You can tell cause it was bad honor when you have bad honor it’s a coyote and good honor it’s a buck and bad ending Micah absolutely destroys your brain
Arthur: he's a snake Dutch Micah: kills Susan (witch Dutch has a soft spot for her) Also micah: he's lying Dutch: you are right micah Arthur:🤬🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤬🤬🤬
Pre-1899 DEATHS: - Unknown Member: Killed for treachery. - Bessie Matthews: Hosea's wife. Died of unmentioned causes. - Copper: First camp dog. Belonged to Arthur. Died of old age. - Annabelle: Killed by Colm O'Driscoll, in revenge for his brother's death by Dutch van der Linde's hand. 1899 DEATHS: - Jenny Kirk: Died of injuries sustained during the gang's failed Blackwater Heist. - Davey Callander: Died of injuries sustained during the gang's failed Blackwater Heist, by the time they escaped to Colter. - Mac Callander: Sustained injuries during the gang's failed Blackwater Heist. Was interrogated and killed by the Pinkerton Detective Agency. - Sean Maguire: Shot in the head by the Greys, in Rhodes. - Kieran Duffy: Kidnapped, tortured and beheaded by the O'Driscoll Gang, outside Shady Belle. - Hosea Matthews: Killed by Pinkerton Agent Andrew Milton during the Saint Denis Bank Robbery. - Lenny Summers: Killed by Pinkerton Agents during the Saint Denis Bank Robbery. - Molly O'Shea: Shot dead by Susan Grimshaw in Beaver Hollow for claiming to have betrayed the gang by telling Andrew Milton and Edgar Ross about the Saint Denis Bank Robbery. - Cain: Second camp dog. Befriended by Jack at Clemens Point. Killed by Micah Bell at Beaver Hollow. - Susan Grimshaw: Shot in the stomach by Micah Bell at Beaver Hollow. - Player Steed: Killed by Pinkerton agents whilst John and Arthur were escaping their enemies, alongside Old Boy (John's Horse). - Arthur Morgan: Either executed by Micah Bell, or dies from his advanced tuberculosis and injuries sustained fighting Micah. 1899-1907 DEATHS: - Leopold Strauss: Died of wounds sustained from being tortured by the Pinkerton Detective Agency for information on the gang members and their whereabouts. - Karen Jones: Alcoholism over heartbreak at Sean Maguire's death and the gang's breakdown. 1907 DEATHS: - Cleet: Hung by John Marston or Shot by Sadie Adler in Strawberry. - Joe: Shot dead by John Marston on Mount Hagen. - Micah Bell: Killed by Dutch van der Linde and John Marston atop Mount Hagen. 1911 DEATHS: - Javier Escuella: Either killed or captured by John Marston in Mexico, and delivered to the USA by Archer Fordham and Edgar Ross, alive or dead. - Bill Williamson: Killed by John Marston and Abraham Reyes alongside Agustin Allende in Mexico. - Dutch van der Linde: Committed suicide by falling from a mountain. - Uncle: Killed by the US Army at Beecher's Hope. - John Marston: Killed by the US Army and Bureau of Investigation led by Edgar Ross at Beecher's Hope. 1914 DEATHS: - Abigail Marston: Died of sickness or grief. SURVIVORS: - Mary-Beth Gaskill: Flees Beaver Hollow in 1899 and becomes a successful writer by 1907. - Tilly Pierre: Marries a successful lawyer and has a child in 1907. - Simon Pearson: Flees Beaver Hollow in 1899. Marries a woman named Ethel in and runs the General Store in Rhodes by 1907. - Josiah Trelawney: Leaves the gang for his family in Saint Denis with Arthur's blessing in 1899. - Reverend Orville Swanson: Leads a parish in New York by 1907. - Sadie Adler: Leaves the USA for South America after avenging Jake in 1899 and Arthur in 1907. - Charles Smith: Leaves the USA for Canada, after helping the Wapiti Tribe move there in 1899, and avenging Arthur in 1907. - John 'Jack' Marston Jr.: Kills Edgar Ross in 1914 to avenge his family. EDIT: Thanks to everyone who replied to me and gave me corrections and new additions.
Yeah but remember if Hosea was still alive Micah would have never gotten into Dutch’s ear and the story would have never ended like that because Hosea would give Dutch good advice not like Micah
@@sallycastillo4981 Micah was already in Dutch's ear, after all Micah convinced Dutch to rob the boat in Blackwater whilst Hosea tried to convince Dutch not to do it but to no avail. Hosea was keeping things together but if he had survived Saint Denis sooner or later him and Dutch would come to blows, if you keep an eye out on the campsites especially when they're in Mountains you'll notice that Dutch and Hosea argue a lot.
The 2 of them just get killed and the game just carried on like nothing happened. Especially since the Sean and Lenny were 2 of the most likeable characters in the gang
Arthur’s death depends on your honor level; Too low - Micah shots him. High - watching the sunrise Karen - believed to have drank herself to death Strauss - arrested, doesn’t talk, dies in prison. Sadie - goes to South America Kieran - captured and beheaded by the O’Driscolls Cain, the dog - believed to have been killed by Micah Your horse - shot, helping you ensure that John escapes.
John killing Micah led Ross right to him, eventually leading to his death, and I wouldnt be surprised if the same happened to Jack eventually. It's a shame but it's true
Yeah that's sad, John did everything he could so Jack didn't have to live that life but as we see at Epilogue of RDR1 Jack has turned into another outlaw.
I laughed at that but I think that is just Reverend being his eccentric self cause he does continue to hold his hand on Arthur’s shoulder until they both stand and then they shake hands
Dutch died in rdr1 when john had him on gunpoint and he did something similar saying he has a plan and saying its a good one But instead of falling into a river he fell on some rocks and died
It happens, he misses the gang and the outlaw life. They were family and now that he left and settled down he uses the photo to remember how things were before everything fell apart and he felt whole again. He loves his life but misses the adventure and excitement that came with rolling with outlaws. It's like an office worker that used to be punk rock with his friends in high school before disbanding for college and such
@@ninaa4192 bro, i just finished this game for the first time, and i'm hella sad and mad. I like John, but i wanted to play with Arthur... It's so sad seeing him gone...
3 DLC’s I personally want for RDR2: 1: Playing as either Bill or Javier after the events of RDR2 when they escaped to Mexico together. 2: Blackwater heist! Who doesn’t wanna see what exactly happened before the escape to the snow mountains? 3: A little prequel to RDR2 where you play as Hosea starting up the gang with Dutch and meeting Arthur!
@@sarahprice7182 DLC: alternate universe where Arthur never got TB or got saved by the Indians and went On with John and his family to live at Beechers hope and helped him dead eye Ross and everyone else and they all escaped and has a happy ending and uncle never died from LUMBAGO
I do, but I would like a complete new story, I feel like the "Redemption" saga is perfect as it is, the story of the Van Der Linde gang is finished (there's Jack Marston, as the only remaining member - if you counted him as one - alive, but I don't care for him that much). So... either a Red Dead Revolver II (reprising the story of Red) or a complete new saga called "Red Dead [something-else]".
Me playing on my first play through: mission failed micah died Me: dang okey I'll try harder next time On my next play through: mission failed micah died Me: i see this as an absolute win
In An Alternate Universe Micah Trapped In Jail: HELP ME ARTHUR Arthur: no Later Strauss: I need you to get money from a man called Thomas Downes Arthur: no Even Later at Tahiti Dutch: Thank god we had a plan Arthur: Yep Dutch: Can you pass me my crown and mangos
Did you read the title? This is a video showing everyone’s fate after the end of the game.. Kieran died, he doesn’t have a story after end game. So no, he didn’t “forget” Kieran, there was just no reason to put him in this video. Idiot
@@thatsalrightwithmeman7867 Hosea, Lenny, Grimshaw, and Sean all died and had nothing to do with the epilogue and were still in the list. So it's only right to have Kieran added to the list.
I think the most poetic thing is Dutch had his clarity moment before his fall in RDR1 where he went to the mountain to kill Micah. He even tells John "I'm here for the same reason as you." To kill Micah. Dutch kills the person who got a lot of his friends killed.
Ultimately by that point Dutch realized Micah was the rat but there was nothing to mend or fix by that point with the remaining survivors. Hence why he just doesn't say anything to John and just walks away. Dutch knew he's the one who fucked everything up. It's just by Rdr1 he stoops to his lowest point with nothing to go for anymore.
