Attack on Titan - Reaction - S4E10 - A Sound Argument

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 พ.ย. 2021
  • We're learning some more about what went on before the attack on the Marleyans, hopefully Eren's comrades don't lose all hope in him o(╥﹏╥)o
    Support us on Patreon
    ✧ / thereactpack
    Follow our backup channel!
    ✧ / @thereactpackbackup4682
    CHAT with The React Pack!
    ✧ / discord
    Our Reaction Playlist
    ✧ / @thereactpack
    UNPACK with The React Pack!
    ✧You can send us stuff at:
    PO Box 11705
    Tampa, FL 33680
    -----------------------------------
    TRACK The React Pack
    Instagram: / thereactpack
    Twitter: / thereactpack
    Twitch: / thereactpack
    TikTok: vm.tiktok.com/ZMdWeQbfY/
    Sam (Reactor)
    Instagram: / samcakes90
    Twitter: / samcakes90
    Twitch: / samcakes90
    Morgan (Reactor / Editor)
    Instagram: / saganakitty
    Twitter: / saganakitty
    Twitch: / saganakitty
    Dani (Reactor)
    Instagram: / yishuho
    Twitter: / yishuho
    Twitch: / yishuho
    Nicole (Reactor)
    Instagram: / nicknackhoff
    Alex (Reactor)
    Instagram: / parkerprime
    TRACK what anime we plan on reacting to in the future!
    ✧myanimelist.net/profile/TheRe...

ความคิดเห็น • 199

  • @junioryeahhh560
    @junioryeahhh560 2 ปีที่แล้ว +103

    The timeline for this episode was easy to identify because of the characters' hairstyles at different times xD

  • @embereve-chan
    @embereve-chan 2 ปีที่แล้ว +207

    I feel like you guys totally missed the part where Armin agreed with Connie that they need options to take Eren's titans if necessary. Definitely a rift between our group forming.

    • @TheReactPack
      @TheReactPack  2 ปีที่แล้ว +52

      It’s hurting my heart, I hate to see the group separate -Morgan

  • @alexinator-hh5fe
    @alexinator-hh5fe 2 ปีที่แล้ว +92

    It really is a shame to see how the relationship between everyone is straining. Hange and Eren used to have such a wholesome friendship and to see where it's ended up is sad.

  • @dejisauce6025
    @dejisauce6025 2 ปีที่แล้ว +83

    Zeke’s plan is to use Historia basically as a breeding cattle. That’s why in the flashback Eren was totally opposed of the plan. So basically Zeke wants to pass the beast titan to someone with royal blood. So if historia has kids she then passes the beast titan to her kids and then her kids pass it down to their kids and the cycle continues. She cares for the people of paradise so she is going with the plan to just keep getting impregnated

    • @captingamer29
      @captingamer29 2 ปีที่แล้ว +20

      Correct me if I'm wrong(it's been a long time since I've read these sections of the manga) but Historia having a child as opposed to straight-up inheriting is a means to stall the process, giving paradise time to figure out another solution. The MP even states just as much with complaining that Historia has gotten pregnant when she was meant to inheret.

    • @toastedt0ast878
      @toastedt0ast878 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@captingamer29 yeah pretty sure your correct

    • @2o7o7dragon
      @2o7o7dragon 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@captingamer29 I didn't read the manga, but my read of it was that the getting pregnant wasn't planned by her or the MPs/higher ups. But since she was pregnant when they captured Zeke they couldn't turn her, since turning a pregnant woman into a titan could be very dangerous for her and especially for the baby. Like if she got turned, when she get's strapped to the titan's neck vertebra it's 100% gonna crush the baby... at least that was my read of it.

    • @AncientDragon101
      @AncientDragon101 2 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      @Owner The plan was for her to first eat Zeke though. Her getting pregnant first allows Zeke to stay alive, and that was not part of the original plan. That one MP guy was saying he thought it was probably Yelena who made Historia get pregnant so Zeke does not die, yet.

  • @HarJBeRw
    @HarJBeRw 2 ปีที่แล้ว +53

    4:35
    Am I the only one who burst out laughing at his "KiYOmI aZUmAbITo" xD

    • @Kobob_KC
      @Kobob_KC 2 ปีที่แล้ว +10

      with the mario voice

    • @pljoo9
      @pljoo9 2 ปีที่แล้ว +13

      honestly he said it almost perfectly, just remove the Italian accent and there you go lmao

  • @ravkaur2447
    @ravkaur2447 2 ปีที่แล้ว +35

    I think that was an error on the animators that they didn't add the cloth on Mikasa's wrist the whole series even though it's in the manga. Instead. they had her mother show the embroidery to her on some cloth back in season one during her backstory.

    • @TheReactPack
      @TheReactPack  2 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      Ohhhhh interesting!! -Morgan

    • @Sprife_
      @Sprife_ 2 ปีที่แล้ว +19

      Yes. As far as I know, WIT didn't know in the first season that the tattoo would be important in the future story. So they didn't animate it because of that. and they didn't want to show tattoos on kids. And Japanese (mostly elderly people) are afraid of tattoos, because they are put in context with the Yakuza. In Japan, you still can't go to some places, were a tattoo can be seen. Like an Onsen (Hot spring).

  • @Uperfist
    @Uperfist 2 ปีที่แล้ว +21

    FYI, The tattoo on Mikasa's wrist is mentionned only there. In the manga, it's the first thing you know about her (we don't know what it is, we don't see it but her mother did it to her). But if you check, you'll see that you never saw Mikasa's wrist without a sleeve on it.

  • @KillerBee300
    @KillerBee300 2 ปีที่แล้ว +22

    Time is literally the whole problem thats dividing everyone.

    • @TheReactPack
      @TheReactPack  2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Yes it’s so frustrating ): -Morgan

  • @breakwoodhopper6739
    @breakwoodhopper6739 2 ปีที่แล้ว +15

    Eren always laughs in horrible situations he's been doing it since season 1

  • @icyjules
    @icyjules 2 ปีที่แล้ว +16

    that threesome joke legit made me spit out my coffee lmaooooo

  • @waltz4life
    @waltz4life 2 ปีที่แล้ว +12

    Eren's original goal was indeed to find another way without using Historia, and that other way WAS Zeke. I believe Eren taking the warhammer titan was just a way to weaken Marley, along with killing all of their higher ups during the festival, in order to buy them more time. But getting Zeke from Marley was his main goal

  • @werner9942
    @werner9942 2 ปีที่แล้ว +19

    24:01 in the manga mikasa is always shown with a bandage on his hand but I don't know why in the anime they don't do it

    • @CrossSky98
      @CrossSky98 2 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      I heard it’s cause Japan is against tattoos for younger people and they can’t show Mikasa as a kid with a tattoo

  • @sastaassh1112
    @sastaassh1112 2 ปีที่แล้ว +22

    It's so funny that hange is questioning Eren about sacrificing historia eventhough he was the only who stood for her, and hange, Levi and the rest of the military are fine with sacrificing historia.

  • @jasmine9581
    @jasmine9581 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    6:12 I learned at some point that in episode 6, instead of the embroidery/arts thing, her mom was putting it on her hand--branded iirc
    So instead of "it's done!" she said "it hurts", and her mother praised her for holding up well, then the conversation continues as before
    6:14 lol I like this trio

  • @cocoyoung5268
    @cocoyoung5268 2 ปีที่แล้ว +28

    Great pitch at the start Dani. 😆 Alex always has the best deadpan expression at the start.
    Awesome reaction, things getting a lil' spicy.

    • @TheReactPack
      @TheReactPack  2 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      Hahahaha straight edge guy, we heatin upppp!! -Morgan

  • @sasankashaw9419
    @sasankashaw9419 2 ปีที่แล้ว +18

    6:29 eren's last smile that we saw in series

    • @vindifference
      @vindifference 2 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      And one of the few times in general. He hasn't genuinely smiled much at all since the very beginning. Most of his smiles have been the determined "I will kill them all" types of smiles, which are very different.

