India Special: Exploring India-Pakistan Unity in Conversation with Ali K Chishti | Podcast #68
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 มิ.ย. 2024
- Ali K Chishti is a journalist, author, and technologist known for his extensive writings on various subjects related to Pakistan and Karachi politics. He has also contributed to Indian newspapers and actively advocates for peace and improved relations between India and Pakistan. Besides, his deep understanding of history further enriches his efforts in promoting dialogue and cooperation in the region.
Daniyal Sheikh Instagram : / daniyal.sheikh1
Daniyal Sheikh Facebook : / daniyal.sheikh123
Daniyal Sheikh Tiktok : www.tiktok.com/@daniyal.sheik...
Spotify : spotifyanchor-web.app.link/e/...
Google Podcast : shorturl.at/nuwO2
Ali K Chishti Instagram: / alikchishti
Ali K Chishti twitter: / akchishti
Refrences:
3:44-14:14 - Pakistan kay SUPARCO aur India kay ISRO mein zameen aasman ka farq hay - Ref: www.thehindubusinessline.com/...
Sucess Story of Indian Economy www.worldbank.org/en/country/...
Solution for Kashmir Dispute www.eurasiantimes.com/musharr...
Abhinandan tribune.com.pk/story/2270371/...
Siachen economictimes.indiatimes.com/...
Hijacking www.indiatoday.in/world/story...
Pakistan Nuclear Threshold www.ssoar.info/ssoar/bitstrea...
BJP Sucess in India carnegieendowment.org/2018/10...
India as Super Power foreignpolicy.com/2023/06/24/...
0:00 - Intro
2:53 - Background in journalism
3:44 - ISRO vs. SUPARCO comparison
14:17 - Lessons for Pakistan from India's economy
20:18 - Contrasting Pakistani and Indian politics
32:40 - Abhinandan as a hero for Indians
42:13 - Future relations between Indians and Pakistanis
47:40 - Impact of Indian Airlines Flight 814 hijack on Pakistan
1:02:30 - Pakistan's conditions for using nuclear weapons
1:08:08 - Concerns about fake news in Indian news channels
1:19:29 - A comparison between India and China
1:25:13 - Cricket as a unifying factor between India and Pakistan
1:38:40 - Closing remarks
1:39:31 - Outro
Being an Indian.... I am happy with No relation with Pakistan ❤
😁😁
True that. 😅
+1
Yes , very true
agree bro😂😂
Keeping it simple, not having relations with Pakistan has helped to keep peace in India.
Absolutely
Because there military control them they don't like civil government making peace with India making military powerless
Just ignore these terrorist
Is best for us
It be ultra stupid to have any relationship with
Pakistan
They can't be trusted at all.
It's a terrorist state
True!
Yes...As they say back stabbing and Friendship can't go together
i was all enjoying the podcast till the moment they said - Burkha Dutt is an amazing journalist . pura coffe nikal gaya muh se😂😂
Lol obviously bro they will always like Barkha Dutt, Ravish Kumar etc. They have the same mindset.
True
Yeah , they can criticise arnab it's okay but saying barkha dutt best journalist shows their true nature 😂😂
They desperately want something that confirms their beliefs for them. It's comforting to them. Cause the current state of defeat is too painful for them to accept. 😂
From the 1940s to the 2010s, India suffered a lot physically, emotionally, and financially. Ever since India cut off relations with Pakistan, every sector has started growing exponentially, whether it's science and technology, healthcare, insurance, sports, entertainment, manufacturing, defense, railways, telecom, agriculture, aviation, infrastructure, mining, etc. India is stronger than ever, and every citizen is determined to focus on its growth story.
India and Indians are happy with no relations..we are great like no blasts no deaths
Atleast approve Pakistans loans like you did it for srilanka
@@DividerinchiefNo thank you. Indian proverb on feeding snakes come to mind.
@@isacr4063 will not give up until u approve loans
Kasmir khaali karde india loan approve karwa dega
@@Dividerinchief 😔Can't be sure where the money will go
Being an Indian.. I think we have got into trouble after having good relations with Pakistan. So its better to stay away from each other. I really loved this podcast, but we dont share any common things apart from language and food.. We have so much cultural differences and thats the most imp thing.
Jbb itna hi ek the to partition kyu hua....they are now so desperate to mend relations with us....paisa kyaa naa karwae Babu bhaiya....
@@Shradha878 credit lene k liye south asian ban jate hai, aur baad mein pakistani
Americans rightly said that Pakistanis can sell their mother for dollars 💵 💸. 😂
@@AA13494 bhai ne kabhi Jaish e Muhammad Hizbul Lashkar ko condem nhi kia ....ye itne alag the ki alag mulk le lia khana same hone dono ek nhi ho skte ...hum inka bura nhi chahte paar inse hume koi relation nhi rakhna iske bina bhi 7 percent growth hai
@@Shradha878 Tomorrow if our economy goes down , these same fools will start mocking india. abhi inki majburi hai. inka ghamand facts or data ne tod diya hai.
