Different effects on different people m8. Composers do. Not trash artists that sold their souls to the devil for fame. Also it was only because of pagan religious rites that involved the misuse of instruments that your religion could be said to outlaw music in general.
I’ve been studying effects of music from Medical, religious and personal journey... After deep analysis I have had to give up music and it by far was One of the most difficult things I’ve done in my life. Interestingly once I gave it up I actually found I was able to do something that I had not been able to do before (lower my gaze in relation to looking at women).
Absolute nonsense! Music has always been part of Muslim culture and banning it on the basis of questionable hadiths is ridiculous! It is this kind of thinking that has brought the Islamic world to its present sorry state!
Imam Phillip's take is a reasonable judgement. But it's also very subjective. How authentic are those hadith he mentioned? I was told there is some doubt about them. And they there is the matter of hadith that he does not mention where the rasool pbuh allowed certain music to be played in honor of him. Why can't we consider that as valid as well? And there is no specific condemnation of music in the Quran as well. So what I've found is that most scholars object to the lifestyles that go along with music. Music tends to accompany gatherings or moments where humans want to break free from restrictions. This often leads to debauchery, because humans tend to do things excessively. But if you're praying your Salat, reading the Quran, avoiding excessive debauchery, and generally living a wholesome life, what is music gonna do to hurt you?
The life of the musician reflects their is a good example. Thank you. I am a Christian just seeking understanding of Islam. In my church, some music is frowned on. Like angry music or music with ungodlieness. I thought I share one reason I found out why some music is harmful. Some music disengage the brains frontal lobes. This opens the brain to suggestion. Another reason is the rythem in music effects the body. Fast loud music raises the heart rate. Some people think music releases anger. But that angry music only increases and maintains the anger. I struggle with temptation of certain music. I thought I share what I learnt and I hope thats ok. I have research more about why adult female singing is not allowed in Islam.
I am convert, May Allah guide you to islam, this is the path we have been give by the Lord of all the universe. and it's path very similar to Christianity and Islam. I would recommend reading the quran the unchanged words of God 😊
@@ehsanasgar7660 may I ask why you converted to Islam? I am a Christian interested in Islam, and I would just like to hear what convinced you to convert :)
Well after reading so many peoples negative comment on this post i would like to state that this video was all about Islam and for its followers so folks of other religion shouldn't or dont need to say anything on this kind of video, No one needs to prove anyone wrong in case of this kind of matter. Let all the religious people live alone for the sake of Mankind please.
They dont know what music is. They are dumb. They say singing is NOT music. LOL. These scholars should try and learn fundamentals of music. They cant behead every bird singing.
+Perfect Piano haha that's funny and I'd like to add to it, singing is not music, gotta put a lil drum or piano then u get music btw check Google for definition of music
The question is between gud and bad music..... Some says all music is haram... But some says not all but bad music is haram...... I think all muslim community should clearify this issue.... .
Islam doesn't prohibit music nor it promotes. Quran says nothing about music. Music is a language and in any language its the use of words and content which matters. Its a genral missconception in Muslims Islam is not a religion where you try to follow happenings in that erra its about the rules and regulations set by Muhammad PBUH by the order of Allah. So if the content of music is promoting vulgerity or hate it must be forbidden and if it is promoting love and respect it should be appreciated.
I'm a non-Muslim, and a Catholic Christian who is also musician; that upfront - I can understand the argument in regard to vocal music that promotes a lifestyle that would be against what is allowed in the Qu'ran and the Hadith (Christian Evangelicals have long made a similar argument, but as it relates to moral prohibitions in the Bible), but what is the Islamic stance upon non-vocal music (i.e. instrumental only)? Plato himself, 400 B.C.E., remarked upon the power of music in both its positive and negative aspects. Secondarily, what would be the response to the argument that beauty - including music, instead of detracting us from God, draws us closer to God? Peace.
brother i used to think like that too until i faced my self with the facts , music ,musical instruments , vocals , whatever it distracts our soul and conscioussness from the state of god consciousness from the state of obediance and worship ( khushuu ) .
I am a muslim and i agree with you totally for surely without doubt there is that music which is spiritual and moving and which brings tears to the eyes.
Please for the love of God Almighty use some logic. I listen to good music and i have never felt so close to God Almighty. I read my salah regularly as well as the Quran which is my daily ritual. So dont make up things.
@@moezhamouda3248 Anything can do that m8. Whether that’s your family, friends, sports, etc, even your own life. This is why Jesus said that anyone who comes to him and does not hate family, friends, and his own life cannot be his disciple.
Ok i got it after watching this video.. According to islam gud music is not haram but depending on it and following its dark side is ban... it corrupt us....
Many people have sensory disorders, which makes it difficult to distinguish different sounds, over another. It's not their fault. Some people cannot read or struggle to read subtitles fast- it seems the option which would afford better ease of understanding to people, is to just lose the music.
Very good points. Consider a few additions. There are claims that some specific frequencies can be beneficial, incl 432 Hz, and this is correct. This does not mean music. These frequencies can simple be "beep beep" sounds (Isochronic tones), or a long beep (Monaural tones), and such tones can be used for healing a variety of illnesses. There was a 2003 study by NASA which documented that 10 Hz among others when played to come tissues (group of cells) for over 20 days, 150 or so maturation genes reverted to developmental genes. That's big news. But that's just tones. Anyways, even music has been used in therapy even by Muslim, even a 1000 years ago. I believe it is OK provided it is not being used for entertainment or anything vain, but for a purpose so useful such as healing. Surah Luqman 31:6 can be used to understand that as well; that those who purchase "vain talks" (singing, music etc.) will have a grievous penalty... The word used for "vain" is "lahwa" which means a sport or entertainment. This does not mean we can't use it for therapeutic purposes, I believe. It is worthy to see this another answer by a doctor and scholar th-cam.com/video/7ILZmpFDQHY/w-d-xo.html Hope this will be helpful in adding a bit more info about the topic. Reiterating, Dr BiIaI was clear and taught the facts clearly. There was just one missing piece of course, and that was not totally out of place because he was discussing about the "issues today", which is clearly using music for play and entertainment.
Musical instruments only produce melodic sound that can affect our emotions, whoever has studied the theory of music they know certain chords and combinations can make feel sad while others boost your mood, etc. Depending on the compositions and performance on particular instrument it may sound beautiful or ugly, sad or happy, etc. All that combined with lyrics makes it more influential on the emotions. Musicians with dirty mind and evil intentions are indeed able to produce evil music. But not all out there is evil, is it? Why the vast majority of Quran reciters and muadhins do not recite plainly in one frequency but their voice goes up and down and creates a melody, simply it is more beautiful, is it not. As the scholar said, music is not prohibited outright, on contrary for example pork and alcohol and adultery are prohibited outright. Sure we have to be picky and careful of what we listen to. I have heard a prominent Islamic scholar Abdullah bin Bayyah (and many others) saying that music in general (especially the western) is not permissible, however on his tweeter he follows a musician Maher Zain, his songs are mostly considered anasheed. There are many others. Yusuf Islam (Cat Stevens) is a extremely famous musician and seriously practicing Muslim.
At the golden age of Islam. Muslims were pioneers of music. In that time Muslims made the biggest contributions to mankind in terms of science. Muslims even invented the guitar for heavens sake. Then the wobblers came and it slowly became Haraam. Now I understand why ignorance is sin. There is an authendic hadith, where Aisha as was listening to music and Abu Bakr (as) who thought he knew Islam better than the Prophet pbuh reprimanded Aisha (as) while in the presence of the Prophet (pbuh) who was resting. As soon as the prophet heard this he condemned Abu Bakr and took Aisha’s as side. Bukhari no 907 Maybe we have come to this position on music because we have too many muslims that are in the same state as Abu Bakr (as) was at that moment these days. In the days of the Prophet pbuh Abysinian slaves used to dance with music in the mosques in front of the Prophet pbuh. Dont listen to these Imam robots. They only preach and don’t question their own ideologies. Music is part of human nature. To go against makes you inhuman and close minded. Furthermore a holy book sent by Allah to a prophet was named the Book of Songs. Why would Allah (swt) name his holy book that is related to songs if it was haraam? The other Abrahamic faiths never had any issues with music. And dont try to use that purposely manipulated and purposely mistranslated quranic verse either. Idle talk does not equate to music but equates to Idlesness! Don’t try to twist it to get what you want. Ever wonder why Sufism allows Music in mosques. Ever wonder why the sufis were the biggest defenders of Islam during the Mongol era. Ever wonder why the honored person mentioned in the Quran that would conquer Constantinople was a Sufi? Maybe they were closer to Islam than those other weak Muslims sects were at that time. Maybe we drifted away from the truth and mistook our condemnation for things we dont understand as a sign of faith. For example, the Burka has nothing to do with Islam, yet muslim women wear it as a badge of honour for their faith. I guess we are all looking for badges for Allah swt even if we have ro make them up. In a nutshell, I call it blindly self deprivation to falsely prove your faith in contradiction to the teachings of Islam. I swear if marriage wasn’t mentioned in the Quran you hardcore muslims would of turned out just like the christian monks! Hitting themselves, locking themselves up for days, not eating or speaking for years and abstaining from marriage in the name of devotion to God.
@shahwaiz niazi Speech is very powerful and can lead people astray! After all Adolf Hitler managed to gain control of Germany through his speeches and then went on to commit great evil! So should we then ban speech? Muslims need to get their heads out of the sand and think for themselves! Blind taqleed is harmful!