    • @ulrch
      @ulrch 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      He was definitely thinking about a threesome like Sam said.

    • @nupreview
      @nupreview 2 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      *SPOILER*
      Nah, his last smile was when he and others were drunk in the refugee camp in Marley with Ramzi and his family

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I'm not sure if she was properly portrayed in the anime, but she was connected to Ymir from the beginning, and Krista was definitely a key person in this story from the beginning.
    Volume 4 depicted a scene of Krista giving bread to Sascha.
    In the anime, it may have been a moment, but in the manga, the scene between the two was specifically depicted.
    Ymir: "I've been irritated since I hid bread for dinner, it's like feeding my pet without telling my parents..."
    "Hey... You're trying to do 'good', aren't you?"
    "Did you do that for sweet potato women? Was your sense of accomplishment and exaltation worth the effort?"
    Ymir speaks
    "What?..." Christa's face is drawn in close-up.
    "I... I... I wanted to do this... Because I want to be seen as a useful person... I wonder if it is...?" Krista answers the question with an ununderstanding look.
    "What?! Who knows?"
    "Anyway... carry her to bed."
    "What!?"
    "It's going to be hard for you to carry."
    "Uh... Why do you do 'good things'?"
    "I'm here to do this imo lady a favor, and I can expect her stupidity."
    The conversation between Krista and Ymir was very long.
    This principle of action of Krista must have been a foreshadowing of the fact that she was also very similar to her ancestor Ymir.
    The anime probably didn't quite describe it properly.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    In the original story, Historia was left alone and ended
    With Ymir gone mentally she becomes unstable
    (That's her when she sees her father again.)
    "Krista was the girl in the picture book I read as a kid and what I needed to live," she says.
    A picture book of the devil of the earth and a girl handing an apple appeared in her recollections
    Crysta didn't have many roles in the anime,
    In the manga, he is depicted as a "kind child who always cares about others" from the early days.
    The girl in the picture book who is "a kind and kind child to everyone" = It should have been a foreshadowing of being the ancestor Ymir
    However, there is no mention of her in the subsequent development of the manga, and in the anime, she is distraught when Ymir is gone, "Krista is the girl in the picture book I read as a child" was also cut, and her upbringing told in the title of the chapter "Crysta Lens" was also mostly cut in the anime.
    It's that the anime portrayed too much of the protagonist or the corps, or a specific character too specially.
    Also, "a kind child who always cares about others" = girlishness, and Krista in the manga was usually cool from the early days
    The anime portrayed her in a more feminine way, which would have led to misunderstandings about her character, especially from the West.
    What is the main axis of this story? It means
    In order to avoid the cancellation of the manga, Ymir was withheld under the name Freckle Woman.
    Also, Krista was often depicted in small panels from the early days, interspersed with foreshadowing that she was a key person, but the anime destroyed that plot
    Inside the walls are giants, whose secrets are held by royalty and related to Eren.
    And it leads to what to do
    Simply that's the main axis of the story.
    The key person in the story should have been her
    To put it bluntly, Levi's upbringing is a reader service, and he has nothing to do with the main plot of the story.
    Also, the mystery of "Canned Herring", which only Ymir could read at Udgard Castle, was also neglected.
    Because people's interests focused on other characters
    If the creator had an understanding of the work and characters, the plot would not have been changed to match the anime.

  • @Rated_RMN
    @Rated_RMN 2 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Eren was just trying to obtain as many Titna powers as he could during their assault to take them from Marley basically

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Since the early days, the two have been depicted in similar poses.
    In the anime, from season 2
    In the manga, after Ymir and Reiner left, the author carefully depicted the relationship between Eren and Historia.
    They were always concerned about Historia, who was sad that Ymir was gone, and they talked about various things.
    Also, the dialogue between Eren and Historia on the wall was clearly depicted superimposed on Grisha and Dinah.
    Historia desperately wants to help Ymir, and Eren stops her, saying, "You'd better not stand yet."
    "Don't worry about me!" retorts Historia.
    Looking at a remorseful Historia, Eren says, "Ymir was always thinking about you how you could survive."
    Even in the royal hut, the two talk about various things face to face.
    Eren tells Historia, who has been remorseful ever since Ymir was gone.
    They say, "You're good now," or "You're normal, you're just stupid and honest normal guy."
    What was the accumulation of that polite relationship between them?
    It was very unfortunate that the anime cut all that scene of theirs
    The fact that the author said, "Eren was happy to understand Historia" should have been a meaningful scene.

  • @irfanbattlestar
    @irfanbattlestar 2 ปีที่แล้ว +10

    8:34 LOL....Different Historia....

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    \"Krista is a difficult character, so I write while researching various things,\" the author professed from the beginning,
    Early in her life, she has several characteristics of an abused child.
    It also shows up in Udgard Castle where he tears his skirt to help Reiner, and apologizes \"I'm sorry.\"
    She has a low self-esteem that says, 'I don't care what happens to me.'
    And \"Krista is the girl in the picture book\", which was cut in the anime but was in the manga, was a slave to the king.
    Ymir's model is probably Loki from Norse mythology, but she also sometimes lies in the comics.
    The scene where Krista gets angry and throws stones at the giant after Nanaba and the others are killed is also her true intention, and even in the snowy mountains, \"I don't mean that\" is true. She doesn't have the idea of \"saving herself\" or \"asking for help\" in the first place. That's what Ymir wanted to stop. But the anime could not adequately express it.
    \"Eren and Krista are similar in essence,\" the creator said even before the anime.
    Eren is Mikasa, Krista is Ymir, and they are overprotective of each other, and Eren's number of titans defeated when he was a human is the same as Krista, and in the manga, the two were often depicted with similar expressions and poses from the early days. In Japan, the two were said at the time to be a \"duo in a hurry to die.\"
    The author said that the image of the three childhood friends became too strong after it was made into an anime, and that Levi became too popular. In addition, anime companies at the time admitted that even women and men had favoritism for certain characters.
    Both in the anime and manga, Historia's character after that was ruined.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    The conversation between Eren and Historia on the wall after Season 2, the conversation between Eren and Historia who stops thinking about Historia (Historia at this time only thinks about Ymir), the conversation between the two in their hut in the royal edition where the author said "Eren was happy to understand Historia",
    Even though I cut them all in anime,
    Depicting the two of them in the Mare edition only makes Historia's position worse.
    If you want to include scenes like this, it is obviously a mistake that Wit Studio cut a lot of scenes about Historia and altered the exchange between the two on the wall ~ the exchange between the two in the royal version.
    Much more is depicted in the manga.
    The anime side brought the scenes of Eren and Mikasa to the fore and cut a lot of the Historia scenes, but suddenly including the exchange between the two in the Mare edition only causes Historia to get antipathy from the anime people.

  • @randalabra3852
    @randalabra3852 2 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    Alex perked up and smiled when he realized it was ep 69 and then side-eyed to see if anyone else was gonna say anything bahahah

    • @AceyJP
      @AceyJP ปีที่แล้ว

      needs to be pinned this comment haha they didnt notice but us boys lol....

    • @jip5889
      @jip5889 ปีที่แล้ว

      Nice!

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    The anime producers and editors did not understand the importance of Krista and Historia, who were key people in the story.
    At the time, anime companies were proud that they had made this work popular.
    The creator cannot interfere with the anime.
    Similarly, Demon Slayer became more popular in anime than manga in Japan, and the reason why this work became widely popular in Japan was because of the understanding and love of the anime production team for the work of "delivering this work". The fact that I didn't draw Tanjiro in favor of him just because he is the main character, and the wonderful love for each character.
    And both as an anime and a manga, it became a beautifully drawn work until the end.
    Perhaps if there had been an understanding and love for the work like Demon Slayer, the development of the story would have been different.
    When the anime adaptation was decided, the creator said, "I don't want Eren to be anything special," and the only order was placed on the anime side, but that didn't come true.
    The anime's arbitrary original development opened up the character's popularity in an early stage, and the story collapsed from the original plan when the character of Krista and Historia, who were key people in the story, collapsed.

