Hey Vladimir, have you heard of Archibald London? Their retail is around $499 but with their pricing now it's around $279 for handwelted shoes with closed stitching. Comparing them to Carmina, I think it's better leather quality as well as better construction.
Dear Vladimir: need index, like this: :-) 0:20: 10. Carlos Santos 0:55: 9. Allen Edmonds 2:00: 8. Cobbler Union 2:50: 7. J Fitzpatrick 3:25: 6. Lof & Tung 4:15: 5. The Armoury 5:05: 4. Sons of Henry 5:50: 3. TLB Mallorca 6:30: 2. Loake 1880 EG 7:10: 1. Carmina
@@v_r_ Vlad, when you type in a number with a colon in it, like this -- 11:20 -- youtube assumes you are talking about the current video at that time, and automatically creates a link to that point in the video! Quite nice feature.
Vladimir Riché The style jumper and Style OG are two more black men that make videos on TH-cam I think you guys should do a collaboration video you’re videos are great especially with the shoes keep it up brother
Great list and very helpful. I have Carmina and Cobbler Union on my watch list and can’t wait to get pairs from each. I also just bought some wholecuts from Paul Evans and find the leather and comfort to be excellent, possibly my most beautiful shoe. Of course, they’re Blake stitched. Have you reviewed this brand?
I have several pairs of Allen Edmonds. I like them a lot, however the main drawback with the brand is their quality control. Whether it is a first or second quality, you just have to be lucky to get a decent pair without major flaws. Great review as usual my man. Keep it up!
I've bought two pairs of Carlos Santos. You can get even get them for closer to $250 and the quality is INSANE for the money. Their handgrade line for nearing $400 kicks the crap out of my Allen Edmonds which aren't even bad. You get nearly twice the stitch density, beautiful patina, and a closed channel sole for less than AE retail. AE is only worth buying these days for either really good factory seconds or on sale.
I just ordered a pair of TLB now, my friend, much based on your reviews and recommendations. They better deliver or I`ll catch you....on some other occasion. But seriously, the customer service at TLB is fantastic and of course I pointed out in both mails and the comments field that your are the man to blame for the fact that I am now their customer :). Peace!
Carmina is selling a suede Chelsea boot that looks out of this world. Definitely buying it at one point. Great informative video as always. As a side note I can't believe the number of subscribers that you have. Your content is way better than some of the other channels on youtube and they have tens of thousands of subs. Go figure
I hear you, man! But I’m sure these channels had to start somewhere. Right now I’m just paying my dues and enjoying the process and grateful for each and every subscriber such as yourself. My time will come... I hope LOL Thanks for your kind words!
Having trouble myself trying to figure out why there are not more subscribers given the quality of the content. Maybe look at keywords and tags and that tech stuff so the channel comes up in more searches and recommendations. I think most people who watch one or two clips will subscribe, just a case of getting it out there more somehow.
Great video Vladimir 😁 those are some good picks. I'd also recommend Yanko from Spain; you can get them for 200 euro on sale, lether that is slightly below Carmina but still good, and very elegant last. Ofc no bevelled waist but at that price point it's no big deal. If you get some shoes from J. Fitzpatrick and Sons of Henrey please review them, as I'm also looking to purchase from them. Take care
Hey Martin, Yanko will be in my under $300 video. They make some really nice shoes for the price. And I will definitely make some videos on J. Fitzpatrick and SOH once I get my hands on them. Thanks for watching.
Thanks, Rob! It’s funny you said that cause I started in January and just last month I was at 500 so to me, 1k is a lot LOL. I’m glad you like the content, there’s a lot more to come.
Great video! New sub. I'm not listening to anybody else when it comes to shoes. I live in Atlanta and visited the Cobbler Union store for the first time last month.
What’s up, Stephen? That’s a lot of pressure but I can handle it...LOL. Cobbler Union makes nice shoes, when I come to Atlanta, I will definitely pay them a visit.
@@v_r_ I personally only knew about Carmina, Cobbler Union, and Allen Edmonds. This video just made my next purchase very hard. After years of wearing the same shoes I had my foot re-measured at the Allen Edmonds store and found out I should be wear a 8(E) instead of a 8 1/2(D) . I do like the closed channel soles like I have on some Giorgio Brutini shoes but on certain shoes like Allen Edmonds, something about seeing the stitching makes them stand-out!
Appreciate this list because it allows me to discover and explore some new brands and styles I’m not as familiar with. That said I like both #4 - Sons of Henry and #1 - Carmina. And I know exactly what Shoe I’m looking for in a new pair of stylish Double Monks in dark Brown - Burgundy color. Was a lot of show and tell here so much appreciated too. 2 Brands and style I can afford and will be checking out. Thanks!
As a owner of 9 out of 10 brands (except for the Armoury) on this list, I’d say your ranking is extremely accurate. Although I would probably remove AE from the top 10.
Just started watching your videos yesterday, and I watched a bunch. I like your taste and the suggestions are solid! Carmina is truly amazing for the price point
I will be honest with you! It's really hard for me to find dress shoes, that I like. I don't like that euro LAST at all. Carmina has some beautiful Exotic shoes, but not the last.
@@v_r_ not the narrow enlongated last! It's hard to find a dress shoe these day. I usually stick with Mezlan. But I had a Hand Painted one made. I guess 2 years ago, but made an adjustment on the last. Making it wider. My first of dress shoes in 11 years. I spent to money to ship back , because of the LAST.
Great video Sir ,Very good description of all the brands some new to me. I did not know Santos were Good Year welted I thought they only did Blake construction .Funny I picked up my first pair of shoes from Loakes last month ,double Wensum brown Monks from their 1880 Legacy line , lovely fit very comfortable. I recommend giving them a try to any fellow subscribers. Might try their Whole cut in dark Blue next. May I also recommend Barkers And Cheaney .Cheers ,look forward to the next episode .
