Mid day meals program was first launched by Tamil Nadu (the state where Chennai is the capital) but by 2002, it was implemented in all Indian states. The program is still on to this day.
Mr Ismail's ending words were insightful: Awam of pakistan keeps looking for miracles , for quick fix solutions Exactly , any process takes time. India's economy is growing because of consistency in government policies . PM Narsimha Rao initiated economic reforms and PM Vajpayee carried it forward even though both were from parties in opposition to each other PM Manmohan Singh government started the Aadhar card and PM Modi used it to direct transfer subsidies to the accounts of the beneficiaries . In pakistan , new government tries to undo what the previous government has done
@@ThePakistanExperience , مفتاح اسماعیل صاحب کی پوسٹ پر سابق وزیراعظم عمران خان صاحب نے یہ کمنٹس کیے ہیں، کہ "'میں بےتاب ہوں یہ انٹرویو دیکھنے کیلئے "'
In india power distribution works like stock exchange. Every one hour the provinces have to keep telling their demand and billing is done accordingly.It is a dynamic system. Power is largely manage/manufactured by Govt institutions like NTPC.
Bharat mein bijli ko share bazaar ki tarah bata jata h, jis sheher ya sube ko bijli ki zarurat hoti hai wo har minute ke hisab se bijli grid se kharid leta h. Sarkari companies bijli bana kr grid mein bech deti h.
@masroorkhalil9655 in some popular states 200 units are free and consumption of 650-675 units in metro cities cost 10-11k and tier 2 cities cost 7-8k.
Recently headline in Dawn said: Shehbaz lauds army chief for role in securing IMF deal Also the Army chief is part of Special Investment Facilitation Council What does the Army chief have anything to do with economic matters of the country ?
let me write it down if you are too dumb to understand. Army chief is and has been a major stakeholder in our country for the last 60+ years no politician has enough political power to make big decisions so they hide behind the army chief cowardly instead of taking the tuff decisions themselves which gives him the space and authority to be basically everywhere.
@@AKumar-co7oe Army is the scapegoat. The people advising them are similar bureaucrats. However, the fact that the Army brass has over-estimated its abilities is the real issue.
Dost - I listened to your podcast after a while. Let me tell you politics may be your passion but your best content by far comes out when you invite a discussion on economics. Your podcast on the economic history of Pakistan was gem, your last session with Miftah was also a gem, the podcast where somebody explained out the economics of water distribution and electricity distribution was a gem. There is very little good quality content that comes out in Pakistan on economics. On siyasat, bura na manein, aapki puri kaum is ki diwani hai.
Just the story around mid day meal scheme as Miftah gives it as an example in many podcasts - it was started around 1960s 1st by Tamil Nadu under K Kamaraj as CM, fun fact Kamaraj himself never went to school/ school dropout and he thought maybe if school provides breakfast attendance will not go down. GoI saw the results and started it 1995. Currently, it's a 70-30 scheme with around $2B/yearly. (Meager and a lot of issues, but covers basic need)
@@rudrakshseth9877 this is actually a new Pakistani trend abb woh india ko kharab bol nahi pate hai kyunki development abb dikhta hai aur bahut zyada tarif karne se bhi darr lagta hai toh India ko kuch achaa bolna hai toh South india bol dete hai aş if south mein kuch aur hi policy chalta hai
Total Expenditure on Military in Pakistan is around $12 billion dollars ( Including Pensions ) Also Military Makes Around $20 Billion Dollars Through Smuggling And Other Black Businesses Pakistan should Cut the Military Expenditure by 4 Billion from $12 Billion to $8 Billion
I am amazed how Pakistan could let go of a leader like miftah shab. He has the potential to bring the 92 moment for pakistan. Please make him PM or FM and let him work he'll change your destinies .
Miftah Ismail, Imran Khan, Ramiz Raja and others in Pakistan. They all have lots of similarities. 1. Enter the system to fix it. 2. Tell everyone that everything is allright. 3. Blame the same system after leaving the post.
@@masroorkhalil9655 Ha. Lekin mai post se hatney ke bad logo ko gyaan nahi dunga ki system kitna buraa hai. I am the criminal because I took the benefits of post and failed.
@@NYN_000 Pakistan problems has these solutions 1- Free and fair elections by evm- vvpat technology or other advanced technology 2- Referendum on either the political system in pak should be based on presidential or parliamentary system. 3- Divide every province of pakistan into two parts north/south and on basis of better administration (north punjab/south punjab, North sindh/ south sindh) Etc- And give Provincial status tooo Gilgit Baltistan and Azad Kashmir 4- Jooo bheee natural resources hain pak mee petrol,gas,coal unnnn seee anne waleee revenue usss district kaa 70% tak share unnnkeee pass hogee yane unnn natural resources see anee wala revenue kaaa 70% wooo district ki elected govt rakhegi rakheengee baki federal govt or province koo sirf kuch heee hisssa milegaa. 5- Pure pakistan meee ek standard digital or fixed tax policy banaou jismeee 15 seee zyada tax naaa hooo direct or indirect or 10lac seee kam.kamane walae peee tax naa hooo or food item peee 5% seee zyada tax naa hoooo or in taxes kooo bant deeya jayee 5- taxes kooo federal govt kooo 5- taxes provincisl govt 5- taxes municipal govt koooo 6-NFC award kooo change kiyeaa jayeee budget kaaa revenue kaaa share 70-75% federal govt appne pass rakhee (provinces appna tax revenue khud collect karee) or isske sath PFC(provincial finance commision)districts koo milne walee paisee or District financial commision (jooo district govt aggey villages or tehsils koooo deee) 7- Pure pakistan directly elected districts govts and village govt(panchayat raj/india) kee election hooo or constitution mee jese pm or cm kee roles or powers likhee hain wesee hee mayor ki powers or responsibility likhh deee jayee (water, sewrage Police, cleanliness) or tax collection jese water tax property tax, motor vehicle tax, service tax, sab mayor collect kareee or local govt kaa subject provinces see leekeee federal govt keee pass or election bhee unke election commision karwayee naa kee provinces. 8- Pak mee yeee Ethnic based qota system govt jobs mee khtam karkee sareew recuritment 100% css exams or merit or ussske professional degree based peee hooo or pak meee single national curriculum laggo kese karna hain usski planning kiiyee jayee 9- The federal and provincial election should be held seprately(Matlab provincial or federal govt kee election ek din peee naa hooo) There should be a gap of 3 months To 6 months 10- Abolish care taker govt 11- Remove perks, privillages, Protocoals, benefits of every beaureacrate, lawmakers(mna), judges, Military officers. 12- Restoration of student unions 13- Protection of agriculture land from urbanization
Shehzad! This is my first time watching your podcast.Believe me, the talk is so enchanting that i can't get myself away from watching the entire episode.💟 Such constructive podcasts are way better than the content of daily vloggers! Thanks for this!
