Will the Rohingya be safe on a remote Bangladeshi island? | Inside Story
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ก.ค. 2024
- The lives of nearly a million Rohingya who escaped Myanmar to Bangladesh are being uprooted again.
Bangladesh's government has started moving thousands of them to a remote island that's prone to cyclones and floods.
It's rejecting criticism from rights groups that the new camp on Bhasan Char is unsafe.
So why is there still no permanent solution to the crisis, three years after the Rohinyga were forced from their homes?
Presenter: Mohammed Jamjoom
Guests:
Yasmin Ullah - Rohingya activist
Saad Hammadi - South Asia Campaigner at Amnesty International who focuses on Bangladesh
Dr Ambia Perveen - Chair, European Rohingya Council
- Subscribe to our channel: aje.io/AJSubscribe
- Follow us on Twitter: / ajenglish
- Find us on Facebook: / aljazeera
- Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
#AlJazeeraEnglish #InsideStory #Bangladesh #Rohingya #Myanmar
![CAMPปลิ้น | EP.77[1/2] ก็ไม่ได้ชอบเอาชนะ แต่เรื่องอะไรต้องแพ้!!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JraaBYOd7I0/mqdefault.jpg)
Hats off to Bangladesh. They done their duty more than enough
Shame on Al Jazeera for biased report.
Agreed. Unlike Qatar Bangladesh is at least doing something for them
What started the Rohingya problem?
Beginning in 2012, the first incident occurred when a group of Rohingya men were accused of the rape and murder of a Buddhist woman (Albert 4). Buddhist nationalists retaliated by killing and burning Rohingya homes. The international community responded by denouncing this "campaign of ethnic cleansing".
Yes it is but why bangladeshi correspondence refuse to attend. We have to attend and defend what they want to stablish
It is a 40 year old problem , it started in 1978 - from then on its always been at least 300k Rohingyas in Bangladesh.
not the first time and won't be the last
This is the failure of UN, EU, OIC and International community. They failed to solve the longstanding problem of Rohingya. They failed to solve the core issue of Rohingya for decades. We can't never blame the government of Bangladesh.
Ertugrul says they're not trying totally the opposite
Atleast Bangladesh government is trying to do something for them..much appreciated
It is the failure of primarily the rich Muslim nations. They must come forward.
Why blame EU?
@@truthprevails5173 because EU and America is the real lord of UN ...
This is failure of islamic world. Qatar, Saudi Arabia...
Full Hipocresy..
This is the best we can do as a small country with a big population.. Human rights should talk with Myanmar, when they will take back there people with dignity and will provide social security.!
Agree... aljazeera never appreciate things
@@user-lr6hw4dq4t no no brother aljazeera just concern fr rohingya n trying to save image of bangladesh bcoz HR n west cristicising..they making complicated like middle east😊😊
@@user-lr6hw4dq4t plz brother dnt make sectarian among muslim wrld..plz...i request my dear brother...
@@xtreme6018 Nobody's criticizing us, it's the fascists and libtards
Sure bro Bangladesh did a great job, and God will give prosperity to your country for your good deeds, youg rohingya people are sincere and hardworking, will be a great asset for a nation growing financially in recent years..
Good luck and God bless you all.. Love and respect from India🇮🇳
Bangladesh is doing best, any country can do in the matter of humanity! Proud to be a Bangladeshi 🇧🇩❤️
There is no talks about Myanmars doing, lol the international medias are turning on Bangladesh. LoL...what a joke.
Bangladesh is still doing lots.
Myanmar: We will not take back rohingyas
Rohingyas: We will not go back to
Myanmar unless they give us rights
UN/international community & journalists : We have spotted the biggest genocide of this century & we will accuse Bangladesh instead of
Myanmar
Bangladesh: We are relocating citizens of
Myanmar to a new island to ensure Rohingya people safety & security.
Can They Speak Arakan language?
Why Myanmar should Accept them as a citizen of their. They Can't Even talk Arakan Or Myanmar Language.