@@Sag7789 our prophet (saw) has permitted the use of duff in the sahih hadith, and the duff was a popular type of musical instruments. The arabs used to celebrate their joy by playing duff. Anas ibn Malik reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, passed by some of the girls of Medina and they were playing their drums and singing the words, “Muhammad is an excellent neighbor! We are neighbors from the tribe of Najjar!” The Prophet said, “Verily, Allah knows that you are dear to me.” Source: Sunan Ibn Majah 1899 Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani Abdullah ibn Amr reported: A woman came to the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, and she said, “O Messenger of Allah, I have made a vow I will play the drum for you.” The Prophet said, “Fulfill your vow.” She said, “I have made a vow to sacrifice at a certain place where they slaughtered in the time of ignorance.” The Prophet said, “For an idol?” She said no. The Prophet said, “For an image?” She said no. The Prophet said, “Fulfill your vow.” Source: Sunan Abī Dāwūd 3312 Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani
music, and sound in general is very powerful, especially for humans but effective on every living and even non living object. Music can do what even drugs cannot sometimes. Music is more influential & humans are much more susceptible to it. We have seen that hypnosis in many instances uses music. Music can be incredibly destructive OR seemingly super powered. The clear cut reason for it's limitation and prohibition lies in the simple fact that it is TOO POWERFUL. A major part of cults is music, like these emos and metal etc (not to blame anyone) and it is clear they have a substantial effect on humans. So it would be likely that God would place a barrier on the use of music to stop it's power from corrupting us.
People who havent experienced the serenity of Quran will never understand this....Alhumdulillah living by the perfect set of rules and a purpose within...
Human vocal chords and wind pipes are like strings and wind instruments so my dear fellow Muslims!!!!!!!! Should we not even talk anymore????? This is a simple example of how Islam is being misunderstood in many ways. Yes there are music that promote sex, drugs, and a freakish lifestyle but music has nothing to do with that. We live in a time where one song worth a hundred lectures if used wisely.
Assalamu'alikum I got your every point clearly Masha'allah super explained! I listening Islamic song which one coled Nasheed with instruments is it prohibited ? If its not affecting society or anything & retune back me good thinking from lots of bad activities. Before I have listened so many Movies, Drama, singer's music maximum opposite from Islamic Coulter which one badly affecting my Religion activity's I did not regular in prayers or anything, when I have started Listening Islamic Song means Nasheed I try my best & performing maximum religions activities & and try to protect my self from all kinds of bad habits Alhamdulillah Nasshed not affecting bad anything in my attitude I have realized it hearty.Dear sir Dr.Billal Philips
I've been having those concerns as well, becasue those instruments are very ancient and core to my culture. Therefore they're often played in very respectable and cultural settings. Indonesia, a predominant muslim nation, has certain music traditions predates which islam and still are played during Islamic rituals.
The question is, (not taking into account the lyrics), does cultural south east asian melodies affects our body , the same way as Nasheed' s melodies played with not-wind-and-string- instruments.
At the golden age of Islam. Muslims were pioneers of music. In that time Muslims made the biggest contributions to mankind in terms of science. Muslims even invented the guitar for heavens sake. Then the wobblers came and it slowly became Haraam. Now I understand why ignorance is sin. There is an authendic hadith, where Aisha as was listening to music and Abu Bakr (as) who thought he knew Islam better than the Prophet pbuh reprimanded Aisha (as) while in the presence of the Prophet (pbuh) who was resting. As soon as the prophet heard this he condemned Abu Bakr and took Aisha’s as side. Bukhari no 907 Maybe we have come to this position on music because we have too many muslims that are in the same state as Abu Bakr (as) was at that moment these days. In the days of the Prophet pbuh Abysinian slaves used to dance with music in the mosques in front of the Prophet pbuh. Dont listen to these Imam robots. They only preach and don’t question their own ideologies. Music is part of human nature. To go against makes you inhuman and close minded. Furthermore a holy book sent by Allah to a prophet was named the Book of Songs. Why would Allah (swt) name his holy book that is related to songs if it was haraam? The other Abrahamic faiths never had any issues with music. And dont try to use that purposely manipulated and purposely mistranslated quranic verse either. Idle talk does not equate to music but equates to Idlesness! Don’t try to twist it to get what you want. Ever wonder why Sufism allows Music in mosques. Ever wonder why the sufis were the biggest defenders of Islam during the Mongol era. Ever wonder why the honored person mentioned in the Quran that would conquer Constantinople was a Sufi? Maybe they were closer to Islam than those other weak Muslims sects were at that time. Maybe we drifted away from the truth and mistook our condemnation for things we dont understand as a sign of faith. For example, the Burka has nothing to do with Islam, yet muslim women wear it as a badge of honour for their faith. I guess we are all looking for badges for Allah swt even if we have ro make them up. In a nutshell, I call it blindly self deprivation to falsely prove your faith in contradiction to the teachings of Islam. I swear if marriage wasn’t mentioned in the Quran you hardcore muslims would of turned out just like the christian monks! Hitting themselves, locking themselves up for days, not eating or speaking for years and abstaining from marriage in the name of devotion to God.
Well on an abstract level, I agree with most of your claim. But I can't verify few of the points you make. My take is, not everything is a matter of religion and our this habit of radicalizing everything by means of religion is poisonous.
At the golden age of Islam. Muslims were pioneers of music. In that time Muslims made the biggest contributions to mankind in terms of science. Muslims even invented the guitar for heavens sake. Then the wobblers came and it slowly became Haraam. Now I understand why ignorance is sin. There is an authendic hadith, where Aisha as was listening to music and Abu Bakr (as) who thought he knew Islam better than the Prophet pbuh reprimanded Aisha (as) while in the presence of the Prophet (pbuh) who was resting. As soon as the prophet heard this he condemned Abu Bakr and took Aisha’s as side. Bukhari no 907 Maybe we have come to this position on music because we have too many muslims that are in the same state as Abu Bakr (as) was at that moment these days. In the days of the Prophet pbuh Abysinian slaves used to dance with music in the mosques in front of the Prophet pbuh. Dont listen to these Imam robots. They only preach and don’t question their own ideologies. Music is part of human nature. To go against makes you inhuman and close minded. Furthermore a holy book sent by Allah to a prophet was named the Book of Songs. Why would Allah (swt) name his holy book that is related to songs if it was haraam? The other Abrahamic faiths never had any issues with music. And dont try to use that purposely manipulated and purposely mistranslated quranic verse either. Idle talk does not equate to music but equates to Idlesness! Don’t try to twist it to get what you want. Ever wonder why Sufism allows Music in mosques. Ever wonder why the sufis were the biggest defenders of Islam during the Mongol era. Ever wonder why the honored person mentioned in the Quran that would conquer Constantinople was a Sufi? Maybe they were closer to Islam than those other weak Muslims sects were at that time. Maybe we drifted away from the truth and mistook our condemnation for things we dont understand as a sign of faith. For example, the Burka has nothing to do with Islam, yet muslim women wear it as a badge of honour for their faith. I guess we are all looking for badges for Allah swt even if we have ro make them up. In a nutshell, I call it blindly self deprivation to falsely prove your faith in contradiction to the teachings of Islam. I swear if marriage wasn’t mentioned in the Quran you hardcore muslims would of turned out just like the christian monks! Hitting themselves, locking themselves up for days, not eating or speaking for years and abstaining from marriage in the name of devotion to God.
I think this is a very good argument. However, evil things are not concentrated amongst musicians, it just so happens that people make musicians into famous people, and put them in the news. So of those musicians who are deviants, of course it is always made into a big news story. I see just as many non-musicians doing wrongful things, and just as many musicians leading righteous lives and inspiring spirituality in others, but these righteous and humble musicians are not 'cool' enough to make it into the mass media.
I've heard this explanation several times, but it is a logical fallacy. An edict from one thousand years ago, cannot be justified by looking at conditions in the present day.
Especially when those conditions were wildly different. Since an industry never even arose out of music back then. It would make more sense if they contextualized it with the fact that the surrounding society was pagan, and they misused a bunch of things, such as Music and statues, but that really didn’t occur to them.
It doesn't say anything about music in the quran itself as far as I know. The one aya where it talks about idle speech is clearly not talking about music in general but rather any kind of idle talk that is intended to make people stray away from the deen. It's especially clear when you read the reason that aya came down.
So what do you suggest? God send another prophet or angels should come down to earth to interpret the Quran? Of course the Quran is going to be interpreted by humans, and they will interpret it in light of their experiences and in the age they live in!
@@godzilla8574 As the Quran says, "Rabbis and monks determined what was lawful and what was not instead of God." (The Quran, 9:31). The Islamic scholars have manipulated hadiths and sunnah to create a religion of their own!
See all these declarations about music is haram, entertainment is haram, having fun is haram etc. Islam is a religion of ease and moderation. I studied and have faith enough to know this is not a religion that makes ones life void of entertainment. Not all music leads to evil, yes some does. In the same argument your smartphone and computer can lead you to evil (pornography, witchcraft), does that make your computer evil in and of itself? Hence the whole "Because it leads to evil, its prohibited" logic does not make sense. The Prophet Muhammad peace and blessing upon him was ok with singing and beating of drums before him. The one hadith that refers against music is questionable but even taken in translation it associates people who will drink alcohol, commit adultery all the while listening to music (Which we clearly see today). Does it make any sense to say music that puts babies to sleep, that makes the hardworking men of labor work more efficient, melodies that come out of the birds and animals is somehow evil? brothers and sisters we must be very careful to call haram what is not haram, Allah almighty warned us from doing this Say: Have you considered what provision Allah has sent down for you, how you have made of it lawful and unlawful? Say: Has Allah permitted you, or do you invent a lie concerning Allah?”(Yunus: 59) .
The background sound is horrible and it is louder than the voice of the sheikh himself !!! I couldnt concentrate on what he said iam so distracted by those aaaaaaa in the background !! Subhana Allah
Bilal Phillips speaks for the Salafiyyah. But according to Ahlus Sunnah there is ikhtilaf. By the way the Hadith does not say musical Instruments. It says ma'azif and it means entertainment but some Interpret it as music. This is another Proof why it is so important to listen to really knowledgeable people.
