Michael's name and demoted him from the Son of God our king and ruler. They did wrong by trying to say Jesus is Michael. Jesus, Yeshua, is the lord of hosts, also Jesus said he would not come in secret and that is the whole key of the JW's that Jesus came invisible only to a select few. No, the whole world will see him when he lands back on earth. there is not secret place, no desert place, no place in the wilderness .. he said all these are not him. for everyone will see him and KNOW it is HIM when he Returns to do Yehovah's work.
Not only did they lower the only begotten Son of God to an angel, they have poked him in the eye by celebrating the memorial on Nisan 13 last year and this year they celebrated it a whole month too early. I can't stand their blatant arrogance!
They bow down to the governing body
You always make so much sense. Thank you Eric.👍👍
I appreciate that!
If Jesus Christ shows up..."they" WOULD RUN TO THOSE MEN TO ASK WHAT TO DO. OOPS TO LATE...isn't that so sad?...oh my goodness gracious 😢
In 10 min.up to 14 minutes of your talk really hits hard to the rank & file JW's.And the proof you qouted is undeniable since it was of the book that we have studied 3 times since 1988.
As usual you hit the nail. Good job bro
Man …. what did I just “witness” for 18 years of my life. 12 years out finally feel normal
Religious trauma comes to mind. It is pure fear of man that holds you to them. Causing this dabilitating illness.
I never believed the Governing Body
The Watchtower Organization is the idol of the JWs.
I agree, the "Governing Body", has become many things in the past several years = Faithful Slave, Voice like Christ and now an idolatry image as you have pointed out. Eric you pointed out Coi 3.5 which is spot on. I like the way the AMP Bible says it
" So put to death and deprive of power the evil longings of your earthly body [with its sensual, self-centered instincts] immorality, impurity, sinful passion, evil desire, and greed, which is [a kind of] idolatry [because it replaces your devotion to God] "
Yes
We studied revelation 3 times. The 3rd time was when they started adding additions from the kingdom ministry, which I still have
Thanks for that.
@@BeroeanPickets thank you for your videos. I really enjoy your content
Yes I remember in 2007 we had to paste revisions into the paragraphs! I agree. A couple of people said 4 times but my book is marked with the dates in each chapter as we covered the book. It was 3 times. I was a book study conductor then.
Glad I found this! I needed this video so much! Thank you! ❤
Great video, the older someone is the deeper the brain washing goes and the harder it is to admit they’ve been misled. I remember it took me a full year to even believe all of the information I was finding during my waking up. I was reading and finding Information Almost every day and still I’d make excuses. the hardest part was to admit that the great governing body could actually be wrong and misinterpret scripture.
You are still asleep if your looking for what you call God
How on earth will our salvation depends on worshiping men! Shocking!
I could feel my heckles rising when I read the headline. Then as the video started I guessed, correctly, that the idolatry accusation would be to do with blind allegiance to the GB. Its true they are followed blindly, but its not in the remit of anyone to judge anyone else. Wrong or not, even the GB are victims of victims. Anyone blessed with truth outwith the Society should be grateful for their freedom, not use it as a stick to beat their former brothers and sisters. Using advice gratefully received from Eric about writing letters to all i am close to, i am slowly but deliberately distancing myself from my congregation while using every second I have to speak to and encourage freedom in Christ(1Jn4.18). Im still grieving my beliefs though and whether i am DF tomorrow or in 6 months as planned, i will still love every one of my congregation and not use my freedom in Christ to attack any of them.
No one person was judged. The skinned and thrown about sheep may find much healing and support from such. We have all been warned about the wolves in sheep's clothing. The Man of Lawlessness will be revealed. 2 Thes 2: "Don’t let anyone deceive you in any way, for that day will not come until the rebellion occurs and the man of lawlessness[a] is revealed, the man doomed to destruction. 4 He will oppose and will exalt himself over everything that is called God or is worshiped, so that he sets himself up in God’s temple, proclaiming himself to be God."
