Toyota Corolla vs Mazda 3 vs Hyundai i30 2019 comparison review
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 มิ.ย. 2024
- Matt Campbell tests the brand-new Toyota Corolla and pits it up against two of the best selling family hatches in the Aussie market: the Hyundai i30 and Mazda 3.
We've chosen the auto-equipped petrol-powered variants in each model's range, with a price cap of $25,000.
Seems fair, but who will come out on top?
Read Matt's full review: carsgui.de/2PJDKbZ
Visit our Toyota hub: carsgui.de/2DbCHAl
Visit our Mazda hub: carsgui.de/2OxRXZu
Visit our Hyundai hub: carsgui.de/2Gi03V9
Check out more hatchbacks: carsgui.de/2HZkkft
CarsGuide - Go beyond the test drive
Check us out: www.carsguide.com.au
Subscribe to our channel: carsgui.de/2aMzFTT
Follow us on Twitter: carsgui.de/2ah6eta
Like us on Facebook: on. 17kv9Ui
See our Instagram: carsgui.de/2aQ0M1H
We're on Google+: carsgui.de/2atBwbF - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
After owning a Hyundai i30 active my 2019 for just over 6 months now I am in love with this little beast of a car
This isn't the Mazda3 2019!!!!
Thank you for the comparisons! This video was exactly what I was looking for.
Love i30 magnifique tout simplement
Suddenly the Hyundai looks boring. Toyota well done for breaking the conventional for a revolutionary styling and engineering.
Look at the Hyundai i30/gt turbo so much nicer interior I just got one I love it.
And the thing is, this is a low spec Corolla. Mid to high spec ones look a LOT better with a lot better and softer maretials, digital dials, different headlights and much more attractive wheels.
The toyota looks a lot like the 2010 mazda 3 hatch i used to have (which isn't bad)
My 2018 SR Premium trumps 'em all.
im in love with that damn Corolla
Love i30 magnifique tout simplement
I own the 2019 Corolla Hatchback XSE CVT, Midnight black metallic with Saddle Tan Mixed Fabric and Leather interior. I’m REALLY enjoying it! Fun to drive.. Constantly getting compliments; people say it looks a lot like a Lexus. Handles very well, and good power. This CVT is really very good. Best of both worlds (automatic & manual).
Is it the one with the fake dual exhausts?
Thank you for the video. Can you please compare the maintenance costs as well? also how much money you gonna lose if you sell the car after for example 2 years.
I hope you guys will re-do this test when the new Mazda3 is released next year. I’m a Mazda3 owner (SP25GT) but fully accept that it’s now getting a bit long in the tooth. Roll on Skyactiv X.
Crosshead1 It says Mazda 2019 too, misleading! Lol
Hi do you know that mazda carry Jatco transmission or any other please let me know
Does the Corolla Ascent have a different back seat in the US? When the Toyota hatch came out, other videos said that it was tight on leg room.
Great review 👍👍
Good intelligent review thankyou.
It's good to see real reviews for Australian roads, and not just commenting on the sportiness and power of the most expensive models :) Especially when it comes to ride comfort and noise - many reviews seem to gloss over this in favour of sports handling etc.
Sporty handling is nice when you drive it for review news car but it actually not enjoy so much when bring families and rough street
7:35 I love that you test the fuel consume !!
I think the best made review i ever seen!
UK 2016 Mazda 3 Sport owner from new...no regrets 5 years on. I love it
Thanks for the comparison! Please do more against the corolla
I think you don't need long warranty with Toyota.
Well the tech in those cars aren't cheap to repair of they break
U dont
cuz it can live forever
I had the same thought as you before I bought the used 2010 toyota rav4 with less than 100,000 km on it last April. since then I spent over C$650 to repair the leaking problem in the rear differential and expected to spend over C$1000 to replace the rear driveshaft which has a bad/ stiff Universal Joint which happens to be unserviceable/ replaceable. Before this rav4, I had a 2007 mazda 3 with over 200,000km on it for over 2 years. no major issue and did not spend over $500 in total for repair/ replace broken parts. I think I should go with mazda next time.
