To know more about the Force Gurkha, Thar Roxx and Maruti Suzuki Jimny, click here - www.autocarindia.com/compare-cars/mahindra-thar-roxx-ax7l-2.2-diesel-mt-4x4-vs-maruti-suzuki-jimny-1.5-petrol-alpha-mt-vs-force-gurkha-5-door-2.6-diesel-mt
@@aryaraj_77 Thar and RE are two brands I will stay away from solely bcz of the image... Even though I like what RE has done with the new Guerrilla 450 and Mahindra with Roxx... but there's no way I'm actually buying... Also I do prefer sporty bikes (but not KTM, cz again, the image) and cars over rugged and retro so there's that as well...
All three of these are fantastic. To see where consumer choice in India has reached is amazing. In the 80’s, 90’s, 2000’s and 10’s we only had those old school flat fender Jeeps and Gypsys with nary a creature comfort. Now, one can take on any terrain in great comfort. One thing all Auto journals have to remember is that the Jimny is the Modern Gypsy. The average speeds in India are no more than 50kmph at the max, in a mix of Highway and City driving. So one can live with the Jimny quite comfortably. Dont forget that with harder acceleration, one will also have to brake harder. So instead of zooming along, it may be better to just chunter along, considering that one doesnt derive any big advantage by “zooming”, considering the typical Indian driving conditions.
Considering interior of Gurkha and lack of features and safety features it's 18 Lakh price is unfathomable I thought it costs around 11 to 13 which would be nice. It's overpriced
@@25StevyLovesDaddyTata true, force should work on its interior, but 11-13 lakh? I just bought Bolero B6 that itself costs 12 lakh and you want Force to sell a 4×4 car with mechanical diff at that price is mind boggling. Thats not possible and its a big engine car so government really likes those tasty tax money.
I have seen one 5 door gurkha in black , it has massive road presence, i mean from images i thaught its old school car but man after seeing on road I'm literally thinking it has more road presence than thar also.😮 Literally loved gurkha after that ❤
Yes. Recently few weeks ago I saw a three door Gurkha (Black) all of sudden because very few people buy it and not easily seen on roads. Believe me it stuck in my mind since then.
@@ajaykumarkonkati exactly, from images on media I don't like that car much because lack of features and interior design but when I see Gurkha , from on that day I realised Gurkha built for off road not show off car like Thar. Even I feel short because I seat in seltos and Gurkha 5 door stand like big macho boy infront of us.🤩
@@jattboy2043 comparing with majority of cars on the road, Scorpio N has low range gear and locking rear diff, so it can go off-road, definitely not as far as others, but I am curious how much it can go. Maybe just a lift kit is needed and then it will have other numbers better for off-roading
Its interesting to compare but shouldn't be compared all are for different purpose Jimny : cute little car for those who are new to off roading Thar roz : the do all vehicle Gurkha : reliable as hell for those who want to go off grid without any worry
Jimny is also reliable offroader (tougher than you think about it).. It's a global offroad vehicle. Watch BRH expedition channel to know about jimny extreme offroading
Jimny: 4X4 for people who understand power/weight ratios, sound engineering, mechanics and have serious offroad driving skill. The bullet proof option which will last a lifetime and take any abuse you can throw at it. Also, infinitely customizable. Thar roz. For people who want a car that looks like an off roader but won't ever leave the city. Plush white interior to impress your poser friends and lots of useless assists which won't help anyone but the most experienced of drivers. Gurkha. Large vehicle for those who need more space. Practical inside and out. Build Quality is mid-range. Practical interior. Not a bad vehicle.
I don’t know, why do people go crazy over Gurkha. The engine is old, there’s a lack of features and the quality and fit and finish are not that good. Also, Thar Roxx & Jimny are equally capable off-roader. It’s not like Gurkha is in a different league when it comes to off-roading
I don't think you ever go off the road with gurkha. Just make 1 proper off road and overlanding trip with someone who know how to do you will understand why people prefer gurkha and then jimny. Thar comes nowhere near those 2
@@iDoSketchgurkha has a very bad articulation, what i felt. Going to the service centre too is a nightmare, overall it has to be a heart over mind and gurkha will bleed that ❤
Ignore these people bro, they are still kids who give unnecessary hate to Mahindra and can't afford anything themselves. Check sales of Gurkha you'll get the answers. Only 5% will actually go offroad and producing a car specifically for them is not viable for a car brand.
@@iDoSketch Gurkha's articulation is horrible and its weight is too much. Force is incapable of sorting things out instead of just slamming the 2.6 same old engine into an unmodified commercial chassis. The 5 door Gurkha weighs the same as the Gwagon, obnoxious case of no weight control at all. (Other 4x4 vehicles of similar/slightly bigger size- ScorpioN-2100, Fortuner-2200-300, Endevour-2300-400kg) Gurkha is tough offroader with more toughness than offroading capabilities. Remove lockers from Thar, Jimny and Gurkha and Gurkha's worth as an offroader is the same as 2014 Scorpio 4x4. If you are clueless or haven't seen Gurkha in challenging conditions check out Prashant Adventure's comparison between Jimny, Thar and Gurkha. Anyone would expect the Thar to come last but the Gurkha's performance was horrible. Had to engage lockers where the Thar and Jimny easily crawled through
Idk why i feel the Gurkha is just the right car but it definitely deserves a lot more like the Thar being a rich Dad's kid... And Gurkha like a kid from middle class family... Its just connects more with me :-)
More sales figures doesn't mean great car/suv, it's just that ppl don't do proper research and buy what they want, instead they follow others like sheep. Every vehicle has its own advantages and disadvantages, for instance Thars main disadvantage is it's first copy of Jeep, whether agreed or not but it is.