@@mamajan99 The man of lawlessness is not the single possession of witnesses. To single them out would be wrong even though they make up part of that group who have been misled. More important to keep ourselves clean and not be pointing the finger at any one group. Personally, my leading is that we are ambassadors not judges 2 Cor 5.20.
Jesus did a whole lot of finger pointing at those who skinned his sheep! I'll follow his example.
@@mamajan99 Math 7.1 he also told us to listen to him.
@@PollokBhoy 1 Jn 4:1 Beloved, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God, for many false prophets have gone out into the world
Very good An Well Spoken
🎯 VERY WELL RESEARCHED !!! 😉👌
Good work , Bro. Eric ! 🙂👍
Much appreciated
Absolutely love your content. Its just facts. You have so much credibility since you walked the walk for decades and knows the inner politics that govern that community. You may have single handedly spared deception, confusion and heartache for tens of thousands if not more from such an intense religious denomination. For those who have ears and decide to listen. I decided to walk away after more than 5 years of attending. Never committed, but when i decided to introduce my family, i saw such hypocrisy from several elders against me. The mask had come off. They expected for me to surrender to them. Its not in my personality to surrender to hypocrites. Just walked away with my wife just been apointed non baptized publisher. I have no animosity towards any of them. I continue to accept calls from members and will always give them a hand if they ask. Its just thier politics, idolatry of the elders and governing body and the false interpretations of several scriptures that is unacceptable to me, and so will continue to keep it at bay until they change.
I have looked for credible ex witnesses as to why they left. I have found you to be the best example for the right reasons. Others leave because they have the itching ears towards false Christian doctrine that gravitate towards wordly lifestyles they prefer. They dont seem to really believe in GOD or his laws. Only a few like you have spoken up and have not strayed from scripture, but instead up hold it.
Hi, Omar. They are completely the hypocrits that you accurately saw for yourself. I was a "born in" JW. I only woke up four years ago. They definitely want to dominate others. Watchtower stole my youth, my young adulthood, my middle age, and was well on the way to ruining my old age. At whatever age... run from them. Jw's consider it a badge of honor to "turn in" an apostate to the elders.
@OmarMartinez-tw4to • Thank you for your encouraging words. I hope that soon more will join us and speak out against such hypocrisy in all religious while holding to the truth from Scripture and spreading the good news. There is still time.
Thank you for a thorough and informative presentation! ❤
Glad you enjoyed it!
To answer your question about how many times we studied the Revalation Climax publication we studied the first iteration three times which I conducted as for a forth time after its revision I don't know, I had already woken up by then.
I wish I had, but I was starting to.
They worship the Governing Body !!!!
There it is! Finally, someone agrees with me!
Hi, I may not always agree with what you say. But I do appreciate your time and effort you put in to your videos. I also like the way you answer comments, with respect. No name calling no yelling. Thanks again
I appreciate reading that. Thank you.
One of the most important videos for every true Christian. Thanks for uploading.
Thank you Eric! Excellent video ❤
Love for you to speak about dispensationalism and rightfully dividing the scriptures.
Bing gives this definition:
Dispensationalism is a theological framework of interpreting the Bible which maintains that history is divided into multiple ages or “dispensations” in which God acts with his chosen people in different ways. Dispensationalists use a literal interpretation of the Bible and believe that divine revelation unfolds throughout the Bible. They believe that there is a distinction between Israel and the Church and that Christians are not bound by Mosaic law. They maintain beliefs in premillennialism, a future restoration of national Israel, and a rapture of the Church that will happen before the second coming, generally seen as happening before a period of tribulation.
@@BeroeanPickets wow thank you! 🙏🏼
Thank you, Eric, well I have been studying with JW back in the early 2000s, but I never got baptised, I have been questioning some things about them that made me not to join them. But I wanted to ask, what organisation can one join that serves God in truth, and spirits.
@tochukwuoparaku5671 • Any organization will eventually descend into human rule. That is why the word is not in the Bible and we are encouraged to bond with fellow believers with Christ as our only leader. If you'd like to join with such ones as Jesus described in John 4:23, 24, check out beroeans.net/events/
He is a trillion percent right!! I’ve been saying they were idol worshipers
Thank you, Eric
Welcome!
