Lessons from Jagjit Singh Chauhan on why Pakistan-backed “Khalistan” campaign crashed
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- #punjab
Why are the loudest calls for Khalistan from the Sikh diaspora? As the
Amritpal Singh saga rages, Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta talks about self-styled ‘Khalistan president’ Jagjit Singh Chauhan to unfurl an intriguing chapter of the Khalistan movement, and also reasons why it failed. Ep. 1196 of Cut The Clutter.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read Jagjit Singh Chohan’s interview
‘You can't get Khalistan through military movement: Jagat Singh Chouhan’ here: www.indiatoday...
Read ‘Police chief K.P.S. Gill turns the tide in Punjab with controversial and ruthless methods’ here: www.indiatoday...
Read 'Operation Bluestar has no champions today: K.P.S. Gill' here: www.indiatoday...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
/ @theprintindia
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our TH-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Early access, exclusive content, special privileges - Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s TH-cam channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month. th-cam.com/channels/uyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdA.htmljoin
Hindu Sikh Bhai Bhai❤
nowadays social media is changing the brotherhood.
hate is the currency of this new platform. Misinformation and false history is another.
😊😊pp
😊
As a Sikh, I never imagined Hindus and Sikhs to be different separating Hindus and Sikhs will be like separating a person from his shadow. Guru Granth Sahib is full of words like Ram, Hari and stories from Hindu Puranas.
The Crux is Khalistan is not possible because fact is Sikhism isn’t different from Hinduism how can a separate country be possible for Sikhs?? India is country for Sikhs
of the Sikhs as well
Sikhs and Hindus have coexisted for hundreds of years together, we are literally the same people, We Hindus used to raise the first born Son of our households as a Sikh, the Sardar of the house who will protect and lead the house in the future. The shared history and shared culture is unlike any other two communities, the enormity of things that are common between us outweighs everything else, it is sad that some people would like to focus on what's different than what's common.
The khalistanis are no Sikhs but a Pakistani and isi propaganda agenda.
Jo bole so Nihal...
Sat shri aakal.
Kudos brother, you have all of India and our heart.
Conceptually, I Never understood Why Khalistanis always exclude 3/4th of Punjab which is in Pak, from which Sikhs were Ethnically cleansed, This movement is the result of Ham headed politics by the Congress trying to interfere when ever Akali Dal came to Power in Punjab, propping up Bhindranwale as a counter measure, only for Him to become a bigger problem, waking up too late and Attacking Darbar Sahib, Party workers unleashing terror on Patriotic SIkhs after Indira Gandhi was assasinated, this is the reason for Khalistan.
Congress party workers did the riots but the blame was on hindus 😱😷....lol...irony is we hindus hate Congress most because we know Congis are anti hindu anti national. Wake up Sikhs😎
Because this is not peoples movement, this is a political movement of some foolish people. Those who are doing this are doing for power and dont have wellbeing of people in mind like ALL politicians.
Oh really! Why are you so scared? We are just 2 percent, you have state power, still do not want to fight 😂😂😂
@@ajeebdastan1152 who are u mulls to intervene between a fight between Hindus
@@ajeebdastan1152 You are not 2%
Most Indian Sikhs are patriotic Indians. You are maybe 2% of the 2%.
I'm a rajput and I've met a Muslim rajput and a Sikh rajput, a general rajput or OBC rajput. We are india and India is us. That's my only identity The rest comes later
Muslim rajputs well thats interesting ,the Muslim rajputs i encountered on twitter were highly supremacists and used to speak ill of Sikh gurus.A big handle named History of Rajputana ,guy behind that account is a Muslim Rajput top tier bigots
Being a Rajput is not the identity but a jaat and Varna. So, Muslim, Sikh and so called Hindu, jaat and Varna does not go
Ethnicity comes first. Empires fall.
Not dalit rajput? 🤣
@@B108-n2g Dalits are Hindus. Whatever you want to prove now.
Hindus and Sikhs have fought together. They have died together. They have been living together for centuries. We celebrate each other's culture and festivals together. No power can separate us. We are unity in diversity. We are India. Jai Hind Jai Bharat.
Great words
1984??
@@sigmamale6143 if someone is spreading a positivity then support him.....Brother those who fought against were also Sikh at that time with Hindus.....and read article 25
@@sigmamale6143 What happened in 84 was terrible, I know many of the people did not not get punishment for their crimes.