Its not the sales, its the third world vehicle with Force Traveller engine more intended towards a bus-like experience. The Thar is a first world vehicle easily, more so now with the 5 door and a much better vehicle overall
Maruti needs to start working on a facelift for the jimny , the company needs to stop manufacturing and clear the existing inventory and update the jimny in its width and make the cabin more roomy with rear seat comfort in consideration for 5 people if possible 3 captain seats with individual arm rests in the 2nd row, arm rest in the front row, with flat folding rear seats for more boot space , the moment they increase the width in a respectable manner and work on packaging like Honda does in its cars then the cabin will feel more roomier Features set needed : 1. Front and rear lock diffs 2. 360 camera 3. Front and rear ventilated seats 4. At least manual Lumbar support for front and rear seats 6. 2nd row seat slide, 3 step recline 7. 2nd row 3 adj head rest and 3 point seat belts isofix child seat mounts 8. 120 HP / 150 Nm 9. Standard mild hybrid tech for fuel economy 10. 6 speed manual 11. ADAS 12. 16 inch wheels for better ground clearance and butch look 13. Class leading approach and rack over angle and water wading capacity 14. 2 part rear door 15. Digital instrument console 16. Auto adj, auto fold mirror's with indicators 17. LED Lighting setup 18. Update the interiors 17. New colours 18. Hill hold assist 19. Increase the length a bit and improve 2nd row ingress and egress 20. New colours 21. Give center console storage and arm rest 22. Door pockets with bottle holder 23. Usb points for all 5 passengers 24. Wireless Android auto apple carplay 25. Improve the turning radius 26. Increased storage spaces Maruti Suzuki has the tech and sources to make it possible and fix all the above mentioned problems which will help them get back the market for the segment
Mahindra has come so far, their team really has to be commended. The latest Thar clearly took a lot of hard work to develop, and it is continually refined throughout the model run. It is a prime example of a product by a company that possesses considerable competence at every level. Well done 👌🏼💯
Gurkha - I can do anything, just know how to handle me. Thar roxx - i am sophisticated but i will handle it. Meanwhile jimny with Highway tyres in mud running around...💃🕺
The purest & 100% offroader is still Gurkha❤️..why on earth will you need an Adas & white interiors in an offroader??..mahindra is trying a family car with some offroad abilities..!
Maruti Jimmy fans aate hi honge apne global product ki badai karne. Jaha bhi jimmy ka mention hota hai ye bhar aate hain. Competition me jimny hai bhi nahi bro. It's a small off-roader that's it. Thar bhi global market me hoti to vahan bhi jimny se adhik bikti
Jimny is an offroad legend internationally. The Jimny can go to places one could never take large and heavy vehicles like the thar and gurkha. It is built for the hills and mountains and is the perfect vehicle for those narrow terrains. Best of all it is backed by maruti’s service.l and reliability. Also being a mechanically simple vehicle with none of those modern fancy bullshit, it only more eager to go offroad. If you want an ego boost because of low self esteem buy the thar. If your self esteem is not defined by what car you drive and you enjoy a reliable, safe and go anywhere vehicle that is a serious and proven off roader, buy the Jimny. The Jimny was built to be modified! The company gives the basic car which can be customized to whatever you like.
FORCE GURKHA NEED URGENTLY NEED ATTENTION... Change feel of old style inside, change seats and its wrong positions, Please learn from Mahindra 🙏 Honesty I don't have budget at this moment but my first choice will be a Gurkha but its seating and old looking interior can push me to go with Thar 5 door.
Thar is too big for the narrow Indian roads and streets. Jimny is OK size wise but from looks point of view it could be 1 inch wider which will enhance its road presence. So bottom line is there are so many cars available in India but not a single car which ticks all the boxes.
Thar are very comfartable and luxury offroad vechicle but gurkha ate feel very well toughed vechicle and steering are basic but give more fun drive in offroad like dust road mud and stone mountain
with 26000 km completed in less than 1 year JIMNY is more suitable for hilly state tried everywhere offroad to highway more km mean more mileage and less maintenance cost waiting for facelift sierra version with powerful engine
Land Rover’s where made for off-roading still they have white interior but thing is 99 percent of owners don’t take them off the road but Mahindra should have given darker interior colors cause majority of the buyers should go off roading but dosent make much sense for the rwd versions they should have gives a darker brown interior for the 4wd versions
Thanks a bunch for the great video as always. However I think Mahindra could give the Roxx 1 more Upholstery option apart from the Mocha Brown they have just come up with. I mean a big thanks to the M Team for giving us this option, nevertheless.. Another color combination like dark Beige and Black or Tan & Black combo ( Viz., in the new Creta ) could work really well with All 7 Body colors available. But the most important area, which could get grimy & greasy real Super quick, would be the Grab handles. Wiping the Grab handles always is going to be a Pain for anyone.
There are studies which suggest, Autonomous Driving or Driving Assist features tends towards increasing the probability of reckless driving. Currently the technology is also in development stage worldwide, and when offered by class leading so called country grown manufacturers, our doubts raise even further. Coming to the design language, one is a copied product, since they do not have licence from the original car maker for stealing its design language. Whereas the other ethically mentioned its inspiration's name in the official press release and gave due respect, honour and credit. It also assembles engines for them in India, both the companies have an ongoing partnership as on date. The ones who are commenting about it, mostly negatively, probably didn't got the opportunity of witnessing it in person, the moment one sits on its driving seat, every doubt gets answered by itself. That it isn't a car or a SUV(although the definition of a SUV is ruined in India), anyways it's a "truck"! Like an American Truck! Buy it, if you like Trucks, we personally do!
