Creality Ender 3 S1 PRO: In-depth review, Ender 3 S1 VS Ender 3 S1 PRO, side-by-side comparison
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 พ.ค. 2024
- 00:00 Intro
00:58 Ender 3 S1 and S1 Pro Common features
01:50 Ender 3 S1 Pro 7 major upgrades
03:04 Ender 3 S1 Pro 3 minor upgrades
03:28 2 other changes compared with the Ender 3 S1
03:49 Assembly, set up
07:45 Test Print 1: Calibration Cube (Overture Green PLA) + print quality comparison
08:53 Test Print 2: 3D Benchy (Overture Green PLA) + print quality and power consumption comparison
09:11 Test Print 3: Eiffel Tower (Hatchbox White PLA)+ print quality comparison
10:22 Test Print 4: London Phone Booth (Prusa Orange PETG)
11:16 Test Print 5: Shelf Brackets (Overture Grey ABS)
11:51 Test Print 6: Phone mount body (Overture Nylon, copolymer of Nylon 6 and Nylon 6.6)
13:24 Test Print 7: Phone mount knob (Polymaker Glass Fiber Reinforced Nylon 6 Filament)
14:14 Test Print 8: Phone mount top (Polymaker Carbon Fiber Reinforced Nylon 6 Filament)
15:23 Pros
17:28 Cons
20:15 Conclusion
Welcome back to Aurora Tech Channel. Last December, I reviewed the Ender-3 S1. It was the most advanced Creality printer I have ever used. It is packed with all the updated features you can expect from a new generation printer and the print quality is outstanding. Last week, PerGear sent me this new Ender-3 S1 Pro to review. When I first looked at the specs, it looked like it was just an Ender-3 S1 with a high-temperature hotend that heats up to 300 degrees to print Nylon, Nylon Carbon Fiber, and other high-temperature filaments. However, it is actually much more than that. Some upgrades are obvious and some are just small details.
Affiliate Links:
Buy Ender 3 S1 Pro:
shrsl.com/48q1o
Buy Ender 3 S1 Pro from Amazon:
amzn.to/3OautY9
amzn.to/3ILHkz2
Buy Ender-5 S1, get SonicPad for free, Combo price $479 (with discount code)
shrsl.com/3xy7v
Discount code for Ender-5 S1 + SonicPad Combo:
US Store Save $120 discount code: 12ES5
CA Store Save $150 discount code: 15SE5
AU Store Save $150 discount code: AUS150
UK Store (no code is needed, GBP 499)
DE store (no code is needed, EU569)
EU store (no code is needed, EU569)
Ender 3 S1 ($390):
Buy from PerGear:
www.pergear.com/products/crea...
Buy from Amazon:
amzn.to/3PBuHZs
amzn.to/3aJ3vJy
amzn.to/3o8i8t1
Creality REFURBISHED 3D Printers (SAVE up to 50%)
bit.ly/3EGO2UR
Used Ender-3 ($79)
Maybe in bad condition, but if you know how to fix a 3D printer and have spare parts to replace by yourself, that could be an amazing deal:
bit.ly/3LPnzHw
Filament and other 3D printing accessories:
Overture PLA filament:
www.amazon.com/dp/B08MVLCFL1?...
Overture ABS filament:
www.amazon.com/dp/B087LXW6FP?...
Overture Nylon filament:
www.amazon.com/dp/B087R3WY6T?...
Polymaker PA6-CF Carbon Fiber Nylon Filament
www.amazon.com/dp/B08T1ZQFKR?...
Polymaker PA6-GF Glass Fiber Nylon Filament
www.amazon.com/dp/B08T152T9S?...
Double Sided Textured PEI Spring Steel Sheet (235x235)
www.amazon.com/dp/B09C5PZT8L?...
Comgrow $49 Dual Filament Dryer
bit.ly/3LadSTs
Related video:
Ender 3 S1 Review:
• Creality Ender-3 S1 In...
3D Models:
Tripod Phone Mount:
Original Design:
www.thingiverse.com/thing:242...