@@danialshah2957 Entertainment is allowed as well as music is actually a topic of ikhtilaf. Some big Ulama like Imam al Ghazali and Imam Ibn Hazm allowed Music. But the Salafiyyah claims there was ijmah in this topic which ist clearly wrong. The Ahlus Sunnah in fact is very rich in opinions. We have still four madhabs but the Salafiyyah claims an own way for themselves to be the one and only truth. They do Not have a madhab so they call their way Manhaj as Salafiyyah. It derives from a modernistic sect called al Wahabiyyah.
The man above is not knowledgable enough. Read Sahih Bukhari & Muslim Hadith] Volume 2, Book 15, Number 103 to confirm my observation. Not all music is haram. The music that is seductive, profain, or that which incites to improper actions is haram. However, the music that is comforting, harmonious or that will increase you to do good things is permissible. As a matter of fact, we know from the authentic traditions that the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, not only allowed music in the weddings but also listened to girls singing: While listening to girls singing on such an occasion, he interrupted them only once when they sang the following verse, “In our midst is a prophet who knows what will happen tomorrow”; whence, the Prophet, peace be upon him, told them, “Cut this sentence out, and continue singing what you had been singing earlier.”
Volume 2, Book 15, Number 103 : Narrated by 'Urwa on the authority of 'Aisha On the days of Mina, (11th, 12th, and 13th of Dhul-Hijjah) Abu Bakr came to her while two young girls were beating the tambourine and the Prophet was lying covered with his clothes. Abu Bakr scolded them and the Prophet uncovered his face and said to Abu Bakr, "Leave them, for these days are the days of 'Id and the days of Mina." 'Aisha further said, "Once the Prophet was screening me and I was watching the display of black slaves in the Mosque and ('Umar) scolded them. The Prophet said, 'Leave them. O Bani Arfida! (carry on), you are safe (protected)'." Your hadith says nothing specifically about music except perhaps that he tolerated the tamborines. But hadith are not very reliable. There were thousands of fabricated ahadith and Bukhari had an impossible task to sort through them. In any case I agree, we do not need to attach a prohibition to music, the prohibition should be attached to the associated thoughts and actions.
Many pieces of music are things of great skill, creativity, passion, and beauty, including music of stringed and wind instruments and music sung by female singers and there is nothing wrong with that. And there is lots of awful stuff where every second word is a profanity. Its ridiculous to make this a religious issue.
At the golden age of Islam. Muslims were pioneers of music. In that time Muslims made the biggest contributions to mankind in terms of science. Muslims even invented the guitar for heavens sake. Then the wobblers came and it slowly became Haraam. Now I understand why ignorance is sin. There is an authendic hadith, where Aisha as was listening to music and Abu Bakr (as) who thought he knew Islam better than the Prophet pbuh reprimanded Aisha (as) while in the presence of the Prophet (pbuh) who was resting. As soon as the prophet heard this he condemned Abu Bakr and took Aisha’s as side. Bukhari no 907 Maybe we have come to this position on music because we have too many muslims that are in the same state as Abu Bakr (as) was at that moment these days. In the days of the Prophet pbuh Abysinian slaves used to dance with music in the mosques in front of the Prophet pbuh. Dont listen to these Imam robots. They only preach and don’t question their own ideologies. Music is part of human nature. To go against makes you inhuman and close minded. Furthermore a holy book sent by Allah to a prophet was named the Book of Songs. Why would Allah (swt) name his holy book that is related to songs if it was haraam? The other Abrahamic faiths never had any issues with music. And dont try to use that purposely manipulated and purposely mistranslated quranic verse either. Idle talk does not equate to music but equates to Idlesness! Don’t try to twist it to get what you want. Ever wonder why Sufism allows Music in mosques. Ever wonder why the sufis were the biggest defenders of Islam during the Mongol era. Ever wonder why the honored person mentioned in the Quran that would conquer Constantinople was a Sufi? Maybe they were closer to Islam than those other weak Muslims sects were at that time. Maybe we drifted away from the truth and mistook our condemnation for things we dont understand as a sign of faith. For example, the Burka has nothing to do with Islam, yet muslim women wear it as a badge of honour for their faith. I guess we are all looking for badges for Allah swt even if we have ro make them up. In a nutshell, I call it blindly self deprivation to falsely prove your faith in contradiction to the teachings of Islam. I swear if marriage wasn’t mentioned in the Quran you hardcore muslims would of turned out just like the christian monks! Hitting themselves, locking themselves up for days, not eating or speaking for years and abstaining from marriage in the name of devotion to God.
@@ACEofficial7 Agree with your strong statement! Not convinced the hadith are as authentic as Dr Philips says, and in any case they are historical, not universal.
@@roberthannah7983 Wasnt originally going to reply to trolls. Dude literally spammed most of the comments. But seeing as people agree to his comments. I am going to give my opinion as a contrast to his.
@@ACEofficial7 Too many things wrong with your comment. I will try to provide clarification to as much as I can. *"At the golden age of Islam. Muslims were pioneers of music. In that time..."* The golden age of Islam wasnt the time period you are referring to, the golden age of Islam was when Prophet (Peace be upon him) was alive. Then when the Khalifa were still ruling. Then the next was when the Sahaba were around. Then when the Tabiun were still around... and so on and on. As time goes on, it will only get worse and the end times will be the worst. Why? Well, when the Prophet (Peace be upon him), he could still guide us with his divine guidance that came directly from Allah, which is no longer the case. Which is why right after he (Peace be upon him) died, there were too many false Hadiths. Then there is also the issue of Sects. “My ummah will split into seventy-three sects, all of whom will be in the Fire except one sect.” They said: Who are they, O Messenger of Allah? He said: “[Those who follow] the path which I and my companions follow.” -Tirmidhi (2641) Since Shia began and the Ummah split right after Prophet (Peace be upon him) died, we cannot consider any other time as "Golden age of Islam" other than the time of the Prophet (Peace be upon him). *"Muslims even invented the guitar for heavens sake. "* I am sorry, what? How does Muslims doing anything or saying anything mean Islam allows it? A Muslim can drink, well some do drink alcohol nowadays, how does it mean Islam allows it? *"Now I understand why ignorance is sin."* Ignorance is not sin. Refusing to listen to reason and follow the truth after the message of Prophet (Peace be upon him) reaches someone is considered a sin i.e. Shirk. Its like saying people who didnt know earth was round in the past sinned bc of not knowing it. *"There is an authendic hadith, where Aisha as was listening to music and Abu Bakr (as) who thought he knew Islam better than the Prophet pbuh reprimanded Aisha (as) while in the presence of the Prophet (pbuh) who was resting.* *As soon as the prophet heard this he condemned Abu Bakr and took Aisha’s as side. Bukhari no 907"* Wow man. You have bent the Hadith as much as you could. In the Hadith, Aisha (May Allah be pleased with her) was listening to two girls singing. And it is widely agreed upon that singing is halal, music is not. And also, the Prophet (Peace be upon him) turned the other way after he said "Leave them be", he did not take Aisha (May Allah be pleased with her) to his side bc Aisha (May Allah be pleased with her) didnt make any claim that he would need to side with her nor did he codemn Abu Bakr (May Allah be pleased with him). Where did you source your Hadith from? It was also Bukhari 949 not 907. -________- *"In the days of the Prophet pbuh Abysinian slaves used to dance with music in the mosques in front of the Prophet pbuh."* And? What does it prove? It took 23 years of Prophethood to reveal the Quran. Not every Fiqh rulling came down on day 1. Nor did everything halal and haram was revealed on day 1. Muslim didnt pray towards the Kabah early on. And Alcohol wasnt announced haram early on. *"Furthermore a holy book sent by Allah to a prophet was named the Book of Songs. Why would Allah (swt) name his holy book that is related to songs if it was haraam?"* Its like asking why did Allah reveal 104 books before sending Quran, the perfect book. You are questioning Allah's wisdom for the way He has done things. Wait hold on... You made the claim that Sufism is tight and they are on the Sunnah more than the Ahl-ul Jama'ah. And you later on also make the claim that Burqa/Niqab has nothing to do with Islam. At this point, I cant tell if you are genuine Muslim who follows the Quran and Sunnah or some fake troll. May Allah guide you.
I'm a Johnny come lately on this topic in this forum, however one thing puzzles me. Muslims commenting here are using this word music like it is an Arabic word in Qur'an and it is the only word that describes sounds in Allah's Creation. Islamic Scholars like Ibn Khuldun distinguished cultural enrichment using art, craft and science from entertainment long ago. It seems as though over the years, Islamic scholars became more popular by focusing on what is haram rather than what is halal. You would think that by now Muslims scholars would have come up with an Islamic word and definition for the natural sounds produced in Allah's Creation. It's like slaves becoming physically free, but mentally remaining trapped in the slave owners name. With Jews and Christians dominating music and entertainment industries world wide, Muslims should introduce and support halal alternatives. Muslims are catching hell all over the planet right now because we keep copying Jews, Christians and associating partners with Allah.