@@justinlei4677 luck of the draw sometimes
Just bought a 2014 Mazda3 Honestly amazing car.
Urinal splashguard? or crocyamaka?
Yep. Have a 2014 grand touring. for 6 months now. Love it.
@@Fryboy-xy1is going to buy the same car as you do you still like it?
Still love the car its been a year now
@@Fryboy-xy1is Still love it now?
I just Got 2019 Corolla hatchback it’s incredibly Fun. 42 MPG HWY.
Noe Sandoval just for that mpg i might end up getting it
As an ex- corolla driver who upgraded to a 2015 Mazda 3 I have not been disappointed. However would reconsider the latest Corolla. Look forward to seeing how Mazda will rise to the challenge!
Mazda 3 in 2019 will be revolutionary car for the car industry...
Jaymate Hi Jay, have you purchased a next gen Mazda 3? I sat in one today and it’s was nice . Those big C pillars do enclose the back of the car sitting in the back I felt a little claustrophobic.
I got the 2018 Mazda 3 touring hatch, and I feel that it is highly refined in the ride, acceleration, technology, gas mileage... pretty much wherever you look Mazda has done a great job providing what American suburban consumers need (apparently not as much for the Aussies, I'm sorry to hear). I can get three car seats, with one being an infant reverse seat, in the back row (it's a really tight pack) and still have enough leg room for 5'11" driver and 5'9" passenger to be comfortable. What this car offers for the mid $16k range (talking real cost not "MSRP") is on par with vehicles that cost 10k more. Most of the features on the vehicle feel as if they have been optimized, whereas many of the other vehicles have new technology that still seems like it is in "beta" testing. Mazda seems to have a knack for knowing what to prioritize when you can't offer everything at this price point.
What about the 2019 Mazda 3?
I wonder if the Hyundai comes with the "Bursts into flames for no reason" trim level like it does here in the US?
Mazda '3 have been out since 2014 and it's still light years ahead. Once the new generation comes out, the competition will definitely be outpaced.
Have you test driven other new cars recently? I have, and the Mazda 3 isn't ahead when compared to newer models from other main manufacturers. It was great when new, but now it's merely average.
Can't wait for the Kai
I'm still driving first gen Mazda 3, 2004, and it is a great car for reliability and still quite fun, but euro brands have got some great models at the moment, I would buy Alfa Romeo, Skoda, VW or Renault over these boring buzzboxes anyday if I was in the market to spend 20-30k.
@@bigchief2331 - I know what you mean. I'm from the UK and have run a Mazda3 1.6 petrol maunal (late 2005 build) from new - not quick, but perfeectly decent enough and still a great handling car. I test drove the gen-3 Mazda3 2.0 manual (updated version) and the CX-3 2.0 Auto 18 months ago and I found the 3 to be not that much quicker than my car. Nice inside and comfortable, if a bit low compared to mine in terms of the seating position. The CX-3 was better, but in the UK, its IMHO 10% overpriced and the 3 can be found in similar spec levels for less after deals or via brokers.
At least Down Under you get spare wheels/tyres as standard - in the UK, we have mostly to 'ask' for them as optional extras nowadays. The 3's space saver also reduces the boot size at fitting it apparently raises the boot floor. Nice touch on the other two to have full sized spares, something I'm looking for in my next car (or at least a space saver - the Mazda3's costs a whopping £395 in the UK [ouch - I could buy a whole set of tyres and a full sized alloy wheel for that much]).
In the end, I decided to keep running my 12yo Mazda3 until something significantly better and value for money comes along that also meets my minimum criteria for reliability and customer service - something that the VAG cars (IMHO) don't do. Maybe the gen-4 Mazda3 and its new HCCI/SCCI engine will be the answer.
Yup.... that's why Mazda 3 is the best seller among all cars. They are light years ahead... lol!
Any idea which of this car has superior automatic transmission? In the long run
So the Corolla is now king. We'll wait and see when the new Mazda 3 is released. We have had the same Mazda for 43 years and she's still going strong.We bought a Corolla too about the same time and it, along with it's sewing machine like 1166cc engine went to heaven many, many years ago.