My remix:
I changed the bottom, so I don't need to insert another nut to fix it on the tripod.
www.thingiverse.com/thing:532...
Follow us on Twitter @aurora_lung - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
![[4K] TREASURE(트레저) “KING KONG” Band LIVE Concert 킹콩은 라이브를 찢어🦍 [it’s KPOP LIVE 잇츠라이브]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/p8bLLOxPDD8/mqdefault.jpg)
I've watched about a dozen S1 and S1 Pro videos today and yours is by far the most informative and easy to follow. Great job and thank you!
I’m a first time buyer , I’ve spent 2 days trying to find decent comparisons videos . This is literally the most in-depth yet easy to understand.
For a beginner like myself, this video was a godsend.
Easily the best I've watched so far, very well explained
Really like the way you structure your videos, very straight-forward. Exactly what I want from a video like this!
As someone getting into 3D printing now, I utterly love these videos :) Very well made, great production values, really informative :D
I purchased an Ender 3 S1 based on your previous review. I love it. I spend very little time tinkering with it. It works as is. My time is happily spent designing and making things. I have recommended this printer to other people and have forwarded your review of it to them. Great job Aurora!
You should try the community firmware, it added a lot of features on the screen menu.
github.com/mriscoc/Ender3V2S1
@@AuroraTech Thanks!
@@AuroraTech Will this firmware work on the S1 pro? I have tried several times now to flash my new S1 Pro, but it looks like there is no support for the touch screen. I really wish they didn't include a touch screen on the pro version 😢
@@AuroraTech will this work on the s1 Pro? I want to have better firmware on here to fix the bugs
What a well done video! Very well organized, filmed, and edited. Most helpful I've found so far.
These are the best descriptive and most comprehensive reviews I have seen. Clear, precise and very well presented.
Hands down best video out there. Easy and precise - nicely done!!!
Absolutely love your channel. Very informative, direct, easy to digest for a beginner like myself, and professional. Thank you so much for making your videos!
its good to see Creality printing things like ABS, nylon, and other more engineering grade filaments out of the box. It was a long road to get my ender 3 pro to get there.
Excellent review. Well structured and perfectly informative. You touched on every point that I wanted to know about this printer.
I am getting into 3D printing for my birthday. It was a little overwhelming until I came across your channel/video. Thanks, this is super helpful and I am bookmarking it for later.
One of the best videos out there, very well done..! Thank you.
It's hard to justify calling the print quality "outstanding" and "amazing" when there are huge blobs in the corners of the calibration cube. This has been an issue on all the Ender 3 printers, and they still haven't fixed it. It would only take a small mod to their mainboard to enable the Linear Advance feature in Marlin which would then fix this problem. The whole reason I switched to Klipper on my E3V2 was because of the huge blobs on corners. It might not seem like a big issue if you are just printing stand-alone parts, but if you are printing parts that are meant to fit together,, then it is a real problem. Apart from that, good review as always, thanks for sharing your thoughts
I’ve printed tons of functional parts without linear advance and haven’t had problems. I just adjust the scale of the object in Cura by 0.5 percent.
@@larrythehedgehog If you're happy with that result, then that's all that matters. But I wasn't happy with it. If you print 2 of those calibration cubes that are designed to fit together in a confined space, then the cubes will only touch in the corners, and you end up with a great big gap in between the parts, and I just don't find that to be an acceptable solution. The point that I was making is that this has been a problem on all of the Ender 3 printers, and it is something that would be very easy for Creality to fix, they just need to add UART control of the stepper drivers. To me, it seems silly that they would add all new bells and whistles to make a $500 printer, but they still can't get the fundamentals right, As I said ealier, the whole reason I ditched Marlin and switched over to klipper on my E3V2 is that Klipper is able to solve this problem without the need for UART control of the stepper drivers.
Wow! I have an original Ender 3 Pro and always wondered why the corners of my prints looked bulged. What is Kippler and can I add it to my old Ender? I may do this to the S1 Pro that I ordered as well if possible. It is kinda of important to me as I print engineering prototypes on this machine. Thanks.