I am Indian muslim and we don’t like any relation with Pakistan. We are so happy without Pakistan however I believe that one day will break Pakistan and merge some parts in India.
Same here
Jai hind
Pakistani should knw what Indian Muslim thinks. Thank you for your opinion
You do realise that standing up for a country which is dar ul harb against dar ul islam, will lend you in jahanum,. right?
Likes of Paramvir adbul hamid no matter how patriotic will go to jahanum,
Prepare for akhirat, and be ready to fight the kuffar.
@@varunkhugshal9049to be honest no normal citizen for India can even stand in war,it is very easy to say we can give life for motherland,but most civilians can't even run a kilometer,today heart attacks are common in 20's we talk about patriotism but we are benefitting kfc, McDonald's,pepsi,coke which are declining health of youth,a soldier is doing service to his country by fighting but we civilians are just enjoying and benefitting foreign products,btw only Allah decides who will go to jahannum or jannat,and Allah says with token of time man is in state of loss except those who have faith,good deeds, resorting people to truth, resorting people to patience and perseverance (ch 103 v 1-4 of Quran)
First time dekha itna well spoken man in Pakistan. We should respect genuine people.🇮🇳
India’s “gps” system is already in place, its called NAVIC(Its reach is only for India and its neighbours which is in line with India’s needs. Its more of a regional navigation system).
In the first 10 mins the guest is severely uninformed and spreading Misinformation. Thats pakistani Experts for you.
And Apple, Samsung, Oppo, Vivo have been ordered to incorporate NAVIC into their phones from next year.
Typical Pakistan TH-camr get excited about cricket, food, media, bollywood but never want to discuss about the elephant in the room THE ISLAMIIC TERRORISSSM, even when his won country is facing it badly. let alone discuss the impact of that radicalaization by isslamic brotherhood. Indians also dont expect and know pakistani have that guts, brain and that heart to discuss the elephant in the room. Such Losers.
@@yeskayess23 it used for army
Better than google maps
Its a myth in Pakistan that Kashmir is the main issue b/w India and Pakistan. Even if India can handover Kashmir to Pakistan on a platter, Pakistan and India will continue to have animosity. The crux of issue is Pakistan’s identity
of defining itself as Anti India. This enmity is there to exist for eternity!
Four Point agenda was nothing more than declaring LoC as permanent border with freedom to local population to travel across the borders easily!
True...Pakistan is created on the basis of hate towards anything that is Indian. And it is not going to change and I believe strongly that Pakistan must not be trusted.
Look at Pakistan's reputation in the western world. Ms Rice has aptly said that Pakistan is migrane of the world.
It was all hearsay. Nothing concrete. And anyways none was presented in our Parliament for approval. Joint control, what this idiot puffs?🤔🤪
Spoken like someone who doesn’t know shit about pakistanis or the reasons the country was created
Typical Pakistan TH-camr get excited about cricket, food, media, bollywood but never want to discuss about the elephant in the room THE ISLAMIIC TERRORISSSM, even when his won country is facing it badly. let alone discuss the impact of that radicalaization by isslamic brotherhood. Indians also dont expect and know pakistani have that guts, brain and that heart to discuss the elephant in the room. Such Losers.
No wonder, Ravish Kumar, Karan Thapar, Barkha Dutta are your favourites, take them to Pakistan & give them Nishan-e-Imtiaz, birds of same features flock together 😊😊😂
Keep them there
And many like them
& we give what imf gives
😂😂😂😂
More like hilal Ie rape jihad ki najayaz paidaish ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool salwari hijde Haider award😂😂
1:39:38 Pakistan 's biggest problem is it thinks too much of itself and needlessly tries to compare itself to India.
Majority of Indians are happy with no relations with Pakistan. No relations coupled with Pakistan's economic downfall has, in fact, achieved more lasting peace than ever in the past
For all ignorant Pakistanis, here it is: "ISRO was previously The Indian National Committee for Space Research (INCOSPAR), set up by The Government of India in 1962, as envisioned by scientist Vikram Sarabhai, recognising the need in space research. INCOSPAR grew and became ISRO in 1969, within DAE.[8] In 1972, the government of India set up a Space Commission and DOS, bringing ISRO under it."