I was not born at that time but I do not want the time to repeat itself.
In my state maharashtra SIKHS are respected in the highest regards even in the rural less literate areas. I want that love and respect to continue.
Karma for Hitler Modi’s Gujerat killing fields
They can have their Khalistan in Canada or the U.K. The governments over there seem sympathetic to them. It's clear that nobody from "Our Punjab"!!! is interested.
Dont care about those foolish people, I dont. None of them will give up their passports/visas if they have to permanently live in Khalistan. Let them have their referendum 2020, 2030, 2040 and so on. Why do you care? Care about the ones living in India!
It's even not your land
@Deb he's Punjabi.
@@sigmamale6143 Lmao who are you. Bhikaris have Pakistan. Stay there and beg. That's what you deserve.
After spending about a decade travelling to multiple countries and continents and meeting the Indian diaspora who have moved out from India in different times, I have made a realization that in the their heads, the time has stopped in India in the year they had left. Since their interaction with the situation on the ground in the country is very limited they still feel that India is still stuk in the 80s or the 90s. They teach or explain India in the same fashion to their next generation and which reinforces their vision since the next generation is even further away...
Maybe thats at the root cause of K word still being around in the Indian Diaspora outside India only. They moved out around operation bluse star OR the militancy period in unjab and they are stuck in that time forever
Rightly said
@@abhijitdeshmukh6902 Rightly said. The second generation lndians having non indian citizenship are more dangerous for lndia. They have developed a mindset which can not change.
Its high time Indians and lndian government should start treating them as foreigners.
Totally agree
What you say is true but add these Khalistanis got political asylum abroad because they were illegally prosecuted in India and were forced to leave their homeland
@@pardeeptandon I would say that if people were prosecuted illegally, they should have continue fighting the case while being out of Indian jurisdiction, since they never showed up they don’t really get to say or prove that it was illegal in the court of law.
Also as far as my knowledge goes, militancy was at its peak in Punjab (Indian) during the Khalistan movement and about 50k people died while Punjab in pakistan was peaceful. This clearly indicates that the movement was sponsored by pakistan so it comes under the umbrella of NSA, POSCO and all the other laws that existed to counter terrorism.
These laws are pretty sharp and prosecution under those laws don’t have an option to be called illegal in anway (Thats my understanding)
Being a Jat I know the ego problem we have in our tribe which transcends religious identity be it Mulla jatt, Sikh jatt or vedic Jat. We just want to be in power everywhere. At broders mostly members of this tribe are fighting with themselves. But in modern times we need to get educated and skilled so that we can compete with others. Otherwise inferiority complex will result in creating anger further. And Brahman in Hinduism and Jatt in Sikhism are threat to basic concept to these religions. Jats have occupied a whole religion . Khalistani is nothing but Jatthood kind of a thing.
When did brahmins ask for a separate state or staged some sort of insurgency when one of us wasn't CM of a state. It's landed castes which are most spoiled, brahmins are just convinient excuse
Finally some wise words spoken
Brahman was never a problem , until and unless you people created a phobia out of it,
@@aniketnainwal3222 casteism was backed by many Brahmans to cement their so called upper caste status. That doesn't mean all Brahman are bad . But yes predominantly Brahmans used casteism and backed casteism
@@Abhishek-ef2er ,
Are people of other castes free from casteism? Even the lowest castes are not free from casteism.
Man this was so good , any director or screenwriters here, just make a biopic on Shekhar Ji. Just so much content in just his experiences.
Absolutely agree!
one pro K movement twitter handle, who is not a jaat sikh, was reminded one day that he can never be the face of their movement as he is a khatri sikh. that was hilarious. they are not even united and are caste supremacists.
The sikh surnames "Singh" and "Kaur" itself came from ancient Rajput surnames/adjectives for males and females "Sinh" and "Kunwar". All sikh Gurus were Kshatriya (called Khatri in punjabi) and called Rajputs in Hindi. It was only later that Jatt peasantry of Punjab and nearby regions became Sikhs and a revisionist ideology was born. Till late 18th century the sikh gurdwara used to be called "dharmshal", and all Gurdwara used to have dharmic signs and deities. Then during British times, further revision happens within sikhi by those Sikhs who got influenced by British and Christian Church, those Sikhs who mostly fought WW1 & WW2 in Europe, or served British empire in india.