At the golden age of Islam. Muslims were pioneers of music. In that time Muslims made the biggest contributions to mankind in terms of science. Muslims even invented the guitar for heavens sake. Then the wobblers came and it slowly became Haraam. Now I understand why ignorance is sin. There is an authendic hadith, where Aisha as was listening to music and Abu Bakr (as) who thought he knew Islam better than the Prophet pbuh reprimanded Aisha (as) while in the presence of the Prophet (pbuh) who was resting. As soon as the prophet heard this he condemned Abu Bakr and took Aisha’s as side. Bukhari no 907 Maybe we have come to this position on music because we have too many muslims that are in the same state as Abu Bakr (as) was at that moment these days. In the days of the Prophet pbuh Abysinian slaves used to dance with music in the mosques in front of the Prophet pbuh. Dont listen to these Imam robots. They only preach and don’t question their own ideologies. Music is part of human nature. To go against makes you inhuman and close minded. Furthermore a holy book sent by Allah to a prophet was named the Book of Songs. Why would Allah (swt) name his holy book that is related to songs if it was haraam? The other Abrahamic faiths never had any issues with music. And dont try to use that purposely manipulated and purposely mistranslated quranic verse either. Idle talk does not equate to music but equates to Idlesness! Don’t try to twist it to get what you want. Ever wonder why Sufism allows Music in mosques. Ever wonder why the sufis were the biggest defenders of Islam during the Mongol era. Ever wonder why the honored person mentioned in the Quran that would conquer Constantinople was a Sufi? Maybe they were closer to Islam than those other weak Muslims sects were at that time. Maybe we drifted away from the truth and mistook our condemnation for things we dont understand as a sign of faith. For example, the Burka has nothing to do with Islam, yet muslim women wear it as a badge of honour for their faith. I guess we are all looking for badges for Allah swt even if we have ro make them up. In a nutshell, I call it blindly self deprivation to falsely prove your faith in contradiction to the teachings of Islam. I swear if marriage wasn’t mentioned in the Quran you hardcore muslims would of turned out just like the christian monks! Hitting themselves, locking themselves up for days, not eating or speaking for years and abstaining from marriage in the name of devotion to God.
We can easily observe that the music industry is full of drugs, sex and other bad things but one cannot just say with any real certainty that it is the music that is directly leading to that. If someone like Yusuf Islam can exist (a person who is a musician and also [probably] a good muslim) then that means music doesn't directly lead to the evil. And if people can practice music without evil then why stop them?
Scientific evidence indicates that plants, animals, water, in fact, the whole universe responds so sound. The universe has a hear beat of 432Hz, call it the universal melody, and the same frequency found in dolphins when communicating with each other. I am sure there is more to it than Bukhari's claim on music, after all, it was written centuries after Prophet PBUH. Perhaps, Bukhari is referring to BAD music but not ALL music............ But here's an argument: In the early 1900's, all musical instruments were set to 440Hz, what i call the devil's tuning. And we all know what followed, rock & pop music emerged, and with them came the culture of sex, drugs and violence. However, latest research on sound and acoustics indicates that perhaps the universe began with sound...which is the 432Hz. If the Creator used music/sound to design this universe, then why should it be considered evil? That's why it makes sense why the Prophet chose singing (Azaan) as the religious instrument rather than the Horn (Jews) and Bell (Christians). In fact, if you look closer, God has allowed different instruments to different nations for prayers. And lastly, if you look back in our history you will find prominent scholars and saints who were great musicians. Having said that, i believe that our scholars have not done enough work to fully establish this topic. GOD knows best.
sound or frequency isn"t music , binaural beats and isochronic tones aren't music too , please try to be more knowledgeable , and athan* isn't singing and recitation isn't singing stop promoting your lifestyle to fit all muslims cause it's wrong simply , u just can't admit it to yourself keep it to yourself brother , keep this code in mind , what seems to be easy in this world is wrong , what seems to be hard in this world is right ; islam is the hardest thing to practice in this world , why ? because it's the ultimate truth and path to righteousness and enlightenment , we can all feel it deep inside we're just scared to dive deep and break our own illusions .
Music is a own language, and if you haven't learned music theory, how to listen to intervals, and the magic of improvisation it is sad to hear that you will never experience this as muslims, due to a couple of hadiths mentioned at least 100 years after Muhammads (pbuh) death. Where is the logic prohibiting music as a complete generality? Logic presented as the prohibition of alcohol, pork and the need to say Allah before you slaughter an animal all makes complete sense to me! I agree that music should be prohibited when it promotes zina and fornication, and when it is used as a way of distraction, manipulation and direction towards something that clearly brings a person away from spiritual value. Also one must evaluate whether music is a form of worship, but enjoying one's art is okey right? But not art in form of music. This is silly and only based on a few hadiths and a vague verse in the quran (31:6).
Prof amir..your comment reminds me of Hadith of Muhammad (saw)" some of Muslims will legalize Music and say it is permitted in Islam" Aamir..sooner u repent the better it is
hmmm I feel there are so much double standard in the muslim society... Many ban music... but when you visit their home, the Television is on all the time, even when there are guests. TV full of music full of drama full of hate and corruption. To say that all music are hateful or corrupt or lead to suicide etc etc, that is stated by Bilal, is to take a small sample of music out and let it speak for all music. Have you ever listened to Beethoven or Chopin or modern music that gives message of love and gratitude and moral ? Very flawed comments unfortunately from Bilal Philips..
Salcm. The background voice actually sounds like a music, please remove it in sha Allah. I couldn't complete the lecture because of it. Very annoying sound
The very nature of a man is to be inclined to having sex with lot of women. But it is haraan. Not permissable a mahor sin. So the nature of a human does not make it a permissability
Muslims made guitar does not make guitar halal my brother, what is halal is halal, what is haram is haram, regardless of who made it. If a teacher tells student not to cheat and student cheats then its student's mistake.
Please DO NOT USE the word authentic hadith according to who and what source Bukhari does not know this deen better then Allah and Rasul our perfect book is Quran and therefore please do not make any statement if you want hadith let me tell you one dear brother bilal Whoever says something that Allah did not or I did not said, tell that person to prepare his seat in the hell fire so if I would be you which I am not i would stop saying things to the people if Quran did not say so dear brother
Music does not have to become an addiction. Listening to some classical music or something will not make an addict, a lunatic, or deviate from searching for God. Muslims I think are grasping at straws, just to prove that music is 'bad' because they think their religion prohibits it. And what does not carry a 'dark side'? Even water, if you drink excessive amounts of it, is not good.
سبحان الله هذا الدكتور الذي كان مسيحي قبل اسلامه وتربى على المودرن والحداثة . يدرك خطورة المعازف والغناء . أكثر تمسكا واحتراما للنص الشرعي من الجهلة من الدعاة الاسلاميين . ممن سحرتهم المدنية فحاولوا تطويع الدين للمدنية والحداثة . فتعدوا على النصوص الشرعية واستهانوا بها . محاولين الالتفاف عليها .
Whoa. So if I become a Muslim, I can't wear my silk shirts anymore? (They're really nice!) And I have to sell my piano? And I can't listen to Adele anymore? Hmm . . . Let me think about that . . . OK, I've thought about it. F*** Islam.
whoa. so if i become a christian i have to ask a sinner (priest) to forgive me instead of asking forgiveness from god? what if my sin is so big and the prist just say " i forgive u my child" this means that the god has forgiven me, this means i can do whatever i want to do because i can get rid of my sins whenever i want. we muslims are slaves , we are affraid of our sins . when we are slaves this means we are limited to do things and not free.so, am i gonna convert? hmmm let me think about . ok i have thought about it NO IM NOT. we muslims love everyone for the sake of god and we donot curse . cursing is forbidden. i can take the point out that christians curse to other nations but i wont because islam is the religion of peace and this is gonna ruin peace.
+Skull Crusher Here we go again with the "Islam is the religion of peace" bullshit. Let's see: Al Qaeda. The Taliban. ISIS (or ISIL or Daesh). Al-Shabaab. Boku Haram. Lashkar-e-Taiba. And that's just off the top of my head. Oh, and take a look at this Wikipedia article--a very LONG article: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Islamist_terrorist_attacks "Religion of peace"? More like "Religion of pieces"--that is, pieces of human bodies. You guys have got to do something about the violent elements in your religion.
Yes, if the music were beneficial, then the musicians would demonstrate that benefit in their lives
Maybe they do
Different effects on different people m8. Composers do. Not trash artists that sold their souls to the devil for fame.
Also it was only because of pagan religious rites that involved the misuse of instruments that your religion could be said to outlaw music in general.
I’ve been studying effects of music from Medical, religious and personal journey...
After deep analysis I have had to give up music and it by far was One of the most difficult things I’ve done in my life.
Interestingly once I gave it up I actually found I was able to do something that I had not been able to do before (lower my gaze in relation to looking at women).
What the hell has what you said got to do with Mozart or Beethoven? How does not listening to music make you lower your gaze? That makes no sense.
Cam you please share your research with us any link to your paper or anything like that?
you and your god is so stupid ...you can't lower ur gaze ..thats ur problem ..not with music
@@soumyadipsarkar5078 I agree he is stupid but God didn't tell anyone to not listen to music. People made that up.
Then I would honestly question what kind of music you were listeninh to.
thank you so much I really appreciate this I have been getting so many mixed responses may Allah bless u and your family inshallah
May Allah bless you Dr Bilal Philips and your family
one of the best explanations i heard on youtube so far.
I agree bro
Absolute nonsense! Music has always been part of Muslim culture and banning it on the basis of questionable hadiths is ridiculous! It is this kind of thinking that has brought the Islamic world to its present sorry state!
best explanation, thank you so much
Imam Phillip's take is a reasonable judgement. But it's also very subjective. How authentic are those hadith he mentioned? I was told there is some doubt about them. And they there is the matter of hadith that he does not mention where the rasool pbuh allowed certain music to be played in honor of him. Why can't we consider that as valid as well?
And there is no specific condemnation of music in the Quran as well.
So what I've found is that most scholars object to the lifestyles that go along with music. Music tends to accompany gatherings or moments where humans want to break free from restrictions.
This often leads to debauchery, because humans tend to do things excessively.
But if you're praying your Salat, reading the Quran, avoiding excessive debauchery, and generally living a wholesome life, what is music gonna do to hurt you?
The life of the musician reflects their is a good example. Thank you. I am a Christian just seeking understanding of Islam. In my church, some music is frowned on. Like angry music or music with ungodlieness. I thought I share one reason I found out why some music is harmful. Some music disengage the brains frontal lobes. This opens the brain to suggestion. Another reason is the rythem in music effects the body. Fast loud music raises the heart rate. Some people think music releases anger. But that angry music only increases and maintains the anger. I struggle with temptation of certain music. I thought I share what I learnt and I hope thats ok. I have research more about why adult female singing is not allowed in Islam.