You are absolutely right. These Pakistani people don't have any knowledge about India and Indian institutions . They collect hollow and shallow information from here and there and put them together to show how they are well informed. Actually in 1962 Pakistan launched a sounding rocket ( sourced from abroad) not a orbital vehicle like medium lift PSLV and GSLV mk2 or heavy launch vehicle like LVM 3. To launch orbital vehicle ( mentioned above) a country needs space port ( huge infrastructure) like sreeharikota, rocket engine test facility etc and also a huge industrial ecosystem to manufacture rockets, rocket engines( like cryogenic engine, semi cryogenic engine etc) . Can these Pakistani tell us where all the mentioned ingredients are available in Pakistan if they did every thing in 1962 . Sending sounding rockets is not space science what Pakistan did in 1962 . After forming ISRO development of orbital vehicles started. Before formation of isro India also send sounding rockets . So Pakistani should compare superco with earlier form of ISRO , not with isro .
Typical Pakistan TH-camr get excited about cricket, food, media, bollywood but never want to discuss about the elephant in the room THE ISLAMIIC TERRORISSSM, even when his won country is facing it badly. let alone discuss the impact of that radicalaization by isslamic brotherhood. Indians also dont expect and know pakistani have that guts, brain and that heart to discuss the elephant in the room. Such Losers.
Sorry Bhai meri TH-cam feed mai aj he aaya par kaha aap bhi itni English Pakistanio ko de rhe Urdu mai likhna tha taki smj aata unko
India's own gps name "NAVIK" already working.
NAVIC hai gadhe ke pille
Yes for military purpose it is already working 😍
@@Andromedagalaxy2na bhai weather and navigation ke liye hai.
Being an Indian I am so happy with no relation with Pakistan
when he said NDTV is neutral he lost it completely
"" Kon kashmiri pakistan mai rehna chahega India ko chodhke 😂😂😂😂 best line 24:09
Not just Nithin Gadkari.. there are other gems such as ashwini vaibhav, jaishankar, piyush goyal are highly educated and intelligent
Ashwini Vaishnav* and Jaishankar are bureaucrats.
@@arunsar7893 yes.. obviously..
factually incorrect information.
1. Indian plane highjackers were paki citizens. It was ISI operation who were guiding highjackers.
2. Pakistan state has openly admitted their support for Terrorist organisations.
3. Siachin is not and never on Pakistani part. there was no LAC drawn there.
4. Pakistan doctrine is spreading terror under nuclear umbrella to neighbouring countries. better read before podcast.
Ashwini vaishnav who is also the railway minister and under his watch the terrible odisha train accident happened....one of the worst accident in the history of accidents in India.
@@arnabkundu114 Does that negate his education and intelligence? .. What kind of argument is this?
India has 29 states and 8 Union territories. Mr. Modi tried best to develop cordial relationship with Pakistan e.g by visiting Nawaz Sharif, which none of the Indian PM did in the past, but in return we got backstabbed many times. So surely it was only India trying for good relationship not Pakistan. MUH MEI RAM RAM AUR BAGAL MEI CHURA this proverb defines Pakistan perfectly.
P.s you can google the meaning of above mentioned proverb😂
28 states😅
I think Pakistani’s need to understand one thing that India has moved on. India no longer consider Pakistan in the grand scheme of things. If Pakistan is really interested in improving ties with India they shoud handover the wanted terrorists to India as a sign of goodwill.
Yes logically we have moved on but at end of day we are not at all happy to see suffering of innocents in Pakistan especially Hindu/Sikh minorities, Balochis and Sindhis. Even Bengalis suffered under Pakistan but became free because of India. Our rational minds have moved on but our hearts have not moved on. Unfortunately, Pakistan has morphed into such an unrecognizable place and now considers China their brother, it is unbelievable that Indian government will ever care about Pakistan.
42:00
Siachen not ego problem. Indian army stand.
New Delhi insists that the present ground positions on the Saltoro ridge should be demarcated and authenticated on a map before any demilitarisation could be conducted, fearing that once India withdraws from the regio.
New Delhi does not want a disagreement on the posts and locations to be vacated by the Indian side. This feeling has further strengthened after the Kargil intrusion by Pakistan. India has therefore insisted that joint demarcation of the Actual Ground Position Line (AGPL) on the ground as well as the map should be the first step to be followed by a joint verification agreement and redeployment of forces to mutually agreed positions.
All Pakistani should first decide whether they want "Gazwa e Hind " or play "Dosti Dosti" with India 🇮🇳......😂😂😂😂... Both is impossible...
love preaching india🇮🇳 but hate to follow their own words.. Pakistani looks to be loving more secular india🇮🇳 and more musalmaan Pakistan..
We want dosti with India and nothing else.