Shehzad is slowly increasing the quality of his podcasts . I may not agree with him but these podcasts give an insight of the Pakistani society, politics, thoughts and the country in general. Although, this is the more upper middle class version . Then there is radical thought that you can hear other podcasts
I think thus podcast gives only a very left-liberal elite version of the Pakistani society. It is like watching the Newslaundry hafta podcast in India to make an opinion about Indian politics. It is very very niche I suspect.
Two points about 56:00: - The packaged food business is a distribution business. Miftah sahab can not run any ads for his products and they will still sell if just puts them in every shop possible. - His party seems to be building a technocrat collective in the eventuality of a Army takeover.
I totally stand with Miftah sb’s stance on ‘Vouchers for Education.’.And Shehzad, regarding your mention of faisal bari’s point of non existence of private schools in some regions for successful implementation of this scheme, I’d like to add that this Voucher scheme basically plays a role in capacity building of the private sector by providing an avenue to the private sector to invest and receive financial gains in the Education Sector.This scheme can greatly increase the number of schools in the ex-Fata belt in Kp,and similar other rural areas in other provinces.True, education should not been seen with a profit lens, but if it is achieving the goal for the state there is nothing much wrong with getting some financial gains in doing it as well. Also, in those far flung areas the model of state investment in education can be made more dependent on the private sector, with state taking more the role of regulation rather than the implementation.
People like Miftah are nice to listen, ground realities of poverty are different, when they are out of power they talk different and when in power they do the same, this are spine less people, when army call's Miftah he shall do the same what is happening 78 years in Pakistan.
Very skilfully skirted the defense budget question. Made it an argument about current expense increase. To be fair, Miftah doesn’t want to get arrested, or worse …
The easiest and unhideable taxble thing inthe world is Land / Property. Yet in Kachristan that is not taxed. In Canda, every inch of the land is taxed. Back in our village in Kachristan, we pay 0 taxes.
I have hope in Miftah!! I am supporting Imran just because there was no other choice, he was better than the rest and because of the victimization to him and his party. Given a choice I will vote for Miftah
The military can ingress so much in politics because it runs massively profitable businesses and crushes out every competition because which business can take on fauji group. It then uses this money to not only supplement its core ops but also to ingress in politics. Ayesha Jalal has written about this extensively in her book.
Bro high respect for ur efforts. What I think it is not personalities or political parties,rather it is the structure that impedes the growth, therefore, next podcast is expecting on the structural changes. Furthermore, the attitude of political and institutional elites holds a paramount importance. Unless their attitude become pro people, pro democracy, progressive and visionary, the country will b in deep crisis. So, some efforts in this regard is expected from ur platform too. Huge respect for Miftah ,an intellectual brain, but he has been remained the part of system, while in the system he was not able to show some worthy progress.
1:33:24 thanks for asking that question. There is no way that a lower middle class person can evade their tax, so the whole purpose of the question was exactly what he said, that the government should really think about what he said🥺
@@shundred Let Pakistan discover oil , gas or any other natural resource like gold , copper or other minerals, it will be of no use to them because: 1 . They don’t have trained indigenous manpower to exploit it or do the correct assessment of their reserves. 2 . They don’t have technical manpower to make plans for their extraction and production. 3. Established foreign Oil and Mining companies don’t negotiate with Pakistan for their partnership because of internal security issues, law and order and religious intolerance. 4. Pakistani military is a tough negotiator with such companies and worst implementing agency of agreements. China , the best friend ha runaway from them after loosing so many lives . 5 . Even if the companies agree to come they will impose so many of inhuman conditions ( like IPPs ) Pakistan will end up paying huge fines in international tribunal and court .
Friend can you make a podcast on CPEC. U always do investigative journalism. U r always in the path of truth. Can u do a podcast on the agreement of CPEC From one of the podcast, I have learnt that the Chinese share of income in Gwadar port is about 94% and the rest 6% income goes to Federal Government of Pakistan. Can u share truth about the reality of the agreement in CPEC. Hope you will be able to bring truth in front of people of Pakistan. Best wishes for your podcasts.
@@muhammadnafay3127BcoZ he is a clown. Doesn't know iota of Pakistani politics 😂😂😂 Even jibran is Elite of Pakistan. Aur ye ammar ali wagaira to West ke Agents h . Lot of them r planted in india too. Today most r worthless. In UPA2 govt all these western agents were indirectly ruling india via an organisation called NAC. U shd beaware
😂😂😂😂Abey jab dusaro ki politcs samajh Naa aye to unke Bich nhi kudaa karte. Naa tujhe india ki politcs ki samajh h aur Pakistan to tere bas ki hogi bhi nhi 😂😂😂
Miftah you are encouraging people to invest in non productive sectors like gold, dollar, property- instead give them good interest returns so that the money can be utilized by industry and export sector
Comment karnay say pehley podcasts dekh lo ya whataboutism Kay illawa kuch nahi karna? 👏 Is the Supreme Court being abolished? - Unpacking Const. Amendments - Salahuddin Ahmed - #TPE 387 th-cam.com/video/XqAGk1oQZno/w-d-xo.html
Miftah bhai please tell me will the retired and middle class survive the inflation at 12% less tax? Do they want to make lives more miserable? We are still paying for all our necessities like water, gas, electricity, education, health and nothing is provided by the state for them!!
