One correction is needed. In India states have been created on the basis of language.Each state is required to practice and preserve it's language and culture. However, in universities all lectures and books of science, medicines, engineering, mathematics and social science are in english only. However, elementary education is imparted in mother young with english.
Even that is changing now. You can now do engineering, medicine and other higher education in regional languages once the New Education Policy is implemented.
Nowadays scenario is changing in my lovely country, India. My department is run by 12 regular faculties and all are graduated from foreign universities like Berkley, Yale, MIT, Linköping, Uppasala, ICGEB, Max Planck etc and this is not a case of my department and my University but also in most of the Indian Universities and research institutions. I proud to be Indian.
Hoodbhoy is very rational man and always strive for taking people towards science and to develop scientific temper. Inspite of living amongst fanatics it quite a job.My Best Wishes for your contribution.
Goes to show the IT , Islamic Terror still persists and religious fanaticism. Its a drawback for the Islamists. Pakistan will never go forward because religious fanaticism is still practicied and supportive with jihad and religion. A developed and intellectual society cannot function without science and technology. That is the weak ness of Pakistan and that the Pakistanis don't realize, that with their terror and fanaticism no country will trade with them, mix with them, develop with them, science is unknown and is a taboo. Allah is everything.
In India English language rules. English and Hindi are two official language and all documents are produced in English and Hindi by the Government of India. We in India have seventeen official languages at provincial level, but English remains the language that rules the roost. In Hindi speaking belt of North India all private schools provide instructions in English language so that Indians may compete at international university.
Hindi is not considered as necessary in parts of India, nor is it accepted by all of India as a national language. There are parts of India where English and the local language are sufficient.
@Srinu is hoodbhoy not loyal to his country ?? And by the way congress made Abdul Kalam president not BJP , if Kalam was alive he would never become president
Why is everyone comparing India and Pakistan. Only then Pakistan cease to have an inferior complex. compare Pakistan with Egypt, Iraq or even Iran. Compare it with muslim countries. Not with non islamic countries. Then you will see the pride returning to Pakistanis.
Indian seculars get impressed because he is talking about science, he is just a typical pakistani with science background. But mentality remains the same
A Pakistani mindset negativity can't be treated as no medicine effects on it. Even education is useless for eradication of negative mindset as it proves from this so-called literal person conversation.
I respect you for your secular views.But Modi is democratically elected prime minister and has done many good things.For the rise of hindutwa, many muslims with in India and the discrimination of minorities in most of the Muslim majority nations is the main reason
Stop being apologetic about anything.. Tell me one right which you as a Hindu has and not any minority has specifically muslim.. I can chart out no of special rights for minorities which is not for majority..
@@ShubhamSharma-tf4kr u really think ur mindset even works in the South dude? No wonder the drastic difference of standard of living b/2 North and Rest of India
What does muslim majority countries have to do with India and bhagwa aatank....... mostly Hindus are running to muslim and Christian majority countries...and living their...no one is coming to India or Pak......when these hindutva aatanki l! nching minorities in in daily basis ...normal people are getting k!lled by them what do those vegetables vendor .a poor shopkeeper and many people who r getting l! nched by these hindutvadis what do they have to do with foreign nations.
Hoodbhoy seems to be an intellect but still uses the media's view of Modi. Modi is actually the most progressive leader in India - he supports and promotes science and the latest technologies.
He as an average Pakistani is delusional. Science and Technology has progressed well under Modi. Hinduism has scientific temper and asking questions is fundamental aspect of Hinduism, be it Geeta or Vedas.
@@zaina5569 Truth is not what you think it is. Truth is based on facts. Please check last 6 to 7 years of scientific progress of India under BJP government.
@@newworld2086 when you come to a channel to listen to Pakistanis criticizing their state and you appreciate it, why don’t you also accept the criticism for yourself. Otherwise please don’t listen to the professor and support killing of Muslims, best of luck
I will appreciate true criticism. e.g. I criticise government for still failing to stop brain drain. The Modi goverment has increased the stipend and salaries of scientists but it is still very less when compared to what they will get outside. Also the spending on R&D needs to increase more and colleges need to be given even more R&D budget. These are the real problems which Modi can move very fast to resolve but he is still going slowly. We need to go big bang to stop the brain drain which never happened during previous government and also during this government it is happening but very slowly.
@@newworld2086 are you actually saying Jodi does not support oppression of Muslims???if you want to call yourself a true secular democracy please look at the United States…anyways I don’t care not interested about Indian Muslims
It is delightful to listen to Parvez saheb. His criticism of India are equally interesting. I think India should welcome such a brilliant man and even in his criticism, we have so many things to learn. Thanks for uploading the video.
Unfortunately 90% of the world's intelligentsia operates on perception..... not on facts. The problem is the negative perception about Modi around the world by the leftist does impacts his image
Hindi!!!! MIT professor Munas Kafatos is using Sanskrit to explain natural phenomena's in class of Physics. Tesla used to do the same. MIT enrolment of foreign students: Year 2020 & 2021 India 311 Iran 35, Pakistan 24, Bangladesh 16 & American with Indian origin? 14 times more than any other religious or ethenic groups.