Hey Adam, Barkers and Cheaney I’m a little familiar with but definitely need to do more research on them. And I’m very looking forward to trying Loake, I always hear good things about them but I don’t think that they ship directly to the US anymore from what I heard. And Carlos Santos have a few different lines at different price points. They have a closed channel also albeit a little more expensive.
One very important thing not too many shoe videos on YT actually tell you is that Carmina is IMPOSSIBLE to wear for many foot types, I don’t have difficult feet and none of their shoes feet me! Not a single one, AE do and when on sale they are way cheaper than 495$! Try before you buy!
Excellent video - very informative and well presented. While my focus over the last several years has been the higher end spectrum of ready to wear manufacturers, I have been pleasantly surprised of late by the high quality / price ratio and genuinely appealing aesthetics of some newer brands in this 300 - 500 range. Lof and Tung and Sons of Henry both made strong positive impressions with my initial purchases, and Justin Fitzpatrick offers a broad amd very compelling lineup. If I were to quibble with your rankings, I'd definitely put Carlos Santos a notch or two above Allen Edmonds. And by the way - CS does offer closed channel stitching at a slightly higher price (though still competitive with Allen Edmonds).
Hey Roger, I concur with everything you said. I believe we’re in the golden age of really good quality shoes without breaking the bank. Personally, I do prefer Carlos Santos over Allen Edmonds, a little American bias in the ratings I guess. Thanks for watching and supporting.
hey fantastic topic!Was a little disappointed not to see PaulEvans in that list.Hadnt heard of Armoury and Sons Of Henry.Thanks for the info.Will definitely check 'em out.TLB Mallorca is Meermin?right?Ive been admiring some of their shoes on instagram since some time now.Take Care.Peace!
Hey Hameed, I couldn’t put every brand, unfortunately but I’ve heard good things about PE though I’m not that familiar with them. TLB and Meermin are 2 different brands but both from Mallorca, Spain. ✌🏾
Hey Vladimir great content and review as always! What were the Carmina captoe Oxford’s at the end in that dark brown marble color? I think I like that last. Do you know the last?
Important to mention that A. Meccarielo offers aome models from $300 to $450 which is definitely a low price forsemi bespoke/MTW handwelted in italy shoe
Not many have sizes in 14 US or 13UK. BUT, at least the two I like most have my size..., Cobbler Union (just got my first pair) and Carmina. Cobbler Union recently stopped carrying my size, but if you contact them they'll send you a pair in your size.
Haha great video, but Carlos Santos needs to be at an higher spot. I bought a shoe from their handgrade line and one from their patina service and these certainly are better than my Allen Edmonds (not that AE is bad, but they just aren't as good). I would put them above a couple other brands not necessarily because of quality (which is still really good, but not anything crazy compared to other shoes on this list), but because they do some of the best patina work of any brand at any point and especially at this price point.
Thanks for watching! Personally, I’m not a Bruno Magli fan. My wedding shoes 9 years ago were BM but I didn’t know anything about quality shoes at that time. But knowing what I know now, I would stay away.
@@v_r_ I own the Alex last. This is hands down my favorite shoe. Whole cut simple but yet elegant and by far the most comfortable shoe I have ever owned.
Thank you, Steven! You can buy TLB directly from tlbmallorca.com and skolyx.se. Loake is a little harder as they don’t ship to the US, so if that’s where you are, you’d have to use a proxy service. But you can find them on websites such as loakenordic.com. Or loake.co.uk. I hope that helps.
I have to say, I really like the look of those Cobbler Unions, especially the sole & that quilted heel cup. I'm about to buy my first pair of "real deal" dress shoes & just cannot make up my mind. *I've gone back and forth from several of your recommendations on your videos. I'm not sure if I should go lower priced for my first pair like Edward & James, Meermins or just spend the extra money on a $300+ pair? Maybe Cobbler, maybe Carmina? Or maybe Spier & Mckay? (Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated) I'm in New Car Sales & image matters. So I want to invest in myself & start learning about men's wear*
My advice would be to get the best shoes that you can comfortably afford. Carmina is better than Cobbler-Union but they’re both good. Where are you located?
@@v_r_ I live in Knoxville, TN. So there's not really a lot of options when it comes to viewing quality shoes in person, or figuring out which last is best for my foot. *I buy size 12 in US (which also gets confusing finding sizes on different brands websites) & I measured my width at 4- 5/16" across. I do like a round toe better than squared though*
Very nice Vladimir! I also follow Hugo at Sartorial Talks, and I think he rates TLB as the best in this range, just ahead of Carmina. Says TLB quality is not seen at this price so he considers them a better bang for the buck. I'd love to hear your thoughts on that! Lastly, Crockett and Jones is on my watchlist and they have a few shoes in this range (just some loafers I think) Were they an Honorable Mention of yours perhaps? All the best, and keep 'em coming.
Forgot to add, I replaced my Allen Edmonds shoes with Cobbler Union, so CU and Loake are my daily drivers m butostly. Adding another CNES pair soon and looking to add a TLB I think after that, still deciding.
Great channel Vlad...can you do an unboxing or video on loafers. I know you mentioned not wearing loafers with suits...what about jackets and slacks w/o a tie????
Thanks, man! Loafers definitely have their use, I’ve actually seen them look decent with a casual suit such as Hopsack or Linen. And they definitely work with trousers and sportcoats. I don’t own a pair at the moment but there’s one from J. Fitzpatrick Footwear that’s on my list so we’ll see.
Vlad, Do you have any thoughts about wearing shoes made with less chiseled lasts for Fall and winter? I just find that the thicker/more bulky clothes become that a well chisel shoes disappears under all of that cloth. Think of it like this: if you put ten speed tire on a mountain bike, the look would be off. Assuming you agree, what does this imply about the connection between the best last for a shoe given the season?
