"He's an ackerman, you can't *erased* his memories" This alone contradict the idea of eren visiting mikasa in paths, if that was the cased, mikasa should've have remembered as soon as their "path convo" ended, which didn't happen since eren CAN'T erase mikasa's memories. All paths visit were back in 131, not 138 nor 139, it was shown in the last chapter.
The one question is why did she remind Armin of the path conversation after said path conversation scene? Edit: Just realize he said something about said path convo by saying “if that was the case, Mikasa should’ve have remembered as soon as their ‘path convo’ ended”. Went through my head, but that doesn’t explain why she mention it to Armin in general.
Come on guys she is only a half-Ackerman. Her mother was most likely an Eldian desendand just like Ramzi, who did not "look" Eldian but deffinitely was one (you might remember that he saw Yimir before he died). Eldians are not limited to the internment zones ofMarley nor Paradis island, they are all over the world spread among many nationalities so Mikasa being one of them even only partially is the case most likely. That would make her voulnerable to Eren's memory altering abilities, also she could not enter the paths to begin with if she wasn't Eldian:D Like Levi, who is also an Ackerman but he was summoned by Eren in the latest episode. Please use your eyes and brain in sync, it will save you from stupid theories:)
@@webig1805 What’s weird is that Mikasa reminds Armin of the path conversation after said path conversation. The video doesn’t acknowledge that. One thing I disagree with you tho is that this theory “is stupid”. It’s not. Just needed a bit more explanation. However, one thing from this theory that is concrete is the fact in the cabin scene Eren said 4 years while paths takes place in a “thousand years” or “two thousand years”. Unless you can explain otherwise. Edit: Just... Year's the characters say lmao. 🤦♂️
@@asuraspath2262 I think you also have to acknowledge the fact that paths (according to Zeke and/or other characters) “felt” like years and in the cabin scene, Eren said “live the rest of 4 years”. So there can be a possibility that the cabin is not “paths”. However, I also do agree of the possibility of cabin BEING “paths” since Mikasa acknowledged the conversation that Armin had with Eren in paths to Armin himself after said conversation. So how does she know about it? Lastly and this is about being called a doomer, if you only base your arguments on “Isayama retconned it”, that’s not a good argument and that’s why people label you a dumb doomer for it.
Mikasa and Levi were in the paths, which means that the founder has some control over Ackermans. Erasing memories may just be a side effect of how attached Mikasa is to Eren. But we don't know for sure if thats the case. What we do know is that the cabin scene was not a separate timeline.
Damn, it's cool how everything makes perfect sense but now I have a doubt, on chapter 139 when Armin woke up he remembered the conversation with Eren, then Mikasa comes carrying Eren's head and she asks Armin if he remembered now too, when Eren came to visit them, but if the cabin is an alternate timeline then when did Eren talked to Mikasa?
I'm wondering the same thing, why would she tells armin "do you remember eren visited us", eren can't make her forget she's ackerman, I think that's a plot hole
i think although it was a real event eren still showed it to her, so instead of creating it in paths like with everyone else he showed her the memories
Good work but I have to disagree. Somehow Eren talked to her in paths. The proof is very simple: after Eren is dead, Mikasa asks Armin if Eren talked to him as well, something along those lines.
5:28 This is because he is lying to Mikasa, in reality he is the same as manga eren in paths, because he was talking to Armin and not Mikasa, he was able to say the truth. Even though cabin Eren wants himself to be Mikasa's only love, he still wants her to live happily so he tells Mikasa that. And I am not a doomer, I want an AOE so bad. I have dedicated so much of my precious time in theorizing, just give an AOE. I am just giving my opinion on this
He wasn't lying because its not the same eren. The whole video just proved that the two eren are not the same person, because eren CAN'T MANIPULATE ACKERMANS. Even in isayama's illustration for the bessatsu shonen he portrayed cabin eren holding manga eren's head. Two different eren in the same illustration. "We've caught a big fish" didn't know fish had eldian blood
@@trotoscolos6725 well, you know even manga eren told that girl who looks up to Mikasa to throw the scarf away. Eren just wants everyone to hate him, especially Mikasa, so *they* don't feel that they were supporting a genocide. Eren from all timelines has the same mindset, it's just the result of different actions that lead to different consequences.
@@IndianAniverse the scarf is chain to eren, that why eren tell her to throw away. if not, its all will repeat again and again because eren promise mikasa he will wrap that scarf as many time she want. that the vow eren make went 1st time he activate founding titan power just like Vow Renouncing War. eren can't brake that vow only mikasa by throw away the scarf. I think that will be divergent point or not.
