ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 ก.ย. 2024
- #s1 #leicar #lumix
Filmed with the Lumix S1 + Leica R 24mm F2.8
Ciao guys and welcome back! Today it was a sunny day and I decided to do a little vlog about a topic that I wanted to talk for really long time...In todays video I'll give you 10 good reasons to chose the Panasonic Lumix S1 over the S5, considering also the firmware updates of 2021.
Don't forge to like the video and to subscribe to the channel!
*Regarding the reason number 3 = on the S1H there's a lock switch but not the front switch, that is nice to have.
Panasonic S1 = geni.us/mzfi
Panasonic S5 = geni.us/HkMB
_________________________
If you have found this video useful, I'd really appreciate a like and subscribe to support my work. Thanks!
_________________________
My IG = / lucabono.studio
Updated List of the gear I use = visuals.lucabo...
________________________
Previous videos:
- DJI Pocket 3 - • The DJI Pocket 3 is a ...
- How to Export ProRes with Resolve Studio - • How To Export ProRes V...
- Good Film Grain for Video - • Good FILM GRAIN for Yo...
- Formatt Hitech Cinema Filters - • Formatt Hitech 2mm IRN...
- Panasonic Lumix S5 - • Panasonic Lumix S5 - ...
- Lumix 24-105mm vs 20-60mm - • Panasonic 20-60mm VS 2...
- Meyer Optik Primoplan 58mm F1.9 - • Meyer Optik Gorlitz Pr...
- Zeiss Classic Distagon 25mm F2 - • Zeiss Classic Distagon...
- Leica R Summicron 35mm F2 - • Leica R Summicron 35mm...
_________________________
If you wish to support the channel monetarily directly via PayPal: paypal.me/Luca...
_________________________
⚠️ DISCLAIMER: I am a professional content creator, photographer and filmmaker.
I am NOT SPONSORED by any brand and I'm free to share my real opinion about anything, even if I get to keep the some of the products free of charge.
► AFFILIATE DISCLAIMER : Some of the links in my video descriptions are affiliate links, which means at no extra cost to you, I will make a small commission if you click them and make a qualifying purchase. Thanks for your support!
________________________
If you have found this video useful, I'll really appreciate a like to the video and subscribe in the channel to support my work. Ciao!
Is there any noticeable difference in sharpness between the two cameras with the same lens and f-stop? Imaging-resource and dpreview studio samples show S1 significantly sharper than S5 at all ISOs for the same f-stop. Sharpness is my main requirement.
I already own an S5 and it's absolutely incredible!! I was looking for another Lumix camera to pair it with, and I think I'll get a used S1.
Totally agree with this.
I opted for the S1 over the S5 too. Very happy especially with the firmware upgrade. I actually like the weight - it helps with keeping it steady - and for me the option of micro HDMI on the S5 was a complete disaster.
I feel the S1 is better made (might be wrong on this), and I also really like the top LCD screen.
Because people are going for either the s5 or S1H you can get serious bargains with the S1 too :)
Thank you my friend! I'm glad you got the S1 for yourself, it's such a beautiful camera!
@@LucaBono.Studio Absolutely! I thought the GH5S had great skin tones, but this one is even better :)
Damn that S1 and Leica is a good combo. I'm tempted to get a S1h now.
Yes my friend, the images that I'm getting from this combination are stunning! I would the the S1 for now...you can always get the S1H later as A-cam
thanks, I like the excellent video features in Panasonic, unlike R6, v-log, but one problem is crop 4k 60p and 4.2.0, R6 in turn, allows reading from the entire sensor and 10 bit 4.2.2
Nevertheless, I still lean towards Panasonic, the s1 seems to be a more serious hybrid camera with impressive photos and their optimal quality in high resolution, when you can completely eliminate moiré and color distortions and get stunning detail. Canon does not offer such advantages, 20mp seems to be insufficient for today, if Panasonic makes 4k 60p readout from the whole sensor it would be great!
I love the viewfinder on the S1. I find it very useful to see such a clear and large image in the viewfinder.
Yeah it's really good, did you try the other viewfinder cover? It's even better with that
Please see my comment above to Luca.