  • @kevint4673
    @kevint4673 2 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Eren doesn't need gorls, he wants FREEDOM 😂. Sam with the sneaky comments in this one killing me: "Threesome?", "Sasha not being there" 😭

  • @SiaLi-
    @SiaLi- 2 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Sam says things with so much confidence 😭

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    The giants are human beings, and the walls are made of humans, and the secrets are held by royalty.
    That was the story that the author had envisioned from the beginning of the series.
    The plot of Ymir and Krista was really very well thought out.
    However, with the popularity of anime, the importance of the characters and the development of the work have changed.
    Even in the anime, many scenes in Historia were cut and changed.
    Of all the female characters, she was the most unfortunate.
    Erwin Smith, Ymir, Historia, Krista Lens
    These characters were the only ones in the manga to have chapter titles named.
    The title of the chapter where she talks about her upbringing was more carefully drawn by Erwin in the anime and was combined with \"Old Tales\".
    In the manga, the chapter title \"Krista Lens\" was an independent episode of her upbringing.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    If you've been reading the manga since the beginning, it's natural to think that it's strange to suddenly be hit in the final episode even though the ancestors Ymir and Mikasa have nothing to do with each other.
    The voices of Eremia, Erehis, and the coupling kitchen must have been part of the work that destroyed this work.
    ・ Crysta's principle of action is very similar to that of her ancestor Ymir. In the manga, Krista was often depicted in close-ups from the beginning. That they were not directed into anime.
    ・The relationship between Ymir and Crysta in the 104th class
    - Historia's upbringing, written in the chapter title "Crysta Lens", is very similar to her ancestor Ymir.
    ・ Crysta is a girl in a picture book
    We should be ashamed that the anime side made so many cuts and changes to Historia, including the fact that it has become such an influential work overseas.
    Historia was the character who destroyed character development the most and was not blessed with directing.
    It is the most stupid thing that Wit Studio did not properly express these

  • @zcreedz755
    @zcreedz755 2 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    From now on you will realize the real role of ERWIN SMITH
    His place cannot be filled

  • @YKB461
    @YKB461 2 ปีที่แล้ว +31

    Just to clarify, Historia is very pregnant at the *current* time of the story. We don't have any indication as to who the father is. The military elite believe a story going around that the father was a farmhand that Historia knew in her childhood. However, a popular fan theory around this time in the manga is that Eren is the father and he impregnates her in order to stop the elites from turning her into a titan.

    • @griff5940
      @griff5940 2 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      Ew

    • @TheReactPack
      @TheReactPack  2 ปีที่แล้ว +10

      Oh my goodness, I mean that theory definitely makes sense though -Morgan

    • @ukiyoideas2215
      @ukiyoideas2215 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@embereve-chan seems "impregnation" its too hard of a word to process.

    • @subarashii95
      @subarashii95 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      So Eren kissing Historia’s hand made him see some “things” but them making a baby wouldn’t trigger something since it’s way more than just touching lmao? Doesn’t make sense imo

    • @Tohlemiach
      @Tohlemiach 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@subarashii95 I feel like if they fucked, he'd just accidentally trigger the full-scale rumbling. No way you're controlling yourself at a time like that.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Before the anime adaptation began, readers from the beginning of the series expected that the key person in the story would be royalty and Christa. She was not portrayed in such a girlish manner in the original work. In any frame she was well drawn.
    And her character development was really well thought out.
    The author professed to have changed the story from the original plan from the monarchy.
    That it became more popular in anime than in manga,
    The anime portrayed Eren too specially, for better or worse.
    After Season 2, after expressing her feelings for Ymir, she says, "Krista is the girl in the picture book I read as a child, and she is the role I was given to live."
    This applies to her "gentle child who is always considerate of others" and shows her connection to her own ancestor Ymir.
    Then comes the picture book of the Earth Devil and her ancestor Ymir, and her upbringing is described in a separate episode under the chapter title "Krista Lens".
    However, her episode "Crysta is a Girl in the Picture Book" was also cut in the anime. Her upbringing was also cut.
    The anime's royal politics edition also featured the action of Levi and Kenny.
    The anime has been significantly changed from the main manga. To protect the hero image of the Corps.
    Therefore, it deviates from the main plot of the story that the identity of the giant is a human being, the walls are made of giants, and the key is held by royalty.
    This is due to the fact that they became too popular by favoring other characters, that anime became more popular than manga and more people watched anime, that Eren and the Survey Corps were drawn too much as heroes, and that extremists were born.
    As a result, there were changes to the Mare edition and the development of the story that were not originally planned.
    Her character development ceased to exist.
    The official favored certain characters as merchandise.
    In the anime, Historia's scenes were cut and altered a lot. She is threatened to become a queen, she has no choice, she cannot escape fate, and she is demanded to become a child-bearing machine, the flow was very sad.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    The author publicly stated that he changed the content of the work halfway from the original plan in response to the anime.
    Historia was the most anime character with a lot of cuts and modifications.
    In the main story, her feelings after Ymir disappeared were also cut, and even in the main story, her character after that was just shaken and could not see her true intentions.
    Season 3 featured the action of Levi and Kenny by the anime producers.
    Historia, who was supposed to be a key person in the story, ruined her character development and character. I think he is the character who has fallen victim to adult circumstances the most.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    As of Season 2, the author confessed that he was exhausted
    It may have been unfortunate to change the character's importance and plot from the original plan to match the anime's response
    Actually. Mikasa, Ani, and Sascha were completed in anime.
    Since the author was also the protagonist of the work that won the Newcomer Award, Krista was the most stable and beautifully drawn from the early days.
    The popularity of the work in anime
    Krista was more feminine in anime.
    In the manga, Krista wasn't that feminine from the early days...
    The storyline was changed from the monarchy to match the anime.
    It was Krista who was the victim both in the work and in reality
    Krista was often depicted in the rough drawings released by the author at the beginning of the series before the anime adaptation was decided.
    I miss the fact that her paintings were drawn alongside Levi
    It may have been Eren and the author who carried it all on his back.

  • @angrok2857
    @angrok2857 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    0:09 no matter how old, boys will be boys