What up, Max? I’ve never thought about that, actually. Maybe it’s because I’m not a huge fan of shoes with real chiseled lasts to begin with. I’m more of the round and soft square lasts type. With that said, I’m such a shoe guy that the first thing I always notice is someone’s shoes regardless of what they’re wearing up top. So even with a big bulky top coat for example, a nice pair of shoes always shine as my eyes always look down first. That’s interesting though cause I’ve never heard anyone ask that question before.
@@v_r_ - I just seen so many beautiful shoes on Pintrest with the most amazing line and curves that are made from chiseled last type. It's like looking at a sports car versus an SUV. Having said that, I notice at least on my feet that I just have a desire for a different look in Fall/Winter. You know something that looks as solid and cozy and the thick wool and tweed clothes that accompany these seasons. For Thanksgiving today, I'm wearing brown, suede cap toe oxfords! You?
I have been loyal to the A/E brand for several years because I have less trouble finding shoes in wide sizes (3E). Are there any other brands of comparable quality who offer wide sizes?
I was lucky enough to find some Allen Edmonds shoes in shell cordovan on eBay for $300 plus shipping. They are by far the best shoes I have ever owned. Maybe check out Ebay for deals and also lots of TH-cam videos show how to restore shoes with various creams and polishes. Really enjoy your videos. Thank you for making them.
First off, your channel is fire. I do have question regarding sizing for the Carlos Santos brand. I wear a US 10 D with 99% of my shoes. I’m eyeing a pair of Carlos Santos oxfords on their 234 last in a UK size 9 which is equivalent to a US size 10. From your experience and considering the last, do you think they might fit. I ask because these are new on EBay with no return policy. However, the price is very good, $280. Thanks bro.
What’s up, Eric? Thanks for your kind words. My inclination would be to say they should at least be close but shoes are very tricky as no 2 set of feet are identical. Is it part of the handgrade line with a closed channel sole or regular?
@@v_r_ They have an open channel sole. The style number is 10008-Coimbra calf patina. They are brogue cap toed oxfords. I greatly appreciate you responding.
I wouldn’t do it as that’s not really a great deal especially since you won’t be able to return them. Check Mehra instead, they have the same style for even less 👉🏾 www.shopmehra.com/products/style-10008-oxford-coimbra-calf-patina-carlos-santos?variant=31503774941239
Thoughts on the Meermin Liena Maestro, AE or Cobbler Unions looking for my wedding shoe my suit is green so not as fomal as tux but thinking of these shoes or can I go less formal then an oxford any suggestions are appreciated. Looking at black freudenberg meermin $310, Cobbler Union Robert which are on last call for $335, Allen Edmonds Carlyle Plain-Toe Oxford 296$
You did not do TLB Mallorca Artista line any justice. First grade-leather from the well-known tanneries Annonay and Charles F. Stead, an extremely slim beveled waist which continues in under the heel, tight sole stitch of 8 spi and more. Features you would find in high-quality RTW and bespoke shoes! And it's about $100 - 200 cheaper than Carmina that include the same features.
You have a point but at the time of that video, the Artista line was brand new and there wasn’t a ton of info on them yet and I didn’t know a lot of guys that had any hands on experience with them. If you’ve seen the other videos I’ve made on that brand since, I think I’ve more than made up for it. I have another unboxing coming up on them as well, stay tuned as it’s probably the most versatile shoe a man can own.
@@v_r_ so if you had to change the top 3 order, would TLB Artista be #1? I've had two very questionable experiences with Carmina in the last month - quality control and customer service are very poor. Toni at TLB, on the other hand, is, well, super hands on and goes the extra mile. Carmina Rain EEE or TLB's Picasso in G width for a wholecut in black?
What’s up, Prashant? That’s hard because most ready to wear shoes come bigger so they can accommodate as many feet width as possible. There are a few makers that have some narrower lasts but closer to a C. Have you given bespoke a thought? Maybe semi-bespoke? I have a video coming on that sometime in September.
@@v_r_ Hi Vladimir, I have and would love to go bespoke. However, I cannot afford it as of yet. I have never heard of semi-bespoke though (looking forward to your video). I am willing to increase the budget to 900USD if the shoe fits me perfectly however I have not found a bespoke shoemaker in that price range. I have been doing MTO in C widths and putting a thin insole as a solution for the time being. Would love to hear your advice and insights. Eg Brannock 10B - I ordered 8.5E from TLB which is equivalent to 9.5C in US sizing. And I plan on inserting an insole. Any thoughts on this?
Would love to hear you comments on Magnanni.Theyre not goodyear welted from what i hear but have Bologna construction and Artisano stitching(no idea what that is).Look forward to your thoughts.
When I used to work as a clothier, we carried Magnanni so that’s a brand that I’m familiar with. I used to recommend them to clients that wanted to stay in the $300-$400 range. But knowing what I know now, there are so many better options out there that I would no longer advise anyone to spend their money on them. I hope that helps.
@@v_r_🤔 Too late,my friend picked up a pair for me on sale for say around $200.I wanted a pair of double monks in my shoe arsenal and the moment my friend sent over the photos,i couldnt resist it.Later on when i began doing my research,i discovered that these arent good year welted which was a downer but like i said it was too late.One thing thats bothering me a bit is the size,the website says one should opt for half a size lower as Magnanni sizes run large.My friend picked up a 42 1/2 EU which im hoping would be fine since i normally wear a 43 EU but still cant be sure until i try 'em on.Fingers crossed!Whats your experience with regards to the sizing?
got the shoes,they look and fit great,thankfully.Turned out they were cheaper than i thought.Paid $175 for these.On the website,theyre for $435,exact same style but different color.Im sure you'll agree that at $175,Magnanni is a steal.Please let me have your thoughts.