@TPE Where is Chairperson FARZANA RAJA? What is the point in increasing BISP budget, except greasing the current CP's palm at the expense of taxpayers' hard earned money.
First thing that came to my mind when I read about the recently discovered "oil well" in pakistan was, Dutch disease. I wanted to learn how will that pan out for Pakistan.
I want to know about why chomsky reject hegel idea of reality is interconnected and holistic and its opposite chomsky accept that we can understanding reality abstracting it from complexity? ...also.do you personally consider hegel philosphy diffcult or nonsense in today world?
Shahzad Ghias and Miftah sir - name a better duo ❤❤❤ Out of the world What Shahzad bhai you don’t realise is the addiction of your content. Intellectual baatein kam hoti hein hamary mulk mein, aur honi chaheay. Ic quom ko koi to raah nazar aye
Congratulations on getting those new cameras, and much improved sound. I'm a filmmaker and photographer so I pay more attention to these things. Love the new graphics too. However, I would love to see you remove those dents in the backdrop.
@@ThePakistanExperience I think that slightly desaturated brown backdrop will look great. I loved that studio you had for your interviews in Lahore. That interview with Sahil Adeem. Banda woh ganda thaa, par light aur studio bohot aalaa thi, lol.
why cannot we renegotiate the debt repayment??? instead of establishing and then running government schools, government should pay fee to the existing best private schools and admit the students there. It will be cheaper than building and running the governement schools
Your discussion on MQM was quite frank although you did not name them explicitly. I really admire your courage. Very candidly, this UP and Bihar elite is criminalistic even in India. This elite bought this culture to Sindh also unfortunately. You cant blame the common person from any community, but to be honest there is perhaps an acceptance of this level of criminality from the community elite.
India also gives subsidy on urea. To avoid the theft we neem coat the urea so it cannot be used for any other purpose than farming For, if farmer get the subsidy, they might sell the cheap urea, middle men will sell cheap urea and if companies get subsidy then to the black market will prosper and government will have to incur loss
Miftah bhai induct Shabbar Zaidi in your team and some other intellectual and non corrupt in your party!! We need real change, dedication and hard work to save this country!!
Only when buying and selling, there is no tax to hold the property. It is a big issue because in Pakistan property prices generally increase more than inflation so people generally tie up their money in land.
Miftah sahab i will support or even join your party if you had these things in your manifesto 1- Free and fair elections by evm- vvpat technology or other advanced technology 2- Referendum on either the political system in pak should be based on presidential or parliamentary system. 3- Divide every province of pakistan into two parts north/south and on basis of better administration (north punjab/south punjab, North sindh/ south sindh) Etc- And give Provincial status tooo Gilgit Baltistan and Azad Kashmir 4- Jooo bheee natural resources hain pak mee petrol,gas,coal unnnn seee anne waleee revenue usss district kaa 70% tak share unnnkeee pass hogee yane unnn natural resources see anee wala revenue kaaa 70% wooo district ki elected govt rakhegi rakheengee baki federal govt or province koo sirf kuch heee hisssa milegaa. 5- Pure pakistan meee ek standard digital or fixed tax policy banaou jismeee 15 seee zyada tax naaa hooo direct or indirect or 10lac seee kam.kamane walae peee tax naa hooo or food item peee 5% seee zyada tax naa hoooo or in taxes kooo bant deeya jayee 5- taxes kooo federal govt kooo 5- taxes provincisl govt 5- taxes municipal govt koooo 6-NFC award kooo change kiyeaa jayeee budget kaaa revenue kaaa share 70-75% federal govt appne pass rakhee (provinces appna tax revenue khud collect karee) or isske sath PFC(provincial finance commision)districts koo milne walee paisee or District financial commision (jooo district govt aggey villages or tehsils koooo deee) 7- Pure pakistan directly elected districts govts and village govt(panchayat raj/india) kee election hooo or constitution mee jese pm or cm kee roles or powers likhee hain wesee hee mayor ki powers or responsibility likhh deee jayee (water, sewrage Police, cleanliness) or tax collection jese water tax property tax, motor vehicle tax, service tax, sab mayor collect kareee or local govt kaa subject provinces see leekeee federal govt keee pass or election bhee unke election commision karwayee naa kee provinces. 8- Pak mee yeee Ethnic based qota system govt jobs mee khtam karkee sareew recuritment 100% css exams or merit or ussske professional degree based peee hooo or pak meee single national curriculum laggo kese karna hain usski planning kiiyee jayee 9- The federal and provincial election should be held seprately(Matlab provincial or federal govt kee election ek din peee naa hooo) There should be a gap of 3 months To 6 months 10- Abolish care taker govt 11- Remove perks, privillages, Protocoals, benefits of every beaureacrate, lawmakers(mna), judges, Military officers. 12- Restoration of student unions 13- Protection of agriculture land from urbanization
47:48 if Pak Ind had better relations we could've had shared grids in some pockets where the excess electricity in Pak could've been bought by Punjab/J&K at the right prices.
*In the interest of common people* *Pakistan's external debt and liabilities (approximately $140 billion)*: *Institution-wise Breakdown:* 1. International Monetary Fund (IMF): $6.5 billion 2. World Bank: $11.8 billion 3. Asian Development Bank (ADB): $7.8 billion 4. Islamic Development Bank (IDB): $3.8 billion 5. European Investment Bank (EIB): $1.2 billion *Country-wise Breakdown:* 1. China: $26.4 billion (19% of total external debt) 2. United States: $5.5 billion 3. Japan: $4.3 billion 4. France: $2.8 billion 5. Germany: $2.5 billion 6. Saudi Arabia: $2.2 billion 7. United Arab Emirates (UAE): $2.1 billion 8. Kuwait: $1.5 billion 9. Qatar: $1.3 billion 10. Other countries: $10.4 billion *Other External Liabilities:* 1. Commercial Loans: $14.5 billion 2. Eurobonds: $6.4 billion 3. Sukuk (Islamic Bonds): $4.3 billion 4. Foreign Currency Deposits: $3.5 billion *Domestic Debt Breakdown:* 1. Government Securities: $73.4 billion (52% of total domestic debt) 2. Central Bank Loans: $14.1 billion 3. Commercial Banks: $10.3 billion 4. Other Domestic Debt: $6.2 billion *Sources:* 1. State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) 2. Ministry of Finance, Pakistan 3. IMF Country Report (2022) 4. World Bank Country Overview (2022) 5. ADB Country Profile (2022) *Pakistan's best friend have forex reserve $ 3200+ billions,but why China is not helping Pakistan by giving $ 10 billions instead of taking loan from IMF(24 TIMES) still counting..*
Jaise india mai aam admi party vaisi Pakistan mai ek honi chahiye...jisme doctar economist teacher lawyer scientist sab join kre young face ho country ke bare mai sochne wale..