@@darkrulier Marlin has a built-in feature called Linear Advance which is aimed at fixing this issue, however, it requires that the mainboard have software control over the stepper-motor drivers to work, and Creality, in their wisdom, decided that software control wasn't necessary. This is why Creality printers still suffer from this problem to this day.
Klipper is an alternative firmware for your printer. It is superior to Marlin in most aspects IMHO, however it requires a raspberry pi to run. Klipper has a similar feature to Marlin's Linear Advance called Pressure Advance, however, it does not require software control of the stepper drivers, and so will work with any of the Creality mainboards.
It was exactly this issue that led me to ditching Marlin and moving over to Klipper, but Klipper has so many other benefits that it has just been win-win
So, in Summary, to fix this issue on your ender, you either need to a) switch mainboards to one that has software control over the stepper drivers (most so), or b) Buy a Raspberry Pi and switch to Klipper.
@@johnrobinson3642 Thanks for the explanation, I'll look for a tutorial for this, I already have a raspberry pi attached to it for octoprint.
This is by far the most clear, concise and informative video on you tube and because of that i just had to subscribe. as somebody that loves 3D printing but is not very experienced at it, i find your videos extremely helpful........Thankyou
A super-professional review as always. Thanks.
This video has really helped me a lot! Keep up the good work.
I m new to this channel and I am very impressed with the quality of this review
Excellent comparison video! Great job!
Thank you! All the information I needed in a single video.
Holy moly!!! You and your brother are doing an awesome job!!! Very informative video. Thank you.
I found this channel while searching info for my 1st 3D printer. So far this channel provides the Most DETAILED information about all Ender3 series. BEST!
this is the 4th video Ive watched comparing these 2 printers, and it is by far the best I've seen!
All the others failed to give the direct side-by-side comparison of feature differences. Many of these aren't clear on Creality's website. This video literally made the choice for me based upon what is necessary to upgrade or not for the $80 (MSRP) price difference.
Thanks again!
I *really really* enjoy your voice and the style of the video! Love your content! I think I am subscribing
Wow, you really got the stuff !! What a great review !!
Love your videos! Very professional and informative! Keep up the magnificent work.
Thank you so much for this review! This was very organized and I was able to understand it very well. I think I am going to get the pro thanks to this video.
I ordered a S1 a few months ago after watching your review. Very happy with the printer.
I’m a you tuber as well and I’m just getting into 3d, I can’t tell you how much I appreciate your videos. Clear and concise. Keep up the great work I know it’s not easy
Love the channel. Great footage. Great hosting. Good work
I just preordered mine here in Gemany. Can´t wait. EXCELLENT review!!!! Thank´s alot.
You guys are Outstanding I've been debating about getting into 3D printing, the cost and which 3D printer to get into for beginners/noobees. Your in depth reviews and cost comparison allow for the end user to decide which way to go, especially if one is not comfortable playing with firmware. I appreciate and thank you both for your time and work, keep up the great work thanks.
First time watching your channel reviews on 3d printer and I am very happy that I watch this before buying the Ender 3 S1 Pro. Thankyou for this great video, it saved me a bunch of time doing research. Will love to support your channel and more. Thnakyou very much!! 😇
Great effort, thanks for providing this review. Keep up the good work.
By far this is the most Helpful Video on the Printer regarding Assembly, Suggestions, Tests with Different Filaments etc.
Thank you Soooo much! Greetings from Kuwait
the best review channel. great job.
Thank you for this! Very informative!
Excellent video review of the Pro! Thanks!
Thank you for the review. This is the printer I have been waiting on
Thank you for this. Tons of information here, I'm now one step closer to buying an S1 Pro.
Great comparison. Super informative and detailed.
Love your channel. Great reviews. Thank you.
Outstanding video review, thank you.
Just wanna say Keep up the good work you video was very nicely structured and very in depth i can safely say i got a good idea of what this machine is capable of thanks to you. Great Video Keep it up.
Why can't all comparisons be like this?
Clearly showing the differences, similarities and features.
Fantastic job!
