I loved that conversation with Reverend Swanson at the train station, but the conversation with the sister is irreplaceable. That was such a powerful scene and the first time this game made me cry. “I’m afraid” was delivered so beautifully, and it showed the humanity in Arthur that we rarely get to see throughout the game. He’s always quick witted, sarcastic, and a smart ass, but that was a minute of vulnerability. A man feeling death creep up on him, knowing he’s impervious to stop it, and realizing that regardless of how tough he is, mortality is still a terrifying thing that every man, woman, and child has to encounter in their lives
8:43 man, the way Dutch tried to stop the guy from beating Arthur to death despite all the armed guards around him... I'm a pretty big rejector of the idea that Dutch never cared about the gang and was playing a facade the whole time, because isn't it just all the more tragic of a story for Dutch to go from frantically fighting the guards to make them stop beating Arthur, to becoming so delusional and paranoid to the point that he would turn his back on Arthur? Makes for a much deeper and tragic story than simply "he was always like that and just fooling everyone the whole time"
5:25 damn she's so disappointed u can tell in her voice "oh ok" she sounds so sad. It's so interesting how he can straight up lie like that without looking guilty
There's a wall you can jump which he ends up following if your quick you can tackle him pretty easy but it's nippy! Took a good few tries to catch the little f'er 🤣
Some of these cutscenes are things that 90%+ of the playerbase will never see. Props to Rockstar for still adding them. Always loved the insane detail in this game.
I just realized the parallel in when Arthur's horse brings him home, Reminds me of Krypto bringing Clark home in the Superman trailer. When watching the trailer I came back to this
Bro, I left a similar comment before, but whether it’s work or a hobby, sticking to something consistently is truly admirable. I’ve played over 1,200 hours of Red Dead Redemption 2 in single-player. The tips shared by RDR2 content creators on TH-cam are things I already know, and I’ve memorized all the roads in the game so well that I can get to any location I want without a map. But the reason I still subscribe to your channel and try to watch your videos whenever they’re uploaded is because I respect your consistency and dedication. I hope you finish 2024 well and keep up your energy in 2025 too. I wish you and everyone you care about all the happiness in the world.
In my playthrough I got the horse(Buell) from the veteran who get's killed by the boar and I was so fucking sad when Arthur got low to the horse and said "Thank You" 16:47 I forged a bond with that horse as it had a story instead of just mindlessly buying the most expensive one.
I hate that first Saint Denis mission, I can never catch the little punk. Tried stealing a horse and riding after him when he's on the trolly and because of the rubber band effect the trolly suddenly turns into a bullet train lol.
I’m pretty sure they changed it but I’m not sure. When I first played, I was able to catch him, after that, never again and I’ve played the game so many times
The first time I played this, nothing happened after Lenny & Arthur’s bar mission, I was so confused. No arrest, or anything. Second play through I actually had a cutscene as shown.. Trippy. 😮
If you managed to escape by not stumbling over the fence (pressing the blurred jump button at the right time) then Arthur will wake up near the station where Reverend Swanson's first mission is. No arrest cutscene.
This video shows that rdr2 missions aren't linear completely rockstar gave us some sort of freedom.They can definitely improved upn this aspect in gta 6
In the fishing mission when Abigail says why she chose him to do it is because “you do what you say “ is that the low honor version ? I’ve always heard her response be along the lines of “because he likes you “
I find it weird how I only went to jail with Lenny after I failed to escape on purpose. Didn’t know that people actually didn’t get away the first time
tbh i played through the story 3 times my wish was after the whole gang splits arthur would have survived for about a year settle down with sadie adler and die while riding his horse with her but unfortunately it doesnt happen
I loved that conversation with Reverend Swanson at the train station, but the conversation with the sister is irreplaceable. That was such a powerful scene and the first time this game made me cry. “I’m afraid” was delivered so beautifully, and it showed the humanity in Arthur that we rarely get to see throughout the game. He’s always quick witted, sarcastic, and a smart ass, but that was a minute of vulnerability. A man feeling death creep up on him, knowing he’s impervious to stop it, and realizing that regardless of how tough he is, mortality is still a terrifying thing that every man, woman, and child has to encounter in their lives
Bro that hit my heart soo hard 😔
The horse coming to save you is neat. I love my horsey
and my horsey love me
I thought u wrote Hosey😂
@@peterman2790John watch out, agent Ross is coming
named mine HorsyMcHorseFace (can't fit the "e" in horsey there)
GOT A BOY NAMED JACK, YES THE BOY IS MINE
9:51 the “Sorry…” makes me feel so sad for Arthur, then the Guttural “OI” makes me happy again :)
he sounded so genuinely remorseful lmfao
what mission is that?