@@v_r_ that means a lot!Thanks for the reassurance.There are so MANY brands out there that its difficult to zero in on one.Guess all brands have their pros and cons.Your advice is of great value.Thank you for sharing your experiences.Peace!
I’ve never handled them personally but a few of my clients have and they love them. I’ve also heard from other shoe aficionados and the reviews are good.
Don't you find it suspicious that your no. 1 choice in your both videos (the below $300 and this one) are brother companies (Meermin and Carmina)? To me it seems you are sponsored by them which its ok but letting people know saves your credibility. Personally I won't pay 300-500 for a shoe built in china and finished in spain.
You couldn’t be more misinformed but you know what they say about opinions, we all have one. Maybe you should do more research before commenting next time or just don’t and sound stupid on the internet. Your choice.
@@v_r_ yo some dudes get big headed after while and don't answer questions and get more aggressive and act like its about them. Yo, so I checked them and I cut the "chumps" off(Im old school 🏫 55 hence the term chump)You got the proper voice for rap btw them bars was mmm they was okay 👌… nah they was dope tho…
This is my Top 10 shoe brands between $300 and $500. I’d love to hear some of your go-to brands in this price point. Let me hear them in the comments.
I think you missed Septieme Largeur, those are awesome shoes. What do you think?
Earned a new sub
Hey Vladimir, have you heard of Archibald London? Their retail is around $499 but with their pricing now it's around $279 for handwelted shoes with closed stitching. Comparing them to Carmina, I think it's better leather quality as well as better construction.
Allen Edmonds is conservative and Midwestern. But i am conservative and Midwestern, too, and that is why I like them.
@@joaqpani8719 I have my eyes on those as well. But this list has 3 or 4 brands I never heard of, so it balances out for me.
Dear Vladimir: need index, like this: :-)
0:20: 10. Carlos Santos
0:55: 9. Allen Edmonds
2:00: 8. Cobbler Union
2:50: 7. J Fitzpatrick
3:25: 6. Lof & Tung
4:15: 5. The Armoury
5:05: 4. Sons of Henry
5:50: 3. TLB Mallorca
6:30: 2. Loake 1880 EG
7:10: 1. Carmina
Hey Alan, this is very well done, I’m not quite sure how to do that but I can figure it out. Thank you!
@@v_r_ Vlad, when you type in a number with a colon in it, like this -- 11:20 -- youtube assumes you are talking about the current video at that time, and automatically creates a link to that point in the video! Quite nice feature.
Got it, thanks! When I get a chance, I’ll update the other countdown videos.
Vladimir Riché The style jumper and Style OG are two more black men that make videos on TH-cam I think you guys should do a collaboration video you’re videos are great especially with the shoes keep it up brother
Great list and very helpful. I have Carmina and Cobbler Union on my watch list and can’t wait to get pairs from each. I also just bought some wholecuts from Paul Evans and find the leather and comfort to be excellent, possibly my most beautiful shoe. Of course, they’re Blake stitched. Have you reviewed this brand?
I have several pairs of Allen Edmonds. I like them a lot, however the main drawback with the brand is their quality control. Whether it is a first or second quality, you just have to be lucky to get a decent pair without major flaws.
Great review as usual my man. Keep it up!
I heard that from a couple people. I’ve never owned a pair but I used to sell them back when I worked in Menswear. I hope they’re working to fix that.
How am I only finding this channel now? I have to put my 'you insulted Allen Edmonds' pitchfork down and click the sub button!
Haha…welcome aboard, fam!
I've bought two pairs of Carlos Santos. You can get even get them for closer to $250 and the quality is INSANE for the money. Their handgrade line for nearing $400 kicks the crap out of my Allen Edmonds which aren't even bad. You get nearly twice the stitch density, beautiful patina, and a closed channel sole for less than AE retail. AE is only worth buying these days for either really good factory seconds or on sale.
I agree, you can catch some really good deals through their sales and factory seconds.
I just ordered a pair of TLB now, my friend, much based on your reviews and recommendations. They better deliver or I`ll catch you....on some other occasion. But seriously, the customer service at TLB is fantastic and of course I pointed out in both mails and the comments field that your are the man to blame for the fact that I am now their customer :). Peace!
The Armoury is founded in Hong Kong, China. Their two stores are located in Hong Kong and New York (No store in Japan).
Yeah I know, I misspoke. I corrected it in the video’s description.
Carmina is selling a suede Chelsea boot that looks out of this world. Definitely buying it at one point.
Great informative video as always.
As a side note I can't believe the number of subscribers that you have. Your content is way better than some of the other channels on youtube and they have tens of thousands of subs. Go figure
I hear you, man! But I’m sure these channels had to start somewhere. Right now I’m just paying my dues and enjoying the process and grateful for each and every subscriber such as yourself. My time will come... I hope LOL
Thanks for your kind words!
Having trouble myself trying to figure out why there are not more subscribers given the quality of the content. Maybe look at keywords and tags and that tech stuff so the channel comes up in more searches and recommendations. I think most people who watch one or two clips will subscribe, just a case of getting it out there more somehow.
Vlad I just bought a couple of pairs of tlb mallorca ArtIsta Goya Last F width - for the money some of the best shoes in my wardrobe, hands down!
Great video Vladimir 😁 those are some good picks. I'd also recommend Yanko from Spain; you can get them for 200 euro on sale, lether that is slightly below Carmina but still good, and very elegant last. Ofc no bevelled waist but at that price point it's no big deal. If you get some shoes from J. Fitzpatrick and Sons of Henrey please review them, as I'm also looking to purchase from them. Take care
Hey Martin, Yanko will be in my under $300 video. They make some really nice shoes for the price. And I will definitely make some videos on J. Fitzpatrick and SOH once I get my hands on them. Thanks for watching.
Great content. How do you only have 1k subs? Stick with it and it will take off!