@@james-wc9mk yes but I'm not sure about that. For example, in season 4 part 1 trailer mikasa without scarf but in release episode version, mikasa with red scarf.
I have become a pluralist after the recent episode, I have no doubt that the cabin was a timeline, but I am starting to doubt if the Anime really is another timeline. I have mixed feelings about the new episode, on one part it seems like Mappa is just trying to confuse AOE theorists and is deliberately making a few mistakes here and there but still providing some hopium. On the other part it seems to me like Mappa is just really inconsistent with its 'artistic choices'.
U make it sound like it's a battle of wits between Mappa and hopechads🤣🤣 one trying to mislead the other while the other tries to piece together concrete evidence
I think the persecution story is that king fritz would have captured the ackerman clan for complete protection even if titan powers are gone but the ackerman hd no choice nd served eldian and after some years they become slves and they realised that they have special powers thats why the edlidans have capture so they rebolted and then they were persecuted and i believe the murdereres who killed miaksa parents were sent by the royal clan
@@asuraspath2262 its the opposite. Ackermans are eldians that were experimented upon and the founding titan lost its control over them. Orientals are not eldians. They are literally another race from another country. Mikasa is half eldian and half oriental.
"He's an ackerman, you can't *erased* his memories" This alone contradict the idea of eren visiting mikasa in paths, if that was the cased, mikasa should've have remembered as soon as their "path convo" ended, which didn't happen since eren CAN'T erase mikasa's memories. All paths visit were back in 131, not 138 nor 139, it was shown in the last chapter.
He also can’t alter her memories either. And I’m pretty sure the headaches are from Ymir looking into her memories if im not wrong.
The one question is why did she remind Armin of the path conversation after said path conversation scene?
Edit: Just realize he said something about said path convo by saying “if that was the case, Mikasa should’ve have remembered as soon as their ‘path convo’ ended”. Went through my head, but that doesn’t explain why she mention it to Armin in general.
Come on guys she is only a half-Ackerman. Her mother was most likely an Eldian desendand just like Ramzi, who did not "look" Eldian but deffinitely was one (you might remember that he saw Yimir before he died). Eldians are not limited to the internment zones ofMarley nor Paradis island, they are all over the world spread among many nationalities so Mikasa being one of them even only partially is the case most likely. That would make her voulnerable to Eren's memory altering abilities, also she could not enter the paths to begin with if she wasn't Eldian:D Like Levi, who is also an Ackerman but he was summoned by Eren in the latest episode. Please use your eyes and brain in sync, it will save you from stupid theories:)
@@webig1805 What’s weird is that Mikasa reminds Armin of the path conversation after said path conversation. The video doesn’t acknowledge that.
One thing I disagree with you tho is that this theory “is stupid”. It’s not. Just needed a bit more explanation. However, one thing from this theory that is concrete is the fact in the cabin scene Eren said 4 years while paths takes place in a “thousand years” or “two thousand years”. Unless you can explain otherwise.
Edit: Just... Year's the characters say lmao. 🤦♂️
@@webig1805 Bro is either dumb, or trolling. Anyway. 3:47
Doomers only have one thing for themselves to say that IsAyAmA rEtCoNeD iT
At this point, yup
@@asuraspath2262 I think you also have to acknowledge the fact that paths (according to Zeke and/or other characters) “felt” like years and in the cabin scene, Eren said “live the rest of 4 years”. So there can be a possibility that the cabin is not “paths”.
However, I also do agree of the possibility of cabin BEING “paths” since Mikasa acknowledged the conversation that Armin had with Eren in paths to Armin himself after said conversation. So how does she know about it?
Lastly and this is about being called a doomer, if you only base your arguments on “Isayama retconned it”, that’s not a good argument and that’s why people label you a dumb doomer for it.
When you create the greatest manga master piece ending in history, and then one day you're like... NAH, I don't want that!
Mikasa and Levi were in the paths, which means that the founder has some control over Ackermans.
Erasing memories may just be a side effect of how attached Mikasa is to Eren. But we don't know for sure if thats the case. What we do know is that the cabin scene was not a separate timeline.
This is obvious.... Levi didn't had any Dream of Eren in Paths otherwise like others he must have also said something
@@asuraspath2262 he cares ab all eldians in paradis bro. BUT sacrifices are necessary
Damn, it's cool how everything makes perfect sense but now I have a doubt, on chapter 139 when Armin woke up he remembered the conversation with Eren, then Mikasa comes carrying Eren's head and she asks Armin if he remembered now too, when Eren came to visit them, but if the cabin is an alternate timeline then when did Eren talked to Mikasa?