@@LucaBono.Studio which one is that? Do you have a link?
Great video! We just picked up the S1 and the S5 for our video production company and we're loving them both! Much love from East Tennessee🙏🏼
Nice, you'll have a lot of fun with them! Thank you so much for watching and for your comment Garret!
For a semi-pro/enthusiast hybrid shooter which one would you recommend over the other?
Which body would you say has aged the best in 2024?
I don't mind Micro HDMI, you can get an adapter and clamp it to a cage. Way more robust
Friend, tell me, does the anamorphic 6k mode in s1 pans only work on an external recorder, but in a carcass? And in s5 there is a restriction on recording in anamorphic mode for 30 minutes, then again the button must be pressed, in s1. no lemit?
Good review! I prefer S5 for its portability and compact size, and in my opinion its a powerful beast of its kind. 😀
Thank you for watching Amir! Yeah sometimes I would like to carry a light camera ahahsh
One of the biggest reason to buy the S1 over S5 for me is the HDMI port. I don't know why Panasonic put the tiny micro HDMI in S5 :
Yes, that micro HDMI is so annoying lol! Thank you for watching!
Why do you consider it annoying? You just use a different cable and that's it.
Great video Luca. I went for the S1 over the S5 as it offers more in the long run, having a higher resolution EVF and the higher resolution back screen is enough to beat S5 in my opinion but the fact that it can do 5k video was the one that convinced me as I do a lot of effects work and having that extra resolution is awesome. Also the extra resolution in 5k produces some awesome B-roll footage too and close-ups of faces and bodies. The S1 Lumix is now my second cam to GH5S and the Sigma fp on RAHANA. The GH5S is my main cam as I can film action easier and the auto-focus is much much better than the S1 and fp.
Thanks for watching mate! I'm glad that you got the S1...the 6K open gate is even better for VFX 😁
Is it easy to match the footage from the FP with the S1?
@@LucaBono.Studio I haven't tried that yet although visually when you see the RAW files from the fp and compare them to even the best files on S1, there is a big difference in dynamic range and colours and detail - You have given me an idea for a video haha - I will try and match them and let you know - What I am doing at the moment with the fp is using it for really glamorous scenes in my movie RAHANA where I really want to show the colours and imagery in a vibrant way and in conversations. I am guessing it maybe easier to match the S1 footage with the GH5S although I haven't done that yet either. So I will do a test and see how they look.
@@SuchetB Thanks buddy! I should try one Sigma FP soon or later...
@@LucaBono.Studio fp is a great cinema camera, which produces great results just not as as easy or friendly to use as the S1 😎
@@SuchetB hey! Can you share your GH5S vs S line experience? A
I have an opportunity to pick up a good condition used S1 for pretty much the same price as a used S5. Only negative thing is they don’t sell S1 where I live so I could try and hold it. I’ve heard the weight on the S1 is a lot and can shock at first hold. As I’m new to this I wouldn’t wanna spend too much money on rigging the camera and a gimbal as of now but would rather prefer to shoot completely handheld. Feel like the heavier camera might help me get more stable shots and I’m gonna get Zeiss lenses so no IS on the lenses so better IS in camera would be a bonus. Which one would you recommend me?
The S1 is a better camera, cheers!
Ciao Luca from Roma! I just bought the S5 but I have to admit that with the new firmware now the S1 is way better. Nevertheless I am happy with my first Panasonic 🥰. You have the big brother and I the smallest 😃
Ciao Fabio! You'll be good with the S5 too, it's probably the best compact full frame camera for serious content creators.
Wow. How is the S1 now better than the S5 with new S1 firmware?
@@raksh9 Because Panasonic made the S1 better ahahah
Totally and sadly true.Ihave the s5 and the card slot just start to fail at the third month.
And consider that just the used body of the s1 its cheaper than the s5.
I'm sorry to hear it mate... Did you try the Prograde V60? Until now I didn't have any problems with this cards on the S1 and S1H
All true!
Great summary of the differences. The price difference between the S1 + Vlog update and the S5 is quite small compared to what you will be spending on the system anyway, so I would agree that if the weight and absence of a flip-out screen is not an issue, the S1 will be the better deal.