Earlier rajput used surname like das , rajput were landless in punjab in akbar period , read ain-i-akbari, jats had 15 more times land than rajput in Delhi, multan and Lahore subah, singh is jatt surname, jatt is not peasant but yeoman and landlord
Yet Sikhism is a distinct religion now
@@noone6796 jatt pakhand. Jaat and Jatt as a group emerged only during British colonial era. Even Ranjit Singh called himself Kshatriya not jaat
@@piyushjaiswal9283 hahahaha jat is the only tribe mentioned in india by Arabs lol, kaikan jats defeated them 5 times in 7th century, it is rajput who are made in 16th century
what's ur point
One of the best CTCs I enjoyed as it is full of SG’s past memorabilia.
Why khalistani flag has Khalistan written in English, not in Gurmukhi 🤔🤔
To Khalistanis... Pols aayage bhago
Good one... LOL! But if it was written in Gurmukhi then would you have understood what's written? They got it right then... LOL! I'm assuming that you dont know Gurmukhi and I can be wrong.
@@jaswindersinghnarula4379 No one needs to understand. Do you understand what's written on the Iranian flag for example. But it's easy to recognize.
@@jaswindersinghnarula4379 then it shows that the whole concept of Khalistan is flawed.
Countries have their name or words inscribed on flag but in their own language not in MacSikh language.
@@deesiInGermany concept of any country which is based on 1 religion is flawed right from start, any religion. I don't know much about flags except India's. I was joking but I guess you didn't got it. Even though I used LOL 2 times.
@@jaswindersinghnarula4379 my bad bro 😂
Damn the knowledge here is Elite 🔥
A painful realty that this Jagjit Singh Chohan who was responsible for thousands of innocent killing by his movement, when visited India in his last phase of life was a state guest. and answering a question about Khalistan he answered that he has changed his mind as if it was a child's game. See the plight of families in Punjab and elsewhere who suffered during this movement.
their families are living in canada and are citizens there... they should make khalistan there in canada... after all they live there
Great piece this is. One thing is clear, India is unbreakable now.
No, it is not. As long as people vote responsibly, it will be unbreakable. What out for NATO and China as well.
Islamists with ummah + western backing (maybe even Chinese) .. & western + islamist ecosystem exploiting caste faultlines. .. & most importantly, the missionaries cutting off Indians from India .. are still challenges to be overcome. I believe, lots of grassroots work needs to be done silently for a long time about the missionaries problem .. while a lot of judicial & extrajudicial, as well as lawmaking & enforcement work needs to be done on the Islamist front (& yeah, keeping up on direct, even confrontational streetpower against them)
India will eventually become unbreakable if Hindus of different regions don't fight against each other.
Hindu Sikh Bhai Bhai❤
Dont let divide and rule prevail once again.
muslim too are brother don t forget
@@harshdata5784 Funny how this isn't coming from a Muslim
@@crimsoncrysolite5056 these days they are high on _nasha_ so in delusion and hallucination.
One day they are bound to come back to their root💪🏻
Remember: Every person living within teritorial and geographical boundary of BHARAT is a _hindu_ so....what do you think muslims of Bharat are😊
@@harshdata5784 Anyone who loves this land and supports its sovereignty over anything whether it is religion or money or language is my brother. Does not matter if he is Hindu, Sikh, Muslim, Atheist, Shamanist, Christian or Jain. Rest of them and they are in a large number for sure can f themselves.
During the peak days of Sikh Separatism, along with this Jagitsingh Chauhan, there was another prominant character called Ganga Singh Dhillon. You mentioned at the end of your video. I recall that he was some way involved in the sinking of Kanishka Jumbojet with some four hundred passengers, over the atlantic in the mid-1980s. Can you please explain his role in this separatist movement?
I imagine SG doing Bhangra everytime he twitches his fingers for “quote/unquote” 😂 .