Thanks for another great review video, Infact the only video that compare both Ender 3 S1 Pro and Ender 3 S1. Could you some day make a review video of comparison between Ender 3 S1 or S1 Pro with Prusa i3 Mk3S+
Super review. You always do a great job with your reviews and this one was very well presented and the details should help anyone make a more informed decision to purchase this printer for themselves. Once again, thank you.
out of all reviews on youtube I trust your reviews the most
Is Aurora the next best 3d printers reviewer ?!
Hi
Love your video's. Just ordered a Ender 3 S1 Pro from pergear. Will get it to Canada sometime in April. This will be my first 3D printer. I was on the fence between the Ender 3 S1 and the Prusa i3 MK3S+ kit for a month but this review made the difference. I like to tinker/build/modify so good quality Creality printing and your review won me over.
Thanks so much!!!
Rick Hubka for Canada
This is the only useful S1 pro comparison / unboxing / focusing on the actual detail and not filling an hour with personality BS :) Thanks my new E3S1pro arrived this week and i'm trying to get a profile migrated into the full version of Cura and Prusa.
Great review as always, lots of great additions on this printer. This seems like the go to starter printer if you want to print higher temp materials!
Fantastic video, very detailed!
Love the in depth review very helpful as I'm currently reviewing upgrading my existing ender 3 for an ender 5 plus but the fact that this is able to get up to 300c is definitely worth a look. Now I just need to decide what's more important print temp or print size 😂
A VERY well-done review!!!
Outstanding review. Thanks for your knowledge and skill. : )
Great comparison, probably the best one on TH-cam !
Question: Is drying the PLA, ABS, Nylon really important? what happends if you dont
Great video extremely informative pretty much everything I needed to know
Best review. Thank you 🙏😊
Thanks for a great video. I'm warming to the Ender 3 S1 Pro compared to other units in the sane price bracket. Thank you
Top of the line review material!
Another great video review and comparison. Clear & concise. I really appreciate your "things you like," "suggestions for improvement" and pointing out the issues/inconsistencies ( high temperature head using brass nozzles). Keep up the great work.
Question - what is you opinion on the different gantry attachment mechanism? The Ender 3 S1 & Pro attach the gantry to the top of the base and the screws thread into the gantry while the Solov S4 attaches the gantry to the side of the base and the screws thread into the base.
I didn't see a big difference, for a larger printer like SV04, it's just easier to insert the screws from the side.
Very smart, great video!
this was a ver good imformative video and was quick and too the point and made me want to buy the s1 pro instead now lol thankyou very much! would recommend this video over any other S1 VS S1 pro video
Great review!
liked and subscribed, I'm so glad that I run into your channel. Thank you!!!!
Excellent video. Very clear and informative 👌. Thank you 🇬🇧...
Great printer
Great review, and points
Thanks for sharing your experiences with all of us
Really like your videos. You speak really well and the videos are to the point and everything is very well explained. Please make some tutorial videos for newbies to 3 d printing if you have the time. Thanks for your work.
Delightful review.
Great tutorial as usual. 😃👍
Thank you very much 😃
Excellent video !!
Excellent presentation skills.
Great video. Thank you for your insight 😄
You are scarily factual and professional. I feel like i need to grow up...
Great video
well, you solidified my choice to buy the new S1 Pro, should be coming in a few days and can't wait to start using it since I have 2 Ender 3 V2 units that I've heavily upgraded, just got the dual Z axis upgrade kits and sprite hotend/extruder upgrades and with all that I've spent (in time and money) to get these printers where they perform pretty well, I could've saved time and money by just getting the S1 Pro. May sell my other printers off and get more S1 Pros haha loved the review, the clear/concise explanations, and the details provided. Subbing for sure.
What a great video! I learned a lot, thank you. I think you convinced me and I'll go buy this printer at Micro Center tomorrow!
Bravo 👏 Seriously. Great job. To the point
Non-functional Ender 3 Pro, Non-functional CR-10 V3. Purchased a Ender 3 S1 Pro. Watched your video review, and as you went over the concepts, realized everything I 've been doing wrong. All printers working, still fine tuning but getting great first prints from all of them. Thanks again. Clear, concise. Thank you.