Thank you for your comment Michael! Do you also have the S1 or are you planning to get one?
@@LucaBono.Studio I'm considering to get one, so I'm weighing my options.
@@MichaelSchagen try them both, maybe you will prefer the smaller and lighter body of the S5...who knows 😁
100% agree with your 10 reasons and the reason 1 is the major one, the EVF resolution and confort.
Thank Didier, I'm glad you agree!
Sigh...I own the S5, but had we known this update was coming...I would have gone with a used S1. I really hope there will be a significant update for s5 in the future
It's ok buddy, the S5 is still a great camera ;)
I don't think that Panasonic will drop an update to the S5, because in their website the S5 is classified as a lower camera than the S1/S1R/S1H
I got the S5, the kit and the 50mm f1.8 ¿This lens are whether sealed? I cant trust this kit in the rain? or i better try to get an used S1 for the tropical forest?
They're all weather sealed but they're not water proof, they don't have any IP certification. Maybe you should look into the Leica SL system for tropical forests
@@LucaBono.Studio :( An umbrela them… I dont got Leica SL money, only Lumix deb jajaja
Topical video! I actually just picked a used S1 with V-Log and Firmware 2.0 over getting the S5 new earlier this week and I'm PUMPED for the camera to get here. Can't wait to try it out!
Thanks buddy, you probably got an amazing deal with the used S1! Have fun with it!
@@LucaBono.Studio I'm thinking that I did! Saved a good $1000+ over buying a new S1 and getting the V-Log upgrade myself. And the camera looks to be in terrific condition!
Also I just bought your LUT pack for the S line and was testing them out on a sample S1H footage I found online. DANG, these luts are great! :D
@@incendiesproductions wow, that's great mate! Saving 1000$ is not bad at all ahahah!
Thank you so much for your feedback about the LUTs, I'm really happy that you like them! I love to use them ahahah
Thanks for the video. Considering picking up an s1 in 2022
Thank you for watching mate! Cheers!
S1 autofocus not available will slow motion plus shutter speed is fix slow motion which gives flicker ...S5 is better in this aspect
They both have AF up to 125fps in full hd
I’m convinced. Need to sell my new S5 now...
Naaa, keep it as B-cam 😁😜
@@LucaBono.Studio I know Im starting to think this as well..haha I already own Sony FX6 though and may be getting another Sony later in year as B Cam =/. I wish they had anamorphic options haha
I did.
Is there any noticeable difference in image quality between the two, particularly low light picture quality?
They're sharing the same sensor. They've the same image quality. Cheers!
Between 4:00 and 5:00 of this video, there is heavy flare in the shape of the iris and not organic at all. I recall Cined also complained about the same issue in their dynamic range tests. How often does this happen? Coz that will potentially ruin the shot
Hi Bela, that flare is a light leak caused by my Leica R adapter. Thank you for watching!
Thanks for your reasons! I shoot photos and 4K videos on S1 with panasonic 70-200/4 and want to buy the second camera. Especially for shooting 4K video on a gimble with panasonic 24-70/2.8. And it is a question what to buy, S1 or S5...
I would get another S1, it's better to have more of the same cameras...the 300g of the S1 will balance the weight of the 24-70 better on the gimbal. IMHO....
Sold my S1H and took an S1. The updates they made is crazy.
The S1 became a really good camera after the update! The internal 6k is awesome 👌
Cheers!
So Luca, I'm on the fence of getting the S1 or the S5 next week. Do you still think the S1 is the better option? I shoot handheld and always manual focus.
Hey Joakim! The S1, hands down!
Hello , can the s1 switch NTSC & PAL ?
There's no need for it...all the recording options are available at the same timr. With the S1H and S5 you have select NTSC or PAL
I'm late to the party but still grabbed one in 2022
But bought an S1 yesterday
Nice mint one
Hope I enjoy it
My first Lumix actually ...
Have fun with it! Cheers!
@@LucaBono.Studio Thanks ... 🙏
It was such a helpful video in specs point of view. But I'm bit confused !!! Should I go for a7iii or S1 ? Can you help me with this.. ?
