ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 พ.ค. 2024
- In a conversation with veteran journalist Neelu Vyas, HW News' Managing Editor Mr. Sujit Nair discusses the Supreme Court's recent remarks regarding the Election Commission of India (ECI) and Form 17C, which contains booth-wise voter data. On May 24, the Supreme Court declined an NGO's request to direct the ECI to upload polling station-wise voter turnout data on its website during the Lok Sabha elections. The court, through a vacation Bench comprising Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma, stated that issuing such directions would be challenging due to the manpower required. With five phases of polling completed and two remaining, the court decided not to interfere at this stage. The interlocutory application filed by the Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR) was adjourned and will be listed before a regular bench after the elections.
#ElectionCommissionOfIndia #ECI #ElectionCommission #BJP #Congress #MCC #SupremeCourt #Form17C #SC #ElectionCommission #ADR #Constitution #JusticeDYChandrachud #JusticesJBPardiwala #HWNews #SujitNair
Next Prime Minister is Rahul Gandhi. We want educated PM
Fir ro kyun rhe ho evm ka bidwa bilap 😂
*NO MODI WAVE-- ONLY HEAT WAVE IN INDIA*
No Modi wave but Modification wave popularly called Manipulation.
😂😂😂😂😂😂keep hydrated please! Seems you are having power cuts. Get cool soon!😊
Losers always make excuses before losing
Eci is a bjp commission . Only guide bjp and act for bjp.
ECI's role is only to make sure BJP comes back to power or face the heavy metal and thrash music
ECI will ensure it delivers Victory to Modi & Amit Shah. Democracy is Dead & Dusted in India.
Agree
I think EC acts like Anil Masi not like T.N sasion
What if Rajiv Kumar released the data after it was manipulated? Why did he take so long to release it now? Can anybody answer this query?
If Rajiv Kumar is found to be playing games with the people of India, he must be jailed along with his family including his parents who apparently has nurtured such a chor.
One never knows .for fame money and power he is prepared to polish PMs boot.alongwith him modi and shah too should be jailed. What they have done in Gujarat is the starting point to disaster
Brave and courageous journalist.
Good wishes.
Wonderful editorial wow Neelu’s response indeed is vibrating and it’s the fact. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👌👌🙏🙏
Nilu vyas very bold journalist. Raised right Qs.
Rajiv
Canada
Nilu is nilu she's amazing. I love to hear her when she speaks.
It's great that we as a nation have people like nilu .
Thank you nilu
This is a good programme. Your choice of madam neelu vyas is great.
Very happy to see this episode .... the detailed ECI...
Neelu rightly exposed a crook
Election commission has been appointed by MODI AND MOTA BHAI.
May be judiciary asked indirectly to release the data before next hearing to save the reputation of the ECI and SC
निलु मेम बहोत कडे,सच्चे सवाल सरकार को बेधडक पुछती है, धन्यवाद निलूजी .
if i hv some reserve of optimism in r country is all bcoz of these enlighten individuals👍
I just fell in love with Neelu's arguments and I love her language. God bless her.
Super we are all with you
Have been an ardent admirer of Ms Neelu Vyas in her role as a journalist. She is an intrepid anchor and conducts her programmes with admirable clarity of thought and expression. Her analytical, incisive skills, her humanitarian perspective, her marvellous felicity of venting her views in both English and Hindi languages coupled with her no-holds-barred rational, plausible criticism of the powers that be, bear testimony to the fact that Ms Neelu is sincerely discharging her duties as a journalist with a profound sense of integrity and impartiality. May her arduous endeavour in waking and shaking up a somnolent socio-politico system reap rich dividends in the path of national regeneration.
In simple terms under Pradhan sevak regime, sangh has penetrated into almost every govt institution. They are trained to work in certain way and they are doing exactly the same.
Thank you for this episode
Nilu you are great
Pl. Understand Mr. Rajiv Kumar is not appointed on behalf of public of India ... He is bound to work on behalf of Modi ji who has appointed him . Who has given him livelihood..
It’s always a pleasure to listen to Neeluji. Thanks for bringing her on HW.