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Eren and Historia's conversation on the wall after Season 2, Historia's feelings for Ymir, and most of her upbringing was cut in the anime,
    \"Krista is a girl from a picture book I read as a child\" = The scene showing that Ymir and Historia are very similar was cut in the anime.
    Significant changes to the anime's monarchy edition, thereby ruining the role of Historia, who was a key person in the story, and her character development.
    Therefore, it will probably end as in the original.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    ・ The anime's formula shows three childhood friends in full, but "Eren thinks differently than Mikasa and Armin" and "Eren and Krista are similar in nature"
    There was a detachment from the words of this early author
    Mikasa only thought about Eren from the early days of the manga and never cared about other people.
    It was depicted as if the essence of Eren was not visible
    That's what the author also mentioned so
    She also started to care about others in the manga until the Mare chapter approached.
    If mappa had adequately expressed Crysta's character development, it would have adequately expressed her character development.
    Would have adequately expressed that she is a key person in the story
    There would have been no alterations in the anime monarchy hen
    I wouldn't have portrayed her more feminine than the cartoon either.
    Crystallens, Historia was a character who was always in a position where she was prone to bashing and hard choices. For some reason that? I couldn't move her, the key person in the story. Since she was a Krista character, she has always had a cool side. The anime didn't express it properly.
    In the anime, the relationship between Ymir and Krista may have felt abrupt, but the scene where Krista gives bread to Sascha was also a foreshadowing of the connection between Krista and the ancestor Ymir.
    And Krista has a reason to believe Ymir at that time. As an anime viewer, I heard from Ymir! It must have been.
    Even in the basement of the chapel she has reason to believe in her father. However, her emotional portrayal was cut in the anime. Why? People turn their attention to Eren. Would viewers be mad if Historia hadn't helped Eren then?
    It is possible that the events of this chapel in the first place were also changed from the original plot. Historia may have been promised a different move.
    "Krista is a difficult character," the author said, but that "Crysta is a girl in a picture book" was cut in the anime and destroyed her character development
    Both Krista and Historia basically maintain her "stupid and overly good-natured" personality.
    The story of Historia helping Eren in the basement of the chapel is titled "Wish" in the manga.
    So what is this wish? It is Historia's own 'wish' from Ymir to her.
    "Krista is a girl in a picture book and what I was given to live" = Ancestor Ymir was a slave of the king
    So Ymir in sync told her. "You live by your real name," Ymir wished.
    And the other is that Historia wanted to "help" Eren who was crying, "I don't need you anymore."
    "I won't kill myself anymore" and "Help Eren in front of me" are both her "wishes" with the words of her best friend in mind.
    Her actions are, after all, always altruistic.
    And it would have been the viewer's wish not to kill Eren in this scene.
    "How pathetic you are, Historia. Everybody wanted you to be a disgrace!"
    "I could save humanity... So pathetic?"
    Historia tearfully retorts.
    There is this conversation between Kenny and Historia that was cut in the anime.
    These words may have been a confrontation with readers who perceived Eren as special and Historia as weak.
    Eren is strong, Historia is weak, and it would have been impossible to move her as a key person in the story, especially in a situation that Western viewers perceive as such.
    However, she is forced to play the role of "queen" and is required to become a child-giving machine for the island.
    And her proposal in the conversation between Eren and Historia in the Mare edition contradicted her character development up to that point and was incomprehensible to comic book readers.
    "Being saved by Historia, who is in a similar situation to herself, is a big event for Eren," the author said in an interview.
    In the end, it disappeared somewhere
    "Crysta is a girl in a picture book", and not delving into the connection between Historia and her ancestor Ymir is a major failure of this story.
    Viewers see Eren as special, but the author had said that "Eren is a slave to the story"
    And that would have answered viewers' requests for something special.

  • @danielreyes2796
    @danielreyes2796 2 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Lmao why does Alex say “we are the react pack” like he’s got a gun to his head 💀

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    As for Historia, it's really regrettable that various things were cut in the anime.
    That's because we destroyed her character in the anime
    It's the conversation between Eren and Historia on the wall after Season 2, and the modification of the royal version.
    "House Wraith is the real royal family, Historia, tell me what you think."
    「... Huh."
    and Levi crams into her
    "Disgusting?"
    「... I can't," she replies with a frightened look on her face
    "Probably, but it doesn't matter, do it."
    "To me... very..."
    "Okay, then run away."
    Levi threatens by strangling Historia
    "Run away from us with all your might, but if you do, we will use all means to subdue you. I'm an abnormal person by nature. If we are at the helm, we can save lives that don't have to die. It's all up to you, Historia."
    "This is your destiny, you can either run away or fight. Defeat me."
    Threatened by Levi, Historia agrees with a frightened face to become queen
    "My next role is the Queen...?
    "Alright, stand up, I begged you, Historia."
    Historia at this time was in a state of debauchery ever since Ymir was gone.
    He has a frightened look on his face from start to finish.
    This showed that she had no choice and could not escape the heavy responsibilities she was born with. This was an important scene.
    It was Reeves who told Historia, "You can be queen and beat that man back." It was changed to Mikasa in the anime.
    Then Kenny appears and Historia reunites with Kenny.
    And Kenny said, "Hey, Krista Lens, do you remember me?"
    "You've grown," I tell Historia.
    Later, Kenny meets Levi again and says, "You've grown up too."
    The anime cut the Kenny and Historia scene
    Saying, "It's my fault that this happened," Historia joins in the defeat of Rod Reiss.
    On the wall was a conversation between Levi and Historia.
    "Hey, Historia, what are you doing? You're withdrawn."
    "It was you, Captain Levi, who told me to choose between running away or fighting."
    Historia retorts
    And it leads to the scene where Historia punches Levi back.
    But witstudio cut and modified all of this

  • @thomholio
    @thomholio 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    The tumultuousness in the main crew’s relationship in this arc always makes me so sad and uneasy.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    \"I'm not afraid of any world with you,\" I think that was the last time I told Ymir. Her character is very well thought out, and although it was cut in the anime, \"Krista is a girl in a picture book\", which is the ancestor Ymir, which also matched her character. But the anime has removed a lot of things about her.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Those who have been watching the manga since the early days miss the days when they thought that the walls were giants, their secrets were held by royalty and related to Eren, and that Ymir, whose name was unknown, and Krista, who was not yet active, were the children of royalty.
    It's stupid that the anime didn't portray it properly, that the anime people couldn't pay attention to it.
    It's foolish that their presence has diminished due to the movement in anime, and that people's attention has been focused on the protagonist and other characters.
    The key to the story was clearly Christa.
    And Mikasa should have had another role as a heroine.
    She has a reason to believe Ymir at that time, and she has a reason to believe in her father at that time.
    Most of her scenes were cut, altered, her character development was destroyed, and the story was expanded to Mare hen, which was not originally planned.
    In the end, what Eren wanted to do doesn't make sense even to the readers of the manga
    Historia was treated the most unfavorably
    It's a well-known story that readers from the early days got angry that the creator didn't understand the work.
    It can't be helped.
    Demon Slayer, Fullmetal Alchemist shows that there really is love for the creator
    Ani, who has been sleeping for a long time after committing mass murder and is reunited with her family and has feelings for Armin, is probably the happiest person.