Thank Sir. ❤
Awesome way of showing this idol worship, I've to my wife she worship men she believes she doesn't.
My father is no better!
My great grandmother is 103 and she has been loyal almost her entire adult life and when I talk to her she really believes the elders and the governoring body are Jehovah’s channel. To me it’s like believing Jehovah has a telephone and only calls the governing body. Her excuse for any questionable behaviors excuse “ we are not perfect”
I had a conversation about four years ago with an 80 year old JW brother who had that same answer for everything. He had even "perfected" that defense for Watchtower. He gave me the illustration that he, as a business owner, can't know exactly what each of his employees does or says every minute. I had only woken up a couple of months before talking with this brother, and sadly, at the time, I was woefully short on any rebuttals. He hasn't answered his phone since we spoke, whenever I've called.
Thanks. This is exactly what I needed. Yes, Watchtower's leadership wants to have their members worship or serve them. Idol worship indeed.
Jehovah God wants exclusive devotion. Exodus 20:5, Exodus 34:14, Deuteronomy 5:9
Again, another great video!
Thank you eric for this excellent presentation.
Děkuji Eriku za tvoji skvělou práci. Dává mi to sílu a vím, že po celém světě jsou bratři a sestry v podobné situaci.🙏😇❤️
P
P😅😅lll😅😅
L
🩵🙏🏼💎
We studied the Revelation book 4 times. The hilarious thing is that by the last time it was studied there were so many revisions and “adjustments in understanding” that it rendered your previously studied copy essentially worthless. Being near Bethel, it became yet another means of judgement if you chose to keep your old book vs. bringing the new book to the book study.
I thought it was four times, but that seems so ridiculous that I began to doubt my memory. I just remember being incensed that instead of studying something truly beneficial like the Greatest Man book, we were yet again studying that stupid book full of outlandish speculation. I remember one friend joking that Armageddon will probably start at Cedar Point, Ohio.
@@BeroeanPicketsI totally agree...why we did not study the Greatest Man book in the book study is just amazing to me, but of course if we had it would have illuminated the the error of the Governing Body as having userpt the position of the Christ.
@@aiercooledengineWhy would the JW study The greatest man book it's about Jesus.
The Lord doesn't get mentioned it's all follow the governing body and the organisation and the spiritual shepherd's.
So sad the rank and file witness do not see it .
Fortunately I did and left
You are a very confused person. I studied the Greatest Man publication. You had the same opportunity. And here is where the heat is on for you.
Jw's practice the first century teachings of Christ. And only what he taught. His two commandments :
1. You MUSTt love Jehovah God with your whole mind, body and spirit..
2. You MUST love your neighbor as yourself.
ot a problem with that ?
@@LouiseWeber-b2m Alternatively modern version you must love the organisation or society and the governing body with your whole heart without question
Psa 146 v 3 Do not put your trust in nobles or the sons of man .
Trust the Scripture's and Christ and not any religion.
And as for the golden rule it's something all individuals should strive to do.
Something that should come naturally. As my Wife is a witness a few weeks ago in a Watchtower that I overheard it was talking about showing love kindness respecting young and elderly fatherless boys etc .
What a sad state of affairs when you as witness have to be told and reminded to do these things.
True Christians don't need to be told about these things they just do it .
And they don't need to tell others how wonderful they are and count time for it either.
You shouldn't be on these sites unless you are searching for something you don't have a relationship with Christ.
I call you Eric because I call my real brothers by their first name not a title. ❤ for sharing.
I accidentally found you weeks ago while researching: "Religion is a Snare and a racket!"
The first few observations that you offered were exactly in line with my views. Holy Spirit at work? Jn 14:26: "The Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in my name, will teach you everything and will remind you of everything I told you." No mention by John of some "Governing Body"!