Just My Idea. Don't Blame Other.
@@user-zw8mt4nc1l They can, and language is no big issue. in Bangladesh, there are minorities living with the bengalis who are most, but they have their own language. So, language is no issue
No single country speaks only one language.. making assumptions based on only language shows only ignorance
Yes no single language but Myanmar country have Major Burma Language
And the Ethnic Group have ethinic language But They can't even Talk Arakan Language. You Need To see chinese shan state They can talk Shan language and China.
@@user-zw8mt4nc1l Language is no issue. It can be learned. But that reason Is too ridiculous to throw people out of country
Bangladeshi here. Rohingyas are very happy to be in Bhashanchor. They will, for the first time get to 'live'. The kids are playing without having to worry about anything. I don't know why the west is desperately trying to prove that the Rohingyas aren't well in Bhashanchor.
They do what has the father (colony) teach them.
There are no 5 stars hotel for NGO that's why it is bad.
🤣🤣🤣
True 🔥
Gotchuu. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
That's true
Right
This is much more effective and humanitarian solution to this problem compare to other refugee crisis around the world. Can you ever show any kind of relocation of refugees around the world with having good accommodation, sanitary,food and security what that is provided in Bangladesh which is one of the most populated country of the world 18 million even millions of her own citizens is not provided with these facilities???
One thing you need to understand that Bangladesh had received a less money from International organisations comparison to other refugee crisis faced countries.
Absolutely right you are.
So true....
*180 million (not 18 million)
@Rashed Ahmed Thanks for the correction, this is a common mistake of mine something expressing in Million or billion
Please AL Jazeera go to Myanmar, ask Suu Kyi to make more comfortable living places and healthy safe environment for her people (Rohinga's), Bangladesh have done more than great despite limited resources. Criticize carefully and responsibly.
Then why bangladeshi crying and saying Rohingyas r problamatic
@@themoviemaniahindiandengli5121 whether they are problematic or not they have the right to go back to their homes.
Why Aljazeera not pushing the Qatari or Saudi government to take them and give citizenship ?, they have land, money and same Islamic culture !
Try to create pressure on Myanmar instead of Bangladesh. That will help Rohingya people..
I agree with you bro from 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
Salute Bangladesh for their courage to help rather than sympathizing words.
India built 250 homes for rohingyas. Bangladesh did the most than any other country. These are countries who doesn't need to do anything. But they did
If the Human Rights have an issue, they should courageously question Myanmar first and the remaining so called rich and socially forward countries.
One day god will bless Bangladesh for these efforts.
Bangladesh is trying to help as much as it can....But what you have done in this three years Against Myanmar... Why you the concern people are not forcing Myanmar to take back the refugees....
Myanmar :Hi 🔫😑🗡
Other People's : ask Bangladesh
Aljazeera : Ok
Shame to all international organisations. They’re interested to continue the problem.
They will be safe on a remote island of England.
Saudis should take them
Muslim countries should take them
No one would take them
Why don't other muslim majority countries step up to help rohingyas? Bangladesh is tiny country,Most of its own indegeneous inhabitants doesn't have homes to live!Al jazeera should pander their qatari to take some rohingya refugees instead of critising Bangladesh!
NO ONE WANTS DEVIL IN HOME
So why don't Arab nations wiz lots of oil backed economy and wealth help them(such as Qatar and Saudi )?
Saudi Arabia did Take over 500K Rohingya stop spreading disinformation You dummy
@Akbar Al-Riyadhi rich arab world doing nothing for Palestine
@Akbar Al-Riyadhi Arabs are helping Palestinians by shaking hands with israel.
They cant do nothing except lip service.. they can't even able to solve Palestine issue in their neighbourhood, how can they solve a issue which is thousands of miles away..
Stop talking nonsense against Bangladesh 🇧🇩 and start raising your voice against Myanmar.
I hope they can start over, create farms and do some jobs, I believe humans doesn't need much to stay alive.
Agriculture & farming can change their future....