Dutch is the one to blame in first place. His narcissist personality destroyed the gang, and only gets worse as the story progresses. the head trauma, concussion, he gets on the trolly robbery also speeds up Dutch's bad mental conditions, he was pretty "sick" and packed a lot of negative psychological and psychiatric disorders (Narcissisim, Gog Complex, Psychopathy, most likely neurological malfunction of the pre frontal cortex, amygdala, and others possibly also in the right parietal lobe, mythomania, paranoid personality, also likely borderline personality disorder, compulsive liar... man, he really scores - which means he may not have it - on almost all of the worst disorders...)
No because the Pinkerton already discovered where John lived but yea they would live happy together. (Except the fact that i Rob trains every Tuesday and never come by the ranch)
@@Jake-hs4ft Just remember there is a 4 year time gap between Charles and Sadie leaving and the first game. It took the Pinkerton's 4 years to find John after he killed Micah.
If you think about it, the last remaining former Van Der Linde members that are still alive/not captured are Jack, Sadie, Charles, Pearson, Tilly, Josiah and Swanson. Milton and Ross said they're gonna kill them all and they failed.
With the exception of Charles and Sadie, the survivors didn't commit any real crimes besides run with the gang. So I guess they thought that they weren't going to cause trouble while the other gang members are still at large.
My reactions to the deaths in both games: Sean: wow Molly: oh Hosea: noooooooo Lenny: NOOOOOOO Susan: aw crap Arthur: I’m suffering immense pain Micah: yes, yes, YYYEESSS And then- John: *cries in outlaw*
Generic Title Sean: jesus christ Molly: jesus christ Keiran: jesus christ Hosea: no pls Lenny: jesus christ.... not lenny Micah: i just want him dead by the end of the epilogue- finally jeez
Sean I was like fuck shit went bad pretty fast! Welp had to expect someone to die. Molly "That bitch!" Hossea no man not him he's like a fa.. * gets shot * Hossea noo let him live! * Dies * Fuck! Atleast I still have the rest like my buddy Lenny * 2 godamm minutes later Lenny dies * no! He is a main character were is his scene he just died mid gameplay! He deserve atleast some dialogue! No more deaths! *Arthur & his horse dies* NOOOO
I reacted the same way, Arthur’s death really fucked me up. I’m in mourning now, gonna go have myself a few drinks and mourn my good friend Arthur Morgan...
The wedding scene brings me on the verge of tears, I'm so happy that, in that moment, they're happy. They're the happiest they've ever been in so long after all the fighting and tragedy. Maybe they didn't get to hold onto it forever, but at least they were given the chance to be happy for a little while because of the sacrifices Arthur and all of the good gang members made in attempt to save them all.
@@StrangeTamer178 Molly followed the rules and no one paid attention to her. Arthur knew she was drunk and lying and no one else cared. Micah as Milton admits is the one who gave away the Gang. Personally I think Micah sold them out before Blackwater as literally every robbery involving him has a massive amount of Pinkerton's and he camped separately from the gang for random periods of time.
This video isn't entirely accurate (in my mind at least). Assuming you played honourably, Arthur is left dying on the mountain watching the sunrise. He then wakes up the next day feeling a bit better - confused, he goes to the doctors and found he was misdiagnosed. That cough? Just a nasty 19th century style chest infection, some medicine will take care of that. The red blotchy skin? Iron deficiency - when ones diet consists entirely of eating plants found across the wilderness, this isn't surprising. The eyes though, surely THAT'S got to be from the TB... nope, Arthur was just under a lot of stress lately. A few days rest, and Arthur is all better, and he goes off to retire with Mary. That was the actual ending. Meanwhile, several years later, John is tasked by the government to take down some "members" of his former gang. See, Dutch, Javier and Bill all hired body doubles due to the paranoia and it's actually them that John goes after. John completes his duties, returns to Beechers Hope with his now returned family and as we all know... the game ends there. The end. You can turn off your console after that, there's just a bunch of farming missions and nothing else - NOTHING ELSE! They all live happily ever after. And it turns out Uncle really did have lumbago, but that gets better as well. Dutch becomes a mango farmer in Tahiti. Javier becomes a famous Mexican troubadour. Bill becomes the face of a brand of hair pomade. And Micah? Micah's dead. Fuck Micah.
Sean died. And also, I know Charles left. However the comment stated “who died, and who left” I just pointed out the people who were most likely going to take Arthur’s side.
Well nobody liked Sean. However if you listen to some dialogue, Sean wants to be just like Arthur, or impress him. I don’t see Sean as a loyalist to Dutch, so I believe Sean would be on Arthur’s side.
Yeah i was disappointed with those "reunions" john had with mary-beth tilly and pearson i would have gladly watched a 10 minute cutscene of them telling john what they did since they last saw him and ask him about the other gang members and also how john just bumped into uncle in blackwater and no convo about what he did either coz didnt he run off with pearson and mary-beth?
That last one was weird. Some dude who looks a lot like Arthur died a sad, undeserving death on a cliff. Good thing the real Arthur is alive and well and living somewhere warm and dry. -im not in denial shut up-
@@Muradachi yeah man why did you put in some look-alike in the last part instead of showing how Arthur is alive and well as a high-honor cowboy in New Austin hanging out with his good buddy Sadie??
@@Muradachi the only trick I see around here is you pulling a switch-a-roo on our boy Arthur for some low-honor peasant who died on a cliff. Arthur is alive just have some F A I T H
you may be in fact assured that is a fact that that image is of the Downes family, not the Trelawny - he had children too, which does not show in the cut scene. plus just put side to side the faces of Trelawny and Edith son and they're nothing alike. It's been debunked already, a small mistake in an awesome video.
Probably should read newspapers myself but I'm too lazy and impatient to read long texts. Funny thing is: No problem reading a 100 comments in a row. A single text that has the same amount of words? Fuck that.
I think that only happens if you and your horse are good friends. I had a beautiful war horse called strawberry and I didn't want it to die, so I did the last mission with the horse you use to go back to Shady Bell un chapter 6
I get how you feel cuz I liked him too but I think it’s because he was only supposed to be a side character and rockstar didn’t think people would like him
That wasn’t trewlany 🤣😭 that Thomas downes son! His mother and him had to move to annesburg when their father died if you get a specific honour you can help them escape annesburg
The gang was supposed to be in Tahiti eating mangos. I wish the gang didn’t break apart. People going separate way and dying was the saddest thing. This is all Micahs fault. It’s best just to stay in horse shoe overlook.
Abigail: “cough cough” John: that’s quite a cough Abigail: LUMBAGO John: NO NO NO! it has to be tuberculosis Abigail: okay fine... “That’s the way it is” plays...
*For everyone who wants quick answers:* Reverend Swanson - quietly left in the gang's final days, went north and became the minister of the First Congregational Church of New York Mary Beth - snuck off in the night with Uncle and Pearson before the gang's final heist, became an author under the alias of 'Leslie Dupont' and kept in touch with Tilly Tilly - left with the Marstons and Sadie following the gang's final heist, married a lawyer from Haiti, had a daughter, lived a wealthy life in a large house with servants in Saint Denis, kept in touch with Mary Beth Pearson - snuck off in the night with Mary Beth and Uncle before the gang's final heist, married a woman called Ethel and ran the Rhodes general store Josiah - quietly left with Arthur's blessing in the gang's final days and returned to his family in Saint Denis Karen - mysteriously disappeared before the gang's final heist and was never seen again, is presumed by Tilly to have drunk herself to death Strauss - kicked out by Arthur in the gang's final days, picked up by Pinkertons an unknown amount of time later and died from harsh interrogation without squealing once Charles - after Micah's death in 1907, went north to Canada and presumably had a family there Sadie - after Micah's death in 1907, went to South America and took up an unknown life Jack - after killing Ross in 1914, wrote the novel 'Red Dead' - which can be found in GTA V at Franklin's mansion - and possibly fought in WW1 The rest - R.I.P.
8:48 Makes me sad seeing John and Abigail finally happy at Beecher's Hope and knowing that a few years later he was going to get gunned downed in that same place.
Huh i tryed to kill him but i couldnt so he ran to the grays farm and i burned him ;-; ( LISTEN I JUST WANTED TO SEE IF WE COULD KILL HIM OR IF HE WAS THE SAINT GENERAL STORE OWNER
@@Waymar19 yeah but Dutch went off the deep end because of how his gang members died, especially Hosea. If he was alive, Dutch would have taken his advice, not Micah's.