Valerie Hodson May Allah show you the right path sister.
I am convert, May Allah guide you to islam, this is the path we have been give by the Lord of all the universe. and it's path very similar to Christianity and Islam. I would recommend reading the quran the unchanged words of God 😊
Sister i saw you two times just this minutes in a different Islamic vids 🙂
@@ehsanasgar7660 may I ask why you converted to Islam? I am a Christian interested in Islam, and I would just like to hear what convinced you to convert :)
Well after reading so many peoples negative comment on this post i would like to state that this video was all about Islam and for its followers so folks of other religion shouldn't or dont need to say anything on this kind of video, No one needs to prove anyone wrong in case of this kind of matter. Let all the religious people live alone for the sake of Mankind please.
I am a proud muslim musician
They dont know what music is. They are dumb. They say singing is NOT music. LOL. These scholars should try and learn fundamentals of music. They cant behead every bird singing.
+Perfect Piano haha that's funny and I'd like to add to it, singing is not music, gotta put a lil drum or piano then u get music btw check Google for definition of music
you are wrong
Salaam Farhan Maybe you need to learn the fundamentals of your faith. Everyone is wrong but you?
the vocals in the background are so distracting and unnecessary. I wish that they would not be included in videos like these
Thanks Sir♥️
Masha Allah
Really very important advice for us , thanks so much .our brother
Finally! I agree with you!
The question is between gud and bad music..... Some says all music is haram... But some says not all but bad music is haram...... I think all muslim community should clearify this issue.... .
Islam doesn't prohibit music nor it promotes. Quran says nothing about music. Music is a language and in any language its the use of words and content which matters. Its a genral missconception in Muslims Islam is not a religion where you try to follow happenings in that erra its about the rules and regulations set by Muhammad PBUH by the order of Allah. So if the content of music is promoting vulgerity or hate it must be forbidden and if it is promoting love and respect it should be appreciated.
mashallah.
Walaikum Assalam Wa rahmatullahi Wa barkatu Sir
I'm a non-Muslim, and a Catholic Christian who is also musician; that upfront - I can understand the argument in regard to vocal music that promotes a lifestyle that would be against what is allowed in the Qu'ran and the Hadith (Christian Evangelicals have long made a similar argument, but as it relates to moral prohibitions in the Bible), but what is the Islamic stance upon non-vocal music (i.e. instrumental only)? Plato himself, 400 B.C.E., remarked upon the power of music in both its positive and negative aspects. Secondarily, what would be the response to the argument that beauty - including music, instead of detracting us from God, draws us closer to God? Peace.
One of the point of views: islamictext.wordpress.com/on-music-and-singing-fatwa-by-shaykh-yusuf-al-qaradawi/
brother i used to think like that too until i faced my self with the facts , music ,musical instruments , vocals , whatever it distracts our soul and conscioussness from the state of god consciousness from the state of obediance and worship ( khushuu ) .
I am a muslim and i agree with you totally for surely without doubt there is that music which is spiritual and moving and which brings tears to the eyes.
Please for the love of God Almighty use some logic. I listen to good music and i have never felt so close to God Almighty. I read my salah regularly as well as the Quran which is my daily ritual. So dont make up things.
@@moezhamouda3248 Anything can do that m8. Whether that’s your family, friends, sports, etc, even your own life.
This is why Jesus said that anyone who comes to him and does not hate family, friends, and his own life cannot be his disciple.
Ok i got it after watching this video.. According to islam gud music is not haram but depending on it and following its dark side is ban... it corrupt us....
This is very well explained in my opinion.
Pls do not put back ground music, we cannot hear your voice clearly.
That's what the subtitles are for. + The voice is pretty clear. visit a doctor.
Many people have sensory disorders, which makes it difficult to distinguish different sounds, over another. It's not their fault. Some people cannot read or struggle to read subtitles fast- it seems the option which would afford better ease of understanding to people, is to just lose the music.
great video
Very good points. Consider a few additions.
There are claims that some specific frequencies can be beneficial, incl 432 Hz, and this is correct. This does not mean music. These frequencies can simple be "beep beep" sounds (Isochronic tones), or a long beep (Monaural tones), and such tones can be used for healing a variety of illnesses.
There was a 2003 study by NASA which documented that 10 Hz among others when played to come tissues (group of cells) for over 20 days, 150 or so maturation genes reverted to developmental genes. That's big news.
But that's just tones. Anyways, even music has been used in therapy even by Muslim, even a 1000 years ago.
I believe it is OK provided it is not being used for entertainment or anything vain, but for a purpose so useful such as healing.
Surah Luqman 31:6 can be used to understand that as well; that those who purchase "vain talks" (singing, music etc.) will have a grievous penalty... The word used for "vain" is "lahwa" which means a sport or entertainment. This does not mean we can't use it for therapeutic purposes, I believe. It is worthy to see this another answer by a doctor and scholar th-cam.com/video/7ILZmpFDQHY/w-d-xo.html
Hope this will be helpful in adding a bit more info about the topic. Reiterating, Dr BiIaI was clear and taught the facts clearly. There was just one missing piece of course, and that was not totally out of place because he was discussing about the "issues today", which is clearly using music for play and entertainment.
Musical instruments only produce melodic sound that can affect our emotions, whoever has studied the theory of music they know certain chords and combinations can make feel sad while others boost your mood, etc. Depending on the compositions and performance on particular instrument it may sound beautiful or ugly, sad or happy, etc. All that combined with lyrics makes it more influential on the emotions. Musicians with dirty mind and evil intentions are indeed able to produce evil music. But not all out there is evil, is it?
Why the vast majority of Quran reciters and muadhins do not recite plainly in one frequency but their voice goes up and down and creates a melody, simply it is more beautiful, is it not.
As the scholar said, music is not prohibited outright, on contrary for example pork and alcohol and adultery are prohibited outright. Sure we have to be picky and careful of what we listen to. I have heard a prominent Islamic scholar Abdullah bin Bayyah (and many others) saying that music in general (especially the western) is not permissible, however on his tweeter he follows a musician Maher Zain, his songs are mostly considered anasheed. There are many others. Yusuf Islam (Cat Stevens) is a extremely famous musician and seriously practicing Muslim.
At the golden age of Islam. Muslims were pioneers of music. In that time Muslims made the biggest contributions to mankind in terms of science. Muslims even invented the guitar for heavens sake.
Then the wobblers came and it slowly became Haraam. Now I understand why ignorance is sin.
There is an authendic hadith, where Aisha as was listening to music and Abu Bakr (as) who thought he knew Islam better than the Prophet pbuh reprimanded Aisha (as) while in the presence of the Prophet (pbuh) who was resting.
As soon as the prophet heard this he condemned Abu Bakr and took Aisha’s as side. Bukhari no 907
Maybe we have come to this position on music because we have too many muslims that are in the same state as Abu Bakr (as) was at that moment these days.
In the days of the Prophet pbuh Abysinian slaves used to dance with music in the mosques in front of the Prophet pbuh.
Dont listen to these Imam robots. They only preach and don’t question their own ideologies.
Music is part of human nature. To go against makes you inhuman and close minded.
Furthermore a holy book sent by Allah to a prophet was named the Book of Songs.
Why would Allah (swt) name his holy book that is related to songs if it was haraam?
The other Abrahamic faiths never had any issues with music.
And dont try to use that purposely manipulated and purposely mistranslated quranic verse either.
Idle talk does not equate to music but equates to Idlesness! Don’t try to twist it to get what you want.
Ever wonder why Sufism allows Music in mosques. Ever wonder why the sufis
were the biggest defenders of Islam during the Mongol era. Ever wonder why the honored person mentioned in the Quran that would conquer Constantinople was a Sufi?
Maybe they were closer to Islam than those other weak Muslims sects were at that time. Maybe we drifted away from the truth and mistook our condemnation for things we dont understand as a sign of faith. For example, the Burka has nothing to do with Islam, yet muslim women wear it as a badge of honour for their faith.
I guess we are all looking for badges for Allah swt even if we have ro make them up.
In a nutshell, I call it blindly self deprivation to falsely prove your faith in contradiction to the teachings of Islam.
I swear if marriage wasn’t mentioned in the Quran you hardcore muslims would of turned out just like the christian monks! Hitting themselves, locking themselves up for days, not eating or speaking for years and abstaining from marriage in the name of devotion to God.
@shahwaiz niazi Speech is very powerful and can lead people astray! After all Adolf Hitler managed to gain control of Germany through his speeches and then went on to commit great evil! So should we then ban speech? Muslims need to get their heads out of the sand and think for themselves! Blind taqleed is harmful!
@@ACEofficial7 Very well said!
Music instruments are harram. Don't make them permissible
@@Sag7789 our prophet (saw) has permitted the use of duff in the sahih hadith, and the duff was a popular type of musical instruments. The arabs used to celebrate their joy by playing duff.
Anas ibn Malik reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, passed by some of the girls of Medina and they were playing their drums and singing the words, “Muhammad is an excellent neighbor! We are neighbors from the tribe of Najjar!” The Prophet said, “Verily, Allah knows that you are dear to me.”
Source: Sunan Ibn Majah 1899
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani
Abdullah ibn Amr reported: A woman came to the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, and she said, “O Messenger of Allah, I have made a vow I will play the drum for you.” The Prophet said, “Fulfill your vow.” She said, “I have made a vow to sacrifice at a certain place where they slaughtered in the time of ignorance.” The Prophet said, “For an idol?” She said no. The Prophet said, “For an image?” She said no. The Prophet said, “Fulfill your vow.”