It is absolutely appalling that they tell followers to obey them even if it doesn't make sense from a human standpoint. No mention about using their bible trained conscience to obey after proper examination as well as consideration that they are uninspired and imperfect.
Correct. All the logic they use to convince members of other religions to examine their faith's teachings goes out the window when turned on themselves.
It reminds me of the words of the Apostle Peter, 1: 16, where he said, (NWT)..."it was not by following artfully contrived stories that we acquainted you with the power and presence of our Lord Jesus Christ, but it was by becoming eyewitnesses of his glory,..(at the transfiguration). The Watchtower org. seems bent on "artfully contriving " stories through their now elaborate use of videos. They use these videos to dumb down the members, and to sway their emotions instead of stimulating their intellect! Paul said at Hebrews 5: 14 that we all need to train our "perceptive powers to distinguish between right and wrong". That means deep study of the scriptures; thinking critically and logically to allow the Bible to answer it's own questions! Not to "trust in the faithful and discreet slave," no matter how stupid their counsel seems"!
John 10:7So Jesus said again: “Most truly I say to you, I am the door for the sheep. 8 All those who have come in place of me are thieves and plunderers; but the sheep have not listened to them
In 1919 the only person in control of The Watchtower, and hence was "the slave", was Judge Rutherford.
A drunkard and womanizer that used doctrine to build his self a mansion .
This brings to mind my late great old friend Christopher Hitchens who stated [ religion poisons everything ]
Hello Eric. Great video, thanks for the good thoughts. You mentioned the book "Revelation-Its Grand Climax At Hand!" (9:34), only you quoted paragraph 14 first, not 18. But this does not affect the content in any way. Thanks again.
Thank you for the video. Great one. I needed it 👍
Thank you for the explanation
The scripture that keeps coming to my mind is: Matthew 10:28 - 'Fear not those who kill the body.......but Him who can destroy both soul and body in Gehenna.'
Hi many thanks for sharing this with all us out here your talk was truth and spot on Act 4 "12 .
Thank you so much
This is great analysis. Growing up I used to love these bible dramas but ever since I woke up I wonder how I didn’t see the manipulation behind them.
I can empathize.
Our powerful heavenly father and his son will continue to expose and crush this cult with truth amen
EXCELLENT EXCELLENT EXCELLENT video!!
Many thanks!
I thought when the governing body said they were not inspired by Jehovah they would all leave but it wasn't the case -_-
'We're not inspired, but if you disagree with us, you are opposing Jehovah'. Sounds like a line from that George Orwell book: 1984
Great video. Truth.👍🙏
Thanks for listening
You know, I've been browsing through this 'money-luxury' youtube channel and watching pieces on 'old money' [who are all connected to 'secret societies' and 'clubs']...I think the WT 'society' has so many 'classes' now, that this money/luxury channel could do a piece on their 'eliteness'. My eyebrows flew up into my hairline over the similarities.
"Salvation is in Christ alone; where will those appear who despise him as their Mediator, and revile him in his disciples? May they stand in awe, and no longer sin against the only remedy." Matthew Henry's Concise Commentary on Ps 4:6-8
I see it as corporate worship
Magneto is spittin facts
Wow ! This blew me away
Awesome message, thank you ❤
Yes, they want you to bow down to the govering body, and obey anything they say. This is Truth, they want you loyal to the governing body & watchtower, not the Bible or God.
They built their own golden calf! “The governing Body”
This is soo true Eric. JWs worship the religion rather then Jehovah. They substitute the governing body for Jesus Christ and they think angels are leading the teaching work rather then the Holy Spirit. It’s unfortunate because the members, no matter how sincere they are, are totally being misled by the teaching of men. Jesus and later Paul reiterated and emphasized not to be deceived by the many deceptions of Satan and unfortunately they did not seem to heed that warning. As always, great video and Hopefully a few will wake up from this religious nightmare. Peace
Excellant.
Looking at the principals of this topic you can really run with it, and I have. And the solutions run from God creating us like robots, or some Buddhistic type of perspective on life.
I'm not advocating for Buddhism, it's just a musing.
