@Store Patternator yes you are corroborating what has been taught by my Guru but he has never explained to me in this detail. I don't get much personal time with him to ask about such things anymore so thank you so much for replying. Pranamami
As a Bengali myself, I cannot thank you enough Sir, for saying these true words about the Bengalis. Here, in Bengal, even the educated (of course, leftist) people think that Bengal's culture is only 500 years old, whereas all archeological evidences are left to rot or to get stolen. Thanks to the questioner as well for placing such a question on this forum.
leftist are master in twisting facts..they are liars..marxist historians never mentioned in history books hindu vijaynagar empire, ahom dynasty but they kept insisting about mughal empire & delhi sultenate..
The afghans destroyed lots of history when they came here and that is one of the reasons we don't get anything before then came. Also a few days back an excavation has been made around Robert Clive's house. And many ancient things have been found some of them being potteries in gupta period and post gupta period. Which already dates back to around 1700 to 1800 yrs back. Now no one knows how many places have British did this. Chances are around many old monuments including churches. But now it's difficult because if ppl go in Church to do these half of the left eco system will come up saying Christians are not safe in this country.
@@saptarshipal6743 Not Afghans actually they had Turks, Arabs and Afghans but the common thing is they were Muslims and according to Islam destroying Non Islamic ideology and architecture is the way to Jannat were they can get 72 virgins and can have s@x all the time.
@@poornachandra80 In Ayodhya Kand, when Kaikeyi asks Dashrath to exile Lord Ram, Dashrath says my rule extends to the whole world from Sindhu Sauvira..to Dravida. I can give it all to you but don't send my Ram away from me. Read the Valmiki Ramayan.
I am a Bengali, my caste or group came to Bengal about 700 years ago from present day Kashmir. We are descendent of Kashyap Muni. We are taught that a vast part Bengal’s land rose from ocean about 1000 years ago and people from all parts of India moved into it. Land is immensely fertile.
1) Even today it called as Banga. Real name of WB as we call Pashchim Banga. 2) Excavation near Tamluk results discovery of a near 10000 years old civilization and sea port system.
In mahabharat time bangal was known as ANGA DESH and karna was made king of Anga desh for several thousand years it was known as ANGA DESH and after thaat it known as VANGA KINGDOM AND THEN to BANG
@ Arijit Chatterjee Anga=Bihar Banga=Bengal Kalinga/Utkal= Odisa Pragjyotishpur=Assam ( home of Bhagadatta) Roughly because present state borders doesn't resemble ancient ones
It hasn't fallen yet. The region will eventually rise up, unlike the downfall of the great middle eastern countries (Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, etc) caused by the West & Israel
@@bablipaul2219 Genetic studies clearly debunk this Shit. Modern day indians have same genes( learn about ANI and ASI). So he was factually wrong, cant blame him since genetic studies were not conducted then.Also the page strangely targets brahmins. the wordpress which u have sent is biased.Proffesor Vilas Kharat is well known for his biased statements on every issue.( it might also have to do with kharat being from a dalit family, i am just citing this which also might be a possibility, cant blame them after all the things that they have suffered). i dont believe in this caste based bullshit, go see Dr. Subramaniam Swamy, a much more learned man from harvard and a great politician, he will debunk all these theories. Also see this th-cam.com/video/CUgoCNtldcQ/w-d-xo.html
Sanjay Dixit Announced to give 2 crore who'll prove this Aryan Invasion Theory. Nobody was able to prove it. 👍🏻 Stop fighting for Tamila & Sanskrit, North & South. Be Indian. Read the fundamental rights, it's our duty to protect the integrity of this nation.
@@MrStylorock But we cant just stay quiet about it. "Lies told again nd again would eventually look like the truth".Even Hitler used this psychology in his political agendas.
@@pranaypatil1969 The archealogy test done at delhi and it was done by brahmins community who are Jews/Aryan by race. What they will tell and what you will expect ? What is the truth you know let me ask you ? Before 17th century there is no proof of durga pooja but kali pooja was celebrated ! before 1920 there is no ganesh chaturthi but vinayagar caturtgi was celebrated. The merging of gods and unification of hindus created a great confusion among the yout. Tamizhan is a race which was distributed in all over india which Ambedkar also told in is book as tramila/tamilzha/dravida.
Being a direct descendant of Dasarath Basu (Circa 1045 AD) with documented history of our arrival in Bengal from Kannuaj back in the 11th century to present day, sharing the same bloodline with some of the greatest sons of this great land, I really found your explanation pretty intriguing. With such formative familial history, it was alway taught to me by my elders, that you're an Indian first and a Bengali second, so I totally agree with your views on this divisive hogwash perpetrated by the colonials to further psychologically weaken us post independence.
@@Rahul_Singh100 "you people", "fake Bengali identity", "hogwash" ?? Well my boy, calling someone's identity fake must be something inherent to your genetic pool sadly it isn't mine. I really don't understand people who have no clue where there immediate forefathers came from, asking someone with over 1000 years of familial history what they should and shouldn't do. Grow a pair chum and stop being a twat on YT. Just to remind you, even the National Anthem of this great country was written by a Bengali, in Bengali. 😏
@@Rahul_Singh100 The curse of Lord Krishna from the end of Dwaparyuga is upon you people soon the Yadavas & followed by you foolish racists will all be destroyed.
It May be a colonial construct but these NCERT people taught us in the history books that the Aryans came from central Asia. It's no more a British agenda, our own people are the divisive force.
There is no Aryan or Dravidian if see vedic ages multi skin color is mentioned just taken an example of droupar yug Krishna black skin Radha white skin Dhropdhi skin color related to evening or light brown.This Aryan and Dravidian concept was made by Britishers their policy divide and rule. Still missionaries are targettin adishivasis for converting them to Christianity telling them we treats them badly for there skin color. If you see Mother Goddess then you will see multi skin color.
Bengal was truly prosperous..people were well educated highly cultured and very intelligent.That’s why British separated the largely Muslim eastern areas from the largely Hindu western areas in 1905.They tried to weaken Bengal….Thank you sir for bringing this topic🙏
But I heard and personally saw the Bengalis are short tempered and vandalism is rampant in Bengal! Who are they? The minorities and leftists! please clarify
Bengal had one of the greatest Buddhist empires called Pala Empire and multiple universities in the post classical period. They were one of the 3 major imperial power in India along with Gujjara Pratihara and Rashtrakuta
@@gamersgient5486well no, you need to learn history again, you are now taking into absolutes. Like a ultra nationalist. Nothing called banga desh at that time, even Bengali as a language and the kamrupa script had not diverted apart from it bihari and odia sister language that time. It was still in aprahmbhasa stage. Palas didn't had a Bengali identity like modern bengal. Just like maghadans and angawashi didn't have bihari identity.
@@noone-zl2di hey Biro go to google and do research in google or chatgpt because I can't share links here they got hide by youtube so you do research by yourself okee? Bengal was from Mahabharat time vanga pradesh we still call ourselves vanga bashi or bango bashi do research about my explanation then you understand
In Mahabharata, a place is mentioned named "Pundrabardhan ". It is present day known as Mahasthan Ghar at Bagura district in Bangladesh. Banga Janapad is that much old.
It's true that there is nothing of the sort aryan/dravidian. But Arya means a "Shreshta" human being because he/she follows Dharma. On the other hand a Dasyu is someone who doesn't follow Dharma. Dravida is actually Travida which is a Samskrutam word meaning land surrounded by three oceans. (Tra means three and vida means ocean). Travida/Dravida adjective can be given to a place and not to a person.
I am an Indian bengali. 'Indian' is my name and 'Bengali' is my surname. Different types of people live in India. Bengali, Marathi, Bihari, Gujrati, Tamil, Punjabi, Hariyanvi, Rajputs, kashmiri, Assamese, Manipuri, Mizos, Nagas, Odias and many more. We are all like rivers that flow seperately but eventually meet in One place which is 'INDIA'. This is what our ancestors Subhash Chandra Bose, Bhagat Singh, Rabindranath Thakur, Sukhdev, Vallabhbhai Patel taught us. Jai Hind 🇮🇳 Vande matram 🇮🇳
@@mashprivel3996 Language ar cultural aspects er dik theke alada alada jonogosthi ... Eta pure genealogical aspect e bolche ... ei technical terms gulo bujhte hbe nhle confusions barbe ...
@@mashprivel3996 ভাই তুই যেই Secular history র কথা বলছিস সেগুলো Marxist historians রা লিখেছে, অনেক Political Agenda আর misinformation আছে তার মধ্যে. বাকি অন্য Narrative কে কোনো জায়গা দেওয়া হয়নি acadmics এ , এর ফলে বাকি Narrative গুলোকে fake মনে হওয়াটা ই স্বাভাবিক! আর সেই কারণেই ভারতে History বুক নতুন করে লেখার প্রস্তাব দেওয়া হয়েছে! 🙏
@@ModernUlysses ওদের চোখের মণি রোমিলা ঠাপার বলে যে যুধিষ্ঠির নাকি গৌতম বুদ্ধের কাছ থেকে শান্তির শিক্ষা নিয়েছিলো 😁 আবার মনগড়া logic দিয়ে সেগুলোকে justify করে, তাদের ভাবশিষ্যদের অন্য narrative শুনলে কান ব্যাথা করারই কথা।
@@parthipansivanesan3938 then we should have 29 different countries? We do certain things differently or speak different languages that doesn't make us different...as we have same roots and ancestry
Bengali language is an middle Indo-Aryan language combined from Sanskrit, Prakrit and Pali. So in linguistic terms, it is Indo-Aryan but it has some Austric origins which comes from our tribal origins.
Full bullshit , there are no clear cut parameters to define what is an aryan language ,only motivation behind it is Lord Macaulay education nothing else !!...
@@DattaMusics Keep saying that while the world moves forward. There have been elaborate linguistic studies. Clearly Vedic Sanskrit was not the only Indo-European language in India during Rig Veda. The Ikshvaku Turvasu tribes had other Indo-European language. If you study common words, grammar, prefixes , etc. you can know which language is a parent or a sister language .
@@sadenb The grouping of indo-aryan and austric are not reliable and at challenge , do your terminology facism while we tear the nonsense apart , dumbass , linguist study of terminologies , sonar resonations , huh !!...you are no linguist , neither you are an archeologist , geneticist do not dare to behave like one . I don't even take you seriously or your dunning Kruger effect infused schizophrenic cognition of how you have real knowledge of language !...get lost there are no language such as aryan or austric ...if the Aryan invasion is well efuted by archeologist like Suri and geneticist like Rai , the language groups and their basis of division is at doubt as well...World is moving forward while you chant Aryan invasion , clearly a deluded has no say in a war or in academics !!...Ghar jaa
I am sc nomosudra hindu but I am proud to be hindu kashyap gotra Bengali. Jai shree Ram har har mahadev jai kali jai Prataditya. Verna diwija systems was based on talent but not by birth in gurukul
You are simply hindu. Don't call yourself by any caste. I as a brahmin(Which I don't believe in) am telling you. My ancestors have done pretty bad things, but now we have to reform and make hinduism inclusive without any need for caste.