Just listening to this podcast what sir mifta ismail said at 19min 40sec till 20min, that that is the problem literally pakistani mentality is that hamare pas Rico dic , hai wasael sy malamal and to quote imran khan 12 seasons hen two and a half men oh sorry Pakistan k . Tou ye bat bilkul sai hai. Arabs got their oil otherwise unka haal humse b bura hota i have studied with few arabs and pak-arab students and they are so dumb k wo sindh k education system mein b fail hojaen. Isi liey shehzad a few months ago i commented on one of your video k simdh k education system pe koi proper na tou bat ho rhe hai na he kuch kia ja raha hai not that punjab is producing no nobel laureates though kpk is in the lead due to malala.
![[#2024MAMA] ROSÉ (로제), Bruno Mars - APT. | Mnet 241122 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dgGqD28J6aQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Mid day meals program was first launched by Tamil Nadu (the state where Chennai is the capital) but by 2002, it was implemented in all Indian states. The program is still on to this day.
1947 🇵🇰
2047 khalistan Nagaland Tamil Kashmir
Sindh / Baluchistan / PoK / Baltistan / Khyber Paktunkhwa 😂
Mr Ismail's ending words were insightful:
Awam of pakistan keeps looking for miracles , for quick fix solutions
Exactly , any process takes time.
India's economy is growing because of consistency in government policies .
PM Narsimha Rao initiated economic reforms and PM Vajpayee carried it forward even though both were from parties in opposition to each other
PM Manmohan Singh government started the Aadhar card and PM Modi used it to direct transfer subsidies to the accounts of the beneficiaries .
In pakistan , new government tries to undo what the previous government has done
🙌
@ThePakistanExperience bhai please reply , imran khan sahab commented on this video 📹 saying he is eager to watch it , is it true ????
But Pakistanis all told from birth that allah is solution for all. Unlike Indian who are told to study and work hard and have less children
The fact that we are getting these kind of podcasts for free is amazing brother ❤❤❤❤❤
❤️
"Sir apka vision" moment hogaya
@@ataurrehmanshaikh2173 🤣 sort of
@@ThePakistanExperience , مفتاح اسماعیل صاحب کی پوسٹ پر سابق وزیراعظم عمران خان صاحب نے یہ کمنٹس کیے ہیں، کہ "'میں بےتاب ہوں یہ انٹرویو دیکھنے کیلئے "'
@@ThePakistanExperience
شيخ صاحب خيال ڪيو ڪارو ڊالو نـ اچي توھان ڏي 🚓
In india power distribution works like stock exchange. Every one hour the provinces have to keep telling their demand and billing is done accordingly.It is a dynamic system. Power is largely manage/manufactured by Govt institutions like NTPC.
Bro can you explain to me in hinglish
Bharat mein bijli ko share bazaar ki tarah bata jata h, jis sheher ya sube ko bijli ki zarurat hoti hai wo har minute ke hisab se bijli grid se kharid leta h. Sarkari companies bijli bana kr grid mein bech deti h.
@@shauryanigam
Kitneeee rate peeeee per unit kyaaa hain
@masroorkhalil9655 in some popular states 200 units are free and consumption of 650-675 units in metro cities cost 10-11k and tier 2 cities cost 7-8k.
Many states are still not on the National Grid.
Recently headline in Dawn said:
Shehbaz lauds army chief for role in securing IMF deal
Also the Army chief is part of Special Investment Facilitation Council
What does the Army chief have anything to do with economic matters of the country ?
🤷
let me write it down if you are too dumb to understand. Army chief is and has been a major stakeholder in our country for the last 60+ years no politician has enough political power to make big decisions so they hide behind the army chief cowardly instead of taking the tuff decisions themselves which gives him the space and authority to be basically everywhere.
Army ko suck to karna hai na. Kaise kaam chalega khusron ka 😏
@@ThePakistanExperience hamare bureaucrats gaali khaate hain for dumb economic decisions, your army makes them look smart
@@AKumar-co7oe Army is the scapegoat. The people advising them are similar bureaucrats. However, the fact that the Army brass has over-estimated its abilities is the real issue.
Dost - I listened to your podcast after a while. Let me tell you politics may be your passion but your best content by far comes out when you invite a discussion on economics. Your podcast on the economic history of Pakistan was gem, your last session with Miftah was also a gem, the podcast where somebody explained out the economics of water distribution and electricity distribution was a gem.
There is very little good quality content that comes out in Pakistan on economics. On siyasat, bura na manein, aapki puri kaum is ki diwani hai.
❤️🙌
@@ThePakistanExperience, love ❤️ you bhai jaan , kya imran khan sahab ne bhi is video par comment kiya hai ?
In India now, every govt school has mid day meals.
Many of the schools provide buses to bring students from villages in radius’s of 20-25 kilometres
@@bbhusari yea all schools where I grew up had school buses.
