Pakistan and Religious Fanatics | Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy & Dr. Ayesha Siddiqa |
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ส.ค. 2024
- Dr. Ayesha Siddiqa responds to questions from Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy: Does Pakistan still need to nurture jihadists for use in Kashmir and Afghanistan? Why has the state continued to support Khadim Husain Rizvi's TLP? Can it afford to keep its pledge to the TLP? How do we get rid of the problem?
#PervezHoodbhoy #AyeshaSiddiqa #ReligiousFanatics
Show of pure intellect!!!
Sir should make a video on Islamic science also which talks about creation of earth, big Bang theory and relativity theory
@@awanishkumar958
Big bang:talwar of madina
Creation of universe: allah bt allah without allah no alu
Only alu ali allah.
Relativity:wahabi vs deobandi. Vs shia salafi
Two great people really , I wish there were more people like them trying to spread rationality to counter the ill-effects of fanaticism . Desperately needed not only in Pakistan but in India as well .
This is how you educate your nation. Thank you sir ❤️
Both highly intelligent true Pakistanis. Allah bless u
Extending our respect and salaam to these two great personalities of Pakistan who always speak about betterment of Pakistan apart from fanatic islam ideology, they always want that people go towards learning of science and technology and other subjects
to develop Pakistan. SHEKHAR NEW DELHI (INDIA )
Please share the names of some indian intellectuals who are fighting the extremism and bigotry in India. Because a few that I have come across disappoint me greatly
Yeh dono Hindustani Hain. Hinduon ki ghulami hi karenge.
Free thinkers who talk their mind without any inhibition
ملک کی بقا ء کےلیے مزہب کو سیاست سے الگ کر نا لازمی ھے
@@tahirmehmood9740 siasat HAZRAT MUHAMMAD (PBUH) AND HAZRAT ALI(AS) nae bhi ki or siasat boori bhi hoti hae or ahi bhi.ap ki yae bat sahe nahi hae kay mazhab ko siasat sae alay kary.
Very insightful and realistic discourse Mr. Parvez Hoodbhoi.
One of the Most Brilliant Jewel of Pakistan and they are blessed to have him in their midst, but alas, Sad to say that Pakistan has Never Listened to his Advice!
Religion is most unscientific thought ever invented
We did not need religious belief in 21 century quantum scientific age.
Both of these are Hindus. They are working for Narendar Modi.
Brave lady
And great man
Simply brilliant. No shouting, no non sense. Just civilised conversation..
Because they are well educated and graduated from good society 😇😇
Thank you Sir and Ma'am for educating us. Much 💕
ماشااللہ ۔۔۔فزکس کے پروفیسر ملک اور معاشرے کی مذہبی ضروریات، اعتقادات اور مجوزہ مذہبی اقدامات پر لیکچر دے رہے ہیں اور بغیر کسی شرمندگی کے خود کو حرف آخر ظاہر کررہے ہین۔۔ خدا ان کی عقل اور ملک کی قسمت پر رحم فرمائے
Muashre Ki zarooriat Ka theka to ulma ne liya hua ha na
@@hasnainkhan7338 بالکل نہین۔۔۔ اگر کوئی مذہبی عالم ۔۔نئے فیشن کی ضرورت ۔۔پر لیکچر دے گا تو عجیب ہی لگے گا۔۔۔ بالکل جس طرح امریکی آشیرباد یافتہ یہ طبقہ مذہبی معاملات میں ٹانگ اڑاتا برا لگ رہا ہے۔۔ باقی یہ تو درست ہے کہ آپ، ماشااللہ ۔۔اسی گروہ سے معلوم پڑتے ہیں جو خود کو عقل کل اور دوسروں کو احمق ہی سمجھتے ہیں ۔۔ذرا امریکہ میں کوئی پادری صاحب کیپٹل ازم کے نقصانات پر لیکچر دے کر تو دکھائیں ۔۔۔ ہی ہی ہی
Voice of reason from a great mind!
Absolutely. Unfortunately, Pakistan has everything, except reason and critical-thinking.