@@sushilsharma4202 'my ancestors did wrong thing'...this propaganda is injected in every so called woke people like u by communists n colonial rule...main point is bad persons are not limited to any caste so don't produce guilt or inferiority complex within yourself. No! your ancestors did nothing wrong...those who did, they were a small fraction of bad people who are present in every society irrespective of caste, region n country. Don't be a puppet unknowingly n propagate the propaganda of communist which trap peoples in guilt n inferiority complex.
See this entire gotra thing debunks the so called caste system. Even my gotra is kashyap, but i am a kashtriya 🤷. Now we know that gotra is based on birth so how people belonging to same gotra has same caste as obviously caste was chosen later and not based on birth ✌️
Sorry to say that you have your brain washed by the commie nonsense so much that you think yourself low and nothing. You are Sudra, and Sudras are great and greatly qualified for social and academic reasons. The caste system and SC was created by the masters of the commies the british. Our Shastras doesn't recognize such divisions. It never did. So, burn your certi and become a free Indian again.
We the bengalis are aryans,we are dravidians and we are mongolians,mixture of north, south,east.This mixture can be well proved by the two or three tire gotra systems in Pashchatya Vaidiks of Bengal
@@plataoplomo9096 It is genetics he is talking about. Linguistically we are just Aryans and have nothing to do with Dravidians and Mongoloids but racially we are mixed.
@@sumit4640 bruv, Tamils, Veddoids and other hunter gatherer groups lived in Srilanka way before bongs went there, especially the Veddoids alongwith Jarawas stayed there before any Homo sapiens even existed in South Asia. Their language Sinhala also shares vocabulary with tribal and Tamil language. These things are mentioned in Mahabodhivamsa book of Srilanka. Infact some of the Tamil Sangam age poets also originated from Srilanka, and their inscriptions can be found in Poonakary, dating back to 3rd century BC. The names also share some resemblance with ancient Dravida kings of Karunadu(Karnataka) and Tamilakam for example Nrupatunga(Rashtrakuta dynasty), Kullathunga(Sinhaladveepam) and Kulothunga(Chola dynasty).
Bengali people's are very hardworking and hardcore nationalist. They are the race who are always in the forefront of the battle against British. Hope in coming time bengal will be the engine of this growing india in it's journey to a developed nation.
As a Bengali myself a geniologist has told me that Bengalis have the highest percentage of East Asian gene right after North East! The fairness of the Bengali brahmins is from East Asian and not North Indian, Aryan, Mughal or British white, the fairness is due to East Asian which also contributes to our shorter height!
That is true to some extent. However me being a bengali, my roots are from norther part of india and it is well documented. So there are many brahmins and bengalis who are from northern part of india and not north eastern though!
All of them do not look the same. People from North Bengal (Darjeeling) look more mongloid but people from South Bengal (Kolkata) look like an average Indian. But we all love our Motherland 🇮🇳.
@Reality Bytes why you people always lint fairness to the brahmins?i am a namasudra from barishal and my skin colour is fairer than bhutais.also in my father's side and mother's side a very few people have dark brown skin.My father have 8 cousins and all of them are fairer.So do not think that bengalis have fairness according to their caste.Also "mithun chakrabarty" is from barishal and is a brahmin but he is not fairer.
aslo bengali fairness is not same as northern people.one day i was talking with a white american girl and i have notices that her skin is harsher than us
All Indias are same it's just geographical differences that made us look differently and speak differently. But there are a lot of ppl who want to divide India in two countries..a harsh reality.
What about people beleiving it to the core despite so much evidences just becouse it suits their Pride. Like why can't they just think be themselves about it?! its not that hard to guess the truth!
Tum daugle to khud apne desh ko batwa baithe ho, aur hame gyan pel rahe ho divisive ki.😂😂😂. Tum bengalio ki gyan c**dne ki aadat jaati nahi hai. Ab chal apne pair pasaar...meri B angali bulbul.😘😚
@@Rahul_Singh100 oor tum jesa mahajan baate to badi karte h UP ek esa rajya h janha Yogi jesa cm rehke vi Bharat ka sabse jyada muslim population UP me h orrr sun meri baat agar itna Hii ethnicity ko leke bol rha h na Karnataka orr Maharashtra ko dekh border dispute Assam mizoram and Nagaland aagar hum desh ke divide karte na tab to ho hii jata BJP jo kii BJS tha jisko banane wala vi EK BENGALI H
@@Rahul_Singh100 orat se to baat karna janta nhi 😑 orr aake apni Illogical concept kii baat kar rha h mid 1970s ke cinema sholay ka gabbar ban rha h 😂😂😂🤣🤣
First of all ....We Bengalis fought and bleed for this country Our revolutionaries bombarded Britishers for Independence. We are Hindu and And proud Indian ...That's it. But don't forget , we have our own distinct style of Hinduism , we have our own rituals , our culture is Tantra based not Vedic .. so if you can't find your similarities with us thats not our problem.
Bengali hinduism is completely different religion in which they eat beef, glorify marrying mullas, gets irritated by jay shree ram, unwarranted wokeism
@@BackspasmANDniggle where did you find we eat beef?? It's all secular wrongdoings by Kolkata's idiots. And we are rural bengalis. Where did you get your wrong facts?
I heard South Indians (Dravid) anthropologically are similar to the 'native' inhabitants of Australia. It dates back before civilization. Actually, languages are a bit different in South India relative to North India but grammatically similar. I don't believe in these Dravidian-North Indian facts, we are Indians united.
What Southern India languages r grammatically similarfrom North Indian languages and India really??? Southern India languages have depth in their words and grammar which is different from North India Hindi ok. Whatever u say but still we r Dravidians only and proud to be Dravidian ok. Go and tell this all things to your Hindi people Aryans because they have discriminated ignored humiliated stereotyped our Southern India people from 70 years, they always feel superior to others.
@@KaliNari-z4i the whole country have some stereotypes about one another's , like people of North only know that all South cuisines are sour but it's actually not. I'm not properly North Indian, I live in Bengal and Bengali in ethnicity. Go ask any Bengali people how much we respect and love South India, they won't say any bad things. I don't know about the Hindi speaking belt. And also there are pretty much similarities between Tamil and Sanskrit, particularly I don't know both these languages but sounds and means similar, can't put examples right now. I just want to know what kind of discrimination happens?
I am cambodian. Many of us have a bit of bengali dna in our blood. It's ancient admixture with central asians and northern Indians from ancient times. This explains why we don't look like stereotypical asians.
@@r.a.stylzhairstudio6920 The boundary between North and South India is the Vindhya Range, so go learn Subcontinental history before telling me I don't know geography.
I was in chennai for official visit for some days , I was standing outside my GH to my surprise some person came to me and started taking to me in tamil , which i could not understand , this happened to me quite a few times, so we can say no one can distinguish between north & south indians just by looks we are so similar
Dravan means solution (as in the solution of something in a solvent like water). Dravida means the region where the land dissolves into the sea. Or where the land disappears and the ocean begins. British people twisted Sanskrit words. These are the correct meanings. Dravan = solution Lavan = salt Just read a chemistry book in Bengali language and Bengalis will realize that there is no Dravidian race.
@@parthipansivanesan3938 you're really really brainwashed my friend. Stop fighting over Tamil and Sanskrit, religion, languages, culture , north & south, Aryans& Dravidians (which theory is false as we all have same genes and no Aryan invasion happened). Stop fighting over stupid misconceptions people put into you. We are all indians and it's our responsibility to respect and protect India's integrity.
@@sincerelyxshristi The question you put on me is the same I need to ask you. Go and analyze the history. India was ruled by the Brahmin community and whatever they are telling, you people are accepting. Haaa....haaa. not on single topic you can answer me that much you're all manipulated.
@@parthipansivanesan3938 did I say anything about the rule of brahmin community? manipulation? Babe manipulation is what YOU did here.. mending my words into something else , dissecting my intention and trying to force BRAINWASHED mindset. I don't just accept whatever people say.. i actually try to research myself not like you who just doesn't try to have a broad mindset. Try hearing both stories before lecturing people to "learn" history. Because trust me.. i probably know more history than you do.
@@sincerelyxshristi ok accepted you know better than me. Please give me concrete evidence that Durga lived in so..so many years ? Who are Bengali and how there name came as Bengali ? Yes indeed I respect India and be a Indian citizen until or unless yours and my culture is respected, isn't it ? If really people say Aryans invaded India then let me know as you are great historian who coined the term Aryan in Indian subcontinent first and till now ?
Bengal comprised of 3 provinces & finds mention even in Mahabharat. The 3 provinces were Anga (mostly north Bengal & North Bihar), Banga (Eastern side of what is now Bangladesh) and Pandrugaur( current Murshidabad).
I'm a eastern side bengali from Northeast 1)I have seen a minor difference that Kolkata Bengali are little bit dull in skin texture (not colour) Maybe because of climate or food! 2) I have seen many Persian people similar facial structure like us! 3) i got little bit triprasa genetics from my dad and grandma
One of my doubts: if Dravidian and Aryan are from same origin, then why two separate lines of languages in the form of Tamil (old) and Sanskrit came into being? Even though most of the alphabetic similarities are found in these two languages but still scripts look different and many of vowel treatments like ए or ओ are different. Example: "को" written in Hindi, is different in Tamil (it's more like Bengali "কো") or "के" in Hindi looks different in Bengali which is "কে"। Both the Bengali styles shown here are remarkably like Tamil. Of course, we know for some time back, Rulers from South India ruled Bengal just before Muslim invasion in Bengal. Typically, Dravidian skin color is darker than North Indian. And as for Bengalis it is mixture of both these two categories. Bengali alphabets are ditto of Sanskrit, except few vowel treatments, as mentioned above. Similarly, skin color too. Hence, I think Bengalis have influence of both these two groups, whether both these two groups (Dravidian and Aryan) are original inhabitants of this sub-continent or not.
@@arkaprovasaha4313 exactly! he has not once questioned if all indians have the same genetic origin supposedly 40k years ago, why did two entirely separate language families develop in India?
@@MichelleObamasBBC yes there are three or four language families 3 or 4 or more than that Indian phenotypes among which the most dominant one is called south asian ( which is seen highly amongst south Indians ) still he'll keep on saying all Indians same Indians and British did it, British separated us. That's it.
Sir, Kunti Putra Karna was king of Vanga,Bhgalpur etc!!! Reference - Last day of the fight between Karna and Arjuna.Karna and Shalya had a verbal spat over certain subjects.
@@Rahul_Singh100 not extinct...Angika is presently spoken in Jamui-Gidhaur-Jhajha region basically Jamui district of Bihar may be in Lakhisarai region too.
Bengalis are mixed peoples I have in my relatives who are extreemly black/dark And strenge is they are brahmins. And I have many scedule caste friends Who are fair skinned. It is almost contradictory to aryan dravidian theory 🤣 Becouse in aryan invasion theory aryans fair skinned sharp facial features and they are brahmins but in this case things are exactly opposite
Coz they got either raped or mixed by consent due to being in same land after invasion.. Same way why we don't see mixture of black, white n brown in Iran..? Coz there were no dravidians else we would be able to see the same in Iran as well ..