According to hypocricy of PAK!s,in an IND vs PAK cricket match....If India wins its AMAN KI ASHA & IF PAK!s win its GAZWA E HIND
😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
Biggest game changer was land reforms done in India in 1952, to eliminate feudal system and create opportunity for everyone
Yes very true.
From Pakistan....You are right that was the game-changer.....Even after the land reforms one of the Indian leaders visited Pakistan and advised passionately to the leader of Pakistan to do the same but at that time these landlords already had power there and it continued till now. The landlords are themselves in the Military, Politics as well as in bureaucracy. Landlords rule everything here. The biggest so-called Democrat in Pkistan Bhutto was himself one of the biggest landlords, Nawaz Sharif, Benazir, and 90 percent of their companions are landlords, They have their relatives in ARMY, beaurucracy and now also in the Media. The army as an institution also has unlimited acres of land.
1 - lieutenant Colonel - 1 plot in DHA or similar area - 1.5 crores
2 - Colonel - another plot in DHA or a similar area - Price - 1.5 crores
3 - Brigadier - 2 (10 marles/ 250 sqyd)plots in DHA or similar area - Price 2 crores/plot
4 - Major General - 2 (10 marles/ 250 sqyd) plots with built houses in DHA or similar areas - Price 3.5 crores/house
5 - Lieutenant General - 2 60X90 (1 kanal/500 sqyd) plots with newly-built houses in DHA or similar areas - Price 5 crores/house
6 - General (COAS) - 2 (3.5 kanal/2000 sqyd) plots with newly-built luxury houses in DHA or similar areas - Price 10 crores/house
NOTE: Only Vice Air Marshall and Air Marshall get one plot worth 1.5 crores. The Vice Admiral and Admiral get one plot, each worth 1.5 crores.
by the way even the junior rank officer are entitled to have one plot after their retirement
@@faisaldj you will sympathise with army generals in India when you will see their 1350 sq feet 9th floor 3BHK flat which also they purchase on bank loans. Even the most learned people don’t know Indian Army chief’s name, he is changed in a similar way as the post office head is changed
42:38 The reality is that Pakistan Army is not even in Siachen. India is not going to give up Siachen
No pakistanis are watching this, which means these guys are not being honest - just appeasing Indian audience to make money.
It hurts to see the amount of damage pakistan did to us 😢.
karma is taking care of pakistan now
One thing Pakistan and Pakistani should learn and remember is that not all Indians and whole India is similar to Pakistan culturally or in any way. South Indian , east India and North east India are completely distinct from Pakistan and Pakistanis. It is only the North and western India which have similarly with pakistan. During partition majority of indian migrant were from these northern and western regions of india.
Exactly I don't know why pakistanis always say same culture, same language. They only know bollywood that's the highly misunderstood concept.
@@dharmeshparikh7837They’re desperate now to resume normal relations with us much like during congress rule but also wants INDIA to initiate things. But, then they’ll also mention “No talks without article 370”.
So basically, desperate and confused, and they know that deep down that they won’t be able to sustain/afford animosity towards 🇮🇳 in a long run.
Ndtv is neutral 😂
Ravish is neutral 😂
P.S: Aap aana cha rhe h lekin hum bulana nahi cha rhe. Toh dono self respect rhkte h aur aap whi rahiye aur hum apne desh m rhe.
Average Pakistanis be like 😂😂
typical napaki
Doodh mangoge toh kheer bhi nahi denge or ulta Lahore bhi cheen lenge.....
Love from India 🫶🇮🇳
The only time this discussion will yield results is when Pakistanis get clarity on what problem they want to solve. India can progress only when it maintains distance from from Pak. So, it is really upto Pak to decide what role they want to play in the region. 2-nation theory is a reality that no Indian can ever ignore. Stay safe Indians! You have enough rot inside your house that you are dealing with
Kejriwal is a Indian Imran khan😂
Rahul Gandhi is also imran Khan
Rahul Gandhi is also bilaval Bhutto
5:16 India's space research actually started in 1962 through INCOSPAR which was the predecessor of ISRO. ISRO incorporated most of INCOSPAR when it was constituted in 1968-69
Sir , U r right . Earlier to 1962 space department was attached with Indian atomic commision .
@@ashwwal3409 ICOSPAR was predated by a private organisation funded by Vikram Sarabhai through his personal funds. These guys keep praising JLNehru while the fact is that the first IIT, AIIMS and IIM came up despite Nehru and not because of him
I think we should appreciate that in this platform where they have criticized their country for whole 1.2 hours. Which is really healthy thing to do than blaming others
It's full of so much calm, composed and quality podcasts, usually Indian don't expect such thing from Pakistan especially nowadays.
Hearing this guest for the very first time, I haven't seen his work in India. But I would definitely love to hear from him again!