  • @leaflenster7340
    @leaflenster7340 ปีที่แล้ว

    8:17 Remember how Eren has the memories of the other holders of his titans? Imagine having the memories of every past titans but three times over now, since the titans were first came into being.
    Ngl I imagine that would take its toll on anyone, and much more so on someone who was always very emotional. You guys have mentioned a lot how he seems so different, but remember that he now has the memories of three titans and now has to process all that information. Those titans have been Marley too, so he's probably able to remember all the nasty shit they've said and done toward Eldians. I imagine it's just been far too much to handle. On top of all these plans floating around and how everything feels such a mess, that's another added layer onto his burden.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    A character with a completely different impression in manga and anime was Historia.
    It is also a tragedy that Wit Studios portrayed Krista more feminine than cartoons
    The original Krista is originally cool sometimes...
    "Historia needs to be a little more girly."
    "What does it mean to be a girl?"
    "I guess being a girl is like this kid."
    "Krista?" = Ancestor Ymir
    And her upbringing, which is told in the chapter "Crysta Lens", was very similar to her ancestor Ymir.
    That was her character development
    If you cut the fact that "Crysta was a girl in a picture book, a role I was given to live..."
    In the comics, she wasn't the kind of person to make such a proposal herself.
    Season 3 was altered and her character development was destroyed and it became like that.
    She is an ordinary girl. But she can't escape the heavy responsibilities she was born with.
    She cannot run away or fight. It was the royal politics that drew it, but in both manga and anime, the hero image of the soldiers was too strong to draw it.
    She receives threats and becomes queen.
    The suggestion "If I defeated that giant~" is also convenient because the Legion thinks of Historia as a pawn.
    So in the end, her actions are altruistic.
    So it was a shock to the readers of the manga in the conversation between Eren and Historia
    Because in both Krista and Historia she was an altruistic person.
    It ended without delving into it in the anime or the main story.
    But Wit Studios cut most of Historia's upbringing.
    The fact that the author did not draw Historia in the group picture in "This is the only thing I can draw", "I should have let her play an active role earlier", "I am not good enough", and the words of regret that Crysta was drawn in the initial name that was released. The meaning of having published it.
    She was sometimes cool in the original and is a normal girl.
    Krista cut the girl in the picture book in the anime and left it in the main story, and ended up not delving into the Historia-related things that were the key person in the story until the end.
    It was portrayed that way in the anime, and the difference in understanding of the characters opened up.
    It was very unfortunate that the author destroyed Historia's character development in the Mare edition in accordance with the anime.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    To begin with, Eren and Mikasa's relationship has also been almost untouched in the Attack on World since the early days.
    It's just that Ani, Armin, and Jean have a crush on Mikasa for a long time, and Sascha and Connie are good friends.
    And the deepest relationship was depicted between Ymir and Krista.
    Krista in the manga was not portrayed in such a feminine way.
    Then, in the anime, after Season 2, Historia breaks down crying in distraught thinking about Ymir, a member of the 104th class.
    This is where her great affection for Ymir is transmitted.
    Without even listening to Eren stop her, she tries to get Ymir back, telling her not to worry about me.
    This is a scene where you can see her great love for Ymir and her personality.
    It was very unfortunate that it was cut in the anime
    Then there is the modification of the monarchy.
    The Legion thinks of Historia as a pawn
    So Levi strangles Historia and threatens
    I can't believe that Ymir would do such a thing to Historia, who has been depressed for a long time. and the scene where Sascha gets angry
    Both Eren and Historia are blindfolded and taken away.
    In the anime, it was modified to make the reason why Historia beats Levi strange.
    This was because Levi strangled and threatened
    So she said, "It's my fault that this happened," and participated in the defeat of Rod Reiss.
    And I made such a proposal according to the wishes of the soldiers.
    So Erwin said, "I never thought this was going to happen."
    That was the monarchy
    Historia hasn't been properly represented in anime since the days of Krista, and her character in particular may have seemed alien to the West, right?
    It was very unfortunate that the author's request "not to draw the main character specially" did not pass
    People's attention shifts to Eren and the other characters.
    It seemed that the author was troubled by the treatment of Historia, who was created as a key person in the story.

  • @adyarrobbani9322
    @adyarrobbani9322 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    the reason why eren send his friend to the front line is because he already aknowledge them. like when he called mikasa when the warhammer said "any last word" because he already aknowledges her that she want to help him as much as she can. in S1-S2 eren always complained that he always get saved by mikasa, in S3 he realize it and didnt complained again. hhe now understood that to fight he must trust his comrades no matter what, and fight together to achieve their dreams. thats what a character development is

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Even for anime such as Naruto and Bleach, the creators of anime at that time could not order from the anime side.
    Several story changes were made to match the anime
    Many anime these days are faithful to the original
    Attack on Titan became more popular in anime in Japan than manga, and there are many anime people.
    Since Season 2 to match the anime, the author has significantly changed the flow of the story.
    Krista and Historia have a lot of cuts and alterations in the scenes, that she was not blessed with directing
    Even when she was a female titan, she brought a horse in the manga, and she was drawn in a very large frame and had a flashier appearance than the anime. Also, when talking to Nanaba in the forest of giant trees, her drawings were close-ups in the manga, but the anime did not.
    Historia's feelings for Ymir,
    That it was cut in the anime that "Crysta is a girl in a picture book",
    Failure to properly represent the key characters in the story destroyed Crysta and Historia's character development, and led to the main plot of the story.
    When Ymir says, "You're trying to do good, aren't you?" Krista is depicted unaware, which is probably very similar to the principle of behavior of the ancestor Ymir.
    So although she wasn't intentionally playing Krista, you can see in the main story that changes were made to her character development.
    This alteration, the main bosom of the story, is really a stupid failure

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    First of all, the biggest mistake of this anime is that it specially draws the protagonist or the corps or certain characters
    And Krista was definitely a key person in this story from the very beginning.
    The problem is that witstudio didn't express that properly and cut a lot of things about Crysta. Because it also had a big impact on the expansion of the story up to the Mare edition and the change in the development
    ・ At that time, Attack on Titan became popular in anime in Japan.
    ・ Anime added original scenes to specific characters from the first period.
    ・ Since Season 2 to match the anime, the author has made major story changes.
    ・ The postponement of Crysta's activities in order to avoid the cancellation of the manga affected the anime.
    The anime portrayed her in a more feminine way.
    As a result, people's interests and concerns were concentrated on the protagonist and other characters, preventing them from moving Krista, the key person in the story. Especially the destruction of her character development in Season 3 of the anime, Mare hen
    In fact, the anime was modified to protect the hero image of the soldiers.
    And the biggest mistake is,
    ・ "Crysta is a girl in a picture book" = being the ancestor Ymir, and her upbringing told in the chapter "Crysta Lens" was cut in the anime.
    After season 2, on the wall there is a dialogue between Eren and Historia
    She becomes desperate to get Ymir back
    At that time, she confesses, "Krista is the girl in the picture book, the role I was given to live." The picture book of the earth demon and the ancestor Ymir showed that the girl Krista in the picture book is the ancestor Ymir at that time.
    However, all these things were cut in the anime and left even in the main part
    The actions of Ymir and Krista are very similar. The author foreshadowed from the early days
    ・ In Volume 4, the scene where Sascha is given bread. Longer and more impressive than in the anime, Crysta is drawn in close-up.
    She is depicted unconsciously doing useful actions for others.
    It is also manifested in Krista's actions to help Daz in the snowy mountains
    But the biggest problem is that witstudio did not properly express these
    Because it forced the role of the key person in the story to change, because it influenced the subsequent change in the development of the story

  • @yousss-rv8cp
    @yousss-rv8cp 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Kurumi, Crista, who appears in the ending of the first season, is modeled on the goddess Izun and Ymir's turn in the original work is increasing.
    Readers at the time thought that Crista was the child of royalty and that she held the key to this story.
    I miss those days very much.
    Although it was inconspicuous in the anime, in the manga the author drew her from the early days, no matter how small the frame.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    The royal edition of the manga was mainly Historia
    Wit Studios made Levi the main
    This is a big mistake
    Because Levi is not involved in the main plot of the story.
    Furthermore, female forms and large giants are above all
    The main plot of the story is Ymir, the ancestor of the giants, which is very similar to Historia's upbringing told in the chapter "Crysta Lens", and "Krista is the girl in the picture book".
    The behavior of the ancestor Ymir is very similar to Krista.
    It is unforgivable that the main plot of those stories, the key persons, was ruined by the anime side with a lot of cuts and changes.
    She said, "This is the only thing I can draw," and she was not present in the artist's group picture.
    The ending of this story did not turn out to be beautiful. It is the result of people not understanding the main plot of the story.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    The content of the monarchy itself was changed from the original plan, but the anime further modified it.
    That's probably because the popularity was concentrated on other characters.
    At the very least, the change of course is unforgivable that she willingly takes on the queen and proposes herself, that Krista is a girl in a picture book, and that she cut most of her upbringing.
    That it portrayed her more feminine than the manga (especially season 2 as well)
    It destroyed her character development
    For the readers of the manga, her actions in Mare after becoming queen were different from the characters of Krista and Historia up to that point, and it was sad.