Please do the same for Pakistan as well, in return we will give you Fawad and Hannia :)
@@NoumanArif007 😂😂😂😂😂 bc 😂😂😂😂😂
@@NoumanArif007 lol you can keep them
The production quality has really upgraded to a new high. The new cameras are doing a great job 👏
🙌
Just the story around mid day meal scheme as Miftah gives it as an example in many podcasts - it was started around 1960s 1st by Tamil Nadu under K Kamaraj as CM, fun fact Kamaraj himself never went to school/ school dropout and he thought maybe if school provides breakfast attendance will not go down. GoI saw the results and started it 1995. Currently, it's a 70-30 scheme with around $2B/yearly. (Meager and a lot of issues, but covers basic need)
🙌
@@ThePakistanExperience, ❤❤❤
Hindustan ke kewal south mein nahi har govt school mein mid day meal milta hai north south east west
Very true bhai har gaon ke school mein bhi hota hai❤❤❤
@@rudrakshseth9877 this is actually a new Pakistani trend abb woh india ko kharab bol nahi pate hai kyunki development abb dikhta hai aur bahut zyada tarif karne se bhi darr lagta hai toh India ko kuch achaa bolna hai toh South india bol dete hai aş if south mein kuch aur hi policy chalta hai
@@Jay78bhupats 1947 🇵🇰
2047 Khalistan Nagaalnd tanil Kashmir freedom soon
Chatistgar , Jarkand , Bihar may Toilet still new technology hay
@@Dhqgwg tera 3 line likhne mein jitne spelling mistakes hai is se toh pata chal gaya you are from Pakistan toh yeh Sab Lahori churan chaat aur so ja
@@Dhqgwg😂😂😂 ok
Always enjoy Miftah Sahib on TPE, more so because of the way you frame the questions, Shehzad. It's always a learning curve! Kudos!
❤️🙌
Indian defence budget is 75 billion usd not 64 Billion usd
Please correct it mifta bhai
Abb I think $80BN ke ooper hein 😊
Total Expenditure on Military in Pakistan is around $12 billion dollars ( Including Pensions )
Also Military Makes Around $20 Billion Dollars Through Smuggling And Other Black Businesses
Pakistan should Cut the Military Expenditure by 4 Billion from $12 Billion to $8 Billion
I am amazed how Pakistan could let go of a leader like miftah shab. He has the potential to bring the 92 moment for pakistan. Please make him PM or FM and let him work he'll change your destinies .
Miftah Ismail, Imran Khan, Ramiz Raja and others in Pakistan.
They all have lots of similarities.
1. Enter the system to fix it.
2. Tell everyone that everything is allright.
3. Blame the same system after leaving the post.
Bro yeee system bana huwaaa heee aesaa hain keee app bhee agar agayee tooo nae kuch karsaktee
@@masroorkhalil9655 Ha. Lekin mai post se hatney ke bad logo ko gyaan nahi dunga ki system kitna buraa hai. I am the criminal because I took the benefits of post and failed.
@@NYN_000
Pakistan problems has these solutions
1- Free and fair elections by evm- vvpat technology or other advanced technology
2- Referendum on either the political system in pak should be based on presidential or parliamentary system.
3- Divide every province of pakistan into two parts north/south and on basis of better administration (north punjab/south punjab, North sindh/ south sindh) Etc- And give Provincial status tooo Gilgit Baltistan and Azad Kashmir
4- Jooo bheee natural resources hain pak mee petrol,gas,coal unnnn seee anne waleee revenue usss district kaa 70% tak share unnnkeee pass hogee yane unnn natural resources see anee wala revenue kaaa 70% wooo district ki elected govt rakhegi rakheengee baki federal govt or province koo sirf kuch heee hisssa milegaa.
5- Pure pakistan meee ek standard digital or fixed tax policy banaou jismeee 15 seee zyada tax naaa hooo direct or indirect or 10lac seee kam.kamane walae peee tax naa hooo or food item peee 5% seee zyada tax naa hoooo or
in taxes kooo bant deeya jayee
5- taxes kooo federal govt kooo
5- taxes provincisl govt
5- taxes municipal govt koooo
6-NFC award kooo change kiyeaa jayeee budget kaaa revenue kaaa share 70-75% federal govt appne pass rakhee (provinces appna tax revenue khud collect karee) or isske sath PFC(provincial finance commision)districts koo milne walee paisee or District financial commision (jooo district govt aggey villages or tehsils koooo deee)
7- Pure pakistan directly elected districts govts and village govt(panchayat raj/india) kee election hooo or constitution mee jese pm or cm kee roles or powers likhee hain wesee hee mayor ki powers or responsibility likhh deee jayee (water, sewrage Police, cleanliness) or tax collection jese water tax property tax, motor vehicle tax, service tax, sab mayor collect kareee or local govt kaa subject provinces see leekeee federal govt keee pass or election bhee unke election commision karwayee naa kee provinces.
8- Pak mee yeee Ethnic based qota system govt jobs mee khtam karkee sareew recuritment 100% css exams or merit or ussske professional degree based peee hooo or pak meee single national curriculum laggo kese karna hain usski planning kiiyee jayee
9- The federal and provincial election should be held seprately(Matlab provincial or federal govt kee election ek din peee naa hooo) There should be a gap of 3 months To 6 months
10- Abolish care taker govt
11- Remove perks, privillages, Protocoals, benefits of every beaureacrate, lawmakers(mna), judges, Military officers.
12- Restoration of student unions
13- Protection of agriculture land from urbanization
Which passhole in the system for 78 years has not done that ??? Give me one name
Shehzad!
This is my first time watching your podcast.Believe me, the talk is so enchanting that i can't get myself away from watching the entire episode.💟
Such constructive podcasts are way better than the content of daily vloggers!
Thanks for this!
❤️🙌
Shehzad is slowly increasing the quality of his podcasts . I may not agree with him but these podcasts give an insight of the Pakistani society, politics, thoughts and the country in general. Although, this is the more upper middle class version . Then there is radical thought that you can hear other podcasts
I think thus podcast gives only a very left-liberal elite version of the Pakistani society.
It is like watching the Newslaundry hafta podcast in India to make an opinion about Indian politics. It is very very niche I suspect.
Spot on@@fakebatli
Brilliant questions by Shehzad.
🙌
Podcast is sensible discussion. Identify problem areas n try to find solution. Pakistan is evolving n some problems r solved with time.
Miftah is a Good Man
I'm saying this as a BJP Supporter from India
Good discussion. But problem is complicated, discuss with Mr.Zakir Naik he will solve all pakistani problems.