Well never expected to get some pice of education from Pakistan but It just happened. Appreciating enlightenment is what Indians usually do regardless of the source.
Thank you!
Subscribed for such more education packed podcast
During Abhinandan's time, F-16 of Pakistan was shot down against an older Indian Plane
That was not true bro
False, no F-16 was shot.
@@bilalbhutta6881lol it's true
Yes it's true we have radar signatures and So, your second pilot went somewhere and then disappeared? It's clear that he was killed by people. @bilalbhutta6881
yes abinandan sir is a hero. he shot down a f16 with a mig 21.
That is false news.
Being a citizen of an islamic country,u expect others to become seculars...funny😂
Pakistani and Indian are not same people.Pakistan is a roadblock in India's growth
If Pakistani have reserved of 10 Billion they are starts war against India … abhi kangaal hai tabhi chup baithey hai 😂
11 billion bhik mil gya h 🤣🤣
@@AmitSingh-ez5isyeh 11 billion bahut jaldi khatam ho jayega aur kuch mahine baad firse bheek mangna shuru kar dega Pakistan 😂😂😂😂....and this cycle goes on to infinity
Ye Modi wala Bharat hai na ki Nehru wala Bharat
Oor nhi too kya😂😂🤣
@@aj_0073 jo bharat tha vhi bharat hai bass iss bharat me confidence hai
The trust issues between India and Pakistan are largely because of Pakistan. The issue is that the "power center" draws it's power from this animosity with India. Also, suddenly becoming all friendly is not a realistic solution. All we need to do is stop our misadventures and in time (10-15 years), we will see the relations organically improving. Honestly, it's stupid of Pakistan to keep beating the Kashmir drum for no reason. We should be more concerned about what's happening in Balochistan and Interior Singh and parts of KPK (Human rights violations) than what's happening in other countries.
It wasn't Faridkot it was Pathankot.
I love the superiority complex of Pakistanis, especially Punjabis. Khud k khane ka thikana nhi, region ka kya banega iski fikar hai.😅
That's not Chandra narayan 3, that's Chandrayaan 3 meaning moon vehicle in sanskrit ! And the Indian GPS system of satellites, the NaviC, fand the satellites group has already been launched with new launches of additional 2nd gen satellites that began in July this year. And the staellite destroying capability in space, India already has become the 4th country to have the capacity. That's not some work in progress.
Everyone chants NARAYANA NARAYANA in their own way :)
The guy is an urdu speaking pakistani, we should forgive him for that..
Indian GPS, NavIC (acronym for Navigation with Indian Constellation) is already functional since 2018. Indian launched 7 satellites and is working great. India is planning to send 4 more satellites as part of expanding this constellation.
You can check the details here:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Regional_Navigation_Satellite_System
This guy for first time seen in Pakistan has proper genuine knowledge of India . Not becz he is praising India but he is telling truth .
Excellent talk.
I think the guys knows more abouth India than most of us Indians.
@imranali8102 talk for urself only.
its so basic knowledge and half . first they didnt interecepted brmahos. second abhinandans plane was shot when he was coming back, he told pak air force attacked .
I think he's bayas on some issues . That abhinandan ko shootdown kr diye uska plane crash hua tha.oor pakistani army did well . Oor indian media remark
As an Indian, we are not interested in any relationship with Pakistan, in Trade or any others...
we are happy....Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@TheGreatVivek7 before making a stereotypical racist slur..
Tell me what will we gain by trading with a Military state and crumbling state like Pakistan
It is everything for Pak to gain and nothing for us.
Our Products & Services have and can expand more in Bangladesh, Africa or South East Asia
Stop being a PAK Boot licker
@@TheGreatVivek7s m e l l y mallu
@@TheGreatVivek7 nothing w o r s e than a s m e l l y mallu
U r s m e l l y state must be separat.from India
Only Secularism Card Won't Work Now. Delivery Of Work Very Important. Public Is Changed Now. 👍
One who worship Cow and one who Eat Cow can not be friends
Kya bakwaas hai
@@nobodyandeverybody979 bakwas nahi Sach hai
@@nobodyandeverybody979
Isliye Bengaliyo ne humesha jutte khaye hai .,.
This people don't know that Indian GPS working and we are using own maps (MAPPLS)mapmyindia 😂😂😂😂
Infact Map my india is most downloaded app in india
yup. downloaded few days back
Haa bro or indian gps jyda aacha hai ye mene notice kiya hai
No relations with Pakistan is good for India peace😊
I can say that these two are really Educated people from Pakistan as an Indian viewer, fine talks, logical, facts..!
India's GDP is 3.7trillion,so closing in on 4trillion not 3
Bro 3.7 trillion in $ in Indian rupee its- 5 trillion
And these guys Talking about trillions
Tv media of both the countries are same but I can proudly say that Indian content creators are not obsessed with Pakistan as much as pakistani one's are...
maybe cuz they want to debunk the myths they have been taught about India since school.