  • @davidnobre5660
    @davidnobre5660 2 ปีที่แล้ว +12

    22:10 yeah Eren wants that Royal combo
    but for real, he was smiling because mikasa was happy
    probably the last time you see him smiling

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    If you read the original story from the early days, you will find that the key person in the story is Historia, and the author's "maternal affection. Eren becomes independent", but Eren and Mikasa weren't portrayed that way from the early days.
    I think it's more natural for Eren to have romantic feelings for Historia.
    That the anime portrayed the soldiers too much as heroes
    Cutting most of Historia's upbringing and scenes
    Adaptation of the anime's monarchy from the original
    "Crysta is a girl in a picture book" and cut that she is related to her ancestor Ymir,
    Historia's emotional outburst for Ymir, who breaks down crying and distraught when Ymir is gone,
    That Eren cut the conversation between Historia on the wall and in the hut.
    That the anime portrayed Krista more feminine than the manga
    As a result, even if you look at the reaction from the West, you have a misunderstanding view of Crysta.
    (The original Krista was not so feminine, but really an angel.)
    Her lack of success in the early stages
    It had a huge impact on her role as a key person in the story, the destruction of character development, the change in the development of the story
    Both in the anime and in the work she ended up being treated unfavorably
    In Japan, there are many anime factions such as Eren and Mikasa.
    The only way to match that would have been to destroy Historia's character development.
    What Attack on Titan became popular in anime
    Various modifications of the anime's monarchy, cuts of Historia's upbringing and most of the scenes, and cuts of the conversation between Eren and Historia in the hut
    Perhaps it will end as it was in the original...

  • @Ultraelectromagnetic
    @Ultraelectromagnetic 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    When it comes to Zeke's plan, it would've been more practical to let Zeke (who has royal blood) father as many children as possible from different mothers instead of making Historia give birth to as many children as possible. That way you get comparatively more children with royal blood to inherit the beast titan and you don't have to sacrifice the queen. But then if anyone in Paradis thought of that we wouldn't have our story. And in any case, Zeke had... other ideas :P

    • @dalanomccalla518
      @dalanomccalla518 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Spoilers
      Zeke refuses to have kids. His whole plan is to "save kids". He'd never breed anyone. Its against his goal.

    • @brunoramos7374
      @brunoramos7374 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Its more convenient to convince one woman who already has royal blood and is the queen to bear the burden of her and her children being basically sacrifices for the survival of their people than to convince several random women to do it, unless you wanted to trick them, but other problems arise with that route, its much better to have Historia consent to it

    • @Ultraelectromagnetic
      @Ultraelectromagnetic 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@dalanomccalla518 Hence my last sentence. Didn't want to spoil it lol.

    • @Ultraelectromagnetic
      @Ultraelectromagnetic 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@brunoramos7374 Ethics out the window (cuz it's AoT), the military junta of Paradis wouldn't have a problem finding people, willing or otherwise. The real hindrance was Zeke because of the spoiler reasons haha

    • @brunoramos7374
      @brunoramos7374 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@Ultraelectromagnetic yeah I know about the spoiler reasons, but I see no reason to not go into the "original" plan in more detail since it is never fully explained why it is the way it is and why it is accepted, another thing that I think is fair to point out is that the Paradis side never fully trusted Zeke, so saying that he would be the one having kids was immediatly out of the question, as the plan, which is already convenient to Zeke, would be almost fully in his control, he would hold a lot more negotiation power if he was the one who had to be the active party in having kids, that would be harder for the Paradis side to accept when put on the table compared to one of their own receiving the Beast Titan and having kids, in this situation Zeke is giving them a lot more and being pretty much a submissive party in the negotiations, which was most likely because he needed the deal to look as good as possible for it to be accepted, im just saying that there are other good in universe reasons for Zeke to say he will pass it on Historia other than "no one noticed that it would be more logical to have a man, who can make more children in less time, make said children"

  • @jon_odinson
    @jon_odinson 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    That "Threesome" comment got me xD. I never thought about it but it makes perfect sense, I mean it is the happies we've seen him post time skip = P

  • @fallenshadow7381
    @fallenshadow7381 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    armin wanted monster ep 24 s1 aot
    now his friend (eren) turn monster everyone wants to cut him down.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    \"Eren was happy to understand Historia,\" the author said of the conversation between the two.
    \"Crysta is the protagonist of the work that won the Newcomer Award\" and \"I was saved by Historia\" were the words of the author himself.
    The early names of Attack on Titan published by the author depicted Krista from the beginning.
    He said that at the direction of his editor, he postponed her appearance to avoid the cancellation of the manga.
    I should have let him play an active role sooner.
    The author left words of regret in the interview that I was not good enough.
    The editors liked Eren and Mikasa, and so did the anime to make Attack on Titan popular.
    The author said that Levi became too popular
    There are factions with Eremika, Elehis,
    In response to the question \"Many people who watch anime are Eremika\"
    \"I think it's better not to be with Eren for Mikasa's happiness.\"
    \"Eren becomes independent of Mikasa's maternal love.\"
    From the early days, the artist said that he drew Christa's face with great enthusiasm.
    He carefully drew her in every frame from the early days
    Changing the key person in the story changed Mikasa and the development of the story

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    If they had simply been giants versus humans and the content of the early plot of the monarchy, people might not have left.
    The monarchy also changed from the early plot.
    In Japan, Historia and Krista before becoming queens were popular.
    Since becoming queen, Historia feels that her femininity has disappeared.
    Her character was liked by both men and women. I loved her too.
    Also, in the manga Monarchy, she did not act on her own.
    She takes on the role of being threatened and becomes queen, and participates in the defeat of Rod Reiss, saying, "It's my fault that this happened."
    And Erwin's real purpose was to learn the secret of the Wall through her, with Historia as queen and the army at the helm.
    So Historia made that suggestion.
    However, the anime altered the story and the reason for her actions.
    Also in the manga her subsequent character development was destroyed.
    I didn't think that decision was correct.
    She is a good girl. I loved her character development, which was the last time she was with Ymir and said, "We're going to live for us."
    Probably everyone in Japan was.
    Her character may have been difficult to understand in the world of Attack on Titan in the West, but "Crysta is a girl in a picture book", and she was very good because she is. In Japan, it seems that the early readers have moved away from the monarchy and the number of followers has increased...

  • @gladefludiu
    @gladefludiu 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Just wanna say that one of the lines is mistranslated in the episode or the intentionally changed it. The line is "I always believed you would never sacrifice Historia", it obviously implies he decided to sacrifice her. The line from the manga is "I always knew you would never sacrifice Historia" and it implies the complete opposite.

  • @Nothingatallllll
    @Nothingatallllll 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    20:56 Grisha had eren after having the Attack titan so there is no conflict with havin g a titan and a baby at the same time.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    It is very unfortunate that we have modified Season 3 to protect the hero image of the protagonist and the anime soldiers.
    That is why the destruction of Historia's character development in the Mare edition was a tragedy for readers of the manga from the early days.
    She was always thinking about others, both Krista and Historia.
    Because the girl in the manga was really purity itself.
    Also, in the royal edition, Historia did not express her romantic feelings for Eren.
    She will not willingly become queen
    Ever since Ymir is gone, Historia has been depressed and depressed.
    I can see how much she cared about Ymir.
    The Legion thinks of Historia as a pawn
    "This is your fate," Levi threatens Historia.
    What the author portrayed in the Monarchy Edition was that the protagonist and the soldiers were not right.
    However, for not being able to convey this in both the manga and anime, and for the lack of depiction of Historia, the author apologized and said that "I was not good enough" and does not mention the work at all at present.
    As for Ymir and Historia, it ended up being left unattended.
    The destruction of the character development of the key person of the story and the destruction of the main plot of the story is a stupid failure
    The anime will end as Eren's story as people want
    From the early days of the manga, even if Eren was the main character, he was not portrayed as a special being.

  • @arytang9869
    @arytang9869 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    4:10 wait Alex speaks Chinese?!!!

    • @TheReactPack
      @TheReactPack  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Yep! Alex knows Mandarin! -Sam

    • @arytang9869
      @arytang9869 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@TheReactPack that's so cool!