43 YEARS??
🤔🤔
how do you have a car for 43 years..
I don’t think 43 years....
@@aprfhul No, 47 now.
You didn't mention the Free Suspension in the comparison!!, which is very very very important while driving in high speed ..!!
Thanks for this review... these are the exact cars that I am looking at for a college bound driver
Glad we could help!
I absolutely loved the way the 2019 Mazda 3 drove when I had a rental. And it is quite comfortable too. You completely lost me when you said the Mazda's infotainment navigation knob was "handy". It's easily the most frustratingly annoying thing about what could have been the perfect vehicle. It is a horrible system, and basically a deal breaker for me, especially compared to what I'd consider is the best infotainment system in the market right now: Hyundai's. Now if they didn't make it look like a tablet for kids super glued to the dash...
I much prefer a navigation knob to a touch screen.
I cant wait to see what 2019 mazda 3 will be like. & the soon to be face lifted i30 hatch also!
Impressive toyota!!
Love i30 magnifique tout simplement
Toyota “fun to drive”!!!
Never thought I’d hear these words put together 😂
Alex F what about the Supra
U meant Z4?
Yaris GR , new one of course. Toyota is changing and getting Very good...strong..
Easiest choice ever , Toyota.
Mazda singature body design is going to be hard to tweak with out erasing it out. For newer models. So what well Mazda body designers do ?
If they showed the fully loaded versions such as the i30 sport turbo it may be a different story, the i30/ gt sport turbo has one of the nicest interiors out of anything I test drive ended up with the Hyundai elantra gt sport turbo and love it
Does stop and start helps in fuel consumption ?
Excellent comparison review video
I brought a 2016 corolla and I love it!!!!
The American version of the Toyota does have standard leather steering wheel and Apple CarPlay. It’s kinda weird they don’t all have it in all countries
Thanks, good basic review. Please repeat when the new Mazda 3 comes along ... it will definitely be the prettiest and hopefully much improved.
Might I suggest that in future reviews you consider driver visibility. The main design flaw in my 2014 Mazda 3 sport is the reduced driving visibility (side view) with the low roof. Share a comment on this.
I'm stuck in between making a final decision of the corolla hatchback or the hyundai kona as my next daily driver. they are obviously different class of cars, but i can only choose one
I haven't test driven a N30 yet but I did Veloster and 2019 Corolla Hatchback was the best, it drove like a dream and acceleration was pretty good. The CVT in the Corolla is really well designed but I loved its manual transmission. Shifting gears was sooooo smooth.. After adjusting the front seat to my height (174cm), the rear seat still had adequate space but as mentioned in the video, the door opening is pretty small so getting in and out won't much fun for a bigger person. Also the cargo space looked pretty tight but with the rear seats down, it will accommodate my needs just fine. Most reviewers do not talk about visibility during test rides, of all the cars I have test-driven, VW Golf/GTI and Corolla had the best, imo.
Love i30 magnifique tout simplement
If these are ''small hatches'', can you provide an example of ''big' ones?
Luko Radulic Subaru Outback
Corolla vs civic > 25k would be an interesting comparison
Mazda 3 is the best looking inside and outside.
Isn't Mazda doing a new 3 series to be launched next year? If so this "2019" review may need to be amended
I have the Mz3THB 2.5L 6 spd manual. It's a lot of fun. And gives performance more like the new turbo small engines without the heat and complexity of a turbo. I'm averaging 31-32 mpg with very sticky summer tires. I'd estimate my 0-60 time at about 7 sec. And it's governed at 132 mph. Skip the 2.0L. Get the 2.5L if it's available in your market. The extra cost is well worth it.
I'll wait for the new 2019 Mazda 3 with the new SkyActiv X engine.
But to choose 1 of these 3 than the Toyota Corolla
When will this come out?
@@Philbyyyy if i'm not wrong next year
It will be introduced this December at the Los Angeles car event. It should be available for purchase early 2019. I can’t wait for it to be out too, i think I’m going to buy it!
I'm going to trade in my i30 for the new gen Mazda 3.