Dear AutoCar व आपकी पूरी टीम को बहुत शुभकामनाएं, आप बहुत अच्छा काम कर रहे है पर महिंद्रा नहीं कर रहा, कहने को तो देश की कंपनी है पर यह देश वासियों की सहूलियत के लिए काम नहीं करती क्योंकि पैसों की दौड़ में शायद करना ही नहीं चाहते या इस कंपनी में सारे इंजीनियर पढ़े लिखे है भी या नहीं क्योंकि इनको टॉप माडल की परिभाषा की ABC भी नहीं आती जैसे उदहारण- My Mahindra Thar 2022 Auto 4×4 Hard Top. Top Model Major Negative Points 1 by 1 Mentioned Below... 1. Top Model होने के बावजूद सिर्फ एक Key Remote वाली है जब सुबह Start करते है तो कई बार उसका Left वाला Door अपने आप अंदर से Lock हो जाता है पर Right वाला नहीं होता ऐसा मेरे साथ 15 से 20 बार हो चुका है। 2. दूसरे Door पर Key Lock नहीं है और दुसरी Key भी Remote वाली नहीं है। 3. Diesel Cap पर Key Lock दिया है पर Door पर नहीं दिया अगर दुसरी Key Remote वाली नहीं देनी थी तो Left Door पर Lock दे देते। 4. Two Door होने पर भी Climb Handle सिर्फ एक तरफ ही दिया है जिसको पकड़ कर गाड़ी में दाखिल होते है इतनी पुरानी कंपनी के लिए कितने शर्म की बात है। 5. Driver सीट पर बैठे Left वाले AC Vent की हवा Chest या Face पर नहीं आती Ac Vent को पूरा Tilt करने पर सिर्फ बाई कंधे तक ही आती है Check करने के लिए सभी Ac Vent बंद करने के बाद सिर्फ ये Driver Side का Left वाला Open करके Check kare... महिंद्रा जी Ac Vent पर थोड़ा ध्यान से काम करलो भाई । 6. Automatic में भी Dead Padel नहीं है 7. 2 Door है और दोनों में से एक भी Glass Auto Up Down नहीं है और Mahinda इसे अपना Top Model कह कर बेचती है। 8. Arm Rest नहीं है Year 2022 तक 9. Pocket में Key होने पर जब चेयर पर बैठते है तो Remote Key का बटन आपने आप दबने से आवाज Alert बजने लगता है। 10. Thar को Unlock करके अंदर बैठते ही उसको मैनुअल Lock करते है तो वो Lock होकर साथ की साथ Unlock हो जाती है। यह कई Situation में बहुत Danger हो जाता है कि जब हम ignition में बिना चाबी डाले और कई बार उसको अंदर से Lock करना चाहें तो वह Lock होकर साथ ही Unlock हो जाती है। 11. Fuel Cap पर Lock होने से तेज गर्मी में Diesel भरवाते समय गाड़ी को बंद करके उसकी चाबी Petrol Pump Worker को देनी पड़ती है जिससे गाड़ी का Ac भी बंद हो जाता है... मज़ाक बना के रख दिया Top Model का.. 12. Highway पर Ride Bouncy हो जाती है। Next Top Model गाड़ी... Neo Plus में Folding Mirror नहीं है, पीछे Ac Vent नहीं है 9 लोगों के बैठने की जगह है और वो लोग 45-48 डिग्री के तापमान में जल-भुन जाए पर महिंद्रा तो महिंद्रा है देश की कंपनी hahaha... Bolero aur Neo Bolero की पूरी Range में और Scorpio Classic and Marazzo में Auto Gear ही नहीं दिया मतलब देश की स्त्रियों के लिए कोई सहूलियत नहीं है जो व्यक्ति या कंपनी देश की स्त्रियों के लिए नहीं सोचती वह देश के हित के लिए कम और खुद के Profits के लिए ज्यादा सोचती है। मेरा मानना है कोई भी गाड़ी चाहे Base Model ही हो देश की Females के लिए Seat Height Adjustment Compulsory होना चाहिए। Base Model से तीन चीजें Compulsory होनी चाहिए... 1- Seat Height Adjustment. 2- Rear Wiper. 3- Electric Folding Mirror Adjustment. Xuv 300 W6 Amt Petrol 2023 स्त्रियों के लिए Hight Seat Adjustment नहीं है सिर्फ Rs 500 की बात होगी पर इन पढ़े लिखे लोगों ने नहीं दी। महिंद्रा की Xuv 300 Amt Petrol City के Rush Areas and Bumper to Bumper Traffic में अभिशाप है ये गाड़ी पर Highway पर बढ़िया चलती है... इनको 2024 में अब अकल आई XUV 300 Petrol की Gear Amt नहीं बल्कि Torque Converter होना चाहिए... महिंद्रा को इतने सालों का तजुर्बा होने के बाद भी ये गाड़ियां बना रहे है या .... 😅 Mahindra हो या TaTa इनको अभी तक Steering Tilt Adjustment समझ नहीं आई की नीचे की तरफ कितना नीचे जाना चाहिए क्योंकि हद से ज्यादा ऊपर की तरफ है जैसे कोई ट्रक चला रहे हो और तो और Bolero में Steering Adjustment दिया ही नहीं... वाह महिंद्रा वाह क्या बात है। Mahindra ji आपसे निवेदन है कि जब कभी आपको समय मिले तो यह कमियाँ चेक करने के बाद इनकी कमियों को दूर करने का प्रयास करे। आपके इस प्रयास से सभी लोगों को इसका लाभ प्राप्त होगा। 🙏 Specially Thar Front Driver Side Wala Left Ac Vent के बेकार डिजाइन की वज़ह से जिसकी हवा मुह या छाती पर नहीं आती... धन्यवाद जी...