And also they want to gain views either by saying negative & positive things
Are bhad me jaaye yr pakistan
It is natural for any country to have open discussion when things are not going well.. it happened in India past and can happen in future only thing we may talk comparing china.. that's all.
@@boblurajput3560completely agree with you
@@thousandwaala8935 👍🏼
Fact = you will find majority of indians in this comment box than Pakistanis 😂
Pakistan be like : Pakistan military has very good air diffence system 😂😂(made in chaina )
On 9 March 2022 INDIA launched missile accidently but Pakistan military don't know who launched missile 😂😂😂
I had no idea ppl in Pak knew about Indian political slogans lyk "modi hai toh mumkin hai" etc😂
1) Indian GPS is already active
2) I would like to seriously ask Pakistanis after all that has occurred during this year, do you guys really trust your army?
3) There's no need to improve ties with Pakistan. We are already enjoying peace now for last 10 years. Honestly what do we gain from Pakistan? Neither it makes anything legible nor is it a sizable consumption market.
4) As an indian we don't want to be associated with pakistanis. Please don't try to associate yourselves with us in the future. Go be arabs, iranians or central asians, whatever you want. You have our blessings.
Sometimes its better to leave that toxic person alone and keep working on your success ❤
First of all this is great show,its not easy to criticize ur own country. Secondly I believe we indians and Pakistanis should stay apart . Religion devide us and now it became a poison, better we dont have any kinda communication.. baas jo internationally maajboori hay uske liye thora baahut communication thik hay
That's Palki Sharma who works in Wion but now she works in Firstpost.
Indian GPS - Navic is launched both for military and civilians since years now
Bhai in Pakistanis ke paas Google 10 saal purani news update deta hai shayad 😂
There is no comparison between India (Isro) and Pakistan (Supraco)
Always love listening to the 2 of you. Some minor corrections, Congress has 52MPs in Lok Sabha and BJP has 303. Also, currently BJP has about 9-10 CMs overall..there are 29 states and 7 Union Territories, Majority states are not ruled by BJP. Great point that Modi actually tried peace with Pakistan till about 2016, when he tried to carry on the Vajpayee doctrine. Things changed post that. I always wish, and hope like Ali that SAARC should be like EU. I dont believe in re-integration but i would want to see open borders in my lifetime. More power to you guys, and love these open discussions
no open borders with Pakistan, Bangladesh, and Myanmar. we could give easy visas to Bangladesh and Myanmar. but no visas for Pakistan.
There are 28 states and 8 union territories. Telangana was added it became 29, but then J&K was redefined as UT so states became 28 and 8 union territories which now includes j&k and ladakh.
Open borders with muslim countries is stupidity
We don't want Pakistan in SAARC. The people there are highly radicalised. From a 5 yrs old kid to 90 yrs old aged person. We can clearly see their hatred towards Hindus(India).
Nope no open borders, especially with those people with completely radicalized mindset.
There is no similarity between India and Pakistan. there is a thing Pakistanis don't understand how big India is. maybe there are some similarities between Pakistani Punjab and Indian Panjab and somewhat Delhi. but does not mean we are similar to Pakistan. we have more than 500 languages and dialogs. every 100 km language, clothes, food change. even in Punjab, you can see a difference between Amritsar and Ludhiana.
Our DNA is different.
India becomes 4th country in 2018 in Asat tech.(anti satellite missile)
If you are really keen on getting Indian perspective on matters related to Indo-Pak relations, try to do a podcast with Indian commentators. That would do a great value-addition to your podcasts. Insightful and intelligent guests like Abhijit Iyer Mitra or Abhijeet Chawda will help your Pakistani viewers in forming more correct opinion about India. A panel discussion having Indian guest and Mr Chisti would be treat to listen.
Not chavda please
@@nobodyandeverybody979why
I would pick Sushant Sareen over those two people when the topic is Pakistan...
This is one India-Pakistan match which I would love to see. In this match, we would defeat Pakistan hands and pants down by exposing the true face of Pakistan. Pakistanis should understand that they should start courting Chinese to be their friends and should drop all hopes of any form of friendship with Indians. We have been backstabbed so many times that no best intention can make us forgive and forget those backstabbings.
@@debanjanbiswas6930 Sareen is a Pakistan hawk they will never do a podcast with him didn't you hear them praising Burkha Dutt, Ravish etc. They would only do a podcast with someone who has a soft stance regarding their country.