19 minutes of awesomeness
All pakistani should listen hood bhai i request
Very interesting topic ..... Factual information Sir we need more debate like this one
He is RAW agent
Don't follow him he want to end islam in pakistan.
There’s not a single religion that can survive the two words, ‘prove it’
"I do not feel obliged to believe that the same God who has endowed us with sense, reason, and intellect has intended us to forgo their use."
- Galileo Galilei
Dawkins is winking at us from behind him.
Galileo challenged the entire world and emerged victorious, what a legend
Please listen to Dr Zakir Niak’s videos on this subject. In shaa Allah will be get the answers.
@@islamicthinkingtv9985 Sure, in the mean time you should read a whole bunch of books on a whole range of subjects. Books that do not necessarily support your preconceived notions. To think that all the humans on planet earth need to submit to your favorite book is horribly egoistical and downright silly. You believe what you want and live your life as you see fit. You have my condolences for having chosen one of the regressive paths that makes people judgemental and petty. I'll put a bullet in my head before I accept Sharia.
@@OINKARL Allah says it is for you to give the message and it is for Allah to call them to account. I can only give the message and it is up to Allah to call you to account.
Rightful analysis.
That meriam's engineering dynamics book in background 👍
Sir, your true, unbiased, most logical, convincing opinion is highly acceptable like Hussain Hakkani. Full Salute to you. Thank God India education system was not creating such demon, evil reiligious blind fanatic idiological due to Nehru's, Patel's vision
Finest of the few intellectuals from Pakistan! Hope Pakistani establishment listens and understands that only education in sciences, etc can help with the country’s progress not terror factories.
imagine if everyone in pakistan got the same education as the people in the video
You are a good man 👍👍🙏
sir Love from India
plz do 1 video on your fav books on physics politics or what were you like or
top 10 fav books or
Must read for not only pak but for your children in India bangladesh or roots connected to south asia
IF IF Kashmir IF IF Islam is taken out conversation
What will Pakistanis - establishment government & people do?
Allah’s thekedars will of course go out of business
You are amazing God bless Love from Denmark
He doesn't believe in God.
Yeh RAW agent hai
Great sir g
Thanx sir aap ny bhi apna channel Bana lya coz Pakistani youth ko normal track per lanay ky lye aap jesy logo ki shaded zarorat hy..
thank you sir
Respect Sir respect Madam
By the way ..what about Corona Vaccine???
Who created knows cure..
Wuhan virus xijingping pingpong Chinchoo majoos majoos
Very fair anslysis carried out in this talk. Pakistan can not progress till to stop nourishing these groups.Already Suffered most during Afghan war.And after shocks of this mistake still are felt.
Word "Jihad" means "Struggle" or "Competition". If people of Pakistan are leaded towards
Education jihad, Science jihad, Technology jihad, since they have a lot of zeal towards jihad, so this type of jihad can be much beneficial.
It's struggle for religion , you can't just throw the context behind it , and it's the reason why it's almost never have been used for the things you mentioned
It's true but above said all it needs brains, 😇😇
These are 2 worthy Pakistani intellectual giants - yet unable to call out the elephant in the room. Cowardice or lack of introspection ?!
As they say you can put lipstick on a pig but it will always remain a pig..
In Pakistan Turkey Afghanistan Saudia Arabia Egypt , these type of liberal people won't survive .
Remember the Punjab governor in Pakistan??
Remember that the plague of Islam has spread deeply into the bones of Pakistanis. It is not easy for anybody to wake up a whole nation of people that are in a deep sleep. It will take a lot of time and slow effort to slowly free the minds of Pakistani people. it is upsetting because we have so much talent and fantastic people in this country but unfortunately we still are living in the 7th century.
I really respect you due to your opinion.
Dear Sir. I want to state this - If there is a democratic govt in Pak and the Army functions under it, as is the case in any normal country we can solve everything between In India and Pakistan. Pakistan Army is to be completely dissociated between what happens between the two countries. Now Pakistan Army has a vested interest in keeping the hostility alive so that it maintains its supremacy in the country. The hold of Pak Army on the country is entirely based on projecting India as an ever existent threat!