I'm wondering the same thing, why would she tells armin "do you remember eren visited us", eren can't make her forget she's ackerman, I think that's a plot hole
@@theunknownplayer9069 she might have just thought it was a visit not an actual event
i think although it was a real event eren still showed it to her, so instead of creating it in paths like with everyone else he showed her the memories
@@theunknownplayer9069 it's not a plot hole when you put the lost girl ova into account
mikasa's time loop ability is not an ackerman thing it's only a mikasa thing just like the girl in muv luv that isayama based Aot on
Good work but I have to disagree. Somehow Eren talked to her in paths. The proof is very simple: after Eren is dead, Mikasa asks Armin if Eren talked to him as well, something along those lines.
5:28
This is because he is lying to Mikasa, in reality he is the same as manga eren in paths, because he was talking to Armin and not Mikasa, he was able to say the truth.
Even though cabin Eren wants himself to be Mikasa's only love, he still wants her to live happily so he tells Mikasa that.
And I am not a doomer, I want an AOE so bad.
I have dedicated so much of my precious time in theorizing, just give an AOE.
I am just giving my opinion on this
He wasn't lying because its not the same eren. The whole video just proved that the two eren are not the same person, because eren CAN'T MANIPULATE ACKERMANS. Even in isayama's illustration for the bessatsu shonen he portrayed cabin eren holding manga eren's head. Two different eren in the same illustration.
"We've caught a big fish" didn't know fish had eldian blood
@@trotoscolos6725 well, you know even manga eren told that girl who looks up to Mikasa to throw the scarf away.
Eren just wants everyone to hate him, especially Mikasa, so *they* don't feel that they were supporting a genocide.
Eren from all timelines has the same mindset, it's just the result of different actions that lead to different consequences.
@@IndianAniverse the scarf is chain to eren, that why eren tell her to throw away. if not, its all will repeat again and again because eren promise mikasa he will wrap that scarf as many time she want. that the vow eren make went 1st time he activate founding titan power just like Vow Renouncing War. eren can't brake that vow only mikasa by throw away the scarf. I think that will be divergent point or not.
@@shahrulzakri6352 the leaked chapter 138 scene in 100cam where mikasa throw thunder spear to erens titans teeth she didnt wear the scarf🤔
@@james-wc9mk yes but I'm not sure about that. For example, in season 4 part 1 trailer mikasa without scarf but in release episode version, mikasa with red scarf.
the KINO awaits us
What does kino mean
@@friedhotwingspretty much greatness.
Kino
Der Toten
kinda obvious but good proof
Kino as always 🔥
I have become a pluralist after the recent episode, I have no doubt that the cabin was a timeline, but I am starting to doubt if the Anime really is another timeline.
I have mixed feelings about the new episode, on one part it seems like Mappa is just trying to confuse AOE theorists and is deliberately making a few mistakes here and there but still providing some hopium.
On the other part it seems to me like Mappa is just really inconsistent with its 'artistic choices'.
U make it sound like it's a battle of wits between Mappa and hopechads🤣🤣 one trying to mislead the other while the other tries to piece together concrete evidence
I think the persecution story is that king fritz would have captured the ackerman clan for complete protection even if titan powers are gone but the ackerman hd no choice nd served eldian and after some years they become slves and they realised that they have special powers thats why the edlidans have capture so they rebolted and then they were persecuted and i believe the murdereres who killed miaksa parents were sent by the royal clan
the real eren is back!
By Primus balls this actually make sense
Cultured transformers fan I see 😏🤝
Very interesting 👍
Broo you re a genius, you re the real reviewer unlike other TH-cam "reviewers " who are spilling non sens in most of their "analysis",glad I found you
Eren said "you'll remember this all, but....."
💀💀 arumin didn't let him finish...bruh
In isayama I put my trust, he can just leave us hanging like this😢
Are ackermans eldians?
they are both different races
there is no proof of how they both are connected but they are both different
Some sources say they are eldians who were done experiments on
@@asuraspath2262 its the opposite. Ackermans are eldians that were experimented upon and the founding titan lost its control over them. Orientals are not eldians. They are literally another race from another country. Mikasa is half eldian and half oriental.
@@sayanbose4931 thank god i didn’t have to explain it