If you notice closely .. He does that even when he is not "quoting / unquoting"
His entire narration is based on his hands going up & down in 'kathputli' style .. if not bhangda
You are very experienced and unbiased journalist (a race vanished long back and hardly found in India). It is pleasure to hear you and your analysis. I have to simply add NO politician can be taken on one’s face value. They have some thing in mind but share something else with others. Looks as if similar is the case with Jagjit Singh Chauhan …
Interesting that even in 1993 SG knew that with the BJP came a focus on keeping the country intact 💪💪
Just like Punjab, insurgency will be finished in Kashmir one day
Kashmir insurgency is coming to an end...Government is already looking forward to take army back and replace it with normal police
He also claimed to be a descendent of Prithviraj Chauhan! What a joker...
Perhaps he was. Do you know any better?
Print is turning out to be the only 'informative' & refreshing media in India in current times of paid agenda, paid activist & anarchist, depressing or outright provocative & fake media. All its sections are well researched & well qualified journalist & editing staff (though most presenters, except SG need to sharpen their presentation skills)
I would like to subscribe happily .. Unfortunately, I'm on hard times currently & trying to work my way out of it. Once I do, I'll subscribe. Keep going well Print. I hope & wish everyone else who watches their content & can pay .. should subscribe to Print to keep this rare species going. Positive & informed societies are built out of such environments. I think I have said enough.
Shekarji, you should consider giving another series of interviews in Canada and UK. Talk about the violence of Khalistan insurgency.
We from South India see Punjabis, as very brave and strong people. This may be stereotypical but we know many turban wala people serving in Indian Army. :)
Then How did this Amitpal ran away? He should have surrendered respectfully, only if he has any good intentions for the work he is doing.
His history clearly explains he's a trans-woman representing women
1. Either he is on run
2.or, Police helped him in escaping,out of hand.
3. He is already in custody, since the day of him announced fugitive.
You will never be leader, and always bow to your hindi masters.
@@m.i.5381 Praising others never make you weak. only insecure people hesitate to praise others.
Anyway I speak Hindi, telugu, kannada. I am master of myself.
You have read the wrong history.
"Potomac Singh Dhillon" was the best Shekhar Sir😂
😂ShekharJi going down memory lane and doing Jatt Punjab jargon translation is so vintage 😊
Thanks for reuploading it... 🙏🏽
Khuswant Singh was badass 😂❤️
Funny how these elements forget to ask for Lahore and Gujranwala areas in the demonstrations/protests.
So much for intentions of these jokers / bad elements and updravis.
RSD Wall,
Hey, don't make them piss in their pants by talking about Lahore and Gujranwala.
Let Khalistani make Khalistan in Pakistan Punjab and Lahore as capital.
SHEKHAR GUPTA : Things Are really Worrying
I had a word with my sikh friend last week he has moved to australia 2 years back, He started talking about how injustices are done with punjab and stuff and concluded indian Government does not like sikhs ,
It was shocking to me I realised How easily Indians in abroad are manipulated turned easily. My Friend Educated in indian, A mechanical engineer graduated in Pune maharashtra
They think water distribution mechanism put in place is injustice, they believe whole water of satluj and yamuna belongs to them only. Wait till they hear about kaveri water dispute, indus water treaty etc. They think state should go bankrupt in order to ensure MSP to rich farmers, if not then state is backstabbing them. This movement is low IQ movement, would die under it's own hubris.
Jay,
So why did the Sikhs move into India when they were kicked out of West Punjab in 1947?
These are gems from SG sir we all wait eagerly for!
Indian govt should record all Khalistani gathering in UK, USA, Australia. Identify them by face recognition. If they have PIO Identity Card , it should be cancelled. This cancellation should be widely publicised ..... Just see how fast the Andolan jeevis disappear !
Most of the animosity is manufactured; through social media shenanigans and money.
I wonder why nobody is talking about how Sikhism itself is the problem.
It has outlived its utility for us Hindus and Bharat. It started as a Vaishnavite Bhakti panth, later had Shakti influences and even had a wonderful empire under Ranjit Singh. But it became totally unhinged during the Singh Sabha movement more than 100 years ago. It is time Hindus woke up and started dismantling the SGPC actively.
Lol it is Sikhism today which is holding India together , Hindus are busy being liberals and marrying their daughters to muslims. I think Hindus should think of mass conversion to Sikhism for saving India. Sikhs have aggressive psychie.
Acha😂😅
100% man. It is time Hindus dismantle the Jatt Sikh and SGPC hold on the religion. It is a panth but they're so radical that they can "excommunicate" sects such as Ravidassia etc. SGPC is a wahhabi type of Sikhism. Time to remove the cancer.