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Where did the author's words "Mikasa is like a mother" disappear?
    that the creators of the anime did not have understanding and love for the work,
    Many cuts and changes to the scene of Krista,
    The scene with Eren and Historia was very cut in the anime
    This is the most common example of a character whose work has become popular in anime, favoring certain characters and destroying the development of the character, in anime. And, as people would like, Eren is the only one in the main story, ending with the end of Eren and Mikasa.
    The father of Historia's child ends up being a man who threw stones and bullied her in the past.
    Both in the work and in reality, Historia was a victim character. Early readers of the manga should have known that she was a key character in the story and that Ymir and Krista's relationship was related to Ymir.
    What was Historia's life like?
    What anime producers have done can never be forgiven.

  • @shawntalks2414
    @shawntalks2414 2 ปีที่แล้ว +26

    Eren grabbed hange bc she essentially trolling him and giving him ish for going threw with a plan that got his friend killed but ultimately worked but the so called leaders and smart ppl had three years and couldn’t find one but criticize him when felt this was the only way to go

    • @erenyeager6210
      @erenyeager6210 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Exactly bro they are just shit can't do anything except criticize

    • @kamranhussain5358
      @kamranhussain5358 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Trolling eren on his friends death is an exaggeration, it’s was to make him talk about his future plans

    • @backinmydaycartoons7957
      @backinmydaycartoons7957 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      This lacks nuance. Paradis wanted to find a plan that worked with minimal violence for both sides, a peaceful resolution. Eren got impatient, and didn't want to wait and risk seeing if a peaceful resolution was possible, hence taking power into his own hands. The so called leaders and smart people as you put it, could have easily came up with, and executed the same plan as eren, with a far more comprehensive and tactful approach, but they never wanted violence, and hence didn't enact such a plan. Eren's way was the violent way that happened to succeed, and due to the fact that Eren forced Paradis' hand, we'll never see if a peaceful solution was possible.

    • @Tcab96
      @Tcab96 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@backinmydaycartoons7957 Your comment lacks just as much nuance.
      Given that Armin, one of the smartest characters in the show/manga, was still wondering if there was a peaceful option while talking to Annie three years later, and Hange had no response to Eren asking if there was another way, I think it's safe to say they still didn't have a peaceful option in mind even after Marley had declared war. If they could've "easily" done it, then they would've, but everyone falls silent when asked for what the actual peaceful option is.
      While they're still wondering what the peaceful option is, Marley is declaring war and rallying nations to attack Paradis. A war they are almost guaranteed to lose if they let Marley act unchecked and without retaliation in some form.

    • @shawntalks2414
      @shawntalks2414 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@backinmydaycartoons7957 what was the peaceful option there wasn’t one like I said they basically gave eren no option I would spoil it for others but I’m not a douche but like I said the so called smart people essentially knew peace was never a option but still continued saying it up still with no plan to achieve this peace.Armin talking annie who’s mass murder instead coming with a plan and hange condemning everyone for there action but her own as a inept leader

  • @Diljabar
    @Diljabar 2 ปีที่แล้ว +22

    Let's go talk to Eren.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    It was a pity that the animation was directed.
    From the early days, in the manga, Eren and Historia were depicted in exactly the same pose when defeating a giant. I think this was foreshadowing. In real appointments.
    I think it was really a mistake that Krista and Historia were portrayed more feminine in the anime.
    She wears a skirt in the original, but she's not that feminine. It's pretty bluffy.
    The way she defeats her is not feminine either. I'm screaming, "Whoa!" In comics.
    Daz who appeared in the snowy mountains was also drawn because he had contact with Eren first, and the two were drawn in the early days.
    On the walls and in the hut, Eren and Historia have a lot of conversation.
    But all these were cut in the anime.
    The cut of Eren and Historia's conversation on the wall was also disappointing
    "I have to go to the other side of the wall as soon as possible," said Historia, who stood up in a state of remorse.
    "You'd better not stand yet," Eren stops.
    "Don't worry about me!" retorts Historia emphatically.
    "If you don't do it quickly, Ymir will go far," Eren says, looking at Historia who collapses in frustration.
    "I was only worried about you, and I was only thinking about you how you could survive in this situation."
    "Why... You can't leave me behind... I promised to live with you."
    Cutting this scene in the anime also led to the destruction of her character development.
    I think Eren is Mika Saend to match the anime
    Probably no different from the original
    In the cartoon, Erwin's face was hidden by a speech bubble as he vowed to the public, "I will clear this regret."
    I don't think I've ever seen such a rendition in anime.
    I think that the anime side portrayed the main characters and soldiers as heroes and special ones more than the manga, and the popularity of the work from the anime made Historia, who was a key person in the story, immovable.
    So a lot of things about her were cut in the anime. That's because people's attention turns to Eren.
    And Eren ended up carrying it all. I think so.

  • @sastaassh1112
    @sastaassh1112 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Eren is ripped everywhere 😂 it's just the animation studio messed it up with animation.

    • @foxillian13
      @foxillian13 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Yeah. Just in that one shot though. It's weird. Every other shot of his back looks fine lol

  • @annabellepajarito2373
    @annabellepajarito2373 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    6:31 the ending we need.

  • @Merctoonz
    @Merctoonz 2 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    They haven't revealed anyone's plan yet...!? Where are you guys getting this Zeke and Eren's plan from?

    • @brofst
      @brofst 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      the plan that yelena told them about last episode.

    • @Merctoonz
      @Merctoonz 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@brofst oh Yelena's plan. Not Zeke's or Eren's plan.

    • @brofst
      @brofst 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@Merctoonz it's Zeke's plan as communicated by Yelena, don't be obtuse.

    • @Merctoonz
      @Merctoonz 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@brofst The show hasn't shown Zeke even talking with Yelena about that plan. Not one scene, it's Yelena's plan until Zeke agrees or owns it

    • @brofst
      @brofst 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@Merctoonz she literally says "this is Zeke's plan". The scouts discuss it as "Zeke's plan". She is acting under orders from Zeke.

  • @comeatmebro8120
    @comeatmebro8120 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    You guys are so much more mature than I am to not make a 69 joke in the intro

  • @OmegaDenz96
    @OmegaDenz96 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    would someone pls tell if the origin of the 3D maneuver gear was explained in that manga "Before the Fall"? i believe the setting of that story was about 75-80 years ago before the fall of Wall Maria. did not continue reading it so maybe someone here did.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Since becoming queen, Historia feels like her femininity has disappeared.
    Although I don't think Krista and Historia are essentially the same.
    "Everyone was disappointed," Historia says.
    "There's no good kid like Crystallens, and Historia is a child who wasn't loved by his parents, a child who was never born and never wanted, and that's a common story in this world.
    "I don't know about the others, but I didn't like you before, I always felt like I was forcing myself to make a face, which was unnatural and honestly uncomfortable."
    "But you're good now."
    "No, you're normal, you're just a stupid, honest, normal guy."
    Eren and Historia meet face-to-face at the window in the hut during the first half of Season 3 while Armin and Jean are caught on their behalf in the Royal Edition.
    Leaving aside the love affair,
    This is also a scene where 15-year-olds save and be saved for each other.
    It is also the scene where the author says, "Eren was happy to understand Historia."
    The cut of this scene in the anime was unfortunate
    The modification of the anime's monarchy edition was unfortunate.
    Although the manga royal edition itself was changed from the original plan.
    However, the fact that Krista could not perform well in the early stages
    Story changes to retain the hero image of the Legion, Historia was sacrificed
    When Erwin learns that the Wraith family is the real royal family, he says, "If we crown Historieis as queen, our Legion will be at the helm," and "And we can get to the secrets of this wall."
    "Where's Eren and Historia?" asks Levi.
    "Where's Eren and Historia?"
    Erwin's words are repeated over and over again, emphasized in bold.
    On Erwin's orders, Levi blackmails Historia.
    It was unfortunate that this flow was also altered.