@@JuggarNxught Benedict Allbright’s bounty hunting mission. you can find the poster in the Valentine sheriff’s office :]
@ doing the work of the gods, respect
8:43 man, the way Dutch tried to stop the guy from beating Arthur to death despite all the armed guards around him... I'm a pretty big rejector of the idea that Dutch never cared about the gang and was playing a facade the whole time, because isn't it just all the more tragic of a story for Dutch to go from frantically fighting the guards to make them stop beating Arthur, to becoming so delusional and paranoid to the point that he would turn his back on Arthur? Makes for a much deeper and tragic story than simply "he was always like that and just fooling everyone the whole time"
Dutch still have faith and loyalty to Arthur until Arthur stop believing in him in the next chapter.
@@jaylinwilkins7865u didnt play da game and instead watched it on yt did u
he prolly actually did get brain damage from something lol
There’s also different dialogue for Strauss if you have high or low honour same with the helping Sadie mission when she kills that fat guy
5:23 Arthur: nooooooo no gift
5:25 damn she's so disappointed u can tell in her voice "oh ok" she sounds so sad. It's so interesting how he can straight up lie like that without looking guilty
i thought hitting the barrel was something that the game made you do, since i did it the first time i played
Heck. I always wake up in the grass, alone. Didn’t know you could be caught.
RDR2 is the best.
Same
I hit the fence, but you can also escape
Fr im playing my third playthrough and i didnt hit the barrel and woke up in the middle of nowhere
I ran into the wooden pole.
6:07 Arthur saying "get me home" sounds like Superman telling Krypto to take him home in the movie trailer.
12:40 You knew that if Arthur was a bad person, he would dream of a wolf instead of a deer.
Black coyote😡😡😡
It's a coyote 😂 I have low honor in my 5th game play but I'm going up hate the ambushes of gangs and the bounties but getting rid of em is fun
@@loganadam3887being bad is true redemption
@@99akno u go from low honour to high honour hence the “redemption “
@Irishvince nah, it’s red dead damnation.
I actually caught the kid before he went to all of his friends so I think that’s pretty hard to do
yeah you gotta intercept him and then hit "Tackle" real quick, took me a few tries.
There's a wall you can jump which he ends up following if your quick you can tackle him pretty easy but it's nippy! Took a good few tries to catch the little f'er 🤣
The 1st time I nearly caught him but I tried to tackle him with the lasso and it didn’t work
8:50 It's obvious that Dutch is worried about Arthur, which means he's not that crazy in Chapter 5.
He's not okay since chapter 2 and being head hit on the ship crush
@@schwarzesfleisch5809Dutch being head hit on the trolley station robbery too at Saint Denis’ (Cp. 4 if i remember well)
@@andysmith8902 yes exactly. Multiple head trauma is not good for your mental health. Killing a bunch of people as well
I might run into the barrel on purpose from now on so I don't have to start out on foot in the middle of nowehere
You can run straight into the post infront of you as well...
Most people just fail the qte to hop the fence.
21:38
John: I'm * title card plays *
Gosh darn it I just got that joke
I did that in my head when I watched it
5:27 i love this stammering Arthur
I totally missed that first scene 😂😂 I've always managed to get away, then Arthur wakes up in a field alone... Not again Arthur 😂😂
And now, Reverend leads a Church in New York
He has fallen so we must rise 😂
No way 💀
Very first playthrough I kept hoseas big black shire he gives Arthur…. His last whinny made me cry so damn hard😭 I loved that horse…
I named mine Big Nig. He was the best.