Problem of Pakistan is Quran which says Gajwa E Hind. Army is only using this. Unless they come out of Islam it's gonna stay same
It is interesting history - A *Cabinet Mission came to India in 1946 in order to discuss the transfer of power from the British government to the Indian political leadership, with the aim of preserving India's unity* and granting its independence - it was a *joint India proposal* of Britain (although before 1947, India was already divided into multiple independent princely states as each state had its own currency, military and independent governmental system) joint India proposal that was offered when Nehru on behalf of Gandhi Jee rejected the prime offer proposed to Indian leadership. *That Mr. Jinnah accepted with exception to ensure minority rights in specific state* As Nehru jee wanted to eat the whole pie, Cabinet Mission prime offer was rejected along with the lame excuses. -- Question is who refused that prime offer of Joint India initially that Britain offered ??
-- Picture is very much clear now
Nehru ruled India just like a communist dictator for 17 years straight
1- Pakistan still part of Communist China and ready to give access to them so called "warm water" theory
2- The fact is till 1947 India was not "Joint India" in true sense -- already divided into multiple independent princely states -- it was not one nation before 1947
3- btw, *now socialist or leftist India is in the hands of Capitalist, not Socialist - Ready to fight on behalf of Capitalist and Imperialist US and UK against the interest of Communist Russia and Communist China*
@@yinyang.333 K then make sure we will fight for thousands of years but will never come out of islam.Islam is our bloodline.
Great scholar Dr Aisha true Pakistani in a result of a book she wrote she can live in UK
Dr Pervaiz is really a gem 💎
It is interesting history - A *Cabinet Mission came to India in 1946 in order to discuss the transfer of power from the British government to the Indian political leadership, with the aim of preserving India's unity* and granting its independence - it was a *joint India proposal* of Britain (although before 1947, India was already divided into multiple independent princely states as each state had its own currency, military and independent governmental system) joint India proposal that was offered when Nehru on behalf of Gandhi Jee rejected the prime offer proposed to Indian leadership. *That Mr. Jinnah accepted with exception to ensure minority rights in specific state* As Nehru jee wanted to eat the whole pie, Cabinet Mission prime offer was rejected along with the lame excuses. -- Question is who refused that prime offer of Joint India initially that Britain offered ??
-- Picture is very much clear now
Nehru ruled India just like a communist dictator for 17 years straight
1- Pakistan still part of Communist China and ready to give access to them so called "warm water" theory
2- The fact is till 1947 India was not "Joint India" in true sense -- already divided into multiple independent princely states -- it was not one nation before 1947
3- btw, *now socialist or leftist India of Nehru is in the hands of Capitalist, not Socialist - Ready to fight on behalf of Capitalist and Imperialist US and UK against the interest of Socialist Communist Russia and China*
Not a single update in all these months? I have donated a like to you. Lots of love.
Great Content, Keep Going Sir.
Well done 👍
Brilliant
Always pleasing to watch or listen you sir ..... and tarek fatah ji .....you both have depth of knowledge
Pakistan was established on the basis of religion. How can pakistan survive without religion ?
Now that india has given itself a religious makeover it becomes imperative that paksitan needs to revamp its rhetoric!
Especially when both countries are unable to tackle the real issues such as poverty, over population, human development, education, health etc, one needs to distract them with either war, religion or some other form of opiate.
Religion is a best weapon for Army Establishment aganist political parties .
100% true
It vary.
th-cam.com/video/eWPoQDOTAXI/w-d-xo.html
Too much religion = failed and backwards country like Pakistan 🤣
@@RyuRaza The main reason for Pakistan's backwardness is that Pakistan for the last 40 years, since 1979 is deeply involved in the Afghan war. Afghan issue will be settled soon and thereafter the real progress and economic prosperity of Pakistan will start. India is ruled by a fanatic, bigot, fundamentalist party. In Pakistan, there are 97 % Muslims whereas in India there are less than 60 % Hindus. In India there are 750 million Hindus and there are almost 650 million minorities such as Muslims, Dalits, Sikhs, Christians, Buddhists, etc., etc.