😂😂
Khalistan Pakistan Free Trade agreement soon
@@meghasaishyam6847 khalistan Jindabad
Two points about 56:00:
- The packaged food business is a distribution business. Miftah sahab can not run any ads for his products and they will still sell if just puts them in every shop possible.
- His party seems to be building a technocrat collective in the eventuality of a Army takeover.
I totally stand with Miftah sb’s stance on ‘Vouchers for Education.’.And Shehzad, regarding your mention of faisal bari’s point of non existence of private schools in some regions for successful implementation of this scheme, I’d like to add that this Voucher scheme basically plays a role in capacity building of the private sector by providing an avenue to the private sector to invest and receive financial gains in the Education Sector.This scheme can greatly increase the number of schools in the ex-Fata belt in Kp,and similar other rural areas in other provinces.True, education should not been seen with a profit lens, but if it is achieving the goal for the state there is nothing much wrong with getting some financial gains in doing it as well. Also, in those far flung areas the model of state investment in education can be made more dependent on the private sector, with state taking more the role of regulation rather than the implementation.
How to fix the Education System in Pakistan - Dr. Faisal Bari - #TPE 288
th-cam.com/video/TlL3jri-fbY/w-d-xo.html watch this
Hats off to you Shehzad Ghias 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
🙌
People like Miftah are nice to listen, ground realities of poverty are different, when they are out of power they talk different and when in power they do the same, this are spine less people, when army call's Miftah he shall do the same what is happening 78 years in Pakistan.
Help me understand what Miftah bhai said now vs what was he saying when he was in power? I love people always whining and complaining
Very intellectual discussions. After sahil adeems podcast of your's, I watch this one, and its really great.
Keep doing the great work.❤❤
❤️
Miftah sb couldn't satisfy me on Defence Budget point
No satisfaction’s answer Defense budget even it’s skipped despite asked several time
agreed 100x
Very skilfully skirted the defense budget question. Made it an argument about current expense increase.
To be fair, Miftah doesn’t want to get arrested, or worse …
The easiest and unhideable taxble thing inthe world is Land / Property. Yet in Kachristan that is not taxed. In Canda, every inch of the land is taxed. Back in our village in Kachristan, we pay 0 taxes.
Mufta Ismael knows very well who are launching him and his party. So it is nothing more than another project. He dodge every question about them.
I have hope in Miftah!! I am supporting Imran just because there was no other choice, he was better than the rest and because of the victimization to him and his party. Given a choice I will vote for Miftah
The military can ingress so much in politics because it runs massively profitable businesses and crushes out every competition because which business can take on fauji group. It then uses this money to not only supplement its core ops but also to ingress in politics. Ayesha Jalal has written about this extensively in her book.
Was waiting eagerly for Miftah Sir!! 🙌
🙌
Excellent video i understand absolutely every single word
🙌
aaj smart lag Rahe Hai..Date after interview??
Bro high respect for ur efforts. What I think it is not personalities or political parties,rather it is the structure that impedes the growth, therefore, next podcast is expecting on the structural changes. Furthermore, the attitude of political and institutional elites holds a paramount importance. Unless their attitude become pro people, pro democracy, progressive and visionary, the country will b in deep crisis. So, some efforts in this regard is expected from ur platform too. Huge respect for Miftah ,an intellectual brain, but he has been remained the part of system, while in the system he was not able to show some worthy progress.
🙌
Govt policy ku ni lati, jin Power purchasers ki recovery rate 90% ha onhy subsidy dy? Jsy k mepco, iseco..
1:33:24 thanks for asking that question. There is no way that a lower middle class person can evade their tax, so the whole purpose of the question was exactly what he said, that the government should really think about what he said🥺
Make a video on Pakistan's recent oil discovery. Experts are saying it is world's 4th largest oil reserve.
@@shundred
Let Pakistan discover oil , gas or any other natural resource like gold , copper or other minerals, it will be of no use to them because:
1 . They don’t have trained indigenous manpower to exploit it or do the correct assessment of their reserves.
2 . They don’t have technical manpower to make plans for their extraction and production.
3. Established foreign Oil and Mining companies don’t negotiate with Pakistan for their partnership because of internal security issues, law and order and religious intolerance.
4. Pakistani military is a tough negotiator with such companies and worst implementing agency of agreements. China , the best friend ha runaway from them after loosing so many lives .
5 . Even if the companies agree to come they will impose so many of inhuman conditions ( like IPPs ) Pakistan will end up paying huge fines in international tribunal and court .
Friend can you make a podcast on CPEC.
U always do investigative journalism. U r always in the path of truth. Can u do a podcast on the agreement of CPEC
From one of the podcast, I have learnt that the Chinese share of income in Gwadar port is about 94% and the rest 6% income goes to Federal Government of Pakistan.
Can u share truth about the reality of the agreement in CPEC.
Hope you will be able to bring truth in front of people of Pakistan. Best wishes for your podcasts.
Very well critique on your guest in such an intellectual way ada saein ❤
❤️
Miftah should add Umar Saif, Ammar ali jaan, Jibran Nasir to his squad (Awaam Pakistan)
Why are you naming clowns? Only Jibran is non biased in this
Ammar and jibran are leftists. Miftah supports free market and umar saif is a technocrat
@@muhammadnafay3127BcoZ he is a clown. Doesn't know iota of Pakistani politics 😂😂😂
Even jibran is Elite of Pakistan. Aur ye ammar ali wagaira to West ke Agents h . Lot of them r planted in india too. Today most r worthless. In UPA2 govt all these western agents were indirectly ruling india via an organisation called NAC. U shd beaware
😂😂😂😂Abey jab dusaro ki politcs samajh Naa aye to unke Bich nhi kudaa karte. Naa tujhe india ki politcs ki samajh h aur Pakistan to tere bas ki hogi bhi nhi 😂😂😂
@@GuzzarAwan kar diya ulti?
The fact is we are in deep shit but still enjoying it!!