Hi Adarsh, what do you plan to do with the new camera? If you need to work as sport or wildlife photographer, the Sony is a better choice...otherwise the S1 is superior.
I want it for wedding films, fashion, product and interior shoots. So should I go for S1 ? Which prime lens you suggest me to get since I was thinking to go for 85mm 1.8
Gracias, por fin los precios están bajando y quiero aprovechar.
De nada! Ahora es el momento adecuado para comprar un modelo usado! ✌
which one is better for videography???
The S1
Thank you for sharing. Which monopod did you use for this vid? it looks really stable!
Thank mate, I've used the Manfrotto one...it's the same that let the camera fly to the ground if you don't hold it. Don't buy it ahahah
Nice presentation with plenty of good info! Thanks!!!
Thanks buddy!
Choose the S1h and your troubles are over ;)
If money wasn't a thing, with pleasure ahahah
One reason to get the S5 over the S1 is the flipping screen.
Yep! That's the only reason why I got one S5 as well ahhahah
I have other problem: S1 or R6?!!
Unless you work as sport or wildlife photographer, the S1 is better imho
I'm really enjoying your videos on the Lumix S series. I have a question as I'm thinking of selling my trusty GH5 and a couple of lenses and then buying either a S1 or S5. The biggest difference for me (or at least my way of shooting) seems to be the EVF and AF. On the GH5 I use the EVF 80% of the time to check I'm in focus and I also have the camera on MF but I use back button focus to get a shot in focus before adjusting any focus the shot might need. So really I have 2 questions! Is the AF in the S1 as good as the S5 with the new firmware update (for video)? And does the EVF really make a difference when checking critical focus?
Thanks!
Thanks mate! Yes the AF performances are the same between the two cameras, but the difference in the EVF is pretty big...the S1 is just a superior camera but bigger, heavier, without the flippy screen (that I hate). Maybe you should go in a shop and try yourself 😜
Hi! I had also one issue already with .MDT file. 6k 25 10bit on V30 but I heard that also on CF Express also happened to guys on FB S1 groups. I do not need to record All-I but for 6k 25 and 4K 50 10bit do you think better V60 or V90. Could fix issue?
Hey Lukasz! Yes you need at least a V60 for 200mbps codecs. With a V30 the writing speed is not enough and the camera will keep a good portion of the file in the buffer before it can write on the card, increasing the risk of mtd files
@@LucaBono.Studio ok, I am thinking about angelbird sd. Here in Poland could be a good choice. Do you think V60 is enough for those 200mb files 6k25 and 4k50 or it’s better to spend more money for V90?
I'm using the Lexar V60 and I never had a problem with them...but nothing is sure with our cameras ahahah! Good luck buddy!
@@LucaBono.Studio haha Ok ;)
3:50, the scene is so beautiful. Shoot with Leica R? Buttery smooth!
Hey Liam! Yes I've filmed the entire vlog with the Leica R 24mm F2.8...it's a fantastic lens!
@@LucaBono.Studio Thanks for your reply. It's very happy and relax to watch your videos. Always nice quality color, of course 😏
Dang that first shot looks good!
Thanks mate!
What profile was this shot on?
Hi Daimen, I've used v-log and graded with my LUT
Many thanks, for great informative video! Perfect, as always!
Thanks mate! I appreciate your comment!
How do you see yourself with the S1? Cheers!
I've a video about it, I do it with the mirror screen 😁
nice informative video man
keep it up
Thank you Ankur!
Does the S1 have any advantages in terms of image quality or better low light compared to the S5?
If you film with the atomos ninja V there are no differences...if you film internally, the images of the 6K from the S1 are looking more organic and less digital
@@LucaBono.Studio thanks for the information. Appreciate it.
Thank you so much!
Thank you for watching Rodrigo!
Hello Luca.
Thank you for your videos.
I'm planning to buy the S5 or S1, I like the size of the S5 and the screen, but I don't like the micro HDMI, and other limitations 😅
Do you think with the firmware 2.0 the S1 has the same af performance as the S5?