Every play through I try keep that horse alive and he always dies somehow:/
@ 😩😩😩
That horse stinks
Some of these cutscenes are things that 90%+ of the playerbase will never see. Props to Rockstar for still adding them. Always loved the insane detail in this game.
I’ve heard that failed mission transition so many times from fucking around…
I just realized the parallel in when Arthur's horse brings him home, Reminds me of Krypto bringing Clark home in the Superman trailer. When watching the trailer I came back to this
Bro, I left a similar comment before, but whether it’s work or a hobby, sticking to something consistently is truly admirable.
I’ve played over 1,200 hours of Red Dead Redemption 2 in single-player. The tips shared by RDR2 content creators on TH-cam are things I already know, and I’ve memorized all the roads in the game so well that I can get to any location I want without a map.
But the reason I still subscribe to your channel and try to watch your videos whenever they’re uploaded is because I respect your consistency and dedication.
I hope you finish 2024 well and keep up your energy in 2025 too. I wish you and everyone you care about all the happiness in the world.
That Nutcracker hat is just too much loll.
10:10
I legit didnt know not dropping him was even an option. I have never successfully lifted him up legit ever
frr same,im ass at lifting ppl
Same here, Honestly, I thought it was part of the mission.
If you pull him up he still jumps to get away from you
Same, i replay the game thrice, all of of them i always drop him and didnt know you could lifted him up
i didnt know the horse bonding one was an alternate ending
In my playthrough I got the horse(Buell) from the veteran who get's killed by the boar and I was so fucking sad when Arthur got low to the horse and said "Thank You" 16:47 I forged a bond with that horse as it had a story instead of just mindlessly buying the most expensive one.
6:25 horse is the only one loyal to Arthur
At 8:45, I dont know why but the way they beat Arthur and he makes the aaah sounds is so funny🤣🤣. Never seen that one before
I hate that first Saint Denis mission, I can never catch the little punk. Tried stealing a horse and riding after him when he's on the trolly and because of the rubber band effect the trolly suddenly turns into a bullet train lol.
I’m pretty sure they changed it but I’m not sure. When I first played, I was able to catch him, after that, never again and I’ve played the game so many times
The first time I played this, nothing happened after Lenny & Arthur’s bar mission, I was so confused. No arrest, or anything. Second play through I actually had a cutscene as shown.. Trippy. 😮
That's because you escaped
If you managed to escape by not stumbling over the fence (pressing the blurred jump button at the right time) then Arthur will wake up near the station where Reverend Swanson's first mission is. No arrest cutscene.
I’ve played this game 3 times and there’s a lot I still haven’t seen. Just wow
This is awesome. Best most in depth game ever. They put so much into it
Years later and I'm still finding things out about this game. Now i can truly be an outlaw
Thank you for have been busy on all these details for in the end show to us differents version of this Game.
16:53 hit hard
This video shows that rdr2 missions aren't linear completely rockstar gave us some sort of freedom.They can definitely improved upn this aspect in gta 6
6:12 i love my horsy and horsy love me
My favorite RDR Channel.
In the fishing mission when Abigail says why she chose him to do it is because “you do what you say “ is that the low honor version ? I’ve always heard her response be along the lines of “because he likes you “
Number 4 never makes sense. Shoots a guy from a distance, strolls over to the other guy he hasn’t spoken to yet and says “where were we?”
That Strauss one is especially sad because he still covers for the game
Loving these videos keep up the great work.
Your game runs so smooth what are you playing it on?
Better said, what are you playing at to not go smoothly. Xd?
PC (RTX4090)
@@TheRealJohnH3 you got a big mouth you know that?
In order for this game not to run smoothly you'd have to have 6 year old pc, which is quite a feat.
mine runs great on my 3060ti.
20:58 John wearing that hat makes this scene so damn funny.
Bar scene with lenny😂😂I've always escaped hated how my horse was always outta whistle range though 😂😂
They really did think of everything. Thanks for the video. 🤘🏻
4:56 bro literally got double dishonour 💀💀
One for each broken heart, both lovers were hurt with that one action
Damn I love how innovative this game was
I find it weird how I only went to jail with Lenny after I failed to escape on purpose. Didn’t know that people actually didn’t get away the first time
I didn’t get away my first time, mainly because I was busy laughing my ass off
I didn’t see any difference kicking Strauss out at night rather than day.