I somewhat agree that problems are there in Punjab like drugs,guns,falling groundwater levels but calling for a SEPARATE NATION IS NOT A SOLUTION.
I believe 'Sikhs can only fight this movement'. I think Sikhs living outside of Punjab should lead this as they are the one who may suffer the most from Khalistan movement.
Also, I believe we should identify and confiscate properties of people involved in this movement, many people living abroad do have many properties here in India!
Now I see why Khalistan movement has very few takers almost zilch in the indigenous sikh community residing in India.The West along with its Pakistani stooge have been trying to dismantle India since time immemorial. I read somewhere that the idea of partition was flouted by the US and they warned the British to not leave India in a single piece since it needed a buffer b/w Afghanistan and India (which it saw as a left leaning country hence a natural ally of the Soviet bloc ). Afghanistan was seen as an important underbelly of USSR ie Central Asian countries,The great game. Fast forward 75 years and they are still using such (underhand) methods just to induce discipline against a recalcitrant India for its stance in the Russia-Ukraine conflict, purchase of cheap crude, ability to act as an intermediary b/w the two conflicting sides etc. They can't confront overtly as it might isolate India and bring it closer to the Russia-China axis which would be catastrophic for the Indo-Pacific strategy of the West as we know of it so you'll continue to see such trends in the near future as India tries to navigate its way through another great game.
I support khalistan movement but in Canada😄🇨🇦 or maybe Lahore
Stop giving that dubai driver undue publicity and this will turn out to be a big dud.
In south India Sikhs are considered and valued at a very higher pedestal. Listening Khalistan word hurts. Why you want small land.... The entire country is yours.
Very well put sir
@@amitsinghi4285 thank you
Lololol....in Hyderabadi Hindi, we use 'Baigan'...instead of 'Baingan' to convey the same....'Dimaag ka baigan karra yaaro'
Divided by language, united by Baigan!!!!😂😂😂
I think this "Baigan" was used in latest web series "Rana Naidu" as well as it has characters from Hyderabad... LOL!
Omg, I remember reading that article as a school boy in India today!!
But I read in the Hindi edition, wonder if it still is in circulation !
@@pratapsinhrajput5879 yes it is
My biggest concern is why the overseas Sikhs community is silent on khalistani propaganda. Are they doing support to them?
perspective helps. good article.
Jagjit singh chouhan conveniently forgot about Rana pratap ,Shivaji , Hemu & others who also fought the mughals / Muslim invaders. Strange he thought only prithiviraj & the khalsa fought Muslim invaders
S Ram,
Sikh chauvinists have their eyes blinkered.
New and modern format of ‘Dada Dadi ki kahaniyan’ by Shekhar ji 💐 I love to hear these retelling of stories, SG… a more palatable ‘hamaare zamaane mein’ :)) Many thanks!!
Loved this episode and more so due to my Punjabi bias 😊
It's just amazing to listen...SG👌🙏
our government is too soft on the foreign Countries on the separatist Incidents against India specially the anglo-saxon once, Next time the referendum is done we should declare that part or region where the Khalistan referendum was held as Khalistan in the foreign soil of UK, Canada, or Australia.
Thanks for the very informative presentation
Thank you for watching...best wishes, Shekhar
Seriously-can you declutter as to why Khalistan idea is popular with Sikhs outside India
Khalistan murdabaad.
Bharaat jindabaad.
Jai hindh.
Vande mataram.
Wahe guru da khalsa wahe guru di fateh.
Har Har Mahadev.
Much of the trouble in Panjab is choreographed from Delhi.Unless Sikh and Panjabi greviances are addressed this issue will not go away!The federal structure of India is not being respected by Delhi power elite!
Achhar Singh Gill,
And how were the Sikhs of West Punjab treated by the Pakistan state?
While you mention subtlety about VP Singh and weak government, there is no mention of Indira Gandhi‘a involvement with Khalistan
What were Maratha?
Chatrapati shivaji maharaj 🙏
@@Maratha1990 Ki Jai
Thanks Sir, for highlighting real culprit
Although I disagreed to you Most Of The Time, but this time Really Good Piece Gupta Ji. i admire
I mean Khalistan is such a stupid idea. You want to create a landlocked country with a hostile neighbor on one side and bankrupt neighbor on the other side.