Hi buddy! Yeah the S1 is much better than the S5...and keep in mind that the S5 is not that smaller and lighter.
@@LucaBono.Studio even in the autofocus? Thanks
@@adkickerfilms4393 The AF performances are the same with all the Lumix S 😉
@@LucaBono.Studio great, thanks!
This video looks and sounds gorgeous!
Thank you Sai!
The S1 is special
It is! Imho it's the best camera of the lumix series (considering the XQD slot)
What do you use the most? S1, S1H or S5?
S1 for my TH-cam Channel and S1R for my photographs in competition with the SL2 which I’m selling now since I largely prefer the S1R
@@DidierMOULINPhotography why do you prefer the S1R over the SL2? Do you miss the extra keys?
@@LucaBono.Studio it’s far more than just a question of number of buttons. I will make a video about the SL2. A real honest video that tells the truth about this myth!
@@DidierMOULINPhotography that would be really helpful! Can't wait to watch it 👌🏻
@@LucaBono.Studio I will work on it tomorrow and will show it once I have sold the SL2... I don’t want to kill my deal!!! Lol !
Great video. Very informative but still light candid humor. Thanks mate!
Thank you for watching my friend!
Hey! I can‘t find the Film Look 7 Lut in the description. Where can I find it?
Hi buddy, it will come soon as LUT and Power Grade...probably next week!
@@LucaBono.Studio Nice, thank you! Looking forward to!
Luca, thank you so much for this video---subscribed for more content.
What an excellent list---and having owned both cameras I thoroughly agree with you on every point.
That is why I have actually sold my S5 and purchased another S1 to replace it. I have also owned the S1H--but of these three cams I really liked the S1 better.
The only issue with the S1 when I first owned it was this: as soon as you hit record the peaking drastically diminishes. As you know this makes it very difficult to track a subject if you are shooting as I do---using fully manual lenses and pulling my own focus.
I wonder: with the latest firmware and all those great new features in the S1----do you know if they have corrected the problem with the peaking? This vanishing peaking only happens with the S1. The S5 and S1H are both fine.---not as good as the GH5s, but very usable.
There are other issues for me and the S1, but I've been able to work around them---but the peaking was a deal breaker for me the first time I owned it because of my run and gun, fully manual style of shooting.
Fix the peaking and, for me, I have the perfect camera.
Thanks again for this video. I'm looking forward to see more of your content! Ciao!
Thank you so much William! A good workaround for the weak focus peaking is to use the monochrome view. For me it works pretty well! ;)
@@LucaBono.Studio Good suggestion. thanks so much. Still, it makes me crazy how they cripple cameras like this in such crazy ways. The S1 diopter only goes to +2...the S5 goes to +4. To see the image of the S1 EVF in focus I have to add a diopter to their best rubber eyecup---I glue it to the eyecup.
The Sony a7sIII EVF--only goes to +3---still not quite good enough---unless you view the EVF with your glasses---which in some ways defeats the whole purpose of the EVF. I and thousands more like me have to have a +4 diopter.
This is absurd that camera companies do this and cause such needless complications. If I owned a camera company I'd do all I could, offering every possible assist, to help videographers get the very best results with the least difficulties possible.
How much more would a diopter with a range to +4 cost? Only pennies.
The only companies I know who don't cripple their cameras in crazy ways: Blackmagic design and Fujifilm. They give you all they can to help you get the shot!
If you've never tried it: Fujifilm X-t4: best peaking of all makers, bar none, state of the art!... and you can move your focus box anywhere on the screen, punch in, and refocus at any time while filming. I used it all the time on Fujis. You never miss a focus pull.
What a great company!
Yes I know and it's sad that it's not possible to punch in while filming and that the focus peaking is not that great... I've always been tempted to get the pocket 6K or the Fuji xt-4, but I prefer to stick in the 35mm sensor size because of my set of lenses (Leica R & Zeiss). I like to shoot wide, 35mm is my normal.
Hopefully someone will make a good full frame camera at one point... I'm not a fanboy of Panasonic 😉
@@LucaBono.Studio Where do you find the monochrome view setting?
Hey, William! Can you share your experience using GH5S and S series cameras? Thanks.