Source: Sunan Abī Dāwūd 3312
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani
music, and sound in general is very powerful, especially for humans but effective on every living and even non living object. Music can do what even drugs cannot sometimes. Music is more influential & humans are much more susceptible to it. We have seen that hypnosis in many instances uses music. Music can be incredibly destructive OR seemingly super powered. The clear cut reason for it's limitation and prohibition lies in the simple fact that it is TOO POWERFUL. A major part of cults is music, like these emos and metal etc (not to blame anyone) and it is clear they have a substantial effect on humans. So it would be likely that God would place a barrier on the use of music to stop it's power from corrupting us.
Whats the name of the song in this video?
It's the call to prayer by, I forget which person. But I will look it up.
The call to prayer is from Nasser Al Qatami but the melody that is sung in the background, I don't know.
is that background sound is necessary?? cant concentrate on Dr Phillip voice
I didn't even notice. It could be an indication you suffer from a certain level of anxiety and you have difficulty focussing.
People who havent experienced the serenity of Quran will never understand this....Alhumdulillah living by the perfect set of rules and a purpose within...
thanks....for the video.....
Human vocal chords and wind pipes are like strings and wind instruments so my dear fellow Muslims!!!!!!!! Should we not even talk anymore????? This is a simple example of how Islam is being misunderstood in many ways.
Yes there are music that promote sex, drugs, and a freakish lifestyle but music has nothing to do with that.
We live in a time where one song worth a hundred lectures if used wisely.
What do u mean?
Assalamu'alikum I got your every point clearly Masha'allah super explained! I listening Islamic song which one coled Nasheed with instruments is it prohibited ? If its not affecting society or anything & retune back me good thinking from lots of bad activities. Before I have listened so many Movies, Drama, singer's music maximum opposite from Islamic Coulter which one badly affecting my Religion activity's I did not regular in prayers or anything, when I have started Listening Islamic Song means Nasheed I try my best & performing maximum religions activities & and try to protect my self from all kinds of bad habits Alhamdulillah Nasshed not affecting bad anything in my attitude I have realized it hearty.Dear sir Dr.Billal Philips
whats the difference between vocal and music?
Vocal is singing
Please clarify that listening Japanese or Chinese flute sounds is halal or haram?
I've been having those concerns as well, becasue those instruments are very ancient and core to my culture. Therefore they're often played in very respectable and cultural settings. Indonesia, a predominant muslim nation, has certain music traditions predates which islam and still are played during Islamic rituals.
The question is, (not taking into account the lyrics), does cultural south east asian melodies affects our body , the same way as Nasheed' s melodies played with not-wind-and-string- instruments.
Please can anyone provide me the references of the Hadiths qoute by Dr. Bilal with international numbering.
At the golden age of Islam. Muslims were pioneers of music. In that time Muslims made the biggest contributions to mankind in terms of science. Muslims even invented the guitar for heavens sake.
Then the wobblers came and it slowly became Haraam. Now I understand why ignorance is sin.
There is an authendic hadith, where Aisha as was listening to music and Abu Bakr (as) who thought he knew Islam better than the Prophet pbuh reprimanded Aisha (as) while in the presence of the Prophet (pbuh) who was resting.
As soon as the prophet heard this he condemned Abu Bakr and took Aisha’s as side. Bukhari no 907
Maybe we have come to this position on music because we have too many muslims that are in the same state as Abu Bakr (as) was at that moment these days.
In the days of the Prophet pbuh Abysinian slaves used to dance with music in the mosques in front of the Prophet pbuh.
Dont listen to these Imam robots. They only preach and don’t question their own ideologies.
Music is part of human nature. To go against makes you inhuman and close minded.
Furthermore a holy book sent by Allah to a prophet was named the Book of Songs.
Why would Allah (swt) name his holy book that is related to songs if it was haraam?
The other Abrahamic faiths never had any issues with music.
And dont try to use that purposely manipulated and purposely mistranslated quranic verse either.
Idle talk does not equate to music but equates to Idlesness! Don’t try to twist it to get what you want.
Ever wonder why Sufism allows Music in mosques. Ever wonder why the sufis
were the biggest defenders of Islam during the Mongol era. Ever wonder why the honored person mentioned in the Quran that would conquer Constantinople was a Sufi?
Maybe they were closer to Islam than those other weak Muslims sects were at that time. Maybe we drifted away from the truth and mistook our condemnation for things we dont understand as a sign of faith. For example, the Burka has nothing to do with Islam, yet muslim women wear it as a badge of honour for their faith.
I guess we are all looking for badges for Allah swt even if we have ro make them up.
In a nutshell, I call it blindly self deprivation to falsely prove your faith in contradiction to the teachings of Islam.
I swear if marriage wasn’t mentioned in the Quran you hardcore muslims would of turned out just like the christian monks! Hitting themselves, locking themselves up for days, not eating or speaking for years and abstaining from marriage in the name of devotion to God.
Well on an abstract level, I agree with most of your claim. But I can't verify few of the points you make.
My take is, not everything is a matter of religion and our this habit of radicalizing everything by means of religion is poisonous.
At the golden age of Islam. Muslims were pioneers of music. In that time Muslims made the biggest contributions to mankind in terms of science. Muslims even invented the guitar for heavens sake.
Then the wobblers came and it slowly became Haraam. Now I understand why ignorance is sin.
There is an authendic hadith, where Aisha as was listening to music and Abu Bakr (as) who thought he knew Islam better than the Prophet pbuh reprimanded Aisha (as) while in the presence of the Prophet (pbuh) who was resting.
As soon as the prophet heard this he condemned Abu Bakr and took Aisha’s as side. Bukhari no 907
Maybe we have come to this position on music because we have too many muslims that are in the same state as Abu Bakr (as) was at that moment these days.
In the days of the Prophet pbuh Abysinian slaves used to dance with music in the mosques in front of the Prophet pbuh.
Dont listen to these Imam robots. They only preach and don’t question their own ideologies.
Music is part of human nature. To go against makes you inhuman and close minded.
Furthermore a holy book sent by Allah to a prophet was named the Book of Songs.
Why would Allah (swt) name his holy book that is related to songs if it was haraam?
The other Abrahamic faiths never had any issues with music.
And dont try to use that purposely manipulated and purposely mistranslated quranic verse either.
Idle talk does not equate to music but equates to Idlesness! Don’t try to twist it to get what you want.
Ever wonder why Sufism allows Music in mosques. Ever wonder why the sufis
were the biggest defenders of Islam during the Mongol era. Ever wonder why the honored person mentioned in the Quran that would conquer Constantinople was a Sufi?
Maybe they were closer to Islam than those other weak Muslims sects were at that time. Maybe we drifted away from the truth and mistook our condemnation for things we dont understand as a sign of faith. For example, the Burka has nothing to do with Islam, yet muslim women wear it as a badge of honour for their faith.
I guess we are all looking for badges for Allah swt even if we have ro make them up.
In a nutshell, I call it blindly self deprivation to falsely prove your faith in contradiction to the teachings of Islam.
I swear if marriage wasn’t mentioned in the Quran you hardcore muslims would of turned out just like the christian monks! Hitting themselves, locking themselves up for days, not eating or speaking for years and abstaining from marriage in the name of devotion to God.
THANX for the video
Technically, guitar is not a string instruments. It has metal or nylon that is referred to as 'string'
I think this is a very good argument. However, evil things are not concentrated amongst musicians, it just so happens that people make musicians into famous people, and put them in the news. So of those musicians who are deviants, of course it is always made into a big news story. I see just as many non-musicians doing wrongful things, and just as many musicians leading righteous lives and inspiring spirituality in others, but these righteous and humble musicians are not 'cool' enough to make it into the mass media.
Well of course, they didn’t sell their souls to the devil.
This goes quite a lot for composer musicians as well, they don’t lead bad lifestyles.
Background noise is unbearable
I've heard this explanation several times, but it is a logical fallacy. An edict from one thousand years ago, cannot be justified by looking at conditions in the present day.
Especially when those conditions were wildly different. Since an industry never even arose out of music back then.
It would make more sense if they contextualized it with the fact that the surrounding society was pagan, and they misused a bunch of things, such as Music and statues, but that really didn’t occur to them.
what is the necessity for a background music going on this video - no one wanted to listen this satanic sound, it is so disturbing.
music increases hypocrisy of heart
Well explained
So Muslims can interpret the Quaran in whatever way they want?
It doesn't say anything about music in the quran itself as far as I know. The one aya where it talks about idle speech is clearly not talking about music in general but rather any kind of idle talk that is intended to make people stray away from the deen. It's especially clear when you read the reason that aya came down.
So what do you suggest? God send another prophet or angels should come down to earth to interpret the Quran? Of course the Quran is going to be interpreted by humans, and they will interpret it in light of their experiences and in the age they live in!
I fall in love with God when I listen to music, I focus on God when I listen to music. Listening for bad means are haram accepted
he is not saying anything by himself he is reffering the sunnah
@@godzilla8574 As the Quran says, "Rabbis and monks determined what was lawful and what was not instead of God." (The Quran, 9:31). The Islamic scholars have manipulated hadiths and sunnah to create a religion of their own!
@@ahmedakhan1 you are right
i love this channel may Allah bless you
This channel has adds on which has music, they earn from this.
👍
See all these declarations about music is haram, entertainment is haram, having fun is haram etc. Islam is a religion of ease and moderation. I studied and have faith enough to know this is not a religion that makes ones life void of entertainment. Not all music leads to evil, yes some does. In the same argument your smartphone and computer can lead you to evil (pornography, witchcraft), does that make your computer evil in and of itself? Hence the whole "Because it leads to evil, its prohibited" logic does not make sense. The Prophet Muhammad peace and blessing upon him was ok with singing and beating of drums before him. The one hadith that refers against music is questionable but even taken in translation it associates people who will drink alcohol, commit adultery all the while listening to music (Which we clearly see today). Does it make any sense to say music that puts babies to sleep, that makes the hardworking men of labor work more efficient, melodies that come out of the birds and animals is somehow evil? brothers and sisters we must be very careful to call haram what is not haram, Allah almighty warned us from doing this Say: Have you considered what provision Allah has sent down for you, how you have made of it lawful and unlawful? Say: Has Allah permitted you, or do you invent a lie concerning Allah?”(Yunus: 59) .