Cool Jackster one reason? Micah is THE reason the gang fell apart. If Dutch would’ve never met Micah, then they never would’ve robbed the ferry in Blackwater.. Micah was the one who convinced Dutch to do it. Despite the fact that Arthur and Hosea knew it was a bad idea and tried to warn Dutch.
The trelawny one is actually Archie Downes, strauss was killed by the Pinkerton’s after getting kicked out the gang, but never said a word, bill and Javier get killed by John and Dutch commits suicide. Reverend potentially becomes a pastor in New York.
Hosea’s death was the one who hit me the hardest he was my favourite one in the gang because he was the only one that didn’t listen too Dutch and actually wanted peace and too stop robbing and killing but he still went with him because he was loyal to the gang and in the end it was Dutch that got him killed for not listening to hosea
I've replayed the game four times. I've never got the low honour ending and been shot by Micah, that ending doesn't exist for me, his high honour death is so much better.
That's weird, I've completed the game twice and both times it's low honour and Micah shoots arthur in the face, i wish I got the other ending though I feel like it's what arthur deserves
cash money no lol just don’t kill people In cold blood and rob their dead bodies and you’ll almost certainly finish the game with high honor anyways. The game seems designed to show you the high honor ending anyways as that is the in canon way Arthur Morgan was killed even if you choose the non moral decision of not helping John and going back for the money.
Dank Dominator me too i cannot stress this enough I've literally never cried so hard I dont get it it's unimaginable to what extent fictional characters make you feel things
4:21 is it possible that I didn’t have this scene? I think I have had it with the “sister” you were helping her when some guy have stolen her cross that was given by her mother?
Charles says that Strauss was captured by the Pinkertons and tortured to death without saying a word about the gang. Reverend Swanson is said to be the new pastor at a church in New York by the Blackwater Newspaper. Trelawny leaves similarly to Swanson (when Dutch isn’t there to see him leave). He says goodbye to Arthur and basically says that he’ll miss him. You don’t know what happens to him after that.
You know when you first show up in Saint Denis with Dutch, and you end up having to chase this kid who steals your satchel? As soon as you reach the first little area where you gotta ask people where the kid went, you can Hear Trelawnys family in the background, he was giving gifts to his kids and his wife! some interesting dialogue there.
Oliver James Trelawny was doing one of his typical leaves, he said he’d be back but Arthur said not to come back, since the gang would be done by then.
It's interesting that Arthur's death is so "violent" if you play the game w/low honor. I only put quotes because being shot in the head would be less horrible than slowly drowning or suffocating in your own body.
@@NhBleker Honestly that would be the truth but isn't it based off of texas kinda? That would be a long walk and a boring storyline for a game unless they are getting in trouble with the law in different states. Plus it would ruin the whole entire first game.
Yeah I fr like donated $200 to box and I’m the only that contributes and Dutch just has the audacity to come up to right after I finish donating and is like: *Arthur I’ve noticed you’ve been slacking with donations recently*
Dutch:We just need..... Money... Abigail:I found dutch's chest it's in the caves John(he picks up the money in epilogue 2) $42,000.... Yes Dutch we definitely don't have the money to ship everyone off to tahiti
Dutch gone insane after hosea die he even left John Micah is a Rat Bill is a fool to himself for Javier he changed after guam compare to Javier in first camp.
![Red Dead Redemption 2 & 1 - All Gang Members' Deaths (from Davey to Abigail) [PC, 4K]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5gjVpYQ9DWQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Best ending is to just stay in chapter two and leave Micah in jail.
Actually I replayed it and just did everything possible to avoid his mission
DAMN RIGHT! I shoulda never broke him out of that jail cell
That’s what I did
Yeah let's just leave him to hang
Don’t forget to not collect debt for the German/Austrian guy lol
It's more sad when you realise lenny didnt even get a cutscene for his death. He just died in the middle of gameplay
Rockstar did him dirty. Lenny deserved to be happy, marry a beautiful girl, and live his best life
@@girthespurr418 Thats unfortunately the point though, he deserved good but just, died.
I loved that feature it emphasised Lennys death
Nathan Cormac / Joel is that a joke or part of the dialogue because that's messed up if it isn't.
@Nathan Cormac / Joel guys he means neighbour
Forgot to include that the Pinkertons found Strauss and beat him to death essentially. He never said a word about the gang.
x808drifter that still breaks my heart
x808drifter underestimated character
Big Boi fuck strauss if he never sent arthur to receive the debt then he wouldnt have got tb 😔😔
Poor strauss
x808drifter Strauss, a cold and dead man, I freaking love him
Charles is the my favorite character.
"Will you ride with me?" -Arthur
"Always." -Charles
Mine too❤️
He's probably the biggest badass that's not playable in the game. Calm and collected in every mission, unless you kill the buffalo
Same, I love Charles from the moment I met him
charles could beat micah in 10 seconds i swear
@@mikha2k prime arthur too
I refuse to believe Micah killed Arthur, my cowbro died watching the sunset
It’s a sunrise.
You can tell cause it was bad honor when you have bad honor it’s a coyote and good honor it’s a buck and bad ending Micah absolutely destroys your brain
@@no-lc9zv and to add insult to injury, Micah spits on your dead body
But admit it Arthur would have killed Micah but he had TB
Tyler Wilson I’m really bout to restart the game cause I just beat it 100 % and imma just kill Micah on the spot or antagonize him
**Micah shoots miss Grimshaw which Dutch has a soft spot for her**
Dutch: *wHiCh oNe Of YoU iS beTrAyInG mE!?*
Not so easy...
Arthur: he's a snake Dutch
Micah: kills Susan (witch Dutch has a soft spot for her)
Also micah: he's lying
Dutch: you are right micah
Arthur:🤬🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤬🤬🤬
@@yes-nc4vo You played the game?
The Kingslayer why does it matter if anonymous played the game or not, they are right. That is exactly how it happened.
@@katiemccausland2586 Yes, but it is not so easy
Fun fact:
You can read in the newspapers that reverend leads the church of New York
Where ? What vender?
Casual Maniac in blackwater the new issue 73 I think
Magicmoose Xxl thanks
Fun fact, just buy all the newspapers as they unlock cheats your allowed to use
Jernej Divjak I found it
The clip of “Josiah” you included is actually Archie Downes, and his mother.
Yeah I thought he looked weird
Went through the comments just to see if someone else noticed. Thank you
Surprised no one else noticed
Yeah i noticed that too. Do we know what he did after he left the gang?
@@hughjanus700 we know that HE DIDNT BECOME THE STRANGE MAN THAT THEORY IS SO STUPID
Pre-1899 DEATHS:
- Unknown Member: Killed for treachery.
- Bessie Matthews: Hosea's wife. Died of unmentioned causes.
- Copper: First camp dog. Belonged to Arthur. Died of old age.
- Annabelle: Killed by Colm O'Driscoll, in revenge for his brother's death by Dutch van der Linde's hand.
1899 DEATHS:
- Jenny Kirk: Died of injuries sustained during the gang's failed Blackwater Heist.
- Davey Callander: Died of injuries sustained during the gang's failed Blackwater Heist, by the time they escaped to Colter.
- Mac Callander: Sustained injuries during the gang's failed Blackwater Heist. Was interrogated and killed by the Pinkerton Detective Agency.
- Sean Maguire: Shot in the head by the Greys, in Rhodes.
- Kieran Duffy: Kidnapped, tortured and beheaded by the O'Driscoll Gang, outside Shady Belle.
- Hosea Matthews: Killed by Pinkerton Agent Andrew Milton during the Saint Denis Bank Robbery.
- Lenny Summers: Killed by Pinkerton Agents during the Saint Denis Bank Robbery.
- Molly O'Shea: Shot dead by Susan Grimshaw in Beaver Hollow for claiming to have betrayed the gang by telling Andrew Milton and Edgar Ross about the Saint Denis Bank Robbery.
- Cain: Second camp dog. Befriended by Jack at Clemens Point. Killed by Micah Bell at Beaver Hollow.
- Susan Grimshaw: Shot in the stomach by Micah Bell at Beaver Hollow.
- Player Steed: Killed by Pinkerton agents whilst John and Arthur were escaping their enemies, alongside Old Boy (John's Horse).