I do not agree with the verdict for one reason. The Thar requires the passengers to climb into the vehicle. Doing it once or twice is alright, but that will becoming annoying on a daily basis. And for that reason, the Thar is not a family-friendly car.
Gurkha has the grade level basics.... but is Force motors ready for spare parts availability of spare and services...... hope Force motors Ltd.... keep upto the actual DNA.... of the Gurkha regiment.... particularly the Gurkha regiment.
To know more about the Force Gurkha, Thar Roxx and Maruti Suzuki Jimny, click here - www.autocarindia.com/compare-cars/mahindra-thar-roxx-ax7l-2.2-diesel-mt-4x4-vs-maruti-suzuki-jimny-1.5-petrol-alpha-mt-vs-force-gurkha-5-door-2.6-diesel-mt
I still dont understand why mahindra would give white interior for an Offroad vehicle
Its probably just how that specific media vehicle has been configured. Im sure Mahindra offers other interior colour options.
Because people don't buy it for off road, only youtubers or 1 Outta 100 customers take it to extreme off road to test it's limits.
Most people won't be offroading
Exactly... Although a lot of people use it for city use only but still it’s makes no sense as Thar still has the DNA of an off-roader
@@aayushkarnik7166they don’t
Ego boost is the main reason for Thar sales 😂
Reason enough, companies run on profits, how they come is not their issues 😂
exactly
such a good vehicle but personally, i would never buy it simply because of the image it comes with and the social consequences.
@@aryaraj_77 Thar and RE are two brands I will stay away from solely bcz of the image... Even though I like what RE has done with the new Guerrilla 450 and Mahindra with Roxx... but there's no way I'm actually buying... Also I do prefer sporty bikes (but not KTM, cz again, the image) and cars over rugged and retro so there's that as well...
@@flaminG-Ghost yeah spot on with the parallels drawn. i am in total agreement.
and to compensate certain shortcomings.
A massive sunroof and super white interior for an offroad vehicle....pure designer brilliance 😅
I suppose a suitable design for urbanites who buy an SUV and never go out of their city!?
During our time it used to be Gypsy, MM 540 and Tempo Trax.
All three of these are fantastic. To see where consumer choice in India has reached is amazing. In the 80’s, 90’s, 2000’s and 10’s we only had those old school flat fender Jeeps and Gypsys with nary a creature comfort. Now, one can take on any terrain in great comfort.
One thing all Auto journals have to remember is that the Jimny is the Modern Gypsy. The average speeds in India are no more than 50kmph at the max, in a mix of Highway and City driving. So one can live with the Jimny quite comfortably. Dont forget that with harder acceleration, one will also have to brake harder. So instead of zooming along, it may be better to just chunter along, considering that one doesnt derive any big advantage by “zooming”, considering the typical Indian driving conditions.
Jimny all the way.🎉 But really wish Suzuki plonk in the 1.4 turbo boosterjet engine aswell as an option 😩
Totally agree. Only problem with Jimmy currently is it is underpowered!
Even engine is ok. But 4 gear TC is unacceptable
Considering interior of Gurkha and lack of features and safety features it's 18 Lakh price is unfathomable
I thought it costs around 11 to 13 which would be nice. It's overpriced
Mostly because of stupid tax and stuff but Force should price it a bit better
@@crazypahadi1677Compare it to the ScorpioN z4 E 4x4 and you'll see that the problem is not taxes, but Force's own fault.
For 13 lakh 😂, u deserve Bolero
@@25StevyLovesDaddyTata true, force should work on its interior, but 11-13 lakh? I just bought Bolero B6 that itself costs 12 lakh and you want Force to sell a 4×4 car with mechanical diff at that price is mind boggling. Thats not possible and its a big engine car so government really likes those tasty tax money.
Bruh it's a fucking car which has a engine from Mercedes and has the shared patent with them, it's far rugged and better than thar jimny Scorpio
I have seen one 5 door gurkha in black , it has massive road presence, i mean from images i thaught its old school car but man after seeing on road I'm literally thinking it has more road presence than thar also.😮 Literally loved gurkha after that ❤
Yes. Recently few weeks ago I saw a three door Gurkha (Black) all of sudden because very few people buy it and not easily seen on roads. Believe me it stuck in my mind since then.
@@ajaykumarkonkati exactly, from images on media I don't like that car much because lack of features and interior design but when I see Gurkha , from on that day I realised Gurkha built for off road not show off car like Thar. Even I feel short because I seat in seltos and Gurkha 5 door stand like big macho boy infront of us.🤩
I recently saw a 5 door red Gurkha and man oh man I was awestruck. Instantly became my dream car. Saving up for it buy one day!
Watching this with 9 rupees in my account
You have achieved Moksh❤😂
Sailing in the same boat☺️☺️☺️☺️☺️
Jimmy ❤️
Almost none of the owners of these cars are going to do any offroading
Jimny owners will.
Correction: Jimny owner already out for a sunday off-road drive.😂
@@Shaycormac1234really? Whenever there's off road videos of India there's like 5 thar and 1 jimny ratio. Lol
Jimny
Gurkha owners busy Gurkha only for off-road purpose unlike other s@@Shaycormac1234
Jimny is 98% fun for 50% price compared to thar
By an atv .. it's more fun than Jimmy and 70% cheaper than jimny
@@Kanishhkaa which one?
@@Kanishhkaa atv isn't a car.. You can't get fun in rain
Atv are not road legal.
It’s like saying tractor is more fun than a car. :)
Mahindra badly needs help with colour choices... White interiors on THAR & 3XO.. so unthoughtful... Also the over done copper inserts on XUV400...