Pakistan is a different sort of Islamic country whereas India is a mixture of different religions where Hindus are in simple majority.
nice..
Two intellectuals, true analysis.
Religion continue to be part of politics in Pakistan since 1947. A legacy of Jinna politics with hindus. But it will not allow Pakistan to grow as progressive society. Respect from India
Really? U say religion n prosperity can't go hand in hand, wat do u say abt Israel?
@@EhsanAfridi religion is fine, but religious extremism and bigotry is not.
What about rss people .they both pakistani they talk about pakistan or pakistani people u indian look your india don't put nose pakistani matter
@@EhsanAfridi Israel is quite secular type country they have hajabi army women in their force
@@faisalg1630 What about RSS? You guys love raising this topic everywhere anyone talks of religious fanaticism in Pakistan. How many terrorists have RSS raised and how many terrorists have RSS pushed into Pakistan to conduct a 26/11 type attack?
مذہب کو اپنی سیاسی، startagic مقاصد کے لیے استعمال کرنا سنگین جرم ہے،
💯 Agreed
Please Ayesha say something about RSS India.
Rss never bombs restaurant or trains or buses stops or force convert teenagers from minority communities.
RSS do ghar wapsi wil you willing to do 😎
Islamists from Pakistan are also spreading the same Pakistani Fundamentalist Atmosphere in UK, Canada and USA and other European countries and the entire English speaking world.
The deep South and religious fanatics.
Dr Hoodbhoy can tiptoe around the main issue which remains that Sub continental Islam is extremely rigid & backward, even Saudi Arabia is reforming but both Pakistani & Indian Muslims don't want to & will remain backward till they don't accept reform - also the hatred they have for all non muslims is the most extreme again in Sub continental Muslims - while they'll happily clean toilets for Arabs - sickening.
On Ex-muslims channels seen number of Mullahs and Moulwis also getting mulhid and leaving Islam.
One may abuse Allah but not the Prophet, else face Blasphemy - Sar tan se juda.
Sir you are soooooooo true man in the dark society
Great dr: !
Please fix the Grammer of urdu text in your display pic. "Hain" Nahi ..."Hai"
How many groups??? Search on gravitas while it is censored here.
dr sahab ap jesa roshan khyal banda es mulk ka primnister hona chahiye
Parvez bhai is khitteme teesare number ka bada Danish musalman hai :
1 . Maulana Abdul Kalam Azad
2. Abul Kalam former indian scientist and president
3. Parvez Hoodhbhai
You got the names wrong. Maulana was “Abul” and former president was “Abdul”
@@mychannel694
Yes, thanks, I stand corrected
Kuch points pe arguments zyada strong nhi lage. Torhi irrelevancy b feel hui kuch points pe, baqi teek hai
Yeh RAW agent hai
Great
It's a shame he is even questioning this. There is no Islam without Jihad.
There was need for external defence .
Now, within country , a move is under Democratic norms.
When u say, it's only Democratic norms, u see it is by the people for the people.
A country which is always on defensive mode, u don't see aggression oriented nations n their designs.
Plz stand by ur country.
Every set of people must strive to groom its own field .
.
Bhai yeh RAW agent hai
@@johnclark3108 Dono ke dono Hindu Hain.
Why she much praise naseerullah babar and banazir the Killers couple of Karachi urdu speaking people, and she says she is from Karachi !
Sir ❤️❣️
Kuch samjh nahin aata ab. K kon establishment k hisa hai aur wo kyun sb logo ko kaisa allow kr deta in k against kuch kehna k liye
Great show
Love you sir ma apka bhot bara fan hu♥️
سر آپ بہت کڑوا سچ بولتے ہیں ❤️
مجھے اندیشہ ہورہا ہے کہ آپ کو کوئی مار نہ دے 😢
Internationaly protected
How internationally protected?
Ol
@@iftikharhaq8147 Superb. You are a genius.