Bengal has mixed Adivasi Aryan Dravidian mixed population. Bengal itself is not a race it has many races mixed in it same as Bihar orrisa Uttar Pradesh and other north indian states .
🎉🎉*Bengal itihasa continued from Mahabharat time. There are too many Great Bengali kings named Shasanka who defeated Harshabardhana, then Gupta, Sen and Paal Dynasty. There was also a parallel bengali civilization called Gangahridi. Which mentioned in Greek history. Google all the names.*
Master da surjo Sen had no mongoloid mix , the gurkha and tibeto burman mix happened and it is normal being near by place, there are no mongoloid genetics even in arunachali people they are tibeto-burman , The Varmans of varendra had Burmese mixing , that's there !!
@@somnathchanda1250 no they are not , The tibeto-burman race has no connection with mongoloid nether does the Japanese have !!...The contextual terms are often counter intuitive in science ! ......So, do learn first before making a fool of urself !....and stop these bro , brah nonsense !!.. Mongolian.race has zero to.do.with tibeto Burmese race in any genetic sciences , this iare pseudo jargons , deprived of context !
Though you are right but since the invasion of Saudia religion and culture these problems started. So better you should give up foriegn religion and literatures and come back to the origin will help to bring peace. Thanks
@@vikramadityahindu8591The partition of the subcontinent brought hatred against minorities. Not only Pak and BD have problems with minorities even India does.
Bengal was founded as Gaur in 600 CE ( time when bengali calendar starts) by Maharajdhiraj Sasanka Deva. Sasanka Deva came from RohtasGar in Magadh where he was a feudatory lord of Magadhraj Mahasenagupta. After death of Mahasenagupta in 605 CE, Mahadhiraj Sasanka Dev founded Gaur ( Bengal) and ruled till 636 CE. Bengal seen Pala and Sena dynasty. Pala dynasty was when buddhism spread to Tibet and Siam Desh(Thailand) from Bengal. During attack of Kannauj by ghaznavids and ghorids many hindu brahmin and nobles migrated to Bengal. Gaur, vikrampur, tamralipi were important places in Bengal during Sena dynasty. Islamic rule came with delhi sultanate in 14th century followed by Mughal and British rule. Abhijit is correct Bengalis are mix of all races just like any other Indians. Modern India owes a lot to the sacrifice and ranaissance of bengal which helped in independence of India. Bengalis are proud Indians.
Some interesting facts - there was a study done on Bangladesh (East Bengal) racial population. The study showed that light skinned people of Bangladesh come of the traditional Brahmin, Kshatriya & Vaishya caste among the indegenous Bengali people and also the Iranian settlers in the region like Persians, Kurds, Turkics & Pashtuns during Bengal Sultanate period. Hence a lot of Bengalis are light skinned and a sizable portion of them have blue, brown, Hazel eyes. They are highly caucasoid. While most people are medium brown to dark brown, there is a considerable percentage of people who are very dark. They are actually ethnically highly australoid & less caucasoid. Then there is another sizable portion of Bengalis who have slanted eyes, straight silky hair and yellow skin tone. They are mongoloid Bengalis. They are descendants of East Asians. Influx of North-East Asians happened during Pala Empire period and Bengal always maintained good trading relation with South-East Asia. Due to geographical location & historical geopolitics, Bengalis are ethnically one of the most mixed Indic ethnic group. Bengalis come from diverse ethnic backgrounds & religions. The only thing that unites them all is the language and culture. You will find that not all/every Bengalis look the same and the direct correlation intellectuals have found this to be the mixing in the past when different ethnicities mixed due to movement of business travellers from different countries settled in East Bengal (now Bangladesh) and marrying the locals within the community.
but i think bangladeshi looks fairer or have more caucasion facial features than bengalis in west bengal.. but bangaldeshi men are shorter than west bengals... my personanl opinion.
I want you say to you please don't say about the religion coz when you asy about the religion then I would to say the islam religion in Bengal 🇮🇳 came from Turks they are not bengalis so please told us about the religion
And Momota says others bohiragoto(baahri)😂😂😂 Banerjee khud Kannauj se aaye hai...didi e na cholbe, ye cheating hai khud bahar se aakar dusro ko bohiragoto bolti ho.
What Bengals thought that day india thought day after that. And the world used to think after India. We all lost it. We need to get it back again. We will surely do it.
I want to tell you the intresting reality - Some of the bengalis came from North India 🇮🇳 - Bhattacharya(Bhattacharjee) , Chattopadhay( Chatterjee) , Bandhopadhyay( Banerjee) , Mukhopadhyay (Mukherjee) , Gongopadhyay ( Ganguly) , Chakraborty , Bose or Basu , Datta, , Dey or Dev , Mitra , Guha , Ghosh and these surnames also came from Northern India 🇮🇳 and Sinha or Sinha came from Bihar and Sen Surname came from Karnataka .
@Bharatiya if you don't know then don't reply to anyone sena dynasty come from karnataka to bengal even they've created many things like dkaheswari temple and you should search about the sen dynasty then talk to me .
@@tapabratapal3276 I am not talking about bhattacharya or Bhattacharjee...I am talking about the region from where they came... As i know from somewhere that bhattacharya were comes from south...U know anything about their origin?
Shankaracharya introduced himself while debating with Mandan Mishra that he is dravid shishu ( son of Dravid ) which means he belongs to the land where three ocean meet.
There is a grammar sukta, I am told, I do not know since I am not a sanskrit scholar, from very well known sanskrit grammarians, that just like the exchange of Va and Ba, Vanga and banga, also takes place in NNa and Da. Dravina Bhoomi, the land of wealth becomes Dravida Bhoomi. That is said to be the origin of the word Dravid, from Dravina. It seems convincing to me, since all the gold mines and the diamond mines, before 1700CE, were in the Deccan, which itself is a corrupt islamization of the word Dakshin. When someone says I am from the Dravida Bhoomi, they mention they are from the south. Again and again in Varanasi, in orthodox religious circles, I have heard the use of the word, Pancha Dravida, including the south and Maharashtra.yes, Arya also means Noble, like Aryavarta. The use of the words Aryan and Dravidian by European Indologists, who did research in europe without even coming to india, has done a lot of harm to our land.
I visited Chandraketugarh. Roman Drinking vessels have been unearthed in Chandraketugarh and fantastic stone and terracotta carvings. Local farmers dig them up everyday and they are sold. It’s a shame that a place of this importance is left to rot and very little have been done archeologically.
You have totally ignored the Indo Mongoloid contribution as admitted by scholars like Suniti Kumar Chatterjee (in his book 'Kirata Jana Kriti') and others as well as the Austro Asiatic contribution in the formation of the Bengali race and language.
@@spacedas915 Poora video dekhne ke baad bhi Aryan aur Dravidian ke chakkar me phanse ho? Angrezo ka 'distory' phailane walon pseudo-secular, liberal, tukde-tukde gangwala "vaampanthi" ho kya, jo is zamane me bhi unki phoote record chala rahe ho?
NE people are descended from people of Myanmar 🇲🇲 Thailand 🇹🇭 and China 🇨🇳 Lke Ahoms came to India from present day Myanmar due to some religious tensions. Earlier they followed some other religion but slowly there rulers converted to Hinduism and they started embracing it That's why they look so different but they are still Indians
@@harkabirsingh1122 And you are as ignorant and fool as Stalin, because you take two benchmarks to define one variable like all mediocre brained commies. And thus define the roots from a Historical perspective but keep the Geography of the present time. Some day you will end up saying Punjabi people as Pakistani, since they crossed border during 1947! 😂
Dravidians are all Aryans, the people who followed vedic principles are Aryan, it's not a geographical identity but Dravidian is. In Vishnu Puran Dravinam means the land which is surrounded by water by three sides. Even Adi Shankara Said "Aham dravirashya putrah". In Rigveda it is clearly mentioned that Aryan means the one who obeys and follows the Vedic principles, that's all. Again am saying every Aryan is Dravidians because all the Aryan lived in Bharat which is also known as Dravid bhumi. And every Dravidians are Aryan.
As a Professor of Microbiologist i know in indian subcontinent DNA and genome structure are same. But our education are carring old religioustical thought, some Bhim badi/ OBC category people, even some Bramhins cannot accept the truth.
India has different ethnicities, but for thousands of years people got along with each other. So, we can't divide between people of our subcontinent now. Even in small countries like Bangladesh, we see massive diversity. As many dynasties from different ethnic groups ruled over Bengal. And you mentioned about high life standard in pre- Islamic era. But actually Bengal experienced more prosperity in Bengal Subah, which was an Islamic dynasty. That's from Wikipedia ~ Bengal Subah has been variously described the "Paradise of Nations"[7] and the "Golden Age of Bengal",[8][9] due to its inhabitants' living standards and real wages, which were among the highest in the world.[10] It alone accounted for 40% of Dutch imports from Asia.[11] The eastern part of Bengal was globally prominent in industries such as textile manufacturing and shipbuilding,[12] and it was a major exporter of silk and cotton textiles, steel, saltpeter, and agricultural and industrial produce in the world.[13] The region was also the basis of the Anglo-Bengal War.[14]
Why is there a large similarity in Sanskrit and various Baltic languages? and Why is that R1a Haplogroup so prevalant in North Indians and the people of eastern Ukraine? We cannot completely debunk the Aryan Theory just because we want to claim that we North Indians are original inhabitants of India. Nobody knows what happened thousands of years ago since there is no clear record of events in the history of India and the other parts of the world in those times. And if the Aryan story is a true story it is not certain whether it was an Aryan invasion or Aryan migration. But irrespective of whether this Aryan story is true or not, the North Indians belong to this country as equally as South Indians and we shouldn't be divided because this is not good for the unity of this country.
Learn about Gotra which refers to Hindu clan or tribe. So mostly Hindus were tribal, and if Aryan Theory is wrong then the Aryans are from today J&K and Ladakh as Tribal clan (There are some real Aryans in Ladakh research about it), where some migrated to west. And for me all these are theories, which not has any evidences. Europians says Aryan migrated to South Asia without any evidence. We can also say that some Aryan migrated from India to europe. And about language, there a language Prakrit which later reformed by Hindus as Sanskrit. And about similarities, take an example of Tamil which is similar to Japanese.
U people Are Negroid🐷 Australoid Mixture 🤮, I will Kick u if u tey to come in North india sala Australoid Chutiya, Kya ek Rajput tum average South ya Bengali jaise dikhte hai??
I hope you reach millions of subscribers sir🙏 . I hope through you people across the nation unify as Indians(no aryans or dravidians) and work for this country🙏
Bengal is a 4,000 year old civilization that thrived between the banks of Ganges to Brahmaputra and sustained itself with the riches of Gangetic Delta.
Some so called leftists and separatists have been trying to shape the idea that we Bengali people are not part of Vedic society... But in vain. Jay shree Krishna 🙏
#AskAbhijit What is origin behind the Assamese and Bengali conflicts in assam? I'm a bengali from assam origin living in mumbai currently unaware of the history and early origins of this conflict.