Bangladesh Government did good thing.
No, but if the UN had any use for its existence then the Rohingya would be safely living in Myanmar right now. What's more baffling is that the limited capabilities of Bangladesh who herself is incapable to provide for its own people is being questioned on what it provides for the displaced people of Myanmar.
People who give an idea and just give advice is different from those who act on the real site.
If you ever feel useless just think of the UN.
With humble, i would like to ask a question.
1) What the international organization have done in last 3 years to repatriate rohingya refugees to their own country?
2) Why only focusing on relocation ? why not focusing on repatriation?
please stop complaining to Bangladesh who are still sacrificing, and govt. trying to do their best for the refugees.
Same question is running in my mind. Bangladesh did it's best to give them a better Life. UN should focus, how we will force Myanmar to take back there people with respect..
May God help everyone who have problems
Myanmar will never take them back. Thats a reality ...if the islands are given to rohinghas ,best to send expertise or skilled persons to help them create a life
How about helping them return back their home in Myanmar instead of complaining. How’s it Bangladesh’s responsibility to look after them? America has vast amount of vacant land and needs population growth Why don’t they take some of those unfortunate people?
Well sweety as a black American I would love some of that land first
@@realdeal8303 you definitely should
@@realdeal8303 yup capitalism is just neo-coloniaism .
I personally am a democratic socialist and I think USA should divided the wealth amongst all of its classes and isn't let the top 5% own 70% of the country.
@@realdeal8303 👍
May ALLAH shower them with his special Mercy and Blessings.
The best solution to solve this deadlock! They have never been Myanmar nationals, and they belong to Bangladesh. Burma doesn't need to take them back!
Good decision Bangladesh, Good work BD navy 🇧🇩
ভাই আপনার চ্যানেল এর নামটি আমার অনেক ভালো লেগেছে।
নামটা রাখেন পাকি-ভারত আর আইএস-ইসকন মুক্ত বাংলাদেশ চাই
We will request our govt to arrange Las Vegas type amusement for western media and NGO's at Bashanchor.
Take one rohingya family to live with your family, share your house with them.
If you can do that, then point your finger towards Bangladesh
NGO'S BUSINESS IS OVER SO THEY ARE SCREAMING .
Bangladesh is doing best for Rohingyas
Agreed
I also agreed
Al Jazeera pls focused on Myanmar government why they still did not take back their citizens. International community should pressure on Myanmar government to take their citizens as soon as possible. Bangladesh already densely populated country in the world so no other choice. Later Bangladesh government will forced them to go back Myanmar their country.
It is not restore why are you fooling people
@@abdulsalamchoudhary7117 source?
Of course they are safer than in Myanmar 🔥🔥
Well done. Shame on myanmarian fascists. Im türk-bhudist and my heart with rohingiyas.
What if we send some Rohinga to Doha? Do you accept them? The answer is no. Because You are so rich but the refugee was so poor. Bangladesh did the best thing that you never could do.
Prayers for Rohingya people for thier new home may Allah protect you always and make this place safe.
Salute to Bangladesh government thanks for your effort may Allah reward you.
Thanks you Bangladesh 🇧🇩💝
Bangladesh TV channel had visited Bhashan Char and have created a beautiful place. We have listened to folks who are in Bhashan Char who were delighted.
So why are Bangladeshi people also not living there?
Rohingya want repateiation not relocation.
@@anitaschug5402 Because it was build for Rohingya people not for us.
Homeless people are actually eager to go there.
I would like to appreciate Bangladesh. Despite having hard times, they are doing their best to provide quality lifestyles to the Rohingya community. The world should come forward to solve the issue rather than pointing a finger towards Bangladesh.
That's a great hospitality of Bangladesh 🇧🇩🇧🇩
Instead of making news articles on "will the Rohingyas be safe on a remote Bangladeshi island", news channels should make videos and articles on Myanmar's genocide on these rohingyas.