@@iftikharhaq8147 th-cam.com/video/eWPoQDOTAXI/w-d-xo.html
بہت عمدہ سر
Mirzay jhanumi pe lanat Latreen group haaaa haaa haaa
Enjoy fanatics
ब्राह्मण से और ब्राह्मणवाद से,
संसार का,
कोई भी मनुष्य,
कभी नहीं जीत सकता,
जब तक वह ब्रह्मज्ञानी न हो।
वामन,
तुमने तो ब्रह्मज्ञान का नाम भी सुना हो तो,
हमें अचरज होगा।
मैं ब्रह्मज्ञानी हूँ।
मैं राजा हूँ।
मैं गीता से ब्रह्मज्ञान को पा चुका हूँ।
मैं यहाँ से युग परिवर्तन कर दूँगा।
मैं यहाँ का राजा हूँ।
मैं पृथ्वी पर स्वर्ग बनाऊंगा।
मैं दरिद्रता का नाश करवाऊंगा।
तुम देख लेना।
पर पहले
गीता को
ब्राह्मणों से मुक्त कराऊँगा,
तुम देख लेना।
अरविन्द जैन
गीता सफ़ाई अभियान
06/03/2021
khadim hussain nay aik video may gaalion ko quran o hadith se sabit kia hay
پاکستان کی سیاست میں بگاڑ کے ذمہ دار بھی جنرل ضیاء حمید گل مشرف جیسے لوگ ھیں جنہوں نے نوز شریف الطاف حسین جیسےکرپٹ لوگ سیاست میں لاےاور ملک کا بیڑا غرق کر دیا۔ سیاست میں پیسہ ضیاء نے اس وقت کے ممبران کوترقیاتی کاموں کے نام پر کروڑوں بانٹے۔
Ahl e sunna wahabi (ahl e hadith dewbandi) and shia 3 hi maslak hn dunya aur pakistan mein.....bibi bht lakh jinaza tha
The main reason for Pakistan's backwardness is that Pakistan for the last 40 years, since 1979 is deeply involved in the Afghan war. Afghan issue will be settled soon and thereafter the real progress and economic prosperity of Pakistan will start. India is ruled by a fanatic, bigot, fundamentalist party. In Pakistan, there are 97 % Muslims whereas in India there are less than 60 % Hindus. In India there are 750 million Hindus and there are almost 650 million minorities such as Muslims, Dalits, Sikhs, Christians, Buddhists, etc., etc.
Pakistan is a different sort of Islamic country whereas India is a mixture of different religions where Hindus are in simple majority.
What the hell are u smoking these days?😂India's 78% population is hindu. Your statics are home cooked not real . But yeah the current regime is bigot .
@@shivanginirai5087: Oh! I am sorry that I disturbed you. In fact, 60 % of Hindus means 300 million Indian Dalits are not included or added in Hindus. Dalits I think are scheduled caste and minorities. If you will add Dalits in Hindus they will become 78 %. My statistics are not home-cooked, my stats are real.
@@aleempervaiz8789 Well Dalits are Hindus only. They identify themselves among Hindus .The schedule caste category signify that they are a marganalised community. Being from different caste does not mean that they are Hindu.
@@shivanginirai5087 If you are happy I am happy. It makes no difference. If Dalits are Hindu, good, treat them equally and fairly. They are the most miserable people in India. do work for their betterment. Be happy.
@@aleempervaiz8789 Well it seems they are suffering from Stockholm syndrome cause in 2019 34% of Dalits voted for bjp which is still a minority but still if 1/3 of a community is going to vote for a casteist party then it is difficult to work them.
Good
Wow, Two giants of Pakistan. Regards from India. I think I have idea but not sure, would love to hear from you guys why and how Pak Army has become such a parasite.
I respect you for positive views but I do not understand you lot of personalities who speak anti India and who have destorted Indian history. You always speak against our PM due to wrong influence of these people. He never speak against muslims.I am not RSS member but please read their ideology of Carefully they want unity of India irrespective of religion. Hindu is not religion it is way of life and culture of India. It has been distorted by congress due to vote bank politics and appeasement of muslims and made them backward race of India. Please check facts before speaking and listening to people who work for anti India. I am not BJP and RSS member. Please note hindu muslim riots are minimum since last 6 years.