NASA has more than 50,000 work force,space x was started by mere 8 men and came up with the most efficient of rocket system design ever...numbers just represent bare magnitude, what makes the difference is the ‘genius’ and it will always be an anomaly on every statistics scale....the figure you show represent something good but it would never be revolutionary...coz revolution in scientific world is most of the time come out of nowhere...scientific revolution never drives by corporate culture it is driven by war...ciao
Ambanis have earned all the money through their talent. So criticising their spending is wrong. Same ambanis give work to more than 5 lakh people india and outside. So being rich is not considered criminal in India
In Nepal Science subjects are taught almost 90 % in English , too. I used to help two languages irregularly Pak. colleague, but uninterested. Iranian are also smart in their study too, as they are good in maths and Science. Pak. still teaching wrong info , hate against other belief , from children’s schools text books , why ? Very sadful. Superior at home but inferior abroad : complexity in superior feeling or inferior, probably . Success and thank you ji.
If any Muslim teaches hatred against any beliefs then he is not following the tenets of Islam. Islam very clearly states that, 'let there be no compulsion in religion, to you your religion and to me mine'. By the way, one must also accept that there is deliberate effort by vested interest to project Muslims in negative way. Godi Media is a great example of it.
@@trulyhumane1591 Did he talk about India or Muslims in any way here. Please refrain from typing stupid comments like this. We have noted what I$lam has done to every region of the world it went. In short, Baap ko maat sikha.
Pakistan is at par with Afghanistan or Srilanka. Comparing Pakistan and India is not reasonable. Even Bangladesh has progressed much better economically.
As An Indian, I Take Positive Things From Hoodbhouy. I’m Indebted To Him For The Knowledge, I Learnt From Him. There Are Certain Things Which Conflicts. But, That’s Ok. We Can Ignore Certain Things & Move On. Modi Has Been Demonised By Many Leftist Media. But, India’s Success Under Modi Leadership Cannot Be Neglected. Though, There Are Some Problems, But It’s Exaggerated To Present Negative Image Of Modi.
Actually in practical we should condemn him for uttering negativity about India and inspite of his known status his weakness has same place as his gains.
He is a curse to India, iits are so underfunded that they were thinking of Discontinuing stipends of mtech, joblessness, and the small businesses owners are under debt and are collapsing
I'm not a Modi fan/bhakt etc but Hoodbhoy's bias against Modi has started taking him towards some bizarre claims. By and large, no technology/science institute has changed its medium of instruction to Hindi or any other regional language. It continues to be English. There, he made a mistake.
Completely wrong even in modi era we Indians use English more in government sector or any other sector. Don't spread falsehood. Yes it is true they try to make Hindi as dominant language but fail every time. ❤️
Yes true... question is if hindi guy learn to talk or study any non hindi language. Hindi can't b a national language alone. We should respect all indian languages as unity in diversity.
Iran is a unique Muslim country where sciences and mathematics are flourishing. Shah of Iran was autocratic dictator, but one good thing was that he encouraged Western education. Students at all levels were give scholarships to study abroad including India, USA, and European countries. Today Iran is harvesting that knowledge for its progress.
Modi s india progress more india , open 3000 million bank account for poor. Hope new education policy 2020 , erdict poverty of india . It's always pleasure to listening parvez hoodboy 🙏🇮🇳
@@mukeshsingla2459 300 million , 30 crore - jan dhan yojna and then direct banefit trasnfer - wo kya hai na india main ham (lakh ,crore ese ginte hai na ki million , billion ese - to wo problem aa jati hai )
People who had been brought up through Abrahamic relegion will never understand what is Hinduism and Sanatan Dharma.They will always see Hinduism from the lens of their monoethism thoughts. Secularism as practiced in Western world is not the right thought process compared to "Sarva Dharma Samavaw " as practiced in India. Unlike other relegion an extreme practitioner of Sanatan Dharma will be always be the most peaceful and inclusive human being..That is why no Hindu has invaded any country to destroy its culture or wealth, but to include anybody in his life and his culture.. The Parsi and Jews had found a home in india while they were persecuted elsewhere, needless to speak about Raja Dahir of Sindh.
2:24 Dr. sahab never expected this from you, thats literally a blatant lie. Our schools/unis the curriculum is in English and then the regional language of the state.
Admirable scholar yet seriously mistaken on Indian education. Except for some avoidable noise on Hindi education is going on as usual. "social scientists". have ideological problems but they are really nowhere as important as natural scientists
Historically in the 9th , 10th Anshu 11th century Muslims contributed richly and In Baghdad there was a library full of books. The scientific thinking started going down with Ottomans time.