Mazda 3 2019 looks too expensive :(
8.4 l/100km for Mazda? How are you driving this thing?! I am having straight under 6s, and cross into 6.5 area only if I drive anything more than 30% city.
I can imagine your numbers only in like 80% city drive.
You'll be surprised at how bad your fuel economy is during rush hour. I've had the displeasure of watching that number creep up on my civic
I only get bad fuel economy if I do short trips
+DaxXx988 and over 9L/100km for the Corolla. How in the world is that possible?! I own an Toyota Auris (Corolla for the USA) Hybrid 2014 and am getting averages of around 5L/100km...Usually between 4.5 and 5L / 100km. I just don't understand how they got the consumption over 9L/100km. Whenever you get stuck in trafic with an Hybrid, your fuel consumption will hit legendary values like 0-1L/100km...so I do not understand them!
@@Henry_Jr_Watsson they probably drove around on a cold engine or in a lot of stop start traffic. This corolla isn't a hybrid though
If you're really onto city drive, you're way better off going electric. However I'm not totally for EVs for some reasons. Internal combustion engines have range (unless if you can get a Tesla) and convenience. Personally I prefer ICs because you can have thrills with engine noise, quicker fuel up times which is very useful on long journeys or if you need to drive the car.... 24/7. Having said that, running electric cars are a lot cheaper so if you really going to do lots of city comutes, then EVs are ones to go for unless your city doesn't have enough charging points!
Both EVs and ICs have ups and downs. You'll need to do some homework and decide which ones is best for you. Hybrids also have ups and downs. The biggest plus side of hybrids is that you can convenience of ICs while you can also better efficiency. As far as I know, hybrids don't have the range "conventional" ICs due to having batteries taking some space meaning the fuel tank or cargo space will have to be smaller. As I've said, you'll need to do some homework on whether if an EV, IC or Hybrid is suitable for you. If you can afford to buy 2 cars then you can definitely buy a small EV for city comutes and a medium (or large) IC for highway, long haul journeys.
As for stringent city comutes an electric car is the solution but don't get caught having to charge the car when you have meetings, appointments and such.
I agree that the Corolla would be the best, plus, they have a bigger fan base than the other two.
That’s also the base Mazda with the 2.0 liter engine instead of the 2.5 liter which gets 184 hp
This video Comment 80% for Mazda,9.9% for toyota, 0.1% for hyundai
quick maths!
What was the other 10% for??
Mazda for consumers who missed school...Good Profits for Shareholders...make them rich
How do you compare a car that isn't release to anyone yet? (2019 Mazda 3) no one has any actual idea what it actually looks like till the LA auto show next month?
It wasn't compared "it isn't release to anyone yet" ...?
The thing is, if your car is reliable, you don't need to worry about an extended warranty. Some manufacturers offer it but not all of them stand behind it. I have been in situations where I brought it to the dealership and they came up with excuses to say they don't honor it.
I have the i30 active with no safety pack for 6month an I'm very happy with it. So much features and space. I think looks best from the trio. The mazda interior presentation is still probably the best.
Thanks for the review do more like this. (ppl buy around this spec 70% than fully load)
Cheers
I30 interior is best. Mazda looks really outdated in center dash really bad. Both Toyota and Hyundai are nice
The i30 is an awesome car
Why is that corolla all plastic inside? Mine has metal door handles, soft touch plastic and leather steering wheel
But will the hyundai go 250,000 miles?
In the USA, I picked up my Toyota Corolla SE Hatchback a week back. Quiet ride , 1st gear auto to CVT, suspension confident. Love it. For two people. Sleek on the highway.
No DRL's on the Mazda? I thought this was mandatory these days?
XenonOzHID It should have. Even the non HID/LED ones have halogen DRLs. My cousin has one.
Matt not in Car Advice anymore?
See how they go against the new Focus?
My last car had problems with the CVT from 60,000 Kilometres. Never again, I will go for the 6 speed automatic in the Mazda.
i'd love it if you couuld tell us first which one came 1st, 2nd or 3rd then explain your reasoning
Sam Pepper from their final comments I am assuming their choices are:
1)Corolla
2) i30
3) Mazda 3
9.1L on 100km. Let's be honest, you pushed those cars to the metal ? 9.7 is what I'm getting in my Lexus RCF 1.9 ton 460hp v8 car when I'm very careful with the gas.