Thanks, Rob! It’s funny you said that cause I started in January and just last month I was at 500 so to me, 1k is a lot LOL. I’m glad you like the content, there’s a lot more to come.
Vladimir Riché yeah you’re definitely on your way to a very successful channel. Nice work.
Thanks, fam! 🙏🏾🙏🏾
Great video! New sub. I'm not listening to anybody else when it comes to shoes. I live in Atlanta and visited the Cobbler Union store for the first time last month.
What’s up, Stephen? That’s a lot of pressure but I can handle it...LOL. Cobbler Union makes nice shoes, when I come to Atlanta, I will definitely pay them a visit.
@@v_r_ I personally only knew about Carmina, Cobbler Union, and Allen Edmonds. This video just made my next purchase very hard. After years of wearing the same shoes I had my foot re-measured at the Allen Edmonds store and found out I should be wear a 8(E) instead of a 8 1/2(D) . I do like the closed channel soles like I have on some Giorgio Brutini shoes but on certain shoes like Allen Edmonds, something about seeing the stitching makes them stand-out!
Im so happy to see this just a week after i bought my first pair of Carminas. Keep making great content Vladimir
Thank you, Jakob!
This is a great top ten! You will definitely grow your following soon. Great information, Great production!
Thanks, Kalief! I appreciate the kind word and support.
Appreciate this list because it allows me to discover and explore some new brands and styles I’m not as familiar with. That said I like both #4 - Sons of Henry and #1 - Carmina. And I know exactly what Shoe I’m looking for in a new pair of stylish Double Monks in dark Brown - Burgundy color. Was a lot of show and tell here so much appreciated too. 2 Brands and style I can afford and will be checking out. Thanks!
Nice list. Unfortunately I can only wear AE. They just have the sizes. The best shoe in the world just does not cut it if it does not fit.
Hey Phil, sadly I’ve been hearing that a lot as of late. But I’m glad that AE’s lasts accommodate your feet.
They have different width. I don't understand why the other shoe companies can't have different widths too.
Some do but most don’t. It’s probably based on their clientele’s demands or lack thereof but I’m not 100% sure.
As a owner of 9 out of 10 brands (except for the Armoury) on this list, I’d say your ranking is extremely accurate. Although I would probably remove AE from the top 10.
That’s impressive, you must have a really nice collection. But I know what you mean, putting AE on the list wasn’t an easy decision.
Damon Qu Agree, though I own three pair....
Just started watching your videos yesterday, and I watched a bunch. I like your taste and the suggestions are solid! Carmina is truly amazing for the price point
Learning a lot from you on brands I have never heard of. Keep the video coming. Peace
Will do, fam!
Sub'd. Great content, Vlad! I need to stop by Carmina in NYC some time. I wish Loake would do the same thing and open up a shop in Manhattan.
Thanks for the support, Amos! I’m glad you find the content useful. Buying Loake in New York is really chore. An NYC store would be most welcomed.
I will be honest with you! It's really hard for me to find dress shoes, that I like. I don't like that euro LAST at all. Carmina has some beautiful Exotic shoes, but not the last.
What type of lasts do you like?
@@v_r_ not the narrow enlongated last! It's hard to find a dress shoe these day. I usually stick with Mezlan. But I had a Hand Painted one made. I guess 2 years ago, but made an adjustment on the last. Making it wider. My first of dress shoes in 11 years. I spent to money to ship back , because of the LAST.
I like how you talk about beautiful shoes with good music rhythm :) please post more videos, subscribed
Thank you, K L! I will
Great video Sir ,Very good description of all the brands some new to me. I did not know Santos were Good Year
welted I thought they only did Blake construction .Funny I picked up my first pair of shoes from Loakes
last month ,double Wensum brown Monks from their 1880 Legacy line , lovely fit very comfortable.
I recommend giving them a try to any fellow subscribers. Might try their Whole cut in dark Blue next.
May I also recommend Barkers And Cheaney .Cheers ,look forward to the next episode .
Hey Adam, Barkers and Cheaney I’m a little familiar with but definitely need to do more research on them. And I’m very looking forward to trying Loake, I always hear good things about them but I don’t think that they ship directly to the US anymore from what I heard. And Carlos Santos have a few different lines at different price points. They have a closed channel also albeit a little more expensive.
This guy is perfectly in rhythm rapping with the music lol!
One very important thing not too many shoe videos on YT actually tell you is that Carmina is IMPOSSIBLE to wear for many foot types, I don’t have difficult feet and none of their shoes feet me! Not a single one, AE do and when on sale they are way cheaper than 495$! Try before you buy!
Excellent video - very informative and well presented. While my focus over the last several years has been the higher end spectrum of ready to wear manufacturers, I have been pleasantly surprised of late by the high quality / price ratio and genuinely appealing aesthetics of some newer brands in this 300 - 500 range. Lof and Tung and Sons of Henry both made strong positive impressions with my initial purchases, and Justin Fitzpatrick offers a broad amd very compelling lineup. If I were to quibble with your rankings, I'd definitely put Carlos Santos a notch or two above Allen Edmonds. And by the way - CS does offer closed channel stitching at a slightly higher price (though still competitive with Allen Edmonds).
Hey Roger, I concur with everything you said. I believe we’re in the golden age of really good quality shoes without breaking the bank. Personally, I do prefer Carlos Santos over Allen Edmonds, a little American bias in the ratings I guess. Thanks for watching and supporting.
hey fantastic topic!Was a little disappointed not to see PaulEvans in that list.Hadnt heard of Armoury and Sons Of Henry.Thanks for the info.Will definitely check 'em out.TLB Mallorca is Meermin?right?Ive been admiring some of their shoes on instagram since some time now.Take Care.Peace!