His viewpoints on India is pretty uninformed and is that of a "typical Pakistani" variety..makes you wonder how informed his opinion on other matters are
Very common conversation and nothing great in it. Today's generation actually interested in speaking more than understanding the mindset of other person. Why are praising.
This was a great video though I'm not on board with the logic at the end - the link between religious orthodoxy and a pro-corporate, capitalist mindset that increases the wealth gap is not causal as he suggests. Correlated yes, causal no. Just because Modi espouses a pro-Hindu philosophy does not have to necessitate that he'll favor corporates over the less privileged.
Hindi is emphasized only as a link language... Nothing more... And it is an individual choice... Kids can also choose 2nd language to study optionally.
Dr.Hoodbhoy deserves much more than he is given in his country.with all due respect De Sahab you need to know that only in metro cities English is the medium of education. Even in Metro schools run by Governments were primarily taught Hindi/ Urdu medium and English was introduced in seconda school. In states the medium of education in primary school were regional.
SALAM Increasingly, I believe, the voices of Civil Society are voices for change, where change has been overdue. They have been voices of hope for people living in fear. They are voices that can help transform countries of crisis into countries of opportunity. There are too many societies where too many people live in a culture of fear, condemned to a life of poverty. Addressing that fear, and replacing it with hope, will be a major step to the elimination of poverty. And often the call for hope to replace fear will come from the voices of Civil Society.
The basic problem with Pakistan 🇵🇰 is that there are very few educated people. An educated person tries to be an expert at everything. A journalist will be a Chief Minister and a cricket board chairman. A physics professor will masquerade as a Global international strategist and Geopolitical expert.
When a person is an educated one. He can have enough intellect to talk on different aspects of life. So it's nothing a rocket science. Even a chaiwala is running a country, so it can be done.
@@khanzlan1613 even pancharwala bhi hawa bhar sakta tumlog beta kitna bhi pad lo but tumare andar moral values, ethics nahin hain bomb fodna hi banaoge APJ ABDUL KALAM NAHI BAN SAKTE
Idk , he seems to be scared there, He's not opening up. Probably audience mai jo gawar bete hue hai unke kabiliyat k mutabik hi lecture de rahe hai. But overall, a 1/10 rating lecture here.
The idea that Hindi has somehow been promulgated only by Modi is completely ignorant. The policy of Hindi imposition has been practiced for multiple decades. Concepts such as Hindi Pakhwara in government offices across the nation have been practiced for decades.
Modi kuch bhi Hindi ki taraf leke nhi gya hai. Jo jis language m padhta tha usi m padhta hai. Sirf ek do medical College m changes hua hai qki kuch bachhe hindi medium se hein.
Dear Sir Sinister Agenda. 1. You are creating a frame of your own perceptions that had privileged bais. Language governs direction of intelligence and information hence salary. 2. German, French and Japanese and Russain raised marvellous civilization with heighest intelligence base with their own language. We could not liberate ourself from over indulgence with English due to our elite and thus any person not capable to fluently express in english became savage and illiterate hence for ruling elite by defination educated in Maddarass/ School or in Urdu were illiterate. 3. I respect your opinion but I differ on account the your generation made no effort to translate the scientific text in urdu even roman urdu. Masses education can be based on native language plus English , math and computer as fundamental basis of new educational policy plus critical education in religion and philosophy. God bless
Hypocrisy is so called scientist of Pakistan - We should not remember our religion - Hindus can never be radicals like other religions, as we believe in plurality
Hoodbhoy's views about Modi is based on second hand kniwledge from his entitled contacts in India No leader in India has done more than Modi fir piverty alleviation Modi has treated poor people witj dignity and respect
Partition of British India has resulted in the prevention of Islamisation of people of remaining Indian subcontinent. Pakistan is declared as a monocultural society with majority religious rights due to phobia of other religions whereas India is declared as a multicultural society with minority religious rights. Utilising this, large-scale en-masse conversations are taking place into Christianity and now Hindus are reduced to 50 to 60 percent only or less. One day Pakistanis will see India would become a Christian majority country without minority religious rights.
i thought this man to be a wise one but still like an avg pakistani he comes to modi and hindu. Modi is hindu but he never ever said against muslims or sikhs agar koi ek clip nikalke dikhade toh me maan jaunga.
Sorry ,ambani ko kb ayyashi. ..krte dekha sir app ne....and about modi u r wrong....sayd app ne apne yha ke news channel dekhe h sir......unhone science math women important infrastructure ,space ke field me bht dhyan diya h yha ke gaov se jo log h unse puche....we have more medical College in modi government in small time....app ki research bht simit h sir...jisse app mazhab bolte h hmare yha vo nhi h....hmare yha cultural and art h...tha ki purani mandore hamare dharm se jada cultural aur art ko dikhati h .. knowledge ko dikhati h....unhe preserve Krna hmari jimmedari h..aur ye kisi dharm vises ki dharohar nhi h.....bhartiy cultural ka hissa h.....har bhartiy ka itihas h h....