Bangladesh being a small country has done a lot for the Rohingyas !! I think its countries like Pakistan , Malaysia , Turkey and many other Islamic countries who call themselves flag bearer of Islam needs to take them in their countries and settle them !!
What facilities are available for over 3K refugees of bosnia trying to enter in Europe. Not a single report on that. Well done yellow journalism. Carry on Al jazeera.
Sir Bosnia is in Europe-
@@izimations i mean to say trying to enter in EU
Well done Bangladesh. Action speak louder than words.
why UN, western media and international NGOs not interested about Bashanchor because there is no five star hotel facility for them. Shame on them.
I agree with you
There is no 5star hotel and this is the main pain for NGO ... WE KNOW EVERYTHING ..... DONT MAKE US FOOL
Bangadesh played good roll despite world were doing nothing,❤️❤️ atleast you took them .may ALLAH bestow mercy on you.👍👍..even my country took them but not much...touch wood, Allah protect from evil eyes🇮🇳🇮🇳🇧🇩🇧🇩
I believe those who against the vashanchor actually they're all agency are making money by rohunga.
if vasan char is not safe place for live,how million of Bangladeshi live near southern part where you can't find even this type of facilities.they are affecting for climate change.why rich countries or international media is not concern.
Bhashan char is a safe place.... If UN or other country thinks it is not good for them please take them to your country or help them to get back to their motherland mayanmer. Bangladesh is doing so much for them and don't blame.
I agree with you brother
The Rohingya issue is the biggest crisis in the world. Where is humanity now? Where are the world's great leaders now? Why don't the great leaders of the world help the Rohingya their rights back? Why aren't world leaders pressuring Myanmar to take back the Rohingya? I'm so sad for these people. And just the fact that they still to this day haven't received any Justice. Will The Rohingya Ever See Justice?
Salute Bangladesh.
Great step taken by our brother country Bangladesh. Love from pakistan❤❤❤
Why are they victim-blaming the Bangladeshi government. Can they not appreciate the work that the Bangladeshi government is doing, which the UN was supposed to do themselves? They need to fix the problem in Myanmar because it’s getting out of control. Why don’t they give the North Rakhine area to Bangladesh. Bangladesh has a massive population in comparison to their land mass. How can they house such an influx of people. This can only mean one thing: they’re not helping Bangladesh, instead victim blaming them because they are a Muslim-majority country.
Bangladesh has its own people to take care during this tough covid times..they have supported the rohingyas to the best they can and it is extremely unfair to make rohingyas completely Bangladesh's responsibility.. News channel and NGO' s are all bark and no bite when gathering international support to pressurize the Myanmar govt..
UN agencies have been invited many times to see the process . Why lie continuously ?
Because, Al Jazeera don't like Bangladesh.
Vashanchor is more better than Cox’s Bazar. But Indian media as well some international media spreading negative propaganda
Agreed
Who is these wrong headed people to give wrong feed back to tv / media?
Yes they will be safe.... Go see for your self...you are more than welcome to take them to your 5 star hotels...we are doing more than we can for them
sahi kaha ,yeah 57 arab kya krrhi hai ??
Qatar should accept some refugee
Agreed
@Harendra Shekhawat Well said bro⭐
@Kabir Miah Well it's not the job of India to take care of your refugees, talk to UN or ur islamic nation they don't give a dm about Bangladesh then why would India should but then also India has build the 250 house to rohingyas.
Also India is not the superpower
u got misunderstanding.
Superpower is the US. India comes on 4th rank and sooner or later it would come to 3rd or maybe 2nd or maybe be 1st crazy.
@Kabir Miah Then who started commenting, why shouldn't India accept some refugees??? 😂😂😂
@Harendra Shekhawat Same goes for the hindus population in these countries😔😪
Allah will cruise them who are torturing another human being😭
Take some of them to Qatar, let's see some example of humanity .
Vasancor is the best than Cox’s Bazar Rohingya camp.Sone NGO, international broadcast, and Indian midia proganda Against Bangladesh. But they cannot talks about Mayanmer 🤬🤬🤬
Check Ananda Bazar News
Bangladesh is doing more than most big countries. Human rights should look at Myanmar and not Bangladesh.