Hey Hameed, I couldn’t put every brand, unfortunately but I’ve heard good things about PE though I’m not that familiar with them. TLB and Meermin are 2 different brands but both from Mallorca, Spain. ✌🏾
Hey Vladimir great content and review as always! What were the Carmina captoe Oxford’s at the end in that dark brown marble color? I think I like that last. Do you know the last?
Important to mention that A. Meccarielo offers aome models from $300 to $450 which is definitely a low price forsemi bespoke/MTW handwelted in italy shoe
I feel like they naturally fell off a little bit since Freccia passed but that's still a brand that I would love to own one day.
Not many have sizes in 14 US or 13UK. BUT, at least the two I like most have my size..., Cobbler Union (just got my first pair) and Carmina. Cobbler Union recently stopped carrying my size, but if you contact them they'll send you a pair in your size.
That what’s up, I like both brands very much. I have to visit the CU store in Atlanta one day.
Excellent job bro . Super advice and explanation
Brother 💪
You ain't no joke! 👊
I just Love your channel 👏 👍 👌 Your expertise is on the money 💵 💰 🤑
Thank You 👊✌️
Your kind words are greatly appreciated, Gordon! There’s more to come.
Vladimir just a short note to say hello. Hoping all is well with you and the family stay safe brother...
They all look great! You are very efficient in presenting information. (Now, give me a heart, or I'll think you're a hater.)
That means a lot, bro. Thanks for your kind words. And I’m never a hater LOL
Haha great video, but Carlos Santos needs to be at an higher spot. I bought a shoe from their handgrade line and one from their patina service and these certainly are better than my Allen Edmonds (not that AE is bad, but they just aren't as good). I would put them above a couple other brands not necessarily because of quality (which is still really good, but not anything crazy compared to other shoes on this list), but because they do some of the best patina work of any brand at any point and especially at this price point.
What’s up, bro? The Handgrade line is better than AE and I love my first CS from their entry level line. So I have to agree with you.
Great review . What do you think about Bruno Magli ? Also the best moccasins ? Thank you.
Thanks for watching! Personally, I’m not a Bruno Magli fan. My wedding shoes 9 years ago were BM but I didn’t know anything about quality shoes at that time. But knowing what I know now, I would stay away.
Vladimir can you do a review on Crockett and Jones.
Hey Jason, I’d love to but I don’t own C&J yet. But I’ll get my hands on a pair eventually.
@@v_r_ I own the Alex last. This is hands down my favorite shoe. Whole cut simple but yet elegant and by far the most comfortable shoe I have ever owned.
Love your videos. I was wondering which ones of these manufacturers make wide shoes since I wear 9 Wide. thanks
Great video, must share. You had a couple of brands I never heard of, so this video was educational to me too. Keep up the good work!!
I appreciate it, Waylan. I get asked about shoes a lot, I’m glad I was finally able to make this video.
Good looking out, Vlad!
My thoughts exactly on No.9
Haha... I’m expecting some pushback on that one.
Hi Vladimir, I like your videos and your selection criteria. Is it possible for you to review Paul Evans oxfords?
Another exceptional video Vladamir!! Where is the best source for purchasing TLB Shoes and Loake 1880.
Thank you, Steven! You can buy TLB directly from tlbmallorca.com and skolyx.se.
Loake is a little harder as they don’t ship to the US, so if that’s where you are, you’d have to use a proxy service. But you can find them on websites such as loakenordic.com. Or loake.co.uk. I hope that helps.
Vladimir Riché much appreciation and thanks for the information. You are a giver and a gent.Keep doing you.
I have to say, I really like the look of those Cobbler Unions, especially the sole & that quilted heel cup. I'm about to buy my first pair of "real deal" dress shoes & just cannot make up my mind. *I've gone back and forth from several of your recommendations on your videos. I'm not sure if I should go lower priced for my first pair like Edward & James, Meermins or just spend the extra money on a $300+ pair? Maybe Cobbler, maybe Carmina? Or maybe Spier & Mckay? (Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated) I'm in New Car Sales & image matters. So I want to invest in myself & start learning about men's wear*
My advice would be to get the best shoes that you can comfortably afford. Carmina is better than Cobbler-Union but they’re both good. Where are you located?
@@v_r_ I live in Knoxville, TN. So there's not really a lot of options when it comes to viewing quality shoes in person, or figuring out which last is best for my foot. *I buy size 12 in US (which also gets confusing finding sizes on different brands websites) & I measured my width at 4- 5/16" across. I do like a round toe better than squared though*
Very nice Vladimir! I also follow Hugo at Sartorial Talks, and I think he rates TLB as the best in this range, just ahead of Carmina. Says TLB quality is not seen at this price so he considers them a better bang for the buck. I'd love to hear your thoughts on that! Lastly, Crockett and Jones is on my watchlist and they have a few shoes in this range (just some loafers I think) Were they an Honorable Mention of yours perhaps? All the best, and keep 'em coming.
Forgot to add, I replaced my Allen Edmonds shoes with Cobbler Union, so CU and Loake are my daily drivers m butostly. Adding another CNES pair soon and looking to add a TLB I think after that, still deciding.
Cobbler union! I was wondering if they would make this list
Great channel Vlad...can you do an unboxing or video on loafers. I know you mentioned not wearing loafers with suits...what about jackets and slacks w/o a tie????
Thanks, man! Loafers definitely have their use, I’ve actually seen them look decent with a casual suit such as Hopsack or Linen. And they definitely work with trousers and sportcoats. I don’t own a pair at the moment but there’s one from J. Fitzpatrick Footwear that’s on my list so we’ll see.
WAY TO CALL OUT THE SHOE STANS FAM. ANOTHER GREAT LIST.
Thanks, bro! I appreciate the kind words and support.
TLB Mallorca, enough said!🔥
Great video! What's your opinion about Henderson shoes?