All Pakistani give wrong reference as concerns study in INDIA, all study as you like which Regional language you prefer even. In higher education no such language is compulsory
Mr. Hoodbhoy is very knowledgeable person but I am surprised that he has negative perception of Mr. Modi who has given pride of place for India globally. Modis vision has transformed India into fast developing economy. When Modi is very popular in India and regarded highly internationally it is hard to understand how knowledgeable person like hoodbhoy has negative views about him.
Subscribe Our Channel For More Videos
One correction is needed. In India states have been created on the basis of language.Each state is required to practice and preserve it's language and culture. However, in universities all lectures and books of science, medicines, engineering, mathematics and social science are in english only. However, elementary education is imparted in mother young with english.
So that the smartest went overseas to make the firang rich. Good side remunerations 2022 1 $billion.
Even that is changing now. You can now do engineering, medicine and other higher education in regional languages once the New Education Policy is implemented.
Nowadays scenario is changing in my lovely country, India. My department is run by 12 regular faculties and all are graduated from foreign universities like Berkley, Yale, MIT, Linköping, Uppasala, ICGEB, Max Planck etc and this is not a case of my department and my University but also in most of the Indian Universities and research institutions. I proud to be Indian.
Good
Hoodbhoy is very rational man and always strive for taking people towards science and to develop scientific temper. Inspite of living amongst fanatics it quite a job.My Best Wishes for your contribution.
Dr Pervez Hoodbhoy is mixing science,religion and politic to make his presentation palatable to his audience,that dilutes his message.
Goes to show the IT , Islamic Terror still persists and religious fanaticism. Its a drawback for the Islamists. Pakistan will never go forward because religious fanaticism is still practicied and supportive with jihad and religion. A developed and intellectual society cannot function without science and technology. That is the weak ness of Pakistan and that the Pakistanis don't realize, that with their terror and fanaticism no country will trade with them, mix with them, develop with them, science is unknown and is a taboo. Allah is everything.
In India English language rules. English and Hindi are two official language and all documents are produced in English and Hindi by the Government of India. We in India have seventeen official languages at provincial level, but English remains the language that rules the roost. In Hindi speaking belt of North India all private schools provide instructions in English language so that Indians may compete at international university.
Not just in north India,in the entire India the medium of instruction in the private schools has always been English.
Hindi is not considered as necessary in parts of India, nor is it accepted by all of India as a national language. There are parts of India where English and the local language are sufficient.
And, accordingly, Indians can COMPETE globally in all fields.
Medium of instruction on India continues yo be English in higher education. Local language as an option is bring introducrd
Listening Hudhboy saheb is always insightful even as an Indian. We may proud such people as common heritage and pride.
Thanks sir
Whom. In INDIA U will EQUATE with Him...
@@palimastana Dr APJ Kalam
@Srinu is hoodbhoy not loyal to his country ?? And by the way congress made Abdul Kalam president not BJP , if Kalam was alive he would never become president
Only as long as he doesn't talk about INDIA.
Why is everyone comparing India and Pakistan. Only then Pakistan cease to have an inferior complex. compare Pakistan with Egypt, Iraq or even Iran. Compare it with muslim countries. Not with non islamic countries. Then you will see the pride returning to Pakistanis.
And when he talks about INDIAN MUSLIMS/ KASHMIR, he spews VENOM , without knowing Facts and Figures. He is PART TIME INTELLECTUAL. 😀😀😀😀🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Indian seculars get impressed because he is talking about science, he is just a typical pakistani with science background. But mentality remains the same
A Pakistani mindset negativity can't be treated as no medicine effects on it. Even education is useless for eradication of negative mindset as it proves from this so-called literal person conversation.
@@sunilamarwaha3053 they are all same, we consider them of our own kind but they don't.
@@krunalpanchal6415 Harami aur muslim ek hi coin ke do hisse hai.
Pork after all.
I respect you for your secular views.But Modi is democratically elected prime minister and has done many good things.For the rise of hindutwa, many muslims with in India and the discrimination of minorities in most of the Muslim majority nations is the main reason
Stop being apologetic about anything..
Tell me one right which you as a Hindu has and not any minority has specifically muslim..
I can chart out no of special rights for minorities which is not for majority..
@@ShubhamSharma-tf4kr Are you born an idiot or just pretending to be one?
He is a porki not some saint.
@@ShubhamSharma-tf4kr u really think ur mindset even works in the South dude? No wonder the drastic difference of standard of living b/2 North and Rest of India
What does muslim majority countries have to do with India and bhagwa aatank....... mostly Hindus are running to muslim and Christian majority countries...and living their...no one is coming to India or Pak......when these hindutva aatanki l! nching minorities in in daily basis ...normal people are getting k!lled by them what do those vegetables vendor .a poor shopkeeper and many people who r getting l! nched by these hindutvadis what do they have to do with foreign nations.
Hoodbhoy seems to be an intellect but still uses the media's view of Modi. Modi is actually the most progressive leader in India - he supports and promotes science and the latest technologies.