- Arthur Morgan: Either executed by Micah Bell, or dies from his advanced tuberculosis and injuries sustained fighting Micah.
1899-1907 DEATHS:
- Leopold Strauss: Died of wounds sustained from being tortured by the Pinkerton Detective Agency for information on the gang members and their whereabouts.
- Karen Jones: Alcoholism over heartbreak at Sean Maguire's death and the gang's breakdown.
1907 DEATHS:
- Cleet: Hung by John Marston or Shot by Sadie Adler in Strawberry.
- Joe: Shot dead by John Marston on Mount Hagen.
- Micah Bell: Killed by Dutch van der Linde and John Marston atop Mount Hagen.
1911 DEATHS:
- Javier Escuella: Either killed or captured by John Marston in Mexico, and delivered to the USA by Archer Fordham and Edgar Ross, alive or dead.
- Bill Williamson: Killed by John Marston and Abraham Reyes alongside Agustin Allende in Mexico.
- Dutch van der Linde: Committed suicide by falling from a mountain.
- Uncle: Killed by the US Army at Beecher's Hope.
- John Marston: Killed by the US Army and Bureau of Investigation led by Edgar Ross at Beecher's Hope.
1914 DEATHS:
- Abigail Marston: Died of sickness or grief.
SURVIVORS:
- Mary-Beth Gaskill: Flees Beaver Hollow in 1899 and becomes a successful writer by 1907.
- Tilly Pierre: Marries a successful lawyer and has a child in 1907.
- Simon Pearson: Flees Beaver Hollow in 1899. Marries a woman named Ethel in and runs the General Store in Rhodes by 1907.
- Josiah Trelawney: Leaves the gang for his family in Saint Denis with Arthur's blessing in 1899.
- Reverend Orville Swanson: Leads a parish in New York by 1907.
- Sadie Adler: Leaves the USA for South America after avenging Jake in 1899 and Arthur in 1907.
- Charles Smith: Leaves the USA for Canada, after helping the Wapiti Tribe move there in 1899, and avenging Arthur in 1907.
- John 'Jack' Marston Jr.: Kills Edgar Ross in 1914 to avenge his family.
EDIT: Thanks to everyone who replied to me and gave me corrections and new additions.
Surjeet Sidhu this deserves a lot more likes but u might want to add.... sadie moves to South America
@@gjte2947 Thanks. Did that just now.
I don't know who Bessie
@@zukia725 Bessie was Hosea's wife before the events of the story.
Damn Pinkertons failed haha they didn’t get everyone to justify their wages
Who cried when Arthur was heading back to camp after saving Abigail
Me I was like crying all the day and in bed 😭 arthur is still in my heart and he will always be
henk .lolgamer he should have taken my offer
I'm not crying I'm just sad
I cried everytime the song Unshaken played
@@agentmilton8709 found you again milton
All the members that died before the gang fell, would have stood with Arthur at beaver hallow
very true
Yeah but remember if Hosea was still alive Micah would have never gotten into Dutch’s ear and the story would have never ended like that because Hosea would give Dutch good advice not like Micah
@@sallycastillo4981 Micah was already in Dutch's ear, after all Micah convinced Dutch to rob the boat in Blackwater whilst Hosea tried to convince Dutch not to do it but to no avail. Hosea was keeping things together but if he had survived Saint Denis sooner or later him and Dutch would come to blows, if you keep an eye out on the campsites especially when they're in Mountains you'll notice that Dutch and Hosea argue a lot.
Hosea would’ve shot Micah then and there
Imagine Hosea, Lenny, Sean, Kieran, Charles, and Sadie all standing against the other members with Arthur and then a full civil war breaks out.
Lenny’s and Sean’s death actually pissed me off first play through.
lennys espacialy cose even when shoting both guys the magic fliing shotgun still gets lenny
The 2 of them just get killed and the game just carried on like nothing happened. Especially since the Sean and Lenny were 2 of the most likeable characters in the gang
that's the point, Lenny's death represents that Arthur had no time to say goodbye
*Did You Forgot Hosea*
@@averyniceguy3964 Big facts ☝️
That's why the morning is called A.M. so we could always remember Arthur Morgan. (I got the honorable ending too)
Charlie Armstrong ooooo that’s good
Oh wow that’s a pretty good way of thinking that
Its not called am to remember arthur
@@user-my7ft6jj9f I know, I'm not an idiot 🤣🤣🤦♂
@@user-my7ft6jj9f are you dumb
Micah: *gets shot 7 to 9 times and the rest in the head*
Also Micah: *shrugs it off for about 6 seconds then dies*
Micah: Welp *dies*
Fanbase:* HOOOZAH*
Idk why your comment has me so weak rn 😂😂😂
Classic rdr
Pinkerton detective agency: Shoots Lenny once
Lenny: Dies instantly
@@theunproffessional8617 maybe it was because he was 19 or it was a really powerful gun
The saddest deaths
3:lenny
2:hosea
1:Arthur
In my opinion Lenny would be second cuz you could save him but the game doesn't let you so he gets blasted with a shotgun
Lenny 1
Carmen Ibarra Lenny was my favourite
Sean's was the most shocking, being the first one and all.
John
That wasn’t Trewlany that was Archie Downes and his mom. They have both recovered from all their hardships because of Arthur.
I know
@@AbdullahKhan-gk8eq Yeah, but few seem to have noticed it. Cheers
The best fight in the game:
Uncle's fight with Lumbago
Ya it’s to hard for the player
Its real serious
Hyunho Ji no it’s aurthers slap fight with lenny
Hyunho Ji more like John marston VS the goverment and military
Hahahahahahhahahahaha
Cried at everyone else's deaths, laughed like a maniac at Micah's
Mamamoo can use me as their thrones also fun to go back later and steal his gun from his frozen corpse
I killed him by shooting repeatedly and slowly in the balls, about 8 times
Sean's death got me bad. Just because it was out of nowhere. I was pissed that entire fight in Rhodes
I shot his head off with a shotgun then lit him on fire
Mamamoo can use me as their throneseee
Arthur’s death depends on your honor level;
Too low - Micah shots him.
High - watching the sunrise
Karen - believed to have drank herself to death
Strauss - arrested, doesn’t talk, dies in prison.
Sadie - goes to South America
Kieran - captured and beheaded by the O’Driscolls
Cain, the dog - believed to have been killed by Micah
Your horse - shot, helping you ensure that John escapes.
How do we rise the honor I don’t like to see Arthur get shot in the face
Nate Pink cherish every life
Arthur’s death depends on whether he stays and helps John or goes for the money I thought
John dies by a huge rain of bullets by Ross and his men. And then Jack marston ends it with the redemption of course
anonymous no name sounds like Broadway empire, Nucky Thompson, Jimmy Darmody and his son
Love how Micah just shrugs when he dies almost like he knew nobody liked or cared about him.
It was more like "Alright, you win.. Guess I'll die.."
Let's all just have a moment of silence for John and Arthur.
And uncle,hosea,Lenny,Sean,Susan,Mac,Davey
Roman Keprt kieran
and miss grimshaw,
Ynnel?
@@romankeprt1129 and the guy every body called an odriscoll
Arthur: revenge is a fools game
John kills Micah
Jack kills agent Ross
He never say it to them
But he said it
John killing Micah led Ross right to him, eventually leading to his death, and I wouldnt be surprised if the same happened to Jack eventually. It's a shame but it's true
Arthur: *Goddamit!*
Yeah that's sad, John did everything he could so Jack didn't have to live that life but as we see at Epilogue of RDR1 Jack has turned into another outlaw.
It pains me that Javier went with Dutch in the end, he was one of my favorites
C3 DeathWalk if you look he actually doesn’t point his gun at arthur or John
Strong I know
He was a coward
If ya think about it this whole gang extermination thing ended with police brutality.
True
Sadie was one hell of character and she’s my favorite! I was so scared she would die in a process. So happy she made it through the end!
You can say that again!
Sadie was the most annoying, psychotic, overrated character I've ever had the displeasure of seeing.
@@Skive_67 I agree, she got Arturo killed 😔😔
@@nicoffee777 Arthur was going to die since he got tuberculosis
meh
She is overrated
Arthur: Tells Reverend that hes sick and dying
Reverend: *scoots away from Arthur*
He looks so scared of Arthur, trying to keep a distance from him lol. He even hesitates when he was going to shake his hand.