Rock the Casbah. Rock the Casbah
The background sound is horrible and it is louder than the voice of the sheikh himself !!! I couldnt concentrate on what he said iam so distracted by those aaaaaaa in the background !! Subhana Allah
Bilal Phillips speaks for the Salafiyyah. But according to Ahlus Sunnah there is ikhtilaf. By the way the Hadith does not say musical Instruments. It says ma'azif and it means entertainment but some Interpret it as music. This is another Proof why it is so important to listen to really knowledgeable people.
So entertainment is haram? What does that exactly mean?
@@danialshah2957 Entertainment is allowed as well as music is actually a topic of ikhtilaf. Some big Ulama like Imam al Ghazali and Imam Ibn Hazm allowed Music. But the Salafiyyah claims there was ijmah in this topic which ist clearly wrong. The Ahlus Sunnah in fact is very rich in opinions. We have still four madhabs but the Salafiyyah claims an own way for themselves to be the one and only truth. They do Not have a madhab so they call their way Manhaj as Salafiyyah. It derives from a modernistic sect called al Wahabiyyah.
Has wine already been given another name?
Hey, I found the answer! You can check out this video and it will explain you. watch?v=drKM4tHfYRg
The man above is not knowledgable enough. Read Sahih Bukhari & Muslim Hadith] Volume 2, Book 15, Number 103 to confirm my observation.
Not all music is haram. The music that is seductive, profain, or that which incites to improper actions is haram. However, the music that is comforting, harmonious or that will increase you to do good things is permissible.
As a matter of fact, we know from the authentic traditions that the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, not only allowed music in the weddings but also listened to girls singing: While listening to girls singing on such an occasion, he interrupted them only once when they sang the following verse, “In our midst is a prophet who knows what will happen tomorrow”; whence, the Prophet, peace be upon him, told them, “Cut this sentence out, and continue singing what you had been singing earlier.”
Volume 2, Book 15, Number 103 :
Narrated by 'Urwa on the authority of 'Aisha
On the days of Mina, (11th, 12th, and 13th of Dhul-Hijjah) Abu Bakr came to her while two young girls were beating the tambourine and the Prophet was lying covered with his clothes. Abu Bakr scolded them and the Prophet uncovered his face and said to Abu Bakr, "Leave them, for these days are the days of 'Id and the days of Mina." 'Aisha further said, "Once the Prophet was screening me and I was watching the display of black slaves in the Mosque and ('Umar) scolded them. The Prophet said, 'Leave them. O Bani Arfida! (carry on), you are safe (protected)'."
Your hadith says nothing specifically about music except perhaps that he tolerated the tamborines. But hadith are not very reliable. There were thousands of fabricated ahadith and Bukhari had an impossible task to sort through them. In any case I agree, we do not need to attach a prohibition to music, the prohibition should be attached to the associated thoughts and actions.
Many pieces of music are things of great skill, creativity, passion, and beauty, including music of stringed and wind instruments and music sung by female singers and there is nothing wrong with that. And there is lots of awful stuff where every second word is a profanity. Its ridiculous to make this a religious issue.
At the golden age of Islam. Muslims were pioneers of music. In that time Muslims made the biggest contributions to mankind in terms of science. Muslims even invented the guitar for heavens sake.
Then the wobblers came and it slowly became Haraam. Now I understand why ignorance is sin.
There is an authendic hadith, where Aisha as was listening to music and Abu Bakr (as) who thought he knew Islam better than the Prophet pbuh reprimanded Aisha (as) while in the presence of the Prophet (pbuh) who was resting.
As soon as the prophet heard this he condemned Abu Bakr and took Aisha’s as side. Bukhari no 907
Maybe we have come to this position on music because we have too many muslims that are in the same state as Abu Bakr (as) was at that moment these days.
In the days of the Prophet pbuh Abysinian slaves used to dance with music in the mosques in front of the Prophet pbuh.
Dont listen to these Imam robots. They only preach and don’t question their own ideologies.
Music is part of human nature. To go against makes you inhuman and close minded.
Furthermore a holy book sent by Allah to a prophet was named the Book of Songs.
Why would Allah (swt) name his holy book that is related to songs if it was haraam?
The other Abrahamic faiths never had any issues with music.
And dont try to use that purposely manipulated and purposely mistranslated quranic verse either.
Idle talk does not equate to music but equates to Idlesness! Don’t try to twist it to get what you want.
Ever wonder why Sufism allows Music in mosques. Ever wonder why the sufis
were the biggest defenders of Islam during the Mongol era. Ever wonder why the honored person mentioned in the Quran that would conquer Constantinople was a Sufi?
Maybe they were closer to Islam than those other weak Muslims sects were at that time. Maybe we drifted away from the truth and mistook our condemnation for things we dont understand as a sign of faith. For example, the Burka has nothing to do with Islam, yet muslim women wear it as a badge of honour for their faith.
I guess we are all looking for badges for Allah swt even if we have ro make them up.
In a nutshell, I call it blindly self deprivation to falsely prove your faith in contradiction to the teachings of Islam.
I swear if marriage wasn’t mentioned in the Quran you hardcore muslims would of turned out just like the christian monks! Hitting themselves, locking themselves up for days, not eating or speaking for years and abstaining from marriage in the name of devotion to God.
@@ACEofficial7 Agree with your strong statement! Not convinced the hadith are as authentic as Dr Philips says, and in any case they are historical, not universal.
@@roberthannah7983 Wasnt originally going to reply to trolls. Dude literally spammed most of the comments. But seeing as people agree to his comments. I am going to give my opinion as a contrast to his.
@@ACEofficial7 Too many things wrong with your comment. I will try to provide clarification to as much as I can.
*"At the golden age of Islam. Muslims were pioneers of music. In that time..."*
The golden age of Islam wasnt the time period you are referring to, the golden age of Islam was when Prophet (Peace be upon him) was alive. Then when the Khalifa were still ruling. Then the next was when the Sahaba were around. Then when the Tabiun were still around... and so on and on. As time goes on, it will only get worse and the end times will be the worst.
Why?
Well, when the Prophet (Peace be upon him), he could still guide us with his divine guidance that came directly from Allah, which is no longer the case. Which is why right after he (Peace be upon him) died, there were too many false Hadiths.
Then there is also the issue of Sects.
“My ummah will split into seventy-three sects, all of whom will be in the Fire except one sect.” They said: Who are they, O Messenger of Allah? He said: “[Those who follow] the path which I and my companions follow.” -Tirmidhi (2641)
Since Shia began and the Ummah split right after Prophet (Peace be upon him) died, we cannot consider any other time as "Golden age of Islam" other than the time of the Prophet (Peace be upon him).
*"Muslims even invented the guitar for heavens sake. "*
I am sorry, what? How does Muslims doing anything or saying anything mean Islam allows it? A Muslim can drink, well some do drink alcohol nowadays, how does it mean Islam allows it?
*"Now I understand why ignorance is sin."*
Ignorance is not sin. Refusing to listen to reason and follow the truth after the message of Prophet (Peace be upon him) reaches someone is considered a sin i.e. Shirk. Its like saying people who didnt know earth was round in the past sinned bc of not knowing it.
*"There is an authendic hadith, where Aisha as was listening to music and Abu Bakr (as) who thought he knew Islam better than the Prophet pbuh reprimanded Aisha (as) while in the presence of the Prophet (pbuh) who was resting.*
*As soon as the prophet heard this he condemned Abu Bakr and took Aisha’s as side. Bukhari no 907"*
Wow man. You have bent the Hadith as much as you could.
In the Hadith, Aisha (May Allah be pleased with her) was listening to two girls singing. And it is widely agreed upon that singing is halal, music is not.
And also, the Prophet (Peace be upon him) turned the other way after he said "Leave them be", he did not take Aisha (May Allah be pleased with her) to his side bc Aisha (May Allah be pleased with her) didnt make any claim that he would need to side with her nor did he codemn Abu Bakr (May Allah be pleased with him). Where did you source your Hadith from?
It was also Bukhari 949 not 907. -________-
*"In the days of the Prophet pbuh Abysinian slaves used to dance with music in the mosques in front of the Prophet pbuh."*
And? What does it prove? It took 23 years of Prophethood to reveal the Quran. Not every Fiqh rulling came down on day 1. Nor did everything halal and haram was revealed on day 1. Muslim didnt pray towards the Kabah early on. And Alcohol wasnt announced haram early on.
*"Furthermore a holy book sent by Allah to a prophet was named the Book of Songs.
Why would Allah (swt) name his holy book that is related to songs if it was haraam?"*
Its like asking why did Allah reveal 104 books before sending Quran, the perfect book. You are questioning Allah's wisdom for the way He has done things.
Wait hold on...
You made the claim that Sufism is tight and they are on the Sunnah more than the Ahl-ul Jama'ah.
And you later on also make the claim that Burqa/Niqab has nothing to do with Islam.
At this point, I cant tell if you are genuine Muslim who follows the Quran and Sunnah or some fake troll. May Allah guide you.
I'm a Johnny come lately on this topic in this forum, however one thing puzzles me. Muslims commenting here are using this word music like it is an Arabic word in Qur'an and it is the only word that describes sounds in Allah's Creation. Islamic Scholars like Ibn Khuldun distinguished cultural enrichment using art, craft and science from entertainment long ago. It seems as though over the years, Islamic scholars became more popular by focusing on what is haram rather than what is halal. You would think that by now Muslims scholars would have come up with an Islamic word and definition for the natural sounds produced in Allah's Creation. It's like slaves becoming physically free, but mentally remaining trapped in the slave owners name. With Jews and Christians dominating music and entertainment industries world wide, Muslims should introduce and support halal alternatives. Muslims are catching hell all over the planet right now because we keep copying Jews, Christians and associating partners with Allah.