This is the best podcast ever seen from Pakistan side...so neutral and authentic. These type of podcast need to be done rather than hatred. ❤❤❤ Kudos to Danyal ❤❤❤
As a Indian i don't want to fight with pakistan but I am happy with No relation with Pakistan .
India Only Needs 10 Nuclear BrahMos for Pakistan which Pakistan Cannot Intercept.
But , we have 15,000 BrahMos
I think in near future the status quo will remain. Instead of friends, both nations are on the path to become frenemies. The consensus this side of the border is to isolate and keep things quiet (like what was done with China for past 40 years) to maintain peace. Opening of borders would invite all kinds of anti-social elements and it takes just one person/organization to derail the peace process and bring about mistrust amongst the nations.
It's cute how Pakistan thinks they can use nuclear weapons on so many conditions. :)
I liked this podcast . The reality here is normal relationship with PAK is not possible and that is something Indians have realized after 26/11. Even if india gives Kashmir to Pakistan, Pak Army is going to ask for more money to maintain the ‘extra’ Kashmir in the budget and it’s problem is never going to END . Better to ignore Pakistan for a peaceful India . Never disturb an enemy when he is making a mistake .
Apko apka Pakistan mubarak, All you Jihadis leave us alone 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 👌
The Indian Regional Navigation Satellite System (IRNSS) also known as NavIC (Navigation with Indian Constellation) is a group of 7 satellites that provides Global positioning system (GPS) service in India.
Let's be accurate. Its regional positioning only but it suits our needs.
93,000 soldiers bhul gaye
I'm so happy fellow Pakistanis are taking this moment to introspect and discuss what changes they need to bring in their country. Pakistan is at the same stage as India was in the 90s (India was also in a bad financial state then). It is not possible to change things in a day but if the country starts working now things can change fast and it will good for India as well. I wish my Pakistani friends all the best!
Good joke brother
You just comparing apples to oranges
India grew because it was not radical where as pak is 70 to 80 percent radicalised
Bhai itne ma hi pighal gaya🤦♂️
You are so wrong. PK is so deep inside the shit hole that recovery is not possible. It is not I who says this - but PK economists that say that. Which is why they will shortly want re-unification with IN. You guys just wait & watch for this to happen. 🙂 Their bullshit - which they feed themselves is that it is all about "South Asia" and Region. Can't they see that IN has progressed inspite of them - and that IN no longer need peace or anything to do with them - for IN to continue our progress? On the other hand they think that they desperately need to mooch of us. Jerks!!!
Just forget wishing back biting snakes Pakistan is working with China against India
Just Excellent Excellent Excellent discussion. The discussion is based on real facts which no body in Pakistan dares to discuss. Sir hats off to both of you.
From 🇮🇳
Bullshit.
As an Indian I am not agree with some of your perspectives, but ChishtiG your knowledge and views are commendable.
Look how he is correcting his stand after speaking truth unintentionally 7:08 😃 That is why we don't trust pakistanis . Galati se sach bol gaya 'Hamare Aadmi' fir bolta hai 'So called ' 😃
If you can stop trade over politics, we can stop cricket for politics as well.
what we get by trading with pakistan
3:57 It’s Chandarayaan, not chandernarayan
India does have its version of gps i think
Its called navik ig
We do have anti satellite missiles as we demonstrated some years back
The kind of economic framework that Pakistan has forget India Pakistan cannot trade with any country. I'm happy we are having no relations with Pakistan 🇮🇳🤘
bhai it was brahmos and pakistan could not intercept it. jhooth to mat bolo dil ki khushi ke lia. it landed in a remote village. go check.
As it hard to accept our nation's mistake but u both have done this hts off to u. Let's pray for peace in both regions n daniyal bhai u r most welcome to India for matches
Ali bhai...u r a big hearted man to accept the mistakes and the first pakistani..mature enough to do so...i hv seen...appreciate u bhai
As an Indian, I think India should not talk with Pakistan. Before 2014, there was a blast every year in major cities of India. I am a Bombay-ite and have experienced terror first-hand. Also, please stop saying that the Pakistan state was involved, and they were all NON-STATE ACTOR who sent terrorists to India. What type of state it is, that is not aware of such a big terrorist attack originating in its own country. Second, the similarity between India and Pakistan ends with Punjab in both countries and some areas of Delhi. The rest of India is quite different from Pakistan, except Punjab. Whether culture, foods, song, dance, or festivals - India has 50+ versions of each. There is nothing like Indian food, there is Tamil food, Malayalam food, Karnataka food, Andhra food, Gujarati food, plus 4 dozen types of just cuisines. These cuisines have no similarity with Pakistani food. Same for people, culture festivals, songs, music, and literature 140 crores Indians are the most diverse, people in the world, in terms of food, language, culture, and festivals, music, dance.