@@tofferooni4972 fcuk that Reverend. I prefer Sister Calderon.
John&Toffee ch. Reverend isn’t scared of Arthur in the high honor cutscene
I laughed at that but I think that is just Reverend being his eccentric self cause he does continue to hold his hand on Arthur’s shoulder until they both stand and then they shake hands
I read this comment 5 seconds away before hit happened lol
Arthur: Deer
John: Wolf
Micah: Rat
ogcen Van Der Linde shit th
Dutch van der linde: snake
Uncle : Lumbago
Hotel : Trivago.
Dutch: "PLAN"
Not a deer, A buck
Bill and Javier's fate was actually being chased down by John in Mexico
and John's fate is to be gunned down by the Government, but that's in RDR1
It’s talking about after this game. If we’re going off by deaths than they all suffered the same fate, it being death since they’re all humans
Same as Dutch but in West Elizabeth
guccifake he had a good plan...
Dutch died in rdr1 when john had him on gunpoint and he did something similar saying he has a plan and saying its a good one
But instead of falling into a river he fell on some rocks and died
I thinks it sad that Pierson is one of the only guys that survived the gang. He looks so depressed by himself.
It happens, he misses the gang and the outlaw life. They were family and now that he left and settled down he uses the photo to remember how things were before everything fell apart and he felt whole again. He loves his life but misses the adventure and excitement that came with rolling with outlaws. It's like an office worker that used to be punk rock with his friends in high school before disbanding for college and such
As John I always go down and talk with him
"Arthur saved my life before he passed. I don't talk about him much... but I think about him." - John Marston
That quote applies to literally everyone whose played rdr2
@@ninaa4192 bro, i just finished this game for the first time, and i'm hella sad and mad. I like John, but i wanted to play with Arthur... It's so sad seeing him gone...
@@atom6028 i kno ur pain bro
@@ninaa4192 i don't even wanna play anymore. 😂😂 I guess all the players went through this. 😂🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️
@@atom6028 oh we did, believe you me
Sean’s death caught me off guard. I was really surprised when he got sniped out of nowhere
I started to cry a little when that happened
@@CowdoggoRule I got angry and sad. Just when I started to like him.
I was like "WTF bro?!"
And it was all downhill from there
My jaw was opened the entire mission dude
3 DLC’s I personally want for RDR2:
1: Playing as either Bill or Javier after the events of RDR2 when they escaped to Mexico together.
2: Blackwater heist! Who doesn’t wanna see what exactly happened before the escape to the snow mountains?
3: A little prequel to RDR2 where you play as Hosea starting up the gang with Dutch and meeting Arthur!
No undead nightmare 2
Did they ever comfirm or deny DLC?
Creanzey We can mix 2 and 3 together. Start with the gang forming and then ending with escaping to the snowy mountains.
All great ideas! Ideas that Rockstar can make...
But ideas that won’t come true because Rockstar are too crazy with the piece of shit online
@@sarahprice7182 DLC: alternate universe where Arthur never got TB or got saved by the Indians and went On with John and his family to live at Beechers hope and helped him dead eye Ross and everyone else and they all escaped and has a happy ending and uncle never died from LUMBAGO
That opening with Pearson was so adorable man, this gang was a family for a while and they all deserved to live the lives they wanted :(
"There's Pinkertons coming fast!"
*_Micah immediately shoots Miss Grimshaw to alert them_*
But why Susan instead of arthur
Jake From State Farm because she had a shotgun and at that one scene where she kills molly, Micah looked like he pisses his pants
@@hiiisme5068 because Arthur had plot armour
@@FriendlyNeighbourhoodSpidey Lol
Jake From State Farm Arthur was aiming at him and Susan let her guard down
Who wants a red dead 3
Nah, I've seen enough
I do, This time following dutch as he builds the gang
I do, but I would like a complete new story, I feel like the "Redemption" saga is perfect as it is, the story of the Van Der Linde gang is finished (there's Jack Marston, as the only remaining member - if you counted him as one - alive, but I don't care for him that much). So... either a Red Dead Revolver II (reprising the story of Red) or a complete new saga called "Red Dead [something-else]".
Rockstar should make the third game with Sadie or Charles as the protagonist.
Everyone
Strauss had to be one of the most loyal gang members cause he didn’t say shit about the gang when he went to court
Yes, he got killed sadly because of this and he willingly took it
But at same time he sent artuhur on a mission what basically killed him because he told him to go to Thomas downes
Chance's are he wouldn't know Downes had TB
Or *LUMBAGO*
Even though his “business buddy” Arthur kicked him out of camp with out any time to pack or say goodbyes
@@Dwight_Lee he did know his was ill though, if only he beat him like that polish guy instead of standing really close :(
Me playing on my first play through: mission failed micah died
Me: dang okey I'll try harder next time
On my next play through: mission failed micah died
Me: i see this as an absolute win
loooool
Seans death is so painful to watch, this character we’ve gotten to know and love not even given a last sentence
Fr, who doesnt love Sean!
A game of thrones move made me meltdown, I loved Sean Mc Guire, he was awesome
@@Attmozzy but he hasnt Not much screen time. Sad
Definitely need Sean in RDR3
yeah, he was one of the funnest characters.
Charles mentioned that Strauss died after not revealing information when interrogated by the Pinkertons.
Pierce Smith if Arthur doesn’t kick him out of the camp, then that’s how he dies
@@hotfootwax9720 No I kicked him out and Charles still mentioned it.
@@hotfootwax9720 Read the comment above yours bruv
@@pierce8878 Arthur kicks him out of the camp no matter what
Pierce Smith well he still dies, but if you kick him out then Charles says a different voice line.
In An Alternate Universe
Micah Trapped In Jail: HELP ME ARTHUR
Arthur: no
Later
Strauss: I need you to get money from a man called Thomas Downes
Arthur: no
Even Later at Tahiti
Dutch: Thank god we had a plan
Arthur: Yep
Dutch: Can you pass me my crown and mangos
😂😂😂
Yes....
Yes
Now that's a plan
@@grimmsekai678 you know what's a plan m.th-cam.com/video/aDbhl_zl-Vs/w-d-xo.html
I love how Javier never aims his gun at John or Arthur, really shows his inner conflict as he sides with Dutch.
he points his gun up into the air, true
Arthur: (dies)
Also arthur : aah found ya lenny
*arthur
@@millahasbo5091 ok I changed it
@@millahasbo5091 I felt like this was adorable
Hosea too
😢
You forgot Kieran. I know he began as an O'Driscoll but before his death he was pretty much accepted into the gang at least by most.
Did you read the title? This is a video showing everyone’s fate after the end of the game.. Kieran died, he doesn’t have a story after end game. So no, he didn’t “forget” Kieran, there was just no reason to put him in this video. Idiot
Sean doesn't have a ending either but he's in the story
@I got Lumbago Looool why you getting rude. Your comment makes no sense either smh.
Oniji Itagaki because he died. He doesn’t have an epilogue like everyone else
@@thatsalrightwithmeman7867 Hosea, Lenny, Grimshaw, and Sean all died and had nothing to do with the epilogue and were still in the list.
So it's only right to have Kieran added to the list.
Kieran will always be remembered as my fishing buddy. I’ll never forget him...
Edit: Holy fuck 400 likes thank you!
I liked that boah Karen
Shane Yazzie that gurl*
IT ABOUT THE BAIT..... he is the bait... sadly a live one
yeah i was so happy when i went fishing with him and i was terrified when he died lol
I remember the naked guy swimming in his mission that told them where the legendary fish was. Good times.
I think the most poetic thing is Dutch had his clarity moment before his fall in RDR1 where he went to the mountain to kill Micah. He even tells John "I'm here for the same reason as you." To kill Micah. Dutch kills the person who got a lot of his friends killed.
Ultimately by that point Dutch realized Micah was the rat but there was nothing to mend or fix by that point with the remaining survivors. Hence why he just doesn't say anything to John and just walks away. Dutch knew he's the one who fucked everything up. It's just by Rdr1 he stoops to his lowest point with nothing to go for anymore.