Thank god I did not went to King's Collage London
Jahan Imran Riaz ko millions aur Pervez bhai ko Chand log dekhen...level Kya Hoga unka
Abe ye loog accupied kashmir par baat kren tu sare recpect kilo 2 kilo sare nikal jae jhhhhhh
ھاھاھاھا ۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔تمہاری جلن بتا رہی ہے جس طرح تم ملینز کی تعداد کو صرف ایک لاکھ تک محدود کر رہے ہو۔
Brailvy jahil hotay hn badtmeezi krtay hn isliyay syasat mn achi tarah istemal ho sktay hn..Verna kashmir afghanistan mn mushrik kuch kr nhn sktay..mulk mn gali mohalay mn danga fasad kr laitay hn.en ko Jo log dheel de rhay hn un ja maqsad Democratic government ko under pressure rakhna hota hai..
C-295 is black law.
Mai ne ayesha siddiqa ko kabhi pak fouj ya imran khan ke haq mai baat karte hue nehi dekha.... Aur ye guftugu title ke hisaab se nehi ho rha
Title is about explaining the reason, it never said the reson is justified, moral or likable.
Why would they, they're opposed to them.
"Mene kabhi Imran Khan ko Nawaz Sharif ke haq me baat karte nahi dekha." 😂😂
Who are you? You are a physicist. Why do you think you are expert in everything. There are two extremist, people like TLP are extreme right then people like you are extremely left. We don’t want either of you. We need a balance. We don’t opinions from people like Ayesha Siddiqa whose single point agenda is to malign Pakistan army.
Excellent discussion!
🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
Excellent🙏
Love from India ❤️❤️❤️❤️
zaroorat ko choro aap yeh batao aapki awaaz kyun kaanp rahi hai
When there were no Hindus and Christians to persecute, then came number of Ahmediyas and now Shiyas.
There after conflicts among Devbandi, Barelvi, Wahabi, Ahle Quran, and so on are expected to take place in Pakistan. No wonder.
kadim hussian rizvi ka janaza dhak k ehki patiii pari ha subki
ھد ھد کو تکلیف ہئے کہ اتنا عرصہ نوجوانوں کو گمراہ کیا ورغلایا مگر پھر بھی مولانا کے جنازے پر اتنے لوگ
جنازے یا آخری رسومات پر زیادہ لوگوں کے آنے کا مطلب یہ ہرگز نہیں ہوتا کہ عوام ان کے بیانیہ کی تائید کرتے ہیں. اگر کسی کو یہ لگتا ہے کہ رضوی کے جنازے میں زیادہ لوگوں کی شرکت ان کے بیانیہ کی فتح تھی تو پھر بال ٹھاکرے کی آخری رسومات میں بہت سے لوگوں کی شرکت کا مطلب کیا تھا پھر؟
Sir kuch log kehte hain APS attack main kuch galat nhi tha. kyun kay humari army talibanoon k gharon pe hawai hamlay karti thi tou taliban k bache bhi tou marte hongay islye unho ne qasaas kiya tha.tou mujhe ye maloom karna tha kya waqai talibanon k bache bhi maray the kya?
Really it is a sensible question ✊😇😇
@
Azhar Shaikh
listen to retired general Sháhid Aziz Sáheb on this topic (he also wrote a book, something like "
Yeh Khámoshi Kahán Tâk"); âb tâk General Sáheb lá patá hê: well, disappearance acts have happened for whistleblowers in the past ...
Abb ubh uk ash
Ahmadion kay saath kuch bhee karo wo sab sahee hai lakin yahee kaam Franace musalmanoon kay saath karay to wo theek nahee hai.
Tum bi tho france me boom pharty hoo
The seeds of this are sown in the vicious communal rhetoric that went into the Pakistan movement from 1940 to 1947. It’s impossible to dismount the tiger - the arc of history was inevitable.
Khadam razvi call house wife's Chand Khas only ziada Nahin hia MS they' don't fight with weapon 🔪🔫. Tung zaban hi hathaya hutay his becare full reason different follow bland open opinion position for everyone