Useful video. Thanks Vladimir. I heard that Loake's makes their shoes in India now with the exception of the 1880 line. Is that true?
I've heard the same but can't confirm it. I wouldn't be surprised if that was the case for some of their entry level shoes.
Vlad,
Do you have any thoughts about wearing shoes made with less chiseled lasts for Fall and winter? I just find that the thicker/more bulky clothes become that a well chisel shoes disappears under all of that cloth. Think of it like this: if you put ten speed tire on a mountain bike, the look would be off.
Assuming you agree, what does this imply about the connection between the best last for a shoe given the season?
What up, Max? I’ve never thought about that, actually. Maybe it’s because I’m not a huge fan of shoes with real chiseled lasts to begin with. I’m more of the round and soft square lasts type. With that said, I’m such a shoe guy that the first thing I always notice is someone’s shoes regardless of what they’re wearing up top.
So even with a big bulky top coat for example, a nice pair of shoes always shine as my eyes always look down first. That’s interesting though cause I’ve never heard anyone ask that question before.
@@v_r_ - I just seen so many beautiful shoes on Pintrest with the most amazing line and curves that are made from chiseled last type. It's like looking at a sports car versus an SUV. Having said that, I notice at least on my feet that I just have a desire for a different look in Fall/Winter. You know something that looks as solid and cozy and the thick wool and tweed clothes that accompany these seasons.
For Thanksgiving today, I'm wearing brown, suede cap toe oxfords! You?
I have been loyal to the A/E brand for several years because I have less trouble finding shoes in wide sizes (3E). Are there any other brands of comparable quality who offer wide sizes?
What do you think of Mezlan? They’re on sale quite often and some of their shoes are goodyear welt. I think they’re made in Spain.
good information!!
I’m thinking about trying a pair of TLB . Who would you compare the sizing with. Also what do you think of Alden shoes ?
Excellent video. Thank you.
Thanks for watching, Stephen! I’m glad you’ve enjoyed the video.
I was lucky enough to find some Allen Edmonds shoes in shell cordovan on eBay for $300 plus shipping. They are by far the best shoes I have ever owned. Maybe check out Ebay for deals and also lots of TH-cam videos show how to restore shoes with various creams and polishes. Really enjoy your videos. Thank you for making them.
Hey Stephen, if you’re patient, you can find some real gems on eBay. $300 for shell is a great deal.
First off, your channel is fire. I do have question regarding sizing for the Carlos Santos brand. I wear a US 10 D with 99% of my shoes. I’m eyeing a pair of Carlos Santos oxfords on their 234 last in a UK size 9 which is equivalent to a US size 10. From your experience and considering the last, do you think they might fit. I ask because these are new on EBay with no return policy. However, the price is very good, $280. Thanks bro.
What’s up, Eric? Thanks for your kind words. My inclination would be to say they should at least be close but shoes are very tricky as no 2 set of feet are identical. Is it part of the handgrade line with a closed channel sole or regular?
@@v_r_ They have an open channel sole. The style number is 10008-Coimbra calf patina. They are brogue cap toed oxfords. I greatly appreciate you responding.
I wouldn’t do it as that’s not really a great deal especially since you won’t be able to return them. Check Mehra instead, they have the same style for even less 👉🏾 www.shopmehra.com/products/style-10008-oxford-coimbra-calf-patina-carlos-santos?variant=31503774941239
@@v_r_ thanks for providing the link. I see they offer returns as well. Continued success and growth for your channel!
Vladimir, please tell me, which brand have quality monk strap shoes with brogue, also are there any loafers that have brogue.
New to the channel great content
Thoughts on the Meermin Liena Maestro, AE or Cobbler Unions looking for my wedding shoe my suit is green so not as fomal as tux but thinking of these shoes or can I go less formal then an oxford any suggestions are appreciated. Looking at black freudenberg meermin $310, Cobbler Union Robert which are on last call for $335, Allen Edmonds Carlyle Plain-Toe Oxford 296$
Dear sir which one is the best shoe care product e.g.cream, polish.
Thank you
I use Saphir Medaille D’Or exclusivity and they always do a good job. I’ve been meaning to make some shoe cleaning videos. I’ll make it happen.
Good info!
Thanks, my brother!
A good, useful list.
Thank you, Antonio!
You did not do TLB Mallorca Artista line any justice. First grade-leather from the well-known tanneries Annonay and Charles F. Stead, an extremely slim beveled waist which continues in under the heel, tight sole stitch of 8 spi and more. Features you would find in high-quality RTW and bespoke shoes! And it's about $100 - 200 cheaper than Carmina that include the same features.
You must be new here. Do your research on me first, bro 😂😂😂
@@v_r_ I saw your unboxing. I meant for this video, Loake for example you went in depth.
You have a point but at the time of that video, the Artista line was brand new and there wasn’t a ton of info on them yet and I didn’t know a lot of guys that had any hands on experience with them. If you’ve seen the other videos I’ve made on that brand since, I think I’ve more than made up for it. I have another unboxing coming up on them as well, stay tuned as it’s probably the most versatile shoe a man can own.
@@v_r_ so if you had to change the top 3 order, would TLB Artista be #1? I've had two very questionable experiences with Carmina in the last month - quality control and customer service are very poor. Toni at TLB, on the other hand, is, well, super hands on and goes the extra mile. Carmina Rain EEE or TLB's Picasso in G width for a wholecut in black?
Hi Vladimir, What shoe brands would you recommend for extra narrow feet?
(Brannock B width)
What’s up, Prashant? That’s hard because most ready to wear shoes come bigger so they can accommodate as many feet width as possible. There are a few makers that have some narrower lasts but closer to a C. Have you given bespoke a thought? Maybe semi-bespoke? I have a video coming on that sometime in September.