The most pakistan could come up with an intellectual is this person...a pathetic political observer with hatred fr modi... basically a pakistani
And what about his n his follower,s stance on different issues like religious tolerance ....etc
Hahaha, his followers use religion as ftool ro hatred
That's why he took NET JRF scholarship for PhD researcher's.. and also promoting gau mutr and forcing Hindhi on us
He as an average Pakistani is delusional. Science and Technology has progressed well under Modi. Hinduism has scientific temper and asking questions is fundamental aspect of Hinduism, be it Geeta or Vedas.
Ugh typical modi puppy can’t tolerate the truth.
@@zaina5569 Truth is not what you think it is. Truth is based on facts. Please check last 6 to 7 years of scientific progress of India under BJP government.
@@newworld2086 when you come to a channel to listen to Pakistanis criticizing their state and you appreciate it, why don’t you also accept the criticism for yourself. Otherwise please don’t listen to the professor and support killing of Muslims, best of luck
I will appreciate true criticism. e.g. I criticise government for still failing to stop brain drain. The Modi goverment has increased the stipend and salaries of scientists but it is still very less when compared to what they will get outside. Also the spending on R&D needs to increase more and colleges need to be given even more R&D budget. These are the real problems which Modi can move very fast to resolve but he is still going slowly. We need to go big bang to stop the brain drain which never happened during previous government and also during this government it is happening but very slowly.
@@newworld2086 are you actually saying Jodi does not support oppression of Muslims???if you want to call yourself a true secular democracy please look at the United States…anyways I don’t care not interested about Indian Muslims
It is delightful to listen to Parvez saheb. His criticism of India are equally interesting. I think India should welcome such a brilliant man and even in his criticism, we have so many things to learn. Thanks for uploading the video.
A misquote : After Modi Hindi is made to learn in many states as a language, but not the subject being taught in English which were in English.
Unfortunately 90% of the world's intelligentsia operates on perception..... not on facts. The problem is the negative perception about Modi around the world by the leftist does impacts his image
It's shows you donot know shit..
Read new education policy... idiot
Can you name the state please 😭😭😭.
I also not seeing any difference , all is going as before .
@@KulwantSingh-eo8uz The name of Modi means Pakistanis can say anything they want. :)
In India English is Language of power and knowledge but it is not a Heart language for many people.
Hindi!!!! MIT professor Munas Kafatos is using Sanskrit to explain natural phenomena's in class of Physics. Tesla used to do the same.
MIT enrolment of foreign students: Year 2020 & 2021
India 311
Iran 35, Pakistan 24, Bangladesh 16
& American with Indian origin? 14 times more than any other religious or ethenic groups.
NASA has more than 50,000 work force,space x was started by mere 8 men and came up with the most efficient of rocket system design ever...numbers just represent bare magnitude, what makes the difference is the ‘genius’ and it will always be an anomaly on every statistics scale....the figure you show represent something good but it would never be revolutionary...coz revolution in scientific world is most of the time come out of nowhere...scientific revolution never drives by corporate culture it is driven by war...ciao
Our population is also 10 times of Pakistan, Iran, Bangladesh so it's completely okay
No Chinese! How is it possible?
Hindi is a northern language. We in South don't speak Hindhi
Inbuilt hate for Modi....Modi speaks Gujarati much fluently (than Hindi)
Dr. Hoodbhoy is brilliant man but it seems he gets his knowledge of Indian politics from WhatsApp University.
Ambanis have earned all the money through their talent. So criticising their spending is wrong. Same ambanis give work to more than 5 lakh people india and outside. So being rich is not considered criminal in India
What about Adani, who is only rich because Modi sold the country to him.
In Nepal Science subjects are taught almost 90 % in English , too.
I used to help two languages irregularly Pak. colleague, but uninterested.
Iranian are also smart in their study too, as they are good in maths and Science.
Pak. still teaching wrong info , hate against other belief , from children’s schools text books , why ? Very sadful.
Superior at home but inferior abroad : complexity in superior feeling or inferior, probably .
Success and thank you ji.
If any Muslim teaches hatred against any beliefs then he is not following the tenets of Islam. Islam very clearly states that, 'let there be no compulsion in religion, to you your religion and to me mine'. By the way, one must also accept that there is deliberate effort by vested interest to project Muslims in negative way. Godi Media is a great example of it.
@@trulyhumane1591 Quran clearly teaches hate against non-Muslims.
@@trulyhumane1591 Did he talk about India or Muslims in any way here. Please refrain from typing stupid comments like this. We have noted what I$lam has done to every region of the world it went. In short, Baap ko maat sikha.
@@srijandatta287 You always note things against Islam. Because you are programmed to think so. I pity you.
Hoodbhoy needs to visit Indian school and university and sit in the class
He has visited a lot. But all that has stopped after 2014.