I like the white interiors but yes there should be customisation options
Yes it's like wear suit and slippers at a time 🤵♂️🩴
Hey it's not white, it's the "Magical Beige" color
I totally agree bro, offroad 4x4 suvs should be dark interiors
@@ychunks3710it is dark brother,in 4*4 its not white
Gurkha's locking differentials just a phenomenal magic. Along with massive road presence.
Thar white interior for off-road sucks😂, always Jimny ❤
You're a jimny owner, aren't u,
Jimny is tiny poooor xraaaap
But isn't Jimny a 4x4 shopping cart?
Jimny beat even Defender and Gwagon in many comparisons where Thar failed
10:19 don't look at features list. Thar roxx ax7l is 22.50 lac whiles girkha is 18 and jimmny is 12.74
It feels good to sit close to each other in a Jimny because in the jungle the closer you sit the safer you are..!
Instead of buying thar roxx ax7L,Buy xuv700 mx diesel 7seater and jimny zeta for 30 lakh.
Offroad brother, you wont understand
@@jattboy2043😂 .. i think you didnt understand offroad.. what he meant is from a hard offroader perspective
@@jattboy2043Jimny is one of the finest offroaders
That's actually a great suggestions! You get best of both worlds
Jimny Rules 🌍
In fact, Thar 5D should be evaluated as a family car rather than offroad vehicle. As hard-core offroad enthusiasts will anyway go for 3Door Thar.
Small correction. Hard core offroaders enthusiasts will anyway go for Jimny*
Jimmy for offroad*
@@sidharth6080 They may or may not be as Image matters.
@@kimphilbi9109 not for hardcore offroaders
@@aldrinpabraham6932 may be you are right
Roxx copycat 😂
Gurkha copycat 😂
Jimny Original design ❤
True
Ever heard about g wagon jimny older generations i agree was original but see the back jimny is copied from a g wagon it even has a gwagon kit
Thuff
So... What's the point.. 🤔
@@deltaandD7516 jimny current one isnt an original design thats my point
Scorpio N could also be in the video for the comparison and it would be good to compare in serious off-road track 😊
Its not a offroad car, morw like a family car
@@jattboy2043 comparing with majority of cars on the road, Scorpio N has low range gear and locking rear diff, so it can go off-road, definitely not as far as others, but I am curious how much it can go. Maybe just a lift kit is needed and then it will have other numbers better for off-roading
@Autocar India - Just want to clarify that Jimny does have a sort of diff. lock mechanism in the form of - BLSD (Brake Limited Slip Differential).
All 3 SUV's are offroading kings !
Its interesting to compare but shouldn't be compared all are for different purpose
Jimny : cute little car for those who are new to off roading
Thar roz : the do all vehicle
Gurkha : reliable as hell for those who want to go off grid without any worry
Jimny is also reliable offroader (tougher than you think about it).. It's a global offroad vehicle. Watch BRH expedition channel to know about jimny extreme offroading
You are so wrong😂 Its the Jimny that does all and the most reliable here. The other two will only be stuck as a mall and a grocery crawler
Solid axles are for new offroaders ?
Here thar is only car which is better for new comers. Jimny needs more manual control
Jimny: 4X4 for people who understand power/weight ratios, sound engineering, mechanics and have serious offroad driving skill. The bullet proof option which will last a lifetime and take any abuse you can throw at it. Also, infinitely customizable.
Thar roz. For people who want a car that looks like an off roader but won't ever leave the city. Plush white interior to impress your poser friends and lots of useless assists which won't help anyone but the most experienced of drivers.
Gurkha. Large vehicle for those who need more space. Practical inside and out. Build Quality is mid-range. Practical interior. Not a bad vehicle.
Gurkha is just phenomenal when it comes to offroad and plus this new 5 door version with new Mercedes engine is gem without any Electronics drama ✅
1:08 Jimny comes with ALL SEASONS TYRES. this is what I understand from other videos!!...
Comparing 12 lakh with 22 lakh is foolishness..... Then u guys add jeep Wrangler also.....
Jimny is compared with G wagan also in offroad test, Jimny is true offroader Those who know ,know
I don’t know, why do people go crazy over Gurkha. The engine is old, there’s a lack of features and the quality and fit and finish are not that good. Also, Thar Roxx & Jimny are equally capable off-roader. It’s not like Gurkha is in a different league when it comes to off-roading
I don't think you ever go off the road with gurkha. Just make 1 proper off road and overlanding trip with someone who know how to do you will understand why people prefer gurkha and then jimny. Thar comes nowhere near those 2
@@iDoSketchcorrectly said brother 😂😂😂
@@iDoSketchgurkha has a very bad articulation, what i felt. Going to the service centre too is a nightmare, overall it has to be a heart over mind and gurkha will bleed that ❤
Ignore these people bro, they are still kids who give unnecessary hate to Mahindra and can't afford anything themselves. Check sales of Gurkha you'll get the answers. Only 5% will actually go offroad and producing a car specifically for them is not viable for a car brand.
@@iDoSketch Gurkha's articulation is horrible and its weight is too much. Force is incapable of sorting things out instead of just slamming the 2.6 same old engine into an unmodified commercial chassis. The 5 door Gurkha weighs the same as the Gwagon, obnoxious case of no weight control at all. (Other 4x4 vehicles of similar/slightly bigger size- ScorpioN-2100, Fortuner-2200-300, Endevour-2300-400kg)
Gurkha is tough offroader with more toughness than offroading capabilities. Remove lockers from Thar, Jimny and Gurkha and Gurkha's worth as an offroader is the same as 2014 Scorpio 4x4.