Before 01:50 mark the greatest mission in gaming history
3:50 i did this by accident on my second play because Im too lazy to fight them😂
I’m pretty sure the reverend Swanson cutscene can be triggered even if you met sister. You just have to have low honor
13:57 thats one of arthurs homies in saint de kne looks how hi salutes
the horse one is actually so cute! (Arthur's sped up run was hilarious)
14:20 do people not go with Sadie?
Why
thats what i was thinking
16:28 first playthrough I kept the horse in the beginning intro stable throughout the entire game and felt Morgan's pain here
Wants you to walk faster, hits you in the leg
I've never even thought about doing half these things
Whats the difference with Strauss at night? It looked the same as the tiem when you kick him out duriing the of the part of the day
16:21 F... I totally forgot about that 😭
10:05 OOOII 😂
12:17 What mission is that? I can't recall ever playing it
Lol I didn't think it was possible to make Arthur more sociopathic
I don't understand how the scene with strauss is different at night
tbh i played through the story 3 times my wish was after the whole gang splits arthur would have survived for about a year settle down with sadie adler and die while riding his horse with her but unfortunately it doesnt happen
Die Optik des Alkoholrauschs, wirkt mehr wie ein LSD-Trip, als...ja...ein Alkoholrausch...
10:09 i did this cutscene cause i didnt know you gotta press buttons to lift him up. I was staring at my screen like wtf is happening lol.
I thought dropping the snakeoil salesman into the river was a forced failure. Been awhile since i played (99+ hour thing).
Whre you get black jacket in saindenis mission?
5:40 you were supposed to run with their horses? i didnt know that i just ran by foot and this happened😭
10:07 I never thought Arthur would say this
The graphics are excellent❤ where to play it ??
It’s on Xbox, PC, and I think PlayStation 4 and 5?
I failed to lift the guy on that first bounty as PC is NOT clear about when you are supposed to hold a button or when to rapidly click it
X'D
Arthur didn’t finish the homework and gets F for the day 8:43
accurate to 1899.
Yeah
God I love this game
The bright side is the game full of variations details but on another side the game play itself anyway.. it's R*
Still have yet to catch that little shit in 9. I've tried over and over again
you need to either underweight or perfect to catch him
For 3. Micah does that even if you just use the key.
What mission is the 6th one? I forgot
Do you always kick out Strauss?
6:08 I didn't see or call me house i just ran all my plays
Wtf
9:23 zesty ahh run 😂😂😂
You can pull the medicine seller up.
Leaving your horse is such a sad part, i miss my Missouri fox trotter
The 11th actually happened to me in my first play through
Bro. I failed to lift the first time. It is SO GODDAMN ANNOYING
Who is the Red Dead hell is going to walk or run into a Barrel tho???
After all these years....
I always drag my feet in Guarma I have a problem with authority.
The gang gets to where they are going but on my terms not the wanna be soldiers
8:56 I spent a whole day trying to get that cutscene on PS4, I just coulnd't and it was frustrating
Dice Right now where I am It is snowing And it's already 3" deep
You should have put all the scenes because some of them is the scenes players did and missed alternative
this game is sick
So is Arthur
So what's the difference in kicking strauss at night? I saw no difference...
2:56 I didn't even know you can steal the keys
Played twice and never met sister smh
Difference is high honor for Sister Calderón.
@@pinchespiderman first time I had bad honor, second time I had high honor the whole time, same outcome
@@iiVERSEii I'll be danged. Sorry for that, then, friend.
Maybe having Sister Calderón spawn for you is like getting moose to spawn for me.
@@pinchespiderman when does Arthur meet her?
@@iiVERSEii Wait, did you never do any of the Sister Calderón or Brother Dorkins missions in Saint Denis?
There's money in the Strawberry sheriff's office
20:14 i thought for a moment it was Arthur Morgan
0:20 i ran into first pole every time i replayed game, i though its scripted