Dutch is the one to blame in first place. His narcissist personality destroyed the gang, and only gets worse as the story progresses. the head trauma, concussion, he gets on the trolly robbery also speeds up Dutch's bad mental conditions, he was pretty "sick" and packed a lot of negative psychological and psychiatric disorders (Narcissisim, Gog Complex, Psychopathy, most likely neurological malfunction of the pre frontal cortex, amygdala, and others possibly also in the right parietal lobe, mythomania, paranoid personality, also likely borderline personality disorder, compulsive liar... man, he really scores - which means he may not have it - on almost all of the worst disorders...)
If I don’t play Red Dead Redemption I, John and Abigail would peacefully live together forever
I wish that was how it worked man😭😭
You mean Arthur and Mary?
Fun fact, I completely skipped RDR 1. Knew that'd be the right decision.
If you don’t play past chapter 4, Arthur doesn’t get sick and lives forever
No because the Pinkerton already discovered where John lived but yea they would live happy together. (Except the fact that i Rob trains every Tuesday and never come by the ranch)
When Pearson looked at the portrait that got me :(
Who all was in the photo that he looked at?
I could only make out Dutch
I couldn't tell who the rest were
@@thomasbaron5367 pretty much the whole gang, you can see arthur sitting on top of the carrige
Same
Imagine how much cooler the first game would've been if Charles and Sadie stayed with the Marstons
Well yeah the agents would have got a few bullets to thier heads
John would definitely still be alive if Sadie AND Charles were there
Jesus Christ wait u play rdr2 Jesus cool nice to know
Well as you know (because you’re literally Jesus) god has a plan and that was apart of it
@@Jake-hs4ft Just remember there is a 4 year time gap between Charles and Sadie leaving and the first game. It took the Pinkerton's 4 years to find John after he killed Micah.
If you think about it, the last remaining former Van Der Linde members that are still alive/not captured are Jack, Sadie, Charles, Pearson, Tilly, Josiah and Swanson. Milton and Ross said they're gonna kill them all and they failed.
Mary Beth
Fr tho if they make rd3 its should have them n some new characters added goin back to Mexico shi would be tight then go unlock canda n south america
With the exception of Charles and Sadie, the survivors didn't commit any real crimes besides run with the gang. So I guess they thought that they weren't going to cause trouble while the other gang members are still at large.
Its sad how everyone who would've backed Arthur died or left the gang.
Jairo Reyes Idk about Sean unless I'm missing something
Technically charles wasnt dead and hadn't left the gang at this point, he for sure wouldve sided with Arthur
I guess Sean would've stayed in dutch's side because of the "loyalty"
@Some shitty meme stealing account Nah.Sean loved Arthur like a brother.He woukd have sided with Arthur
If Hosea didn’t die there wouldn’t have been a divide
My reactions to the deaths in both games:
Sean: wow
Molly: oh
Hosea: noooooooo
Lenny: NOOOOOOO
Susan: aw crap
Arthur: I’m suffering immense pain
Micah: yes, yes, YYYEESSS
And then-
John: *cries in outlaw*
Generic Title
Sean: jesus christ
Molly: jesus christ
Keiran: jesus christ
Hosea: no pls
Lenny: jesus christ.... not lenny
Micah: i just want him dead by the end of the epilogue- finally jeez
Sean I was like fuck shit went bad pretty fast! Welp had to expect someone to die. Molly "That bitch!" Hossea no man not him he's like a fa.. * gets shot * Hossea noo let him live! * Dies * Fuck! Atleast I still have the rest like my buddy Lenny * 2 godamm minutes later Lenny dies * no! He is a main character were is his scene he just died mid gameplay! He deserve atleast some dialogue! No more deaths! *Arthur & his horse dies* NOOOO
What about Kieran?
ynneL?
I reacted the same way, Arthur’s death really fucked me up. I’m in mourning now, gonna go have myself a few drinks and mourn my good friend Arthur Morgan...
All members deaths : Oh no !
Micah death : oH YeS !
😉
😁
🖕
Yes and Dutch because he is asshole (He dies in the 1)
Except for Molly. I hated her.
The wedding scene brings me on the verge of tears, I'm so happy that, in that moment, they're happy. They're the happiest they've ever been in so long after all the fighting and tragedy. Maybe they didn't get to hold onto it forever, but at least they were given the chance to be happy for a little while because of the sacrifices Arthur and all of the good gang members made in attempt to save them all.
Edgar Ross: 😈
Molly was so drunk she said a lie she never did
Last attempt at getting attention from Dutch, she should have left the gang long ago for her own sake
Then got blasted for it. Grimshaw was a G. Molly knew the rules
@@StrangeTamer178
yeah but alcohol and desperation do not care
@@StrangeTamer178 Molly followed the rules and no one paid attention to her. Arthur knew she was drunk and lying and no one else cared. Micah as Milton admits is the one who gave away the Gang. Personally I think Micah sold them out before Blackwater as literally every robbery involving him has a massive amount of Pinkerton's and he camped separately from the gang for random periods of time.
@@JohnReedy07163 I agree with that
They should make a game about Uncle and his battle with Lumbago.
😂😂
Most of the game would be sleeping either in Dutch’s camp or John’s ranch.
Why do I imagine a Lumbago Royale were you've got to infect people with Lumbago
Game of the year 2020
Lumbago is pain in the lower back, Uncle stands no chance.
“We ain’t both gonna make it, go, I’ll hold em off”
-Arthur Morgan
win!theking78 That is John not Arthur
win!theking78 lol thats not Arthur😂
@@buddyartyt3400 its Arthur Morgan how said that not jhon marston have you played the game
BuddyArtYT wrong
BuddyArtYT Lol it was Arthur who said that before fight with Micah
They were one big happy family until Micah came along and broke them apart. It was so sad to see them all leave and die.
You didn’t show the good ending for Arthur and now I feel sad
I got the bad ending and it became so much more satisfying for Me to kill Micah in the end.
B C S I am going to play the game a second time and I will get the bad ending just to feel so angry to the point I want to kill Micah three times over
me too
He dies eitherway
I only wish I could have slowly stabbed Micah like how he did to my versions Arthur.
This video isn't entirely accurate (in my mind at least). Assuming you played honourably, Arthur is left dying on the mountain watching the sunrise. He then wakes up the next day feeling a bit better - confused, he goes to the doctors and found he was misdiagnosed. That cough? Just a nasty 19th century style chest infection, some medicine will take care of that. The red blotchy skin? Iron deficiency - when ones diet consists entirely of eating plants found across the wilderness, this isn't surprising. The eyes though, surely THAT'S got to be from the TB... nope, Arthur was just under a lot of stress lately. A few days rest, and Arthur is all better, and he goes off to retire with Mary. That was the actual ending.
Meanwhile, several years later, John is tasked by the government to take down some "members" of his former gang. See, Dutch, Javier and Bill all hired body doubles due to the paranoia and it's actually them that John goes after. John completes his duties, returns to Beechers Hope with his now returned family and as we all know... the game ends there. The end. You can turn off your console after that, there's just a bunch of farming missions and nothing else - NOTHING ELSE! They all live happily ever after. And it turns out Uncle really did have lumbago, but that gets better as well.
Dutch becomes a mango farmer in Tahiti.
Javier becomes a famous Mexican troubadour.
Bill becomes the face of a brand of hair pomade.
And Micah? Micah's dead. Fuck Micah.
@@arsalannoori3596 ironic dude
I want to save this...
chrisninety1 This is perfect.
chrisninety1 dude this cheered me up. I’m going with your ending..Arthur is still alive man
Micah Bell fuck you Micah fuck you 10000000x you fucking rat!
Micah *shoots miss grimshaw*
Dutch: who amongst you is with me??
stfu overused joke
Anthony Padilla why are you so annoyed about it
Rozh Salvator She was betraying him thats why i put a bullet in her
@@micahbell5572 😂😂😂😂
Jokes on you, Uncle laced your drink with L U M B A G O
Dutch:I...I
Dutch’s mom: he is speaking his first words! Say my name !
Dutch:I HAVE A PLAN AURTHUR!!
Dutch’s mom: 😢
Tahiti
Mangoes
All the people that died or left would’ve been on Arthur’s side
TSF _ Yeah, if they Had Lenny, Hosea, Sean, and Charles. That would have been the real gang.
TSF _ I don’t know about Sean
Sean died. And also, I know Charles left. However the comment stated “who died, and who left” I just pointed out the people who were most likely going to take Arthur’s side.