The repartee from Mr Khushwant Singh by way of a rebuke was the fittest way to deal with such a situation. The Indian State and the Constitution has treated all citizens and communities as equals, so separatism and insurgency of any kind in any part of the country is totally uncalled for.
Thank you for this gem of post independence history. Archive it!
shekhar Gupta ji aapko punjab ki bahut tension rehti hai , achi baat hai….Lakin kabhi aap story karoghe ke 2% brahmin baniya ki population hai India mai or 80% media, Supreme court or BJP ke cabinet or RSS pe kaisa control kiya huya hai??
Punjabis use Baingan we hyderabadis use Baigan 😂😂
SG, the war in East Bengal started in March, not several weeks before December 3. Dec 3 was the date India officially engaged Pakistan.
Hindustan zindabaad....Vande maatram🤞🤞
Even khalistani should understand khalistani dream is impossible in there dream too...😂😂
India was also impossible don't worry bruh just stay alive to see
@@sigmamale6143 ,
Alive to see the original Khalsa Raj of West Punjab being liberated?
@@prmohanoneplus1714 what does it mean bruhh I support khalistan
@@sigmamale6143 ,
Yeah.But that Khalistan should be the original Khalsa Raj which was established in West Punjab.
V.P. Singh was probably the worst prime minister of India
Every hindu family willingly gave away their eldest son to sikkhism till 80's...all Gurudwara's had the images of Hindu God's and Godesses,it's after crystallization of SGPC sense of separatism were fanned gradually....coupled with this was partion movement launched by muslims and the then colonial govt which used these tendencies to further their presence. ..
No power on earth can separate the Sikhs and Hindus for sure ....point is saner elements within Sikh community need to assert their presence
No idol worship. Why is it so hard to understand our holy book
@@Amardeep661 Hinduism is not a monolith with everyone Idol worshiping. Non idol worshipers, agonistics, spiritualist all have space in Hinduism. No one says ..if you don't worship idol then you are not Hindu,if you are not sure about scriptures then you are not Hindu(carvaka) etc. It's in your head that just cuz you don't do idol worshiping ,you are superior and others who do are superstitious and inferiors. It's the abrahamic influence in you which talks about separatism. More Hindus go to gurudwara and bow to gurus than Sikhs. We do that not cuz we think Sikhs are superior but cuz we believe avatars of gods descends on earth after some interval to check the evils of society. We see Sikh gurus as avatar of gods..that's why we bow to them, that's why we bow before Jesus as well. That's why more Hindus go to church to lit up candle than Christains. Open your eyes.
@Valkyrie my point is that being a sikh you can not worship or pray to pictures of idols. You pray to akaal purakh (almighty god).
@@Amardeep661 is Sikhism an abrahmic religion? Hindu gods, hindu saints are mentioned hundred times gurugranth sahib.
@@Amardeep661 that doesn't distinguish between Hindus and Sikhs for the reasons which I mentioned above. The excuse of not idol worshiping translates into supermacy which translates into hatred and separatism. Sikhs say Sikhs demographics are under threat cuz of Hindus.. fact is Abrahamics are converting Sikhs in masses into their religion not Hindus. Hindus don't consider Sikhs as others but our own . In fact almost all new converts to Sikhs are Hindus. Hindu stalwart netas which Sikhs despise like Yogi, Modi etc bow down to gurus and have deep sincere bhakti for Sikh gurus. Whereas abrahamics which you consider as minority brothers don't have much respect for your gurus. They never pray in gurudwara , nor sing glory of Sikh heroes of past. It's done by Hindus.
in the khalistan story jatts are lot talked about but I've seen that a lot of separatist leaders among them were Rajputs too, as with the person SG is talking about
There is a difference between protest and terrorism Sekhar Ji. Whatever happens in UK, Canada and US are acts of terrorism.
If someone insult Indian flag and challenge India as a country then it’s not a protest.
India is an empire ruling over historic independent kingdoms. Sikhs are indigenous to the land and they have a right to self rule under UN international laws.
@@m.i.5381 yes.. get your land in Punjab Pakistan. Not an inch of India will be carved out again for separatist of any kind.