Assamese who are east asian looking they are actually from east asia like thailand, khemer, vietnam origin. They established kingdom there and thus mix with bengali people. It happens as the bengal and kalinga kingdom was actually dominanting culturally and economically to SE asian region and tibet. So people from both the sides have no problem to have kings from either side , as both having same cultural and religious values. Many bengali and kalinga and even southern traders sattles in SE asia by marrying a princess in these region and their ofsprings sometimes become king in mainlabd kingdoms. So these Assamese bengali conflict is relatively new than the deep history we share.
@@goognoon523There was no bengali in assam before 1826. The culture present there was kamrupi culture and people following it are called kamrupi people. Kamrupi people may belong to brahmins ,kshtriyas like baro bhuyans,koch who have east asian facial features and local tribals like bodo,kachari etc. kamrupi people followed shakta hinduism and MAA kamakhya was their chief deity. Before people of kamrupa kingdom sanskrit, later magadhi prakit became a prominent language in whole eastern india(Vihar,bengal,kalinga,kamrupa). After magadhi prakit kamrupi people adopted kamrupi prakit and even today kamrupi script is used by assamese people.
Thanks for bringing up the topic of chandraketugarh,dear sir. Chandraketugarh is near my maternal grandparents village,which is Berachampa. My grandad's elder brother, Mr. Dilip Kumar Maity was an archaeologist. He excavated various sites in Chandraketugarh,and found various artifacts like pottery,sculptors,etc. I am extremely proud to be related to such a person. And also thank you sir for making such wonderful videos on various topics. It's time India learn about it's ancient history which has just been left in denial and ignorance for decades.
If therewqs no aryan or dravidian, then why do the dravian people speak language that are totally different from the northern languages??? Indo aryan languages i.e. hindi urdu bengali punjabi guajarati assamese have soo much common and they are similar in a way with ancient sanskrit and persian While the Dravidian languages are totally different and belong to a different language family altogether... If all of india belonged from the same tribe, then tamil telugu etc. Would havs been a part of indo aryan languages... A large region wouldn't start speaking a different languages unless the new language is forces upon them by the ruler. I would request you to kindly explain me on this, thanks
There's a bit genetic differences between Indo Aryan and dravidians. If u say no difference, u r denying genetics. Bangali people, inclusing bangladeshi people, are mixture of northern and southern Indians. Bangladeshi people has also have admixture with South East asians, but in very small scale. Majority is northern and southern Indians mixture.
Hi Abhijit, although you started with the origin of Bengalis, and later distracted to origin of Dravidian and Aryan. You had few wrong info, let me correct. The origin of Bengalis actually more than 5000 years old (even older). You can find the name "pundravardhana" in Mahavarata, which belongs to Bengalis. However, Bengalis are not ethnically pure Aryan, but due to the geographic location a mix of Aryan and Austric (native) nation. Thanks.
He did not distract to the origin of Dravidian...etc. The questioner asked him about that. Watch the video with more concentration before commenting insensibly. There were two questions: the first was on origin & the next was about Aryan-Dravidian. So he answered the first one first, before 'distracting' (according to you) to the second part. And there is no 'wrong' info also. He just did not get into more detailing that you perhaps expected. He has a time limit for every question and cannot go ahead detailing to each and everyone's expectations. For that he or she needs further self-research. This is just a Q/A kind of blog session. Understand that!😠
![[UNCUT] เก็บ "สจ.โต้ง" เอี่ยวมาเฟีย รู้ตัวคนบงการ ก่อนสั่งลั่นไก I คนดังนั่งเคลียร์ I 13 ธ.ค.67](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/o-J_p62D40w/mqdefault.jpg)
Iranian American proud of my Vedic roots. Jaya Bharat
@Store Patternator thank you i would love to learn more about this.
@Store Patternator yes you are corroborating what has been taught by my Guru but he has never explained to me in this detail. I don't get much personal time with him to ask about such things anymore so thank you so much for replying. Pranamami
Great to hear from you, brother. May the gods bless you.
@@AbhijitChavda you too 🙏🏼
@Store Patternator so the bengalis are from puru clan or parshu clan?
As a Bengali myself, I cannot thank you enough Sir, for saying these true words about the Bengalis. Here, in Bengal, even the educated (of course, leftist) people think that Bengal's culture is only 500 years old, whereas all archeological evidences are left to rot or to get stolen. Thanks to the questioner as well for placing such a question on this forum.
leftist are master in twisting facts..they are liars..marxist historians never mentioned in history books hindu vijaynagar empire, ahom dynasty but they kept insisting about mughal empire & delhi sultenate..
The afghans destroyed lots of history when they came here and that is one of the reasons we don't get anything before then came.
Also a few days back an excavation has been made around Robert Clive's house. And many ancient things have been found some of them being potteries in gupta period and post gupta period. Which already dates back to around 1700 to 1800 yrs back. Now no one knows how many places have British did this. Chances are around many old monuments including churches. But now it's difficult because if ppl go in Church to do these half of the left eco system will come up saying Christians are not safe in this country.
@@saptarshipal6743 Not Afghans actually they had Turks, Arabs and Afghans but the common thing is they were Muslims and according to Islam destroying Non Islamic ideology and architecture is the way to Jannat were they can get 72 virgins and can have s@x all the time.
@@saptarshipal6743 Well said :)
@@saptarshipal6743 talking about nagerbazar clive house ??
The word dravidian was first coined by shankaracharya refering to where he came from, the place where 3 oceans meet! There are no dravidians or aryans
No it wasn't. Ramayana uses the word Dravid several times referring to the southern regions.
@@truetool source?
@@poornachandra80 In Ayodhya Kand, when Kaikeyi asks Dashrath to exile Lord Ram, Dashrath says my rule extends to the whole world from Sindhu Sauvira..to Dravida. I can give it all to you but don't send my Ram away from me. Read the Valmiki Ramayan.
@@truetool yeah but it doesn't mention ppls right?
@@nunuasura No, just as a region. There is no racial classification on the basis of Aryan/Dravidian in our shastras.
I am a Bengali, my caste or group came to Bengal about 700 years ago from present day Kashmir. We are descendent of Kashyap Muni. We are taught that a vast part Bengal’s land rose from ocean about 1000 years ago and people from all parts of India moved into it. Land is immensely fertile.
Gotra se ap kashmir se ho ye pata nahi chalta ha ap bangsaj ho aisa kahe sakte ho...lekin kashmir se directly nahi bol sakte ap
@@adityabanerjee0244 bangsaj ka matlab kya hota hai?
I have the same gotra...... But i don't know about my ancestors and I'm Bengali
@@adityabanerjee0244 banglai bolun Hindi te gyan marte hobena
@@plover8083 descendent
1) Even today it called as Banga. Real name of WB as we call Pashchim Banga.
2) Excavation near Tamluk results discovery of a near 10000 years old civilization and sea port system.
In mahabharat time bangal was known as ANGA DESH and karna was made king of Anga desh for several thousand years it was known as ANGA DESH and after thaat it known as VANGA KINGDOM AND THEN to BANG
@@vineetthakur182 , Anga is Assam and North East. Even today it is called as Anga.
@ Arijit Chatterjee
Anga=Bihar
Banga=Bengal
Kalinga/Utkal= Odisa
Pragjyotishpur=Assam ( home of Bhagadatta)
Roughly because present state borders doesn't resemble ancient ones
I want to drop 'west' word from bengal and 'paschim' word from banga.
@@ultamuri1857 , ok! Then add Bangladesh (East Bengal) politically with India. 🧐🤓
We are Indians.. Hardcore indians.. all indians are brothers and sisters of bengalis. That's it.
😅 true
lol
@@yogiadityanath8214 what? What is funny about that. ?.do you think i am wrong?
Right..
Joy bangla
It just makes me cry on how our great Bengal has fallen
It hasn't fallen yet. The region will eventually rise up, unlike the downfall of the great middle eastern countries (Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, etc) caused by the West & Israel
"We are Indians firstly & lastly"
- Dr. Ambedkar
Ambedkar call Brahmin Bideshi
@@bablipaul2219 If he did, he was ignorant.
@@bablipaul2219 Genetic studies clearly debunk this Shit. Modern day indians have same genes( learn about ANI and ASI). So he was factually wrong, cant blame him since genetic studies were not conducted then.Also the page strangely targets brahmins. the wordpress which u have sent is biased.Proffesor Vilas Kharat is well known for his biased statements on every issue.( it might also have to do with kharat being from a dalit family, i am just citing this which also might be a possibility, cant blame them after all the things that they have suffered). i dont believe in this caste based bullshit, go see Dr. Subramaniam Swamy, a much more learned man from harvard and a great politician, he will debunk all these theories. Also see this th-cam.com/video/CUgoCNtldcQ/w-d-xo.html
Babli Paul
You are a rice bag
@@bablipaul2219 no he didn't believe in Aryan invasion shit........his followers do believe in this myth
Sanjay Dixit Announced to give 2 crore who'll prove this Aryan Invasion Theory. Nobody was able to prove it. 👍🏻
Stop fighting for Tamila & Sanskrit, North & South. Be Indian.
Read the fundamental rights, it's our duty to protect the integrity of this nation.
Why you getting fear by this issue ? if this theory is fake ..nobody give dam about his issue. We can't hide the truth because nothing to loose 🙏🏻
@@MrStylorock Did you see what happen in Afghanistan? Same thing can happen in India in next 10 years. So stay United.
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
@@MrStylorock But we cant just stay quiet about it. "Lies told again nd again would eventually look like the truth".Even Hitler used this psychology in his political agendas.
its a fake theory
@@pranaypatil1969 The archealogy test done at delhi and it was done by brahmins community who are Jews/Aryan by race. What they will tell and what you will expect ? What is the truth you know let me ask you ? Before 17th century there is no proof of durga pooja but kali pooja was celebrated ! before 1920 there is no ganesh chaturthi but vinayagar caturtgi was celebrated. The merging of gods and unification of hindus created a great confusion among the yout. Tamizhan is a race which was distributed in all over india which Ambedkar also told in is book as tramila/tamilzha/dravida.
Being a direct descendant of Dasarath Basu (Circa 1045 AD) with documented history of our arrival in Bengal from Kannuaj back in the 11th century to present day, sharing the same bloodline with some of the greatest sons of this great land, I really found your explanation pretty intriguing. With such formative familial history, it was alway taught to me by my elders, that you're an Indian first and a Bengali second, so I totally agree with your views on this divisive hogwash perpetrated by the colonials to further psychologically weaken us post independence.
@ALLAH WHO FUCKBAR yes i am kankyakubja brahmin mukherjee
I read about it
@@Rahul_Singh100 "you people", "fake Bengali identity", "hogwash" ?? Well my boy, calling someone's identity fake must be something inherent to your genetic pool sadly it isn't mine. I really don't understand people who have no clue where there immediate forefathers came from, asking someone with over 1000 years of familial history what they should and shouldn't do. Grow a pair chum and stop being a twat on YT. Just to remind you, even the National Anthem of this great country was written by a Bengali, in Bengali. 😏
@@Rahul_Singh100 The curse of Lord Krishna from the end of Dwaparyuga is upon you people soon the Yadavas & followed by you foolish racists will all be destroyed.