Peanutbutter I know Sean died, but I don’t think he would be on Arthur’s side
Well nobody liked Sean. However if you listen to some dialogue, Sean wants to be just like Arthur, or impress him. I don’t see Sean as a loyalist to Dutch, so I believe Sean would be on Arthur’s side.
Old gang member: JOHN!!! I thought you were dead!
John: Hey-
Old gang member: welp my trains here.
wow stolen comment
kova ukko lol I love it when people think I steal comments when I actually don’t. Probably just a coincidence dude. Calm down.
Dont worry,pearson will always stay hehe
Yeah i was disappointed with those "reunions" john had with mary-beth tilly and pearson i would have gladly watched a 10 minute cutscene of them telling john what they did since they last saw him and ask him about the other gang members and also how john just bumped into uncle in blackwater and no convo about what he did either coz didnt he run off with pearson and mary-beth?
@@Berzappy wow stolen comment
That last one was weird. Some dude who looks a lot like Arthur died a sad, undeserving death on a cliff. Good thing the real Arthur is alive and well and living somewhere warm and dry.
-im not in denial shut up-
Yeah it's weird dude like obviously Arthur wasn't sick and ended up with a bullet in the head. this video is bullshit.
@@Muradachi yeah man why did you put in some look-alike in the last part instead of showing how Arthur is alive and well as a high-honor cowboy in New Austin hanging out with his good buddy Sadie??
@@nananderson7259 I think this is a trick of some sort.
@@Muradachi the only trick I see around here is you pulling a switch-a-roo on our boy Arthur for some low-honor peasant who died on a cliff. Arthur is alive just have some F A I T H
TAHITI!
I'm fairly certain that the Josiah one wasn't Josiah, but Edith Downes and her son
you may be in fact assured that is a fact that that image is of the Downes family, not the Trelawny - he had children too, which does not show in the cut scene. plus just put side to side the faces of Trelawny and Edith son and they're nothing alike. It's been debunked already, a small mistake in an awesome video.
damn when pearson looks at that gang picture
That shit got me good wasn’t expecting it when I was watching the credits
Nah man, when John proposes with Arthur's ring
@Andrew Ryan remineces on the past life the good times my man
pat that was really sad, it was like a family for me😣😣
@@mykiefrm20 he could get killed for it tho
Reverend is a successful priest in New York, found in a strawberry newspaper
Probably should read newspapers myself but I'm too lazy and impatient to read long texts.
Funny thing is:
No problem reading a 100 comments in a row.
A single text that has the same amount of words? Fuck that.
Kenneth Bone didn’t know that
Spoiler..... In the credit scene i saw a dead body getting eating by crows near by a church isnt that the reverend or im mistaking what i saw.
All but a few lived and none of the cool ones
Except Charles of course
Nelson Gaskell and John
Admiral Yawn Well John dies at the end of rdr1, but he outlives basically every other gang member.
And Sadie
@@frallbobroggins4005 Jack outlives everyone
John but he dies in red dead 1
Rdr1: I wanna play as John not jack
Rdr2: I wanna play as Arthur not John
I cried when Arthur thanked his horse
I think that only happens if you and your horse are good friends. I had a beautiful war horse called strawberry and I didn't want it to die, so I did the last mission with the horse you use to go back to Shady Bell un chapter 6
I had the same horse from the beginning. I nearly broke in tears when he died. I almost cried even more when Arthur eased him into death.
For me buell died and I just got him so Arthur didn't do the thank you thing
@@the_world_solos I guess it was not sad for you
I loved my horse "Bidellis Cloppity."
Sean's happened to fast and it seemed like no one cared which I kinda hated
Dylan Smith all the characters deaths made me feel bad
Except Micah
I get how you feel cuz I liked him too but I think it’s because he was only supposed to be a side character and rockstar didn’t think people would like him
Mr Thicc yea I hate Micah
yeah no one cared yet arthur was complaining about it but miss grimshaw's was so emotional that no one even looked
That wasn’t trewlany 🤣😭 that Thomas downes son! His mother and him had to move to annesburg when their father died if you get a specific honour you can help them escape annesburg
Looking for this comment
No wonder he looked so different
You’re right that isn’t Trelawny but he did go back to him family in Saint Denis
Don't forget they also own a couple of businesses and the golf course in california which is Las Santos
@@shadowhunter6668 how did you know that?
The gang was supposed to be in Tahiti eating mangos. I wish the gang didn’t break apart. People going separate way and dying was the saddest thing. This is all Micahs fault. It’s best just to stay in horse shoe overlook.
Uncle got shot in the 1st game
John sacrificed himself for his family
Abigail passes away from an illness
Jack lives on....
TheGrandRice Abigail was only 37 I don’t think she passed of old age she probably got sick
Abigail: “cough cough”
John: that’s quite a cough
Abigail: LUMBAGO
John: NO NO NO! it has to be tuberculosis
Abigail: okay fine...
“That’s the way it is” plays...
@@chrisulrich2969 I think if u look at her grave she had pneumonia
Abigail was still young by 1914 so she probably died of illness.
White_ Wulf_ it was an assumption I never calculated there age sorry
This Game and Arthur will always have a soft spot in my heart. Best Game Of All Time.
And Yes I have Played God Of War.
but have you played extreme animal racing?
I dont think you've ever played lego star wars 3
@Jose Garcia which Skyrim?
Garfield Cart you dingbat
The last of us bro
0:29 pearson looking at the old photograph is so gaddamn sad tho..
IKR everyone is sleeping on it when he looks at it it it just hits hard it sad
Yup..You got me
Very cliche
@@WyvrnOnYT they were in new Austin probably before the game, they must of been there before blackwater
They were a happy family until Micah showed up
*For everyone who wants quick answers:*
Reverend Swanson - quietly left in the gang's final days, went north and became the minister of the First Congregational Church of New York
Mary Beth - snuck off in the night with Uncle and Pearson before the gang's final heist, became an author under the alias of 'Leslie Dupont' and kept in touch with Tilly
Tilly - left with the Marstons and Sadie following the gang's final heist, married a lawyer from Haiti, had a daughter, lived a wealthy life in a large house with servants in Saint Denis, kept in touch with Mary Beth
Pearson - snuck off in the night with Mary Beth and Uncle before the gang's final heist, married a woman called Ethel and ran the Rhodes general store
Josiah - quietly left with Arthur's blessing in the gang's final days and returned to his family in Saint Denis
Karen - mysteriously disappeared before the gang's final heist and was never seen again, is presumed by Tilly to have drunk herself to death
Strauss - kicked out by Arthur in the gang's final days, picked up by Pinkertons an unknown amount of time later and died from harsh interrogation without squealing once
Charles - after Micah's death in 1907, went north to Canada and presumably had a family there
Sadie - after Micah's death in 1907, went to South America and took up an unknown life
Jack - after killing Ross in 1914, wrote the novel 'Red Dead' - which can be found in GTA V at Franklin's mansion - and possibly fought in WW1
The rest - R.I.P.
John: Dead Eye’d an entire revolver clip on Micah’s head.
Micah: Not a single bullet to the head.
Seems legit.
ALSO Micah:guess i will die then i broke the rules.....**SPLAT**
I got his eye, there was just a hole
He got him in the mouth
tc doggo HAHAHA
It's called a revolver cylinder, not a clip.
"I dont talk about him much, but i think about him."
"-Me too...And Dutch?"
"- *HMPF* "
When I saw this I just thought of a pillager noise
Dutch is a bastard
@@christophertalmage3392
Tbh i dont blame him
Arthur was sick and dutch knew he will die and he also killed micah in the end so yeah
Yeah... that was John Marston’s fate... he lived happily with his family
He died in red dead redemption 1
Krispy Me yes. I’m aware. That is the reason for the sarcastic nature of my comment
@@thuriyanaing7499 r/wooooshhh
Swan Ronson rdr2 is based before the events of rdr1 so yeah that was his fate when it comes to rdr2
Ha! He sure did buddy.
Strauss died in police custody, never spoke a word.
8:48 Makes me sad seeing John and Abigail finally happy at Beecher's Hope and knowing that a few years later he was going to get gunned downed in that same place.
And uncle too
Yea the first red dead is even more tragic when you think of it
Mr. Vega ya when John came home from killing micha and told Abigail that it’s over I was like nope sorry
Agent ross had to do if mr vega
In the first one, when I killed Ross, I burnt alive his wife and brother. Then I got on with killing him.