@@v_r_ Hi Vladimir, I have and would love to go bespoke. However, I cannot afford it as of yet. I have never heard of semi-bespoke though (looking forward to your video). I am willing to increase the budget to 900USD if the shoe fits me perfectly however I have not found a bespoke shoemaker in that price range. I have been doing MTO in C widths and putting a thin insole as a solution for the time being. Would love to hear your advice and insights.
Eg Brannock 10B - I ordered 8.5E from TLB which is equivalent to 9.5C in US sizing. And I plan on inserting an insole. Any thoughts on this?
I’m surprised To Boot New York wasn’t on the list 😳
What’s up, Omer? If you can find some TBNY around $150, I think that’s a good buy. Any higher, you can do much better IMO.
@@v_r_ thanks for the reply. I got mine for $160 just a month ago. Not bad for the price i paid.
THANK YOU!!!...ON POINT!
No doubt, bro!
I ordered some Loafers fromJFitzpatrick this evening.
What do you think of Magnanni Shoes?
What about meermin shoes?
Love it!
Thanks, fam!
Would love to hear you comments on Magnanni.Theyre not goodyear welted from what i hear but have Bologna construction and Artisano stitching(no idea what that is).Look forward to your thoughts.
When I used to work as a clothier, we carried Magnanni so that’s a brand that I’m familiar with. I used to recommend them to clients that wanted to stay in the $300-$400 range.
But knowing what I know now, there are so many better options out there that I would no longer advise anyone to spend their money on them. I hope that helps.
@@v_r_🤔 Too late,my friend picked up a pair for me on sale for say around $200.I wanted a pair of double monks in my shoe arsenal and the moment my friend sent over the photos,i couldnt resist it.Later on when i began doing my research,i discovered that these arent good year welted which was a downer but like i said it was too late.One thing thats bothering me a bit is the size,the website says one should opt for half a size lower as Magnanni sizes run large.My friend picked up a 42 1/2 EU which im hoping would be fine since i normally wear a 43 EU but still cant be sure until i try 'em on.Fingers crossed!Whats your experience with regards to the sizing?
got the shoes,they look and fit great,thankfully.Turned out they were cheaper than i thought.Paid $175 for these.On the website,theyre for $435,exact same style but different color.Im sure you'll agree that at $175,Magnanni is a steal.Please let me have your thoughts.
For $175, that’s a good buy. They’re decent shoes but definitely overpriced. I’d say you got them at the right price. Enjoy them!
@@v_r_ that means a lot!Thanks for the reassurance.There are so MANY brands out there that its difficult to zero in on one.Guess all brands have their pros and cons.Your advice is of great value.Thank you for sharing your experiences.Peace!
How about Grantstone shoes?
Hey James, I’m not too familiar with them but I’ll look them up. Do you own a pair?
A pair of their shoes (loafers), and several pairs of their boots. Very high quality materials and construction.
Nice
Thank you!
What do you think would be a good shoe for a size 9 wide from Carmina?
What’s good, Demetrio? Not sure I understand the question. Tell me more.
I like the look of the Carmina's. I have small, wide feet. I just want to know if Carmina makes a style of shoe that is good for me
I see, Carmina does make some of their shoes in wide. But it’s hard to gauge the correct sizing without trying them on. Are you in the US?
I just saw that Carmina has a store in Manhattan. I'll go visit.
I be feeling like a kid in a candy store every time I go there. You’ll enjoy it.
Yo Vald I’m going all the way in on my first pair of CapToe oxfords? Holla at me👍🏾
try winsonshoemaker 230$ with closed channel stitching, handwelted, and a very good quality
Thanks, I’ll look them up.
No Vass Budapest?
Isn't The Armoury from Hong Kong?
Yes they are, I said Japan by mistake. SMH
Allen Edmonds is the best fit
Please learn to love Allen Edmonds!!!
Haha...shoutout to AE
armoury is in hk
You’re right, that’s the flagship store. The other one is in NYC where I am. But the shoes are made in England.
I just realized I said Japan by mistake. You’re 100% right.
I need to stop by Cobbler's Union.
Anyone has any personal experience with Yanko shoes?
I’ve never handled them personally but a few of my clients have and they love them. I’ve also heard from other shoe aficionados and the reviews are good.
@@v_r_ thanks Vlad. Merry Christmas. I spammed the same question on another video apologies
Also, do you know any (EU) seller besides Skolyx? They won't be re-stocking a pair I'm looking for
Check Patine and Seamless Bespoke.
Would you ever buy of the rack?
If this guy is not Haitian, I'm going back to Haiti...
Haha...you’re good, fam. You don’t have to go back 🇭🇹🇭🇹🇭🇹
Don't you find it suspicious that your no. 1 choice in your both videos (the below $300 and this one) are brother companies (Meermin and Carmina)? To me it seems you are sponsored by them which its ok but letting people know saves your credibility. Personally I won't pay 300-500 for a shoe built in china and finished in spain.
You couldn’t be more misinformed but you know what they say about opinions, we all have one. Maybe you should do more research before commenting next time or just don’t and sound stupid on the internet. Your choice.
Except of AE they all look the same! As an European living in the US I am committed to AE’s design and US manufacturing!
That finger tho
What do you want me to do, bro? LOL
@@v_r_ haha its just funny. I like your videos man, good stuff. subscribed.
Bro this dude is a magnanni Hater. 😂😂
Yo man 👨 I just subbed your channel, hope 🙏 you don't switch it up
Thanks, bro! I only know how to be myself plus I have a lot more where that came from.
@@v_r_ yo some dudes get big headed after while and don't answer questions and get more aggressive and act like its about them. Yo, so I checked them and I cut the "chumps" off(Im old school 🏫 55 hence the term chump)You got the proper voice for rap btw them bars was mmm they was okay 👌… nah they was dope tho…
I was better back when I used to do it everyday. I’m old now LOL
Are you anti American....
Are you?