@@m.i.5381 and UN, China , Russia can fk off
@@m.i.5381 Punjab was never an independent state in the history of 5000 years and only exception is maharaja ranjit singh kingdom which only lasted for 50 years . Sikhs cannot claim Punjab for just 50 years rule if that the case then the empires from Bihar like nanda , mauryan , gupta etc should also claim Punjab as Punjab was under them for centuries same goes for afghans also they also ruled Punjab for centuries.
@Big daddy neither was the "Indian Union"
The Indian Union is a British exit strategy.
Before the British land was a battle ground formed into many kingdoms and principalities.
Interesting you love to go back 5000 years, the world was run on system of Empires. Even then, this land held many competing Empires.
An and you go back more thousands of years to a system of Empires, then Italy claims the whole of Europe - Roman Empire.
But these Empires have long gone, because ethnic groups have demanded self rule.
Truely enjoy listening to your narrations, thank you very much!
The Audio is there now.
I think youtube took sometime to process the audio😂
Sekhar is library in himself. Have so much experience, knowledge.
Fantastic CTC by Shekhar sir
As usual, one more favorite of shekar gupta is Punjab
Upsc and all states group 1 aspirants along with their regular study material, should mandatorily watch Sekhar jis CTC to strengthen their history and GK
I have added his CTC to my playlist and i watched him during my way to class 😂
Oi oi oi. Hold on a second. The northeast fought the mughlas till the last mughal days. It's a shame that it was not a war but by trickery by mainland the demographic was changed in the region.
Wonderful! 🙏
Please explain the relationship between Warris Punjab De and BKU's Rakesh Tikait as this farmers protest led into this Khalistani movement. Today the NRI community in Canada, UK, Australia and US seem to be getting divided. Hindus are no more trusting Sikhs overseas. Also what is the Lawrance Bishnoi Gang in all this relationship. PM Modi visited Gurudwara in London and even served langar. Now suddenly why has it come to this. There is an invisible force (Pak, China, CIA, Left, Soros, AAP) but we deserve to know the people behind.
Congratulation to Jyoti Yadav and Bismee Taskin for winning Ramnath Goenka Excellence in Journalism Award.
Also it's nice to hear D Y Chandrachud mentioning Shekhar Gupta with reference to Cut The Clutter in a funny way!!
No Punjab, no India.
Marathas... Rajputs...Hemu.. Didn't fight against the muslim invaders.. Whom did they fight against...thin air ?
Prithviraj chauhan was hindu.. Why the hell did he call him his ancestor?
SG at his best. Loved this episode ❤
Wonderful journalism SG sir.
good episode 👏
Jatt gave singh surname to Sikhism and rajputs, earliest rajput used das surname.
Shekhar Sir, this is brilliant. I don't have kids but your CTC are gonna be in their study table when I have them.
One thing is for sure no aap MLA of Punjab can visit Canada USA and Australia
This of one the best. Ganga singh Dhillon.
Nice report
Where's the audio?
I was watching the video earlier it suddenly got private n unavailable any reason....
That classic Punjabi sense of humour that the late great Khushwant Singh delivered is a gem 😂.
Why does Shekhar refer to Indira Gandhi as Mrs Gandhi? And why is there so much respect in d tone??
"Than than Gopal" can be translated as "fuck all".
Very interesting...
I thiink this is a political problem which needs to be handled politically with respecting the opinions of the opposing group. Just asking for khalistan cannot be seen as a crime. the right to self determination is a basic human right under international law. the answer is on the table. taking a hard stance is the reason why this keeps popping up. If asking for hindu rashtra is handled politically and the proponents are not vilinised than why cant the same treatment be given to so called khalistanis
@@mithsindia5150 Do you live under a rock?
Projekt Jay,
By the same argument, the Sikhs should claim their Khalistan in West Punjab, the place from where they had been thrown out forcibly.What rights had been taken away from the Sikhs in West Punjab is far worse than what is being denied in the Indian Punjab.
@@prmohanoneplus1714 I think it’s fit them to decide what they demand. You and me can’t decide for them or anyone else. It’s basic human rights. Do you see the same kind of reaction from the UK government when Scotland wants referendum for independence. That’s the difference between a functioning democracy and a third world country
Did anyone see vk sing interview,
2012 coupe story was reported y gupta,did he stand still on it?
And response to remarks by vk...