@@estarat
Not in the last 8 years It shows
@@estarat i appreciate, no paki in india
Pervez hoodbhoy is prejudiced against Modi ji... he needs to reunderstand india and Hindus...
Imagine an atheist like hoodbhoy is anti modi..!!!
@@raangnambar8816 zahil kaum ka nominda
Absolutely Right ✅
@@raangnambar8816 He is PSEUDO ATHEIST 😊😊
@@raangnambar8816 did he say he is an atheist?
Pakistan is at par with Afghanistan or Srilanka. Comparing Pakistan and India is not reasonable. Even Bangladesh has progressed much better economically.
As An Indian, I Take Positive Things From Hoodbhouy. I’m Indebted To Him For The Knowledge, I Learnt From Him.
There Are Certain Things Which Conflicts. But, That’s Ok. We Can Ignore Certain Things & Move On.
Modi Has Been Demonised By Many Leftist Media. But, India’s Success Under Modi Leadership Cannot Be Neglected. Though, There Are Some Problems, But It’s Exaggerated To Present Negative Image Of Modi.
Damn it ...u praised modi....now u won't get a like from the channel
Actually in practical we should condemn him for uttering negativity about India and inspite of his known status his weakness has same place as his gains.
INdia speaks English everywhere and nothing has changed because of Modi. The only change is Hindi is accepted in general business
Modi has increased support for trade and industry. Sir you are a knowledgeable person. Please check facts thoroughly.
But growth of GDP has drastically come down, further joblessness has increased; standard of living has come down below that of 2014
He is a curse to India, iits are so underfunded that they were thinking of Discontinuing stipends of mtech, joblessness, and the small businesses owners are under debt and are collapsing
I'm not a Modi fan/bhakt etc but Hoodbhoy's bias against Modi has started taking him towards some bizarre claims. By and large, no technology/science institute has changed its medium of instruction to Hindi or any other regional language. It continues to be English. There, he made a mistake.
Can maize grow after peeling it.
Or any thing other natural thing without ghaib who is in ghaib
Thanks 👍 for kind information.
I didn't know Pakistan didn't even teach Darwinism. How can this country even stand among contemporary world with this kind of darkness?
You'll be surprised to know that many Muslim majority nations (eg Malaysia) also do not teach evolution. It's shocking.
Completely wrong even in modi era we Indians use English more in government sector or any other sector. Don't spread falsehood. Yes it is true they try to make Hindi as dominant language but fail every time. ❤️
Yes true... question is if hindi guy learn to talk or study any non hindi language. Hindi can't b a national language alone. We should respect all indian languages as unity in diversity.
Recently your radical minister ordered to say "vandematram" instead of "hello" 😂😂😂 what BS is this?
@@raangnambar8816 bcz your ammi wants hello
@@rustydong2374 your mataji is still in gufa with her Kamasutra skills. 😂😂😂😂
@@raangnambar8816 teri ammi teri bua hai mulle.
Iran is a unique Muslim country where sciences and mathematics are flourishing. Shah of Iran was autocratic dictator, but one good thing was that he encouraged Western education. Students at all levels were give scholarships to study abroad including India, USA, and European countries. Today Iran is harvesting that knowledge for its progress.
He is a very bold guy he is a gem he should be in India
Modi s india progress more india , open 3000 million bank account for poor.
Hope new education policy 2020 , erdict poverty of india .
It's always pleasure to listening parvez hoodboy 🙏🇮🇳
3000 million means 300 crores bank accounts. Population of India is around 150 crores.
@@mukeshsingla2459 300 million , 30 crore - jan dhan yojna and then direct banefit trasnfer - wo kya hai na india main ham (lakh ,crore ese ginte hai na ki million , billion ese - to wo problem aa jati hai )
People who had been brought up through Abrahamic relegion will never understand what is Hinduism and Sanatan Dharma.They will always see Hinduism from the lens of their monoethism thoughts. Secularism as practiced in Western world is not the right thought process compared to "Sarva Dharma Samavaw " as practiced in India. Unlike other relegion an extreme practitioner of Sanatan Dharma will be always be the most peaceful and inclusive human being..That is why no Hindu has invaded any country to destroy its culture or wealth, but to include anybody in his life and his culture.. The Parsi and Jews had found a home in india while they were persecuted elsewhere, needless to speak about Raja Dahir of Sindh.
pooodaaaaaa sangeeee
@@jojijoseph293 if you see my DP it is taken in a mosque.. What i have written is just not to make a sensation.. It's my experience.
You are right - Agree
Even the best minds in Pakistan cannot be unaffected by modi hatred
2:24 Dr. sahab never expected this from you, thats literally a blatant lie. Our schools/unis the curriculum is in English and then the regional language of the state.
Admirable scholar yet seriously mistaken on Indian education. Except for some avoidable noise on Hindi education is going on as usual. "social scientists". have ideological problems but they are really nowhere as important as natural scientists
👍
Modi ji never uttered a single world about Hindus or Muslims in last 9 years; he treats all citizens equally;
Historically in the 9th , 10th Anshu 11th century Muslims contributed richly and In Baghdad there was a library full of books. The scientific thinking started going down with Ottomans time.