To this day when i need something from a general store i only go to pearson. Even if im in the mountains
Same
Huh i tryed to kill him but i couldnt so he ran to the grays farm and i burned him ;-; ( LISTEN I JUST WANTED TO SEE IF WE COULD KILL HIM OR IF HE WAS THE SAINT GENERAL STORE OWNER
@@cecilepiedboeuf1128 tell it to the judge PUNK
Support his family
Where’s his store
Micah was the one reason the gang fell apart
Crazy fucking bastard
It's because Hosea died
Not really. He was a catalyst but Dutch was going off the deep end anyway.. and when the leader is lost so are his followers
@@Waymar19 yeah but Dutch went off the deep end because of how his gang members died, especially Hosea. If he was alive, Dutch would have taken his advice, not Micah's.
Cool Jackster one reason? Micah is THE reason the gang fell apart. If Dutch would’ve never met Micah, then they never would’ve robbed the ferry in Blackwater.. Micah was the one who convinced Dutch to do it. Despite the fact that Arthur and Hosea knew it was a bad idea and tried to warn Dutch.
Seeing the conversation between arthur and reverend just makes me see that having a low honor gameplay doesnt make sense.
15:36
dad coming home with the milk after 15 years when he heard you became a millionaire
JkbUltraKing67 congratulations son, you finally earned my love lol
Miles Upshur 😂
they always have a gun too
💀
yeetyboi and hold us at gun point…
0:00 1-Pearson
0:34 2-Mary-Beth Gaskill
2:32 3-Micah Bell
3:14 4-Tilly Jackson
3:38 5-Lenny Summers
4:18 6-Reverend Swanson
6:42 7-Susan Grimshaw
7:09 8 Downes family -(Mistake)
7:32 9-Hosea Matthews
8:41 10.11.12.13 John Marston Family And Uncel
9:16 14-Molly O'shea
11:19 16-Sean Macguire
11:53 17-Karen Jones
12:02 18-Charles Smith
12:39 19-Leopold Strauss
14:13 20-Sadie Adler
14:48 20.21 Bill Williamson And Javier Escuella
15:33 22-Dutch
16:24 23-Arthur Morgan
HoTop GaminG *Downes family
ok
You spelled uncle wrong
spelling things wrong is one of the best things i can do XD
HoTop GaminG I assume trewlany just went back to his wife and kids in Saint Denis
The trelawny one is actually Archie Downes, strauss was killed by the Pinkerton’s after getting kicked out the gang, but never said a word, bill and Javier get killed by John and Dutch commits suicide. Reverend potentially becomes a pastor in New York.
a newspaper says that reverend becomes a pastor in NY
Where is Trelawny?
@@ellbent nobody knows
Popup
Guess Arthur is right about his disappearing act XDDD
@@ellbent Maybe he went back to new york
Hosea’s death was the one who hit me the hardest he was my favourite one in the gang because he was the only one that didn’t listen too Dutch and actually wanted peace and too stop robbing and killing but he still went with him because he was loyal to the gang and in the end it was Dutch that got him killed for not listening to hosea
I've replayed the game four times. I've never got the low honour ending and been shot by Micah, that ending doesn't exist for me, his high honour death is so much better.
Same here I never want low honour
Well done, ir is unacceptable to have Arthur shot dead by Micah.
That's weird, I've completed the game twice and both times it's low honour and Micah shoots arthur in the face, i wish I got the other ending though I feel like it's what arthur deserves
Should I fish for a whole day to get honour my up and donate like 500 dollars to camp to also get honour up?
cash money no lol just don’t kill people In cold blood and rob their dead bodies and you’ll almost certainly finish the game with high honor anyways. The game seems designed to show you the high honor ending anyways as that is the in canon way Arthur Morgan was killed even if you choose the non moral decision of not helping John and going back for the money.
you should have included red dead redemption 1. Bill, Javier and Dutch get killed by John. Uncle and John die at the end of 1.
Dutch was not killed by John. Dutch had a plan, a good one. And he performed it himself and did it well.
@Milo Mondragon Hell no, Dutch emerge right in the River Styx.
Milo Mondragon r/woosh
You do have a chance to capture Javier, which is what I did.
Dutch was killed by some *RoCkY BoIs*
I got the honorable ending. It was much sadder than the dishonorable one. I cried for 20 minutes straight.
Dank Dominator me too i cannot stress this enough I've literally never cried so hard I dont get it it's unimaginable to what extent fictional characters make you feel things
Dank Dominator I’m still crying
me to
RIP Arthur Morgan. Lets give a tribute to one of the greatest, if not THE greatest, video game character of all time. Sleep Well.
It’s a game
4:21 is it possible that I didn’t have this scene? I think I have had it with the “sister” you were helping her when some guy have stolen her cross that was given by her mother?
If Hosea was still alive Tahiti really would’ve been the move
Yeah.....
Hosea could’ve stopped this mess from happening, or at least back Arthur up
Gir The Spurr hoseas death is what made Dutch a crazy
After hides died the gang fell apart
If he and all the other members didn’t die they wouldn’t of spilt up the gang
How dare you represent Arthur’s ending with the shot in the head. He deserved to die peacefully looking at the sunrise...
@FERMINDAL why would you call him loser
TB =/= Peaceful imo
@FERMINDAL So? Never thought about a movie you've watched? Damn you must be a though guy, just be careful you dont shit your pants
@FERMINDAL FUCK YOU (also he is talking about the true ending end scene)
@FERMINDAL why are you watching this then? Isnt their an adoption agency waiting for you?
Charles says that Strauss was captured by the Pinkertons and tortured to death without saying a word about the gang.
Reverend Swanson is said to be the new pastor at a church in New York by the Blackwater Newspaper.
Trelawny leaves similarly to Swanson (when Dutch isn’t there to see him leave). He says goodbye to Arthur and basically says that he’ll miss him. You don’t know what happens to him after that.
You know when you first show up in Saint Denis with Dutch, and you end up having to chase this kid who steals your satchel? As soon as you reach the first little area where you gotta ask people where the kid went, you can Hear Trelawnys family in the background, he was giving gifts to his kids and his wife! some interesting dialogue there.
Oliver James Trelawny was doing one of his typical leaves, he said he’d be back but Arthur said not to come back, since the gang would be done by then.
Trelawny was the Strange Man in red dead 1
CamoGaming YT no hes not dip shit
@@camogamingyt8916 No no hes not
It's interesting that Arthur's death is so "violent" if you play the game w/low honor. I only put quotes because being shot in the head would be less horrible than slowly drowning or suffocating in your own body.
I just love the fate of Charles: “Went to Canada”
Magma gaming At least he ll prob meet with Rain Falls and his tribe there :)
I beleive he married a native girl there too.
@Arthur Morgan its a bug
StormSoul The gang would’ve survived and thrived if they went north to Canada after Blackwater.
@@NhBleker Honestly that would be the truth but isn't it based off of texas kinda? That would be a long walk and a boring storyline for a game unless they are getting in trouble with the law in different states. Plus it would ruin the whole entire first game.
Susan: gets shot* Mr Morgan I’ve noticed you haven’t been putting anything in the box lately
Arthur: *shoots her in the head a good 6 times*
Yeah I fr like donated $200 to box and I’m the only that contributes and Dutch just has the audacity to come up to right after I finish donating and is like: *Arthur I’ve noticed you’ve been slacking with donations recently*
wE aLL nEeD tO eAt Mr. MoRgAn
Fr I gave them 2 gold bars I found and Dutch said "Arthur, the gang and I have noticed that you haven't put anything in box lately" like BRUH
Dutch:We just need..... Money...
Abigail:I found dutch's chest it's in the caves
John(he picks up the money in epilogue 2) $42,000.... Yes Dutch we definitely don't have the money to ship everyone off to tahiti
I love the fact that Charles and Javier are the only ones who showed concern and stopped for Lenny, true friends
And Arthur too
Javier turned fed tho
Dutch gone insane after hosea die he even left John
Micah is a Rat
Bill is a fool to himself
for Javier he changed after guam compare to Javier in first camp.
javier and charles were real ones shame javier went wit dutch
@@xiscaw tbh, he didn't even know what going on, he wasn't in the camp hearing what Arthur said about Micah and he didn't see micah shot Grimshaw.
number 8 the ending is not Josiah，is the man who Infect TB to Arthur when collect the money,is the men's son.
Arthur helped them on the feeder mission in chapter 6 .