If you are clueless or haven't seen Gurkha in challenging conditions check out Prashant Adventure's comparison between Jimny, Thar and Gurkha. Anyone would expect the Thar to come last but the Gurkha's performance was horrible. Had to engage lockers where the Thar and Jimny easily crawled through
why cant force use chrome logo on steering wheel?
Because it’s badge has no value
When is mansoon off-road comparison coming
Coming soon!
Idk why i feel the Gurkha is just the right car but it definitely deserves a lot more like the Thar being a rich Dad's kid... And Gurkha like a kid from middle class family... Its just connects more with me :-)
After watching full vedio
I got the conclusion is that ,
At the Comparison between JIMNY, GURKHA,THAR ROXX.
(Thar ROXX🔥 is best in all of them)
if you want the most capable, practical and reliable vehicle for your money, the Jimny is the clear winner.
Excellent presentation 👏 👌 👍 🇮🇳 All Indian 👍 🚗 Cars
If Off-road is main purpose then Go with Gimny.
Best it the segment.
Simple machine with very capable.
Thank You for the detailed review. It has helped me to think about what I really want to go for!
Is Gurkha a competition? Not sure if Gurkha manages 3 digit sales every month.
More sales figures doesn't mean great car/suv, it's just that ppl don't do proper research and buy what they want, instead they follow others like sheep. Every vehicle has its own advantages and disadvantages, for instance Thars main disadvantage is it's first copy of Jeep, whether agreed or not but it is.
Its not the sales, its the third world vehicle with Force Traveller engine more intended towards a bus-like experience. The Thar is a first world vehicle easily, more so now with the 5 door and a much better vehicle overall
Guys, I am not saying it's a good or bad vehicle. What I am saying is with ultra low sales/very few takers, is it relevant in this comparison?
Not even yearly sale is in three digits
Maruti needs to start working on a facelift for the jimny , the company needs to stop manufacturing and clear the existing inventory and update the jimny in its width and make the cabin more roomy with rear seat comfort in consideration for 5 people if possible 3 captain seats with individual arm rests in the 2nd row, arm rest in the front row, with flat folding rear seats for more boot space , the moment they increase the width in a respectable manner and work on packaging like Honda does in its cars then the cabin will feel more roomier
Features set needed :
1. Front and rear lock diffs
2. 360 camera
3. Front and rear ventilated seats
4. At least manual Lumbar support for front and rear seats
6. 2nd row seat slide, 3 step recline
7. 2nd row 3 adj head rest and 3 point seat belts isofix child seat mounts
8. 120 HP / 150 Nm
9. Standard mild hybrid tech for fuel economy
10. 6 speed manual
11. ADAS
12. 16 inch wheels for better ground clearance and butch look
13. Class leading approach and rack over angle and water wading capacity
14. 2 part rear door
15. Digital instrument console
16. Auto adj, auto fold mirror's with indicators
17. LED Lighting setup
18. Update the interiors
17. New colours
18. Hill hold assist
19. Increase the length a bit and improve 2nd row ingress and egress
20. New colours
21. Give center console storage and arm rest
22. Door pockets with bottle holder
23. Usb points for all 5 passengers
24. Wireless Android auto apple carplay
25. Improve the turning radius
26. Increased storage spaces
Maruti Suzuki has the tech and sources to make it possible and fix all the above mentioned problems which will help them get back the market for the segment
And the price will be above 22 lakhs due to these features, then who will buy it? 😂.. Jimny is a small offroad suv, wahi uski pahchan hai..
no thanks
u build it yourself
Gypsy ki successor hai
Manly + Massive 4X4X4 Gurkha
Manly + AI Thar Rox
Manly + Compact Jimny
Proud all are Indian Made ❤️❤️❤️
Very good comparo, keep it up....
Mahindra has come so far, their team really has to be commended. The latest Thar clearly took a lot of hard work to develop, and it is continually refined throughout the model run. It is a prime example of a product by a company that possesses considerable competence at every level. Well done 👌🏼💯
Yes they have managed to Chinese engineering by copying US vehicle and selling in India . Well done
Gorkha❤🎉😢😮😊Force 😊😮😢🎉❤Sach
Gurkha - I can do anything, just know how to handle me.
Thar roxx - i am sophisticated but i will handle it.
Meanwhile jimny with Highway tyres in mud running around...💃🕺
Jimny is the best...easy to maintain, low service costs and no fckin useless sensors .
I wanted jimny 3 door. 😭
Will jimny launch its pick up?
@Autocar India is Honda launching the WR V in 2025?
No
What s means here 4×4×4 In Gurkha it's different from 4×4?
The purest & 100% offroader is still Gurkha❤️..why on earth will you need an Adas & white interiors in an offroader??..mahindra is trying a family car with some offroad abilities..!
Mahindra urgently needs to change its designers
King Bolero 💥
Force Gurkha looks beast
Maruti Jimmy fans aate hi honge apne global product ki badai karne. Jaha bhi jimmy ka mention hota hai ye bhar aate hain. Competition me jimny hai bhi nahi bro. It's a small off-roader that's it. Thar bhi global market me hoti to vahan bhi jimny se adhik bikti
So your point being?
Thar can't be sold in foreign countries due to copyright by jeep
Arey bhai bolna kya chahte ho?? Yaha Sirf offroad vehicles ki baat ho rahi hai, selling ki nhi...
Selling me India ya foreign kahin bhi thar aage ho skti hai
But specifically hardcore offroad ke liye jimny better hai
Yeh bachha kuchh kehna chahta hai😂
Dammm , Gurkha looks like the big daddy of both thar n jimny
Jimny is an offroad legend internationally. The Jimny can go to places one could never take large and heavy vehicles like the thar and gurkha. It is built for the hills and mountains and is the perfect vehicle for those narrow terrains. Best of all it is backed by maruti’s service.l and reliability. Also being a mechanically simple vehicle with none of those modern fancy bullshit, it only more eager to go offroad.