I liked 2 things about this guy, his clarity of thought and his laughter😂👌
🙌
In comming days Miftah Ismail can easy replace Taimur Rahman as Secretary-General of the Mazdoor Kisan Party
No no their economic world view is quite different
Miftah you are encouraging people to invest in non productive sectors like gold, dollar, property- instead give them good interest returns so that the money can be utilized by industry and export sector
Love from azad Balochistan
Return love from Azad Khalistan 😘
???
@@lanoklom9697 love from Azad khalistan lahore
@@vaibhavadlakha8160 love from azad naxal india, and occupied Aksai Chin,
@@lanoklom9697 bro tumhari economy ko halat dekhke lag raha hai ki pehle Azad sindh na ho jaye 😂
Developed relationship with Iran India and China jointly politics is not a simple game .
First time Hunaid Lakhani ne fee vouchers program ka Idea tha.
Allah Hunaid Lakhani ko Jannat Naseeb Kare. He is one of the best educationalist.
Issse achaaaaa naae bachoooo kooo scholarships deeejayeee keeee woooo
Beacon house schools, yeaaaa o level keee yeaaa best Ib schools seeee padhane meee unkooo scholarships deejayee
kyunkee innnki normal fees 30.000 seeee 40.000 tak hote hain
Miftah made an excellent suggestion on getting private educated citizens on government school boards.
Cocomo ka zikar har miftah ismail podcast me hoga kia?
Cocomo kay zikar kay bhagyr Miftah Ismail kay saath podcast hosakti hay?
@@ThePakistanExperience I get you but its kinda repetitive now 😭. Lost that humorous touch
How much of Pakistan's total Annual revenue collection is eaten up by the payments to the IPPs and the Defence?
Stock market and real estate are casinos. The people were encouraged to do speculation instead of investing in industries
63-A aur jinho ne kia unki tareefo pe bhi aik podcast hojaey kai kitna acha kaam hua hai democracy kai liye ya wo nahi karna? 👏🏽
Comment karnay say pehley podcasts dekh lo ya whataboutism Kay illawa kuch nahi karna? 👏
Is the Supreme Court being abolished? - Unpacking Const. Amendments - Salahuddin Ahmed - #TPE 387
th-cam.com/video/XqAGk1oQZno/w-d-xo.html
Miftah bhai please tell me will the retired and middle class survive the inflation at 12% less tax? Do they want to make lives more miserable? We are still paying for all our necessities like water, gas, electricity, education, health and nothing is provided by the state for them!!
the only intro we enjoy is the intro of TPE
❤️
Kmaal video
Bring technology in Agriculture use feudalism to Advantage (economy of scale)
inflation is less because people have no money to buy
Miftah sb. Giving very insightful information. Kudos
🙌
The Fun part is that Pakistan's 2002 IPP policy was glossy scrutinised in India and the expected disasters were predicted by Indian economists.
@TPE
Where is Chairperson FARZANA RAJA?
What is the point in increasing BISP budget, except greasing the current CP's palm at the expense of taxpayers' hard earned money.
Can we adopt the proportional representation system, where vote is given to a Party , not the individual.
Tax filing should be simplified. Wealth statement should be mandatory and if undisclosed it should be confiscated
First thing that came to my mind when I read about the recently discovered "oil well" in pakistan was, Dutch disease. I wanted to learn how will that pan out for Pakistan.
I want to know about why chomsky reject hegel idea of reality is interconnected and holistic and its opposite chomsky accept that we can understanding reality abstracting it from complexity? ...also.do you personally consider hegel philosphy diffcult or nonsense in today world?
Mr Host are you related to 1960s era attorney general of pak mr. Ghias sheikh sb?
No
The video quality seems to have improved.
🙌
Shahzad Ghias and Miftah sir - name a better duo ❤❤❤
Out of the world
What Shahzad bhai you don’t realise is the addiction of your content.
Intellectual baatein kam hoti hein hamary mulk mein, aur honi chaheay. Ic quom ko koi to raah nazar aye
❤️❤️❤️
Congratulations on getting those new cameras, and much improved sound. I'm a filmmaker and photographer so I pay more attention to these things. Love the new graphics too. However, I would love to see you remove those dents in the backdrop.
❤️🙌
Sounds same hay boss.
Dents nahee hain it’s rockwell inside kapra for sound proofing so kapra bends
@@ThePakistanExperience Ah, maybe I felt sound is better cos the image got better so it's a psychological effect, lol.
@@ThePakistanExperience I think that slightly desaturated brown backdrop will look great. I loved that studio you had for your interviews in Lahore. That interview with Sahil Adeem. Banda woh ganda thaa, par light aur studio bohot aalaa thi, lol.
Too good!! Thoroughly enjoyed this one
🙌
why cannot we renegotiate the debt repayment???
instead of establishing and then running government schools, government should pay fee to the existing best private schools and admit the students there. It will be cheaper than building and running the governement schools
I really want Miftah and Shahid Haqaan in PTI.
Your discussion on MQM was quite frank although you did not name them explicitly. I really admire your courage. Very candidly, this UP and Bihar elite is criminalistic even in India.
This elite bought this culture to Sindh also unfortunately. You cant blame the common person from any community, but to be honest there is perhaps an acceptance of this level of criminality from the community elite.
Bhai abb se audiance question ka bhi timeline laga do experince bahut accha ho jayega
❤❤❤❤ very well
❤️
Try to bring tourism to a particular place only so u can provide security
India also gives subsidy on urea.
To avoid the theft we neem coat the urea so it cannot be used for any other purpose than farming
For, if farmer get the subsidy, they might sell the cheap urea, middle men will sell cheap urea and if companies get subsidy then to the black market will prosper and government will have to incur loss
Amazing podcast but i have request for you please invite Dr mehrub
The intro is too long, the previous one was perfect
Corruption on a small level can be avoided by technology AI cameras
Its time you call jibran nasir for his views on amendments
Shehzad can you do a detailed video on those 18 billion subsidies?
Good idea
Miftah bhai induct Shabbar Zaidi in your team and some other intellectual and non corrupt in your party!! We need real change, dedication and hard work to save this country!!
Just a genuine question....trying to understand the taxation system here. Is there no property tax in Pakistan?
Only when buying and selling, there is no tax to hold the property. It is a big issue because in Pakistan property prices generally increase more than inflation so people generally tie up their money in land.