No, the decline was after sacking of Baghdad.
Iranian mullah announced fatwa that math is the language of devils and instantly took their society to Stone Age!
Even in the ottoman empire many of the great scholars wee non Muslims
Koi data nahi ki Modi ke Ane ke bad English ke badle Hindi education bad Gaya. Fekam fek.
Professor Hoodbhoy is a great personality. We Indian respect him as we respect the greats of India.😊🙏
His viewpoints on India is pretty uninformed and is that of a "typical Pakistani" variety..makes you wonder how informed his opinion on other matters are
Love you Dr hoodhboy !
I can't believe ke yeh log itni badi University m Urdu n physics padhate hein. Ohh God. Yeh hai leval.
So many things to learn from this respected Professor. Whatever he talks about, he talks with authority.
Very common conversation and nothing great in it. Today's generation actually interested in speaking more than understanding the mindset of other person. Why are praising.
Local language in higher education will be an option. In primary school local language is added because many fond it easy.
Professor talked about India with doing proper research.
Dr ji ko mera full salaam🙏. Respect 🙏... Har soch mai Tiranga 🇮🇳
Dr HOODBHOY SIR IS AN EMINENT SCHOLAR AND VERY HIGHLY INTELLECTUALLY TALENTED PERSON.
EACH AND EVERY WORD IS A GOLDEN WORD.
Except knowledge ABT india n bjp which is based on imran khans WhatsApp University
Actually old search of foolish person in India ends on you,harami. It is a very general talks he is doing and nothing is great in it.
how come every one of them has got modi wrong the amount of people lifted out of poverty is record high and will be record high in near future
It’s in Modi era india is 5th largest economy in world. And it reach 3rd spot in same Modi era.
Hoodbhoy may find it hard to rise above religious prejudice, but the fact is that Modi has done more for the poor people of India than any previous PM
Yes in europe we are very close witg indians because same culture same dress same food,,,
Once a paxtani will always be a paxtani.. it'll never stop spitting venom when it comes to India, Hinduism and Modi.(I'm not a Modi ji fan)
This was a great video though I'm not on board with the logic at the end - the link between religious orthodoxy and a pro-corporate, capitalist mindset that increases the wealth gap is not causal as he suggests. Correlated yes, causal no. Just because Modi espouses a pro-Hindu philosophy does not have to necessitate that he'll favor corporates over the less privileged.
Persians were always inventive and scientific - Islam actually slowed them.
There were many Iranis who wrote test books for engineering worldwide
Pakistan media and politicians misinterpreted Modi for their Benefit
Physical geography is the branch of the natural science
ھود بھاہی ہمارے گھر میں رہے ۔بہت پیارے بندے ہیں اور ہمارے گھر میں ایک درخت لگا کر گئے اور وہ درخت اب بہت بڑا ہو گیا ہے ۔
English still prevails as prominent medium of instruction in India
Hindi is emphasized only as a link language... Nothing more... And it is an individual choice... Kids can also choose 2nd language to study optionally.
Language doesn't matter.. Chinese log Chinese me sikhte hai..even Japanese too
Dr.Hoodbhoy deserves much more than he is given in his country.with all due respect De Sahab you need to know that only in metro cities English is the medium of education. Even in Metro schools run by Governments were primarily taught Hindi/ Urdu medium and English was introduced in seconda school. In states the medium of education in primary school were regional.
SALAM Increasingly, I believe, the voices of Civil Society are voices for change, where change has been overdue. They have been voices of hope for people living in fear. They are voices that can help transform countries of crisis into countries of opportunity. There are too many societies where too many people live in a culture of fear, condemned to a life of poverty. Addressing that fear, and replacing it with hope, will be a major step to the elimination of poverty. And often the call for hope to replace fear will come from the voices of Civil Society.
The basic problem with Pakistan 🇵🇰 is that there are very few educated people. An educated person tries to be an expert at everything. A journalist will be a Chief Minister and a cricket board chairman. A physics professor will masquerade as a Global international strategist and Geopolitical expert.
When a person is an educated one. He can have enough intellect to talk on different aspects of life. So it's nothing a rocket science.
Even a chaiwala is running a country, so it can be done.
@@khanzlan1613 even pancharwala bhi hawa bhar sakta tumlog beta kitna bhi pad lo but tumare andar moral values, ethics nahin hain bomb fodna hi banaoge APJ ABDUL KALAM NAHI BAN SAKTE
Idk , he seems to be scared there, He's not opening up. Probably audience mai jo gawar bete hue hai unke kabiliyat k mutabik hi lecture de rahe hai.
But overall, a 1/10 rating lecture here.
The idea that Hindi has somehow been promulgated only by Modi is completely ignorant. The policy of Hindi imposition has been practiced for multiple decades. Concepts such as Hindi Pakhwara in government offices across the nation have been practiced for decades.