Stop speaking and start doing. Send Rohingya people to their homeland with dignity and respect. Do not blame the country whom helped them. Bangladesh is a poor country but still they are doing what they can. So please stop playing blame game and start help.
Qatar should take responsiblity of all Rohingyas. Instead of criticizing Bangladesh. Bangladesh already done enough. 🙂
I met few boys from Rakhain when I was in Malaysia ,Malasia and Indonesia give shelter to them in a big number, they told me the spine chilling ordeal of looting and grabbing what they earned by generations
They were rich and educated, even in Malaysia they are working hard and earning enough, but what they really want either go back to their home country live life normally, if Bangladesh succeed to put them back to track they will be a great asset for their nation, their sincerity and hardwork will bring prosperity to Bangladesh.
That island houses is better than my house!
What a wonderful gesture by Bangladesh, they were not forced to do anything yet they acted👏👏👏👏👏
All I can say is most sensible leader anywhere now.
Rohingya refugees should make a huge army and take their mayanmar back ..... otherwise it is useless to protect those who can't stand for their people and motherland ..... Respect for bangladesh from india 🇮🇳🇧🇩
I cannot help laughing when you talk about the Rohinga people being traumatized at the thought of repatriation at Vashanchar. The real trauma they experienced occurred in Myanmar where they were being burnt alive, their children being thrown in the fire and their women being raped by the Myanmar Army. Why did not you talk about that trauma, may I ask you, Mr. Journalist?
These people are prolly overwhelmed by everything happening at such a fast pace. The conditions on Bhashan Char are good to say the least. They have free food, shelter, water, even wifi! If Bangladesh had the financial prowess of Qatar, it would've been even more amazing. Bangladesh has the highest density of population itself (in the world) they're still doing so much. Dear Qatar owned channel before spreading negativity, have your facts cleared. Easier said than done. You should respect Bangladesh dude. It's a golden country, sonar Bangla with an equally golden heart❤❤
Sod off! Hats off to Bangladesh for doing this while being a low income earning country. The Middle East should take the refugees rather than complaining.
But where did they come from, so many people didn't just drop off the sky. Send them back. You need a modi
Says the fascist leader
We aren't racist or fascist we will take care of them untill Myanmar negotiates. If Myanmar doesn't negotiate we may even declare war on Myanmar . Before the pandemic in march, Bangladesh moved 10000 soldiers to the town of waikhyang and paglirara.
Some people said they Move from the bengla state before Burma Last King Thibaw(1885) abdicate So Burma Military Gov Who Drawing The basic Law 2008 (The Dictator of Burma) Decided To Not Accecpt Them As a citizenship. The the Basic Law Of burma Said Only Have the ancestor Who Become Live in Burma Before Burma Last King Abdicate Can Only Citizen Of Burma(Myanmar). Sorry For My Bad English)
@@user-zw8mt4nc1l lol bro its call "discrimination against indigenous people" and yeah we bangladeshis can rewrite constitution and say "we owned burma 500 years ago and we own it now" and declare war against burma. Its that easy? its just justifying the interest of your military. Your country is dead economically and your people suffer every day. Thats what you do to make your people busy and not to blame you.
@@ffuad6278 Your country own Burma Haha Very funny joke No One in Bengla dynasty rule burma Before 500 year Which dynasty rule burma?
@@user-zw8mt4nc1l Myanmar is a joke. I keep laughing at all the protests 😂😂 have fun people of Myanmar with your military dictatorship. You all deserve this dictatorship 🤣🤣🤣🤣
This facility in Bhasan char is best of the best done by any country or government in the world. UN and several NGO don't like it because they think it's not convenient for them. They are not thinking about rohinga they are thinking about them only.
That island is much better than their current refugee camp. Bangladesh Navy had taken full responsibility. International community who is opposing this decision should be ashamed for failing to create pressure on Myanmar.