"मैंने किसी चोर को अवतार लेने के लिए धरती पर नहीं भेजा है।" राम ने कहा! 😀😀😀
Great job madam we need more of you ❤❤❤❤
Right 👍
Thanks for the candid interview
Why is the BJP not interested in the form 17/C...dall main kuch kala hai
India’s democracy has been on disconcerting decline. In 2021, Freedom House downgraded India’s status from a free democracy to a “partially free democracy.” The V-Dem Institute went even further, categorizing India as an “electoral autocracy” and placing it in a category alongside its historical rival, Pakistan. India’s global Democracy Index ranking slipped from 27 in 2014 to 46 in 2022 as a result of democratic backsliding, according to the Economist Intelligence. Democratic backsliding under Modi has taken on many forms-cracking down on political dissent and the free press, intimidating political opponents, vilifying ethnic and religious minorities, and revoking the autonomy of the Jammu and Kashmir territory (over which India, China, and Pakistan struggle for control), to name just a few.
Vote for Congress to save democracy
It is a treat to listen to such logical n intellectual journalists n activists
Excellent discussion. Kudos to both ❤
Golmaal hai bhayi sab Golmaal hai
Sleeping commission.
The EC has noright to call us trouble makers
11 days, 6 days, 4 days.... they mastered the process over each cycle.
Neelu Vyas on fire
Its such a delight to hear two good minds discussing ECI and its decision making abilities.
Good interview..
Questioning is a problem now...all have to clap n nod.
Very suspicious activities by ECI. SUPREME COURT should have taken strong measures in order to save democracy instead of sparing EC and defer the case .
Neelu ji 👍 great explanation on facts....
Daring personality....
Never seen such a Biased ECI.
BJP is not asking for 17C because d increase in votes is for them. So why will they push for 17C?
Are you guys naive? RK has been handpicked by Modi (against SC guidelines) to meet the tasks entrusted to him. The main task is somehow make BJP cross the finish line. Only a massive margin can make India alliance to come to power.
What is disturbing is for all simple and basic transactions like withdrawing money from bank, getting gas cylinder, filing FIRs etc, we may need to approach courts in future.
What a word to end the pleasure!!!!!!! BHAJANS 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂. BUT when deeply meditated, ITS A FEAR OF LIVING IN THE PRISON!!
Why ruling party is not worried about change in percentage of votes?
There should be atleast 9 members committee for the appointment of ECIs . Two from Judiciary, Two from Govt , Two from Opposition, The President of India, Two from Civil Society . Then we will can have best ECIs.
ECI must work hard to restore its credibility.
To the point. Great work
Failed to win the hearts of Indians.
Yes we were checking after casting vote that was Slip printed correct details, button pressed correct .. election commission brought this situation.
already failed
They know every thing but they will not do. they don't want to do. They feel people are slaves.
But still there is a chance of manipulation. It may be that the votes can be taken out from the opposition candidates and that number of votes can be added to the candidates of the ruling parties. This could have been the reason for the delay in announcing the final voters turnout.
ECI is HMV (His Masters Voice) . No point crying ECI when the appointment is questionable supported and allowed by a system. I will never vote again if ECI is not transparent.
No doubt, Judiciary is also lenient on this Matter...They are living in the comfort zone..
They are not at all bothered to the people of India..
What role? These rascals should be charged with dereliction of duty.
well answered Neelu, I hope India is not heading towards a civil war......BJP has to be chased away to keep peace in our country.
He is not failing he is made to fail.
Yes, ECI working very hard to fail INDIA. All his actions & statements shows that he is biased towards ruling party
Thanks a million Miss Nellu for your dare to comment
"I have not sent any thief to earth to incarnate." Rama said! 😀😀😀
In Odisha ,we observe that ,ECI is the poppet of BJP.but no action for BJP for serious violation of laws made by ECI
Spl CJI should take Executive order from special questions to monitor only BJP to monitor biased and penalize heavy financial penalty to stop Nautanki Bazaar.
Done deal, ECI already did their job. No point debating on C17 form, damage is done. The party whom ECI wanted to support has already done. T N Sheshan ki aatma k aak bahut dukh ho raha hoga. Kabhi socha na thaa ki ek din aisa bhi ayega jab ECI ........
Awe the lady is stinging in her expressions on the conduct of the CEC. 👍
Jai Congress
Sujit, thanks as always, would you have Ms Nilu answer thisQs: would this manipulation lead to the ruling dispensation returning to power unfairly.