I was going to buy i30 but now changed my mind after my Hyundai Santa Fe Highlander had issues with differential, required replacement in 4 years, luckily in warranty otherwise I was up for huge bill, on top of that customer care doesn't care.
Vivek Makhija and that is what it is all about. Often though after sales service seems to be dependent on the dealership often.
Mazda looks way bigger and upmarket👌🏻
Indeed!
Plastic BMW lol
Not if you go for higher spec Toyotas. Then the Corolla is a lot more plush. With soft doors and much better seats. Also with a digital speedometer (if you like that sort of thing, of course) Too bad they went for one of the lowest specs in this video.
Toyota Corolla Hatchback is the best vehicle in my opinion.
Boot space is really important. The corolla is really a half of class size down. I would go the Hyundai or sister Kia Cerato with the longer warranties too.
Sad to see the humble hatches losing their manual transmissions. I used my 2010 mazda 3 sport to learn how to drive stick, and wouldn't dare trade it in for any of the newer Gen 3's. It's under 90k km's and still has that zoom zoom feeling when you launch it ;)
The new Imprezas should have also made the cut in this test though.
I have December 2019 130 active nice ride full size spare big plus no problems good ride 25k on road love it.
I own a Mazda 3 2016. 2.2 sport nav... Great car... No running issues.. Info system slightly letting down as it goes to default and loses player memory without warning. Paint finish poor and chips and scuffs really easy. I have the Mazda red.
You did say all three are front drives? How come Mazda have that transmission tunnel in the middle then?
Lmao that's what I was thinking
I drove a Corolla rental car in the Coromandel NZ and it was awesome, better than my old 90TSI Golf.
Back in 1983 my first car, a second hand 1973 VW Beetle had exactly the same fuel consumption as the 3 tested cars here. What did al those engineers did do in the past decades?
Your VW beetle only produce 50 hp sir, this car triple it your power and more with same gas consumption, do it at 100 miles an hour, your beetle will consume gas alot more than 3 of these but u realise that the beetle wont reach that speed
just like any other car of that era
I choose the new corolla!!!
They Are all 3 good cars
amen to that
Just inherited a Hyundai 2018 Active X and I know cars as I have 3 HSV V8s this car surprised me with it's handling pace and obviously Fuel economy.Boot space is a real winner compared with Mazda and Toyota.Warranty 5 Years with Unlimited Ks.
And didn't get the 2.5L Mazda why?
Great video and well done Matt. However when it comes to real world, it's a little bit unfair to put Mazda 3 Maxx against the new Corolla.If you wish to shop around and have good negotiation skills its not hard to get a new Mazda 3 sp 25(with a bigger engine)or a Mazda 3 touring (with leather seats) for under $26k drive away while the base model auto Corolla is more than 27k drive away because it is new so you can hardly get any discounts.
I've got a 20019 Toyota Corolla SX Hybrid love it. My over all Average fuel usage is 3.8 per 100 km. I'm saving around $ 10 per week.
Wow very efficient, can u tell me, smoothness ride?comfort ride?
What is a Citroen C4 doing there?
I own a Porsche Cayman 981 GTS and a Hyundai Elantra GT Sport (1.6 l Turbo - 201 horse power - 195 lbs torque) with multi link suspension. I think the Hyundai Elantra GT Sport is just the better package than the I30. With this configuration the Mazda and the Toyota cannot compete. It is 90% of the Golf GTI for 35% less money. Clearly the best value hatch.......
All three brands are good en strong!👌
Lie
The 2019 Mazda3 should have been included.
Yes i have the new Mazda 3 limousine for 1 week now
The gen 3 is has better suspension
Surprised about the review on toyota interior. When I test drove it, it felt cheap and plastic. Also corolla looks boring just like their Yaris camry Prado and kludger. And their pricing is a trap, everything can be had as an option for extra. Serving is cheaper but you need to do it twice a year so end up being more.