If you want an ego boost because of low self esteem buy the thar. If your self esteem is not defined by what car you drive and you enjoy a reliable, safe and go anywhere vehicle that is a serious and proven off roader, buy the Jimny.
The Jimny was built to be modified! The company gives the basic car which can be customized to whatever you like.
Fix the Jimny rear seat and I think it’s quite a good car.
Right, I am going to work with cushions makers to see if it can be improved
FORCE GURKHA NEED URGENTLY NEED ATTENTION... Change feel of old style inside, change seats and its wrong positions, Please learn from Mahindra 🙏
Honesty I don't have budget at this moment but my first choice will be a Gurkha but its seating and old looking interior can push me to go with Thar 5 door.
Modifications can always be done in seats, if love the vehicle
Thar is too big for the narrow Indian roads and streets. Jimny is OK size wise but from looks point of view it could be 1 inch wider which will enhance its road presence.
So bottom line is there are so many cars available in India but not a single car which ticks all the boxes.
I wander why Mahindra has given only the options of white interior when it’s a more or less off roading vehicle.
Where is wrangler?
All these vehicles are 5 or atleast 4 seaters. So, why not to put these on test with passengers in same off-road conditions?
Which of these three would fare well on the long run, with rough and tough usage??? My best guess is the Jimny. It is thee Best.
Enhance your video quality -missing 2160p!!
Lol... 1080p full hd will be sufficient for 99 percent of the people
Jo Acha lagta hai Lelo yar..And drive together..Indian automobile market is 🔥
Thar are very comfartable and luxury offroad vechicle but gurkha ate feel very well toughed vechicle and steering are basic but give more fun drive in offroad like dust road mud and stone mountain
Force Gurkha lover ❤
It would be nice there are more than person driving and offering their reviews.
Thar 3 door ka kimat kam kab hoga ??
However, the Gurkha on road commands epic presence on road.
Gurkha presence overshadowed both from exterior look
Jimny-anytime...anyday😊
Sir namaskar🙏, I am looking for used jimny car, please let me know if you know someone who is selling
with 26000 km completed in less than 1 year JIMNY is more suitable for hilly state tried everywhere offroad to highway more km mean more mileage and less maintenance cost waiting for facelift sierra version with powerful engine
Land Rover’s where made for off-roading still they have white interior but thing is 99 percent of owners don’t take them off the road but Mahindra should have given darker interior colors cause majority of the buyers should go off roading but dosent make much sense for the rwd versions they should have gives a darker brown interior for the 4wd versions
Thanks a bunch for the great video as always. However I think Mahindra could give the Roxx 1 more Upholstery option apart from the Mocha Brown they have just come up with. I mean a big thanks to the M Team for giving us this option, nevertheless.. Another color combination like dark Beige and Black or Tan & Black combo ( Viz., in the new Creta ) could work really well with All 7 Body colors available. But the most important area, which could get grimy & greasy real Super quick, would be the Grab handles. Wiping the Grab handles always is going to be a Pain for anyone.
Maturity is when you realised Jimny is best off-road vehicle
Jimny is best ❤
There are studies which suggest, Autonomous Driving or Driving Assist features tends towards increasing the probability of reckless driving. Currently the technology is also in development stage worldwide, and when offered by class leading so called country grown manufacturers, our doubts raise even further. Coming to the design language, one is a copied product, since they do not have licence from the original car maker for stealing its design language. Whereas the other ethically mentioned its inspiration's name in the official press release and gave due respect, honour and credit. It also assembles engines for them in India, both the companies have an ongoing partnership as on date. The ones who are commenting about it, mostly negatively, probably didn't got the opportunity of witnessing it in person, the moment one sits on its driving seat, every doubt gets answered by itself. That it isn't a car or a SUV(although the definition of a SUV is ruined in India), anyways it's a "truck"! Like an American Truck! Buy it, if you like Trucks, we personally do!
Here Jimny's disadvantage is - Normal Highway tyres
Having jimny frm 23 ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I genuinely feel thar should have been named Armada
Dear AutoCar व आपकी पूरी टीम को बहुत शुभकामनाएं, आप बहुत अच्छा काम कर रहे है पर महिंद्रा नहीं कर रहा, कहने को तो देश की कंपनी है पर यह देश वासियों की सहूलियत के लिए काम नहीं करती क्योंकि पैसों की दौड़ में शायद करना ही नहीं चाहते या इस कंपनी में सारे इंजीनियर पढ़े लिखे है भी या नहीं क्योंकि इनको टॉप माडल की परिभाषा की ABC भी नहीं आती जैसे उदहारण-
My Mahindra Thar 2022 Auto 4×4 Hard Top. Top Model Major Negative Points 1 by 1 Mentioned Below...