T Q both eminent journalist, the way a series of questions put over to & the answers/replies received, indeed the debate of the instance.
Election Commission of India is a constitutional body and they are expected to be impartial and fearless. All their actions should be transparent. Which party wins the Election is not important. What is important is that we should conduct our elections in a transparent manner so that people will have faith in our system.
One retd ias officer suggested...soon after results released if there is huge 17c discrepancy then people from all constituency can put a case in sc and sc will definitely take it up coz the case is from all people
As of now sc i believe cannot send any notice during elections
I always like her views in every interview she does
❤❤❤❤❤
What happens to the 1cr 7lacks Extra votes, Don't you think this should be removed
Everybody has an opinion of ECI ..it's exactly the same opinion !😅
Janta will finished EC Rajiv kumar
If I remember correctly at my age of 82+ now,once PM Indira was banned to contest Elections perhaps by Allahabad H.C for violating MMC during Election. Why the same should not be applied on the people,be he the Lord Vishnu by debarring from contesting Elections ?
Surely I N C win this time MP Election and INDIA Alliance form the Govt this time,
Inspite ECI behaviour Mr. Rahul Gandhi is aswast to become pm himself 😂
Modi ji is now non -biological..
No matter how much you see him bodily.😂😂
Won't All this will be more reasons to justify the call to cancel or disband election process henceforrh in rhe country???
I am concerned that it is a set up to justify next move of the next government (if the same one returns back)?
There is no point 👉 EC. I guess damage is already done. SC could v played a more responsible role in this process. Opposition too is spineless here.
चुनाव आयोग और सुप्रीम कोर्ट की कृपा से यह चुनाव मोदीजी जीत चुके हैं। ये चुनाव छल कपट और परपंच से हाईजैक किया जा चुका है। अब केवल मोदी की जीत का एलान बाकी है 😢
Very good planning to defend the win or loss in elections are getting ready by parties for debate after results and its outcome for parties .
Let’s hope the best that the results will be as per people’s mandate and not fabricated.
What's the remedy of manipulation of whole electrol process? When it's so corrupt why it's allowed to carry on? There should be fare & free election.
But what guarantee is there that the data was not manipulated befor publishing given that it took so many days
क्यों अब अंग्रेजी बुक रहे हैं ??
जब ECI का चयन मोदी जी ने मनमाने ढंग से किया , जब लोक सभा चुनाव 2024 को महीनों लम्बा खींचा गया , तभी अंग्रेजी बुकना चाहिए था ।।
अब बुकने से कुछ नहीं होगा 😮
Sudden change of EC as regards to announcing of voting data makes me suspicious, there is every chances government creating a situation for revoting because INDIA alliance is in advantage and they have the edge:
1 don’t insist for revoting , in case candidate is winning without manipulated votes they can be declared winners
2 if any one is winning with manipulated votes, revoting must done
Can have reelection if whole thing manipulated by ECI ?
In one word ECI is a patriot of Modi
My question is whether the voter turnout data has been given boothwise or parliamentary constituency wise. If it is boothwise, then that has to be tallied with the Form 17C and if it is constituency wise, then the figures given in each of the Form 17C have to be added and the total number of voters turnout has to be tallied with the figures given by the Election Commission.
EC is Autocratic
The ECI lawyer is misrepresenting facts to the hon'ble court. He must be sacked for his idiotic arguments. Such a stupid fellow must not represent the people of India.
🎉
Yes.... Of course.... EVM helps BJP TO WIN ....WHOM TO OPPOSE IT?... Why the opposite parties are unable to avoid it....Why they are relevant
@akash. Pleae cover this topic jointly too. With. Rsvish kumar and news minute
My prediction is, if bjp failed, ec will be disqualify 5 to 10 congress mpies and come back
29:15 on..
Why is it fair enough if the bench says we will not take up this case unless all phases are over? I dont understand why the so called candid journalists all shiver in their pants and stop short of criticizing the judges. Pissing scared of contempt of court?
This is the problem. One of the biggest problems of judiciary is the excessive fear in public, of criticizing the judges. Why is criticism of judge, automatically contempt of court? We shouldnt make judges immune to criticism as if they are some divine beings.
In a true democracy everything should be open to criticism, including, individual judges, judiciary and courts.