You dont seem to know Volkswagen
Engine + Steering wheel 26 000
Some features: 56 000
Not 2019 models.....
Yep the new corolla is a beauty. It’s a no brainer.
The backup camera of the Toyota shows a VW beetle, but no VW in the test.
I think i30 I have currently Hyundai with a 5 year unlimited klms warranty and I’m up to 145k and no recalls at all the the warranty won me over when and I’d choose Hyundai over the new corolla and aged Mazda 3 now
Plus has slightly more features like apple car play and digital radio as standard which wins my votes
Wait so there is no mention of the fact that the top tier trims on the Mazda is 184hp not the smaller engine here!
Mazda for me.. I wonder which one is more expensive to maintain
Depends on how long, more than 3 years less than 5, it would probably be toyota. More than 5 years probably the mazda.
Never had an issue with Mazda’s. Had one for work and it never had an issue. Unlike my Mercedes A45 which had a couple of issues.
I've daily driven my Mazda3 since I bought it new in 2016. Its definitely been the cheapest car to maintain that I've ever owned.
My next car will definitely be another new Mazda.
Bad Drivers Of The Illawarra My 13’ Mazda CX-5 also never had an issue, feel premium but cheap to maintain.
The mazda is
The automatic in the Mazda3 is crisp and responsive. If you go manual then you clearly go with the Mazda. CVT is a boring driving experience.
Lucky then that the Mazda 3 (or a Corolla) is not a boring experience (giggle giggle).
the corolla's CVT can simulate a 10 speed automatic, so yeah and it launches in a physical first gear.
IIIRattleHeadIII CVT is lifeless and boring.
@@mr.speyside5240
I give facts and arguments, you give... feelings...
IIIRattleHeadIII Anyone that is a gear head knows that driving is an emotional experience. So yes, the emotion and fun you experience while driving matters. CVTs are boring no matter how well they “simulate” the gearing of a traditional transmission. So yes, feelings while driving do matter.
Great review style and content.
Compare the top of the range models
Great video! Corolla wins
Just because the Mazda 3 has a 1.6 litre doesn't make it any less than what it really is because the ones with the 2.0 and 2.5 are way better in handling and way more fun and easy to drive than the others, out of all of them I will take the Mazda in heartbeat any day
I agree with your choice of the Toyota Corolla from these three cars. But it would be interesting to see the Corolla when it is compared to the VW Golf, Honda Civic, Ford Focus and Vauxhall Astra (when the new Astra arrives).
NB I think that Vauxhall is called Holden in Australia.
Why not test the manual versions of these cars?
Because realistically, nobody actually gets the manual apart from 5% of people
Yep, why would you get a manual base model economy car, unless you really like saving fuel or changing gears.
It's more to do with most people not being able to drive a stick shift. I personally find it annoying to constantly shift gears in gridlock.
They hardly makes manual coz most ppl are.too.freaken lazy to learn own to use 3 pedals
+Roughie king It's not about being lazy. Here in Europe, getting the automatic always adds 1-2k EURO on top of it's base price. Automatics are very comfortable if you have daily work-trafic and often get stuck in trafic jams. It's a no-nonse thing as it is very easy. Most people in Europe by far still drive an manual because they are cheaper to buy though!!
I wish they still had the Hyundai ascent
I think the best are the Toyota and the Mazda
But I got the SX Toyota corolla hatch and it does have a 5 year warranty 🤔😀
I'm sorry but any base Mazda doesn't get running lights. The I sport here in America (above the EV base) even gets a leather steering wheel, running and interior lights, And alloy wheels for 2015. I have the 2014 I GT hatch first model year, and even mine is better in features than this base 2018 model. You guys seem to be testing them at the lowest trim level. Even the Corolla has a higher trim than portrayed.
That's the point. This is a comparison test of low spec models. The Mazda 3 GT and Corolla ZR are more expensive.
@@Driver6M but who really buys a base model anymore for money saving unless they have a decent amount of equipment for 22k when used cars go for 10k or less...
I think they are standard on the new 2019 Mazda 3 models according to review videos I have seen.