There's a reason why ISIS forbids music
At the golden age of Islam. Muslims were pioneers of music. In that time Muslims made the biggest contributions to mankind in terms of science. Muslims even invented the guitar for heavens sake.
Then the wobblers came and it slowly became Haraam. Now I understand why ignorance is sin.
There is an authendic hadith, where Aisha as was listening to music and Abu Bakr (as) who thought he knew Islam better than the Prophet pbuh reprimanded Aisha (as) while in the presence of the Prophet (pbuh) who was resting.
As soon as the prophet heard this he condemned Abu Bakr and took Aisha’s as side. Bukhari no 907
Maybe we have come to this position on music because we have too many muslims that are in the same state as Abu Bakr (as) was at that moment these days.
In the days of the Prophet pbuh Abysinian slaves used to dance with music in the mosques in front of the Prophet pbuh.
Dont listen to these Imam robots. They only preach and don’t question their own ideologies.
Music is part of human nature. To go against makes you inhuman and close minded.
Furthermore a holy book sent by Allah to a prophet was named the Book of Songs.
Why would Allah (swt) name his holy book that is related to songs if it was haraam?
The other Abrahamic faiths never had any issues with music.
And dont try to use that purposely manipulated and purposely mistranslated quranic verse either.
Idle talk does not equate to music but equates to Idlesness! Don’t try to twist it to get what you want.
Ever wonder why Sufism allows Music in mosques. Ever wonder why the sufis
were the biggest defenders of Islam during the Mongol era. Ever wonder why the honored person mentioned in the Quran that would conquer Constantinople was a Sufi?
Maybe they were closer to Islam than those other weak Muslims sects were at that time. Maybe we drifted away from the truth and mistook our condemnation for things we dont understand as a sign of faith. For example, the Burka has nothing to do with Islam, yet muslim women wear it as a badge of honour for their faith.
I guess we are all looking for badges for Allah swt even if we have ro make them up.
In a nutshell, I call it blindly self deprivation to falsely prove your faith in contradiction to the teachings of Islam.
I swear if marriage wasn’t mentioned in the Quran you hardcore muslims would of turned out just like the christian monks! Hitting themselves, locking themselves up for days, not eating or speaking for years and abstaining from marriage in the name of devotion to God.
We can easily observe that the music industry is full of drugs, sex and other bad things but one cannot just say with any real certainty that it is the music that is directly leading to that. If someone like Yusuf Islam can exist (a person who is a musician and also [probably] a good muslim) then that means music doesn't directly lead to the evil. And if people can practice music without evil then why stop them?
That industry outright sold their souls to the devil for the most part.
Scientific evidence indicates that plants, animals, water, in fact, the whole universe responds so sound. The universe has a hear beat of 432Hz, call it the universal melody, and the same frequency found in dolphins when communicating with each other.
I am sure there is more to it than Bukhari's claim on music, after all, it was written centuries after Prophet PBUH. Perhaps, Bukhari is referring to BAD music but not ALL music............ But here's an argument:
In the early 1900's, all musical instruments were set to 440Hz, what i call the devil's tuning. And we all know what followed, rock & pop music emerged, and with them came the culture of sex, drugs and violence. However, latest research on sound and acoustics indicates that perhaps the universe began with sound...which is the 432Hz. If the Creator used music/sound to design this universe, then why should it be considered evil? That's why it makes sense why the Prophet chose singing (Azaan) as the religious instrument rather than the Horn (Jews) and Bell (Christians). In fact, if you look closer, God has allowed different instruments to different nations for prayers. And lastly, if you look back in our history you will find prominent scholars and saints who were great musicians. Having said that, i believe that our scholars have not done enough work to fully establish this topic. GOD knows best.
+Prof Amir I wish more was said with the knowledge above in mind..
+Prof Amir Tell me more brother.
sound or frequency isn"t music , binaural beats and isochronic tones aren't music too , please try to be more knowledgeable , and athan* isn't singing and recitation isn't singing stop promoting your lifestyle to fit all muslims cause it's wrong simply , u just can't admit it to yourself keep it to yourself brother , keep this code in mind , what seems to be easy in this world is wrong , what seems to be hard in this world is right ; islam is the hardest thing to practice in this world , why ? because it's the ultimate truth and path to righteousness and enlightenment , we can all feel it deep inside we're just scared to dive deep and break our own illusions .
Music is a own language, and if you haven't learned music theory, how to listen to intervals, and the magic of improvisation it is sad to hear that you will never experience this as muslims, due to a couple of hadiths mentioned at least 100 years after Muhammads (pbuh) death. Where is the logic prohibiting music as a complete generality? Logic presented as the prohibition of alcohol, pork and the need to say Allah before you slaughter an animal all makes complete sense to me!
I agree that music should be prohibited when it promotes zina and fornication, and when it is used as a way of distraction, manipulation and direction towards something that clearly brings a person away from spiritual value. Also one must evaluate whether music is a form of worship, but enjoying one's art is okey right? But not art in form of music. This is silly and only based on a few hadiths and a vague verse in the quran (31:6).
Prof amir..your comment reminds me of Hadith of Muhammad (saw)" some of Muslims will legalize Music and say it is permitted in Islam"
Aamir..sooner u repent the better it is
Even the lyrics has no Sex,drugs,nudity or any of harmful words still haram haram
Background voice is irritating
The sound behind is very wrong
Well i got attached to the voice in the background to be honest lol so i assume that should be haram aswell now 🤭
Do you even understand the explanation in the video? If u do, u wouldn't ask the question.
hmmm I feel there are so much double standard in the muslim society... Many ban music... but when you visit their home, the Television is on all the time, even when there are guests. TV full of music full of drama full of hate and corruption. To say that all music are hateful or corrupt or lead to suicide etc etc, that is stated by Bilal, is to take a small sample of music out and let it speak for all music. Have you ever listened to Beethoven or Chopin or modern music that gives message of love and gratitude and moral ? Very flawed comments unfortunately from Bilal Philips..
Salcm. The background voice actually sounds like a music, please remove it in sha Allah. I couldn't complete the lecture because of it. Very annoying sound
The very nature of a man is to be inclined to having sex with lot of women. But it is haraan. Not permissable a mahor sin. So the nature of a human does not make it a permissability
But muslims made guitar, a string instrument. Aside from that, it was actually a decent video.
Muslims made guitar does not make guitar halal my brother, what is halal is halal, what is haram is haram, regardless of who made it. If a teacher tells student not to cheat and student cheats then its student's mistake.
Shows the hypocrisy of this whole screed. In the backround of this lecture is a voice intoning....singing
+Rudi Mwongozi you clearly didn't watch the video. Not that I necessarily agree with it but it's definitely not hypocritical.
Singing isn't haram...
Remove background music
The Story of Sheeth (AS) - Music & Adultery Begins / MercifulServant
th-cam.com/video/ee6qv9oOkyA/w-d-xo.html
Please DO NOT USE the word authentic hadith according to who and what source Bukhari does not know this deen better then Allah and Rasul our perfect book is Quran and therefore please do not make any statement if you want hadith let me tell you one dear brother bilal Whoever says something that Allah did not or I did not said, tell that person to prepare his seat in the hell fire so if I would be you which I am not i would stop saying things to the people if Quran did not say so dear brother
Music does not have to become an addiction. Listening to some classical music or something will not make an addict, a lunatic, or deviate from searching for God. Muslims I think are grasping at straws, just to prove that music is 'bad' because they think their religion prohibits it.
And what does not carry a 'dark side'? Even water, if you drink excessive amounts of it, is not good.
@@amelkatrin3464 Thats OK, lots of people dont like classical music. But dont drag religion into it!
Every and anything can distract us from god. So this explanation fails.
pls google the wahabi radical
سبحان الله هذا الدكتور الذي كان مسيحي قبل اسلامه وتربى على المودرن والحداثة . يدرك خطورة المعازف والغناء . أكثر تمسكا واحتراما للنص الشرعي من الجهلة من الدعاة الاسلاميين . ممن سحرتهم المدنية فحاولوا تطويع الدين للمدنية والحداثة . فتعدوا على النصوص الشرعية واستهانوا بها . محاولين الالتفاف عليها .
يا رجل ان الإسلام دين سماحة
Whoa. So if I become a Muslim, I can't wear my silk shirts anymore? (They're really nice!) And I have to sell my piano? And I can't listen to Adele anymore? Hmm . . . Let me think about that . . . OK, I've thought about it. F*** Islam.
whoa. so if i become a christian i have to ask a sinner (priest) to forgive me instead of asking forgiveness from god? what if my sin is so big and the prist just say " i forgive u my child" this means that the god has forgiven me, this means i can do whatever i want to do because i can get rid of my sins whenever i want. we muslims are slaves , we are affraid of our sins . when we are slaves this means we are limited to do things and not free.so, am i gonna convert? hmmm let me think about . ok i have thought about it NO IM NOT. we muslims love everyone for the sake of god and we donot curse . cursing is forbidden. i can take the point out that christians curse to other nations but i wont because islam is the religion of peace and this is gonna ruin peace.
+Skull Crusher Here we go again with the "Islam is the religion of peace" bullshit. Let's see: Al Qaeda. The Taliban. ISIS (or ISIL or Daesh). Al-Shabaab. Boku Haram. Lashkar-e-Taiba. And that's just off the top of my head. Oh, and take a look at this Wikipedia article--a very LONG article:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Islamist_terrorist_attacks
"Religion of peace"? More like "Religion of pieces"--that is, pieces of human bodies. You guys have got to do something about the violent elements in your religion.
u never named the christian groups and slaughters brother haha or whose behind those groups u just named lol , this argument is too old i'm out