Yes Muslims in India and that in Pakistan follow the same religion and some of them may be watching Pakistan TV series. But please get out off the hobby horse that we die for Pakistan TV shows and songs. So what unites India? Our common civilization ethos has its roots in Hinduism. I am a Jain and would like to ask how many Jains remain in Pakistan and how many of our Jain temples survive?
India is closing in on 4 Trillion dollars. Will hit 10 Trillion in 10 years or even earlier.
Kaafi ache se edit kra bhai ne pakistan ki sachai chupane ka 50:38
Yes absolutely correct man .this podcaster is a totally fake guy
They think we don’t know about that😂😂😂
As an indian I agree with you on the news media and respect Pakistan maturity on Abhinandan ji and the rocket reaction from Pakistan
😂😂 Really maturity 😂😂
P0rki minister in their parliament said, "Sweat was all over the head, legs were shaking, asked to let #Abhinandana go for India will attack in midnight."
Brahmos accidentally penetrated p0rki radars. India told them Sorry, it was mistake.😅
Maturity is - Pakistan attacked 4 times,
multiple terrorists attacks, parliament attack,
Jammu Kashmir & Punjab Terrorism,
Inspite of this... Indus water treaty remains.
Otherwise we being upper riparian country , don't have to give concession to Pakistan.
Zaahil...they r forced to leave abhinandan
They created the whole drama out of it.
Bhai tumhara ek politician tv pe aake ye kehta he ki hum chand ko ghar bethe bethe dekh sakte he to vaha jane ki kya jarurat 🤣
Barkha dutt is amazing journalist 😂
Stoopid
What a joke!!!!! 😂😂😂 Very funny....
@@beentheredonethatseenit3456 yar , badi gandi hai vo oorat mtlb virodh karte krte vo anti national baate krne lgti hai isse freedom of speech nhi kha jana chahiye . She must stop this nonsense
😂😂
Barkha Dutt was a joker in the international arena.😃😃😃
successfully conducted an Anti-Satellite (ASAT) missile test, named Mission Shakti , becoming the fourth country in the world to demonstrate the capability to shoot down satellites in orbit. So far, only the United States, Russia and China have this prowess.
Look at his happiness 😊 talking about attack on India
No compromise can happen with these people
So many wrong points to correct. i can't believe this coming from a so called "expert" :
1. India's GDP is now $3.7 trillion according to IMF 2023. It's closing in on $4 trillion not $3 trillion. India crossed $3 trillion in 2021.
2. ISRO's navigation system is already in space. NAVIC is a regional navigation system and not a global positioning system. It is for India and its neighbors.
3. Why can't Adani join space sector ? It has a very good renewable energy company called Adani Green. It can enter space sector.
4. Pakistan's early reforms were good but it degraded . India's socialist policies was not good. It conducted reforms.
5. 4 point agenda was never a formal thing.
6. Attack was on Pathankot not Faridkot.
7. 33:00 lies kick in. There were no trees. India's satellite imagery is precise. There were militant establishment. And India did its job. And also, he is mixing two events. Balakot strike happened in a different time.
8. UAE did nothing to meliorate relations between Pakistan and India.
A few points on the host:
9. Pakistan had to let go because of Geneva convention not because of goodwill.
10. Talking about why India entered Saichin, why the did Pakistan enter Kashmir in 1948 after signing the instrument of accession ?
11. Pakistan is not even in conversation in Indian discourse. Until Pakistan does not stop harboring UN designated terrorists , there can be no relation.
In conclusion, this video convinces me that India and Pakistan should not have any diplomatic ties in terms of policy. You can keep talking as much as you want. .
Bilkul sahi ye chutiye aapna propaganda fela rahe hai or me dekh raha hu comments me indian bhi sahi man rahe hai is se pata chalta hai indian kitne chutiye hai paksotaniyo ki bato me kitni jaldi aa jate hai
bhai hamara hogya hain navic satelite space main hain navy and army and airforce use karti hain as a own gps of India and we also have satellite weopen
Bhai google map jese india ka khud ka app aa chuka hai MAPPLS map my india name se or ye google map jyda aacha hai khud try karke dekhna
Barkha dutt, ravish kumar ? Sensible journalists ? Heh bhagwan kuch padhlo pakistanio 😂😂🤣🤣
Both of them (Host & Guest) are the soft 2nations theory lover and soft critic of pakistan. They have their own views and they thought somehow once pakistan were ahead of India in every aspect.
And pakistan is a nuclear power. Pakistan has the temporary economy crisis.
They never realized bangaladesh much ahead of pakistan in economy.
1:33..mwy be you don't love your dictatorship army. But as Indian we love our every jawan ❤❤❤❤...their life more important to us than a cricket match