@@Rahul_Singh100 what is your real identity in the ancient time every Indians talking to each other in sanskrit language not in hindi
It May be a colonial construct but these NCERT people taught us in the history books that the Aryans came from central Asia. It's no more a British agenda, our own people are the divisive force.
Rightly pointed out
Communists taking over our education.
True
Never trusted NCERT myself.
Yes, they are the breaking india force, the so called liberal, secular, intellectual communists!!
There is no Aryan or Dravidian if see vedic ages multi skin color is mentioned just taken an example of droupar yug Krishna black skin Radha white skin Dhropdhi skin color related to evening or light brown.This Aryan and Dravidian concept was made by Britishers their policy divide and rule. Still missionaries are targettin adishivasis for converting them to Christianity telling them we treats them badly for there skin color. If you see Mother Goddess then you will see multi skin color.
Exactly
Thanks for your wisdom
@@velmurugankandasamy9656 why don't you find by yourself my brother
True
@@velmurugankandasamy9656 go read Vedas for yourself
Bengal was truly prosperous..people were well educated highly cultured and very intelligent.That’s why British separated the largely Muslim eastern areas from the largely Hindu western areas in 1905.They tried to weaken Bengal….Thank you sir for bringing this topic🙏
There was a proverb -
"What Bengal thinks today, India thinks tomorrow"
But I heard and personally saw the Bengalis are short tempered and vandalism is rampant in Bengal! Who are they? The minorities and leftists! please clarify
Proverb!poor-verb only!@@riddhirahman
@@srinivasanthanu6751right now, bengal is shit, after Muslims increased and mamta not doing any development, bengal was great but not anymore
ASA a Bengali I can’t imagine us being smart 😂
Bengal had one of the greatest Buddhist empires called Pala Empire and multiple universities in the post classical period. They were one of the 3 major imperial power in India along with Gujjara Pratihara and Rashtrakuta
And during the pala empire the nalanda vishwavidyalaya was in it's peek... Vanga pradesh includes modern day bihar bengal bangladesh and odisha
@@gamersgient5486well no, you need to learn history again, you are now taking into absolutes.
Like a ultra nationalist.
Nothing called banga desh at that time, even Bengali as a language and the kamrupa script had not diverted apart from it bihari and odia sister language that time.
It was still in aprahmbhasa stage.
Palas didn't had a Bengali identity like modern bengal.
Just like maghadans and angawashi didn't have bihari identity.
@@noone-zl2di hey Biro go to google and do research in google or chatgpt because I can't share links here they got hide by youtube so you do research by yourself okee?
Bengal was from Mahabharat time vanga pradesh we still call ourselves vanga bashi or bango bashi do research about my explanation then you understand
@@noone-zl2diyeah it was under the Palas that bengali language took shape as it is today.
@@FS-me8mj😂😂cute
In Mahabharata, a place is mentioned named "Pundrabardhan ". It is present day known as Mahasthan Ghar at Bagura district in Bangladesh. Banga Janapad is that much old.
Really 😱??
@@anik_kun_medico yeah . "Pundravardan" was later known as "Mohasthangarh" was one of the important city Mauriya empire
@@aminmuhammad8061 oh, wow!
Thanks for information ☺️
Bengalis are australoids mostly but I think its a mixed group.
@Land Fin akhand Bharat??????😑
There is nothing called aryan or dravidan. All mooted by makaulay education. Arya means elder. Dravida means Dramila sage n that is Tamilians
It's true that there is nothing of the sort aryan/dravidian. But Arya means a "Shreshta" human being because he/she follows Dharma. On the other hand a Dasyu is someone who doesn't follow Dharma. Dravida is actually Travida which is a Samskrutam word meaning land surrounded by three oceans. (Tra means three and vida means ocean). Travida/Dravida adjective can be given to a place and not to a person.
Totally agree
@Anupam Singh changes are there cause of geographical difference idiot
@Anupam Singh one lives in tropics and other in near equator
@@Manijkoi even sangam and dravid are sanskrit words lol and secondly a north indian brhamin made tamil facts man
As a bengali im thankful to sir for talking out loud about the reality. We are Indians by heart and always will be
I am a bengali and i believe sir is 100 percent correct. I am a Hindu and an Indian
So, what are you ? Bengali or Indian?
@@sharjilmahir both
Shut up converted we are proud Bengali and a proud Indian @@sharjilmahir
I am an Indian bengali.
'Indian' is my name and 'Bengali' is my surname. Different types of people live in India. Bengali, Marathi, Bihari, Gujrati, Tamil, Punjabi, Hariyanvi, Rajputs, kashmiri, Assamese, Manipuri, Mizos, Nagas, Odias and many more. We are all like rivers that flow seperately but eventually meet in One place which is 'INDIA'. This is what our ancestors Subhash Chandra Bose, Bhagat Singh, Rabindranath Thakur, Sukhdev, Vallabhbhai Patel taught us. Jai Hind 🇮🇳 Vande matram 🇮🇳
Damn! You pfp and username is cool. Are you a Charvak or Naastik?
Kemon achen amar Based Banghali bondhu
Btw I saw u in mohak mangal's video too
@@observer1492 observer 🥵
You are First a human being then an Indian
Tamil is a language and that too a Lankan one, not a nationality.
thank you sir love your content from bangladesh
@@mashprivel3996 ke shunte bolche?
@@mashprivel3996 😂 আরে gandu history te onek rokom perspective thake, konta vul konta thik seta bola khub kothin.
@@mashprivel3996 Language ar cultural aspects er dik theke alada alada jonogosthi ...
Eta pure genealogical aspect e bolche ... ei technical terms gulo bujhte hbe nhle confusions barbe ...
@@mashprivel3996 ভাই তুই যেই Secular history র কথা বলছিস সেগুলো Marxist historians রা লিখেছে, অনেক Political Agenda আর misinformation আছে তার মধ্যে. বাকি অন্য Narrative কে কোনো জায়গা দেওয়া হয়নি acadmics এ , এর ফলে বাকি Narrative গুলোকে fake মনে হওয়াটা ই স্বাভাবিক! আর সেই কারণেই ভারতে History বুক নতুন করে লেখার প্রস্তাব দেওয়া হয়েছে! 🙏
@@ModernUlysses ওদের চোখের মণি রোমিলা ঠাপার বলে যে যুধিষ্ঠির নাকি গৌতম বুদ্ধের কাছ থেকে শান্তির শিক্ষা নিয়েছিলো 😁 আবার মনগড়া logic দিয়ে সেগুলোকে justify করে, তাদের ভাবশিষ্যদের অন্য narrative শুনলে কান ব্যাথা করারই কথা।
We are indians, irrespective from where we are we should unite under one common nation and let's make India great again.
Nope we are culturally different and we are under unification of one country. thats it!
@@parthipansivanesan3938 then we should have 29 different countries? We do certain things differently or speak different languages that doesn't make us different...as we have same roots and ancestry
@@sourinkhan9819 yes but who own the ownership of all of our common things ? That's what matter my friend !
@@parthipansivanesan3938 india is a civilizational state dude and we are one
@@tz4668 I am not saying we need to be isolated but there is a cons in getting unified and some people gets advantage due to that.
Hinduism can only be destroyed by dividing Hindus in multiple communities, caste, regionalism etc etc
Toder moto chutiya der jnno ,aajke bangalider keu sojjo korte parena, alimuddiner jaroj.
hinduism is indeed a joint of many small religion. haaa...haaaa aryan lies all over !
@@kuru6212 u must be psycho
@@parthipansivanesan3938 you are a sick communists you need a doctor
@@tz4668 haaa....haaa you are just a ignorant. You need a brain brother !
Bengali language is an middle Indo-Aryan language combined from Sanskrit, Prakrit and Pali. So in linguistic terms, it is Indo-Aryan but it has some Austric origins which comes from our tribal origins.
Full bullshit , there are no clear cut parameters to define what is an aryan language ,only motivation behind it is Lord Macaulay education nothing else !!...
@@DattaMusics Keep saying that while the world moves forward. There have been elaborate linguistic studies. Clearly Vedic Sanskrit was not the only Indo-European language in India during Rig Veda. The Ikshvaku Turvasu tribes had other Indo-European language. If you study common words, grammar, prefixes , etc. you can know which language is a parent or a sister language .
@@sadenb The grouping of indo-aryan and austric are not reliable and at challenge , do your terminology facism while we tear the nonsense apart , dumbass , linguist study of terminologies , sonar resonations , huh !!...you are no linguist , neither you are an archeologist , geneticist do not dare to behave like one . I don't even take you seriously or your dunning Kruger effect infused schizophrenic cognition of how you have real knowledge of language !...get lost there are no language such as aryan or austric ...if the Aryan invasion is well efuted by archeologist like Suri and geneticist like Rai , the language groups and their basis of division is at doubt as well...World is moving forward while you chant Aryan invasion , clearly a deluded has no say in a war or in academics !!...Ghar jaa
Not every bengali though. Majority of us fo belong to aryan race
@@LoneWolf21672 but aryan is not even a race
I am sc nomosudra hindu but I am proud to be hindu kashyap gotra Bengali. Jai shree Ram har har mahadev jai kali jai Prataditya. Verna diwija systems was based on talent but not by birth in gurukul
You are simply hindu. Don't call yourself by any caste.
I as a brahmin(Which I don't believe in) am telling you. My ancestors have done pretty bad things, but now we have to reform and make hinduism inclusive without any need for caste.
@@sushilsharma4202 'my ancestors did wrong thing'...this propaganda is injected in every so called woke people like u by communists n colonial rule...main point is bad persons are not limited to any caste so don't produce guilt or inferiority complex within yourself.
No! your ancestors did nothing wrong...those who did, they were a small fraction of bad people who are present in every society irrespective of caste, region n country.
Don't be a puppet unknowingly n propagate the propaganda of communist which trap peoples in guilt n inferiority complex.
@@sushilsharma4202 yes I want caste to be removed from our sanatan dharma.
See this entire gotra thing debunks the so called caste system. Even my gotra is kashyap, but i am a kashtriya 🤷. Now we know that gotra is based on birth so how people belonging to same gotra has same caste as obviously caste was chosen later and not based on birth ✌️
Sorry to say that you have your brain washed by the commie nonsense so much that you think yourself low and nothing.
You are Sudra, and Sudras are great and greatly qualified for social and academic reasons.
The caste system and SC was created by the masters of the commies the british. Our Shastras doesn't recognize such divisions. It never did. So, burn your certi and become a free Indian again.
We the bengalis are aryans,we are dravidians and we are mongolians,mixture of north, south,east.This mixture can be well proved by the two or three tire gotra systems in Pashchatya Vaidiks of Bengal
TBH aryan Dravidian is a fucked up theory.
but when i read history of sinhalese people they were bong origin and they comes under indoaryan race.
Linguistically yes ,but if ur sayin genetically its nothing but western theory
Yeah, you are right. We are a mix of these 3 races.
@@plataoplomo9096 It is genetics he is talking about. Linguistically we are just Aryans and have nothing to do with Dravidians and Mongoloids but racially we are mixed.