I'm not really sure what your musing means.
@@BeroeanPickets Food a wife your job regular exercise even if you don't want to do certain things, I've always found Paul's definition about submitting yourself to do something makes you a slave to it, which makes almost any regular and consistent activity idolatry or could the definition change if has to do with setting those things up over God, only if their considered normal activities? Such a fine line to walk. Much like walking on eggshells. Makes you not want to think about it to much otherwise you'd be overwhelmed with a since of paranoia.
Eric, thank you so much for this video!! One more nugget of your wisdom to add to my "sinful JW"bag. I am so happy to see you looking so well rested. God bless you my brother!!
Thank you, and so glad it was helpful!
You are 100% correct about everything and I have kinda of thought about it - if JW are correct and being the correct religion gets you into paradise / heaven I worry for my family.
They have always been wrong in their end time predictions Deutr 18:20-22
"the one prophet prophesyes that God has not proclaim shall die"
Instead of debating what "the goat herders guide to the galaxy" does or does not command, can we debate whether it is indeed the word of our creator? There is good reason to beleive it is not
Like the nod to Douglas Adams. I know for those seeking to discredit Scripture that there appears to be good reason do claim the Bible is not from God. However, much of that is based on a faulty premise, one that is unfortunately applied by the churches themselves.
Thankyou.
You're welcome
Eric, this was a great video. Thank you. I think that I do the idol worship goes beyond the governing body. I truly believe they idolize the organization just like another religion idolize the Virgin Mary. In many ways, they idolize themselves for their own righteousness…..Galatians 2:21
All Christians bow down to the Pagan gods, Christianity is deep,y rooted in it…
not all
@@alcedo_kf - Christmas, Easter, Halloween, The Cross, Wedding rings, Fasting (lent), The idea that people have immortal souls, The Greeks taught that at death the soul would separate from the physical body, it did not come from the bible. The ancient Egyptians developed the concept of going to heaven. The list goes on and on, and on, and on... Christianity is stolen mythology, it is SERVING TWO MASTERS!!!
Best video on watchtower I’ve seen. Very important work here.
Gosh I remember it was either 4 or 5 times but I was only a child, my understanding now is because they thought the end was actually at hand due to the passing of brother Franz (their oracle or prophet who was the mind behind all their publications after Russells death). 9:30
That's all they talk about is the gb as if they died for our sin, or the Jehovah, Jehovah it's really sickening. They should be giving glory to Jesus John 14:6 and also keep in mind John 17: 17 The father word never change
Watchtower is DANGEROUS RIP Raymond Franz please read Crisis of Conscience
My parents had an issue seeing me wear a cross and having a picture of a Jesus in my house but they had no issue having a picture of Charles T Russell hanging in their house. One time my dad had a shepherding visit to a guy in the congregation who had a plaque with a bible verse but it had a cross on it. The guy said he loved the verse and it’s message and my dad likened to having the cross on it to a swastika and demanded he burn it.
Everything is black or white for them. They do as they are told without any independent thinking on their part.
Wow I have been waiting for you this explanation idol worship that goes on with Jehovah's witnesses and the governing body
Thankyou
You’re welcome 😊
Blatant idolatry for sure!!....masked in misapplied scripture, JW doctrine and emotion.
…by the way, your book “Shutting The Door To The Kingdom Of God..How Watchtower Stole Salvation From Jehovah’s Witnesses” ~ very much appreciated and I Highly recommend to all no matter where you are in your spiritual journey ~ if you can not order it due to circumstances ~ ask someone to do it for you…Thank You Brother Wilson ~ hope all is well.
27:37 can you explain the statue in daniel with the feet of clay and iron? Im still in and this does seem to speak of our time. Thank you.
The kingdom was established when those four kingdoms were still in existence. That was the time of Christ. However, the kingdom of God and of the Christ will only crush those kingdoms at Armageddon. That may be soon, or it may be a while yet.
There's that word again: "Soon".
😁
The governing body came into the spotlight I BET, when information on anything was available easy with internet and search engines 😂