@@sarfrazahmad2580 Got it ! Thank you !
Miftah sahab i will support or even join your party if you had these things in your manifesto
1- Free and fair elections by evm- vvpat technology or other advanced technology
2- Referendum on either the political system in pak should be based on presidential or parliamentary system.
3- Divide every province of pakistan into two parts north/south and on basis of better administration (north punjab/south punjab, North sindh/ south sindh) Etc- And give Provincial status tooo Gilgit Baltistan and Azad Kashmir
4- Jooo bheee natural resources hain pak mee petrol,gas,coal unnnn seee anne waleee revenue usss district kaa 70% tak share unnnkeee pass hogee yane unnn natural resources see anee wala revenue kaaa 70% wooo district ki elected govt rakhegi rakheengee baki federal govt or province koo sirf kuch heee hisssa milegaa.
5- Pure pakistan meee ek standard digital or fixed tax policy banaou jismeee 15 seee zyada tax naaa hooo direct or indirect or 10lac seee kam.kamane walae peee tax naa hooo or food item peee 5% seee zyada tax naa hoooo or
in taxes kooo bant deeya jayee
5- taxes kooo federal govt kooo
5- taxes provincisl govt
5- taxes municipal govt koooo
6-NFC award kooo change kiyeaa jayeee budget kaaa revenue kaaa share 70-75% federal govt appne pass rakhee (provinces appna tax revenue khud collect karee) or isske sath PFC(provincial finance commision)districts koo milne walee paisee or District financial commision (jooo district govt aggey villages or tehsils koooo deee)
7- Pure pakistan directly elected districts govts and village govt(panchayat raj/india) kee election hooo or constitution mee jese pm or cm kee roles or powers likhee hain wesee hee mayor ki powers or responsibility likhh deee jayee (water, sewrage Police, cleanliness) or tax collection jese water tax property tax, motor vehicle tax, service tax, sab mayor collect kareee or local govt kaa subject provinces see leekeee federal govt keee pass or election bhee unke election commision karwayee naa kee provinces.
8- Pak mee yeee Ethnic based qota system govt jobs mee khtam karkee sareew recuritment 100% css exams or merit or ussske professional degree based peee hooo or pak meee single national curriculum laggo kese karna hain usski planning kiiyee jayee
9- The federal and provincial election should be held seprately(Matlab provincial or federal govt kee election ek din peee naa hooo) There should be a gap of 3 months To 6 months
10- Abolish care taker govt
11- Remove perks, privillages, Protocoals, benefits of every beaureacrate, lawmakers(mna), judges, Military officers.
12- Restoration of student unions
13- Protection of agriculture land from urbanization
47:48 if Pak Ind had better relations we could've had shared grids in some pockets where the excess electricity in Pak could've been bought by Punjab/J&K at the right prices.
Inflation figures are an eye wash!! Inflation went up by 38%+12%=50 and interest rates down to 12% making lives of retired people miserable!!
Bhai 4 months hone wale Dera bugti main internet band😢😢😢😢😢😢
Miftahs interviews are all the same....He is clever..business bhi karo and Pakistan se entertain bhi ho.Tru Memon.
1:01:44 us ne khilana tha?
*In the interest of common people*
*Pakistan's external debt and liabilities (approximately $140 billion)*:
*Institution-wise Breakdown:*
1. International Monetary Fund (IMF): $6.5 billion
2. World Bank: $11.8 billion
3. Asian Development Bank (ADB): $7.8 billion
4. Islamic Development Bank (IDB): $3.8 billion
5. European Investment Bank (EIB): $1.2 billion
*Country-wise Breakdown:*
1. China: $26.4 billion (19% of total external debt)
2. United States: $5.5 billion
3. Japan: $4.3 billion
4. France: $2.8 billion
5. Germany: $2.5 billion
6. Saudi Arabia: $2.2 billion
7. United Arab Emirates (UAE): $2.1 billion
8. Kuwait: $1.5 billion
9. Qatar: $1.3 billion
10. Other countries: $10.4 billion
*Other External Liabilities:*
1. Commercial Loans: $14.5 billion
2. Eurobonds: $6.4 billion
3. Sukuk (Islamic Bonds): $4.3 billion
4. Foreign Currency Deposits: $3.5 billion
*Domestic Debt Breakdown:*
1. Government Securities: $73.4 billion (52% of total domestic debt)
2. Central Bank Loans: $14.1 billion
3. Commercial Banks: $10.3 billion
4. Other Domestic Debt: $6.2 billion
*Sources:*
1. State Bank of Pakistan (SBP)
2. Ministry of Finance, Pakistan
3. IMF Country Report (2022)
4. World Bank Country Overview (2022)
5. ADB Country Profile (2022)
*Pakistan's best friend have forex reserve $ 3200+ billions,but why China is not helping Pakistan by giving $ 10 billions instead of taking loan from IMF(24 TIMES) still counting..*
Madarsa syllabus should be revised Govt + Any kind of skill should be added so they become resource
Miftah ismaeel was a great welth minister
Jaise india mai aam admi party vaisi Pakistan mai ek honi chahiye...jisme doctar economist teacher lawyer scientist sab join kre young face ho country ke bare mai sochne wale..
good one
🙌
Good discussion...
🙌
Elite ki bulkul fair assessment!!
Just listening to this podcast what sir mifta ismail said at 19min 40sec till 20min, that that is the problem literally pakistani mentality is that hamare pas Rico dic , hai wasael sy malamal and to quote imran khan 12 seasons hen two and a half men oh sorry Pakistan k . Tou ye bat bilkul sai hai. Arabs got their oil otherwise unka haal humse b bura hota i have studied with few arabs and pak-arab students and they are so dumb k wo sindh k education system mein b fail hojaen. Isi liey shehzad a few months ago i commented on one of your video k simdh k education system pe koi proper na tou bat ho rhe hai na he kuch kia ja raha hai not that punjab is producing no nobel laureates though kpk is in the lead due to malala.
Oh and yes this is my other account dusri id sy bht annoying ads arhe thy