@@sumit4640 bruv, Tamils, Veddoids and other hunter gatherer groups lived in Srilanka way before bongs went there, especially the Veddoids alongwith Jarawas stayed there before any Homo sapiens even existed in South Asia. Their language Sinhala also shares vocabulary with tribal and Tamil language. These things are mentioned in Mahabodhivamsa book of Srilanka. Infact some of the Tamil Sangam age poets also originated from Srilanka, and their inscriptions can be found in Poonakary, dating back to 3rd century BC. The names also share some resemblance with ancient Dravida kings of Karunadu(Karnataka) and Tamilakam for example Nrupatunga(Rashtrakuta dynasty), Kullathunga(Sinhaladveepam) and Kulothunga(Chola dynasty).
Bengali people's are very hardworking and hardcore nationalist. They are the race who are always in the forefront of the battle against British. Hope in coming time bengal will be the engine of this growing india in it's journey to a developed nation.
So, Bengali s fought British to serve Indians? lol
@@sharjilmahir Go check Govt Data then speak
dravida means region where 3 seas meet.arabian,indian,bengal
@@Vpr2255 what?
@@Vpr2255 oh
As a Bengali myself a geniologist has told me that Bengalis have the highest percentage of East Asian gene right after North East! The fairness of the Bengali brahmins is from East Asian and not North Indian, Aryan, Mughal or British white, the fairness is due to East Asian which also contributes to our shorter height!
That is true to some extent. However me being a bengali, my roots are from norther part of india and it is well documented. So there are many brahmins and bengalis who are from northern part of india and not north eastern though!
All of them do not look the same. People from North Bengal (Darjeeling) look more mongloid but people from South Bengal (Kolkata) look like an average Indian. But we all love our Motherland 🇮🇳.
Dude I stay in west coast and my entire family is short. 🙄
@Reality Bytes why you people always lint fairness to the brahmins?i am a namasudra from barishal and my skin colour is fairer than bhutais.also in my father's side and mother's side a very few people have dark brown skin.My father have 8 cousins and all of them are fairer.So do not think that bengalis have fairness according to their caste.Also "mithun chakrabarty" is from barishal and is a brahmin but he is not fairer.
aslo bengali fairness is not same as northern people.one day i was talking with a white american girl and i have notices that her skin is harsher than us
All Indias are same it's just geographical differences that made us look differently and speak differently. But there are a lot of ppl who want to divide India in two countries..a harsh reality.
What about people beleiving it to the core despite so much evidences just becouse it suits their Pride. Like why can't they just think be themselves about it?! its not that hard to guess the truth!
Tum daugle to khud apne desh ko batwa baithe ho, aur hame gyan pel rahe ho divisive ki.😂😂😂.
Tum bengalio ki gyan c**dne ki aadat jaati nahi hai. Ab chal apne pair pasaar...meri B angali bulbul.😘😚
@@Rahul_Singh100 oor tum jesa mahajan baate to badi karte h UP ek esa rajya h janha Yogi jesa cm rehke vi Bharat ka sabse jyada muslim population UP me h orrr sun meri baat agar itna Hii ethnicity ko leke bol rha h na Karnataka orr Maharashtra ko dekh border dispute Assam mizoram and Nagaland aagar hum desh ke divide karte na tab to ho hii jata BJP jo kii BJS tha jisko banane wala vi EK BENGALI H
@@Rahul_Singh100 tum nithalle Logo sirf ethnicity ko bol sakte ho magar concept jaata nhi racism ka boht litna gaali khaata h be tu sabse
@@Rahul_Singh100 orat se to baat karna janta nhi 😑 orr aake apni Illogical concept kii baat kar rha h mid 1970s ke cinema sholay ka gabbar ban rha h 😂😂😂🤣🤣
History of Bengal goes back 4000 years from the great Gangaridai civilization.
Yes
That right!
Oh I would love to read more about this. Can you tell me a book which I can refer? English please
@@dss6838 "Gangaridi Itihas & Sanskritik Upakaran" by Narottam Haldar.
@@gaudiyawarriors87 will read it pakka
I'm from Bengal but I didn't know that much of my state . ❤️
Follow this channel sob jene jabe 👍
Tahole jano, noile nijike lenin bole ghosona kore debe ekdin.
Actually bengal is an ancient place,Bengali is a mixture of ancient maithili and odiya...we all believe in equality,ie,we are proud bengali...
First of all ....We Bengalis fought and bleed for this country Our revolutionaries bombarded Britishers for Independence. We are Hindu and And proud Indian ...That's it.
But don't forget , we have our own distinct style of Hinduism , we have our own rituals , our culture is Tantra based not Vedic .. so if you can't find your similarities with us thats not our problem.
Bang on
Joy tontro ,Joy maa kali ✊✊
Bengali hinduism is completely different religion in which they eat beef, glorify marrying mullas, gets irritated by jay shree ram, unwarranted wokeism
@@BackspasmANDniggle where did you find we eat beef?? It's all secular wrongdoings by Kolkata's idiots. And we are rural bengalis. Where did you get your wrong facts?
@@ankanghosh5272 two of seniors from bengal eat beef, although they are more dharmic than me
E Madarchod Africa ja, Kashmiri Pandit Looks Like a Bengali Negroida🤮
We sri lankan sinhalese are mainly decendants of vanga (bengal) ....
Greetings from the land of Vanga (Bangladesh)
Oh interesting!
Nope you aren't
I heard South Indians (Dravid) anthropologically are similar to the 'native' inhabitants of Australia. It dates back before civilization. Actually, languages are a bit different in South India relative to North India but grammatically similar. I don't believe in these Dravidian-North Indian facts, we are Indians united.
Only Adivasis in South India.
It was much in the past when sea level was very low, whole south east asia, Bharat and Australia used travel between each other region.
@@cyno002 no... that never happened. Sea level was never too low to travel to Australia.
What Southern India languages r grammatically similarfrom North Indian languages and India really???
Southern India languages have depth in their words and grammar which is different from North India Hindi ok. Whatever u say but still we r Dravidians only and proud to be Dravidian ok. Go and tell this all things to your Hindi people Aryans because they have discriminated ignored humiliated stereotyped our Southern India people from 70 years, they always feel superior to others.
@@KaliNari-z4i the whole country have some stereotypes about one another's , like people of North only know that all South cuisines are sour but it's actually not. I'm not properly North Indian, I live in Bengal and Bengali in ethnicity. Go ask any Bengali people how much we respect and love South India, they won't say any bad things. I don't know about the Hindi speaking belt. And also there are pretty much similarities between Tamil and Sanskrit, particularly I don't know both these languages but sounds and means similar, can't put examples right now. I just want to know what kind of discrimination happens?
I am cambodian. Many of us have a bit of bengali dna in our blood. It's ancient admixture with central asians and northern Indians from ancient times. This explains why we don't look like stereotypical asians.
2/3 of Bengal is in South India 😂🤭😏
@@Eelamtruththen why TMC is not there, Let Mamata didi know this fact.
@@Eelamtruthyou must learn geography
@@r.a.stylzhairstudio6920 The boundary between North and South India is the Vindhya Range, so go learn Subcontinental history before telling me I don't know geography.
@@Eelamtruth go and learn geography you must
I was in chennai for official visit for some days , I was standing outside my GH to my surprise some person came to me and started taking to me in tamil , which i could not understand , this happened to me quite a few times, so we can say no one can distinguish between north & south indians just by looks we are so similar
Are you a Bengali vaidya?
@@sotyaanweshee I am from lineage.
I'm tamil. I'm in Kolkata right now and a few days back I was on the road waiting for my cab. People asked me route to some place.
Vanga-lam is the word still used to refer bengal in tamil 🤞🏼
Yes correct !
That means we are all staying in bharatvarsha for long long time.
Not tamil ok . Bengali is my mother language and sanskrit is my father language .
Bengali language come from sanskrit and tamil joker language 😂😂😂
Awrsome . Thank you. I am Bengali Hindu.
I am a Bengali and I am an Indian neither Aryan not Dravidian. Jai shree Ram 🚩🕉️
I am a Bengali and my first identity is Indian 🇮🇳
We're indebted to you for delivering to us these free knowledge and enlightening us about our history and culture, truthfully. Thanks!
Proud to be a Bengali!
And Indian!
We need more scholars like you, Sir! ❤
Dravan means solution (as in the solution of something in a solvent like water).
Dravida means the region where the land dissolves into the sea. Or where the land disappears and the ocean begins.
British people twisted Sanskrit words.
These are the correct meanings.
Dravan = solution
Lavan = salt
Just read a chemistry book in Bengali language and Bengalis will realize that there is no Dravidian race.
Dont study anything and omit here, Dravidians means south indian brahmin. the real race of india is Tamizh i.e naga
@@parthipansivanesan3938 you're really really brainwashed my friend. Stop fighting over Tamil and Sanskrit, religion, languages, culture , north & south, Aryans& Dravidians (which theory is false as we all have same genes and no Aryan invasion happened). Stop fighting over stupid misconceptions people put into you. We are all indians and it's our responsibility to respect and protect India's integrity.
@@sincerelyxshristi The question you put on me is the same I need to ask you. Go and analyze the history. India was ruled by the Brahmin community and whatever they are telling, you people are accepting. Haaa....haaa. not on single topic you can answer me that much you're all manipulated.
@@parthipansivanesan3938 did I say anything about the rule of brahmin community? manipulation? Babe manipulation is what YOU did here.. mending my words into something else , dissecting my intention and trying to force BRAINWASHED mindset. I don't just accept whatever people say.. i actually try to research myself not like you who just doesn't try to have a broad mindset. Try hearing both stories before lecturing people to "learn" history. Because trust me.. i probably know more history than you do.
@@sincerelyxshristi ok accepted you know better than me. Please give me concrete evidence that Durga lived in so..so many years ? Who are Bengali and how there name came as Bengali ? Yes indeed I respect India and be a Indian citizen until or unless yours and my culture is respected, isn't it ? If really people say Aryans invaded India then let me know as you are great historian who coined the term Aryan in Indian subcontinent first and till now ?
Bengal comprised of 3 provinces & finds mention even in Mahabharat. The 3 provinces were Anga (mostly north Bengal & North Bihar), Banga (Eastern side of what is now Bangladesh) and Pandrugaur( current Murshidabad).
According to aryan invasion theory, my sister is Aryan and I am Dravidian
It doesn't matter if we're Aryan or Dravidian..... We're all Indians...jai hind 🇮🇳
This is an awesome way to simplify history and topics that sound very complex that are taught in school 👍
2023, Ariyan Invasion theory has been proved, with keeldi reasearch completed. Ariyans came to this land.
I'm a eastern side bengali from Northeast
1)I have seen a minor difference that
Kolkata Bengali are little bit dull in skin texture (not colour)
Maybe because of climate or food!
2) I have seen many Persian people similar facial structure like us!
3) i got little bit triprasa genetics from my dad and grandma
Northeast bengalis are mixed with Nepali and Nepali are Pahadi ( hill aryans)
@@DeusEstAmor________137 their is no Nepali here for ur kind information 🤓.