Congratulations! Bangladesh..
Our support is with Bangladesh
The humanity that Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina has shown by sheltering the Rohingyas deported and persecuted from Myanmar is an example to the whole world. It has prepared people for living. The government is providing various facilities.
It's safe for living but some NGO they didn't get any five star hotel that's why its not safe for them but truly its safe place
It’s fun to watch human rights activists statement! 😀
If Myanmar don't take back those in Myanmar,Myanmar should force by international community and also by UN.If they refuse to take back Rohingya people again and again,Myanmar generals should arrest and Punished.
Bangladesh is doing better than Myanmar. Rohingya are not Bangladeshi people, they are outsiders. Bangladesh is a good country because atleast Bangladesh is helping them. But it is not possible to set rohingya with bangladeshi people. Bangladesh is already very dense.....🙄🙄
Bangladesh has shown humanity towards Rohingyas. Which no other country in the world has shown. It has even created a safe haven for the Rohingya. I thank Hon'ble Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina for this.
Why are all pressuring & blaming Bangladesh? U all should Focus on send back Their home at Myanmar . Bangladesh has done a lot. They are ungrateful. At Least They will not die at Bahsanchar.
Say thanks to bangladesh govt instead of blaming by sitting on Canada and Europe
Where were your international act and community when these Rohingyas were killed? NGOs taking a huge amount of money and taking sun☀ bath on largest beach in the world eating sea food these are what in danger not the Ronhiyas, if your international community really can do anything except corruption on fund then take Rohingyas back to their Home,that's what they want or take them to Newyork city we have no issue
Bangladesh is trying to help as much as it can.The facilities created in the island include 1,400 cluster houses, 120 cyclone shelters, administrative buildings, offices for the U.N. and non-governmental organizations, schools, two hospitals with 20 beds each, relief centers, warehouses, fire and police stations, lighthouse, mosques, a helipad, 2 megawatt power plants, and road and drainage networks. A 12.1 kilometers long and two-meters high embankment with integrated drainage has been constructed to protect the inhabitants and onshore infrastructure from flood. Facilities for agriculture, fish and poultry farming, cattle rearing and dairy production have been provided in the island.
No one help us. World making joke of us. We are people of bangladesh help them.
It's better rather than leave them missirable places where they don't know where they are going. Thanks to bangladesh for taking care of this refugees.
Take some rohingyas in your office dear AlJazeera...We are doing our best..
Bangladesh is a small county with limited resources and around 180million of population... but they have open their kindness three years ago and kept it on.. Rohingya peoples has been given a shelter, hospital, dormitory, security, school, playground, and even foods by the government of Bangladesh while Burma(Myanmar) used to burnt them alive... it's just a shame to some of news channels who's bullying Bangladesh instead of Myanmar...
Oh you are so worried about them!Al zajeera pls give shelter them in your country. Or send back to them Myanmar. If you can't do that then stop criticising Bangladesh.Bangladesh has given them highest security and human right.
Why u r anxious abt bd Government’s activity, they have already helped Rohingya refugees to enter in bd while no country moved forward to help them...
At the new address in Bhasanchar, each Rohingya family is getting a separate house for themselves, with cooking facilities, electricity, water and sewerage facilities. Along with that there are playgrounds, cyclone shelters, and even livelihood opportunities.
The Bangladesh government has spent Tk 2,312 crore to evacuate one lakh people from the 11 lakh Rohingyas in the Cox's Bazar camp to safer shelters.
A poor and overcrowded country like Bangladesh is giving them shelter and food. And Al-Jazeera is high lighting 2 or 3 minor negative sides. This will motivate Bangladesh not to help refugees in the future.
Bangladesh govt taken any kind of safety Measures for this island. Bangladesh navy and coast guards all ready to save them from all kinds of calamity. Those Rohingya willingly goes there, I think they are most fortunate people among the Rohingya. All this cluster village not built for Rohingya, all this houses will be allotted for homeless Bangladeshi peoples after abandoned by Rohingya.