This video is a terrific help to me, and I'm now completely hooked on your amazing reviews! I did a double-take when I saw how young you both are - smart as heck! I'd be beaming with pride if I had a daughter with even 25% of your smarts lol.
Thanks for these amazing, well-crafted, in-depth reviews! and the videography is simply pro-fe-shun-al too :D Keep it up !
P.S. I love when you say "Eiffel Tower" it's like "Challenge Extended!" hah. Totally an eating popcorn moment.
This video is amazing.
A really informative comparison video. Now I know why the Sprite hotend on the S1 Pro has a higher max temperature than the one on the S1. I will be printing LW-PLA and the S1 Pro is the one for this rather than the S1. Also the stand alone Sprite hotend available soon here in NZ is the 300c version, which I can install on my Ender 3, so I will have two printers for LW-PLA printing…Thanks much appreciated. Laurie New Zealand.
Keep up the good work👍
I like your video's keep the good job
i like the jazz music for your videos
Sei dolce, professionale, sincera ed affidabile nei consigli. Che Dio ti benedica sempre.
i own a couple of prusas and they work ofc great, but this S1 looks really good. Getting convinced of try it
Thank you to you and your brother, Aurora.
You are awesome! Thanks for this great video...
The best S1 review on youtube. Fact.
I really enjoy your videos and based on your review, just purchased the S1 Pro, arrived 2 days ago and I have printed several files. 100% pleased with the results. You mentioned community firmware - can you tell me more about this or direct to a “how to” area to find out more. Thank you greatly from NZ. Keep up the good work.
This is a great video. I wish I'd seen it when setting up mine. I will say there are a number of things I found difficult when setting up as this was my first 3d printer. However you covered more than anyone else I've seen when reviewing it. A rather large problem I found was that you cannot pause and resume prints. There's a bug in the included LCD screen where you cannot resume after putting a pause command in your gcode. It won't even resume if you use a timed pause. So you cannot do multi-color prints, print on fabric, add magnets, etc. This may not matter for some, but ut is one of the reasons I bought a Sonic Pad - which was a huge pain in the ass to get working (though your other video was invaluable once I *did* sort out the firmware issues.) I actually love the printer when it's working but I think consumer-ready is still a ways off for Creality. There a number of silly little things that could be fixed with better programming.
such nice video!
Good job!
Thanks for the excellent comparison, Aurora Is it possible to upgrade the S1 to be able to print nylon and other high-temperature materials?
Way more thorough then most companies 👌🏽
You guys are so awesome. I learn all I need in your reviews, so detailed, Thank You. My question is what should I do with my 10S Pro V1? I have made a few upgrades but WOW, The S1 is outstanding and the S1 Pro is so complete. Will 10S Pro ever get any of these upgrades too? I print 1.64 scale model trains and need the bigger cube of the 10S. Seems like the best approach may be to join the ranks of multiple printer shops. As we increase production for customer parts this S1 Pro could be a work horse for us. $500 is not too bad for the feature rich machine. Thank You both so much, very informative, and again Thank You Parents too! Great job by all. Dennis in Virginia
You're awesome 👍keep up the good work
Another great review from this sister-brother duo! I'm a 3D printing newbie and I am hooked onto your channel. Since the pricing on the S1 Pro is almost getting within the range of the Prusa i3 MK3S+ kit (as also mentioned by another commenter), it would be interesting to get your thoughts on whether these should even be considered at par. A head-to-head video match up between the two on some challenging prints and materials would be a bonus :)
The kit is the kit. It’s only reasonable to compare this to the assembled printer, which is 2.2x the cost after shipping.
The prices are still miles apart. The PRUSA is 60% more expensive.
Excelent Video, I really like your clear pro and con section, also the Variety of materials and the messurement of the energy consuption. I think the videos coul'd be further improved by printing extreme hard test Items, with low clearance, overhangs etc., where printers do fail, so you can see when they fail and compare them in this categories.
so make it
@@ChadLuciano I'll watch it.