    • @evanreynolds1034
      @evanreynolds1034 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      bro you have commented a whole essay with all these comments and nobody is gonna read them lol

  • @mysub6969
    @mysub6969 ปีที่แล้ว

    21:10 why they looking at each other like that 👀👀

  • @skribe
    @skribe 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    heres the kicker with sasha and nicolo. in japanese the name Nicolo and Meat sound similar so sashas last words may have been Nicolos name.

  • @thalunizz21
    @thalunizz21 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Things are getting even more complicated, things aren't the same anymore with our group.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Isn't it that people forget what the main plot of this story was?
    It may be a tragedy caused by Ellen believers
    The Historia thing was especially neglected and ended
    The ending of the anime will not be changed
    The ending of the story was never completed. That is, the anime side favored certain characters and cut and modified a lot of Crysta, who is a key person in the story.
    That's probably the result of not being able to move the key person in the story.
    Among the collective characters drawn by the author, saying "I can only draw this" and "I am not good enough", Historia was not the only one among the 104th class students.
    Perhaps that's the answer
    That Wit Studio made cuts and changes to various things about her
    Dialogue between Eren and Historia
    Changes to the monarchy to protect the hero image of the Corps
    The original story showed that she could not escape the heavy responsibility she was born with.
    She was so pitiful
    She is in a state of remorse and does not do it on her own accord
    Was not such a character
    It was sad that the readers of the manga were forced to sacrifice her precisely because they knew that she was not such a character
    A modification of what I voluntarily took on in Season 3
    Season 3 focused on the confrontation between Levi and Kenny
    It was the worst thing
    It was incomprehensible to the readers of the manga that her character was suddenly destroyed in accordance with the anime in the Mare hen

  • @jojy43568
    @jojy43568 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    I love dannys voice idk if thats a weird thing to say lol

  • @hikskrchi1828
    @hikskrchi1828 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    "what actually can youd? if you got something up your sleeve, let's hear it"
    damn.

  • @stanleyho8009
    @stanleyho8009 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    4:10 Bro did my mans just speak Chinese? What the hell?!

  • @ashikshaikh7861
    @ashikshaikh7861 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    As always your reactions are super good and you all are pretty good making theories. Have a great day💖🔥

    • @ashikshaikh7861
      @ashikshaikh7861 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@johanneseiche664 u need some help bro?

  • @GreywardenRimu
    @GreywardenRimu 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    0:09 NOICE

  • @davidnobre5660
    @davidnobre5660 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    18:55 that would be cool to see

  • @felixmejia10
    @felixmejia10 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    OMGGGGGGGGG MORGAN SAID EREN!!!! The biggest war in the fandom. EreHisu vs EreMIka.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Viewers of Eren followers are the same as Mikasa and blind to Eren
    And the end of this story is that Eren loses sight of the main plot of the story and the key people, and in the end does not know what he wanted to do.

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    To begin with, Mikasa, the heroine of the story, was rather in the foreground in the manga from the early days.
    The anime drew too much of the protagonist, the corps, and certain characters so specially that they could not move the key people of the story, Krista and Historia, and they could not do anything. Because she was always in a position where she was susceptible to radical fans, bashing. People's attention was focused on other people. This is the result of readers and anime enthusiasts taking him too specially.
    In the original story, the conversation between Eren and Historia was not meshed and made no sense. However, it was probably tailored to the anime school.
    The anime's royal chapter was also altered, but the original monarchy edition was also changed from its original plan, and the thing about Historia was the most tragic character with so many cuts and modifications. Even during the work, it was not handled well.
    With the collapse of the main plot of the story, this story collapsed.

  • @davidnobre5660
    @davidnobre5660 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    15:45 not sad, to rage

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Krista is a character that is preferred by both men and women in appearance and character in Japan. Many women have loved her since she was a crysta.
    I wonder if it was different in the West ...?
    The reader knows that changing her name does not change her essence is a good girl ... Her birthday is January 15, which is Good Boy's Day.
    In Japan, Historia before she became queen was probably more popular than after she became queen.
    Her personality was not always properly represented in anime....
    Japan, both men and women, when I was with Krista and Ymir, when she called herself Historia, she was lively and everyone loved her.
    The anime and the author destroyed her character development....

  • @user-fv7wb4vu5l
    @user-fv7wb4vu5l 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    The author said that the robe that Historia is wearing matches Ymir's 104th class ...
    It's stupid that people forgot the main plot of the story
    From the beginning, the author did not portray Eren as something special, saying that he was a slave to the story.
    Also, what about romance in the Attack on Worldview, it was not suggested that Eren and Mikasa would have such a relationship.
    Sascha's Niccolò too... It was surprising that the characters had a romantic relationship.
    And... Mappa would have drawn the monarchy as it was in the original...
    Historia's scenes have been cut and altered a lot.
    The dialogue between Eren and Historia is also ... (In the Royal Edition, Historia thinks nothing of Eren because she thinks about Ymir all the time.)
    It is a big failure of this anime
    This work is the result of losing the main plot of the story.
    The ending was never completed
    It's the result of anime bringing combat to the fore in Giants vs. Humans
    A work that loses a key person in the story by cutting or modifying a lot in anime will not be beautiful.
    Historia's great affection for Ymir, the 104th class student (that's how Historia read Ymir's letter, "You're an idiot... Ymir. I don't know this."), Crysta cut and altered the foreshadowing of the girl in the picture book in the anime.
    It's stupid to cut a lot of her scenes
    Ancestor Ymir and Mikasa have nothing in common
    It was Krista who was very similar. The principle of action, the upbringing.
    It is unforgivable that Wit Studios altered it as a cut.
    It's the destruction of the main plot of the story.

  • @khotunkhan3950
    @khotunkhan3950 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Jeez I was soo disappointed in Armin this episode

  • @yousss-rv8cp
    @yousss-rv8cp 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    From the early days of the manga Historia, when she was Crysta, her appearance and gestures were not drawn in such a feminine way.
    In the previous company anime, the female characters were drawn too femininely, and the author was angry about lipstick.
    In the anime, many scenes of Historia have been cut and changed since the early days. (There are no other characters) and her treatment has always been unfavorable in anime.
    From how she became queen, her pregnancy was really shocking and sad for the readers of the manga.

  • @sastaassh1112
    @sastaassh1112 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Historia is pregnant who would be the father 😏 maybe his name starts with E 😏

    • @nhy4313
      @nhy4313 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Of course is Econnie

    • @subarashii95
      @subarashii95 2 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      It starts with F and ends with kun

  • @TVGameControl
    @TVGameControl 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    6:32 that boi EREN YAEGER 😎😂😂

  • @GTRMclaren722
    @GTRMclaren722 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    This is a clear example of less is more. Hope your girls return to just 2.

  • @patatebanine4278
    @patatebanine4278 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    6:32

  • @miggybluesky
    @miggybluesky 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    I love you, Dani!

  • @imposter1415
    @imposter1415 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    I'm making a live action aot video as well.

  • @felixmejia10
    @felixmejia10 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Any manga readers? I really want to talk about Mikasa's azumabito mark. I'll put a spoiler warning
    SPOILER
    In the added pages, its clearly implied that Mikasa didn't pass on her mark. Did she or no? She clearly kept her bandage on for her entire life, even when she was buried. Isayama put heavy emphasis on that. She definitely had a family but seem not to pass it on. I would expect her to pass it on as her beloved Mother said so. Pls don't be toxic

  • @visualityyt6594
    @visualityyt6594 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    14:38 :)nice

  • @kiomusashi4022
    @kiomusashi4022 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    6:28 omg xD

  • @vinren3893
    @vinren3893 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    I can’t concentrate cause sam looking too good 😭