1. Top Model होने के बावजूद सिर्फ एक Key Remote वाली है जब सुबह Start करते है तो कई बार उसका Left वाला Door अपने आप अंदर से Lock हो जाता है पर Right वाला नहीं होता ऐसा मेरे साथ 15 से 20 बार हो चुका है।
2. दूसरे Door पर Key Lock नहीं है और दुसरी Key भी Remote वाली नहीं है।
3. Diesel Cap पर Key Lock दिया है पर Door पर नहीं दिया अगर दुसरी Key Remote वाली नहीं देनी थी तो Left Door पर Lock दे देते।
4. Two Door होने पर भी Climb Handle सिर्फ एक तरफ ही दिया है जिसको पकड़ कर गाड़ी में दाखिल होते है इतनी पुरानी कंपनी के लिए कितने शर्म की बात है।
5. Driver सीट पर बैठे Left वाले AC Vent की हवा Chest या Face पर नहीं आती Ac Vent को पूरा Tilt करने पर सिर्फ बाई कंधे तक ही आती है Check करने के लिए सभी Ac Vent बंद करने के बाद सिर्फ ये Driver Side का Left वाला Open करके Check kare... महिंद्रा जी Ac Vent पर थोड़ा ध्यान से काम करलो भाई ।
6. Automatic में भी Dead Padel नहीं है
7. 2 Door है और दोनों में से एक भी Glass Auto Up Down नहीं है और Mahinda इसे अपना Top Model कह कर बेचती है।
8. Arm Rest नहीं है Year 2022 तक
9. Pocket में Key होने पर जब चेयर पर बैठते है तो Remote Key का बटन आपने आप दबने से आवाज Alert बजने लगता है।
10. Thar को Unlock करके अंदर बैठते ही उसको मैनुअल Lock करते है तो वो Lock होकर साथ की साथ Unlock हो जाती है। यह कई Situation में बहुत Danger हो जाता है कि जब हम ignition में बिना चाबी डाले और कई बार उसको अंदर से Lock करना चाहें तो वह Lock होकर साथ ही Unlock हो जाती है।
11. Fuel Cap पर Lock होने से
तेज गर्मी में Diesel भरवाते समय गाड़ी को बंद करके उसकी चाबी Petrol Pump Worker को देनी पड़ती है जिससे गाड़ी का Ac भी बंद हो जाता है... मज़ाक बना के रख दिया Top Model का..
12. Highway पर Ride Bouncy हो जाती है।
Next Top Model गाड़ी...
Neo Plus में Folding Mirror नहीं है, पीछे Ac Vent नहीं है 9 लोगों के बैठने की जगह है और वो लोग 45-48 डिग्री के तापमान में जल-भुन जाए पर महिंद्रा तो महिंद्रा है देश की कंपनी hahaha...
Bolero aur Neo Bolero की पूरी Range में और Scorpio Classic and Marazzo में Auto Gear ही नहीं दिया मतलब देश की स्त्रियों के लिए कोई सहूलियत नहीं है जो व्यक्ति या कंपनी देश की स्त्रियों के लिए नहीं सोचती वह देश के हित के लिए कम और खुद के Profits के लिए ज्यादा सोचती है।
मेरा मानना है कोई भी गाड़ी चाहे Base Model ही हो देश की Females के लिए Seat Height Adjustment Compulsory होना चाहिए। Base Model से तीन चीजें Compulsory होनी चाहिए...
1- Seat Height Adjustment.
2- Rear Wiper.
3- Electric Folding Mirror Adjustment.
Xuv 300 W6 Amt Petrol 2023 स्त्रियों के लिए Hight Seat Adjustment नहीं है सिर्फ Rs 500 की बात होगी पर इन पढ़े लिखे लोगों ने नहीं दी।
महिंद्रा की Xuv 300 Amt Petrol City के Rush Areas and Bumper to Bumper Traffic में अभिशाप है ये गाड़ी पर Highway पर बढ़िया चलती है...
इनको 2024 में अब अकल आई XUV 300 Petrol की Gear Amt नहीं बल्कि Torque Converter होना चाहिए...
महिंद्रा को इतने सालों का तजुर्बा होने के बाद भी ये गाड़ियां बना रहे है या .... 😅
Mahindra हो या TaTa इनको अभी तक Steering Tilt Adjustment समझ नहीं आई की नीचे की तरफ कितना नीचे जाना चाहिए क्योंकि हद से ज्यादा ऊपर की तरफ है जैसे कोई ट्रक चला रहे हो और तो और Bolero में Steering Adjustment दिया ही नहीं... वाह महिंद्रा वाह क्या बात है।
Mahindra ji आपसे निवेदन है कि जब कभी आपको समय मिले तो यह कमियाँ चेक करने के बाद इनकी कमियों को दूर करने का प्रयास करे। आपके इस प्रयास से सभी लोगों को इसका लाभ प्राप्त होगा। 🙏 Specially Thar Front Driver Side Wala Left Ac Vent के बेकार डिजाइन की वज़ह से जिसकी हवा मुह या छाती पर नहीं आती... धन्यवाद जी...
Jimny Professional offroad tool ❤
Bhaiya qj src 250 review vlog please 🙏
I do not agree with the verdict for one reason. The Thar requires the passengers to climb into the vehicle. Doing it once or twice is alright, but that will becoming annoying on a daily basis. And for that reason, the Thar is not a family-friendly car.
When will tata bring there 4×4 model
Will be good for public
Imagine Nexon,Harrier or Safari with 4×4 capability
Watching now?
Thar Roxx has no competition from Gurkha and Jimny. It competes with Scorpio-N.
2 hard core offroaders are Thar and Gurkha
GURKHA a1 my dream car 😢😢
Thar roxxx can use for family and off road capabilities
After 6 min of review I decided Thar Roxx❤
Jimny is way better for everyday and occasionally off road,getting in and out of that roxx is a nightmare if you consider everyday use
Tyres not equalised then it’s a game of grip.
There is one more you are missing, bollaro camper4x4
Gurkha has the grade level basics.... but is Force motors ready for spare parts availability of spare and services...... hope Force motors Ltd.... keep upto the actual DNA.... of the Gurkha regiment.... particularly the Gurkha regiment.
Time for force motors to collaborate with Mahindra 😅😅😅😅 just like Suzuki & Toyota 😂😂😂😂
JIMNY 💪