Looks like only Indians watch sensible folks from Pakistan.
So many people are following Dr Hoodbhoy in Pakistan.
You guys seem to be against nationalism in India but promote nationalism in Pakistan. What is the logic behind that?
He suffers from inferiority complex. And always underestimates Pak
Modi kuch bhi Hindi ki taraf leke nhi gya hai. Jo jis language m padhta tha usi m padhta hai. Sirf ek do medical College m changes hua hai qki kuch bachhe hindi medium se hein.
ye bhaai ko Hindu, Hinduism, Modi, Indian nationalism ke baare me jyaadaa jaankaari nahi hai.
Dear Sir Sinister Agenda. 1. You are creating a frame of your own perceptions that had privileged bais. Language governs direction of intelligence and information hence salary. 2. German, French and Japanese and Russain raised marvellous civilization with heighest intelligence base with their own language. We could not liberate ourself from over indulgence with English due to our elite and thus any person not capable to fluently express in english became savage and illiterate hence for ruling elite by defination educated in Maddarass/ School or in Urdu were illiterate. 3. I respect your opinion but I differ on account the your generation made no effort to translate the scientific text in urdu even roman urdu. Masses education can be based on native language plus English , math and computer as fundamental basis of new educational policy plus critical education in religion and philosophy. God bless
Thanks a sir for your feedback and so balanced approach.
Team ASG
Hypocrisy is so called scientist of Pakistan - We should not remember our religion - Hindus can never be radicals like other religions, as we believe in plurality
MODI2024 450+
Hoodbhoy's views about Modi is based on second hand kniwledge from his entitled contacts in India
No leader in India has done more than Modi fir piverty alleviation
Modi has treated poor people witj dignity and respect
May be.
Modi is a curse to india
Comments on Modi govt in India from outside largely depends upon that person's or regional interests..... not on facts Unfortunately
Partition of British India has resulted in the prevention of Islamisation of people of remaining Indian subcontinent. Pakistan is declared as a monocultural society with majority religious rights due to phobia of other religions whereas India is declared as a multicultural society with minority religious rights. Utilising this, large-scale en-masse conversations are taking place into Christianity and now Hindus are reduced to 50 to 60 percent only or less. One day Pakistanis will see India would become a Christian majority country without minority religious rights.
Surprising comment.
Which we*d?
The Bengalis have some chinese genes
Modi era is the best era for science and technology in india
What's wrong in promoting Indian language its rather wrong to promote a foreign language like English, get out of ur mental colonization
i thought this man to be a wise one but still like an avg pakistani he comes to modi and hindu. Modi is hindu but he never ever said against muslims or sikhs agar koi ek clip nikalke dikhade toh me maan jaunga.
Modiji ne mazhab ka sahara liya, aur pura pakistan keya liya, secularism? India doesn't bother pakistan anymore, discuss yourselves and be happy.
YE KIS PAGLKHANE SE CHHHOTA HAI HR LANGUAGE BOLI JATI HAI IND ME
N.E. MEIN TO LOG JAPANESE BHI SIKHAYI JATI HAI
Mind your language
Sorry ,ambani ko kb ayyashi. ..krte dekha sir app ne....and about modi u r wrong....sayd app ne apne yha ke news channel dekhe h sir......unhone science math women important infrastructure ,space ke field me bht dhyan diya h yha ke gaov se jo log h unse puche....we have more medical College in modi government in small time....app ki research bht simit h sir...jisse app mazhab bolte h hmare yha vo nhi h....hmare yha cultural and art h...tha ki purani mandore hamare dharm se jada cultural aur art ko dikhati h .. knowledge ko dikhati h....unhe preserve Krna hmari jimmedari h..aur ye kisi dharm vises ki dharohar nhi h.....bhartiy cultural ka hissa h.....har bhartiy ka itihas h h....
All Pakistani give wrong reference as concerns study in INDIA, all study as you like which Regional language you prefer even. In higher education no such language is compulsory
Mr. Hoodbhoy is very knowledgeable person but I am surprised that he has negative perception of Mr. Modi who has given pride of place for India globally. Modis vision has transformed India into fast developing economy. When Modi is very popular in India and regarded highly internationally it is hard to understand how knowledgeable person like hoodbhoy has negative views about him.
This guy is actually a madarsa chap posing as intellectual.😅
Dr parvez is an average pakistani
Respect to you sir, love from India....
Ajeeb sa interview. Interviewer Prof Hoodbhoi ke taraf dekhta hi nahi jaise ki koi nayi naveli dulhan 😂
It wasn't an interview but a q&a session after a lecture.
Dr Hoodbbhoy keep religion out of your lectures.
The guy is clueless about india.
Why is he so against local languages
Aap bhi dimag ki khidki khole Pehle
Good chance here for Modi bhakts to shout. Enjoy.
Pakistan become Brin rein
He nothing know about india