Not to mention
Nepali don't really have Mongoliad features at all
One of my doubts: if Dravidian and Aryan are from same origin, then why two separate lines of languages in the form of Tamil (old) and Sanskrit came into being? Even though most of the alphabetic similarities are found in these two languages but still scripts look different and many of vowel treatments like ए or ओ are different. Example: "को" written in Hindi, is different in Tamil (it's more like Bengali "কো") or "के" in Hindi looks different in Bengali which is "কে"। Both the Bengali styles shown here are remarkably like Tamil. Of course, we know for some time back, Rulers from South India ruled Bengal just before Muslim invasion in Bengal. Typically, Dravidian skin color is darker than North Indian. And as for Bengalis it is mixture of both these two categories. Bengali alphabets are ditto of Sanskrit, except few vowel treatments, as mentioned above. Similarly, skin color too. Hence, I think Bengalis have influence of both these two groups, whether both these two groups (Dravidian and Aryan) are original inhabitants of this sub-continent or not.
This person is very nationalistic and avoids discussing about human migration, hapogroups and language families.
@@arkaprovasaha4313 exactly! he has not once questioned if all indians have the same genetic origin supposedly 40k years ago, why did two entirely separate language families develop in India?
@@MichelleObamasBBC yes there are three or four language families 3 or 4 or more than that Indian phenotypes among which the most dominant one is called south asian ( which is seen highly amongst south Indians ) still he'll keep on saying all Indians same Indians and British did it, British separated us. That's it.
Tamil actually has a lot of similarities to the old mesopotamian language.
@@abhishekghosh4384 thats not true.
Sir, Kunti Putra Karna was king of Vanga,Bhgalpur etc!!!
Reference - Last day of the fight between Karna and Arjuna.Karna and Shalya had a verbal spat over certain subjects.
Karna was Anga Raj.
Not Vanga Raj.
Anga is for region of Angika language which became extinct, in present day Bihar.
Not vanga(बंग) but Anga(अंग)
There is difference between aanga and vanga
@@Rahul_Singh100 not extinct...Angika is presently spoken in Jamui-Gidhaur-Jhajha region basically Jamui district of Bihar may be in Lakhisarai region too.
@@vickydonor5922 Stop BSing. Angika isn't spoken anywhere in Bihar. It's not even an official language of Bihar. 😁
Amar sonar bangla ami tomay valobashi ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Bengalis are mixed peoples
I have in my relatives who are extreemly black/dark
And strenge is they are brahmins.
And I have many scedule caste friends
Who are fair skinned.
It is almost contradictory to aryan dravidian theory 🤣
Becouse in aryan invasion theory aryans fair skinned sharp facial features and they are brahmins but in this case things are exactly opposite
Coz they got either raped or mixed by consent due to being in same land after invasion..
Same way why we don't see mixture of black, white n brown in Iran..? Coz there were no dravidians else we would be able to see the same in Iran as well ..
@@GmBharath19 WHICH INVASION SIR ?Haven't heard or read about invasion?
@@GmBharath19 do you have any proof of invasion ❓
Stop this faith narrative Aryan and Dravidian it is just a communist movement to divide India.
@@soumikmondal2050 actually colonial now continued by Commies
Ya India under various empire , culture mixing is obvious
Of the great civilization of India ❤️🙏
Bengal has mixed Adivasi Aryan Dravidian mixed population. Bengal itself is not a race it has many races mixed in it same as Bihar orrisa Uttar Pradesh and other north indian states .
And some mongoloid
🎉🎉*Bengal itihasa continued from Mahabharat time. There are too many Great Bengali kings named Shasanka who defeated Harshabardhana, then Gupta, Sen and Paal Dynasty. There was also a parallel bengali civilization called Gangahridi. Which mentioned in Greek history. Google all the names.*
Bengals has a good mix of Mongolian race.... Specifically in the extreme Eastern United bengal..... Like Chittagong
Master da surjo Sen had no mongoloid mix , the gurkha and tibeto burman mix happened and it is normal being near by place, there are no mongoloid genetics even in arunachali people they are tibeto-burman , The Varmans of varendra had Burmese mixing , that's there !!
Mongoloid is a race..... Tibeto burman is a ethnic groups within mongoloid race with distinctive slit eyes, fair skin
@@somnathchanda1250 no they are not , The tibeto-burman race has no connection with mongoloid nether does the Japanese have !!...The contextual terms are often counter intuitive in science !
......So, do learn first before making a fool of urself !....and stop these bro , brah nonsense !!.. Mongolian.race has zero to.do.with tibeto Burmese race in any genetic sciences , this iare pseudo jargons , deprived of context !
Nope you are wrong , They are related to Barmiz people not Mongol
"race" is an unscientific concept.
Well said "we are same people". Love ❤️ from Bangladesh...hope our politicians understands this
Not only politicians your people must understand.Stop burning Hindu Housed and torturing them
Though you are right but since the invasion of Saudia religion and culture these problems started. So better you should give up foriegn religion and literatures and come back to the origin will help to bring peace. Thanks
@@vikramadityahindu8591The partition of the subcontinent brought hatred against minorities. Not only Pak and BD have problems with minorities even India does.
@@15incognitoWe still have our bengali culture and language. You should know one thing we would never give up Islam for anything.
@@RavenPaven India should have expelled muslims completely.
Bengal was founded as Gaur in 600 CE ( time when bengali calendar starts) by Maharajdhiraj Sasanka Deva. Sasanka Deva came from RohtasGar in Magadh where he was a feudatory lord of Magadhraj Mahasenagupta. After death of Mahasenagupta in 605 CE, Mahadhiraj Sasanka Dev founded Gaur ( Bengal) and ruled till 636 CE. Bengal seen Pala and Sena dynasty. Pala dynasty was when buddhism spread to Tibet and Siam Desh(Thailand) from Bengal. During attack of Kannauj by ghaznavids and ghorids many hindu brahmin and nobles migrated to Bengal. Gaur, vikrampur, tamralipi were important places in Bengal during Sena dynasty. Islamic rule came with delhi sultanate in 14th century followed by Mughal and British rule. Abhijit is correct Bengalis are mix of all races just like any other Indians. Modern India owes a lot to the sacrifice and ranaissance of bengal which helped in independence of India. Bengalis are proud Indians.
Vanga is much older, gaud is a part of vanga,there are others such as pundra, harikela, radh, varendra etc.
In tamil still we call Bengal as vanga desam.
❤️❤️
Some interesting facts - there was a study done on Bangladesh (East Bengal) racial population. The study showed that light skinned people of Bangladesh come of the traditional Brahmin, Kshatriya & Vaishya caste among the indegenous Bengali people and also the Iranian settlers in the region like Persians, Kurds, Turkics & Pashtuns during Bengal Sultanate period. Hence a lot of Bengalis are light skinned and a sizable portion of them have blue, brown, Hazel eyes. They are highly caucasoid.
While most people are medium brown to dark brown, there is a considerable percentage of people who are very dark. They are actually ethnically highly australoid & less caucasoid.
Then there is another sizable portion of Bengalis who have slanted eyes, straight silky hair and yellow skin tone. They are mongoloid Bengalis. They are descendants of East Asians. Influx of North-East Asians happened during Pala Empire period and Bengal always maintained good trading relation with South-East Asia.
Due to geographical location & historical geopolitics, Bengalis are ethnically one of the most mixed Indic ethnic group. Bengalis come from diverse ethnic backgrounds & religions. The only thing that unites them all is the language and culture.
You will find that not all/every Bengalis look the same and the direct correlation intellectuals have found this to be the mixing in the past when different ethnicities mixed due to movement of business travellers from different countries settled in East Bengal (now Bangladesh) and marrying the locals within the community.
but i think bangladeshi looks fairer or have more caucasion facial features than bengalis in west bengal.. but bangaldeshi men are shorter than west bengals... my personanl opinion.
I want you say to you please don't say about the religion coz when you asy about the religion then I would to say the islam religion in Bengal 🇮🇳 came from Turks they are not bengalis so please told us about the religion
And Momota says others bohiragoto(baahri)😂😂😂
Banerjee khud Kannauj se aaye hai...didi e na cholbe, ye cheating hai khud bahar se aakar dusro ko bohiragoto bolti ho.
@@moses7336 It's totally Wrong even india average height And Bangladesh Average Height same.
@@moses7336your personal opinion doesn't matter, West Bengalis on average are shorter than us
What Bengals thought that day india thought day after that. And the world used to think after India.
We all lost it. We need to get it back again. We will surely do it.
Not with the current politicians we have be it BJP or TMC..no visionary leader in Bengal
I want to tell you the intresting reality - Some of the bengalis came from North India 🇮🇳 - Bhattacharya(Bhattacharjee) , Chattopadhay( Chatterjee) , Bandhopadhyay( Banerjee) , Mukhopadhyay (Mukherjee) , Gongopadhyay ( Ganguly) ,
Chakraborty , Bose or Basu , Datta, , Dey or Dev , Mitra , Guha , Ghosh and these surnames also came from Northern India 🇮🇳 and Sinha or Sinha came from Bihar and Sen Surname came from Karnataka .
@Bharatiya if you don't know then don't reply to anyone sena dynasty come from karnataka to bengal even they've created many things like dkaheswari temple and you should search about the sen dynasty then talk to me .
And what about my Surname ?? Can you tell this one ??
Bhattacharya comes from south as per I know.
@@vickydonor5922 no Bhattacharya is also known in English language- Bhattacharjee like bandopadhay - Banerjee
@@tapabratapal3276 I am not talking about bhattacharya or Bhattacharjee...I am talking about the region from where they came... As i know from somewhere that bhattacharya were comes from south...U know anything about their origin?
Once an epic community but how far have we fallen now
In Tamil Nadu we still call them as மேற்கு வங்கம் (west Bengal) / வங்கதேசம் Bangladesh (Vangadesh and not using Ba )
Shankaracharya introduced himself while debating with Mandan Mishra that he is dravid shishu ( son of Dravid ) which means he belongs to the land where three ocean meet.
There is a grammar sukta, I am told, I do not know since I am not a sanskrit scholar, from very well known sanskrit grammarians, that just like the exchange of Va and Ba, Vanga and banga, also takes place in NNa and Da. Dravina Bhoomi, the land of wealth becomes Dravida Bhoomi. That is said to be the origin of the word Dravid, from Dravina. It seems convincing to me, since all the gold mines and the diamond mines, before 1700CE, were in the Deccan, which itself is a corrupt islamization of the word Dakshin. When someone says I am from the Dravida Bhoomi, they mention they are from the south. Again and again in Varanasi, in orthodox religious circles, I have heard the use of the word, Pancha Dravida, including the south and Maharashtra.yes, Arya also means Noble, like Aryavarta. The use of the words Aryan and Dravidian by European Indologists, who did research in europe without even coming to india, has done a lot of harm to our land.
which is not an ethnicity but a geogrphical location#facts
Thanks!
Proud to be muslim,proud to be bengal,proud to be Bangladesh.
Love from Bangladesh, sir.
Check ex Muslims ☝️
I visited Chandraketugarh. Roman Drinking vessels have been unearthed in Chandraketugarh and fantastic stone and terracotta carvings. Local farmers dig them up everyday and they are sold. It’s a shame that a place of this importance is left to rot and very little have been done archeologically.
You have totally ignored the Indo Mongoloid contribution as admitted by scholars like Suniti Kumar Chatterjee (in his book 'Kirata Jana Kriti') and others as well as the Austro Asiatic contribution in the formation of the Bengali race and language.
Hello sir, I am from Assam, NE India. NE is very much interesting in all terms. Can you please describe us about origin of NE.
All Indian only.
Assamese log Mongolian, Aryan, Dravidian ye tino milkar bana he.
@@spacedas915 Poora video dekhne ke baad bhi Aryan aur Dravidian ke chakkar me phanse ho?
Angrezo ka 'distory' phailane walon pseudo-secular, liberal, tukde-tukde gangwala "vaampanthi" ho kya, jo is zamane me bhi unki phoote record chala rahe ho?
NE people are descended from people of Myanmar 🇲🇲 Thailand 🇹🇭 and China 🇨🇳
Lke Ahoms came to India from present day Myanmar due to some religious tensions.
Earlier they followed some other religion but slowly there rulers converted to Hinduism and they started embracing it
That's why they look so different but they are still Indians
@@harkabirsingh1122 And you are as ignorant and fool as Stalin, because you take two benchmarks to define one variable like all mediocre brained commies. And thus define the roots from a Historical perspective but keep the Geography of the present time.
Some day you will end up saying Punjabi people as Pakistani, since they crossed border during 1947! 😂
Love your videos from Bangladesh.
How's the situation over there in Bangladesh? 😑
@@debarghyaroy9948 We are good here. There are not so many cases that hindus facing problem. I can say that I can live peacefully here. Thank you.
@@swadhinchakraborty1 Well you have my best wishes from the other side of the border. Stay safe. Just checking a review you made!🙂
@@debarghyaroy9948 Thank you brother.
@@debarghyaroy9948 broo this bangladesh not pakistan and india that kills minority
In bengal we have our own calendar that calendar says we are 1428 years old culture.We still use that calendar to count durga puja days
🙂🙏 you are the best teacher.
Namaskar from kolkata!
Abhijit Sir's busting level of Arya-Dravid theory is next level🔥🔥
The oldest archaeological site of Bengal is known as 'Mohsthangar', located in the Bogra district of Bangladesh.
Dravidians are all Aryans, the people who followed vedic principles are Aryan, it's not a geographical identity but Dravidian is. In Vishnu Puran Dravinam means the land which is surrounded by water by three sides. Even Adi Shankara Said "Aham dravirashya putrah". In Rigveda it is clearly mentioned that Aryan means the one who obeys and follows the Vedic principles, that's all.
Again am saying every Aryan is Dravidians because all the Aryan lived in Bharat which is also known as Dravid bhumi.
And every Dravidians are Aryan.
"Vangadesh" that's interesting because we don't have the sound "v" in Bangla, because "v"="b".. so maybe the language also changed over the years 🤔
U were invaded
I'm a proud Bengali ❤️❤️
Did a genetic test. I found out that we are a mix of north, south and even a little East Asian!
From an Indian Bengali
কোথা থেকে জেনেটিক টেস্ট করলেন?
In tamil we calling, Vanga Desam & Vangala Desam
❤️❤️
As a Professor of Microbiologist i know in indian subcontinent DNA and genome structure are same. But our education are carring old religioustical thought, some Bhim badi/ OBC category people, even some Bramhins cannot accept the truth.
Do not consider OBC bcz this category have wide variety.
Like gujjar which have actual central asian race.
Except then most of us same.
In tamizh we still call vanga Desam, vanga kadal..bay of Bengal, vangalathaan... Bengali.
❤️❤️
India has different ethnicities, but for thousands of years people got along with each other. So, we can't divide between people of our subcontinent now. Even in small countries like Bangladesh, we see massive diversity. As many dynasties from different ethnic groups ruled over Bengal.
And you mentioned about high life standard in pre- Islamic era. But actually Bengal experienced more prosperity in Bengal Subah, which was an Islamic dynasty.
That's from Wikipedia ~
Bengal Subah has been variously described the "Paradise of Nations"[7] and the "Golden Age of Bengal",[8][9] due to its inhabitants' living standards and real wages, which were among the highest in the world.[10] It alone accounted for 40% of Dutch imports from Asia.[11] The eastern part of Bengal was globally prominent in industries such as textile manufacturing and shipbuilding,[12] and it was a major exporter of silk and cotton textiles, steel, saltpeter, and agricultural and industrial produce in the world.[13] The region was also the basis of the Anglo-Bengal War.[14]
Why is there a large similarity in Sanskrit and various Baltic languages? and Why is that R1a Haplogroup so prevalant in North Indians and the people of eastern Ukraine? We cannot completely debunk the Aryan Theory just because we want to claim that we North Indians are original inhabitants of India. Nobody knows what happened thousands of years ago since there is no clear record of events in the history of India and the other parts of the world in those times. And if the Aryan story is a true story it is not certain whether it was an Aryan invasion or Aryan migration. But irrespective of whether this Aryan story is true or not, the North Indians belong to this country as equally as South Indians and we shouldn't be divided because this is not good for the unity of this country.
Learn about Gotra which refers to Hindu clan or tribe. So mostly Hindus were tribal, and if Aryan Theory is wrong then the Aryans are from today J&K and Ladakh as Tribal clan (There are some real Aryans in Ladakh research about it), where some migrated to west. And for me all these are theories, which not has any evidences. Europians says Aryan migrated to South Asia without any evidence. We can also say that some Aryan migrated from India to europe.
And about language, there a language Prakrit which later reformed by Hindus as Sanskrit. And about similarities, take an example of Tamil which is similar to Japanese.
U people Are Negroid🐷 Australoid Mixture 🤮, I will Kick u if u tey to come in North india sala Australoid Chutiya, Kya ek Rajput tum average South ya Bengali jaise dikhte hai??
I hope you reach millions of subscribers sir🙏 . I hope through you people across the nation unify as Indians(no aryans or dravidians) and work for this country🙏
May be Indians but still we have our own identity that is Dravidian. We r proud of it ok.
Bengal is a 4,000 year old civilization that thrived between the banks of Ganges to Brahmaputra and sustained itself with the riches of Gangetic Delta.
Some so called leftists and separatists have been trying to shape the idea that we Bengali people are not part of Vedic society... But in vain.
Jay shree Krishna 🙏
#AskAbhijit What is origin behind the Assamese and Bengali conflicts in assam? I'm a bengali from assam origin living in mumbai currently unaware of the history and early origins of this conflict.
British relocated many Bengalis in Assam for tea cultivation
Conflict due that many illegally migrated to Assam from Bangladesh?? At least that what I hear from my Assamese friends.
Assamese who are east asian looking they are actually from east asia like thailand, khemer, vietnam origin. They established kingdom there and thus mix with bengali people. It happens as the bengal and kalinga kingdom was actually dominanting culturally and economically to SE asian region and tibet. So people from both the sides have no problem to have kings from either side , as both having same cultural and religious values. Many bengali and kalinga and even southern traders sattles in SE asia by marrying a princess in these region and their ofsprings sometimes become king in mainlabd kingdoms. So these Assamese bengali conflict is relatively new than the deep history we share.
@@goognoon523There was no bengali in assam before 1826. The culture present there was kamrupi culture and people following it are called kamrupi people. Kamrupi people may belong to brahmins ,kshtriyas like baro bhuyans,koch who have east asian facial features and local tribals like bodo,kachari etc. kamrupi people followed shakta hinduism and MAA kamakhya was their chief deity.
Before people of kamrupa kingdom sanskrit, later magadhi prakit became a prominent language in whole eastern india(Vihar,bengal,kalinga,kamrupa). After magadhi prakit kamrupi people adopted kamrupi prakit and even today kamrupi script is used by assamese people.
@@goognoon523 ahoms came from yunnan province of China.
Thanks for bringing up the topic of chandraketugarh,dear sir. Chandraketugarh is near my maternal grandparents village,which is Berachampa. My grandad's elder brother, Mr. Dilip Kumar Maity was an archaeologist. He excavated various sites in Chandraketugarh,and found various artifacts like pottery,sculptors,etc. I am extremely proud to be related to such a person.
And also thank you sir for making such wonderful videos on various topics. It's time India learn about it's ancient history which has just been left in denial and ignorance for decades.
Hey Is nath a Bengali surname?
If therewqs no aryan or dravidian, then why do the dravian people speak language that are totally different from the northern languages???
Indo aryan languages i.e. hindi urdu bengali punjabi guajarati assamese have soo much common and they are similar in a way with ancient sanskrit and persian
While the Dravidian languages are totally different and belong to a different language family altogether...
If all of india belonged from the same tribe, then tamil telugu etc. Would havs been a part of indo aryan languages...
A large region wouldn't start speaking a different languages unless the new language is forces upon them by the ruler.
I would request you to kindly explain me on this, thanks
Long Story can i explain ?
@@abhishek2026 yes please
@@asfaquekhalid Abhijit ji has answered in 2 videos
th-cam.com/video/mQ-XNpxQ4XA/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/LMWzV5cavnU/w-d-xo.html
@@asfaquekhalid U people Are Adivasi 😂, North indian upper cast are pure Ary an persian
@@asfaquekhalid we ahom should revive tai language
There are evidence of human living 42000 years ago in Ayodhya Hills, Purulia which is the western district of West Bengal. I am a resident here. 😅
Proud to be a Bangladeshi 🇧🇩 Bengali.
I am a bengali and i don't know i am dravidian or aryan but surely i am an Indian.
Bengali history was way befor india
Bengal is father of whole India
There's a bit genetic differences between Indo Aryan and dravidians. If u say no difference, u r denying genetics. Bangali people, inclusing bangladeshi people, are mixture of northern and southern Indians. Bangladeshi people has also have admixture with South East asians, but in very small scale. Majority is northern and southern Indians mixture.
Thank you Abhijit Sir for this video 🙂
Bengalis are very intelligent,talented and brave people....
Hi Abhijit, although you started with the origin of Bengalis, and later distracted to origin of Dravidian and Aryan. You had few wrong info, let me correct. The origin of Bengalis actually more than 5000 years old (even older). You can find the name "pundravardhana" in Mahavarata, which belongs to Bengalis. However, Bengalis are not ethnically pure Aryan, but due to the geographic location a mix of Aryan and Austric (native) nation. Thanks.
Thanks. This is good info!
Correct..
He did not distract to the origin of Dravidian...etc. The questioner asked him about that. Watch the video with more concentration before commenting insensibly. There were two questions: the first was on origin & the next was about Aryan-Dravidian. So he answered the first one first, before 'distracting' (according to you) to the second part. And there is no 'wrong' info also. He just did not get into more detailing that you perhaps expected. He has a time limit for every question and cannot go ahead detailing to each and everyone's expectations. For that he or she needs further self-research. This is just a Q/A kind of blog session. Understand that!😠